CorpusRecord 216301

December 2024 State Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Nebraska Department of Education
Date
2024-12-07
Location
Lancaster County, NE
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,469 words · about 92 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e the board meeting will begin in five minutes e e e important thank you the board meeting will begin in two minutes if you could take your seats please e e h okay the December 6 2024 state board meeting will now come to order good morning and welcome to the December 6 2024 State Board of Education meeting board members please engage your microphones before speaking and turn them off when you are finished speaking please note that board members may be using their cell phones and laptop computers to access the agenda and information related to this meeting live streaming is available through the State Board of Education website with the recording secretary please call the role paty Co Johns here Lisa fricky microphone won't work but I'm here Patty Gobles I am here okay

002Kirk Penner Sher Jones here Elizabeth TM Here Deborah ner here commissioner Maher here here seven present one vacant thank you corman's established please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance I pled aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all information regarding the open meetings Act is posted as you enter the room from the main entrance doors the open meetings Act is also posted on the State Board of educ ation website the next item of business is the commissioner's report commissioner Maher please provide your report good morning and thank you um the first thing I would tell you is that there are no items that have been identified to be removed from the

003consent agenda if board members wish to remove additional or any items from the consent agenda please fill out the form at this time any items that that may be removed from the consent agenda will be taken up under additional business again good morning board members and happy December it's hard to believe 2024 is just about over um we've had an incredibly productive if I do say so myself and dare I say positive year I thank you all for your hard work your time and your dedication to making that happen I want to give a similar public shout out to our staff here at the department of educ ation our nde team works every day to improve outcomes for students and I'm grateful for their dedication their expertise and their commitment and their willingness to put

004up with this commissioner I have three Focus areas for my report today um cell phone policies updates on my meetings with school leaders and my early conversations with new board members so let me first start with the topic of the cell phones in schools I would I would remind you that um this conversation started uh with me at least on September 15th in Scott Bluff with the superintendent's advisory Council and it was a discussion with superintendant based on what I was hearing from a national uh from a national perspective a national conversation and at that meeting the superintendent asked me is are you hearing about this topic from our schools are you hearing about this topic from um your board members are you hearing about this topic from legislators what what's the impetus for the

005conversation and I said no just the conversation has really come up at a national level with my colleagues around the nation and I was just curious as to whether or not the Department of Education uh would provide any utility to local school districts as you address this issue and uh they said no and so I thought no no issue we we won't do anything further that was on Monday September 15th on Thursday September 18th I had a phone conversation with a board member who said hey I'm hearing from folks wondering what we're doing about cell phone use in the meantime I'm hearing um from members of the legislature as well talking about hey are you doing anything about this in October uh the this topic came up at one of the committee meetings and as

006a board you said hey why don't we do some research on this topic and report back to the board on what you find out so as a result of uh conversations since September 15th and as a result of the board saying in October we'd like you to do a little research we did um and by we I mean Dr Rita uh Dr Zab bre I asked to put her team together to create a Statewide somewhat informal survey about school Needs school practices school policies that surround the topic of student use of mobile technology during the school day and with the the help of Dr Yates and the research team we uh put the survey together and the survey went out to 245 Public School superintendents or actually somewhat less than that but to all of

007our public school districts to uh to figure out what was actually going on before we figure out what steps if any the the board might want to take we received 216 responses um so I want to share as as you see in the PowerPoint uh the results of the re of the responses first of all I won't go through every slide in detail but I'll just highlight some of the information on the slides 216 out of um I think somewhat less than 245 responses is an amazing response rate so we we really appreciate the schools and their willingness to respond to this survey um one of the things that we ask is if you have a policy um tell us the a little bit about it um what type of policy is in place and

008you you can see from the survey information that it runs the gamut from no school no phone use in school at all to somewhat of uh some limitations on cell phone use in the schools um the uh the next slide talks about when was the policy implemented and I think the purpose there is is for you just to see that all all policies were somewhat recent in terms of their implementation the other thing I would tell you is that some superintendents reminded me that while they might have to answer no to the policy that they have practice embedded in handbooks Etc so um by virtue of what they have in their handbooks they are addressing the issue of cell phone use in their schools question I think that's interesting here is how is the policy

009enforced and as you might imagine it's the responsibility really a joint responsibility between teachers in the classroom and administrators in the building as to how policies are enforced and then you can see we we asked about um consequences and how effective do you think the policies are currently and uh you see nearly 160 of the 180 responses say either somewhat effective or very effective to me what that highlights is there is a need for um cell phone use uh um Administration in in um figuring out the best way to look at how cell phones are used in schools today um the the next question was how how effective is the what's happening going on in your school schools and you can see that our our administrators responding to this um either said there's no notice

010no noticeable impact or improved safety I shared this information at the December meeting or excuse me the November meeting with the superintendent's advisory Council and I asked why do you think that might say no noticeable impact and they said um because either number one we've had it for a while and it's just become how we've done business or or two um we don't notice the impact um from the superintendent's office so it's not to say that cell phone use uh policies practices aren't important um next do your parents generally support uh the the cell phone use you can see almost all said either somewhat supportive or very supportive and do teachers generally support your school 's cell phone policy to me I think this is an overwhelming yes and what I've heard from Superintendent at

011least is if there was no policy teachers were coming saying please help us with this issue in our classrooms um so some of the themes what what did we see from the surveys that uh the survey results you can see as we move up in grades at the elementary school level um generally speaking there was limited access or no access allowed of cell phones in schools at the middle school there was a little more access but still pretty restricted and at the high school there was controlled access um during non-class times and we can talk a little bit about what does that mean and then the another key finding we found was there was um some difficulty on consistency and autonomy in policy and mentation from District to district and that there is a general

012Trend that as the younger the school per the school aged person is the more restrictive schools are with their cell phone policies uh other other themes in terms of enforcing the cell phone policies is consistency and enforcement across staff and classrooms as you might expect I walk into classroom 101 and the teacher says I don't want to see your cell phones I don't want want to hear your cell phones if I do U consequence X will happen and I walk into classroom 102 and it's hey I just don't want to hear them the difference between one classroom to another uh in in terms of uh the the enforcement policies student adap adaptation and avoidance um is a I would say an evolution um some students who aren't used to using their phones at every minute

013of the day really have no problem is what I've heard some some people who are tied to their phones have trouble and figure out how to use their phone regardless of what the what the policy [Music] is I thought that sounded or thought that would be a really cute thing to do uh but that's why we're having the conversation cost and feasibility of policy and enforcement there are tools out there that restrict access but in talking to superintendant um I would say most districts at least at this point are saying I don't want to spend the money on that we want we want to be able to address the issue through policy and practice and then um some resistance to change and need for stakeholder support and generally speaking they said parents tend to fall

014in this is a oversimplification but parents tend to fall into one of two categories we really want to have more enforcement and less cell phone use during school time or I want to be able to contact my child and so there's a there's a little bit of a dichotomy there on that stakeholder support state policies there are State policies um that we've looked at around the nation that also run a a similar gamut um and really um we found fall into four buckets one bucket would be States incentivized policy some way generally through their uh their Departments of Education um a second bucket would be that policies are recommended for school districts a third bucket is that policies are required of school districts and then a four a fourth bucket is that there is a

015Statewide restriction on cell phone use and I really tried to figure out how do they do that how do they do a Statewide restriction it's not quite as restrictive as you might as you might think if you really dig into what those states are doing but useful information you will have access to all of this information anybody will in our public and so they can see the information that we have from the various states around the country from there so what are we seeing from a national perspective 72% % of high schools um have teachers who say cell phone is a distraction and is a major problem in the classroom again I'll go back to teachers are saying please help us with this particular area um second secondly we're finding that removing cell phones can

016positively impact student learning and the research on that is just beginning to emerge um cell phone uses cell phone use can negatively impact students mental health uh and all that all that goes into that topic schools are finding success with cell phone banss as the bands are less ambiguous so that there's not a lot of room for interpretation what does our cell phone ban um actually mean and then no matter what kind of cell phone uh policy you have need to emphasize and solicit Buy in from parents in the Greater Community several of the superintendant that I talked to at the superintendent advisory Council said that one of the one of the key things prior to implementation of their policy was making sure that conversations were had in a robust way with teachers with student

017groups and with parent groups generally speaking the community groups were very supportive uh but they really needed to get Buy in from teachers students and parents um there's also uh back up with if you would there's also I think an important distinction that can be made when we talk about um banss students with disabilities or health challenges may require the use of some sort of assistive technology and that may include the use of cell phones so obviously if if there's a medical reason some sort of uh self-regulation that comes in the form of a 504 or a student's IEP certainly we we uh school districts are providing for those sorts of topics now we can move forward um consideration so what does the board do at this point I'm not here to to say I

018recommend that the board do this rather I think at this time it's it's good for the the board to consider what what next steps do we take as a board if any and I think there are a lot of options for you so what I want to do today is just talk to you about options um number one you can um do something as simple as a board acknowledgment of a commitment to addressing the cell phone use in schools um we you can do an acknowledgement of the research and we can provide research to schools regarding what cell phone use and schools looks like um also uh I think it's important for us to recognize the uh the authority of the local school board in in this uh on this issue and all issues U

019but also a recommendation of minimizing distractions and then uh a consideration for policy recommendation for local school boards those are and that's just if you want to go the route of a position statement where IT addresses those particular issues also or in lie of uh you could uh consider having policy guidance and practices for districts what is the what is the purpose of a policy what definitions and exemptions can we put in there uh what roles and responsibilities can uh all of the entities identified on the slide have uh um also we could provide model policies for schools to consider if they don't have one or if they need a diff one that is different than the one that one that they have and we could provide examples of communication messages so really I think

020go ahead um what I think really your options are are as simple as think of this as a Continuum as simple as doing nothing just receiving the information to mandating um a a policy or mandating U an assurance statement that says You must have a policy locally uh putting a position statement together providing a mod model model policy I think the Continuum for this board to consider um really is quite vast and a consideration for you to think about as we move forward now I'm not saying you need to do this or you need to do that but I think the uh the options for you right now are are uh really for you to consider after looking at the information we've provided to you through this survey so having said that want to take

021a minute for dialogue yeah thank you for all your research and for you know being such a good listener to all the stakeholders involved in our work um I mean I I love the idea of a model policy and and but I support whatever steps uh my peers want to take uh today or in the future my question is since you did hear this bubbling up back in September and October from some state senators like do you see them getting into this space or do you think they're going to respect that maybe this is best coming from us so if I understand your question you want me to interpret what the state legislature will [Laughter] do I think first of all it was rhetorical no I get I get it but I think it I

022think it's important I think the the conversation on cell phone use from a national perspective has been a a um has not been a partisan issue it's it's it's been one that has crossed the aisle so I think that same thing will hap will happen here in this state I think if if the board doesn't address the issue this is pure conjecture but I think if the board doesn't address the issue I think we will see some influence coming from from the capital and maybe on the other part it's not so much what I know or think but I'm hopeful that if the board addresses the issue in whatever manner you see fit I think that will go a long way with Folks at the capital knowing that you're being proactive on the topic as

023well okay so Lisa and then Patty and then we'll save I'll go last ladies first yeah okay absolutely well I I agree thank you so much for researching um with your staff um I would hope that this would stay with the state um Board of Education andde um having mandates for schools come from the legislature is concerning to me um I think the nde has built a really good rapport with the legislature through communication and I appreciate that and I would hope that um if we do something it's more along the lines of a um a model policy where districts you know from District to District size to size um it makes a difference and there are different models that could be effective in different size schools um so I I would suggest just going

024with a model policy and ensuring that um districts are encouraged to create something because I was hearing the same thing cell phones in classrooms and teachers coming up with their own um way of handling it backfire because kids would they had little pockets where they had to put their phones and they bring an old phone put it in there and then be at their desk so yeah I mean there are a lot of things out there so having a schoolwide uh policy from The Local District with a model policy from the state might be the way to go you know when we first started talking about this and we talked about research um I thought the research that you gathered was really important because we kind of need to know what our Baseline is so

025I I do appreciate that but I interpreted it from the perspective of how how does social media because when kids are on their phone most of the time that's where they are right how how is social media and cell phone usage really imp impacting individuals psychologically as well as from a learning perspective and I appreciated the re the references that you had listed there but after we talked about this I um I read the anxiety Generation by Jonathan height and there is so much really well done research that is pointing to how this is affecting people's attention it is um especially with adolescent girls it is the cause it's not correlational it is causing anxiety and depression and that's not exclusive to girls but because girls are shamed more than boys that that's kind of

026the angle they were taking with this research so I guess you know I I guess where I'm going with this is after reading that book and some of the other studies that I've read I'm convinced that kids should there should be a ban kids should not have cell phones in school because what happens if you restrict it from the classroom and you just say you can't use them kids find a way to use them so enforcement becomes impossible right so and if you are restricting them but you can between classes you can access your phone kids are still distracted because they're trying to think about how many messages have I gotten or what's on my Facebook page right and and the last thing we want for kids with learning is for them to be distracted

027for their attention to be negatively impacted for kids to have mental health issues that can be prevented or at least minimize some if they're not using cell phones during school hours so you know I that really changed my position after reading that book so I I just did some checking I was noticing California um with my grandkids I said you know and can can your to my son can your kids have cell phones they're in elementary he said no they can't I said is that an elementary policy he said that's a districtwide policy and I so I think we need to really I guess where I'm going with this is I think people need information because we all use our cell phones right and I'm sure we all can identify with some of the ways

028it's impacting us being distracted at times or how it has affected our attention when things pop up and we immediately look at whatever has popped up and maybe we go to that and then we come back and say now what was I doing so I I think this is really a much more serious has a potential to be a much more serious impact on education than maybe we think about just on the surface so I I think I'm for whatever the board decides to do whether it's a model policy whether it's a position statement and a model policy whether it also includes some additional resources or maybe a summary of research because I think when people really start understanding impact it influences decisions that they make sorry about that long editorial but thank you Patty

029I appreciate that Kirk I will be brief uh two things um we have an elementary teacher from Aurora and a middle school teacher from Aurora and I believe we have a cell phone band in Aurora so if you want to talk to them before they leave you could get pick their brains from what I understand it's going very well the second um item my head Dr it's for Dr Maher this is one subject area but do you believe superintend are looking more to the State Board of Education for guidance um as a local board member back in the day you're always looking for protection for the or looking for policies to follow there are other issues within the state picket that maybe the superintendant are looking for guidance from the State Board of Education so

030they are protected in case you know somebody comes after them do you sense that as a former superintendent I I as a board member always remember looking for policy to back up the the decisions that we made on a local board is it your belief and I'm not asking but go back to your superintendent day that it would be better coming from the State Board of Education than it would be the legislature which I believe and are they really are they not doing some of this and being proactive in some of their board policies because they don't have backing from the State Board of Education really good question I think there are a couple of camps there I think one is one thing I've heard from superintendent was um we we're really get a handle

031on this and I don't don't need the Department of Education to be involved if I'm already out and and forward thinking the other Camp is just what you explained there if I'm having the struggles locally to get done what I need to get done I'd sure like to have the department of Ed come in and say that shout so it it's really it's really a couple of camps that that I'm hearing from on the topic um anybody who hasn't spoken do you want to give input okay Dr marer all right I'll continue with my report you thought that was it didn't you just a couple of other things number one I would tell you that in November I brought together for the first time non-public school leaders to share more about our our literacy project

032and and priority and also brainstorm ways that we will include uh folks from our our private schools uh in on this topic because remember our goal is to have all Nebraska kids read better not just uh kids who attend one form of Education or or another uh so that that's important additionally I heard from these School lead ERS on specific challenges that are facing their students and facing their schools I look forward to continuing the dialogue I will have the private school leaders group run a parallel path to the superintendent advisory Council that I have so we're bringing in school leaders from both public and private schools to have conversations and making sure that we're meeting the needs of all Nebraska kids um and then also and uh I met recently with the superintendent advisory

033committee uh just prior to the State education conference in Omaha a couple of weeks ago uh we heard a presentation from Dr Matt Hastings uh from the Nebraska State Workforce and education group The ins group and we discussed um also in addition to the ins presentation your Statewide legislative priorities sought feedback on on model policies that we have and shared the results of the cell phone survey that that I just went through so uh we highlighted a new partnership also with the Nebraska Department of Economic Development on teacher Recruitment and Retention more to come on that in subsequent meetings uh but I'll in uh I'll engage this Advisory Group two more times this year uh finally I'm excited to share with you that Dr for and I have now had the opportunity to meet with

034three of the four new board members or board members elect and the fourth of those four we'll be meeting with here in just a couple of weeks uh we've had an opportunity to share some Logistics of what it means to sit around this table I'm sure you're all wondering right now what the heck did you tell them U but I I look I look forward to January and certainly building with the new board off of the strong found ation that this board has put together I'm I'm very optimistic about the conversations we've had and I look forward to u to that to the new board my report will conclude with two presentations one is from the outgoing teacher of the year Scott Phillips and one will be sharing of the great impacts from our Esser

035Statewide Investments so with that I would say Scott welcome I hope it's not for the last time but it is for the last time under under this opacus and I would just say to you prior to your presentation that I have truly appreciated your representation of the state of Nebraska and I can only hope that future teachers of the Year take the same passion the same Zeal and represent our state as Scott Phillips has represented our state I thank you and I thank your wife for all of the time and energy that you've put in to Scott being our teacher of the year with that Scott so it wouldn't be a normal presentation if I don't bring a tote right so just just to briefly speak on the uh uh cell phone so um I

036also with teacher of the year you fly a lot and so I started to get into um either physically reading books or listening to um audio books and I also listen to the anxious generation and um as a parent not just a teacher but as a parent it kind of was eye opening to realize how much of an effect um cell phones are having on society and not just not just schools so definitely take a look into it it's it's some pretty pretty heavy research I guess put it that way so sorry it's always it's hard to see we'll be okay all right see if this works nope you would think after the fourth time doing this I'd be a lot better right I think it's that button but I'm not sure oh there we

037go I hit the wrong button my apologies so um on the title slide here I have to kind of laugh about this because um I kind of learned throughout the the process of being teacher of the year that um they call it the toy right it's just easier than saying teacher of the year we say toy and I was um emailing my staff one day and I was just saying hey I have something for a toy presentation and then they're like what what kind of toys like they're like are you going to like a like a seminar where you're learning about like like old school toy it was really funny so makes me kind of laugh all right so I started off with this at the very beginning and I want to kind of end

038with it also and so I'm going to um turn the floor over to you and I'll just take a couple um we don't need to have everybody share but um a reminder of what something positive is so something positive can be past present or future and U just kind of short and sweet just what one sentence is plenty uh it could be something kind of bigger news or it could be just something simple like you went out to eat with your family last night so um my positive is that um it's it's kind of like a surreal moment the last couple 48 hours or so uh last night we um handed the torch over to the 2025 teacher of the year uh and then we um my wife and I had a um a a

039long overdue um date night we went to Low's last night downtown and um were able to stay in town and my my parents who are also here I'm right behind my wife there um they were able to to um experience what it's like to get three little children ready for elementary school in the morning so I'm sure it went great but um um I'm going to turn the floor over to you we get a couple positives put you on the spot well it's positive I'm really excited we have all four of our new board members here today so welcome and it makes me feel good awesome let's get one more um I'm really positive that even though I'm leaving this board that I'm going to continue contributing to education and I live in a constitutional

040republic which is a beacon of light for the world so that's my positive awesome thank you so this year I could wrap up as definitely a learning experience and I'm going to share with you what I learned throughout the year and try my best to kind of wrap this this year up of service but um the first thing I want to just leave with you is that it it will be a year that will stay with me forever whether it's professionally as a teacher or as a father or as a husband um I just learned a lot about myself and about my family and about um just like who I am as as a person throughout this experience of being teacher of the year so um it all started back in Lincoln uh last year

041when we um had my own passing into the torch ceremony and I kind of chuckle when I see this picture because um we had a heck of a time trying to keep my my youngest child um uh steady during a presentation where I'm thinking this is not not a great first impression because she's Gott rolling around she had to go to the bathroom during the thing and I'm like oh man this is a bad start but um I look at it now and I see everyone in that picture that just has meant so much to me throughout this whole process and if anything I've learned is is it takes a village and the amount of time that my my family have put into watching my kids or my wife being by herself getting the kids

042ready in the morning just really really means a lot but um this this is one of the things that I I really I think I want to leave um behind for my legacy as teacher of the year is the whole idea of the ripple effect in education every day we have this opportunity to um drop pebbles in the metaphorical ponds of of students and it could be with what we say to them it could be how we how we act how we um uh orchestrate our lessons whatever it may be but thank you yeah mentally prepare here a little bit no pressure okay uh but um this quote's awesome so if you drop a pebble in a pond the ripples go out the test is how big of a stone can you throw in the

043pond and and we think about that in our lifetime we have all these little moments that we we have these Ripple effects that leave Lasting Impressions on students but um my goal as an educator is to as much as possible throw bigger and bigger rocks into into the pond of of these students and just being able to hopefully down the road they realize the the impact that I I was able to leave um in the classroom I I used this quote last night um during my my like outgoing um presentation but it just means a lot to me so be where your feet are and this to me is is is probably one of the biggest lessons I learned this year and it was you know when I'm at home it's okay to just be

044a dad and understand that like it was if if I was there with my kids I I wasn't supposed to be somewhere else like answering an email or trying to respond to something because as teacher of the year it can be a little bit overwhelming sometimes you're trying to teach your kids I always use the example of area of a trapezoid because I think it's funny but like um uh but teaching kids about trapezoids but at the same time trying to answer this email to someone that that wants a presentation done or trying to make sure um my kids are taken care of or my wife is is feeling cared for and so just the whole idea of being where your feet are to me means that it's it's okay when I'm at home to

045just just let School sit sit aside it's okay when I'm at school to focus on just school and not worry about basketball or not worry about teacher of the year stuff and and it even went a step further when I was at presentations like I was like hey I'm here so I'm going to be here I'm going to enjoy this moment I'm going to have fun um probably one of the best groups to present to was the high school age kids and it makes me really hopeful for the future of our education in Nebraska because there's a lot of kids that are considering education that we had a lot of fun this year presenting to them so the whole idea of being where your feet are is enjoy the moment while it lasts because before

046you know it it's it's all all said and done now this one's kind of funny when you think about middle school kids okay so a Shepherd should smell like his sheep um now I laugh because middle school kids can kind of be stinky sometimes but uh this whole idea to me was that um I still need to be in the thick of of of things I still need to be in immersed in my classroom it can be easy um even with with as a teacher to be distracted by this and to to put that in the desk and to say okay I'm going to I'm going to be among my students I'm going to be among my class um my team uh my colleagues my family um that that whole idea is just a really

047a really important idea to me of being immersed and being present in what you're doing so the the final lesson that I learned I feel like is the uh the by far the biggest one is the idea of priority so here's my visuals I have a a couple different supplies here so just give me a second okay so I have this container and in this container is a bunch of sand I'm hope oh man if I make a mess here this could get really dicey really fast all right there we go okay so there's a bunch of sand and there's some marbles on top of that and I'm going to use this one to kind of demonstrate what um I learned about my priorities so in life we have some um bigger priorities right we

048have our family my wife my kids and they're going to be now first of all I love pickle ball anyone anyone pickle ball is a lot of fun so uh my family my kids uh my wife it could be as simple as my faith and then go one one more here um my my made my mentorships that I have in my life so right now they all have room to fit maybe not the greatest but they all fit and if we um uh get our priorities kind of out of whack what happens sometimes is that um it's harder to fit those things so I have some other things in my life that are still big priorities but maybe not as big as the um the metaphorical pickle balls here right right so these would be

049things like my job my coaching responsibilities maybe mowing the yard sometimes um all those things so that's right I got to be careful not to make a mess all right there we go okay so as I I F all these here now the one thing I want to point out and I'm a math teacher right my wife made made sure I did this right but this is the same amount of marbles as it is in this container too that that'll come in handy later in this presentation so and then the last things in life are the things that you know they're fun to do but maybe we know we shouldn't put them at the top of our priority list um so that would be for me once again like pickle ball maybe watch that new

050Netflix show and as I put those things into my life and prioritize those things this is where I gota be really careful not to make a huge mess sorry awkward you guys get you get the point there right okay so as I place those things in my life they still fit and um for me throughout the the teacher their experience what what I kind of learned pretty quickly probably mid-February was that when I try to place everything that maybe isn't as important but still kind of fun into life first like the sand and then I place the other things like my job my coaching responsibilities and housekeeping items whatever it may be second and then as I start to place those more important things in my life what happens is that at some point it

051I can no longer fit the important things and like it was a realization for me that yes it's cool being teacher of the year like awesome experience I I would highly recommend it to anyone that's considering it it's it's changed my life in a lot of ways but at the end of the day me being a dad and a husband and a father like a mentor those are the most important things to me and so priorities have like and I had to learn it the hard way sometimes like get I mean the hardest part about teacher of the year I'll be honest is doing sub plans like you're missing school and then you get back to school and it's like where were we at and I like well I was talking to these people in

052Lincoln and it's just it's just a a very very stressful at times job but when I kept my priorities in line that's when I felt like I was I was doing a lot better job um as teacher of the year and not just that but as a father and a husband so this is my my parting gift to you and this is really special to me for a lot of reasons so this goes back to my seventh grade year in middle school and um I still have this paper so her name was Miss brungart Miss brungart was my teacher in seventh grade and I just recently reached out to her letting her know that I was going to do this at my presentation at the state school board meeting and so this paper it used

053to be red okay so that's how long I've had this paper uh and it says Scott Phillips at the top of it and this kind of goes back to my my my seventh grade year we walk into the room now keep in mind this is prior like one to one so all we had was a bunch of Kleenex boxes on our tables and in front of those Kleenex boxes was a stack of like little white papers and we went around and U Miss brungart told us to go ahead and write one positive thing about each person in the room and it couldn't be um based on like the material items so you couldn't say like I like your sweatshirt or I like your your shoes and so um then we had to put those all

054in the different boxes and at the end of class Miss brungart grabs all the boxes and she like walks out of class see you later and then like that was it and we're like okay what why did we do that um and then a couple months later she surprised all of us by giving us a type up of all the positive things written on there so as I I I've kept this and keep in mind when I was in seventh grade I didn't know I was going to be a teacher it wasn't like I kept this saying like I I'm going to keep this because someday I'm going to use this when I'm presenting to people like that's not why I kept it I kept it because it meant a lot to me and and

055it's it's the value of this may be a penny right it's a piece of paper and a sleeve protector but um it meant a lot to me to keep this because of the fact that um things I read on this list about myself at the time in seventh grade I did not believe about myself and so that to me teaches about the Power of Words how much words can change um in a in a positive way so um what I do in inste grade is I give um a paper like this and a sleeve protector to each one of my students at the end of the school year and um I have a little bit easier access to with technology to have the kids type it up and it's a little bit easier for me

056unlike Miss brungart had to like physically type all these in there but um I do it the day before Christmas which is like a really good life hack for teachers right like you want the day before Christmas is kind of chaotic as a teacher when kids do this they're all like super quiet and like I wonder what someone writing about me so they all write about each other and then it takes me a while like I'm going to guess probably 2 hours per class period to prepare this but then I I go through and I I put all them on a piece of paper I put them inside side of a a sleeve protector for the kids and I give it to the students on the very last day of school so like the last

057day of school also a little bit chaotic right as a teacher and that's a great way for me to say you know great job this year here's what your students wrote and then when you give it a little bit of time too like the kids kind of forget what they wrote for each other which helps a little bit too so they're not they're not super concerned about it um but I've seen some impactful moments with this this is like my by far my favorite thing I do with my students and this is just a generic example that I chose but the next one I'm going to show you is a pretty special example to me because this one look how much more depth there is to that now the the cool story about this was

058I gave this to this young lady in seventh grade a few years ago and she's just sitting there and she's reading all these things and just just balling and the cool thing about this young lady was that she wrote a detailed description for every one of her classmates okay so sorry um so that ripple effect we talk about is teachers like it means much more than just teaching them standards and like I I I really care about teaching them standards and teaching them about math but at the end of the day I care about who they are as people so we're GNA we're be okay all right so I um prepared some for you and these are all written by um a variety of people some of them are from your peers um some of

059them are from potentially from family members and the fun thing is you do not know who wrote what all right so don't worry about it don't be like oh I wonder who wrote this um and uh at the bottom of it I wrote I wrote a little message for myself but I want you to hold on to this and just keep this and just know that that I truly appreciate everybody so my lovely assistant my wife this is Carissa my wife so she's going to help me pass these out all right so all I'm going to ask is this is just this kind of the way I handle it in class too is I just want you for about 30 seconds to just take we're going to have a it's going to be kind of

060quiet in here it's going to be okay a little awkward but um I just want you to take 30 seconds just to read what people wrote for you and um yeah just just we'll give it a quiet 30 seconds here for all right so the the picture you see on the screen is um last year's group of kids and this is like so so first of all the deaths are all randomly placed in my classroom it's the last day of school right we're kind of getting things put away and picked up and like you could hear a pin drop in that room and so every year I kind of like quietly snap a picture um because I just want to remember that how much how much words mean so I'm going to stop talking before

061I just start losing it here but um I I truly appreciate the support and just the opportunity to represent the state this year thank you [Applause] thank you Scott um you might hold your tissue box closed because I'm I'm actually gonna open this up now for um some responses from our filow board members here so yes Lisa um thank you for not only touching the hearts of your students but everybody that meets you you understands how sincere you are how compassionate you are how caring you are to anyone that you meet but especially teaching your students and going Beyond to care for them as individuals I'll never forget the detailed note that you wrote to me um at the beginning of your journey and thank you for who you are what you do and what

062you will do in the future thank you Scott would you would you mind sharing what was on your list yeah yep because I think probably the kinds of things I might say to you are probably things that other people have already said to you uh keep mind I'm a seventh grader okay so no judging here and you've changed oh we we'll see here um they said he is smart you are very kind to all people a good athlete helpful and a good friend this where get kind of funny um um a loud Yeller enthu enthusiastic uh this was a compliment in middle school but they called me a beast that was cool back in the day um awesome guy that likes to eat um I told you it gets kind of weird um awesome sense

063of humor smart and hardworking fun and talk to and a good listener cool funny really nice friendly uh good at sports caring and a Gentleman py and then we'll go to Sher well I'll keep this as one of my last Impressions although I hope it is the last impression that I have the opportunity to get but I still have my note in my planner which is the first impression so um you are a force to be reckoned with I love the the comment that you are a beast and I bet I might have liked math if I had you you're a teacher I'd put money on it but thank you so much for being so um open to us I think sometimes people come here and they go oh they're the State Board of Education

064you know and they go quick and slam uh who they really are slam the door of who they are I don't feel that way about you you open the door wide and so many things you said resonated with me and changed me and thank you for being here and I just want to say say Well done our good and faithful teaching servant thank you and I just want to say I this past year you've inspired me in so many ways but you also let me uh think about things from a different perspective and from one of the most important perspectives you know I mean you're uh on the ground uh you know in the trenches every day and I you do amazing work and uh really grateful to you and your wife and your family

065because I know uh you know what you're doing takes time and energy and I'm glad you have found a way to make sure that you're prioritizing the important things but just really grateful thank you all right Scott thanks so much I just want to add to you who you are what I see you as is you're a force multiplier and you are Rippling out so thank you for that thank you for your service to our state this year and blessings to your family this holiday season and going forward thanks for coming thank you to your wife too and your parents yeah and I am going to turn this back over to the commissioner thank you well done Scott thank you and I knew I knew you would do something like this I didn't know what

066You' do because I never know what you would do but I knew we needed something exciting and riveting after you were done and so I thought the best thing we could do just take a break just take a break actually this is kind of the time when we usually take a little break and what I'd like to do is then give that opportunity for one last um handshake or pat on the back to Scott um and the board will I'm going to give us time because I it's important we will reconvene at 1010 so we're going to take a 10-minute break so the board is on recess e e e we will resume the board meeting in two minutes e if board members could resume their seats we'll start in just a minute okay if

067you would please take your seats we will resume the board meeting tell me when you're ready and te we got to be our that's right well welcome back uh we will conclude the commissioner's Report with uh a a report on our Esser funding our Esser achievements and our next steps with to do that we will have Lane Carr Lane good morning everybody that is a really tough act to follow um but in a way we are celebrating our achievements here as well around our Esser Investments and it's really hard to believe that in just two short months it will be the 5-year anniversary of the first covid lockdowns and as you know these three rounds of funding um have been a result or were a result of that and a response to um to that

068crisis really that we were facing 5 years ago and then subsequently right so my goal today our goal today is to share just a little bit more about again sort of this highlevel overview of the Esser funding as we're wrapping a bow around it and sort of thinking about what's next I want to share the immense successes that we have been responsible and I say we because this board made decisions about reallocations for Esser funds um and also for where those Investments of those Statewide priorities should be I want to also share a little bit about how some of these projects are continuing and how we've sustained them there's this discussion about the Esser Cliff that we are at and in a lot of ways we've used other grant funding reallocated or reappropriated internal dollars

069to keep some of the projects that we saw high impact forward and then answer any questions that there might be if there are three takeaways that I would have you walk away from this presentation it's the responsiveness of our Esser funding Investments it's that we've taken to heart the lessons that we've learned from these Esser funds and it's the lasting impact that these investments will have so just as a reminder of this there were three rounds of Esser funds and our focus is really going to be on this third portion which was the American Rescue plan you see that the vast majority of the money again rolled right through our districts to our districts who did incredible work and hard work with these funds investing them in high high quality instructional materials in resources for

070students in mental health supports in their teachers and their professional development and so much more that story continues to be told and we need to work with our districts to tell those stories about the Deep Impact that those dollars had but we're going to really focus in on that last portion the nde set aside which all told was a close to 70 or 80ish million dollar so a lot of money focused in on how we can create Statewide structures and processes to respond to the crisis as we zoom in a little bit further you'll see that there was a specific requirement for some of these dollars to be spent for summer and after school programs I'll speak to how we allocated those funds and the impact of those dollars we had a important use of

071funds focused specifically on evidence-based interventions this was a requirement of the ARP Sr dollars and that EV in space had a very specific definition from the US Department of Education and then there was some flexibility around emergency use being able to respond quickly to things uh that we saw pop up at the state level for our schools after the passage of the American Rescue plan we very quickly went through a process of gaining feedback from the state of Nebraska we had already uh begun this process with the two prior tranches of funds but we're focused on now that we've had a minute a year actually uh for us to go through the investment of Statewide funds what what should we be doing with this again massive amount of federal dollars in ARP Esser so we

072had 14 Roundtable sessions we put out a second survey and from that we found that there were five key priorities that we wrote into our um plan this was the only time that we had to have a plan approved by the US Department of Education for these funds and that was approved in 2021 and focus on these five areas Comprehensive Mental Health Services a focus on family and Community engagement zeroing in on the teacher Pipeline and professional learning addressing unfinished learning and supporting acceleration and then focusing on our systems here at the department so that we can reduce some of that burden on our schools and they can focus their time instead on the important tasks of teaching and learning so that was what guided our uh and informed our decisions and your decisions as

073we move forward over the next now almost four years a a little bit about the timeline here again I won't spend too much time other than the last two bullets which is that the timeline is sort of up and you'll see a little asterisk by the September 2024 in that the feds allowed for some flexibility to carry forward projects that were already in the works that just needed a little bit more time to continue and I'll speak to that here momentarily the vast majority of our funding has been spent the vast majority of our schools funding has been spent or is it planned to be spent out by January of 2025 so as I was speaking to you about sort of the Tak homes that I want you to walk away with I want to

074start by saying we were very intentional on how we allocated These funds for Statewide purposes I shared just an example of the tools that we used to identify schools that might need uh more resources than others this is an example of a a map that we created that showed uh triangulated certain data points to say here are some sites that might have a special need and so that is one way I think that we were um specific speically responsive additionally we have been thinking from the very beginning about the return on investment so making sure we're not just throwing money on the wall and uh throwing out activities out there but making sure that they have a plan that that plan is grounded in evidence and that we're then spending a lot of time evaluating

075those outcomes and a focus on continuous Improvement this is a quote from a mental health provider uh that we again funded through a school district and through an ESU a focus on continuous Improvement and making our systems better so that when these funds are over AKA right now we have a better system than we did prior to the use of these funds so that's just a little context and now I'm going to walk through a few a very few of the contracts some of the projects and the impact that we've had so I start with those summer and after school dollars that I mentioned earlier in all we had about $1 million for summer and after school projects that reached across the state as you can see in this map we had new sites that

076we called um incubators these are sites the green that had never had a 21st century Community Learning Center or any sort of out of after school programming prior to Esser funds again we wanted to make sure that we were deepening the the projects that already had those those are called the accelerators and those are blue but we wanted to show some of our school districts what they might be missing with some of this after school and summer school potential we're really proud of the impact that these had we saw that almost 10,000 more students were served over the last three years with these dollars across the state again a large uh portion of locations in rural areas and we've seen that those sites have continued even afterwards they've used private foundations in in their in

077their own school districts they've applied for the first time for 21st Century Learning center Grants from us theyve found a way to keep these projects moving there's a little bit more here kind of breaks down the difference between again those accelerator sites which are ones that had uh had students already had programs already and then those in the incubators that were brand new so that was a huge portion we had to spend money on summer and after school and we knew that time was such a valuable resource so making sure that these programs were high quality was was critical for us too another big portion of our funding was spent on mental health support and this came in the shape of tiered support So ensuring tier one uh recognition of needs for students and training

078for teachers and for staff and understanding mental health needs and things that we can do in the classroom to support our students a little bit better we also provided funding to esus and to districts for tier 2 and tier three supports meaning several districts were able to hire licensed mental health practitioners counselors or other or or have part-time uh staff come in and be able to support uh student and staff mental health you'll see a we have tons of testimonials we we knew that schools had a need it popped up right away several of the schools too that we have visited over the last year have mentioned that they saw this great need in their schools continue to see mental health as a top priority and having a licensed mental health practitioner in the building

079full-time oftentimes they were able to use our dollars and their own dollars to blend that together make sure that students had access you can see it re resulted for this um this in school provider in staff and students having a better access to problem solving abilities so that's an incredible amount of work that was again our the work was happening in our schools and we were able to sort of be around the outside and saying here are some of the things that we think should be part of this but we want you to locally design that and we then took on the uh the important job of evaluating all of this as well a project that continues is the Nebraska growing readers project it was so nice to have a first lady pillin at our

080Teacher of the Year banquet last night and as you recall this time last year um the first lady and commissioner kicked off our Nebraska growing readers project we've subsequently added dollars to this project a couple of times using these Esser funds aligned again to your priority around literacy but the the end all Beall with this project is to eliminate book deserts within our state and ensuring that all families have access to at least 100 books is such a critical part of a child's development and it's fun to be able to show you this map and say that over 800,000 books have been distributed at this point at 1100 sites across the state focused in again on our early childhood centers Elizabeth we need a little help in mcferson County Arthur County Etc I did notice

081that all of the deserts that remain are in District s we have some time another cool offshoot of this has been kindergarten Outreach so it we originally had intended to reach 3,000 incoming uh kindergarteners this year and we got to almost 3,200 uh with 200,000 books directly distributed to those kindergarteners one of the fun Parts about the growing readers is that there is Nebraska isation of it I made that a word in that nebras Nebraska teachers Nebraska parents Nebraska uh staff Nebraskans are able to write books as well we had a really cool project and if you go to the growing reader website you will see a mother who has a student with a disability was able to write about that student and the special um uh connection that she has with him she also

082then recorded it her reading it so that students across the state can access and see her in her own voice speaking about herself son it's really cool if you're interested in writing a book let me know cuz we can make that happen Switching gears slightly I am really proud of the focus that and the refocus that came from the board the board uh said hey we need to make sure that we're spending uh ample time and energy on focusing on the teacher shortage this came about a couple of years ago and we're really pushed by you to think through what this could look like we created the teacher shortage Grant and we're excited to have several University Partners in the back uh who led this work and were able to be highlighted and show the

083impact that these dollars had you'll see just some of the partners here on the screen and the work that they did ranged from Recruitment and Retention efforts training uh and engagement and from that we were able to say hey we we think we have something here with this parad to teacher pipeline let's think about what that could look like and from that building into the apprenticeship grants that we've been able to now uh double down on over the last couple of years so it started with these ideas it started with this laboratory in our higher education and District Partnerships and now has led to a sustained effort uh into the future here with not only a state appropriation we're very thankful for that but also this Federal grant focused on teacher apprenticeships and then importantly

084too is the learning that we have from these programs Remains the impact evaluations the tools that have been created the curriculum that has been created for educators Rising for example continues to be sustained and we have that now as a tool that our students for the next several years will be able to to use and and take advantage of I'm going to keep going and share a little bit about our community schools pilot programs we were able to think of ways to open the doors for our schools so that parents so that community members and so that Community providers could be engaged in the school day and providing support for our students and our staff during the school day I'm going to share just three of the examples and how every Community School is different

085right and that's the point it's about the community and the local need in our pilot program we had three sites we had Grand Island that really leveraged these dollars to expand Early Childhood support they did not have enough funding and they had a massive childcare need and we're able to use the school structure use private dollars use School dollars and then use these Esser funds to ramp up the child care services that they provided in Skyler we saw uh some really cool work around translation services and supporting parents in being involved in their school schools and their students schools even when they don't speak the language that their teachers do so having that translation support was critical for Skyler and we also saw a mobile Vision Clinic able to come to all of the elementaries

086and provide uh after parents said yes right we want this uh having our students being able to have their Vision checked and get glasses on the spot if necessary and then in Fremont they focus in on community engagement we want to make sure our parents are in our schools that they're contributing to our schools that they're helping in our schools that we're being responsive to their needs Etc so that was really again laboratory in action but an immense study also took place and that uh study the the three years of that study are all on our website similarly we said let's take a slightly different version of this and think about it in a regional perspective so we did a rural version of this Community Schools pilot as well we looked at the same sort

087of needs assessment that might be needed for each community and we said hey do this at a regional level and see what bubbles up and how we can share resources across again we saw great results we saw um districts come together we saw counties come together to pool resources as a region which as we know is really important for our rural sites again switching somewhat gears here again we were so proud of the amount of energy time and effort that our districts spent and also resources on highquality instructional materials you'll see in our um in our graph here there's some information about how many students had access to in the elementary middle school and high school grades high quality instructional materials and you'll see afterwards how many almost 100,000 students now have access and that

088was you know as they were adopting into this year I'm sure that that adoption process that locally controlled adoption process for these materials continues over this next year and we could see that number even Skyrocket further so that was at our district level and we were able to provide the guidance we were able to provide some shaping to that conversation I could speak in depth about each of these projects but I will not I'll be brief here and say that another thing that we were able to do is focus in on again some pretty nuanced academic needs so tntp was able to support us with two two things multiple things one was a focus on secondary Learners in the science of reading so we talk a lot about Early Childhood science of reading we know

089that fourth fifth sixth seventh Beyond graders who are struggling with reading also need support and our teachers need that training to be able to do that that was one of the projects that tntp was able to support us with we haven't spoken much about math and I'm sorry for that commissioner as a former math teacher sorry Scott as the math teacher right but math has been an important investment and Nebraska has been on the map a little bit around our work with zern which is a high quality instructional material it's an online uh platform that we made available to all public and non-public schools in the first year and then we able to sustain it for those districts that wanted it into the second year and then used Innovation dollars in the third year for

090an even smaller cohort zern has used our Statewide model and our data to show the impact that these uh that the that the tool has for others and instruction Partners has helped create coherence within our agency making sure that across the mtss work across multiple different divisions within our agency and offices that we have created some coherence so that our services to our schools what we provide to our schools is aligned with each other and we're not speaking different different languages when we're going out to work with our schools I should have noted that I am the person who's presenting on this but I actually did very little if not any of this work so many of the people sitting over here along this wall and those several that are not here um did this

091hard work of managing and ensuring that the quality that we got from all of this money was there and also that there was a a strong evaluation component to each part of this promise I'm about to wrap up here and just want to note to another critical part of all of this was the cross agency collaborations and Partnerships that we were able to build one that I'm really excited about is the Nebraska Center for the education of children who are blind or visually impaired we were asked by them hey you know do you have a van nde that we could use and we were like what do you mean what do you mean by that and they're like well ours is rusted out and unsafe for kids we said well we don't have a van

092but we can use these Esser funds we'll partner with you we'll partner with ESU for and we'll get that I was looking to Amy but I think that that van should be here by December and we're really excited to be able to ensure that our students uh um in the Southeastern corner of the state have safe uh compatiable transportation for themselves that's something that is going to last right that is something that will last for for several years similarly we worked really closely with the Y rtc's what we noticed when we were working with them previously under Dr fren's leadership was that there was not coherent curriculum across the different sites so we were able to use Esser funds work in partnership with DHHS to purchase highquality instructional materials for all of the sites and

093ensuring that there's consistency and coherence across each of the Y rtc's we we also bought some really cool uh career exploration tools for our Y rtc's and several of our rule 18 schools those are those interim program schools making sure again that students even when their education may not be the top priority they might be getting Recovery Services or intensive services at these sites that they still have access to the same high quality education opportunities so thankful for our esus uh and all of this but specific around professional learning to support high quality instructional materials building on those partnership conversations we were able to work with Nebraska Children and Families Foundation to stand up some specific expertise around these four areas and similarly to the Nebraska Chamber Foundation to have an education and Workforce alignment

094specialist that was Dr suin or is Dr suin from previously from Millard and he had presented to this group a few uh year to the board a few years ago or a few months ago and continues his work kind of being a bridge and also a translator of here's what Educators need here's what the workforce is saying how can we keep that moving we also have a ton of resources that have been built out again that is another piece of the sustainability conversation how we've ke kept that going so what's next well we are wrapping up but we're also looking forward to some of the last little bit of work that we are doing we successfully received a request for late liquidation is what it's called making sure that the funding is still in our

095bank account so that we can access it for the projects that we have outlined in this plan and a couple of those projects are ones that you should be familiar with focusing in again these literacy Partnerships that are really kind of laying the foundation for the clsd grant to take off right un unk and the University of Nebraska Lincoln each with sort of a different flavor around that I'm excited to share to two final Investments that will have a lasting impact in the CTE space one is focused on uh helping students and helping businesses matchmake in work-based learning experiences the Nebraska workplace portal and then the second is Pathways to Career which provides student level or sorry Workforce data labor market data to schools when they're doing the revision process so we know about the

096revision process and how schools are looking at what our community needs what our region needs there hasn't been a consistent way to do that across each region and so we used we developed it we built it using these essr funds to make sure that all of our schools have the same level of access to data to know what their CTE program should be focused on to meet their community's future needs you may have seen a couple of conversations in the paper recently about American Rescue plan hcy which is homeless children and youth this is funding that is similar to the mckin vento dollars but in a lot of ways very different in that these funds were not only went to schools that had mckin vento programs but also beyond that schools that have never had

097um mckin vento dollars for homeless and homeless children and youth but have homeless children and youth and so we needed to make sure that these dollars were going out one of the coolest projects that we were able to to lead um was the second bullet here where we went with our school leaders to Walmarts across the state or to uh local Supply suppliers across the state and families came to those places and were able to get access to back to school gear I was so happy that Scott mentioned how stinky middle schoolers are because we were able to buy deodorant and we were able to buy a Axe Body Spray and all of those things that you know Middle School boys think they need right School Scopes shoes coats all of those things that we

098often take for granted and without these dollars our families would have been without it it was really special to see um how excited our families were how excited our parents were um to be able to do this and have have these resources we were also able to flex very quickly so um when the the horrible tornadoes occurred in North Omaha we were able to use these funds and flex very quickly there were newly homeless children and youth in our state and part of that was around dislocation and they needed just be supported so being able to provide supplies and also being able to provide some mental health support for those students so there's tons of stories each one of these in and of itself could be its own story but I'll just clude by saying

099that our biggest goal is to make sure that we learned from this process that comes in two ways one is evaluating evaluating evaluating and looking at the data to make sure that it has had an impact on the parents on the families on the students and on our staff we're also trying to think about what worked and how can we keep that going so thinking about our uh clsd Grant right the comprehensive literacy State development grant that builds off the progress our safe Grant the the uh apprenticeship Grant building off the progress that we made there we're uh we're excited that it is over right and we are so thankful for the funds that we were able to leverage that have made a real difference for our students so I'll pause there commissioner if you

100have any additional comments there otherwise I'll see if there's any questions any questions from board members I always look left so I'm going to look right this time Sherry do you want to start I know just really a comment and I'm sure you are thinking about this or nde is but as you were reading through these and everything that has been done the word sustainability kept coming up in my brain how to sustain the things that need to be sustained and what are some of the things that have done their good and okay we're okay with how is that going to be addressed or have you considered that sure your your your comment summed it up there were some things that these were recovery dollars it was meant to be let's pour some funds into

101this to make sure our kids get back to where they were and Beyond and in a lot of ways we think we've done some of that so some of it will just be done and that's okay and we want to learn from those processes um so that God forbid we have another crisis that we need to be able to respond to we're hoping we can do that even better but sustainability share is critical we've been thinking about a lot of the other federal grants that we could pursue we're we're again have already received several of those federal grants and then also internally what can we do around some of our federal dollars that might be a little bit more discretionary for us to be able to focus in on those things that worked Lisa you

102were so thorough I just have one quick question with the after school programs when I was a part of it oh 12 years ago or so um I remember one on-site visit per year and I just wondered what the other evaluated tools are for those programs you bet so we matched our we didn't want our sites to have to do stuff that was different from our 21st century Community Learning Centers so we match matched the evaluations so that included um student data so attendance data behavioral data things like that that we were already collecting for 21st century as well as pre and post surveys for students and and families and our report for 21st century and our report for the uh essr funded after school sites will be on our website soon okay yeah you

103got it anyone else KK where are we at with the upgrade of the computer system and all that was a chunk have any update on that and I don't know if it was These funds it was partially These funds and some of the others as well yeah significant Investments it wasn't something that I mentioned here in our um in our presentation because it is more internal facing right a couple of things that have been really critical are the move to the cloud and that sounds like a a small and easy thing but it is insanely expensive and uh also a really big deal for cyber security which is top of mind for all of us right so that was a huge portion of the fund was moving from a physical location where some of our

104data was living to the cloud where it is more secure I would say we're on the way there and close to there but part of our uh funds that we have asked for additional time to spend out are Focus on on exactly that so we'll be able to report back to you on that and some of the progress most of the progress that we've been able to make over this next year semester what Kurt just said reminded me of something else with the computers um I don't remember what staff member a few months ago said that um some monies were being utilized to instead of hand inputting I don't know if you can answer this so whoever can answer it can tell me later um so that we don't hand put things in that it

105it becomes computerized do you know anything about that and if not that's okay I know very little so we'll find out more for you so because I was hoping because it said accuracy would improve with that and that's been a again it's it's been a significant portion as just the modernization of our systems we had old old systems where we had to manually put things in to now being able to leverage our schools have all of this data that's coming to us every day we want to make sure that we're reducing our touch points to that so that it's clean safe secure and also accurate Lan I had a question um with the ARP hcy funds yes um my question was were we able to utilize some of those funds for homeless youth who live

106in areas that don't have Community Resources yes is the very short answer and the longer answer is that it was it's difficult when these sites had never had a uh TW uh system in place to identify those students in the first place so it it's um often times easier when there's a large space and a person whose job that is in a rural place we know that the person who doing that is also driving the bus coaching teaching Etc so it's it's difficult to find those students identify those students but we were able to do so with these uh hcy process and we also asked for some additional time because once we identified the schools that had those students we said okay go ahead and start serving them and they said how what what does

107that even look like so we were able to get a little bit more time for this extension right here um to to support those schools in supporting those students thank you you got it that concludes my report I was gonna say that was the longest commissioner report we've ever had but because of that you took all my time so no I'm kidding there is no president's report today so we'll now move to our public comment period this period may be available to any person who wishes to address the board on any matter appearing on the agenda up to 90 minutes will be allowed for the public comment period a majority of members present and voting may take action to extend the total time allowed for public comment period a majority of members present and voting

108may also take action to allow or terminate public comment at any time during a meeting if you are not signed in and wish to speak please sign in at this time those wishing to speak must be signed in at the table outside the meeting room each individual speaking to the board will be required to complete a sign-in card for identification of oneself individuals are required to include on the signin card their name address and name of any organization represented individuals may be prohibited to speak in public comment if the signin card does not include the required information persons speaking to the board during public comment should State their name city and state at the beginning of their allotted time and may submit printed materials for the board but may not use any other form of

109media anyone refusing to be identified will be prohibited from speaking each person may address the board for up to five minutes a majority of members present voting present and voting may take action to reduce or extend the amount of indiv ual time allotted to all speakers if at any time persons appearing before the board exceed the time limitations set forth in this policy or on the agenda or become abusive or threatening in language or behavior it shall be the responsibility of the president to refuse permission to continue to address the board we have one public comment submitted and vice president ner will announce the names Nancy Packard if you'd come forward thank you I'm Nancy Packard of Lincoln Nebraska and uh what who do I represent grandparents parents and teachers of America um uh this

110is fortuitous that I came into this talk about uh media because I have a grand I have eight grandchildren but and all of them as much as we try all of them are on media too much and uh I was with my 12-year-old grandson recently and try not to you know it's it's hard to not be saying get off your phone are you still on your phone it's hard to think of what to say so I remembered that I've heard that very very few children are not using media there are few parents who are able to do it and it's not necessarily successful I can't speak to that I don't know how accurate that is but I do in my experience there are very few who do not use media and this time I said

111to Oliver um um there's no control group and he said what and I said um Oliver I heard that almost no um children are there are almost no children in America who are not on the media and I and I probably asked him if he knew of any and he Pro and he wouldn't probably and I said um you know you're just at the age when your brain is changing and developing and all the children it seems like all the children are using media and we don't know how that's going to turn out because there's no control group there's nobody we can compare it to this group is not using it and all of these are so we don't know what's happening to your brain well I said it's timely because tomorrow if Oliver follows

112through he's going to come and we're going to make a a wrap about their's a no there's no control group for our Christmas party um so I wanted to say that there is no control group we don't know what's happening to brains we're just watching it oh I wonder what's going to happen when they're all 30 um the uh uh two points I wanted to make are for parents I I don't know how I don't understand I want to continue to come to the state school board meetings I don't understand what author you have but I know you have great Authority somehow and um if you can help all parents to um in support of not using media because every parent is by himself trying to figure this out every parent is it's it's something

113parents shouldn't have to do and teachers in classrooms are doing the same thing too they it's it's um it's a terrible thing to do to parents and grandparents and teachers and mostly children so that's all I have to say thank you thank you there is no written public comment submitted at this time is there a motion to adopt the consent agenda I move to adopt the consent agenda it has been moved and seconded to adopt the consent agenda per board policy there is no discussion on the motion to adopt the consent agenda would the recording secretary please call the role Gobles yes Neri yes cojon yes Jones yes fricky yes Penner yes T Meer yes seven yes one vacant the affirmative has it and the consent agenda is adopted the next item of business are

114the reports of the standing committees item 7.1 I'll report on behalf of of the executive committee meeting the executive committee reports on the December 5th 2024 meeting of the committee members present were chair Elizabeth higm and vice chair Deb ner the committee reviewed one action item for a contract for state board team building training nine proposals were received the committee recommends the board approve a contract with the National Association of state boards of Education nasbe to perform this service the committee had two information items first the committee reviewed a report on systems involved Youth and discussed potential legislation to implement the findings from the report and second the committee reviewed received an update on the current collective bargaining process this concludes the executive committee report Elizabeth T Meer chair reporting are there any questions on

115the executive committee report Patty not not a question but I guess just a a concern a piece of advice for the future that uh you know I certainly understand our bylaws say as a president that you can expend a certain amount of money without board approval but I also know that we all sign a conflict of interest form and in this case there were nine um proposals submitted there were two people you and Deborah who made the recommendation and one of those organizations the one that was recommended obviously you sit on that board in my my way of thinking the appropriate thing would be for you to have recused yourself and have someone else help make that recommendation because and and that I mean obviously I know you're planning to abstain from voting but it's

116also part of that selection process as which organization was recommended so just something really to think about in terms of the future we we talk about and I know transparency is something that you have talked about as being very important and I think to not be in the position where it may appear that an organization was given prefer preferential treatment because of your connection with them just to protect yourself to protect the board perhaps recuse yourself and have someone else fill that role for you thank you for that um just so all the bo all seven board members know I received the file I reviewed them and without any comment sent them on to vice president ner for her to review and make recommendations and she pulled out too that she felt were the top

117two we had a conversation and both agreed on the nasb um proposal and so it was a joint effort and as you did say I am going to abstain from voting and just did take my seat this November on the nasbe executive board as the new member rep so um I don't have a long-term affiliation but I appreciate that feedback from you anybody else have comments on the executive committee report is there a motion on item 7.1 pointa yes I move to approve a contract for state board team building training with the National Association of state boards of Education I second it has been moved and seconded to approve a contract for state board team building training with the National Association of state boards of education is there any discussion on this motion I guess

118the only comment I would make is that I appreciate this training that will be um Coming forth with having four new members on the board I think this is um just a will be a valuable proactive kind of development time for us so I appreciate this training thank you all right seeing no further comments the motion is to approve a contract for state board team building training with the National Association of state boards of Education with the recording secretary please call the role Penner yes Gobles yes cojon yes Jones yes ner yes freaky yes T Meer abstain six yes one abstain one vacant the affirmative hasset and the motion to approve a contract for state board team building training with the National Association of state boards of education is adopted agenda item 7.2 chair pat

119coj will report on behalf of the budget and finance committee meeting py the budget and finance committee reports that at its Thursday December 5th meeting members present were paty Coons Lisa fricky Sher Jones and Patty gobbles the committee reviewed one action item for two contracts related to the state assessment award enhancing the instructional value of Statewide assessments the committee recommends board approval of this item the committee reviewed two discussion items including the monthly board report expenses noting no concerns the other discussion item was an update from nde staff related to a contract for the Improvement Grant learning plan platform the committee supported the nde staff recommendation to not move forward with this contract at this time last the committee reviewed two information items including the update on the implementation of the computer science and technology

120education funds and a potential contract that may come to the board in February after the procurement process is complete the the other item reviewed was the first quarter monthly budget status update this concludes the budget and finance committee report py Coon's chair are there any questions on the budget and finance committee report okay any questions on the reports in item 7.2.8 is there a motion on item 7.2 pointb yes Madam chair I moveed to authorize the commissioner to enter into contracts using US Department of Education cgsa funds to carry out Grant activities second it is moved and seconded to authorize the commissioner to enter into contracts using US Department of Education cgsa funds to carry out Grant activities is there any discussion on the motion the motion is to authorize the commissioner to enter into

121contracts using US Department of Education cgsa funds to carry out Grant activities would the recording secretary please call the role T Meer yes yes Co John's yes ner yes fricky yes Jones yes Penner yes Gobles yes seven yes one vacant the affirmative has it and the motion to authorize the commissioner to enter into contracts using US Department of Education cgsa funds to carry out Grant activities is adopted agenda item 7 point 2. C board members are there any questions or discussion on this item okay agenda item 7.3 chair Sher Jones will report on behalf of the planning and evaluation committee meeting thank you president techm the meeting and the planning and evaluation committee reports on their committee meeting on December 5th 2024 the members present were Patty UB debor ner py cojon and chair Sher

122Jones the committee reviewed three action items with nde staff providing summaries and answering questions related to a rule 11 teacher waiver request assessment and Reporting plan and assessment technical report and model policy for authorized security Personnel carrying firearms the committee recommends board approval on these three items the committee reviewed an action item related to the nebras Nebraska literacy project plan the committee recommends no action at this time to allow additional time to answer questions and address concerns which have recently Arisen and I'm going to take the Liberty to add to this script on this particular item in regard to the literacy project plan as a board we understand the gravity and importance of having a wellth thought out plan including how to execute it with Fidelity and effectiveness especially considering the sizable amount of the

123money being allocated which is over $55 million I look forward to our board being able to put our stamp of approval on the final plan developed by nde staff and I acknowledge and thank them for the work they have already done um on this so thank you continuing on with the script the committee reviewed informational items related to rule 11 teacher waiver requests for two school districts nde staff will bring these items to a future meeting for discussion and subsequent approval this concludes the planning and evaluation report are there any questions on the planning and evaluation committee report is there a motion on item 7.3 pointa yes Madam chair um I moved to approve the rule 11 teacher waiver request for Weeping Water Public Schools I second the motion it is moved and seconded to

124approve the rule 11 teacher waiver request for Weeping Water Public Schools is there any discussion on this motion okay seeing do you have one no okay all right seeing none the motion is to approve the rule 11 teacher waiver request for Weeping Water Public Schools with the recording secretary please call the rule tag Meer yes ner yes Co Johns yes Penner yes Gobles yes Jones yes fricky yes seven yes one vacant the affirmative has it in the motion to approve the rule 11 teacher waiver request for Weeping Water Public Schools is adopted agenda item 7.3 is there motion on 7.3 point B I move to adopt the assessment and Reporting plan and assessment technical report for 2425 I'll second the motion is moved and seconded to adopt the assessment and Reporting plan and assessment technical

125report for the 2425 year is there any discussion on the motion okay seeing none the motion is to adopt the assessment and Reporting plan and assessment technical report for 2024 2025 would the recording secretary please call the role Jones yes fricky yes Neri yes T Meyer yes Co Johns yes Gobles yes Penner yes seven yes one vacant the affirmative has it and the motion to adopt the assessment and Reporting plan and assessment technical report for 2024 2025 is adopted agenda item 7 point 3 point C the committee recommends no action at this time agenda item seven .3 pointd is there a motion on this item yes I move to approve the model policy for authorized security Personnel carrying firearms in accordance with Nebraska revised State Statute 28-1 12404 is there a second oh second sorry

126it's moved and seconded to approve the model policy for authorized security Personnel carrying firearms in accordance with Nebraska revised Statute 28-240 4 is there any discussion on this motion P yes Madam chair I I just want to um Express appreciation for the thorough process that was used and the number of of important stakeholders who who were involved in the process and Who provided advisement um this is a an important but complex kind of policy so thank you for all of that thoughtful effort would the recording secret oh the motion is to approve the model policy for authorized security Personnel carrying firearms in accordance with Nebraska revised Statute 28-24 .04 with the recording secretary please call the rooll Gobles yes freaky yes Penner yes tag Meer yes Co Johns yes Jones yes ner yes seven yes

127one vacant the affirmative has it and the motion to approve the model policy for authorized security Personnel carrying firearms in accordance with Nebraska revised statute 28-1 124.401 and Elizabeth techm committee members reviewed the rules report on their own a public hearing was held December 3rd for revisions to rule 21 certification nde staff shared the hearing summary and testimony um public input did not change the process uh or the commissioner's recommendation the committee committee having no concerns um about moving this forward uh recommends approval of the hearing draft a public hearing was held on December 3rd for revisions to rule 24 on endorsements nde staff shared the hearing summary testimony and non-substantive changes that would continue special education endorsements that were proposed to be eliminated in the hearing draft committee members discussed the non-substantive changes and

128recommendations approval of the draft that includes those revisions nde staff provided an update on rule three High ability learning providing the public input draft for committee review the committee recommended staff mve forward with soliciting uh public input on the public input draft and on rule three um the staff person who worked on this did an outstanding job the details um for alignment across the state was much needed it hadn't been looked at since 1998 and so kudos to that department the staff person that worked on that very well written and that concludes my report Thank you Lisa are there any questions on the rules and regulations committee report okay see none is there a motion on item 7.4 pointb yes president tmar I move to approve revisions to rule 21 second it is moved and

129seconded to approve revisions to rule 21 is there any discussion on the motion Patty yes um I I take review of rule changes very seriously and I guess um particularly I I I'll speak to both proposed changes for rule 21 and 24 because the comments I'm making apply to both really last night at the Teacher of the Year celebration I heard reference several times to teaching as a profession that's the lens that I used to review these proposed changes I think even though some of the re the language is nons substantive some of these are pretty substantial changes in terms of maintaining and doing everything we can to Uplift Education as a profession and being very careful to not make changes that really devalue our profession as a profession let me give you a couple

130of examples when we allow individuals to add endorsements without any pedagogy just taking and passing content test that's devaluing our profession because what sets us apart as a profession is that teachers and other Educators have a set of skills and knowledge that is exclusive to them I I don't ever want us making changes that it's already our public already is starting to see teaching as not being a profession that's very troubling to me um another example of this is when we call professional development we give credit for professional development for teaching that's not I'm sorry that's not professional development that's doing the work that you're hired to do I I have grappled with this for the last week I attended the hearing I wanted to hear what other people were saying um and I really

131have been grappling with whether to vote Yes or no I understand the intent of the rule changes you know we're trying to address teacher shortages I appreciate that I appreciate removing the barriers I think it's important to simplify I think we need to be a specific as possible with these rule changes when we make them I don't want my intent is not at all to derail the process that's been worked on my intent is I guess to say as we move forward I hope that we're always in addition to maintaining quality because that's critical and there are some things in here I'm a little concerned about in terms of quality but we also need to be advocates for teaching as a profession right trying to promote minimum teacher pay that's a way that you try

132and continue uplifting our education profession so I I will vote Yes because I think it's important for us to move these forward but I hope again in the future that we really we really use a lens of maintaining and uplifting the important critical profession that we we govern Lisa um thank you for your perspective I wondered Madame President could we call um Brad forward for a question yes Mr do you have I have a specific question yes Le has a specific question could you come thank you um we had a great discussion and your input yesterday was greatly appreciated I want to make sure I heard correctly yesterday that um passing this today um within a year or a year so they can be altered for change is did I hear that right if we

133pass this today anytime the rules of regulations are passed there's always a chance to revise rules in subsequent years the last rule revision to rule 21 was passed by the board in June of 2023 um so about a year and a half timeline so there's always abilities for future boards to change or adjust regulations yes all right I just wanted to verify that fact um we had great discussions great questions I had concerns about part of this and two of the items or three um were legislative mandates so that that's troubling to me um I don't know if they talked to nde I hope they did but um I think it's really important that we put uh these into place knowing that they can be revised with if there are any concerns over this year

134and part of what I'm okay with it says um universities may reduce they don't have to reduce 50% I mean there's so many things in there that uh are good to limit the barriers to teaching so I would encourage our board members to vote for this so we can move forward in getting um teachers qualified teachers into the teaching profession and there are some safeguards um in place so I just think it's important that we pass this today thank you Lisa um yes I think one thing that Lisa said and I hear in um our other report as well is that um they talk about the pedagogy and teaching is not just knowing the material uh a lot of people have a lot of knowledge about something but they would have a great degree of

135difficulty walking into a classroom in 2024 and in the future if they do not know how to teach it and so Lisa you're warning uh this is what I hear from many teachers is that people do not know teachers going into the classroom do not know how to teach what they're teaching they uh not all of them of course but uh I want our radar to be up and all three of us won't be here unless we March in in the year but I want a radar to go up because um and all of you on the board that M here in that learning how to teach a subject is so important and that's the pedagogy and that's what most of this affects so um warning um I well taken y so okay and Deb

136wanted to speak next Brad I actually will have a question for you I'm sorry we're going to keep you in the hot seat because I want some clarification so I'm going to let everybody else speak and then I'll ask mine so I appreciate the discussion uh and the perspectives and um you know where I'm coming from is I spoke with three superintendents one from a accredited private school and two from public schools and both uh are all three uh were highly supportive of the changes that were made and I don't believe that there's anyone on our board or working out in the field or any superintendents that want to do anything that's going to negatively impact the standards that we have for our teachers we all want quality teachers but we also have to face

137the realities of uh today and when those realities change we can change our rules again is my opinion um we and I'm speaking on behalf of both rule changes uh my comments will be the same for both today in any policy there's no way we're going to achieve Perfection ever and we're always going to have people that find challenges with the policy we're presenting and and uh I appreciate that one person did reach out to me maybe you heard from others I only heard from one person that had any concerns out of all of the positive uh feedback for these rule changes and all the many steps to get input from so many different stakeholder groups and so I just respect the fact that um you know like everyone here I want quality expectations for

138our teachers but I also feel like we have to move forward and so I do support both of these rule changes thank you so Brad my question is involving the endorsements so so rule 24 and I know we're not on that one yet but you're here so um rule 24 that would be adding additional endorsements correct I I believe you're referring to adding additional endorsements based on a Content test and that is a a legislative uh component that was added based on State Statute 79810 subsection 3 and it's adding in right right now the commissioner allows for the additional endorsements based upon that state statute to limit that to only individuals that are current teachers or holders of regular teaching certificates which would be the initial standard or professional teaching certificate so teachers who have

139completed what we would consider teacher prep coursework to that in layman's terms correct correct okay thank you for that clarification any other board members okay thank you the motion is to approve revisions to rule 21 would the recording secretary please call the role Gobles yes ner yes fricky yes teg Meer yes Henner yes Co John yes Jones yes seven yes one vacant the affirmative has it and the motion to approve revisions to rule 21 is adopted is there a motion on 7.4 Point C oh yes I do uh this what are we on 7 point oh here it is I got it uh I move to adopt the document titled non-substantive revisions to rule 24 it is it is is moved and seconded to adopt the document titled non-substantive rev revisions to rule 24 is

140there any discussion on the motion yes Lisa in the rules committee Brad explained to us that um they checked with the AG's office to make sure that these were appropriate so they didn't have to have another hearing and so I just wanted everybody to understand that so Thank you Lisa okay seeing no further comments the motion is to adopt the document titled non-substantive revisions to rule 24 with the recording secretary please call the role Penner yes Jones yes fricky yes ner yes Gobles yes teg Meer yes Co John's yes seven yes one bacon the affirmative has it and the motion to adopt the document titled non-substantive revisions to rule 24 is adopted the next items on the agenda items 9.1 through 9.2 are information items and written reports for the board agenda item 10 good

141of the order this section of the agenda is intended for board members to offer informal observations of the work of the state board board members may make brief announcements about attendance at future events for the purpose of informing other board members no business or motions or suggested actions of the board may be offered at this point in the agenda nor should board members engage in substantive discussion about other agenda items or introduce new agenda items and so at this time I would like to recognize um our three outgoing board members um Katy Coons who has been on this board for eight years and has served as a past president Lisa fricky who's also sat on the board for eight years Patty Gobles who has been on the board for four years and served as a

142past president and Jacqueline Morrison who has departed early but served on the board for four years um we appreciate your service um to this board to Nebraskans to students and we also appreciate your representation on various boards and organizations um representing the state board so thank you thank you for that and I'm going to open up the floor for comments since I'm the oldest board member thank you for laughing uh in many ways I just want to say I uh came on this board uh uh not knowing everything that I needed to know and equipped with everything I needed to be equipped with and I've learned so much from Lisa and paty and Patty and uh I just you've made a huge difference I think our board has changed uh and uh I think that

143we are becoming I I just like the changes I've seen I I really feel like we've had um the ability to disagree and have good discussions and learn from each other and change our minds and uh I just think that's so important uh today and anyway I just appreciate all the contributions you've all made to the board and I just you're going to be missed and I know you're all going to stay active in all you know this field and advocating for all the important things that you've been advocating for the last four or eight years uh and so I look forward to our paths Crossing so thank you for your work just make it very short I sincerely wish you all well and I've appreciated getting to know each of you on a personal

144level so thank you so much I I was going to say I also want you three to feel like you can speak to your time together and your time on the board as well so yes Lisa um the past eight years have been a learning curve and as new board members will experience um you learn a lot that first year and so I'm glad to see our board members are here or were here today yeah they're still there uh but I believe especially this last year that we worked as a team and with good leadership from our commissioner Deputy Commissioner and other um the legal input input from Dr fyen but we have a a tremendous staff and we do our homework we read you know at least I read everything and yet there was

145still information provided by staff to enhance my understanding of moving forward and how it can affect our students teachers districts so I want to thank everybody um and I appreciate I would have run again because I I love the uh the work you know policy rules helping Schools teachers and especially students but the political climate is just really hard and I I know we're political but I turn it over to all of you to continue your fantastic work that positively changes and by way of the amount of Grants and funds that that you all have accomplish the differences you've made in districts um is Kudos and I'm sure you'll continue that work to keep improving Nebraska schools for every single student so thank you all well I plan on making good friends with my couch

146and uh watching a lot of movies and eating a lot of chocolate and um after I get tired of that then I'll hunt for a new educational goal um and that might include my two great grandkids and my three grand uh Grand kids uh spending more time with them and um implanting my vast knowledge of the universe to them and hoping that they'll listen uh I I walked out of school eight years ago when I retired and I said to two of my friends I think I'm going to run for the state school board and they were like yeah that'd be great and uh I did it and I have learned as Lisa said so much um throughout the time uh working with this with this board and I uh I think eight years was

147plenty for me because I do want to do all those previous things that I listed in my life um my one granddaughter told me she wanted me to live to be 103 as long as it didn't hurt and um it's it's starting to hurt just a little bit so before I really start hurting I want to do some running around the backyard with them and that sort of thing but you can trust me I'm going to find some things that you guys are working on that I'll want you to know my opinion and I'll be on the other side of the board with my opinion and um I'll bring some uh people with me that I think we feel the same and uh but I'll do it with a great deal of respect because I

148know what it means to be sitting on this side of the board and I walk away wanting each of you to know that just despite the fact that we disagree adamantly on some things we agree on one thing and Kurt and I talked about this just about a few minutes ago our our priority is not some future office is not uh being recognized when you walk down the street oh there's py cojan she's on the state Schoolboard people don't know us that way it's not to make money our priority is and always should be the good of the students in Nebraska making them recognized all over the United States for the great education that they have and the great ethics and Ethos that they have coming from our educational process and with that I say

149thank you to people like Ryan for who uh follows the letter of the law and uh commissioner ma Maher for being here and I don't know what you have but you have some kind of magic that makes all of us feel special and every time you talk to me I feel special even if I talk too long I get called on that a lot okay anyway so I'm not going to talk very much longer anymore I do want to thank uh the two people that uh have uh kept me in line uh with my husband being ill um and done all of the um saying can you make it to this can you do this what do you up for lunch I I've got one more minute to call uh those two people have been

150so gracious to me and I have a little gift for both of you after afterwards I'll bring up so not not here but not sometime later okay all right thanks for the Memories it was a good time it was the best time it was a party um I I won't speak very long because I don't want to get in trouble um but but I will say you know coming on to this board four years ago felt like walking into probably one of the most contentious times that have ever existed on this board um it it felt like for a couple of years that it was really difficult to move forward because there were so many distractions and that for me personally and professionally was very frustrating but also the realization that anytime I've been confronted

151with a challenge my Approach is always how do we turn this into an opportunity how do we try to get to a point that we rise above it so we're better for it we've done that and that's impressive right it took us a while we've had some really difficult meetings we've had some difficult times on this board but I think we've learned through that process I I see our board this year functioning very effectively that's so gratifying to know that we were able to to come out of challenging times and to be able to accomplish some very important things over the last several years I appreciate the staff thank you all so much and when I decided not to run for reelection people in Norfork said you have to run for the Norfork School Board

152again and when I decided to do that many of them said to me are you just a glutton for punishment and my response was always I don't think so because my experience on the State Board though it has been at times challenging has also been very fulfilling and I take that with me to the next experience so thank you okay thank you and I have been signal that the commissioner would like to say a few words surprise surprise right just a couple of things and from my lens of one and a half years on the board I'm I'm reminded of a John Wooden quote that it's what you learn after you know it all that really matters and and I was pretty certain a year and a half ago when I sat in this seat

153that I knew it all but uh to all of you collectively and to um you four including Jacqueline Morrison and you three specifically uh I learned quickly that I didn't know it all and I I thank you for the constant education and I also thank you for your purity of thought I really believe that you are always um of positive intent for the state of Nebraska and for the students of Nebraska and I don't know that I could give a higher compliment than that so thank you for that also as I was sitting here thinking what should I say I thought you know to teach is to touch a life forever you have taught me specifically and you have taught thousands and left an indelible mark on the state of Nebraska that you may never

154know but thank you for your work thank you for your service and uh thank you for the the relationships that we've developed individually as well good luck we're we're all going to continue throwing big Stones right into the water yes py I I forgot to thank the staff that staff I especially want to thank you for this morning all of you that met me um outside and inside the doors and rushed me up here and I I had to laugh CU I thought I got one minute what's wrong with you guys well we we do appreciate your service to the board and to the students of Nebraska and as a momento we have um clocks for each one of you to remind you of your time spent on the board um you are also your

155parting gifts are um your you your name plaque and um I know I know yeah I'm sure you'll put that on the door but um and then also your pictures that we had done um it was a very nice touch that our staff has decided to do to um display our pictures and so as you leave um we want to we want to send that with you as well um there's just really not a way to thank people for the amount of time an energy um I'd say Blood Sweat and Tears that you put into this because we we understand we understand what what what you've put into it and so there's really a clock is just a small momento but we hope that when you look at it you will remember the good times

156and you'll forget the bad thank you so much for your service and with I I was expecting pay I you know what Patty you guys wanted to come up with something Lobby the legislature I'm going to rat on her yesterday she gave me [Laughter] $10 sorry it wasn't more and okay was just going to wrap it up but I just have to say like we we all do really come from different perspectives we represent very different districts we don't always agree but we work hard to get along and I thank you for that and I thank each one of you for who you are now with that I'm going to thank everyone who attended in person and who tuned into to the broadcast the next meetings of the State Board of Education are scheduled for

157January 9th and 10th of 2025 in Lincoln Nebraska Board training work sessions will be held Wednesday January 8th and Thursday January 9th 2025 in Lincoln Nebraska the December 6 2024 state board meeting is adjourned thank you all right e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.