001good evening and Welcome to our Pittsburgh Central School District Board of Education meeting at this point um the meeting is now called to order at this point would you please join us to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance flag of the United States of America stands Nation indivisible lice thank you may I have a motion to approve the agenda will be from Emily the second from Sarah okay all in favor none opposed that motion carries thank you next we'll have a public hearing for real property tax law 668 yes thank you very much um this is a uh it's necessary to have from a procedural standpoint a public hearing for any comments on um real property tax law 466 d a it replaces 466 DK which was previously adopted by the Board of Education um
002I think in summary um from what we've looked at from an analysis standpoint uh I think originally the law was passed uh for First Responders this property tax exemption the Board of Education was fully briefed on it uh in terms of uh the tax impact and and the shift per se I think what's happened is there's been a refinement through legislation in terms of the criteria the number of years who's eligible what happens in terms of uh surviving um um spouse situation um and so then the thought was uh to update that we have a whole year to do this but I thought since we have it we get out ahead of it especially uh you know with a taxable status date again it's it's a whole year but I I thought it would be
003best to just U provide an update there was some discussion as to whether or not we really needed a public hearing the law says public hearing a is different than k um but essentially uh there wasn't really anything um significantly new other than like I said a refinement of uh you know some of the criteria um we've had this in place now for two years I don't see any uh new or signif ific shifts um and what I do see is just a refinement as I said in in the process and procedure um with that I'll pause for any questions are there questions okay hearing none thank you Mike we appreciate next we'll have our principal's report Miss Sarah Jacob from Barker Middle School good evening everyone evening um I just want to start by
004thanking the board of education for your wonderful visit yes or last uh Thursday morning it was great to be able to connect with everyone and also be able to walk around the building with you um and share you know more of the exciting things that we have coming up at Bark Road so I just want to say thank you for that um so looking at at this school year the 24 25 school year um these have been really our areas of focus at Barker Road um we um have some of some of what I will go over is kind of year two of things that we're working on and some things are kind of new this year um starting with our uh right off of the um Leadership Retreat from this summer with the board
005of AD and our district leadership and pdta Leadership um and the work we were doing around culture and Dan Coyle's book um we started off with a summer I in August um so this was our instructional leadership team um in addition to that we also had our team leaders attend and we really spent a whole day focusing on what this means for Barker Road um so we really you know we we recognize that we had a we have a very strong culture of Barker Road but really looking at how do we make those connections deeper and more purposeful um so what we looked at starting in that summer was um we had a lot of discussion around that safety vulnerability pieces but we also looked at our shared purpose so we went back to our
006mission and vision which I think had not been in front of people in some time so coming back to that looking at those things and then really focusing on the work ahead um it was really focused on deepening those connections not only with staff staff to staff but and student to student but also student to staff so we really looked at um this school year how can we um focus on things continue the things that we were already doing like starting off the school year with our large sixth grade class being able to go to Camp Arrowhead and focus on team building um not only with their peers but also with their sixth grade teachers as kind of an entry into Barker Road um but also looking at the things that other opportunities that we
007could um expand on um especially when we looked at the staff piece um if you walk through the halls of Barker Road this week we're doing an underground staff spirit week so for instance this week every uh staff me or today I'm sorry every staff member was in tiedye um the kids have no clue what we're doing um and it's kind of been a trend in the area and and even Nationwide but it was kind of fun because in true Middle School form uh one of uh our Middle School our eighth graders came up to a teacher and said why are you all in tiedye today ew and we were kind of like well so she didn't appreciate the tie-dye but she noticed right so it was just that one little moment that one little
008connection so we're just trying to do fun things like that throughout the year um a lot more um staff activities that bring us together as well things like grazing days and things like that um to just really strengthen um um that um staff piece we're all kind of siloed and it's hard to get out with the busy days but we're trying to be very purposeful about that um so it was really like I said about creating connections um not only among staff and students but everyone as a learning community um year two of our strategic initiative so we have um jumped into this work um and actually are in the midst with our fall work and leading into we're we're going to spend a lot of time actually at our January faculty meeting around our
009social emotional benchmarks um that piece we we looked last year at our nextg skills we looked at our C crsc framework um and we're still coming back to all of that but this um fall we really focused on some of those seal Benchmark components to um this conversation and our strategic initiative again strengthening that rigor and authenticity um while creating a welcoming and affirming environment um and always circling back to the Hub in a lot of those conversations as well so the acal component has really been a focus um and we're also leaning on some of our district supports too um and uh creating for instance in our um faculty meeting creating just an seal corner for just be best practices a place that's kind of a standing agenda item to be able to share
010um not only um share from myself or from Richard as our assistant principal but also really bringing in other voices from different departments and different teacher leadership within the building our Capital project so we are um the excitement just continues to build it seems like forever ago that we um that the community passed um the capital project um but it's getting it's getting closer and it's getting more real for everyone which is really exciting as Mike's nodding in his head um so we um know that this spring we'll actually you know see the the work start to um occur and as such we've really focused on trying to make sure that we're creating a lot of um space for discussion for feedback for questions you know it's a it's a a big project and pretty
011much every part of our building is going to be touched and that has staff you know on a little bit of pins and needles about what that really means for them over a two and a half year span um so we've already held one session with staff where we've been able to kind of give a kind of you know big overview um and then we actually had our second opportunity today where we did more of a Q&A session with staff which was really great um and I think that again it's it's about you know how is this going to affect my classroom how I'm interacting with kids how I'm teaching and so forth so that's been really fun but but um it's finally getting to the point where we're really seeing some of that work
012is is getting closer and closer um and we got a little taste of that obviously with the the vestibule and uh that phase one part that all the buildings experienced so um I think the biggest key Point here is we're going to just continue to keep that feed feedback loop open um and working in strong collaboration with pdta on this to make sure that people are feeling comfortable people have questions they know that they have a space to be able to ask them um and that we can also in turn get those answers back to folks as soon as we can um so that's been great and we had a really like I said successful afternoon after school today with um any and all staff that wanted to come and hear more about the project
013and like I said um be able to ask questions we actually asked staff to um submit questions ahead of time so we had kind of an idea of where the conversation was going but then also just opened it up at the very end for for just a open Q&A session so lots of good stuff there and um lots of excitement I will say as well um just around the the plans for Barker Road and then just lastly um you know this is a continual theme and something very near and dear to my heart is just what it means to be Barker to the core um about three years ago we did a reboot of our seven corpor principles um and we coined the term being Barker to the core it's taken on a life of
014its own I think probably all of our families have heard that term before um and we really try to infuse it into everything we do um so not only do students hear about our seven core principles and what it means to be Barker of the core in the classroom but really it's woven into every conversation that kids are exposed to from you know reminders in the cafeteria about safe and what it means to um be respectful of others or if we're talking about um being inclusive and with our after school opportunities and things like that and making sure that our our clubs that our students that are participating in clubs are carrying themselves you know with those seven core principles in mind um we're using it for a lot of our conversation with our um
015within our um Student Center and our counselors um we're doing a lot of the Fall was um again going back to that Community Building piece and we had a lot of community circles in classrooms and things like that and a lot of the topic um revolved around our core principles and not only how they are um how we see them here at school but beyond the you know classroom walls and things like that and and the the the school walls um so really honing in on what it means to be kind and empathetic and be able to connect with others in um that standup way that is um very important to us um you know and I think that um with this I think that it's a it's a really proactive piece as well and
016um like I said it kind of traverses all areas in the building um and hopefully beyond the the school walls too um so being Barker of the core is still live and well if anybody needs a t-shirt just let me know and um the kids are um they're doing a great job at this we highlight students every week with great kids of the week on the morning bark which I know you've all seen and we're so fortunate to have that daily um uh Morning Show but every Friday part of what we do is um highlighting uh three different students one from each grade level and it all ties back to our core principal so they get that postcard that a staff member is nominated ated them and they've either nominated them for one of the
017core principles a couple of them or all of them um and that goes home and those students obviously are recognized um on the morning bark and with their uh Pontillo's Pizza slice as well which is always exciting um so live and well Barker to the core um with that that's kind of our an update of Barker Road I didn't know if anybody had questions of course yeah yep yeah lots of work to be done there yeah you're welcome thank you all thank so next we we would um like to entertain a motion for the approval of the November 12th 2024 minutes that would be from Dave and Emily so all in favor none opposed thank you we also need a motion to approve the December 3rd 2024 special meeting and that will be from Kim
018and Renee all in favor none opposed thank you so for our Board of Education reports from mro County School boards associate Association we will first hear from Kim from the information exchange committee thanks um so the November information exchange committee meeting uh talked about two current SED initiatives the Blue Ribbon commission and regionalization so for Blue Ribbon Commission on graduate me graduation measures uh the work began in 2019 and now they finally have a comprehensive road map so that's starting to get rolled out um under this initiative New York State schools uh will transition to one diploma so right now we there are three different diplomas there will be one diploma with options um to include Advanced designations as an endorsement or a seal that you add locally on the diploma and basically a big
019change is that instead of just class cred and assessment requirements there will be multiple ways for students to um demonstrate their proficiency and reach graduation so assessments will still be offered but not required for graduation for all students so the next school year 2526 they're going to release new credit requirement details um but the first freshman class that will be um starting on this new track won't be until 2027 so still a few years but we'll get some new learning standards uh rubrics guidance so there'll be a lot more coming in the next couple of years about this the second one was regionalization um so regionalization is a collaborative model where districts can partner to address student needs and operational efficiencies so this is something that um New York State education department is uh pushing
020through or encouraging through our Bose uh district superintendent so they would look at um basically is is opens up a pathway for districts to partner together uh to offer Advanced coursework to offer a range of subject areas maybe share staff or share student Support Services extracurricular activities um partner together with uh Regional indust um industrial uh organizations basically it just allows meeting challenges in a new way uh so a lot of districts are coming up against Financial and um other challenges so this would just allow different districts to work together so what's going to happen next is there will be a needs assessment that superintendant can um can work with the district and uh district superintendent um to get to find out what opportunities might be available um and I know the Board of Regents
021had a meeting this week where they were looking at some amendments so there might even be a little bit more to come on this but it was was a lot of information at the info exchange so it was a really good meeting thank you Kim can I ask a question so that's Notting two districts together truly to be on the surface of yeah okay so more like a shared services model rather than in corporation yeah yeah we're not combining districts yeah good question thank you next we will hear from Emily Kay from The District Operations committee um okay so in November District Operations brought in representatives from rg& and then had a zoom with a representative from Nera to present on the programs and resources they offer to support schools transitions to electric buses um
022for me the big takeway was that there certainly is money out there from both RG and Nera to help with this transition but it was really hard to tell how much we would actually qualify for um one thing that rg& did strongly suggest was um including them from the very beginning of the process towards the transition both because of the longtime Horizon but also because um of potential impacts on the electrical grid as more districts are going so they want to know if they're going to be hit with a ton of districts moving at the same time and then prepare for that early um they the rg& also went through their current rebate and incentive programs um but a lot of these required your District to either be part of a dis advantaged Community or
023to make your charging Depot available to the public in order to qualify it sounds like these incentive programs might be changing as they get further into the Mandate they were pretty clear that they were listening to feedback and trying to modify but that's sort of where it sits right now um the nerta zoom um they just went through their bus and charger voucher incentives as well um and ways that they felt they could help with a fleet electrification plan um like rg& though it showed that they have the money available for the grants but it was really hard to tell how much we would be able to qualify for so thank you very much Emily any any questions n next one we'll hear from Sarah paloo legislative committee chair just want to say real quick
024that yesterday we had our Zoom advocacy sessions at 9:00 am and 3 pm we had uh we have 10 of our representatives there we actually this year invited a representative from their office to attend as more of a listening session to just um Talk talk about the work that we've been doing so far this year and um that will then carry into our legislative breakfast on February 1st so it was a very well attended meeting both sessions and um more to come on that thank you thank you Sarah so upcoming dates to remember from December 23rd to January 3rd our schools are closed for a winter recess um January 9 there will be a board visit tour at Jefferson Road Elementary I meet by show of hands may I see who can attend thank you
025so much we appreciate that and um on January 14 is our next regularly scheduled meeting next we will hear from Mr vesb with financial report thank you so much uh first for your consideration is the acceptance of the October Treasures report um you know October's um always the the culminating event in terms of um the tax collection process so it results in our Maximum cash flow so you'll notice a number of um Investments and diversification uh since we've been using 3+ one uh you can see on the interest and earnings report even with um interest rates trending lower uh than previously uh we're greatly exceeding the year-to DAT expectations uh in terms of Interest earnings and and um I really look at that as continued strength because we've secured multi-month uh locked in rates uh
026as we've done that cash flow analysis so that's really good news on the revenue side and obviously the substantial Revenue has been through um tax collection um some minor updates um we did receive a First Foundation Aid payment of 1.8 million and um we're do we continue to do well as we Surplus equipment uh through auctions so those are some highlights on the revenue side side um on the school lunch program couldn't be happier with our progress uh year-to date uh just a loss of $1,000 compared to the previous year a loss of 73,000 so things are stabilizing um participation is up I think interest is up uh and I continue to see an investment in food um you know so it's not just about the profit but it's about um increasing the quality of
027what we do on the Food Service side of the operation uh nothing significant for report on the expenditure side um that concludes my report thank you Mr besie and may we have a motion to accept the treasurer report from October 31 2024 that would be Sarah Dave are there questions hearing none all in favor none oppos thank you you guys have thank you next for your consideration is the approval of real property tax law a um which we previously discussed uh during the public hearing thank you may have a motion for approval of the resolution for real property tax law that would be from Emily and Dave sorry and okay so are there questions hearing none all in favor none opposed that eyes have it thank you and then finally for your consideration is the
028uh Cooperative bidding that we do uh with uh part of the electric bid and again uh we see rat stabilization because we buy in bulk so where you see significant increases maybe on um the consumer side we're not experiencing that uh on this side because of our buying power thank you thank you next we will hear from Mr clar Human Resources report thank you and good consider we have the professional staff report we have one change in status from probationary to tenure one supervisory and Technical appointment one administrator resignation for retirement with 26 years of service to the district one supervisory and Technical resignation with with 23 years of service to the district we have one administrator resignation one school nurse resignation one building substitute resignation we have spring coaching salaries and we have per
029DM substit appointments and I do apologize we have two names that appeared twice it's just a clerical error thank you Mr Clark may I have a motion to approve the professional staff report yes that will be from Emily and Kim any questions hearing none all in favor eyes have't thank you thank you next for your consideration is the support staff report we have one clerical appointment we have one clerical resignation one custodial appointment two custodial resignations one food service appointment and one food service termination thank you may I have a motion to approve the support staff report will be from Renee and Sarah thank you any questions hearing none all in favor none oppos thank you thank you next we have three positions that we'll be recommending to the board for consideration uh the job
030descriptions and justifications are included in the board packets um the overall common theme really centers around the removing of the single point of failure that we have with some of these um positions uh improving operational efficiency um no budget impact as we're resif and and looking at Staffing um not adding full-time uh employees but looking at restructuring and shifting so first is uh for your consideration is the transportation assistant may I have a motion to accept the transportation assistant B Dave Sarah are there questions yes so just want to understand um Sean more about the budget neutrality of the positions um just thinking about the bigger con context like we are we just asked our community to help with advocacy work and looking at that 1.5 million gap in our budget so do do we
031is this just are we looking at just renaming a position like replacing a position or is this in addition um I'm just looking for the to kind of understand the bigger picture it's a great question it's not additional positions it's looking at restructuring and and really taking a a clear look at what positions we have what's actually needed and required and as I we do have and it came out in an audit as well we have positions like you think about director of Transportation you think about director of Food Services where we have no backup if that person is out there's nobody who can really take on the tasks and run the day to-day operations and then it causes a lot of chaos um it impacts students it impacts parents and families so part of
032it is making sure that we have some sort of uh uh redundancy in place not exactly we think about it in terms of this too so I think about human resources and I have um Orlando opens on as our director we don't do exactly the same thing but we have some similarities in our roles if he's ever out for a lengthy period of time it's very easy for me to pick things up because I do some similar things and vice versa so having that where we don't have a single point of failure the person's gone so now the job responsibility is really fall flat we we really needed to Shore that up and that was something that we've been building over time but it's important to to look at from a budgetary standpoint how do
033we do that with with no budget impact when we think about transportation we are we're very short in terms of what we've budgeted for for drivers in in many areas of transportation and what we currently expend and I know Mike can expand a little more on that um I would say it's similar in terms of the Food Services we have we have allocations but we we don't have current Staffing um what I can say about Food Services is currently the director spends I'd say about four out of the five days actually in building supporting where staff absences are and Shoring up their Staffing to make sure that the lines still run that the kids are still getting their food um that things are getting ordered uh things like that so I don't know if you
034wanted to expand at all mik just a little bit on the financial piece the um well first of all the proposal for food service is separate right so that that budget is outside of general fund uh the transportation um to just you know zero in a little bit in the past we've had um four dispatcher positions we've Consolidated three um an assistant director position gives us more flexibility in terms of safety backup for safety backup for director backup for driving backup for dispatch so there's just more fle flexibility in the position so the idea is to convert an existing position and um and not fill another position so that we have a more flexible option in terms of backup and you know we're looking at the same model in Food Service uh and the same
035model in terms of of U benefit coordination as well um you know it's one of the it was one of the surprising things to me that there wasn't a designated uh position that is that oversees that so it's a it's a consolidation the existing position um as opposed to adding a new FTE which is typically what you do when you create these we didn't take that model uh at all it's a reallocation of resources for more flexibility I think the primary uh area where're where we're vulnerable not so much in custodial maintenance because um you know we we have that situation now but in some of these other positions we just didn't have the backup and I think as Sean alluded to there was an audit finding and we have had some challenges with backup
036and payroll which we now have taken corrective measures to fix that we now have a payroll supervisor and an assistant so some of these critical support staff operations positions really need to be firmed up um first and these wouldn't be positions that even with a significant deficit that we necessarily would look away from because these are flexible positions that are actual in the field working positions as opposed to you know adding you know I know the position titles seem more administrative but they're not um they're actually in the field working position so I think it's a better utilization of resources especially in in tough times and if we did have to make Cuts we'd have to make some sacrifices in other areas to offset that expense so I think that coupled with uh you know
037with the rationale that that Sean's provided I think really gives an overview of of the situation if I could just add to simplify an answer as I've met with every um budget coordinator across the district uh no one is um able right now to increase their budget so as we look at these positions it's budget neutral or um or or a budget reduction given what we're looking at with our advocacy work to give a really crude example of of what both Sean and Mike are saying I met with with Mike last week because it looked like we were going to have possibly a really snowy icy day one one day and I said let's just revisit our protocol for calling a snow day and our director of Transportation was out and our director of um
038operations was out and there was no number two to to to take the the helm for either one of those and so we do need a sense of redundancy when people are out but also trying to figure out um the best way to look at our budget crisis if you will as a mechanism to make us more efficient and utilize our Personnel in a way that um is going to benefit us uh in um a way that we um haven't had in in the past so that redundancy is huge and being um uh Nimble and responsive is going to be huge for us moving forward than thank you Mike so with that um are there any additional questions hearing none all in favor none opposed motion carries the next position to be considered oh I'm
039sorry opposed okay sorry oh oh you're not okay one one not okay one not in favor I'm so sorry I missed that okay thank you so I'm I'm just picture about we like there are other I feel like a position that doesn't interact directly with kids at this point I am really hesitant to add um when I know that we are not replacing C we asked for early retirements we're looking to not replace certain positions um I just feel like there needs to be you know everyone's being asked to do more with less we have teachers using their own money to buy you know supplies for classrooms and things like that so just fiscal responsibility I just feel like less of our fewer of our our kids are using buses right now because we've asked
040parents to fill out surveys and ask them to opt out of busing um we have we're enforcing the distance minimum so that fewer families are eligible to utilize the buses we have the app so that communication can go directly through the app to parents so it just I'm just I'm just struggling with this position I'm sorry no no apologies is necessary so just to be clear we could not do anything and if we did nothing the situation would be worse so if we just kept status quo and didn't bring anything to the board the budget would stay neutral and everything would be um not as well equipped to hand emergencies next year if we did this we're better equipped to handle emergencies and we're still budget neutral so I just want to make that clear
041that we're not increasing the budget in any way shape or form what we're trying to do is to be sensitive to emergencies and um to be responsive without increasing the budget so what this is doing is taking our current staff in either reducing or r titling so that people can have the responsibilities to um be a backup for uh a person when they're out and um so I just want to make that clear that when we ask for approval or not we're doing that with in the in the name of budget efficiency and and and safety for um for our system so maybe that wasn't clear maybe we need to bring this back up um uh but uh this is not a budget decision it's it's a budget neutral decision it's a restructuring that's going
042to help our uh students staff and families thank you so that motion carries and the next position to be considered is for assistant director of school Food Services he have a motion to entertain that position would be Dave and Sarah are there questions hearing none all in favor thank you so that motion carries thank you the next the the final position to be considered this evening is benefit specialist and U may I have a motion to accept that position that would be Kim and Emily okay any questions hearing none all in favor okay that motion carries thank you so much thank you next we will hear from Miss Woods special education report good evening the committee on special education and preschool special education recommendations are on the consent agenda thank you Miss woods and from
043there we will have our superintendent's report Mr pero thank you there is not a need for an executive session this evening um I will share that I really appreciate uh Kim's comments and and questioning and I think everything that we do should be questioned and and be under scrutiny uh to a large extent when it deals with uh budgetary mans as we are uh looking at a $1.5 million deficit that we have to close um that was an example of how to restructure without um adding costs to the to the budget but there are going to be requests to add things to the budget and we're saying no um so I appreciate the the questioning there we're we're not adding areas uh within our budget this area uh this year um we are looking at
044ways to be more efficient um so we have uh started with a a $1.5 million budget deficit that's after adding a significant amount of Reserve funds that we um uh in addition to what we normally add so we are um um we have been successful in um looking at attrition uh and trying to keep budget reductions away from students away from job loss uh so through attrition alone uh we're looking at reducing that from 1.5 now to about $700,000 uh we have about $800,000 in savings uh from those that are retiring from uh hiring uh new staff and we have a lot of other things that we're working on as far as efficiencies to to bring that back down to zero uh which will help us in the future years so we are um also
045working hard and I need to thank our advocacy team uh for all of their work relative to um communication to staff families Community um newsletters emails hard copy uh letters being mailed Home Videos Etc sharing that we deserve more than we're getting pittsbur rarely uh will ever um try to uh advocate for things if if if we don't feel that it's it's welld deserved so it's been a long time since we've truly advocated for something and I think the last time was for full day kindergarten and that was because we weren't getting funding period um for something we um are guaranteed to get and we just weren't getting it so we advocated for that with Foundation Aid uh we just have not been getting it uh period we're we're not getting it um close to
046um our Nextdoor neighbors uh we are overlooked we're in a in a category that we need to um get out of uh as far as uh a an old um wealth index formula uh if we were to calculate since 2012 what we've been promised and underpaid it's about $100 million and we do we're we're underpaid $100 million well at the same time there's districts that have been overpaid and we don't want to make this and us against them concept but um we have been underpaid $100 million when other districts have been overpaid and that's just a that's just a fact when I when I think about what our community has endured uh the last two years with inflation rates being between 8 and 10% and the cost of everything um going up and what we
047received reive per student last year was I I don't want to say laughable because that might be disrespectful but um I think that the amount of money that we received was disrespectful to be quite honest we received approximately uh $1.75 um per student increase last year so we had an an increase of $10,000 per Stu or $10,000 for our district for foundation Aid uh while we watch um others proportionately get a lot more uh we receive approximately 34% less than our our neighbors and um and I and I feel like we produce a high quality the highest of quality of education for our students and and we're vastly overlooked by the state as it relates to Aid so I'm asking everyone to contact our legislators uh our local legislators um especially uh Senator bro um
048and assembly woman uh Jen Lunsford uh to Champion this with us uh we are doing um our own work with um responses to uh calls from Albany and meetings um with the education budget chairs on both the Senate and the assembly level uh but what we really need our eyes on this because if there's eyes if if if people really just looked at what we've been receiving um they would hopefully understand the problem everyone has a tax cap to contend with uh we we have a tax cap to contend with and everyone has their Foundation Aid to contend with I would share that our tax cap uh the last SE uh several years has averaged out to be about one under 2% uh and at the same time our foundation Aid uh has been um
049significantly lower than our than our counterparts so I'm asking for our communities to just join us in a campaign uh to check our website under advocacy uh to look out for more information from our newsletters uh and emails and work with us uh to help um Advocate with our legislators so that we get our Our Fair funding in the event that we do not receive uh a significant increase in Foundation Aid uh we do have a plan B and a plan C uh which are uh significant reductions to um program and personnel which we're hoping we're not um going to have to get to so um I'm asking everyone to to please write to our legislators ask them to Champion uh public education in Pittsford uh and work with us to resolve a problem that
050um I feel that is compelling enough where uh our legis legislator should want to help us and with that I would wish everyone a happy holiday um and uh just share a bit of positive news that I've I've talked about before our students are doing amazing I I feel our students are back uh to where we were preco uh you walk down all of our nine buildings uh students are doing uh amazing um work both academically and uh relative to their behavior we had a a substitute we've had several substitute administrators in our district the last couple weeks and they've um obviously been retired for a little bit and have worked in other districts and uh The Constant Comment I receive is that uh they've never seen um students so um well behaved and well-mannered
051and well adjusted um compared to where they they they they were working in Pittsburgh so uh love to hear that love to see it I want to thank our staff for doing an amazing job thank you to our community for hanging in there and um wishing everyone a a happy holiday thank you thank you Mr pero next we will um entertain a motion for the consent agenda from Renee and Kim thank you all in favor none opposed that motion carries so next is there any old business yes name I don't know if this really falls under old or new business but I just kind of want to swing back to Kim's um question and I just want to thank the both of you um Mike and Sean for explaining that in Greater detail because even
052when I read through that that was one of my concerns was what is this going to look like um and Mike thank you for your report because you get into even more detail about you know we do have plans a b and c I think this is stressful for all of us who are making these bigger decisions we definitely want to make sure that we're all doing the right things for our kids um but it really reading that report um led me to have a few questions as well so I just wanted to say thank you for asking the questions and for the three of you giving us such a detailed uh description and answer as to what we can look forward to so thank you thank you so is there any new business okay
053hearing none we have a public comment this evening and um I'd like to ask Timothy via to please come forward thank you hi there everybody uh last name is actually pronounced VI I don't know why my parents did did that to me I'm sorry um so I have three kids at Park Road and I did recently receive that letter that you were all talking about the advocacy letter um which highlights important funding challenges um and I do believe that the increased funding is necessary I also believe it's vitally important to examine our District's current funding priorities the district chose to rely on bosies for some legally mandated Services those positions compensate significantly less than compal positions with other employers and those Services experienced extended interruptions substitute coverage was not provided these decisions were clearly financially
054motivated and they create a clear record of impact on our most vulnerable students so one of the district's core values is a supportive environment for all for some students that supportive environment requires specific Services mandated by law which may cost more and require you to make necessary but potentially unpopular budgeting decisions resource allocation choices have long-term implications Beyond immediate budgets and political expediency districts that show a documented pattern of prioritizing cost savings over legal obligations eventually face extensive attorney fees and costly external review processes that redirect the limited resources away from the students I am actually meeting with Gen lford I will be advocating for increased funding uh but this advoc advocacy comes with an expect ation that it aligns with clear priorities you got to meet the legal obligations make student centered Staffing decisions
055that prioritize protecting the most vulnerable students first and maintain transparent communication so the path forward requires balancing fiscal responsibility with educational equity and legal compliance and if you wish I I do welcome any direct dialogue with any of you at some point Mr V if I would love it right now okay uh so the first thing I would share is a huge thank you again this is your second time here in public comment and what I really appreciate more than anything else is you coming here directly and speaking with the Board of Education and US versus going to to um other sources right so that shows me that you genuinely have a concern about this um when you came last time I'm hoping you feel that I was genuine in my response with regards to
056uh getting support for PT the area that I would disagree with you on respectfully uh is that this has been a fiscal decision for us that that's that's 100% it's actually the opposite of that the reason that we've worked through bosis for PT and OT is because of the consistency that we've had in the past relative to um having people come in and service our kids having gone through what we've gone through um this past year like everyone is with Staffing staffing issues um we are um uh revisiting uh what we are doing relative to Bose's role in our school districts as it pertains to PT and OT and so in in other in other areas so we have purchased back all of speech language for example so our all of our speech teachers are
057pretty much I think Elizabeth right are all Pittsburgh are are now in District uh our OT and PT are the are very challenging um positions um our goal is and I agree with you this is not an area where where um if we're going to save a several thousand by going with with with uh bosis versus hiring oursel that's not that's not in our discussion our discussion um has been how do we provide consistent support for our kids you don't see those things and I don't expect you to see them because they're happening in my office and they're happening with all the the the people around the board right now um so our goal is um at minimum to increment um over the next couple years um a a um a hiring of our own
058PT for example and to the point where we've already started working with with our um different bargaining units around where would they fall and where would their pay scale be and and and in the complexity with all of that so those conversations are happening right now um and and our goal is the same as yours the the only misnomer I do want you to to do what you want with it is to understand that we've never um put a a a cost on PT um we've instead looked at where can we get consistent support in PT so thank you I don't know if you have any questions any anything else you want to ask I okay since you're inviting the dialogue um so why was there not already like a robust system in place for
059backup Services through private contractors in the event that bosis was unable to provide yeah good question so we've what we have found um is everything that before there's been um so for example when we talked about redundancy in in um in what we were hoping for um there was always redundancy in either subs or contracts outside contracts that bosis can help us with because bosis has access to contracts that we don't have um so we've never had an issue with it before what's happening now is that physical therapists occupational therapists have so many other areas that they can go to and get paid a lot more money um and right that's that's the issue right right that that's one of the issues and and unless your focus is on on students in schools right so
060we've never run into the problem before until um I would say this past year uh and and but that's but that's not it's not limited to PT and OT it's limited to all of our services so when we have a bus driver if if we were to contract with a student first and someone would say why don't you hire a bus driver well we can't we can't find one so we um we haven't felt this with PT and OT as we have this year um but we're finding that um we're having this problem in almost every area uh where if someone is out how do we replace we know it's our responsibility to do it which is why we are pursuing trying to to to bring back our own which would be aligned to your
061public comment but not aligned to your notion that we're we're we're not doing this because we want to save money it's not that I think you're trying I think you're trying to be responsible with taxpayer money um and of course you know Bose has a state aid ratio you know so all of that factors into it but when you look at the postings on indeed and you know BOS is advertising a position 45,000 to 75,000 and the ufr is starting at 75,000 to like 125,000 if I was graduating as a PT I know what job I would apply for you know and and so it's it's going to be difficult as you mentioned the inflation has increased the cost of everything people are seeking higher wages right at the same time you were trying to
062suppress how much the district is paying because you're accessing less funds from the state um and and so you're going to have to make decisions and so my point is that they have to be aligned first of all to what's legal and obligatory and what will support the most vulnerable students agree agree I would love to keep would love to keep going but I agree I do not disagree with anything you just shared okay yeah thank you thank you thank you Mr VI and now we will have a motion for adjournment that would be from Sarah and Renee all in favor none opposed that motion carries thank you happy holidays everyone