CorpusRecord 233129

Tuesday, January 14, 2025 Board of Education Study Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Sweet Home Central School District - BoE
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,251 words · about 69 min
Collected
2026-06-27

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001see oh wait maybe no it's not working for me okay moving get start okay all right thank you for your patience um we are back from executive session uh any comments on the approval of the agenda we'll be voting on it next week minutes from the previous meeting we'll also be voting on that next week sorry say that again I didn't hear you and I lost my screen go ahead um approval of the agenda and minutes from the previous meeting do you have any comments on either all righty Communications does anyone have any Communications again I have several and I'd like to do my little um what do you call it next week your shout out your report out on your visits to your Elementary buildings I'll try to say this quickly I'll start with

002that because uh uh wasn't quite surprised but the uh central office was there talking about the building use and new Transportation schedules for possibly for next year I thought I thought that went pretty well uh Heritage Heights PTA again runs a nice meeting but an extended meeting last night again mostly because of the presentation I think we're going to get again tonight so I won't talk much about that was pretty well understood from what I understand and uh there were some concerns about this the times and the scheduling and that thing I also heard that from another person today they called me about that kind of trying to figure out how that will change uh their lives with for their children okay just so you know again um they did have another question about Ames

003web versus standardized testing and why do we need to do both if a web is adequately measuring the progress of students and from what I understand is a progression and is useful that you can uh detect specific to a student some needs that need to be addressed and again the question about standardized testing is it still required are all students allowed to opt out does that come out of the schools in a letter that says you can or cannot opt out that was the question okay you don't need to answer that now I'm just relaying you the concerns of these people although if you have an answer I'd like to hear it think so so as web is um we um have switched from Star reading and math to am web um is a way

004to progress monitor um really get a post on our interventions that we use to support students the standardized testing I believe you're referring to three through eight math uh Ela science um and then as you get into the secondary schools you're talking about um our our testing that goes across all the subjects um so they are they are still um very much a big part of what we do to get a handle on what our students need to be successful can parents opt out of them yes at the three through eight category they can um and that that is communicated families know but we do a lot of work around helping families understand why they are important um so that the students do engage in those assessments because it really helps us have an understanding

005of that next step around as web and interventions we need to put in place so they they go hand in hand okay I'm I'm I'm all for finding where our students are versus I guess the state and locally so I support all that the um the other concern there was the amount of time out of the classroom to do the testing is it really a five day process where they're not really being educated they're being tested I guess so you're you you may be speaking of over time that they take because there are multiple assessments that our students take there's the ELA test and then there's a math test um and then at certain grade levels there's a science test um and so as you add up all of that time over a course of

006a year it could be approaching that amount of time yes but it's not all back to back okay so you need the time to do the testing but it does take them away from day-to-day learning I guess okay it's I think again I think it's required I think it's a good thing the the photo situation again I've heard this from several people and I brought this up to with the Heritage Heights PTA last night they are allowed to from what I understand Don you can confirm this if they want to change the photographers they're using for the school pictures they have the authority to change that as their ptas in their building so yeah so I apologize I I didn't respond back because I was collecting uh information back but it turns out that all

007of our buildings use the same vendor um I'm going to go back probably in my previous role uh probably seven years or so ago uh when we met collectively as a PTA Council might have been the last year that the council was around uh we did they did Express an interest in getting one vendor across the district to Aid in pricing uh for all schools because the pricing was all over the board so we did that we got them under contract uh for that particular year and then when um honestly when I we transitioned into the role it the the the responsibility went back to the building so Mr rabenold to answer your question the ptas and the PTO and ptsas are at Liberty to change the vendor if they so choose I I know

008that at the elementary level the PTO and PTA groups choose that uh at the middle school level I'm not exactly sure how that works I know I think the PTSA is involved but there is a yearbook advisor that also works with the vendor as well okay I I just think if they're made aware of that it might okay I can certainly do that I I believe that for the most part the buildings knew it but I can certainly reaffirm that that's perfect thanks D you're sure appreciate it I think that's all I have I appreciate your time thank you okay all good Durk yep yeah all good thank you um okay unfinished business we have none superintendent report Dr janri um we have two presentations for the board tonight thank you Mrs baglia um our

009first is on uh where we are with AI I know we talked about it from um the beginning of the year actually we started talking about it last year um and coming up with some policy that will allow us to grow um as AI continues to influence um instruction here and um Dr Wilson is going to present um I know Mr kumro is in in the audience um tonight as well who's leading the efforts uh with our technology committee um to recommend policy to the board and we thought because it's a board goal um this year that we would like to present to you uh where we where we are and get your feedback good evening so we really want to dig into Ai and where we are as a district and we have a

010lot going on with it it's a good opportunity to share so why now why um this talk around AI well I know that we all are engaging in our world right and you can you there are times that you actually end up engaging with AI and you may not even know it it has become that much involved in what we do day in and day out so there's this rapid transformation in education and the workplace and we really want to ensure that we remain proactive Equitable and responsible in leveraging these tools our students are using them our our teachers are engaging in them we want to know at what level we want to support them so that we get to the high highest level and we address some of the things that could come up

011as you are engaging in the use of AI so our purpose is to empower teachers to integrate the generative AI gen AI into learning while maintaining Equitable access so that gen AI means that there's learning that the AI is doing based on what the information is out there on whatever topic you're engaging in with AI I'll come back to that in a minute because it does add into one thing that we want to make sure we stay very close to as we engage in this work with AI we want to provide a clear expectations and guidelines for reasonable AI use by students and staff um helping our students know when is a good time to engage in this work helping our teachers set up assignments that make sense to help students learn their way through

012Ai and we want to safeguard uh data privacy and compliance we always have to keep that at the Forefront because we are bound by education law 2D um and that really is tied to that personally identification um information anything that's Pi making sure that we are engaging in the work that keeps all of that um secure and so as we dig into um our AI use we really want to make sure that taking that genitive approach um that we really um hone in on and you'll see this written throughout that policy there's a policy that's before you this month to review um that the idea that bias could be evident in that in that work and so helping um provide the professional development helping our students and our teachers understand that that is there and

013how do they navigate that and figure out when that could be there and dig deeper um when using AI I'm going to turn it over to Mr cuml thank you everyone yeah so just uh kind of giving a bit of an overview of what you see uh specifically written down on this policy really what we're trying to do is Empower our teachers to decide uh how they're going to use gen AI in their own classrooms this is really going to involve uh making sure that all students have equal access to AI especially being a one toone District we're going to find that a lot easier here um students still are going to be held accountable for their work in the end I know that's going to be a kind of a big fear amongst teachers

014maybe even amongst the public but really trying to stay upfront and really again as it even says in the district personal use just trying to train our staff to know what is uh responsible and accountable work when you're using AI you always have to put it into a checker check your accuracy and those sorts of things so we've really designed a lot of training and some things like that that are going to come up uh kind of rolling through this policy encouraging them to reread whatever whatever it is that they're submitting cor yeah have you have you used it yes yes I yeah there's a real quick there's a famous kind of story in the news recently a court lawyer tried to use uh AI chbt to generate his court case he did this didn't

015proof fre it didn't fact check ends up CBT loves making things up made up some fake court cases he submitted it to a judge not a good look so yeah we need to make sure that our students understand and know how to use Ai and importantly this policy is just that stepping stone into that to just make sure that we have Foundation uh opening enough for our teachers to learn the all the trainings and support that they're going to need for our students Tre do you mind going to the next slide so really what we're kind of looking at here um progressing through getting this accepted uh you know into February we're looking to start an awareness campaign in March really starting to kind of put out a lot of communication making sure we're getting

016surveys out to teachers uh we want to figure out where they're at right now where we need to take them uh so a lot of teachers probably use it but we don't know who uses it how much they use it what they need to know there's been some trainings offered you know through bosis internally as well in the use of AI and so we've already developed some surveys to put out uh to our staff to figure that out we also want to make sure we're surveying students uh the community as well to try to figure out how it's being used around you know even real world applications what the fears are in the community uh and we really need to get ahead of that by starting this planning process and the trainings and making sure

017we're getting a lot of feedback from that we do believe that this might expand into the student code of conduct we're going to have to look at that through uh work with our technology committee and just seeing if we do need to fine tune it to to make sure that it aligns to any new policy that we're having excuse me and then starting next year in the fall we really want to make sure that teachers are prepped uh if they want to use it in their classrooms they are clear on how to do so and really kind of going through that we want to make sure again the whole process needs to be monitored reviewed uh so surveys are going to be kind of put out periodically through this process and ongoing so we can

018make sure we're Gathering the information back uh and figuring out any you know problems that are we should anticipate are going to arise and getting ahead of those uh and making sure that we're progressing and keeping up with where we need to be to to keep our kids uh you know ready for this Workforce that is going to heavily involve AI use thank you just ask as you roll this out yeah um where are parents going to figure into this because I think that's a vital you mentioned Community but I think we need to be pretty specific to Target our parents so that they're on board with it just to help our kids how are those going to piece in I'll jump in and I'll let Michael take over um as part we already have

019surveys queued up to ready to go if you agree with the policy going into place one is to our parents to engage them to see what do they know about what their kids are doing but then how do they use it at home it could be a useful tool for parents who want to do extended work at home and they are hitting a wall with how to how to do that so we want to know what they're using it for and we have that ready to go but is there more you want to add no I think that Dr Wilson brings up a really good point though um making sure that parents know that this is available I think it really plays into this if you were to think about I mean you would need

020a teaching professional to do a lot of uh content writing but if you could go into chat TBT and say write me three Passages at a second grade level and it will do it for you and you know that it's accurate and that's very power powerful to use at home and I think yeah extremely important that parents understand and know that we're using it and how they can actually capitalize it in as well oh I just realized we're hitting the end page here I'm looking down um we talked about this at the um at the policy committee meeting when Brian and I and you know handful of us here in the room and one of the things I stressed was making sure and you've talked about it making sure people understand you need to fact

021check your information I brought up the example which I thought I still had my phone but I don't is I was looking for populations if I few dates I looked up the population in New York and it was using Gemini which is a Google product and then when I went back and started looking a little further in the information it gave me it started telling me okay the population of New York was like 19.8 million and then I said it listed like the population of New York City is like 19.2 million I'm like no because your county has about a million people Monroe County has about these things don't add up and the question is do people recognize when they don't add up with my concern and that's I think that's something we need to

022stress so we get into it the other part and Brian and I agreed is we were doing the policy on this is we wouldn't recommend this policy we wanted the board to discuss it rather than just us saying okay this is a good one from the policy committee so we were we wanted to make sure you guys all had time to think about that before we voted yes or no I know Brian you want anything else to that I think you summarize it well I think that um you know I've been I've been using AI uh in my day job and you know working with it with students and such um um you know it's important to make sure that um faculty knows that you know it is well within your right to say you

023can't use it on this assignment or you can use it on this assignment but you have to tell me you're using it you know the other my favorite story that that comes out of my day job is you know about the Trojan Horse and that you know if you don't reread you could have copy and pasted that that Trojan Horse and you're supposed to be writing about you know the color of leaves and now you're talking about elephants because that's where the Trojan Horse went and you know it's it's you you have to be careful it can be very dangerous but you have to also be very clear and concise is what you're looking for and always make sure you reread it because if you don't reread it you could be way out in left

024field the one thing I will add just on a a professional level that I think is important for the students to understand is that there are now I can tell you in the accounting profession in the legal profession that there are standards being developed and I would imagine in a lot of other professions um in most companies now are saying you have to be careful this is not a substitute for your Professional Knowledge and advice and so on and so forth so I think that emphasizes to our students who are you know being trained for the workforce that um you know the importance that the the firms are out there now you know recognizing this I mean I and I guess I'd rather see the student you know a student somebody get burned in school

025then then on a professional level you know you know because it takes all it takes is one one at time to really get embarrassed by and then you you remember it for life that how important is to you know double check things and do your own another one I wanted to bring up and and you guys mentioned it too was the policy itself um which is in here um I asked and this policy was was provided by our policy service through A1 bosis and we made a few tweaks as we went along on it um when I went to the nisba conference in um New York back in October I talked with some people from Miran policy Services while we were there and they did mention that they had that policy they also stressed to

026me that they strongly believe that it should also fall under our code of conduct which you g touched on so I appreciate that and I think that's something we need to make sure it happens whatever committees it comes through as we go along I think we also Dei is gonna be talking about next meeting right if I remember right yeah so I think it needs to be attacked from a couple different directions but I think that's very important too that we include it there and make sure we get it right plus I went to I'll be at least five different sessions that were Ai and almost all of them said the same thing you know I said some didn't even think you needed a policy law you put it in your code of conduct others

027were goes back and forth between there but they all pretty much threed so it had to be part of our code of conduct too we're looking at um taking our code of conduct and um really putting that Dei lens on it so we're in in the middle of that work right now as you mentioned um and part of the work will be to include uh the language around AI Mr cro has already um worked to collect different ways to look at how that could play out in a code of conduct we will decide as a committee um there's another another committee that also will be engaged in this work our professional learning committee um because you we really have to engage in that conversation around professional development so there's a huge implementation plan that Mr

028coll has um has developed and um will be ready to um lead right out right out out of the gate if the policy is approved um the original uh policy itself was reviewed by uh the technology committee which he leads um but it includes uh District administrators School administrators teachers community members I have a question for you um sorry who creates the training for students or for staff or for parents or whoever is going to be receiving it yeah so we already have some developed internally by our technology coaches um but really A lot of these are also found kind of going around here one Bose's offers trainings for AI some are going to be developed internally but others we can look externally if if we need something like that um but various kind of

029sources can you go through the teacher Center to arrange some of these yes that's how the it's being um that's how it is being uh made available to uh staff now um we also have planned superintendent conference day if we are um giving the green light we are Michael is going to be leading Mr cro is going to be leading um a session um with staff around um the work that the technology committee did which is that high level of understanding of AI to make sure that we all enter our thinking around AI at the same level we all engage with the same language and the same understanding the same definitions is this all leading to creating a policy or are you referencing the policy we have our F I think it's our first reading

030tonight we are referencing the policy you have in front of you yes this okay okay can somehow can we put that on the screen is it in this report I don't know if it's in the it's in your packet the first read agenda on the I know it's on the agenda but I want I want you to read it because I don't know how this ties into what you're talking about tonight the the first reading of the AI policy that was reviewed by several pages read it if you want um I don't know if it's several Pages this is just a it's missing a piece oh um it under janary time to really read through this digest it listen to what you've said today right it's only the first reading it's the first reading and

031I believe you table it for this month and so you have the month and then we come back to it next month right okay the first readings it is a 34-page document where do you see a 34 page document all I see so when you go into the board packet PES where it says revised policies first reading open that up in the AI is the first policy in there after you see the four or five pages of description of what we're we looked at this month yeah stuff policy itself is like four pages four there yeah I'm looking for it I still don't see it is it it's on the screen going far enough here we go I got it okay it's down below all right this the summary there didn't look like much of

032anything that's why I asked yes okay so okay good the definitions okay that's all I had thank you thank you thank you thank you everyone um our second presentation for the night um is regarding start and stop times for next year for the 2526 school year uh so um I have the pleasure of being joined by Mr Kennedy our director of Transportation uh and um wanted to update the board on the work of the building use committee uh and um first of all say thank you to all the members we have our elementary principls our Middle School principal um sitting in on it uh we have uh two parents a teacher represent representative two board members that sit on it and district office that sit on it um as well and we've done a lot

033of work this year knowing that start and stop times were going to change when we announced last year um the um adoption of the teacher contract in the new teacher contract it requires us to adopt 15 more minutes of instructional time for every student at Sweet Home in the and 26 school year so we knew that um transportation times were going to change start and stop times were going to change and we also knew that um my presentation would go off the screen and not work um the entire time oh Amy you got jokes no correct hopefully it comes back hold on I don't know Virgil's Apple TV right there it is okay so um that is one thing that made us look at start and stop times we also know that our driver shortage

034continues at crisis levels in the district um and we are um for every two three drivers we gain we lose two or three more uh due to retirements and so while um we've gained a few we're still at the same level as we were three and a half years ago with when I came to the district and we still we have about 700 more students now um so um our bus runs as many of our public know and the board knows um it's been a struggle this year um Scott and his team have done a great job of condensing the times and making sure that we're not late um for for school um but with the staggered Elementary times which I'll talk about in a minute uh that posed challenges while it saved us some

035drivers it it posed some challenges um for us as well um so we are going to recommend some wholesale changes some big changes um as a committee that include a change in the structure of our runs so this proposal um will include that the high school and the middle school have similar Bell schedules they'll be off about 15 minutes and I think um you know I I've talked about it um whether in the B the ammer b or in our newsletter um that this was a a thing that we were really um hoping that we Middle School would have more opportunities um for extracurriculars after school programming more teachers would be available for that um as well so I'll get into that in a minute the other uh change that we are proposing is that

036grades 6 through 12 will ride the bus together to and from school on the same run to fill our buses up uh in the morning and in the afternoon uh since 6 through 12 have similar stops um we uh found it advantageous um to have them ride the bus together um in our Communications with our ptas and PTO that question came up of some concern however uh we believe that our older students serve as peers for our younger students and really the issues that we've seen on the buses are are Middle School no no surprise there um so we believe that this will help um our Middle School um students on the bus so we're going to propose that the runs uh fall in this following order the high school the middle school and then

037all four elementary schools would be on the same schedule um while I said before it did the staggered times that we are experiencing now did have its benefits as is in terms of freeing up drivers for other things like after school that we were able to bring back um it posed other issues especially with the elementary run being in the middle of the day um one parent not home to greet their child throws that run off and would also throw the middle school off as well because the Middle School happened um after the Elementary uh buses so and finally we're recommending a walking radius right now there is door to-door pickup no matter how close you live to an elementary building and we were we would like to propose a walking radius of 0.25 miles

038that would free up one bus run P per Elementary building for a total of four bus runs um that would give us uh leeway because right now we have mechanics driving we have front office staff driving um and that hopefully will free them up to do their mechanic work and front office work um while we have um dedicated drivers um on the road and Scott feel free to if you're doing great all right we're rolling all right all right this is good so some potential benefits of the Middle School change in particular uh middle school students would have more time in the afternoon to participate in extracurricular activities middle school students could also be home in the afternoon to care for their younger siblings more Middle School teachers could host extracurricular activities right now we

039we have very few Middle School teachers um able to coach like a varsity or Junior Varsity Sport because the high school gets out at 2 o' we also it also should note that we have the latest middle school day in Western New York um with a around a four o'clock dismissal so um you know uh swet home has that long that long day and it really limits um opportunities in the afternoon um this change would also bring us um I'm sorry the elementary run as the last run of the day and all onone schedule will help eliminate delays um I think the elementary principles are very happy that they could go back on one schedule and not a staggered schedule uh any longer it would also free up PD in the afternoon where our elementary

040teachers from multiple buildings could get together because now they'd be on the same schedule we get closer to our goal of reestablishing after school runs at pre-co levels um we believe that we can bring back run um after school runs four days a week um and multiple buses taking kids to different parts of the district um so they're not on the bus for a long period of time um and one of our goals as a building use committee was to have little impact on what the current elementary schedule is so parents wouldn't have to change their workday that dramatically um and that was a goal and I really appreciate Scott's work there to Crunch the numbers and come up with a recommendation that we believe Falls right in the middle of where our elementary times

041are um right now for elementary 1 and two so here are here is our proposal um this was uh seen today by the billing use committee um and seen um first by the board and now our public So currently on the left column you will see that these are the 2425 um start times we are proposing um that we go from four runs to three and at the middle school be the second run so um 6 through 12 would be on the be picked up they would be dropped off at the high school for a 719 instructional start time and they would end their day at 2:05 um after let's say let's go back to the morning um they be dropped off and then then um the middle school would then be dropped off they'd

042be on the bus at the high school then they would go to the middle school for an instructional start time at 7:40 um the middle school day would end at 2:24 for our students uh and then the elementary would start at 8:55 and depart uh the instruction would end at 3:10 but students get their coats on pack their bags that s sort of thing take five minutes to do that and they would depart the building at 3:15 so some notes um here um that that we wanted to make you aware of uh it's a pretty simple change at the high school we would go from and middle school we' go from a 40 minute period to a 42 minute period to accommodate that 50 15 minutes of extra instruction and honestly because there's nine periods

043at both buildings our students will be getting 18 minutes of instruction uh in addition at the middle school and the high school um which is a which is a very good thing uh the Elementary schedule uh we would enhance our Ela math and social and emotional learning there right now they're from our principles it reported teachers are running out of time they would could use this extra 15 minutes to enhance um those three areas the high school middle school teacher contact time for students goes from 6 uh 29 to 6:44 uh 6 hours and 44 minutes which puts us well over the minimum uh minutes that students need to be in class uh throughout a year um our state aid is tied to those required minutes so um we feel like we're in a good

044spot now right now we only have about three hours I think three three minutes or three hours of wiggle room um in in the schedule this would put us way over um the requirement minutes elementary teacher contact time would go from 6 hours and 15 minutes to 6:30 and the teacher length of day uh already is at 7 hours and 15 minutes per at all schools but wanted to reiterate that this uh schedule fits into uh those parameters that were set through uh either the teacher contract or um by the by the building use committee so we believe that um there are a lot of positives that come out of this proposal um and and we believe um it's really going to benefit our middle middle school students um due to the fact that they

045will have everything from the musical um to sporting activities to clubs um Elementary band is also very um something that we've wrestled with because of the staggered schedule now that the elementaries will be on one schedule um that will give us collaboration time between the four buildings for elementary band um so that's going to get back to what it was prior to the staggered schedule um and then we're going to free up drivers for afternoon runs and we're really really excited um about that as well so um I think that's where we're at with the proposal for the start and stop times um we wanted to give uh just for communication purposes we have i' I've mentioned it in the amers B I wrote about it in the newsletter um we have done the tour

046of PTO PTA meetings we've been to every one of our buildings um to talk about this with our parents um as well um you know and I know many of our board members were at those meetings but the reception seemed overall positive um for sure and um you know our Middle School families that were there that night at the PTO meeting um I I got a lot of positive feedback from them as well um because they do feel it's a late afternoon um dismissal so um I think I covered everything and you got it all right with that said i' I'd open up for comments feedback I think the what we'd like to do is um if you're okay with this um obviously this is public and we published these times tonight um we'd like

047to send it out in some commun Communications this week um and then invite anybody to the board meeting next week or or in February for comment period um so they have time to Mullet but I I I believe our community has been well informed that these changes were coming they just this is the first time they're seeing the times um and it was really important that the elementary time not have a major shift because we know those are our youngest students parents have to rearrange their work schedules um and and um we wanted to make sure that we took that into consideration if I could just also add to this this model if we go forward with this model um as you know we spend a significant amount of money on contracted Transportation uh in

048in large part because of our shortage of drivers but what we'll do is we'll go to work when I say we Scott will go to work uh and uh he'll we'll start to kind of plan out um kind of how runs will look and then we'll get a sense of uh how many runs that we'll need to continue to contract out uh and and look at things that we might be able to take back as well uh Scott and his team have been doing a great job as we've been getting drivers to try and take some back some of those things but it's much like you know when we lose a driver to retirement and we you know or lose two drivers to retirement and only hire one for every run that we take back

049we seemingly get added another run because of uh our mckin vento kiddos um so the goal is then once all this kind of comes out in the wash that we would look at our overall contracted transportation and go back out and rebid uh to see how we can do an improve um some of those costs to the to the district as well uh because um it's a it's a big expense and it continues to grow and it's making life difficult in the business office is there a way you can use AI to help form these efficient roots that you'll be looking at yeah software that we Sorry probably the software that we use um does have predicted um functions within it I don't know if it classifies as AI but there is efficiency uh built

050into the system that we can click a button and it does um maximize our route I have two things um is it possible to get an overlay map of each of the elementary buildings with the two with a 0.25 mile radius circled on just so we can get an idea of yes where kids would be walking from okay thank you um and the second thing is I will say as a Middle School Parent of a child who plays High School athletics putting those back and near each other um we were picking up my my daughter at least three times a week early so that she could either make a bus or not miss more than an hour of practice every day um I'm sure it would change not only for a Athletics but also for

051plays and and other activities like that but um I know there's a lot of middle school middle school athletes that play J junior varsity and varsity and they're either if you get out the middle school at 350 is that the time 345 and the bus is leaving at 4:00 for an event there's no way other than a parent getting a kid out of school early to get there um or or practices start at 2 o'clock and you're there for 25 30 minutes of a practice so yes I I actually I'll be running into this Friday where I'll have to pull my son out of school to make a junior varsity game um on Friday because he's at the middle school so are we is it in the cards here to have I know it's going

052to go High School pickup and then Middle School pickup is it in the cards to have a bus that's going to go from the Middle School to the high school for those reasons oh for extracurricular for extracurriculars okay um the other we had a parent at the building news committee also bring up the musical um his I think daughter daughter not getting home till nine o'clock uh because the the Middle School Musical practice um couldn't start till 4:30 so um yeah I think that was another parent we heard from um at the PTO PTA meeting at the middle school last week I had two parents pull me aside and you know say thank you um because of the late if you're doing anything after school it's it's a late night for for middle schoolers and

053will you um once you figure out that quarter mile radius will you send something individually to families so that they know that how will that be handled yep we'll work on that if you if you're okay with us moving forward um we'll work on that um and inform the families that will be impacted by it um you know uh we we're we're thinking about them a lot but we're at a at a point where um you know that door to door pickup if we can free up a couple couple things it's unusual to have door to door pickup even um with no walking radius around a school it's it's parents always have the option of driving their kids drive you know Mr Jason we'd more than likely make that notification home to those Walkers probably

054twice once now and then once again when we notify um students of their buses uh for summertime or lack there as a member of the billing use committee I I particularly want to thank Scot because I know you put a lot of hours into this we talked about it after the meeting today um but this is over the last couple meetings we've kicked around a couple different iterations and I think the one that we had at the previous meeting I wasn't happy with I just didn't think it was going to fly and I'm glad you were able to come up with this I'm personally very happy with the way this one's going to work out I think and and I you get my blessing to go ahead and move forward on it for whatever that

055sort of yeah I I can't think it's got enough and he's been on it since moment one when we started tossing it around um last year actually we appreciate you couple things I wanted to ask um I appreciate everybody's hard work with this um I one I think it's important though for the public to know that we're looking at both sides you know the challenges or so maybe some of the downsides of some of the changes um but before I get to that question I have is uh the Middle School um what I'm wondering is it looks like if I'm looking at this correctly there's about an hour and 15 minutes between the Middle School start time which is the later between the high school and middle school and then the Elementary start time so

056just curious as to why this seems like a decent Gap um you right okay um so the three things that go into routing a school bus are geography the capacity of the bus and the amount of time available to get where we have to get um we are looking at bringing back all four elementary schools on the same schedule it's going to require loading our buses as heavy as we can load them in order to accommodate that which is going to take more time so we're going to need that time in the mornings to get them on the bus and then at the end of the day because they are the last ones that will give us that cushion that we did not have when the middle school was after that okay so we're hoping

057that that's going to solve our problems and F and further sorry Scott I think it was the goal of the committee not to shake up the Elementary schedule too much we wanted to stay as Clos as to where we were uh in this current calendar year and that time frame that 855 time frame is kind of right in the middle of Elementary one and Elementary 2 uh this year follow up on that Scott I think you're still planning out the door you know door Todo pickup for the kids in the elementary school beond that obviously that takes longer than that that's corre mile or half a mile down the street that they're walking and then um if the high school and middle school run you know let's say that group was I'm just asking if

058this is a possibility I'm just so I know for my own knowledge could that could they be swapped in other words Elementary does the timing you know starts at the 730 7:40 7 whatever you know that time and then high school and middle school you know they just you just swap the two groups around is or are there outside of the parents being home and that I'm just saying from a transportation perspective or is there more behind the scenes I me I I think you know that would be a question parents are asking like why can't we just do the Elementary first all the Elementary first in the high school and middle school later is it as simple as like you know that we've got x amount of time on the high school middle school

059buses we've got x amount of time on the um Elementary we could take those blocks and just L literally move them or is that too simplistic um well it it's it's an awesome thought um with high school and middle school we do corner pickups it is far more streamlined than doing door to-door pickups uh the 719 start for high school means that our bus drivers will probably be on the road between 20 after 6 and 6:30 in the morning in order to get all of the students picked up uh to do elementary door too we would start picking up probably um as early as six o'clock in the morning for that 6:10 in the morning for Elementary start at 7:19 okay don't I don't think it's feasible to to be asking parents to do that

060well I think that's very important right because there is this I think in again a simplistic world people thinking well you know I I think it's easier you know the high school and middle school kids want us they need more sleep or there's and there's and that's the other piece I want to get to in a minute but you know that's a significant I mean 6 6: a.m. is what you're saying right potentially the drivers would probably start their runs at 6:00 a.m. with elementary kids I mean that's that's a an early start I mean and where you're saying where it's a high school and middle school because they don't have to go door too they can actually push that out a little bit further sounds like if I'm understand that correctly I'm sorry as

061it it sounds like what you're saying is that because the elementary and uh schools are like door too whereas the um High School Middle School are a point where they're being picked up that allows you to push out that pickup time a little bit more on the early end correct yeah you would the corner stops for high school everyone has to be at the corner yeah stop stopping every driveway or every other driveway adds a lot more time to the to the overall run yeah and you know I know that um the question I've gotten is Williamsville is starting you know they're actually starting later in um you know they've gone through this initiative and I again I think it's important that we just mention this from a public perspective because I will say this

062is concerning I I you know am am leaning towards supporting this um but I will say I I I I wish there was a way logistically we could get our middle school and high school start times later because you know for instance California they're now mandated an 8:30 I believe it's 8:30 or later for middle school and high high school because I I believe that's there's a and I think the National Institute of Health has published some information um you know there's some studies out there that have indicated a lot of Health uh benefits I'm just wondering if the building use committee um at least explore the health and emotional benefits because you know I WR a study that it was like a 9% Improvement in graduation rate because uh um in one of the

063studies said because of the the kids are getting more sleep and that and again my understanding is that the way adolescent sleep is different than the way younger kids sleep so um it's not just we're just one group's getting up earlier than the other and it's a wash you know it's it's more that literally like there's a difference in the way high school kids and sleep and develop versus you know the great so you know I understand we're limited by resources and our ability but I also guess I want to understand from the building use committee if you know some of those studies and those other pieces were looked at because I mean these are coming out from you know organizations that are pretty reputable like I say the CDC National Institute of Health um

064you know you can just do a Google Search and there's a lot of studies out there and I do understand there are some um you know the other side of it but it seems like more of the evidence is pointing towards from a health perspective a potential benefit towards later start times I mean I couldn't see California starting at 8:30 it it did come up um that was a that was a concern no question that that it's early um I think we ran it through the building use and we also ran it through the athletic committee when you start dismissing a high school at 310 3:30 because our elementary runs take so long you run into sports issues you run into athletic contest that could start early or buses getting on the road to travel

065to athletic contests um so that 3:00 uh 310 3:30 dismissal for the high school was a was a major concern for the committee and for um athletic use that came up in as well um so that was definitely discussed um and I think the Williamsville example they they their their entire district is contracted um transportation so they can start every building at the same time if if they wanted to um I don't know exactly what their start and start times are but they have a lot more flexibility with with the with their with their schedule because it's all contracted through them so we can't do we can't start the high school the middle school and the Elementary at the same time so just to piggy back after off what Dr janri said I've said on

066the building use committee for the entire for its entirety at this point um with the exception of the last couple months that I was out um we've talked extensively about that uh last year or two years not last year the year before um we did speak about that a lot in terms of the Health and Wellness of our of our high school students what we found was um from a parents perspective as much as as that extra sleep and and diligence would be nice for our high school students our high school students a wouldn't take advantage of it having a high school student I know that for a fact um but also it it puts our elementary families into a little bit more of a pickle in that if you have a high schooler that's

067getting your Elementary student off the bus or on the bus or whatever it doesn't allow for that anymore so now if you allow our elementary students to be out at 2 or 230 now you need coverage earlier to cover your kids where whereas in the past your your older kids were able to do it um so we we've kind of run the gamut on a lot of those situations so we did talk a lot about some of those things um I I'm I'm aware of the studies that you because I think I was the one even that brought it up up and that you know they say that kids are perform better if they have more sleep and then I'm kindly reminded of our uh covid times um you know a little bit of background

068in in some of the situations that I was a witness to you know in a in a child that uh had medical reasons for needing to get sleep between certain hours Co hit and then those hours weren't accommodated because they didn't have to there was no reason to get up there like they got up because class didn't start till nine o'clock so they got up at nine o'clock they didn't get up at 6 to get get off to school and and so things get really screwed up what I found was even with my own kids you know lights out at 10: one o'clock I'm still hearing them giggling with their friends like what's going on and you go in and they're like well I don't have to get up cuz I don't have class until

06910: 11 whatever and it being parents that had to work made it very hard to navigate during that time um so when I say even my own kids wouldn't benefit from that they would benefit from that but they wouldn't take advantage of it I will attest to that as a high parent of a high school senior who has late arrival so his start time is 8:15 I believe so that's an hour later he's up an hour later he's not getting an extra hour of sleep yeah he's not going to bed any earlier that's how my kid is too so and so I would only the only thing I would say is my reading of these Studies have indicated that it's not necessarily the time it's the way they sleep it's a circadium rhythm that they're

070saying is different it's later for you know that that that's later for adolescence I appreciate and I don't um you know uh deny what you're saying in terms of it's just these are professional studies done by organizations I think it's important at least as a board that we acknowledge that that's something we've considered in this process because a lot of parents I think will you know bring these things up I mean I've had some questions um and um uh so I I would just ask that you like I get the logistics of it I think what I would hope is that we continue to Monitor and look at that as you know as things change of you know I'm fine with the elementaries where they are and in the way that work I'm just it's

071more concerning about the high school and the middle school that there're they're early and if if at at any point in time there's options that can push that out 10 minutes 15 minutes I think there could be some benefit the the last thing I want to ask CU um when I was in high school it was like a mile it went to Buffalo Public though I don't know if they've changed but you had to be a mile away at least in high school um before you could get um busing um and I remember that took me like 20 minutes to walk so a half a mile I'm thinking it's probably a 10-minute walk right I'm just wondering like we're saying 02 like what's the determination of 025 versus a half a mile I don't know

072there's a big difference I'm wondering like are we could we get quite a bit more out of it it was we just weren't sure we could get more out of it maybe it was another maybe it was another bus that we could save um but we knew with 0.25 we could at least save one per per building um and uh I don't know if you want am I saying that right or you are you are um the quarter mile is is what we ask all of our middle school and high school students to walk to a bus stop already so we decided to stick with or look what look at what that would impact our our runs uh the half mile U we wanted to stay as as equal I guess as possible with all

073of our schools and try to give everybody that same walking distance uh to do a half mile would save an additional bus per school perhaps yeah I just think again for kind of going in this direction we're kind of peeling off the Band-Aid it may be better to say hey we're going to a half mile we're going to now get four more buses or whatever it might be because a half milees what 10minute walk I mean it seems reasonable it doesn't seem unreasonable you know versus a FIV minute walk I mean and I know everybody's a little bit different how fast they can walk in the winter and whatnot but you know just again I I do have confidence in the committee and in our our um our administrators but I think these things are

074just important at least publicly to bring up because this is impactful in a meaningful way I mean impacts every kid what time they get up what time they got to go to school what time they're getting out it impacts every the teachers what time they're starting um and it impacts the parents I appreciate the balancing act I think you know we're trying to do one of these and I appreciate what you said Brian about the start times and and the kids you know sleep Health but I think being able to participate in the sports is going to help their mental health for that part of it so again it's just that Balancing Act I I think you've done a great job looking at everything to try and you're not g to make everybody happy that's

075for sure um but I think we're doing the best we can with the information we have right now yeah I'd like to add to The Balancing Act piece um when you talk about secondary Ary school students they're the big things that bring them to school that help them stay connected are the extracurriculars right the sports the clubs the plays the the musicals um the concerts um one thing that that is being talked about here is that California as a state has made this across the entire State um I think that's the difference here we don't have a region or or even like our state who has made that shift making that shift and and being one of only you know the only District or maybe one of another one one one more District in the

076area would lock our kids out of those other opportunities so there's a lot of research out there too about those extracurriculars and those being really important for secondary schools in particular so I think again The Balancing Act and I think that's the difference between California and New York right now that Regional shift allows them to shift all the sports to that to that time so so so so I won't tell my two mile story like I did last night it was great last night we heard it I did have to walk to school from uh I was just under two miles so there was no bus for me to K more East but anyways um the side benefit is what I heard last night was um possibly the older students home to let the elementary

077student in now that doesn't always apply because a lot of the high school and middle school students are extracurricular type kids but again it's it's a good possibility if I understood it right and you know the other thing here and this is a tough question I guess is at what point do we make a decision that maybe we have to go all contracted I I mean we why can't we recruit bus drivers in our current arrangement we can't we don't have the money in the budget we don't have is there an answer to that we've we've we've done it all we've talked about it all as a committee um a couple years ago we had extremely competitive rates um right now we're falling behind in our rates and that's something that we have to look

078at but a couple years ago we had a you know and the doors did not flood open with with drivers it's a shortage that exists um throughout the state and throughout the country really um and that we're we're experiencing um the the rates are changing you know the salary rates are changing constantly and we've we've actually that's our next meeting to talk about where are we competitively um with the rest of the region um and so uh it's just the price is going to continue to go up um and as the demand continues to rise and the supply continues used the fall um we're we're faced with that situation as far as Contracting we we just built a really big building over there and spent lot on that I know that that's why it's a

079tough question but we Derk just to kind of further on that a little bit to um you know what I'll say is just in my seat across the district to to Dr J's point it's not an issue that is just pertinent to Sweet Home it's everywhere and quite frankly I think that our district in terms of positioning of of drivers in the number of drivers that we have we're probably better off than many districts already than many districts are um some of the challenges for hiring the like the aggregate age of our bus drivers is such that you know more retire than we're able to hire and it's and it's some of that is starting to change a little bit I I think from that standpoint um so it's just it's unfortunate that we can't

080get ahead of the game more so than anything else uh but what I will say in terms of Contracting Transportation you know um we we operate a hybrid model now and I'm this is just a a a a rough estimate I would say based upon what we spent both between contractor Transportation now and our in-house transportation that if we were to go to contracted full contracted Transportation our transportation costs would triple along with a loss of control over how does Williamsville get a way with it they just have a bigger budget schedule they might they might I mean it's just you know that's that's something that we're going to have to you know you know obviously I don't think we're at that point now um because I think that we are doing a good job

081and we've we've starting to get back uh the drivers from that standpoint but um but Williamsville doesn't own their Fleet and Williamsville does not own their fleeted and they haven't for many many many years that's correct so you know the money we have I I yeah invested okay I'm just curious how do they cont how do these contracted companies uh how do they attract I guess that's the question so I I mean just our our you know Scott if you can chime in here too but I should read our our our our starting bus driver salary is $24 2284 an hour starting bus driver and and contractor transportations are are offering 322 to $34 an hour with a $5,000 signing bonus right now and the district then assumes that costs does the um State have

082any help there is that well we get we get Aid back it's it's back on the on the on the back end of it so any dollar that we spend in terms of transportation we get you know 66 cents on the dollar but still it's just I I don't know without I mean without looking at a fully contracted model I I I'm guessing based upon what I know we spend for the small amount of contracted runs that we do now it's it's a cost that is exorbitant it's exorbitant additionally if you follow follow some of the stories that are out there about the transportation um labor drought we'll call it um even our contracted companies are feeling the the need for for drivers and the need for hires they're not they're not even fully staffed

083they try to be but from what I've heard they're they're not fully staffed either I don't know if you know anything about that Scott but um I do I know that uh we have experienced that ourselves in as much as uh they arrive late to schools they have there have been times where they call and say they do not have drivers available to do the work um they have the same criteria that we have however um as a private entity um they um can make different um arrangements for their drivers than we can uh contracted drivers uh contract uh Services actually put their employees on unemployment during the summer or during a week off uh we don't do that here that's advantageous for people that that need the money or want to you know go

084for the top dollar um we don't offer that here we offer other benefits within our district that keeps our drivers and attracts drivers to us um there's two different models I got it so if you know anybody looking for to spend some time with kids some D want you to get rid of the bus all I need is a name just I I just I I wanted to go on record here like it's it's just for what five years ago when I started in this job we had close to 100 bus drivers we have 57 now give or take total of 68 includ all of our mechanics and all of our office staff straight bus drive to drive yeah straight straight the is my job bus driver 5758 we have continued to keep the same

085level of service that we did when we had a 100 bus drivers so what his team is doing is honestly Second To None um and I I cannot appreciate what they've done what they continue to do for our kids in times when it's become extremely difficult so with with 700 more students in in the district which is unheard of right so uh I think that this will be a huge advantage to us um for a number of reasons uh to be able to kind of further enhance opportunities for our kids um and uh you know continue to do the great work that that's gotten his team do so I I just want to add this because it brought up about the extracurriculars and the sports and I do 100% support that we need to have

086our kids that those opportunities for them but I will let just mention that Amherst High School ends at 322 Williamsville I think is proposing 340 so my my and because I know I'm going to get these questions is if they can end late I can't why can't why and again I understand the logistics that's probably the the reason more than anything is logistically but I am saying I want to just publicly acknowledge that you know I think it is there you know we had mentioned that you know getting involved in the sports and the activities would be you know somewhat challenging getting out later well our neighbors are doing it you know so um you know and those are times later than what the elementary is at 3 310 I think they're we saying so

087this is you know um yeah I just want to mention that because again I think you know it there it's worth noting that we're at least consider thinking about that um and at least for the the you know the other board members to to understand that you know there are schools out there getting out later um but I think more than anything it sounds like this is more of a logistics and issue and challenge those and the Amis and Williamsville both contract you know and so they can run they could run their elementaries at the same time as their high school if they if they wanted to we just can't do that here because of the number of drivers right yeah so it comes down to Logistics it seems like more than and equipment and

088and Equipment right exactly don't have enough buses to do all of at the same time okay that's enough set as there's a tradeoff here right what may may impact students in one way so that we have enough transportation Services it's I understand where you're going with it and I understand what you did but again there I think as Brian's saying there is an impact and I we are going to hear about it from other parents and it was absolutely 100% discussed debated um in building use and Athletics talked about it as well oh ja thank you thanks Scott thank you all right I'll just quickly go through um I just wanted to share uh as well we have awesome news Heritage Heights has been named a leader in me Lighthouse school um we were able

089to capture hopefully this works oh you can't hear it darn it but anyway M that's Mr Perry announcing to the school um that they were um designated as a lighthouse school now all four Elementary buildings are lighthouse schools leader and me it's an extensive um process it's a site review by the leader and me team uh that comes into Heritage Heights and does um interviews uh students teachers administrators parents um and uh we could not be more proud of the work that's happened um at Heritage Heights over the past two and a half three years um to get them to this moment so just congratulations to everyone at Heritage Heights for this awesome achievement and they will be here in February I think Mr Perry will be here in February um to tell you more

090about um getting there so we're we're super excited for him and just want to congratulate the entire Heritage Heights Community can I just say that um at our PTA meeting Mr Ryan mentioned that May 14th was the lighthouse review for Maple marir so they're it's full cycle yes yes we appreciate the board's commitment um to uh to leader and me uh and uh you know as you see at leadership days what the impact this program has on our students is it just incredible from a from a confidence standpoint public speaking standpoint advocacy for themselves standpoint uh just just you know I know all of you have attended a leadership day um they are some of the best days that we have in our district and uh because it's full kids on display I also should

091note that that uh this was the first year that all the buildings did um student L parent teacher conferences this year uh and um all indications are that they were successful so um just the leader and me program has been very beneficial for us and uh with your support we're going to keep it going they're doing a lot of work at the middle school and high school as well and um we're going to see if we can get leader and me District status um coming soon so uh that's a goal of ours uh as we announced last week um and I told all the ptas this as well that our Panther logo contest is in full swing um kids if you're out there watching a board meeting tonight you would love your submission no uh

092the deadline for turning in their Pig papers was last1 well I thought it was last week so they don't oh was it I thought it to watch no the the participation participation was due last week so I doubt anyone's watching tonight oh sorry that was a reaction on my part I tried I tried um so if you were out there um or if you're a parent watching tonight and you're a kid uh and your your child has a um has some artistic ability or no art artistic ability but wants to be part of this great contest please have them work with their art teacher to submit um each building will have a finalist in the top 10 and um we're going to ask our community to vote May 20th um students parents um all residents

093will be allowed to vote uh so it's going to be an exciting day and um I always end it by saying that anybody who wants to have a voice in what our Panther logo is going to be has the opportunity to express themselves either through a submission or through a vote so there is no restriction on how many kids from any building that want to participate they can participate they can participate and their building will vote on the finalist finalist each building that vot is February 14th at the buildings okay and then um we're going to work with a graphic artist on the final 10 so the high school will have three in the top 10 the middle school will have three in the top 10 and each ele Elementary building will have one in

094the top 10 okay y very good thank you Music Fest is back I announced it uh we announced it a while ago but uh February 2nd 12:30 to 4:15 I know the music department um sent out a schedule to families uh this week and so we are on schedule very happy um that the music department um is working so hard to uh bring this tradition back um to sweet home and uh to have it at the UB Center of Arts is is a deserving place um to showcase the great work of our students um and their teachers so we're excited um please be there February 2nd it's the week between the AFC Championship and the and the Super Bowl so no football that day and it promises to be a a wonderful event um that

095showcases the musical talents of our kids and then finally um with sadness we wanted to uh let our community know that a a panther through and through has has passed um way way too soon um so Lori kinti uh was a um an incredible volunteer um here at Sweet Home uh she had two daughters that went through the district um and when they graduated was the last one graduated five years ago um she continued to stay on and a ginormous roles in Dollars for Scholars and the PTA um here at sweet home um she was the executive secretary or executive assistant to Darren Brown Hall at Williamsville um so she her familiarity with the schools and education um was incredible um if you've ever met Lori you would remember her she always greeted everybody with

096a hug and a smile um I remember when I first got to the district here she was one of the first community members that I met um she told me who she was and it was just um welcome with open arms um she was really vested in the students of our district and wanted to give them opportunities she didn't just go to meetings she volunteered at every event so any kind anytime you saw a um uh a a a a craft show um a meat raffle uh she was there um and um and you could feel her presence um she's gone way way way too soon um and it leaves a big hole um here at sweet home um that will be impossible to fill I know um the PTA is is getting together Thursday

097night to talk about ways they can honor her um and her real Legacy here um at sweet home um I've talked to my um my friend Darren at Williamsville um and he's devastated of course um because uh she is just um was always a shining star so um we're extremely sad um just a wonderful person wonderful human and someone who put this place ahead of her own interests time and time again so don I don't know um I just uh um just a a story more so um you remember for the longest time Mike moral was the president of Dollars for Scholars uh and Mike uh stepped aside uh about four years ago um and uh I had to find somebody to kind of sit in the role and I identified Missy Lisa who many

098of you know in the role and Miss's like well I'll come and listen to what you have to say and uh Missy said I'll do it but I'm bringing Lori with me um and she was always there she um texts about just about anything about silly ideas for fundraising uh she brought little necklaces with pork chop around uh for the meat raffle so we could be identified easily to sell tickets um she was the reason uh as you entered the high school she was the reason that we have the alumni brick area uh out front of the high school uh it was her idea um to kind of move it forward uh and she's spearheaded every brick sale since um you know as Mike had said she uh has been a long time since her

099two daughters went through uh sweet home but uh boy oh boy tough one tough one you never saw Lori without a smile ever ever yep um when I uh got my doctorate she wrote me a note called me Dr G for the rest of the time that I've known her um she would work with Sherry quite often to try strange lunch for me and Darren which never really worked out um and every time I saw her she's like when are you two doing lunch and I'm like we're trying we're trying but she just um always just with a smile everything was with a smile so tough tough loss for Sweet Home tough loss for Williamsville and someone who we're gonna remember always and and honor her Legacy here um and we're working on plans to

100do that so um I I attended the PTSA meeting was very difficult to get through um as they remembered Lori as more than a colleague but but mostly a friend and a volunteer here at sweet home um as hard as it was to get through that meeting I will not forget several of them as they as they struggle to put words to out repeatedly would go I know you don't want me to be sad I know but um all that to be said she was an amazing amazing support for every organization that she was involved in you know multiple entities here at sweet home but also in Williamsville and um the racing team that she supported so heavily so it is sad for us but she would want us to celebrate having known her I

101was just gonna say one more thing like she we we were at the PTA meeting for the high school three four weeks ago you would have never known in a million year Lori would have never never let you know that she was going through what she was going through um people that I've talked to were shocked they couldn't believe it because she's just always that spiritful so I will say that uh the high school PTSA because we're starting to for Dollars for Scholars um solicit um returning scholarship uh folks and the high school PTSA has been very generous uh they traditionally offer four scholarships uh to graduating seniors um at $1,200 a piece uh and they've changed um their kind of their Mantra and their prerequisites for uh their scholarships to shift more towards uh

102a kind of a service model uh to kind of emulate what what Lori had done uh and they've named scholarships after her to kind of start so um as Mike had said um we're meeting with the PTSA Thursday night uh to kind of talk further about how we can honor her but uh it's just tough tough one tough one tough one tough one okay that's what I have tonight that's a hard act to follow yeah does anybody have any questions for Dr janesty okay um upcoming events we have um Dei meets Tomorrow there's a few PTA meetings some Elementary events Martin Luther King Day is on Monday there is no classes district will be closed um and midterms are coming up also next week for the high school right just high school regent exams um

103that brings us to our first just mention something real quick um since I won't be able to mention it next week um on the 28th of January U Maple Mir the staff will be doing a MC teacher night over at uh McDonald's I will be taking over from Mr Ryan at the cash register I believe during some of that time so anybody who can join us please come down is that over the the 20th or the 28th no it is the 28th so Tuesday thank you um that brings us to our first open session anybody want to speak no okay all right new business we'll be voting on new business next week we have our special ed placements I read through the 42 Pages there was nothing that stood out and again thank you to

104our special ed department for the work they do for our kids our monthly financials revised policy second readings yeah I'd like to ask a couple questions on that looks like you're terminating all those policies that are on there is that correct yes the four that are recommended to delete that's what it looks like okay so in terms of exemptions for Veterans for not terminating that just the policy we don't think we need to have as a school district is that correct Scott I don't remember off the top man do you remember what the reason was I seem to remember that it was mentioned elsewhere in policies I don't remember what it was no we're not December we're not eliminating the veterans exemption no okay but I don't remember the reason off the top of my

105head I remember it right in which policy are you talking about 5241 think it was because screen reflects outdated and incomplete information furthermore to make certain property tax exemptions available a district must hold a public hearing and adopt board resolution granting the exception it is not sufficient to place the tax exemption in a district policies policy manual but the exemption doesn't go away correct the exemption doesn't go away if we were to modify or change any sort of exemption it it's got to be brought uh to the board's attention then it goes to a public there's a public comment period of 30 days and then it goes to a public hearing and then the board votes to adopt the change okay but it it's Allin in law anyways sorry it's all defin in law anyways

106so the policy is redundant okay it doesn't really fall under our jur like our ability that's already out there is what you're saying as what from what I recall it's it's not something right we have an impact we I know before most of you on the board we went through this ready for the veterans mhm thanks Scot and it's it's okay all right okay any other questions you said you had a couple I'm sorry you said you had a couple questions did you have more I thought all those policies were being terminated if I read it right one reason or another by other things and being replaced is that what's going on they're just they're part of something else the minutes the the first reading minutes yeah you got it yeah they were just and

107included in other things so there wasn't a need to policy recommends leading this policy that's 5241 policy committee recommends the leading this policy policy 5574 policy committee recommends the leading while on this one it's just uh the change to the wvp coordinator which I believe was Joe Joan bis is that correct that's somebody else leave of absence uh recommends adopting this one okay so these are second readings so either I vote Yes on them next week or I don't correct yeah but I just want to make clear the exemptions are not going away they're just not really necessary as part of in the policy manual that's what's been determined or covered under state law already covered okay that was my big concern these other two uh property tax exemptions same thing 5241 is different than

108the veterans correct or 5240 it's same idea same idea and then the Medicaid compliance program we're not um going to hit the numbers I think that's the correct expectation there's a there's a a threshold there's a dollar threshold in there that we don't hit so it doesn't apply to the district okay again I just no problem need a clarification no problem thank you sure okay on to First reading of the policies there are six any questions or comments can you explain yeah certainly Title Nine and sex discrimination is is that based off of something that came through State Ed or is it Federal Title 9 law that coming pass through State Ed to bosies and now we have to adopt some policy which it looks like we want to use an attorney first which my

109guess would be the attorney was going to say it's law we have to adopt it but I I if it were me if I understand what they're trying to do here I'd really push back very hard on that I don't know if anybody else have a different reading of that so the policy is being amended because the regulations for the U from the US Department of Ed has been changed to include gender identity and some other issues about equal rights and sports is that correct no it's about um married and pregnant students so according to from what was written the US Department of Education moved that off of Title 9 into its own so the equal education opportunity 7554 we're removing the married pregnant student and giving that 7555 its own policy but 3421 is

110not for married couple married people providing equal opportunities it doesn't look like that I'm reading okay sorry that was the other one it's sex discrimination now explicitly includes discrimination based on sex stereotypes characteristics pregnancy or related conditions Etc so how do you feel about that any kind of discrimination is against the way that I feel I'm sorry what you say discrimination of any kind is not something I support discrimination in Title 9 Sports would mean you would allow this has nothing to do with sports it's en Title Nine Sports it does not say sports nothing to do with sports did you read this yes it gives you all the details and sports is not mentioned in there a single time what is Title Nine then I don't know that's that that's not what it's talking

111about I I thought title n was to allow for equal participation in sports they title n has been around for years lemonade it has nothing to with sports has everything to do with discrimination against betterly protected categories yes right that's my problem this is the this is Rewritten to align with regulations that we have to adhere to I think that's the first piece the second piece is why we have an attorney reviewing it it's just um there are is some leeway I believe in the investigation process of of you know how if a if a complaint comes to us there's some we way into how to handle that and so um that was just something we wanted to double check with the attorney so we can get a complaint from any definition of a person

112and uh they can actually sue us if we don't allow them to participate in what I I don't know this no it's harassment it's not participation yeah this it's harassment they're harassed what does n tell me me what that title 9 means in this capacity just discrimination in general I I guess I'm going to have to find the title 9 law how this ties together this well this just to be sure this is title n and sex discrimination and sex discrimination it's so title M even if Title 9 is more encompassing this is a policy just related to that element of it overall it's the federal civil rights law that prohibits sex-based discrimination in any educational SE okay okay that makes sense okay and and I would just say the the pieces are more related

113to pregnancy those are a lot of where the changes are coming from and allowing for you know some um exceptions and um you know I think equity for a a pregnant students okay and there are other categories correct so I guess it's in any educational situation that we can be uh charged with harassment if we don't allow or have something to say about a particular person's participation or uh allow to play in that particular be part of that particular situation so Title 9 is that all encompassing all Educational Services provided yes correct and that policy is actually not up for vote next week no go to an attorney first yeah we have to they have to do right Scott correct it's not next week this is the first read first read the first read 34

114to discuss is not even up for a vote on the first read correct correct so so you have any guess where the attorney's going to go the law is the law right so anyways it it's just a little disturbing today so okay that's all I had about that sure okay um disposal of obsolete property we have uh some uh athletic equip um athletic uniforms thank you and some um old chairs it looks like um but mostly mostly some old athletic uniforms any questions okay overnight field trip request this is for the baseball team to go to Myrtle Beach there baseball team is holding a meat raffle on February 7th you can see any player if you are interested modified JV and varsity all right that a shameful plug sir uh yes it is Shameless plug

115shamess uh um next is the high school course planning guide just one question are there any significant changes I tried to go through it Page by page but they kept bouncing there are no significant changes changes I saw that I don't know if any no significant changes changes I'll argue no changes no significant changes right okay yes I found some changes that's why I'm asking but I gave up because it I it got difficult to look at them side by side okay I just want to make sure there's no sign were I me minoring changes here and there like that right we made significant changes last year so okay that's what I want to make sure a handful of years back they tried to sneak some through on us which I would have been pushing

116for somebody to get fired if they actually got them uh the last one is a transportation contract that is a piggyback that does not have any cost to the district is that correct that's correct that is a West senica Central School district is looking to piggyback on one of our existing Transportation contracts uh and in order to do so and for them to receive Aid our Board needs to authorize that piggybacking no cost to the district thank you any questions okay they will be voted on next week um typically we save our informational items for next week but we have two board members that will not be available for us next week uh if they have informational items to share I'm going to let them do so Maryanne you're first um just a couple things

117I mentioned the McDonald Knight if you can come out and support that would be great I attended the PTA meeting and they met their first wig goal which was at least 95% of attendance so last Friday and I know we got pictures Mr Ryan dressed up in the panther I want to give it away who was under new Panther outfit but it was Mr R um and he's always elementary students that are watching yes his best on so the panther had his pretty identifi he's just a good sport with all this their next wig um um assignment will be they're going to try for 100% growth as mathematicians by May um let's see what else with that um as I mentioned the lighthouse Review Committee is on May 14th they had a successful holiday shop

118um fifth grade committee continues to work for their end of year and they're going to do a winter skate party on February 7th let's see if there's anything else in that's that's probably it how often is the lighthouse review every four other year I thought every other year liouse Rie two years two years every two years okay that's more frequent than I thought okay thanks yep thank you you're welcome uh Dirk did you have anything you wanted to share I shared a little bit earlier because we had a presentation from from uh central office about the buses Etc and AI but on the just one other thing about the uh Panther logo uh Katie PTA president was not very happy wearing it because she thought it was old and smelly so they're kind of hopeful

119that with the new logo or the new panther head they'll get a they'll get a new uniform Mr Ral I will say I've gotten several complaints about the smell of the panther so it is definitely been a topic at central office and we are waiting on our new logo to uh design a new yeah that'd be great and uh Antonio Perry High School principal was there and very proud of his accomplishment there so uh a very nice meeting and uh I'll once once the minutes are available I'll pass it on okay thank thank you thank you very much all right everybody else will be here next week correct okay perfect that brings us to for a second Open Session anyone Personnel we'll be voting on Personnel next week and with that may I have a

120motion in a second to adjourn to Executive session for contract I just want to recognize uh saw Maggie McDonald's name on there she'll be retiring I believe it's on the I'm allowed to say that publicly right so uh if you don't know that she taught my my youngest daughter many many years ago so I will miss having her around I thought she was a a great teacher and a great person so anyways that's all I have on that thank you great anybody else okay can I have a motion in a second to adjourn to Executive session for contract negotiations and matters related to employment history of an particular individual are we still doing that yes we're still going to Executive we be returned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.