001e e e good evening everyone we are calling the December 17th meeting of the Board of Education to order we have a tobacco policy in place there is no smoking within 100 feet of any school building please rise for the pledge board clerk will you please call roll trusty canson here truste Jerome here trusty Mitchell moral here trusty goodr here truste Hemingway Lynch here trust Rondo here trusty Bishop here thank you thank you our first item on the agenda item 2.01 is our High School principal's welcome good evening and welcome to antora high school I wanted to start off by just expressing how proud I am to be the high school principal can you hear it now yes okay I will start over again I just really want to express how proud I am to
002be the principal of Anora High School I can tell you that I have the absolute best faculty and staff and our students are second to none I'm Blown Away by how many times I hear how great our students are how their behavior is how they've impressed people within the community at other schools sport whether it's sporting events competitions we have a lot to be grateful for and I am extremely proud of Faculty staff and students and very proud to be part of this District because of all of that we are having an absolutely excellent year and that's in spite of the fact that we have thrown so many new initiatives and goals at our at our faculty our staff our students me um and they just keep they just keep excelling over and over and
003over again so what I thought for tonight's presentation I would do is I would try to connect some of the initiatives and some of the goals that we're working on to some of the board goals because you'll see how they really are connect Ed so every initiative that we're working on could really be a presentation in itself because they're really that packed so I'm going to kind of summarize these quickly um and maybe at another meeting I could hit a topic of your interest but for now I just want to kind of Breeze through these and you know any questions I'd be more than happy to take so you know one of the boards one of the boards go goals this year have to do with climate and climate and culture and just like the
004board we're committed to creating a nurturing environment uh we want students to be engaged we want to take a look at students individual paths and interests so we were really grateful that you support all the programs that we're offering all of our courses all of our uh Athletics activities um it's really it's really it's really amazing what we offer related to the climate and culture I'm going to talk a little bit about the P the personal electronic devices and where we are with that I also want to have a little discussion about social emotional learning and that Community Mentor program so let me just start by giving you a little bit of an overview of where we are this year right now the high school currently grades 9 through 12 have 366 stud students in
005addition to all of the courses that we offer that are required our core courses we're also offering 32 electives 16 advanced placement courses eight college level courses and of course there's 20 different career Pathways that a student could choose from if they if they pursue the uh career and tech programs it's amazing 366 students to offer as many courses as we do and it's intentional the way we offer these courses we will rotate courses from year to year we try to work with our counseling department to make sure that students who are in a specific track let's say for college have an opportunity throughout their career to take a course they know the students they report back to us what we should be offering we will add new new electives we'll add new courses uh
006based on student interest the challenge with our courses is that now that we're getting smaller and smaller and still offering the same amount of electives and college classes and such is that now these courses only appear one period in our schedule which makes it very challenging because they often conflict with one another even though we have one of the most uh sophisticated computer schedu in programs that will identify where it's best to place those those courses inevitably some students are not going to be able to get into a course that they want and will have to make a decision it's very tough to hear and it gets very emotional for some students but we do the best that we can to make sure that we're offering these courses as many times as possible throughout the
007students career But ultimately students will need to make a decision this is this is similar to Athletics Athletics we have a combination this year throughout the year we'll be offering a combination of 30 varsity and Junior Varsity Sports again it's 366 students so all these programs are competing for the same students coaches often have to make decisions or make accommodations to allow students to play multiple sports or these programs are not going to exist extracurricular clubs in addition to every everything else that I've just stated we offer 26 opportunities for club sports or other extracurricular activities keep in mind those those activities are occurring after school you have the same students that are going out for a splitting their time between Athletics the clubs and other interest that they have outside of school this is
008not a a new issue for us and we've been working through it over the years I did put up a a slide that kind of shows the high school enrollment over the over the last uh five years um so you can you can see you know how we got to 366 and unfortunately the trajectory doesn't look that great because we are continuing to decline so while we have 366 high school students this year we're also going to be graduating one of the larger 12th grades one of the larger classes that we have and our ninth grade that will be incoming next year will be among the smallest enrollment so with that loss we're going to go from 366 students this year sorry to 330 students next year so those problems are going to be exacerbated
009and we're going and you're going to see a few few more challenges for us and then what I did was just just for your own um knowledge I kind of projected it all the way out to the 2028 29 school year where we'll end up with 314 students grades 9 through 12 and again this isn't to be this isn't to be negative because we are going to continue to be creative we're going to continue to find ways to offer courses and meet students interests but just think it was important for for everyone to have the same understanding of where we are where we're going and what we're doing also in the area of climate and culture uh there's there's a lot uh going on with personal electronic devices and we see this Nationwide uh our
010teachers clearly identified that electronic devices last year were having a significant negative impact on our students it was affecting them in so many different ways from paying attention to navigating social situations to uh creating issues in the social emotional realm uh it it was a constant distraction and again like I said this is a nationwide issue but we're not willing or we weren't willing still not willing to wait for someone to come in and fix the fix the problem and we knew we had to intervene so we made we made the decision as a team that we were going to uh eliminate or not allow any personal electronic equipment to be used this school year uh during the instructional day we knew that we were going to get some push back and quite frankly the
011push back really wasn't as bad as we expected I'm sure I'm sure the board took took some heat over it as well uh certainly I know the superintendent got some emails um but we know it's the right thing to do and sometimes the right thing to do isn't the most popular and isn't isn't the easiest what I can tell you is you will not find one staff member in my building that thinks that this is a bad idea after what they're experiencing now to quote the majority to staff members this this new initiative is a game Cher what does that mean it means students are more attentive in class they're more focused their interpersonal skills are are are growing dramatically they're communicating with one another in the hallway they're not walking around looking at personal
012at their personal devices they're making eye contact they're in the lunchroom having conversations with their peers and as silly as as it sounds or strange as it might sound they're actually playing at lunchtime they're getting involved in games that some of us would say wow I'm surprised that you know a 12th grader would want to play Four Square it's kind of a middle schoolish type of a a game they're also through all these games and all these interactions they're learning how to navigate conflict this is something that that's been lost over the years it is it is difficult it was very difficult to implement and we're now in a really really good spot um when we first started and I I just created a quick slide just to show you in the month of September
013when we first put this into effect our office received 57 referrals for students who are violating the electronic device policy that we had in place in in October there was a drastic reduction to only 23 incidents that were reported and in November 16 so we've gone from 57 non-compliance issues to 16 and so far in December we have a total of two and I'm going to assure you that it's not because people got tired of reporting it the kids are leaving their devices home there's always going to be kids who are going to sneak it into the bathroom and whatever to make that call so be it but the bottom line is it's a dramatic Improvement I'm going to move on to Seal Seal also aligns with the board's goals um you know o over
014the years we've been continuously refining how delivering our seal Services we've we've always focused primarily on our ninth and 10th graders with the thought process being that you know students will come to the high school with those skills because they've hadal circles for for you know all these all these years it it is a big adjustment coming into ninth grade and we we want to support the independence um but the ninth and 10th grade Le grade levels are really where we want to focus our attention and by 11th grade those students should have those skills and be able to have those difficult conversations especially around the controversial materials that are being presented so uh we're we're very happy what it's turned into we've also made this more of a homegrown program so when we were
015learning the program we we utilized outside sources to kind of you know help us learn about how to how to convene a circle how to run run the circle what type of topics how you know what what's the general rules and we learned those practices but over the over the years we said we have to figure out what's important to antora what what is it that we're hearing from our students our community how do we how do we better support our students and and we've done that and I'm going to explain that more in a little bit but we still make we still convene our circles uh at at least once a month we now have approximately 24 staff members who are trained and who are running circles they're facilitating the groups and at the
016ninth and 10th grade level each there's about 10 to 12 groups at each at each grade level this year we also added seal coordinators um oural coordinators we have we have a school social worker Megan Shanker is one of the coordinators and a high school science teacher Brianna funk is also a seal coordinator and since I just said her name I'm going to put her on this on the spot not really she prepared but I'm GNA ask her to talk about a couple of slides um so our circles have been going really well uh over the past year and a half now we've taken a lot of feedback from our nth and our 10th graders last year we took a lot of feedback from the ninth grade group that was finishing and we asked them
017what topics they were struggling with uh they came up with specific topics like their study habits and life skills and hygiene uh and bullying and things like that that they were struggling with coming from eighth grade to nth grade so because of that we were able to come up with a goal for the ninth grade group and it is cooperative team building to become better citizens of the antor community and with that we've decided for them to make a game show that they're going to end up running for the eighth grade circles specifically around those topics that they have already said are issues for them transitioning from that eighth grade to the ninth grade um so they're going to end up facilitating a game during one of theal circles for eth grade and it's going
018to help them engage in team building role assignment and how to work constructively with their peers for our 10th grade group last year was our first year that we did a carnival we got a lot of really positive feedback from our students they absolutely love being able to play the different games that the 10th graders had designed so we are keeping in that goal with the active leaders in creating a culture of inclusion our 10th graders are again going to design carnival games for the ninth graders to play uh they get a little bit more wiggle room where they get to pick a lot of their topics um some of the topics that have already been identified are bullying and social media pressure risk reduction conflict resolution and Teen Mental Health First Aid so a
019lot of these games are are designed completely by the students and then they're run by the students for our ninth graders at oural carnival that will be in May and then sorry this year we have a youth Advisory Board um that's actually made up of some 11th and 12th graders and they've been able to apply for it they get community service hours and they've started guiding uh Megan and myself into different ice breakers that they really liked when they went through theal program and how to really make it a whole for the entire School Community okay I know I'm moving through this really quickly um another program that we we we had to change a little bit not change much but is a community Mentor program and for those who aren't familiar with the program
020Community Mentor program really allows high school students the opportunity to pinpoint an area of Interest something that they want to study an independent study and learn learn more about um and then throughout the semester our community Mentor program advisor or coordinator uh Works to uh connect connect the student with a Community member uh who obviously Mentor them they'll work they'll explore the independent study and through monthly meetings and some you know guided activities uh they will create in they will create a uh a real polished presentation of everything that they've learned at the end of the year this this I and I want to be careful what I say because you know this isn't like a done deal yet but uh quite frankly this this is going to play really nice into the different Pathways
021that are being discussed by by the uh State Ed um and students currently do earn a half credit for completing the program um we have we hope to have all of our mentors in place soon um hopefully at the next board meeting you'll have all the icrs for from all the mentors but with us tonight I do have David Nelson Epstein who is taking over the the program last year K goldbach ran the program and she did so for so many years so we're kind of rebuilding it and I'm really impressed that David's been able to uh pull things together very quickly so David you want to talk a little bit about where we're at hi um so K has been had been doing the program for decades um and she was ready uh to
022retire uh so I took over and uh so it was uncertain at the beginning of the year whether uh the program was going to continue so uh guidance hadn't really pushed it very hard last year so um I kind of the the startup was a little slow so I I uh kind of advertised at the beginning of the year and and students had a a deadline of uh November 1st for applying to the program uh there were 25 students who approached me uh with uh interest in in the program um by November 1st there were 19 students who had submitted applications to be uh placed with mentors um the plan is well that I have almost all of the students uh placed with mentors so 13 students have been paired uh there are four more
023in in process we just need to sort of work out uh the details of uh those and I'm still looking for mentors for for two students I'm I'm fairly hopeful and actually at least one of those students said well if you can't find me someone is it too late for me to put in a second choice I said absolutely not just get it to me by Friday and you know I'll work on it so they're kind of having me in the building is uh kind of a nice adjustment uh because Kay was only there when she was doing Mentor business so kids can actually approach me and kind of uh adjust um the again the plan is to have all of the forms in for the next board meeting then um I'll set up meetings
024with each student and their Mentor where the three of us will sit down and sort of Define the parameters of of their particular uh project um the idea is that this all be uh Project based um and sort of tailored to the to the students interest um I have up here the the list of all of the the subjects so uh there's a there are three students who are interested in either screenwriting or or film making uh two students who uh are interested in photography um one student who wants to do a mentorship in emergency medicine that's going to be an interesting one um I have two students who are interested in education one in early childhood and one in little older kids um there's one student who wanted to uh pursue scholarly writing on
025the subject of philosophy so um her reading list is going to be interesting uh I have one student who uh is pursuing psychology one student who will be doing uh Chinese language and actually uh this is something like so the Chinese language one uh that Mentor will be working like sort of via Zoom which I'm I'm trying to sort of limit the number of people who are working virtually but by by sort of opening up to sort of video conferencing it gives us sort of a a wider range of uh mentors available uh I have one student doing watercolor painting uh through the uh Woodstock School of Art and then one student who wants to learn to do high performance automob automobile tuning okay and uh and those are the topics uh that that we're
026going to be pursuing I have a student interested in pastry sheffery and I'm I'm working on that one and I have a student interested in the writing of comic books not specifically the drawing of comic books and I've pursued a number of avenues and I'm still working on that one and that's it yes David I'm just so the the two areas that you haven't found a mentor yet are the pastry chef and the comic book writer okay good I I was just hoping that you would say that out loud here in the meeting just in case somebody's listening at home or maybe in the audience and either wants to Mentor or knows a mentor well I did uh approach uh uh Jackie kchan from uh the golden notebook who sent me in the direction of
027a great writer who uh hasn't gotten back to me yet yet which maybe maybe maybe that'll happen anyone okay and finally the the last uh board goal that I just wanted to tag on to is I know the board has set a goal regarding chronic absenteeism uh which which we uh we as a a team had said that we were going to be looking at student attendance uh during the school year so we had already started some initiatives so what we're focused on is we're really focused on on average daily attendance uh by our students and what we want to do is we want to try to maximize the instructional time what we've done as far as daily attendance is we have a number of mechanisms in place right now to constantly run reports and
028monitor you know the attendance of students this is being done in collaboration with the health office uh our counseling office our psychologists our social workers our our community leison um our goal is to put as many interventions into place as as possible uh the The Chronic absenteeism uh number or percentage that comes out we're not as focused on that percentage because there's just so many there's just so many variables within that chronic absenteeism formula that uh we really we really can't can't address uh but we are working on improving the daily attendance one of the things we also did just as a side note that's not on here is we also had changed our schedule um we used to have Home Room at the very beginning of the day first period and one of the
029reasons why we wanted to change it to third period was really for communications basically go to your communication goal but was was because we have we have a number of students who have late arrivals so they never got to hear what was going on in the in the building and especially if we were if we were praising them because we always have students doing amazing things they'd miss hearing the accolades about themselves um an unintended consequence of this was because the day didn't start right away with home room and students took their time getting to class and were often late now they didn't have that so what we're finding is students are actually getting to school on time or more students are getting to school on time um and the instructional day starts starts right
030away so that that was an unintended consequence another another interesting thing that we implemented this year was a new electronic wway pass system and again we did it for different reasons uh our intended consequences or our intended reasons were were to address one um I don't know there's no better way to say this the high the bathroom passes are absolutely disgusting you think about how many students take a bathroom pass and they where do they take it into the bathroom I'll let your imaginations Go Wild on that one but we wanted to eliminate that the second thing is is that we wanted to have some accountability of where students are at all times so if there was a lock if there was a lockdown or some some you know some reason why we needed to
031locate a student and they weren't in their class we'd be able to quickly log into a system and say oh so and so is in the counseling office there's nothing more embarrassing to us than when a parent comes unannounced to pick up their student for whatever reason and we can't find the student because they're on a path somewhere maybe they went to the library or the counseling office but it this kind of el eliminated that issue so we have better student accountability there were a couple of un unintended um consequences or results from this as well um one of them is that um students are more cognizant about getting back to class on time we never told students there was a time limit on any of these passes but they see the teacher issuing the
032pass and you know we just put a five minute you know time limit on the pass just so you know it'll turn red and it'll alert us in the monitors that someone's out of class for an extended amount of time and again the purpose is to make sure the students are right you know are they having a medical emergency are they are they have having are they stressed out and having an emotional issue um but we didn't realize that the students would be looking at that all the time when they got back from class so over the course of of the actually the first few weeks of school students started getting back to class A lot quicker wasn't wasn't what we were looking for but we'll take it um the other the other thing with
033the electronic hallway passes is that it's giving us a considerable amount of data about mised instructional time while our goal is never ever to dissuade or limit students access to bathrooms the nurses office counselors Etc um it does yield a lot of great statistics meaningful statistics I had no idea that in the first three months of school we issued a little over 24,000 hallway passes that's an enormous amount of passes what we also were able to see is how many times certain students were leaving the same classes or how many times students were leaving uh a a class every single period the counselors have that information and they use it as part of their counseling with students is there a real issue that the students experiencing that needs to be addressed it could be medical
034it could be emotional it gives us great data they're also coming up they also came out and see that there's a there's a correlation between the students who are missing a significant amount of time in a particular class and the students um average in that course so there is a lot there's a lot of great data but overall our goal with looking at attendance is to try to get back to pre-pandemic levels because attendance rates were doing well prior to the pandemic and what I did was I kind of gave you a little bit of a I gave you a chart that kind of summarizes it looks at the time frame of September 1st to November 30th in each of those 10 years so you could kind of see you could kind of see where
035we were what our r were uh going back as as far as 20156 and then at you could see the trend and then we hit you know the pandemic and uh you know I wouldn't make much out of that 94.5% or the 89% um because obviously that's the the height of the pandemic but you can see in the last three years we're gradually raising those attendance rates so anyway this is the type of data that that we look at a regular B basis our liaison are constantly being given this these data and it's also shared at our faculty meetings so I just hit you with so much information in different orders um but overall I just want to say thank you for continuing to support us I know you have very difficult diff difficult jobs
036and it's greatly appreciated so I'm sure there's no questions or comments I'll just start off by um I don't have any questions but I just want to thank you for a very thorough presentation that was tied to our goals I mean we really just uh adopted those goals a couple weeks ago and um you're already reporting good information to US based on those goals and I really appreciate the presentation from you and your team thank you any questions for Edelman jusy Lynch thank you just a quick question I I was curious um how you're um um incentivizing kids to um stay within the rules within the personal electronic devices the change is there sorry I'm thinking about um looking at those numbers I'm just curious was is there what the consequences were and or the
037incentives for making kids change their behavior sure I think the first thing is awareness awareness that one we are going we are going to address it an awareness of how those behaviors are impacting them and their academics and their social emotional functioning um I can tell you and I I'm sure I'm sure the teachers can tell you and actually probably if you take a look at the newspaper article that the that the students just wrote they are seeing the benefits of not having these devices bothering them they are not having the conflicts they're not having the stress and the anxiety of oh God I could use it I could use my phone when I get to the cafeteria what's so and so saying about me what H you know so I think in a lot
038of ways they're actually relieved and I don't believe that a lot of them are really missing missing these these devices and just as a side note we've also been able to counsel some students there are some students who have anxiety that need to talk to their parents on a regular basis our goal wasn't to cut that communication off but to provide a better way to do that so if you if you say I need to call my mom I'm stressed out sure you could take your phone go to a go to the school counseling office we'll arrange that for you um you know there has to be some exceptions to this but it has to be done reasonably and it has to be done in an appropriate manner so students respect that there are alternatives
039so some of those referrals that you saw that big 50 whatever it was you know was students trying to navigate what we were doing and they had to be told hey it's it's okay you don't know who's picking you up after school and you're anxious about that you know what during lunch come to the office we have a phone that you could use if you really need to text your parent let us know you know give us a a general reason why we will give you that safe space so when students saw that we weren't like you know throwing the hammer down and you know every time they want to use it but we were trying to be supportive so they're learning to nav Navigate a responsible way to use their devices is that kind
040of answer trusty Jerome and then trusty canson um thank you so much uh very exciting to hear about the seal and the mentorship uh program um I guess I'm going to ask about academics which is also a board goal as we are a school district um and I'm a little concerned that the sprawling programming from what you presented me here with our declining enrollment problems would negatively impact performance and um I guess it's very appropriate to me to hear a little bit about not only academic performance although I think that that's a a very valid question but also like what are we looking at in terms of continuers whether that's in the trades whether that's in going to college like how are we doing there um that's something I'm very interested in sure so I
041just want to just want to be clear that we are still offering all of those opportunities it's it's a lot more guided as to what students are selecting as their first and second choices um and especially to align with whatever their postgraduate goals are as far as the career in Tech portion is that's that's honestly a non a non-issue we get our students into any career in Tech program for the for the most part bosis tries to close you know there's a limit and they'll close us out on certain programs but we continue to push and somehow we miraculously get our kids into the programs of their choice I'm very convincing when I harass them um um in term in terms of colleges it's it's it's amazing where our students are getting into and I
042could probably provide that information to you I'll give you a list of where students um went to college last year um I think that we have a very rigorous program I think our students do really well and the reports that we do get from the colleges show that our students are uh really do an an amazing job and are well prepared for college but is there something specific in there no that that that's kind of vague but you wouldn't have it on hand anyways I understand um I guess that um as I look at the those all of those offerings that we have I think oh I wonder whether there's been any thought about editing given that we don't have a student body really to support that many offerings and as we look to sort
043of reenvisioning our district is that something that's going through the administ or your as the principle something your your mind like how do we this is something that was for a class A much larger class size so how are we smart about figuring out things that people want and then maybe not disappointing so many people by having cohorts that or you know um sections not being able to be filled sure so two responses on that is one is one of the benefits of becoming a smaller uh student base is that our counselors get to know our students a lot better so while they're not formalized portfolios they are really they're really in touch with what Pathways these students want to take in college so they're already projecting what type of courses so for example a
044AP Bio typically gets low enrollment numbers but if our counselors are saying that we have these students who are interested in I'm just going to say like a biomedical field or a track we're going to make sure that either in their junior or senior year that course is projected to be on the table for those students now some of the other courses and I try not to I don't I try not to overburden the teachers but I I do I feel I should mention this um if there is something that's not offered in our course catalog and a student is adment that they need to take that course or need to explore that course our teachers are always willing to provide independent studies they dedicate their time and will come up with the cours work
045the students will get credit for that course work and it's always proven to be an enriching experience for the for the students thank you um and just one last and then I'll I'll put it down but uh to say that the mentorship program to me as I heard about it seems like a really nice pivot when you are talking about individual you know building a class around one individual student does that make as much sense as maybe investing more resources into something like the mentorship program or an independent studies I'm just throwing it out there into the world as we figure out what to do as our enrollment declines definitely a discussion item and there's ALS it's also um you know it's also gonna be interesting to see how this plays into the new graduation
046requirements uh the the challenge with the independent studies is that students are limited by the state on how many independent study credits they could H count towards graduation so we have to be thoughtful about when they're taking that class so you know for example sometimes a student in nth grade will say well could I independent study that it's like well don't you know don't use up all your independent study credits now um so yeah it's going to be interesting to see how these graduation standards change and how we have to adapt that program sure thank you um I just uh related to what we were just talking about I just had a really quick question so when you said you're rotating classes those are it sounds like they're year-long classes as well as semester electives
047okay and is that happening sort of on a predictable schedule so if I'm in Sam in 10th Grade I'm going to know that you know AP bioi will it's not going to be available to me until 12th grade because it's not happening next year or is it year by year so I'm going to give you the answer like that that I don't like when the attorneys give us it depends so you know if it's if it's a if it's a core course um or one that's going to count towards grad towards you know graduation you know those are really predicted you know the the the a especially some of the APS and the college level courses when you start talking about you know General electives we still maintain a student driven schedule and that what
048what that means is you know we'll say you know what the the art Department could handle you know all these electives students are interested we're going to we're going to put all these electives out we're going to see what the student interest is and then we will will run those and then really the thought process is is if you run those one year you know they're not going to have to take it again the next year so the other course should naturally run thanks and the other thing was I just wanted to uh I've been talking about this all year very much applaud freeing the kids from their devices I think is a great thing and I just wanted to share that um I uh one when I was researching the topic uh I saw
049one school did something that I thought was uh good which was uh they they actually created like a call home phone that was a landline and they put a nice comfy chair next to it and they put it on a table with a little tablecloth and there were mints and and a box of Kleenex and it became this and it's almost like a private booth that um that if you do need to call home during the day that was where you were LED and you have this space that this is what this is for rather than sending kids to their phones and I think just wanted to throw it out there because I thought it was a great idea but thank you for what you're doing thank you for that anyone else thank you so
050much thank you and have a happy holiday season you too all right we're are going to move on to item 3.01 uh the board will be awarding tenure uh before we um vote to uh uh to recommend the tenure or to approve the tenure that the superintendent is recommending um Amanda Allison our uh assistant superintendent for pupil Personnel Services will read her recommendation for Rosalie mnin okay so a thank you Board of Ed trustees I want to introduce Rosie minin embarrass her a bit right here with her family um it is with great joy that I have the pleasure to recommend Rosalie mnin for tenure as a school social worker within the antora central school district Miss Merin joined antora on April 12th 2021 as the parent Community liaison she has demonstrated dedication adaptability and
051a deep commitment to the well-being and success of our students and their families in the role of parent Community liaison Miss Merin has excelled in coordinating vital services and resources for families this has ranged from mental health and case management to transportation and in Home Services her efforts in supporting attendance for all district enrolled students has and continues to be crucial in addressing chronic absenteeism and helping students reach their academic potential Miss Merin has also proven invaluable in securing essential residency and medical documentation conducting wellness and residency checks arranging holiday resources for families in need and I will just say I have gotten so many emails this year about her support of our students through all the different charities she's working with so big big kudos for her on that and connecting students and families
052with County Services in addition to her Lees roll Miss meron has also served as a school social worker at both phenicia and Bennett Elementary Schools in these capacities Miss mnon has provided School counseling service to students and parents support and training to Guardians she's attended csse and cpsc meetings delivered the too good for drugs program at the elementary level maintained detailed records written social histories and provided counseling to preschoolers Miss merin's active participation in team meetings and decisions making processes highlight her commitment to collaborative thinking over the past four years miss m has shown remarkable flexibility in adapting to evolving District needs she has always led her work with a focus on providing exceptional support to our students and families her prior experience to joining anara includes roles as a case worker for social services
053childcare worker at Aster residential home and a social worker at the Northeast Trauma Center her wealth of knowledge in various Social Work areas continues to support Anora to learn more about trauma informed care county social support systems and resources and case management in light of her impactful work dedication to antora and commitment to our community's well-being I recommend Rosalie Merin for tenure yay [Applause] and also Carol GMA our director of special education will read her recommendation for Lauren petrisky good evening Lauren is here as well and if can give a little wave you're welcome to stand up here with me if you like so um it is with great enthusiasm that I recommend Lauren petrisky for tenure as a school psychologist at Anora Central School District currently in her fifth year at Bennett Elementary School
054Miss petrisky has proven Prov herself to be an invaluable asset to our school Community consistently demonstrating a deep commitment to Student Success collaborative practices and Innovative approaches that enhance both academic and social emotional outcomes for our students her role at Bennett in her role at Bennett Miss patrisi has engaged in a range of services from Individual Counseling psychoeducational testing to whole GL class social skills support Miss petrisky has also provided targeted pushin lessons for our fifth grade girls using the ailia project curricul um focusing on Regional aggression and strategies for managing social dynamics effectively as an active member of the multi-tiered systems of supports or as we know the mtss committee Miss petrisky has played a key role in developing our district mtss handbook which continues to serve as a guide for Best Practices across
055the district Miss petrisky is deeply committed to systems level thinking and effective integration of mtss Frameworks data analysis and resources to maximize student support she is passionate about developing effective educational diagnostic strategies additionally Miss patrisi participates in grade level data team meetings collaborating closely with teachers and staff to interpret data and design interventions that support student growth Lauren petrisky also brings Rich experience in csse and cpse evaluations her prior roles as a school psychologist and csse chairperson in Ellenville and at the matso school in dist School District in Alaska have provided her with the the broad Foundation of skills in Behavioral Management adaptive skills programming and evaluation processes Miss petrisky has a background that includes working with diverse populations including students with significant needs in behavioral and adaptive skill development this experience combined with her
056work at Inspire preschool and her specialized internship at the center for Spectrum Services has made her highly skilled in conducting diagnostic evaluations and understanding the needs of students with autism in light of her wonderful contributions her commitment to evidence-based practices and her dedication to the antor community I wholeheartedly recommend Lauren petrisky for [Applause] tenure the following named instructional Personnel having served a period of probationary status consistent with the education law of the state of New York and provisions of the commissioner's regulations and having received continuing satisfactory evaluations of performance are hereby recommended by the superintendent of schools for approval for 10year status with a probationary period of 412 2021 to 411 2025 certified School social worker Rosalie mnin hereby receives 10 year excuse me on 412 2026 2025 I'm sorry psyche sorry eek oh my
057god um with the probationary period of 92220 to 31 2025 certified psychologist Lauren petrisky hereby receives tenure on 32 2025 may I have a first trusty remand second trusty Mitchel Morel any questions or comments trusty kudon hi trusty Mitchell Morell hi trusty Goodrich hi trusty Jerome I trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I that's unanimous congratulations [Applause] there are cookies outside the auditorium we'll take the break the board will take about a 10-minute break but please uh step outside and have a snack and congratulations again e e e actually have another one on our website now under the um Community Forum from December uh our our facilitator and her I her I can't remember the title she used um the wonderful artist who uh created the artwork from December that's up on our website as well
058so we'll probably be able to feature that in one of our future presentations is it her scribe her visual scribe visual scribe see it came to me um so really what we wanted to do is is kind of bring everything together that we've we've kind of talked about in bits and pieces um to really kind of go over what the planning what the planning has entailed what will continue to entail as we go toward towards um a may vote so in looking at what would be part of this Capital project I'm sure I know many of you have heard the term building condition survey that is what the Architects do every five years look at our buildings you know what are the you know what are the priorities that need to be repaired and things
059like that obviously any project that we're going to put to the voters we want to make sure that we are capturing those those kind of high level um nuts and bolts things um as you know we have done many staff and Community involvement sessions We are continuing to do them we're also in valuating what of our wants versus what are our needs needs again going back to the nuts and bolts um continued feedback from the community we we are going to have three Community forums three staff forums and we've also had a student forum and then as we work through all this what is the cost going to be and what is the tax implications So currently we have many people helping us in this endeavor besides um besides us in in central Administration we
060have Point Road Studios Sharon laosy from um helping us as a consultant uh Clark Patterson Lee as our Architects um we are also looking to bring a new construction managing management firm on board we have fiscal Associates as our fiscal advisers and Hawkins Delafield and wood as our bound Bond Council and there will be the ones that will help us with the financing so the uh project Focus areas um this is these are really just kind of the general areas that came out of the visioning sessions um and they are as you can see all encompassing um from health and safety to site infrastructure to Academic Program enhancement School communities these are all things that that were um brought up in those visioning sessions as things that the the community the staff um really wanted
061to see as we were looking to do a project so we're taking all of these areas into account as we start moving forward my favorite was this road map to vote day I have to say I stole this from another school um as you can see it's a long windy road and through the middle the entire time we're planning and estimating so um it never stops until we get to the to the May 20th vote day um but it consists of all of our meetings our staff engagement student engagements Community forums looking at enrollment doing these Board of Ed presentations getting to where the board adopts a resolution and then ultimately getting to the May 20th vote uh important dates coming up these are all dates that we will continue to look at supplying information
062gathering information um with the ultimate goal of um adopt having the board adopt a resolution for the annual um election uh as you can see March 4th we kind of put in bold that's when we will present the final um Capital project project presentation to you um and um end of February we hope hope we shall have um all the detailed scope with the estimated cost of the project is obviously we would want to make sure you have all that for the discussion on March 4th so I know another is question that's come up so if the project vote passes what would a a tenative timeline look like so this we had done this based on um well a lot of it was based on uh s uh review and approval because as you can
063see that's on there for um 6 months because it has unfortunately taken that long um we we have had the discussion though with the Architects that if we do get a May uh a capital project approval vote then we could work with the Architects to design something that might be kind of a have a have a shorter approval process something that might be a little smaller in scope that we could then actually do in the summer of 26 potentially the fields um if there was something else I the fields was something that we were thinking of that would be Standalone and an immediate improvement improvement for our campus and our for our community I just wanted to mention um because if you look at that at first glance you may not realize that's July 2025
064to June 2026 so the 25 and the 26 are actually 20 yes years not days just wanted to make sure that was clear to everybody my apologies um yeah so we we left ourselves an entire year to design this this this next project which it allows us to do it in many different ways um that's kind of that was kind of the plan but as we said we could actually design something smaller in a faster timeline uh so a lot of questions have come up as as far as how do you pay for a capital project and what are the pros and cons of the different ways of doing it um very similar to how people buy homes you have two choices you can borrow the money to buy your home or you can use
065cash there are pros and cons to both for example cash which is how we have historically paid for our projects over the last uh multiple years um you have no debt but you're still getting building Aid um some of the cons are you're you're limited in what you can do with the cash that you have on hand so we save money great then we then we have voters vote on a small project and that's kind of so it kind of goes up and down based on what you have for cash and how much cash you have varies from year to year um only gives you kind of the ability to do small projects and then of course you've got the the cons of the escalating cost if you're only doing small projects every year borrowing
066on the other hand also has pros and cons so the pros to borrowing is you can maximize work tends to last last longer you get the economy escap scale when you're doing a larger project um competitive bidding um biders like big projects because they know their people will be busy for a long time for example we're talking about two summers companies love it they can plan their work for two whole years uh and then you also get building Aid that'll help offset your debt and you get predictable payments so it's kind of like your mortgage you know every for the next however many years what your monthly payments or in our case their annual payments are going to be the cons are obviously you're taking on debt and there is the potential for increase in
067taxes this one I did oh so kind of like I said um School construction projects require long-term commitments that will need to be repaid annually as principal and interest so very similar to as I mentioned um uh a mortgage so schools have have what schools generally do is they issue short-term notes initially they're called banss Bond anticipation notes we can issue those um for up to five years and then after the five years what normally happens is you roll all those bands into a bond so what you can you know so so the idea is try to pay off as much of the Bands as you can so you're not bonding as much when when the voters go to vote for a project they are not voting to borrow that money they are voting on
068what the project the maximum cost of the project will be we say that the vote that the district May Bond up to because again we don't know what's going to happen but it's a it's a not to exceed amount the hope is we save you know like we can save money we can pay down our bands and then we don't have to to bond as much um and then usually what happens with the state is the state will then issue or we will try to issue debt that will coincide with our with our um building Aid so 100 10,000 a million dollar project 31% I'm sorry let me back up million dollar debt payment actually I think I have that slide but anyway we try to get the aid to match the debt that's okay
069I just wanted to note uh one of the reasons that districts will take out the bands the bond anticipation notes for up to 5 years is if we are doing projects in the way that we are imagining so staggering them over the course of the time you don't want to borrow the full amount ahead of time and be paying on it so if you have a small project in the first summer you take out a ban for just that amount and then the next summer a ban for that amount and at the end a ban for whatever's left and then when you have all the work completed then you Bond it so that you're not needlessly holding that money thank you for explaining that better than I did so what affects the additional tax burden
070so you have your building Aid ratio this is the aid that we would get on the debt maximum amount any school in New York state can get is 95% our building Aid ratio is 31% which means for every dollar of the project 31 cents comes to us from the state you can limit the amount you're borrowing by using capital reserve we've been very lucky in that we have historically had good Capital reserves and we've we've put it to the voters asking them to give us the ability to put money aside for a capital reserve um interest rates are obviously a big issue we are starting to see a decline uh the FED has cut rates um the banks have adjusted their rates so in the future they are envisioning that the rates will be going
071down the one thing that we have control of is the percentage of the project that's aable understanding that just because we want to do X number of dollars worth of work the state may not necessarily that that's X number of dollars of aidable work so we have to be very careful that we do work that is aable by the state um one example of a scope of of scope of work that might not be aidable is average class size 800 square fet we say you know what our kids need bigger spaces than that we want to give them 12200 ft that's fine but understand you're not going to get aided on that additional 400 ft by the state um and then of course we're looking to the budget savings that could come from a single
072campus the transportation savings utilities uh building repairs and again um not replacing employees that could be uh retiring so just some key components of building Aid and this can be a very complicated um formula just very very similar to the foundation Aid formula but kind of what makes up building Aid so the the state looks at what they call um building Aid units and they take enrollment into account so again if you wanted to build um you know a multi-million dollar 300 classroom building State Ed is going to be like yeah but you don't have enough kids for that for that so we're not going to Aid it uh they also look at your maximum cost allowance so you are allowed to spend Mone on projects up to a certain dollar amount again depending on
073your enrollment and and all of this and it's it's um reset every five years as you can see right now we have a maximum cost allowance for the middle school high school of 66 million and for Bennett of 23 million um we also get Aid on interest so they ALS they assume that people borrow money to do these capital projects so they will also give you building Aid on interest uh so right right now currently we're at 31% they do say they can make adjustments annually we have not seen an adjustment in many years just as a side note they give us two payments per year and then delays could occur if uh final cost reports are not filed in a timely manner which I will tell you we have never done so this is
074kind of when I was talking about um what a payment would look like um for us now I took $30 million as a project is that what it's going to be we don't know this this was in talking to the Architects and and then just in really kind of generally thinking of what schools have done and how much they've been able to get 30 million seemed like a good a good starting place um so I wanted to kind of show you what the difference would be is if we borrowed $30 million into the project or if we borrowed $20 million used $10 million but it was still a $30 million project so these are both $30 million projects it's just the funding sources are slightly different in each so in the first example we're doing
075all borrowing estimated annual Bond payment for that borrowing would be $2.5 million a year we would $462,000 of building Aid which means the taxpayers would have a local share of a little over two million every year in our general fund budget we put money in there for small projects that's that 750 $50,000 if we do a large project we won't need that $750,000 in our budget so we can pull that out that would still leave a 1.2 a little over 1.2 million dollars um that would be part of the local share so could we save $1.2 Million by consolidating maybe um but what if we did a $30 million project borrowed 20 million and used 10 million from our our capital reserve well then our an our annual Bond payment is 1.6 million because we're
076only paying on 20 million not 30 we're still getting $462,000 of building Aid because the building Aid is based on the project not the borrowing so that makes the Lo no local share 1.1 million again take out that 750,000 that we no longer need in our budget and now we're looking at um needing to come up with $388,000 a year from savings from from uh consolidating which is very reasonable um so just kind of where do our taxes come from in a district I know this is kind of because we we have so many towns that make up our um School District as you can see Olive is actually our highest taxable um assessed town at 1.5 billion um Woodstock is second at 1.1 billion and then Hurley at a little over a billion and
077then we've got um obviously marbletown shandan and Lexington that make up the the rest so we have almost $4 billion in taxable assessed value in our district um as far as reserves um I know a question came up well if we use $10 million then we're not going to have any money left well first of all a capital reserve can only be used for capital projects that's what it's that's what it's designed for as you can see we've already we we already have $6.6 million in our capital reserve um so the other reserves would still remain we only only we have our our maximum allowable 4% in the unappropriated that's the two little little under 2.8 million that is that's our emergency fund that's the family of five who moves into the district and every
078child in that family has an IEP that sends them out of district there is half a million dollars right there minimum um will it happen could it happen that's why we're allowed to keep that uh so right now we have um over $18 million in fund balance and reserves I just wanted to note the capital reserve that exists now the voters approved the creation and funding of that Reserve to a maximum of 10 million if we um if we maximize that Reserve we can ask the voters to create another reserve and continue to um accumulate savings to use to offset the cost of a future Capital project um and so we Ed that 10 million 10 million in the example because we have that established Reserve that's been authorized to be funded to a maximum
079of 10 million but we can continue to save money and create another capital reserve to use to offset the cost so as this isn't going to happen for a few years we're not going to have debt payments for a number of years we can continue to save to offset it and to minimize the tax implications for our taxpayers and then for all of you who are interested and I'm sure you all are on what these um what the purpose of these reserves are uh Victoria very kindly put a link to the reserve plan which is on our website and that's um something that you all approve um every June um and uh so it's also nice bedtime reading so uh as I mentioned this the consolidation savings just looking at uh where we are currently
080um so we are currently slated to save over $600,000 simply by not transporting to Phoenicia 2425 not to say that our transportation budget went down by 600,000 because if you're remember we had to bid out a new Transportation contractor that increased the contra contract by 40% so basically if we hadn't had that savings instead of going up by 20% we would have gone up by 60% in our transportation budget uh but in addition to that savings we also saved over 35,000 pounds of carbon emissions which I think is is a is a a nice thing as well uh for utilities uh we will'll obviously sa see Savings in pellets electric oil water cleaning I don't have numbers yet for Phoenicia because we really haven't been that far into the school year we haven't even gotten
081our November bills yet from the uh utility companies they seem to be a little behind uh so as we get that information I will be tracking that but in addition to that the savings and the savings from salaries and benefits by not replacing employees represented almost a million in this year and that it was all um employees who had retired resigned and did not need to be replaced so that was um a large savings as I mentioned um in a previous board meeting a year and a half ago we were looking at roughly 30% of our uh staff that would be eligible to retire in five years so this is the start of it yeah last year is like kind of the first year and it's going to continue for the next few years so
082future board of ed meetings as um we mentioned February 4th will will uh look at offering you some initial designs and initial funding considerations March 4th with the final design and the maximum not to exceed cost and tax impact in addition to a recommended uh recommendation as to the number of propositions to be included uh as we mentioned earlier um the board has the option of re of putting more than one proposition on the ballot in response to capital projects for example one could be health and safety one could be infrastructure one could be Athletics that's just an example uh there are many different ways of doing it we'll obviously discuss it with the Architects with the construction um managers with our attorneys um because multiple reasons we obviously want a successful outcome um in
083addition we want to make sure that whatever is done is will be approved by the state so for example if you want to do an athletic field let's say Athletics was Proposition 3 and I don't know something health and safety is Proposition one if proposition 3 passes and proposition one doesn't the state's not going to is not going to allow you to do that so generally the way a lot of schools do it is in order for proposition three to pass proposition one needs to pass or proposition one and two need to pass before proposition three um so there's a lot of different ways um it's kind of like a menu at a restaurant so um and then in addition I I didn't put this in there but the other thing to mention is um
084The Proposition would have a as I mentioned an up to amount so we would look to up borrowing up to and as Victoria said as we were able to save money as we were able to do this we don't have to borrow all that money it is really a um it's a ceiling so and then March 18th we would look for um the Board of Ed to approve the proposition that will be added to the ballot sure so um as always people who have uh questions or comments or suggestions um in addition to being absolutely invited to our community forums the next one will be on January 15th here um and the RSVP form is already on the website and I know uh at least one person in the audience has already rsvpd maybe maybe
085more but I know at least one um that was record speed thank you so much now I know the form worked um so that Forum will be on the 15th and then we'll have another one in February but in addition feel free to reach out to any of us that are listed on this slide we are happy to sit down and have a personal meeting we're happy to have a phone call um we're happy to email but actually I prefer conversations but I'm whatever works for um anyone who has additional questions trustees have questions yes trusty Jerome I'm gonna ask that we each ask one question and then give you know because I'm assuming that there may be multiple questions and unless you have two questions that are completely related um and we'll just kind
086of take turns yes thank got it I will do that okay um I just have a my first question is uh page 14 we are to where taxes come from um taxable assess value I remember last year you gave a presentation because Woodstock taxes went up quite a bit is this is this how much each Town pays in taxes can you talk to me a little bit about that because we just had such a spike in Woodstock and I want to understand what this taxable assessed value means so the taxable assessed value is the states is is what the state says this is what what we're T what what their towns are taxing on am I getting that wrong oh the assessors the the taxable assessed value is actually done by the assessors in each
087Town it just shows the the different components of what townships and how large each of those townships are for us and then the taxes themselves have the have that added um Equalization rate that's that's why that's different than the taxable assessed value yes though Hurley actually got it this year so um I wanted to ask about the building Aid ratio toor is is 31% can you just describe about how that number has come to is it is it because of high taxable assess value and also that that's it so it's pretty much related the higher your the higher your property values are the less you get as a percentage I believe it's also it's not just property values it's income wealth as well in we are um by statistics significantly wealthier than most districts and
088it I think at one point it really was more property wealth but it is truly a combination of property and income wealth at this point okay and my my quick related question is I think you answered it is that building Aid comes in once a year yes and it's a right before it's part of our it's part of it's part of our um part of our uh our state aid that's Revenue every year the state tells us what we're going to get we build it into the budget okay thank you thank you so much um for the presentation can I ask you to um to again uh superintendent you mentioned something about the the difference between the first five years which is potentially where we would have the the um we would issue the short-term
089bands which are the the bond anticipation notes and then we would go to potentially issuing the bond and so in that fiveyear period we wouldn't see potentially an increase in taxes is that accurate and also would that give us an opportunity to look for other sour ources of funding potentially our savings as you were just explaining may increase and or we could look for um potentially private investment or grants or other things that may help offset that Bond cost is that accurate usually the ban I've only had experience with bans in other districts because we don't we have not historically borrowed here so I would actually want to ask our fiscal advisers in terms of the schedule my understanding from my experience is that a ban is an annual Note and so it literally is
090re banned each year until you Bond it so there is uh sometimes a small payment but it's not the full annual payment for the bond but I would ask them to to maybe give us a just an example schedule I don't know that we would need one for five years if we're only anticipating two or potentially three years of construction you would want to move on and bond it uh once the project was complete but that would extend the amount of time as you were just referencing that we can save and potentially look for additional funding because the proposition that the voters would approve would include an up to amount we are in no way uh obligated to borrow that maximum amount and we would not want to if we could avoid it okay thank
091you I think it's also similar to when you do a home construction you know you you construction loan you know you you say I'm going to build a house that's going to cost me you know $200,000 like okay but you know and then they kind of release the money as you need it and you're really only paying in and I think it's similar you're only paying interest until such time that okay my house is done now I'm taking a mortgage trusty Mitchell Morel then trusty goodr I um I asked you a lot of questions over email when you first sent this and I noticed you Incorporated a lot of them so I really appreciate that um two things first of all I know the 30 million was a guest I don't know if you said
092this but when do we expect to get that actual number um our hope is that we will have preliminary numbers for you by um February 4th and then um oh the other thing is there is a slide about if the if the bond passes can you talk a little bit about the process of if it doesn't pass and also if we do it in propositions if some pass and some don't so if the if the project vote doesn't pass then the board has has options very similar to if a budget itself doesn't pass um the nice thing about a capital project vote is you're not limited to doing it just on vote day many schools actually do it um in the late fall early winter kind of November December time frame um the nice thing
093about this timeline is if this project vote doesn't pass in may we could look at and I would suggest doing an exit poll and saying okay if you didn't vote for the project why so we can get a feel for you know what it is the community didn't like about the project um and then retool it go out in let's say in November and still meet most of this timeline whether it's a smaller vote whether it's a different you know type of V v um or the board can decide not to do a capital project at all which I wouldn't recommend because our building condition survey really says we need one in terms of the packaging of the propositions that's also a board decision um as missir said earlier some districts do multiple propositions and
094basically put the things that our things that are um listed as high priority in a building condition survey for infrastructure or health and safety put that in the base proposition and then put things um what you see typically is things like athletic fields and turf uh as a separate proposition with the caveat that if you don't get the infrastructure even if the turf proposition proposition passes it's not going to be accepted without the infrastructure but that's entirely up to the board so the idea of what the propositions would be would come from more like engineers and Architects and lawyers but we would approve it we wouldn't come up with the idea ourselves well you can absolutely give input though in terms of what you'd like considered but I think we would certainly get our recommendations
095from uh The Architects and Engineers um the serial long-term bonds they typically run how long 10 15 years uh 15 15 20 1520 okay so and they are callable after five so they could renegotiate the interest rate that is a fiscal advisor's question I know we have um we have been able to prepay bonds um I just wanted to mention a lot of times municipal bonds are not callable because they are non- taxable for the people who have purchased them so if that that absolutely is a question for fiscal advisers when they're creating the bonds but that might impact your ability to get um institutions to bid on them thank you great presentation by the way thanks thank you any other questions trusty Jerome I'm just looking at the Timeline um and uh you trusty
096M Mitch Morel you asked about like when we would look at numbers and it says here end of February Supply with detail scope and estimated costs to be voted on and then end of February and then on March 4th the final Capital presentation to the bo Boe and then on March 18th the resolution that seems super to not be looking at numbers until like real estimated cost till you know four days before it's going to be presented does that and end of February Supply Bond council with detail scope and estimated costs you know I mean I'm just like oh boy that's not very long to study right well again I think the reason I mean we'll we'll be talking with with Bond counsil throughout all of this but you know I don't think I want
097I wanted to leave a little time for that final Community forum I mean yes I mean that's my concern like are is the public going to have enough time to sit with these numbers to really understand them to really feel like okay you know this is this is the this is a good thing you know um for us to support in terms of how it's going to impact I mean who here has done a capital project I've done one with the Woodstock Library who's done a home improvement or a renovation do they come in on budget or on time well we have to come in on budget that's not an option okay we're not allowed to spend more than is authorized okay can what about time uh the time frame that's all set out in
098the bid documents right but right now we're dealing with delays with certain upgrades because of the S which I've heard just being on the board for a year can be a very not always you know doing things right on time so again you know okay so budget clearly that's great but in terms of timeline also three years to complete what we looked at Nuts and Bolts Plus kind of rebuilding a school I just there's questions there for May you know yeah absolutely um but also for the voters to consider whether they support it they have from the middle of March until um the end of May when they vote so we're going to continue to communicate throughout that time and answer questions so that that process will continue for sure okay the the March date
099is for the board to adopt the resolution okay I'm gonna stop with that and we'll do another round chesse canson okay I have just some quickies so I may do more than two okay but they're really fast um the these These are Muni bonds as which as you said the people who buy them don't pay any they're Triple Tax Free for the people does that mean we get a lower you know they typically they pay less um interest to the people who purchase them does that mean we're also paying a below Market um interest rate it it all depends on the market and when they go out on the on the got something to add it also depends on our um Bond rating and we have a wonderful Bond rating oh good because we have
100no debts and we have savings um quick question bands versus the the longer bond is there a curve between those is there in other words is is the rate better on short-term bands than on long term long it's usually better on long term better on long term okay and my last question is um they recast our they Rec recalculate our our maximum cost allowance every five years do you know where we are in that circle cycle right now like when was the last time that was set um I think I just I think this is this is Rel that's good for the next five years or so we haven't done a lot of projects so okay great thank you and I think the maximum cost allowance was created not necessarily for districts like antora who
101have a 31% Aid ratio and don't do a lot of capital projects but for those districts that have a 95% Aid ratio and can get a lot of projects approved by their voters frequently Sarah thank you um just following on the question about um you know this the the timeline and the number of propositions that you're recommending um at what point in potentially this is a question for you uh um trustee Bishop but what's the schedule for us to think about that process in terms of you know the strategy behind for example a may vote versus a November Vote or the number of propositions as you've outlined there's some advantages to splitting them up over having one just curious what when we should anticipate that conversation or if we should just start to be having
102that ourselves as a board I think the may vote the board already gave us as a timeline um but in terms of the propositions we can start having those conversations at each meeting if you want to just start kind of comparing your philosophical ideas about how to package things and that that can only help us and inform uh what we're doing um at the same time thank you try goodr so I'd like to talk a little bit about what we're not doing so just to clarify this uh I think everybody here at the board understands this but I just want to clarify it for the public so we're we're not going to increase the classroom size or the section size for K through three we have a policy for that or regulation regulation so correct
103correct okay so classroom size not increasing you mean student number of students in the class another student per we have guidelines correct so the the other thing is we we're not planning on busing K through five elementary kids on buses with middle school or High School correct no um the one of the reasons being that um it would it would require one you know one short bus run a day and and it's not costeffective for for for transportation companies to bid on that it would mean a driver would only be working three hours a day um so and then you know it's it's it's already hard enough to find bus drivers trusty kudon yes I just want this is jumping ahead a little bit in our agenda but I just wanted to make a little
104report because it relates to some of the questions that are being asked um that uh the construction this is from the uh facilities committee meeting from the other day but um the constru the construction it's all right if I talk about this yeah the construction firm that we're thinking of hiring um part of the reason part of the compelling part of their presentation is they would help with both structuring propositions and they also have a very good in-house estimator which which we can talk about later when they come up but both of that will help us get to as accurate and well structured ass set of propositions as we can get to so it's it's not entirely we we have help we potentially have help with that process yes it definitely takes a team um
105you know that's that's the nice thing about um having the people working with us that we have is that they are incredibly um motivated helpful and uh just very smart people trusty um I'm looking at page 11 and um you explained that you're not far enough into pH into the year to see the savings of phenicia but questions that go through my mind are you know I know that that saved us a lot on Transportation but when we look at Woodstock and West Hurley those are the most densely populated portions of our very very large District that we will now have to be busing to a central campus from so what runs through my mind is like I know you can't be totally accurate but are we thinking about what those numbers like you we
106can't have we don't know what the utility savings are but could we give an estimate um you know building repairs I I would love it if there was some more numbers that even if they were estimates we could sort of have an idea of what that looked like um just so that because those it's really the cost is such a big a big piece of all of this and you know if we don't have to pay taxes on it great I don't that seems you know less likely when I look at what we all that could be done but in any case having some more estimates around some of these things and answering some of these questions I'm curious whether um we could do that prior to some of the the dates that we listed
107out sure okay great thank you so much for the presentation thank you Trustees for the excellent questions to be continued I'm sure and as uh Victoria said we are all whoa I guess John is doing that sorry John no but as I said uh our door is always open and seriously if you have anything that um any questions that you have much rather you call us and ask us right away than say you know what was that thing we talked about the other day I already forgot because I say that to myself all the time before we before we introduce um assistant superintendent laugh and I just want to um ask the board if you know uh questions that you're going to ask at the next meeting it is helpful to email superintendent or the
108assistant superintendent but I'm asking that we don't do email conversations and like kind of responding back and forth and kind of chiming in that really needs to happen at the table so and I think you know for us it's really valuable to have the conversation at the table but it's also I think even more important for the community to be able to experience that along with us yes I have to say I appreciated you sending those questions in advance Emily because another part of my my problem is is that you know I've done this a long time and to what seems to me is like oh yeah like it's easy like when when you sent the questions I'm like oh yeah didn't think about that so I appreciate that great they're I mean really great
109questions go ahead yeah and I totally understand they very fluent in this which is great but I do sometimes find it hard to understand and on that same note I think it's great to have the superintendent because she she talks more like a layment sometimes about this stuff and it's like like you say something and then she says it another way and I'm like oh okay like it could get confusing and it's good to have a regular person up there a regular person okay okay all right thank you so much ladies and so now we're going to move on to item 4.02 um assistant superintendent for curriculum instructions Stephanie laen will present the New York State assessment summary for grades 3 through 8 good evening everyone so I have the opportunity to speak with you
110about our New York State assessment scores um from the spring of last year and uh one of the ways I want to just mention and when it comes to assessments here this is one uh sample assessment that we do it is one dipstick and one test that we do every year um it is a a formal test that is um standardized and that we can compare year-to year so it's a a good test for us to take a look at and dig into we do many other types of of Assessments here and when it comes to looking at what our students know and what they can do this is just just one part of uh the kind of puzzle that we use to think about how we can support students so I just wanted to
111frame that before we get started so in the first slide this really just shows uh you a bit about the participation rates and the difference um between participation in the spring of 24 and the spring of 2023 generally you see participation rates growing um you can also see participation rates for our Science assessment that was given uh in grades five and eight this year we had a substantial jump in participation rates from the spring of 2022 between 20222 and 2023 so um the more robust participation in each grade the better because we have a better um idea of what's going on across the grade bands this chart is I want to speak a little bit about when it comes to performance by cohort so when what you see here is proficiency rates measured uh students
112who made between levels three and four so we are comparing proficiency rates from the 2223 year um to the 2324 year one thing I want to clarify this is not comparing students are were in grade four in 2022 to students who are wearing grade four in 2023 this is watching the students progress by grade for example you'll notice um that for third graders the percent we had proficient at 50% um it's not applicable for the prior year because we don't they do not take a a state assessment in grade two so when you look at this chart we are talking about in grade four you will see their performance the prior year in grade three at 54.2% so I just wanted to clarify cohort and what this chart meant are there any questions about that
113before we move on okay a little bit more about the standards and assessments because the state Assessments in uh the spring of 24 they were um based on new standards s that came out in 2022 so the 2023 and the 2024 Assessments in math and Ela they are reflective of the Next Generation math and Ela standards that were implemented fall of 2022 so we have two years two results of those assessments based on the same standards that allow for comparison um it isn't invisible for us to really compare the Assessments in Prior years while we could certainly look at them they're measuring different standards so it isn't really mathematically a strong thing to do um it's hot link there in that last bullet for those of you who are interested in the design of the
114spring assessments really how that's put together any of you who are um psychometricians that I'm aware of or secretly interested in that you'll find a lot of data to support that there also just a reminder of scores um scores uh are rated from one to four four being the highest performance score a student could achieve on this assessment and a level four is um generally rare because what you are measuring if a student achieves level four they are performing above grade level standards they are really excelling so a level four score is somewhat unusual a level three they are right on target they're EXA performing exactly where they should be um in standards for that grade level and then level two they are approaching that standard partially proficient and level one they tested uh below
115proficient for that grade and another thing that's hot linked at the at the bottom um the parent Guardian report that goes home every year for students who took the assessment there's a a sample report in math Ela grade five science and grade eight science something that the parents would have seen this fall when this was mailed out for students who took the assessments the next series of slides breaks it down a little bit further by grade level in math and in ela again with grade three um you cannot make the comparison to the prior prior year uh because students did not take this test in grade two so you can see the rank from level one to four and proficiency um is considered level threes and fours combined so later on when we look at
116rate of proficiency we're looking at for students that scored level three and four combined so as we move through every slide is just a different grade broken down with their specifics you can also see the number of students who took the test at as well so as we progress through grades 3 through 8 um one thing I want to add about the Science assessment that is a a new assessment this year we have new science standards and they were fully implemented grades K8 in the 2324 school year and they are being implemented in grades 912 by course over the next few years so that is rolling out year by year science assessments were revised to match the new standards and were given in grades five through eight previously to that the um assessments were given
117in grades four and eight one thing that's kind of exciting about the new standards the new assessments they do touch base on what we are calling our science investigations there's a series of science investigations that are done throughout Elementary School um Year bye that build upon each other and the assessments uh assess those skills that they are developing as one as well um so there's different practices ideas and Concepts that are added in but they do the science investigations are a key part of this so um some data on the science assessments from grade five as long as well as participation rates the next slide gives a comparison of um anora's scores on average in comparison to New York State and olster County so our Ela um 3 through eight proficiency was at 49% for
118our district um oler County at 39% and New York state for 46% you can click at detailed comp comparison at the bottom and do a much deeper dive of what that looks like math proficiency antora at 46% oler County at 46% and New York State at 54% for that assessment and then the science um that should be five and eight proficiency antor at 47% olster County at 45% New York State at 44% so obviously you can see from the data that our proficiency is not where we want it to be and this is something that we've been spending a lot of time and energy and effort working on and addressing I'm really doubling down on and speaking at the grade level and building level as well as District level this year excuse me so um
119administrators and teachers what are the next steps what's happening what what have we been doing and what are we doing continuing to an analyze the data to see what can we learn about the need to refine our instructional strategies as we continue strengthening the implementation of a revised literacy and math curricula you may recall from my presentation last year on the science of reading we have revised our um curricula for for literacy at the K5 level and we have a new math curriculum so when we're looking at implementation three to five years minimum five years is a much better dipstick of what the effect of a curricular implementation is you know obviously we've talked about it um the gaps that were created uh through um as a result of covid and our attempts and the
120actions we've taken to really try to drill down on that so uh branching Minds to continue on our current next steps um administrators and teachers continue to review multiple data points in branching mins to determine which students need extra academic support um in our AIS Services we've increased our AIS support in grades 6 through eight in math and Ela our K5 staff and eventually our 68 staff this year they're learning how the branching Minds data platform form can enhance mtss um our process that will really ex strengthen identify and help us to not only identify students who need support in specific areas um who need who needs it what do they need it in and are the uh interventions that we're taking throughout the school year are they working and that is a really really
121important question that we are refining our ability on how to answer that that and how to Pivot if the answer is no and also um our mtss coordinator Elizabeth phow is leading the work as we refine our ability to use the data that sits in our branching Minds platform to make decisions around evidence-based instruction and resources to close those gaps and we've had a um we've talked about mtss before we've talked about branching Minds platform um I've linked a a deeper dive into that as to exactly what that is and our finished mtss handbook which is a a really beautiful work of art for um instructional data Geeks like myself it really is our guiding star on how we proceed with this process and um next month in January Miss phow will be presenting on
122mtss and she can uh deepen or answer any questions that you might have as a result of today and looking more deeply into the handbook and things along those lines what questions might you have oh sorry trusty goodr um if you wanna you don't need to answer this now but maybe this might be a hard one because I didn't send you an email on it so um if I look at this and I see there's no advantage to get more students in the level four is that correct well not statistically when it comes to proficiency yeah I mean your your objective here is to get them to three or four we want students to perform as best they can so I mean I'm not it's not that for isn't great but if you're measuring proficiency
123it doesn't matter in that measurement thank you trusty Jerome I'm curious about page eight just those numbers just are strikingly high for um level one um and is there any like supposition like what what happened there there just seem to be could you give me a grade level please oh I'm sorry uh five okay yes I've been thinking a little bit about this and I was kind of working backwards when we really look at who are our grade five students and what has been their instructional educational experience that could perhaps address that because it does stick out um one thing I think it's important to realize with grade five um our grade five students were in first grade um the 1920 school year so the the year that Co really struck us the foundational work
124that's being done in first grade and then also in second grade which we know is hugely disrupted um it's really significant so you know my hunch is that when you would Trace back I haven't done this specifically but when you trace back the specific standards that they're struggling with which we can do and do when we look at the assessments when you look at the particular foundational times and years that might be um significant also um the way we approach literacy and our focus on Phonics that was not happening when they were in kindergarten in first grade so that is something that is different instructionally now um so those two things came to my mind because I've been pondering that as well trusty Lynch thank you so much I'm curious as you said um looking
125now what what do we do about this I really appreciate your approach and I was just wondering what metrics you're thinking about using to better understand if some of these interventions are working excuse me so we have um different interventions that go on both in the classroom where where classroom teachers pull small groups and work on specific skills and measure that in the classroom we have also have interventions where our AIS teachers our reading teachers our math AIS teachers either push in or pull students out where they're looking at those um working with those students specifically this year we have implemented progress monitoring tools specifically uh we're using um Ames web um that we've added this year again something that's statistically normed and where we're really looking at um research-based interventions when it comes to
126what we might do to intervene so we have a really um tighter line on what we're doing how long we're doing it and is it working so again I would just say refining the process we've also given given teachers different tools to measure that trusty kutson just a couple quick questions um in terms of test refusal do we know do do when PE when when families or kids refuse to take the tests do we do they do we ask a reason do they provide a reason do we know the reasons are we allowed to ask the reasons so I think it it it varies but we don't have a very high opt out rate now but they you can see there's kind of a band that sometimes it kind of moves in so I think
127um one thing that we've been working on is at the building level having conversations and trying to communicate with parents on the importance of the why of showing up for the assessment it's something we're going to continue to work with teachers because we know teachers are are the best um the best and first and most frequent means of communicating with our elementary parents and students as far as me messaging really um speaking helping to helping them to make sure we can convey that message across the board about the why because if students don't take this test then we don't have any data on how they're on this data point on how they're performing on a a um a nationally standardized test and there is um you know while I think that we certainly have really
128relevant and standards-based assessments that we create at the local level we also have our Maps assessments which are benchmark assessments those are nationally normed but the more data we get here um the more the better we can help the student we can help know the student and the student um and the their family can understand really where they are when it comes to uh not just looking at them individually but looking at them on a larger level when it comes to nationally or across the state because eventually eventually you know when we take things like SATs or um you you do get normed in that way and and you are evaluated in that way and it's important I think for families to understand that and have a um a look or maybe an early look
129or an early understanding on how student's performing in a normed assessment thank you and my other quick question was um you mentioned that you put in a new math curriculum recently does does changing the curriculum typically correlate to a dip in test scores the next year and um you also said you're refining instructional strategies is that in the form of PD or what what what is that so this is really our second year of actual deep implementation I would say go one year back and we did have some teachers that were kind of getting into things rolling up their sleeves trying something out but I would say this is really our second year of full implementation um so any type of switch could could account for you know a dip arise obviously but the professional
130development piece um in fact our uh the most recent um superintendent's conference day uh K through five we had full day um illustrative mathematics were in working with our teachers we have um since we've adopted that they've been in multiple times a year and a David trer our olster bosis content specialist is in the district two times a week working rotating through our K five buildings and um he really is side by side with us when we work with this curriculum when they learn about the curriculum and then he follows that up in smaller group rotations so um there's quite a bit being done um with that and it's it's really exciting thank you any other questions Tristy Jerome I think that you just spoke to this but I just you know as we look
131at all of the the the tech stack of the individual data of the students and how we we're small District we can go and we can work with the students individually um organizational instructional strategies that are sort of more macro um look at what we're doing in our school are we assigning enough homework are we making it competitive enough is it too competitive that people are up like I'm just wondering are those kinds of questions being um examined as well as just that very micro like okay this person yeah this micro level I would say those are ongoing discussions um continually and one of the really great things that we have been doing um within the past year or two is we're able to when we do a professional development we pull both elementary schools
132together so that grade two happens at the same time in both buildings so I really think it's also important not only for those to be kind of Silo discussions that are happening in an elementary building but that they are happening across District as well well because we want to provide um as much common experience for our students as possible regardless of elementary school building that's very important any other questions all right thank you so much thank you very much all right on to item 5.01 the Board of Education hereby accepts the minutes of the November 12th 2024 and November 25th 2024 meetings may I have a first trusty canson second trusty Rondo any questions or comments all right we'll vote trusty canson I trusty Jerome I trusty mitell Morel hi trusty goodr hi trusty Lynch
133hi trusty Rondo I okay great that's unanimous thank you on to superintendent district news good evening uh this is our last week of school before the holiday break so I wanted to start um by wishing everyone a restful and joyful break this has been a busy year so far and it will likely only get busier as we move into the second half of our school year so please rest up um as we mentioned earlier we've already hosted one Community Forum we're preparing for the second Community forum that will be held on January 15th all of these will be held in the High School Middle High School cafeteria um I did send out an email with the information and the RSVP is up on the optimizing onto our web page we will um following break be
134posting an item on the front page of the website and also have social media posts um I wanted to wait until after the break so it didn't kind of get lost in all of the holiday celebrations and when we get back people can um kind of reach clock that and put it on their calendars um please remember that uh although we would like for participants to RSVP so that we can have the appropriate number of tables and chairs set up please know that if you realize at the last minute that you can attend and you have an rsbp do not hesitate to join us um we want to ensure that everyone knows that they are invited and welcome regardless of whether they have rsvped uh this is the season of holiday concerts um um unfortunately
135for our uh music faculty both the Middle School and High School concerts were last week back to back but they did an incredible job and our students really um performed incredibly well our Bennett concert will be tomorrow night our musicians continue to shine and every concert is worth attending uh the Middle High School concerts were recorded and are available to be watched on our YouTube channel if you were unable to attend and would still like the um pleasure of seeing those performances uh we were happy last week uh to also be able to host the town of olive for their Boysville buyout properties Community Workshop we appreciate being a partner with the town of Olive in this process um and although I could only attend for about half of the workshop this was it is
136a really wonderful initiative and it appears that there are a lot of ideas that are being considered that would uh integrate these properties into the town and create lovely spaces that would be available um and enjoyed by many this presentation uh that was shared here in our cafeteria is also available online through the town and um I'm G to apologize now because I have about two and a half pages of information about um Foundation Aid formula study that was done by the Rockefeller Institute so I'm going to give a little cliffnotes um version of uh this lovely report that is available online uh so I'm just prepping you for that so the purpose and origins of the foundation Aid formula is it was established in 2007 to address the educational inequities that were highlighted in
137legal cases uh such as the campaign for fiscal equity and it was also designed to consolidate multiple funding streams into a formula that uh adjust for district wealth student need and local capacity and it really did um consolidate our state aid runs used to have so many more different Aid categories and it was much more complex and and this did simplify it um but the New York state constitution mandates a sound basic education for all students and that uh campaign for fiscal Equity really underscored the state's obligation to provide Equitable Educational Funding um and the foundation was kind of the response to that the initial design was based on a successful School District's model which used performance benchmarks um to determine adequate funding levels it included uh oddly an efficiency filter which uh would exclude
138High spending districts from the calculation so first the state identified a pool of districts that were termed determined to be successful based on performance but then divided that pool in half by the per pupil spending amount and eliminated the top half to create their um Foundation Aid so uh that already put us all behind the eightball so in the foundation Aid uh Rockefeller report the challenges that were identified were data accuracy and relevance because most of the metrics used in the formula at this point are outdated they fail to reflect the current poverty levels demographic shifts and inflation rates the formula is really overly complex uh and it makes it very difficult for districts to plan unless of course you're on sa of harmos there are Equity concerns because wealthier districts often receive disproportionate funding
139due to outdated or misaligned components and their the declining enrollment Statewide and increasing diversity among students really requires the waiting to be recalibrated and it has not been changed so the recommendations from the Rockefeller um Center include updating this base uh successful school districts model um using a broader pool of districts and also another issue is that the standardized testing that is used in the successful school districts model is going to be outdated based on the outcomes of the Blue Ribbon commission we're not going to have those same standards tests um and they also need to eliminate the efficiency filter which sort of pulls out those districts that spend more per pupil because that immediately creates uh an artificial ceiling for the spending um another component in the foundation Aid formula is the pupil needs
140index the current index is based on poverty um English language Learners students rece receiving free and reduced meals and Geographic sparsity this is considered uh an extraordinary needs percentage the pupil needs index but the poverty data being used in this formula is from 2000 which is then multiplied by a factor that is meant to adjust for the increased cost of providing an education to students in poverty but it's all it's it's taking outdated data and trying to manipulate it to make it more relevant and it's not really functional so the rockfeller uh Center is recommending instead of using that outdated poverty Factor instead use the updated small area income and poverty estimates for poverty metrics um and it's interesting if you look at that metric for olster County um we fall sort of in the
141middle uh the highest percentage is Ellenville at 24.2% we land at 13.5% um and the lowest with that metric is newal at 8.2% another recommendation um related to that pupil needs index is the metric that is being used for the English language Learners is kind of a a flat metric and they are recommending that it be scaled um based on the service intensity for those students who were receiving English language learner Services um depending on the student it could be a much more intense service that is required and then there's also a recommendation to adjust the sparsity metrics to to better reflect rural District needs which um may work in the favor of a district like antora um they're talking about shifting from the CPI that is currently used in the formula right now it
142is the CPI for the whole United States so they're recommending that it be shifted to the CPI for the Northeast um and they're also recommending that it be um an average a five-year average of that number be used instead of having it change each year based on um actual inflation so that would decrease the effect of spikes in inflation and increase predictability for districts which I'm sure all districts would um appreciate um they're also talking about trying to revise the local share contributions that they expect districts to be able to contribute they want to simplify calculations and align them with actual District wealth and then they have um included in that very lengthy report a couple of different potential formulas to use for that and then they wanted to recommend that districts be able to
143choose the most favorable formula I would love for us to be able to choose the most favorable formula I don't know that that's going to come out in the end but it was a recommendation um the report does also recommend phasing out the save harmless Provisions which um is what has kept our funding stable and uh at the level that it's at for a number of years the recommendation although is at least much more kind than what the governor was recommending last year last year the governor um proposed reducing the uh save harmless provision by 50% this year and the other 50 next year whereas this report recommends phasing out at least 50% of the save harmless over five years as the um Foundation Aid formula reforms are being made so that would be a
144much more gradual and uh predictable phase out for us and then of course they want to redirect the savings to underfunded districts with growing populations which unfortunately I don't believe we are in that um category another recommendation towards the end of report towards the end of the report is to allow uh districts to retain larger unspent fund balances so right now by law as we mentioned in our capital projects um presentation districts are allowed to maintain 4% on appropriated fund balance so that's 4% of the next year's budget can be maintained for those emergency situations that are not anticipated um 4% for a lot of districts is not a lot of money when you look at what could happen so the recommendation would be to increase that by 6% to a maximum of 10% um
145something that I see as a concern is that in the recommendations they they use the word reserve and fund balances as if it were the same thing and they are not the same thing we have reserves that are um legally allowed and created for very specific purposes unappropriated fund balance is the actual complete opposite of a reserve account so I'm not sure how that recommendation is going to um play out in the end the report actually went beyond Foundation Aid specifically and made a couple of other recommendations which were really interesting and at the very end and they include providing additional funding for the increased mental health supports that are being provided by school districts which would be wonderful as well as a recommendation for New York state to fully fund the transition to electric
146vehicles for all school districts which I thought was a lovely recommendation but very oddly appended to the end of this report on Foundation aid but I'll take it um and that's all I have because I didn't want to talk for more than that thank you so much any questions for the superintendent I think we'll have to digest some of that before we have any questions trusty Jerome it's not really a question but just to sort of like recap that Foundation Aid is a significant part of our school budget every Year and that last year there was a imminent threat that it would be removed that would really have caused re rot rot havoc on our district and that the this is a these are recommendations about how to phase it out but it does still
147look like it will be phased out and so it just impacts The District in that way that's sort of the real Cliff Notes on the matter I agree I think the real Cliff note is it was a crisis situation potentially with the governor's budget last year and now it is a a situation that we will have hopefully time to plan for and address as we move forward if if the recommended uh actions are put into place I mean these are just recommended recommendations in it it could be implemented in a completely different way but I would hope that since the state spent a million dollars in getting this report done that they would at least take into account some of these oh the other thing to note is that all of these recommendations were made
148almost independently in the report um the gentleman who ran this study made it very clear that although he may have an idea of how each of these recommendations individually would impact a district and there are a lot of tables at the end that show some of the changes that would happen were the recommendations to be adopted he never put them all together to say if everything that I've recommended happens to the foundation Aid formula this is what the outcome would be so it's very interesting way to approach it trusty canson yeah I just wanted to quickly just interject that if uh if you watched any of the public hearings that the Rockefeller um group had they were very upfront about saying you know we are going to issue this report it has absolutely no force
149behind it you know and that what gets enacted and what doesn't get enacted will be decided in the push and pull of Albany Politics as it always is so um but you know the OB as you said obviously they commissioned the report for a reason and you know this this is out there and it should be um paid attention to but but in the end it's going to be the legislative process yes anyone else great all right uh Board District news does the board have any news to report trusty jome I went went to Great concerts last I went to the um Middle School concert last week and I couldn't I couldn't believe how how many children were on stage taking part in these programs I actually kind of want to know like what the
150percentage out of the class the the stage was packed this theater which looks so big right now was was literally every seat was filled it was really really incredible and heartening and I always have to Big give a big cheer for that um and then I also just wanted to quickly say that with these vision sessions they're excellent they're an excellent way to familiarize yourself with what um we're talking about so please come um and that was it thank you anyone else I will just tag on to what you said I came to the middle school and the High School concerts last week they were amazing they were both really really great we have such talented students and staff um you know lots of support staff here uh teachers helping out keeping keeping things under
151control um really great and I just I wanted to share with the community that um the board had a very successful Retreat last week um we uh worked hard all day and made a lot of progress I think um we uh had our Retreat off campus this time at Oliver at the how is it the Howland house it was lovely and um and we really accomplished a lot oh there was something else I'll think of it five minutes from now anyone else all right okay uh we'd also like to congratulate this year's recipient of the ster County Schoolboard association's distinguished friends of Education award Christina signor trusty [Applause] Lynch thank you um the antora Central School District would like to recognize Christina Senor for the olster County School Board association's distinguished friend of Education award
152when I first met Christina we were sitting at little tables in the Phoenicia Elementary School's library for a PTA meeting she was hosting her first meeting as president newly elected her Bright Smile greeted us all and it was instantly very clear she was not new at all she knew most Everyone by first name and she felt back at home she had already served as PTA president when her two older children were in the school and she returned to serve when her youngest son Ashton entered kindergarten she brought all of her experience but she also brought food with a beautiful salad and matching bowls made a makeshift Buffet placing a lovely tablecloth and a vase with fresh flowers over an unused book cart she encouraged us all to enjoy it acknowledging it might be the only
153night out for some of us that month she arranged for child care in the gy she thanked us for coming and offered the principal opening remarks but then was quick to assure us that the rest of the time was meant to be our meeting she was there to take our ideas forward and to ensure that we make our beloved little school as sweet and fun for the kids that it could be and that's exactly what she repeated often it was a Beloved School and she made it sweet and fun for all the kids phoenicia's Traditions were kept alive and made richer every year Christina was involved her aunts and her uncle went to Phoenicia and her mother attended School in the mount treer Firehouse before phenicia was built Christina herself graduated from antora in 2001
154and went on to Sacred Heart University where she met her husband Mark working together at a student travel company Christy did two years at Sacred Heart and then transferred to PA College of Art where she graduated with a degree in graphic design they stayed in Connecticut and she worked as a marketing executive at Blue Buffalo in 2014 they returned to mount trer New York to so her firstborn son Jude could go to Phoenicia they moved uh into her grandparents property after they had passed just next to her parents the Community was so important to her her sisters her parents and extended family got their big sister back and so did Auntie she brought the sweet and fun to every single child and teacher in that school a school with elevated poverty rates she helped the
155administration make every kid feel special when they walked in she's the beautiful bright light who rolled in the hot cocoa and popcorn for a surprise movie day or created a pumpkin patch for a fall festival literally she organized a the local Farm to donate 142 pumpkins and place them in the sidey yard of the school so every kid could have the experience of picking out pumpkins in October when one of our young students lost both parents to drug overdose she sent our school counselor to the house with clothes and toys quickly donated by her PTA officers she organized Square dances talent shows Valentine's parties where every detail was considered light shows and photo booths with cake pops and most creative snacks she was of course supported by a DieHard team of parents but it's her
156vision and her ability to elevate every little event to make our beloved little school as sweet and fun for the kids as it could be in 2022 when the district announced a plan to close Phoenicia Elementary School Christina fought gracefully and forcefully to reject the proposal her Beloved School was the epitome of what we all value in Community Schools but shrinking enrollment numbers and infrastructure forced the decision and Phoenicia was facing its last year in its 60th anniversary year Christina was heartbroken but undeterred for the kids she organized a subcommittee of PTA and teachers to ensure the transition was appropriately mourned but also wildly celebrated every kid got a t-shirt that read Phoenicia School proud to be a part of it she advocated to bring three artists to the school to support the kids in
157processing the transition through murals theater and dance she and her PTA then pulled off a farewell fair with circus performers face painting a DJ food trucks live music and tons of fun some of the first class of Phoenicia were in attendance and teachers and friends from across the 60 years of this Beloved School all became all came to share in the festivities she had turned the cafeteria into a museum of photos from over the years celebrating all that this community gained from this little school in 2024 when the Phoenicia Community moved to its neighboring school at Bennett Elementary Christina was then elected to serve as the Bennett PTA president she accepted with a co-president as she was also named our high school booster club's fundraiser her dedication to the children of our district is unwavering
158I know she does it with the help of many other strong mamas a few wonderful dads particularly Mark and a Cadre of older siblings including lla and Jude but her standard for what every child deserves her ability to include everyone one and reach Beyond ingrained circles in our community her commitment to tradition and her understanding that kids need to love school to thrive at school make her this year's recipient of our award we're so grateful for your time your energy and your love for aunti yora and all of our kids and your willingness to close the Phoenicia school with dignity and Grace and maintain your focus on our kids and their experience is an example we all work to emulate thank you thank you for reading that Sarah and for writing it excellent all right
159finally our student representative report um Olivia please give your report and please do leave as as soon as you want to this is a long meeting it's really going to be difficult to follow after that speech um so some exciting news from ontora the ontora school newspaper the tal released their first issue this school year the newspaper includes student opinions on the cell phone policy club events such as the Beller bash 5K and a student oh and a letter from the senior class president I recommend taking a look um the middle school and high school had their annual Winter concert two High School musicians participate in all state this year and the middle school band recently traveled to the capital to perform Additionally the 5-we marking period has just recently passed and winter sports are
160underway and that's all great thank you so much all right uh on to item 9.01 the board will acknowledge public be heard comments from our last meeting meeting uh the following folks spoke Lori Madison Heather longar and Lindsay shans is anyone oh here we go Megan brener Hi Megan oh Megan let me just read the um the statement real quick uh the board the board appreciates hearing from the public including students on any agenda or non-agenda item please understand that by our adopted parliamentary procedure the board cannot engage in discussion or answer questions during public be heard please know that we hear you and we take all of your comments into consideration the board does reserve the right to uh to correct any inaccuracies or misinformation during public be heard please limit your comments to
161three minutes be civil and do not name any particular individuals or promote any commercial Ventures or products people wishing to express individual student or Personnel concerns can bring them to the superintendent's attention in private thanks Megan welcome hi I'm Megan brener um I mother to three amazing superhuman little babies uh one including a rising kindergartener who will go to Woodstock Elementary she'll be five at the end of January I'm very excited and twin two-year-olds Maven Wyatt I actually live right around the corner from Clark um I have 30 seconds worth of a question I just wanted thank you initially for presenting the school construction update it's it's really great to see and to hear some of the numbers and I'm looking forward to participating in the community Forum on uh next month or in February
162um and for the updates excuse me the Forum is in January January 15th and then the the updates the preliminary numbers should be ready by the 4th I believe February 4th so I'm looking forward to that I'm wondering in the wake of this recent uh presidential election if we've given thought um and if this was covered before I arrived today please forgive me for not not catching up if we've given thought to a future um and the construction the reconfiguration plans with this incomings Administration pledge to close the Department of Education um if we've if we've given thought to how that will impact the scope of the project if we lose all federal funding um um specifically thinking about the Federal Building Aid um if we haven't I strongly encourage you uh the Board of
163Education here everyone that's that been elected um to scope that out uh given this impending future and the truth for all taxpayers across the district thank you is that your is that the end of your that's it okay can I just clarify um for you there is no federal building Aid okay all building Aid is provided by New York State okay great it would still be great to scope out the future where there is no funding at the federal level thank you thank you Megan any any other speakers all right to item 11.01 um discussion and possible action the antor Central School District Board of Education hereby agrees to participate in the process of regionalization with the understanding that all future activities will be voluntary and not mandated by New York State education department may
164I have a first trusty Goodrich second trusty raand any questions or comments trusty canson oh you were just waiting to vote okay any questions or comments okay trusty kutson I trusty Jerome I trusty Mitchell Morell trusty goodr hi trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I all right that's unanimous thank you item 11.02 is discuss the school board Dash the school the board of educ I'm going to call it the School Board of Education dashboard topics and I've seen some emails about that with some suggestions um who would like to be begin the conversation trusty Lynch thank you I'm just pulling up some notes um this is a um an item that we've been talking about you know all um this since the summer and we wanted to revisit it because um now that we have our
165goals established I thought it would be important that we think about again holding ourselves accountable to those goals but also help helping to better understand um sort of the the biggest um factors that would go into our duties around the financial and academic um stability of the school district and being able to just make decisions more quickly when we've got some data at our fingertips each meeting um so that's the intention um there's I no um a full understanding that this requires extra work um but also I also recognize that a lot of this data has actually already been um collected and often presented to us it just happens to be presented maybe you know six or eight months ago and it might not be top of mind right I'm just reminded even by some
166of these conversations we're having around the budget process or other things so I just want to acknowledge that as well but um with that in mind I just actually in reflection on the Rockefeller institute's recommendations I thought well here's a few things that we really should have top of Mind in terms of um some of the criteria so to speak in in in their recommendations about how you might make adjustments um for for um uh our financial responsibilities I thought that that was quite relevant but open for just obviously discussion I shared a long list um over email that I just wanted to make um uh public and and bring to your attention the first is obviously aligned with our goal around attendance numers um I know we've heard from um the administration that that
167different the buildings actually keep this data differently so I think it it might help us to better understand how we saw tonight that the high school has this data for the last 10 years other buildings are not keeping the same data or in the same way potentially so just having a clearer understanding of what our attendance numbers are um would be helpful um a graduation rate uh the number of AP classes offered again some of this is just offered tonight so that's helpful um the percent percentage of money uh in reserves although again taking what the superintendent just said potentially saying you know what's legally allowed in the reserves not to be um um misconstrued with the fund balances two different things um having some clarity on that would be helpful number of students uh
168below the poverty line or what the um what they're calling the local income and property wealth threshold or ratio um the number of students in enl the number of students in special education the number of students on waiting lists for mental health services um some of these again would just help us understand um yeah the the costs um for educating our students and keeping um um yeah those numbers in mind and then um again relevant to tonight's discussion was the pass rate um for levels like the level three and fours on the state English language and art math English sorry on the state's Ela and math exams uh in grades three through eight those were just a few suggestions thanks I was wondering for the attendance data that you're looking for um do you have
169a sense of what you'd like to see I know our high school principal just presented average daily attendance which is you know I know we had the discussion um a few months ago attendance is different from chronic absenteeism do you have a sense of of which right and and the and the definition has changed of absenteeism too so just I wanted to be more I was and correct me if I'm wrong but I I'd like us to be prepared to understand the current definitions of absenteeism I think that's what's most important rather than the numbers that we used to look at which had more of the um 10% rates around absenteeism because they that seemed to be flawed it could be a medical issue or other issues we we really want to understand our own
170absentee rates so are you actually looking for absent attendance or absenteeism I think we we want to see absenteeism okay but I it's up for discussion I'm can I ask are we looking for unexcused absences is that the rate that we're looking for because um we have absences that are excused medical um which wouldn't fall into chronic absenteeism but what I'm what I'm hearing is maybe we want to we want to present unexcused absence data is it's also going to be a little bit different in the secondary because attendance is taken by period so student could come first period not be there for certain periods and that will impact the rate um but we can certainly put our heads together to think of a way to to look at unexcused absences try canson yeah it
171just occurs to me that some of these numbers are very Dynamic and some of them only come in every so often once a year even um it might be worthwhile just separating out and I don't think any speaking for myself only sorry I won't say that speaking for myself I you know I would not be monitoring attendance absenteeism on a daily or probably even weekly basis but you know it would be interesting probably on a monthly basis to know what the change is from the previous month I I I think we have to find a balance of you know when has enough time passed that we can make some meaning out of whatever the change is and what's not onerous for the for the administration and truster randoo I can just say so when high
172schoolers just because it just came out when they have their progress reports and report card so that's quarterly that that's tracked there so I don't know if that's a logical time so it's not making extra work and you're just seeing quarter 1 compared to Quarter Two compared to quarter three so it might be a very easy number to pull at a quarterly like when report cards are issued basically are those um is that data by day like attendance for the day or for the period it's for the period okay I thought so so maybe the attendance reporting has to be different for secondary versus elemente yeah okay trusty Mitchell moral I'm just surprised to see there's a waiting list for mental health services is that the case just because we they're just keeping like we
173have so few students so just not enough staff or I'm just curious so I can respond to that there is no waiting list for any students in our building seeking mental health support from any staff in our building where we do have a bit of I think maybe two students on a waiting list is for our Aster clinician which is our communitybased mental health support but if there is a student that is in need of any Mental Health support in our district we are progressively staffed in mental health and we will provide whatever support we can to help that student chesse Lynch thank you for that um and sorry just to clarify we made an investment in the Astro Services as a board we support that added um um service and so I think it's
174just helpful for us to know how is it being utilized is there a waiting list is there demand for more services that's what the metric would might be helping us to understand that's what I was hoping I can readily provide because I get reports from Aster every month their clinical hours the amount of referrals and certainly can provide um input to weight list I believe when my last checked in which was about last week um they had two people but they anticipated there would be no wait list as things were moving around so I I think we can probably say there is not a weight list for any Mental Health Service currently that we know of right now great I think some of these data points for instance the the ELA and math proficiency rate
175I mean that that's going to be an annual the graduation is going to be annual the number of AP classes is going to be an annual um our unappropriated fund balance is actually done every year when we close the books that's a one-time annual um our reserves are done annually in terms of the the way I think it was requested the number of students below the poverty line or the local income and property wealth threshold I'm not sure which um data to provide we can provide the the economically disadvantaged percentage which is off of our New York state school report card we can provide um the K through6 free and reduced price meal eligible percentage of students or um that data point that is in the foundation um Aid the foundation Aid report the um
176where is it small area income and poverty estimates which I think is more um current but is I'm not sure it's a relevant number individually so our economically disadvantaged percentage is 44% our k6 free and reduced price meal eligible percentage is 48% but the small area income and poverty estimates is 13.5% taking in isolation I don't know what that yeah I don't I don't know what the relevance of those data points are but I'm happy to provide any of them but they are also I think an annual number trusty Jerome um just around engagement um student engagement like Ela and math scores that like we reviewed tonight that makes sense I'm also again uh interested in uh students participating in our Sports and music programs just because it is such a big uh draw for
177the district it's and and um we do have such an active student population I don't know specifically it could be you know what we're offering it could be how many students are participating um but I think that those would be very valuable alongside the um um the academic performance oh then I also had one more around funding I mean financials um which was just you know I do think that you know how much this District depends on federal funding versus State funding versus local taxes that's of interest to me especially when um those two of those things are under threat so um that would be another suggestion Tristy canson sorry I thought of one more from tonight um uh device infraction referrals I thought that was very interesting Lance gave us the month by month
178and I and since that is a new policy and it's one of interest to me I would love to see you know if that stays stays at two this month or goes up or you know how it's doing the rest of the year any other suggestions all right um let's see so that was just a discussion right we're not okay great all right moving on to item 11.03 the discussion of adding an additional uh school resource office sir would you like to start that conversation sure I'd be happy to um we have historically had one SRO in our district uh who prior to this year tried to make it to every campus each day and I think was often successful um but now that we have over 80% of our students on this campus uh
179he feels like he's not getting to the Woodstock campus as um consistently as he would really like to um and this is the first year that when we've had the conversation about it um Deputy Sharon has said to me you know what I think it would be a good idea to add an additional SRO so that there is consistent coverage in our Woodstock campus um and I feel like it is also important we I feel like our culture even nationally has been shifting I think things are unsettled I feel like we have as a district very much focused on safety in the past couple of years we've done a lot to really tighten our safety procedures we've worked with a safety consultant alteris and they also believe that this is a a positive step to
180add that coverage to this other campus um and it would just be an increase in coverage for that campus it's not as if they don't have the services of an SRO um but it would be an increase in coverage because we recently received a $50,000 grant and aid from the Senate that is not tied to or earmarked for any particular activity we don't have any um large requests that we are unable to fulfill using our budget right now it seemed to dovetail with this uh opportunity to add a school resource officer the school resource officer I believe um was quoted to me at about 111,000 for a full year so we would not have we'll be lucky if we have a half a year by the time we get through the contract process with the
181county it would be my recommendation to go ahead and add an additional SRO so that we have full-time coverage in that building um I think part of the reason we have felt comfortable having not as much coverage in the past is that there is a small police force in Woodstock but the more that we focus on security and knowing that that police force is small they don't often have many officers on and if they are somewhere that is not nearby the school if there's an emergency they're not going to be able to get there in time to make a positive difference in a situation um so I would like to recommend the addition of a school resource resource officer at least until we are on a central campus um that's my recommendation and I'm I'm
182happy to have additional discussion trusty Mitchell moral um I support this um but I do have a question um what is it it's my bedtime um okay oh yeah I know what an SRO does like in an emergency situation but can you walk us through like a day to like what they're doing on a day to day I just am unsure um the role of an SRO although yes to be there in an emergency situation they are also there to build uh positive relationships with the community with the students most importantly um and to be a resource for all things in the in the building um we rely on our school resource officer as our partner in all of our safety drills and safety procedures but really it's building those connections and relationships uh and
183positive experience with our students and their families as well uh our school res resource officer is often a liaison and an assistance for our families so we have money to cover the year and then we would just figure it out for next year type of thing it would have to be incorporated into the budget next year yes trusty Lynch thank you it's a it's a wise proposal I guess I was just just curious because I do feel that there's also a huge safety risk with the lack of um Child Care op options in the district I worry about our k through6 Community quite a bit and the lack of um after school stiens for teachers um to reduce the number of clubs and opportunities for after school care um is another consideration that I would
184just put on the table for use of of unrestricted funding um I find it um both to have a safety aspect but also builds um a huge part of our culture and community and um when we lost that opportunity um in the Bennett School in the new configuration and and it's very widely felt um by both families and and students so um I'd highly consider that as well as a potential funding um priority trusty Jerome um I support that trusty Lynch um and that was my question I guess was were there any other options on the table it's it's a large chunk of change right so um important for the community to be aware certainly that we're considering such a thing and also um to I thank you for bringing up an Al alternative use
185for the the money and wondered if there was anything else that you had pondered it might be good for uh I had not considered something else for it I feel like the safety is our absolute Bedrock Cornerstone um and we have the opportunity to really improve that and that's been recommended to us so that would that was what I was considering in trusty canson uh yeah I my I've been thinking about this and um my feeling is that I I do support the SRO I kind of wish I didn't have to and and my thought process is I'm really mainly concerned that um we're growing to kind of an unknown really in all of our lifetimes um change possible change in the tenor of Civil Society in this country um based on what is promised
186to be done by the incoming Administration um and it's it they they are proposing to do things domestically that we just have not seen in our lifetimes um and if Civil Society does experience major disruptions which is possible it's you know it's I'm not I'm try trying to be alarm I'm going trying to say it's going to happen but it could happen um I think putting someone whose full-time job it is to sort of um think about the the the safety of the wood stock campus uh will enable perhaps the the faculty and and administration that's in that building to uh worry a little bit less about that and focus on the kids and and and teaching um during the day um and it seems like a very sensible thing to do at this point
187when we don't just don't know what next the next year and the year after that are going to look like I wish I didn't have to say that uh Amanda do you have your hand up go ahead I just want to say as as the um assistant superintendent who's worked very closely with Deputy Sharon in looking at our safety initiatives we are a leader in this region in terms of the initiatives that we have undergone in the training um in terms of looking at threat assessment and it is daily if not multiple times a day that I am getting alerts on my email that there's a cyber threat or a swatting phone call that are are coming closer and closer to home to the ne to the districts very near and neighboring to us Intruders
188coming in um so I think it's a it's a it's an unfortunate reality um I think Deputy Tom is I've never met anyone like him he's incredible he's amazing but he's pulled in many directions uh especially when we're looking at our secondary students bigger kids bigger problems we are constantly he's constantly mitigating threat assessments um and trying to uh support keeping our students safe and being preventative before something unknown comes on to our kid campus and that it becomes a full-time job just managing almost the secondary component of this campus so it it's I I see him trying to scramble and get to places and I worry with the growing number of threats that I'm seeing and the use of technology in ways I don't think we could have ever imagined um that he's he's
189being utilized in ways he's not going to be able to manage that so that's what I'm seeing in terms of the trends and I just wanted to point that out thank you trusty Lynch did you have your hand up okay trusty Jerome so he's dealing with cyber security threats um Can what does that mean is he getting on the computer and figuring out or they're saying they're going to breach or they're saying I don't understand what that is so we're getting the the some of the new trends in um in threats are swatting so we could get um phone calls or saying that we're going to we have people that have bombs and and they're coming and they're and you have to act you can't necessarily say oh I think that's they're just joking who's
190taking that risk um we have we have not had one of those we have not let me let's be really clear but to us that is a growing Trend that is happening in districts within our County and in our state and Across the Nation they're coming from all over the the place um he's also dealing with threats on social media that may come up or things that people may have said um even from other districts he has to stop what he's doing and work with our teams to investigate that um our cell phone policy certainly helps damp dampen or damper what what that's going on but still exists um and things that happen after school that may impact the safety of our kids when they come into school the next day he has to stop
191what he's doing work with our team and assess that and we take that very very seriously trusty Lynch I guess I just want to also say that um that reiterate that we are a leader in this work and there has been actually an issue when Deputy Tom was offsite and came to an emergency on the Phoenicia campus and dealt with it appropriately our staff are highly trained to prevent um these situations from taking place before he gets there and then when he gets there and then you know even in the after assessment so just wanted to make that known that we've actually lived through this reality where he was not at the phenicia school and a emergency happened um by potential poal Intruder the um question though I guess is just how um I I
192recognize we're a leader and I want to remain a leader but is this common across the district across other schools that there's more than one SRO in a school district on different campuses in other elementary schools okay yes it is much more common that there are multiple SRO than one thank you trusty Rondo I just want to thank the administrators for all of that information and trusty kudon you articulated my feelings very well as well and I fully support having um an additional SRO I uh was just going to say the same thing really trusty kudon um said it best you know for me um I to I totally support the addition of a of an additional SRO in the unknown climate and culture that we're entering into trusty goodr just want to say I
193also fully support having an SRO at Woodstock um I don't know if we should vote on it today maybe delay that till the next board meeting to allow the community to provide any feedback if they so choose hopefully that the community would would support this I just wanted to add that it's not on the agenda for a vote tonight we did put it for discussion only and in anticipation that we would vote in January and that as you said that would allow um any community members who felt strongly one way or the other they could share that with us any other question questions or comments okay to be continued at our next meeting all right we have a break built in take a five minute break yes okay we'll take a five minute break but
194really keep it about five minutes e e e to agenda item 13.01 the consent agenda the board hereby approves items number 1302 through 13.16 May I have a first trusty Goodrich second trusty Rondo any questions or comments trusty Lynch yeah thank you um trusty Bishop I wondered if I could make a motion to separate um item 1309 the Personnel agenda from the consent agenda I can answer that for you and I apologize if I F Well in my words I'm pretty tired um but if you want to move an item from a uh to a specific time link later on the agenda uh what you'll need to say is I move to postpone item number 1309 um which is the Personnel agenda which I'm anticipating is what you would like to remove yes thank you
195I just like to move it not remove it well we'll move it to later in the meeting so if you could please say I move to postpone postpone item number 1309 to after item 13.16 okay trusty Bishop I move to to move uh item number 1309 later in the agenda to after 1316 and so now you'll need a second and a majority vote thank you Amanda may I have a second trusty Jerome and we will vote trusty can I ask one question so what we're doing is moving it after 1316 but outside the consent agenda so that it becomes its own separate agenda item okay thank you any other questions trusty canson I trusty Jerome I trusty Mitchell Morell I trusty Goodrich I trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I and so that is unanimous thank
196you and clerk so now you'll vote on the consent agenda without item 13.09 all right so we had a first and a second on the consent agenda do we need a set do we need a first and second now that it's been amended did you want to do a roll call vote for consent first and then we'll move on after do you want to finish that and then we'll move on to the next sure so we have a first in a second and any any comments about the consent agenda um I approve uh this 13.16 ESP Special schedule you great thank you all right so we'll vote on the consent agenda trusty canson I trusty Jerome I trusty Mitchell Morell I trusty Goodrich I trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I thank you that's unanimous thank
197you uh now now we have to motion to take 1309 off of the table so trusty Bishop if you could please say I move to take the motion from the table and then we'll second that and have a majority vote and then we and then you can vote on 13.09 I motion to take agenda item 13.09 off the table may have a second trusty Rondo and then we vote on that so now you'll vote on 13.17 and that will be the Personnel agenda the new number okay so the board hereby approves item number 13.17 the Personnel agenda y may I have a first trusty Arondo may have a second trusty Goodrich any questions or comments yes I'm very confused we are actually now approving item 1317 we're voting on it we're voting on it we're
198voting on The Personnel agenda okay but vote to approve it and I I don't understand why we separated it from the consent agenda but a truste requested that change to be made okay any other questions or comments okay we'll vote trusty kudon hi trusty Jerome I trusty Mitchel Morell I trusty Goodrich I trusty Lynch no trusty Rondo I and I vote I so 6 I one no and I'm going to find my place on the agenda real quick and I apologize for going back um but we I know that we've already done this so we're we're gonna have to rewind just a minute um the board just has to vote to take that motion from the table I know that we already voted on that but just for the minutes if we could if you
199don't mind just going back slightly so what is my motion uh to to take um to take the motion from the table which uh trusty Rondo seconded but we didn't have a majority vote on that oh or we can skip it can I just explain what she's trying to say so the board um voted to remove the Personnel agenda from the consent agenda and said it at the end and then there was a first and a second to bring it to bring it back in sort of back into play but there wasn't a vote I think we missed the step to vote there and then because you have to bring it back into play and then you vote on it so we had a first and a second but I think what Amanda saying is
200we needed to vote there I see okay so let's take a vote since we already had a first in a second on that we will just vote on putting um item 13.17 back in play okay trusty kudon hi trusty Jerome hi trusty Mitchell Morell trusty Goodrich I trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I that's unanimous thank you thanks for your support there Amanda okay on to contracts and independent contract retainers uh so the board will approve all contracts and independent contract retainers proposed and that is items 14.02 through 14.8 may I have a first trusty Goodrich second truste Mitchell Morell any questions or comments trusty kudon I trusty Jerome I trust MIT Morell I trusty Goodrich I trusty Lynch I trusty Rondo I that's unanimous thank you on to item number policies we have a second
201reading and Adoption of policy 3310 School District records the board hereby uh adopts policy 3310 as written may I have a first trusty Rondo second trusty Mitchell Morell for the policies is it okay if I switch to all in favor okay any questions or comments all in favor that's unanimous thank you item 15.2 second reading and Adoption of policy 7240 Student Records the Board of Education here by hereby adopts policy 7240 I think I said the said it backwards the other time um as written may I have a first trusty Jerome second trusty Rondo any questions or comments all in favor that's unanimous thank you item 15.03 second reading and Adoption of policy 7242 student directory information the Board of Education hereby adopts policy 7242 as written may I have a first trusty Rondo second
202trusty Jerome any questions or comments all in favor that's unanimous thank you uh 15.04 second reading and Adoption of policy 7250 student privacy the Board of Education hereby adopts policy 7250 as written may I have a first trusty Goodrich second trusty Mitchell Morell any questions or comments all in favor that's unanimous thank you on to committee reports any committees to report trusty Jerome well the communications committee met and we had a great great conversation with Holly Brooker about um board briefs which I think she sent out a draft of that to everybody today um and that was the main content of the meeting I'm Sarah do you have anything to add to that thank you um she just sent a a draft to our committee so we've made a few edits and then we'll send
203it along to everybody and we just ask for a quick turnaround as you always do um because we'd like to get this out this week um for the month of December since it's our December board brief um the other thing that we surfaced was um we asked we result it resulted in a an offer to have a um a presentation or um demonstration thank you of of um a potential new communication tool for um our schools to be in two-way communication with uh amilies in in the community um something like the remind app that's already widely used could potentially be offered um across every building so um instead of by individual classrooms so we're just looking at different opportunities to increase uh two-way communication for the school you you said something like and I couldn't
204hear what you said um the remind app or um other apps like it um there was another one that was recommended um called parent Square thank you I was going to say parent swap parents Square um and it is um also widely used by many school districts with great um um interest from um our Holly who is our our consultant as well who recommended that we just take a look at it together as a committee and make before we make recommendations more broadly great thank you any other committee reports trusty kudon yes this is a report and a question um facilities committee met and we interviewed uh construction manager um potential construction manager firms and what that would be would be the um firm we would hire to represent us and overseeing any potential Capital
205Construction they would be here every day supervising the contractors that kind of thing and uh what I referred to earlier was um uh both of the firms that we interviewed uh indicated that they would help us with the pre pre-bond process um uh figuring out how to structure the propositions and also getting as accurate an estimate of the costs that we can possibly get you know with the understanding that s approval comes in the middle and and a year passes or whatever um and my question is um were we not supposed to vote on that tonight and I don't see it on the no okay we decided we're going to um have um the AIA contract done first they will be working with us um before that as well though okay because there is no
206cost for pre-referendum work that was the other thing I was going to mention that neither firm uh was going to charge us anything before the um for this pre-approval portion of the work so thank you audit committee we uh we had a audit meeting um there was we Monica did a presentation about the American Rescue plan and also went over a lot of what the superintendent talked about tonight with Foundation and the Rockefeller Institute and we did review a little bit the presentation that Monica did tonight about uh the bond and consolidation pricing and we were GNA we made plans to talk about the budget on in our next meeting thank you any old business 17.01 trusty kudon I'm sorry it's so late G be really fast um I just wanted to Circle back to
207something I brought up earlier in the year that's been kind of floating out there and and I'm the reason I'm bringing it up is because um it was a proposal I had had to discuss the book about uh social media effect on on particularly 10 to 16 year old kids I thought it was I read a book I thought it was very interesting I've been it's been my copy has been making its way around the uh School Board various trustees have been reading it and then uh it came to our attention that um a Red Hook School District on the other side of the river um through a grant from a um educational support Foundation they have over there bought 200 copies of this book and are doing the book discussion that I had suggested
208that um antora do at some point this year um for their uh families um I just wanted to Circle back it's not a very original idea this this is there's a lot of I think this book is really out there in the culture and a lot of parents of school age children are finding it very interesting um so but what I wanted to suggest is uh put the put off uh anything we do until like June because our our plate is so full between now and may there's just really not room I think um but I would I just wanted to put out there that I would be interested in in in seeing if there's an appetite to discuss this book in our like third grade fourth grade families because I feel like they're the
209ones that are reaching a sort of a decision point about how they're going to deal with technology in their own families and this is there's just pertinent information that I think um you know it's obviously a very personal decision but I think there's a very pertinent information in this book that parents of kids that age would be very interested in and I would be very interested in participating in a discussion about this book um but probably not until the spring so I just if anybody watched that meeting and was wondering what was up with that um I just wanted to Circle back to that trusty kudon um to what degree would you be involved with that in that book talk um so in I I have actually I used to volunteer as a book talk
210leader in um there was there's an organization called learning leaders in New York city that runs a program called book talk and I did book talks with fourth and fifth graders so I would definitely feel comfortable facilitating a small group um I would love to maybe this is maybe an RFI I would love to see if any of our anybody in our counseling staff would be interested in reading that book and just opining on it and maybe participating I don't know I if that that maybe falls out there outside their professional responsibilities but um I really I was thinking of something just very informal like um you know passing out the book just the way a book club usually works and coming up with some discussion questions and just having an open discussion uh the
211structure could be determined at that time but I would definitely be willing to facilitate and maybe other find other people who would you know because if if a lot of people interested you might need several smaller groups great thank you giv us a lot to think about it's a great idea trusty Lynch just offer to be any resource to you in the Bennett Community if it's useful I'm on the PTA and a parent of third graders so happy to help thank you any uh any other old business any new business any requests for information trusty Jerome um do we have an AI policy uh we don't yet but it is up for policy committee um okay consideration okay super that I was just going to request information around our AI policy very timely very timely
212good lead in okay thank you can I just mention that assistant superintendent lir um Works quickly like magic and has provided um the fact that or the data behind the request to consider how much Federal funding we receive uh we currently receive approximately $1 million which represents uh a little bit under 2% of our budget I will um bring that to the next meeting because it's spread across five different grants so I'd like to present that with the um intended purpose for each of those thank you thank you both any other requests for information may have a motion to adjourn trusty goodr second trustee Mitchell Morel all in favor okay that's unanimous thank you all and Happy New Year e