CorpusRecord 234204

Board of Education Meeting, 11-19-2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Board of Education
Date
2025-01-11
Location
Putnam County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,745 words · about 66 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening and is Tuesday, November 19th, 2024. The board will enter into executive session to discuss the employment of two individuals. I need a motion and a second lien are on the motion. Jennifer on the second. All in favor? Motion passes four, four. We will return at 630 for the public meeting. I'm all right. Good evening everyone. It's November 19th and the board is returning from executive session, so I need a motion and a second to return to open meeting. All those on the motion and Leon are on the second. All those in favor? Motion passes second. So we will open tonight's, um, meeting of the Board of Education with this motion. Native land to the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty

002and justice for all. So we'll start off with administrator's remarks. This is an overview of the story. Yes. Thank you. Uh, just, uh, recaps, uh, for Veterans Day, all of our builders commemorated Veterans Day with very moving and personal ceremonies, which began with the first our high school Salute to Veterans concert. Our district and community have a very rich history of service with so many of our students, faculty, staff, parents, family members having chosen to serve in the military. And it was beautiful to see so many of them highlighted and honored, and we thank them for their service. And, um, as we head into next week, I just want to extend my wishes for a happy and healthy Thanksgiving to everyone. Thank you, Mr. Andrews. Yeah. Just, uh, one more. Uh, tomorrow we'll have our

003monthly, uh, year one teacher academy. I want to thank in advance, uh, my Solaris and Judy who will be leading that session. Uh, the focus is going to be on strategies for our learners and watching them, uh, stronghold and school and partnership. Um, and I would like to extend a very warm Thanksgiving to our community and our side. Thank you, Mr. Carlton. I'm sorry. I'll give you the wrong thing to do for the remainder of my problem. Thank you very, very much, for that is very, very compassionate. Thank you. All right. So thanks for opening, doctor. Yes. Thank you. Um, that morning, um, we had first, um, all, uh, 200 plus of our Brewster students, uh, participated in our, uh, and JROTC annual inspection. Um, started early this morning with equipment and, uh, uniform inspection,

004quizzing of cadets and over and over, um, thorough evaluation. They needed an amazing classroom in review ceremony leaders for the early this morning. Uh, we can't say enough about the nature of this program and all that it does for our students and school community. Um, the area manager who visits dozens of schools spoke only in superlatives about our students, programs and instructors. Um, and we're all thrilled, uh, yet not surprised by how well it went and accommodations that were shared. Uh, some of them. And Slater, who is in the reserves, is also in attendance. Uh, as were a considerable amount of parents and supporters, it was a great day for and JROTC program and Bruiser overall. And another thank you to Master Chief Campbell and Captain King for all that they do. And since this

005is the last full week before Thanksgiving, you go first. I'm going to try to comment. So these these guys are not. I would just like to pause and express gratitude for this learning community. You know, yesterday and we had a follow up tragic visit, but we had visitors that came in for three days in February of 2023, and we had great reviews then. Um, but um, yesterday when we were sharing the progress that we had with vision 2026, not only were they sort of blown away by those accomplishments, but they started and ended with, what a nice place to be with an amazing, special community for sure is, um, and it's certainly nice to have that external validation, although we don't necessarily need that. Right. Because that's what we feel every day when we come

006to work. This is a great place to, to learn, um, a great place to come to school. People are kind, constantly demonstrate willingness to help one another. Um, so with that in mind, uh, that we say Happy Thanksgiving and a restful, rejuvenating holiday to all. Thank you. Thank you. Um, uh, along the same lines, I wanted to, um, point out some things we've talked about in some of the, um, the goals from our various schools, our administrators, each of the goals. And we talked about how important it is for our students to have at least one adult in the building that they relate to and feel that they can go to. And I was recently at a dinner for one of our sports teams where that was so evident for several of the players on

007the team and the connections that they had to the coaches, and it had nothing to do with a play or win or loss or anything on on the field. Um, you could really just tell there were genuine connections between these students and these coaches. So I thought I would highlight that because these are the things we talk about in our meetings. So if we see it in action, it's always nice. And I also would like to, um, recognize, uh, November 17th is a school related professionals day where we honor education support staff in our district, which includes our bus drivers, cafeteria workers, custodians, uh, secretaries, aides, and everyone else who supports the students, teachers and in the in the care of our buildings. So we talk a lot in this room about teachers and administrators.

008Um, but we all know that this school district doesn't run without our support staff. So thanks to all of them. And, uh, again, happy Thanksgiving to everyone who keeps going forward. And, uh, we put that in as a nice break. So now, uh, we do not have our student representative tonight so we can move on to the presentations, recognition and discussion. Uh, number one, district highlight PNW, Boces student of distinction. Yeah. Thank you. We'd like to welcome our friends from, uh. But I really want to answer both if we have Deputy superintendent Doctor Lynn Allen. Uh, you know, academy principal, um, as Jessica miller, uh, to present to our student of distinction, uh, Gabriel Castro. 40m. Thank you and good evening, everyone. Uh, my name Lynn Allen, deputy superintendent in northern Westchester counties. It's always

009wonderful to return to first year, as you said, Michel. It is a lovely school, community and community at large and driving up here. I have many fond memories of work with you and so many others around the room. So thank you again for welcoming us. But as one of our treasured 18 component school districts, um, we appreciate your ongoing support and partnership in all things, but most importantly, the support of our amazing shared students. On behalf of Neil Vuong, our District Superintendent, and our Boces. For, I would like to sincerely thank the Board of Education Superintendent and the Booster Cabinet for providing us with time tonight to celebrate our outstanding student of distinction. At this time, it is my great pleasure to introduce Jessica miller. She is one of our career Academy principals at our

010Community Technical Education Center. She will do the honors of recognizing our very special student of distinction. Hello. Anything real. So we do here. Ariel Castro is our November's student of distinction. I'm going to read a little something that your teacher, Mr. Reno, has shared with me about how he said that Gabriel was a senior in the construction electricity program at part of northern Westchester Boces is known for his exceptional work ethic, dedication and the positive attitude he brings to everything he does. Your teacher, Mr. Larry Marino. He speaks highly of his commitment to both his academics and his hands, hands on work in the program. Gabriel constantly strives to excel in every task he undertakes. But what truly sets Gabriel apart as his character? Because easygoing nature and kindness create a supportive and collaborative atmosphere

011in the classroom. Whether helping a classmate or offering a word of encouragement, Gabriel consistently goes above and beyond to support those around him. Gabriel has made a lasting impact on Putnam. Northern Westchester Boces and his teachers are excited to see all that he will do next. And you? We have no doubt his positive influence and strong work ethic will make him a shining star in all his future endeavors. So, uh, doctor Dash, I mean, you know, you like to come up and present Darrow with a couple of things. You know, a couple things, right? In that regard. Happened here. Okay. Second of all, thank you again for providing that time. We're going to go outside. It takes a few more for us and family. Thanksgiving to everyone one more time. Thank you. Okay. So, um,

012we will move now to number two. Discussion, regionalization and advocacy. You. This one. Sorry, the screen's not working, guys, but, I mean, if anybody needs to move, do whatever you. You shared some information on regionalization at our last board meeting, so we wanted to follow up with some additional analysis and thoughts so that the board can decide which advocacy direction I would like to take, if any. So we'll begin. This is over two slides. Um, with the definition of regionalization as provided by the state education department. And you can see the underline in some areas for emphasis. Uh, so it's asking for local districts to communicate what they that in the form of a strengths and needs assessment, uh, which will be submitted to you actually in a couple of weeks around the 48, 30

013pages. Um, from there, it's asking us to leverage this aid existing capabilities, town and infrastructure. So this is not an initiative where there's going to be additional, um, binding that's attached to it. Uh, in fact, we think it might be the opposite, but instead looking to see what is currently available, maybe not every share, but, uh, throughout that being the region and the regional conversation where districts are identifying, warring and choosing, um, the resources or opportunities that may not exist, uh, or that do exist within their districts. Uh, and then looking at, um, other opportunities throughout the, throughout the districts. Um, you can see on the bottom it talks of the urban region should you can see on the bottom, uh, it talks about an emergency regulation. And that's important because that is a, um,

014not an often used, uh, way in order to implement, um, an initiative. And you can talk about why that matters. Uh, so here's what region of the timeline looks like. And following our, uh, superintendent, as well as some local discussions with, uh, superintendents. As I mentioned, we have a strengths and need assessment. That is due a couple of weeks. Um, there is an expected follow up from both of you, both in the spring. And then, uh, in the form of a finalized, uh, plan for the region in October of 2025. Um, so, you know, take the rest of the school year to review that. And a regional variation. This regionalization plan will come into effect in the 2627 school year. So on its surface level, sharing resources is a good idea. Not that it's a

015bad thing to look to see what other opportunities may exist and other districts. The issue here are some of the questions and concerns that we have about the implementation of it, and what this could actually look like, that road. So the first part is why is is, um, the state education department asking us to collect data? They already have. We have, um, like I said, 48, 50 pages of information to share. Some of that is quantifiable, which we've actually gotten from the red, which is a state agency. Right. So we're getting the information from them. We're inputting into the record. We're sending it back up to the state. The second is, um, you know, and other superintendents have talked about, you know, the question should really be, how are you doing this already? You know,

016if if we if a goal is to get districts to collaborate more, how about we identified areas where it's actually working and and we we've talked about this to and previous um, board agendas. We've had uh, not just shared services, but we've been able to, um, uh, unite with other uh, districts for athletic teams, etc. So, so we do it where it makes sense, uh, makes sense for us. And the next part is this emergency regulation. So essentially what this does and the change, the process this is already in because it's an emergency regulation. The powers that are inherent within it are already in effect. Um, and then I'll get to that a little bit more. And when we get to the concerns and then what's the end goal. So how will all of this

017work and work at a policy level? Um, be uh, what will it be used for? So here's what some of the main concerns are. We distill it down into three categories. So there's a strong assumption and fear that this is somehow tied to funding. So the idea is or the thought is, you know, the timing with this, uh, with the Rockefeller Institute, which, you know, Victor has talked about and we talked about a couple of times where there's this foundation aid formula. And I also wanted very rushed Taiwan. They're going to come forward with some recommendations to get to the governor and to legislators. They're not binding. So nobody has to take any of them up. Um, but the idea or the thinking is that people in the state is asking districts to talk about

018the resources that they have and the needs that they have, because if there's a cut in any sort of funding region, this regional or nation effort may be able to sort of stop that gap or bridge that gap, right. Which is a problem because this if we're really talking about, um, sharing resources, it's not in any way tied to foundation aid or any sort of funding. That's what we need in order to survive. I was just I didn't know there was going to the second concern. Um, is this erosion of local control. So part of the executive, um, or the emergency regulation is that um Boces superintendent can direct districts to collaborate. So this is not about the current Boces superintendent. You know, Boyle is the nicest guy you'll ever meet and you're the greatest

019partner to have. So this is not about him. This is about the loss of local control for school boards. What the emergency regulation, as it's stated currently, it says that the superintendent can say Carmel and Brewster, you need to collaborate on X, Y and Z or your district. It doesn't really matter. They have the authority to do that already in this emergency regulation. Um, and the final concern is, is redundancy. So sometimes redundancy is a good thing. Um, but if we're already looking at and there's already some sort of partnerships that are happening with Boces outside of Boces, you know, throughout the region, um, why are that not where we're starting and, and uh, and leveraging these particular efforts. So and again, I know we were contacted by a, um, a school in Long Island

020and then, you know, this has, um, come to, um, more into, into focus given some of the meetings that we've had, you know, throughout the region. Um, so the board did want to have some sort of, um, some sort of revolution, like, we're not gonna have a revolution. You can read about that. But, um, then this resolution could address some of those concerns that were, uh, explained in the previous slide. Why the emergency regulation, um, why, uh, are we looking at a loss of local control and having school boards not able to have that say over those allocation of resources? And then finally, most important, and Victor, maybe give me an assist here on as if I'm not explaining it. Well, the the whole idea of safe harmless for foundation aid. We heard last year

021that, um, a number of our neighbors were impacted because the tax cap formula, um, had the state harmless um, aspect other removed, meaning that just based on the formula alone, some districts could get less state aid than they had in previous years. And that was a late notice, right? It wasn't good for planning, etc. Um, what what some people think is that this regionalization effort is almost a red herring for some sort of change. The foundation aid formula that will be coming out with the Rockefeller study, that could potentially result in less funding for districts. And then the state could say, well, we have less funding, but now your neighbor has this program that you have to cut to go ahead and have a partnership there. So what one of the options is if we

022do have, um, any you passed a resolution, um, that that should really be, in my opinion, be front and center because that is the the end game here. Right. Like that is what we, um, we rely on foundation aid in order to, um, throughout our schools, 25%. 1515. It amounted to 15% of our total budget right now, and 75% is self-funded by our own taxes. And then the other 10%, like so, 85% is self-funded. Um, it's like 7030. We're just talking to foundation aid, right. Because there are many components of state aid overall. Foundation aid alone is 15% of our total program budget. So if the board did want to act on anything in the future, you know, the donor meetings could be a resolution that has, um, any or all of those components or

023something else. And if we want to instead or we could wait for, um, the release of that foundation aid study and, uh, to find out what the thinking could be at the state level to further refine the advocacy message. What's this? I worked on the Founding Fathers study at the beginning of December. The right around in December. And now in the near port of new. So we'll know. We'll know what comes in the study before, I mean. We'll know it some from the study, probably by our December morning. If not, then, then in January. Yes. The point? Yes. So I love board meetings. We know that we haven't watched the last one, and I'm not as educated on regionalization as I should be, but I think the timing is a little bit ironic in terms

024of, you know, uh, a month ago we just had our whole advocacy thing on, you know, what do we want? Uh, the for the, um, New York State Board doing. We have this is like, this looks like a mandate versus, you know, anything else. And it is taking a lot of control. So who best knows the needs of their students? So regionalization, who do we get coupled with. How are we going to go hang out with Scarsdale. Um, you know, like there is just there, you know, when you look at the broad scope, when you talk about this all the time, there's schools that we want to try to emulate and be a bit more aligned. But the socio economic elements of our, our situation and what we have built over the last many years

025to serve our constituents and the number of kids that have parents that are moving here because of special ed and all these programs that we have. Like I just my mind is blown at the timing and the underhanded ness and the kind of nasty vibe to nature, in my opinion. Um, regionalization up to and taking the control out of, uh, of the school districts we share all the time we're going to approve tonight. You know, one of the things that we have to once again, allow our lawyers to be able to work across school districts. We have shared sports team, we have shared services, you know, all across the spectrum. So I don't I don't I don't understand the need for and the timing is, um, a little coincidental. Um, and also, you know, I

026think there's a feeling that it's a well intentioned effort, just not very well thought out. Right. So the what what does this mean down the road? Why the emergency regulation that automatically puts this into into play right away. Um, so it was just that it started with a mandate of a conversation. And now because of this, um, emergency regulation, it essentially says that these powers exist, you know, as they, as they are. So, you know, state Ed has been, um, you know, supportive with us, especially for the programs and grants that we've been able to build. And like you had said over time. Um, so I'm thinking that this is just not a this is a, an idea that they have that's, well, well-intentioned, that isn't necessarily thought out. And it comes to you. What

027is what are the impact actually going to be on school. And so because the timeline is kind of scary that they are not like doing we're doing the whole analysis. We're getting input, we're getting voter feedback like, uh, taxpayer feedback. There's none of that. There's a mandate sensitive setting on this. And I for one, again, my own personal opinion, I have never had any faith in any government. And they're wonderful oversight, especially when it comes down to like education programs and mandates they have they don't actually work. And you're trying to govern rural, suburban urban areas. And, you know, we are all of those things just in in our little two county, three county area where all of those things, how do you actually bridge anything like that? So I think we know where I

028stand, but I'm also very passionate about that because it it's it's quite infuriating the timing and the you, you used the nice word of, uh, coincidental, but it's, it's, it's, uh, it's deceitful. That's what I would say. As a little more clarification about the, um, voted to grant a quarter because this was an emergency. The regulation, the Boces superintendent can already, like direct leverage. Part of the regionalization plan can do that. Yes, once they know I'm asking. That was my question. Is that in in place now, or is that after the plan is put in place, that it's after the plan is put into place as part of its powers through their powers of the, um, then regulation. You have some Scott? Yeah. Um, I know today I was talking to somebody weeks Slater, and

029I was talking with somebody begging for support of aid and the hold harmless and the foundation aid question. And he goes to me. Did you hear about regionalization? So the fact that he brought it up and asked for tells me that this is something we need to. I'm not going to. Always passionately. Yes, Jamie, but this is something we need to take seriously, and I would prefer to get on it right away. I mean, in my mind, we work on the excellent suggestions of Doctor Ghosh. I point out the factors, and I would also I mean, if this is going to be a region, I would reach out to everyone related to, uh, Portland, rather Washington, because that's going to be every transaction. So these are the people we need to talk to. I would

030approach, um, Westport and see how they're doing it. Then we can see if they can build on the accuracy. This is something we're better to get ahead of. And then hopefully it comes out that so much of our just like some of the changes yes, I was making SD was making do last year, a lot of public government came up and they rolled it back. If we can get enough going in advance and I'd say, okay, they're on it and we'll have to do whatever the governor is on a multi-month tour, listening, tour, listening to people about our policy. While that is an important topic, this part's parts of that. Yeah. And then finally council and there is no discussions of no things going on. And I would whatever you do. I mean, I even

031asked him if he thought we'd have an hour, but if you ever need a support to reach out to Brewster. I wasn't speaking to 74 before I was, and if you broke the board and wanted to discuss it in any of the Assembly, our state senators needs support from a local aspect on how we really feel about this and what our real concerns are. We need to get this out now. So that's, you know, my $0.02 on that. So is it fair to say that the board is interested in advocating against or. Yeah. Thank you. Okay. All right. So we'll start with that. Um, you know you can do it any number of ways. We can then reach out by a, um, another board in an extensive letter. You can do a resolution on more

032of the resolution though. So would a resolution work for you guys? Yeah, it's a it's a more official act of the board. We vote on it. So to me that's more there's a little bit more weight than a letter. Uh, I agree with that. But I would actually like to see, depending on the level of agreement, um, more multi-pronged approach. Um, you know, um, reaching out to, uh, Putnam, starting with Putnam schools and the, uh, all of those within um Boces to see where others stand. I'm sure many of us, we could do it informally or formally, but if we're able to build, uh, a good yeah, a coalition of people and then go out for senators and go out to our local officials and our our, uh, county executives as a three county branch

033or half of, uh, half of Westchester, then, you know, that's a much more powerful message. I mean, I'm happy to pose a, uh, like the next time should go to a vote in a meeting on phones anywhere in the area. I'm happy to, to get, you know, 100 people there to, to to start protesting this. And again, I'm passionate about this, but I just think that, um, this timeline and I it's got exactly what you said about the phones. We're thinking about the phones, we're talking to people. And then this was just fully done through. So if others would agree, I think that we should do a multi-pronged approach that goes beyond resolution. Michele, you have I mean, you obviously have been talking with, um, other superintendents. Um, when you talk to those, um, surrounding

034districts on this, do you have any they have any um, I'm meeting with two of them tomorrow. Um, and I will I will definitely bring this up. Um, the, um, uh, lower housing council, school superintendents, um, put out a, um, a resolution, um, a sample resolution for anybody. So I wanted to do that. Um, and, um, I can most definitely reach out to the others besides formulating it tomorrow. Well, it may also be helpful if we could put one together to share ours with those, um, to share our resolution. It would be a draft because we can't, you know, vote on it until our next meeting. Um, and see if they would sign on to that or, you know, obviously they can tweak things the way they want, but it certainly wouldn't be. I agree,

035we're looking for powers and numbers. Um, but and it wouldn't be even if nobody else wants to do it, our resolution is just not going to be voted on. And so they haven't seen you know, obviously, the point is that we will send it to all of the various, um, leaders, including, uh, but all our legislators and, and everyone, uh, to know where we stand. But, um, I don't know, it may be helpful. I don't know how quickly we could get one to go with it, just a and share it, because it makes it a lot easier when you hand it to another board for them to just consider something that's already written. And I would imagine I have the same concerns that we do. Um, so that's a thought as well. Okay. Um, so

036are we on board with the resolution? Uh, yes. Okay. And, um. Obviously. We're going to need you. Um, but would there be, um, you know, would there be two board members who, like, if you're you're going to put it out? I want it to be on the next agenda. So, you know, we. We want to have it in vinyl before that. So maybe if there were two board members who could do it or sort of work in a in a subcommittee type thing, um, that might help us get the language. I don't think it's going to require much, but at least for a while already. So, you know, so we can figure that out. Um, but just a thought in terms of trying to get it, uh, in a file format as soon as possible.

037Uh, so do you need anything else from us? No. Thank you is to move forward. But are you aligned with that? With that? I'm very worried about a loss of a foundation. Even if we're not impacted back with public education. We need to at least the district's need for for planning and stability to know the minimum amount of foundation that they're going to get year to year. And that predictability is key. And I worry that this is tied to that somehow. But if it weren't, because I've been in conversations many moons ago with, um, Putnam County, uh, legislators that were like, what would you think if we just had one super amount? But you guys are nuts. Obviously, I have long standing views on this, but I'm just, you know, you're not comfortable. I'm just

038wondering, in terms of regionalization beyond what we already do. Are you aligned with that? I mean, you said it earlier. What we have been able to build over time is unique research. It meets the needs of our, um, our constituents, and we're continuing to get better at that. Um, I'm not opposed to sharing where it's actually doable, right? But the idea of a mutually beneficial but to take local control away from school boards, from districts, and to change the face of all of our districts. Um, because of that, you know, that because of this mandate, I'm not in favor of that. Yeah. Just operationally, if they do try to push it. Now we're talking about extended transportation planning for our children and other places on top of the electric bus methods. So I can just

039see this piling on top of each other. So any help will be appreciated. Thank. Okay. Great. All right. So now we're going to move on to create a small value created line change or call center school district. Regarding based on a fairways residential development project with the California. The girls. And. Okay, so just a quick background. So we were approached over the summer, uh, by the Town of Carmel assessor, uh, to discuss a potential change in the school boundary line between Brewster School District and Cornwall School District. So there's a residential housing development, uh, consisting of two such developments. So one is called Gateway Summit. It's in blue and following slide is. And then there's the other one that's fairways uh, which is on uh in orange on the following slide. Again, both of these

040developments have been approved for construction by the Town of Carmel Planning Board. So, uh, so I'm reading those two bullet points. Okay. So I'm going to go to blue one. Uh, it's a mix of 150 active adult, uh, single family homes as well as, uh, non age restricted fairways again in orange. On the next slide is 150 units of non age restricted homes with varied designs, predominantly located in the Brewster Central School District portion of the uh, of the development. So both uh, both developments actually bisected Brewster and Carmel boundary line. You'll see in a moment. Uh, again, both of these are located exclusively within the town of Carmel. So, uh, again, we were approached for Brewster and Carmel by the town assessor, recommending the school district boundary line be modified in the best educational

041interests of the future. Student occupants, uh, all attend one school, which would be Brewster and I. Bolded and underlined in the best educational interest of, uh, future student occupants, because that is the requirement within the York State Education Department and any boundary line modification. Uh, so just a quick aside, the Boces district superintendent, one of the responsibilities of district superintendent is to apply on behalf of the two component districts for any boundary line modification. Again, the New York State Education Department wants to ensure the best educational interests of our students. Um. That's fair. Yep. Um, I just want to point out that. First bullet under. It's the first stop. Yeah. Me something? Um. Simple. It says that it's not restricted. Um. Well, that. Yes, we're a portion of that are non age restricted homeless people.

042So it's. Yeah. So Gateway summit again. Gateway summit predominantly is in the Carmel Center. So this was put on uh to gateway. Summit is in the balloon and it is predominantly in the Carmel School District. Uh, and mostly, um, age restricted, but a portion of which is not age restricted. And it's actually that arm that you see that shoots out, which goes between Brewster and Car. This is the existing family. Yes, yes. Oh, might not be okay. Yeah. So. So this, uh, so this map, uh, was provided by the assessor and the developer, and it shows the, uh, the existing school boundary line, which is shown in a dotted, uh, reddish pink, uh, color there. And as you can see, the the the existing school boundary line does not match any of the existing lot

043lines of any of the properties there. Uh, and I learned through this process that that's not an uncommon, uh, situation. Uh, it was very surprising to me, but I learned that it's not uncommon. Um, so you can see the existing school boundary line, um, bisects both of those, uh, both of those properties. Uh, I should say both of those developments. Um, again, the blue is gateway. Gateway Summit. So again, this portion, anything to the north, of course, is Carmel. And I think to the south of this poster, except for this section here, which for some reason just up north. Um, so you can see again gateway summit. This section is is entirely in the Carmel Central School District. However, this small piece of piece of the arm is within Brewster. It then goes back to

044Carmel on this side. There was in the, uh, in the orange or the light brown here is predominantly in Brewster. However, a portion of it is up in Carmel, where it is again, this school boundary line bisects those two developments. So recognizing this, the assessor approached again, both Brewster and Carmel, uh, and made a recommendation for a proposed boundary line. Before you do that, since you're over there anyway, because this is what confused me. Can you. Because now that I understand where this actually is, can you just go over where this is located? Yeah. So because I think that was a confusion when we were looking at it before. Yeah. So believe so here's obviously Centennial Golf course. Simpson Road runs uh this way now. So I would say route 686 is all the way.

045Oh yes I think you're right. Right, right. Yeah. That's right. So we're talking about the entrance to gateway is north of Route Street, like route Road or Route Tree or whatever that route is in exam. Whatever. I forgot that that one is below the plot lines we're talking about here. And then Simpson Johnson's road and under the center. That down down here go through town and Fair Street is all the way right over there so you can see this. Yeah, you can when you if you're going to class. Yeah. Before like, you know like so it was all cleared away from way up the hill. And so this is the opening. But we're actually going to drive out there the other day just to see what it looked like. And it's, it's, I think the,

046the houses over here to the right. Yeah. That's going to be like the golf course loops around them. Yes. Right. Just for clarity sake. Like, just everybody gets it. The golf course loops around. It took me a while to figure out where exactly were talking about, and once I did, it made a little more than okay with the narrative. So with someone that lives on the border of Carmel, this is full on sitting in Carmel, like they're like, it's all the way. Castles into Carmel. If you mean. Yeah. It's so it's like the two of us, like, you know, like which again, I'm just pointing out the oddity of our squiggly lines, and I'm quite, you know, you're living like them. I know that really whatever has always been part of rooster, I know that,

047but I'm just saying, like, these are Carmel kids getting on a school bus and traveling all the way out of Carmel and going all the way up. These are rooster kids, know what I mean? Cause they're real, live in car, right? But there's no dispute. The entire piece of property is physically loaded located in town, but part of it is in the Brewster Central School District. And that's just that's not going to change that. And think about, um, think about um, oh my god. And like and hunters club. Yeah. And there's one is even closer to George Middle School. Yeah. But it's rooster school. So I mean it's me and a boundary lines are, you know, they are what they are. And, you know, we also have boundary lines within the town of Carmel and

048students who live within the town of Carmel already attending Brewster. Yeah. So I know I'm highlighting the illogical nature of all that, and even more so again, and this was a learning experience for me. Look at the existing school boundary line and this, you know, particular you know what it it doesn't even follow the the true boundary line of this property. Right. So that was in the top corner of your Carmel kid in the bottom corner right there Brewster. So that was, you know, again, another uh, incentive for, you know, for us to fix, you know, air quotes, but fix this to make the, um, the school boundary line agree to the, um, the actual lot lines. So this is what was recommended. So the green portion you can see, um, is what um, is

049currently Carmel School District would become Brewster School District. The blue uh horizontal lines is what is currently Brewster would become Carmel. And the rationale behind it is, uh, as you recall from the last slide, the vast majority of the townhomes on the right hand side are already within the Brewster School District. The only portion that would be Carmel School District, again, is that green portion. In exchange, Brewster would be providing Carmel School District, uh, with that, you know, the, uh, the blue horizontal lines, no question asked. Um, uh, the subcommittee meeting. Now, if you look at this geographically, it appears that Brewster is is yielding more, uh, land to Carmel than it's receiving in return. And while yes, that is true, geographically, the school taxable assessed value of that portion in green is greater than

050this value of all of the others in the, uh, the blue horizontal line. So that's what that's. Yeah. So that's that can make it commercial land which would then go to court again. He was asked, well what is the value of it. Well, currently, because it's vacant land, it has very little small taxable assessed value. But it's been over 200 years since the town of Carmel has been in existence. And that property is yet to be developed. So, you know, so Carmel's incentive is, uh, potentially receiving, uh, uh, commercial, commercially zoned property. Brewster is, uh, incentive is receiving no, uh, approved construction. And again, in the grand scheme of all this, what's recommended is what's best for kids. All of the students attending one school district. So just to move on to enrollment. So the,

051uh, plans environmental assessment form. So every time a developer wants to complete a project, the planning board requires an EAF. We have included a, uh, demographic report, enrollment projection, and the projected 93 school age students from these both of these developments, remember gateway, uh, which has a portion of of non-major restricted as well as fairways based on our existing school boundary lines. Assuming that we did absolutely nothing, it was projected that 68 students would attend Brewster, 25 would attend Cornell. Um, and again, the major issue at hand is several of those townhomes are bisected by the school boundary line. The logistical issues associated with that are incredible. Where you may have, um, you know, one, one family paying school tax to Carmel, but attending Brewster, in which case Brewster, then Bill and Carmel and vice

052versa. Uh, again, not being completely familiar with how it works with townhomes, I imagine that it's, uh, exponentially more complicated. Uh, and just a further note. So in terms of our enrolled in Brewster and I will be, uh, providing the board with the enrollment projection reports in the next five years. Just a look back of just five years ago. We are 128, uh, students. Fewer, uh, than we are today. So in terms of involvement, uh, even if there were 93 students that way. But then surely, you know, over some number of years eventually inhabit, um, these, uh, these townhomes, it would still pale in comparison to where we were again just five years ago. As an additional note, uh, we just learned this, uh, upon receiving the, uh, enrollment projection report. So our independent demographer,

053uh, uses a different factor for forecasting, um, future residents. So with all of these projections, there are different studies that are used to to use factors like the 0.86 for, uh, for every, you know, a two, two bedroom townhome and others might be 0.80. So, you know, there's different metrics that are used to, um, you know, to project again in a day. They're off the projections. Uh, but I did I did find it interesting that, uh, in that report, um, uh, the demographer projected 67 totaled, uh, students as opposed to the 93 included in the. I think I have a question on that. You said earlier in the past that it was 93 students for just a section we were talking about, but now you're saying it's 93 students for full. Yeah. All right. And

054if we're in total 69 for Gateway and Fairway, you know. Well that's my clarification because he had said what he just said was that it was for both. So that's my question. Is it for both Gateway and Fairway. Yeah it's it's for the we're only talking about the boundary line for fairway not for gateway. Well I think the gateway portion. So the gateway portion here and here that is in cardboard, so that those 25 students that are projected in here are the 25 students that would inhabit these these townhomes theoretically got the 68 would be in these townhomes that are already within the boundary lot. And again, it's, you know, to say that it's, you know, 25 here and 68 there. No, I want clarification for, you know, or are we're talking about like. The

055whole rest of gateway, are we? Or you're actually talking about the same section. So we're we're still talking about the same section, right. So so so this area these are all the age restricted townhomes. So these are all age restricted. The only area that would inhabit students is this section here. So in total this section here would yield again based on the area 93 students of which 25 would be included in this area and the remaining 68 in Brewster that are good. That's unless somebody eventually challenging the construction site. That is short. And the same could be said of any development, right? Right. Anywhere. So as of today, first year, we would get, uh, the expense of kids and get the taxes, but with the expense of kids. And Carmel would get no expense of

056kids and get the tax that Carmel would receive. Carmel is actually yielding, uh, school tactful assessed value. Yes, but but if we if we have $35,000 a kid, I know you guys are going to fight me on that math, but it doesn't matter. Except that we are now going to have more kids in our schools, and Carmel is going to have none and still get that. All of those, uh, age restricted people I want to make. So I do want to make clarity. Carmel is already entitled to the age restricted portion that is exclusive and then within the Central School district. And none of that is up for negotiation because those already exclusively reside within the Carmel Central School District. The only the only you know, issue you know at hand really are those non

057age restricted portions, which, you know, again, uh, you know, falls between the boundary line of both groups. So there's, there's no ability to negotiate what's already in Carmel Central School District. And uh, with respect to the age restricted portion. So so, so when I go shaving, there are 25 kids, right? That's that. Right? Then we have to decide whether it's in the best interest of the students to all people together in the program, as opposed to be exploited as it is, we're getting the 60 whatever or whatever the actual number turned out to be. I don't think any question that we get together is in the best interest of the kids. I don't think anybody would argue at that point. Um, but. My sticking point and I told Victor this. My sticking point here is

058the amount of land we are now yielding to farmland. And I know in Victor's world it's doesn't matter because it's not taxable yet. And I understand the logic of 200 years, whatever. But like the land and the golf course that we'd be yielding, you know, Centennial is not doing so great. So, you know, that's people in the land that could be built up at any moment. And if you're doing development, then all of a sudden this makes it ten times easier for somebody else to come in and do development, even though it's been I mean, all those places are 200 years that have not had any. Right. So now you have a fly by. Sticking point here. It's not about the kids. Like they should all go to school. It's the amount of other land,

059undeveloped land that we are building. And yeah, I don't see why we at Centennial already try and approach, uh, or build townhouses prior to this. So they've been trying to develop a golf course for years and then tell them not. But once again, we have to base it upon the fact that it's undeveloped land. We can't say, well, that might be one of my mavericks. So I would prefer to keep all the land. But we're going to take the kids. But that's you. It has to be a trail. But it doesn't have to be a tree. So you just said it's non-negotiable. Everything's flushable. But let's look at it from this perspective. If the lines stay the way that they if they stay the way that they are, then we're getting 63 kids. They're getting

06020. Whatever those numbers are, if we move it, we're getting more kids. We just took on more expense. Why would we give them land in return? Why would they get the taxes and taxes from those for those kids that cost a lot of money? That's all that is the bottom line. All kids cost money. So but but we're getting and we're kids and we're getting the taxes associated with those kids, which then also lessens the existing tax burden on our current family. And considering where that might be. Right. And there's no doubt that there could be development, but there's there's horrible. I you know, I can't imagine I mean, reverse the roles. I wouldn't agree to give up, um, basically all the taxes. So you get the kids and you get the land first. What

061was Carmel down there in Carmel if you asked for it? That's you know, that's we you know, they got they're giving up, giving up by the beginning of taxes. Like I don't I can't see us agreeing to that. But we're reverse. Okay, but it's on a townhome. We're looking at. What? On a tax bill. What's a Hunter's Glen townhouse? I think so it's probably $6,000. So now we're going to get $8,000. Like having having 90 kids and getting $8,000. That's that's not a huge influx to manage. You got special ed kids in there. You have kids that we're going to have to send. Externally to other schools, we have a whole host of things that are going to happen. So just, uh, to touch on the tax impact. So in calculating what the tax impacts

062of this boundary line change would be, we have to perform this in vacuum. Right. Assuming that nothing else changes within the tax base. Again this is highly unlikely scenario. But just for the purposes of crossing out what this impact will be, uh, in assuming the or accepting the assessor's recommendation, moving a boundary line, it was result in a small tax rate decrease across the board. Obviously Carmel's impacted more because it's within their town. Uh, but a home in the town of Patterson and town of the, uh, southeast, respectively, would see a decrease in their school tax bill of $17 per $100,000 of school taxable assessed value. So to groups, you're seeing obviously a tax benefit. What was the cost that we've put against these numbers. So, um, bus aides, bus drivers, gas teachers as it

063relates to the tax rate. Exactly. So it's not factoring in. We actually put that up and I say, oh, we're going to save $17, $73 exclusively as it relates to a tax rate. Know. Exactly. But now what are all the costs that are associated with 90 something kids? You know, the same could be said of 90 kids who move into all different houses throughout the entire school year, except that we don't have, you know, we just saw a decrease in the in the report that we're going to see a little bit later today. We actually saw a decrease in the number of houses, which I don't know how that happens. Uh, but we have like, uh, like 500 or something less residences with within our town. So we, we don't necessarily we are seeing over

064the last ten years a 10% decrease of the number of kids that are attending Verster. And so we're not expecting a huge influx, although I know we're going to see today is that we're going to see a slight uptick. But we have problems at JFK. We have four trailers sitting on our grounds because we have space issues. And £0.93 actually impacts our space issues. In your review. Again I'm sorry that so if if no change is done, the number of students that come to us on that one. Okay, we're at 68 and we're talking about 45. If we agree to this, change it 2525 and that's based on that. Yeah. If we were relying on the demographers for different, uh, calculation, I think it's, um, 15 students as opposed to 25. But at one point

065Kamal sent us a letter saying we'll take all weekend. So Kamal asked the developer to change their model and put all of the senior housing in Brewster, and they wanted all projects and that was never acted upon. I also want to make clear I'm completely indifferent to whatever the board decides. My role is simply to relay to you. I'm fired up tonight. Not by anything but what's been provided to me and the recommendation made by the assessor. You should put this one before the I think. And I also I do feel strongly and I think we've kind of agreed reluctantly. What's best for kids is that everyone attends one school district. I agree with that. They just walked away with the tax dollars and no expense on the kids. That's a big thing. So what

066Carnival is actually agreeing to is, is yielding school taxable assessed value to Brewster that they are otherwise currently entitled to. So you know say Carl's yielding to Brewster school tax assessed value of that portion. And yes potentially 1520 kids in school taxes. I have three kids like you put three kids in a 7000 $8,000 town home. You like that is the thing that $14,000. Yes. They're taxes from all of the other things that we spend money on and so forth. But that is always my count, is how much you get from a house tax to how much we have to pay for what we not. What would your salary you know, the assessor provided this recommendation as well. Now when you say all or nothing, what is that mean? Like let us take all the

067tax of all the kids and all the taxable housing or none of it. So in other words, you're requesting Carmel to provide you with the entire top left corner. That's right. Now, exclusively within the Cardinal Central School District, the non age restricted portion. Be a pipe dream and they'll never go for it. But they did come and say we'll take all of the taxable income from from it from you and for them to accept. Well what they'd ask is that they flip it. They simply ask to be limited. What you're asking of them is group for Kamal to provide Brewster with a, uh, a load of school taxable assessed value that's currently and exclusively situated in Carmel Central School District. They would be really, uh, increasing taxes on their community in order to shift that

068to Brewster. It would never happen. Well, there's nothing built there right now. It's it's zoned in corn. It's to be built. Right. But it's not it's not shifting. It's not increasing their tax base to their consumer. So to their to their constituents. Right now it's adding school taxable assessed value to all of their remaining residents. So everyone is going to see it. That's a that's a future. That's not a it's not going to increase their constituents tax bill. Or when the when these houses come on the books it will it will eventually decrease their, you know, the tax burden on them. Exclusive to this. If they were to give it to Brewster, they would be saying to their existing community, we're not giving you this tax benefit, we're going to shift its Brewster and said

069so their residents can receive that tax benefit, right. That's never going to happen. And all these kids that's it. Income. Well if we're just talking about the the senior to, uh, the senior uh, portion, there is no enrollment issue with that on the and my point is that as a patron, I would be absolutely never happy if you were to present to me and say and say, Victor, can you look into this? What would this mean if we gave Kamal a, uh, a senior, you know, senior living facility, um, you know, located near the Carmel border? I would tell you, you would be effectively raising taxes on all of the remaining residents if you were to do that, if we took on the senior living facility and didn't have a formal would be losing is

070what I'm trying to explain to you. But they asked for that. That's exactly what they did. For he did. And they they what they asked for was not not to to give it to Brewster. They asked for the, uh. Yeah, I know, but I would rather I would rather have followed along on that path and say, let's flip it and let's get the taxable income from an age restricted living situation and give these kids to Carmel. And my question is, is like, I understand, like nothing went anywhere. And, you know, town Councilman Laka was actually said we never responded. So my question is what has the developer said? Is that is that still viable? Is that still on the table for calm? These are my understanding is that they're already under contract. And I did

071drive out there and they are already being built. Um, so this is this is moving forward. I think it seems as if there's three options here. We one option is to keep it the way it is, which. Doesn't keep all the kids. Nobody wants to live stream. The second option is this option that is being presented to us, where we take the kids and they have the right land up there that's currently not built. And or the third option is some, you know, we need some portion of that land, but I don't know. And I don't see from Carmel's perspective necessarily why. They would go for that. But I think the only really negotiating point is the strike areas up there. I agree with you that that because we want to put the kids together

072and what it is. But then, Victor, where did this. Come from. I understand the assessor's recommendation. But why are we like. A hold is on the right word. But why is this all we're looking at? Were there other options or are there other things negotiated along the way? Like how was it decided that we would see this much land? And I understand what you're going to not tell me about houses, but like, where was that decided that this was the plan. So the primary obviously the primary approach, we have to make sure that the boundary line that concluded off. Yeah. That's right. Right. Starting with that, that very small green portion is has as a very large school taxable assessed values. So the assessor then looked and said okay well how can I balance this

073equation. So it's not a, you know a complete without with Brewster, you know, robbery of, you know, school of taxable assessed value. Uh, and he proposed again trying to, um, close the school boundary line along with the existing lot lines for, for the town, which is why the top boundary line goes straight across, um, as opposed to the existing, you know, gerrymandered, um, you know, rectangle out there and then coming back down the line and going in a straight line. Um, and that meets the existing boundary line of um, of that area. So again, it, it was recommended in an effort to somewhat balance the equation. Again, Brewster is still, you know, cutting head back on the school taxable. So can you put the other picture up the existing okay. So. And the one little

074corner is the boxed up top, and it's the only sort of download. But it. It's like half of both of the commercial, the commercial outs at the bottom. So it's like a potential residential. Rectangle at the top. And then. You know, half of to, um, commercial. What's at the bottom? Right. Right. Yes. Right. So it comes down below that it sets, and then it meets every. Where's the line? But when you go up there, there's a fake, like there's there's one house and then there's space here. Yeah. But we're going to try to channel left and then you have a fake light with that interference. That's the right way to do this. And I did again I did drive all the way up there. They're already starting to build I believe this action up there

075okay I got what if they were to build and that guy came on up? I think that's what they want to talk about. And if that was the I mean that's it could happen. We cannot control what happens in the future to rally this property. I mean, they if it's there, if it's theirs, it could be built on and they could receive the taxes from that property. That's that's a definite. But I think that's the argument in it. Maybe. Yeah. That's a down at me. So like there's potential to build a significant number of housing on there. But do we go to Centennial. Oh yeah. Yeah that's Centennial, that uh square at the top. And what about Townsville? What do we know? That's 171. Sorry, I can't read. Um, I don't know. Okay. But in

076the families Isabel and I. So the only thing going on right now is gateway is being built, right? There's clearance on both areas, but the only construction currently. Doing escape like that been going on in a bad way at this time. So whenever that goes on, then it becomes an issue. When it's built. Then we decide in Palo Alto where the kids are. They're even going to be kids. A lot of times they over inflate the number of kids or the growth rate over the number of kids, but you just have to go with where we are today. And also what is the actual. Authority of a school board when it comes something like this, is it to negotiate? Yeah. We both, both school boards have to agree, but apparently they have to reach an

077agreement. Right? Is that the school boards part or is that that's in the tax section in this case the property's all in Cornwall. So the only tax assessor involved is the Cornwall tax assessor. Southeast tax that's that would represent our site is not involved in this at all. Right. So they don't have to say town of South East legislator legislative doesn't have to say it's all been decided. And they're basically purely on the value as it is today because we can't go one way. Well, they gave us this whole part of yeah that it's built on. And that part doesn't get better than it was when it was reversed. We don't know. So we'll just have to go with where we are today right on the options that we've been given. I agree with Dan.

078I don't think we should see that much land. And I think that especially these lower lots, I mean, lot one, uh, obviously you have a, an intersection of that, but that is viable, viable land for commercial. Um, and I don't think we should be giving them vote on whether we keep it as it is. Are we? We do say, well, I think there's, um. Victor, correct me if I'm wrong. I mean, this is still a negotiation. Yeah. Uh, we we assume that we're going to present this evening, and the board was, you know, heavier than we were before the resolution. But, you know, I don't mean I mean, I think we go back to the, uh, I just think it's going to be a no. We're going to miss this meeting. Sorry. And again, it's

079perfectly fine. I just think that we can, you know, send Victor back and say, even though on what is, you know, projected right now, we're doing better than you. We are doing better in that. I don't know if Harry like being on my call, but Carmel people were like, yeah, we're all for it. Probably like it wasn't costing anything. They weren't like it wasn't what they. What would be the proposal? You know, I don't know, we just I don't I don't know what the negotiations were up to this point, you know, but I don't think in terms of the negotiations or whatever conversations, it was this proposal. But I don't know. I guess it's why why are we beholden to this proposal? Like, I understand that is the Carmel assessor's numbers. I get all of

080that. But we aren't I mean, we don't we don't I get it. But like but this is the only thing we're being offered, right? This is the only answer we're being offered. And I think that's that's what I meant by the whole thing. Right. This is the only thing we're being offered. Um. There's a genius, a genius point. Or at that point, like no one else is looking at this except carpet. So yeah, like, why can't our tax assessor. So if we're talking about the movement of tax line, why can't our tax assessor be part of that conversation? Technically our tax assessor we have three of them. We have one in Santa Patterson, one in southeast and one in Carmel. So, you know, like I know the town of Carmel is where this exists, but

081I would hope that any of our assessors would be objective in presenting any proposals to any of the school districts within where they cross within those towns. So, you know, again, we have three assessors, one in Carmel, one in south east, one in Patterson. Why? Why not ask the Patterson town of the assessor the same question? Because it's not bordering. It's bordering it like. Okay. Fair point. I still think that along gender lines where. So if you have a proposal that you'd like for me to to go back to Carmel, I'd you know it. Certainly. Well, I think that would be more of a like a work session for us to discuss. I mean, we could do it all night. These kids are going to be miserable. Um, but I think it's definitely something that

082we have to either put on the agenda for next meeting or have a work session to talk about it, because I think it is a little bit bigger, and it's also out of our realm of knowledge base. So we'll make some stuff up and happy to put that back. But you know, it's a that's I want to talk about the tax assessor because you think you're like these are people that that have no expertise in it. Like that's what I was. That's what I was seeking. Well. Kind of. I mean, so it seems as if we are, you know, not going to adopt, um, what's currently being proposed. Um, I have no issue with a work session, but what we, you know, we need to sort of have some idea of what information we're going

083to need for that. We also could go back to Kabul and say that's, you know, the border. It's not good enough for Brewster. They could always propose something different to us. But, I mean, we can't just have a work session and look at this and say, you know, we need to know who owns what. You know, where the boundary lines are. Is that whole. Not a lot because I can't remember the the straight lines on the bottom left. Is that one taxable loss. Yeah. Uh, no, there's, there's several of us. And I don't know that it necessarily matters. Yeah. Who owns them? Um, because we're able to amend the boundary law. I do know that it's, uh, vacant commercial land. So there's no impact on students. You know, at this moment, I guess it would

084be then what lines? I guess, because maybe it's there's three lots on the bottom left and we keep one. You know, I don't know, but I don't know that we're going to know any better in a, um, in a work session. That support we know is appropriate. Could you decide? Go back to cargo. Give me a vessel. Well, I said no because you could give me a property like that. Listen, I don't know. I don't know the values. I don't know the captains schedules. I mean, it looks like a lot. And if it turns out that they did. Yeah, we got handed a delegate, but we don't know that. And we have no experience sitting anyone here. And I don't think we're going to putting in the time of some intercessor to a work session

085and ask her to give us our opinion on the appraised value of the land, because I picked this and they're going to say, this is the right side of the land. If we feel as a boy that we want a little less just I don't know. Just say, is there another offer? Well, I think I would like to guide you a little bit. So like that top that top box over there is, um, residential. The top box is currently on the golf course. Um, you can build. Okay. So if you cut that in half and you say right, at any point in time, if this gets developed, the lower half, which are rooster kids down there, girls hangs out with rooster, the top half girls hangs out with Carmel. And then we divvy up that.

086Then I would be much more comfortable than we do half an hour on the commercial. I don't think we should be ceding the land. Yes, we're giving them bats that that forage. But if we factor in the number of kids and the expense of kids, and they're walking away with no expense in, that's a pretty big deal. I just want to make sure I'm clear in what you're suggesting. Are you suggesting that it be conditional so that it be given to Carmel until or otherwise? No. I'm sorry. I'd like to bring it up now just to give us some. You guys get the top box, we get the bottom of the residential, and you get the right side, and we get the left side of the commercial. Um. I'm sorry. I was having trouble. Just,

087uh, you know. Yeah. Uh, then, like, this sits next to Brewster kid, so we could divide that and say, break down here. Are you? If you if anybody ever builds. These are still Brewster kids. These are Kamal. And then just split this up and say, great. This sits next to Brewster. You got we'll take this. And Kamal think that. Because it is just kind of everybody making it up. Yeah. I just don't know if because I believe that the, the, um, proposal is following the existing lot lines. So and I don't know if certain other. Yeah. And I have to have that order that could all be one line. So. Yeah. We were to, to make that proposal. We may be having a similar issue where like the school boundary line and, uh, you know,

088just take the top part of the Centennial golf course portion. We would have the same scenario if, you know, eventually, you know, that didn't become developed, where we'd have the same issue, where we have the school boundary line going through. Yeah, that we're potentially we will. And then we'll have to sit down and negotiate again at that point. But I don't think that we should be ceding land that could potentially be something. So so again I just want to make sure. So what you're suggesting is so again, this is already Brewster. What you're suggesting is keep this Brewster. Um, and you know, this, uh, part of the Commons. And then down here, I mean, the boundary line itself is, isn't there like the what didn't they say in the meeting that there that there were

089lots combined or one that had lots combined and the other map didn't have a lot line or something? Yeah. Down there. Yeah. I it was one of these I want to say this says loft five. And again I'm not familiar with, you know, where this lot ends. I think he said that this one was subdivided. Yeah. The other map had other a lot of time. Right. But there's some conversation in the meeting about resolving that actual the lot lines in one of the maps were not the lot lines anymore. So so again, just theoretically, if I were to, to call him keep this rooster, can you shift that to Carmel and then down here, what would we do with this area. Keep block one. So so that would say rooster. She wants the 1916 and

090then this would go yeah, this seems a lot. The that lot is further away from rooster. That's the commercial park. Yeah. They're all commercial and all these all down on the bottom. Yeah. Dissimilarity. And this again is slightly strange to. Okay. So. That you'd like. Is that all right with everyone? I mean, it's it's a collective decision. Yeah. Um. Okay. So we can go back with that and and see what the assessor has said. Well, the good news is I wasn't around for the meeting itself. Well, actually, we got on. So, um, the this timeline, uh, is now going to be obviously time. Um, and we'll, uh, reach back out to the assessor. I'll inform, uh, my general partner, Kamal. Uh, and we'll, we'll go from there. Um, so I've decided an update on our

091next board meeting. All right. Thank you. Lieutenant. All right, uh, we'll move on to public, uh, remarks. So it's our first opportunity for public remarks. If anyone has any comments they'd like to make to the board. You can do so by going to the podium. Um, stating your name. Every speaker has three minutes to make whatever remarks they'd like to make. We just ask that you direct your comments to the board, and that you not identify any students or staff in your comments, if that's something that you feel that you need to do. We ask that you do that by email to the board and the superintendent, which is BOE at Brewster Schools Dot board. So if anyone has any public remarks, this first opportunity for public remarks is limited to our action items on

092the agenda, which is um D and E on our agenda. So we ask that this remarks period is only limited to those action items. There's another opportunity for remarks at the end of the meeting that is not limited. So if anyone has any remarks you'd like to make with respect to the action items, please make your way to the podium. Okay. I don't see anybody here in the meeting and we did not receive any emails relating to action items, so we will move to action items. Action item number one acceptance of Enrollment Rejection Report 2025 2026 through 2029. Group three. Yeah. So each year we request an independent demographer to prepare an enrollment rejection report. So our report this year prepared uh, by statistical forecasting, uh, projects, our enrollments have remained relatively stable over the

093next five years. Uh, we missed out there earlier on volume been declining by about 1% for, uh, recent past and years. Um, and we present that to you, and you're exactly right. All right. Thank you. Can I have a motion and a second for this item? General. The motion start on the second. Anyone have any questions or comments? Hi there. Um, so as I mentioned in the census, uh, and I know you don't manage the census or anything like that, but the housing units did decrease over the course ten years. We don't see a lot of tear downs happen in Brewster. We've actually seen housing built in Brewster at that same thing. So I'm just wondering when we look at, uh, taxable homes and dwellings, like what is the. Do you know of the reason

094for that? It's not like anything that we're seeing that we see in our, uh, in the income we get for the fact that from taxes, I'm showing them. No, I mean, uh, obviously we're aware of the commercial growth within, uh, within Brewster, but not necessarily residential growth. Um, you know, there are. He does reach out to the, uh, planning boards of each of the three towns. Uh, and there's a section, um, that projects, uh, risk, um, in response to, uh, any new housing that that comes about. Um, so that is on page 33 of the report. So there, uh, you know, a number of housing developments that are in process. I don't have any broke ground yet, and some of them are in process. Um, and he evaluates what the potential projected enrollment impact would

095be for pension. I can't. Thanks. Anyone else? All right, let's get another vote. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Action. Item number two. Approval of tax refund and budget amendment number three. Yeah. So, uh, we modified this, uh, resolution earlier. Uh, recognition that, uh, this money was actually already set aside at June 30th, 24, in our tax reserve. So there's one tax refund totaling $10,964, which again, we'll be paying out of our tax reserve has been recalculated by our treasurer, reviewed by our attorneys and recommended for that. Okay. Thank you. Can I have a motion on the second for this item? Jamie, on the motion. Start on the second. Any questions or comments? I think, Jamie. So, um, we had taken a reserve of how much previously? So we have a tax rate

096reserve of 248,000, which is representative of, you know, maybe a dozen different large, uh, flanks that we knew that were pending against other. And it's within the southeast, Patterson and Collin. Okay. So we took the reserve. We no longer needs a reserve. Well, to the extent of $10,964. Okay. And then we didn't get any money back. No money had ever changed hands. It's just that we're now putting. We're saying we no longer. We have to refund them. So we have to refund to the taxpayer that amount that I'm sorry, I'm talking more about the bankruptcy ones specifically. We did. Okay. Oh, yeah. That's a different separate. Uh, this is completely unrelated. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. I thought that this included, uh, part of, like, the 100,000 in here. The 117,000 was part of that. And

097maybe I'm on the wrong one. No, I want time. Yeah. So you remember 19 actually down the road? That's what I said I was first. Um. Yeah. Originally, estimated revenue was 117. So we're just changing it by 2500. So on page two shows the refund amount. I'm sorry. Page three shows the refund amount. Okay. I was in the decathlon. Um, okay. Okay. Perfect. Thank you. I was in the other attachment that showed the 117,000. 119,000. Either way evaluation and a reduction based on facts and that that's okay that I'm sorry 170 billion. That's our budget amendment. So that what what what that this is why I was so confused. So what? Uh, so what this resolution does, it authorizes us to reimburse the taxpayer or, uh, you know, for overpayment. And then it also allows

098us to utilize our attack service reserve to pay for that. So it uses that reserve money and then basically appropriates it through our budget. So that's why we have a budget amendment that it takes us from the reserve package to the budget. And then we can utilize it to cut the charge. Okay. Thank you I appreciate that. Uh, yeah. The 170,000 through April. Okay. So yeah. No, I can't see my I get commas and, and, uh, periods anymore. Any other questions? All right, let's go to the votes. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Action. Item number three. Disposal of district properties TV star playground equipment. Yes. So our City Star playground is nearing completion. We're hoping that we're going to be able to utilize it hopefully within next week. You believe? After Thanksgiving.

099Um, and with that, we're, uh, requesting the board authorize us to donate that to the, uh, town of southeast for their use. Um, okay. Great. Can I have a motion and a second start on the motion? What's on the second? Any questions or comments? I would just like to thank the district for working that with the town. Uh, last month I was in the village with all my kids on both sides to see the interaction with our community. But. What else? All right, let's go to the vote. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Action. Item number four. Acceptance of donations a sum. Semper fi and the world's middle school state. Yes. Uh, the British Central School District is grateful to the Booster Rotary for their monetary donation to the Brewster High School Semper

100Fi Club, which will go towards the club's work and benefit our community. And we also thank partner Northern Westchester Boces, which general generously donated materials to the Steam program at H.H. Wells and these materials will help enhance instruction and student experience. Okay. Thank you. Now the motion and a second on this item, Jen on the motion. Melissa on a second. Any questions or comments? I would just like to thank part of Westchester Boces at Madison Rotary for these connections. They. Anyone else? All right, let's go to the vote. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Action. Item number five. Approval of waiver of potential conflict of interest between Brewster Central School District and Pharmacological District. I think you could table. Okay, so we'll table this because it was related to the, um, gateway discussion

101that we don't have. You I need a motion on the table. Do it. Okay. All right. We'll move on to action. Item number six, preliminary approval of overnight field trip for New York Tech Valley first robotics regional competition. Thank you. We're requesting preliminary approval for the overnight trip to the bird for Brewster robotics team. To the New York Tech Valley First robotics regional competition, which will be taking place March 26th to the 29th in Albany, New York. We have a motion and a second for this item in order on the Mountain Journal. And the second. Any questions or comments? Seeing none. We'll go to the vote. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Action. Item number seven is approval of affirmative policies 5683. Evacuation. Lockdown and emergency dismissal drills 1630. Voting Procedures Policy 5683.

102Includes revisions in response to amendments of the Commissioner's Regulations relating to School Safety Plan requirements, which became effective July 31st, 2024. The revised regulations outline the procedures for the conduct of drills, and the amended regulations provide additional details on when drills must be conducted, while also creating new parental notification requirements for districts related to drills. Policy 1630 reflects updates to voting procedures that were recommended by our attorneys. They are mostly focused on revisions for early voting and absentee voting following New York State building regulations. Okay. Thank you. Can I have a motion and a second this item later on the motion, Scott on the second. Any questions or comments? Seeing. Now we'll go to all those in favor. Motion passes six zero. Action item number eight. Approval of resolution for a general agreement between the

103district and Employee number three nine to order. Hi. Yes. This was discussed with the board at the November 5th. Uh, executive sessions. Okay. Thank you. I have a motion and a second for this item. Uh, gentleman motion or so on the second. Any questions or comments? Saying. Then we'll go to the vote. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Thanks for that. Item number nine. Approval of stipulation of agreement between the Brewster Central School District and the Brewster Teachers Association. Uh, yes. This uh stipulation defines extended absence as noted in the contract, and also resolves a grievance from the UK in September. Uh, additional information has been shared with the board prior. Okay. Thank you. I have a motion and a second for this item. Scott on the motion. Jamie on the second. Any

104questions or comments? Saying, now we'll go to the vote. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Action. Item number ten. Approval of Memorandum of Agreement with the Brewster Teachers Association regarding NJ ROTC. Uh, yes. So, as was mentioned earlier, we start our day today with an exceptional annual inspection for our NJ to see. Program area Manager Gregory Washington, who attended this morning's events, spoke about the remarkable impression Brewster has made on him. Uh, we are the model for other students to follow. Uh, kudos to Master Chief Campbell, Catholic King, and, uh, and JROTC students. Furthermore, Mr. Washington spoke about the continued support by all stakeholders for our program, and this MoU continues to establish ongoing support for our very much thriving, uh, program. Advertise. Great. Thank you. Can I have a motion and a

105second for this? Uh, Scott on the motion and Jim on the second. Any questions or comments? Uh, I would just like to thank the district for continuing the work with Rothesay, as we saw today. Uh, 200 students, one fifth of the high school population and one out of five, 20% is, uh, involved in Roxy. It's very important to the community and the privacy support. Thank you. And, uh, other side, because both Scott and I were there this morning. Uh, it was my first time, and it was incredibly impressive. But the one thing that I just want to say about Roxy is. And what I didn't know as a Brewster High School grad, I just thought everybody had Roxy. And I didn't learn till later when I got on the board that actually it is, uh,

106very few schools have it. It's a zero sum game. Um, so you have to keep that. You have to foster it. One of the things that I think is, um, most impressive about the Roxy program is it's 20%, it's cut. It's an activity in a club, but it is the most diverse. Uh, every single vet, there's every kid is represented in there, whether they're an athlete, a scholar, you know, uh, a part of the arts program, the whole span of kids. You have kids showing up that, um, you know, like, we saw some children that has, um, you know, some, uh, disabilities and so forth. So it is the most inclusive group that you could possibly have. And they're all there and they're all part of this program. So it was it was truly impressive.

107Right. Anyone else? All right, so let's go into the vote. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Moving on to the consent agenda. Uh, yes. Just one quick comment on tonight's agenda. I'd like to recognize Lillian Stennis reading G for JFK. Uh, 25 years of service. District will be retiring at the end of this. Uh, I forget to say thank you. And I have a motion and a second. Jamie. On the motion on the second. Any questions or comments? I see now. We'll go to the vote. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Um, we are now at our second opportunity for public remarks. So once again, this, um, is not limited to anything on our agenda. Um, if anyone has any remarks they'd like to make to the board, we just ask

108that you go to the podium and state your name. All speakers have three minutes to make whatever remarks they'd like to make, and we just ask that you not identify, um, district staff or students by name. Um, so and again, this is not limited to anything on our agenda. So if anyone has any public remarks they'd like to make tonight, please make your way to the podium. All right. We don't have anyone in the meeting. Uh, the public remarks. We also did not receive any emails. Um, any additional emails from our last meeting? Uh, so we will move on to board remarks and BOE committee updates. Then if you don't have anything you like to share. But. Uh, couple of quick items. Um, I was able to stop by the beef sauce transition fair that

109was going on tonight. The, uh, the amount of resources in. That was incredible. It was great to see these items. And I'm hoping to continues to be involved. And it was kind of items, uh, like by the board. We there's an upcoming, um, Westport event on the 25th. It's a community conversation. It's from 7 to 830 on the 25th. And I talked about managing social media communication. I'm going to try to sit on, but if anybody had some time, it might be, uh, something worth listening to, what with the data. Uh, so 25th. So I think it's Monday. I think, um, was able to get to the town of southeast of Veterans Day celebration, and our old master, Chief Campbell, was the speaker. That was very great to see the input and the input and

110our own made lobby. Ruby was, um, singing the national anthem, and I kept making her say more and more songs by the village. The speak and the representation was great. I also got over to the middle school, and last week they had an internet safety presentation, which was amazing and scary all the same time. Um, and the man who was putting it on, actually, children went through the school district and it came about because people in the school district really came up and talked about it, and he was approached by the school to give his reservations. And and he broke out into this event. Um, yes. The sad part was that was six and seven and it was put out to the middle school and see. Bizarre. But the great part was they were able

111to be with students and they had the students quiet for an hour. So there was a quiet for an hour. He was asleep, I learned. So a lot of hopefully going to information was passed that day. And, um, more follow up on the bus patrol, you, um, citations going on the bus cameras. We said last one and over 130 and they're still working on. And I told them that came out with 250 violations. And this is just about here. This is just us. And these are the ones they approved. So it's probably even more that they don't have a little bit of. So it's out there. It's scary. And it's certainly. Back. All right. Thank you. Scott. Anyone else ready? The year public library budget passed. So thank you to all of the voters who

112voted for the library budget. Anyone else. All right. So we will move on to upcoming meetings. So our next board meeting is is December 10th. And then we have a work session scheduled for this. Uh 6 to 8. Right. Back to work. So moving forward isn't that a they would like a work session with us right now. Topic to be. Oh, okay. Um, sorry, I was making it about the, um, construction. Okay. So there is a there's a possibility board session. Okay. That'll be held Monday, December 16th at 630. We want to hang out, so that will be noted. We'll get to 2031. That'll be noticed if if it happens, work just the same way. All of our meetings this month. Um, as always, if you have if anyone has any remarks they want to

113share with the board, they can do so by sending an email to the, um, board and superintendent that BOE appreciates all that work. So at this point, I just need a motion to adjourn the meeting and a second on the motion on the second. All those in favor? Motion passes six zero. Thank you, everyone, for coming. And have a great Thanksgiving. Good.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.