001pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right good evening everyone meeting call to order 7:38 have myself Mr Sansone Miss Corel all right um I I have one board announcement real quick um Mr Coleman took the oath of office on Wednesday 1219 um unfortunately due to a prior commitment he was not able to make tonight's meeting um but glad to have him on board just wanted to make sure everyone knows um is there any other board announcements I got to um attend the publishing party at Cottage Lane and it was it was really nice it was a little bit different than last year with the third grade um but the fourth
002grade had um some really passionate children talking about tornadoes and um lots of other interesting uh scientific uh earth science stuff um but they were they spoke a little bit louder than last year which was was good um but it it's always nice to have um parent participation and and really creating that Community uh that I think we're all appreciative of uh here at South Orangetown so I attended as well but I would think I was in an earlier session than you um it was very little difficult to hear them but at the same time it was it was good we got there I literally got there because a parking Cottage Lane I got there right after my daughter finished so I made her reread it but hey it was a good um and to
003watch all the other students and everything that they put together and the projects it was and how can I forget they they were just beginning to make lunch and it smells so good I almost stayed so may maybe next time it was the loaded tots all right um if there's no more board announcements anyone okay can move on move on to the superintendent report so happy New Year everyone I know the statute of limitations might have expired on that if you've watched Curb Your Enthusiasm or anything but uh Happy New Year before I get uh into the full superintendance report I'm going to ask we have Maryann vany from RS Abrams uh here on the zoom to give us our risk assessment report so I'm going to turn it over to Maryann hey thank you
004so much I appreciate the board um asking me to present for the results of the risk assessment update um as you know um this is a report that we do every year we reassess the risk and then we make recommendations on cycles that we wanted to look in depth but before I start I just wanted to thank Natalie espanol and her team um they did a great job working with my team getting us all the information in order to get this audit done timely um for you for this meeting so thank you Natalie glad to have you on board Natalie and I work together in a prior District so I'm really happy to be working with her again um so overall we did meet with the uh audit committee last month um so you have
005as you know an audit committee made up of board members and community members we did go in depth in the draft uh report on the areas that we did look at this year so the way we do our risk assessments is we do a lot of interviewing we look at policies we look at your procedures and then we assess risk based on the um procedures that we do perform and we do look at different areas every year so this year we looked at accounting and Reporting we looked at your payroll human resources and benefits student services and student related and data services so overall um all those areas were assessed as low risk um we did have some recommendations in the accounting and Reporting area which I know Natalie is is looking into as far
006as procedures um they are recommendations based on osc um they're not required but they are recommendations so that was part of the accounting and Reporting section um in addition when we do this report or the risk we also look at the status of Prior year findings that you did have in other reports and I'm happy to report um that you did um implement the policies that we recommended last year so all the policies that were recommended were implemented as well as the purchasing procedures um they were implemented so we were happy to report that the status was all where it should be um so overall a great report um really most of the areas I would say everything was assessed at low which is a good thing um and then what we want to do
007for the cycle report which I believe the board does have the engagement letters for the two in-depth cycles that we do um one being on capital projects because I know you do have capital projects work uh districtwide projects going on now um as well as also the capital assets and inventory cycle so those are the two cycles that are recommended based on this risk assessment and then what we'll do is we'll come back to the district next month and we'll start working on the in-depth review of both those Cycles which um were recommended by by us as well as the audit committee um agreed to those two areas so I don't know if anybody has any specific questions on the report but all in all you know great great results and I look forward to
008doing the next two cycles and presenting that to you um I have a question regarding the um high with the star for facilities maintenance yes can you give us a little bit more into that sure so as you recall we did a facilities report um so we did follow up on the recommendations that we did make last year with the report the district is still was still in the process of implementing a lot of those areas so what we're going to do is we'll incorporate reviewing those recommendations in the two cycles that we're going to be working on so as of the point of this report they they were not 100% completed they were still working on those recommendations so we want to come back next month or the month after and they should have
009most those in place and we will test them to make sure that they are in place so um if I can just Dr kolad if you could just give us I I don't see Jack available right now but the program that we started P library right is that implemented is that it's it's one of the things that being done I mean because that's where we were the last time was it was still so Master library has been implemented in all the schools but there are a lot of different um functionality with it and things that are still being added to the system so preventative maintenance it's not full and running yet it is full running all work orders go through that system anything that's done in the system is is through that system however there
010are still other preventative maintenance things that are being added and I'm not sure if that's what you were referring to if there are other things that you uncovered were you referring to the master library system as one of those recommendations for tracking capital projects and work did you hear me asking me or you yes I was asking you may oh you are okay so we we do have a lot of recommendations last year to improve the monitoring of your facilities and um so when we did go out in the field a lot of those recommendations were still in process so I know we want to come back and I know some have recently been implemented but we didn't you know we want to come and just verify that so I think when we come back
011what our goal is to go through all those recommendations in that report and then M ensure that they are functioning and they are working and you know if there's anything else we want to recommend maybe if it's you know so we feel comfortable the way you did it is what the way it should be so that's our game plan cuz facilities will kind is it's very similar to Capital and and the capital assets so we're going to kind of incorporate that all into our reviews coming up so you have some time to make sure everything is ready and then we're going to come in and verify that okay thank you okay so I see um a period ending on June 30th 2025 but you when you just spoke about facilities you said in the next
012month or two you were going to come back so are we expecting some kind of rundown on your results in a few months or are we or you know when I'm just wondering okay so we're required to complete our Cycles by the end of June so that's why it says June 30th that's how the cycle goes generally we come to a May board meeting I believe with you um so we will have we're planning on getting everything done by the end of April for the two cycles and then we'll present it for the board and the audit committee for in May I was just looking at the uh the rest of the list there and that was the only category that it was a high risk correct the facilities planning it was considered still high
013risk because we have not implement we have not tested it yes which we noted in the chart that that has not been followed up on and we will follow up on it with our next cycle we have somewhere in in here I don't recall reading it what what your what those were what those what was completed and what wasn't completed of your recommendations just so we know they were all when we came out in the field they were all still in process so when you say they're all still in process they could be 1% or 99% complete correct doesn't have to necessarily mean almost it's just not complete in general based on your recommendations it's just yeah there was still in process so it wouldn't make sense for us to test it if they were
014still working on it so that's why we wanted to wait till it was implemented which from what I'm understanding some of them were implemented after we were out in the field but until I come out and see that I can't say whether it was implemented or not can you give an example of one of those recommendations I don't have the report in front of me from last year it was last year's report so I know that it was tracking doing a ticket system tracking any kind of workorders major part of that yeah yep Dr Kula can I just clarify sure um so when Marian hi Marian nice to see you today thank you for your presentation um so when Marian came out to do the risk assessment that was specific to those areas that were
015identified as low risk for this um type of review the facilities that was indicated as highis that was a full internal audit that was performed last fiscal year um during the time they were out last in the last few months they weren't here to follow up on the update of that implementation correct Maran right the implementation took place after we were doing assessing these other areas so while they go into the next cycle they'll look deeper into the facilities implementation and just for clarity of the board we're not required to do two cycles within the fiscal year correct so if you want the review of what was done on facilities to be a little bit more detailed and provide for time we can just do one cycle um instead of the two the inventory as
016well as capital we can decide to do that as well I just wanted to make sure that we were within compliance as well thanks for sharing that all right thank you Marian all right thank you so much have a good night all right moving on to our PTA president's report so our associes PTA president um wasn't sure if she could make it tonight so I will read the report out soes PTA wants to thank all the volunteers who made both The Cottage Lane Scholastic fair and William O Schaefer penguin patch holiday shop a huge success the teacher grant program was able to fund 16 grants between the two elementary schools and they have invited the teachers to present on their grants at their March PTA meeting they've also kicked off ticket sales for the Gilded
017glamour benefit event that will be held on March 6th and they are seeking sponsors for the event and more information can be found on their website at s o c pta.org soes pta.org also reporting out for the SS PTA just that the next meeting will be on February 4th at 7 p.m. in the SS Library anything else oh good and Michelle is here from taeny high school yes please thank you hi uh we wanted to say that our membership is higher than the last meeting we're at 280 members now um we've been asked to help uh with the Harlem Wizards fundraiser for uh for the red and white booster club which will take place at the high school on March 24th at 7M um we're gonna there's going to be Sam and I are going
018to volunteer we're looking for uh five teachers from each grade to participate if anyone is interested to know someone who may be um Reflections had two finalists in art and photography the scholarship committee ran a uh rans some successful fundraisers and applications are ready for the seniors um between Noco and Cassie we got over 7 almost $800 uh we went over the bylaws and discussed how we may increase membership next year um to offset a higher membership cost to the New York State um PTA uh and the main fundraiser for Project Graduation is scheduled at the saloon in um in Pearl River on March 1st from 7: to 11: it's an event for all of the district um not just senior families it's a great uh evening with fun Raffles and tricky trays DJs uh
019Etc and we're looking for volunteers thank you all right thanks Michelle right so continuing with my superintendent report as I said Happy New Year I hope everyone had a wonderful winter break and that you got some time to spend with uh family and friends before the break I just want to share some highlights we did uh receive some uh actually not before the break after the break we received some wonderful news that our trustee uh board trustee Katie gravino had a baby boy Dominic uh Lewis and we want to just send out congratulations she couldn't be here tonight uh but wishing her and her family well also uh as Mr Finn mentioned uh Dr Jr Coleman was recently elected to the board of education and we swore him in on Wednesday December 19th right before
020the break as Mr Finn mentioned he couldn't be here this evening because of a prior engagement but looks forward to our next board meeting and uh he's already met with myself and several members of cabinet just to get brought up to speed uh on all the work that we're in the process of doing also prior to the break I had the opportunity to attend a thank you breakfast for our bus drivers and crossing guards at Cottage Lane that was an awesome event um and I remember before the break there was a comment made about our crossing guards and acknowledging just uh how important the work is that they do so it was a really nice thing for our student leaders to do with Cottage Lane and they really appreciated the warm reception and breakfast and
021many of them came so it was nice we also had our annual DARE graduation that took place on December 18th here at South Orangetown middle school and this program has been in place for many years this program featured student presentations and remarks by our dare officers Luke grainy and Amari Lopez We would like to publicly thank our D officers Officer graany and officer Lopez and the Orangetown Police Department for working with all our sixth grade classes this year the ceremony this year was well attended by parents and it was really nice to see how our students and officers created such a strong bond over the course of just one semester the kids like the program a lot you can tell um not only do they like the officers but they really seem to get a
022lot out of it including internalizing the healthy decision-making model that is embedded in a series of lessons about making good decisions good choices and also how to handle peer pressure in tough situations I also want to highlight uh some student achievement so congratulations to the 37 taeny high school student musicians who were chosen to perform in the Rockland County music educators Association senior all count and contemporary jazz choir music festivals this took place at North Rockland High School last weekend selections were B based on the students outstanding solo audition scores from last Springs New York State Music Association solo evaluation Festival this strong representation is a testament to the talent of our students and our K to2 music department and the support of families in our community so congratulations to all of those students moving
023on to Athletics congratulations to senior soccer player Brady Jacobs who was recently at one of our board meetings he was honored this past weekend in Chicago Illinois at the National Soccer Coaches conference for being named an All-American a 5-year Varsity player Brady broke the longtime Rockland County goals record in leading the team to the first section title in our school's history also in sports the merged Rockland County varsity's ice hockey team all girls ice hockey team was given the opportunity to play at Madison Square Garden last Thursday against the Northern Westchester merge team so the team is presented by three tapen students Colette Curley Hannah Sora and Josephine matulac this is the third year of the merge County team as a continues to grow as a high school sport in the region our tapenz wrestling
024team hosted the first annual Dutchman duels this past Saturday and they won the championship congratulations to the team on this great accomplishment our girls basketball team uh our girls uh athlete Kristen felen scored her 1,000 point during the winter recess at an away game and she was honored last week at our home game for this great accomplishment congratulations to Kristen who will continue her academic and athletic career next year at Sacred Heart University and as of today our boys basketball team is currently undefeated and ranked fourth in class AA in New York state and our girls basketball team is ranked 17th in the state and that's according to the New York State Sports writers association so our teams are off to a great start so as a part of tonight's superintendent report I want to
025take this opportunity to address uh Mr sanson's request uh at our last board meeting which was on December 17th with regard to the spring 2024 New York State grades 3 to8 Ela and math test results so um do you want to pull up we just have a couple slides uh to share with you and and myself and miss corkin and Mr arieta want to uh just share some information thank you you want to do it from there I can come up thanks jie so I want to begin with the end in mind which is that we know we can do better I was glad to hear that there is an understanding that test scores don't always accurately depict the district's ability or knowledge or that of our students but I also want to state that
026the publicly released test results uh that came out in November were released to the district last July and the results were not embargoed this year uh and that's the first time that the state did not embargo the scores the results don't reflect the teaching and learning taking place across the districts and and we are working to address address this so tonight we're just going to share a brief overview some of the factors that may have affected our Ela and math state test scores in grades 3 to 8 and this overview is not an attempt to make excuses or to portray that we're satisfied with the results however we will explore some of the factors that may have affected these results as well as all the things that we've been doing to set our students up
027for Success on these particular tests but more importantly for success as students in a multitude of areas including developing soft skills such as the characteristics you've seen in the earlier board presentations for M schools on the profile of The Graduate responsible use of Technology citizenship character education and of course literacy in South orang Town we have been focused on improving the level of Engagement for our students through embedding student Choice which you heard a lot about the creation of new learning spaces and maker spaces with curriculum the expansion of our music and chorus program enrichment opportunities extracurricular activities as well as preparing students to do well on high stakes assessments When comparing ourselves to other school districts on a variety of measures there are many areas that need to be looked at and considered and
028miss corkin and Mr arieta are going to share some more detailed information on these particular test results as well as some of the curriculum and instructional changes that we all have been working on Genie so the first thing that I just want to clarify is that um at the is that the um South Orangetown received the test results in July without levels included on it we began immediately starting to share District level results with central office administrators and building level results with building administrators data was shared with the teachers in late August once the levels were uh released by New York State the reports were then sent home to parents with individual student results in September once the data was released by the state with levels in August the state allowed us to start talking
029about them publicly so the data was not embargoed nearly as long at all uh this year as it has been in previous years so we have been sharing the data publicly and with the board all along prior to New York State publicly sharing their data specifically on September 12th this detailed report it is attached in your file there this detailed report was sent to the board in the board report this has the exact results for our state testing the board was also asked at that time for specifics of what they wanted included in the state in the data presentation and did they have any questions on this report in addition to that the results was shared publicly as part of the district data presentation on October 1st this slide these two slides again they're attached
030were included in the data report the link is in there but I don't think the links are quite working but that's okay it was included in the data report these are the State Testing results again at the end of that presentation the board was asked what questions they had regarding anything that was presented all right all right let's let's take a time out here I understand what you're trying to say we had the knowledge we had the information we had it ahead of time but skip that I still would like an explanation I'll go to next okay I'll go to next so a brief history of the New York State Testing and things that need to be known in terms of that common core standards were introduced in New York state in 2010 with State
031Testing beginning in the 2013 school year 2012 13 school year in 2013 the optout movement began throughout New York State due to objections to the standards themselves as well as the testing process and testing validity and tying scores to evaluations for a long while these tests weren't released the questions weren't released the answers weren't released New York state exam began being revamped in test development test length and scale for tests in 20178 Next Generation standards were released in 2018 with the first assessment based on the new standards originally SK scheduled for spring of 2021 but due to covid pandemic that was pushed back to Spring 2023 computer-based testing for New York state began with optional implementation in 2017 again they were for full implementation by 2022 but due to covid pandemic it was pushed back
032south Orangetown began implementing computer-based testing for all grades um 3 to8 in Spring 2023 the advantage of having uh implemented the CBT in Spring 2023 is that now not only do we have access to the released questions from New York state that's new but this year for the first time we have access to the answers that our students gave on these assessments so we can look at and do an error analysis on the free response questions to see what are our students doing what are our students saying and how why is it not full credit on the assessment in the past South Orangetown has not put an emphasis on the New York State assessments for some time now historically the emphasis has been on educating the whole child not on test preparation since 2013 when
033Common Core State Standards first began being assessed on New York State tests South Orangetown has continuously ranked fourth or fifth in the county that's this report that you were given in December fourth or fifth in the county every year for the 3 to8 New York State Ela assessment but during that same time period our New York state regions results often ranked higher in many subjects including English since spring of 2018 we have consistently ranked first in AP English in the percentage of students who scored three or better first in the county The Only Exception was spring of 2020 when many students did not sit for the exam due to the covid pandemic the district has been placing a stronger emphasis on state test results than they have in the past this is a shift in
034mindset that takes time to bring to fruition from administrators to teachers to students and to parents parents have not thought that these were important and we have now been trying to let them know that this is important this year the district will be communicating the importance of students taking these assessments to help parents and teachers better understand the role of assessment and informing instruction another piece of this an important piece of this is transitioning to test prep test results are shared with teachers as soon as they are available both class and grade results are shared with teachers when I say class results I mean both the results of the kiddos that the teachers taught last year as well as the kiddos that they're about to teach this year so that they can do be reflective
035in their practice about what they did last year and also be PR uh Preparatory of what are the needs are for their students this year released questions are being reviewed by teachers item analysis of multiple choice questions are being reviewed with teachers and samples of student responses are now being shared with teachers to determine best approaches to guide students to earn maximum points on constructed responses after school test prep sessions are also being held at SS a class period has been added to the schedule this year for all students in grade six this class is star Ela and star math and it contains test prep at SS also a special schedule is being implemented at various times throughout the year so that students can take the star math and star Ela Assessments in a similar
036environment to how they take the New York the New York State Ela and math tests now I'm going to turn it over to Mr aretta thank you all right so um uh part of the request uh was not only just to look at the uh the test scores but also to give an overview on uh what we're doing in our um review of our reading program um so here I have a just a couple of slides here the first is just a timeline uh some of these predate uh uh me when I was the principal at the high school and when Dr kulot was the assistant superintendent for curriculum instruction so what you'll see here is just a timeline of different adjustments that have been made um at WIlliam Mo schaer and Cottage Lane uh
037many of these adjustments were made uh based off some some of the data that Miss corkin was talking about so as teachers and principes um and administrators are seeing um needs um adjustments in the instruction so for example in 21 2122 uh was the introduction of hegerty uh to address pheic awareness at William O schaer um as The Core Curriculum in in kindergarten um and then using a pheic awareness assessment schoolwide um phonic assessment uh same year uh being used to uh uh Drive the RTI and mtss process if you recall back to um I think this was in Miss corran's uh presentation um in October uh we showed like a a scale of the phonic scores and she showed it over time and how certain students achieved at a certain level but then that
038number continually went down as they were receiving the interventions um the increasing use of decodable texts at William O shaer in the following year um last year as part of ela leadership we looked at the uh New York State standards and how our approach um aligned um to the New York State Standards um and then um uh miss beglin Mr Galvin made phonics the focus of observations of all observations um at William O schaer to open up conversations about our practice around phonics and then also to D drive additional professional development uh last year also so miss corkran uh talked about just kind of transition to you know giving um really teachers permission to do test prep um so last year at Cottage Lane uh we introduced Freckle which is an online platform um really
039it's to reinforce reading comprehension strategies um and reading comprehension is a big part of the the state exams um so they we're using that at Cottage Lane last year um to reinforce those things um this year uh we've done professional development at Cottage Lane um on constructed responses constructed responses are parts of the State assessments um so one of the instructional coaches went to Cottage Lane and did uh PD with the teachers on strategies to help students uh decode constructed responses and and answer constructed responses um an emphasis on vocabulary instruction at Cottage Lane last year and then this year um The Cottage Lane Administration are using um their informal observations to focus on word study again to open up conversations and to gather information for future professional development ment those some steps that were
040taken that have been taken so far um many of these are a repeat of the um this the the summary that I gave in the fall in a um a communication to the community um so so what what we did this year is that we pulled the ELA leadership team together uh and we asked them to to do two things first is to create a list of what we call non-negotiables or desired attributes and those those are the things that are that we value in South Orangetown we asked our faculty our teachers uh what they valued uh as part of a a reading program um then uh we they took that back to their teams and so every uh every teacher at Cottage Lane and um William O shaer had a chance to contribute to
041that list we then merged that the state uh released A literacy review guide um which I'll get I'll come back to that in a in a little bit so we wanted to make sure that we were following what the state expected us to do but also what we valued as you'll as you can imagine many of those things aligned um and there was a lot of repeat some of the many of the things that we've said as a value the state also valued and said that we should be doing in our our reading program so from there what we do is we created a rubric and then we gave that to the folks the the ELA leadership they started the process of of kind of doing an audit for lack of a better word of
042our current program and identified areas that we were doing that were strong and areas is that we could use Improvement and this is from the teacher perspective um in the classroom from there um we had focus group conversations uh with so the building uh principles at each building at William O shaer and Cottage Lane uh myself and the ELA literacy coach uh went to each grade level to talk about those things and to talk about the the things that they were identifying as this is what we are we're doing well and this is where we we feel like we need some uh adjustment so the next step in that is going to be doing the same process with other programs um so right now what we're doing is we're in the process of creating a
043list of alternative programs and we created the programs in really three buckets so phonics word study and then complete reading programs so we are in the process of gathering information on what other districts use what other what some of the the research is recommending um of other programs in those three different categories um and then we're going to use the New York state literacy guide and the the non-negotiable list to kind of go through and to evaluate those programs and I'll I'll come back to that in next steps in uh at on the next slide so some of the other things that we've done is uh last year we had mess in the district we're going to have her again in the district this spring um Dr scarth Miss beglin and I have a meeting
044with her at the end of the month uh to plan some stuff for the spring but she has also been almost like having a residency at uh Rockin Bose's and we have had many many teachers and administrators attend the workshops at Rockland bosis with Molly NES again to provide that professional learning and then just recently uh the state rolled had another Statewide meeting at each Bose's um I attended with Miss beglan and what they unveiled there is that as of September 1st 2025 every District uh is going to have to verify that they are following the state's best practices and the best practices align with the literacy review guide um and so we're going to have to do that every single year uh for K through three that are practices as far as teaching reading
045are aligned with the uh the New York State um Ela best practices um so they just unveiled that so a lot of the work that we've been doing this year is going to serve us well in in meeting that mandate from the the state so next steps as I talked about will be looking at so really in um the month of February is we'll be looking at uh those alternative programs using that Nic um literacy review guide and the desired attributes or non-negotiables that I spoke about and then we'll make decisions um so I think there's a there are many considerations that we'll have to think about so one of the things that we've heard um from teachers so obviously we looked at those three buckets right so we looked at phonics we looked at
046word study we looked at reading program um is that the teachers have been saying that if we make a change can it not be all at once right so there's got to be a roll out there's got to be an intentional plan um for how we do that so that it can maximize success so implementation will be something we have to think about we'll have to think about budget um and what gets phased in when um because these many of these programs are very expensive um and then going along with the professional development and the training so to make sure that we have a plan for that and then also that we are budgeting for those things um and then the last thing I think that we have to think about as we're doing this
047is if you go back to the this slide as you see like over the course of the past you know four three or four or five years a lot of work has been done uh by William O schaer and by Cottage Lane um and these are just some of like the building wide things and as U Miss corkran mentioned like there's stuff that teachers do every single day in their classroom um as they've been you know the results have been shared with them for their students and the strengths and the weaknesses that their students have so one of the considerations I think that has to be considered is making sure that we're honoring that work so that we can kind of see if those things that have been done are working um and I think
048that also has to be considered as we roll out whatever changes um we decide to make um is that we're doing it in a ways that we can actually see is it this change that's working is this the change that's you know um that we're seeing a difference in um because if you do everything all at once you're not going to be able to it's going to be harder to parse those things out so I think those are just some other con considerations to uh to think about and that is an update on the uh the reading review thank you I appreciate the uh presentation um last year I didn't get an answer this year uh it's quite thorough answer I would have liked to have got the information before the meeting so I could
049have reviewed it this is a ton of information I not have to do a deep dive on the weekend um lot of thought went into this I wish you guys had just sent it out at least a day instead of just five minutes before the meeting um out of curiosity what uh what phonics program do we use in our district right now we use TC phonics College yes but I thought I thought that it was implemented July of 2023 that Teachers College was not to be used so Teachers College has phonics program they have a reading program they also have professional development the decision that was made in July of 2023 was to not consult with Teachers College consultants for professional development it was not to just get rid of a program because we didn't
050have anything to replace it so we're in the process of doing that right now and we bought n Mount Molly Nest back again correct because we we hired her last year twice she came in twice yeah she did uh two faculty meetings we're bringing her back again is this part of her original contract or this is a new contract no we built in uh money into this each obvious each budget season is different so when we we built the budget last year we wanted to build in some money in case we wanted to bring her back again teachers elementary teachers feel that she's worth it the feedback that we the feedback that we received last year was positive um obviously not I don't think any single person it was positive to my ears yes and
051I think also um I can pull the the amount of teachers that have gone to bosis this year as a follow-up um with Molly with Molly Ness okay yeah so I can share how many of those teachers have I really like to hear those numbers because I I you know I I think Dr kolot and I had this discussion when I was being on boarded and I said that the teachers in this District have a there's a pool of resources and to put something together in the elementary level for reading and writing from all sides everybody that can give something to the aable to do that instead of bringing hiring bringing in another consultant or somebody else that's going to tell us how to do it or talk about brain science we have the teachers
052in the district that already do it they put out that time they give that effort I just I just think that we're wasting yeah they I mean whoever has spoken to you is is not the feedback that IED it's it's no one's spoken to me it's what I've it's what I've gathered by watching my own children as well as other children students and understanding that teachers all come from different walks of school different colleges different programs they can all put together one program or because listen Teachers College isn't a horrible program to some yes to other stud students they need extra there's teachers that acknowledge that and understand it so to put together one pro a program with multiple sides yeah one student and I'll just clarify and maybe I'm just misunderstanding you Molly Ness
053is not going to create a program for us no she's not you're right we all know that okay just we did that last year and when she came in the end of the year that we knew she wasn't going to she talk about brain science and Prof learning L about her I've read a lot lot on on her and her what she's providing and I'm not saying she's she's not providing any thing that's not you know great information but at the same time you have teachers here that have 30 years of teaching behind them and they'll tell you just give me just give me five weeks with your with your kid two days come in at 8:00 in the morning 8:40 in the morning for 20 minutes I have great teachers in this District that
054can really create a better program than what Molly else will offer or any consultant at that point right yeah I would agree and I would just say that uh the ELA leadership team that Mr aretta referred to has teachers on it we have teacher leaders across the board that are very involved in this work and they will be involved in making that decision and making those changes I think Molly NES coming back is really followup from last year um just to have her back one day in the district and it's also good to have outside she's been working with a lot of other districts who are a little further ahead some further behind so it's just good to have that outside perspective if we pull her out of the budget this year then we could
055save some money yeah agreed thank you um I if we're going to continue to just be fourth or fifth or sixth in the county I'll just I won't ask anything next year I'll just keep my expectations grounded as where they are my just concern is when it comes to the budget if we're number two in the county and the amount of money we spend per student why is our reading score lower than New York City I just don't understand that but if we're going to go the route that we're educating the whole student and that's kind of sugest subjective expression then I guess I'll just deal with the scores and I won't bring it up next year so thank you for your time well I just want to add to that what I heard was
056that this is a process and it's not an overnight process and so I would like to um like to look at where we are now and hope that next year we're on track to increase our scores I mean we're we're looking at what the problems could be and I see an array of different things and we're choosing one thing at a time to see what affects the students and and what has um better outcomes to increase their reading scores so um I I get your frustration Dave um see we were fifth in 2017 fifth again teaching teacher we're telling teachers to to teach to to teach so we pass the test not just to teach we're not we're not letting teachers teach I would I would disagree with that um so I think one of
057the things that we try to do um so for example I mentioned incorporating Freckle so Freckle is is a reading comprehension so I I think there's a reality that you're teaching kids reading comprehension all the time I think but it's doing the kids a disservice if we're going to Value the test score um to set them in a a setting that is similar to how they're going to take that test so Freckle is online so teachers teach reading comprehension all the time right teachers are assessing students all the time um in their classs and using a variety of different ways of doing that so I think the incorporation of Freckle um is to make sure that students are used to answering reading comprehension questions on a computer um rather than answering reading comprehension questions when
058they're sitting in a a small group or with their teacher uh one-on-one or in a whole group discussion so I think by and I think to Mr sanson's point if test scores are a metric they're not the only thing but they are a thing um and I think that test scores have come up and we've had this conversation a couple of times I think we're doing the the teachers a disservice if we're not giving them those resources and allowing them to do that my perception in being new to this role and being fairly new to the district um as Miss corkin was looking at the the timeline is that for many years the message and really from not anyone sitting at this table or or many people in this room um from either the board
059or or central office was that the tests are not important and so that is seems to be and I think it's a reality that it's a it's a changing value and I think that that's okay so but then to say that we're just going to teach to the test and not doing good teaching um you and I agree is that there's lots of experts and there's lots of great teaching going on in every single day in this in this District in classrooms K to 12 and so I think what we're trying to do is we're trying to get that sweet spot of giving teachers permission to acknowledge the test uh giving families permission to acknowledge the test and also providing not doing it a service to the kids of saying that the test is not
060important the test is not important and then the kids aren't here tonight but we're here talking about the kids and the results is we're not doing everyone involved in the process a a a service or we're not being genuine if we're not being upfront with them and clear about what they could do so I don't I please do not take away from this presentation by the use of the word test prep or the fact that we're introducing certain um platforms for teachers to do that is that we're teaching to the test I think what we're trying to do is that if the test scores are going to be important and our value which is a valid value um then I think we need to do certain things in changing our in our culture that's all
061all I think we were trying to to say thank you for saying what I was thinking thanks for texting it to me Steve app I think all the things that that have been shared that we've been working on will have an impact and I think it is reasonable to have an expectation that we will do better I I don't think anybody here thinks we want to be fifth or sixth or fourth every year in a row um there is a shift in culture and the tests have gone from being something that were opted out of uh they were tied to teacher evaluations we had uh teachers own children not taking tests for for a long time and we've seen that opt out movement uh fade a little bit but we still have a significant number
062of kids not sitting for those assessments and then we know when they get to high school they have to sit for region exams so there's a lot that we're working on but I do think you can have an expectation that we will do better um and we will be sharing those results out in the future and and it's a great conversation so I I think it's healthy um and it's it's striking that balance as Mr arietta said you know we want to be able to prepare kids well for high state assessments we know that our kids have to perform well in these types of situations and we're going to prepare them well to do that so thank you all right so just before we adjourn to the B budget work workshop sorry I do just
063want to share some information publicly uh from the New York State education department from the state level uh stuff that I have shared with you in board reports in the past and it has to do with regionalization and Foundation 8 and so as you know the New York State Department of Education initiative uh in terms of regionalization uh uh issued an emergency order back in September uh for all districts to comply with a regionalization survey uh which we have done uh the lower Hudson Council superintendent sent a letter to commissioner Rosa expressing our strong opposition to the emergency rule that was implemented uh and the Genesis of the letter stem from uh really the absence of proper stakeholder engagement throughout the process so uh the council along with many school boards did request that the
064New York State education department immediately withdraw the emergency rule that was enacted in September and refrain from renewing it this month so we did get a little bit of an extension although we are in compliance uh and we're really asking the department to develop a comprehensive plan to engage all stakeholders in meaningful dialogue and any future policy or regulation that would ref input from local school boards uh and local school districts who will be adversely affected by the implementation uh we know the school districts in our area are diverse and the needs of each of our school districts are unique a one-sized fits-all approach really undermines the ability of local school boards to govern effectively in the best interest of their communities so as of last week it does appear uh I went to lower
065Hudson Council last week that we are being heard on regionalization uh and the State Education Department is considering uh a different approach to this I also want to bring to the Public's attention and this was shared with the Board of Education uh the Rockefeller report that was released uh regarding state aid School Foundation Aid uh and they made recommendations for changes to the funding formula that was developed and implemented back in 2007 so last year as you know the New York State education department requested a study of the foundation Aid formula which is the current method used by New York state to allocate a large large proportion of State education resources the school district and as you know we rely heavily on state aid here in state south Orangetown so they created uh the funding
066formula in 2007 and they Consolidated 30 separate school aid programs into one formula uh and we are still using the formula from 2007 uh even today so the Rockefeller report is 293 Pages I'm certainly not going to bore you with all the details um but I did want to just mention that that report is out and those recommendations uh have been received one of the things uh that's important is that we don't know what New York state is going to do as far as implementation of these recommendations and one thing that was clear from the report and the researchers is that they do not know with the essential recommendations how each recommendation will affect the other recommendations in a particular area in New York state one of the areas uh that impact the formula is
067the regional cost index for uh New York state is broken up into a whole bunch of different uh geographical locations and the regional cost index in Rockland County is not uh where it needs to be and so there is advocacy with our our local legislatures at the recent uh Rockland County legislative webinar that I attended uh there was a lot of discussion about the regional cost index being shifted or adjusted uh and they are Lobby lobbying for that to happen in all ALB should that happen Rockland County stands to receive an additional $24 million in state aid which for a district like South Orangetown is roughly around a million dollars so uh we're hoping that that advocacy makes its way to Albany and that there is some adjustment to that Regional cost index in the
068near future another thing that uh we are advocating for is at the very least this year that the state used 2020 data uh or or more recent census data rather than uh from 2007 so we'll see how that plays out um in the State of the State address uh today Governor hul addressed a few uh priorities that affect K to2 so I just wanted to share those because that's hot off the press so Universal School meals uh they're proposing funding to ensure all Point all 2.7 million students uh across New York State receive free breakfast and lunch which would provide approximately 400 meals each year uh and they're projecting would save families an average of $165 a month on groceries Food Services is something that we're continuing to work on and one of the things
069that was identified as an area for improvement in our school Community survey results um so I was glad to see that and maybe it's an opportunity for us to to really improve uh our uh Food Services also um included in the governor's proposal in the executive budget is to address distractions caused by smartphones and they're looking for a Statewide standard we are obviously way ahead of that with our our cell phone policy uh that we implemented across K through2 uh another thing that came out today is they're looking at um giving credit for high school students who are taking college courses you know we have lots of kids that take college courses at tapenz high school but there was a cost associated with that so I was I was glad to hear that that that's
070being looked at and thought about it's possible our kids would be able to get college credit um and and not have to pay for it uh they're also talking about expanding media literacy which is something we've been talking a lot about um and they're creating a teacher guide uh and launching a public education campaign um and one of the other things that's going to be coming out is an indigenous educational materials curriculum resources focused on indigenous cultures histories and contemporary issues will be developed uh ensuring cultural accuracy and promoting understanding so those are just some highlights from the State of the State and that concludes my superintendent report I don't think so all right no public commentary tonight um um we can move on to board discussion um committee reports I have a facility to
071report I don't know if anyone else has a report um but I can just go right into the facilities committee notes from January 8th um regarding phase one of the capital project the William O Schaefer case work uh Nickerson uh has been providing pricing for that we have the Cottage Lane back backlit sign is 2 weeks out from being completed um regarding HDMI resolution to be discussed um cat 6 versus [Music] HDMI um then we have the tapy high school outdoor classro d uh drainage um issue uh the contractor has uh given a proposal to solve the problem and it's under review then regarding phase two of the capital project we had the kickoff meeting which occurred on January 8th we have pack and play uh out of March pack and I don't remember that
072pack and play um it brings me back to the days of having a a very little kid um has a March deadline to ensure adequate building prep time and then we have the Taven High School auditorium the post the bid in April and that work is going to be six to seven month work scope then we also have the taby high school science rooms that we're we're working on with the construction manager working on estimates for those and the principles are confirming the specifics in each scope then we have the phase three submitted to S on 104 sorry it's so far out summer work 2025 we have the TZ admin Suite SD is reviewing comments that uh the S review comments are have been received and then we have um a fall bid on that
073work and then in May 2025 we have the budget vote considerations we have the taby cafeteria serving line renovation that we've been talking about um other various building requests from each uh each of the buildings and we are prioritizing considerations for review the field study the TZ nurses Suite the William mche for casework the taben high school serving line the school store entry and the William O schaer main office that's it there any other committee reports no okay okay so we can we have revisions for policy 4532 that one line uh we have the one line that was added the serving as a classroom Ambassador parent a single day field trip chaperon so not not a very big change um to the policy but have everyone's okay with the policy or we okay to I
074don't want to uh I don't want to try and explain the the change because I'll probably butcher it I don't know if dark ttic wants to explain explain I think it might help our audience at home and the audience here if we explain the change because I think it's much more simplified there was one more added so thank you evening board trustees um policy 4532 has been a bit of a journey uh we've been working on it for two years uh it's all in the cause of safety for the school district um but essentially um as we were revising policy 4532 over the last two years our schools have been making their own efforts to improve safety for field trips uh that's kind of changes happen at both fronts um at one point in the
075iteration policy 4532 I think we had three tiers we collapsed tiers to two tiers so there's um different levels of thresholds we take our volunteers through level one would be that they uh complete an application that they understand the expectations of school district as a volunteer tier two volunteer goes through a background check their board approved they have a reference uh much bigger application and that's typically for our sports program volunteers or folks like Who oversee our robotics Club to which happen to be on tonight's agenda in any case in speaking with our principal team um they gave a lot of good Insight at the school level that we have a number of parent volunteers and classroom ambassadors that are in classrooms regularly with teacher supervision and to make them a tier 2 volunteer would
076probably be um not a great match and a bit cumbersome uh because we have over 100 parents in our school district throughout the year in the classroom so that's one reason we want to bring our parents and our classroom ambassadors into the tier one uh category and we met with our principles last week we also talked about fi field trip chaperon and essentially at one point in time we thought we'd have field trip chaperon be tier two uh volunteers but again um our principles work really effectively to um limit instances in which volunteers are with students by themselves when they go to museums or theaters So based on the recommendations of our principal team we think it makes sense to ship the one day field trip chaperon into tier one as well that's the explanation
077and it's in the red line too can I answer any any other questions or provide any more information young lady who pointed out the classroom Ambassador issue right can somebody point it out that's what CAU of our attention I feel like I I think a PTA member wrote To Us Mr s back in December one of our parents wrote to us and I think the parent made an excellent point and I think we all agreed it made sense to revise the policy so um I you know I think there minor revisions we could certainly either approve it this evening if you feel comfortable or we could take it back to the policy committee but I I think we feel pretty good about where it's at at this point in time thank you thanks Joe okay
078um so if if we all are okay with that we can make a motion to reopt it is motion so moot let me just say sorry motion to reopt Revis policy 4532 School volunteers motion thank you n thank you Dave all in favor I I all right got that one done for you Joe um all right if there's any agenda items you'd like to discuss can someone kind of uh I guess summarize there's a lot of brusi Contracting ink here I'm just curious if somebody could something in layman's terms I'm just trying to I think there's like five five or six issues here speak on that yeah there's a usually there's one or two I want to see there's six in here so with with the closing and wrapping up of some of the contract
079of the work like the SS nurses Suite A lot of them a few of them are funds being returned so decreases in the in the contract so it's actual actually favorable for the district so for instance one on page two states credit for the balance of unused contract allowance so it reduces their remaining contract value um of cost that they're not going to incur at this time this was all stuff from phase one from phase one yes and while I'm here just um as Maran presented the audit report the risk assessment there's two separate resolutions and the business agenda for um the two separate areas of recommendation for her to do an internal audit on so as I stated one is required they recommended two and just giving the board a full um perspective we're
080assessed that low for most of them except for facilities facilities they just have to do a followup up and that's not within the fee that's just kind of touching base and looking into what we have implemented um my perspective I'm fine with doing both but if it's not required I don't think we need to incur the additional cost um I also think it'll give them more time to review data that we'll give them for the facilities um update it's up to you either way we can go it's not necessary to do both we can go with one if you see the summary page where they had the the chart where everything was low except for facilities everything is low so they're recommending two every item on that list was reviewed within the past two to
081three years just giving you a full um perspective on that up to the board either way is fine so it was projects for the inter yep and capital assets on the next page to do one um when do they need to know bu so once you approve this then we'll you know move forward with the service I'm just wondering if the three board members here decide you know what we're good with one board members come on and say you know what I they have a persuasive argument as to at a later date or is it now or so they wrote them up in two separate agendas I mean two separate um agreements so if it's the next meeting we can add it later we can add it yeah but these are to be done before
082June of this fiscal year all right with approv I mean but they'll they'll most likely issue a request list as soon as this is approved so if you feel unsure and you want to approve both that's fine as well that means say that again they'll they'll they'll send me a full list of items they need to review and if they're looking at two areas they may send them all as one batch I don't want to complate the decision but just wanted to let you know it's not required to do both definitely leaning no Capital project is could do one or you could do both so just do one stay with one for now yeah and they'll come back with a facilities update too we're going to remove 10K from thank you n thank you thanks
083okay so one change I have is there anything else I have a question for uh miss luo the new club uh the Red Cross Club can you tell us a little about that I know you have an explanation here but it looks like a great Club idea would this give the students any type of certification e so they won't um because it says you know CPR in here and CPR is a day training will will they receive the CPR certification from American Red Cross or no again that was something that they talked about being interested in um you know largely at our school yeah so that's something e but do they have to be part of the club a it's a great idea um I'd just rather see them get a certification no I would
084too but it sounds to me like it's in the stage is that 8 hours of course I just like the fact that it's something that's potentially life you know saving well CPR is life saving so I know but I mean it's just I high school I wasn't thinking about this kind of stuff it's interesting 18 18 is the state age for them to become so I mean you're looking at seniors yes and some some of them are the end of all right um is there anything else on the agenda now we can uh I can make a motion to make revisions the agenda to remove 10K from the business office consent agenda do I have a motion Mo thank you all in favor I I all right now motion to approve consent agenda categories 7
085through 12 motion give that one to Diana Dave second thank you all in favor all right um if we have any new business if not we can move on to the ni budget Workshop we have planned all right um so then I will make a motion to adjourn the meeting to a budget workshop at 8:53 p.m. a motion thank you thank you all in favor hi hi all right thank you everyone all right so we're going to bring some tables in so we can all sit around for this need