001e e e good evening we are calling the February 4th meeting of the entour Board of Education to order we have a tobacco policy in place there is no smoking within 100 ft of school buildings please rise for the pledge district clerk will you please call roll truste can un here trusty Jerome here trusty Mitchell Morell here trusty good here trusty Hemingway Lynch here trusty Rondo here trusty Bishop here thank you thank you all right on to item agenda item 2.01 our high school principal Mr Lance Adelman will welcome the board good evening and welcome to the middle high school I promised tonight I'm going to be a lot shorter than the last time I I presented I know last time I was got a went a little bit longer than expected so I'll make
002up for it tonight uh the school year is moving by very quickly and we're now in the third quarter and I just thought it would be nice if I gave a few a few updates uh first I just wanted to say how proud my faculty is of our students and their performance on throughout January exam week during that week students sat for a total of 1,824 midterm exams and when we looked at all of the data from the from that testing period we had about an 86% passing rate which is about 5% higher than it's been in the past last year was about 81 81% so now the next part of this puzzle is that we take all of that data from those exams and we use it to help Drive instruction so it'll be
003data informed instruction so we could take a look at where some gaps are and hopefully move students to their goals by the end of the school year um with that said uh grades have been posted uh on the parent portal uh honor roll for second quarter is now available on the high school's web page and will be posted up to Facebook as well in the very near future and congratul ation to all of those students um I did mention in a recent parent update that uh student course scheduling for the 25 26 school year has already begun all of the information is on the counseling office's website which could be reached through the high school's website uh I also made sure that on board docs there is a copy of a description of all the
004electives that we plan on offering as well as the student course selection sheet so you can see exactly what the students see um our councils have already visited classes and students have already selected preliminary selection of courses that they're interested in the next step will be the councils will meet individually with students and then also report back to the parents you know what courses they the students have selected we'll take that data and we'll make determinations on which courses avable which ones we could actually run which ones we may not be able to run based of course on student enrollment and you know that's part of having a student driven schedule um I also wanted to mention that we're really proud we're really proud to announce the relaunching of our student bookstore which will now
005include a student thrift store over the past few months DEA students have been collecting donations of gently used items including clothing shoes and accessories like handbags sunglasses Etc um this initiative has been a collaborative effort led by Deca members with a support from some science students interested in sustainability and also our intro introduction to business uh class students in addition to Thrift Store items the bookstore will also sell onto our merchandise DEA is very excited to be able to add additional products uh to try to boost school spirit so there'll be a lot of school spirit items there and then looking ahead for the spring and I'm getting a little bit ahead of myself because we're just finalizing these plans but I I know it's going to happen so I'm going to say it anyway
006um and this is based on student interest we're also going to be introducing a slushie machine which will be in the bookstore in the spring of course it'll it'll offer 100% fruit juice and we'll we'll adhere to all of those crazy guidelines that we have to those nutritional guidelines that we have to uh adhere to um we're looking for a soft opening on Monday February 10th and the store is going to open during the second half of each High School Lunch Period to start and then we're going to see if we could bring it into the middle school but we want to we want to start this slow so we have we have a lot of different items uh that have been donated they're really great items and everything is priced like extremely low so
007um this is really going to open up some opportunities and kids have already been looking in to see what's in there and it's just going to continue to grow so it's going to start off a little slower than we than I would have liked to but I think it's a good I think it's really a good start um through this experience students are going to gain valuable Hands-On skills in pricing Inventory management customer service operating a register merchandising um and like I said right now they're just working on uh publicity for the store as well as they're developing the work schedules so it's it's kind it's kind of nice to see them the students take this over okay finally I wanted to take a few minutes to introduce our new musical director who is Mr
008Ken shes he's also known by the students um they call him Mr s which is causing some confusion we just figured out today because our assistant principal Mr shimble fig so you know the common theme is that you know students have hard time pronouncing the names let alone spelling the names so now we have confusion on who's Mr s who they're talking about but we'll we'll figure that out but Mr s is a very experienced teacher with a very very impressive resume his extensive background in theater and dance makes him a true asset to the district and we're really look looking forward to seeing him help develop our program I've asked him to come talk to us tonight just a little bit just about his vision and also about the upcoming plans for our musical
009event which will be in April so let me introduce good evening um after holding an interest meeting in November Miss Carol the coral music teacher Miss wiland the visual art teacher and I realized that the majority of the students interested in the spring musical um this year were younger and that it might be best to find a way to use the concept of musical theater to build the foundations of theater education we held an audition Workshop in December three weeks prior to the actual audition during which students workshopped um audition songs and learn the dance phrase for the actual audition our educational objectives with the spring musical are to perform a cabaret or Musical review Style Show so that students learn to develop a reciprocal relationship with the audience focus on vocal technique and lyric
010inter lyric interpretation allowing students to connect to the performance of a melody with a clear objective by chosen actions to elevate physical awareness by connecting acting techniques to Lyric centered staging and choreography and finally to develop an understanding of Ensemble through collaborative rehearsal practices the title of the spring Musical review is songs that tell a story there are 19 musical numbers from the past 100 Years of Broadway shows to be performed by 20 students all students who auditioned were cast simp simple costumes and conceptually driven lighting will allow the audience to focus on each student's performance Journey students were asked to research each show and write brief monologues that they'll perform between the musical numbers so that the audience learns about the show from which the next song is performed My Hope Is that this
011experience for students families and the community will only be the first step to creating a more constant and consistent theater education program for the district we've had um s rehearsal so far the students are fantastic and are already making lots of discoveries that I can tell are showing up in their day-to-day lives the performance dates are April 4th 5ifth and 6th and I hope you'll help us spread the word I want to make a special shout out to Mr kuden who stepped in to record our rehearsal tracks for us he saved the day last week and I'm really appreciative um and as a final thought I wanted to share that I moved to showan little more than a year and a half ago after having spent 40 years in Performing Arts education and I thought
012my time with students sadly had come to an end so I'm thrilled to be working with them them again and right here in my own neighborhood so thanks very much for the opportunity and other than that we're all hoping for a snow day on Thursday so if you have any influence that would be greatly appreciated um but any any questions thank you so much thank you okay all right on to item 3.01 uh we have the ster Bosey team presenting on AI I believe uh assistant superintendent Laughin has a few words to say yes thank you good evening everyone um before the olster bosies team begins I wanted to provide some context to their presentation as the board considers an artificial intelligence policy superintendent McLaren and I felt it was important for the board to
013have an opportunity for a broader discussion on how AI affects education as well as the best practices we can consider to move forward over the past two years we have partnered with uler bosis particularly West trabel who works in antora on Tuesdays and Wednesdays to provide staff with professional learning on AI as well as instructional Technology support tonight we have oler Bose's assistant superintendent Sarah dely lmch supervisor of instructional Services Dr Julie Ross kimman and Innovation specialist West cheli with a presentation to Foster our thinking and discussion so welcome that sounds good right all right good evening everyone uh I am Sarah Dudley lamik I am the assistant superintendent for instructional services at ster bosis we are very excited to be here tonight to give you a very brief overview of some of the things
014to think about in the world of AI um as you're looking at your policy and ultimately as you're looking at what you want to um provide for your students and what you want to encourage and support in your students moving forward with the idea AI um our our team is as U Stephanie mentioned Dr Julie Ross kimman is here but we also have three other Innovation Specialists who are part of our model schools program which is all about um educational technology across the state but Molly kahel Shelley coochi and and West treli um all have done a lot of work over the last two years um immersing themselves really in the world of AI I think each of them has taken a little bit different um Direction with that but I feel very confident and
015I'm very proud of of the learning that we have been doing to be able to share with all of you um not only internally within New York state but across the country as well if you uh we did share some of the areas that we have experienced and where we've been and what we've done um in the world of technology for for many many years um I would say I would classify myself definitely as as a Learner in this area I am not the expert in AI I I trust and learn from all of them regularly so I'm not going to talk a lot this evening um I'm going to let them really give you a feeling of where AI is in education right now not only for our K12 students but as we look
016forward at higher education where they might need to be and then also look at your um possible wording in your policies to try to ensure that these policies are you know malleable enough to grow with the world of AI but then also protect our students and our Educators um and encourage deeper thinking across the board for everyone um disclaimer and I'm not sure if I was doing this but I'm going to do it anyway the slide General disclaimer this world is changing as we speak right now so things that we're presenting now may not be truth tomorrow or the next day or the next day we're presen to you what we know in this moment but and we are making some projections of where we think things will be as we move forward you know
017I think we've been saying that about educa or about technology for as long as I've been in education which is over 20 years at this point but truly now we are at a day-by-day um basis and situation so the more we can be thoughtful um and prepare ahead the better it will be for our students and and for all of us so from with this I'm going to hand it over to jul I believe she's going to take you through where we are right now thank you good evening everyone and thank you so much for having us here today uh just very briefly as uh Sarah was explaining yes our team collectively brings over Decades of experiences working closely with Educators students and policy makers we want to make sure that you understand that AI
018is evolving rapidly uh and so exactly as Sarah said what we say today might change tomorrow uh so it's very important that we we continue to research uh we are currently all part of the vital program uh we have been part of IST and the standards along with the AI and GM um offerings that were available so we continue to partner with organizations with schools for our own education so just a little bit about the current state of artificial intelligence in education as we already know AI is shaping education it's transforming how we teach how we learn and how we operate our schools in New York City the Department of Education is piloting an AIP powerered reading tutor or tutors actually to help provide personalized instruction aiming to enhance student literacy at Georgia State University
019the AI chatbot pounce which okay that that was its name uh is a summer tool that is used to help students with enrollment helping to answer thousands of students inquiries about financial aid registration and application deadlines ai's influence is growing the National Education Association from October 24 and the office of educational technology from May 2023 has said that AI is not a tool it is a major shift in education and they recognize that some students can leverage AI at home but they really feel that others who cannot are missing out and that's where schools must come in and address that inequity key challenges so how do we harness good AI for good while ensuring that it doesn't compromise learning it doesn't compromise fairness or student data privacy our policy approach is built on working with
020Educators policy makers and Technology experts to adopt to new challenges in education we feel that AI should not I'm let's try that one more time I was going to say AI should not enhance no no no sorry AI should enhance but not replace education it is a powerful tool but human teachers remain and students as you can see in this diagram at the center of all learning adaptive AI tools can tailor lessons to individual student needs so what we also need to look at is how AI can generate answers automatically for students so we have to rethink like the blue ribbon commission and align with rethinking assessments and instructional methods to promote real world learning for our students for future strategies we suggest training Educators to use AI ethically and efficiently embedding AI into policies
021current policies that you have but this should also be a research a review a um rollout and a review again we want to help embed AI into policies to support and not undermine education and as I get ready to turn it over to West to talk about one specific policy that we are looking at and working with I want you to just think that AI is a reality it's not a choice the question isn't whether we use AI in education it's how we use it responsibly how we use it responsibly to rep to prepare students for their future and again just to let you know with that Decades of collaboration and experience we are uniquely positioned to help schools navigate ai's challenges thoroughly and effectively thank you good evening thank you for having us um
022before I talk about my slide I would like to preface that I've been looking a lot into um AI guidelines and policies the federal government re issued in May 2023 a document that's about 71 pages long and I always approached these documents from the perspective of a teacher or a student because we said they are the center they are the trenches the problem is that these kind of documents are hardly helpful like for instance the the one from the federal government in the 71 Pages mention AI literacy many times but never defines it so as a teacher and I'm told I'm reading the document that I have to teach make sure that my students are AI literate but they don't even Define what it means all frustrating 23 states have issued guidelines not New York
023so far um they range from two page to 80 something page for Ohio I think um some are very good North Carolina and Washington Washington uh state is the only state that has a section in the guidelines that addresses students directly which I found was great idea that's the only state that have done this um I read a very long article detailing everything I know about the poses but um I'm going to give you through this um New York State School Board Association that released a three-page document guideline last fall uh which is still um valid uh I'm going to explain why this document is very good and could be adopted by a district as is yet for teachers and students not very helpful and it's just like the beginning of the work so from
024these pages I I selected two quotes but the entire document is like this so the first one one acknowledgement says that the district acknowledges that many students are able to access gener um generative AI outside of school and may be able to use gen to complete School assignments however not all students are able or willing to do so and should not be penalized for not using gen but this is great because they acknowledging the digital divide and that some student that have parents who are like well versed in technology May or more affluent may have the paid subscription to chat GPT and be aware of every development and then know that you can share your screen and you can on your computer nowadays you can share your screen with chat GPT so that chat GPT
025sees what's on your screen and you can talk to it and ask questions so it's not just a chat bot that you ask a question to see an answer it goes farther so some students will have access to this some other students are still living in 2022 prior to this existing I've never used it so the difference between these students there's a real risk of magnifying the digital divide when this tool could help mitigated now if you look at this quote not all students are able or willing to do so and should not be penalized if you're a teacher this is very curious how do you not penalize a student for not having something to me when I read this it means that we should provide AI access to our students and train them to
026level a paying field of course if we decide this if someone decide this you or I don't know then which AI are we going to provide there's some decisions to be made so in this document the New York State School Board Association if you read carefully be between the lines you'll see that there's many decisions that need to be made if you want to have policies and guidelines that are actually helpful to the main stakeholders teachers and students those decisions will have to be experimental in nature which is why most federal or state guidelines are so unspecific anything specific will have to be experimental because this is brand new and this is changing all the time so yes for that first quote I think that the most rational response to this would be to provide
027AI to all students and make sure they train they have a baseline training uh second example that's one of the four recommendations the four guidelin four recommendations in that document it's my favorite one the board respects the professional capacity of the instructional staff to assign work that is less susceptible to student use of gen to circumvent learning and allow for multiple methods for students to demonstrate competence and understanding plain English that means uh teachers will figure it out just like with remote learning in 20 you have to teach remotely how no one knows but they respect the professional capacity of the instructional staff there's something similar in the federal government document with the respect for teachers when they said that we have to find out how to do this um but that work that is
028less susceptible to student use of jni I'm not sure what that is because nowadays like any task that we traditionally ask students to do can can be automated there's very few things left like even even recording a video of themselves now you can you can have ai do this you can have an avatar it's it's not easy to do yet but it is possible that you can create an avatar of yourself that speak with your voice and you can just upload whatever text and you have that you your image in your voice say whatever you want so even asking them to film themselves saying something or recording work even that we can't really be sure so I'm not sure what that means that part about the assigning work that less susceptible that that the LA
029the last part is the lifeline allow for multiple methods so essentially that I guess that means if you suspect that a student has used AI then you can request that that student does something else to demonstrate that they actually worked I think that this should be formalized this should not be left to each teacher to decide how to interpret this the district should have decided on an interpretation of what do we do if we suspect ation anat what is the appropriate response and we need to tell the teachers here's how you handle it it would be safer to include stakeholders such as students even parents in the process of making these decisions because then you're not going to have more too much backlash I don't know if you've heard about that lawsuits in that um
030student was disciplined for using AI it was like a straight A students aiming for Stanford and now he has a c so the students are suing the district because they didn't have a policy in place so the document as far as the the board is concerned or like the District administration to cover you back in that respect adopting the the document as is those three pages that's good enough but the teacher though and the students I think that um I'm going to pass on this one if you read carefully the the document and you think about what it means and it suggest you have to answer in my sense four essential questions the first one is the question of representation who will make the decisions who will this like I said those um when we
031said how do we not penalize then we have to to provide it how do we make that decision so who is going to make that decision are we including parents or not is it a one off a questionnaire or is it at board meetings or doing are you creating a committee just for this how each district will have their own ways of working through challenges like this but it needs to be decided who's going to make the decisions and uh wrote and write the guidelines then the second question is how are we going to make sure that whoever is drafting the policies understand what they're talking about because there's a lot of things to understand and to consider when uh because to make an analogy imagine yeah we're not deciding on a tool it's not
032like do we adopt Google classroom or not it's more like yesterday the internet did not exist today the internet does exist in smartphones should we have a policy about internet in schools of course we do AI is the same kind of of deal just like happening very quickly so the third question once you've trained uh stakeholders and decided how the decisions are going to be made uh then there's defining the mandates the question how will the district translate abstract the guidance into specific actionable policies that define acceptable and Innovative uses of AI what is the district's responsibility maybe some of you will decide well it's just a technology that's not our job to train students to do this and some of you might think differently but where does your responsibility how far does it extend
033that is also something that the district has to answer for themselves the last last question the fourth one comes after once the guidelines and policies are drafted then what systems are put in place to support teachers day-to-day to follow along the developments of AI as it progresses as it changes Etc Etc um I'll come back to to the previous slide those are the main themes that you will find in any uh guideline documents from the federal or States um AI is already here we've been using it for computer adaptive assessment for instance even Google Google Search now has the large language model so it's unavoidable um it should enhance and not replace humans that's also Common Sense here uh the a policies must align with school policies and legal framework so protect student data and
034intellectual property and then ongoing monitoring as it evolves it's never going to be a one one job is you're gonna have to think about this uh in an ongoing process so my job here is really kind of a wrap up of um the very brief overie that we gave you but I think wesp did a nice job of of emphasizing to you that the work of the policy is your first step and then there's a lot more work to do after that to help our students and our teachers our community understand the impacts to understand um again when is AI a super tool for enhancing learning and when is AI actually detracting from um processing critical thinking whatever that might be um so so you know we would love to be able to help you
035talk through that but definitely um there are big decisions to be made and just adopting the nisba policy because they've said that that's a good one is okay but it's going to bring up questions as you move forward so you know thinking about what input do you want to get what kind of stakeholder groups do you want to bring together um you know I would Advocate that student voice is critically important in this conversation um because they're living it in a way that making some presumptions many of us are not um they're seeing it they're using it they're doing it and it's very very very difficult to determine when a student is using it um there's almost no I me there's really no no um online things that you can you know push a paper
036through and it'll say yes this is AI um they're not accurate um right so I mean yes you can put them through but you don't know for sure if that if it's if it's real or not um so you know there needs to be some really deep conversations and I think this is coming together at a time when we're looking at new graduation measures um those are dovetailing I think very nicely right um but but that's serious thinking about how are we changing what's happening in classrooms for our students and this is not just something that's impacting our 9 through 12 students right now it's probably having a bigger impact there but AI is going to be a part of our children's lives moving up and through a little anecdotal evidence my daughters are both
037in college one is actually student teaching right now yay teachers right um and the other is going into microbiology and they would say that um you know their four years has really been the Genesis or the beginning of chat gbt as an entity colleges don't really know what they're doing with it yet either um but that's not going to be in place for long because they're going to have to adjust as well um so the more that we can do at this level again to enhance critical thinking to enhance um humans ability to be human right is important and I would also state that going Beyond just higher education as we're looking at our trades artificial intelligence is going to revolutionize them as well we already know that things like YouTube and video has changed
038a lot of what our trads are doing they don't need as much you know face to-face training um we all don't need as much face-to-face training when we're when we're looking at a problem in our home right it's very easy to look things up online um AI is going to influence a lot of that as well so this is critically important um we would love to help you work through this do we have all the answers absolutely not um but we do have a lot of the questions and it will really be up to you to think about where Auntie Ora wants to sit on this conversation and you know where are your expectations and your lines um that you want your students to work within or around or over whichever direction you want to
039go as a district um certainly we're open to coming back and talking more deeply uh or if there's another situ you know anything else where you'd like more information we realized this was very very brief and quick overview um but if there are any questions right now we'd be happy to take those probably there'll be able answer Jesse Jerome not really a question but just you know I I think our board in our district in our Administration has talked about being human first I work for an AI company in my day job and I represent the customer I represent that bridge to people there's a real opportunity here our emphasis on music the Arts um source and citations as we look at models I think that that's a really important thing as we decide what
040tools we decide that we want to adopt but I just want to say to my fellow board members like this we can do this in a really great way for our students at ontora and not have it be a scary thing but um have it complement that which we do so well which is having kids together with teachers in classrooms doing stuff or out in the world as we look at the portrait of the G graduate thank you any other questions or comments tresse kudon yeah I mean I think this is this is a very long conversation that we probably should not start at this moment but um you know what what has always struck me having live you know live you know I'm almost 60 so I I've gone from no personal computers to
041what we have now and it always seems like um governing entities governments are always well behind the technology in terms of figuring out how to ethically and you know use it um and so I'm just wondering so it to me it feels like we're on a bicycle pedaling after a bullet train you know at this point and I'm sure that's pretty much the reality but um I'm wondering you know if there's any if you're seeing um short-term action just as as a um a protection from for not letting this not letting us be too far behind um damage that could be done to our our students um I'm just going to give a quick like off the top of my head I won't say off the cuff answer um don't block it um you know
042that that is a a um that is something that districts are doing in places um I don't think that's actually really that plausible because most students have access anyway so blocking it again just enhances that digital divide um you know so I think acknowledging that this is real we need to have these conversations and kind of get cracking on it is probably your best way and and I would say unlike maybe some other things in technology in education again in the many years that I've been alive at this point um it really has only been the last couple of years even though it's developing very rapidly that it's been widespread that it's been out there in schools um so we're if we jump on it now in an education sense we're a little ahead of
043it than we kind of normally are right and I will say you know one of the benefits of of covid is that our students many of our students have devices you know your schools are equipped to be able to G give access in a way that we weren't even going into Co um and I know all of you are are very well aware of that um so you know we we do have a lot of things in place to to make this work and to start thinking about it um and again I believe that that New York State education department is going to support some of this work too with the changes that they're proposing for graduation measures I would just say it's I agree do not block we seem to go from one extreme
044to another when it comes to educational technology I would say Do not block and do not isolate meaning AI is separate from everything else that we do no AI is embedded just like every other technology tool that we use is embedded and should be embedded in all of our curriculum it shouldn't be seen as a separate entity but with that there needs to and language everyone needs to be speaking the same language everyone needs to understand what students can do safely so first you need to recognize that you are not behind there are counties that are blocking it and I did say counties and I've been having that conversation I'm part of a podcast and we're a group of varied folks from higher ed special ed Elementary High School and one of our participants their
045entire county has blocked AI so we do not want to do that so the fact that we're having a conversation we're already had of the game believe it or not it's important not to block it's important not to isolate and it's important for everyone to be on the same page and have conversation and it's important to keep our students safe so whatever tool we're using because they're already using it but we want to teach them how to use it ethically and we want to teach them how to use it safely and how to how to teach students how to use it to enhance what they're doing not replace their learning that's that's my so just to follow up I don't see this as a technological challenge I see it as an ethical challenge primarily um
046and a huge one for our students who are just learning how to be ethical and how not to cheat themselves out of out an education and and I think the power of these tools is just mindboggling and to expect young children to handle that is is is a big ask of them and we need to help them and we need to help them soon there is a whole conversation about um so there's a framework called triple um technolog enhancing extending and helping to engage students learning and there's been a big conversation with researchers about is AI ering students learn well okay just calc we didn't want to give the kids calculators we didn't want to put them on the Internet we don't want to give them phones these are their tools these are our tools
047we have to at the scaffolding from elementary to just want to add a few things about about blocking is illus um they can block from the Wi-Fi but they can't do anything about the cell phones it's not just cell phones now you have like Lael device you have smart glasses that you can talk to that talk to your ear and no one can hear so yes even if you P the students for the phones you don't know they have a second phone or they have the smart glasses you don't know about those things and so blocking it is amounting to only giving access to the students who have more devices that are more connected so magnifying the device sorry sorry I thought I had that loud elementary teacher voice I apologize I was saying thinking
048all think of all the things that goes through a student's mind who's trying to unblock the work there is that critical thinking there is that computational thinking that pattern recognition so they are going to find a way to do it and in a sense you know what it's kind of cool I'm sorry as a tech person because they are going through so much thinking so we have to to find the positive way to engage that thinking of deconstructing and and decomposition for Learning and if we're not providing it for them you know they're gonna find it themselves just to close if I were up to me and if I had the power I would not introduce this until at least 11th grade but the reality is that they are using it I was in an
049eighth grade class the other day and I as the students all of them use CH all of them so cheating is one aspect but that's not really what I'm most concerned about what I'm most concerned about is that up until now we've always relied on written assignments to teach how to think and now that we can't reliably know for sure if the writing comes from the students we need to find another way to teach them how to think it's not about being good writers very few students are going to be making a living of their writing skills but thinking that's important trusty Jerome I'll be brief but I did think you know of that model of you know you have to you have to draw all the characters from the Midsummer's Night Dream or you
050have to you know represent it in some other way make something that should do cited interviews with people where you're referencing and you're talking to people and your they can be almost verified sources you know there are ways to make it really exciting and fun to Circle a subject in a 360 view rather than just that traditional like okay I'm going to write a paper about it so I think we're going to be a great District because we're a creative District I think we're going to figure this out um I wanted to take a moment and thank you all for coming tonight and just to express to the board that you know as we were looking at the AI policy I think that's a great start and I think the nisc has a lot of
051um good components to it but as assistant superintendent Laughin and I were speaking and then West came and spent some time talking with us and going through this it became very clear that that might be a good place to start but that is just a start and we just wanted to introduce that that whole process to the board as a whole so that um as we move forward we can actually think about what kind of regulations and guidelines we want to put in place and who we want to include and and you know we have we have subject matter experts who work with our schools and Wes is in our classrooms and and really an incredible resource so we just sort of wanted to tie all that together for you tonight and and you know
052I don't think we're anywhere near figuring out the whole process but just to know that we need to think through it and we need to come up with the whole process thank you thank you very much we love being here um feel free of course reach out anytime thanks have a great rest of your meeting thank thank you so much so we have a lot to think about now today on to item 3.02 our assistant superintendent for business Monica lir will present the rollover budget and the budget assumptions testing testing okay um so there is a lot going on this time of year uh we are besides working on budget obviously very heavy into um what a capital project may look like but I don't want to lose sight of the fact that that the
053budget is what drives our daily life here in the school um this is what supports all of our students all of our staff so here we go um as for our initial draft Levy so I don't know why can't see the whole picture but you've got the presentation um the tax levy limit calculation is due on March 1st so this is just a draft based on on what we currently know um you can see our tax base growth factor has increased from 1.75 to 1.83 what that means is that is actual physical brick and mortar growth in the district so those are new homes new businesses additions to homes um it has nothing to do with increased values it is truly additional taxable entities so what the state says is if you have additional taxable
054entities you can raise your tax levy because now you have additional homes to tax um and they calculate that for us that's not something we come up with um Pilots we still have one pilot um up uh up that way um it's not much um we did have some prior year exemptions um the CPI as I'm sure does not surprise anyone is the 2% which is the maximum um our current pilot will be a little higher than our last year's pilot our current exemptions um are 426,000 we have no carryover available for this year and we have no uh retirement exclusions like we did last year so currently we are looking at a maximum allowable tax levy of 49 m88048 as you can see last year's um adopted tax levy was a little less than
055what the maximum was so we are looking at an increase of 2.99% um again that is the draft that is not saying that is what we are going to LY that's purely what has to get sent to the state and the next board meeting we will probably have the final just to kind of show you again how we compare to other schools in the district as far as our tax rates you can see onour all the way at the far right we have the lowest tax rate in the counties and you might be saying well this interesting looking lines how come everybody's going down at the for 2425 because you have to understand this is a tax rate this is the dollar per thousand of assessment that you pay um and I'm sure as you've
056seen on your own tax bills assessments have gone up in our district and what this is basically saying is assessments are going up everywhere so the tax rate is going down because their assessments are going up so a home that may be assessed at you know $200,000 paying $10 is now at $400,000 paying $8 so their tax rate is going down but that doesn't mean that their taxes are going down uh so the initial projected revenues for 2526 um I can say I am pleasantly surprised that our state aid is scheduled to go up so the governor um very graciously gave every school district that uh was considered overfunded as we are the minimum increase of 2% so we are receiving a 2% increase on our formula Aid in addition to some other increases on
057our expense driven AIDS we have the 2.99% increase in the tax levy miscellaneous will stay about the same so we're looking at uh little over $61 million for projected revenues so a little over uh 2.4% so just to kind of go over again about the expense driven AIDS because this kind kind of gets confusing for people our 2526 budgeted AIDS are based on our 2425 budgeted expenses however 2526 actual AIDS is based on 2425 actual expenses well we're still in 2425 so the state says well we think you're going to spend this much so we think we're going to give you this much aid but if you don't spend this much or if you spend more than this much we might give you less or we might give you more so that makes budgeting really
058fun so because as you can see some of our AIDS are pretty high Bose's Aid is 36% um okay building a 31 that's not high so and then just for uh you know excess public excess cost private excess Cod that's our special ed and the way they they figure out that Aid is first we have to pay what is called a basic contribution and then we get for the example of public we get 25% over over that basic contribution so to say that you know we get you know Aid on on our our our um special ed students it's actually aid over and above what we would have paid if they were in our district so so kind of a little bit of a misnomer we do have the highest basic contribution in the county
059because again it's based on our budget and what we spend per student we're number 24 in the state not bad considering there's 700 schools in New York State uh and it's usually the long Island schools that are higher so our initial projected expenses for 2526 um we are looking at a um about $140,000 increase in general support a slight decrease in operations and maintenance a uh little over 2% increase in instruction a slight decrease in transportation and not surprisingly a hefty 5% increase in employee benefits as you know that encompasses our health insurance community service Debt Service excuse me Remains the Same and um we're looking to continue with the um the uh Capital uh transfer to capital for um the general fund as well at the 750,000 Mark so just as far as a
060summary uh salary makes up uh a little over 40% of this budget so almost $26 million there is an additional 680,000 that is not in that 25 million 862,5kg uh benefits is uh 21, 69221 or what 33.7% of the budget again based on contracts as I mentioned previously we have about 240 active employees that take health insurance and 322 retirees that take health insurance and we also reimburse retirees for their Medicare Part B everything else is a little over 26% it's 16, 875 that's our supply our materials our equipment our contracts maintenance bosies is a large part of that um and transportation is a large a large part of that as well so as far as the highlights of the 2 526 budget we're really planning on continuing what we have been doing these last
061few years I think we've been you know very strong in our instruction we've been doing a lot with um mtss that you know um Miss phow had given the presentation for on We are continuing our all of of our mental health supports the professional learning um we are um able to decrease some runs next year which will help we will be bringing back the summer skills academy which we have not budgeted in a few years because ARP covered it for a few years and then we unfortunately couldn't do it last year due to construction and we are also um including the additional resource officer so Bud budget drivers that we still have the antia contract is still in negotiation um we have seen a large increase in the Bose's budget we do pay uh $611,000
062in a debt payment to bosis for construction that bosis is currently undertaking in addition there has been an increase of 108,000 for the new I park that's that we will be in that will be in next year's budget and then um CTE is actually seen a very large increase of 187,000 and what CTE that's the uh Career and Technical I apologize for not putting the full word there the Career and Technical um Center for uh bosies so it's the cost is based on a three-year average in 2223 our three-year average was 56 now it's 87 so we are sending a lot of kids to bosis when you consider that our high school enrollment has gone down um health insurance um is budgeted a 10% increase we have not gotten the official rates yet hoping uh
063soon think I have a meeting next week uh the teacher retirement system is going to go down slightly from 10.11 to 9.59 ERS is going up slightly from 15.2 to 16.5 we still have a little bit of uncertainty of some special ed placements um as I mentioned the rein reinstating the summer skills academy is going to uh Drive our budget and as well as the additional resource officer so as it stands now our projected difference between revenues expenditures is just under $3 million um La for this current budget we've used um just under 2.8 million as our appropriated fund balance so the fact that our current difference is 2.9 Million makes me feel very confident that we will be able to come to a good budget as you can see historically we've used between uh
0642.7 and 3.2 as appropriate a fund balance so we're well with within what we historically use and then I'll just end that with um uh my recommendation is as we move forward if I can find Savings in additional places seeing that we are in in such a good place to um to try to bring the tax levy down to closer to a two a 2% if at all possible if that's obviously in the end it's the board's decision but that would be my recommendation that's good news thank you questions or comments trusty Rondo quick question Monica can you take us back to slide two and explain what a pilot is please I absolutely can I apologize a pilot is called a payment in lie of taxes so it is something that um is done by
065the county with certain um places I guess for lack of a better term that um are looking to build grow expand they will say hey if I hire this many people will you give me a pilot a payment in Le of taxes and usually it's a percentage of what they would have paid in taxes that they are now paying us a lump sum versus going through the process of what their assessment is and their tax rate and things like that so it's basically a flat dollar amount agreement that's made between the corporation um or the entity and the county trusty Lynch yeah thank you very much um in our last meeting we talked a bit about potential impact of cuts from the um at the federal level I don't see that listed here on projected
066revenues um we have we've we've pretty much been told that there will not be any Cuts as somebody who works with usaid I'm just wondering if we need to be prepared well we've never worked with us all of ours comes from I'm just saying um if the Department of Education changes course um I'm just curious if there's so uh you know other than I mean as as I mentioned we have about 680,000 of Revenue I mean I'm sorry of salaries that's in Grants other than that it's maybe less than 400,000 of other monies we we really are very I won't say very lucky but if we did lose it it would not be a large amount for us as as much as it would be again understanding that we're considered a wealthy District so we
067don't get a lot of aid federal or state would it be here in the in the miscellaneous no it wouldn't be it would be it's outside of the budget you don't vote on it okay it's it's a it's a it's something that we do yeah it's separate dollars currently like some of it's spent on besides this we spend we pay um we pay some Bose's people that that maybe some that are here tonight to come into the district but all told it's a it's about million and a half trusty Jerome yes bear with me on page five can you just again explain the excess cost Aid and the that word the highest basic contribution in the county and I don't quite understand yes sure let let me tell you I've been doing this for 20
068years and I still have trouble sometimes understanding so the excess cost Aid are our um special education students so you have Amanda correct me if I'm wrong we are required to um send our kids to the least restrictive environment in District is obviously the least restrictive if we cannot find a program from them here that we we are required to look at what's called a public environment so bosies is one example they're considered a public so we sent some of our students out to special ed programs in bosis if we cannot find a public placement for them we can send them to a private placement so if it's a public placement so if they're placed in bosies we pay the first $43,000 and then anything over that so if the cost to bosis is 100,000
069we pay 40 we get 25% of 60,000 as Aid back to the district if however there's no public placement and they put in private we pay the first 43,000 and anything over that we get 61% back so it's I always thought it was strange that we got more Aid on private than public but yet we are required to try to keep them in public as much as possible yes I think I understand um and so the so the contribution is based on what we pay normally per student so every every school district has their own basic contribution okay based on their budget and the number of students that they that they educate right so that's the 43,000 and I understand all that but I'm just looking for the reason why our basic contribution is high
070because we have a $60 million budget and just over a thousand kids okay basically that's it 6 million it's not a oneto one but you got understand like Pine Plains for example has about a $37 million budget and has the same number of kids right okay so it's but again it's you know understanding we have a much higher Transportation cost because of we're lar much larger so it's you know it's but that the state that's how the state does it okay I understand it thank you Tristy canson thanks an apolog if these are basic questions I'm looking at the sum of expenses on page seven yes can you break down a little bit to 21 million in benefits is going to 240 active employees and 322 retirees which is a function I assume of the
071fact that the retirees were here when we had a lot more students so that's why we have more retirees than correct well and plus remember when you know when they could retire at 55 so you have a retiree who may be retired at 55 we have a 30e old replacing them but the person that that 55-year-old replaced could be 85 and still alive so we could be paying three health insurance is for one position okay and my question is do you have any sense of of that 21 million how much is going to active employees how much is going to retirees how that projects forward yeah so so retirees is not as high a dollar figure as active employees and that is because the the um annual cost for the retirees once they hit Medicare
072is lower in addition many of the retirees are single whereas a lot of active employees are families and there's a there's obviously a cost savings for a single versus a family plan um so it is um I know I had the percentage in the LA I think I did the percentage in the last uh presentation and I apologize for not putting it in this one so okay but it is not as high for retirees as it is for AC and my last question is up top says we have now 316 between instructional and and non-instructional fulltime those are fulltime full-time but 240 are taking health insurance the other 76 are are probably on the buyout because we actually have quite a few married couples in the district as well okay so if you're married one
073has their SP the spouse has to take a bio yeah and does that affect our responsibility in their retirement or not only if they're employees only if they're employ yeah okay thank you other questions okay thank you so much for that presentation we look forward to the next one we forgot I to do that and we're moving on to the presentation of capital project initial scope and funding considerations all right moving on um we're very excited to be um having this presentation I think we are really in the middle of all of our planning and we've had a lot of time with our community at our community Forum so now it's great to be here and sharing this uh at the board table so we always want to come back to the visual distillation that
074we came up from our visioning sessions because we really um we really just love this uh depiction of the visioning co-creating the future of antora which is what we all want to do collaboratively um we wanted to just share this slide as um kind of a look back at what we were talking about uh almost two years ago uh and what started us on this path and a lot of the reasons that we were using for moving towards uh a central campus so I'm not going to read this but we wanted to include it here just as a as a representation of kind of how how far we've come and where we started so then we wanted to um kind of put things into buckets because uh Sharon lovsky who who has been our Navigator
075and our just absolutely incredibly skilled facilitator helped us come up with these categories of how we view all of the work that we've been doing and so we're looking at it through the lens of students first staff forward fiscally responsible and with community and so we were really trying to create um bullets that show how we are guiding through this process in these buckets um and so you know for students first we are really looking to create a campus that will allow us to have the best staff possible and fill in those teacher retirements because everyone in the state is going to be having and facing uh difficulties hiring the best staff as uh our experienced faculty and staff retire and allow that will allow us to maintain and even possibly enhance our programs and
076our student supports and having our students build relationships with and among the community regardless of their actual physical location um and looking to provide equity for all of our students having them be in one building regardless of what their program might be and then balancing our bus times for our students um looking again staff forward at recruiting high quality new hires um maintaining our class sizes as we have committed to despite the pro the projected retirements um and eliminating the need for teachers to travel between buildings because that is not the best most efficient use of their time or their skills and allowing for increased collaboration um vertically and horizontally among the grade levels so that we continue to enhance our programming and the instructional practice can grow being fiscally responsible again balancing attrition with
077program needs and wants so being fiscally responsible and replacing only those staff members that we need to if we are on one campus we can be the most efficient version of ourselves um and as we've seen closing Phoenicia Transportation efficiency with elimination of multiple attendance zones is an immediate savings and and I think we have been so grateful to be doing this process with community and incorporating the the priorities of the community I am amazed continually by the enhancements to the design that have come from hearing all different voices um and all the different input the designs that I had in my head are nothing like what we have now and what we have now is just so much better um and we continue to want to learn from the community this was one of
078the the slides that we had at the last Forum we really want to know what additional information the community would need um to make an informed vote uh kind of we'd like to know what the community's willingness is and how much investment the community is willing to make to realize more of our vision and what would the community's priorities be and uh we are always happy to be contacted so our contact information is here sure so this was another slide that was at the community forum and really what this was um showing us is that we are looking at what the potential opportunities are for savings with this project uh structuring the funding in order to maximize the building Aid by using a combination of cash that we have um on hand through the cash
079through the capital reserve along with the financing and then um the building Aid as because a building Aid would be uh based on the full cost of the project including the cash not just the debt so we would be getting building Aid on everything and our debt payment is obviously only on the amount that we're financing looking at Grants and um potentially using that to um support some Environ the environmental sustainable um sustainability um initiatives such as geothermal and solar which we've been working with um CPL on and you will actually see on the consent agenda a contract with CPL to do some initial look into the potential of geothermal and solar and similar to what we did with EV buses uh 75% of the cost of that is being covered by nerta so we
080thought that would was a good use of the additional 25% um again construction efficiencies looking as we mentioned before uh a larger project you kind of get economy a scale uh and then trying to commence as soon as uh practically possible possible to uh reduce the escalation costs and inflation as the future comes upon us so we also included this is another slide that came that we had shown at the community Forum uh looking at the potential um projected cost savings with both Phoenicia and Woodstock uh and what the cost Savings in today's dollars are and the cost Savings in 28 29 assuming a 3% annual escalation and I will tell you these are very conservative numbers because that is my nature is to be very conservative and this kind of shows um savings over
081time and um was brought to my attention thank you very much that this is this is really a look at what budgets would look like the savings is the Delta between the lines so the blue um dotted line was so 2324 that was our budget a little over 62 million had we gone with all three buildings where we would have potentially ended up in 20 20 30 31 the red line is um with Woodstock and Bennett again we started at 62 million we would have ended up at for 23 2030 I can't even say 2030 2031 and then the green um dotted line as you can see again it's not that our budget is going down it is just that the increase is lessened so as we were trying to come up with some ideas
082in terms of how this project could be packaged um our initial thought is that we would do a core proposition and then a supplemental proposition and in trying to put together a potential package these are the dollar figures that um we came up with based on the items that were included in each of these propositions um and so if you look at this Slide the idea being the core proposition is really going to structure be structured around um What would most impact our students so we included um the Bennett addition which includes new classrooms a library expansion office spaces bathrooms a security vestibule a Lobby um the new gymnasium replacing Windows renovating the student entrance um renovating the music rooms that exist uh potentially adding another Music Room uh enhancing the Art Space reconfiguring the
083cafeteria in the kitchen and reconfiguring the Bennett outdoor spaces so Shifting the play space and the parking areas swapping that so the parking area that is up above Bennett would become play space and the play Space would become additional parking and it includes the new Bennett um traffic pattern and drop off Lane um it also would include the high school science classrooms the renovation of the counseling Suite which we also have been um contemplating calling a wellness Suite main office renovation the nurses Suite uh Auditorium and parking by the tennis courts and then for the supplemental proposition we had included the work at our um multi-purpose field so potentially putting in artificial turf upgrading the track which was resurfaced probably over 10 years ago um putting lights enhancing drainage at that's not uh at the
084main field that's at the other fields um putting in a student Commons demolishing the bus garage and renovating the East End parking over here by the bus garage and then including solar and geothermal uh based on contingency with getting grant funding and these are just some of the images uh kind of examples that's not the word I was looking for inspirational images that our Architects have provided for things that once we get into the design phase we could look to um to come up with some ideas for our designs obviously that is uh in the future but it's really nice to look and see what's possible so that we can um once we have an approved project we can meet with our stakeholders meet with our faculty and staff and kind of give them some
085choices and help them dream so I'll let you talk about okay I'll I'll go back to math so what would a $70 million project with $55 million of borrowing look like so understanding first off that the debt payment would not be projected to begin until 20 29 2030 so we have a we have a lot of years to save money so this can all change so but just again conservatively because I always try to be conservative um an estimated annual Bond payment for a $70 million project of which 55 million is borrowing would be um probably around 4.1 million the estimated building Aid between 1.2 million I'm sorry between 940,000 and 1.2 million again because it's dependent on how much of the project is aidable so I want to make sure I give you a
086a lower range and you know kind of a higher range which would leave us with between 2.8 and 3.1 million of a local share but if we take out what the 750,000 that we are saying that we um budget for small projects that may no May no longer be necessary and also subtract the minimum that we thought Consolidated savings would project and this is just that Woodstock savings from the previous page we are looking at an annual payment of between $637,000 and $947,000 a year which represents roughly 1 to 1.5% of our current budget and then as I mentioned in our uh in the budget presentation we are currently paying $611,000 for Bose's debt and that debt will end prior to any start of a bond payment for this project so with 55 5 $
08755 million impossible taxpayer share we would spread it out over uh 20 years the length of the debt so the potential tax impact would likely be between $25 and $35 per year per $100 $100,000 of assessed property value over the life of the debt so for the average $400,000 home it would be roughly between1 and $140 per year yes so um I know looking at us you're like the numbers don't seem to quite add up it doesn't seem like it's a lot of money I think the thing that people especially in this District tend to forget is how large a taxable entity onour is we may only have a thousand students but we have $6 billion dollars of taxable property and I'm not supposed to say this out loud so okay I'll say it anyhow
088New York City's picking up the biggest piece of this um so again we are very lucky because of that and that again is one of the reasons why we are considered a wealthy district and one of the reasons why our building Aid is 31% so as we mentioned before we we love questions any comments anybody has we are all available our doors are open our emails are there um yeah so is there any other questions Jesse Lynch thank you very much so helpful um I just a question about the supplemental proposition the way it's articulated um I just want to be clear that both the track and the bus garage are past their useful life you've said in other presentations so would those what would happen for example if we took some of those if
089we started to take take these different components apart um what would what would happen to some of these other ISS some of these other um projects if they if it did not pass uh and we needed to take out you know obviously make sure that the track is safe for students to use and so if we need to just resurface the track we could do that we could likely do that in our anual budget our own budget okay but that will not get us the turf in the middle it will not get us lights it will not get us um some of the enhancements that we were looking for understood understood in terms of the bus garage y we have minimal maintenance that we're doing right now I mean we have we have maintenance we
090have a mechanic I don't want to understate understate that with our vehicles that we have now um it continues to serve its purpose we would be better off without it if if it's in a proposition and the voters don't approve it then we continue on as we have it will not serve electric buses but we don't have space for electric buses and that's kind of up in the air right now there's a lot of talk that that may be pushed out considerably um the state is is realizing that the timetable that they've put in place is not realistic right and the and also the the new traffic patterns that were proposed in the visioning exercises would also not be feasible as a result cor right yeah okay and the other thing I just wanted to
091mention is that this um multi-purpose field um potentially also has savings um for us over the long term I'm wondering if it's possible to even consider how we would articulate that but as I understand it you know there's um time saved with staff who are lining fields who are organizing you know and arranging different PE times to make sure kids can get outside and still be you know fields are available for for use from the athletic sports afterwards there's a lot that goes into the current maintenance of our field versus what we potentially could save in both efficiencies and other things with a multi-purpose field there's a lot of equity that also comes with that across multiple Sports so I think about um you know the benefits of some of these things and how we
092might be able to articulate them to a community um who's thinking more about nuts and bolts understandably and maybe not seeing some of the savings that are also part of this and and obviously some of the much needed upgrades that are part of the you know supplemental proposition you are absolutely correct it will be um much more available for use because we won't have to keep classes off of it keep kids off it so that we can paint the lines for that night or mow or recede or there are a lot of um there's a a lot of manual labor that goes into maintaining that field and I'm I'm always very appreciative of our um facility staff who takes care of it but it's a lot you're absolutely correct okay and in additionally also just
093wondering if there's a potential to somehow project out the savings with solar and and geothermal as well I'm just thinking about well I think part of that is going to be um hopefully with the analysis that CPL will be doing for for us I don't know if that will be available I'm not sure what the time frame is for that to be available but um that is part of the the work that they're going to be doing and you know mostly funded with a niera grant and in terms of the packaging of the propositions this is what we have come up with but we have these meetings we have this meeting we have the second meeting in February we had the first meeting in March to continue to discuss and think and refine this you
094know this is this is not a complete uh and final package this is a discussion item of course thank you trusty goodr so I just want to say uh to superintendent McLaren assistant superintendent lir uh assistant superintendent Laughin and all the other administrators I realize the amount of work that's going into this slide deck and the thought that must have gone in uh if when I first read it I said you're putting everything together but then after I read through it I said that makes sense so I I really appreciate the the work that everybody's put into this so I do have a couple questions um just to clarify um the projected Consolidated savings I guess that's on page seven that's not in total that's annual correct yes just to clarify that so and um
095you're going to be as I said in the bottom you're going to be committed to the class sizes that are you know so that's we're not increasing class sizes and you don't want them too small either that's correct right so they want to you want to rightsize them so and that that that is an excellent some point trusty um goodish because one of the one of the issues that we have had over the years and we continue to have is as we look at our income in kindergarteners often times one building has many more incoming than the other and so we have to shift the line between the buildings every year to try and balance that and that creates additional expenses in transportation because we're constantly shifting the bus runs back and forth and having
096bus runs go further into certain neighborhoods and we try to do it thoughtfully so that it's not very halfhazard but it's hard to do that I mean worst case scenari you could have a a one grade level that requires six classrooms and that would be worst case it could happen or the other worst case scenario you you have a grade level only has two right so and you have to be able to handle that situation correct so um um the other um the on page on the draft initial project budget details on page 10 so the right box there middle school high school work do you have any idea what percentage that is uh I don't off the top of my head but that's a great question that we can add okay yeah I was
097just curious you know what that what that might look like so um I think U question about the solar and the geothermal was already asked there so I think that was all I had I think of something else I'll raise my hand thanks great thank you trusty kutson and then trusty Jerome yeah um just a couple of questions one is um on page seven you you you projected a three% annual escalation and transportation costs but I do remember hearing that from last year to this year our per best costs went up 10% right so I'm just wondering if you if you have any idea idea what the actual say over the last five years or so um escalation year-over-year for transportation has been um off the top of my head I don't know but what
098I can tell you is that we generally have a fiveyear contract so for five years we know what it is so for five years we know it's actually it's 3.25% it that's built into the contract but again every time we have a new contract it kind of jumps up and then we get five years but then again it also depends on the runs because we only pay per run so each run has its dollar amount if we have 10 runs this year we only have eight runs next year obviously it'll go it'll go up by eight runs at 3.25% not 10 runs at 3.25% so that's why gets a little tricky and is is this is this um 3% projection factoring in any EV like no no at all so potentially if we have to
099start acquiring EVS that the cost run could go up even more could go yes as every school district in New York state would then face okay and sorry I have one other question I just wanted to reiterate when when looking at this slide uh Miss lir and I both feel very strongly that we need to be as conservative as possible it is likely that we will save considerably more than that but we don't want to put something out there that is U that we don't feel comfortable uh will actually happen with much certainty and my other question was and this is a little bit more complicated one but it's on about the about the I think the graph on page eight is key uh for um understanding sort of um you know the the the
100Ben the rationalizations and the benefits behind this project and um I want to make a characterization and I want you to correct me if I'm wrong but is it fair to say that over the last 15 20 years or so that this district has been basically doing improvements on the the buildings as they are needed peace meal yes and we when was the last time the district did a big Capital project 990s late 90s late 90s 2003 sorry okay so 20 years ago so the green line which is invisions this project happening correct also includes a lot of improvements to to the the student experience whatever and my what I think I I don't understand and I would love to understand the balloon blue line and the red line do those Encompass um the status
101quo sort of approach that we've been taking yes or does it so so that is no improvements in those building that's no major improvements that's no major improvements in those buildings that's just so if we had continued just sort of um keeping the the three old buildings maintained and you making small improvements here and there then your your projection is that the annual budget would have approached 80 million by 2030 and same thing for uh if uh the middle line with two buildings MH okay all right thank you just an observation and I'd love for it to be thought about um in upcoming presentations but as I look at this first student first sta forward fiscally responsible with Community um I see that most of the information and this is about fiscally responsible and the
102subjectivity involved with the student first piece I feel like that hasn't really been explored as much as I would like to I'd like to hear about it more we have have a lot of information how it's um operationally efficient um so I guess that's a request um to look at again when we look at disrupting the educational experience the fact that Woodstock is really well attended doing well you know I'd like that piece looked out a little bit more or I have questions around that piece um and then just the way that it's chunked out you know uh Tristy Goodridge I had the same question like how are we chunking out these um pieces when we looked at the core proposition versus the supplemental proposition we've got 155 around the supplemental proposition the core proposition
103is 54 and although it's explain that that won't be a big impact you know I don't like to see my taxes go up but I would do it for our district but how does it break down between what's Bennett and what's middle school high school because we want to optimize ontora and I want to understand what is going into the the yeah how that breaks down um is it just about the elementary schools or how is that really affecting the middle school high school so I would love to see that um that number and then to your question trusty kitsen about the you know we see these these lines um and the the uh we look at the the one building the difference between the two- building solution and the one building solution as a
104difference being you know something that isn't as dramatic as the three building solution but is we were you were saying that that includes no capital none of the improvements that we see on that page with the propositions um but is that just how the propositions are chunked out right now or could there be a a two building solution that did see some campus improvements as well or have we just not decided that in terms of how the propositions are or being organized well a two building proposition you mean keeping with both Woodstock and vett would make that red line even higher because that does not include any any Capital Project work any major Capital project but we would have that sustain there would be a more um Capital project there would be more long lasting
105sustainable improvements to the district yeah but it's not Incorporated in that line okay so it would change the trajectory of that line okay um yeah I think it's just basically about I'm just saying about how it's chunked out that's where I have most of my questions right um yeah but thank you other questions uh trusty Mitchell Morell um just to clarify maybe what truste Jerome is saying I think it can be very confusing for Woodstock voters to have to choose between like improving the middle school high school where they'll end up and or they see it as a choice and closing Woodstock and it's like looking at this it's just I think when I saw it I felt like the amount were saving was more negligible than I thought it would be um especially when
106you're talking about you know a town school closing I in my opinion it will drive down enrollment as people send their kids to private school more and it's just a harder sell than I even thought it would be so I guess like what would you say to a Woodstock voter who's like why do I have to choose between these things um actually I don't believe that it is a choice between these things depending on our enrollment we may end up up at a central campus regardless so this allows us to thoughtfully prepare for that and make this campus the best experience it could be for all of our students um if we end up in a place with enrollment and budgetary constraints where we have to come to a central campus because we can't afford
107to maintain more than one campus we won't have prepared and then I feel like we would not have honored our students trusty Jerome and then trusty Goodrich just a quick comment though but we did just finish that conversation about what a wealthy District we are right so um I just want to again it's confusing to hear like how we do have so much money and yet we are in this precarious position so so let me clarify when I say we are a wealthy District when we say we are a wealthy District we're not referring to our bank account as onto our Central School District we're referring to the ability of our district to pay school taxes we are not allowed to necessarily raise school taxes like we used to uh when I first entered this
108profession we could Levy whatever we needed if we needed a 10% School tax levy then we could Levy that and there was no 2% tax levy limit in place um so when we say we're a wealthy District that is literally just the measure that the state puts on us in terms of the ability to pay taxes so just to build on trusty knudson's uh questions there so let's say uh we needed a new roof or had to replace one of our boilers in Woodstock uh that's not included in that savings no that is not included in okay that could happen um the what could a bond pavement look like uh slide 13 I guess it was uh so is that based on a bond or 10 years 15 years 20 years it's a 20y year
109bond I'm sorry 20 year 20y year bond 20 year bond okay thank you any other questions or comments Jesse kitson I just want to make one more comment that I hope this is very numbers focused which is understandable I hope we have some time in upcoming meetings to flesh out more in in full the um educational equities that are involved here and benefits and um you know teaching the way this affects teaching and the the kids experience because it isn't all just about numbers it is you know and I and I do believe the student first is is a big part of this but I think it would be great if we could just explicate that for the public a little more in in in this setting at some point over the next few weeks
110and just really focus on that part of it I think it would be a great idea to have um assistant superintendent Allison and assistant superintendent Laughin present um you know because the benefits to all students um are many and uh and this benefit to students with special needs are as well and I think it would be important to to hear those detailed absolutely I'm sure they would love to make an appearance uh maybe even on February 18th I'm sure they would thank you sure just a specific question in regards to bus runs so when we do start busing from the most densely populate portion of the district District or if we do start busing from that Woodstock area here the elementary school there there would be two sets of bus runs right one for the
111elementary school correct which would be earlier and then another set of bus runs high schools first oh I mean rather High School Middle School first and then and Elementary okay okay um but they're they're on separate buses coming at different times okay and and we anticipate that that will continue that was a question that was raised at The Forum you might remember um but we have um we understand that although some people think because we would have all the students here they would all be on one bus run but when you actually try to operationalize that structure it doesn't work because right now with the two bus runs it actually creates a full-time job for a bus driver and if we had one bus run for the entire campus that would make it a part-time
112job job for a bus driver and we would need twice as many and I don't want to try and fill those positions because they're not going to want to do that job it wouldn't be it wouldn't be viable but just to add on that point I think it was you know an important conversation that the district had around later start times which was a different discussion obviously I take your point about um bus drivers but I just think we need to include that conversation as well because there's I know interest from some and changing the start times and there was a lot of good analysis that's still available on the websites about the pros and cons to that and particularly some of the limitations I as I recall and the um high school schedules and
113such to be able to allow our um student athletes to participate in sports and other things there's just broader limitations in terms of and I'm obviously not doing it justice but I just want to make sure that we're referencing a broader conversation and not so much just about the employment of our bus drivers which is equally you know it needs to be taken into consideration absolutely my point was not actually the employment of bus drivers it was our ability to get kids to school but your point is absolutely accurate and aside from Sports because I don't think that discussion should necessarily be driven entirely by Sports as you saw um earlier we have 87 students participating in Bose programs if our schedule doesn't align with our neighboring districts our students will suffer by not having
114access to as many bosis programs as they have among other things I mean it's obviously it's a much larger conversation for scheduling but those are some very high uh very important things to consider one of the other um big topics that came up around later start times was uh the most recent time that we discussed it as a board was the um inability for parents to find child care in the morning and if younger children were going to school earlier it was going to or later it was going to impact um parents ability to get to work uh and find child care which is very very hard to find out here anything else all right great thank you so much item 4.01 acceptance of minutes the Board of Education hereby accepts the minutes of the
115January 14th meeting May I have a first trusty Jerome second trusty Goodrich any questions or comments trusty kutson I trusty Jerome I trusty m Morel hi trusty Goodrich hi trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I okay great that's unanimous thank you on to superintendent district news although I feel like I've already spoken enough this evening um so I'll start with weather I'm happy to report we did not utilize any snow days in the month of January I can't even imagine that that is a true statement but unfortunately February looks to be a different situation the forecast for Thursday of this week is looking uh pretty dismal and the forecast for Wednesday of next week although it's still early is also looking fairly Bleak uh we do have five snow days left as of right now though
116so uh I'm very hopeful that we can make it through February and March with that uh Bank of snow days I want to give out many thanks to all who attended Community night on January 17th the booster club in conjunction with our athletic director and her staff and does of other people um of course Leah Smith in the athletic office is always a crucial part of any of those plans uh everyone really collaborated incredibly well together and uh put on an amazing event that was really highly attended by students families and community members and I think everyone um greatly enjoyed it there was there was really good food there too um we do have an upcoming Community Forum uh our next forum uh and our last currently scheduled forum is February 25th um and referencing
117my earlier comments about the weather we do have a pre-planned snow date of February 27th in case in Clement weather happens um we had another planning meeting today with our Architects and our construction managers we're really looking forward to continuing our community conversation in addition to our board conversations we are grateful for everyone who has participated in this process and as I said earlier it's really amazing to see how the various discussions have shaped our Concepts and it is definitely a case where putting many people with different skill sets and experiences into the conversation has resulted in a much better outcome than would have uh been possible otherwise a quick plug for the meet greet need event that was going to take place on April 7th uh last year we had the wonderful return of
118this beloved event and I know that the committee has been hard at work to make it even better this year so please put it on your calendars uh and bring your appetite your cash um I wanted to provide a brief update on our Phoenicia campus uh at the end of December the shandaken town supervisor had sent us a written request uh to place a proposition on our ballot to transfer ownership of this phenicia campus to the town my understanding is that this was discussed at the town of shandaken board meeting last night the town Supervisor has let me know that there are some questions about the property and the town board is going to be looking for some addition information which of course we are happy to provide any information they need once we have
119confirmation that the town um is ready to move forward we will place this on our board agenda for discussion and potential action possible action in an upcoming meeting in order to have this process take place and have this appear on the ballot in may we would need to approve it at our board level in March and then it would appear on the ballot to be voted on by all of our voters along with our budget School Board election and whatever propositions um we determine will be put to the voters uh in support of our capital projects as Miss lir had mentioned earlier we were very pleased to receive the governor's budget proposal which included the save harmless provision and a 2% increase in Foundation Aid I'm really hopeful that this means the governor will be
120thoughtful and take time to analyze the recommendations that had been included in the Rockefeller institute's report on Foundation Aid before she makes any drastic changes we were also grateful to hear that the funding freezes from the federal government don't appear to be in place for education at this time not sure how many more caveats I could put in that sentence with both of those indicators we anticipate this year will be a much more typical budget process and not as uncertain and harrowing as last year was at this time our next uh virtual parent Workshop is on Wednesday evening tomorrow night from 6:30 to 8:00 p.m. the top topic being discussed is depression in children and teens uh the link to join this Workshop is currently in a popup on our web page and it's also
121in the calendar on the website and last but not least kindergarten registration for September 2025 is open anyone who has an incoming kindergarten student or who knows a family with an incoming kindergarten student please either register your child or encourage um the family or your acquaintance to register their child registration information can be found on our homepage uh it's been shared on social media and I anticipate that it will be in the next newsletter that goes out to our entire community so please get the word out we are welcoming incoming kindergarteners thank you any questions for superintendent okay great thank you uh okay okay Board District news any board trustees have news for the district trusty canson this is just a quickie but the uh the booster club has afforded me the honor of of
122uh helping out with their uh trivia Bowl which has been set for March 5th from 3 to 5 I think it's going to be in the cafeteria here it's going to be a lot of fun competition answering trivia questions there's going to be teams we're hoping to get some faculty captains uh and uh have some really fun um going on on the afternoon of Wednesday March 5th I will mention this again at the next meeting but if you're a trivia head uh get your team together there the I think the booster club's going to put out registration for teams in the next few days pay attention and uh we should have a lot of fun thanks excellent sounds exciting and fun trusty Mitchell Morell uh there was the Winter concert at Woodstock and it was
123like so packed standing room only because this year actually for the first time it's third and fourth and I think it used to start in fourth so it's just so cute they played all sorts of songs it was orchestra band and chorus and also I think that same week was Bingo night which is also one of my favorite events and it was they the best prizes and my kids had so much fun great thank you anything else I'll just say that um trustee Rondo and superintendent McLaren and who else was at oh and uh former trustee story who is now our Bose's representative attended the ster School Board Association um legislate uh meet with the legislators um um event last week um it was very well attended and there was a very Lively conversation uh
124the uh uh legislators kind of introduced themselves and talked a little bit about their areas uh their Geographic areas and then also their uh their interests and took a lot of questions and uh Lively debate back and forth with um mostly superintendant uh but it was it was very interesting um and I just want to also give a shout out to uh the booster club and and all the folks that made Community night uh such a huge success it was really great anything else okay our student representative Olivia good evening um so a little update from the high school um so SEC the second quarter has just recently ended um along with midterm and region exams um as mentioned before this year's Community night was held on January 17th um at the community night winter
125athletes were recognized for their successful Seasons um we would like to thank the booster club for organizing such a wonderful event for the community in addition to sports entour students middle and high school travel to participate in the all count music festival some up upcoming events include the pancake breakfast organized by Beller bash which will be held this weekend and lastly this week is school counselor's week we would like to thank our school counselors for all their dedication and hard work thank you thank you on to acknowledgement of public be heard item 8.01 the board will acknowledge uh public comments that were made at our last meeting and we uh appreciate Mark Will's comments is anyone signed up to speak tonight okay okay the board appreciates hearing from the public including students on any agenda
126or non-agenda item please understand that by our adopted par Elementary procedure the board can't can't engage in discussion or answer questions during public be heard please know that we hear you and take all of your comments and into consideration the board does reserve the right to correct any inaccuracies or misinformation during public be heard please limit your comments to three minutes be civil and do not name any particular individuals or promote any commercial Ventures or products people wishing to express individual student or Personnel concerns can bring them to the superintendent's attention in private Jillian KH Ura it is good evening as you all know there's a new Administration in the White House the recent we in recent weeks there has been certain executive orders that have been signed that's slash Dei and Title 9 my
127questions are what plans are you making to continue these policies oh geez here we go to continue these policies and to protect the school Community will this affect the partnership with Morningside I understand that there was a vote to revamp the Dei policy but what does that look like recently Kingston and Red Hook School District issued statements further clarifying their stance on Dei on what they will and won't do to keep their immigrant and lgbtqia population safe this District cannot be silent on this silence gives permission for terrible things to happen I'm here as a mother a wife a sister daughter friend and Community member I would never say I know how these two groups feel because I don't I'm not ignorant however I am married to an IM immigrant and I have family members
128who are gay these groups of people are not here speaking up because they're terrified we are in precarious times it is my sincere hope that this board and administration takes a much stronger stance on these issues thank you I just wanted to um clarify and confirm for you that following the meeting this evening there's already a family letter ready to um go out tomorrow morning it's been drafted and translated already so it will be going out thank you for your comments Cara introduce yourself and I'll put your name on the list hello everybody Cara kivis just here as a representative of the Woodstock PTA and I wanted to let the board and administration know of some upcoming events um we have our sweetheart breakfast Friday the 14th and Bennett is actually doing a similar thing
129which I think is really cool so similar breakfast but both be having it at our respective schools um February 28th we're having a spaghetti dinner and the fourth graders are going to be helping serve um and then saving the date for our talent show Friday March 21st so open to the public anyone's welcome and open invitation too for the spaghetti dinner and uh sweetheart breakfast thank you thank you any other speakers tonight okay great thank you so much on to item 10.01 discussion and possible action uh the board will consider adopting a resolution which I will read whereas every school AG student regardless of immigration status this has the right to access of free public education grades kindergarten through 12 in accordance with article 11 of the New York state constitution and the antora Central
130School District hereen after the district supports that right and whereas the district has a legal responsibility to ensure that all schoolage children who reside within its boundaries regardless of immigration status and others as required by law have the opportunity to attend school in the district and whereas though uh through its policies and practices the district has made a commitment to a quality education for all students which includes a safe and stable learning environment means of transportation to and from uh School sites the preservation of classroom hours for educational instruction and the require reement of School attendance and whereas educational Personnel are often the primary source of support resources and information to assist students and student learning which includes their social and emotional health and whereas the district is committed to complying with existing state and
131federal law therefore be it resolved that consistent with New York State education department SED regulations and guidance the district when registering students will not ask questions or request information that may reveal the students immigration status and be it further resolved that any District staff or faculty member that receives a request from the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement office ice or any other Federal immigration Authority regarding a student or students will take no action and will immediately forward such request to the building principal who will then consult the superintendent who will forward the district's attorne forward to the district's attorney for legal advice and be it further resolved that the district will not allow law enforcement to interview interrogate or remove a student from school property except as consistent with the applic applicable law and board
132policy and be it further resolved that the district will comply with the federal family education and Privacy Act furpa and Regard in with regard to the release of student information to any immigration authorities and will consult with the district's attorneys with regard to the compliance iance with furpa and be it further resolved that the district is committed to addressing incidents of immigration related harassment bullying and discrimination pursuant to the dignity for all students act Dasa may I have a first trusty Rondo second trusty Lynch any comments trusty canson I trusty Jerome I trusty Mitchell Morell I trusty goodr I most definitely trusty Lynch hi trusty Rondo hi that's unanimous thank you we'll take a five minute break e e e all right welcome back everyone on to our consent agenda the board hereby approves items
133number 12.02 through 12.1 may I have a first trusty Goodrich second trusty Jerome any questions or comments trusty kudon yes I just want to say that with the help of an experienced Mentor I have reviewed schedule U and everything appears to be in order great thank you any other questions are com comments all right we'll vote trusty kutson hi trusty Jerome I trusty Mitchell moral I trusty goodr I trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I that's unanimous thank you lost okay I just wanted to say as part of the um I know it's it's past the discussion stage but as part of the consent agenda we had some generous donations and I just want to thank everyone who made those contributions some of them were to benefit the meat greet and eat and it was nice
134to see that all right on to item 13.01 um the Board of Education hereby approves items number 13 02 through 13.07 which are independent contract retainers and contracts may have a first trusty Jerome second trusty Rondo any questions or comments all right we'll vote trusty Canon I trusty Jerome I trusty Mitchell moral I trusty Goodrich I trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I thank you item 14.01 second reading uh and Adoption of policy 1322 ex officio student member of the Board of Education the board hereby adopts policy 1322 as written may I have a first trusty Jerome second trusty Rondo any questions or comments all right trusty kutson I trusty Jerome I trusty Mitchell Morell I trusty goodr I trusty Lynch hi trusty Rondo I great that's unanimous thank you um on to committee reports committees
135that have met you right um let let's start with facilities and then we'll and then we'll come back to policy and Communications all right the uh facilities committee uh meeting was on February 16th meeting was attended by uh 12 members a lot of uh active discussion uh we discussed uh the summer 2025 renovation um 3A construction which is um for the middle school high school 16 middle school high school rooms and middle school gym um summer 202 renovation of uh 3B middle school high school security vestibule lunch Pavilion tennis court parking lot and the SD approved our middle school high school elevator upgrade and maintenance of a new electric uh generator that was a Lely discussion so it seems we have a new generator there's a somebody pointed out there's a different process we need
136to uh uh maintain that so I'm not going to get into the technicals um and we talked about optimizing Anora plans which uh include you know an outside uh walk around to try to figure out you know so we could visually see where the extension of the building was going to be that was a rather cold night um I left early because I had a dinner appointment but actually I left because it was too cold so that's all I have thank you I just have a question is the maintenance of the generator something that we do ourselves or do we have a special company that comes in and does that no it was more the you know it turns on automatically every week okay and we need to put it under load a heavier load
137than because the generator was bigger than the load for the building so we but to test that uh to to actually m maintain that we have to have a I think a truck come in and put a heavier load on it so the uh soot doesn't build up inside the diesel motor something like that I'm not an expert at this so any other facilities committee folks want to say anything about that about anything Jesse Canon just that the next facilities Comm meting is uh uh I believe February 20th at Woodstock school thank you um policy committee sure um we are working on our Dei policy and we are combining it with one we really liked from Highland where they actually hired I believe a consultant for two years so it's extremely thorough it has a
138glossery it's really impressive and we're kind of combining it with the nisba one and still figuring it out which one we're going to use more but both are excellent and I mean either one would be great but I think we're going to pick and choose our favorite parts from each right and we also um while we were working on that we uh we also asked superintendent to print out copies of the Dei andb resolution and so that we could really kind of match the policy to the resolution um and as we incorporate both of those good polic policies that we were looking at communications thank you um you'll see on your um tables there's a copy of the uh Communications plan thank you for making those copies um and um you'll see many of your
139comments were reflected in it um since we've uh shared it last uh late fall early December I think or late November um but this is the finalized plan so um do take a minute to review it I think you'll find it very exciting and a huge um you know Leap Forward from where we've been in terms of um Our intention to create a transparent and um uh two-way communication plan for the district um we also spent some time just talking through um you know the content for upcoming newsletters and so you'll be seeing drafts and again appreciate quick responses as we try to get those out in a timely fashion um one thing one other thing that we discussed was the um I can't remember what we were calling it but the the kind of
140the planning calendar for the most important events in the district and um our consultant Holly Brooker is is putting together a uh a spreadsheet similar to the one that um our district clerk has made but it's got more targeted um more the more important um activities that go on in the district like the big concerts um Community night uh meet greet and eat things like that that that um we really and and at least one um event that's happening in each of our townships like Olive day the Hurley Heritage day um we're not sure what the shandaken day is called but there is one and um I think we landed on the Woodstock Library Fair as times that we really want trustees to commit to being like at the table and we'll and we'll do
141it sort of like we did for Olive day uh last year where we kind of broke it down by hours so that you know you're not there the whole day um and you know we'll ask people to sign up but when H Holly Gets that to us we'll we'll distribute it to everyone or share it with everyone um want to talk about leg action oh what oh sorry Caroline no go ahead are you yeah go ahead I I was going to mention just one other thing which was sort of exciting and it's an opportunity to plug our digital communication the board beef we're using a new um tool s'more I'm not sure anyways it allows us to um add a little color a little life to our community Communications which I love um and the
142engagement was really good we were able to see and track engagement and just want to encourage everybody to sign up for the U monthly uh uh e email newsletter that kind of just breaks down what's going on in the district um it's really has great information it's not it's not a heavy read and it doesn't overwhelm you inbox we send it once a month so um where can they where is the easiest place un optimizing antora there should be a link to our to our board re yeah that was really great too thank you go ahead and on our main web page on the board page there's uh a link to board briefs and the sign up is included in those each one of the briefs as well oh go ahead we were really busy
143um I also just want to tell everybody that um we did schedule a meeting with administrators to review the potential of um the parents Square app and the and any potential costs that might be incurred um so we would will'll report back out on that but wanted to make sure um the T this the board knew that we were including building principles and others who would have to be involved and making something like that happen and be utilized so just wanted folks to know where that was Sarah could you just tell us in you know 10 words or so I don't want to put you on the spot like what is the parent Square app um this is a communication tool first and foremost um but maybe I could ask um Miss Allison to explain
144it because her child School uses it so she would have firsthand information before the sure so the parent Square app is an app that can be right on your mobile device and it allows you to directly message your students um providers teachers related service providers um to receive what we would consider like shout points um messages to receive you know things like benchmarking like through your NWA testing or any school events so you immediately it comes through on the app you also get it texted a text message as well as an email alert um and it is um allows you to have confidential and private correspondences to like comments to um for a teacher to send a a classwide reminder or um a building wide reminder for uh a parent but to something uh very
145easy and accessible to use happy to for you guys to take a look at my parents square if you'd like you can even read my ridiculous messages thank you thank you so much trusty Rondo sure I'll talk to legislative action so this Friday we have a training through nisba for the virtual Capital conference it's all day it preps us for next week being Lobby day on the 11th which is Wednesday uh trusty bishop and I will be attending we be meeting with um Senator hinchi and Senator oberbach are other representatives and assembly member saraha and assembly member mayor um or the representatives again we're planning uh trusty Bishop has so kindly offered to lead the group of ourselves and also other local trustees from the county and uh what we'll be focusing on are the
146EV bus mandates and the Assurance of continued state and federal funding for education including Title One and title two and the extension of the waiver allowing retirees earning over $35,000 annually given the current Nationwide teacher shortage and increasing the cap on Bose superintendent salaries so we will go and we will bring back as much information as we possibly can great thank you oh sure so you're going to discuss the EV buses uh I know we have had one of our resolutions that we sent in was to provide a hybrid as an alternative are we going to discuss that or awesome great thank you I'm so sorry trusty Rondo can you just repeat yourself I didn't hear the third thing you said about funding extension of the waiver allowing retirees to earn over $35,000 annually given
147the current Nationwide teacher shortage truste kutson yeah I just wanted to put in a pitch um when you're talking about EV buses I think part and parcel with EV buses is in electric infrastructure in our County and Central Hudson and uh I I I would be very interested in knowing the state of play between the government and Central Hudson because I know that there's friction and advocacy happening there but uh I think that will impact the EV buus future uh significantly in this County thank you any other committee type reporting okay we'll move on to Old business is there any old business I was hoping to discuss our uh chapter one reading in uh the governance core 2.0 and um I think I told you when we handed the books out that I had I
148had also purchased a copy of the like the implementation book or or workbook but um for this part and I believe probably for all for all the chapters um the activities are more um um I think beneficial to like if you were doing a presentation on the book and really leading a large group but one of the activities that I thought was interesting was uh just to kind of discuss a quote or a passage that um that you were drawn to or that was meaningful to you so I would just open that up if anyone is interested in commenting and you know no pressure oh trusty kidson um so um I used to uh volunteer in a program in in New York City called book talk so I was I've LED book discussion groups for
149fifth and sixth graders and one of the um we used to do like short stories was the first semester usually and the standard piece of advice was since it's a short story read it twice before you come to discuss it and um so I I did that but I'm also just going to make that General I'm going to put on my book talk leader hat and recommend to my fellow trustees that when we're going over these chapters read them twice because I definitely got more out of it the second time I read it uh I just wanted to say that the phrase that kept jumping out at me from this chapter is moral imperative um and I think that's really the the um sort of the organizing principle of of what these authors say good
150governance is based on and I think it's very easy um in positions like we have to get caught up in the um minutia and details and react to situations um and um not often as we should take time to reflect on what our moral imperatives are um in this job and um so I I found that really useful just to to the advice to sort of Step Back From the the day-to-day and the you know the and really think about what it is we're trying to do here was that a hand truste Jerome oh okay yeah I didn't bring my copy but that would be the piece that stood out and I was also um uh ha or glad to think that the members of this board the members of our Administration I think that
151we work well as a cohesive unit even with differences in opinion I think that our moral imperative is is aligned um you know just thinking about you reading the uh Dei policy the tonight or the immigration piece you know different people on this board we've all talked about how important this is we're all in alignment um I think that in the majority of cases we're in alignment so that was that's nice to know for our district trusty Mitchell Morell so forgot my copy but I um highlighted a lot of things and these are just like General things I thought were interesting not necessarily in regard to us but one was that in Six States I think it said you have to run with a party and I'm like thank God we didn't have to run
152with the party like that would have just complicated things so deeply but it also shows you that you know the party doesn't say at all sometimes so I just was grateful for that and I can't believe that's a thing anywhere and also just that like um if you think of it as a graph like the closer you get to May the more political it can become and then like the farther you are you know it like politics almost fade away completely um so I just thought that was interesting to thank you trusty Rondo I agree with you trusty M moral when I read the part about partisanship I was no I was shocked I mean I I had to like really put the book down for a second and and and Brea you had to
153call your husband immediately so the thing that I I found a lot of things very I tuned into so much of this chapter and part of one of the statements around the governance Corp and what it said is it's a force for raising the bar and closing the gap of learning for all students in the district not just as an aspiration but as a reality and I think we all work really hard including our administrators and the rest of our faculty each and every day sometimes things get in the way but it's always we're always looking ahead and we're always putting students first so I'm very very proud of that thank you I loved that um that the authors were separating politics from governance and uh and then also how they described the the you
154know the in in very brief detail in this first chapter the um the role of the board versus the role of the administrators and and you know what we each do and another thing that I I was found a little um I don't know I was glad to see it in here um is that and it it really is a very different um um look at a board trustee role or the school board role as a group of seven that um that we should um really interact more with staff and that we should interact more with administrators whereas I think with the training as I recall uh my mandated board training uh really kind of um advised against that almost it's really the board is the board and you know we we don't mix with
155uh you know uh with the administration or the uh or the staff and the faculty and I and the students I mean like you know that's why we're here and so I was really excited to see uh that part of it and um yeah I'm looking forward to reading more of it trusty Lynch did I see your hand I'm sorry no but I'm happy to to comment um unless I'm jumping in the queue okay I was just GNA pick up on um actually what um trusty cansen was saying but there was a passage on page 26 um um but it said um the moral imperative deep focus constructive monitoring and corresponding action are an Unstoppable combination and I started that because I I have to say that I feel like in the three years that
156I've been uh a trustee I feel like we've taken one of those four things um you know seriously at different you know different times and now in my at least this year I feel like we're we've Now sort of done all of those things um but the the moral imperative I think has always you know been there but this idea of of deep focus that that that combined with deep focus constructive monitoring and corresponding action um at one time or another I feel like we've um been able to again just sort of you know deepen those layers so to speak um and I I've just noticed um you know how well uh um this particular year this this board has been able to um work together as you said as well trust each from great
157thank than you superintendent McLaren U similarly on page 26 I had I had focused on just the the simple phrase that the moral imperative embodies an emotional and empirical commitment that all students can and will learn I just feel like that really does guide everything that we do but I was struck by on page 21 the guidelines for serving on the board because I feel like this board has really um sort of set the bar for following these guidelines and I think that this board has been very welcoming when uh new trustee has joined and and has really accepted everyone um regardless of um whatever their particular viewpoints are on any particular issue and really been committed to working together and respecting and you know number two listening empathetically um and remaining committed to deep
158learning and to understanding in depth the core issues of a moral imperative and I think this word really has also stayed true to the Norms of the board and I think the Norms of this antor school board have been in place for a really long time but I think they are really really working and I'm really impressed with with the teamwork and the commitment of the board as a whole thank you I have to say I in reading that and actually especially those guidelines for serving on the board I felt very very proud of our board very proud um you know it hasn't been an easy year uh we're discussing difficult topics when we continue to with um I think respect and Grace and I and I think that says a lot about all everyone
159who's sitting at this table really all of us Jesse Jerome I just want to say that a lot of the tenor is due to a really great leader so thank you thank you all right anything else trusty kutson lest we be too self- congratulatory I no I I I agree actually I agree with everything everybody's saying but I also want to you know we all need to remind ourselves that these are habits that we need to make a strenuous effort to maintain and to practice every day um and especially over the next few months I think because uh you know things are going to become more uh the the the discussion is going to become more energetic in the community and um and we uh need to remember these points and hold fast to them
160like you know this is time to tie ourselves to the Mast of of our best selves and our best practices as board members um and I I I'm confident we can do it but uh let's let's commit to that yes I pledge um and I I think this is a actually a really good time to be reading this book for us because it'll remind us of that you know as we go through it Tracy goodr it was interesting just sitting here listening to everybody that uh I I agree with everything and U it's I I respect everything that everybody just said you know I respect the board and the administration thank you all right okay um chapter two for the next meeting okay great we'll read it twice okay I'm gonna read it three times
161um any other old business any new business any rfis okay who's GNA move to adjourn trusty Rondo second trusty Mitchell Morel all in favor okay thank you all good night we'll see you on February 18th for