CorpusRecord 217482

Concord School Board Finance Committee 1-27-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Concord School District
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Merrimack County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,788 words · about 66 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001so I would like to call to order the January 27th 2025 finance committee meeting with me today I have carara Meer I can't handle this if you're watching no gaveling today um Sarah Sadowski Jim Richards and of course Mr D um so I shall open it and Jack I'm going to pass it right on to you we've got a pretty robust agenda today thank you so much and I'm excited to hear from our guests yeah no problem so um you need another minute to set up booting up we canall we're cing okay yeah so our first uh item will be health insurance we've done this a couple times over the years um uh Kirsty carpa is our lead suant for it relates to our benefits um she's been serving the district since what 2012 I

002believe when we came on maybe a little even even before that um [Music] and um so she's kirsty's from barcelow and Janna mccusker is from school care who is our health provider that uh uses Signa in the back end for the plan so they'll be here to tell you about kind of where the district is where the trends are going um and answer The Good the Bad and the Ugly okay fantastic and then our second item will be the van transportation which we handed out that proposal to give you some concept of uh what we're thinking and then just the uh overview of the budget schedule that you have in front of you for that starts February 12th and then I scheduled a nonpublic as it relates to um collective bargaining if you needed to

003get into some more details that we can't get into in the public session great okay thank you good we're opening okay it's all right you're good you should have the presentation hand it out to you do we do I while we're waiting for myu open so thank you um [Music] here so we can definitely make this um interactive so that ask questions as we go through um but what I've tried to do is put together a little context this is obviously a giant line item it's over $13 million it's huge medical trend is something that is um you know exceeding inflation and so it's an area that often there's is a lot of um it's it's challenging area to understand so we'll kind of go through um what's impacting Trend globally and then your claims

004and things like that why I can't get this to open um but while we're waiting for it to open we can just start um so if you open the presentation up um so we're going to go through uh some Trends year renewal on the school care plan performance Sigma then we'll talk dental vision ancillary and kind of put it all together um so why I can't get this to open um if you look at the spreadsheet where it says employee benefits renewal um you want to try to click that while um we as you know or may may or may not not had a very challenging year last year um we're coming off of a couple years of really high claims and so um the the claims that were going to go over that impacted

005this upcoming renewal we had um two significant high cost claims that really really impacted um the school care increase so you can see here the school care increase ranged from it was 13.4% for the two plans that you had everyone on and then um with a change in plan design which gave a 4% decrement we could get it down to 9.4% so that's the range that we're going to go over for the medical um for dental you're self-funded by Delta which is exactly what you should be for a group of your size which means you pay a flat admin fee and then you pay claims um you actually don't charge employees for this so um which is very generous um the admin fee is unchanged it's going to be 10.56% of claims so that's not

006changing um there was a slight uptick in um what they're projecting the claims to be so 2 to 3% increase so um we're seeing just you know Dental Trend be um increased a lot after Co and we thought it was going to come back down and it didn't so we're seeing a lot of groups um and I work with a lot of schools and a lot of municipalities all across the state with dental Trend in the four to 6% range it's not uncommon to see six when I was challenging Delta Dental on that they were saying well think about it what is what are dentists but like a thousand small businesses across the state which are all more expensive to run than they used to be and so it gets pass through and claims so

007with you at 2 to 3% you're actually kind of much better than Norm um vision is fully insured um but we were seeing this across the board we were anticipating a rate decrease and you got one a 15% decrease it's held for 4 years vision isn't very expensive but it is an employee paid benefit and it is something that we always tell people if you wear glasses or contacts take it because you're going to make money on it and if you don't wear it glasses or contacts don't take it um but anyway you got to decrease that's nice it's a it's a low cost benefit and then Mutual Omaha the ancillary which is the life ad and D long-term disability Etc and we got a rate hold um with Mutual Omaha which um is we've

008been getting re holds several years in a row which is great all right so yay we have a presentation I'm doing it from my machine oh you're doing it from your default okay okay so um if we move to the trends so what's Trend so medical and RX Trend trend is if you have a procedure today a year from now what's that procedure going to cost and so um we'll get into that we'll get into the drivers of that but so in New Hampshire right now we're seeing medical trends and in just regardless of whether you're with Harvard or whether you're with Anthem or whether you're with Sigma at a robust like 10% when carriers come out with a renewal they put a 10% Trend in and I mean I've even seen one this year

009it was at now they don't do a lot of business in New Hampshire but at 11 and I mean it's just jaw-dropping to to see double digit numbers in in Trend and we're going to get into kind of what's driving that the good news is that school care runs um lower than Trent they're running they so at 6.8% and that's pretty consistent that they'd be a few points below Trend that has been the norm for school care and um and the pool that they manage um and we can talk about why in a little bit um so when we say medical and RX combine trend for Signa 10.3 I 100% saw 10.3 all year long like that is definitely what they were coming out with they're saying 88.5% for new business I guess that's a

010comment that they're attracting uh well-run groups to them um so but 10% for Signa prescription drug Trend at 11.3 and we're going to talk about this but like prescription drugs are the driver right now these specialty RX the glp ones which are the weight loss drugs Gene therapies it is just a an enormous cost um I used to have high cost claims would be somebody had a surgery or a baby that was like a pre baby now it's often a drug some a child got prescribed a drug they're doing very well on it it costs the employer $300,000 a year you know like Etc like up to a million dollars a year like drugs are really driving a lot of the high cost claims now and I don't think that that's going to go away

011um some drivers here of medical inflation so um I talked about gene therapy What gene therapy is and you're going to hear about this in the news it's it's it's definitely um a growing area of um medical intervention it's kind of a oneandone so it would be like um it can cure certain types of blindness or sickle cell disease or hemophilia with one treatment but it the treatment could cost $3 million you know like from a million to $3 million so it's rare but they exist now that never used to exist so um so those are those are coming down the pike and this the the burden of this is that we have an employer delivered healthc care system for many many many groups including schools and municipalities and so you like who Bears the

012burden when you know somebody's I mean could be any one of our family members or us that gets you know has some disease and then all of a sudden there's a cure but it costs x amount what do you do so those are coming down the pipe um Advanced Cancer Care so we're seeing a lot more people living a lot longer and have much better quality of life at the final stages of life you know like 5 years more or something with certain drugs like Kuda like there's certain ones that are really you see them prescribed a lot people are doing a lot better but they cost money um transplants I can't even tell you like transplants are pretty common now like they're The Med medical medicine has come so far that it is not

013unlikely to have a liver transplant a heart transplant a kidney transplant I have a lot of groups that are having transplants so that's something that isn't it used to be very rare and now it's not very rare um The Chronic conditions are well work force shortages so that would be like the travel nurses the the Staffing where they have to you know like contract higher cost people to come in um you're going to see and you do see this in the news a lot where uh a hospital goes public and you name the carrier it's I think it's St Joe's and Anthem right now but like it'll be Signa and somebody else and where the hospital gets really upset in the negotiations and they go public and they're like you know such and such carrier

014want you know want such and such increase but the carriers are saying yeah but you're trying to charge us 25% more and we have to pass that on so it's so frustrating because both sides need each other and usually we get to the 11th hour and fth 59th minute after it's been in the Press forever and all the employees are so worried because they have a surgery you know and then they always tend to agree because they need each other but this is happening more and more and more and the reason it it's happening is because it's really hard for a hospital to stay afloat these days like a lot of them are in the red so they feel like they have to have bigger increases from the carriers but the carriers are like what

015are we going to do we're at a 10% Trend already so it's really hard um so that you've seen more of that uh chronic conditions so those are not new but like the the vast amount of our population that lives with diabetes and things like that those are obviously um at a a huge amount of cost in the system mental health so that is if I I actually work with Riverbend and I was meeting with them today and I was like you guys should come up with something where you can just go out into the public and meet with employers and just deliver a mental health first aid like everyone is asking for more Mental Health Resources so it doesn't matter what industry you're in how big an employer they are it's it's just there's

016such a need and there's not enough providers and there's just not enough resources and so that is really taxing our system um and then consolidation so you're you we always hear this you know the mergers right whatever Massachusetts hospital is coming up and buying whatever other hospital or private Equity coming in so all these things is just um really are are all adding to the medical inflation and then the drug inflation um is so the advertising all of those drugs that we see at night every you know you can name them all you can sing the jingles but those are the ones that are where we see the cost and like they're super expensive um it's there's a direct correlation between advertising drugs on TV and people wanting those drugs and getting prescribed those drugs

017and those are the high cost drugs um the glp ones those are the um the weight loss drugs so that is such an area of um motion so emotion people are really really invested in what side they're on on this and and uh they're really expensive so you know right now in the United States they cost probably you know 1,000 to ,200 a month um 40% of the US population technically could you know be qualified I mean you just you can't I mean so so and it's interesting to see like the different tax that groups are taking like there's whole states that have pulled them out to save millions of dollars the Mayo Clinic has said we're just going to cap it at $20,000 a lifetime you know so once you hit 20,000 we're not

018covering anymore and then there's a most groups right now are still not covering them because they worry if they offer them how are they ever going to take them back and they're so worried about their high cost claims already and they just don't feel like they can afford them and it's still really early and you know are cheaper forms going to come out and what are the long-term effects and but the um there's just a lot there and I like I'm getting texts today from colleagues that are at Wellness fairs they're like like people have a lot of opinions about these and you know and they we hear it a lot so so those are you're not those are not going to be going away part of the conversation adding a lot of cost and

019we don't cover those I remember from last year we had this conversation we don't cover that so you don't so school care we did a whole bunch of focus groups and ended up an employer could choose whether you wanted them or didn't want them it was going to be 6% load and did anybody take them at this time no yeah no doesn't look like any um they did a lot of due diligence you know and then came forth with Rate glp1 rates or non gp1 rates and but imagine like if you're you know you've got labor unions and you you know you put it out there and then how do you take it back and it's really um so I don't know where that's going but it's um it adds a lot of cost and

020it's it's definitely a controversial area right now go to the next one so we probably talked about most of these um so the deflators so um you know trying to use ambulatory surgical centers or Urgent Care instead of the er um we you know there's a lot of a burgeoning kind of industry of like nurse care Navigators that could steer people to lower cost high quality care so what does that look like bio similars are really interesting so Huma is one where there's going to be a bio similar but what Huma keeps doing is they increase the rebates to make it cheaper for groups to keep on Huma than to use the biosimilar so we go and we check and then it's still better to be on Huma so the the games these pharmaceutical companies

021are playing with these drugs where they're making a lot of money it's it's quite something um but you know as as drugs come off patent there will be um generics that are become available um it I will say the inflators far outstrip the deflators right now in in medical and RX TR next so what are groups to do um oh Jack has the old one without the um so um so um we're seeing it will go through school care has done a good job of some of the programs um but like programs that address diabetes um um if a group has gp1 medications and sorry there's a typo there it says GPA but it should be gp1 um having step therapy having limits having making sure that they like some groups make them do coaching

022and if you don't meet a certain criteria of the coaching then they won't give you the drug anymore n is partnering there's all these things coming out to try to make sure that people are doing something in addition to getting the drug because what happens is when you lose the weight you lose both muscle mass and body fat you lose both and unless you are doing a weightbearing exercise and eating a high protein diet and trying to keep muscle mass when you if you stop taking the drug and you gain it back you only gain fat back so you lost muscle and fat and you gain only fat back and so in the long run if unless it's paired with a lifestyle maintenance program it it isn't going to be to your best interest from

023a health perspective um so there's a lot there um we talked about biosimilars so what else can people do um drugs like drug formularies where not everything is allowed like whether it's a narrow formulary or you know it forces people to take um certain types of like generics versus brand names um and then Health coaching um I think that we are seeing a lot more coaching a lot more robust eaps with coaching um um just trying to help guide people through this like really expensive Maze of medication and trying to keep people healthy um so and these this just shows like a range of costs like so um prior off so what prior off case management disease management I think sometimes um people feel frustrated when they have to like jump through hoops to get

024a certain surgery or something a lot of those are in place for for the carriers to try to make sure that it's the right surgery for the right person at the right time um you know are we seeing groups pass more on a little uh you know a lot of group a lot of the plans there's not a lot more to pass on you know like we've kind of gotten to the point where how much more can you increase the deductible how much more can you you know so some C sharing initiatives I'm not there's less and less return for passing it on um but you know like some incremental passing on of of deductibles and co-pays um Wellness programs um I think on the wellness side we're seeing a lot more Focus now on

025mental health and there seems to be a more burgeoning newer um focus on that and I think that's probably needed um it's it's really challenging I mean I I I think we're starting to struggle with the costs are getting so and it's like there's only so much you can do to keep them contained and and if even when we do put in some of these programs you change it on the margin but you're not changing it at a macro level like you're not really significantly changing things by hundreds of thousands of dollars occasionally occasionally and you'll see like when you put in a um like save on prescription drugs two years ago you saved a ton but once you do it and everyone's on it you know like then like the next year you don't

026get other another 100,000 you're kind of on that new level that's what we're kind of finding so school care all right so this was your these were your renewal rates for 7125 um and we're going to go over kind of how your claims were running and why you ended up with this um but remember we were just talking about Trend right so like trend is running you know for Signa at 10 school care and you know 6.8 um you had a high cost claims year so for the plans that you were currently that you're current ly on you ended up with a 13.4 um there are um plans you can see below the 2.0 plan where there's a little bit more of a deductible went from 1250 to 1500 or 2,000 to 2500 so that

027you've got a 4% decrement um if people went onto those plans you got to remember not everybody hits the deductible right so only a portion of people actually hit that deductible um and to be honest B B on what I've seen in other groups that's a really good detriment for that amount of change like 4% for you know going up 250 or $500 is a very is a pretty significant decrement um so anyway that that's that's great school care hadn't changed that in a very long time it's I think that it's very healthy and appropriate to keep um the deductibles kind of inching along because medical inflation it doesn't inch it goes much FAS faster than that and so if you don't do anything what happens is you don't you don't you don't you don't

028and then you end up with too big an increase and it's a it's it it's always I think better to just be kind of incremental and judicious as you go along um and so passing that on um was a smart thing and that was voted in by um the school care membersip so this is an ey chart we're not going to go over it all just say I've got this going back to 2018 what we do is we track every year what was the trend um what were you know how did you do what were your build rates what were your effective rates did um was you know did you get a return of the reserve Etc so um this is a snapshot from that um but you have for the past few years been

029running above Trend so you know and and we see this you're a big group you're 100% credible and it feels like it's like anything like it so it kind of like you'll have a high cost claim period for a while and then things resolve and so but you've been in one of those higher cost claim periods with just high cost claims like you know things you can't control creamy babies I mean you know just things happen but you for a few years you've been running above Trend which has led to um increases that are higher than the school care average and we don't have to go into this this is more detail about that so that um so this is how when we look at the claims experience that was used in order to produce

030the renewal that you're getting 7125 this is the the duration July 23 through June 24 so you ran a um 103% loss ratio so let's just talk about loss ratio that takes all the claims it divides it by the premium so you're underwritten to a 92% loss ratio that's what we'd like the claims to be um 92% of the premium that gives like an 8% admin for you know you're plan to be run Etc but you ran AT3 right so for every dollar the district gave school care they paid A1 three C in claims with no room for admin or running the program or anything like that so that's that was last year um so that's tough when when you have a year like that um you know you're going to get an increase especially

031when think about it the status quo is you know 6.8% that's like with doing nothing right that's like you ran at a 92% loss ratio You' probably get a 6.8 you ran at 103 so you got to think about it like that um this is what we were um up against that we had these two little babies and so and this is not an uncommon thing newborns are are among the high cost claims nationally always on the list so newborn can be very expensive so a little baby ends up in the NICU it costs a lot of money um we're actually uh we're seeing more of that I don't know if people are having kids at older ages but it is very common to see like prey babies that end up with $400,000 claims very

032very common um but and Cancers are also obviously um on the list there and that's also always a top driver of high cost claims so there's nothing really surprising um but you you had a fair amount of high cost claims so this so for the most recent time period that we're looking at you had eight that were over 150,000 totaling 1.9 million the prior year you had seven to um that were totaling 1.4 million and school care pools that claims over 150,000 out of your renewal so basically you pay a pooling fee and then they take those out and that's meant because obviously if you had if they didn't pull the things out then you know say you had a million dollar claim you know everybody's premium would go way up that doesn't make sense

033so that's meant to be make things kind of Equitable um and to smooth like for smoothing factor so that over time it doesn't go so up and so down um so it was a CH here to the next one um this is and I chart it's just to show you that things have turned for the better okay so this is this year um this is the first six months of of the current plan year that you're in so July 2024 to December um 2024 and you're running in the first six months of the year at an 85% loss ratio which is really good so the babies are better um you know your claims are running better which is great um now what's going to happen schoolcare will use 75% they're going to have there's going

034to be two columns they going to use 75% of your most recent year and 25% of the prior year okay in the formula in figuring out your renewal so um part of your prior year experience is still going to be in there um and it's kind of early so there's eight more months that we're going to have until school care you know delivers your renewal or um calculates everything out so it it's it's it's too early to tell like there's a lot that can happen but let's just say we're in a whole better place than we were a year ago sometimes I feel like I come into these I'm just setting the stage for the big increase but I we're kind of in a better spot right like a lot of that's resolved you're running

035right now much better much better position um you have to remember that that doesn't necessarily mean that you get a flat right because we have medical Trend so you have to think about that but compared to a 103 an 85 is awesome so and this right now are the current um high cost claim so um very normal neoplasm cancer cancer want me to turn it over down yeah sure I can take I'm going to turn it over to Jana so what we're trying to do here is we did we have like year bullets and then how it compares to school care as a whole yeah so this is um it's called a cap report and so we pull these together each year you've probably seen some of this data in the past um have already

036gone over this inform with Jack um so he's seen a lot of this information but it just talks again it you know there's a lot of chart information again on the right hand side but the conquered total plan spend again we talked a little bit about this it's trending at 10.1% compared to school care total plan spent at 10.9 uh the medical plan for conquer per member per year is up 99.2% while school care is up 10.8 um and as we already touched on obviously prescriptions tends to be the higher cost driver and that's not different for both groups conquer's up 19.6% with school care being up 11 and a half and so this is just talking there's comparables between the current period which is July of 23 through June of 24 so the last

037full plan year comparing to a base period of the previous full year so that's July of 22 through June of 23 so it's just giving you a snapshot of how those two live for the last two full plan years and in the middle of that ey chart on the right you can see 13,736 th000 that's literally the total cost that of what you paid like you if that's employer plus employee but still like that's your total spend that's a lot of money yeah and there's a red circle there which we'll actually touch on on the next slide to pull that piece out because it's talking about the Specialty Pharmacy spend which christe already alluded to that's again it's just a really high cost driver and I know when I'm chatting with folks on the phone

038I'll I'll just kind of it's it's it's almost like watching the stock market you know it's very you know supply and demand driven it's not wholly static and so It's Tricky for folks when their drug prices seem to move on them that's just kind of how it tends to flow so conquered specialty plan spend um is trending at 42 and a half% but one of reasons though yeah yeah and so Chris you alluded to this before so she talked about that save on SP program some of you may or may not have heard of it it was a program we put in a couple years ago um and it's really a program that siga came to us at school care talking about they're always working with us looking at our own Trend what can we

039do to implement as far as programs go to mitigate costs as much as we can and the save on SP program is one that we did put into place with them it takes um a few specialty very high cost specialty drugs it's a fin group and it can shift from year to year but it it has been pretty static um folks who take those high cost drugs can get into that program and it takes the cost of the drug and really pulls it out of their plan it doesn't affect their deductible it doesn't affect their at a pocket maximum but they as an employee actually have zero cost for those drugs so it it hits the plan we pay at school care sort of a lesser amount it's a bit of a a way for

040Signa has found a way to be creative at using those drug rebates they use the manufacturer coupon yeah and they apply the coupon to the plan cuz it's hard sometimes for those to complement and work with insurance companies Medicare all those things those rebates are really tricky to merge with insurance so this is a program signate implemented to allow them to be able to use them and apply them and and make it easier on the employees so it did save a lot of money initially and like we said then you're able to benefit from it in the initial program but then as it on on that savings has been found and now you sort of moderate again and this is sort of what that starts to look like so the first year back is sort

041of a a snapbag of a rubber band and it's it's different but it should start to moderate out also so I think you're just seeing sort of that snapping of the rubber band it's still in place the people are still on them but it's just that you don't get another 22% like they've already that's already been saved now we're just at that lower level and then you just add on new drugs and right so yeah and that'll be they'll keep playing with the names of the drugs on there and and Signa keeps watching that to see what's going to be the most effective to make sure that that that makes a difference going forward so these are some of the other um things that we saw in the data another thing that we saw that

042kind of jumped out at us is noted here is that there seems to be more visits to cardiologists so that sort of showed up I don't even think it was on the last plan year before that but it's shot up 68% over the pre previous year so again that's just something that okay here's a little clue about a condition that's showing up within your employee pool um and so it's just sort of something to take note of um go ahead for the next slide so you might think okay what this is what I always try to think about and what I talk to folks about when we're reviewing these numbers is what can we do you know it's one thing to hear about it okay sorry yeah there's nothing that you can do about some

043of this stuff but there are some things that can be done and that's where we talk about the well-being program you know we are always out there encouraging folks to take advantage of it um do any education that we can do so folks know how to navigate it how to use it for themselves we created a program that tries to meet folks wherever they are whether they're already exercising want to start haven't started not sure if they're interested you know all sorts of places um and we can give them incentives of $600 for their employees as in also for their spouses that are on the plan so that's what they can earn by doing very ious activities and we include all kinds of things preventive visits physical exercise mental health activities know they take part

044in an EAP case management there's a lot of different ways folks can earn these incentives because health is a pretty wide- ranging thing and we want to help them get better as much as we can with whatever program they will use so the next slide shows you a little more detail about that um alluding to health coaching here because we talk about some of these chronic conditions Health coaching is a wonderful way to sort of help people and they can earn up to $600 um so they can maximize their benefit if they elect a health coach if they're dealing with um cancer treatment or some of these more chronic type of conditions they can get themselves a health coach and have help from that person on a regular basis and they'll help them make sure

045they're finding in network providers if they need prior authorizations for surgeries or treatments they will help them get those in place same for prescription drugs help them navigate that because that can get complicated and making sure so this person sort of holds their hand knowing that they're having to do a lot of help and um get a lot of treatment throughout the way so this is a way to help them do that and we give them incentives to try to take advantage of that so they can get the most support that they can get can I ask quick question please is that like a reduction off their deductible or you actually give them incentive cash in hand that's what it is yeah yeah absolutely yeah we've got a new program we're going to be rolling

046out next year that'll give them a little more flexibility on what those incentives look like but it's much the same yeah that's a great question um and so this outlines what your top spend is by condition a lot of these tend to be pretty static throughout our groups um you can see on yours muscular skeletal um conditions are one of the biggest drivers it is on every single group that we work with it is in the top three every single time um and you can also see neoplasms or cancers um is also right there at the top so it's talks about your cancer spend um that's up 4.6% and the spend per claiming so each person getting treatment has gone up 31 a half% so your total spend has gone up but what the people

047that are getting their treatments are having to pay has gone up exponentially um and our school care cancer spend is a little bit less at 3.6 and spend per claiming is up 10.6 so not quite as high as the 31 that your folks are seeing so it depends it's hard you know where you go for treatments can matter what types of drugs that you're being prescribed matters how long is the treatment matters I mean there's so many factors in there so again not necessarily controllable costs but things to just be aware of of what might be happening with that um and then again we already mentioned that there were two newborns that had a high cost um and that spend was up 500 plus per so that's a big one and again not much that

048can be done about that so when we talk about muscular skeletal that has always been on everybody's chart every District that we work with throughout the state and so that's why we have implemented this program called hinge Health we've been doing this for a few years now it's a completely free basically atome access to physical therapy um I got to guinea pig this program in the beginning and so you literally virtually get to meet with a physical therapist they assess your motion how are you moving what can we do to help they assign you exercises you do on a regular basis you get all these fun little gadgets little you know straps you can put on so they can track how your leg is moving if that's what you're exercising tablets um all sorts of

049different things and so it's obviously for folks who are maybe experiencing shoulder pain knee pain all the regular painful Parts back all the sort of thing um free physical therapy from home and the idea is really helping people to manage their pain hopefully improve it in such a way that they are can jump off off of the track of straight to surgery because a lot of folks will go in and they got shoulder pain and it's kind of you know you hear this a lot where someone has a hammer and there's a nail so you go to see your Osteo person and they're like okay surgery so there there can be other managing things that you can do so if you can get in a nice Physical Therapy Program and free uh from home you

050can work out at home and not have to go out and do anything um another program that they've implemented this year is a women's pelvic health program cuz finally we're starting to talk more about specifically Let's Help women in the ailments that they deal with as they age this is one of those and so that's been a very popular program we've had a lot of folks taking advantage of that and again we do our best to make sure people know about these programs and encourage them so anything that we all can do to help make sure folks know there are resources out there to take advantage of so this is your preventive care how are you all doing getting um breast cancer screenings cervical cancer screenings and colon cancer screenings these are what we specifically

051measure on these y'all are doing really really well and that's great to see that you can see that your screening rates are going up everything is um right along the norm as it should be or even higher than and when they look at your Signa Norm which is you know the blue ones if you will those are actually um comparing them to National Education groups throughout the country so coner school district is doing quite nicely compared to the National averages so keep encouraging folks to get their preventive screenings because you can find things earlier that makes a really big difference so this is your Pharmacy executive summary here um your generic prescription so folks getting generic prescriptions that's up um that's doing quite nicely at 94.9% and that's up slightly over the for year which

052was 94.2% and it's right along the lines really of our school care average of fol taking generics and so that's always very encouraging when you get to see that a lot of people are heating that that's another sort of steering program Signa puts into place to encourage folks to get generics if there's an option available and they can physically react positively to it so you all are doing really nicely on that front which saves cost and the next slide helps to outline this I always like to point out when you look you can't really see it again but on that whole list of 25 prescriptions these are the top drugs that your folks are taking there is only one on there that's um capitalized meaning it's not a generic necessarily every other one is a

053generic drug so the volume of drugs most people are taking those and that one that's not a generic is pretty low cost so it's not too too bad but it gives you an idea too of the types of conditions folks are treating depression cholesterol hypertension thyroid issues those are sort of the top driving you know causes that folks are taking and they're not changing from year to year either same reasons for last year um and I know a lot of folks tend to think it's concerning that so many people are taking a depression prescription it it really isn't if your folks are depressed I mean a lot of people are I'm glad they're getting treatment for it it's a positive thing that they're taking prescriptions to manage you know their conditions that they're dealing with

054so I look at that as a positive thing but again looking pretty positive there so another another type of program we were talking earlier about the glp ones um and folks trying to help manage their you know lose weight get more physically active we have this program called omada um now it's a little bit more elaborate called omada Complete because there are different types of programs within this another free know certainly entirely free employees there's a pre-diabetes program so folks who are being told you are pre-diabetic you ought to do some changes about your health this is a free program they can get involved in um new there's a program for folks who've already been diagnosed with either type one or type two diabetes and then also hypertension or high blood pressure so as folks

055are diagnosed with those they can take part in this completely free program they get connected with a health coach that navigates kind of holds their hand checks in with them on a regular basis answers any questions supports them with exercise programs and nutrition programs so we're talking about that option of folks to to um include gp1s on their coverage this is the program that we're asking them to put in place as well so you have to take part in omada um and it's a really positive program we've heard from so many of our our employees that they love it I was talking to a woman earlier today who's like dying to get back in it because she just had so much benefit and you get like a personal coach right yeah and they will help

056you out they'll they'll bug you as often as you want them to bug you you know they'll be right there and answer any of your questions but people have a a great amount of success with that it's been it's been a wonderful program we're really happy about that so you know as we see the data and we see your claims and things that your employees are dealing with these are some of the answers we work with Signa to try to come up with to give a solution so that folks can take advantage of that and again do what we can to sort of mitigate some of the cost that you do see with your claims because some of it we can try to control and do something positive about how will our our participation rates

057and and um we don't generally get sort of by group but I would say our our school care pool is is doing pretty well there's a pretty good amount of folks that are in there and and they keep in increasing each year more and more folks hear about it and again we hear from some folks there's one of our gentlemen in our membership group our um Council that loves it is in it just like cheerleads about it and we I everywhere I go I do a training with employees and there's always someone in the room that's like I've done it and I love it and it's great and it's helped me a ton so you know when folks do call and ask us about glp1 coverage and like you said currently we have to say

058no we don't and you know conquer doesn't cover it or whoever doesn't cover it this is a great option to be able to jump into instead and it's free um and we'll do our best to help you get there you know without having a secret prescription thank you so how much how how frequently or what do you do to in our schools to educate people and promote this do you have like do we have like a a you know you know health fair do we have a week of just giving them information what do we do as a school district to do that I know for our sake so we so I I'll speak for my end is we do open enrollment presentations we try to do those in the springtime come out with every

059group and make sure they do that if they don't invite us on to campuses to schools then we have um virtual presentations or on our website they can listen to the presentation they're all right there so folks can hear about what programs we offer throughout the year we're always open to doing on-site trainings about any of the resources we have and then we do a lot of you know emails and and other sort of virtual pre you know information sharing so newsletters and other emails and instant messages SMS messaging all kinds of things to make sure folks are aware right now we're doing a good for you recharge another like through the well-being program where every single week folks are getting an email and we're talking about all these programs Mental Health Resources um types

060of programs like these so we we try to get the word out it's just a matter of folks do we do do we do things in professional development do we do things in you know you know teacher rooms any of those things yeah I mean Michelle and her team are out in the buildings okay but a lot of the information we get is all via email so I know about the the hip program or whatever you call it and all the different things yeah heard of it they do they do direct mailers too we get direct meal and then um obviously Michelle and her Department do a lot of that work yeah I know I get phone calls on a regular basis and we'll talk to people whenever they have questions about PD I don't

061think we' really had anything with PD I just I'm looking as to how often we're getting in front of people with this I mean certainly it's the uh cost savings for the district but more importantly it's the health outcomes for our employees our teachers and staffs important the other thing that they do which is very interesting is they'll do personal phone calls M yeah which is I think that's a little a little extra stuff compared to the you know sometimes you're like who is this that's that's who it isely good point good try okay almost there yep Moving on but I will say that sign's programs they're not just fluff like they're very meaty like they're they actually they're pretty robust um so they do a sign does a good job um okay so Dental

062quickly um not as large a spend as medical it's paid by the district um the claims increase projected um for 7125 for the year is 27,000 um you you there's something called a pre fund where they kind of like keep a deposit on hand and it just kind of goes up and down down depending on head counter claim so you need a little bit more for the pre fund your admin fee was held um Dental's pretty predictable um you have you know $1,000 max out of pocket once you hit that like everybody gets a bucket of $1,000 do once they're done their $ th000 they're done so there's no high cost claims in Dental it's a capped benefit and then vision is fully insured and you've got the 15% rate decrease and help four years

063so that's great and neutal Omaha is f insured and we got a one-year rate guarantee with a whole on all lines of coverage which is great and we choose mut Omaha because they're very accountable so um they're that we have real people that we work with and boy did they um they uh we'll go over and above I've had a couple times when maybe like a clerical error was made or something and but you knew the intent of what the group wanted but and they'll say to me like you know legally you have no ground to stand on I'm like I know that's why I'm calling but you know what they meant and they will honor it and pay claims out which is rare um and so that's why we choose and we stay with

064them yeah and then benchmarking so um we'd like to Benchmark your plan against um others and so this is a miman database so um we're going to look at your 2025 numbers but it's it's it's for the 2024 data because we have to obviously have a whole year of data and we're just at the beginning of 2025 so we're going to be looking at 2024 Benchmark data here we're going to look against the national um so just all all groups nationally New Hampshire and then educational groups um nationally and so um on the right is School care and on the left of the Benchmark so if you look at the deductible um so your yellow plan had uh 12250 and then the orange plan has 2,000 and you can see the benchmarks nationally in New

065Hampshire and then in the industry so obviously deductibles are much higher than what you're passing along um and then out- of pocket maximums you can see you're at 2,000 for the yellow plan 4,000 for the orange and if you look to the left they're all running around 6,000 um as the Norm so um you you know your plans are much richer than what we're seeing nationally in the state of New Hampshire or in the industry as a whole and the phrase stien has been removed what is that in reference to and then the orange plan has a um HSA uh contribution you know where the district is putting money into the health savings account and there used to be a stipend is that what you're asking the stipend has been removed so there used to

066be a salary augmentation to help s school care is limiting how much of that deductible can be funded but conquered had a program for a while that was negotiated that would make people like that would make them whole um but that's been removed um so it it wasn't something that was there forever and to be honest um it really wasn't something that was even um I don't know maybe appreciated is a wrong word but people didn't seem like they were willing to take they're ready to take the plan before they even knew about that part like it it it so it didn't seem like it was necessary maybe and then the 2.0 so if we go to the next one so these are the looks very similar these are the 2.0 plans where the deductible

067went up a little bit but you can still see relative to the benchmarks that you know there was definitely room to kind of just inch that deductible up a little bit from the yellow plan or the orange plan and then if you go to the next one so this is bigger premiums so um it's a little bit of a eye chart so you're you're on the left and then on the right are The Benchmark so your premiums are higher but you have to remember your plans are a lot richer okay so we're comparing it against deductibles that are 3,000 or $4,000 deductible plans and you're at you know 12250 or500 or 2,000 so your plans your premiums are more expensive your plans are a lot richer and then this is a little bit of an

068ey chart but this is the employee and employer contributions and so um we've got so like if we take the yellow so the yellow and then the yellow with choice so the top like the 18630 would be a monthly employee contribution for the yellow and then for the single and the yellow with Choice the monthly contribution would be 17888 it's a little it's the 4% decrement of the the two plans and then on the orange and that's at an 85 so that's with the employee paying 15% and the employer paying 85 which is your current split for the yellow when we move over to the orange you've got some people at an 8515 some people at a 955 and so that's why like if we take the top one so the orange plan the employee

069contribution at8 55 so they're paying 15% would be 14370 at 955 where they're paying 5% be 4790 and if we go just below that that's the orange 2.0 so that's how that's how you read it um so um you know your employee contributions are it depends but a little bit higher um than some of the than some of the benchmarks it depends like two person is not higher single is higher so you kind of have to just like read across the charts think that was it was the last slide Le in mine got the last one on the the last slide and that concludes the does anybody have any questions thank you I think one thing that's important to note that I mentioned in the last budget is that if we had stayed status quo

070from 2012 and kept that original Green plan and you any ones that have green planed are retirees that were able to keep it and I think there's only two left now but we've had a cost avoidance of about 4.2 million just on the district side so that's 6% on the tax rate right there if we had just done nothing kept all the same plans kept same contributions so with their help uh Melissa Witherspoon who's the benefits coordinator here um we've done a lot of work to try to educate people and slowly migrate plans and kind of keep up with Trends obviously you see nationally New Hampshire and industry it's a little I mean from a pay standpoint for the deductibles it's a rich plan but it's not overly Rich where it would have been if

071we had stayed where we were so the the family uh the green plan for a family for 12 months is $5,5833 plan I think is 41 so and the orange plan is Let's see we do 2 5 8 6.5 I'm sorry yellow the Orange is 31,000 and the yellow is about 40 4 so significant difference let me think about that $55,000 for a family for a year for a Health Plan yeah so you did save a ton I mean Jack really has deser ton of credit he's like is like the Trailblazer like way out in front and then other districts kind of watching what you guys are doing but he really adopted some of these things way before others and you've saved a ton of money by doing it okay good thank you thank you

072thank you so much I feel like I need to go exercise feeling last year too you gave the presentation I was like I need better heart health yeah thank you for the motivator yeah do you want extras kept here or you all set with I don't think we need the extras yeah thank you want to go for a walk no should walk do you want to make a motion to go for a walk I move that we move okay that was such a great do joke I loved [Music] it all right I want to talk that was a great hour but yes we are thank you very much thank you appreciate it you too goodbye thank you all right were you tagged in Mr fito am I taged were you tagged in yes okay yes

073well I was tagged in because uh one of the things that kathen asked me to do early on this year was to kind of look at a proposal to how do we I don't know I don't even want to say save money cuz save money may not be the thing but how do we fix our cost a little more yeah around some of our band Transportation because as I approached the board earlier in the year we're way over we were over $700,000 um in what we had to do and we um came and talked about using some of my special ed um you know Reserve account to be able to um do that we did that earlier in the year and it's been steady to what we predicted we've been right about there you know

074we're hovering right about there so did some research talked to some vendors um and put together a proposal that you'll see in front of you that kind of outlines um all the components that Jack and I believe will be involved with if we're to look forward and have our own van transportation Division and again this is in draft form this is our um best estimate on cost based on what's out there currently and we walked through several complaints um and please stop me and ask questions along the way um we looked at what the fleet would cost us if we we P if we purchased Vans around $50,000 a piece we looked at um personnel and drivers um you know estimated salaries things like that but that's still very rough numbers because that would of

075course have to be negotiated so again in doing that um again management how would this be managed and who would be there we need coord Ator we need someone to schedule the routes a scheduler and a kind of air traffic controller of all these buses that would have to have to happen in vans that go around um and then um scheduling software things like that maintenance Personnel um and then um as you see um those costs and then benefits of course which we just heard all about um facility cost if we lease the facility what that would that look like and Jack and I you know as I think you must think Jack and I just drive around look at properties but Jack and I um um looked at another property actually for for this

076and uh kind of said that we had something in mind and in contact with the real realtor to see if that was something that would be available to us and it still is available so it's something that we would have a facility to put these Vans at um and then Fuel and maintenance um costs of course I outlined insurance and liability um what you need training and certific in certification there still does need to be a certificate in training for them although it's not to the level of a CDL all right it's it's still it's still a bus driver training that requires a um many hours and a test by the doe and a certification and all the the the the safety measures we take if someone's going to be with children such as background

077checks all those all those things we want to make sure they're safe and then annually they'll have an amount of hours they need to do to maintain their license to on top of that but we looked into all of those um particulars and costs and it seems doable to be able to do that and then of course some technology that we would need we would really want cameras we would want GPS tracking we would want um route scheduling software to to go along with that and then um they will be school bses for the conquered School District so they have to be identified in that and the strangest thing that we found out is you can't have green buses I thought that was a strange little tidbit I found out when doing this I don't

078know why but you can't have green buses cuz I wanted them to be green with white lettering and I was told no I'm so sorry no so sorry so we we'll we'll pick a color down the road I guess that's not a huge detail but I was just trying to something distinct we were thinking of so that is kind of um signage and things like that that will have to go on in the cost of that and then on the next page I broke out a budget summary for you along with kind of what it would cost for additional onetime cost to get it up and running we're looking about you know um you know as you see 1.8 one about a little over a million dollars you know $ 1.1 million about that and

079then what what I'm what I'm more feeling pretty good about are those annual costs and where we are and and yeah you know it's higher than we have budgeted this year for annual costs but that's pretty fixed I don't see that you know over the long-term fluctuating change so that's kind of what this would look like there's opportunity also here that we can um you know to look at our neighboring districts who also have these costs to possibly partner with them and and bring this down you know and and and and you know if I have a if I have a van going out to the Sea Coast with two people in it well I got six more spots that I can kind of pick up from Arch Valley or bow on the way and

080and load that b up to go out because there's you've heard me talk about programs there's not many right now we're having trouble placing we're having trouble in programs but we're all utilizing the same programs in the area because there's not a ton of programs um within a 15 20 minute drive us they're all 30 to 45 minutes of programs that we utilize for itage Replacements that doesn't count Foster homeless all the other areas we have to place we have to so quick question then based on the number of vans would you expect we'd still have to contract out at least some transportation in addition to the fleet this figures the amount of kids that we currently have and current needs we have so we should be able to um no guarantees as I said

081this is a draft this is my best thinking but it looks like this should be able to um take care of our cost so we wouldn't need to do that gotta thank you that part right because one of the things that occurs to me right off the bat is that for an accessible van you're looking at Double like the $50,000 piece so for Equitable access we'll definitely need accessible Vehicles we have some of those now so we we we we also have you know we we still have our small buses that wouldn't go away and they're still they're still there that that that that that runs through Transportation now so for our for our our our wheelchair V things like that we have you know accessible things like that we still have some of our

082band that will still probably run for for a little bit but not to the right now as you know there been a drivers we have bands that aren't moving today because we don't have drivers to put in them with CDL licenses and no accessible buses they going to the Sea Coast or anything right um John can or would you be able to talk to me a little bit about like do we bill for Medicaid for transportation yes we so can you talk a little bit about what kind of Revenue we could bring in with something like this um it's uh it's so varied that that I wouldn't want to put a number to it but it does it comes down to it's a a percentage per dollar so it's basically roughly 20 cents of a

083dollar that we can look at to to do that so it's kind of um depending on there's a lot of factors to that what are the supplemental factors that the child needs and why they need it and all those things factors come into it length of drive you know is there a is there a nursing support is there a a monitor support needed all those things come into it so there's multiple factors on the different rides right but hypothetically I see what you're talking about of economies of scale if we could get other local districts to Buy in to a 30-minute commute M theoretically we could build for those students we could they they would build for them they would okay sending District but we could we could build them for the cost of of

084the transportation the mileage the whole everything that you see on this list a percentage of that would go towards us building District just like now if we have a you know you know for example we have um a a a a kind of a chart best way to say it for how we build students from Deerfield who come here if they have you know exua needs and we have to build for them we we do that now and and and Jack and Don silly who works in my office work on that all the time to have adequate bills and make sure that they are for the services rendered this would be very similar we'd have a system of like you know is it a bus doesn't need you know what's the cost of that bus

085does it need anything special on it or a specialized person with that what's the cost to run that bus what's the maintenance on it what's the wear and tear on it there' be an upcharge for all of that back to the to the other other places too so it's got potential I can see why you're exploring it yeah can I ask two questions the estimated driver costs is based on comparable salaries for our current drivers is that where that figure is coming from that in an average uh when I looked up and did um did some some search around and talk to a couple other what are vendors paying things like that that's just an average cost of what what there's a lot of these newer startups out there um because of the extreme cost

086and they're charging us a lot right now you know they're charging us you know anywhere from $300 to $600 a day to transport our kits right now and um so by just talking to the industry standard of what the costs are and what they're paying their drivers is right around there okay that's great because I would expect with a shortage of drivers that we would want to incentivize people to work for us um it it's like anything you know my I'll just say my concern I said to Kathleen this morning she says how how how good are you feeling about this and I said kind of I'm feeling uh somewhat good about it but I'm feeling that that I'm still concerned from a personal matter you know where we struggle with that that level of

087personnel um you know where it's you see it in restaurants you see it in nurses you see it in you know anywhere in the hospitals you see it something like that that that pay rate in that in that that level of employee were short everywhere you know our our EAS our our population it's a very hard there just isn't a huge work force out there for it so it's a concern that you know if if we're hiring that you know we're solving one problem but I'm not sure we're not creating another one then all a sudden now everyone's driving a bus and I don't have enough educational assistants in the in in in the buildings or people in our lunchroom or people of our custodial staff you know that of pay is right around where

088they all are my concern is I'm solving one problem creating another and and not to be not to be so pessimistic about it but it's a good proposal I think it's solid the numbers it's just there's some concerns about that everything you know that we can get the vans that we can get all those things those are still some some questions that are out there yeah which actually brings me to my next question which is based on those concerns would you see a phase in approach as or a hybrid approach better than a full Fleet approach like do you think the I mean do you think we have to have sort of a a minimum threshold of Van to make it worth it to get the software to lease the space and or do you

089think that it would be that we could invest in maybe half of this and then do another like maybe start with 10 vans and then do another 10 vans down the road I'm unsure I'll be totally honest with that I'm unsure I I don't um I don't have experience running a a never so I have to just say that it's not you know I I'm an educator taking care of students with needs completely this is this is a little so Jack and I have talked a lot about that so it's kind of um there is experts in the field that run bus companies um so I I wouldn't know that supply and demand part of it yet I just know that this is kind of based on the numbers what we would need would it

090be worth it to hire a transportation consultant to give us that reassurance like somebody who would lend their expertise to a proposal um Jack what do you thought director coach anybody I think there's a public session portion of it and then a non-public especially as it relates to negotiation so if you go in the nonpublic I can tell you some of that strategy for a few minutes but you know it's really going to depend on how things happen over the next month of some things that we've putting in place and uh we've been given back some feedback from our current director on how we could potentially take the 60 to 75 students that we have now and maybe consolidate that and roll it into our existing CDL buses we do have two non CDL buses

091now um and then what would be the ramifications of that okay but there's some things you'll be voting on in the next month that might help that thank you the 175 you said that's how many kiddos were transporting as of a specific date or is an average over the past few years it's it's about average about where we are we stay we you know you looked at you know we've had a and I said this at um you know we when we talked about the annual report too um that that we've increased but very steadily we haven't had a huge jump so I mean we've stayed where our percentages have gone up like one or 2% like over the course of three or four years we haven't really so that's about average and what we

092are okay over the last three years um side note I really commend you for diving into this this is probably I don't know a stretch assignment in many ways so it's great that you here presenting this in front of us um that takes a lot of courage and you did wonderful work with us so that's thank you yes um and then I Know Jack previously and I apologize if I missed this at another meeting you have had some preliminary highle conversations with other districts that they would be interested in working with us on this right might both have had that conversation as well right and you felt like they were eager like yes they would like to know how yeah they can contribute they experience the same challenges you have in terms of costs and

093and they're as I say they're getting their pockets cleaned right and so they're looking thinking that collaboration and yeah coming up with a plan together will um benefit all of us it really would John described it you know you go into the Sea Coast you're going to go by maram Valley and Bo and maybe somebody else on the way yep and um I think school districts will benefit from that and um right now these private companies we pay full price the next town pays the full price and the next town pays the full price they got the full bus but it's in the car yeah yeah so we we think think we can I mean don't get me wrong everything John told you was right on right spot on but y we think that has

094has some potential yeah I agree so we we also do a lot of cost share now like if I know if it's a if it's a District bus going somewhere when we're on the phone with all the myself and the directors in the lakes in the South Central Region we we talk often about this there's an email goes out I got a student going here you know can I can I hit your Ral with you and can we share costs on that we do that that's so right we do that continuously it's been part of what I've done for years and uh doing that um the night see we back on the I'll be more optimistic this time I think when I talk about it though the fact is that we have infrastructures in place

095we know how to employ people we we have good systems in place you heard about our healthc care and all the benefits we have for employees so we're we're at an advantage over some of these smaller smaller um you know organizations because we have infrastructures in place and for this this would just be another faction of what we do um in doing it's not a it's not a huge out there left field stretch and it's it's our business we understand the business we understand what kids' needs um even sometimes more these provid as we understand the individual individual needs of the child and like you know for example if um they're anxious about buses they're anxious about things like that we already know those informations we're not sharing it you know we're we're we can

096train people on certain you know low incense disabilities if it's something new for the driver that hasn't dealt with we have that ability so there's there's so many advantages to to bring it in um when we put kids at the center of that I think well there's also advantages because we run our buses we operate our own buses we're not so many other districts contract out to an outside you know agency that operates all of their buses so they don't have the uh expertise and then knowledge base that uh that we have so that gives us an advantage and a you know a competitive place can you remind me about how much we spent last year on similar Transportation costs it was almost $2 million Bud 750 and we were 1.3 over so do you

097know about when a break even point would be if we went forward with this a couple years probably right it's going to be yeah we think a couple years depending on if things simmer down and whether we can absorb summon in our existing Fleet depending on if we hire drivers right that's we have 26 big buses 12 small buses right now right so um but drivers are the challenge and that CDL we think is one impediment right to to the process that U we'll tell you about some things we going okay thank you cara yeah um thank you for entertaining these questions you guys uh understanding that the service that we provide with our own Fleet May cost more initially than than you know like if things do smooth out and transportation goes you know

098costs go down and the contracted services are there are there issues with service with the contract and services that would be uh that you would be more confident in if we had our own Fleet like are there cancellations that we worry about are they you know like do you think our service would be better coming from inhouse or do you are do you have a high level of confidence in our contract and services so right now we our contract services do a really nice job and they and they're there we you know Terry karate has done a really nice job with having kind of his go-to um services and he he he keeps his uh keeps the vendors very close and very good contact with that so I want to really commend him for that

099he's done a really nice job with that um I think that what is it's lag time you know um in and sometimes we just sometimes we can't get rides sometimes it's it's Terry and me two weeks in the phone trying to figure out a change in ride or sometimes it doesn't always go well and you got a couple mix of kids that don't get along on the bus and we need to make a change we need some of those that is a long lag time for us right now so it sounds like administrative time yeah and administra so so some of this would be a lot more fluidity in us having control over you know that's it I get a homeless student that that if we have a student that's homeless that let's just say

100um from Manchester and in is living you know that we have to transport you know back and forth you know things like that I can do that fairly quickly if I have a little bit more local control Terry's done a great job to be as responsible as he can he doesn't own those companies so it's really we're competing against multiple other districts for these few slots that are open right now this opens the pool a little more so when you open the pool a little more there's more respons if we get the drivers right d thank you for mentioning that the use of your time and our Administration time like you're and when you have to spend so much time doing that you're a very highly paid traffic controller so if you do feel that

101there is a strong will free up some of your time and and use those your hourly rubric that hourly into other things that would be worth it right so okay that would be interesting to know just keep track like I would save like 10 hours a month that's significant right yeah yeah okay Kathleen oh sorry I'm just gonna ask a question how how what's you how do you want to proceed that was my question was that gonna be your question I think you're all I was about to ask yeah what's next step great question Kathleen excuse me I have to leave for my next meeting see thank you yeah I think we have an appetite to continue so I think unless you have an objection you're going to see this in your budget number one

102and number two once we do the last second to last item on your agenda public section we'll go into a non-public for 3 minutes so you can see some of the mitigation stuff we're starting yeah and that will impact the budget considering what you guys will do yeah in your negotiations Committee in the next couple weeks okay okay that right I think especially before the public um hearing I think being able to talk about that cost savings again from a Time perspective and when when that break even point is I think having a clear idea of that will be really impactful yeah okay and again I just want to stress too I think Jack Jack and I talked about this the break even point this what it's going to do is fix costs in the

103long run costs are rising very quickly going to get worse this will you know although in the first year it may be a little more because there is always that startup and everything else happening the second year won't the second year will be pretty fixed in the third year right now now I'm trying to build a budget and come to Jack and he looks at me and goes what do you think the number is going to be right and depending on a lot of factors and what they charge me it's hard for me to put a pin in what transportation for homeless preschool Foster on a district all these other factors it's hard to put a pin in that because it I'm dealing with many vendors and in in a in a lack of Workforce

104so it's like how do you know what that's going to cost you this will say here's our fixed cost on this if it's effective and it works it's a long-term investment but again it's employes but I'm also confident that Jack will you know spread the costs out appropriately that maximizes you know or minimizes the impact our budget and Max maximizes the benefits we get some things to mitigate it so you don't all at once and we don't plan on dropping you a million bucks and saying yeah that's what it is we'll have some Creative Solutions to get there so whether we phase it or right okay and honestly like this looks good to me just on first impression I know there's going to be unanticipated costs and unanticipated benefits that we haven't you know so

105I'm not worried about like things coming out of left field necessarily what I care about is if you think this is a good idea and you think this is a good investment and you think this is proper for conquered District to have you know like you guys are the experts and if this is a an investment that you think is good for the district in the long term we want to hear from you um because just from a practical perspective it seems like a really good idea but if you're like the workload is going to be too much I want to I want to hear that and we can come up with a fiveyear plan for when it's going to work for us or if you're like this is never going to work for us

106I I genuinely care about your opinions on this so we have such good experience because you already own your Fleet right so you've experienced what it's like to own it and um uh because it's been a positive thing even through the most difficult times you had you delivered when other companies were didn't have bus drivers couldn't deliver couldn't do Roots you were able to do that because you had the ability to be flexible to change and I I see that same uh sense still considering some of the concerns John brought forward but but all solvable to me that that it's the future investment that counts for me yeah Capital yeah and I you know I drive up and down 93 I can't tell you how many Mom and Pops we've seen uh just every morning

107driving up and down the highway and when when I know that we can find it in a way to benefit us control it's about controlling costs you know we'll never they won't go away John will tell you he has 140 preschoolers that need to get somewhere or we all of a sudden have homeless family or a foster placement that takes it right out of our hands right you're in a good place for it yeah my I personally feel that the biggest risk in this would be the investment and then not being able to hire enough drivers right to offset that so that we don't see as great a savings or benefits as as as we perform out on this and I think we just need to be cognizant and manage that challenge and risk that's

108not going away in some ways that licensure that they have to get for the big buses is really a uh it's an impediment for us right because it's a lot to do that and you know your drivers tend to be a little bit older and they don't want to go through all that so when I see the folks driving up and down 93 join that road every morning with me and they're a little bit older they don't need that level of life and they have two or three kids on the bus not 42 kids or 50 and it does make a difference and so Jim I agree with you I'm worried about that but with some things that Jack will share with you about our negotiations and I think we we could manage this well

109and I also think that are there are benefits and there's employment uh items that make guard District very attractive or more attractive than other opportunities and other companies they just shared that with us as tonight thanks all right and this may be in nonpublic or maybe you've mentioned this could we um would we pay for the become certified or the license shair yes okay cool okay we shall are we good to move on let's move on thank you very much for how am I doing jack great great perfect we'll tighten it up real quick so you have in front of you the budget presentation schedule this is brid version from as earlier based on the request of the board as my understanding so February 12th will be the opening presentation with a budget overview and

110then you'll have three work sessions um before the 5th when you would need to post the budget because your Charter requires 10day notification y so we're going to squeeze all that in do a little bit of a crash course see where we're at on the fth WE Post then you have your public hearings you'll have an open session after that public hearing and then look to finalize on March 26 Jack when will we as a board be able to see the budget in detail you usually post put that in the uh in my goal is to value that Friday the 14th okay so people can spend Valentine's Day with their budget rather than maybe a significant out oh that sounds so great with me although some others may choose the 15th to be the all

111right um an idea that I have floating around I probably will not be able to get to it this year but if I set it for up for next year I spoke to a bunch of other districts and they found working with their local public television doing quick Public Finance 101 and this is not on you this is board members creating a quick video be like okay this in this upcoming hearing we're talking about this let me give you Baseline what that means and we may get no views we get tons but giving that Baseline education public that's available snip like little just like we were talking about with schooly like how to videos um so I'm working with a few folks to see what's already out there too to direct people like this is

112what we're talking about that' be great two people watch it it's two people do you think we could thread them with the with the actual hearing like so that when they go to YouTube to watch the hearing that's what I'm hopeful for like yep they would be before or after right and would be awesome and there's a lot of resources already out there that we can use um gfoa wherever um so I'll work with them and see what we can do which would be nice sorry go ahead sorry so that's that I think this was sent out to you prior and I haven't checked to see if this is posted on the web if not we can do that tomorrow and usually what we do is we post this and then we have a com

113for the minutes a column for the I don't know theyum for the documents I'll check in the morning so aw I think we wanted to in front of you first make sure there wasn't anything else so um yeah that'll be good very cool and then final agenda item we'll go into nonpublic for a few moments yes for that last item what am I supposed to say okay so I'll make a motion to go into nonpublic session pursuant to RSA 91 2 article one section A is there I guess you have to ask for a second I will second okay and then do we roll call this one I believe roll call this thank you Jim Richards yes carara maker yes Jessica Campbell yes all right we're now you need your G the eyes the A's

114have it yes so non you yeah you can tell them we're not going to come back in public you're doing a great job yeah I think you're doing fantastic than it yeah all right let me see if I can get this up front so you can see what's you don't have to although you will I did notice that Liz gaves with authority man for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.