CorpusRecord 232964

Grand Island CSD Board of Education General Session Meeting 2-3-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Grand Island Vikings TV
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,590 words · about 93 min
Collected
2026-06-27

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001to non emergency we're on live are you here tonight [Music] number one M number one [Music] t mic phone number two mik two cence cence check check two test test two rock on with mik two one two three four five six seven eight n 10 11 12 multiplications of 12 let's try it no not really uh M number three super mik one two three check check one two M number three number three M number four mic number four three is quiet let try three again three I think is loud all are quiet interesting okay I'm going keep talking four check check one two four I probably turn four up a little bit one two three is your speaker up one two three one two three mic number five this is mic number five check one

002two one two one two three microphone number 61 two12 12 312 and the podium M two three two three podium one two test one two I will look into the input in the program and see if that will help you know they doing the they doing the Overflow room tonight uh there is an overflow room in a large Camp yes there is an overflow room you think are is presenting and then the good news she go no okay we're going to try this now and see if you can hear me [Music] better I'm in the corner fair enough I raised the input on the program so hopefully you can hear me better check one one two three starting with the podium any better check check one two it's playing louder in here so that's why

003I'm concerned about the Street and you're probably overflow room tonight as well any word on the volume check one to so any students who are speaking in here make sure you're nice and close to the microphone please thank you any better on the stream as far as volume level check one two there's agendas and okay you're welcome hi good how are you you I do think he a like not [Music] chck check them two one two three one two 3 one two three CH Che mik number two M number two M three M three microphone number four check four Mike six Podium Podium podium was it's pretty how are youting this must be small not realiz [Music] did how no problem just want to make sure you got your new one really [Music] yeah I

004had no time to get my that's why did you cut it there are all from to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands indivisible andice with us this evening we have Roger broker trustee Jay Grover trustee Jude our district clerk Dr Brian Graham superintendent um Dr Ashley Dreer president Sue marsten Vice President we have joy Mara trustee Daniel Bruno trustee John Fitzpatrick assistant superintendent of he has a very long Title Here curriculum staff development and Human Resources Cheryl Cardone our assistant superintendent of pupil Personnel Services and Dr Robert Merkel assistant superintendent for school business and finance um announcements if you could silence oh and Sher Steins is exced evening um if you could silence your cell phones please um we would greatly appreciate it and please

005note there are emerc sits directly behind me and directly in front of me in the event we have to leave um during the emergency um okay if I could have an approval for the agenda for this evening please if I could have a motion and a second all in favor I any objections any exensions motion carries 60 and if I could have a motion to approve the minutes from January 6th please and the second all in favor I any objections any exensions motion carried 60 we have a couple student ambassadors with us this evening um first uh Le good evening good evening Dr Graham Dr Merkel Miss Cardone Mr Fitzpatrick and members of the Board of Ed tonight I have here with me Lexi young Lexi is seventh grader from bcms She's our multimedia Specialist

006of our student council and a member of the modified girls volleyball team she's here to just give you some updates about what's been going on at dcms hello everyone my name is Lexi young and today I'll be talking about what is going on in the middle school and upcoming events this month we will have be having our suer sale and a Valentine's Day volleyball tournament the student council suer stale suer sale takes place next week students can purchase a sucker for 50 cents or a ring pop for a dollar to have sent to their friends on Valentine's Day suckers will be available available for purchase outside of lunches Monday through Thursday and suckers will be delivered to home rooms on Friday the Valentine's Day volleyball tournament takes place Friday February 14th right before break students

007can sign up by forming a team of six and Don $3 each each team chooses a charity or cause to and the money will go to the cause of the winning tee JB DEA students are going on going on field trips to visit local businesses and learn about what they do students are also working to make no so blankets for the homeless students will be staying after school for the next two days to help cut and tie these blankets that will then be sell them that will then be donated to those in need the yearbook is holding a contest for students to create the cover of this edition of the yearbook students have the opportunity to draw or create a cover on the computer that will have the chance to be featured on the front

008cover students will vote to determine the winner of this conference also recently a group of French students had the opportunity to spend a long weekend in Quebec they had a fantastic time exploring the city and learn about the culture while practicing the French language thank you for your time thank you [Applause] good evening everyone I am so excited to introduce to you Annabelle linen feler I always pronounce the name on I apologize um Annabelle has been so active in our school Community uh most notably in our music department you have seen her on stage and you will continue to see her on stage with our something's rotten play coming up we hope everybody comes to see uh next year Annabelle will be pursuing her studies at Robert's Wesley where she's looking forward to studying abroad

009without further Ado good evening my name is Annabelle linen felzer and I'm a senior here at Grand Island high school I'm honored to have been selected as the tonight's board Ambassador for the high school this month I'd like to highlight some of the great things that have been going on in our school lately over the past two weeks the high school has been closing off their second quarter students have completed their region and Midterm week due to snow days midterms have been rescheduled for later in the week or during classroom time the second quarter grades are available today February 3rd on the portal this past month inter Club has been collecting donations of socks and underwear during all home basketball games and in the in the library the Rotary Club of Grand Island will distribute

010these donations to support our local community the class of 2026 is currently doing an online fundraiser through Little Caesar's Pizza the fundraiser will end on February 10th the pizza can be shipped to your house or picked up at a Little Caesar's location the donations will go towards the junior class to help support future events over the past few months 35 Grand Island high school students have been rehearsing for this year's musical something rotten along with the performers the pit Orchestra led by Mr El and Mr Reed will accompany the cast to bring the show to life there will be three shows in the High School Grand Island theater Thursday February 6th and Friday February 7th at 700 p.m. and Saturday February 8th at 600 p.m. tickets are available for purchase online for $12 pre-sale or

011at the door for $15 they also offer a discount for seniors and students for $10 pre-sale and $13 at the door over the past month we have upgraded our gy gymnasium and wait room there has been upgrades to the wait room equipment and we have refinish refurnished the gym floor check it out next time you attend a sporting event the Grand Island boys barity basketball team is off to a great season this year they have a 13-1 overall record with a league record of 61 putting them at a third place spot for their A1 Conference standings recently winter sports have been starting to have their senior nights these nights are a fun way to recognize the seniors for the many traditions for many years of participation and hard work they put into their sport this

012tradition allows the teams to celebrate their senior past accomplishments and wishes them the best of luck for the future thank you for having me here tonight and go Vikings thank you that brings us to the correspondence recognition good news as we're very excited Mrs P bout maybe you could help illustrate some of the wonderful work you and your entire team and our students are doing for something rather wonderful so inel did a wonderful job of introducing our show um I'm Miss cout I am the producer and the director I have Mrs Jennifer meret at the end she's our vocal director but also does so many other things as the kids all know um set design and and helping with the prop list and just the list goes on and then we have from um our

013Middle School we have Mrs Jessica trippy Rogers who's our choreographer um the three of us are kind of known as the directors because um we kind of have been working together as a team to kind of bring this together you heard Annabelle talk about um Matthew ell's and John Reed who've been doing the pit um conducting and getting the pit ready for their um their part in the show and then we also have Mr Sean s who's helped to build the set as well as Mr Mark Gorton who's been doing the technical stuff in the back and then um Mrs anelia shinta who is our lighting designer so we're very lucky to have a robust amount of staff here at the high school who all are involved we also have um Mrs Nanette Keller who's

014one of our um SRP members she is one of our vocal assistants who helps out um and numerous parents and community members who've been involved in costume design and set design um so it really does take a team we have 35 kids in the cast and and about equal to that in the pit I believe um between the two um tomorrow we're going to be performing for the high school students um so we're really excited to kind of showcase some of our our numbers and then we go up this weekend so great and I did not know this show and I've been en thoroughly enjoying sitting in the auditorium watching rehearsals I was there most of the entire production on Saturday and if you guys didn't know Dr Graham is our number one fan of

015the musical the music he's very loyal to us could you you or somebody on your team just give us a little uh overview what is the show and what should we expect you want to do it Alejandra and I'm I'm going to Showcase this because he he he wrestles he does the shows he's multifaceted and I actually went and found him the wrestling mat like you have to come tonight um but if you want to speak a little bit as your character I kind of set it here so if if you need a little help first well the show was set in the 1590s and the show follows two struggling playwrights Nick and Nigel botom their brothers and who are desperate to outshine the legendary William Shakespeare um but and by the way who plays

016I do oh yes um but when they seek the help of a so-called soothsayer they stumble upon an idea so outrageous so ground breaking it just might change theater forever the result the very first musical love it's very fun it's very it's a very fun Journey yeah I think not knowing what the show was and sitting through it uh I a big fan now uh so I've never seen it before I think the the community is going to love it uh and there are really great catchy numbers and dancings outstanding right so miss boutes or something else any of the other so you know we don't come empty-handed and I make them do just about everything so if you guys want to stand you want to stand in the center a little bit guys are

017going to entertain our board with just um like Dr Graham said there's so many wonderful um numbers in this production and we really hope that the community does come out and support us we know it's not a a big Blockbuster show but it it was a wonderful show on Broadway many of us saw it at Shay it was just recently at musical fair and our kid our kids have really I think some of them actually said this is one of their favorite ones they've done so um they're going to be singing a little bit of Welcome to the Renaissance which is our opening number does somebody want to take the lead and kind of Conduct in y and so for the um I guess so yeah traditionally you would perform for the but if the

018board's okay if you want them to perform for the camera we can do that okay go ahead and then we'll get a group picture with the board do Mrs M do you want to lead him in uh Alejandro if any of the board members want to sit there are some empty seats maybe they would like to sit next to Alice and Tyler and enjoy the show from from the audience perspective [Music] inak the golden the days are over [Music] new a little bit from our opening number we really are very proud of our music department um and our our theater our theater Club as well and so we really welcome everybody to come out this weekend so great and if the board can join the students we'll get a quick picture [Music] Thursday at 7

019Friday at 7 Saturday at 6 I'll take a couple pictures get ready eyes open three two one thank you and Alice do not thank you very much thank you very much I just say instruction you can review the the updates that we have for the month of J thank you okay that brings us to Personnel instructional if I can have a motion to approve pi1 through pi6 please motion and the second all in all in favor instructional I any objections any exensions motion carried 60 and if I could have a motion to approve non-instructional pni 1 and pni 2 also with our um with our a um non-instructional add-on the second all in favor I any objections any exensions motion carried 6 Z and Dr Dr I don't think we have any intros today from

020our admin all right thank you so much okay all right that brings us to the finance section with Dr Merkel good evening board members how is everybody tonight um I have two action items actually three action items because I do have one Walkin um so we'll do those those real quick and then we'll get into our first uh look at the 2526 budget so uh item a is a donation a generous donation from Giza uh to support the emerging leaders conference for the middle school students uh Item B is B uh uh budget transfers over $115,000 and then the walk-in item is a um student student data privacy Consortium uh agreement so um as as you guys are aware edlaw 2D requires that we have DPA data privacy agreements with all of our software vendors

021um traditionally since this has come about in the last few years we've had to every school district has had to get these data privacy agreements signed with every software vendor that they deal with that collects student information so literally every school district was working with every data vendor to get these agreements signed what they have uh come up with is instead of every District having to get that agreement with every vendor is that once the uh bosis has an agreement with the vendor the district can piggy back on that agreement which basically uh allows that District to have the same protections under the agreement um as if they had negotiated their own saves everybody the the vendors the districts a lot of time and uh that's essentially what we're asking you to agree to tonight

022um in order for us to piggy back on other contracts through bosies the board does have to make make action and U approve a resolution in regards to that is there any questions again about uh items a b or My Walkin item yeah I have a question about the resolution um can you just elaborate as to the paragraph that States uh the dpas are presented to school districts and or bothos SE for final execution and do not require the expenditure of funds Beyond those budgeted I just want um better understanding of do not require the expenditure of funds Beyond those budgeted absolutely I'd be happy to answer that so uh these data privacy agreements there's no cost for the vendor or the district to uh do these agreements so essentially what that's saying is uh

023so even though we're still covered by the data privacy agreement in this shared piggybacking uh Arrangement the the actual contract and uh the agreed terms of the contract the financial part of it uh does not change based on this agreement so they're kind of two different things one uh each district will still have a contract with either the bosis or the vendor for that data for that software whatever it may be and then this agreement is separate from it and what that means is that we won't be charged any more money for having this agreement in place does that make sense yes thank you okay [Music] absolutely any other questions if I can have a motion for a and the resolution please motion and a second all in favor I any objections any extensions motion

024carried 60 thank you everybody so uh there's a couple informational items there for you and we'll go to item G which is the first draft budget presentation for the 2526 budget year it is H good for to do this presentation now is I we're all good for that perfect all right so as the board knows and has approved our most recent strategic plan we did make an adjustment uh just a few words uh added to the mission statement so you'll see that on the screen in front of you or on the handout that you have uh we're still working to inspire each student to achieve their Highest Potential but we've added by honoring their unique pathway and fostering academic Excellence supporting personal growth and promoting uh social responsibility as always I think over the last

025uh this is my ninth year uh these have been the budget goals to sustain a long-term budget designed to provide the best Diversified education program for all our students retain retain to the extent possible all Community mandated student programs and activities and as uh hard as we can to protect the fund balance so we always have fund balance to help us with the future uh of all of our programming additionally you'll see new newer uh strategic plan goals they cover academic Excellence operations student well-being and Community connections and those goals were just approved by the board in December as you know the budget development process is probably one of the most important things a governing body does in a school district so we're very very pleased that this particular Board of Education takes the time

026the energy and digests all that is presented to them additionally I would say that Grand Island is very unique it's very transparent you will today see all of the asks all of the wishes and maybe there could be in March an update of one or two more wishes that would be uh inserted into uh the budget and the board has you know the entire uh transparent process to go through and say yes or no or find middle ground and all that is presented to them over the next few months uh the process is outlined in this calendar and we thank the board for your active participation you'll see the next time we're together will be March 10th where we'll get a second uh look at the budget and then again on the 24th and as

027you can see just down the schedule it gets very busy over the next few months today uh there's going to be a lot of information shared with you so this agenda will be something that we'll be touching upon uh throughout this presentation and I'd like to just share ask Bob to give us a kind of a th 30,000 foot overview of what is happening in Albany and how it impacts us here in Grand Island thank you Brian so um before I get into that just a couple quick notes on the budget overall you know as Brian said um you know likely be some changes as we go go into March I've met with most of the Departments and uh buildings at this point um um couple just today you know the snow days threw threw

028a little Loop in that and had to reschedule the meeting some a couple times Phil can attest to that but um you know it's really great to get out there and and talk to the department heads and the building heads and see what the needs are out there and um so that those will all be reflected in here today I've also been working with uh Rick Tims on on you know viewing our long range financial plan and you know that's going to play into here as well as well as uh I've met with several insurance companies and we're going to be doing uh quoting on on a lot of those things as well just to make sure that we're getting the best bang for our buck uh in every area of the budget that we

029can um also that will be included for March that there's not much about on this uh meeting is the retirement so uh retirees do have until March 1st to notify so by the time we get to the March meeting we should have a much better idea of uh where those retirements will be so look forward to that in March and um we're still looking at upk and other items for next year so this will give us a first flush but expect that there's probably going to be a couple additions and and a few changes before uh we see it again in March so um that being said let's take a look so essentially the uh summary from the governor um you know she's put some some money into education here which was good to see

030there was quite a big increase in Foundation Aid 5.9% $1.5 billion doar which is good as you're aware they are looking at um redoing that whole funding formula uh they they did that uh they received that report from the Rockefeller Institute last fall uh SL winter so they're going to be finding ways to incorporate that over the next few years I would imagine but uh was pretty happy with with where we ended up for this year you know always would love more but um so there was five 5.9% increase in Foundation Aid um expense driven AIDS are expected to stay uh at the current legislative funding level which means um you know there's there is a Formula based on expenses um and so we expect those to go up slightly as costs increase slightly so

031also good news for us there um and then they're looking to put some money into preschool and summer school uh special education programs a 2.2% increase there uh a couple other things to note that might affect us are uh the governor reg recently talked about some cell phone policies and so there could be a financial impact on us for that if we decide to go with pouches or anything like that so uh more news on that to come as that evolves um she also signed the bill for the heat bill um that that governs uh the temperature that can be in classroom so we're going to be keeping an eye on that and evaluating anything that we need to do around the district to uh mitigate any heat issues and then um so those are

032just a few things coming down the pike and then the last thing that I wanted to share with you that she's discussing is universal free meals for everybody um so she is discussing doing that and in this year's budget too which would be awesome you know it's very important for the children to be nourished in order for them to learn so that would be great news for our families so uh looking at state aid uh again most of it favorable uh I do find that sometimes with the expense based AIDS they do seem to overestimate those a little bit um looking at what what they project and what the actuals are um I've just found that that they do overstate those a little bit um one thing that that I'll point out and I I

033will refer back to later if you look at the private access cost Aid line it looks like we went down by $300,000 there so there's a lot of times um in both the the high cost high cost exess cost and the private excess costs where things kind of flow between those two categories so you'll see one go up and one go down um but you see three different numbers there so on the left you see 73 that was the ex ex cutive proposal from 2425 this time last year so you really want to compare that number to what's in the third column that 696 that's uh a same point in time reference both from January one from 24 one from 25 the numbers in the middle are the the actual Aid runs in November based

034on what we actually report as a school district in the st3 so uh as you can see our what we submitted for that was quite a b bit higher than what they had projected which we will still get that money back but just so you kind of understand that 980 going back down to 696 is just them underestimating a little bit and it's an expense based Aid so we do get Aid back based on what our expenditures are for that particular are but overall um with the eight package that the governor put out you know uh much more exciting than last year yeah and just to for our board to understand understand last year we had a zero change in Foundation a well at this time last year we were talking about a 60,000 which

035ended up being restored back to zero but yes um so typically in the foundation Aid uh um formula you would get at least a 2% increase but they were talking about not even doing that last year um they ended up you know putting us back at at the same level but um early forecast looked like that might happen again and happy to see that for now that hasn't happened and there was some sort of increase in there so overall um the the total Aid you know looks like it'll go up by about a million dollars overall with the the total Aid without building Aid being 850,000 so those are what's on paper that the the governor puts out I do decrease that little a little bit which you'll see later on um to adjust for

036some of those things that has have historically been over projected um like the uh Transportation Aid so I I will point that out later in the presentation when I get there uh looking at the calculation for the tax levy limit also known as the tax cap so as you are all aware there is a uh formula for determining how much our tax levy can go up year-over-year um with without having the super majority vote so this year uh based on the formula we are again uh you know this was another another good spot for us so uh the allowable increase is 1.27 million or 3.14% for a total Levy of 41,8 46,4 if you look at uh page 11 the next page you'll see how that could play out on a tax bill um a

037couple of the assumptions that I made on this slide are listed on the bottom um I found that the medium home value according to the Grand Island community profile is about 185,000 and the uh star value or the star rate for the 2425 school year for Grand Island is$ 24, $30 so I tried to use some real numbers in here um so you'll see the as estimated uh tax rate is $828 as you may or may not be aware um the there is a reassessment going on on Grand Island this year in 2025 and that could is likely going to change the rate um so it looks different the overall tax uh Levy of $41 million if that's what we decide to go forward with would not change so uh that that the total amount

038that's levied doesn't change it's just how the rate gets calculated because if your assess value goes up and the rate technically goes down so we likely via the reassessment see this rate go down um so just pointing some of those things out any questions on any of that that number yeah so I think we've used 165 in the past I think that went up wasn't mean yeah last last year and I I agree with you I agree last year it was at 180,000 and if you actually look at the bottom left I put the link there uh so it's the double star link so it's Green Island New York Community profile and that's where it said 185,000 yeah I was kind of shocked myself I was like well I thought it was going to be

039a little bit higher but I thought it would be appropriate to use the median and not a low or a high number so I was just curious y absolutely um so uh if you look there on page 12 that is the formula for which the tax cap is calculated again just looked uh looks in a different format there and then you can also see on that slide some of the projections that we have seeing what uh the formula would produce out in future years last year uh the maximum amount was 2.4 7% we did go out at that amount um and that was an increase over the prior year of 978,00 again or 1,272 559 any questions on the tax cap or tax levy limit formula there for those calculations all right so now we

040will uh start getting into the revenues here so the revenues are are the money coming into the district so um you can see that the one of the biggest ones is the real property tax Lobby that's on the top that came from the tax cap formula um state aid that state aid particular number does not include building Aid which is listed down below we get uh taxes from Erie County to help us support some of our Learners that is estimated to be 4 Mill million again this year um state aid for bosies that is also broken out from the state aid category uh we are looking at an increase from last year there interest uh we did quite well last year on interest um as you may or may not be aware those interest rates

041are starting to go down a little bit so you know uh I'll be keeping an eye on that looking at some forecasts but you know I don't want to overestimate too much in area um payments in the of taxes for some of our solar farms and other projects about $114,000 there uh tuition 143,000 and then uh some reimbursements and other receipts for 36,3 33,300 respectively so all of that together comes in at 72 m653 690 so that would be our Revenue so the total budget that I will show you in a couple minutes is 78,3 [Music] 4,191 and uh so that is the maximum uh amount of expenditures at this point the difference between those numbers is what we make up by using appropriated fund balance um from our fund balance and from our reserves

042and that number right now is currently at $6,295 [Music] a decrease in use of that balance by 1 million almost $1 million from last year going on to page 14 State a as a percent of the budget um you can see it's it's hovered right around 32 33% so this year it's at uh about 32.43% all right dra budget so getting into the estimated major expenditures um starting with salaries so um salaries when we did the budget last year uh we were in the middle of negotiating with two of our units the teachers union and the administrator Union so um those projections may have been a little high last year which is why the the increase at this point um for next year is modest um I will be you know verifying all those numbers

043double checking but we will also be evaluating some other positions that we might choose to add in there um so you know that number will likely change by the time we meet again on March 10th um for substitutes there was a uh slight increase there and then uh cash and credit payments for some of the classes that are git members Gita members take uh I did do a $30,000 increase increase there um those have gone up and um we have paid quite a few of those out over the last several years uh the benefits just a slight increase in the benefits there uh working very hard right now um we just uh saw some results from an RFP recently and presented that to some of our bargaining units and looking forward to see where that

044might lead um but as of right now uh looking at a modest increase in benefits for next year ERS is a rate that we do not set um I believe it was 15.2 last year if I remember off the top of my head um so a good increase there TRS on on a better note did go down uh by almost a percentage point or a half a percentage point so small decrease there and then uh V is um we feel that we can leave that where it is right now there was no increase there as of right now uh retirement benefits uh for our three bargaining units there was an increase there of 195,000 workers comp insurance um we are bidding that out right now um looking at at all of our options so we're

045going to keep that steady at this point uh Bose's a slight increase there uh Debt Service uh about $275,000 increase increase uh utilities will stay the same fuel is going to stay the same special education tuition has gone up slightly so a slight increase there Building Maintenance uh that's going to go up and and a portion of that is going to cover our costs associated with the EPC so with the EPC there's going to be um we have to there's going to be some legal fees associated with that for our attorney to do the Seeker there's also going to be um um some fees with uh doing the the bidding of the lease with our financial advisor Etc so I did build some costs in there as well as some increases um that have uh

046necessitated that increase transfer to funds going from1 175,000 to 250,000 so that breakdown is $100,000 for our Capital outlay project which is the same as last year the inre increase of $75,000 is for um the summer 448 program for our special education students so uh as part of that program we do have a 20% local share and uh the last couple years we have under budgeted in that section A little bit so I did put an increase in there to cover that uh portion of our costs under contractual busing I did keep that the same uh we started off pretty good this year but have since added uh several runs so we will likely get close to that this year um still working with Teresa and doing recruiting um we do have some prospects but

047we'll have more retirements this year so you know still working very very hard to to try to get to the point where we don't need these expenditures anymore as of right now no no I I'm I'm pretty confident um that we can stay within that number again for next year you know we we've had a couple surprises this year um with special education runs we do have one uh run that we were able to work out with West Sonica so you know that cut the cost of that run for us almost in half just by sharing it with them so you know we're continuing to to try to find ways that we can save wherever we can and um so I I'm pretty confident we can stay within that for next year but I sorry

048go ahead I didn't mean to cut you [Music] am um I do but not in front of me um I I think there's going to be three to four off the top of my head but I can get that information for you for sure yeah and to that end I think Teresa also told me about three that she's expecting and she might have you said three today I think you also said you might have three in the pipeline so just be net neutral right you don't have if you had three in the pipeline and no retirements we be in great shape yeah so continuing to you know that's a point of focus for us and you know we we are very gracious for for your support in that area you know and for the the

049adjustments that the board has made in that area but uh just continuing not not quite where we hope we'd be but we'll keep on working at it and and do what we can we haven't gone backwards we just haven't gone forward yeah are we are we n neutral is it about a neutral has it gotten worse but hasn't gotten better it crack yeah it really yeah it's just it's kind of just maintained because of the anticipation of the retirees and then we did have three that got through the road within the last three months so I got one on the docket but um you know we know those are coming and this is the time to it takes four months to get somebody in to get them trained to go so right now we got

050to do a good push for bringing the recruits yeah so we we've gained a few we've lost a few so we're kind of neutral at this point but still still out there beating the drums um and then uh the last category is the other category which contain contain several different items those are outlined on the next page uh slight increase there of um $185,900 so as you go to the next page just ask a quick question absolutely you know I'm always asking about the other um just if you can refresh my memory for on page 17 the next page where it talks about contractual for the 2.3 million really what does that in contest so there's there's a lot of different things in that um the transportation contractual is not in there I did pull

051that out as a separate Major Impact item um but there's uh you know a lot of things from the business office for example our nyser pilot policy is about $400,000 so that covers our uh Property and Casualty Insurance through nyser um all of our audit type things you know our our external audits about $30,000 our internal it's about $20,000 so that's another 50,000 um the last year we had the uh building condition survey that would have been included under there that was about 130,000 which we will get a good chunk of that back in Aid um so all of those kind of items and as well as uh you know typically anything we have a contract for can come out of that category so a lot of the software contracts that we have a lot

052of the special Leed contracts that we have um so I'd be happy to put together a list of things that can come out of there we do we always use every I don't do we use this full 2.3 we use a good chunk of it I I couldn't I'd have to look to say yes no but a lot of times it things will get shifted you know we get a specializ student that has a placement you know it might come from line to another but we do typically use a good chunk the good majority of it yes you're welcome any other questions on any of those items in the other category I know there's been a lot of questions on on this in the past I just wanted to um you know address those questions

053did you I'm sorry did you address miscellane I I didn't so uh there's about $83,000 in there um that one is not used as common but there are some instances um where they just don't fit in another category so um I I can't think of a specific example off the top of my head but I could I could get some examples if You' like that absolutely it's always just good there are higher numbers and under the other category if the public asks us you know really what's in Contra what's in this and are these dollars being used maybe can allocate it elsewhere absolutely I'd be happy to provide that thank you you're welcome okay uh any other questions on any of the major expenditures or the other category right so um as you can see

054on the next page this is just a year-over-year view at the TRS and ERS rates um the TRS uh has been pretty steady over the last several years which is is good the ERS rate has been a little bit more volatile um so you know it has seen increases over the last 3 years so hopefully this will be the the the top of that mountain and hopefully we start going back down but you know I won't hold my bre today so uh now getting into the budget overview so on these next two slides 20 and 21 these items have already been included in the budget as it's presented to you today in that uh $78 million budget um so these ones have already been included and then the next ones on the requests those have

055not been included yet so just to make the distinction between those so um under the human resources category you can see the changes there 319,000 $ under the instructional program a change of 32756 um in the buildings so just a little note on the buildings uh I did a lot of work with with the building principles to reallocate some of the funds to help them get at what they're looking for rather than increase some of the categories we said all right well maybe we don't need much over here let's put it over here so we did did move some things around there um there was uh some some textbook lines that were over budgeted a bit so we did peel those back uh the the textbooks all stay within the state AED amount which I

056think is about 178,000 in that range so we we really stayed fairly neutral on the on the building side of things uh there was some increases in b& which I mentioned earlier so overall for the school buildings there um the subtotal there about 109,000 uh districtwide uh $3,000 increase in supplies the conference in travel so the conference in travel was really reallocated um I talked to to John and one of his priorities is to uh provide some opportunities for some of the teachers to go to more conference uh programming so instead of increasing a lot of those conference lines what we did was we pulled the money back from the buildings back to uh district office and any requests to go to conferences we'll go to John and he'll be able to use that bigger

057pool of resources to to get at um send teachers to conferences that align with our new strategic plan Etc uh it just gives us a little bit more you know in some of the buildings the budgets were smaller and might not been able to support uh everything that that we were hoping to support so we did kind of rearrange the conference in travel um contract ual $150,000 increase uh and that is uh a lot due to increased Insurance expenses legal and financial expenses for the EPC um Support Services Transportation $25,000 for uh equipment increase um that that could change there that is what I built in for potential Stop Bar bus cameras so uh we're going to be starting that part pilot shortly if we choose after that pilot not to move forward with that

058this will come back out uh and then we get into The Debt Service so The Debt Service subtotal is $274,700 and then that $75,000 increase uh in a transfer to the special Aid fund to cover the art the district portion of those summer programs gives us a total Appropriations increase of 1 Mill [Music] $1,936 60 Revenue changes in revenues so state aid earlier I talked about the uh million doll increase I removed I think it was about 275,000 that I thought was overstated that that they overestimated for transportation there um and some other things so the the actual projection that I have for State a is that we will receive an additional $36,250 as well as the tax levy limit increase of 1.27 2559 gives us a total revenue increase of $2 m8800 uh for

059a total uh net increase of 86340 so our our expenses versus revenues is almost a million dollars to the good which is good news but um as I pointed out earlier last this year's budget the current budget 2425 we had about uh over $7 million in appropriated fund balance we still have 6 million plus in appropriated fund balance in this budget which you know comes from our our Reserve funds and our our uh fund bance so enrollment oh did you have questions yeah I did sorry I I remember my question okay so the um the contractual under District R for 150,000 on page is it part of this contract that we just talked about on page 17 with the 2.3 million because we talk about insurance expenses there also yes yes so so if you

060take a look at the total Appropriations increase um that 1, 111,000 $936 is the same increas as on page 16 so these increases are just the point of 20 and 21 kind of shows you which buildings and departments where that money went to it it gives a little bit more Global overview of where those changes occurred in the budget so that one is part of that correct you're saying okay great thank you you're welc any other questions before Dr gam gets into enrollment no all right um if any students that are here want to leave and get their sheet signed before we start the next section come on up and get your sheet or you can stay for this exciting we understand how exciting it is you're welcome thank you for coming my poor son

061Tyler he gets to say this is my son Tyler he's here uh he's joining us tonight he is working on his citizenship in the community mirit badge so he needs to attend a public meeting and uh he should be taking notes over there so yeah well it just it happened that um that it was it was convenient for my wife to drop him off tonight so he is joining us and happy to have him herecome take your child to work day it so uh for the board and I think for our community I think the board and the community well I should say I think the community should know how um how indepth the board gets with all aspects of the budget development as I said earlier it's one of the most important things that

062the board of education does uh to that end uh this board will challenge uh Administration with respect to class sizes and understandings of what is best for student students and that is a healthy debate and or uh conversation so I do appreciate all of that and uh last year we had some of that uh conversation it was very uh rich and deep and I appreciate the board's input as you'll see on these slides just takes us back a little bit give the board an understanding of how enrollment has changed over the last few years uh you can see that in uh as of April 2020 we had 2,815 students enrolled in our schools and then in the 2020 2021 school year it was 2742 slate decrease and then uh moving forward the next year the

0632122 school year uh 2816 and then 2223 2787 uh the past year we saw that you know hover around 2754 this year we're at 2786 and this chart right here shows over time uh the changes by building so when I arrived in 2016 there were 981 students at the high school uh this year there're about 870 students so you can see the significant change in the high school all students this includes all students yeah y the middle school when I arrived at 700 right now our middle schools at about 615 youth uh 4 130 in 2016 actually an increase right now at 475 pegine 2016 410 now at 421 sidway has fluctuated 373 379 394 400 438 is that was a pretty big year 430 401 and then 405 so when you look at this

064there's a lot of questions I'm sure the community or the board has I think just overall families are smaller in size uh I grew up with four brothers my wife grew up with four sisters uh large families are you know still happening but we're also seeing a trend with uh you know children either one or two and the family so as this board looks at Grand Island in its totality when there are uh thoughts of developers wanting to build more resident uh projects uh that doesn't necessarily mean five kids will be coming into all those houses right it really might mean only one or two uh so it is good in my opinion when uh people want to develop on Grand Island and add families it's a beautiful community and we totally support uh enrollment

065uh going back up to 2,800 or a little bit bigger than that so that gives you a little bit of an overview uh this just adds projected numbers so it's the same chart with one more you'll see that the high school has about 870 we're thinking it's going to be about the same between 860 870 again um and then I think you'll see it start to move up after that back to the 900s the middle school we do think there'll be about 15 more students than there were last year uh a slight decrease at Huth a little increase at kabine and then a slight decrease at sidway I think that's really important to see that and we'll show you we're see those numbers so overall over the past n years you'll see this chart you

066know shows uh the changes right and uh this is the district in its entirety and the projected uh bar graph you know still slightly above 2750 but not at 2,800 or higher at this time you'll see the same at the high school uh from 980 uh to the projected 8 60 okay and then again this is just you know A visual representation of what I just showed for the middle school and then for combining HTH and kabine you'll see this trend which is good for the district this trend upward combining both Youth and Kine with a slight drop a little bit and then sway is just a little bit harder to predict right you have lower numbers higher numbers and then kind of if you were to draw a line you'll see it just slightly

067going down a little bit nothing too dramatic so this uh chart as the board knows uh represents uh Elementary class size ratios uh the these three columns where my mouses represents sidway then H is in the middle and Kine is near the last three columns updated for this school year our current number of kids that are not uh in special classes so when you when we look at this total this the there are 178 children in nine kindergarten classrooms with a class size of about 20 there are other children in self-contained classes that are not shown in this number and that's true for first grade as well so you'll see that this year we have 20 classroom teachers not self-contained not special education teachers in special classes these are just our general classes there may

068be children with special needs in these classes but they're not self-contained you'll see that overall our average class size is at 19.2 with 20 teachers attributed to the 385 kids so that's how you read that these lines represent second third fourth and fifth grade for both HTH and kabine so you're seeing our current number of students enrolled the teachers attributed to them and the class sizes one of the things that you'll see are 2 one teachers here 20 teachers here and 18 for Kine you're going to see in projected numbers this number to go down this number to go down and this number to go up and what you'll also see is which I think is very important for our board to always remember that kabine is a title one school that represents sign you

069know signific more children that come from poverty and what we really want to ideally see is that the average class size ratio is slightly lower than at HTH and and I wouldn't say necessarily slightly lower than sidway but you do want to see a little bit more resources applied to kegin because of the title on school we have talked about that a lot so as we move forward you'll see without self-contain that just breaks it down which we just looked at and this represents um all of the students K to five and then all of the students K to 6 so this board has been excellent at supporting small class sizes uh throughout the district are there any questions so far okay so as we move forward you know that we look very carefully at

070live it's called live birth data and those births from five years ago attributed to Grand Island now so as we look at this chart you know we're seeing that perhaps in the year 2020 there were 175 births attributed to our Island and so we can use that number as a predictor and we multiply a little there's a multiplier to this so instead of saying hey we only think there will be 175 kindergarten Rob we add a multiplier to make that a little bit bigger and the number that we're attributing to this number would be about 192 any questions about that I do want to point out this is a very interesting number right here right so when we're sitting together a year from now this number will probably still be 162 5 years ago in

071the future right and that that M that number we probably will not be predicting 192 kids coming to that kindergarten class in 2026 right we'll be we'll be looking at a smaller number does that make sense okay if I could just add on to that so that multiplier that Brian speaks of is uh in forecast 5 they compare the the live birth data to how many kids actually enroll in kindergarten for a given year so that's where that that multiplier comes from it for us I think it's right you know around 1.1 something like that typically um meaning that usually we get a few more kids that enroll in kindergarten than we're actually had for light birth so just to elaborate on on what that multiplier is a little bit Yeah but that number for

072next year is most certainly concerning so you've already seen this chart it's just duplicated again just to make a point that when you see that there are 20 teachers in kindergarten and first grade at Sway and 21 at HTH and 18 the projected number looking ahead to next year we're looking at going from 20 to 19 from 21 to 20 and then from 18 to 20 so moving a teacher more than likely out of sway moving a teacher more than likely out of Youth to provide an equitable uh class size ratio at Kine so you'll see that this says 20.6 which is really 21 this says 21.7 which is really 22 and this still with the decrease of one teacher predicted at uh the whole building at class size of 19 so if I were

073to just jump up and show you we're at 19.25 at sidway and going down in projection we're looking at 19 so really by moving a teacher we will not change the class size ratio but it will support p raos a little bit better than it is now so you can see so so you'll see right by grade kindergarten projected at 182 which is really 19 first grade 19.7 which is really 20 then second grade 21.8 which is really 22 and then in kaby 20 right so this might these classes might be 22 whereas at kegm it might be at 20 for second grade right and then third grade class size ratios of 22 and a half which is really 23 and at kegy 18 which is just unique it's a smaller group of uh students

074and five teachers attributed to that uh so we got uh second third and fourth grade there are 133 kids at youth with six teachers class size of 22 110 at kabine five teachers class sizes of 22 and then you can see in fifth grade class sizes of 20 or 21 and 22 a little bit so we do our very best to support all classrooms all buildings uh and in this uh projected number we think that this would uh provide Equity across the three Elementary schoolsan if I could just uh PPE in on that slide too so uh Brian referenced the title One funds over at kabine so every year we have to do a survey John actually does it to show that uh what we're providing at kabine is they call it a comparability report

075we have to compare kabine to HTH which has the same age of students and they want to see that there's more resources over at kabine because we're getting those additional Title One funds to support those uh needier students over there so just so everybody's aware we do have to report on that to the state so we want to make make sure that that we're doing what we need to do to make sure that that that is falling in line with what we need to report yeah thank you so looking ahead we had a lot of debate last year about moving a middle school teacher to Elementary we did not do that and you know so currently we have 190 children in sixth grade supported by nine teachers and a class size of 21 you can

076also see the numbers here for middle school and then High School uh and then whoops and then you'll see here we always kind of break out the kids that are in self-contained classes at the middle school nobody for sixth grade seventh grade we have five e8th grade we have three so as we look ahead to uh next year you know we're still keeping nine teachers they're working with 190 kids we're going to keep nine teachers and they're going to work with 2117 kids class size actually goes up and last year we had a big ation about that I was I was recommending that this number go down to eight and this this class size ratio would have go down to 24 well here we are keeping that teacher we're going to have class size ratio

077of 24 next year one M Reas just want to make sure you're aware of that and that's it for Roman any questions about enrollment very good all right so let's look ahead to some more uh wishes and wants and needs uh Bob did a great job in just showing the board over the last two years what the board has U been gracious enough to agree to add to our program so that is represented here for your review uh any any other highlights I think that just says it all right yeah I mean one of the biggest things I wanted to point out was our investment in cyber security you know we've all seen events over the last couple years the cyber security events you know we obviously have a big budget so we're a Target

078you know and um the these Bad actors are exploiting unfortunately um you know the private sect or the public sector in schools and things like that so we've done a lot of work with you folks the last couple years to make sure that we're protected on that front um and I did talk to Josh today to to make sure that there was and anything else and we feel pretty comfortable with the package that we have together now we we feel protected but you know it's it was a big hit over the last couple years you know it took a lot of resources to make sure that we're protected so thank you for your support on that you know that was a lot of what was included in there as well as several other things so

079just wanted to to highlight what we've supported the last couple years and then we'll get into uh the requests from the buildings and the Departments um again so these requests that I'm going to show you here were not included in this budget at this time um and there are still some other requests that will be added in here um based on my conversations with Cheryl and Robin and um Athletics I still need to put in there so there are a couple more requests that will be going in here after uh for our next meeting um I just want to I know you had a a slide right here just this I know this is an estimate it's not a perfect slide but you have corre just so that the board understands if the board were

080to approve adding a full-time equivalent Personnel whether it's administrator or a teacher or SRP generally speaking this is what the ask looks like just to so we understand you know what we're looking at um you know you have the salary and then there's a lot of benefits that come along with it so just so we fully understand what the requests are and what the impact would be on the district uh if we decided to to move forward with any of these requests and then you know for the board's understanding these numbers just represent the family plan correct clearly you know if a new SRP was added sometimes they might choose a single plan or whatever or maybe their spouse has a plan that would would then correct be a savings for the district but it's

081just important when we plan to know that approximately what we're asking for what that uh could could cost correct and you see the employee contribution there that varies based on the collective bargaining unit with each of the units um ERS and TRS also varies the the SRP are in ERS and the Gita and admin are in TRS um FICA is is just 7.65% of the salary regardless of the unit and uh the contracts also do uh include some Provisions for some other benefits um so I did include some some estimates you know maybe be lower or higher but just to give us an idea of of what you know those costs might be and this information is also important for our district team our administrators or supervisors not just the board right because sometimes somebody

082might think well it's only 40,000 you know the salary well they might forget about ERS they might forget about p and other benefits so this definitely spells it out very well and I and I know sometimes in the presentations where did he get that number from so I did try to take take some extra time in this presentation to be you know very forthcoming with with where some of those numbers came from and you know they're not always perfect as it is a budget you know everything is is educated estimates right you know some of it we have hard concrete quotes and numbers on and a lot of the other areas it's our our best guess using data you know they do a lot of data collection ISM talking to our folks looking at the

083the performance of our current budget our past budgets um to make projections for the future I'm just going to kind of briefly go through this for the board you know how we process this we show you everything everything that's been asked for uh sometimes it's hard for us to put it down on paper because we're like What are you asking for but for the most part but it's important for our board to to understand that transparency sure yeah talk to one of our custodians yeah a little chilly over here we're testing out the new air conditioners well done thank you so a couple things when you look at when you look at this chart there's it seems like there's a lot but some of it is isn't very costly so as our principles and supervisors

084share with bob their wants wishes and needs um it it is then shared with you uh breakfast monitors we know that the governor is really saying hey we're going to give breakfast and lunch Universal free meals it may require us to have supervision more supervision than we have right now at the high school and that may be true in other buildings as well uh this is a request to increase art from 6 uh with an addition I guess will be8 in total or 2 FTE and you can see uh equipment for science and chemistry the big ticket item here is uh the district doing everything we can to make sure that we're complying with the governor's uh heat or temperature uh law or mandate or whatever it is uh which could increase uh costs particularly

085on second floors where it's the hottest in the schools so right now that's estim number it might go down there may be other ways to pay for that but these are portable units that we would use in the interm you'll see requests for different uh computers or iPads cameras uh advisor ships that the uh Mrs Brett's Harvey would like to see in her building so all those things are listed here we'll continue to have these conversations with you in the weeks and months ahead other big ticket items I think would be just maybe refreshing of some of the clear touch televisions you'll see $30,000 attributed to that um and maybe some furniture so a lot of asks that uh are up to about 300,000 requests from high school any questions about the high school I

086just see that they're asking for a few more detectors um have we ever seen any information um with the VAP detector that we the and maybe meeting that I have missed but is there any way we could get an update to see just I we I think we SP $42,000 the last year the year before we just see yeah it's a great idea some sort of a report might be a great time to get in I'll ask John to work with Hillary and schedule some time they we're going to have presentations from some of our High School principles at the next uh board meeting to be elaborate but a report statistical information to increase with the investment that we made absolutely thank you for sure moving on to the middle school you'll see uh we

087have a broken uh TV in the conference room that needs to be replaced we have uh some other smaller items and more of a Furniture request for our cafeteria wouldn't be the entire cafeteria right uh but at least looking to refresh update maybe up to 20 tables yeah that was just an estimate of 20 tables when I was putting this together I do believe the intent is for the whole cafeteria eventually maybe not next year but um eventually uh I know the pritur there is getting kind of rough so very good I think that's a item too maybe for the school so wondering in the event that we decide to do that maybe yeah comine purchase advantageous at the same time effective maybe yeah cheer and both maybe we that at the same time I

088just Hillary mentioned that I don't see it there I don't just a thought process uh it might have been uh on the next page yeah it's it's on the Capital High School replace cafeteria tables and chairs Mak sense same together so you'll see to if it's okay we'll talk about sidway uh Mr an talk to Mr Dr Merkel you'll see a request from sidway to have a shared assistant principal that would be shared amongst three elementary schools you'll see the cost uh that is estimated for that request backwards is that the where are you looking so the the one on the bottom would be a uh it's a longterm he he uh specified that himself which is why there's already an X there in the 2026 and beyond that eventually he'd like to have his

089own assistant principal so phasing from the shared assistant principal uh to having his own assistant assistant principle in the future okay request for AIS math at Sway and a probationary building based sub request this looks like a one building based sub for sidway that would would uh equate to 91,000 I'm assuming Bob that you're attributing Health Care uh was that the request from corre that that goes back to that uh slide 45 that's that um 91 right yeah okay 91322 in this chart here in this so you you just applied this right correct Goa and it could be lower could be higher but correct yeah yep but you'll see the you know the tell made that request and uh what we have kabine a request for a special education teacher a full-time enl uh Cheryl

090did a good job whether it was last year or two years ago showing the board The increased numbers of children that have English as a second language need uh we think we've we've hit the threshold and we more than likely you'll see enl Services uh continue to stay on the draft uh budgets from now until the last uh presentation with the board so you'll see that and this just attributes uh some enl help at kabine some at Huth and probably some other areas of the district buing yeah so we'll sure will cover that next time in March when she presents the pupil Services uh overview for the board so you'll see uh you know extra request for math or special ed or enl from kabine HTH uh asking for some support for lunch monitor um

091and I'm assuming Bob that's a full-time SRP employee with all benefits that's why it says 88,000 right uh correct yes they that might have been overestimate I'll take a look at that I was thinking of fulltime but but now that we're saying this out loud it's probably not a full time correct thank you is that an addition additional correct I how many do they have I think they have three now they reorganized there was there was I believe if I recall this correctly um there was they moved I believe the fifth graders into a different space for eating so they need two monitors in each space um what was the reason for uh I believe it was uh stated that there was an increase in enrollment so I think there was an increase in enrollment

092for this year I'm not sure if that's going back down next year i' have to look back at the SL but but I I believe it was based on promised and an increase than okay and we'll and we'll continue to look at these requests right uh this is a teacher on special assignment one of the the feedback that we're getting in many buildings with the Gita and the SRP is that more so than ever before we're working with children who come to us with uh significant Behavior needs aggression uh hurting others hurting themselves or hurting staff uh through this presentation the district will be asking the board to consider allowing us to create a teacher and special assignment position with a specialty particularly in behavior management understanding functional Behavior ass understanding how to create behavioral

093intervention plans and support some of the neediest children prior to sending some of these challenges Outsourcing it to other entities we think we have amazing teachers we think we have amazing SRP and we clearly know that we have some Specialists who understand special education who understands behavior management and we we think we're at that point prior to Outsourcing our own work uh and moving children to other agencies off of Grand Island we want to do our very best to make sure that kids have the greatest opportunity to stay in the district to be with their peers and to have their best uh opportunity to be to reach their Highest Potential so we'll talk about that in March for sure uh through Cheryl's Department did we hire a behavior specialist a couple years ago yeah right

094and how is this we still have yeah it Brett Brett's case mode is is he hit a ceiling there's too many kids that that have these needs so this person would support different from his position how will the two positions be different or are they the same well given the board's approval we would put out a posting then we would have internal applicant apply to come out of the classroom or come out of their specialty area to be the specialist and then we would back fill it with a longterm sub so we would still have would we still have the behavior specialist position yeah yeah Brett would still do his job or that position stays the same this isn't a second person that can provide the FDA the bips that functional behavioral analysis and help

095help teachers support but the position would it be the same function that uh BR does now yeah and it might have some additional duties yeah so what are we doing well I think there's a and if I could speak bluntly I think the tolerance level of working with uh children with intense needs has has changed over time and I think the tolerance level is decreasing so it really is telling me that we need to provide more support for kids uh and though sure I think you want to say something but I know you're going to cover this next time but basically without adding this extra support it could result in Outsourcing this work and costing the district more so this actually could be a costeff effective way of keeping kids in the district yeah so

096I just want to be sure Cheryl understood that so there's two maybe two possibilities for Sue's question what is the cost to Outsource and bring in a specialist to do this work and not have it done by art so what does that cost cuz when I arrived year we used a company called turning turning point and we were spending about $350,000 so we actually have faded that away so we so that would be good for Sue and the board to know what would cost to hire a specialist out Outsource that work like a consultant but then secondly what does it cost to take a child and have them go to an agency or some yeah Summit or summit's a great example um anything like that just a what is the current tuition not exct have

097be good for them to see the tuition cost right of different agencies yeah the students with more behavioral needs like Summit and and quite hon ly you know there are children sometimes that end up going to an agency where we've expended all of this effort and help right and and usually at that point parents are hugging us and Thanking us because we've done so much but really what's we're seeing is case flow is so high that he can't do it in result do we are the thee um expected to increase to based upon the last couple years increase in that um like in terms of from prior years so we had 81 position that we had to um reestablish at kabine brand new um and then we actually had an additional 611 classroom in Cube

098as well next year early projections we're already showing that we absolutely have to keep the 811 at K but we are adding a third 611 at Sway and we also will be um adding a 235 new onine we're splitting that in two because right now it's a two through five we're going to have to split that in two because of the need of our students some of this could be you know not scientifically speaking but if we go back five years right co uh children learn learning differently learning remotely social skill development is a challenge right for some kids not all kids but we're seeing maybe a spike in young kids coming into school hurting other PE uh right now we're working John fatrick and charl Cardone are working with laen stain to address particular

099child Community who is being very aggressive in their Community uh sponsored upk setting uh Cher and John and Laurence Stang have come up with a really important plan to support this child but the we're seeing a little bit more of this type of behavior andent TR to upk or into our classrooms I know absolutely all good questions so you'll see that of all the wishes and asks and lots it's an increase of 1.1 million and then you'll see under operations uh requests for um youth doors uh to be more secure and today we walked in the high school and we saw uh that Hillary pointed out some flooding throughout certain doors in her building so uh I I'll turn this over to you just to talk about operations so is as you are aware we

100did the building condition survey um this year and so Phil and I have started working through that um and really prioritizing and try to figure out um you know what what do we want to Target for this next Capital project that we're uh potentially going up in December for a vote um what can can wait what really needs to happen right away so we're really going through that with a fine Toth comb um to help guide us on our next Capital project as well as all of the wish list items from uh everybody around the district so um some couple things uh in operation so last year we had a request from Athletics for um both doing the gym floor and striking the track uh restriping the track so we did uh choose just to

101do the gym floor last year so this year uh we brought back the request for uh restriping the the track outside and then in my conversation with Phil um the one large mower that they have is about 12 years old it's getting harder and harder to get the parts for that so while we're not asking for that replacement for next year um we are starting to take a look at that so replacing that mower with the same size mower would be about 140,000 but an alternative to that that Phil's been looking at is buying a tractor and then having mowing attachments that would go on the back so that it could it would have about the same width of C uh this would be for our larger areas but then those those uh mowers could

102be removed from the back of the tractor and the tractor could be used for other things as well so it seems like that's the better option as of right now but again this um I I again indicated that was an x uh for the 2026 and beyond that will be a future request but just wanted to to put that on the on the radar that that would be coming down the road um never really mentioned yet but I've been really working with our department heads on coming up with replacement plans for things um I'll talk about it in a minute when we look at the buses um but I've also been working with Robin bless you uh been working with Robin on a replacement plan for all of our Tech needs um I've been working

103with uh Josh on replacement plans for various things so really trying to make sure these big ticket items that we're starting to come up with a a good plan and how we make sure that we're keeping up to date on things and and replacing things you know in a reasonable fashion so that we don't end up with huge expenses at some point all at once um so on the next page there those are all of the requests that kind of fall in line with the capital project so I will bring these requests to our team at Young and right again this is not an exhaustive list there's still a few things I need to add on there yes ma'am please move the lamp post y if you walk up the sidewalk to the district office

104you will see that there's a lamp post right in front of the sign says I don't I don't oh it's literally right in front of the sign yeah supposed to come back and do some fix up work and for whatever reason they didn't come back and F so it get if we could just add that it's just one of those things that you see you it yeah we all see it now Joy um yes can I Circle back to page 46 47 one thing that we noticed was that um all schools with the exception of kabine are asking for the cafeteria tables and chairs there but the high school is in with the capital project consideration can we move the other school's request into the capital project consideration since you have the high school yeah

105we we we can really put those either either either place you know uh this was a need that we noticed last year that was part of my request last year to to uh give the buildings more equipment money so they could start replacing some of these over time instead of having big ones um you know it's uh FF fixtures furniture and equipment are not aidable so even if we did it on a capital project we wouldn't receive Aid on it um so really we have different location build the yep y b I just want to make sure that uh the committee of the board that meets for a capital project discussion why am I oh this this is your slide so for Jo and Ashley and Roger Roger I think you're taking over for Glenn

106do I have that right by yep corre just to remind the board that on Wednesday February 26th here at district office at 6 p.m we have the capital Improvement scope meeting that would include Joy Ashley and Roger if you're able um so please look at your calendars let b or I know if you can come we will have dinner you know for the board but at that meeting will be young and right and campus who will go step by step through the building conditions survey and many of the items that may be on this list and we definitely are asking for the board the committee members to do your very best to join us for that because we will set up a regular schedule after that 6 o' here um super important because for Joy

107Roger and Ashley after we meet it'll become a board report where the three of you will share back out with the entire board these conversations and as we move through this work it is our wish that in December of 2025 we're going out to the public to vote on a capital project in the future so this the building condition survey is now complete B over the last couple months I think it's finalized so it's very rich in detail Phil Marina would be there Bob be there I would be there and as we work together we will add other constituents to these meetings after the three board Representatives give us some Direction so I appreciate uh the board if you can those three members to join us that would be outstanding and I guess uh Ashley

108I guess I would say uh you know I don't know if this is allowed but if one of the three are not available and you want to send it an alternate that would help uh with the consistency of the messaging so any questions about that okay perfect great thank you so much go ahead that thank you um so as I said that's not an exhaustive list uh we will be adding some of that to that but I will be putting together a comprehensive list of all the wish list and BCS items to share with young and rights so they can start on showing the all the the the items and then we'll have to uh break it down and prioritize it it's amazing how those dollars don't go nearly as far as you want them

109to um you know Bill and I were looking at the building condition survey and we just got through a few items and we were already at $5 million you know real quick so you know it's going to take a good amount of work to go through these and prioritize but we will do that together and hopefully find a project that's good for the community and keeps us moving in the right direction okay uh going on to proposition two vehicle purchase so um we had our transportation Study last summer and um Teresa has worked with me on coming up with a replacement plan for the buses so our Fleet our our active Fleet is about 45 buses uh and we typically try to keep them for 10 years so if you look at replacing 45 buses

110over 10 years replacing four to five buses per year last year we only replaced three buses so I did go a little bit higher this year and looking for five buses um and then also included on this is two uh for 4x4s we have about 12 of those I'm working with Phil on also doing a replacement plan for those trucks and for like the big Mower and some of his equipment so that we can come up with a more comprehensive plan and do better planning and look at our long range financial plan and how these things impact that so uh based on these requests with uh two large buses three smaller buses and then uh the two Ford trucks that would uh bring our budget up to 85,000 which is an increase of uh about

111130,000 over last year it has been around 675,000 the last couple few years but if you uh take a look back uh before that we were in the 700 range before that so um you know just want to make sure we're replacing things over time so that we don't end up with big expenses all at once yes ma'am I have a question about that driver so so that's the challenge right so to answer your question directly no not necessarily right so you know if we're if those buses are are done or if those runs are done by a contracted bus we would have a bus that that is not doing those runs so you know there's a couple different directions we can go with that you know our goal is to get rid of the

112contracted runs and to to be doing those runs so in order to maintain our Fleet and and the capacity to do that we do have to continue with our um replacement plan if we wanted to to modify that we would have to come up with like a hybrid model where you know we would dedicate these runs are going to be contracted runs and essentially take those out of our replacement plan um you know maybe a conversation that we might have next year if if we continue to not see success and that that those contracted runs are staying at the same level um would you have that we could have that convers ation this year but I'd like to continue to try to to to recruit more drivers and keep trying to get at that are

113any of the electrics ready for purchase so on my next slide I'll I'll have a little bit about that Joy did you have a question first um yeah just a question what is the average age of the 350s when they start to age out is it miles mileage are they out of warranty yeah so so um typically I believe we get a 5year warranty with them um and so there is uh about a dozen of them in the fleet um I've had some discussion with Phil about possibly getting a bigger like dump truck style so in a year that you know if we put that in the replacement plan somewhere that would probably be one vehicle just that dump truck cuz those are more costly in year um but that would give us some more

114capacity but these these trucks are out there plowing all of our Lots they're all good and covered in salt every year so you know they are they are you know typically the miles are not very high you know that's typically not the reason they start rusting out they wear and tear from plowing you know the maintenance starts getting expensive typically we've been pretty lucky with the trucks unlike the buses where when we sell the trucks after five six seven years we we yeah we've done pretty good so I I think the last ones that we auctioned off this year I want to say we were around $25,000 a piece not too bad after having them for five or six years so you know we've been pretty lucky in that respect but you know a lot

115of it is you know not necessarily due to the mileage cuz they're typically staying on the island but you know the wear and tear from plowing all the lot you know so they're out of warranty correct correct yes ma'am okay great thank you um all right any other questions on proposition two so this uh next slide is um just something that I wanted to get the the board's temperature on um and see if this is a direction that you wanted us to go um so I did put together some facts and figures on on an electric bus so I did not include this in in the current budget um and my thinking is that we would SE this proposition out for uh you know so people could vote on that separately from proposition one and

116two but um I'd like if the board would like to to entertain buying one electric vehicle this year um or to you know that's really up to you um if if we wanted to explore that then what I would probably try to do is do that on a separate proposition so that it if it did go down it didn't take our entire bus purchase down cuz that would that would be very disruptive to our replacement plan um but what I would do is if we did decide to move forward with the proposition three and we did try to get an electric vehicle or two this year I we would do it in a way that those Vehicles would be removed from prop or wouldn't be that that money would be reallocated from proposition two to

117proposition three so if we did do one or two that would decrease what's the number that's on on proposition to and and you know be replaced by electric buses and I feel proposition to the way it is just in case correct correct um so I got to figure out exactly how to to to word that but you know I wanted to get before I went and did all that extra work I wanted to get your the board's feeling on you know if if you wanted to move forward with that or wait another year so if I can dig a little bit deeper into what I've put together here um so in the upper right is um some projections that the uh one company put together for us on what the potential State a or uh

118not State a but um potential incentives could be so for a type c uh just the bus voucher would be about 147,000 if you have a qualifying bus for scrappage you could get another 61,2 I believe they've changed the requirements on the scrappage the scrappage used to be it had to be x amount of years old it had to blah blah blah blah blah blah blah and you had to put a hole in the engine block I think they've Chang their tune on that a little bit and broaden that a little bit so that um I think it can be almost any bus you put a a a hole in the diesel engine and they're happy with that I believe um have to do more research on that um so and then if you if

119you make it vehicle to to grid capable there's an add-on for that vehicle to grid I'm not sure if if everybody's familiar but that would be using your uh electric buses as a battery Bank essentially to feed back into power back into the grid and then the the the electric company would reimburse you for that power not something that I think we would want to entertain because uh it voids warranties on the batteries and and I don't think what they're paying you for the electric electric is worth the cost and the wearing tear but they'll give you to 250 as an incentive just to have it not saying that you have to use it you can get the that incentive I believe just for having that capability so uh if you add all of those

120incentives combined it comes up to um [Music] 221,000 so if you look in the lower left corner where I have incentives there um um the the bus incentive by itself is 221,000 there's also an additional incentive for 55,000 so if you put the charger incentive together with the bus incentive that's about 276,000 so if you look over on the right um so a lot of these calculations and some of these assumptions came right from the wendle study that we did to the electric bus feasibility study that's where I got some of these projections from as well as um you know some for sources I found on the internet so when you look on the right hand side what I tried to do was put together a 10-year projection the state is you know estimates a

12112E life cycle but our plan is a 10e replacement plan so I thought it would be appropriate to use 10 years here um so if you look at the final cost net of incentives at the bottom you'll see that the cost is about the same after incentives for an electric bus versus a diesel bus that takes into consideration the difference in fuel cost the difference in maintenance cost and again that a lot of that information was from uh the study that that we did so less the incentives you're looking at about the same price so a word about that I believe Sher asked earlier you know what what what would the total cost be I mean Brian came up with about 45,000 buses around the state I I saw something on the DMV that was

122about 50,000 so with the incentive sure it makes it makes those about the same price I don't anticipate that they're going to have enough incentive to go around for 50,000 buses so once those incentives are out the cost is going to be significantly more for an electric bus versus a diesel bus not to mention um you know you look at the total cost for infrastructure from the Lend study that we did and I believe it was around $8 million if you divide that out over our Fleet of 45 buses that's about $177,000 per bus in infrastructure alone on top of the very expensive buses so you know again really questioning the the feasibility of it but wanted to have the conversation and and you know see you know as of right now it looks like

123doing one one to two buses would be kind of neutral for us given that we get the incentives the way I would want to do the proposition would be that we we would only do the electric bus if we got the incentives you know because outside of the incentives it doesn't make too much Financial sense for us to do that the other part that I'm still exploring is what is the cost for us to install a charger so I've gotten quotes on the Chargers um there's uh a couple different styles the the the one style is a a 30 Kil 30 Kow oh I put it right on the top there the 30 kwatt unit um is about 55,000 that can do one bus the 60 Kow unit and 75,000 can do two buses but

124that is uh exclusive of installation so I've been talking to our Architects and really trying to find out hey what do I have to do what is it going to cost me to get some one of these installed right I know what the the cost of the vehicle is and the charger but what what do I have to do do I have to get a separate permit do I have to do a whole Capital project to get one charger installed I'm not sure I'm still exploring that so just wanted to to get the temperature and see what your feelings were on whether we wanted to to move forward with the proposition three do we want to try for one or two buses um so just looking for some feedback on that that part yes I

125like it thank you for putting the work in um what like so the overall infrastructure of the Chargers how would this you put the put two charger in how would that then play into bigger picture we so they would put it in the right yeah so currently we believe that there is um some capacity in the infrastructure that we have to tie this in so we might put this one like next to to the maintenance Bay or just outside the maintenance Bay so this might be an addition to that extra stuff that other stuff is going to require some huge upgrades we got to do switch gear upgrades which you know let's talk about that for a second just this the the lead time on the switch gear once you order it they're saying two

126years just just to get that equipment so you know we looked at three phases for for the infrastructure again you know so if if we put phase one and or phase two on the next Capital project it's not going in for a few years so they're saying we can't buy anything but Electric in a couple years here we're not going to have the infrastructure in place you know it's not even by the time even if we included that in the capital project once it's approved we're waiting a couple years on switch gear so it's still a lot of questions out there my question is is what are we currently what's the capacity without doing the upgrades not much not much I I I was teasing this out of wend and then they came back with

127a like $80,000 proposal to to put together this pilot with me so I I didn't want to move forward with that expense at this time um but that's why I'm kind of exploring this I'm thinking we can put one to two Chargers in without going through all of that and and having those big infrastructure you know but but still some assumptions thinking that I can do this you know that's why I'm exploring talking to talking to the Architects to see you know are those assumptions correct can we really do this or are we going to have to do other other things this is such an illc conceived mandate from our governor to all school districts across near yor state that it's it's resulted in so much advocacy not only from the Yuri County Association of

128school boards to New York State School boards Association to the Iran Andress school superintendent Association to you name it uh I'm sure Teresa you're organization as well as pushing back uh so we need to continue on that path too we need to continue to Advocate that this is absolutely ridiculous and we need much more time and much more evidence uh to ever consider uh trying to meet this mandate which by the way in 2027 requires us that we can no longer buy a gas or diesel bus in 2027 and then by 2035 all of our Fleet must be um you know electric or uh you know or I guess hydrogen could be an option down the road uh so it's so there's it's such a bad law but to that end as you know in

1292027 we have to we have to buy we can no longer Buy gas your diesel so it's important to to do this good work to to show how bad this law is but it's nice that you think it could be cost neutral to you know if if we were just to move forward with a bus Joy so quick question has there been any new communication coming out of Al with regards to the electric bus mandate after January 20th because there is the executive order that President Trump signed in the law the American executive order that eliminated the Mandate on electric vehicles so it's interesting so as I'm watching the news and the president is signing these orders one of which is the requirement for electric vehicles and it's funny as we were going I actually

130pulled up the executive order so I'm not yeah so there's going to be some communication and I'm just wondering if anything has come down from Aly now because now this conflicts with the executive order that President Trump just sign yeah thank you Joy Teresa have you seen anything to this yet just in the fact that yes Fally I mean the push is coming from Trump to are allowing this um new choices right for electric buses or not however New York state is holding firm fcal holding firm on converting everybody to the electric bus so um we just need to continue advoca yes and I think it's loud and clear I I haven't really met a superintendent that like this is the Great thing ever so I think I think in unison we all understand and

131we need to continue the you know shouting from the rooftops that this is not good for schools and the only real I just I just wanted to say it's it's also important to know that it's just not school buses it's Metro buses it's it's all buses so while we as school districts are looking at it I mean cities and towns buses have to looking as well right so so while we're looking at 45 to 50,000 buses for school districts what do city buses need I mean just it's just it's a huge it's a huge undertaking and and a huge amount of money and electrical resources uh joy to respond to that too I you know the only real changes I've seen so far are the schedule for amortizing The Bu for for building Aid I

132can't remember if it went from 15 to 12 or 12 to 8 but they that's the only real change I've seen uh changeing tune from the state other than that it seems everything is still I mean it's still new I mean the exec border was just sign June correct and here we are you know first week of February so do I think anything's going to come down as of yet no but it's interesting because that's Federal directing that you cannot mandate it so it'll interesting to see how H responds to it and uh what they're going to do if they're going to file suit or whatever they're going to do to try to roll this out when the president is saying no it's a good point and and I'm glad you brought it up because

133um you know when Tes and I were talking to our representative from the bus company he brought up these coupons so the way that they're doing manufacturing is you have to sell x amount of electric buses I think you get one coupon per or I I forget but you have to do so many electric buses to get a coupon to make a diesel bus so the the diesel buses are now being held up too because they they're not selling enough of the electric buses to get these coupons to actually manufacture the diesel buses so they're really and maybe that'll be the Tipping Point yeah yeah they're really that might be the that just might be it they won't be able to meet their quota and districts will need gas and Diesel buses as it is

134right now is you know we we're not seeing buses for a year from the order date you know so it's typically in the past they've uh been able to take a letter of intent saying we project you know we're not held to it until the board or the community actually votes on the budget but once they get those letter of intent they'll typically order a diesel bus to shorten that time that it takes for us to get it once it's ordered with the electric bus they're so expensive and they they're getting shut down so much at at votes that they're saying we're not touching those until they're actually voted on by the community and approved by the community so it's it's really changing the the Dynamics quite a bit it's almost like we're in a

135state of influx right now so am I 100% on board with electric proces at this moment no because this order was just signed and here we are trying to figure out a budget for this upcoming year and we don't know you know if the federal government is going to Trump what the state government is mandated exactly no pun intended but you know it's interesting so you know and that's going to be a question that someone a citizen may ask someone in the public like you know why are you going to roll this out if I'm watching the news and I see this executive order was sign eliminating this mandate so I me these are questions that we have to be prepared for when you know when we're at tops and at the gas station and

136stuff like that when people walk and talk to us so for me I would pause on in my for me I would pause on this for a minute only because we don't know it's just it's pretty new at this moment we did ask too um about the incentives like do we see these incentives changing or do we see them being eliminated with some of the things going on as of right now we were told no we don't for but you know there's a lot of craziness going on right now so there's a lot of unknown with what might happen with all of this stuff so that is correct you know and really the only reason I I put it in front of you is because the possibility that it would be cost neutral but wanted

137to provide you with the information so that I think it's important to keep your fact findinding right like to figure out exactly what the installation is for that charging station I mean I would I wouldn't stop trying to give us Tois we still have time to decide if want proposition it's always information keep working on it it's just I would it could be in the 11th Hour that you know we hear from Albany that they have to pause it because of the executive order but you know we should definitely still be prepared in the event you know I coule questions I know you mentioned anticipating the incentives maybe running out um is that a first come first serve I believe most of them are first come first serves I I think there's quite a bit

138right now um you know I I would necessarily be worried about not getting it now but the their ability to to cover it for 50,000 buses it's going to run at some point I don't know what that point is going to be I don't know how many buses we could potentially get before that happens but you know now then then you got to start replacing them at full cost you know and I would anticipate that the costs come down gradually over time as technology improve improves and they're making more and more of them but there's a pretty big gap you know you take that incentive out out of out of there and you're spending $275,000 more in operational cost C almost $30,000 a year more to operate an electric bus than a diesel bus you

139know and I know they're making a lot of improvements on diesel too the the fuel itself and on the engines and those are just getting I don't want to say cleaner but I I suppose they're they're getting less harmful so you know there's there's some improvements on that end too you know a lot of people feel that you know it would be great if they would just take the money and and like put it into the City of Buffalo where there's a lot more impact you know you got a lot more population density where you know there's a lot more impact from the diesel I don't know just just some thought you know to to get it rolling good there before you do it in a lot of the state and there's still a lot

140of townships where it's not even possible for them to do this because the electrical grid can't even support it exactly and it almost seems like um in terms of first first it would be like fostering schools like pay them um and that's unfortunate but um also I question I forgot it already um oh do we know any schools close by that have already purchased Elric oh yeah there's there's quite a few um Lakes Shore has has a bunch of them a lot there's several districts that are are looking to purchase one or have purchased one or two um but there are districts that have have also V it down even even at a cost neutral are almost free you know because of the incentive so you know there's priority zones that that there's additional incentives

141for we unfortunately don't fall into one of those priority zones but there's districts that that basically would have been cost neutral zero cost to the district to purchase it because of the incentives and they still voted it down that would be interesting to see like we have the data [Music] very interesting it's really very important and I would say for our board too right if you do direct us or you know support us in moving forward even with just one bus just understand that the community may come vote no on that proposition but they might be upset with other propositions in the budget and board members running for board so it's a it's a very complicated uh situation and you just mentioned Deus Point who was going to be cost neutral the community voted it

142down Lakes Shore is in a different boat because they have access to about $8 million in federal and or other incentives it hasn't been a problem there but I do worry that people will vote that down and be angry without being fully informed yeah think the if we want to have the communication of is going to have to be yeah over communicated and definitely you know this is not this and this right like one or the other but I definitely think we need to keep backing I'll do some work on that slide for the March 10th presentation and and try to put some better numbers together um great thank you absolutely slide 51 just summary I guess y slide 51 is just a a summary going back over so uh you can take a look

143at the revenues uh state aid again is uh estimated at 21, 36,39 th000 with the building Aid portion of that at 4.24 sales tax at 4 million other Revenue at 1.2 and then that allocation of our Reserve fund balance of 6.29 million for total revenues before the tax levy of 37 mil 98045 couple that with the 41846 tax levy gets us to our total expense number of 78 9441 190 which is composed of 37665 289 in salaries $2,730 72 in benefits and 20,5 48,00 729 in other costs and those other costs there again are you know this this is a much higher view summary so that covers boses fees utilities fuel building materials um and the other category items as well any questions on that all right so slide 52 just highlights our other dates

144we've got our next uh session coming up on March 10th our third presentation will be on March 24th we'll have a session on Monday April 14th if necessary I will say uh on the budget timeline that I put up last month I believe I had April 13th on there that was incorrect that possible extra meeting date would be Monday April 14th um or whatever the board chooses and then uh April 22nd will be the last board meeting that we have to adopt the budget before the mandatory B budget adoption date and then we're scheduled to do the budget hearing on May 6th and the budget vote on May 20th any other questions on the budget thank you very much thank you okay that brings us to special M thank you I have three items tonight

145um I have the cpsc and the Cs program recommendations um and do do some of the changes of the building principles you know I to catch up with um David joining us um it's just a uh I redid the dignity for all students and coordinators to reflect you know who was so if I could have action those apprciate it motion for a through C please and the second all in favor I any objections any exensions motion carried 6 thank you differences to the superintendence report yeah so J making a comment about my slides so I won't spend a tremendous amount of time you obviously have had the super superintendent report buil into board dos you can take a look at it uh there was a kind of nervous energy at the beginning of last week

146regarding the pausing of federal uh funds but that has uh been halted so that's really a non issue for us uh I do want the board to take a look at the slides that Hillary has provided you um clearly you know that starting in July we need to have a student representative sitting at the board table they're they're not voting and they don't attend executive sessions but this is uh something that all school boards are dealing with throughout the uh State and these are the recommended suggested steps uh so I'll just kind of briefly go over that this outlines the responsibilities for the particular person who may end up being the successful uh student candidate so you'll you'll see the uh responsibilities and duties uh here you'll see that there will be an application process

147and that'll flow through the high school uh the students will have to apply and provide a personal statement a resume provide two letters of recommendation and um additional information there uh additionally uh Hillary will put together a team of teachers and class advis advisor student councel advisers class advisors school counselors and high school admin that will review all of the applications they will uh put together an interview panel uh and then there will be a final selection and uh recommendation to the board based on that process the timeline will happen pretty quickly so by March 1st application information will be sent out screening of applicants will begin in March uh by the end of March and uh middle of April selected candidates will be interviewed and then there will be a recommendation to the board

148uh for May 6th and then that new student uh uh member will begin on July 1st or the 1 meeting in July so there's just some information for you to review uh does anybody have any quick questions about that timeline or some of the recommendations yeah sounds like a great idea uh we'll be asking Felicia to help us out a lot like I you know I mean I'm sure there is a student but what if we can't the well we'll definitely cross that bridge you know I'm sure there are but I'm just saying I mean the process I it'll be open up for nth 10th and 11th graders yeah well you know I I once as a middle school principal there was an eighth grade student who wanted to be um in politics and you'd

149be surprised there there more than likely will be somebody you know that'll find this very fascinating and interesting and the good thing here over the last 9 years we've had student ambassadors really be willing to share but at the end of the day um we that person may be just a very involved person that we may not we may need to have an alternate for that person based on their activities uh with sports or extracurricular yeah yeah yeah to leave at 9:00 leave at 9 or today was 30 minutes it's earlier so that was even better so uh we're very I'm very fortunate to have Hillary and her mindfulness uh to approach this with her teachers and we look forward to seeing how the process evolves uh I'm not going to read this word for

150word uh I am the president now of the Erie Niagara School superent Association we wrote a letter to the to the governor that letter has been sent and signed by many uh superintendents in Niagara and Erie County asking the governor in a very polite way and thanking her for her advocacy for the well-being of children to reconsider the Mandate of banning cell phones all across New York State there are some superintendents and some districts that are looking forward to that ban and they would they would embrace it and love it there are some superintendents in districts that are not looking forward to Banning that us a sweeping mandate across uh the state this letter just highlights um some of the thoughtfulness of the uran Agra School superent Association and outlining some of the potential challenges

151of implementing that mandate one thing that I would like uh the board to pay attention to besides the administrative burdens of our administrators at the high school trying to enforce this mandate I would like to make mention that the governor's proposal does uh ask for exemptions to be made for particular students who have individualized education plans or 504 plans or medical needs and also children who might have English as a second language need there are many internet enabled devices that support children with IEPs Bal fours or their medical needs imagine your child has a diabetes and your child's uh internet enabl device not only communicates with Mom and Dad on their blood sugar levels but also our school nurse there's an exception which is smart to make sure that a child can have that access

152but once those exceptions are built into to a sweeping mandate if I'm the child who has diabetes and Ashley is my pet and we're sitting next to each other and I'm using an internet Naval device and she cannot it points a finger at private medical information that a child should not feel compelled to share with their peers or the adults in the school so this idea of the exception is sort of smart but I think it opens up a can of worms for children that have maybe a particular learning disability or a particular uh special education need in the autism spectrum that their internet naal device is okay but that somebody else is not and I think that puts children in a very very uh delicate situation that reveals personal private information to others so

153I tried to outline those thoughts in this letter um and we did I did this letter has been sent to the governor and Ashley was a champion at the Erie County Association of school boards and she spoke up on behalf of BR Island and that the perspective similarly that's in this letter uh not only did Ashley speak up but I would say Ashley almost every attendee at the ER County Association of school board's legislative meeting spoke against the sweeping mandate and that prompted the Erie County Association of school boards to reflect uh and Ashley knows that I shared with the irie County Association of school boards these thoughts and I know that they're looking at that and they've drafted their own letter it isn't it hasn't been approved yet but I think you'll see the

154Erie County Association of school boards say similarly that this is not uh the sweeping mandate is is to um DP home in yeah I think it definitely calls for local control of such a mandate so that we can decide as a district how it's implemented um and what works in this District may not work for another District so hopefully the governor will listen to um ensuring that at least at the very least there's more local control over such any other thoughts around the table okay great so hopefully uh these letters and this advocacy will have uh some type of influence on the governor but I think it's important for the board to know that it may not and the governor has set aside $ 13.5 million to purchase coaches uh for uh cell phones and

155I just don't think that's the greatest use of a sweeping mandated uh funding and I this letter asks her to instead make it a a grant not a sweeping mandate so as Ashley said one District might be like yes we love this idea we want the pouches and we're going to spend the money well in another District who has excellent teachers excellent Administration where this isn't a a horrible issue in this particular school we could move in a different direction yeah and L goana was uh implementing the pouches and loved it but according to the representative of our legislative their District just loves the cell phone band loves the pouches so what again as I said what works for one District may not work for another yeah so we'll see what happens with that and

156then uh uh I'm not going to spend a lot of time there was wonderful news a former teacher and coach Bill riffle has been inducted into the Western lacrosse Hall of Fame I want to thank Sue Marson for bringing this to my attention these are some pictures that either Chris Simpson or others have shared with us and uh you know we'll try to do our best to shine the spotlight so I was trying to get a hold of them today to see if maybe he could come even tonight he lives in the state of Delaware but he already um they already left uh first thing yesterday morning so they're already back but he did mention that in may he possibly will be in town I'm not sure when or dates were um for the meeting

157in May but he he said that he might so told him to keep me posted yeah I talked to um I talked to one of the players that was with him on Saturday who happened to be at the Bandit being with him and he he said it was just it was just a great EV they don't really make a big deal about it the Western New York Lacrosse Association or whatever but um it was kind of neat the uh the 1991 team that went to the section or won the session my brother Mike was on it Steve St was on it so um there's quite a few it was kind of neat they that on Facebook and kind so I just was a great teer were here really really special man great man great so

158um as we slide through we already talked about the musical these are just some really great photos of of the exciting sport opportunities that are happening throughout the district uh Mrs personal and Mrs pernick Wonderful Character Matters play was outstanding don't forget to um you know share with your friends and neighbors that were obviously looking to hire bus drivers Hillary and I had the great opportunity to present at the Western York Education Service Council on the future of artificial intelligence so I want to thank Hillary for her uh excellent presentation and uh Sue do you want to say anything I know it's my superintendent report but no you can go on okay so uh just for the community June 18th will be our second annual uh Grand Island cruise night it was tremendous uh event

159last year we're expecting similar or even more outstanding opportunities for the community to really enjoy that event and there there's a rindy just in case we need it and then the golf outing Jude I know you're in the process of finalizing that but the we're looking at Friday July 25th at Bieber Island this year not River Oaks and we're working with the wonderful City Montana to put that together so it's very exciting so thank you very much thank you um that brings us to the Board of Education Report with Su you know what I just have a few uh LS at the uhta council meeting our last Giza uh meeting and the k if anybody has any questions yeah and I just have the legislative report also attached for your review um ditto Sude if

160you have any questions let me know and we did not have anyone sign up for the public comment session or general items not included in this agenda so that brings us to Committee of the whole items and information for the round table beginning with Roger thank you happy birthday to my son I'm also um just quickly I wanted to thank the alliance Club um Tom wowski uh he actually came and worked with all of our nurses at H Sway and St Stevens um they scream multiple students and um they ref um collectively about 10% of our students um in each building you know for f the checkup with with an eye doctor so they do do this every year um I just wanted to thank him and thank the building nurses and the building principles

161for organizing I think you heard enough for me tonight very good I just want to add that uh there was some anxiety recently about the thought that um individuals from the Immigration and Customs uh enforcement agency and our Department of Homeland Security would be trying to enter schools just want to let the board know uh as well as the community that that is not the case at all so um we we have a special lunch in with the irie nager School superent Association where we'll have a guest speaker from the Department of Homeland Security and that person's job will be to just to communicate that Federal ice agents are not going to be entering Schools they're not looking for children and they themselves are parents and they understand the the important uh role that we

162play in the education of children so just for our board and for the community this is not something that's going to happen here in our school so just wanted to reinforce that thank you thank you okay with that um I would like to ask for a motion to journ uh the regular board meeting at 10 p.m a second all in favor I any objections exensions motion carried 60 good night everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.