CorpusRecord 232906

SOCSD - Board Meeting 01-28-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SOCSD BOE
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Rockland County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,078 words · about 101 min
Collected
2026-06-26

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001for late start motion to reconvene to a public meeting at 6 uh 7:45 motion thank you Diana do I have a second I have a second second thank you D all in favor okay please stand for the pledge aliance to the FL of the United States of America and to the Republic for stand one na God indivisible andice for all just like to take a brief second to welcome our newborn member to his first meeting here uh thank you rob for taking time out of your schedule to serve the board looking forward to it thank you okay are there any board announcements Rob this is just set a time for your any of us to share um anything that's been going on in the past uh since the last meeting um you know anything that

002you've attended or um anything that you want to share with the community well I wasn't here last week uh so just to introduce myself to the community too I've I've lived here 15 years now uh three students through the District Two still one William O schaer one here in the Middle School uh I'm a formally trained scientist I also now work in the biotech field so I have a PhD I'm actually a 10e Sunni faculty member also so I have a lot of Education experience um hoping to bring my expertise of running companies uh to the board looking for efficiencies all the while trying to improve curriculum and overall experience for the students so really excited to lend some time uh to thect especially being a parent so understand how hard it is to be

003a parent working today um want to int introduce myself formally in the minutes and last week I wasn't here sorry I was I was out in the big biotech conference in San Francisco so I apologies just elected and then skipped out on the first meeting but that wasn't wasn't by Design so I had something that uh prepared um since the last meeting we had a uh discussion and a presentation of a curriculum um I was able to do some homework in the meantime I wasn't able to react to it in real time it was thrust Upon Us literally 5 minutes before we were unable to really come up with any questions but I come up with a statement after I did a lot of research and uh I feel that it's my opinion as one

004of the board members I mean not share the same opinion as everybody else but it's been bothering me and I would feel much better if I said it out loud so when a young family moves to South Orangetown as I did 10 years ago it's natural to worry about their children's education many choose to relocate to Rockland County hoping their High School uh their their High School tax contributions will enhance our district success I share the disappointment in our District's ongoing struggle with academic performance despite significant increases in Staffing and budget over the past few decades our results on state tests are still concerning we spend the second highest amount per student in the county yet our test scores do not reflect this investment while a holistic approach to education is important I wonder how

005we're measuring success if the state tests are deemed unimportant resources like niche.com show that despite being similar in size to neighboring districts South Orangetown consistently unper performs on state tests while receiving similar ratings we need to consider whether we are using the most infective curriculum and how effective our response Intervention Program is that's RTI if only 50% of our students are reading proficiently I look forward to collaborating on solutions for our district we have unique potential here and I believe we can achieve better outcomes for all our students thank you all right thank you um superintendent's report sure good evening everyone apology for the late start so I just want to begin tonight also by welcoming Dr Rob Coleman to his first meeting as a new member of our Board of Education and we look

006forward it's fine go ahead excuse me we look forward to working with you to support our students parents staff and entire School Community just a followup uh to our literacy presentation from the last board meeting we will be also presenting at the next uh SEPTA special education PTA meeting to provide an update on the reading review process including the work that's been happening with our Ela leadership team administrators and teacher leaders as you know we are using the New York State education Department's literacy guide to review programs to ensure that we're in compliance with the New York State education Department's requirement to be in alignment with the pillars of the science of reading and that literacy review guide has been helpful as we're we're looking at other programs Mr arietta is presenting tonight on curriculum

007and instruction so he'll be sharing more information during his presentation in just a little while as far as the the grade 3 to8 Ela and math assessments our students will be better prepared to take these standardized tests this year we will also be communicating with families about the importance of our students taking these assessments to help inform instruction I know as a parent um and for students and teachers this information is helpful to capture particularly as students develop and continue to take High Stakes assessments throughout high school and Beyond so we're looking forward to sharing more information with the community as we go through those curriculum changes moving on to Deca uh congratulations to the four taben High School Deca club members who medled at the New York Region 3 conference at Rockland County Community

008Rockland Community College and they qualified to compete at States in March in Rochester and this is our our business Club the first place uh winning first place for financial Services were Juniors jaywan C and Lucas W and coming in second place for business law and ethics were seniors Michael H and Nate P the club which returned this year after a multi-year Hiatus provides opportunities for high school students interested in business careers to test their Knowledge and Skills against peers from across the region State and nation and as you know our business program has grown tremendously in the in the last few years and we've added a lot of courses uh to that business pathway we also had students attend the model un conference we had 12 members of tapy high school's Model United Nations Club

009attend the 24th annual Columbia Model United Nations conference and Exposition and that was held at Columbia University last weekend this conference brings together delegates from around the world to engage in intense crisis simulations that cover a variety of topics time periods and regions also last weekend last Saturday our Science Olympiad team we had 30 members from taben High School compete in the division C Invitational hosted also by Columbia University and we finished 39th out of 67 teams the team will spend the next two weeks preparing for regionals which will be held in early February at bym Hills High School so this year we uh every year have a eth to nth grade student orientation where in the past we've had um teachers and counselors come down from the high school to the Middle School to

010talk to kids about tapen high school and this year we flipped the script and we had all of our eighth graders well half of them went today and half are going um on Thursday and the eighth graders um rather than uh having the Freshman come down here the middle school kids went up there they restructured their program to bring the rising nth graders to the high school they toured the building they also were treated to a music uh performance from some of the high school kids they visited the art Department business program Computer Science Project Lead the Way engineering to check out the electives firsthand and I spoke with some of the eighth graders and teachers when they came back to SS today and they were very excited they were all coming back into the

011building smiling so we were glad uh that they were able to have that opportunity and they were also able to hear from our high school principal Miss Luciano so it is college career and Civic Readiness week at William O schaer and Cottage Lane Elementary School and the school counselors have coordinated a series of age appropriate activities that engage students in thinking about potential careers Cottage Lane will host a career panel for fifth grade students this Friday featuring professionals representing Health Care technology legal and human resource fields uh also I just want to mention our budget Outlook tonight our assistant superintendent for business operations is going to be sharing our state aid projections we are entering into Uncharted territory we're looking at probably a flat state aid budget to budget um from this year to next

012year um we also know we have continually Rising costs in terms of salaries benefits and contractual obligations and uncertainty about how and when the state will implement the recommended changes to the foundation Aid formula and also Dr Lloyd will be presenting tonight uh and talking a little bit about our staffing Outlook we do have a number of retirement notifications and we're looking very carefully at those positions and working towards any savings we can capture as we reorganize and hire new staff and so at this time uh we have as a part of the superintendent report tonight we have presentations from Mr aretta Dr tesk and Dr Lloyd and then we're also going to hear from our assistant superintendent for business oh sorry sorry before we do that we have an update from our uh Clark

013Patterson Lee uh on our construction project sorry about thate interrupt but there was recently the girls true leading team right they they recently won oh right they came in first place in white PLS they came in first place White Plains yes can we just mention that sure as well as the um gymnastics team I think they met placed as well it was their last home game their last home meet I'm sorry I don't really know gymnastics very well but did we me I don't think that was mentioned I didn't mention it so thank you for bringing that up well I'm just curious I'm I don't have well my daughter's not old enough to be in gymnastics through the competitive level level but I look forward to it how does that work with the gymnastics team

014how does that work with the cheerleading team I feel like they're not getting enough representation as far as their contribution to sports additionally they're not on the calendar so when you go to the Athletics website it's not on there you have to go to the uh J I forget uh the actual website I think it's JR school to figure out when they actually compete or when their next competition is why is that done like that I saw an email about that over the weekend I think Mr pill is addressing that well when we have an answer for that as far as why it is not on the calendar I think there's a there's a disconnect between the sports teams and I think a lot of the sports teams are doing a good job of publicizing

015their own events outside of the district I don't think the district is is doing enough to I guess raise them up so to speak especially for girls teams for teams that have are prominantly female all right so I think I I'm an agreement with Diane I think maybe we just need to see better representation across the board and I appreciate the parents and the students contributing to social media posts but that shouldn't be the only way I shouldn't be fortunate enough to get the information from a friend of a friend of a friend or just halfhazard Discover it I think that it should be blasted out we celebrating our students and I don't think it's done consistently across all the sports so I think that's something that Mr Phill is going to have to address

016absolutely thanks for bringing that to our ATT is not here tonight well I know we just had a boys and girls basketball game at Pearl River and taby high school so he might still be boys girls got it um there is a service that's offered by Bose Communications and some of the districts have taken advantage where they are specifically assigning someone to cover Athletics so that's something also we could talk about as we go through the budgeting process to have better coverage but certainly Mr pill is aware of of that concern and is addressing it all right Mr Kar thank you uh good evening um how you doing tonight good miss you it's nice to be back we likees Natalie but we I I I got to play second Fed so um that's good so

017uh to I want to apologize I'm so sorry with the outcome I think you deserve a Super Bowl I you deserve I hope you didn't destroy your house afterwards I felt so bad for you I'm sorry no not uh nobody was hurt in the process so everything I thought you right away I was like oh everything's good everything's good there as as as a Buffalo Bills fan and been for years there's always next year okay thank you um just to uh bring uh Mr Coleman or Dr Coleman up to date uh my name is Greg Kern I'm the former interim School business administrator here for the district I've been kept on as a consultant to run scope budget um make sure the bills get paid for the uh for the construction project tonight we have

018our uh January update or in between we're in uh in between year one and year two we have a four-year project of construction tonight with me is uh from the Palumbo group is Mike doogle and from CPL Clark Patterson Lee our architectural and engineering firm is Lisa Falone uh I will turn that over to them and answer any questions at the end Mike thank you Greg good evening board we appreciate the chance to present so we've had a um uh a a great um great 2024 a lot to be uh lot to be proud of let me see see if I know how to see if I can new guy [Laughter] thing so just to take you through the um uh the capital projects uh we'll be talking about phase one scope and schedule both

019what we completed in 2024 and what we're ready to complete in 2025 Phase 2 schedule which which will uh begin this summer uh at TZ high school phase three Lisa will cover uh uh some of the details there the auditorium project uh which we'll be bidding later on uh and then we'll take you through the budget and uh fin the Q&A in 2024 we uh we completed in at William moay for the classroom Renovations the e eell renovation uh the new coach's office the new AIDS room new nurses suite and we're happy to say that we've uh We've achieved uh 70% completion on the HVAC upgrades uh we spoke about that uh in length before about uh how that really helps us in 2025 and then the new Outdoor Classroom at Cottage Lane also a

020uh new Outdoor Classroom we have the outdoor Fitness path new secure entry vestibule we we have the uh uh haac upgrades also 60% complete which will help us uh in 2025 the new main office suite and the music room Renovations here are some pictures this is Cottage Lane might recognize the uh uh the entry vestibule as well as the music room came out beautiful and recently we just uh installed the the uh backlit sign and the uh the main office you see the outdoor path uh I thought it was important also to include the uh some of the ugly uh equipment that we put on top of the roof uh just so you can see some of the HVAC work that we did at least the scope of it uh new principal's office and again

021another shot of the uh uh secure vestule at WIlliam Mo schaer we have the uh the new Aid room uh and a couple of classroom shots and then a reverse angle of the the a room very happy the way that came out and at CLE and at Schaefer they both installed the uh outdoor classrooms really came out beautiful phase one also at tapen high school we had the new Outdoor Classroom uh the gym bleach move and the uh new sound and scoreboard installation that's a good shot of the Outdoor Classroom really looks beautiful it's almost impossible to take a bad picture here nice scoreboard so for uh the uh middle school for 2024 last year we did The Outdoor Classroom there as well so we put up four outdoor classrooms last year uh in addition

022we had the um uh the CIP 2024 nurses suite at uh William OA I'm sorry at uh uh the Middle School there's a good shot of the uh Outdoor Classroom and the nursa suite came out beautiful hopefully uh uh some of you folks have gone to take a look so our scope for 2025 is to finish up at the elementary schools we'll be finishing up the uh back classroom backwing classroom renovation at William O shaer uh we've got the HVAC upgrades to complete and the casework upgrades at Cottage Lane we're going to do the new resource and it room where the old main entrance was we'll be combining some rooms there and uh the balance of the HVAC upgrades the work plan for phase phase one for the balance of the work in 2025 we've

023got a start date of June 27th with a substantial completion date of August 23rd we've um Incorporated uh uh the pack and play for Jack spokes to uh uh have enough time to to uh move the furniture out and of course it's just a much smaller scope uh this year because of the work we did last year moving on to phase two 2025 is um uh what we'll do this summer the uh classroom Renovations in the 400 wing and Corridor the HVAC upgrades casework upgrades and the Boiler Room renovation will take care of in 2025 26 the same uh classroom upgrades in the 300 Wing similar HVAC upgrades and casework and we'll be adding the fitness room uh in 2026 in 2027 we'll be doing the 200 Wing the similar HVAC upgrades and casework and

024the steam tunnel demolition will be uh adding to the scope for 2025 Phase 2 begins the 27th we have a u substantial completion of August 22nd again allow and Jack plenty of time to coordinate his uh his pack and play phase three um scope of work is entirely at South Orangetown Middle School major scope of work includes classroom Renovations and HVAC upgrades for the third floor and the second floor language Wing um also a boys restroom renovation in the second floor language Wing the girls restroom adjacent to that was renovated a couple years ago so that'll bring that up up to standard um Athletic Field reconstruction which includes new softball baseball and multi-purpose fields and a walking path around the exterior um similar to the one installed at CLE this year schedule um these documents

025are currently at the State under review We just received engineering approval and we're awaiting architectural and fiscal review comments um we are anticipating bidding this in the fall of this year for contract award before the end of the year very similar to The Phase 1 and two schedules and this is a planned 2-year construction project for summer 26 and 27 talk to this as well so the High School auditorium renovation project that's our next upcoming bid um this was originally part of the phase 2 scope of work um due to the specialty theatrical nature of the project we isolated this bid scope so we are planning on posting is forbid in April um and that'll get us contracts awarded hopefully in June of this year that will be a full year before construction starts again

026theatrical um needed longer time on lead equipment sub mitts it's it's going to be great to have the contractors on board a full year ahead of time and construction is anticipated starting in June of 26 um through the end of the year December of 26 moving on to budget you want to take this one too sure um so this shows where we're at currently with the projects all of the contracts and any change orders um you'll see the majority of them have credits right now we're positive on those contracts the abatement one has a change order um so at the bottom you'll see the overall right now we're around $7,000 worth of change orders this is again for phase one so it's just mid year in the project um overall the projects look looking very

027healthy we still have healthy allowances for most of the contracts so this should even itself out um and we are we can say we're on budget right now right for phase one phase two phase two um contracts were just awarded so no change orders no change to the values but this shows where the contracts fell so total project is about 12.8 million right now that includes um the state contract Nickerson casework as well as the boiler purchase yeah considerably lower than what we what we anticipated coming in questions this silly question the 49 the $50 million Bond covers all three phases yes and that's it it's just three the break there's been a breakdown of like the 19 million for phase three those it's just not included here so oh do you have a do

028you have a summary of all you're saying or you're phase two and phas like what's the proposed breakdown of like different oh we can get you that information we do have an estimate on the um documents that are at state right now so I think we're right around Budget on that we'll get we'll get that over to Brian to send to you and then just to bring Rob to bring you up to speed a little bit on it um over this past summer we had some issues at the end of the summer getting the project done with enough time to really have the classrooms prepared for the teachers um and and we really focused in the uh facilities committee on making sure that um we do a better job going forward and so some of

029these projects that uh when they were first put together they thought they were only going to be years or years three years we've we've extended that and and and made the projects go a little bit uh longer same work but just making sure that um we don't bite more than we can chew and make sure that um at the end of the summer that the projects are done and we we don't have issues when it comes to having the the rooms prepared for the teachers big problem for us is the school has to be closed C students so we're working with a limit amount of time so we were trying to cram too much in at least it was felt that way because of miscommunications last summer so we pushed back on extending the schedule

030um it was a little bit more costly but nothing that wasn't within reason and This Way teachers will have a signif amount of time um to get back in the building there shouldn't be any issues with cleaniness Etc we shouldn't have the issue reoccur each summer that's what we're worried about yeah yeah the other question too is sorry the whole 50 the whole bond has already been passed the whole 50 20 2022 I think it was 2022 I think it was like february2 Dr Coleman the uh Auditorium renovation is part of that too I think I mentioned that was phase two funding we're just separating the bid out because of this wellon yeah I have questions about that so regarding that auditorium not till December 2026 so that means we can hold the fall play

031correct in the auditorium at the high school this year or yeah this year so what what are our next steps regarding that can we put that out please yeah so it wouldn't be for this September it would be fall of 2026 we just found out that this project was going to go beyond August so we haven't made any definitive plans but one of the ideas was we would hold the play at the middle school I wouldn't do a Justice if I summarized it but what are some of the difficulties with the auditorium renovation uh mostly it's the submittal and uh ordering process submittal and approval process uh that's probably triple what you normally would let's say for HC or electric because it's highly specialized the other the other uh uh issues are uh it's it's

032so highly specialized that there are companies several companies that do it around the country so we're dealing with a regional issue as well so uh things like getting Advance uh uh deliveries for equipment let's say if we order them in advance and we get them here they're sitting for a long long period of time these are light this lighting for instance that has computers in them the highly sensitive uh we're not sure about where the liability should be if we accept something like that um the warranty starts as soon as they deliver it so there's there's those kind of uh uh issues that come up with it um so the submitt process and the ordering process is probably what did we say 20 20 to 30 weeks yeah that's time year we're going to have

033with the contractors is going to be used up like that's it's not just dead time um and the other thing to note is it's not a general contractor for this it's a specific theatrical contractor so that's what he's referring to there's very few in the area um so that's definitely important to make sure we lock one of them in and I think the schedule like Dr Kad said we just recently you know found this out based on our tpg and cpl's other projects talking with our theatrical consultant um as soon as we have that contractor locked in in June then we'll be able to really see what they think is realistic for schedule but always just trying to make sure you're wear it maybe six or seven months we impression it was doable in the

034summer season and if is me brought this up and we discussed it a great length and I think because it's such a Nuance part of the renovation or at least the bond it's going to have to disrupt one of the plays yeah it's see on the FR as long as we have a second like the next steps for what we're going to do a contingency plan for what we're going to do for those plays in place before we even start this whole situation but it's the same with the basketball camps we're going to have to find somewhere probably through them to set up it's just everything's going to be disrupted everything's not perfect I it's a hard pill to swallow but it's just it's only going to happen and then the choice was either on

035the front end or the back end of the year and they felt like um it was very important to have graduation be uninterrupted yeah some of the other challenges are that we can't really do work in advance we can't kind of have do it and then open it again just just by the the nature I think as long as we communicate the schedule as best as possible we move things around so no the kids lose anything or excluded Any Which Way communicated out to Community as well MERS yeah and we'll discuss it in the facilities meetings as we progress and and provide anything you know that that we can I have more questions I if I may Mo schaer um the rest of the AG fact up and running is that everything that we did

036last summer the helicopters putting them on the roof I mean we're going to be fully operational by September of course well there there will be some some balancing afterwards because eight weeks just isn't enough to do everything Soup To Nuts um one thing that we're we're lacking now in both buildings and it's by Design is really the the um uh kind of the controls and brains um that that basically is installed and programmed as one so with having 70% when we install the other 30 that will happen uh by the end of the summer for sure everything will be operational then but it will not be completely um uh operational in the sense that it was designed probably for a month or two after it'll take them to balance everything out they also need to

037go through Seasons to make sure that that the system responds the way it should so we'll always be um uh adjusting after after school opens but we we try to do that uh with the least amount of least amount of visibility and we're we're sure that the the classrooms both at at all four schools will be ready to be occupied and the teachers will be able to come in by the 23rd uh yes yes uh that's substantial completion there's still some times beyond that uh that's built in as a buff substan but at the same time the teachers will be able to set up their classrooms within those 5 days because if I believe I'm looking at the calendar correctly school starts the 3D or fourth depending on what we approve I believe the teacher

038day I'm stay off the top of my head was the 26th it wasn't the date substantial corre that's right yeah because the 23rd is Saturday so that's why I'm questioning it okay so I think we left Monday because I need to come do punch list you know we had to leave time for cleaning so yeah the teachers will have at least four days to come in and prep their classrooms yes yes y solid that's a solid answer 100% as we're standing here yes all right I just want to make that's why we asked to get the classrooms back a week earlier yeah and to build your confidence hopefully a little further we have one one more week on the calendar this year than we did last year and substantially less work for the for the

039elementaries uh the high school is uh actually I proposed doing more work uh and they they paired me back so I'm very confident in in what we're doing uh the in the um in the elementary schools we're doing about a third of the work that we did last year as far as uh uh taking sections of the classroom of the of the schools we're also uh employing a much better um uh permanent barrier uh system the schools will actually be open all year except for the small areas that we're working as long as these teachers can get in there and make sure they're set up for Yes incoming year and they don't have to come in on their on times if they're not contract it's really just that punch list day that's why it's not

040the day after the contractor out because the CRI did punch list while they were literally unpacking which was frustrating yeah you know again the August 23rd date it's a Saturday it's not a business day so right so they'll be out of there then I'll plan to be here that Monday I'll plan to be here that Sunday yes you will you can drive by and you'll see me I work weekends maybe too actually thank you thanks for the question thank you guys I just had one quick question uh The Outdoor Classroom at TZ have we gotten anywhere with a drink issues have we the uh contractor made a couple of um a couple of propositions to correct it uh in talking to Greg and Natalie we're we're probably just going to go to them going with

041the original design uh there's nothing wrong with the the system now it's just not what you paid for uh and some of the options they gave us weren't really weren't really coming close so we we feel more comfortable just going back and and saying hey you got to do what's on the drawing so we'll make that that clear to them and and then we'll come up with a schedule for the uh for the warm weather thank you allor right one last question for you uh I love the new Cottage land entrance I think it makes more sense logistically to be the focal point the center of the school I love it y um my question for you and maybe you could better explain it than than I could is we're going to do some more

042work on the entry way and what was that in regards to in regard to uh I mentioned you mean in my presentation yes the entry way explain that better the updates we're going to do the old entry way uh we're we're we're putting a resource room in there and and uh uh actually growing combining the three rooms okay so the current small resource room off to the last and then the room in the front that's sort of storage I think where there's an old coiling door that wall will be so all both of those and part of the corridor will be one big bigger resource room right that won't change the access to the hallway at all no it's just where that person where the greater used to said oh yes I remember there's little

043that be reduced no it looks great thank you thanks oh the U there'll be a new service there as well new electrical service which we're excited to finally see the in all right thank you I appreciate you guys being here thanks folks Thank You by right you're up all right all right so before I begin I um Mr Sanson I want to thank you for sharing your comments and your thoughts um about the um achievement levels in the district um I can assure you teachers and principls are working TIR tirelessly um every day to to address those those concerns uh just as a very quick uh story this morning I was at in Cottage Lane uh meeting with the fourth grade teachers with the math instructional coach and it was kind of was just like

044a very good snapshot of the work that's happening every single day um in all of our schools um our math instructional coach was presenting uh to our uh fourth grade teacher some data that provided by Miss corkran um from our our most recent math assessments state math assessments and so the the point of the of the the focus of the meeting was to provide teachers with some examples of questions items that students scored well on or scored poorly on um and then to making you know teachers aware of so these are the students that they had last year um but these are reflection of the you know the fourth grade math curriculum um so in live time teachers were brainstorming ideas about how to U Better address that how to talk to teachers the the

045coach was providing resources um and providing plans for you know for how teachers can address those types of things so I just thought again just you know as as a result of your uh uh comments just to provide a a small very small you know example of some of the the the work that our teachers principes instructional coaches are doing um every single day in um in all four of our our schools um so again thank you for for sharing your thoughts um so for the um the the presentation tonight um some of this is just an overview and you know you you've heard some of these pieces in um last year um so I'm not going to go into tremendous detail on a lot of it I'll spend more time talking about uh the

046curriculum review process and the impact on the budget reading is something that we've talked about um recently so I'll I'll kind of use that as a um an example to highlight some of the uh the presentation so just kind of uh looking at the uh office of curriculum instruction the office of curriculum instruction uh really kind of Acts you know or or uses these five guiding principles um in our work um so it's one ensuring faculty members have the resources and the support to develop their Student Center Les lessons and units of study uh that example I just provided was uh you know one kind of example of that um with uh miss corran's work and our instructional coaches working with teachers to to uh provide those resources and to uh have those conversations it's

047also an example of uh meaningful professional learning opportunities for faculty members so that they can continually develop their content knowledge and their instructional practice again that that very small example I provided does talk about some of the professional learning and and by having a chance to participate and listen to the conversations that were happening this morning um you saw the um and heard the teachers kind of you know absorbing that in real time and then really talking about where they can make adjustments in their instruction um and their use of the curriculum in this case math um continue to build internal capacity to lead that professional learning right so that more of us are having those conversations about how we uh seek to improve um how we manage uh the the change process um and

048how we work with students so that they can meet those uh high expectations to empower the principles and assistant principles so that they can lead their buildings effectively right like you know looking at the principal and the assistant principle as uh leaders in their building not just to manage the building but also to be leading some of those conversations around curriculum and instruction and then um budget wise is to look for efficiencies in our budget to accomplish all of the above um right so it's not the type of thing where you can consensually add add add U but it's looking for ways that if our focus is in one area we want to make sure that we are uh really evaluating everything that we do in the office so that we can find those efficiencies

049this is just an overview of the you know the four main categories that the office um is involved in um so you have Core Curriculum I will I'm not going to go through every single uh piece of the the the four areas but the Core Curriculum that's the curriculum that every uh student uh is exposed to and there's a variety of different supports there um so that we are uh working with teachers and principles so that students can access that Core Curriculum um one of the things that we've talked about also recently is that well-rounded education and we take a lot of pride in South Orangetown of providing our students with a variety of different um opportunities so that they get Beyond The Core Curriculum and not just the minimum um so some examples there

050you'll see examples at every single building whether it's the electives at the high school the explore classes at the middle school um the enrichments at WIlliam Mo schaer and Cottage Lane our subn programming a variety of those things um to provide that well-rounded education that professional development um that I just mentioned in the initial slide uh using our internal capacity coaches team leaders our leadership teams doing instructional rounds where we're visiting each other's classrooms and providing feedback working with Dr Lloyd's office on the new teacher orientation and providing um our newest faculty members the um induction and support so that they can successfully acclimate to the expectations of the district and then some of our you know Partnerships outside whether that's through Consultants the tri-states cons Consortium which is our accreditation organization um and then

051just putting all that together with our professional development committee and having a a broad broad range of offerings for uh principes and teachers to access and then Early Learning we've we've spent a lot of time over the past couple of years talking about uh upk um obviously the the class at schaer is a I think as Miss Corbell pointed out last meeting a point of Pride um in the district but also managing our relationships with um bosis who helps us oversee all the other providers um and then really kind of making sure that um all of our our youngest students um are having a quality experience whether they're in schaer or in one of our uh providers that we contract with throughout the county so those are the really the four main categories um that

052we uh are involved in throughout the uh in the office so I'll spend a little bit of time here we've we've spent some time talking about reading and I can kind of put in some like some real time uh examples here so right now we're in the the we're doing this constantly different areas and sometimes the um depending on where our focus is um we're currently doing this with our math and our Ela programs at the elementary school um I'll talk a little bit more about math on in the next slide but I'll I'll use this to kind of highlight some of the stuff about um where we are with our our reading program so we're currently in the in the review uh phase of the um of the curriculum review process with our reading

053program so as you see there that's really looking at a a variety of different things collecting data looking at some of those those State scores analyzing our current curriculum analyzing our current approach uh in the last board meeting I talked about some of the things that we've done in order to do that uh Dr kulot referenced the the New York state literacy guide which you know the state is really expecting everyone to use uh in order to do an evaluation of their approach to reading um and so where we are currently right now um is we are kind of like towards the end of that that Pink Arrow at the top um so we spent some time oh my time's up uh for a minute now you have you have three more minutes okay all

054right all right I I just fast forward it's to 4:30 tomorrow morning when I had I have to wake up to run around Rockin Lake like a maniac um so the uh we're lost my TR okay so we're using the night New York state literacy guide uh to review our current practice and I had a meeting with uh the principes at Cottage Lane and William O schaer and our our Ela coaches earlier this week to set our timeline for the next step of that which is really the biggest step um and it's the one that a lot of people are you know have have been asking about lately so we've identified like three com three really buckets and I think I I said this in the last meeting so forgive me if I'm repeating myself

055phonics word study and overall reading program uh so what we have done is we've collected a number uh a list of other programs in those three specific areas and so at the end of February and the beginning of March we'll be bringing those different programs in uh we were just uh working again with the principles uh earlier this week to design a protocol um we do not want to just leave it to a small group um or to uh one or two people to make this decision so we have developed a a Proto developed a protocol um so that all teachers in cottage and William O shaer will have an opportunity uh to give feedback on these other programs um using a a rubric based off the New York state literacy guide um which again

056is is is aligned with the the science of reading among a number of other things um in addition to what teachers we've spent some time going to team meetings um uh all grade levels at at William O shaer and Cottage Lane and listening to the teachers about where they see the deficiencies in our current approach where they see the streng in our current approach and what they would like to see moving forward um so we kind of have collected all of that information and then we'll use that to evaluate we evaluated our our current approach and then we'll use that to evaluate um other options that are out there um so that will happen at the end of February um we have a date for uh to look at phonics and word study uh with

057the teachers and these other programs and then March 6th I believe um is when we will bring in the reading programs and follow the same protocol so that all teachers in those buildings um are giving us feedback so then we'll be at the point uh of the adoption of curriculum um so depending on what the feedback is from the The Faculty um is that we were are will then make a decision on um an adoption uh of what curriculum we would adopt um and you know it's interesting so if you would ask obviously I'm I'm new to this um reading conversation having been a a high School person um and I've always been kind of like you know hedging my my bets of if we make a change if we make a change um but

058the more that I speak to our our faculty it it becomes clearer that um it seems like there's going to be some type of change what that change will be is still to determined because I think we still have to go through that that rest of the review process um but listening to the faculty and as I've kind of you know had more of these conversations uh it's become clearer um where I don't feel like you know it has to be if if if I think it's to the point now where it's um you know the faculty have been pretty clear uh that there are some things that they want that we don't currently have um so we'll be then in that adoption phase um and then once we do that so then it goes

059into the next two phases which will again by making the decision in early March that gives us the rest of March April and May um to start to talk about professional development talk about about what the teachers will need uh to make those adjustments or to implement something new if it is something new um and then also using so we want to use as much of the rest of the school year as possible even though it's an extremely busy time for teachers um because once you know um the summer comes is it's not part of the you know the the contractual year for our faculty but we do have many many teachers who do participate in professional development and curriculum writing over the summer so we of course would use that uh me mechanism and

060that that is part of the the budget as well um and that is kind of those two last you know curriculum writing professional development um are really kind of they're aligned right so because those two parts that where U we're preparing the teachers to implement a new curriculum and then it also should be ongoing that professional development should be ongoing because obviously the first time you do something is is not always the best and you want to make sure that we're providing those things and troubleshooting things as they come up um last is the implementation right so that would be September and so Dr kolad has mentioned a couple of times I believe that um uh right after the break Miss beglin and I attended a meeting uh facilitated at Rockin bosies which was hosted

061by the New York State education department is as as of September 1st 2025 superintendents in every district will have to do an ATT attestation in the uh business portal that we are meeting the science of reading in our science in our reading approach K through three um and so I think that is another important date to look at there and another important you know factor that is um playing a role in this as well so just kind of going to the last I'll um I'm going to jump down to the third bullet so for Budget implications for the um office of curriculum instruction um is obviously we need to prepare for a potential change this could be a very expensive change um and I've you know had conversations with uh the business office about this

062so that's something that we need to be prepared for it really is curricular wise the the major um potential expenditure in the curriculum office budget so math I just want to come back to that we have we're completing this this process in math as well um we have had conversations with teachers and with principles and our instructional coaches that the reading would take precedence over for that so we're still completing that math review um so that we're ready after uh any potential changes in ela are implemented we are ready for um potential math changes as well that um process is still ongoing as well so I um depending on what that potential change could be so but the budget would um be built to support the reading um first then going back up to the

063top bullets you heard from the principles last week about the potential potential addition of a of an enl teacher this would have an impact on soms and Schaefer um who currently share um uh one of their uh enl teachers we've talked a lot about addressing class size now not necessarily does that mean an addition of Staff um but it could be looking for efficiencies it could be uh looking for ways that we can save um and potentially add a section um or add a teacher without having to add one to the budget if that makes sense and look for those efficiencies uh curriculum and right this is a very minor one but this is one that recently came up at curriculum Council the high school is advocating for a um a chemistry course to try

064to keep more kids uh taking chemistry um so that is a um a potential again small comparatively to some of the other things we spoke about um in in chemistry at the high school we want to make sure that we're maintaining our current summer programs we've seen um we've talked about in the past our reduction of of title funding so our summer programs have come more and more into our general fund whereas they during covid they were 100% funded um by uh grant money that money has gone away so we've absorbed some of that those costs many of those costs into the general fund and again going to that well-rounded education giving kids those opportunities during the summer um also enrichments at the elementary school uh building those things that program has only grown especially

065a Cottage Lane so I want to make sure that we support that um looking at how we use Consultants um and you know I think I've spoken my last uh last year's meeting about kind of pushing the pendulum back to relying on um internal folks but still using Consultants where um there's a value there and then curriculum writing as I spoke about in the um the curriculum review process so that our teachers have time um so that they are making curricular adjustments because that's you know teachers do that every sing single day and every single year as they're you know again going back to the math example that I led with making those adjustments sometimes on the Fly and sometimes in a little bit more of an intentional organized way uh through curriculum writing over

066the summer um so I will now turn over to Dr Tess um who will talk about her office thank you good evening thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak about the uh budget outlook for PPS so a brief overview of what is people Personnel Services um I always remind people that our department is seven years young um I can't say that I guess as of next year but we're very excited that um we literally have built out a department that really takes all of the student services and brings them together and gets them to literally aligned to do the best that we can for our students every day um I won't go through every single one of those bullets but throughout the Journey of building this department we have sought efficiencies um and

067I think you'll see that when we get to the slide about bud budget implications but it does we do oversee counseling nursing registration family engagement we see oversee everything related to special education including school psychologist speech otpt um and certainly the placement of students both in District programs and in out of District programs as well as 504 in addition to that my office is responsible to work closely within our community to identify students who qualify under bikini vento or homeless uh people sometimes are shocked by that I I use the term in our community here that we have a lot of hidden poverty you would not know that and keep in mind that even when a family um has the tragic loss of a house fire and they lose their home uh that qualifies them

068for a period of time uh under mckin vinto as well we also cover foster care and community supports our relationships with the candle uh organization coming in and doing free counseling services for all students here at the middle school and the high school um um and a whole bunch of other community supports that we try to bring in to wrap around services for our students the major piece that drives the PPS budget is special education every year I provide this snapshot to uh to the Board of Education Community about what do our numbers look like so as you can see and and we've seen a significant Spike postco um with regard to uh referrals to special education keep in mind that referrals to special education are not just in the sense of um parents coming

069parents that are in the district that have lived here and now they're referring we sometimes look at people who move here whose students have active IEPs and by law we must meet that IEP so I think the numbers don't always tell the stories the way I want them to tell um you'll see that we have a slight decline in cpsc or preschool Services um not significant but it is a bit of a decline but we do have a significant increase in our special education students work K through 12 keep in mind that when I say 12th grade that we host a very unique program here in our um tapy high school we have something called our co- program which actually houses students until the age of 21 uh and those are students that typically would

070then transition to uh job placement Services through the office of people with developmental disabilities um they get job coaches and and all sorts of things they're an amazing part of our high school so I just share that because those numbers literally go from uh cpsc all the way up to the age of 21 so it's a it's a quite a large pool of students when it comes to the impact on budget um it really is flatlined in the sense that our budget primarily is being driven by the needs of our students um we are not asking for any additional mental health Andor prevention Staffing at this point um we're grateful uh for the community organizations that provide free counseling to our students and then help help us refer them to permanent therapist if needed um

071our school counseling levels we're maintaining our school nursing levels we were maintaining um two years ago we merged our family engagement coordinator position with the office of registration um there was a retirement in the registration office so we shifted it so that we could begin a full onboarding process with our families through that um merger if you might I think we've gotten a lot of positive feedback about how people especially those that are not part of the K registration but maybe coming in in January they just bought a house here or um any grade other than K would really feel like they're being introduced to the community through our family engagement coordinator AJ Walker so again I'm very grateful for that the only thing I'm I'm seeking in this budget is to remove the mail

072room responsibilities that fall in the office of PPS um because as you know although we had declining enrollment our registration numbers are still pretty high and as you see the special ed numbers are high and we are seeing some significant uh impact on our clerical so we're looking just to see if we can do some shifting of responsibilities it's not a in any way shape or form a request for additional uh FTE in that place in that uh resource with regard to special education we are one of the few school districts that continue to support students all the way through high school and I think that's very important to note we are proud to say that through the efforts we have made on Fu to be fully inclusive and supportive of all students to reach

073their highest potentials we have started working with the high school two years ago to identify students who need special education services but that are challenging the upper level courses um whether it be their third year of regent math or chemistry so we've begun to do co- te on a 3x6 model or an every other day model we anticipate that we will have more students chall alling those higher level classes um by the results that we're seeing which is amazing we are looking to explore based upon the projections just process-wise uh the way Special Education Works is for every single student all 500 that you just saw that have an IEP in this District we have a tremendous uh obligation to meet with every teacher to look at their data based upon trimester one or quarter

074one and make a projection as to where we think they'll go in the spring of this year or next year and we capture that uh for the purposes of budget we then meet in January so we are currently we just finished meeting with William oer yesterday we met with Cottage Lane last week we are looking to expand the Continuum of services at our elementary schools what does that mean uh we may be looking to add special classes for special subjects uh to William O shaer Endor Cottage Lane again this is all under review we're dealing with children and there parents have an active voice at the csse where these decisions are made but that may impact um FTE needs at the elementary school as heard by our principes at the last budget Workshop we are

075asking that Occupational Therapy Services which are currently being contracted through Rockland bosies be brought in District meaning that we will take the money out of what I put in my Bose's budget for occupational therapy and through the help of Natalie's Wizardry figure out how we move that over effectively uh into the general fund so that we can uh have a full-time occupational therapy on our staff the reason we're seeking that is because then that person uh becomes available to us as part of our um independent contracts to do work with our students over the summer to do help with our parents to attend SEPTA meetings right now uh we don't have that OT doing that it's a Bose's employee in addition to that I always ask for contingency positions um as the housing market changes

076or stays stable we never quite know who's going to uh arrive at our door um any student can arrive with an active IEP or students coming from out of New York will sometimes arrive without an IEP but need services so we always ask for contingency positions and again just so that we have any unexpected changes built into the budget and of course we expect the annual increases in our our Rockland Bose's budgets and our private placements and when I say private placements those are New York State approved private placements uh through the New York State education department last but not least um we are seeing an increased request in our parent population to do what's called iees or independent educational evaluations specifically neuros psychologicalscience iCal report will give us greater depth into various um needs

077strengths um and help us build a stronger learning profile if we're having a student whose needs um or whose progress is not being to the level that we expected to um we have board policy that governs this um we'll be looking to update the regulation side of that with regard to um 2025 rates um and we'll continue to do that and then of course although Mr ariet is office oversees homeschooled students parents who choose to homeschool um according to New York state regulations and it's been the case now more than before um any student who's homeschooled who has an active IEP does get service by the district so we have had to set up um contract agreements with agencies to provide speech OT and PT outside uh our regular classrooms and now we'll turn it

078over to Dr lloy for thank you Dr Tessy good evening board trustees good to see everyone the Human Resources office oversees several major areas including compliance employee accountability contract implementation recruitment hiring and Staffing and policies and procedures for this evening I really want to share how we go about looking ahead to the budget process um before I do that just want to share that we try to Anchor our work in policy 9,000 Personnel goals and policy 9240 recruiting and hiring that really drives our long range planning in the Human Resources office we have three overarching goals that are connected to those particular policies including leveraging practices that enhance our recruitment processes um facilitating actionable feed uh feedback and dialogue between our administrators and staff through performance reviews and attendance reviews and really we see our

079office has a place to support our faculty and staff we want to be a very responsive office and we'll talk about how we go about being better at that each year this is a cycle and when we talk about the budget process from a human resources perspective we kind of look at it in two different ways how can our office support the overall District budgeting process and how do we think about our budget process as as an HR office so the first perspective I'll talk about how we try to support the district's overall budgeting process and I'm just going to step back a couple of months when we came back into the school year in the fall one of the first things our office started doing was setting up meetings with our building leaders and

080our department leaders and we visited them September October November and we wanted to make sure that we were accurately accounting for our staff and FTE and making sure that the way we're paying our folks are connected to the appropriate funding sources during those conversations with our building and department leaders we also like to get a sense as to their visioning and what they're looking to accomplish not only in the next school year but in the future school years and that's where we'll collect information about what they're looking to do in their buildings and we'll bring that back to conversations and you might recall board Trust at the last budget Workshop our building leaders and our department leaders actually shared notes regarding what they're looking to accomplish in the 25 26 year and there after um

081on the left here when we're considering we're just about we're at um late January early February the recruitment cycle really starts in late February early March but what's kind of neat is a couple years ago uh working really collaboratively with our teachers union and our Board of Education we were able to integrate What's called the retirement notification program and essentially what that means is on the second Friday of every January our teachers those teachers who plan to retire on June 30th of that school year they notify Dr kot's office and that helps us in a couple different ways because now as of uh January 28th we have a really good sense as to those teachers who will be leaving us and we're not even in February yet um so for the 2425 school year we

082anticipate that we'll have two elementary teachers uh retire two music teachers one school counselor one science physics teacher one social studies teacher and one technology education teacher and that information is quite beneficial for a couple different reasons one we could now start talking about those positions that we absolutely need to fill um if we need to fill the technology education position I could camp out at sunnio and see if we could find some outstanding applicants um but that'll be a conversation we have we also could talk about repurposing some of those positions for other needs at the build bu or Department levels and lastly in some cases we might even consider holding or abolishing positions to um notice savings for the district and now we're going to be heading into the recruitment process uh early

083March into April and May uh all eyes will be on the district's annual budget vote and as we look at this particular HR cycle the goal is always that we hope we have all our teaching and administrative positions filled uh towards the end of the summer and then we bring up folks back uh in August and fall and I think Ry mentioned this a little bit earlier we'll have an orientation program we'll get our folks set up we really when we talked about uh policies 9000 9240 earlier we really do try to go about recruiting folks from a coup couple different ways and resources I'm not going to go through all the resources but those positions that have arrows next to them seem to be our our core um resources that we use in the

084HR office uh contacting local Regional and state colleges uh internal postings there's number of times where we have a great um faculty or staff member who's waiting to go into another position of District so sometimes the best people are right there with us uh we'll go to local Regional and state job fairs and I'll talk about that in a few moments and then we use What's called the putam North and West Chester online application system it's commonly referred to as Olas for positions uh so this spring I'll be heading over to new PO for the Mid Hudson teacher recruitment day on March 19th and followed by that I'll be uh at my almaa at Sunni Court on March 20th for the central New York teacher recruitment day um in on Saturday of March 29th we

085have the uh I'm on the lower Hudson Council of school personel administrators we have a virtual educator job there Mr ariet and Dr Tess are going to join me we're going to look to recruit some individuals through that fair and then we'll also visit our local colleges in this case we usually have an open invitation with St Thomas aquinus College to visit their education career fair and the the the great thing about these opportunities they're really they're nominal fees they're not costing us a lot of money it's really just costing us time and meeting lots of applicants it's not really expensive so that's kind of how we go about in HR trying to support the district's budgeting process and then when we talk about how we look about our own process in the Human Resources

086Department I talked a little bit earlier about the three goals that we have as a team we want to can always be um enhancing our recruitment processes bringing the best people into South Orangetown we want to Foster feedback between our administrators faculty and staff and we want to be responsive to our faculty and staff so what I've outlined here is not our entire HR budget but I would say the core drivers of the work we're trying to accomplish in HR and I'll just go them go through them real briefly um right now we're in the process we talked about this last year we're in the process of trying to get away from paper uh when we evaluate all of our different units we have lots of paper uh in HR we want to move to

087electronic platform so we're looking to move uh to the Frontline evaluation module we think we'll find a lot of efficiencies with that move um we've also my office oversees the equity Coalition and last year we partnered with NYU um to unpackage New York State education Department's cultur responsive sustaining framework and we had 25 teachers administrators in cohort one and we're getting ready to start our second cohort this year and really that work enables us to better understand ourselves as individuals better understand other people's perspectives and really best meet our children and students as they come into our school system or come into our schools um so this was interesting The Envision Employee Self-Service Portal George and I are working on that right now last year Board of Education you might recall we had a a

088community climate survey but um the team was kind enough to give us a human resources section so I can get specific feedback from faculty and staff and one of the things our staff said to us is you know G whiz we're a little Antiquated um but what I mean by that is right now a lot of our faculty and staff members will reach out to me in order to understand what their attendance acrs are what their benefits are what they're getting paid on a bi-weekly basis and we're in 2025 we we should be able to have our staff access that information in real time from their cell phones um so right now we use what's called The Envision Human Resources program there is a patch or a tool that enables District to have staff connect

089to their attendance benefits and pay um and George and I are exploring that together right now so I don't have a price in that but we're Consulting together to to make that a reality we heard our staff we're trying to get there um a couple years ago we integrated background checks that's been going excellent background checks with our fingerprint process so that's a standing budget and right now at the tapen high school we have it's essentially a teacher apprenticeship program it's called today's students tomorrow's teachers it's commonly referred to as TST um so that kind of represents our budget and the drivers of our office and I think at this time uh Mr AR Dr Tess are ready for any questions that the board might have about our particular office thank you uh so first

090I just want to thank the three of you for a very thoughtful comprehensive presentation I know it takes a lot of time to put these together uh to have three central office administrators present in one night on all of what you cover in a short period of time was a lot to ask so I really appreciate you being concise I won't go over some of the highlights I took in my notes at this time I will open it up to the board for any questions or comments um maybe I'll start so one thing I didn't say is you know my my two things so that I want to focus on joining the board are and I think they were actually both touched on in your presentation but very good presentations but um the like the

091hidden poverty and the the reading so and how do I attack those two things I think I want to make a taxpayer friendly budget and I want to improve the reading in the district or at least try to do that particularly because one of my kids uh is struggling with with reading so um I and I heard and I'm this is this is my position as a board member I'm not sure if other board members will take this position but one thing and especially if I'm going to try to really pour my my skill set into helping with the budget would be I heard the comment that uh know switching to a new reading system might have a big price tag and while we we've heard the words like we're looking for efficiencies across the

092board and because we're everyone's budgets are tight uh I think that's one area where we should be making the decision and in my opinion even if we had to go into find funds from somewhere else is we should be making the decision that to the switch to the reading program not because one costs 100,000 and one cost 200,000 because we're the the difference in the cost should not should not be the driving Factor so I want to be sure that we're picking the right program even if we have to quote unquote overspend slightly now me as a fiscally conservative guy to say overspend that's hard for me to say especially if I'm joining the board saying I'm trying to be as tax Fender you know taxpayer friendly as possible um but that's the one sort

093of area uh from the reading that let's let's pick the right one and we'll think about how we can pay for it somewhere else especially if the curriculum unit is getting a block grant and I don't want the the curriculum team to be like well now we're over budget because we picked this larger reading program the board will like see and when we're doing the full budget digestion that like we understand why everyone made the decision we're picking this reading program because it's the best and then it's on us to figure out how we're actually going to pay for it and we're not going to try to pick this you know the B option because it's 100 Grand cheaper that's just not or that that's not how I would proceed and once this sort of

094thing like I I know when you and I you and I met that you're really trying to go for the fall implementation but I just want to make sure like there's a time like it it was a little bit opaque for the the larger audience here about the projected timeline of the switching to a new now I appreciate you're still in a process of and this is a very long-winded question sorry I might run out of time but maybe just want to my question would be is like can you just comment on the timeline with all of that all of the things that I've just said in in my yeah so um we would want to so we're obviously and I i' I've said this before about the you know with a curriculum review you

095want as much time as possible to evaluate as much data as possible and in a budget process you have a condensed amount of time um so I think it's it's working with the business office to build in the the money that we would need in order to to make that decision um and then just to really put dates on it um we've spent the time uh evalu in our current uh program we've been receiving the the the feedback from the the state and attending the required meetings with the state and so at the end of February February 26th um is that we would bring in um other programs for phonics um which really impacts William O schaer uh word study which would impact Cottage Lane um we would take our teachers through a a protocol

096to review those programs um and then so we can make some decisions the following week March 6 um is our standing date for our Ela leadership uh Team I as I said I don't want to just put this on the the you know dozen or so folks who are on the ELA leadership want as many teachers as possible to have a voice in that process so again we would have a protocol where we would bring vendors in um to do presentations uh to so that they could talk about and teachers could ask and we would have a a tool that they could use to evaluate that and so then after that March 6 date we would be ready to make that decision um and then that would give us the time to to do those

097other things that you mentioned about the the roll out communication um training all those different types of things that whatever you know came with those different programs just so as I understand like the cost would not be a like if we made the switch on the reading program VI one time yeah many programs uh it's there are some smaller costs that are annual but the big what I was referring to of potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars would be to buy the materials and then you might have some ongoing costs if there's um if there's workbooks and things like that that you'd have to buy every year but it would be nowhere near you know the the big number that I mentioned earlier and just to add on to that there on the rubric used

098to evaluate the programs there is no cost consideration they're just looking at what the programs offer cost will not be a factor as far as determining which program gets chosen okay hang out minute y right so can you just help me out for a second understand why other districts particularly nette whose program I pulled because I was concerned why we're not implementing any other programs in our Pro in the reading program that we have here doing right now strictly we're using PC strictly not strictly are we using heg for phic awareness that's but when but perer uses heg in kindergarten and first and I believe they use bridging BR Gap bridging gaps okay older or as an intervention we're not doing any of that are are we can you yeah so there's a variety of

099different programs that we use as interventions so but if they're using in prer I'm just using perver as an example because that's the information I got I'll preface it with I'm not no knowledge about every single thing that does I don't understand why if we have teachers trained in heg or in bridging gaps or in phonics because all you know teachers come from all different you know backgrounds and and different educations why aren't we implementing them into the reading program so last year um so as if also just cave just and it shouldn't cost us much shouldn't cost shouldn't be a big budget item okay for having these teachers Implement that are already trained in these programs correct they they already cost as much buying a reading program not buying a reading program implementing their

100programs or asking them to teach the kids how to read and write because that's why forever does it well you're saying expanding from kindergarten to first like yeah I mean heg has got a B and C for my understanding programs why I mean these teachers are not just taught in heg they taught in AB andc the programs right I think I think um I think per River uses an Orton Gillingham program they also do that as well Orton Gillingham is usually only used or was only used for students with dyslexia but they're finding that it's PR it's making right these kids read because some kids fail in certain areas so why aren't we introducing that program when we have teachers train Norton gilam or hegerty why aren't we implementing that now so I think I

101think there's a couple of different things um so one is so last year in my first year um of this um in this position one of the things that I learned was that there have been a lot of different adjustments that teachers have made over the course which I highlighted in uh last week's or last um board meeting's presentation um and so I think some of the things that I spoke about in the beginning of like there's teachers are making adjustments every single day every single year they're making adjustments based on the kids who are sitting in front of them and so some of the things that the the buildings have done um of introducing hegr using different phonics assessments um focusing on you know word study at at Cottage Lane um um Miss beglan

102and Mr Galvin making phonics the focus of their observations last year at William O schaer where every single teacher was being observed on how they taught phonics there's I think um I tried to allude to this in in the last um presentation that I did two weeks ago is there's an element of when you start to make those adjustments and teachers are making those adjustments based on their their training or based on adjustments that we're making uh across the board is you you need to give that some room to breathe to see if what you're doing is is working um so I think as we went through last year was to kind of see if those things are working and many of them are um but I think also there's also um you want to

103also manage so for example New York State coming out with the the literacy guide and really kind of putting um charging all districts to look at their reading program and evaluating their full approach so then that is what led into to this year and as I said you know in the in my presentation if you would have asked me and I was very you know I think some some people got frustrated with me of like in the beginning of this process it was always if we make a change because we were at the beginning of that process um because last year we wanted to see if those tweaks that the teacher and the principles we're making we're working this year now and and again some of them are and I think there there would be

104some people who would Advocate to give that more time but I think it's at that time so now if you ask me are we going to make a change I've definitely shift from if to when now it's just a matter of figuring out what that change looks like um so I think that's to kind of give some of those changes that teachers and principles make give them some time to breathe and to see if those adjustments are working that would be my answer to your question about why we didn't do those changes last year um and then what was the second part of the question I'm sorry what programs are we implementing at this time what's that what programs are we implementing at this time intervention wise just let's start with phic awareness that's in

105kindergarten kindergarten and first and second grade for any kids that still need it and in first and second grade for any kids that didn't meet The Benchmark at the have to go for intervention correct but in the TC which TC phonic right um so then the word love um and I wish my miss beglin and miss Dr scur here because all the names are always Escape me um and then there's our interventions of Wilson Reading Sunday I'm sorry just go back so in general General without any intervention it's TC phonics and word love word love and then there's the um uh the the units of study the TC units of study for reading and writing so we're still unit using unit study TC College all that why are other districts implementing other programs in their

106General Ed not as an intervention I can't speak to why other districts are but if it's working and they're excelling in those areas why aren't we looking at that we have teachers that are trained in those programs why aren't we utilizing them so again I think I would go back to my first answer was that the teachers and the principles have made adjustments um in their approach um and then giving that those those changes is an opportunity to see if those changes are effective but this has been going on since 2020 I believe is when they started coming out with the directives of changing the program and here we are in 2025 and we have not made any changes or added anything in as this as a unfortunately you know I can't speak to 2020

107or you know prior before last year about why I didn't make changes and can you tell me how many kids students currently are being uh are r I'd have to look that up and I can put that in the board report can we can you put it in the board report for each grade level who's RTI who's being pushed to RTI okay I have more questions but you're not I think you're good okay next one's for Dr scarf Dr Scar's not here I'm sorry Dr Tusk Karen are you able to give me the number of IEP students uh currently possibly within each grade I mean you could you could go within each grade I could pull those out can you put them in the boorder report for y I can th and as well as

108504 students um and as well as referrals so valuations last year we Lori and I look at this as part of building the budget for contingency positions for those unknowns so last year uh we had about 69 to 70 referrals for initials which is very high you don't like a average grate level or sure so uh if I had to look at the statistics quickly typically we get more than 50% K through five and then the next level would be the middle school and then the high schools usually within the single digits we don't get a lot of the high school um in reviewing this year's data because it's something the teachers always ask us to do at this time of the year too to say Karen as we build these sections so why I

109always ask for contingency positions uh to date we've had 30 initial meetings this year um with again close to 50% being at the elementary school which is again very common that's not that's not new I just want to be clear on that it is very common that we get initials at the elementary school for obvious reasons um and then the middle school and then the high school um we did see a unique um Trend in reviewing this data so far this year and that in the Middle School referrals for initials um we're getting referrals that are not in up in classification which is a good thing um that just happened to be unique this year but we should get those on the RTI numbers right if they're yes so some of those students right so

110there there's two ways students get referred to the CSC one is through the art so the RTI team in the building um brings the child that has been receiving RT RTI services for several years they'll bring that data up to the csse table not the CSE the child study team let me get the right acronym um they'll do uh looking at student work protocol they'll ask questions and then we actually have a a full-fledged referral in-house that says you know here's the leg work we've done in this child we're not seeing the progress that we expect uh we think we should um typically Lori and I then call and have a team meeting with them that says you know let's go over your data what about this what about this what about this um we

111rule out if there is an ADHD component uh especially at the secondary levels if we know that there's other um physical social emotional and mental health issues that my office may be aware of that may not be common knowledge for other reasons uh we'll rule those out um and then we reach out to the parent and say you know we received a referral for your child so this year we're we've done 30 of those so halfway through the year we're right on target to hit the same amount we typically get a spike and referrals um get second right as we're doing annual reviews we see the spike um and so that's what we're looking for as well okay if you could possibly try those numbers yep we have we have them ready to go because

112the projection books are done so I can just peel those out for you and do you want them both in District and out of District that would be great that would be great so we could break it down I I just have before anybody else ask any questions I you're good um I just have one more comment currently in the state of Massachusetts I'm sure everybody's aware they're suing the the TC College I don't I just want to make sure that we're ahead of the this because it's only going to happen here soon it could be a federal class action in the end but I just want to make sure we're getting ahead of it and we need to start implementing something to get ahead of it it's just going to happen we all know

113absolutely and the timeline that Mr aretta shared I think shows that we are going to be making a decision very soon and making a change typically in this District over the years whether it was uh aligning to science standards a new science program when we implemented Turk investigations at the elementary level there's a process that we go through to evaluate our existing program to look at new programs to provide professional development and Implement a new program so if there are other districts that may seem like they're further ahead that may be the case it doesn't necessarily mean the implementation is being done the way that we would do it with Fidelity and consistency across grades and across classrooms um so we are where we are we did stop working with Teachers College two years ago

114we have no contracts with them we don't do any professional development with them and we haven't purchased materials we haven't sent teachers for training we haven't had consultants in the district so we did make that change uh two years ago and now we're in the process of implementing something new we also implemented hagy phonics and and made some other adjustments phonics is only being used in kindergarten and as an intervention correct just to make sure that I'm it's Core Curriculum in kindergarten yeah in kindergarten but it's not is it being used as an intervention for first and second grade yes so we will be in alignment with the science of reading uh by September we will have changes in the curriculum we'll have uh professional development for teachers we'll have summer curriculum hours in place

115and we will be implementing it uh I think in a very thoughtful and careful way with input from all of the teachers that it's going to impact I think we're skipping over sorry I think we're missing a key fact here that the governor has made the state move towards the signs of reading we're one of 10 states without any type of law passed with signs of reading so it's not like we had a choice it's not like we were progressing towards this on our own we're basically being forced to do this relate to the party that's what I think our concern is and that's why we're trying to make a ground right now so I don't think that us saying we're getting ahead of it we're trying to be you know I guess fixed the

116problem in real time we're we're kind of reacting to the state at this point I think that needs to be said out loud I mean 10 states out of the 50 and do not have laws and we're going to be hopefully one of the 10 that are left this this September I would just say that we are where we are in our curriculum review cycle prior to the state coming out saying that we had it be in compliance by September so we hit a buzzer beater essentially that's what you're saying I'm just saying it's not reactionary well then you're telling me that Teachers College wasn't picked up in two years we're continuing to use it so I don't know how to gauge that answer I think there's a disconnect and we're gonna have to have

117a sit down and discuss the curriculum moving forward because I think we're we're asking questions we're not getting the answers that we're hoping for um I think that there needs to be a larger discussion moving forward because there's definitely some confusion and we're getting different answers that just are not adding up I think that uh it's a bit confusing sorry I have one I have one sort of other question question I'm like always a 30,000 foot guy so it seems to me there's a and I don't really quite and maybe this is something that needs to be flushed out after the meeting but if you're supporting students who firstly there's a lot of Ip students right so the system seems to be stressed um if a lot of students are getting reading intervention what's the

118policy to sort of like go like we can we so the first question is do we address all students in William O schaer who need reading intervention or are they tiered with the idea of like we're trying to catch up a group we bring them back into the general sort of general student body and then we address the other students is that how that works or maybe you can help me understand that hi um uh Mrs Corin and I actually have been uh leading a team um in the RTI and mtss process um for the past uh year and a half and what the there is a tiered approach and one of the things that um William O schaer has implemented is that their tier one tier one is what takes place in the classroom

119and they no longer do pullouts right away to give those supports those supports are pushing supports at the the lowest level and then when students are pulled out it's they cycle back in once they're meeting um success from the pull out part um so any students that are success on on that cycle back in and don't need to be pulled out again but those are that's data that we look at carefully of are students needing to be put back in or not and um that kind of that sort of thing is that the question that you were asking sort of sort of asking that but like so when do they go to me what it seems like anecdotal but multiple parents um where you pull you pull the student out they improve their reading they're

120returned back into the tier one but then they sort of drift back you know what I'm saying so my my suggestion would be is like when you pull them out is not to just try to get them like sort of to the Bottom now I don't know if the if we're able to do this because there's so many students who support but instead of just getting them to like the basic cut off of like the basic the most bottom qualified reading level for their grade sort of drop them off more into the middle of the pack you know what I'm saying so the reading level because you're dropping them into you're you pull them out of the race you say you train them up to we get almost as fast as the last place person

121in the race and then you say now you have to run just as fast like you want to drop them off sort of in the middle of the pack because they've already shown the build that they slowly they don't learn reading as fast as the other of their te so how do we like get them to support not to just say okay now you're back into the tier one population instead we're going to drop you off at the you know the peak of the bell curve because we're going to assume you're going to be sliding down but maybe that slide is not so there's a couple of things that are at work there and one of them is that we want to it's not just a matter of of meeting a specific like bottom of

122the pack kind of number it's also about making sure that the students have the skills that they need to be able to keep up it's not it's not one when when a decision is made about RTI support ntss support it's not based off of Just One Piece it's based off of multiple things one of them being the teacher's conversations of do this have we taught the students the skills that they need in order to or do they need more support do they need to continue in the RTI support because you know every every child learns at a different pace and at a different at a different speed we need to be able to address those those paces and those speeds on an individual level and see have we supported them enough okay I'm just thinking

123maybe the rubric needs to be like skew since since clearly there's a like a sore soreness here with the reading in the district we maybe want to skew the rubric to keep the support even if it's four weeks longer but I don't know if we can do that from a resource perspective but to just try to skew it a little bit where we're extending the the pullout support just a little bit longer to just to get them a little bit more ahead and instead of trying to reach X level of you know of achievement or skill set let's give them X+ one just try to get them a little bit further all of our most struggling students now I don't know exactly again I'm like a 30,000 foot guy I don't know exactly how to

124do that that's where you guys come in but there could be a plan like look we want to extend the the pullout support in particular in William O schaer from X number of weeks to X Plus y number of weeks just to give them a little bit more of a lifespan like of a of a of support and maybe that that especially in Schaefer because these people these you know the pupils will go students will go along and that's when you really learn to read so I don't know exactly how to do that but when I hear like how the process is is like well maybe the root cause is to just get our early readers like a little more support early on especially those that are struggling and if it's a numbers issue we

125where we just have so many of them and we have to move on from one to another we can also we also could pull resources from other where to start to help move that along it's an excellent point and we do try to make sure that you know one of the goals and and one of the challenges is to make sure that it's the um student need that's um put driving what the support is that's available not the other way around so we don't we don't move kids out of it just because like we have too many kids in so we have to move them out like that's not if a if a student needs the support then I'm maybe it would be good maybe it would be helpful for us to see the data

126on on students that maybe are taken off and then brought back to see if that is an issue that's the thing that we're looking at yes so you know if if if what you're if what you're concerned about is that we're not giving them enough to keep them where they could be um maybe seeing how much of a problem it is so yeah I would just say the guidance needs to be just extend that like Interventional Heth a little bit longer maybe that's going to solve a lot you know sometimes it's a little fix we'll see how it plays out but uh I think it needs to be sort of especially in the early earlier school to just figure out how we can give that direct prvention for you know the longer see that helps

127alleviate lot of issues that combined with what with a new system maybe we're going to be in a significantly better place in 12 months all right so I know it's late but um our assistant superintendent for business and operations just going to give us a quick high level overview of I think we need do um Natalie I hate to do this to you but we can't make these people suffer any longer I really but I think it's unfair to make them sit here any longer they have concerns they want out I'm really sorry but I think we'll sh to public commentary right all right I think we need to look at our our formula our schedule moving forward that people they're taking time out their schedules I we're obligated to be here and I think

128it's unfair for the parents have to sit here and wait for their turn to to voice whatever opinion it is whether we you know agree with it or disagree with it and that's their right but I think we need to look at the formula and maybe put public commentary sooner rather than later we can certainly do that that's something we've discussed I think it's it's not right everyone here has been so polite and I'm sorry I didn't know it was going to run this late none of us did but we're going to try and do better you guys can watch the rest of it at home on the live stream with your kids so we apologize all right so we'll move to public commentary protocol for public commentary is as follows all opinions are heard

129everyone should be an active listener each person is responsible for his or her behavior respect diverse perspectives be conscious of your speaking time and tone a limit of 3 minutes is an appropriate time frame to to State your issue speakers may not give unused time to other speakers issues of specific Personnel either positive or negative cannot be discussed at board meetings references comments or discussion that does or may identify a specific student or students by name or situation will not be discussed publicly due to furpa law issues pertaining to specific students should be addressed privately with a student's teacher principal or school counselor in accordance with policy 1400 public concern before bringing the issue to the superintendent's intention the board reserves the right to close comments on an issue if residents become unruly or disrespectful

130or if the topic is something that the board is legally unable to discuss in public if an unusual number of people are attending to bring forth a specific issue the number of speakers could be limited depending on the number of people wishing to speak during public commentary the board reserves the right to reduce the time limit on each speaker until everyone is heard the sole purpose of public commentary is for the board to actively listen to the community meeting protocol requires that questions presented to the board during public commentary will be responded to when possible at the board's discretion questions requiring investigations will be referred to the superintendent and will be responded to in a timely fashion through future board meetings electronic mail mail or telephonically provided the contact information is supplied on the public

131commentary signup sheet Desiree zagaroli thank you for having me and thank you for everything you do for our community I really appreciate it um and you know I'm glad to piggyback off the discussion we were just having that's what I'm here to speak about um I come before you today feeling both nervous and compelled public speaking is not something I'm comfortable with but after years of watching my son and many others struggle with reading and comprehension I find myself with no choice but to stand here and Advocate not only for my child but for all the children facing these same challenges over the years I've connected with countless parents who share similar stories many of us are frustrated and concerned as we watch our children fall behind despite their best efforts I stand here today

132representing all of them while I could stand before you and site the research the studies and the data I won't because the truth is you already know it the numbers you presented at the January 14th meeting speak for themselves only 42% of students in this District are proficient in reading that is a stark reality if it weren't for the exceptional teachers in this District those who go above and beyond to help students who are struggling I shudder to think how much lower that percentage might be but even with their tireless dedication we know that many of us as parents have been forced to spend thousands of dollars on outside tutors specializing in structured literacy just to help our children catch up the research is clear the numbers are undeniable on October 4th 2023 I was

133informed we were reviewing research-based programs that was a year and a half ago I question why we are still in the review phase and I'd be curious to know what programs have we actually reviewed we are out of time this is not a problem that can wait it is urgent and it needs immediate action the special education department has been inundated with students who are struggling with reading however we cannot be sure these children have true learning disabilities or if they simply haven't received the foundational literacy instruction they need this is not a special education issue it is not a teacher issue it is not a child issue this is a leadership issue that demands your attention every child deserves the right to be taught the foundation ational skills needed for literacy we need consistent

134instruction that we can count on year-to-year teacher to teer that means adopting a research back structured literacy program that ensures all children learn to read and write I urge you as leaders in this District to take immediate action and do better for the students who rely on you thank you for your time thank you [Applause] Paul zagaroli my name is Paul zagaroli and I'm a parent of two boys in this District I'm proudly married to Desiree um I'd like to commend the teachers in the district for the outstanding job they do and the administrators I'd also like to thank you guys for your service I'm sure this can be a thankless job sometimes um I to moved to Rockland in this district 10 years ago um the primary requirement I gave my realtor was South

135Orangetown School District um because of the reputation of of this District everything else was a non-starter um but I'm also concerned uh to hear that the other districts are being more proactive than us in replacing the curriculum the reading curriculum ahead of the mandated roll back of teachers College uh I trust that you'll do the necessary thing for the students adopt the curriculum that will best teach them to read um and not do the bare minimum to achieve compliance or or take the you know cheaper option those outdoor classrooms are beautiful but they won't matter if our kids can't read and Nick Turner um good evening board members R Rudy with only 42% of students reading proficiently the data is clear our tier one instruction is failing too many students the parent of a dyslexic

136child I see how inadequate foundational literacy impacts students with specific learning needs strong tier one curriculum is critical for ensuring all students acquire the literacy skills necessary for Success there we go while your recent comments may have been well intentioned they came across as dismissive to families deeply affected by the emotional financial and academic strain caused by the poor reading outcomes uh years ago when it became evident that the teachers College was insufficient icient immediate action should have been taken now is the time for Meaningful change honoring our teachers means giving them the training tools and materials to succeed they are dedicated professionals working within a system that doesn't equip them adequately your responsibility to adopt a science-based reading curriculum with urgency to also address the harm already done to students um many now in

137upper elementary middle and high school by providing remediation and intensive intervention to help them recover foundational skills research shows early intervention is key yet critical learning Windows have been squandered causing lasting harm neuropsychologists confirm that learning challenges are difficult to identify when curricular are inadequate compounding these issues failling to act now board is on educational negligence we urge you to reallocate the budget immediately prioritize a structured literacy program teacher training and high quality materials in the 2025 budget adopt a proven program use the insights from two years of program reviews to implement a research-based structure literacy approach without further delay invest in teacher training equip teachers to deliver effective evidence-based instruction and provide remediation allocate resources to help students harmed by inadequate instruction recover essential skills continuing with the status quo or delaying action disregards

138our students right to an Effective Education the time to act is now please reflect this urgency in the upcoming budget to ensure every child receives a literacy Foundation they deserve thank you thank you members of the board and administration I'd like to Echo what everyone said and thank everyone for coming out um and just to you your questioning was great and I think the answer is tier one needs structural literacy question I would also want to just emphasize that TC phonics is not science of units of study which is in the first bullet point of tonight's curriculum represent um slide is not science of reading it's debunked it doesn't work we need I'll also point out that as a parent with a child in tier 2 and tier three that TC phonics was used to

139attempt to give my child less Services than they needed not more I knew just enough but I really am concerned about all the parents who don't know enough to get their kids what they need so if tier one is fixed mediation for the students that have already been harmed because they did not get that foundational literacy and this is very well documented podcasts and articles and documentaries if you need any more evidence um and making the decision to switch uh there is a cost but not switching the cost is so much higher in cost of in terms of human costs the emotional strain the mental health strain on children and their families is so high already um so I just really hope that we can get this right this time and that we do it

140with a sense of urgency thank [Applause] you Kaitlyn oh okay Luciani okay Alexis star good evening um firstly I would just like to Echo what everyone else has shared so far this evening and thank them for all the research they've obviously done into this topic um I have not researched it as thoroughly at all um but I I you know I appreciate what they have done and one thing I have noticed I have three children currently in the district um in the middle school they're tracked in math and science and even to a certain extent in art and and um technology but they're not tracked at all in English and I know that the teachers aren't necessarily happy with this and to me it does say something that Ela is somehow not as as valued

141in the district so I would like um the district to consider that as well um on a totally different note I read through the Pont comprehensive plan and attended the public hearing and it appears that the village of permont is proposing a floating PUD plan Ed development Zone um which looks like it's potentially to be plunked down on the school district property on 9W in Pont and residents were asking how can we be building our whole comprehensive plan around development on property we don't own so my question is are there currently any discussions on selling any portion of this um School District property um and in case there are any discussions going on um to this end I for one would just like to say that I would encourage you not to consider selling any

142portion of this property once it is sold it is gone forever this property is a value to us as a building as grounds for our students it was used as our 2 to three building about 10 years ago I think population is sure to go up again and we will need a beautiful and spacious facility for our children children need room to play they need the fields there they need to explore this campus provides beautiful green fields and adjacent woods and wild space which would also be advantageous to our children um this building is currently of value as a rental property um rent is an ongoing source of Revenue as opposed to a sale which is only um of shortterm benefit there is a wild portion of this property going down to the old eie

143path it contains wood streams ponds Wetlands Wildlife it's essential for decreasing erosion and flooding which are a major concern in Pont in fact our DPW superintendent ID identifies flooding from construction on Route 9W as major issue his department is facing um there's a long history of advocacy for the preservation of this property and the wild portion of this property um it is my understanding that it was donated to the district for preservation of open space there are residents groups that have attempted to get the county to purchase the property as part of their open space acquisition program um so in short as far as I'm concerned this property as of incalculable ecological economic e economic and educational value to the people of this district and it should not be up for sale thank you just

144a quick comment I have not had any discussions or conversations with anybody about selling any property I haven't been approached by anyone and I agree and I've been here 17 years this has come up multiple times um we do anticipate at some point investing Capital uh into that building because this 49.9 ion dollar project doesn't even address anything at uh tapenz elementary school or the former tapen elementary school so we we know it's an important asset and we plan on keeping it at least from my perspective no talk all right thank you everyone for your time thank you for coming out and and giving your public commentary and apologize for having you guys wait so long I didn't anticipate the meeting going so late so appreciate you staying can we move back to yeah Second

145Chance a pause to yeah I go to the bathroom can we take a pause oh yeah okay all right you're going to have to pause sorry no don't don't be sorry sorry we hit the PA butt sorry now we went back and forth about who was going first me I I don't have enough copies for everyone but I just want to share this very wait for for me oh go one more one more got one more com never more copies app all right thanks Natalie good evening um my colleagues present and learning more of their areas um the dialogue that goes back and forth um different perspectives um so my goal with this presentation is to go over some of the parameters that we have to face When developing the budget that starts with the

146revenue sources that the district um are that are available to the district for public school funding there are three main sources of revenue there's the local tax levy that's driven by the tax cap formula and whatever is adopted by the board and U vote voter approved then there's the state aid portion it's driven by the state funding formula there's two components there's the um entitlement portion which is rolls into the foundation Aid and then there are expense driven AIDS such as Transportation Aid um certain specialed uh tuition and educational cost Aid each district is assigned um an aid ratio by the state based again on various factors and and um that's how we generate the expense driven Aid categories um there's also a third main public school funding source which is federal um those are

147mostly accounted for in a separate fund uh so we receive some title funds which have been reduced from the prior year to this year and we also have special federal funds for special needs um and the small portion of Medicaid Revenue revenue is booked to the general fund budget and another portion of our general fund budget entails pilot which are payments in lie of taxes um those are special agreements made with development corporations um for a specific period usually um the purpose is because they provide certain benefits to the community whether it's generating jobs and and other um features um we also have interest earnings and know um being that the district does have a solid cash base um we do have earnings but they are allocated to specific funds such as capital those earnings

148get um allocated back into the capital fund if they're restricted to let's say TRS those get allocated back to um TRS all within the limitations prescribed by the office of the controller we do have interest earnings within our general fund that are within our general cash that pertain to our general cash so that's a a budgeted amount within our general fund Revenue another source that a district can look to use our appropriated fund balance as well as the use of Reserve funds for the specific so and some key notes related to that budget General broad um information the overall proposed Aid increase of 1.7 billion or 4.8% as throughout New York State um the foundation Aid proposed increase of 5.8% includes minimum 2% increase for all districts um they're using some updated census data which

149is good factoring some changes in our demographics the expense based AIDS are funded within the formula um so they didn't propose any changes to how those are also propos universal access to school free meals currently our high school participates if this is approved all of our students will have free meals available to them that's going to change though right all the district will have all the schools will have free so long as it's approved as who pays for million there's a who pays for there's a that we yes it's separate it's um accounted for in a separate fund it's called the C so it's self-balancing if ever we were to incur a deficit at the year at year end the general fund supports it whether it's a small transfer the food service fund last year

150we actually ended with the sufficient for the next and in the state limits we're able to maintain that within the C fund was your question about Universal meals univers all schools in the state going to tell us that then we have to everyone can eat for free who pays for that in the governor's budget there were there was $250 million it is federal pass through funds and the portion is congestion pricing work will be interesting because what what what quality will the food be because will they be can you opt out of that no can you I don't know how they'll roll it out the C program that our high [Music] school um 25% poverty level after the 256 school year Universal or that it could be now they're talking about implementing it for September

151through the governor's budget but still don't understand do they give you a block grant to cover our food service check or do they just tell us you have to give itas so we the mail count each month at 100% is that would that cover those kids that qualify I imagine different schools use different food vendors to some degree so there might be different costs per student in different areas so it's going to be interesting to see how they handle that on the topic of vendors when are when is our vendors contract up is it next year I'll double check but I believe we have a couple of years so thank you they're usually on for five years years that's okay so looking at the state aid runs that were issued last week the First Column

152shows our current budgeted amounts totaling 17.6 million um these are the different categories we have Foundation 8 at the top that that change I have a second column showing the but then um I received an email from the state um indicating that because of our enrollment data from what was issued on the state aid 11 11.7 numbers right that's what they sent in email to lower at that amount because our enrollment data was the past the the enrollment data they had previously 88 is a little bit of a moving Target throughout the year um values at certain points based on financials issued after our audit um and then 's Aid excess and private excess cost categories we receive from special Aid special ed services and you'll see that there's a decline which made me kind

153of question why but some of our ratios that the state uses for our um have declined as well hardware and software these are materials um on a student count basis again taken against a a ratio imely 5 million in expenditures explain thaty we're we're spending 5 million on transportation and the aid that we get is 2 million so it's a little bit over 5 million this year budgeted and next didn't we complete a survey or have a survey done regarding the transportation and what show I don't recall the survey that we we issued showed that 35% of our families and students don't use busing just 35% 35% across the board the challenge with that is we're still obligated to provide a seat on every bus for every child yeah uh and we have the contract

154that's going up so our transportation a is at 38% of the so each category has a different percentage so we're looking at almost a flat change in state aid and just for contacts last year we received a $1.6 million increase year over the year what's the usual amount you get increased year-over-year the state over a million typ like 10% they're giving show I can send you the trend from year to year that's actually a big big hit yes tax levy is 89 then we have the tax based grow growth factor which is assigned to District um on the state have to add in the prior year pilot so there are adjustments made to the one a lot of the factors are the same before and after so they either add or subtract prior prior year

155factors and then the new factors for this year are you know the reverse is done for us so we have pilots on the top of 76,000 from last year those are added back and then for this year below the line you see um the deduction of the current year pilots and then when I say current year I'm referring to the tax year that we're discussing overall the tax levy limit before current year exclusions numbers um the district has set aside 2 million for the most part on average year toe for Capital Area that we can disc million because that's what I so the the current the exclusion for 2526 thatb service those are old obligations that we still have on the books for next bosis allocated rent and capital so bosis is undergoing their own

156construction portion of that is allocated to each district transfer to Capital which is the 2 million L we deduct any expected building aid for next year it's ear marked at um if I go back to $933,000 um and that number is also a moving Target based on when we file our um final cost reports for each project that anticipated Aid is deducted from the anticipated Capital um expend net amount which is the 3,000 um added back to the tax levy Drive the final tax levy limit with exclusions maximum increase of again this is a rough calculation because a lot of this has to be discussed as far as capital so you said the building Aid hopefully will come up to a million guys factoring in a few um items that haven't been been included in

157the state aid run but we have submitted documentation this is just calculating how much we could increase in right that's if we if we went out at the cap that's right think the factors that the factor that can change here is the transfer to Capital again it's a cap so the decision can be made we're doing our budget projections now we're putting in 17 Million number oh the state aid yeah that we don't expect that to change no and it'll change late we finalize a lot of these um 17 out shouldn't move anymore right correct it shouldn't but throughout the year they'll come with different data points so it might be as late as April and that's when you're adopting the budget I don't expect for it to be a significant change a factor in

158additional building aid for final cost reports that as I mentioned in Revenue sources there's always um fund balance this is where we ended oh that's the beginning balance 7123 so the ending balance was 32 million was um the audited fund balance at 630 have all the reserve items here that say restrict the encumbrances are actually when we close out the year those are existing peels that roll into the next or they're paid they don't um don't have to expend from the following Year's budget because we already made designated for subsequent expens so this was the applied the appropriated fund balance the 67 where it says assigned second line from the bottom then un assigned fund balance this is the amount that meets the 4% for the office of the controller um and we're required to

159fund that at 4% each year right Miss espanel that's the tax that's the the limit if it's if it exceeds that it's basically an audit comment um it's kind of an indication like you have too much fund balance according to the state standards as we get closer to the end of the year and I start projecting fund balance um we can make recommendations to the board as as to where they want to apply additional restricted funds or if the decision has been made to applying some of the funds to the following Year's budget and so forth try to right now as we make money on our money in the capital reserve or the UN was the perfect one it's only 52,000 but the tax certification Reserve 7.5 million but if you put all of those

160res together we have 30 million in right right now when it makes money it gets dumped back into the pot that made the money possible to like $1.2 million but it's all restricted and going back to its original generation limiting us because it remains restricted funds but are we able to say look we'll put right now interest rates for put it back into the restricted pot we're leveraging our resources our savings I don't know how we can Implement that so it may be certain ones that we can make that kind of move on I did go back and read from the control that usually which is like regular accounting you allocate the interest back to the fund that it's that generated that that earning um so on on our restricted the unrestricted cash we can

161budget a little bit more but we're expecting that interest rates are not going to be 5 or 4% they're probably going to be more like 3 7575 and it can change at any time but um we can increase the budget for interest a little bit more related to that unrestricted portion then we can assess and I'll assess with Auditors with legal to make sure that we're not moving any interest out of the fund that it needs to um no so I believe capital is more restrictive is voter authorized that money belongs there they all have a unique set of rules as far as funding um use and also the generation of some of them have a cap so where they can exceed a certain amount those are amounts that I just have to meet with

162legal make sure we take the appropriate action for board to authorize the movement the boards authorize the movement um seems like where the budget's going anything we can squeeze out we should try to not being irresponsible it's the other thing is that some of these funds can be used for their purpose a taxer we wait for that type of settlement to occur um but working with legal and the town their estimate they sent a new um spreadsheet has been less than this 7.5 so we have to work on reducing that amount because that should that amount should only be at the um estim again the second one elar is um employee when you pay out benefits upon someone's departure that amount can only be true that estimate at that calculation actually RS and TRS are

163to be used for those expenditures in the budget so we can work out a plan of using X amounts or future expenses every so often develop that plan out um you'll deplete the fund um but it's a a balancing right with your fund balance every year you may generate fund balance to supplement again and put so those were the general you know the the funds that we'll have to work with in um putting forth for the budget this just deciding what amounts from where um so that was the goal for January we I I provided the revenue estimates started the tax cap calculation and really February is getting down into the expenditures we already started definitely a collaborative effort and my goal is to provide you with all the information so feel free and once

164May 20th P we'll have our adopted budget for the following yes hopefully jumping ahead but yeah yeah thank you Natalie you welcome I'm all right so well I mean depending on the [Music] presentations commentary um so we have uh board discussion any committee reports um I I was um absent from the uh curriculum Council yes um a lot of what we shared to tonight about reading um the chemistry course uh was approved that I mentioned in the budget and we just gave some updates on our leadership teams the math leadership team did their instructional rounds uh Science Leadership Science Leadership team unpa uh the new assessment at the elementary school there the new textbook at the middle school and there'll be new lab investigations at the high school which they uh looked at um and

165then we also spoke about very briefly um this Friday is our follow-up visit with our Tri States so uh the way Tri States works is that they come and they do a visit uh they did the visit two years ago um and then they follow up up with you um in the second year to see how you've made with their progress It's a much lighter visit when they do the visit they come here with a whole team and they're here for three days um the follow-up visit is a two-hour Zoom um we prepare a brief presentation we go over some of the recommendations that we took to heart and uh tell them the progress we made and just as a reminder our Focus was on student voice um and presentations debates things like that um

166so we'll be sharing with them uh on Friday so that's what thank you if you could just possibly put that into some sort of agenda and what extra notes so we could put it into the yeah I'll I'll send you the minutes that would be perfect thank you yep want to thank Kathy for her thoughtful notes as always um just Rob one thing that we do on the board is we um we participate in the different committees obviously um coming in um late to the game most of the committies are we already have members so you you you can we'll take a look at at the Committees and see where you can possibly fit on a committee um but at the beginning of the year is when we choose and we kind of give people

167the the ability to say hey I want to try this this year or this you know something new or something your your expertise are in um but we'll get you the list of the Committees and we'll get you who's on it and and Kathy's the best always um but take a look at that and and we'll continue the discussion and and figure out where we can get you what makes sense um no more information on committees we can go to any board discussion on any agenda items do have a few addendums I'm going to read off can I just ask a question on the one of the addendums sure Red Owl we're going to lease to them again for five years right it was one year one year one year one year yeah additional 5

168years right that's what it says here renewal of a lease agreement with red owl LLC for period of an additional 5 years am I in the do I have the right paper no yeah I mean I was told one year but I'm reading as you are it says oh you're right it says five years five years there oh it says it says five years but period of an additional five years oh not there we go and then it goes on thank you yeah no that's good that you have question about Red Owl before we they're not partici participating in upk correct so that so but for next year oh okay no for year they are participating yeah so Diana you had asked I think it was either at the last board meeting or the board

169meeting prior to that do we have any uh upk seats in the district and the answer at that time was no right since that time we have reached back out to Red Owl and they have indicated that they are willing to participate in upk we were able to get them in work with us to the RFP process so I agreed to extend the lease for a year to have them participate to provide some seats for our kids and we're going to see how it goes so we're really happy about that we didn't specify a number because of space and grants and all of that but we'll see how it goes for the year but they they're not 100% in they are 100% participating in upk they are correct all right how many seats for next

170year in this process yes just interested but they haven't signed any agreements said that they're going to participate well this lease I just don't want to this lease is is that's why the lease is written in the way that it's written so this is a essentially a one-year trial based on their cooperation as I'm getting I wasn't participating in the negotiation no I'm just I he multiple voices trying to find out like if we're giving them an extra year like listen this is going to be a trial basis we need to find some type of agreement we need we needed Red Owl to work with us to and all of our providers any any providers in the community to offer but if they're renting from us directly that's why I had changed the lease and

171um amended it to include that language so we're optimistic and hopeful that we're going to have opportunities for our kids in District and we'll continue to grow and expand as we move forward any questions before I read your off the addendums start with the business office consent agenda addendum lease extension agreement for Palisades building be it resolved that the South Orangetown Central School District Board of Education determines not to renew the lease agreement with red is Academy LLC for a period of an additional 5 years but here hereby authorizes its president to execute a lease exension agreement for the pal school and premises with red Al Academy LLC for a one-year period commencing on October 1st 2025 and terminating on September 30th 2026 a copy of the lease extension agreement shall be incorporated by reference

172within the minutes of this Mee we also have a certificated Personnel addendum appointments it is recommended that the Board of Education revised the FTE increase following ESO member from Daniel rafy 0.3 FTE increase at tzs effective 16 2025 to on or about 131 2025 that to Daniel raffy 0.3 FTE increase at TCS effective from 162 25 to honor about 124 2025 recommended that the Board of Education approved the FTE increase of the following ESO member anthonyi chfi 0.2 FTE increase at tchs effective 127 2025 through honor about 131 2025 then on continuing education it is recommended that the Board of Education revise the appointment of the following for the 2024 2025 school year from GIS sat review math one and a half hour per class one day per week for a duration of six weeks

173beginning 1 12225 ending 3525 at a rate of 190 per class not to exceed 1,140 that to Jean sat review math one and a half hours per class one day per week for a duration of four weeks beginning 12225 ending 3525 at a rate of 190 per class not to exceed $760 it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the appointment of the following 2024 2025 school year Barbara Murphy sat review math 1 and a half hours per class one day per week for a duration of two weeks 625 and 21325 at a rate of 190 per class not to exceed $380 both addendums I have a motion to add the addendums to the professional Personnel agenda and an addendum to the business office agenda to the consent agenda motion second thank you all

174in favor I I and we can move to a motion to approve the amended consent agenda categories 7 through 11 I have a motion second second thank you all in favor I I all right any new business at this hour all right motion to adjourn the meeting at 10:20 p.m. motion thank you thank you everyone a second yeah that's that's in the uh that's all in the agenda so it's like one loop I get a second second thank you all in favor I I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.