CorpusRecord 232564

Board of Education Meeting – December 9 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WPCSD Videos
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Westchester County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,756 words · about 71 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] today is Monday December 9th 2024 this is our regular Board of Education meeting for believe it or not it's December please stand and join us in the pledge the mission of the White Plains Public Schools is to educate and inspire all students while nurturing their dreams so they learn continually think critically pursue their aspirations and contribute to a diverse and dynamic world next Dr Ricker good evening if I could ask you to join us in a moment of Silent reflection in the memory of Patricia Riley high school Spanish teacher from 19 I'm sorry October 1966 until she retired in February of 1985 and Lauren Ashley McCormack former student graduate White Plains High School class of 2010 thank you thank you and next we'll have our superintendent report Dr R you want do announcements announ

002first just announcement sorry okay um next we'll move into announcements um from board members I think um uh Jessica you and I uh we were able to attend the csca holiday celebration on on Saturday um great turnout um and we had a great time uh lastly uh we were also together at the friends of White Plains event and as I always say no one has better friends than my Plains they support our programs and um it's just really fun to go and support the event knowing that it supports our students anything else uh yes so I also went to this is during this past month I went to the college Signing Day where three White Plains High School students were signed for um playing Z1 Sports at three different colleges which is really cool um

003Gavin towns in at Wagner College for baseball Lily dadis at niaga University for D1 tennis and Ava gaglani I think um for the US University of Florida south Florida for D1 softball so that was really exciting to be able to attend um and I also went to the Ridgeway Turkey Trot which was a big event at Ridgeway it's I think it's their biggest fundraiser of the year and it was a lot of fun it was a beautiful day and it was full School participation it's a PTA event and the teachers did a a really fun race wearing those Inflatables and nobody fell down so that was pretty good and Mr suji won the the race um there were medals and snacks and Bubbles and a DJ and lots of fun so um and I think

004the school raised up to $50,000 with that one event so congratulations to them um and I also went to the unveiling of the we go swing at Delino Park which is a swing that anyone of any ability can ride on it's the apparently the first one of its kind in Westchester so that was really cool to be able to attend as well and and um I think that was it okay any other announcements I'll make some announcements um I just came from Highlands before I was here they were doing an internet uh safety awareness um sponsored by PTA Council and uh what what I heard at least for the beginning was was quite powerful um I went to the uh fall play at the high school uh they did Romeo and Juliet um so that

005was very enjoyable um I also attended the friends of uh the White Plain schools uh pre- Thanksgiving um reunion they had a lot of alumni there and Friends of White Plains uh great great turnout um Rosemarie mentioned it's December already I went to the White Plains middle school um 8th grade Winter concert and finally got in the mood for uh for December and the holidays um so that was very enjoyable uh Keenan Bean has been doing a series of webinars um on school law um they are our Council and we really appreciate that they do this um so they had done one on a updates um evaluations of classroom teachers and building principles and they have another one coming up uh pretty soon um there was a regional program um it was the lower Hudson

006County of school superintendence the um Duchess County of SCH school boards associations the Rockland County School boards Association Westchester puam school boards Association they had a regional program uh with a presentation by Michael Rebel um from the center for educational equity and he talked really clearly about Foundation Aid Kane was also there as well as Dr R Dr Via ta and and I um so that was a really um informative event uh Westchester putam School Board Association um had a community conversation sharing about social media and Dr RI and I were both there on on the zoom session they also did an advoc advocacy meeting they're finalizing their uh legislative um advocacy positions and uh finally the New York State School boards Association um did a webinar on the 2025 legislative and state budget um

007and it's sort of a preview and uh they they did send an email with a reporting if anyone missed it was really well done I think we did Hall of Fame too right oh yeah we all yeah a number of us yeah so I'll just quickly add on this Saturday December 14th is the holiday craft fair here at the high school I think they they're saying they're going to have about 90 different vendors it's from 10: a.m. to 4 pm and that's always a good time with food and a lot of the great last minute fps to BU for loved ones and spirit Weare and lots of spirit yes yes are we good okay okay so now we will go to our superintendent support thank you madam president it's uh it's my great pleasure to

008introduce our exico student Board of Education members for their monthly update good evening everyone it is a pleasure to share with you today the wonderful initiatives and activities taking place across four of our schools this December as we reflect on the past month we see an inspiring commitment to fostering a sense of community kindness and collaboration that is truly remarkable each school has embraced these values in their own unique ways and yet there is a undeniable or there are undeniable similarities in how these schools are working together to create environments that nurture not only academic growth but also emotional and social well-being across Church Street School Mas Ridgeway and Post Road we see a Common Thread each school is prioritizing inclusivity empathy and Community engagement from promoting acts of kindness to educating students on environmental

009responsibility these schools have fostered an environment where students feel supported and empowered whether it's through schoolwide events Partnerships with local organizations or special Focus themes like empathy kindness and inclusion every effort demonstrates a shared dedication to to building strong stronger connections within School communities and Beyond at Church Street School the focus on empathy this month is reflected in both their curriculum and extracurricular activities for example Church re School kicked off the month with the wi future recycle program through classroom presentations students learned about the importance of recycling composting and reducing their environmental footprint this initiative not only helps students understand the ecolog pschological impact of their actions but also Fosters a sense of responsibility for their community and Planet the we future recycle program provides an excellent opportunity to build environmental Consciousness in students and

010church treat school is clearly committed to sustainability this month Church Tre school has also been embracing empathy as their trade of the month and the schoolwide activities tie beautifully into this their book of the month is a hat for Mrs Goldman a story that teaches is about kindness and understanding Church re school will have a schoolwide read aloud of this book during cozy day encouraging all students to reflect on empathy and warmth in addition students will have the opportunity to add pom poms to a large winter hat whenever they show acts of kindness this visual representation of Goodwill will not only serve as a reminder of how small acts of kindness can collectively have a huge impact but also bring the whole school together in a meaningful way furthermore Church re school has organized a

011glove and hat collection to support local families in need reinforcing their commitment to community service and care it's wonderful to see how church Tre School continues to engage students in giving back and creating a culture of empathy looking ahead Church Tre school is excited for some wonderful events in the coming weeks they are eagerly anticipating the winter spirit week and Winter concert both of which will allow students to express their school spirit and creativity a Additionally the school is thrilled to welcome the students from White Plains High School's education Pathways program further strengthening the bond between the high school and the elementary school while giving students a unique opportunity to connect with future Educators over at Mas November was equally busy and it was an equally busy and impactful month the theme of being an

012ally not a bystander per permeated many of the school's activities with students engaging conversations around inclusion acceptance and tolerance through classroom circles and discussions Mas has done a fantastic job of addressing these important social issues and helping students understand their role in creating an inclusive environment this focus on empathy and community building is also evident in the school's strong Partnerships with families Mas hosted a series of workshops designed to support students and families covering topics like Title One reading math and enl services these workshops are instrumental in ensuring that all students have access to resources they need to succeed M's environmental efforts have also been impressive in partnership with txte Mas launched a plastic bag Drive the goal is to collect 1,000 lbs of plastic which they will be recycled into benches for the playground

013so far the school has collected 227 lbs and it's inspiring to see students rallying around this cause learning about SU sustainability and taking actionable steps towards making a difference this project is a perfect example of how students at Mas are learning the value of community engagement environmental stewardship and teamwork another exciting initiative at Mas has been the school's Mitten Tree project for kindness month in December the school participated in a one school one read of the book The Mitten tree where students families and fac were all encouraged to donate mittens and hats to children at bdale Children's Hospital the schoolwide effort to spread kindness and generosity is a beautiful tradition and an inspiring example of how small gestur can have an enormous impact Mas is also continuing to nurture the development of future Educators this

014month the school hosted their second annual Pathways program welcoming 25 students from White Plains High School who are pursuing careers in education the school spent the morning observing or the students spent the morning observing classrooms participating in lessons and engaging with staff and students this hands-on experience provides invaluable insights into the teaching profession and allows Mas to continue its meaningful partnership with the high school moving to rway school they've had some heartwarming events that have brought the community together in powerful ways the Veterans Day breakfast and parade was truly a special event over 40 veterans were honored and students presented each veteran with a letter of thanks for their service the parade filled with songs and gratitude exemplified the school's commitment to teaching students the importance of honoring those who serve events like this Foster

015a sense of respect and appreciation for others which is essential in building a caring and empathetic School Community Ridgeway also had a successful Turkey Trot fundraiser which rated much needed funds for the school thanks to the efforts of the PTA the funds will be used to enhance the school's Courtyard and provide additional learning opportunities one of the highlights of this event was the strong Community Partnerships that were formed with local businesses supporting the cause and parents coming out in large numbers to show their support over 300 parents attended which is a testament to the strong sense of community at richway the PTA also installed a new miral in the school's hallway celebrating the inclusive beauty of all students this mural will serve as a daily reminder of diversity and unity that makes Ridgeway such a

016special place Ridgeway has also continued its tradition of Buddy reading during American Education week where older students paired up with younger students for shared reading activities this initiative encourages relationship building across grade levels and provides students with the opportunity to share their love of reading finally at Post Road students or Post Road November was a month of exciting engagement during American Education week the school invited parents to participate in classroom activities and join their children in the learning experience this Hands-On involvement has proven to be excellent an excellent way to strengthen the connection between home and school additionally Post Road hosted a family literacy night which featured stem themed story walks this Innovative event combined literature and Hands-On activities such as Building Bridges and flying paper airplanes while families read books like Andrea Bey by

017Andrea Bey like aah twist scientist and Rosie revier engineer it's great to see how Post Road is blending creativity with education in ways that Inspire both students and families the school also celebrated World cultures day where classrooms were transformed into different countries students had the chance to learn about various global traditions and cultures and the day culminated in a kindergarten parade of flags which displayed the countries of origin of many of the students and their families this event helped instill a sense of pride in students while promoting cultural awareness and acceptance in addition Post Road exceeded their miles and smiles fundraising goal by raising $20,000 and in celebration the staff and students enjoyed a fun-filled roller skating event this was a great way to celebrate the the school's sense of community and spirit the month

018wrapped up with inclusive schools week where the schools embraced empathy and inclusion by dressing up to celebrate everyone's uniqueness reinforcing the importance of welcoming and accepting School culture in conclusion each of these schools are doing amazing work to support and uplift their students and families whether it's through through environmental initiatives kindness campaigns community building activities or cultural celebrations Church Street School Mas Ridgeway and Post Road are all living examples of what it means to create a truly inclusive and compassionate School Community thank you to continue at East several memorable events have taken place recently the Veterans Day assembly was a heartfelt tribute to local veterans students performed patriotic songs read poems and honored White Plains High School alumni veteran Devon Smith Dr R and mayor roach attended addressing students and families with inspiring words following

019the assembly students and Veterans connected over breakfast providing an opportunity for students to Express gratitude and learn about the experiences of these honored guests in celebration of the end of quarter 1 students enjoyed an Afterparty filled with live music games like GaGa ball box ball and volleyball along with a variety of snacks this event served as a wonderful way for students to unwind after their hard work the friendsgiving student lunch on was another highlight with students voting on the menu making the event collaborative and personal the lunch on was filled with laughter gratitude and a true sense of community additionally a bullying prevention and Online safety assembly led by Officer Ashley Garcia emphasized kindness digital responsibility and the lasting impact of actions both online and in person looking ahead the school is excited for the

020upcoming winter concerts on December 11th and 18th Avid day on December 19th and the winter wonderland student lunch on on December 19th as well Highlands has also been busy with engaging events in late November sth grade students participated in a community building volleyball tournament where teams faced off against one another and the winners competed against the faculty team the event created a positive and fun atmosphere fostering student relationships and teamwork in December Thomas Grimes presented to students on Internet safety addressing important topics such as cyber bullying identity threat and long-term effects of online Behavior parents also had the opportunity to attend the same presentation that evening receiving valuable information on how to keep students safe online the school's holiday helpers event is underway helping Families in Need by providing gifts and food for the holiday

021season community members are encouraged to sponsor a snowflake to bring joy to local students and their families further an eighth grade volleyball tournament will take place on December 11th continuing the community building efforts and promoting school spirit White Plains High School hosted the climate change action Symposium and comp and competition in November organized by the stem Club the event featured presentations from local community groups focused on innovative solutions to combat climate change the Ry Nature Center enriched the event with a nature station exhibit and mayor roach opened the event with welcoming with a welcoming address s Dera a climate change activist delivered an inspiring keynote speech as well Additionally the principal advisory committee recently met to discuss school lunch offerings and explore strategies for ensuring that all students have access to nutritious free meals every

022day during the meeting students suggested new options including a variety of Beverages and vegan Alternatives and brainstormed ideas to promote school lunches more effectively while encouraging greater student feedback on December 5th the school held the eth grade parent information night where prospective family and students tore the building met with Administration and learned about the diverse course offerings at White PLS High School further the Key Club has been actively involved in the holiday season partnering with lifting up Westchester for a toy drive which supports teens ages 14 to 18 in addition donations for Thanksgiving provided over 45 families with gift cards for holiday meals the hot chocolate run on December 13th this Friday is another exciting event hosted by the Key Club in athletics the girls swim team had a successful performance at states with saskia

023ikan placing fourth in both the 50 and 100 free the hockey team also had a strong showing at the guy Matthews Memorial Tournament over Thanksgiving winning two out of the three games winter sports are now in full swing with modified tryouts taking place this week lastly the Harry Jefferson Memorial basketball tournament will be held on December 13th where the court will be dedicated to the late Sue Adams and current coach Spencer Mayfield the event will bring the community together to honor these individuals and celebrate the school's athletic achievements that is all for this month's report thank you you've heard me say this before there's no way that I could do as good a job thank you so much uh for for again another great month of of updates and you know I think um really

024illustrating all the tremend things that happen all throughout the school district there's so many moments to point to with pride um both led by our students engagement with our community um it's it's just so great to hear so thank you both very very much Dr R the girls mentioned the educator Pathways program yes yeah so they're now I know they're taking courses at the high school but they're also visiting the elementary school yes um the students who are in our education if you're not familiar with the education pathway program we are um working on growing our own fact faculty members here right at white blains high school um students can earn and are earning college credit um as well as experience in the classroom and and they are now transitioning into classroom observations um and

025visiting Elementary School classrooms and learning from cooperating teachers it's really it's a fantastic program I should also just mention since since we're talking about it um big thanks uh to Senator Shelley Meer who's also chair of the education committee for a $155,000 bullet aid grant that is earmarked directly for um the educator pathway program so uh it's it's thanks to celor mayor of course um and congratulations to the program again welcome everybody and and uh happy holidays there's so many festive events concerts celebrations that are going to be taking place all throughout the month hopefully you'll be able to join us at many of them I know Friday night is going to be an exciting night as well um and a very meaningful night as we dedicate the court uh here at White Plains High

026School it's also going to be some great games that are going to be played that evening wrestling tournament um had its second annual uh wrapped up its second annual uh I'm sorry the wrestling team wrapped up its second annual tournament this past weekend um with our Tigers performing very very well um the team is going strong and uh big thanks to all of our coaches and parents and Guardians and of course our wrestlers for supporting um that program I also want to thank the PTA Council as well the the program um that that's available it's happening right now uh at Highlands is highlighting the importance of understanding all of the potential pitfalls of digital interactions social media platforms um that can exist uh for our students and for parents and Guardians all of us um

027to learn as much as we possibly can in real time about how those Landscapes are consistently changing and shifting um and providing ways real practical ways to be able to keep our children safe and secure in a digital landscape so thanks of course for the PTA Council for leading uh as well in in that area and our cell phone um policy is is is coming along really well we were just talking about this um surveys thank you very much again are are being distributed here at White Plains High School eliciting or soliciting feedback from our student body um related to how uh we should approach cell phones in school um there was a and continues to be a big push related to to Banning phones at the high school level um this board of education

028and many in in Westchester County as well as around the state are looking at a more nuanced approach that has our our students as partners in that process um in identifying appropriate times to be able to engage with our devices as well as noo times like instructional time um and and that's the work that's taking place here and I think we're up to over 200 respondents so far and and that'll keep happening and and then we'll we'll come back to the board of education's policy committee for for review in a couple of months so that's good news Madam president members of the board on the on tonight's agenda we have a capital projects update and we have the team here um thanks again gentlemen for being here this evening but what I'd like to do

029is if it's okay I'd like to shift the Church Street School transportation update above um and attend to that update first uh because I know we have members of our community here as well and I want to be respectful of your time uh and we also then before we move into the capital projects update can move into public participation um and to allow folks who might want to address the Board of Education to do so and not have to wait um until later in the meeting so is that okay M great okay good evening again and and and thank you very much uh for the opportunity to present an update uh here to the Board of Education as well as the community and let me start out by saying and and many of you have

030heard me say this already this is a a challenging situation uh that we find ourselves in and what I'm going to attempt to do this evening is kind of walk through um where we were where we are and where we're going to be looking toward uh the future and we're really focusing this evening's conversation on Church Street Elementary School start and end time we have an existing Challenge and our challenge is that the cost of District transportation has increased dramatically uh we anticipated that the costs would go up and they went up even more than we could have anticipated so we conducted an audit in the 2023 2024 Academic Year in preparation for the ins spiration of the present contract with our service provider during that audit we anticipated an increase of roughly 30 to

03140% over the total cost of what we were paying for transportation in that existing contract the market costs and the actual costs far exceeded that and got up to around 50 to 60% in terms of what came back during the request for proposal process now folks have asked is there could there have been a way that those cost could have been reduced at the request for proposal process and unfortunately the answer to that question is really no that process is governed by law and so the specifications for the expectation of the service are put forward by the organization and then qualified biders have the opportunity to bid on the work and so when the proposal came back those costs or that those costs increase were really beyond our control as they would be any organization's

032control so we were already above what we had anticipated would have been higher costs when when that proposal when those proposals came back and so now we have to identify or figure out a way to save costs associated with those increases so what do you do well you could reduce expenditures elsewhere in the organization to compensate for the transportation cost increases right you cut programming cut purchases you cut Services right you could ask the White Plains taxpayers you could ask the community to support piercing or exceeding the tax levy cap to address the shortfall it's important to remember that in order to be successful in exceeding the tax levy cap you have to achieve a super majority of the vote so it's not a regular majority you you have to receive 60% of the vote

033and we could also look at adjusting the transportation service tiers to achieve the efficiencies that were identified in the 2023 2024 audit of the services and then that would reduce the overall cost it wouldn't take care of all of the cost increase still about $5 million that we have to attend to but it would reduce the overall cost of the service when we're looking at our fiscal stability and the overall health of the organization it's not just today it's not even just next year but it's three five seven 10 years we are trying to keep an eye on a constantly moving Target we're trying to predict to the best of our ability what costs are going to be in out years so that we can plan appropriately to preserve and enhance Services Program and opportunities

034for our students none of us ever wants to be here talking about a situation where we have to reduce Personnel where we have to cut program where we can't add another modified sports team if we need it where we can't offer before and after school assistance extracurricular assistance none of us ever wants to be in those situations and some of us have lived through them 2008 2009 2009 2010 you've been there you know we want to make sure that all of the decisions that we're making related to costs today are going to be decisions that will increase our likelihood for sustainable programming in the future not become a liability that we would then have to necessarily come back to you for again in the future and say we can't afford to do this but it's

035not easy in the long range plan for prior years and this is 232 uh I'm sorry 23 24 to 2728 we updated it to reflect the estimated budget shortfall so we knew we knew that we were going to be dealing with remember we were factoring in based upon the audit recommendations um and so we're looking at ways to to address that $5 million shortfall by a number of of different Avenues but what are the drivers well they're mostly things that are outside of our control just like what we experience everywhere else in the world um we have no increase in in property tax assessments and that's due to the increase in in payment in lie of taxes outside of our control understandable all all important to the overall health of of the community to growth

036and development all all important but outside of our control and it does affect our tax levy cap state aid is conserv at best conservatively projected at 2% now we did hear just recently that the governor talked about not reducing the save harmless provision and Foundation Aid which is really welcome news an important news throughout the state the white place is not a save harmless School District um so it doesn't really change the calculus for us in terms of what we can expect in the governor's executive budget that's due to hit right around January 1 so what are we doing we're we're being conservative in our prediction about any increase to Foundation a and Foundation a is your money coming back to you right it's allany redistributing state tax dollars to support education and so we're

037advocating always to ensure that White Plains receives its fair share of your tax dollars back to support your children's educational experiences and we were just at as you mentioned the the the conversation with Mike Rebel and we know that Foundation Aid is going to get another look throughout the state of New York as it needs and we will continue to advocate for white planes because our needs have changed um and we should be getting more of our tax dollars back to support our program but we can't count on it so we have to build on what we can count on significant increases in in health insurance and property insurance and pension costs all of these costs are beyond our control they're all Market driven costs we're experiencing them outside in in our other aspects of

038Our Lives as well so we know what those cost drivers are and again we planned for those cost increases we just didn't plan for the additional cost increases that came above the 40% so these estimates don't include changes for the new Transportation agreement and and what we were talking about this evening in in terms of the tier for Church Street Elementary School Again Church street is is the school that presently has the schedule that starts earlier than the other four elementary schools 30 minutes earlier than the other four elementary schools it's about $2.8 million we'll call it two $2 million a year every year for the duration of the contract right it's not an insignificant expense and it's a significant service meaning we understand the importance to the families at Church Street Elementary School of

039the present schedule we understand that we we respect it but we also know that we have to make decisions now that are going to put the school district as a whole including everybody at Church Street including all of Transportation including all of the programs and services that are students presently have and those are those decisions that we have to look at right now we're updating the the long range plan for 2425 and 28 29 um and we're looking at budget development for this coming year we're also exploring additional ways to save money to maximize our resources but they're not they're not going to cover the increased cost to maintain that tier of busing at two additional $2 million as part of the development process what are we looking at we're looking at retirement incentives lease

040revenue for space that may be available within the district to be able to lease to realize Revenue through that way we're constantly looking for efficiencies in the organization areas that we can realize additional savings and reallocate those savings elsewhere into the organization and the use of fund balance and we have to be very careful with this because we want to make sure that anytime we use fund balance it's going to stretch as long as possible because it's one time only it's not much different than you'll remember when we received the federal dollars related to co relief and the white PL City School District utilized it to upgrade all the school HVAC so every school in the white PL city school district will have air conditioning and we did it with one time only money right

041we have to make those kinds of Investments with onetime only expenses we have to be really mindful of that we need of course needed to communicate with the Church Street Elementary School Community as well as the Greater Community here in White Plains and and we started out by sharing the challenge with the community we did that in September about a year out from when any change to the start and end time of the school would take effect and we received feedback in a variety of ways and we're still receiving feedback and I suspect we'll receive more feedback this evening and it's welcome we solicit additional feedback through feedback surveys that were distributed for four consecutive Fridays they were done so in a mixed method approach they were not done so in a check the box

042and there was a purpose for that in the mixed method method approach both qualitative and quantitative we were able to receive information related to what parents and Guardians community members wanted but also they were able to share if they wanted to what they needed so if this change did have to happen how best could the school district support you and your family to the extent that we're able as an organization and so those surveys went out every every Friday for a month and the feedback was good over 300 respondents now you might you might ask well they were they unique responses we don't know we didn't track them there was no attempt to identify if if they were new every every week and that and that's because the feedback was meaningful even if it was

043coming from the same people week after week we wanted to hear it we needed to hear it and we needed to figure out a way to try to address both challenges at the same time so we looked at the we looked at the survey data and I'm going to share with you um the outcomes of that in a moment um and continue to seek Avenues to provide additional support for for parents and Guardians in our students as we also navigate the fiscal reality and the challenge associated with the increased cost and then we're going to continue to to remain open to learning from the community and receiving feedback from our community members as we always have and make no mistake about it we've heard a lot from the Church Street Elementary School Community but we've

044also heard from members of the greater white PL City School District Community as well um related to the conversation and that's important as well because all of these conversations while they may seem like they rest in One Singular area it touches everything within the School District transportation in a sustainable and efficient manner is critical to all of our children all throughout the school district and so it is a CommunityWide conversation what did the feedback tell us in Broad Strokes highly negative is the majority 54% of the respondents said this is terrible and they gave a lot of feedback as to why they thought it was terrible and then you had folks who also told us that you know lower minimal impact to them and that's that's fine or even no impact or or believe it

045or not you had folks say this will actually work out better for our family and it tells us something I see every day is that every single family has unique needs every single family while they're commonalities has a different set of circumstances that they're all working toward so for us what can we do we can try to serve everybody as best as we possibly can what were the concerns expressed um again mostly related to employment related to parent and guardian work schedules right um and before and after care services wrap around services for children all completely understandable absolutely you know we said this at the beginning when we first started this conversation any discussion about a change to the family routine to the school day it's a big discussion you know I I I have

046a seven-year-old and an 11-y old I know what what the morning is and I understand that a change to the routine poses a big Challenge and so for us we're trying to figure out how do we navigate that and how do we also provide the the supports here at school to try to make any any potent potential change not easy but at least more tolerable community members gave lots of feedback align all of the elementary schools with the Church Street School schedule make everybody start earlier right it's reasonable you can understand if you if if if you're thinking about your family as we all would be in that situation you you would think about that explore an expansion of before and after school Services especially at Church Street one of the things that we heard

047really really loud was this year we we had weit lists at some of the schools we have to make sure that we don't run into that challenge in in serving not just church Elementary but all of our elementary schools but certainly Church stre Elementary if you're talking about changing the construct of the start and end time by minutes we had people say that the school district should pay for before and after care services for all of all of the children throughout the district unfortunately well I'd love to be able to tell you that I would want to do that even if I wanted to do it we couldn't that's not something that the school district can do but what we can do is we can work with providers we can work with providers to try

048to make sure that the costs associated with before and after care services are as low as they possibly can be and we can also work with providers to try to identify ways for flexibility in the service that parents and Guardians are purchasing so maybe I don't need service five days a week maybe my family just needs two days a week and maybe on one of those days it's in the morning and one of those days it's the afternoon as much flexibility as possible increased taxes here's the cap and increase taxes to preserve the current structure that was a recommendation again reasonable if if that's what you're thinking and the impact to your family is going to be that great you can understand it cut cut programming somewhere else or cut something else I'm not going

049to tell you what to cut Joe but cut somewhere else to keep or get two million extra dollarss to be able to keep the the the Paradigm intact of course that creates a number of other concerns and challenges as you can [Music] imagine and then align align the the the four or align with the other four elementary schools figure out a way to help and support families to deal with the 30 minute swing as as as the schedule would line up to the other four elementaries and the board just some of the of the questions that the board of education has asked and this is really important because you know for the seven Board of Education members um nobody wants to be having this conversation I know that is it necessary is there another way

050that was a first question can we figure out another way to come up with the $2 million can we caught from another area in organization without really injuring the overall academic program is there are there enough efficiencies that we can Cobble together to fill the Gap what about one more year could we could we keep it for one more year again reasonable question right but but also we'd be facing the same scenario again can we work to make sure that after school school care in every building especially Church Street is available and without weit lists yes can we reconfigure the routes to maintain the the the present schedule at Church Street are Grant funds that we could access to be able to fill the Gap and raise the money to cover the costs and and

051there aren't um unfortunately there aren't what we can do what we P control is trying to figure out a way to support families moving forward and so before after care and wraparound services at all of our elementary schools especially Church Street we're working toward increasing the capacity working with our providers making sure that we're hiring now to have folks in place to be able to support the program and if it expands uh next year want to make sure that it's based in every Elementary School this was a a concern that was raised often is that you know I don't want my child to have to go somewhere in the morning and then have to be transported back and folks had made you know raised appropriate concerns about the number of buses on the road the

052number of buses on the road will be fewer when the elementary schools are aligned and we would intend to offer these services at the school for those who wanted to take advantage of it at the school I mean you know for folks who wish to continue to take advantage of other wraparound Services of course that remain would remain unchanged we also want want to and will have the opportunity for earlier enrollment so if people need to make changes they can start planning for it now and opening up the enrollment process in the spring that would be ready for September of 2025 as I mentioned focusing on Church Street Elementary making sure making sure that considering the change and for Church Street and our Church Street Community that this would be new making sure that they

053have all of the appropriate services and supports that they need beginning in September of 2025 I mentioned me having flexibility in the type of service you can access not everybody needs five days a week morning and afternoon and we are working with our providers to be as flexible as possible to offer those services and also at the consideration of costs we we want to make sure that these costs are as low as they possibly can be because one do and again right I I understand if it's a dollar that I didn't intend to spend next year it's it's an increase and so it's a hardship and we know that and so what can we do then to try to keep those costs for folks who need to take advantage of of those Services as low

054as we possibly can an additional Community Partners and opportunities and we're not going to stop you know when folks come to me and they have a problem try to figure out a way to help them and we're going to do the very same thing in this circumstance and I I know again that this is not welcome news but it's also the truth and and what I'm sharing with you is a very real problem a very real fiscal challenge the approach that we took and our taking to address that issue and to try to minimize the overall systemic impact that that cost increase will deliver to the organization because it is not just about today it's about all the days forward in terms of preserving our overall program and the total fiscal health of the school

055district dist you're going to hear a huge construction update capital projects update in the moment all of that work is being undertaken without increasing taxes through planning and that's what we try to do to the best that we can now we tried to plan for a big increase in transportation costs and it even exceeded our prediction our highest prediction of 40% what will we be doing going forward so moving forward we will update the entire white PL City School District community on the outcome of the work that we've done what our anticipation is next year in terms of aligning all five elementary schools we will continue to provide and in that update will come come this week we'll continue to provide budget updates to the community related to closing the gap for the 5 million

056existing we will update the long range plan to reflect the changes that need to happen this year and also dependent upon the executive budget Governor hok released it then the one house when it comes later what our projections will be for moving into the future as well as coupled with any changes to Foundation Aid and the calculations for foundation Aid and how they may impact the white PL City School District we'll present the long range plan we'll present the non-instructional budget we will present the instructional budget and then ultimately we'll present the proposed budget and let me be really clear and this is important I will not be recommending that we pierce the tax cap I will not be recommending that we exceed the tax cap what I will be recommending is that we all

057look for ways within this organization to realize efficiencies to protect our students programming and that may require some changes that may require some changes but what it also will do is it will make sure that the program that we love the programs that our kids access every day whether they be academic or extracurricular the Arts Athletics extension opportunities that they exist into the future that is the most important thing that we can do so not welcome news but it's the truth and I will not recommend end hearing the tax cap unless it was something that was catastrophic for our school district and make no mistake about it this is catastrophic for for for some of our home some of our home structures and some of our morning plans and routines I understand that I'm not

058minimizing that at all but I also know that we're speaking to the entire Community thanks for giving me your time and I'll give you a moment to get back so if the board has questions are we confident and you know optimistic that our Community Partners would be able to provide the child care that that we would need should should changes occur for all of the schools uh we are we've been meeting with with uh executive director Williams um members of of the the White Plains youth Bureau team as well as other uh other providers um to make sure that we have contingency in in in a number of areas in the space um what I can absolutely share with you and you know and and and would would talk about too would be that everybody

059understands the gravity of the situation um and and everybody in in the White Plains Community is working to meet the needs of parents I mean overwhelmingly that's what we heard from parents and G we we certainly overwhelmingly heard that there was going to be an impact related to employment schedules and the like but overwhelmingly secondary um was was the wraparound services so everybody is is moving right now to plan for September other question so first uh thank you this is not easy to hear you know we've been discussing it for a few months now um but thank you for the outline and and rationale um my question is you spoke about the greater White Plains Community so we've been targeting uh Church Street with our surveys and our conversations um when is the letter or

060communication going out to the The Wider Community to inform them of the what's been happening if they haven't been following the board meetings um yeah it's funny you mention that because I was going to ask you after the meeting we're gonna have to we're gonna have to pull that together fast um you know and and from the board as soon as as soon as we can um we'd like to be able to get that out um we've roughed up you know all of course all of the supporting details for the board um and uh I would anticipate Dr te of this tomorrow and possible and guess just a follow-up question we've spent so much time on mental health and and wellness with our students that in when we do address this potential change this change

061the impact academically and and socially and emotionally with our students what sort of services or like how are we going to deal with the impact on our students at specifically Church Street if that's who it will impact the most you mean if there was a an a negative impact on students in terms of their academic performance or their social otal yeah that's a great question um the the the school communities again you know were very fortunate here right because every one of our elementary schools has guidance Counseling Services Support Services um and and so the school communities of course would be ready and willing to assist both children as well as parents and Guardians if need be specifically the numbers of counselors we have at elementary schools psychologists we have right at at least one

062everywhere and we have additional that we can draw upon if we needed to at any particular minute y you the cabinet the board we all play a balancing act as we have to take a view of what's best for the district as a whole while still being attentive to and addressing specific building level and individual needs given those lenses through which we responsibly budget and that the board and and let me just I'm going to interrupt myself and just say that the board has read through and examined from you know every angle all the data all the information we've received um through multiple perspectives we've been influenced by the advocacy efforts and the feedback we've gotten so again given the lenses through which we have to have to budget the board wants to ensure that

063every possible option has been considered and so are there any stones that have been left unturned and I will tell you that my husband and my kids will tell you this is the kind of question I ask all the time and I you know will ask repetitive is there anything that we haven't considered I really I really appreciate that question um in fact we we continually ask ourselves that I feel like every day um if there if there is we'll keep looking for it um you [Music] know there there there's there's never a time where you want to be in a situation where delivering news like this that has a a negative impact on family you just don't want it you don't want it and you want to figure out a way and avoid it

064at all costs as you possibly can so even though right now you know we're making I'm making a recommendation it doesn't mean I'm going to stop looking for efficiencies it doesn't mean we're going to stop looking um you know for for ways uh to address the challenge it's not like you know okay that's over um and that's important for our community I think to hear because you know it's important that we share every bit of information that we can and it's also important that we remain open to not only feedback but constructive criticism to hearing about this from folks and their displeasure um to being challenged to explore other options and so as I stand here yes I don't if I had identified a way uh I would share that with you and I'll also

065tell you that we're going to keep looking that a concern that we have going forward once there's less buses and the RS have been consolidated really we work on we work on balancing the buses especially at the beginning of any Academic Year for two if we're lucky two weeks if we're unlucky it could be longer um in this new agreement those types of considerations and concerns were laid out for all in in in the in the RFP because we we want this service you know this is a service that the White Plains Community the White Plain City School dist is paying a lot of money for and we want it to be an excellent service so all of the buses are going to be new buses all of the buses are going to have all

066of the present day safety measures and features within them whether it be GPS technology whether it be camera technology whether it be Zonar technology making sure we know who's on the bus who's getting off the bus where they're getting on where they're getting off all of that and that will help to make sure that all the buses are appropriately leveled for ridership but that will be a daily process as well and so throughout the school year um if some buses are have lower ridership will'll be able to make changes to the number of buses on routes if we needed to address a situation where there was overcrowding as we have done in the past um we will have that ability to do it within the contract um the service should be better in terms of

067the the students experience in the vehicle um there will also be as I mentioned fewer buses on the road um so in terms of just you know daytoday traffic around town um that should that should help but but most importantly for safety um yes we we will absolutely be able to accommodate all of our children who who choose to ride the bus thank you sure so can you hear me I don't know I can hear I can hear you I'm not sure okay um so uh I mean I had a lot of the same questions that have already been asked but and I hear your comment about not wanting to recommend the piercing of the tax cap understandable if we were to consider and this might be a a an an question um if we

068were to consider piercing that is probably a convoluted process are we able to do that in Time For an upcoming school year you you you could put you could put a budget that's that's a good question so no it's not a bad it's not a bad question and it's not at the it's it's not at the wrong time you could put forward a proposed budget that would exceed the tax levy cap limit um yes you you could do it um you do risk of course a great deal in that process um one of the things you risk in that process is so one of the things that I've also heard from folks is that this is something that needs to be done it was in an audit that told you that this is an efficiency

069that can be realized when I say folks I mean community members follow me up right um and so the expectation is you're going to do it and you weigh that just like you weigh you know don't do it I definitely though also understand folks who whose primary concern is the overarching school district and the entirety of the program and so for those folks you know the the message was um you need to do what what is going to be the fiscally appropriate fiscally prudent and fiscally responsible thing to do and you also need to then figure out how you can help the families who need the help so you could um but the the the the response to a budget that exceeds the tax cap for this particular purpose um I think would be very

070risky and what would um I'm sorry can I follow that up uh what would be what would happen if we couldn't get 60% of the city to agree yeah um of having a budget that doesn't pass yeah the good news is in the state of New York you would get another opportunity to put forward a budget and the likelihood that we would be standing exactly where we are right now is extraordinarily High because one of the things that the Board of Education I would imagine one of the things that the Board of Education would be looking to do would be to identify what put you over exceeding the tax cap this would put you over exceeding the tax cap and you know you could you could argue well again find $2 million somewhere else in

071the organization you have a big budget find $2 million somewhere else and then we would be also having a conversation about the negative impact which because it's a hypothetical could be larger um that that that would then incur so best recommendation most conservative in the sense of what will be most fiscally responsible what can we do to make sure it's the most sustainable solution for the future so that we don't have to revisit this conversation again is is what I'm putting forward it's a good question anybody else Joe Madam president I would just like to make a comment the white the White Plains Board of Education and all school boards have two primary constituencies first our students who were who we are responsible for educating and the taxpayers who financially support the students education it

072is the responsibility of the school board to represent both of these groups to the very best of our ability the taxpayers of White Plains have been and we hope will continue to be very strong supporters of our school district as we endeavored to provide the very best education for our students through continuous Improvement like all complex organizations our school district is ever changing and focused on meeting the evolving the evolving needs of all representing both of these constituencies is a balancing act Dr R and his team have done an admirable job preparing budget after budget that allow our students the very best opportunity to learn and upon graduation from high school to lead productive lives in whatever they choose to do while at the same time being fair and responsible to the taxpayers as you

073have seen in Joe's presentation and the questions asked by my fellow board members we have spent a great deal of time listening to our community members who shared feedback and perspective as well as thinking of creative and outof the-box solutions to a very real Financial challenge as Joe has mentioned this is not a conversation that any of us want to have however it's a conversation that we must have as a challenge before us requires action in a manner that will best meet the needs of all of our students throughout the entire white plane School District simply put the cost of transportation for our students under the new busing contract will increase the expense side of the budget $2.8 million annually this increased expense means we would need to cut existing programs Andor services in other

074parts of the school district or increase the 2025 26 proposed budget by $2.8 million causing property taxes to increase above the New York State statutory tax cap limit and will require a super majority of 60% voter approval for the budget to successfully pass this is an action that cannot be taken casually and as Dr Rick has said should be avoided if there is an alternative we have worked very hard trying to come up with an alternative that does not include changing school hours for Church Street again none of us take disrupting any fam's daily schedule lightly we understand that many of our Church Street families are not pleased with this outcome we agree however cutting existing programs or services or exceeding the tax cap are not viable sustainable alternatives to maintain the 30 minute earlier

075start and end times to the school day at Church Street as we've seen in the presentation there are many initiatives the school district and our partners are working towards to minimize the negative impact of the of the change in every way we are able thank you other question thank you well you know and again I I just I would like to to thank everybody who took the time to share feedback um offer be thought Partners to to offer potential Avenues um of exploration um and also to Our Community Partners um who are stepping up to make sure that we are able to fill to the extent that that we are able um any gaps uh that that have been created by aligning all five elementary schools to the same start and end times Madam president

076I as as I had mentioned if it if it's okay um with the board we could do uh public comment we can move into public comment um for folks who might want to and then we can come back to superintendent report for the capital Improvement update yes thank you thank you okay we're at the point in our um agenda for public um participation we would ask that anyone wanting to make public participation please step to the podium on my right here your left and state your your name and address please limit your comments to three minutes there is a maximum timeline uh time limit of 25 minutes for public comments I would like to add that although we don't directly respond to individual comments during the public meeting all comments are heard documented and noted

077for further investigation and followup the superintendent and the cabinet can discuss concerns with you directly onetoone as part of the follow-up process please know that we do value all feedback and we'll work with you to ensure timely followup to your questions and concerns is there any public participation hello here again um sure you all recognize me at this point Julia Oliva 175 Trenton Avenue um I have just seen this presentation for the first time so my thoughts are going to be just kind of based on what we heard but I do think that the opposite perspective is very very much needed here when you say by you I mean the superintendent R when you say reducing existing expenditures without any real examples just sounds intentionally ominous and frankly in my opinion is fear-mongering we have

078been asking for other options for what could be cut since September and even with this presentation tonight we have no real options why is this taking so long shouldn't this have been considered before this option to change CSS hours with put on the table or maybe just maybe the thinking was that this change would go under the radar and no other options would have to be given something to think about something for the White Plains Community to think about I want to make clear that this proposed change would be on the backs of Church Street families before care will not be for free even if enough become available it will be at a cost and as a reminder 61% of CSS families are economically disadvantaged so while I'm glad the district can balance budget as

079a result of this change what about CSS families and their budgets should they not eat should they not pay rent something to think about but but please continue just to worry about the taxpayers which we also are clearly there is no concern for that and at the end of the day our children I also want to say I'm hearing random numbers when we first had a presentation by the superintendent at our PTA meeting he said it was a 2.2 million cut or over overe expense for the new Transportation now I'm hearing 2.8 million what is it I'm concerned that we're not getting straight budget numbers and I want us also keep in mind and something I've said to the board of aded and something I've said to the superintendent many of our families have one

080car or no cars so now you're taking away their transportation you're going to offer before care awesome possibly right now there's weight lists how do you expect those children to get to before care please give me a response no you can't respond how will they get to before care there's no answer to that so when the question was asked have you overturned every stone looked at every issue no you haven't you also have not fully addressed the overcrowding and the lack of monitors that will be on those buses have you also let all the ele elementary schools know that more students will be on the bus and that kids will be on the buses for longer I think they'd want to know that thank you good evening Christa Williams 109 uh North Broadway I had

081something prepared but um in l oh sure little short got it better okay Christa Williams 109 North Broadway I had something fully prepared I've spoken at a um board meeting in October and I am disappointed in how this information has been rolled out since September so now I need to gather my thoughts I do urge and request that Dr RI and the board come to Church Street and give us the this presentation in person talk to the families because we are not getting information this should have been publicized that this presentation and this discussion would be here tonight and it was not we might have more people representing our families speak to us we have our 377 signatures signed in opposition of this from in 48 hours it was over 200 the last signature was

082today 4 hours ago I can give you name of every one of those people and now we will open it up to the rest of White Plains because now you said you have data showing the rest of White Plains is okay with it the school districts the teachers the parents of other schools our petition can be open to them too we have the emails and we will do that and bring you information we need transparency which you are not giving us we have been ousted from the youth Bureau two years ago it is a significant change in a family's budget to go from a Family Youth Bureau to the YWCA or the YMCA huge huge increase and now you want us to put our kids there at 7:15 in the morning and pay another my

083family alone will be paying over $55,000 a month in before and after care in a city school district that does not have in-house after school I am from I work in Portchester I from Portchester we have our own after care in our school buildings open to everybody for $150 a month this is not Equitable across the board for families and you keep putting it on us we're not asking for anything we're protecting what we already have speak into the microphone okay sorry I'm Too Tall but my voice is loud enough um I'm Bessa zabai um uh 12 Westchester I'm actually really proud to be here because I've been alumni and um I graduated from White Plains High School and I know uh graduated actually with some of the children of the of the Mrs Eller

084hello um I always knew I was when I have children I would move back to White Plains because this was the best I always believe and still believe this is the best place to raise your your children and I stand by this till the very end and um uh was actually living in Europe when I unfortunately had to move back to New York with my son Alone um due to a failed marriage but the one thing that I looked forward to the most was coming back to White Plains because I knew that this was the a safe place the diversity the love the culture everything um I am a single mom now for four years and when I heard that this change uh was going to happen I um um my I know that my

085whole life will be turned upside down um I unfortunately don't I don't have any other option um and so Dr R respectfully you you mentioned the needs of the families but this doesn't this doesn't fulfill any of my needs and are you prepared to fulfill the needs that I would need as a single parent um we chose Church Street because of the time um it works perfectly with my schedule as a single mom Mars gets on the bus at 7:40 I take the 8:04 train to the city um do I have to risk now my dream job um in the beginning Mrs Eller mentioned that the mission in White Plains is to for the students to find their dream place I work for the United Nations if it wasn't for White Plains School District I

086wouldn't be where I am right now everything in my life comes back to White Plains and so if this change is going to happen Dr R are you are you prepared to meet my my personal needs and I'm sure of the needs of so many parents for that before school care because for me this isn't going to work at all so I'm I'm looking forward to hearing um if this change happens um what you will do for me and for all the parents but especially for single parents thank you [Music] th this is hard this is a hard conversation but I I have to say um on behalf of all of us we hear you and I'm sure the the superintendent in the cabinet um also hear you and we do appreciate um hearing from

087you thank you that'll close public thanks [Music] president thanks president Eller and and just and again thank you to the to our community members and and you you mentioned it before you mentioned it before um yes I I would be willing to speak with anybody about their individual circumstances and try to partner and problem solve the best I can and also there there's limitations and I recognize that but I will always try to exceed what those limitations may be and try to find a way so um I appreciate the the comments I appreciate again all the feedback and and um offer my thanks I do um I do also want to before I turn it over to uh our our facility update I do want to also mention that we have members of the faculty

088and staff who are here with us this evening late and thank you um who are going to be recognized on this evening's agenda for tenure and there's going to be a big recognition of course at the toward the end of the Academic Year where we're all going to come together and celebrate together beautiful spring weather um but I do also want to draw attention to miss Flores who's uh a member of White Plains High School a teaching assistant Mr s Dano uh from East viiew Dr Burger Ridgeway uh Miss Vargis uh Post Road Mr beas districtwide fizzed and Coach all right Mr be um and uh and Miss metet as well from GW and you're yay all right great so so it's coming it's coming you're on the agenda it'll be here the guy uh

089told us that this is going to be a holiday version of the capital update all the good stuff it's all good stuff thanks so thank you I was saying how we started all this work about $120 Million worth of work back in 2018 and planning and planning and planning and the successful approval of the projects back in 22 um and so we continue to move forward so I'm happy to present the team um our Architects h2m and Triton construction our our construction management company um and jav air Hernandez our director of facilities and Frank stefanelli our former director um you know everybody just working together along with the board and the superintendent to really continue to make this uh come to fruition hi everybody uh Chris Pierce TR construction I'm also here with uh vice

090president Tron Teddy cukis and senior project manager Bob fice the hbac infiltration projects we're at there's seven jobs in total the F we call the first five that are essentially done and those are Church GW East View Highlands and high school those all the work has been done there we've mentioned this at uh some previous board meetings there is a little bit of communication back and forth between the controls version and the controls that are within the equipment okay and that's limited to those two vendors okay the what happens is there's some communication problems and I and a couple overheating problems I want to tell the board that this is a this is a small percentage of of the project okay they about installed I think roughly 325 new units throughout the school district um

091we're down to in terms of things causing issues in in a single digit percentile at this point and we're meeting regularly every Tuesday with both uh those two vendors the equipment vendor and the controls vendor and we're going to get through it um we're close uh and then F finally the last two projects which which started later Ridgeway M marinick uh they were bid later awarded later um all of that infrastructure work is essentially done and has gone well uh the biggest there was a switch gear delivery which we knew about um lead time issue uh so the switch gear is coming for both those schools at the be in January of 25 uh as soon as switch gear is here Ridgeway can start right away uh and and and finish the completion M marinex

092I'm sorry I have It reversed Marin can start right away and we should have AC available to start testing in the spring at Ridgeway because the switch gear is in the same exact spot you have to take out the old switch gear put in the new switch gear so AC is not going to be available uh at Ridgeway until the summertime when when school's out in terms of all the projects that uh were undertaken over the summer they are in the process of getting punch listed by by h2m uh the punch list being addressed by the contractors and going into the Final close out and that's for the fields and the track the all the uh the ceiling and lighting replacement in the High School uh the new bathrooms at uh George Washington and the

093punch list for each of those projects that we just R through is is is minimal um so we're we're in a spot to close all those jobs out uh again this is a repeat slide we've seen before just before and after of the Damon house demolition um that fence will remain up uh to support the and contain the new construction so um so that will be there when when the new work starts uh and then finally with all these La these projects that close out there is some final negotiation on uh either open change ERS Andor processing of uh credit change orders for allowances that weren't used and we don't we don't see anything we actually see in all um sorting itself out with no nothing substantial to report in terms of the recent bidding

094and bidding projects we opened the district opened bids for the four Elementary School renovation project a church GW mamin and Ridgeway uh combination of you know a little bit of different work at each at each School the quarter flooring the cafeteria at Church Street uh cafeteria and gymnasium ventilation at GW quarter flooring Roofing library and cafeteria upgrades at M Marin and the library and cafeteria uh upgrades at Ridgeway the bids all came in on the opened on November 20th all all the biders got scoped out and found responsible uh uh under budget or under budget for the projects and all uh all biders and recommended um contractors that have either done work within the district or h2m or Triton back okay um so I this is this is all great news um and uh okay

095and I'm going to turn over to Joe good evening everyone joose Sano from h2m uh just going to talk through some of the projects that are currently in uh wrapping up design or preconstruction so that includes some phase two upgrades at the high school um Air Handlers Project Lead the Way uh Corridor widening security improvements and uh Ada accessibility we're currently working with the district and evaluating uh scope and cost with the construction manager through the design process at Rambo the alterations in h project are submitted to the state there again we're re-evaluating the scope of work of renovations to be performed again with the goal ultimately of um applying cost savings to the overall budget and certainly the larger project of the high school edition and then the high school edition itself so when

096we last presented we had touched on a shortfall in building aid from what SCD uh has recently projected compared to what was estimated pre-bond since then we've had extensive coordinations with both the district SED and bosis we've worked on revising a design program and layout of the addition to maximize aid from the state within the addition itself we're in the process of finalizing that and executing reapplication paperwork then we will then resubmit to SED um for a complete estimate on the building Aid once once we resubmit we anticipate turnaround pretty quickly because again the overall construction documents for that project have been reviewed and approved we're waiting on final project manager sign off with the state but we anticipate a quick turnaround once the preliminary submission is is re um resubmitted in s calculates their

097aid we're also discussing um open construction schedule considerations with both the district and the construction manager certainly our initial plans had this project out to bid uh within the calendar year of 2024 being that we are a bit behind that projected schedule with State approvals we're going to be looking at adjusting the construction schedule moving forward and should have more information once we receive a final approval from the state and then to touch on the the building Aid discussion once more so to go back as we had mentioned we had a a anticipated um an unanticipated shorall and building Gade between the original estimate and where the state came back by working with the district and replacing some non-instructional or administrative space within the new edition with instructional space and that's a combination of General

098classroom and special education spaces we're looking to maximize building Aid within the addition that combined with the the cost savings from the elementary school projects the current projects under construction as well as looking to scale back the scope and scale of renovation R Shambo we are confident that those cost savings will be applied towards the high school so that and in combination with the increase and building Aid that we are designing will be able to um accommodate the budget that we anticipate having so you said low lower building ba significantly lower or just so yeah so we don't initially that was very yeah no the the initial estimate was uh I should say the initial estimate and what we received back from SD was significant we're able to uh likely cut that Gap in in

099half I would say we don't have final numbers yet but by replacing the non-instructional spaces within the addition with the instructional spaces as well as taking some special education programming from the existing high school and reloading relocating it to the addition we're able to maximize the aable units of the addition itself and just quickly instructional spaces are we talking like four walled classrooms is it no excellent question so yeah so so within the addition we had some space identif ified for potentially an IT office um Union offices that the district has been able to accommodate space in other buildings so now that we it's not a password now that we um have replaced those spaces with instructional spaces the non-instructional spaces don't generate any building Aid so now that we are representing that same square

100footage with aidable or instructional spaces we are able to increase the aid available from the state for the new addition thank you [Music] sure you comment um more specifically on why the building Aid ended up being lower than expected as as well as I I couldn't tell from these diagrams how they differed from the plan previously in terms of instructional and non-instructional spaces so I don't know if there's something else you can send us which would be more indicative of where the change have taken place yeah absolutely we could if if uh if we are able to get the screen back up I can I can show you between the two slides but to go back to your first part of the question so the the concept program that was developed for the addition pre-bond

101so we're talking 2021 to 2022 had a certain um amount of um building programming when I say program I mean classroom spaces um instructional spaces Etc post bond and throughout the design process that program modified some classroom or instructional spaces were removed or scaled back as we were working through the updated budgets of the addition so the initial concept program that we estimated the building a off of M changed somewhat significantly to what was ultimately uh designed and agreed upon to fit within budget now when we submitted to the state they came in much lower than even we anticipated with those difference in programs and we and we've worked and have coordinated withd on Spaces that we feel they either Miss or didn't calculate appropriately those spaces along with replacing the non-instructional spaces with the

102instructional spaces we are confident will uh make up a good amount of the the building Aid unit that we feel the state missed on their first review I do need to um just share with the board and S and and the team at the State education department has been really tremendous in working with us and and coming together and working and working with the full team I know that commissioner Rosa as well as the Regents um as well as the governor as well as as well as as well as are all very very interested in making sure that there is there is a rebirth of Career Technical education opportunities that are directly connected with secondary education all throughout the state in New York as well as the nation corre and so they have really been

103helping us to make sure that this gels in in Partnership as well with Southern Westchester bosis um and so that that I think went along we you know we had a great meeting where we were able to kind of talk you guys were able to talk through um you know and and massage those uh those plans um and so that that was really beneficial and I would be remiss if I didn't thank SD have they changed their methodology well well now they have the independent reviewers again are back but we missed that but this was an actual opportunity for us to meet directly with them and talk to them about our plan and our vision went through great detail the finance Council went through great detail um with the committee um with the team uh

104last month so we'll resend that presentation which was very specific um and really showed those diagrams and plans the reason I'm smiling is because you can't see it on TV but I'm looking at the guys in the booth are telling me I'm doing a terrible job microphone to you uh but to go back to answer your question if if you could uh Focus your attention on the screen for a moment so um just a simple diagram and I know these are at small scale we can certainly send for for your review these are this is the design of the addition uh I'll say pre pre-program revision so on the left side we have the ground floor plan the right side the first floor plan um left side of the page the the top portion of

105the addition was earmarked for uh family information center offices a potential it office suite and a I'll say vanilla box base for a future future medical buildout the modifications we made are replacing those non-instructional spaces with a combination of General classroom and special education spaces these General classrooms are oversized for what a typical classroom could be so that they could potentially accommodate a Career and Technical education type program um either with in in coordination with bosies or if the district in the future is able to implement a program like that on their own but those are the the modifications so if I if I go back you'll see the current layout and you'll see the modifications that were made uh to both floors before and after sure yeah not a problem and uh that takes

106us through it folks so I appreciate the time I'm happy to answer any other questions if you have thank you thank you all very much have a great holiday guys you too happy holidays everyone next we're going to move to our summary um action items we have summary action items 4 through eight may I have a motion so moved second I'm going to read this really fast and with great gratitude because this is amazing um Item B donations my goodness follow me on this $1,500 donation from quatal publishing to buy supplies for the high school library program $1,000 grant for White Plains High School youth to youth club from the National Road Safety Foundation a $500 donation for the Dr Leonard G roads memorial fund from Donna Joseph White Plains High School Key Club and

107midnight run have received several donations from the following sources $2,500 donation from the pantanelli family Oakland trading Corp $300 donation from Scarsdale police benevolent Association a $250 donation from The Professional firefighters Association of the city of White Plains New York incorporated a $200 gift cards donation from the White Plains Police benevolent Association 150 gift card donation from the 1020 uh Post Restaurant 150 gift card donation from the White Plains hockey team a $100 gift card donation from Freebird restaurant $100 donation from Michelle shenfeld thank you Mr sheld a $50 gift card donation from the Klein family a $50 gift card donation from student Lila Tomlin thank you Lila a $25 gift card donation from Moren nyis thank you a $25 gift card donation from student Bel sepper thank you all so much White Plains High

108School PTA donated $4,850 for the following $1,200 for the orchestra page Turners $1,000 for the sale art night $985 for the Spanish probes $895 I'm sorry science probes $895 donation for the SP that's where it happened Spanish class trip $500 donation from the enl for the enl culturally relevant books and $270 donation for reusable headphones and the word is with gratitude there's more oh there's more wait wait but wait there's more oh yes the following grants were donated by the friends of White Plains $18,000 grant for the Beyond Broadway d program in all elementary schools a $900 Grant to the high school sale program for tickets for students to attend the performance of hairspray at the WPA White Plains Performing Arts Center thank you so much to everybody for your generous donations really truly amazing

109and we're [Applause] grateful are there any questions all in favor I thank youbody I would I really want to thank all of you for coming out this evening and for supporting all of our colleagues um and and congratulations I know it's a little bit later than normal but thank you very very much everybody for being here thank you congratulations next next we'll move on to individual action items we have the recommended approval of the request for an extension as per csca contract of the P paid period of absence Beyond 30 working days due to an accident in the line of duty for employee 3286 effective November 1824 through December 13 24 to include an additional third 20 working days may I have a motion are there any questions all in favor all right next we

110have the recommended approval of a resolution approving a stipulation of settlement in connection with impartial hearing Reporting System case number 620 317 may I have a motion any questions all in favor I next this is good thing next we have the recommended um we have the recommended um approval of the six school election site at L Central Hispano for the May 20th 2025 school election the location is 295 Central um Avenue in white plan I if I if I may just offer the board and the community um the the the identification as El Centro espano as the voting site again we're grateful for El Cent support it is a polling place for general elections and you may remember this came from conversations related to the inability to access the community room um that was available

111to community members um for a long period of time and then a subsequent conversation with with the neighborhood association and members of the community on how we could bring a closer site for for our our community members in Battle Hill um and I want to thank the the neighborhood association and president WI and and all those folks are engaging with us I'd also like to thank the common council members um for offering their support and of course El Centra Spano um for for opening their doors to us we're really happy and and happy that we were able to come to this yeah thank you may I have a motion so move second any questions all in favor I I next we will move into our board um oh the field trip I'm so sorry Mr

112SP I know they were just coming they were coming for me you know what I got a new prescription too I do I have a new prescription it should be in the um when I get home at the door next we have the recommended approval of an overnight field trip for Post Road Elementary School fifth grade class um and this is Nature's Classroom may I have a motion second question all all in favor I have fun now we can move to board committee did I miss something El no no okay so I I'll quickly go we had curriculum earlier this week um we had an awesome meeting where we had um various departments uh offer up some new course offerings and electives at the high school across multiple disciplines uh a robotics course uh for

113the high school an intro to dance which uh Mr West was super happy about as we put on the extension for the Performing Art Center uh to really have robust performing arts program climate and the human impact uh elective we have a dual language in global one uh government and economics of food sounded really interesting as well and a financial literacy course will be offered as well and this is all with very no cost to the district and just some reworking of um yeah moving Parts but yeah we're very excited to see how more options for our children in terms of el neutral budget neutral is nice yes you know the instructional program and really the creativity um and forward thinking um perspective of our faculty of our staff really thinking about what students need

114what they want what they're interested in and if I can just add also um embedding even more Civics into the social studies curriculum and it's really very gratifying because I remember several years ago being at a Westchester putham School boards Association present ation on Civics and I brought back a lot of materials to to the district and that really I I think there was some impetus at that point we had a social studies uh curriculum review and we really started working on um putting more Civics back into our you know program and um and then being part of the pilot program for the Seal of Civic Readiness and so when I have heard from other school District around the state boning the lack of civics education it's really it's it's a point of Pride that

115here in White Plains we're taking this very very seriously and we're always looking for opportunities to expand so I'm I'm really appreciative of that um we also had Finance Craig do you want to speak to that uh last week we had a finance audit committee meeting when our claims auditor and our internal auditor um visit the committee to give an update on uh various workings that they're doing for the school district okay thank you and also we had special education yes we had special education committee where we visited uh three self-contained classrooms at Church Street School grades K through 2 um another kindergarten class and grades three and four or 3 through four to observe the teachers and the students and see how important the importance of the classroom setup to provide a predictable environment

116and routines and why it's important for both students and teachers to create a productive safe learning and working environment um so it was interesting to see and to see the students and the teachers and um uh at Church Street and it was a very um enlightening day for me because I hadn't seen that before I hadn't had the chance to um visit a classroom before uh a self-contained classroom um and now we're going to visit the um Highlands and white PLS high schools uh classrooms as well to see how this progresses into the secondary education years can I just add for special education um that uh there was a meeting that was held for the transition from cpsc to csse the committee on preschool education and the committee on special education for those families who

117have incoming kindergarteners who have been part of that cpsc process and was really well attended um and I think very much appreciated it was a very very clear presentation so families um know what what to expect um and can I also comment on the The Wellness uh the the Safety Committee and uh the board did receive the recording of that meeting so I won't say very much about it but um Jeremy from alteras is our leaone and um they are really doing you know an excellent job along with Dr Via T um and really did you know sort of updates um there's been training for you know threat assessment procedures zero eyes more coordination um you know with the police there's been stairchair training there have been updated maps of our buildings that there you

118know with input from the fire department um health and wellness um you know there's lots of walking pneumonia going around um if you haven't noticed um and we do have a supply of masks and covid tests if God forbid you know they're needed in the future okay thank you next Dr vicker anyone here okay so before um before we we head into executive session I would like to just first of all for all of our colleagues who are here who received tenure on this evenings agenda would you you just please stand to be [Applause] recognized we orchestrated the meaning to be a little bit longer to see if you had the grit and I also would like to just uh congratulate I know she's here this evening as well miss Britney Graham uh from Bridge

119West [Applause] congratulations Britney you're welcome thank you everybody before we before we move to go into EXA um thank you John mavage and the Audio I don't know Joe Joe Joe Joe thank you too Joe thank you just thank you both um for your your work tonight and without further ad do may have a motion to enter into exact session to discuss matters of a personnel negotiation second all in favor I I happy every happy holiday [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.