November 17, 2025 Voorhees BOE Meeting

001[clears throat] So hello everyone. I'm so so sorry that I cannot be there with you in person. Um but this was a really important meeting to be a part of. I did not want to meet miss it. Um but I apologize. I am in California for work. Um but we are we've coordinated it so that both Dr. Hackett and Julie will assist and and we'll try and get through this as best we possibly can. So let's call the meeting to order. Pursuant to the Open Public Meeting Act, public notice of this meeting has been given by the board secretary in the following manner. Posting written notice on the official bulletin board at the Vorhees Township Public Schools Administrative Building on August 4th, 2025. Sending written notice to the Courier Post on August 4th, 2025. Filing

002written notice with the clerk of Vorhees Township on August 4th, 2025. And posting on the Vorhees Township website on August 4th, 2025. Please rise for the pledge of allegiance. Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> Board secretary, will you call the role, please? here. >> Mr. Rosner >> here. here >> here. [clears throat] So, we're going to slightly change the order of the meeting um so that we can get our Oage students that have so gracefully joined us to do a presentation. We're going to do them first and we're then going to do the service awards and then we'll get into the regular agenda if that works for everybody. So, Dr.

003Dr. Hackett, I'm going to turn it over to you for the Osage student presentation. >> Okay. Good. Thank you, board president, and good evening, everyone. I now like to bring forward the principal of the amazing Osage school, Mr. Kramer. >> All right. Good evening, uh, President Watson and Dr. Hackett and members of the board of education and community members in attendance. Thank you so much for coming. Two years ago, Osage's librarian, Mrs. Caitlyn Puzzac asked if she could implement a student of the month program at Osage to help teach and recognize positive character traits. Since this was something new for Osage, I wasn't sure how it would run or be received by the students, parents, and staff. Well, it has far exceeded expectations. Miss Plus has done an absolutely amazing job. Not only do the

004students enjoy being recognized, the parents of the students of the month love coming to the school to be a part of our special assemblies. And then at the beginning of this school year, fourth grade teacher Miss Carrie Man asked if she could start something called behavior bravos to catch students being good. The students are thrilled when they are recognized by a staff member and get get to have their behavior bravo displayed by the front office for all to see. It has been a great addition to our school and actually goes along with our student of the month program wonderfully. I would now like to introduce Oage's librarian, Mrs. Caitlyn Puzzac, to speak more about student of the month. Thank you, Mr. Cranmer. Good evening. When teachers are asked why they chose the profession of teaching,

005the answers are pretty standard. You'll hear responses like, "I want to make a difference and kids are the future." These are the reasons we became teachers. And we continue in this profession to encourage all children to be the best version of themselves regardless of their ability. To make kids feel like they matter and that we see the value they have. To teach them to see the value in others and most importantly in themselves. But as any educator can tell you, this is not an easy task. After 20 years in education, I found myself asking, "How do we make sure that students are meeting all of the academic standards and objectives that we present to them while at the same time reminding them that character matters and making the right choice every day in all areas

006is just as important as their score on a test? How do we recognize the positive qualities that are already there and try to foster a desire for excellence and growth?" >> [snorts] >> A survey of the staff at Osage identified character traits we'd like to foster in our students. It was important for us to choose values that are not necessarily directly tied to academic success because we wanted to ensure that all students had access to this program and that no child was excluded from receiving an award. Each month we read a paired text together as a class as an introduction to that month's character trait. Seeing oneself reflected in a book is one of the great joys of literature. And there is no better way to help students understand and internalize a character trait than

007by watching it come to life through relatable characters and meaningful stories. Integrity, perseverance, compassion, responsibility, and leadership are just some of the chosen characteristics. And while no one trait is more important than another, the program has fostered more than just a desire to be a great kid. Students are asking difficult questions of themselves and others. During a discussion surrounding integrity, which we explain as doing the right thing even when no one is watching, one student asked, "Mrs. Puzzac, how do you know we're doing the right thing if you're not watching?" During a discussion about perseverance, another student remarked, "It's really hard to make the right choice after you've made the wrong one." This program continues to open the students eyes to a world of personal growth with conversations extending to the concepts of humility and

008grace, inspiring them to approach others with empathy and understanding and offering it to themselves as well. I'd like to introduce Gazi Hussein and Amelia Dawson, fifth graders at Oage and recent recipients of the student of the month award to share their experience with the program and share what it has meant to them. >> Hi, my name is Razie. I am a fifth grader at Oage and I was recognized for exemplifying responsibility in February 2025. On the morning of the student of the month assembly, I saw my parents in the cafeteria. Was I the student of the month? I thought. I looked at them and pointed to myself with a questioning look. Me? My parents nodded. I felt proud and excited that I got picked. After you get recognized, you go up to the podium, get

009your award, and walk back to your seat. It is also nice to have students on the edge of the row putting their hands out to give you a half high five. Once the student once the assembly is over, all the students of the month go to the library with their parents to have snacks and take pictures. It also makes the school a more positive place. This is because when a student gets picked, it boosts their self-confidence. Then that self-confidence gets passed on that's passed on to other students who might need it. This makes a big impact on the whole school. So what does makes a student deserve the award? Well, there are different qualities that different students have and we learned them in library class. Every month there is a new trait like integrity, perseverance,

010friendship, generosity, kindness, and responsibility. For example, integrity is doing the right thing when nobody is watching. If a student always does the right thing no matter what, they could deserve the award. If a student deserved the perseverance award though, they could have been struggling in math or ELA. When they got something wrong, they wouldn't get discouraged, but would keep trying. In school, we do a lot, but none of our peers take the time out to recognize a student's personality. With the student of the month award, though, students appreciate that they get recognized for something other than grades. I'm glad to have received the responsibility award, and I'm also glad that my school has this program. Thank you for listening to me. >> Hi, I'm Amelia Dawson and perseverance and when things are hard and you

011still do them because you want to. One of the most challenging things I've had to do is readjust to being a new school. I used to I used to move classes and in schools a lot and I was not used to the way Oage works. But thanks to my great teachers and welcoming students, I feel like I haven't lost school at all and that I've had these friends forever. My teachers were probably the main reason I got the perseverance award [snorts] because even when I didn't know something or had a hard time doing something, they still pushed me to do better. And because Yeah. And they never gave up on me. I am still so thankful for them pushing me past my limit because it had made me so much smarter and better at the

012things I thought I would never be good at. Not all children get A's on every test or win first in their sports division or get accepted into le into elitemies. Not all children will grow to be the president of a company or the head of a law firm. But encouraging students to be good humans and grow in kindness, integrity, bravery, compassion, and perseverance will serve them well beyond their academic years into a future where the best measurement of success is not the job they do or the salary they make, but how they show up for themselves and to the people in the world around them. At this time, I'd like to introduce Osage fourth grade teacher, Mrs. Carrie man. >> Good evening. As part of the summer district climate and culture committee, our team was

013tasked with developing initiatives to further strengthen our school climate. During a collaborative brainstorming session with colleagues, the idea for behavior bravos emerged. Once the seed was planted, I approached my ever so supportive principal, shared the concept, and asked if I could leave lead the initiative as part of my internship this year. He responded with an enthusiastic yes. With the help of my Osage family, we designed a program that intentionally acknowledges and celebrates students in meaningful ways. We wanted to honor the students who consistently do the right thing. Those who are easygoing and dependable yet sometimes go unnoticed because their positive choices are simply expected. Additionally, we wanted to encourage students who may experience behavioral challenges but are making an effort to improve. It is essential that these students feel the pride of making positive choices

014and that their classmates recognize that everyone is capable of success. An exciting element that connects both pro excuse me programs is our behavior bravo bonus wheel. During our student of the month celebration, Mr. Cranner and I share the total of Braavos earned and then draw three names from the pool of students who received Braavos that month to spin the wheel for a special privilege. This feature has become something the students genuinely look forward to adding a fun and motivating twist to the recognition process. We're excited to welcome a few students who will be sharing their behavior bravos they have earned. >> Hi, I'm Gia Jin and I received three behavior bravos in the month of October. My first bravo says Gia helped out her classmate during the NJSLI directions training. Awesome job looking out for

015your peers. My second bravo says, "During math, Gia noticed her classmate was cold but didn't have his jacket. She offered her sweatshirt to him so he can warm up. So thoughtful of you, Gia." My third bra says, "Jude continued to focus on her math work instead of getting distracted by her talking classmates. I enjoy getting the behavior." Braavvice. >> Hi Hi, I am Olivia Lee. I am a fourth grader in Mrs. in Miss Man's class. I have received two behavior bravo so far. My first bravo says Olivia displayed excellent hallway behavior by facing forward and not talking to classmates. My second bravo says Liv is so supportive of her classmates. She goes out of her way to help them and include them. She sees a classmate needing help and automatically sets in. Getting behavior bravos

016made me feel proud and excited. >> Good job. >> I'm Jet and a fifth grader. I'm a fifth grader in Mr. Brooks and Mrs. Riggs class. I received two behavior bravos in October. One from Mrs. Riggs and one from Mrs. Mola. My behav My bravos are for being helpful and showing kindness. My first bravos from Miss My first bravo from Mrs. Modus was from recess. It says, "Helping from the kindness of his heart by gathering sports equipment. Thank you for caring about Osage." My second Bravo was from math class. It says, "Jet is Jet always asks to help students who either come to class late or misses a math lesson. He is not only a great teacher but even a better friend." I will now turn it over to Mrs. Morgan. In closing, our student

017of the month and behavior bravo programs are about more than just certificates and recognition. They're about creating moments that make our students feel proud about who they are and how they show up each day. Each time we celebrate a student's effort and positive choices, we're helping them build confidence and showing them that what they do truly matters. We're also incredibly proud of the strong sense of community and family we've become at O. Inviting families to celebrate with us adds a special touch. Seeing parents and guardians beam with pride as their child is recognized really reinforces what makes Osage feel like home. As Maya Angelo said, "People will forget what you said. They will forget what you do, but they will never forget how you made them feel." Through these celebrations, we hope our students and

018their families feel appreciated and inspired to keep striving for the best for their best every day. Thank you for allowing us to share our programs at tonight's meeting. Now, let's give our students one more round of applause because they are the superstars. [applause] >> Thank you so much. >> We're going to come down and give some gifts to the students, but I want to say to you, congratulations and Osage is truly a family. And all the teachers and Mr. Kramer, Miss Morgan, you all make this work and you all make this possible. And I'm just so excited. I was fighting back tears. It was absolutely beautiful. So, Miss Kettover, the vice president, and I'm going to come down and provide some gifts. >> And I'll just say a quick word since I'm here. Um, thank

019you so much. I'm so proud of all of the students. Um, I had the I've had the privilege of being at Oage's fifth grade graduation for the past couple years, and it is such a pleasure to be in the environment. You do create a wonderful connected family. So, thank you all for being here to support your kids, and thank you for the teachers, to support the students. It's been it's wonderful to see all of you tonight. Stop. Perfect. Thank you. >> At this time, if the parents of the Osage students want to exit, you are more than welcome. We'll give you some time to do that and we'll get into the service awards next. Okay. Are we ready to go in? Yeah. Okay. So, we have a lot of service awards. Um, this is one

020of my favorite things to do uh on the board because it shows how incredibly dedicated everyone is to our district. Um we are going to make a short statement even for people who are not in attendance today because it's important that we recognize them. Um but I I just wanted to make make sure everybody understood and appreciated that as we kind of go through the very long list of esteemed colleagues. So starting with Dena who was who is not in attendance. Dena began her teaching career as an instructional associate in 1999. Over the years, she taught kindergarten, first grade, and second grade. She never imagined how deeply this journey would shape her, not only as a teacher, but also as a person. Thank you so much, Mrs. Appleen. Moving to Yes. Moving to Janetta Barnhart.

021With a remarkable teaching career spanning over 28 years, this dedicated educator began her journey in 1997 within the Vineland public school district, where she taught both second and sixth grade classrooms for two and a half years. In 2000, she joined Vorhees Middle School, initially teaching sixth grade before finding her passion in seventh grade reading. Her commitment to literacy and student success has been further demonstrated through her role on the VMS ELA textbook committee. Beyond the classroom, she supports students as a mentor and contributes to school spirit and athletics as an assistant cheerleading and softball coach. Starting in December, she will embrace a new challenge as the reading specialist at VMS. Proudly balancing her professional and personal life, she is a mother of three sons and has been happily married to her husband, Jerry, for 20

022years. Thank you so much, Miss Barnhart. Miss Kelly Beck not she is also not in attendance. As a proud product of the Vorhees school system, Mrs. Beck was inspired to pursue a career in education by her fifth grade teacher at Crescent whose positive impact stayed with her. She completed her student teaching at Hamilton, later serving as a substitute teacher for the district and then as an instructional associate at Osage. She went on to teach fourth grade at Osage for nearly 20 years before transitioning to Signal Hill 5 years ago as the enrichment teacher. Mrs. Beck's deep connection to the district makes it incredibly meaningful to give back to the community that shaped her. Thank you so much, Miss Speck. Mr. Jim Brown. Mr. Brown has served as a special education teacher in both the resource

023classroom and in class support general education classroom. He has been on the RTI committee and has served as the assistant boys basketball coach and head girls basketball co basketball coach. Mr. Mr. Brown is blessed and honored to have had the opportunity over the years to serve with so many dedicated and highly professional teachers who have provided the students of VMS with the highest quality educational experience possible. Thank you so much, Mr. Brown. [applause] Miss Jennifer Bono. Miss Bono has worked at all 25 years at Signal Hill. She began in 1999 as a building substitute and instructional associate and by 2000 had her own classroom as a second grade teacher. [snorts] She has taught second, third, and fourth as a classroom teacher. In 2005, Miss Bono received her masters in reading and in February of 2014

024became the reading specialist at Signal Hill. Her proudest moments are honestly just seeing students feel proud about their own success. Thank you so much, Miss Bono. Miss Danielle Clark, also not in attendance. Miss Clark has worked as an instructional associate in the district for the past 25 years at different schools throughout the district. She is not in attendance this evening. Congratulations, Miss Clark. Mr. Frank Conpsion. Like many new educators, Mr. Conpsion entered teaching with more hope than experience, but he was really fortunate when he came to Vorhees 25 years ago and had amazing mentors and colleagues that helped him find his way. Not only has he been a health and physical education teacher at Vorhees Middle School for the past 25 years, he also but also the assistant track coach. He is grateful for one

025thing that was has always remained constant, the power of connection. The relationships with students, families, colleagues have encouraged him through the years. Frank states, quote, "I would not be where I am today without the unwavering love and support of my wife and daughter, whose encouragement inspires me each and every day to strive toward becoming the best version of myself." End quote. Thank you so much, Mr. Conpsion. Jenny Conpsion. Miss Conpsion taught health and PE for 20 years at VMS and the last five at ET Hamilton. She was a group leader for the CER summer camp for fourth and fifth grade for 20 years. A few highlights of her career include being the head field hockey coach at VMS where the team had many successful seasons and championships. Probably the biggest highlight of her career are

026the lasting bonds and friendships that have been forged with families and students in this wonderful community. She was truly ble blessed and grateful for the day in June 2000 when she was selected by the district as the health and physical education teacher. Thank you so much, Miss Conpsion. Susan Donnelly. Miss Donnelly began her teaching career as a sixth grade science teacher at the Vorhees Middle School in September of 2000. She worked as a VMS sixth grade science teacher for 15 years before accepting the position of supervisor of special projects in 2015. She holds a bachelor's of science in psychology and elementary education, a master's degree in educational technology, and a second master's degree in school counseling, and the New Jersey Educational Leadership Supervisory Certificate. She is proud to be a part of the Vorhees School

027District. She has fostered great relationships and takes pride in her work as leader in the school community. Miss Donnelly is most grateful for her daughter Kaylee, son Nathan, and the love and support of her family. Thank you so much, Miss Donnelly. Le Gman. Mrs. Grossman was at Osage for her first year of her career and has been at ET Hamilton ever since with the exception of one recent year at Crescent. She approaches her work with caring, creativity, and a strong positive attitude. Whether student teaching, long-term substituting in self-contained classrooms, in resource classrooms, in inclusion classrooms, doing home programming, in ESY, as an RBT, or while teaching her fine arts class, creating creatures in Saturday Spectacular, Le continues to learn and be inspired by our students, their families, her co-workers, and administration alike. That is why

028after all this time, Mrs. Gman looks forward to each school day and genuinely appreciates the chance to make a positive difference in the lives of our precious students. Thank you, Mrs. Gman. Jeff Lanzelada. Mr. Lanzela has worked at VMS all 25 years teaching seventh grade science. He taught in the same two classroom throughout his career. In addition to teaching, he has served as the head wrestling coach for 25 years, head track coach for over 10 years, chess club adviser for over 10 years, and as the VTEA executive treasurer for 15 years. He has also served on other commun committees over the years, faculty advisory, student teacher mentor, and teacher teacher mentor. Mr. Lanzela's proudest me proudest moments are the positive relationships with parents, teachers, staff, students over the years. He says, "There's nothing like getting

029an email or handwritten letter from a former student saying how I changed their lives or outlook on school and how they are [clears throat] now successful in their own careers and family life. Thank you so much, Mr. Lanzel." Cliff Lavine, thank you to the board of education and the administration for this recognition. Cliff appreciates the opportunity to work with students in this community for the past 25 years. During this time, Cliff has taught sixth and seventh grade students. Cliff enjoys mentoring new teachers and students. He also enjoys additional responsibilities that include supervising afterchool sports and Sunday reflection classes. Thank you so much, Mr. Lavine. Nancy Long Bodessa, not in attendance. 25 years in Vorhees School District has given Miss Long Badessa countless memories, amazing colleagues, and the privilege Oops. Thank you so much, Miss Long

030Podessa. Natalie Mola, a proud former Osage student, Natalie Madola is celebrating 25 years in the Vorhees Township Public Schools. Dual certified in elementary and special education. She has taught every grade from 1st through fifth and now serves as Oage's enrichment teacher. She co-leads the innovation committee and has served on multiple district and school committees guiding her work with a brief a belief in empowering students to think critically, act compassionately, and create meaningful change in their world. Thank you so much, Miss Medola. Nancy Noly, not in attendance. Mrs. NI served as the district substitute caller the first 10 years of her career. The next 15 years she has worked at Osage as an instructional associate. In 2014, she received the inspiration and education speak instructional associate award. Mrs. Nalty has worked after school for the child

031study team at all four elementary schools. She has been a member of the Osage Green team and has worked in the ESY program for the past 12 years. Thank you so much, Miss Nely. Aaron Putman. Aaron Putman has been a special special education teacher at Osage for her whole career. She has taught in many different grade levels and classrooms. At the start of her career, she served as co-director of the VMS drama club for eight years. She has also served on the DEI committee, innovation team, anxiety committee, and ICS cohort. She currently is a design team ambassador with the NGA consortium. Her greatest passion as an educator is helping all students feel like a valued and important part of their classroom community. Thank you so much, Miss Putn. Andrea Story. Mrs. Story has spent Mrs.

032story has spent the p past 25 years at Osage where she has the privilege of serving as both the inclusion and resource room teacher. Over the years, she has proudly contributed to our school community through her work on the RTI committee faculty council and as a senior representative for the VTEA. One of Mrs. Sto's greatest joys has been teaching children to read using the Spire program and helping te colleagues bring this resource into their own classrooms. Mrs. Story's teaching career began in 1995 at the Lynenwald public schools where she taught in a self-contained classroom. She later taught in Baltimore County public schools before joining Osage in 2000. Mrs. Story is so grateful for the opportunity to grow and learn alongside such an amazing team and wonderful students. She states, quote, Osage has truly become my

033second home. End quote. Thank you so much, Miss Story. Rachel White with a dedicated 25-y year career in health and physical education. Miss White has had the privilege of teaching 18 years at the elementary level at Crescent Signal Hill and ET Hamilton. The past eight years have been at VMS helping students grow in both fitness and character. Throughout her career, Miss White has organized and run 18 field days that took careful planning, teamwork, and dedication to create fun, safe, and memorable experiences for every student. She has mentored new educators, served as a bus supervisor and member of the faculty advisory committee, participated in the VTEA staff volleyball games, supervised as an afterchool sports supervisor, and worked CER beforeare afterare weekends and summer camp programs. Mrs. White has also contributed to the CER super Saturday spectacular

034program to further support school community. Thank you so much, Mrs. White. And last, but surely not least, Julie Zalinski. Mrs. Zalinsky began working in Vorhees Township in 1988 at Crescent School and started full-time in 1992 at Signals Hill School through the CER programs. In 2000, she became a contracted teacher at Vorhees Middle School where she proudly remained ever since. Over the years, Mrs. Zillinsky has coached soccer for eight years and currently supervises the Viking Academy morning class. Her greatest accomplishments, however, are her three amazing children, Kylie, Grant, and Blake, who continue to inspire her every day. Thank you so much, Mrs. Zinsky. And let's give another round of round of appl applause to all of our service award members. [applause] Okay, moving into the agenda. Can I get a motion to approve the board minutes

035of the October 29th, 2025 regular meeting, please? >> So move Stuart second. Rudder. >> Voting is open. Eight yeses, one abstension for Mr. Rosner. Motion carries. >> Great. Thank you. I do have some um comments this evening. >> Mrs. Watson. >> Yes. >> Can you give Can you wait one minute? People are shuffling out. >> Oh, yes, absolutely. Okay, I think it's okay now. Thanks. >> Great. No, thank you. Okay, so I have a couple of comments, so please bear with me. Uh, good evening everyone. Before we begin tonight's agenda, I want to take a moment to recognize and celebrate our service award recipients. These individuals have dedicated 25 plus years, in many cases far more, to educating and supporting the children of Warhe school district. Their commitment, stability, and deep love for our students

036have shaped generations of families. On behalf of the board of education, I want to sincerely thank each of you for your extraordinary service. Your work is the backbone of this district and we are profoundly grateful. I also want to acknowledge something a bit more personal. This is my favorite time of year. Thankfulness grounds us. It refocuses us. It allows us to see past the noise and return to what really matters, community, purpose, and the well-being of the children and families we serve. Gratitude is good for the soul. And as we head into the holiday season, I want to wish everyone here a joyful, peaceful, and restorative break. May it be a time of rest, reflection, and connection for you and your families. Now, as we turn to our more formal remarks tonight, I want to

037begin by acknowledging that since Julianne has chosen not to seek re-election, tonight marks her final meeting as a member of the Vorhees Board of Education. In reflecting on her tenure, I want to take a moment to appreciate her service and notably to share what effective schoolboard service truly requires. As people often forget, we are mere servants of the community. Volunteers called to hold our schools and administration to the highest standards of excellence. Board service is not simply about passion, intelligence, or having strong opinions. It is about partnership. It is about trust. It is about humility. And it is about recognizing that no single member governs the district. We succeed collectively or not at all. Over the last several years, we have learned sometimes through difficult moments that when trust is absent, progress stalls. When colleagues

038cannot trust one another or the admin or the administration they hired, the work becomes heavier for all. When every administrative decision is questioned reflexively, when collaboration is replaced with confrontation, and when feedback, thoughtful, constructive feedback, is dismissed as hostility or criticism, or better yet, bullying, it creates strain that ultimately diverts attention from where it belongs, our students. We have experienced moments where tact and subtlety were lacking. We have seen criticism delivered publicly rather than addressed privately. We have seen colleagues challenged instead of supported. We have seen important partners second-guessed not because of disagreement on substance but because of collaboration but because collaboration itself was difficult. And yet through these challenges this board made a choice. We chose to grow stronger together. We leaned on one another. We listened more carefully. We clarified our values. We

039focused on results. We refused to allow conflict to define us or derail us. And that strength shows in our accomplishments. We opened a preschool, a major complex undertaking requiring trust, coordination, and unwavering dedication to families. We navigated difficult and sensitive issues with transparency, unity, and professionalism. We rebuilt our sense of team, not by ignoring challenges, but by recommitting ourselves to the mission every time adversity arose. And I want to say something honestly and respectfully. Julianne is incredibly smart. She has strong public policy instincts and cares deeply about the issues she champions with a greater willingness to collaborate, more trust in the people around her and a readiness to accept feedback without viewing it through a lens of conflict. I believe she would have had a profound impact and been extraordinarily influential member of this board.

040But board service ultimately depends on the ability to work with others, especially when we disagree. It depends on elevating the district above ego. It depends on remembering why we are here. To serve children, not ourselves. As we move into the next chapter, I want to affirm that this board remains committed to partnership with our administration, to respectful governance, and to forward momentum. We are entering this next phase stronger, more cohesive, more aligned than we have ever been in years. Tonight and always, we move forward as a board that trusts, collaborates, listens, and works together for every student in this district. Thank you, and happy holidays to all. My name is Julianne Birdie, not Julianne. Thank you. >> Fire drills and safety drills are on the attached. Harassment, intimidation, bullying report is also attached and suspensions

041are also on the attachment. We have one OPER request that is now closed and turning it to the board secretary to share maintenance work completed. Thank you. Um during the teachers convention break from uh Thursday, November 6th and Friday, November 7th, as well as Saturday, November 8th, uh Mr. Matthysse and his staff uh did some work throughout the district, which they always do when the when the students and staff are not present. Uh they accomplished a lot of different items, and I'll just mention a few of them. There was HVAC work that was completed. Um, intruder locks have been installed throughout the district and the school we're working on right now. We're just really upgrading different locks. Um, at VMS, a light post was installed at the ECDC playground. Um, we have rod grants that

042are going on, rod grant projects that are going on throughout the district. Um, boilers at VMS, sorry, boilers at Osage and Signal Hill and HBAC work at U VMS. That work was being done during that time period too. And then flooring was installed in Signal Hill in their gym storage room. So every time we're off, they just jump in and start doing things while nobody's here. And they always accomplish so much and we thank them for their service. Thank you. >> Thank you. I also want to extend a thank you to Clark and his team for the exceptional work they do every chance they get. Superintendent report. >> Good evening everyone. Good evening everyone. Again, thank you board president. Um, I want to first again acknowledge our Oage students for their wonderful work and all

043of our staff members who are reaching 25 years. Those two groups go hand in hand. Dedicated staff members who are here and give all of what they have to this district result in students who feel really good about themselves and they are in an environment that's conducive to learning. So, those two groups go hand in hand and I just want to thank both of them again. Um, there were a few questions at the October board meeting. Um the first question was um why was there a confidential resignation on the September agenda? Um there were two resignations on the agenda and they were voted under one resolution um and there was no confidential um resignation. I think that may have been spoken in error but there was no confidential resignation. Then the next question was policy

0440143 which was board member election and appointment. there was questions about um the vocational section of that policy and tonight when policy gives their uh committee report they will address uh that issue when they give their report. Uh I'd like to um remind parents that on December 4th I will be presenting our next parent virtual workshop which is understanding regulation 5600 which is code of conduct and behavior incentives. In this workshop, parents and guardians will learn about regulation 5600, which outlines student behavior expectations, possible consequences for misconduct, and positive incentives that encourage good choices. Participants will gain a deeper understanding of how the code is applied in everyday school situations and how consequences are determined and how the district uses proactive strategies and rewards to promote positive behavior. So, I hope our parents can come

045out on December 4th, 7 o'clock. you will receive a reminder email. Um, as my retirement is on the agenda this evening, effective July 1st, 2027, uh, looking ahead is meaningful, but preparing to say goodbye to a community that has become like family is not easy. The experience we have shared, the challenges, the celebrations, and the everyday moments in between have shaped my time here in a way I will forever cherish. I am thankful for my time here and I look forward to the next year and a half as we continue to nurture, support and empower every child and ensure that our district continues to thrive and grow stronger. So in the meaning of Thanksgiving, Thanksgiving is a time to pause, reflect and express gratitude for the many blessings in our lives. As superintendent, I am

046profoundly thankful for the talented, caring, and dedicated staff of Voorhees. Each day, they go above and beyond to nurture, challenge, and inspire our students, ensuring that every st child has the opportunity to thrive. I want to also express my sincere appreciation to our board of education for their steadfast commitment and thoughtful leadership. Their time, insight, and service help ensure that our schools remain places where students and staff can do their best work. I'd like to thank our families and community partners for their trust and partnership. Their ongoing support and collaboration strengthen all that we do for our students. So, as we enter this season of gratitude, I wish the entire Vorhees Township Public Schools family a Thanksgiving filled with peace, joy, and meaningful moments with those you love. Thank you very much. Moving to audience

047participation. Anyone wishing to address the board, please approach the side table on the right and write your name and address on the login sheet. While the board is limited in its ability to respond to the public on matters involving personnel, litigation, negotiations, and attorney client privilege, the board will now hear comments from the public relating to items on the agenda for this board meeting. Comments are limited to three minutes. The board will not take action this evening. You will be notified at some later time by letter, electronic mail, telephone, or in the context of a later board meeting of any action the board does take. I'm back. Um I have actually have some comments on policy on the revisions of policy 2422 um regarding the statutory curriculum requirements. New Jersey has taken meaningful steps to

048expand cultural representation in K through2 education. The Almistad Act as well as the AAPI, Latino and Hispanic Heritage and LGBTQI inclusive curriculum laws all set a strong precedent by requiring these histories to be integrated throughout the K through2 social studies curriculum. However, Jewish history and identity are not incorporated in the same way. The only statewide mandate requires Holocaust and genocide instruction once at either the elementary or the secondary level. As a result, students often often encounter the Jewish story primarily through Holocaust, learning about Jews mainly as genocide victims rather than as people of a 3,000 years of shared history, culture, and continuity. Leaving out the broader identity fosters misconceptions that can fuel bias. Be before passing revisions to policy 2422. I respectfully ask that Jewish history and identity be explicitly integrated across 12 K through

04912 with the same weight and visibility as every other mandated cultural curriculum representing minority ethnic groups. Thank you. Hi, Danielle Riggs Oage School. I have a year and a half to figure out what I'm going to say, Dr. Hackett, so I'll get back to you. Um, Miss Verie, thank you for your time on the board. Um like you had said in one of the previous meetings, um you may not agree with uh the position people are taking and it may not align with yours as a mom or whatever, but um you do what we encourage our students to do and that is to listen to it all and form your own opinion. So um if you want to feel good, come to Osage. It's a real happy place. So, I'm going to speak about these

050two ladies right here. Um, these are unpaid positions. The amount of time and effort I'm going to try and get through this without crying because [sighs and gasps] these programs I'm probably the person in the room with mother maybe Bruce and I or might be tied who've been here the longest. And to say that these programs are effective is an understatement. Osage is such an amazing place and my biggest regret is I didn't get there sooner. But I know Caitlyn Pu Puzac as a colleague and as a parent. To say that she has more than enough on her plate outside of school is an understatement. She came up with this program on her own and it gives the parents and the teachers an opportunity to put into words how these kids align with these character

051traits. And if you could see the moments the kids are so excited the other kids are cheering them on. It's incredible. And Caitlyn, you are just a beautiful soul. Period. my sister from another mister, Miss Man. To say her plate is not full is an understatement. This program is all about moments and we all have those moments in our lives where we could have gone the other way. We're grabbing these kids at such pivotal moments and Carrie has done a phenomenal job. If you could see these kids when they have to take them down to her room. Well, first off, any kid that gets to walk in the hallway, it's just like a great thing. Shoulders back, heads high, smiling, and then they get to tell everybody what's on that behavior. Bravo. So, the moments

052that you two are providing, there's there's no paycheck that would ever be able to give you. and to Bob and Lisa who create an environment um my son's college the theme is be impossible to ignore and that's Oage Oage everybody is on level playing field no matter how smart how athletic how artistic so bravo and kudos to my friends and colleagues Are there any other comments? Okay. Okay. Moving into business meeting statement. Um, as we move into the business portion of our meeting, we want to recognize that it may appear as if the board takes action with very little comment and in many cases a unanimous vote. Before an item is placed on a board agenda, it is thoroughly reviewed by the superintendent and administration. The superintendent then presents the recommended action to the appropriate

053board committee and works with the committee to ensure that the members fully understand the recommendation. Once the committee is satisfied, the item is placed on the board agenda for discussion and action at a public meeting. Board agendas are made available to board members several days in advance of the meeting, giving us ample time to review the agenda and have all of our questions answered. Further, we are kept up to date between meetings on the ongoing work of the administration and important issues in the district. All of these efforts ensure that we are well informed and prepared to take action at our meeting. Moving to policy committee report. Uh Miss Branch Stewart, can you provide that report? Certainly. Good evening. The policy committee met on November 11th for about a half hour. Dr. Hackett, Mr. Moscowitz,

054and board members Julie Ketter, Crystal Mayan, and I were present. The committee discussed and recommends full board approval for all policy items on tonight's agenda, which include for first read policy 9280, parent conferences. The committee notes that the language in this policy has been revised to reflect the position that notification of intent to report a conference is requested whenever possible and that the use of AI note-taking apps is not permitted during conferences. And for second read policy 0143 board member election appointment noting that we are a type two district um but we have omitted language pertaining to vocational districts and policy 2422 2422 statutory curricular requirements reflecting statemandated curricular inclusion of contributions of diverse communities. Our next meeting will be held in January. Thank you. >> Thank you. Can I get a motion to approve

055all the items under policy move >> second? Helen, I don't think your mic is on. >> Mr. Sorry, Mr. Bryce, can you hear me? >> I can hear you. >> Okay. Um, what is your vote on this item? >> Yes. Thank you. The motion unanimously passes. >> Mrs. Rudder, can you please provide the academic excellence committee report? >> Sure. The academic excellence committee met on Monday, November 10th for approximately 1 hour. It was myself, Miss Watson, Miss Kettover, Dr. Hackett, and Mr. Moscowitz. Um, we do not have any action required at this time. We did have a follow-up discussion from October's meeting. Um, we talked about we reviewed the extended day survey responses for from parents who declined the service and we are satisfied with the district's decision to continue extended day in the morning.

056We talked about the March 20th inservice framework. We are really excited about the feedback that we are taking into consideration from the staff in the district and we will be sharing the activities at the next meeting in January. And then finally, we talked about improving um student experience from VMS to Eastern. Our next meeting will be Oh, I don't have it on here. Um next year, [laughter] that's all. I have a quick question on the academic excellence committee report. Um, and there's fi it's fine if there's no answer today, but I actually looked back at the last six months of academic excellence committee reports and noticed that in every single report it explicitly says no decision or no action required from the board. I guess I'm a little confused here on whether the AC academic

057excellence committee is immune from full board approval on any decisions that they make as that doesn't seem to be the case for any other committee or is it just that no actual decision-making is happening in that committee. The committee report seems to indicate recommended recommendations and decisions are being made within that committee on behalf of the full board. But these decisions never seem to require board ratification. So just a little point of clarification here would be greatly appreciated as often there are items under the academic excellence committee section for approval but that doesn't seem to mirror what the committee is actually making decisions and discussing. Thank you. >> Can I get a motion to approve all of the items under curriculum? >> So moved. Rudder >> second sewer. >> Online voting is open. >> Motion

058unanimously passes. >> Mr. Razner, could you please provide a personnel committee report? >> Yes. The [clears throat] personnel committee met last Thursday, November 13th. In attendance, myself, Miss Ruer, Miss Watson, Dr. Hackett, and Mr. Mosquitz. Um, we discussed an employee termination, [clears throat] the NJAC appeal, a residency hearing update, and an employee leave matter. Thanks. >> I have a question about the personnel committee report. Was the personnel committee um presented [clears throat] with the full comments on the NJQAC appeal? I I've asked for that data and I was told it's not provided it's not been provided to board members. So I'm just curious um when discussing the NJQAC results if that was um provided to the rest of the the board committee. Thanks. No. All right. >> Can I get a motion to approve all

059the items under personnel as recommended by the superintendent? >> So moved. Rudder. >> Second. Get over. >> Online voting is open. Motion unanimously passes. >> Mr. Rosen, can you please provide a finance committee report? >> Uh, yes. Um, the finance committee met on Wednesday, November 12th. In attendance, in addition to myself, was Julie Kettover and Crystal Mun. The district attendees were Dr. Neil Hackett, Helen Haley, Daniel Kerry, and Alicia Dan Anella, who is the board attorney. Um, we discussed the following items. [snorts] First of all, all items on the tonight's agenda under finance, transportation, and building, and grounds for vote were reviewed, and the committee is recommending approval on all items. We talked about the solar update. Uh, we had a discussion of a proposal from Gable. Um, I don't know what their name is.

060Gable Associates or something that's a consultant for the New Jersey School Boards Association for feasibility study and RFP development, vendor selection process, and project management. Um, and the committee decided that consideration of this project has been postponed to 2026 as the district does not believe it has the bandwidth to do a comprehensive evaluation at this time. We also talked about the Marato field agreement and we're still awaiting for action by the township on the agreement. We also talked about additional change orders for the Vorhees early childhood development center. Two in particular, one was a drainage trench for the road behind the building due to pooling of rainwater and the second item was a relocation of pipes due to swap of certain equipment in the building. Um there was an extensive discussion on the newly requested

061change orders for item number one, the drainage trench. After review of the site plan and photos of the water pooling, it was decided to ensure safety particularly in the upcoming winter with potential for freezing to approve this item. Work is expected to be completed during the winter break so student transportation will not be disrupted. For item number two, the relocation of the pipes, there was no notification to the district of the additional cost when the swap of equipment was made, nor prior to commencing the additional work. The district had no reasonable opportunity to make decisions relating to this additional work or received information on the difference in the cost of the swapped equipment. Therefore, this item has not been approved and is not on the agenda for vote tonight. Um, we also talked about the

062Voy Easttown Center redevelopment. Um, there are several hurdles before this project gains traction. The district will monitor its progress with the regular contact with the township two years prior to the anticipated completion of residential construction or as soon as more detailed information is available, the district will evaluate the impact on school capacity and will engage in addressing any capacity needs. At that time, uh, we reviewed the status of the current district construction projects, transportation of students added to the district from the Victory Commons development and a planned food service RFP due to the expansion of food services from the original agreement, specifically adding VECDC and breakfast at two schools as required by regulations. There's no action by the board required at this time. Um, the next finance committee meeting will be in January 2026. >>

063Thank you very much. Can I get a motion to approve all of the items under finance? >> So moved. Rosen. >> Second. Cut over. [snorts] >> Online voting is open. The motion unanimously passes. >> Moving to transportation. Can I get a motion to approve all of the items under transportation? >> So moved. Rosen. >> Second. Rder. >> Online voting is open. motion unanimously passes. >> Moving to buildings and grounds. Can I have a motion to approve all of the items under buildings and grounds? >> So moved, Rosen. Second, Rosner. Online voting is open. >> The motion unanimously passes. >> Public comment. Anyone wishing to address the board, please approach the side table on the right and write your name and address on the login sheet. While the board is limited in its ability to respond

064to the public on matters involving personnel, litigation, negotiations, and attorney client privilege, the board will now hear comments for the public. Comments are limited to three minutes. The board will not take action this evening. You will be notified at some later time by letter, electronic mail, telephone, or in the context of a later board meeting of any action the board does take. Um good evening. A couple comments for tonight. Um one um when I was doing the quick math for the teachers. So that was about 475 years in Vorhees. [laughter] Um and that's one of the ones that uh a lot of people always wonder like why how do you get the key people? So I mean that was just a quick math with that. That was pretty substantial. Um, two, the two programs that

065we have at Osage. Um, I'm fortunate enough. I'm the one who lets the parents in before they come in. Um, and it's just nice to see that. I mean, it's nice to see that sometimes to see the recognition of their child that they know they see and see someone else. So, I have to say I'm I it's thoroughly enjoyable. Um, and the uh the Bravos are great because it is funny when they see their name up. they do look and they're sincere like they're not um made up compliments and things and I think the kids freed into it a lot. Um the other comment I was going to make and I was discussed earlier I did want to thank uh Mrs. Verie for her service. Um anytime you're away from your family, of course all

066the other board members that are here, but anytime you're away from your family and stuff, it it's well appreciated. Um and like I said, I I enjoy sitting in the audience and listening to everybody, so I feel I get a lot from Mrs. and from the other members. Um, I'm not, you know, I'm not privy to things behind the scenes, but I just would like to offer my thank you. Um, and happy Thanksgiving and thank you. I'm back again. Uh, Julianne, congratulations on serving your term on the board. I am so proud to call you a friend. We didn't start off that way. In fact, we could not have been any more opposite. But once we were forced to sit next to each other, we got to know one another and we became fast friends.

067Our relationship is exactly when you what you say to never judge a book by its cover. Serving on policy with you during your first year gave me a front seat to your immense knowledge base and all you have to offer our community. I learned so much from you and how you really put your heart and soul into everything you take on. You are an amazing mom to four children. You work full-time at a career that is reaching national level and recently having a bill that was introduced to Congress. If that's not an immense accomplishment, I don't know what is. I am beyond impressed. Um, and it's so impressive and you have you really dedicated your life to our community. Each month you show your vulnerability when talking to the public about your own mental health

068struggles, putting your sexual orientation in the forefront, and standing up for our teachers in our community. Our community was so lucky to have you show the public what a board member should prioritize, our kids, teachers, and community. Thank you, and I know you'll put all this energy into something even greater in the future. And one more speaker for you. nervous. >> Hi, my name is Aurora and I'm an eighth grader at Vorhees Middle School. I would like to take a moment on her last night here to appreciate all the work Julianne has put in nationally providing migraine sufferers like myself better accommodations around migraines. It gets frustrating when we're constantly being told to stop being overdramatic or that it's just a headache. And her bringing awareness to the real pains of those who suffer with

069chronic migraines has made the struggles reach a wider audience and bring visibility to what migraines actually are. And I'd also like to bring up that as a fellow poter who's currently trying to get through middle school, she has always been someone to lean on for guidance and information. I appreciate everything she's done for us invisibility disabil invisible disability community because our pain should be anything but invisible. And the more you talk about it, the more we can learn. Thank you again, Julianne, for always being there and using your voice for good and being polite even when people try to put you down. Your light can't be dimmed. Thank you for listening. Thank you for all the comments. Moving to >> Mrs. Watson. One more comment from the public. >> Okay. Sorry. >> That's okay. Hello.

070Um, I wanted to take a moment uh to thank Miss Ferdy and also to um advocate for uh constructive disscent and to consider how we are giving space to um [clears throat] what can be very useful. I know in my career there have been many times where as an engineer I feel it's my job always to um red team everything and and I know that's not always accepted. It can feel uh to others like I am finding negativity where there doesn't need to be. And uh when I go to others and I say, "Okay, I have this what I think is a great idea. Please tear me apart in your mercy." Right? The idea is if they let me know what's wrong now, it will save me trouble in the future. It is a positive

071thing to accept a certain amount of potential uh what seems like negativity. And it is it's important to make space for that by not always responding to it as if it's animosity. Um and I I I kind of get get some of that sense here. Again, I I don't know uh what else is is going on, but I kind of feel like not only is that important here, but it is an important thing uh within the school system as well to to help promote that and to give space for um things that we we don't feel we we understand. But uh people are are uh being friendly by being uh pointing out things that are wrong. Thank you. >> I think that we are complete with the public comments. >> Okay. Thanks. Okay. Board member

072comments. We're actually going to start with the ad hoc student discip student discipline committee report from Mr. Bryce. >> Thank you, Madam President. Uh the student data ad hoc me meeting was held on November 12th at 7 p.m. Myself, Mr. Rosner, Miss Branch Stewart, Miss Donley, and President uh Watson were in attendance. During the meeting, we were able to discuss the following. how to better inform the community of what an official HI is and to get a better and understanding of when one is substantiated and one and when one is not. We also talked about watching and discussing the uh the amazing creative video that's on uh on HIV that's located on the district website, but we kind of discussed some ways to kind of try to make it more visible to the parents on

073the website and how to possibly kind of shorten it without losing the value and the message of the video. We also discussed other creative solutions for that video and how we can advertise it so to speak to the parents and community members so they can have a chance to view it. Um committee discussed possibly showing that a back to school night uh presentation a possible parent and community district sponsored event. Uh just trying to figure out how we can make it um you know kind of go viral so to speak. Um, we also discussed uh care of solace and other possible alternatives such as the nurtured heart approach and challenge data utilized as additional interventions in directing children away from negative behavior. Uh, the committee will uh continue to uh meet sometime in January. That

074is all I have. >> Thank you very much. Opening it up to comments from the board. Miss Verie maybe Mr. Bryce, you're on mute. Pardon me. I do want to wish everyone a happy Thanksgiving and um just, you know, want to uh celebrate the Oage uh the teachers and the people that were uh 25 years that 475 years of service [clears throat] is a lot of service. So, I I'm thankful to be a part of this community, thankful to be on this board, thankful um you know that you know we come into contact with all um all our members. So, thank you. >> Thank you, Miss Munan. >> No, I'm good. >> Over. >> Not at this time, >> Mr. Rosen. Um yes I I almost never speak but I um the last person who

075spoke joged my memory of something that I was thinking of. Um, there's a thing where you say, you know, everything I ever learned, I learned from Star Trek. And um, I just finished uh, watching Star Trek Discovery season 4, and there was this an something happened on that episode, and I thought it was um, something that they could learn from. Um the situation was that the president of the Federation was aboard the Starship Discovery and they were in a very delicate mission and the uh captain was taking a gave out orders and the Federation president um asked a question. So after the, you know, tension passes and and there there's a quiet time, the captain and the Federation president go back to the ready room and the captain says, "You know, I want to point

076out that when I'm on the bridge and we're in the middle of a delicate mission and you start questioning me, it undermines the confidence of the crew." And the federation president turned said there's a difference between asking a question and questioning. If you ask a question because you want knowledge, greater clarity, or as a way of introducing an all an alternative way of thinking of something, those are all good things. But questioning to undermine a person's authority or their or to to uh attack their competency is not the right thing to do. So that's a lesson I learned from Star Trek and I thought I'd share it. >> Thank you, Mr. Razner. >> I'm not sure. >> Miss Rudder, >> no comment. >> This is Branch Stewart. Happy holidays. You can respond to me when

077I'm done. That's fine. Good evening. [clears throat] After three years serving this community, tonight is my last meeting of the board of education after making the decision not to seek re-election. It wasn't an easy decision, and it's bittersweet, but it was the right decision for myself, for my family, and for the work I've been called to do beyond these walls. I know everybody wants to go home, but I'm going to take a few minutes to share my reflections on my time on the board, the realities I've faced, and the issues I fought for, and my hopes for the future of our district. I'll start with the reality of the culture and climate I endured in this board. From day one, questions were frowned upon by board leadership. But I believed then and still believe now

078that my job was not to be a rubber stamp. It was to ask questions, especially when it was hard, to be curious, and to offer ideas that might strengthen the decisions we were being asked to make. I was once told by another board member something to the effect of,"Well, one day you'll learn not to feel like you need to read every piece of paper in the board materials packets. That I'd learn to quote just trust." That statement was honestly terrifying to me. The idea that anyone would vote on decisions impacting our children without reading, thinking critically, asking for more information when necessary, and doing the work. It's frankly unacceptable. This is a volunteer position, yes, but it is also public service, and the impact of our decisions could change the trajectory of a child's life.

079There is too much at stake to make decisions lightly lightly. So I read every document. I took notes and I asked questions and for additional information to make informed decisions. And more than once my questions resulted in changes, agenda agenda items pulled, policies amended, issues reconsidered. So to my fellow board members, I hope the day you stop reading agendas is the day you submit your resignation. The people of this district deserve better than that. But there is a culture on this board that punishes people who speak up and that comes from the top and that was in full display tonight in our board president's opening statement. A culture that turns independent thinkers into targets. I have been bullied, ostrac ostracized, and even threatened for doing what I was elected to do. I had committee assignments

080stripped away. I was the subject of a policy proposal designed specifically to silence my ability to speak to the public. A policy that quietly disappeared after I announced I was not seeking reelection. I have been threatened with baseless eth ethics complaints for asking questions and speaking to the public on the record. A complaint like my colleague Randy Stupler endured. a complaint that was ult ultimately dismissed as baseless and yet cost our district thousands of dollars. I [snorts] even had to file a police report after being threatened with physical violence. This behavior is not isolated. It's systemic. It's happened before. It has happened to others and will likely happen again. Richard, I'm rooting for you. Stay strong. And it happens because board leadership and administration allows it to happen because they want it to happen. They

081encourage this culture and behavior because it empowers them and discourages others from ever challenging, asking too many questions or speaking out due to fear that they'll be the next target. Despite all the personal toll it has taken, I am immensely proud of what I've been able to do over these three years. While a single board member cannot pass a policy alone, progress often requires someone to spark an idea, write the first draft, or ask the hard question. I championed world language education across all grades. And while we've made meaningful strides, I believe live instruction that begins in third grade is still too late. I hope the district continues to push this forward and expand our offerings because the data is clear that education must start early to be effective. Sorry, [snorts] I fought for preschool

082expansion because early childhood education is one of the most powerful tools we have to reduce inequity and change long-term outcomes. We've [snorts] made meaningful progress and I'm hopeful for the future. I still have continued concerns regarding the imple implementation of our preschool program and I think it's important that the box is not just considered checked and done. We must continue to innovate and perfect what we are doing to offer highquality early childhood education to every three and fouryear-old in the district. I also pushed for smart district goals that can actually measure that we can actually measure and for a true strate strategic plan something that this district has lacked for far too long. I look forward to watching and participating in that strategic planning process as a member of the public. I hope this board

083will invest in a meaningful collaborative process. I authored and successfully passed policies to undo harmful book bans, to require written committee reports, and to restore the recording of our meetings when board leadership and the administration made the initial unilater unilateral decision to stop it. I was the only board member to consistently raise my voice for these important transparency measures, but the work is not done and I worry that there will be setbacks if the community does not continue to expect and demand transparency and accountability from this board. I advocated for school safety and I'm proud that we now have better systems in place to track who is coming in and out of our buildings. Common sense measures that help protect both students and staff in an increasingly dangerous world. I advocated for inclusion of holidays

084like Diwali, Eid, and then Lunar New Year, which we must ensure is acknowledged in future years. Our school calendar should reflect our full community. These are not just symbolic issues. They are a matter of respect, of representation, and of belonging. I drafted a policy to encourage professional development for board members beyond what is just required by law. If we're going to govern well, we have to be willing to learn. And attending schoolboard conferences and trainings outside of our own community and even state, can bring a pre fresh perspective and new ideas. I encouraged and participated in the creation of better board onboarding processes, including a handbook to ensure board members can hit the ground running when they are first elected. Something that would have been immensely helpful to me when I was first elected. I

085advocated for a change in the way board documents are shared with board members so that we have more time to absorb the materials we're voting on and have a less less surprised popups when we're on the deis. I question ballooning construction budgets and change orders when necessary to try to safeguard taxpayer investment in our district. We are a heavily taxed community and the school board budget reflects a large portion of those taxes. We owe it to our community to be strong stewards of their money. And above all, I've tried to center the children and families who are too often overlooked. Our district is changing. We're seeing rising numbers of families living below the federal poverty line. I was once told by the board president that speaking about these issues was quote insulting because we live

086in and I quote an affluent district. But I'm not embarrassed or afraid to say that some families here are struggling. These families are part of what make our district diverse and beautiful. And I'm proud that I've stand I've stood up against increases in school lunch prices and other issues that impact our most vulnerable students dealing with housing and food insecurity. I know what it's like to be the poor kid in an affluent school district. And I'm proud that I spoke up for those children and families. And I pray someone else on this board finds the courage to carry that mantle forward. [snorts] Because the whole point of high quality public education is to educate and lift up students out of poverty by leveling the playing field, not keeping children there. And while I'm proud of

087the successes, I can't help but feel a sense of sadness and guilt for leaving this position when there is so much unfinished work. I authored a policy that would have required disagregated suspension data to help us address racial and disability based disparities in school discipline. That policy was never even permitted to be discussed in committee, not even a discussion. And so this board continues to not review disagregated suspension data except for like once a year. Our policy committee has been more concerned about law and order and punishing students rather than dealing with the underlying symptoms that perpetuate inequity in our schools. I raised concern about ebikes on school grounds. This is a safety issue and we should not wait until there is a tragedy on our school grounds to take action. I authored a policy

088to protect immigrant students, family, and faculty from the trauma of immigration enforcement on campus, and it too was never brought to a vote. I raised concerns about how we continue to make a profit off of selling sugary snacks to 5-year-olds in our schools while teaching healthy habits in health classrooms. If we're not modeling the same values we teach, what are we doing? I was told I was being difficult to collaborate with for even bringing up this issue. Basic skills support is still too limited. Many students don't qualify for an IEP and they are still struggling and too of often their only option is a short pullout session that causes them to miss other instruction during the school day. And too often that pull out session can be cancelled because basic skills teachers are often pulled

089to cover absences instead. I [snorts] still believe that we need a return to afterchool tutoring all of the options on the table. That doesn't mean getting rid of the the morning club or basic skills. It means just let's us let's have all of the options on the table to reach every child where they are. If we can find teachers for afterchool cursive club, I feel like we can find teachers for reading and math help. And if we can't, we need to ask why. Are we paying our teachers enough? Are we supporting our faculty enough? Let's find out why they're not interested in in providing this since that's what the um what I've been told is the reason why we're not providing afterchool tutoring anymore. And when it comes to student data, we need to be

090more proactive in assessing the success of our programming and interventions. Are we seeing meaningful improvements? Not comparing two different classes, but the same class, the same students receiving interventions we're investing in. We've made progress in expanding enrichment clubs, but we need more intentional STEAM opportunities integrated into the curriculum for all students, not just the ones who are already at the top, especially in the areas of artificial intelligence, robotics, and engineering. We're not preparing students for tomorrow's job market with yesterday's curriculum. And these opportunities should not depend on the on the school your child attends. There should be some consistency through our throughout our elementary schools on the type of enrichment programming offered without stifling innovation. We must prepare for the impact of new development. We know there's construction happening and where it's slated to happen

091in the near future and we know families are coming and yet I don't feel a sense of urgency coming from the border administration. Let's not wait until we're at critical mass. Start exploring solutions now. Revisit boundaries. Make plans for expanding space. Assess facilities. It will be more affordable and less disruptive if we plan now instead of react later when there's a crisis on our hands. As a school district, we are also largely arguably the largest land owner in our community and likely one of the largest users of energy. I was encouraged by the finance committee's exploration of solar panels and encouraged the board to finish that job and to think through additional ways to reduce the district's carbon footprint and communication and transparency. I think we have work to do. I think that commun committee

092meetings should be open to the public. I think board meetings should be livereamed again and allow for audience participation from home. Committee reports should be shared in public agenda items and parent workshops and presentations should be recorded. We need to meet families where they are. If you're doing good programming and no one is showing up, that should tell you something. We can't just check a box. We need to be more data oriented and creative. If we're expending resources and energy, it should be meaningful and impactful. And most of all, we need to talk to people. If board members are discouraged from talking to the people most impacted by our decisions, then we are incapable of making thoughtful decisions, even with the best intentions. We need to listen to our community. We need to figure out

093how best to solicit and encourage their active participation. And no, parent surveys where just 20 parents respond to questions that are designed to solicit a specific answer is not it. People aren't coming to our board meetings or answering a parent survey because we're doing such a great job and they have nothing to say. They're not coming because they don't know how to participate and we're not meeting them where they are. And they don't believe their voice will be heard and we're not actively seeking them out in a way that acknowledges the reality of people's lives. And frankly, they're afraid to speak up. They're afraid that they or their kids will be beun be punished because they've seen what happens to me and others when questions are asked. Why would anyone put themselves on the line

094and stand up there and say anything to our community? I hope you show up and speak out because your voice matters and makes our decisions stronger. You have ideas, so share them. And if you're seeing a problem, speak up or email this full board, not just the board president. Email everybody because otherwise we won't get it. Demand more and expect more and then run if your voice goes unheard. We need to do better and we need to demand more. And I promise I'll be there to help you. Though I'm stepping away from this seat, I am not stepping away from this work. My life has changed a lot in the last three years that I've served on the on the board. When I first ran, I was working part-time and I was pregnant with my

095fourth child. Since then, I've taken a full-time national leadership position. That work has already helped shape new federal guidance from the federal department of education to protect children with invisible disabilities. And I and as was mentioned, I have legislation introduced in Congress that requires more of my time, focus, and travel. Stepping away from the seat allows me to continue to make an impact on a broader national scale and be more present with my family when I'm home. But I am not going far. Starting in January, I will no longer be bound by ethics restrictions that prevent me from organizing. And I look forward to showing up at meetings, not as a board member, but as a community organizer, my roots, helping families and teachers raise their voices and push this district to what I believe

096it can and should be. We have a fine school district. We have a lot to be proud of, but that doesn't mean we should be complacent and okay with just fine. We have more resources in this district that many others don't have. And that means we have an opportunity to demand more. So, I have a few closing things. To the new board member who hasn't been to a meeting yet, but will take the seat in January, I implore you to do the work. Read every single piece of paper you receive. Ask questions. Don't assume the administration will make the right decisions. Ensure that they will. You're here for a reason. To my fellow board members, our job is not to protect the administration. Our job is to protect the public. Our job is to ask

097questions, to govern, and to lead. If we're here just to be another rubber stamp, then we've lost our way. It's okay to be friendly with people on all sides of the aisle. It's okay to compromise sometimes. It's okay to change your mind. Life isn't black and white, and there's a lot of beauty in the in the gray in the middle. So, put your personal vendettas and your egos aside and focus on what really matters, student outcomes, the children who are depending on you to get it right. to our teachers and staff. I'll be honest, some of the things that I've heard said about you in private meetings and off-hand comments by some of my colleagues have been appalling, and you deserve to know that. I have listened when you've spoken. I've stood with you even

098when it didn't align with my personal values or my personal um what would be best for me personally. And I hope that someone else on this board will now step up and take my place and do the same. I know you don't want empty compliments and meaningless speeches about how great your emails are or how nice your classrooms looked at back to school night. You deserve praise for all of those things. Of course, but you want and deserve board members to stand with you when it matters because you didn't go into public education for the money. Let's be honest, you got into it because you're passionate and you care and you want to make a difference in children's lives. And I've tried to stand with you when it mattered and it has been an honor

099to do that. I will endeavor to continue to stand with you when I can. So, thank you for speaking up. Thank you for your service to this district and our children. To the people of Vorhees, thank you for giving me the honor to serve and make history with me. This has never been about a title or a platform. It wasn't a power trip or a stepping stone. It's been about the children of this district who are counting on us to get it right. And I've tried my absolute best to always keep that in mind. To those of you who have personally reached out throughout the last three years, thank you for your quiet words of encouragement and support. You kept me going even on the hardest days. And several several of you are here tonight.

100And I can't tell you how much that has meant to me. To my schoolboard partners family, thank you. My schoolboard partners fellowship was life-changing and I learned so much about what is possible, not just through the program, but through the colleagues and friends I made with schoolboard members across the country who are doing just incredible, inspiring work, laser focused on equity and student outcomes. You continue to inspire me. Finally, thank you to my family, especially my husband Kevin, who has put up with lots of long nights and the emotional toll that this service has taken on me. Your advice, support, and love made this possible, and I could not have done this without you. Borhees, this isn't goodbye. I will be cheering this district on when it succeeds, and I'll be here to speak up

101when it falls short because the stakes are too high to do anything less. Thank you. [clears throat] >> Do any remaining board members have any comments? >> Sure, I'll go. [clears throat] Well, first I'm sad um that we're being portrayed in a way that we don't do anything or that we're complacent or that there's only one person on this board that cares about the kids or does anything for this district or has any integrity. And so when that perspective is spoken in meetings over and over again, um it's painful. So, I'd like to take a moment to share another perspective on some of what's said tonight. First, I I want to be clear that none of us on this board want any member to feel singled out or treated unfairly. Every person at this table

102was elected to serve, to contribute, and to bring their voice to the work that we do. And I know I value that. And I value you, Miss Furry. I do not believe that your opinions are problematic. And I think the rest of us, the eight of us here would 100% agree with that. There are normal differences of opinion, strong debates, moments of tension, some some yelling too that happens behind closed doors that happens on maybe every board because people care. Sometimes you get what you personally want and what you think is best for the district and you get the board to support it by like working with each other and making sure that you have consensus and to build even if it's constructive disscent. Constructive disscent is good. I agree and that happens here. It's

103not everyone agreeing all the time about everything but sometimes you get the board to support it and sometimes you don't. Now, you might be feeling targeted or pushed to the outside, but your behavior has something to do with this. You can present all you want to people here and everyone claps and feels good about it, but that's not the whole story. Like anything, there's truth between many sides of this. It's not a black or white issue. And you have made comments tonight and throughout your tenure here where you publicly disparage everyone on this fort. I mean, you heard the comments tonight at last month's board meeting instead of addressing your concerns about committee and tenants internally and working through and building consensus and having conversations, maybe asking if someone's not feeling well or something's going

104on in their family that they can't attend. You feel like it's your job to expose when someone misses a meeting. you called out me after the first year when I was on a committee for not having enough committee meetings and I'm still learning how to govern and how to do this right and that was 2 three years ago and I still remember that and earlier this year we had a conversation about the policy on what bore comment should be and you had some good valid points But then instead of sticking with the points, you started talking about how the committee hasn't debated a single meaningful policy initiative that hasn't come directly from a third party vendor or been handed us by the administration. These are just a few >> that was a fact. >> I

105am not sure what you expected the response or impact to be other than negative. I don't understand why, but it seems that you feel it's your mission to expose some supposed board dysfunction by discussing inner board workings publicly or implying that people are not doing their jobs. That makes it harder for us to collaborate and stay focused on the issues our community expects us to address. We can disagree even strongly without publicly attacking each other. You and I have spoken directly about this, about how to get your message across without throwing people under the bus as recently as June of this year. And we spoke about this as a group in December 2024 at the BOR retreat to work on this dynamic. Everyone here agrees you're smart, thoughtful, and have great ideas and a genuine

106passion for the district. And we talked about ways to communicate ideas effectively without creating unnecessary conflict or tension. And I hope you know that those conversations came from a place of wanting you to succeed and wanting the board to work well together. Finally, I'd like to apologize to the public for how much time is being spent on this. Thank you, Mr. Ezner. >> I would like to make a comment as well, Mrs. Watson. Um, first I just want to say to the Oage family and teachers, I really appreciated your presentation tonight and bringing the students, I'm really touched by your innovation and your desire to support students to be acknowledged for something other than their academic achievement. Um, in a world with so little kindness, I think it's really important to acknowledge students for good

107behavior even when no one's watching and there's no expectation necessarily. And you could just see it in the way they spoke tonight about their achievements, how proud they are. So, thank you for cultivating good humans. Thank you. Um, this next part I actually hoped I wasn't going to have to say. Um, but I but I do. I cannot let Ms. Ver's narrative stand. Um, and it breaks my heart, but I but I need to say what I need to say because I need to be able to look back on this and know that I um spoke my truth about the experience. Um, so I'll speak plainly about the kind of leadership board work demands. Um, picture a rowing crew fighting rough water. One rower has strengths, smarts, and plenty of ideas about how to win.

108But she refuses to row with the team. She splashes teammates, calls out every mistake but her own, and insists the boat would soar if everyone just followed her. Some of her ideas are genuinely interesting, but the way she engages makes it impossible for the team to hear her. The contribution is buried under the behavior. Public education works a lot like that boat. In a system this complex with so many stakeholders, individual brilliance doesn't move a thing. You can have the sharpest idea in the room, but if you cannot build trust, if you cannot partner, if you cannot align with other human beings, the idea has no place to land. It evaporates. A vision without execution is hallucination. And execution depends on real relationships. Without them, nothing gets off the ground. This shop can be challenging

109and it is thankless most of the time. It demands thoughtfulness and strategy. It demands setting yourself aside for the good of the whole. Ego has no place here and neither does grandstanding or credit seizing seeking. By the way, Miss Very demonstrated the problem in her comment. Notice and re we rewatch if you need to how many times she said I. Collaboration, consensus building, listening, alignment, and humility are all critical success factors. In my work as a leadership coach, I take seriously my responsibility to speak to the best version of the person in front of me. I did that with Miss Verie repeatedly for years. After our board retreat, we even had a collective moment that I genuinely believed was a lasting breakthrough. I walked away hopeful. So when she quick quickly reverted to self agrandisement

110and publicly trashing her colleagues, I was devastated. I felt betrayed and deeply let down. I also felt repeatedly offended every single time she suggested that any of us weren't doing our work and that she was the only one doing her job. It was and is absolutely untrue. It is quite frankly shameful that she would even suggest that. These are some of the hardest working, most dedicated public servants I know. The accusation was not only patently false, it was insulting and it caused even further alienation. But please remember this alienation was fully self-inflicted. As as everyone has said, Miss Verie has a strong mind and ideas worth exploring. But good ideas don't matter when you cannot work with people. It doesn't matter that you might have a contribution to make or an innovative perspective to bring

111when you cannot build trust or sustain relationships long enough to move anything forward. In this kind of system, ideas don't live on talent. They live on partnership and trust that go well beyond transactional connections. Her behavior and ways of being on this board made it impossible for her to be heard. I imagine that was deeply frustrating for her and it's sad but it was a situation entirely of her making. And to the speaker who spoke about constructive disscent, I have been on teams my entire life professionally and personally. This is not constructive disscent. The truth is that the place she finds herself in now is the direct result of her choices. Not bullying, not exclusion. choices she made over and over and over again. Many of us tried repeatedly to pull her strengths into the

112boat, to create a different dynamic, to build bridges, to repair. But collaboration requires at least a willingness to hear other views, to bend, to even be wrong. Sometimes when that willingness isn't there, nothing moves. I wish her well, and I'm grateful in a complicated way that her time here has made this board stronger. We are clearer on who we are, how we work, and what real leadership in public education requires. Thank you. >> Point of personal privilege. Since my name was mentioned multiple times, I'm I'm gonna I'm gonna I thought I was done, but >> you my my name was my name was mentioned. I >> can we shut this down for 15 minutes. And President Watson, I do intend to actually mention Miss Bird's name again if she wants to wait until after my

113comments so we can consolidate it. >> Um, I do not have the board policy on board comment in front of me. >> We don't have a board policy on comments. They tried to pass one. We didn't get one passed. Um, but what we do have is that our board uh meetings are typically um run by Robert's rules of order. I defer to the board president who you elected. >> Miss Branch Stewart, >> the board president has not given any Stewart since you have not spoken. Julianne, you already spoke for 15 minutes. Allow the rest of the people on the board, you've said your piece. Allow the rest of the people on the board [clears throat] to speak and then we can close this meeting out so that everybody can go home tonight. >> Mr. Branch,

114>> thank you, President Watson. and and I as well feel compelled to speak candidly about the transition ahead. January not only marks a new year but a much needed opportunity for a new chapter chapter in board government governance. I look forward to a board that can operate with unity, respect and a shared purpose free from dysfunction, delusion and conflict that have too often overshadowed our work. It's no secret that we have been challenged by behavior as shown by Miss Verie this evening that undermines the abil this board's ability to function effectively. There have been repeated breaches of confidentiality, actions motivated by personal agendas rather than the best interests of our students, decisions made in alignment with individuals whose intentions do not support the progress of this district. performative public activism contradicted by private acts of

115obstruction. And that's just to name a few. Those choices, specifically by outgoing board member Julianne Birdie, have impeded progress and created unnecessary division. Ironically though, as Miss Cuttover pointed out, they have made us a stronger board going forward. one with members that I am very grateful to serve with and confident have the best interest of the district in mind will work collaboratively even during times of disagreement which we absolutely have and will prioritize service over self-interest and social media accolades. This is exactly what our community and our students deserve. I'm genuinely optimistic about the future and grateful that we will begin 2026 with a renewed opportunity to restore professionalism, rebuild trust, and refocus on what matters most, the success and well-being of our students. Thank you. >> Again, person point of personal privilege since my

116name was mentioned repeatedly. Um, you I I I I think this speaks for itself. Um, but the amount of lies and complete nonsense that was just told tonight um is it's insulting to me, but it's insulting to everybody in this room to even have to listen to it. Oprah emails. There's receipts on all of these things. you can see the things that I ask for and say um it it's all Oprahable Oprah the emails um and and continue to do that and hold these people accountable. Um I know that I will continue to hold them accountable and with with along with the public because again the public demands more than this. Um, and if you think that by saying you do you're doing a great job and you're do you're um, you know, I'm saying

117that I'm I said I a lot. Yeah. I I believe in the power of storytelling. I believe that it's important to tell a story and bring people along so they understand um, where I'm coming from. And that's what I've tried to do throughout the my time on this board. And I knew today was going to be tough. Um, so I I came in with knowing that, but but this is this was sort of beyond the pale. Um, but it it really um solidifies that this was the right decision because no one should have to endure what I just endured tonight. And and the fact that you all are in charge of public education is hor horrifying because would you want any of your children to just sit through what I just had to sit through

118tonight? Um, I I I sure hope that's not how you treat your own children at home because this was this is horrifying. >> I mean, you beond of this to the people. I'm tired of the disrespect. I just want to say I appreciate the opportunity served this board. I appreciate the opportunity to prov Thank you to the rest of this community for the opportunity to serve and I will continue to do so. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Is there a second for the motion to adjurnn? >> Second. Rudder. All in favor? >> I