001that was not was in is back in so they they stick around thank you very much for sticking around okay ready to begin okay so this is our first presentation in the board um during go setting talked about wanting to have more presentation about curriculum and data um so Amy Parkinson is our director of curriculum instruction and assessment Works closely with teams in your schools um she has two pieces of information to share with you tonight one um is some assessment data and the other is the um material slection we've been talking about that all the umbr media specialists in the SAU have been working on this for about a year um so am's gonna review their work with you and her it's easier to look at data in color did Amy I have the
002camera on fortunately we can't do you need one I have one than well yeah I'll take one though so hiet you yeah so I've been working with your team so when we get to the last section with like some of my recommendations I actually started working with some of them already let's go guys because they were really excited to get started so in general what I did for you is I gathered up some of your assessment data from the last year or so and then some of the data is actually from R um if you have looked at the um maybe yeah it might be a little clunky um if you look on the SAU website there is a link on the curriculum page that goes to a data dashboard that has all the data
003for your District um a lot of the stuff from here is in there it also links over to your I ready account information just so you can have it but I thought it would be helpful to just come and talk a little bit about how I already breaks down the data and then a couple Trends we're seeing with the staff data um so we'll start with I ready your I ready data opposite way okay um it comes in a couple different ways so we when we pull the data we can look at the beginning of the year view the view of where they should be for their grade and then we can look at the view of where they could be potentially on the State Testing that is brand new it just opened up at
004the very end of last year um so we have not really seen enough to know if that's a valid indicator of State Testing yet um but we are looking forward to seeing a couple more Trends come in and see if it matches up but the the first one is actually that I look at it's the beginning of the year data from this fall so where your students are based on where they should be at the beginning of the year so if they're green they're like good to go there where they're supposed to be on average or they're above if they're yellow they're a little bit behind but definitely catch up and they may catch up without much intervention at all um they may need a little bit of extra help and then red are the
005students are generally going to need more help getting caught up for the school year um so overall your numbers are are good they match where we're going sorry I don't know is that okay questions no go ahead um is and I assume I think this is from the whole school not a particular grade or anything correct yeah and sorry I am fairly new to standardized testing is this from a standardized test yes so this is from your I ready testing so I ready we implemented it last last year SAU wide from K to n we pulled it back from n9th grade this year so it's K8 um however it's done in all the schools in the SAU and what it does is it t assesses the students three times a year in math and in
006reading and what it does is it says here are some questions how are you doing on them it's a computer based test and then says hey you got all those right let's move you forward to a more difficult question and it keeps adjusting its levels until it can figure out exactly where our student is we do not start K until winter bench have not heard of this yeah in the fall we do a uh organic Benchmark or where we look at kids what what the letters they know the sounds they have right in the winter which is January we will do we will do K because we like to get them it is computer-based and we like to make sure that all the students that the computer part is not what they're being tested on
007right that they know how to use the mouse and they know how to press the buttons and do all of that so that we're not holding them back on that because there's nothing worse than knowing a kid knows something and knowing that the test itself is what broken Boer alert we're going to talk about that when we get to the science test in the kindergarten we have touchscreen Chromebooks too because not every not all the kids can use a trackpad or a mouse so we have touchscreen freaking earing in first grade yeah so this is so the fall assessment um is going to give us a couple things so the first one this is just your general overall placement for the fall where we're going where they are beginning um reading sour if keep looking
008through and this is why I gave you a color version it's because it's a little bit easier to see beginning of the year are the students where they're supposed to be according to their peers across the country um and and yes you know this is this is actually this is good sometimes you would have a little bit less green but um you guys I mean dude your phological awareness there is like through the chart nice job um is it bonic something too that I mean some kids get and some kids don't and it's it's a tricky thing that's a tricky test yes so the fact that they're there it says a lot it's also one of the few tests and you'll see this when you look at like the where the students are for the
009end of the year SC um where they just don't assess them after a certain grade so once a student has tested out of the phonics the the computer just says no they they got this we're all set um so reading know we're doing well there's some areas that we generally need to work on and this a recommendation for later on usually it's that comprehension that's across the board so that's tricky it takes a lot and it's one of those skills that sometimes the development takes a while I what grade is I can't be here at kindergarten it does yep yep so they start looking at their ability to read and understand stories and listen to stories and understand them in kindergarten and both true stories and fictional stories so it's pretty impressive how it does
010it um the system also one of the things I like about it is that partway through it gives them little breaks and they get to play little games that are both strengthening their skills but are also really fun and some of the skills they're strengthening are things like how do use your touchpad or your mou like you have to scat caps like and some of them are hey here's a game on having a pizza parlor that's my personal um sorry can I just ask another broad question um so this is I ready is I assume this is like a New Hampshire Department of Ed approved product or approved product it is if it is an approved product is not from the new New Hampshire Department of Education but it does count as an improved product
011and can be used um to qualify our dyslexia screening so that is a nice little treat we are transitioning in that across the SE for different parts we're still using some of the old screeners just because this is so new to us yeah I was going to ask like how do we know sort of what percentage of the state is using it or like just so we have comparative data like is it new they it's no it's been around for a while and in fact they have like full curriculum programs they have they have a lot of stuff is a large company um but it is one of those situations where like the normed data the numbers are huge comparing it again okay but it's not Statewide no it is not Statewide the stas is
012Statewide in a required test this is something we have chosen to support our students going it does test the same things so the alternative would be like St tting yeah so and the STAR testing especially as you get into older grades um like I I was a high school teacher for a long time um the students memorized the answers to the STAR testing so it was kind of hilarious because they would go in and be like oh I know the answer to this one and they would just click the button and like well that's not a good assessment um math so our beginning of the year stuff it's still looking pretty good like there are areas that are less strong across the board State Testing School testing all geometry and that algebraic thinking so again
013this correlates pretty closely to that comprehension a lot the algebraic thinking stuff and geometry is is a strle um pretty common though but not like we're not in alarming points so the next set of data looks much worse that's why I put it twice I put in the second part but only because this is where your students are in the fall based on where we would expect them to be in the spring of that year so if we gave them this test like they end of the year test now where would they score um and so yeah you know this this one grade level below which is yellow well that's to be expected because they are almost an entire one grade below and the test take out part in like September early October sounds like
014a preest it is like a preest yeah so we could use this data next year and compare it to their post test and that's what their growth scores are so if you look at any of the data things we talk about growth scores that's what it's judging on do we have spring test from last year yes we do yeah so and all that's on the data dashboard like everything is on there so you can see all the going back and the growth scores and everything they did when we're talking about if you look at look as far as being like three or more grade levels below which is like looks like for reading it's 9% I mean that's pretty high or is that not high considering it's K to eight so it's K to eight
015and it's so so one to eights it could not be like not a lot of kids but also um this is also going to include all students so all students took the assessment so students who are working at a much lower level due to needs are T are falling under this one too you mean like identified students like identified students who have reading struggles it wouldn't be in adapted test or something it would be the same test it keeps them at the level it's the same test and it adapts to them as they go and we provide supports like roud and all of that but modify we modify it but we do but it doesn't have like a full accommodations within the Test's see so things that by the end of the year like um
016high frequency words yeah I mean if you look around the school there are words everywhere like there are things written everywhere in this school tons of stuff you can see why their high frequency words are really high um phonics phonological awareness Grace not this is literally like do they recognize their alphabet and that letters come together to make words so once they get to a certain age they're like we're not even going to ask you a question you know that that's the letter a um literature comprehension literature there all that but again this is end of the year based on their fall like they're doing well on that we can see where we want to work and that's what Specialists will use and like some of the groups will use to focus their work um
017math not not quite as great one keeps going other way um but still like so what this what they tell you in the training is that anyone who is up to about like the this like a little bit into the pink section right so the this like M two grade levels below all of those people are going to be fine those kids are fine we'll catch them about that are a little bit behind it's this part that they're concerned of um but still like we can see that okay geometry let's look a little bit more geometry how are we doing geometry what are we doing with geometry for like Littles I think sometimes it's a scary word in in reality it shes um algebraic thinking my biggest pet PE was always not just calling it
018algebra for like Littles one apple plus one apple equals two apples no one cow plus how many cows equals three cows that's just algebra that's all that is you're just using different words um so working on that algebraic thinking and when you work on algebraic thinking and you work on the comprehension from the lit it's all intertwines so can ask a question so when you do the testing in the fall and then you're doing this testing so you know where they need to this is all individual data that you have and so I'm assuming then that this is used for like the wind placements and things like that or if they need a little extra help they behind yep yep and um as the year goes on the next wave of testing is like January
019into the very beginning of February um what's going to happen is it will start showing each student has like a report with like graphing where they are where they're going where we would expect them to be they met that goal all of those kind of things so we can then reassess groups look at supports that are happening celebrate all their all their successes we can do all of that we're always looking at this data during plc's um this is where our reading and math specialist um and interventionist this is the area that they're focusing in on uh so do you have plcs that are just those people or do you are you plc's broad like a you know broad group of people or we have P every grade level has a PLC meeting so you're
020doing plc's of like people not like when when we did them in our school like there might be a guidance counselor there' be administrator there might be a middle school and Elementary it's grade level yeah so so if it's second grade we're meeting with a second grade teachers some off often the parent Educators might join us the um Administration and um one of the interesting things for this school is also that as we were talking about at the last cob Bron board meeting um coob Bron is also using I ready so the data follows the students so it is possible to like look at student work along the way and conquered is not conquered is not however they are getting more schools pretty quickly so we'll see where it goes all right the next section
021is like a lot of data so it's something that like you know the nice thing sit around see have a data read wait for Santa has some SN um in general what this is and this is all in the data dashboard where you can then take it expand it make it bigger do all of that stuff but um it is your assessment data broken down by grades from the state assessment so the top one is your most recent set of scores the bottom one goes back to 24 2015 some disclaimers in this data that you should know from 2014 to like around 2018 2019 this was all a different test it was a different test then we had a year with no testing and then we started up with the new test so the 2018
0222019 is kind of a transition year with the testing but the test was different we used to have an S back and now we have the N New Hampshire SAS um so they're they test generally the same thing um but in reality we've seen there's a bit more and we've seen this just in testing in general a lot more expectations for analytical work so you which one the older one or the new the newer one so you cannot just memorize a bunch of stuff anymore and do really well in the test pretty much all assessment has moved in that direction you need to be able to do critical thinking analyze all of that whereas before like back in the day I know back when I took the test all you had to do is memorize
023the certain things and you would be fine so we are expecting a lot more from our students go way so third grade tricky first year I don't think it likes me Kristen yeah the the click the clicker is connected to the hard drive over there um fourth grade okay fifth grade about the same six seven and eight so especially in math this is very common that in sixth seventh and eth grade you start getting some changes um your s SC are actually pretty strong from hairs JW um eth grade um you will get an anomaly in eighth grade it's pretty common you'll notice like the scores are always are generally much worse like it's not just because it's like eth grade right um part of it is why are we doing this it's not important
024100% am be gred there's a lot of from grade teacher over here's a lot there's a lot of social aspect to it where you're like okay and we encourage them as much as we can to do their best and do their important stuff but there are something we see the same thing with 11th graders like like I used to be the 11th grade tester Y is this the spring test or the fall test this is the spring test this is spring for the state oh right it's only once during the SAS only once during minutes in the spring yeah and so I mean these eighth graders are are done by the time they get like mentally they're done could you speak a little bit though if we go back to like looking at say you
025know fourth fifth grade well I don't know it's still pretty high because both the red and the yellow are saying that they are not proficient right yeah and so you're talking about like a 35% that's like a third of our kids saying that they're not proficient could you just maybe speak a little sure so one generally we are about on par and there if you look on the last page you don't have it because you didn't have the oh oh I'm sorry yeah I added one extra page I did I put in the assessment proficiency over time comparison because it's come out from the state I know it just came out earlier um so that kind of Compares where we are at compared with the rest of the state overall like our proficiency versus the
026bottom if you look at it with the exception of us dropping Below on science this past year you guys have been pretty much above it but it's still not great so your school does not have as much of a problem like this year this past year was not an issue with it but we do have some issues with participation rate so in the state of New Hampshire it is allowed to opt out of a test parents will opt out student does not take it okay um the state however deems every opt out as an opat no matter what so we are still held accountable for those students not taking the test so if we ever drop below 95% like participation rate everything below 95% will will be a zero like every every continuing thing you
027only have one where like a 94 participation rate that was science I'm not understanding what you're saying so participation so if you have 100 students who take a test yeah and 95 of them take the test in the state of New Hampshire all their test scores count very good job really proud of you once you start doing like if you have of that 100 students 10 students oped out you've dropped down to 90% the 5% that's difference between 90 and 95% participation will count as a zero they won't count as like oh no only 90 kids took your test so we're going to take your percentage still in the percentage so then it looks like it's less than it really is I was wondering how affected with I was wondering how the testing because that's
028been a question I have you know a lot of people are proponents of getting your kids to opt out of the testing and I was wondering how it affected the school testing when they do that it does not it has not here like in this past year it did not okay by much like the science is like 1% um and as a whole Deerfield is very high like participation rate compared to the state average because the state average can drop down like science one section was like 66% okay y are are you saying that the 34% score that you're showing here in our district last year in the science test which is below the state average could be because of the incorporation of zeros because students are taking the test not for you guys not
029for us for some of the other schools yes and no because there's only 1% difference but if we get to a point where close we have so many students that are opting out then it could be that our our percent of of proficient could be then lowered by zeros of people who are not taking it you could yes gotta okay um and you'll notice like there's like the 8th graders disproportionately out way like this like there's back and forth there's only two groups to take the science only the fifth graders and the eighth graders um and we already know the eth grade doesn't really like to take tests get it there's a social thing so getting that incorporation back in about like how important it is um that's science is just fth and where's the
030other math the other difference is that when it comes to English language arts and math those tests for SAS are pretty long a lot of the science tests are not very long they're they're they're shorter do they still do the um they used to have like like an experiment that give them materials yeah so those are part of it and like some of like the digital version of it like and so it's it's It's Tricky yeah um but in but as you can see like if for the state our average is 36% like I do question some of the Val like the test itself like that's really low so what's going on I can tell you what we've done in response to it yeah but um in response and this is on the last page
031some of the key takeaways one of my recommendations was to look at Earth Science and motion standards because those are the ones that historically have been the worst I can go back datawise and look um your science department I met with the science folks the other week couple weeks ago we looked at their standards and we looked at like their curriculum and what they're teaching and they have some ideas about the competencies making the standards me align with ngsss which is the National Science standards that most schools like all line up with and ours do line up it's just a little bit of a wording situation but they are heavily invested in really looking at their curriculum and moving forward with some potential suggestions for changes in this wave um and they've already started to
032work on like some of this to make sure that this stuff is getting incorporated into it I know I know that science instruction too is it's very it's very different for a lot of newer teachers coming in and teaching it's not the same as te you like they get a lot of support on how to teach literacy and how to teach math in the universities and they get very little in science and I know because I used to teach the class and they gave me six weeks to teach them how to teach science so I it would be nice I mean I'm just wondering about the support that they're getting I know we we used when I was here we used to try to do a lot to try to help the teachers on how
033to teach critically and how to come up with the units and get them to think about it and how to make it you know fun science is I'm sorry but I'm very Prejudice and science is the most fun subject right but you have to you really need support in in learning it and also a lot of people have huge science misconceptions especially like forces and interactions there a lot of misconceptions there first systems a lot of misconceptions there and they really need to work with the teachers to make sure that they know those misconceptions yes so yeah that's that is the work that they doing and there is a team have been meeting and I met with them again I met with them and like we kind of structured what we want to do and
034I also hooked them up with some contacts from some of the other schools and um but also like getting com communication about like how we we're teaching science in the classroom um and sometimes it's just a reexamination of what we're doing like really just looking at it um on the state test because I think it has changed some since I even left teaching as far as identified students taking the test are they yes in order to not take a test as an identified student um you have to fall within the level of like what we call dlms so they used to be called the portfolio system even those are still assessments it's just done alternatively it's not done through the SAS um how the SAS says it you can put in accommodations and what for
035it um they are generally limited they're mostly time based right and sometimes reading aloud and like having a scribe right um but for the most part you it it's everyone so I remember like the reading section you couldn't read it to them correct so even if they had they were identified right we're testing reading but if you have a child who reading is their area yet you can't help them with it um which they've modified some of that so a little bit better and one of the things that's nice about I is that it will be it can be the test to the students as they are taking it as just a general accommodation and I think that one of the benefits of that company and that organization as a whole is that they recognize
036that accommodations for one student can benefit all students so why not try to get the most out of it for our kids yeah but I mean we're trying to actually test knowledge correct versus reading correct not your ability to read like see that on the screen do you know the science the other thing and just again from my own teaching experience as far as science when I first started teaching we had a lot of time to teach science and social studies remember when we went to science camp other schools were like in awe with the amount of time we had during the day to teach during the week as my years came to an end there was less time to focus on science because more Focus was put on other things so it's difficult to
037get in everything that needs to be taught when you don't have the time during the week to do it too and for me I loved teaching and so I would like to see make sure that we're giving the teachers the time to teach what they need to teach too in that area you see that in the measurement data like there's a measurement like category and ey writing and you can see where students start taking science as like a separate Standalone because all of a sudden they're measurements for but way up like there's your evidence like that's a good idea we should be doing this so yeah um so recommendations like I said the science we' started working on it um increase focus on comprehension skills I was talking with some of the interen interventionist some
038of the support staff we are working on that you also have some like cool programs that is getting focused on and then that need to focus on a little increasing geometry and sometimes it's as simple as identifying it as geometry and moving forward and just incorporating it in um we use big scary words in math sometimes and you know math is one of the few areas where hey thank you um where they come back and they're like hey wait I don't do math and people feel okay with saying I don't do math you would never say like I don't I can't read but you're okay with saying I can't do math um and like that's just a cultural shift in how we approach some of these things but yeah I'll have the new data for
039you as soon as it gets reorganized once you take the testing I just put them onto your system so your kids would be good to go when you come back yep and the teams are ready we've talked about that at PLC is the next round of benchmarks and so do parents get the data for their child specifically uh in the in the fall they are given it in November during parent teacher conferences um some grades were not clear that that's what they were supposed to do so we've tried to to fix that piece some will be sending the fall data along with the winter Benchmark data um so that parents have that information and then we send it we'll send it in the spring as well and um each Progressive one for the school year
040will incorporate the data from before so you'll be able to like a cute little chart so and for the teachers from from our point of view it also provides us the ability to go in for any student and say what does this student need to work on and not only tell us what they need to work on but give resources like free resources available from or just like here there's a whole bunch of things that you could work on with this student here are some groups that you could put this student in based on their ability it it really does a lot of that stuff and helps out we use some of those things because we like to have a more Hands-On approach to putting kids into groups but it's nice to have those little
041benefits yeah and are the I mean Pro I assume not but are the resources available to parents or like if a parent sees a particular concerning result because they reach out to the teacher and say you know I'm concerned about their geometry comprehension can you provide me some resources so you can work on yep and uh oftentimes we direct them to our math website as it's many people don't know how it is filled with Rich information and games to play and it's it's an amazing resource and U for reading um the reading Specialists are working on increasing online presence with that kind of information as well so awesome but yes teachers will be able to provide that for parents and Guardians that be fun to do science have easy experim do home I I had
042one student two brothers and he went home after everything I did and did it at home so then when I had his brother the next year he's like oh yeah I remember when Nate brought that home that's cool [Music] a so this is coming from thank you it was in your packet so you might have it not sure oh yes it is in the packet but thank you I I saw your email too late I'm sorry I was so quick to respond to the first one and then good um so this is just so for the past year and a little bit the um library media Specialists have been working on trying to update and the material selection policy um and this is their proposal that they were going to put forward on it um
043what they did is they went to they talked to their colleagues they went online they went to a whole bunch of different schools and saw what they had done with their proposal and they kind of took it looked at it and said well we're not too far off but here's where we want to just clarify some items and go through um and they just want to make it a little bit more user friendly so they made a huge nice little selection purpos of policy um and it just outlines who's responsible for what where the ultimate decision Li you'll notice that they put things in like in the school district so that we can just fill it in when it's time um and then they also included the appendix documents which are like okay if you
044are interested in a reconsideration of a book that has been chosen for the school this is the this is the procedure that we'd like you to follow please answer these questions um these are pretty much the ones you will find on any school website at this point for the policy um and then on the last page is their ratings form so we get that we go through it the team decides look at how we're going to judge um it also gives them the template of how they will be looking at books and materials coming into the school in general I think the one thing I wanted to ask about I like this the one thing I'm concerned about is it's days in in the classro in the library before a decision is made needs to
045be pulled um and I was wondering if there could be any I mean is it I would assume that if it something need office very you just pull it not wait for 35 days but I just wonder if that should be added in the policy just to make some you know the discretion of the principle or something because if I was a parent and I thought there was a book that was I mean I understand we're doing it we don't want everybody to control what is in our in our libraries we feel that they're there for specific learning purpose um but I'm just concerned about if it's something that's I I didn't expect it to be we just that issue recently that wasn't something we want still on the on the shelves for 35 days
046so that's now the plan for this is ex board it went to EXA board and now it's going to all individual boards yeah is each the exact board can approve it for the SAU but each individual district has will also approve it and can each individual board make changes or would that have to go back to the exact board we can make changes um the request from all the library media Specialists is to have one standard policy throughs yeah why why is that the the goal well it had to do with consistency just in general for the SAU especially since it's going to go to um part of it involves the superintendence so making sure that everything's aligned more closely do you know why oh sorry so then if the let's just the policy committee
047on our board has questions about some of the details in here what would you like the procedure for that to be they did not specifi one specifically that they would like but they wanted to talk about so I could just get get them back to you and you can you're in touch with the committee and I'm in touch with the committee and then if there were any changes that would need to be made at the request of up board then the whole body would need to meet again and then go through the exec board and then come back to the it doesn't have to go back to the exec board ultimately you make the decision for your different School District policies you know this group got together and they're they're you know they're excited about
048it and they work really hard and they think oh this would be great if we could all have the same policy whether that happens or not is that's each board's discussion okay yeah and I believe that the 35 days came from they weren't explicitly clear about this but I believe it came from looking at the other schools and what their policy is and just in a general like how long it's going to be but under the understanding that like if something's like feel like that's here that's why I have that con as a parent if I was reading this I would just be concerned like it's going to be there for 35 days Haven made a Qui L um it refers to the school library Bill of Rights and the attends which um is that
049on on the file that's this is on page three is that is that on the file can I find that somewhere did I no you should have you did not include it in my cop either it was online I think it online okay I think it is but awesome I just want to commend them I like like that they have actual form and you know and they work really hard to put a lot of thought into it because it's been it's been an ongoing process for a while so they really wanted to make sure they were addressing the needs of the community addressing the the interest in like providing for our own students and our own children and I so more like a consistent look across the state in the and I also like that
050you put in the respective review sources in here I it's very helpful for a teacher to use that yeah okay so we'll put it on your agenda for first reading next time was it on for first reading I can't remember if we already had it on there it was but we know yeah okay so it'll be first read next or should we go to Second next I can't remember if we moved everything to Second keep it on I don't remember but we yeah you don't ever have to approve it and if you're not ready so keep it on there great thank you thank you so much about question yeah okay awesome than I do think this um draft was requested by people us y that's right okay thank you so much for joining us okay
051we will move on to the defa budget approval welcome Amber thank you long time no not even 24 hours um okay so we have approved the operating budget bottom line we have not yet approved the default budget line so anyone who was here last year probably recalls that there were questions about the default budget calculations and there was an article about it in the Jo is that so we did take a closer look at the default in our calculations um so we did make some adjustments here and we invited Amber to sort of share how the methodology for um calculating the default budget sure thanks for joining oh no problem so when you uh open your packet the default budget kind is over to the right it's the second to last column um but before
052I get there I just want to kind of go through our process of how we did or how I developed um the default budget so as just like with when we create a regular budget we start from zero and kind of build up with some this is a little bit different in the fact that we have to take the prior year into consideration because a default budget is last year's expenditures plus or minus onetime expenses plus any contractual item so but I still approach it like I do an operating because I still go line by line to see what everything is can I just clarify something sure so you said last year's expenditures is it last year's that's different than a budget actual right so like correct it's last year's budgeted not what actually occurred
053expenditures budgeted yep just wanted to clar so for instance like we'll take like General supplies if we budgeted 5,000 and I would then look at that line to say okay in that 5,000 was there anything in there that you would only purchase one time or is that more generalized like your paper your pencils your everyday materials and and and Kristen says yeah it's paper materials and then I also had to buy this but I'm not going to need it next year because it was a one-time thing I would subtract that out of it I would only include the generalized materials something that would carry from year to year anything that's a one-time thing would be subtracted up that's why when you go through the lines you may see in the supply lines it's not going
054to exactly match the default because there are things that are one onetime expenses so I go through every single line I determine okay is this a line that could have a potential one-time expense I put together a spreadsheet that I send to miss wiy who then goes through the spreadsheet and says okay in this line these are the things I purchase okay yep I had this thing that I only needed last year we're not going to purchase it again I then subtract it out or if it was one or it could be something like she says okay I know we need to create I KN I know we need to cut some some lines to try to lower the budget at the end this is what I typically spend because this is really what we
055need but I need to find some money somewhere to cut those aren't things that I would cut from a default budget because those are things that we would typically need but we just have to make Cuts somewhere so you shouldn't lose your everyday items just because you have to make a cut does that make sense so some of the the things that um need need to be included or anything that's contractual like a CBA that's included uh any other types of contracts that um are voted by the public so transportation is included um because it is mandatory by law special ed is included because it is mandatory by law so there are some items that are yep that are mandatory and some items that are not so I go through line by line to determine
056what is a one-time expense what is contractual and what is mandatory by law those are the items so I know there's been discussion over the last couple years in regards to the default budget I have gone through several conferences workshops I've spoken with our our Council on multiple occasions and that's has been the guidance in the past with that said I know there was a lot of chatter last year so over the summer and a little bit into the fall I looked out at some more documentation also um received some additional guidance to see if there was any methodology changes and from the guidance I previously received there was some so when I went through the very first time I created the budget um I had taken a lot of of those items already into
057consideration so the changes you're going to seats this evening are minimal because I had already taken those the reason why you're seeing some changes tonight is because we've investigated a little bit further there was an article as Kendra has mentioned that was posted so I took a look at what was in that article to see if any of that aligned with the different methodologies that needed to take place um so that's was my Approach so I did come up with a spreadsheet um that you have in front of you there's um two uh three boxes the first box that's in blue is the um comp comparative default for 2425 compared to our 2526 default that was your our first proposed so when I gave you the budget back on I think it was like November
0584th was your first version that was where it was on the first version in the very Middle where it's like a pinkish red color that is my second version okay so the areas that are on here that I um looked a little further into or um some positions that are not covered by a CBA um are contractual in the sense where they might be a multi-year agreement but are not part of a CBA so when we budget for those if they're not in the middle of a contract we always budget those at the end of the budget and then once the year comes it gets buil out into their actual salary line so I took a look at those the other things you'll see on here um some of these items were items that were
059list listed in that article so I paid special attention to those um co-curricular officials was on there um custodial salaries uh substitute salaries secretary salaries those types of things the other section was utilities now utilities there is a lot of um differences I it's probably I think one of the most challenging areas because I think the guide there is different levels of guidance there one document will say one thing another document will say another thing and legal council might say some some something slightly different so from the guidance I received utilities are considered are necessary for an adequate education so you will see that I have kept the utilities in where somebody else may have taken them out from a document um that they may have read what I will say is there is some
060guidance that is out there that is currently under litigation so there still battling whether they think it should or shouldn't if you put us all the Bas in the same room I will guarantee that we all do it slightly different so that was one of the areas I think I found most challenging there was some items under facilities that I took a look at which was ground maintenance um and then one of the other things that has been uh I would say one of the guidance I received several years ago was in regards to if you had like a um like a technology recycle plan if it has been in fruition for multiple years uh I would the guidance at the time was you could carry it forward the new guidance I've received is that
061wouldn't carry forward with that said when I budgeted the first round I had already taken that into consideration because some of the things that I had read over the summer um did State something different so unless the only time that type of plan would move move forward is if you the budget was the actual operating budget was adopted because then technically they're agreeing to that plan to move forward the one reason why I bring that up specifically is most schools have a three to fiveyear technology replacement plan so there is a specific plan in place to carry forward year after year uh some of the other things that were not included in the article but I considered items of reconsideration um was liability insurance uh co-curricular salaries maintenance agreements in regards to like software so
062we talk about that line in regards to that's the line where um the SAU helps out and does the bulk shopping and then we disseminate out that those deals to the districts and you're charged only per your util uh utilization for your school that was one of the areas I looked at and then contracted Services which would be like plowing Landscaping things like that um which I would not consider at this point moving forward um an item that would be made be in default a lot of that has to do is a lot of those contracts are a one-year contract not a multi-year contract um but if we were in the middle of the multi-year contract and and the the operating budget moves forward potentially it's arguable that it becomes you're saying is we would
063have to use whatever money we have PL and this would have to stay the same it would stay the same even though you would need to pay a higher price you would have to find somewhere in your budget in order to cover the expense um and then those are really the areas so comparative to what I first put together and I'll give you specifics we'll go through specific uh the difference between the first time I created the default in the revision um with the slightly different me methodologies the difference you're going to see in your bottom line is 18,600 okay on this sheet if you look all the way over to the right which is the purple section I've given you what the differences are in all the sections I've listed and then I've also
064given you the line numbers that attribute to those within your budget so if you go to line 38 which is is on page five um page six P6 at the very very top the special ed coordinator is the is the POS one of the positions you'll notice that the default um the proposed excuse me the default 24 the proposed and the default 25 are all the same the reason why those are all the same that the proposed is exactly the same is because that multi-year contract was coming to an end so that's why the proposed lines up you'll find in other sections like when if we go down to line um 108 that will be slightly different that's on page 13 that's the principal salary you'll notice in the Middle where the default column is
065for 2425 which is your voted budget you'll notice is 102 the proposed is 108 and then if you go to default it goes back down to 102 even though that position is in year two of a three-year contract it would not make it into the default because it was not an item that was pre prior approval that the community had approved it was a increase that the Schoolboard had entered into after the fact it's is it an increase from 102 it's an increase from this year's contract which is correct so the the the yes and so I say 108 but that really is two years of salary increase because when we budgeted for last year um it was the first year of the contract but again it was budgeted down below under the 2900s but
066once it's a multi-year contract it will then be year two would be budgeted in the actual line so it's really this year's increase and next year's in increase in that particular salary line so it's not like getting a $6,000 increase in one year it really is two years thank you Amber yeah does that make sense okay all right so some of the other lines are line um 57 which will be on page seven this is your co-curriculars this is your co-curricular uh officials and you'll notice that the default was 17,190 and the default proposed is also 17,190 the actual proposed budget is lower the reason why it's lower is because right now there might be some um sports that aren't running but that's not to say that the district doesn't need that or didn't want
067that but they're just not running so they shouldn't lose the funding just because they don't have enough students currently once they have enough students they'll be able to run the program so the money needs to be available for when that happens now should their budget get approved and they get the actual they get the 13,000 so they would have to budget more next year to try to cover that program if you go up one more to co-curricular salaries you'll notice um the same the voted default for this year is 42,000 the proposed budget is 39,000 the proposed default is 42,000 same methodology there we're just lowering it for the proposed because know we're not going to have some programs Run next year but it doesn't mean they should lose the funding for it it's the
068same thing you can compare it to um a position that on a roster that is an open position that hasn't been filled just because the position hasn't been filled or you don't um you're having trouble filling it doesn't mean you should lose that position in your roster you would still get to carry that position to your default the only time you wouldn't carry a position to your def default is if you add a position so you say okay I need one more fourth grade teacher that additional FTE wouldn't make it but if you had an open fourth grade position that was open already on your roster but just hadn't been filled that would move forward does that make sense okay if I'm going too fast let me know all right um let's see here so
069on line 13 one which is custodial salaries same methodology there as um principal um the principal salary that is also um a group of Staff members that are not covered by a CBA so when um Patty brings to you um during budget session and says okay these are the group of individuals that aren't covered by a CBA would you still like to give them an increase and typically it's you know anywhere between two to three % or so plus a market adjustment if that needs to happen again always budgeted in the 2900s and then moved up this particular area along with food service has received Market adjustments in the p over the last few years to help bring them in alignment with the what the rest rest of society is is happening if you go
070down the street or not down the street here you go down the street from where I live you go to a Wendy's they are already making 15 plus dollars so we tried to bring that those staff members up so the school board has done that with that said those increases should not make it into a default Bridge because it was not what was Prior voted can I ask a couple questions so online 64 nurse that could gone up well if one it's CBA and um there's also additional days in there add not correct correct that's why there for the proposed is 82,000 but the defaults 80 I cannot include the five additional days now should um the district receive the proposed operating then moving forward those five additional days will carry from year to year
071but because the public hasn't or Community has not voted that in at this point it doesn't and that's something that we've that methodology has been going on for years that is not a change and the point two is a one day nurse we okay but we haven't added any additional it's just the additional five days so it's the same thing for line 114 that's Network Tech same thing correct correct correct yep but we have always we've always done that that I the there's two positions It's usually the guidance and the nurse are typically get additional days for some the districts and if you end in a default they keep losing those additional days so they haven't made it into a budget in quite some time um let's see here I think I can probably so
072really line um The Substitute salary which is line three which is going to be um on page two of your budget um you'll notice so um 2425 we budgeted 4,710 the proposed is 50,000 uh the proposed default would remain at 45710 we would not get the extra funding there the other salaries are pretty much the same so then let's go down to line 136 which is electric so really this next section is the utilities um and the guidance that I have received is that utilities are necessary in order to Pro provide an adequate education in order for you cannot have your electricity shut off you need to be able to pay it um as well as propane oil and so forth one of the other things that makes it a little bit challenging with some
073of the utilities is that like for instance Oil propane they tend to they're not contracts aren't July to June they cross over the fiscal years so they may end in like May or or end in November or something like that so it's not it does from year to year it's not a it's more on calendar year tends to be or even an off cycle but not a fiscal year so they do cross over ground maintenance which is line 145 on page 17 the default voted was 55500 we're proposing 63,500 the default would revert back to 55 though most of the all of those are really year-to-year contracts so they would not make it through okay uh line 33 I'm sorry it's going back and forth I probably should have put them in order for you
074line 33 on page five I believe it will be um right in the very middle of the page this is the computer network work replacement this is where I was talking about that computer recycle um plan that we that all the districts have you'll notice that the um voted 2425 was 60,62 the proposed is 60,000 and the proposed default is 60,000 the reason why it matches is because there were some items on that plan that um wouldn't be purchase every year the other thing is is if your Five-Year Plan comes to an end we wouldn't Carry It Forward right so because your meth your the things you're purchasing might be slightly different so sometimes it will match your default and sometimes it might go it might be lower because of the one-time expense like maybe
075I I don't know what I maybe they needed cameras or something like that for a couple years but all right now have the cameras on the fourth and fifth year we don't need the camera so we would take that so that's why that one's a little bit slightly different so those are pretty much the areas that were in the article the areas that are down below that I said other areas to consider I had already taken these into consideration there's no changes in liability insurance there was no changes in co-curricular salaries from the first um draft you received no um changes in the maintenance agreements which um it are the bulk shopping for your software I had already taken that into consideration and the contracted Services um which are you're plowing mowing that type of
076thing I had already taken those into consideration the first time so you won't see any changes from the first round in those lines um but what I will say is I did not carry forward um the increases um the proposed increases that we're proposing for next year in the operating budget those were not carried forward to the defa I just didn't need to make any changes because I had already taken them into consideration can I just mention um we we had multiple meetings all week every night and I apologized that I did not get this before our assistant left for the day so I wasn't able to post itead time I we've been really trying to do that for the public so I just want everybody to know why it was like 4:30 when finished
077it um so I will get Clos to tomorrow anyone ask looking for it um it wasn't intentional so this version of the budget includes the C subtraction of 18, it does it does I went through and made those changes compared to the the prior budget yep question the that transfer to food so the so the reason why that one is down there is because up above you'll see like where in the middle section where it's co-curricular officials the very bottom is Food Service salaries so that would need to be modified um it need it actually would need to go up in the reason for that being our proposed is 97,000 and the default is 99 it really needs to revert back to 99 because I will tell you that there was a roster um miscalculation
078um in the propos so the propos will actually be sure so it it does need to go up the reason why it is listed below is because when you change something in the Food Service budget it is a separate budget outside the operating it affects a couple Lines within the operating budget there's a transfer and then there's also a line at the very last or second to last line of your budget where it is the the total Food Service program so it affects both those lines I would need to increase the transfer food service and the total of the Food Service program so I just wanted to put it down below because it is technically outside the operating budget um because those salaries aren't included it's a totally separate budget but because it a there
079is that program is not sustainable on its own there is a operational piece that covers that budget to get it to break to zero and you also have to um budget total Appropriations which is why at the very end of the budget you'll see Grant expenditure in Food Service expenditures because you have to Total appropriate so you have to take your fund one your grants plus your food service to get your total appropriation okay all right other questions are we ready to move forward with approval all right I will go ahead and make a mo to approve the uh proposed default budget in the amount of 20,200 20 million 2886 any discussion thank you for l oh you're welcome appreciate you welcome the double checks and I will continue to review guidance as it comes
080through and any changes I will make sure to to to update you and moving forward awesome all right all in favor of the motion I I any all right excellent Dr one article um so I noticed today that again we we're doing some training at the office right now um we did change the you have wanted to change I think it was two three and four to be funded from Surplus so but the missing sentence was this sum to come from the 20 June 30th 2025 un assigned fund balance available for transfer that sentence is missing in the drive so I added that that has to be there um and then change from the last meeting to three and four to um I did notice that two three and four are missing the words of
081the amount oh oh yep Oh you mean spell out 10,000 numbers have we um double checked the names of our trust our trust Joanna doesn't have to come I I asked that get done um I didn't review it to make sure it was correct but I did ask that for you did you Amber did you Che um yes I believe I did when do we need the final versions to be um as soon as you take action we can send it on to the NBC I think the only outstanding article that we needed to talk about was the you had brought up Stage Road at the last meeting yeah upate the board on yes stage big exciting fun um so yes Patty had sent uh an email to Legal asking to draft a warrant we
082would need more specific information about the assess no appraisal of the property so I could try to get an appraisal in the next week or so I don't think that's particularly likely um but you know if the board wanted to try to move forward with it this year we could try to get an appraisal done on the property so the the way that the Warren article reads is um you know that sh the school would have the authority to sell this property assess at X and the proceeds will be placed in you have to have an estimate of what the properties were right and that would be establish in the trust fund also at the same time no we were G we were going to put it in like building the building one or Renovations
083or whatever then that takes away all our freedom to make any kind of deals with anybody sort of yes so that that means it would be sold market value is what that article would say that's what the town would be approving it would be well it would it the draft language said um terms and conditions that GS to be the best interest of the district and further to appropriate up to the sum of so it's you're going to get as much as you can you have to put an estimate on what the property is worth and then if you ended up getting more than that the extra would just come in as um re offset but a question I had last time when this came up was if we wanted to work with the Conservation
084Commission let's just for example to come up with some sort of another solution that language in that article would preclude that would not be an possibility we would be forced if it was approved to sell it for market value well I don't think so it say says up to further and further to appropriate up to the sum of x from the net proceeds of the sale and if you trying to sell it for less than that you could sell it but it you have to have an amount to say up to the sum of blank from the proceeds would go into the trust fund so you have to have an amount there but if you sold it for less then that's the amount that would go if you sold it for more the rest it
085goes to the dollar value listed within the warrant article would have to go to that fund the town has to approve how much money is going into war right I mean yes except that we have to sell it in half for monetary value couldn't give it away so could we sell it to the town for a dollar I not that would be the point we're trying to someone could argue that it's not in the best interest of the district yeah to do that um so I guess maybe then I would not argue for pushing ahead in a week to try to get this thing to go through I would rather take a year till next march to touch base with the town and you're not getting any public input putting this on seems like an
086uned I don't disagree um you know it was a thought that a fleeting thought that I had it's a great idea but if we had more flexibility after after that vote I would be in favor of that this sounds like we locked into a little bit or more so with a particular kind of rout and I think it's to to commit to that I agree I mean you know it's possible people in town have very have a lot of thoughts about this and want to see it conserved or something um maybe we need to do a committee set up a committee next year with people from planning board Conservation Commission energy committee concerned citizens whatever and do have a committee and look at what's the best you then something have a public forum like you
087did with high school have di is it probably is too late for this but then what about a different slightly different wording for an article that would be more like a poll kind of a question I know we don't like those so much but like to to get the most feedback this is the time to get the most feedback from the town about selling it or conserving I think you could do I mean I don't know that you would need a warn article to make like an exploratory committee but you could ask like should the school board create an exploratory committee to consider the sale or the best use of bester for that's not the that's not I talking my idea is asking the town if they would like to sell it for profit or
088whatever or conserve it but I think the problem with that though is that you don't really know what the conserv it could be so people are voting on something that they really don't know what it could be we also don't have an appraisal of the property so if someone is saying how much could we get for this could this pay for our unit ventilators so that we don't have to pay for it you know I agree I think we should unfortunately probably wait and keep it on uh I would like to sort of deal with it though I'd like to make that a goal for next year yeah and it was last year we talked about it yeah I think we actually put it on but we talked it yeah but I think this is
089the time to make it and then maybe handle it in the right way because I I agree with you I'd rather have input from the community to really do a thoughtful thing with this piece and not just I also you know I think that there are I've already heard comments that oh they're just going to put a bunch of houses on it and now we do have the study from the planning commissioner whoever that says you know exactly how much it would impact the school population potentially um so we can share all of that information have a have a more educated discussion on it I noticed that the top the date in the wrong year on the warrant yeah 20 2024 we this has I don't think it's I don't think voting onered it hasn't
090been sent to okay so I can send it if you're happy with the amounts edits mentioned is it in the order you want funded too I excited kind of a boring warant this year sometimes that's a good thing we only have four so a board member doesn't have to present one someone gets a free P wow drawing straws yeah wow all right any other comments or do everyone find to make the edits as discussed and S toal and we have hopefully the final draft for you need vote on and they can certainly have the draft should we send them a draft have all right we need a motion unless you want to I can add in the numbers and we can vot on on the Articles now like for the first one you've already voted
091on your budget so it's more okay day is the next meeting right not new new unfortunately now we're not putting New Year City together uh are there any informational items no it was I sent a letter to school board they on one call now have G opening or okay I didn't get one okay I I have yeah okay uh we are then back in public comments K bur and Karen Road it's uh it's interesting follow along the board you guys uh see standardized test uh data presented because a lot of times people poo poo uh standardized test is not telling us anything snapshot in time and then we look and we're giving an awful lot of standardized test and putting a lot of stock into it in this in this school um and I I
092find that that Duality very very interesting that that some people say well don't don't look at this but yet we we're looking at it it sounds like we're looking at it for uh placement of students um Etc and so I think it's something board numbers really need to to give some thought to as to what you think those tests really are um what they're doing what they're they're providing uh to students because other than the SAS none of them none of them are mandatory you don't have to get kids standardized test if you don't want it you want to go back to Old School schooling that's not really why I I stuck around all night I stuck around all night because I've been saying it and other people been saying it couple of years ago
093there's some real animosity between the board um and a large swath of the public and then we got a lot of new numbers on and for a year or two it it seemed like it was going in the right direction and and and things were moving along in in a good way right to bring Unity back to to the community and I think we're slipping back rapidly to U what was causing people a lot of consternation just a few short years ago and and it doesn't matter to me you have a difference of opinion right the challenge is it it's it's your credibility right that when when when you say things that demonstrably able to be proven to be incorrect and you dig in your heels it it goes to character it goes to to
094trustability and then when we have and so if you lose that trust is any of that trust right especially if you us losing it a little bit at a time then when something goes on something you know nobody expected if people are already distrustful and wary about about their governing board over their local public school and what's going on that compound it it's I used to have a saying discipline in the classroom is like a healing balloon right so long as you hold on to it you're okay but if you let it go if you lose you lose control of your class it's almost impossible to get it back right it's really really hard and it's the same thing with our credibility so we need to be very careful very careful what words we use
095how we express things to make make sure that our remarks are factually accurate factually correct to the point because when they're not and people can call things into question then we lose credibility we lose respect to the public and and that it is of critical importance especially for the public school system because unless you can afford to send your kid somewhere else by law you have to send your kid here 180 days a year whether do you like or not that's that's the option right it's mandatory public school and so this should be the most transparent the most easy to work with the most clear Board of any elected board or committee anywhere because it's the public school and that's where people are sending their kids and and so I just really ask that that
096you you go home and and just take a fresh look at it think about it because we need a school board that that people believe they can come to and be heard that they can they can come to and get answers and that they believe that they're being told uh the the cold honest truth straight down the middle and and that's really important and and if we don't do that then then we have all kinds of trouble I appreciate the extra time uh Merry Christmas Happy New Year happy happy honor thank you other public comments sure yeah which letter C okay I will make another motion to go into nonpublic session to nhrs 91 col 3 section 2 small letter C second roll call yes yes yes yes