001e aha there's a school board meeting room salute to the flag of the state of New Mexico I pledge alance flag of United States of America God indivisible withy and jusice for all salute the flag of St per friendship among noted cultures okay next we'll move on to the adoption of the agenda which is an action item is there a motion to adopt the agenda so Mo okay we have a motion do we have a second second we have a motion in a second do we have any discussion Antion item okay hearing no further discussion all those in favor say I I opposed hearing no opposition motion passes and I would like to wel welcome everyone this evening to our special board meeting of December 10th 2024 and next we'll begin with our presentation of
002our superintendent search consultants and we'll begin with uh New Mexico School boards Association presentation uh well good evening Madame President members of the board uh my name is is Tom Sullivan uh thank you for this opportunity to describe our services uh I think we've both worked uh with your District previously and look forward to uh to doing it again I've been involved in New Mexico education for 50 years uh 25 in moriarity 10 in Farmington 13 of those as a superintendent uh I've done other work as the state's director of the superintendent Association and more recently this this type of of thing uh and I'll let Dr Paul introduce herself and then jump into a PowerPoint that uh that she's developed that I have no clue how to really no I'm teasing but we'll we'll
003rely on Dr Paul for the technical sides of things good evening everyone um my name is Linda Paul and um I'm a retired superintendent here in New Mexico and I'm clearly the junior one of this team I've only been in New Mexico for 34 years as opposed to uh Mr Sullivan's 50 so it's a pleasure to be here with you tonight I know that everyone is busy and you have a long agenda so I'm gonna go ahead and um switch over to the PowerPoint um unless Javier you can help me with um with setting up the the um PowerPoint see present now select a tab to share all right sorry this is my first time on Google meet so I'm not quite sure how to do this um Javier are you still there can you
004help me out with that okay they're work on getting it set up and we can uh we can present it for you on this side Miss oh good excellent so I'll just cue you and say next slide okay so are you looking at the first slide that says Alam mordo superintendent search yes yes wonderful okay so next slide as we go um so tonight what we'd like to do is talk with you about our seven-step process to look for a new superintendent um Talk briefly about a timeline um what we like to do is talk a little bit too about how long to advertise how we handle applications background checks and then finally um the negotiations so let's dive in to the seven step process so although you're hiring us as board Consultants this is
005still your search and so no matter what you are in the driver's seat and you're the one that's helping us to navigate through um what you want for the new superintendent in your school district so we start off with an initial work session with the board it's an open meeting and we go through a lot of different points I've listed some of them on this slide we talk about how you're going to involve staff and community in this process we're going to talk about some promotional material for your district and for the um the area we we'll also look at the job application and um then we'll talk with you about how to advertise the position we have a a set of um no cost ads here in the state we can use the New
006Mexico Coalition of educational leaders site we can use of course the school boards association website we'll use reap if your district is a member of that um and if you're interested in more advertising perhaps on a national level we can help guide you through that that will be one of the few costs that would be a flowthrough cost to you is the cost of the additional advertising we set up a dedicated email address for the application process and then we manage all the applications so the applications come to us in this dedicated email address and then we review those applications make sure they're complete Etc we will talk with you about the interview process when that comes down the pike and then um hiring the new superintendent and some next steps so next slide so
007the first um session as I mentioned earlier I'm not going to read this whole thing to you but one of the most important things that we do at that meeting is number one identify what your desired qualifications are for the new superintendent we talk about a timeline and again we we discuss and plan any Community or staff um involvement and then um we we really pick your brain about what is it you want how much experience how much teaching experience how much administrative experience Etc so and if I can jump in on that just uh it's as good a time as any to to bring this up uh as as large uh and sophisticated frankly a district as you are uh we would still caution since you may have a number of internal candidates or
008you know Regional candidates uh as we develop with you those uh those basic requirements how many years of this or that and so forth uh avoid uh excluding any of your own folks we've run into that before and it can create create some fiction and the other thing I just might add now uh is that when when you get down to uh you know when are you available or when do you start it may typically be July 1 but you may be looking to announce that person certainly well well in advance of that in terms of when their expectation or possible transition activities might become your timing is outstanding I mean it it is it is perfectly reasonable to expect that we can advertise the um position in January of 2025 and have a new
009person um ready to roll no later than July 1st if you want to bring them in a little earlier for some transition time that's entirely up to the board but your timing as as I mentioned is first class this is the best time to go out for a new superintendent you'll get the best candidates you'll get people that are looking for a position actively and they're not looking to leave their District in the middle of a term so next slide so community and staff um engagement whatever you plan in the beginning in in that um initial meeting we'll Implement so if you want to do advisory committees to help you interview we can do that if you want to do a candidate Forum if you want to do a meet and greet there's many many
010different um options available to you and we'll go through those with you at that initial meeting and then we'll we'll do we'll take it from there and do the planning do the contacting um will if you do use an advisory committee or committees um as some districts have we'll ask that the board make the initial contact and then we will go we'll take it from there next on on that point uh you know whether it's one or multiple uh committees we would ask you folks to provide probably three names each uh we found that a a a committee of uh of 15 is manageable and there may always be somebody that winds up with a conflict and uh you know it even gets to 12 that's uh that's more than enough to give input for
011the board's needs and I don't know Linda did did you mention the possibility I know you mentioned meet and greet and such but uh uh we can certainly also get a a quick Survey Monkey to broaden that input Beyond just the advisory committees thank you I I did not mention that so many districts select to do um a a survey a CommunityWide and staff-wide Survey in advance of advertising to get some more input on what are you looking for in the next superintendent what are some of the strengths of your District what are some of the challenges about to to come down um the road so yes where there's we have lots of tools to um to obtain additional um staff and Community input next slide so we'll finalize the promotional material we make um
012brand new M promotional materials for your District we use pictures from the district we use some text from your website or your Facebook Facebook page um and then we finalize of course the the application some boards want an essay um as part of the application some boards like to wait until the day of the interview so again whatever your board decide decides and desires we'll we'll do our best to implement next slide so as I mentioned earlier we manage all the a all the advertising and all the applications and so we will review them first you have Total Access to those applications please hear me when I say we are not keeping anything from you we just wait until the end of the advertising period so if the if the position closes let's say February
0131st you'll have access to all of those applications February 2nd or third depending on how many so you'll get access to them just not as they come in in fact the access you're granted may be more than you wanted because we will ask you to to read carefully all of them prior to our screening meeting and that's part of that next step good job Tom next um next slide please so you do the initial screening and again if you want our input we're happy to do that sometimes we we sort the candidates into two piles like read me first and read me second um but not every board wants that and so you do the initial screening and you screen your candidates down to who you want to interview we do the background checks and
014um and we're going to be very um particular about that because if you go out and do background checks that's um that that may be setting the board and the district up for a problem down the road so we'll do the background checks now that being said if you have information about the candidate we're all yours we want to hear about it we will candle the communication back and forth from the um candidates to us so that they're kept in the loop and they know what's going on with the status of their application and I'm sorry ladies and gentlemen I can't see you so if there's any questions please like speak up um because I I can't see you if you're you're raising hand we weren't sure H how much time uh you know you
015were willing to put up with us for so uh we're kind of speeding through this but uh and we can ask answer any questions at the end but as Linda said please don't don't hesitate to ask now we're very questioning people so be prepared good I like it all right next slide please so the interview process typically we set aside a full day for interviews and the way that day works typically is everyone comes in The Advisory committees if you use them the board the candidates everybody comes in in the morning has a light um continental breakfast some coffee the board calls themselves into order and goes into an executive session and then the board will interview the candidates if you use advisory committees they will interview separately and then um we typically close with
016a lunch for everyone so it gives you an opportunity just to kind of see how the candidates react in a less formal situation and then the board will again convene itself into executive session we typically join you for that and that's where we present all of the background information and um and then you make a decision about your new superintendent yeah and and we will have uh as as we go into that executive session we will have compiled feedback from any advisory groups that you're using uh you know not a uh you know thumbs up or thumbs down on five applicants but rather a pretty detailed analysis of how they responded to questions and and what kind of strengths and skills they have and please again know that we do not allow the advisory committees
017to select the next superintendent that that's not their job they are advisory we that's right large letters absolutely so we gather their input we have some tools to do that so that when you get to Executive session that afternoon you have all of the information from the people that you selected if you're using advisory committees um and you have the background information we can also I'm sorry go ahead no no go ahead I'm finished um we can also do press releases if you'd like and or um language to send out to the staff because as you know the staff can get very interested in um this process and so we'd like to keep them involved as well Tom well I was going to say since you folks are recruiting these folks or nominating them I
018guess well recruiting may be better because we would ask you to certainly speak with them and uh let let them know what they're getting into but you know if you've recruited them our assumption is that they're folks that uh you respect and whose opinion uh you know you would appreciate but we also would expect that they weren't going to say and if you don't go along with what I think I'll never speak to you again so in fact when we've contacted people uh they have been overwhelmingly flattered and pleased to participate in this process and you know thrilled to do it for their districts I'm dead serious about that I could I could find all the names and and hand them to you next slide please do we pay for the interview subjects to come
019to our district or do we do that in a zoom meeting or what's we can we can do either one I think Mr Sullivan and I definitely prefer face Toof face um and it's pretty well expected that the candidate will pay their own um way to Alamagordo to be interviewed um I we've never paid for for candidates to um to come to a district if if um you know Logistics are too too difficult we can use zoom we I have a zoom account that with my business that we can certainly use we can use whatever platform you want to but we strongly recommend that we do it face to face yeah we would want to meet with you face to face as we develop those promotional materials we would want to meet with any advisory
020groups uh you you identified face Toof face we want to be with you during the screening process face to face and we sure want to be with everybody face to face when we're interviewing right and so at the end of that process hopefully by the end of that day some boards choose to use a Saturday so they don't have to pay for substitutes for um teachers or or other um employees of the district to participate some say nope it's really important to do it during the work week for our community whatever the board chooses We Will We Will um execute that and so um after that after the board selects their new superintendent we can um facilitate some additional services or we can facilitate some additional meetings with you and the new superintendent if you'd
021like it's certainly not required but some boards feel comfortable to have somebody um kind of neutral to come in and help get everybody off on the right foot Next Step next slide so you have our price um in The Proposal that Mr Sullivan sent um it we we believe in a fixed price um contract and so it the the fixed price includes all our services it includes background checks any advertising that that is little or no cost um we will handle again as I mentioned earlier if you want to um advertise in education week or aasa we would ask the district to pay those those costs and then um travel to the district um by mutual agreement we try to keep it three trips but if it turns into four it turn I think I
022outlined four and and I I will commit to that because uh uh I was thinking in terms of uh they're definitely being an Advisory Group and I would not want to not meet them before we ask them to come to interview and like I said we we we fix the price so that if it's four trips it's four trips um that that's not an issue next slide please and so again additional advertising or additional um uh Services we're more than will willing to provide for an additional fee um we would also ask that the district um provide any copies that the board might need for um for the meetings postage we really don't use postage too much anymore but if we need to do that we'll we'll save receipts and we'll ask for reimbursement next
023slide and other than that that is the only fee that we charge we don't and Di you we say this is it this is our fee and um and we'd love to do business with you we have tons of references if you'd like to um speak with some of your colleagues um Mr Sullivan and I are both going to be at the school boards Association conference this coming week so if any of you are there please feel free to stop by and say hi um if you want some references we can certainly provide those in advance and you'll have an opportunity perhaps on Friday or Saturday to actually talk face to face with some of those people next slide I have a question this board member right um of course You' mentioned that you we
024just do the background check on the final candidate yes sir on the the what now you don't do them on the on any of the others I mean what happens if you get to one you think you're going to like and then you do a background check and find out it's a flop uh why wouldn't you do it on a couple of them is it rather expensive or no we sir we we will do the background checks on all of those finalists that you wish to invite for your interviews and those will be indepth we would not plan to do formal background checks on every applicant as Linda said you know we'd probably be able to sort some of these into read first and don't read first because frankly uh we've been at this so
025long that we see some Usual Suspects for lack of a better term but uh no uh yeah we'll do thorough background checks in state and out of state and everywhere else that we can find on your finalists we also do um social media we check social media we check the um sex offender website we check um NM courts I mean there's there's a variety of different um places that we we go to to look for yeah I think that's very important I think in the past there's been some negligence there and and U I think it's cost the district a lot of money in the in the past what I can tell you is that recently and it's not fair to the district but it was good fortune uh a candidate that they were high
026on very high on uh as we researched that had uh been in legal action in with the previous District adversarial legal action and uh you know that was that was the end of the game uh and you know we were able to discover that and uh uh it wasn't easily explained away do you do you or can we ask those individuals if they've had ever had any litigation or any um procedures uh regarding their previous employers or is that is unethical or is that not allowed um let me take a stab Tom and then please fill in um number one we ask some very pointed questions on the application for example have you ever been asked to leave your prior District or a prior district and if the answer is yes please explain I mean
027just because that happened doesn't mean that that's a horrible situation we want you to be the judge of that so you would receive all of that information but we do ask those questions on the application like I said I I we look on the application and see where they've worked if they're from New Mexico that's easy um I can check andm reports I can check um a couple of other sites that I that I go to to look for litigation um if they come from other states I do the same thing I i' I I work and work and work and work until I get um their information from whatever state or states that they come from and frankly um my best source of material sometimes are the local newspapers you know if I put
028in if if somebody is from let's say Joplin Missouri and I type in that person's name and J Missouri bam you know here comes all the media um attention that was um was given to that particular situation so we'll we'll look as as deep and as far as we possibly can the the other thing and I'm not sure if I understood the earlier question is uh we would prefer that board members or uh you know any other staff from the district not get actively involved in that uh that that we would prefer to be the ones that do that kind of uh background and reference checks and bring you our information we certainly can't prevent it from happening uh but we think it can Cloud the waters and and maybe get us into some uh
029awkward situations legally the other tool that we have in our toolbox is the last page of the application is a release from the candidate to us to do a thorough background check so oftentimes I'll call a district and say hey I'd like to talk with you about you know XYZ and they'll say oh we're not allowed to say anything unless there's a release and I could say great I have a release and I can email that to them immediately so um we try to put as many tools at our disposal to do a thorough background check it's not to say we can't miss something but I'm here to tell you we spend hours on each applicant looking and looking and looking yeah and you know not to make light of this but uh I have
030neither read or written a bad letter of reference uh so I don't put as much stock in them unless it comes from somebody who I consider a reliable source in which case I will certainly call and and spend quality time but uh you know we're more likely to call people that aren't listed as references if we have a relationship from that district and and if it's in state we certainly do uh my work at the State Association level allowed me to meet uh colleagues in the same roles in adjacent States uh not the same people any longer but I have no problem calling and uh I've done so recently in adjacent States I have other questions but I'm not going to say nothing right now does anybody else have a question okay it's back to
031you then because do you have any of the other questions right now please we're we're more than comfortable answering questions at this point I'm just we kind of got stung here year or two ago and there are just some things that went on that recommendations got written which in my opinion probably shouldn't have got written not like they did but that's one thing too how do you check a recommendation and know that it's actually the truth or that it's it's the right recommendation how do you know somebody just didn't Pat it just to get them to move on or whatever that's a great question that's a great question and like Mr Sullivan said we don't rely on those letters of reference at all we we ask them for them because it's part of the process
032but frankly we pick up the phone and call or we get in the car and go you know i' I've got a recent and graphic example and I don't mind sharing it I hope there's not a large crowd here unless there some on zo this this good friend of ours uh highly respected superintendent for years and years in the Southeastern par part of the State uh I called and asked him about someone who I knew he had had some dealings with in an administrative capacity previously uh and he essentially said I wouldn't hire him to pick up something in his yard uh the respect I had for that individual would have trumped anything I had read from other references I'm telling you that right now yeah and and you're right there in this day and
033age there's so it's so easy to do um you know I could write a stellar recommendation for myself right now using AI or lots of other things and um and it would look legit you know I want to add one thing if I can Linda because I think it is at this point especially you mentioned AI our recommendation strongly is on the morning of the interviews part of the rotation for those candidates is a writing activity and it's a a prompt that puts them through their Paces in terms of judgment and communication skills uh several scenarios uh we would even invite you folks to uh you know give us the kind of topic we have inappropriate behavior embezzlement bullying you know all those kinds of things that may very well uh reach the level of
034board superintendent relations and uh it won't be generated by AI it will be written on the spot yeah I'm not a huge uh fan of artificial insemination yet other than the fact I grew up on a dairy farm and it was that's a good one okay any other questions thank you anyone else have any questions no they've answered all mine okay I think we're done with all of our questions so president yes ma'am well while they're still here so they have the benefit of it I just bring up a couple of points that are relevant to what what they've raised absolutely um so I I know you all can't see but this is Alena gagos good to see you both how are you good um so I just I wanted to bring up a couple
035of things because um I know that I probably won't be at your at whatever the next step is in this process but I was just um in terms of the approach to to committees um one other thing that that I don't know if you two have um Dr Paul Mr Sullivan if you've done this before but one of the things I know that districts have H struggles with is that no matter how much uh you emphasize that the committee is not the decision maker the board is that at the point that the committee is actually interviewing um and and assessing that that can get very cloudy in their minds um and so then you get into the well they didn't picked the candidate that that we thought was the best um the other thing too
036is I don't think it's clear legally uh whether their notes um their assessments are letters of reference letters of reference aren't subject to AR public record um your um matters of opinion are not public record uh but whether a third party like a committee is I think is an open question and so um one of the approaches that um for those obviously the the step that Mr Sullivan and Dr Paul described um where they come in and and get a profile of the candidate is extremely valuable um and I highly recommend that um whatever route you take that you undertake that process as far as committee another another way and again I don't know um Mr solivan and Dr Paul whether you've ever done this before but uh would be to have your constituent groups
037so if if your committee is made up of Sometimes some districts will divide it by constituent groups where you've picked so many parents and so many um staff and so many you know categories of different constituent groups business people to make up that number whatever uh I think um Dr Paul and and Mr Sullivan had a specific recommendation as to number and I would certainly defer to them on that and then the Consultants would then facilitate from that group interview questions uh that you all in your interview that is confidential where your opinions are protected you all would ask so you've got the questions representing those constituent groups but you're the one assessing the answers and and they're not they're not confused about what their role is so I I do think that from an
038IA um perspective that how you approach any third parties um needs to be carefully thought out from a legal perspective and I don't think that we have a clear enough answer about what category of public record um that committee's uh opinions are and that that can create some some legal layers that you may you may not want to contend with and you may not want to contend with the perception no matter how well everybody communicates that they're not the decision makers that their their candidate didn't get picked so there are other ways to get that Community involvement if you choose another way but I I would caution you and any Consultants about the ipper piece thank you that's a that's a great Point um and just so you know one of us is with that
039advisory committee or committees at all times and so it's a facilitated interview it's not just oh go down the hall and interview them one of us is with the board one of us is with committees and we have other um Consultants that we trust that we can bring in if you have more than one committee well and to add to that uh I will not do a rotation among the committee members you know like this person asked question three this question person asked question four uh as a facil it Ator I'm going to ask all of the questions so that I am confident that they were asked the same way and again we're not going to be subject to any you know uh con contesting of that later but uh uh Elena I absolutely respect
040everything you said I would hope that we've done this enough and and not had that kind of uh blowback that we have been able to establish it's always somebody who's a rogue uh but I think we've been able to established that clearly that uh it's the board's decision and people have been excited to be asked to participate but they pretty well understood what that role was I think we've done that pretty well I really do very well okay any other questions from the board or all right well thank you for your presentation thank you very much thank you quick question uh Madam president uh is is if there's somebody else coming in behind us are we allowed to stay on if if not we'll just await a communication from you if there's somebody coming behind
041them are they allowed to stay on or we are just waiting for communication so um president CAD Waller members of the board and Mr Sullivan um so uh there is someone there is another Consulting coming on and I did specific ask them since you were first to uh uh agree that they would not observe yours in real time certainly this is this is streamed and recorded So once the meeting is over what you choose to do with the with the public document um that's AC easily accessible um is up to you but I did specifically ask them since they were second um to to represent that neither they nor any of their Associates uh would be watching it in real time just so that they didn't have any advantage so I'm glad I am you're
042second you're first so I think it's a little bit different but since they extended that courtesy it it maybe makes the most sense to absolutely uh and uh more than glad to honor that hope to hear from you folks all right if there's any other questions we'll be around okay thank you very much thank you bye now bye bye okay do we have the well I I apologize I got focused on the conversation let me and of course they're not watching so let me let me call we don't have an issue with you focusing on us pleas we like that hello okay okay we have our second uh presentation for our superintendent search Consultants thank you for coming oh it's our pleasure so hopefully everybody can hear me okay can everybody hear yes all right
043fantastic well thank you uh first and for foremost for the opportunity to visit with you this evening I'm joining you virtually of course from my hometown I'm in Austin Texas just finished a a different board meeting and so I'm I'm hunkered down in a private room so I can uh spend some quality time with all of you um and thank you for your service to public education it's uh it's an honor to be um sharing some of the evening with you and happy to to go in any direction that you prefer I did provide um a copy of our formal presentation but I do want to honor your time and and your commitments that you have this evening so I'll I'll defer to you board president and what your your hopes and aspirations are for
044tonight's discussion uh I'm sure everybody has read what their proposal was but if you could just give us like a reader Digest condensed version of your proposal and we can ask questions from there we always have a lot of questions so be prepared okay yeah so what I may do then is just run through overview the presentation that um that we provided virtually okay um and you know I'll just go through that quickly and use it as a backdrop so um do I have the ability to share my screen yes you should be able to all right bry's tech savvy so let's see here sorry bear with me one moment I'm just seeing if I can get to okay so I think we're good now you should see the first page of our presentation yes
045okay wonderful okay um what you'll learn about us is we're a very techsavvy group we use a lot of technology to support our school district partners and our school boards um so I'm going to just go and burn through this uh really quick and again uh my name is James G I'm the president and the CEO of JG Consulting um joining me this evening is my colleague Robert alaro and I'll let him introduce himself really quick okay oh Robert are you with us okay he may not he may not be um so in the spirit of time we'll go ahead and and go through this quickly all right our mission is quite simple and I've had an opportunity to review um a little bit about the the school system that you serve um and I
046feel that our mission and our vision align quite nicely with um a lot of the um Endeavors and the different things that you have going for you um in the the great work um in Alam mordo but the few words that I'll highlight here in within our mission are Equitable inclusive transparency and and and of course to all come together to support a well-managed process as you seek to recruit your next superintendent and the impact of of this work can be measured in many ways but ultimately it's the satisfaction of of each of you as elected members of the school board in the community but also and most importantly uh the students that you serve within the school system some of our recent successes and where we've worked um in your great state of New
047Mexico include Talis Municipal schools we recently recruited their current superintendent and also lost Cruz's public schools and then some others there Adams 14 is a school district just north of Colorado and AA friia is in the state of Arizona so we are full service um executive consulting firm based in Texas but we do work Nationwide and I'll talk a little bit about our diversity as we continue through this presentation um some of the differentiating factors that um make us stand apart from our colleagues and our peers in this space we utilize quite a bit of Technology as I indicated a moment ago we have an interview portal which I'll show you a screenshot of that here momentarily we also own a proprietary uh uh website which is superintendent search.net um it's a free tool to
048use and you can actually use it for other positions not just the superintendent um search work that we will potentially U support you in but other things such as teacher vacancies coaching V vacancies um sea level administrative roles um and then it's free uh we do we don't not charge uh our other District Partners to utilize it anyone can sign up and begin posting job positions there and I'll show you what that looks like here momentarily as well one of the things that we're very keen on I talked about transparency as a part of our mission uh but we do quite a bit of surveying and so my understanding is that you're an active Community um you have engaged um members within the internal infrastructure but also externally so if it's the will of the
049board to survey the community to to Garner input and feedback as we begin this process we can survey anonymously of course as many people as as you wish to um and in as many languages as you would like so our surveying tool enables us to do that um and last but not least we have a new data portal that takes all of the aggregate data of the academic uh scores for the candidates in whatever state and School District they're currently serving in so it's essentially like if you can Envision um a baseball card if you're familiar with a baseball card you might have the image of the player on the front and you flip the card over and it has their statistics we're essentially taking all of the disparate data from across the US and
050and helping our school district and our school board Partners make sense of all the overwhelming metrics that are out there uh because again if it's the will of the board to cast a wide net um we're going to attract Talent from all over the country if that's the pleasure of the board is is to cast a wide net okay um so to give you a little bit of an understanding of the interview portal um this is what it looks like in in essence so it's um ond demand interview the candidates are asked to answer a series of questions they answer the questions independent of us so it's very impersonal in that regard but it gives you as a board myself and the representatives on my team an opportunity um to engage in this kind of
051pre-screening preting process um so it's just another great layer of getting to know the candidates and an opportunity prior to bringing them in in person you know before they come in on Planes Trains or automobiles to meet with you so it's not to circumvent the in-person interviews but rather give you an opportunity and give us an opportunity to get to know the candidates a little bit better uh that software uh excuse me that proprietary job search page that I referenced in the website this is a screenshot of what it looks like this is the homepage all the little blue dots that you see across the United States those are um actual data points of where there's job vacancies um so you can see there's quite a few the comprehensive survey tool um this is just
052a screenshot of our internal system but again we're we want to um promote and include everybody as much as as you're willing to and to solicit input and feedback and again it's an anonymous survey tool that we use and it can be done in as many languages as you'd like the uh data portal that I referenced earlier and I use this um uh baseball card analogy so essentially you're taking all of the different data sets from across the US and whatever accountability system they're in whether it's New Mexico Texas Colorado um really it's it's a un veral system but we're looking for metrics in certain key areas so the subdomains um and the academic performance and let's just say third grade reading in math and so we can do a side by-side comparison of districts
053in comparable size to Alam mordo um not only in the state of New Mexico but other states where candidates might might have worked or are currently serving a little bit about our success rate in the track record for us if you look on the leftand side where it says St statistical overview for us we have conducted almost 180 executive searches uh I mentioned earlier that we're a full service firm um so we conduct executive level searches for all administrative levels and executive levels for school districts nonprofits and even City municipalities um so we recently conducted an athletic director search as an example a director for transportation um general counsel Chief Financial Officer we just finished a um a rather large superintendent search in in Stafford County Virginia um and i' like to mention them because
054very similar in terms of the military installation there in the DMV the um that area of DC Maryland and Virginia they have a strong military presence in their community and they currently have a little more than 35,000 students in their organization um over the course of the last 10 years we've conducted City 61 superintendent searches Nationwide uh 68% of the superintendents that we have hired are currently in their respective roles today um so the average tenure of our sitting superintendence is a little bit more than six years um and the national average if you're unaware um for a district year size is a little more than three years and 50% of the superintendant we have recruited in place um are women leaders and the other graphic that you see kind of more on the center
055of the page that those are just National statistics according to um a national survey conducted by a third party um earlier I mentioned and alluded to the fact that we can cast a wide net but again it's the will of this board if that's what your wish is um our experience is rooted in traditional education but we do have experiences working in non-traditional sectors I mentioned nonprofits we've uh recruited city managers so we have you know a pretty good reach in terms of the types of talent you'd seek to recruit now the leadership profile will determine um what that Talent will look like but no one will know the community better than you and and your your staff your students and your constituents so we're going to seek your input and your guidance and ultimately
056defer to you what type of leader you are looking for to serve in this role um so we're looking to find the right fit and the candidates that aren't necessarily looking for a job or the types of people that we will recruit uh so we don't want folks that are running from something but rather toward something um and and that's where we shine we poach and recruit Talent who isn't necessarily looking um to abandon ship so to speak um some of the associations we work with I understand you know you have your local Association but we also work with all of the state Affiliates and but also the national Affiliates so ASA the American Association of school administrators allas is the Association of Latino administrators and superintendents we just finished recruiting their executive director which
057is a National Organization the National Alliance of black school Educators the National School Board Association and the list goes on and on there are 35 uh repurposed recovering superintendents that work um as members of the team um and they're all located throughout the United States Mr alaro will be um co-chair with me working alongside you but you have the the the depth and the bench of all of my tremendous uh repurpose is what they call themselves uh superintendence that have new recently retired um this is just a suggested timeline by no means are we um uh inclined to follow this this is just to give you an idea of the major Milestones so we're visiting this evening we have the winter break um starting here soon and then the recruitment in the and the screening
058process can begin in January and February we can also simultaneously engage with the community if you so feel that is is a necessary asset of this process uh effectively close the application in February review candidates with you show you the videos um of each of the candidates review all their artifacts letters of Interest resumés academic transcripts uh the background reports Etc um aim to interview and February as well and then um hire your superintendent in March and again that's just s suggested and it's just based off of uh what little bit we know um now I I do have a video it's just a testimonial I don't have to play it I'll defer to you if you want to see it we can quickly watch that or if you'd like to just um ask questions
059I'm also happy to answer questions what do you say team do you want to watch the video do you want to go straight into question I don't know how long is the video I don't know what it heard it's just a couple of minutes it's a testimonial from a a superintendent she currently serves in the Dallas Independent School District and it talks about the process I just want to be mindful of your time with us this evening I don't have a problem with all right let's watch it okay terrific are we watching did it did you start it oh it's not transcribing to you you can't see it no oh okay yeah it might be just the feature because I have two presentations open I apologize um I could send it digitally just in you
060know to and and again just to be mindful of our time but if it's appropriate with board counsel I can share the link and you're welcome to also visit our website these videos are accessible on uh at JG consulting.us we have a number of different testimonial videos and and other reference points that you're welcome to watch okay I think we can all watch it independently okay well I'll stop sharing my screen now and I see that uh my colleague uh Mr Robert Al has joined us I just wanted to give him an in uh an opportunity to introduce him himself really quick I know you can't see us but we're all waving High okay okay so does I think he's trying to speak okay you might be on mute Robert I had I had the
061mic off well hello and thank you for giving us an opportunity to visit with this evening um just a little bit about myself I'm a retired superintendent from Texas a regional superintendent retired from Nevada so I've worked in very small school districts and very large school districts and doing superintendent searches and administrative searches for the last 13 years so good even yes yeah good to see you okay thank you all right I know we have questions let's ask our questions do you guys um do you how thorough are you on the background checks so what at what level do you start doing a background check once you've uh there say there's been say there's been 15 people uh submit an application for the job do you do every one of them or do you just
062narrow it down to uh some fine list and then go from there yes sir great question so uh we do highlevel reference checks um as it pertains to all of the applicants so just to use your round number of 15 if there are 15 applicants we do high level reference checks and and also that includes making phone calls and other inquiries to individuals who perhaps aren't listed as a reference or a point of contact on their application materials because this line of work as you can imagine is very incestuous myself and Robert other members of the team will know somebody who is connected professionally and or personally to the candidates um so we we do a great job of um determining if there are any issues there I made the comment earlier that we're seeking
063individuals who are not running from something but rather towards something now as far as the more thorough background checks we engage a third party and it is done with the candidates that you select for an interview uh because there is a an expense associated with each person um so we're also being mindful of the comprehensive budget that we've proposed so that is done for the for the group of candidates that you wish to interview and they do everything from credit checks verifying academic credentials if there's unpaid parking tickets I mean some of the things that we're able to uncover and discover to share with you so that way you're not blindsided um is quite remarkable um I joke with our Schoolboard partners that if Jac kusto dropped the treasure chest in the bottom of the
064gulf our our partner would find that information we've um we've seen um in the past where um letters of recommendation or have been written and how in depth do you go on those as far as verifying if it somebody really writing something that's true or something somebody is writing something just to appease that person and alleviate any other future potential problems right no that's a great question and again uh to my earlier comment about speaking with individuals who might have some sort of affiliation or wherewithal of the candidate is where we're able to uncover if there is any sort of malfeasance in their uh their work history if there are issues you know again to I think your point if there's authenticity to what is being said about that person we do our due diligence
065because we have skin in the game if I may put it plainly you know our um our success in our track record um is solid we have never failed to search and you know we are very intentional about recruiting exceptional Talent uh because our brand and our our name is is behind the work um and the long-term commitment to Alam mordo is important to us um and so verifying and doing the due diligence that is required and necessary that is something that we we take very seriously um so we wouldn't put you as a board in a position to be held to answer for something later if there is anything whatsoever um a candidate is required to disclose if there was something in their work history or their personal history and they also have to
066provide a written statement so there's a verification form that we require as a preliminary uh measure for determining if there is anything um with regard to again their professional or personal work history um so that way even before we begin the formal background check we have some level of understanding if there's anything in their work history so that way you're not blindsided you're not left at the altar we're not left at the altar and there's there's cohesion and and you know you're not held to answer later for something that was unknown um so we're going to bring forward all of the information to you so that you can make an educated and informed decision as a board when you speak to them do you make them put put their left hand on the Bible raise
067your right hand tell the truth and nothing but the truth so help yeah uh well I will tell you this I'm pretty direct um and our team we will ask them the basic simple question is there anything in your personal or professional history that could potentially embarrass the school board and you know if there's any sort of hesitation or if there's like this pontificating we can tell you know we've Robert I'm sorry the fth that's right that's right so you know we we've been doing this a long time and um you know and I've had the pleasure of working with Miss gyos and her firm and she can attest that the thoroughness and the vetting that we engage in there's so much due diligence and you know this is incredibly this is an incredibly important
068decision for all of you um and that's not lost on us how much time and effort goes into this and the last thing we want to do is get to the 11th hour and and be blindsided by something that we you know we could have known or have avoided um early in the process um so if there is anything I'll work with board counsel and disclose what it is that we discover PRI U prior to any in-person interviews or any decision big decisions you might need to make um as we advance through each major Milestone of the process together I'd say one of the first rules of Schoolboard members is we don't like to be surprised you it's not a good surprise whatsoever so so can I ask um so this the background checks that
069you conduct who are they conducted by are they conducted by professionals or is this something that that your staff does or just walk me through that because I want to make sure that I'm comfortable with the fact that sure actually doing the background checks the third party that we work with it's a it's an organization that specializes in it so the thorough background check is is um done by a sure hire is the name of the organization so they're uh that's their sole purpose as an organization and they're the ones that will provide the encrypted files that you will have access to um so I I mentioned some of the different assets that are included in the background check per candidate it can range I mean these PDF files can be anywhere from 40 to
07050 pages and if especially if um the individual has served in different communities or different states so like my my my good colleague here Mr Alo represented school systems in multiple States these entities like a sh hire check all of the different municipalities and where he or she may have lived and worked and so we're checking all of the the local municipalities but of course doing the the doj the Department of Justice background checks the only thing that this company won't won't do but you will as an organization if you choose to hire um one of the candidates that goes through the process all the fingerprinting and things of that nature um so that's a little bit more about the thorough background checks now the reference checks uh the high level social media scrubbing the
071other things that we will do internally that's conducted by our staff if you uh choose to use the doj or the FBI to do checks and would you wait till after January 20th please I will defer to the board so if that's the directive and pleasure of the board it's it's this is your show we work at at the pleasure of the board okay so sa for example you know there's a candidate from uh California and we would need to make sure that they were eligible to receive a New Mexico public education department lure would how would we handle something like that right and I'll defer to uh Mrs skos if she's in the room um but my memory serves me correctly there is reciprocity and it's a a universal Trend where if they're an
072outof State candidate incoming um to serve in your community your school district I believe there is um a formal process that gives him or her um an allowance of time to complete that certification it varies from state to state but generally I want to say um Most states it's one year but I'd have to defer to to general counsel and um president CAD Waller and members of the board and Mr geta um and good evening Mr geta um so my experience with search groups and that's a across more than one and and that includes um JG Consulting is it generally when if you've got out of state um applicants and if they they get to the level of of either of semifinalist is that the consulting firm works with your HR department the HR departments
073usually I mean they they routinely are are looking uh and working with the peed to extent to the extent necessary to know whether or not that individual is going to meet the the criteria to be able to um to be licensed and and assume the position so that's usually how that's how that's handled um I don't I like Mr g i i think H HR is actually the best in the best position because they do that routinely so I don't usually get uh into the examination of that I let the district's HR Director um confirm so there's typically no problems with that process I've not run into any kind of barrier yeah it's it's fairly common um and it's um somewhat of a known quantity in fact I referenced our two other District Partners in
074New Mexico um Los crus and in t both hired their superintendent from from different states um in my understanding from those incoming superintendant and working with them still to this day uh their their process was rather seamless but um but Mrs guos is is is accurate in stating that HR and your human capital team can certainly help but we'll we'll work closely with them to ensure that you know we're checking all of the boxes as necessary okay anybody else have any other questions gentlemen think I'm good okay all right well thank you for your time this evening oh you're welcome it our pleasure thanks for the opportunity and best wishes on a successful search and we look forward to hearing from you all right thank you very much take care okay uh so next other
075items of business uh which is an action item for the board to take action on whether to proceed with a superintendent search so would anybody like to make a motion on whether to proceed with a superintendent search I would like to make a motion I think we need to do our due diligence and appease our constituents and the promises that we ran on to do a search and considering the circumstances that we have been put in and the progress that we've made I think it's transparency and I think it's going to look good on all of us okay so you're making a motion do we have a second second okay we have a motion in a second do we have any further discussion okay hearing no further discussion all those in favor say I I
076I opposed hearing no opposition motion passes okay so since we've decided to proceed with a superintendent search uh we should select a search consultant does anybody have a motion on which search consultant they would like to select I am going to be honest and admit that I have not had a chance to read the full scopes of their proposals and I would like to either have a little time to do that or discuss that in our meeting if we can okay well we have to discuss it here okay we can't the only thing we could do would be to table it so I would make a motion to table it until our regularly scheduled meeting okay we could do that right okay a second okay we have a Motion in a second do we have
077any further discussion no I agree okay that was a lot of information okay so we have a motion to table it and we have a second and we don't have any further discussion so all those in favor say I I I opposed okay hearing no opposition motion passes and we'll move on to consider nullification of service agreement between specialized education of Arizona and almagordo public schools and I'm going to hand it over to Mr Crab Tre yes good evening good evening president caler members of the board um on August 8th 2024 the board agreed that APS would enter into a service agreement with specialized education of Arizona also known as cesi and they were going to provide special education programming to our students um under the service agreement cesi provision of this program was to
078begin on October 14th um as of today cesi has not delivered this program me um which has resulted in a failure is a this failure is a material breach of the service agreement um so the service agreement declares that any material breaches of the agreement by cesi Shall render the agreement null and void uh based on C's failure to provide special education program programming to our students the action item here is that the board would agree to recognize this failure as a material breach and consequently to exercise the district's right under an agreement to toct clar it null and void um The Nullification of this agreement with cesi will not affect the district's ability to provide special education programming to the students uh the district we have provided and will continue to provide special education
079programming to our students in compliance with the individual with disability Education Act and it's implementing regulations by using the Staffing Resources that we currently have so this is something we were trying to to do in addition and it just wasn't able to happen so we have this item here um an action item here on this agreement okay so do we have a motion to uh approve the Nullification okay wait call for a motion I'd like to call for a motion to consider approval of the Nullification of the service agreement between specialized education of Arizona cesie and almagordo public schools I would so move okay we have a motion do we have a second second we have a motion in a second do we hear any further discussion um I would like to ask a couple
080questions so this company uh failed to perform obviously are are there going to be any other proposals put out to try to replace them or are we just going to try to take care of it in house yeah so I mean we're brainstorming other ideas that we could possibly use um right like you said right now we provide as Services as we need and this is an extra thing we were hoping to try out this school year um but wasn't able to do um dur due to them being able to staff it are are we currently keeping up with the demand in the district at at all levels Elementary Middle School and High School yes absolutely we're in compliance this agreement had nothing to do with any Services were provided we were just trying to
081try out an additional thing to see if it would be beneficial to our our district or not can can I ask if they provided any reasoning as to why they couldn't fulfill their it was Staffing we weren't able to staff it they weren't able to find the Staffing to in place to run this program they weren't able to find the Staffing yes yeah because that was their yeah okay okay so we have a motion in a second we've had discussion so all those in favor say I I I opposed hearing no opposition motion passes and next we will uh call for a motion to go into closed executive session to discuss limited Personnel matters is permitted under Section 1015 D1 H2 of the open meetings act specifically for the board to discuss and prepare the
082acting superintendent's midterm evaluation for the board to discuss appointment of an interim superintendent including possible contract terms for the board to discuss and legal councel to advise regarding its contractual obligations related to existing superintendent contract okay so do we have a motion to go into closed executive session I'll make a motion okay we have a motion do we have a second second and if Lisa would any further discussion no further discussion if Lisa would conduct a roll call vote to close the open session and convene and closed executive session okay at this time I will conduct a roll call vote to close the open session and convene and closed executive session at 6:40 1 p.m. president cadwal how do you vote I vice president Murphy how do you vote I secretary danus how do you
083vote I member Wright how do you vote I and member McMurray how do you vote I thank you let the record reflect the board has voted I okay e e e I want to use the cowbell next time though instead okay I would like to call for a motion to reconvene an open session so move do we have a second second okay uh Lisa if you would conduct a roll call vote to reconvene an open session okay this time I will conduct a roll call vote to reconvene an open session at 9:23 p.m. president Cadwallader how do you vote I vice president Murphy how do you vote I secretary danakas how do you vote I member Wright how do you vote I and member McMurray how do you vote I thank you let the record
084reflect the board has voted I okay no action was taken by the board during the executive session matters discussed were limited to D1 items a through c as published on the agenda and next we have other item of business which is an action item for the board to take if any related to existing superintendent contractual obligation and I would like to call call for a motion to move to direct that the superintendent receive her full travel allowance under her existing contract so moved okay we have a motion do we have a second second second any discussion all those in favor say I I I I all those opposed okay hearing no opposition motion passes and I would like to call for a motion to adjourn so moved do I have a second second now you
085two go two motions two seconds all those in favor say I I opposed hearing no opposition we are adjourned thank you very much e