CorpusRecord 234246

BOE February 6, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Carle Place School District
Date
2025-02-07
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,542 words · about 37 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I think Chance, any of you willing to go wrestling championship Friday, Saturday? You wanted to do that Wrestling Championship Trooper wrestling. So, because I, I don't care. The Ohio State very, uh, very school like. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Or first I like to call, I like to call to order the February 6th meeting of the car Complex Board of Education All Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. United States America stands one liberty, Please remain standing. Heavenly father, we invoke th blessing on all in attendance here and on those we serve. Help us to bring wisdom and humanity to our deliberations and nice spirit to our work. Please be seated. Welcome to the February 6th meeting of the Car Place Board of Education. Resident Zino cannot attend tonight's meeting due to illness. We'll start

002with comments from the board and I'll take the lead. So if you heard, uh, Justin and I whispering to each other, um, like to congratulate the car place we lead Jane Gymnastic team. They are conference champs, either solo or kind of depends on the outcome of, of their competitors meets this weekend. But, um, as a car place, gymnast alumni, uh, we had some other alumni gymnast in the stands and you know, it made us feminist when we were the conference gyms in 1980. A little dated, but I thought I'd share that. So I wish the best of luck to the CarPlay Wheatley gymnast. They are a phenomenal team. It was very inspiring. I would also like to congratulate the performing art actors and actresses and the Willy Walker. If anybody took the time to see

003that play, I'm sure you left singing. It was fantastic. All the kids of like, they were having a wonderful time as well. Lastly, I'd like to thank you. The Car Plays Education Foundation for donating the sensory items. Thank you. I'll now turn it over to Vice President. Uh, good evening everybody and thank you for coming. Um, I also wanna say congratulations to our gymnast. Great job. Um, and I wanna congratulate all the Russian students who participate in the wonderful introduction of, and a big thank you to all the teachers and parents who love me Academy. I also wanna share my gratitude, appreciation for the incredible success of our recent parent university workshops In sessions provided great learning opportunities for families for the big education and hard work of the Parent University committee. Your commitment to

004organizing and running this event did not go unnoticed. Thank you. You either time, effort, and passion for supporting the community. And a special thank you also goes out to the teachers and area professionals who generously share their expertise through a variety of engaging sessions. And now turn it over to Trustee And good evening. Uh, Willie Wonka was a fantastic, fantastic show. Uh, fantastic display of our students and status, talent, dedication, uh, clear how much heart went into working ion to life. And I know my family and I really appreciate and so many of us offices appreciated work done there. Uh, parent University was also a success. Uh, I really enjoyed my workshops, uh, highlighted the strength of our school community partnership and these events Do that right to provide valuable insights to help support our

005students and foster a sense of belonging. Uh, thank you to everyone involved. Uh, I appreciate the positive response enthusiasm I received about our Place robotics piece. I had mentioned during our last meeting, uh, committee meetings like the STEAM committee are great places to drive initiatives like that too, and gather support the, to make it happen. Uh, I've also been in contact with certain CP alumni who are interested in even donating, uh, to that to offset some of the costs that are associated. Um, Thank you evening everybody. Thanks for coming. I wanted to again, um, say how wonderful Willy Wonka was. Uh, I brought my family with us, with me to watch, and the kids, the talent that comes out of our place for such a a small community is amazing. Not only are they smart,

006but they're so talented in, in, in the arts that I'm like so proud for me from here. Um, parent University, um, was everything that I needed at that moment. Um, going through a little stuff at home, you know, with my family, um, health wise. And I needed that social emotional workshop. The two of 'em that I went to that literally hit the spot. Like I needed that. And if you haven't been to one of our, um, parent universities, please, the next one that comes out, please go because it's so uplifting. It's something that, thank you Dr. Pinal for bringing that here. And then lastly, I went to Charlene's, um, parent, um, Valentine's Day dance tonight. And how cute these kids were running, not running around, dancing around, I guess you could say. Taking pictures, doing

007crafts. These are the things that bring the community together and you know, thank you everyone that put that together. Thank you. We'll now hear comments from Dr. Alright, thank you very much Roy. Well welcome everybody. Um, I'll start with, because we've talked a lot about Luka, which was fantastic, and here, university, I do say myself was a success. I want to talk about some academic items tonight. First and foremost, I want to make sure, especially as we're at the outset of budget season, that I want to say to the community, we have been hard at work on a plan to support students in all of our subject areas, particularly geometry, chemistry, business. I've worked with Ms. Fredericks, who cannot be here tonight. I've worked with Ms. Fredericks and Mr. For Ms. Cantor, Ms. Poland, to

008work on a plan to support our students and our teachers by topic through performance analysis, through academic support and professional development. And we will have ongoing review of the student's progress and needs unit by unit also for professional development and the needs for additional assessment and additional instruction as we work towards the end of the year, right? That is our sole purpose here in school, is to turn out educated students. And, you know, in talking with them as if we have to build this plan, we have to monitor this plan. We have some good outcome for students, right? That's why we exist. So keeping in that vein, we've had great athletic achievements this year. We have had some really, really nice academic achievements as well. Our frog scientists have been doing a great job. Science

009Olympiad, we had two medals just last week, um, second in the helicopter division, seventh in the air trajectory division. We have some really, really strong high school students who are doing great things with science. Also, we have two young ladies, Alyssa, Chile and Kayla Enrique, who have been participating in the International Day of Women and Girls in Science. These two kids are serious powerhouses when it comes to science, and they are in the top 10% in the county. And their work has just moved on to the second round. And I think of all the submissions, only 12 were chosen. And Kira and Alyssa are moving forward into the next round. All of our students science ly and our two young ladies who are in the international day of women and girls and science are under

010the tutelage of Ms. Danielle for Acre. So I wanna say thank you also also to MS. Four Acre for helping to make that happen for us. Um, it's really, really great to see kids enthused about science and taking it seriously and compete, right? Because we have a great track record as competitors. As you've been hearing tonight, um, we have our art show in this room last night. If you have a chance to see what is in the case on the way out towards the main entrance, there are artists in this school that are outstanding, right? They can hold their own with artists all over Nassau County and beyond. Very, very creative, visionary, intelligent kids with something to say. So please make sure you check out what's in the case, like really beautiful and moving work.

011Also, our mock trial team, like I said, Carl k students compete. They competed last night and they knocked off a very strong opponent from Port Washington. Our kids are motivated. They care about the law and legal processes. They're well led and they're self-starters. It's a really, really awesome thing to see. Um, we wish all the best to our gymnasts, right? Athletic competition and all of our teams who are moving towards the playoffs in their winter sports less. But by no means least it's winter, it's cold, it's nasty out there. Our team, our facilities and custodial team was out there again this morning at oh five 30. Dark and cold, getting it done, making sure everything is clean. Snow's again this weekend and next week they'll be added to. Everything was in great shape when we

012got here. So thanks infrared and to the whole team on that. Um, we have a really good first budget presentation tonight. I thank everybody for coming. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. Oh, thank you. I know we'll have the presentation. Budget, pleasure. That one didn't water come on either. It turned itself off. Sometimes They just fall Asleep. Okay. Does anybody Really need that tv? All right, so thank you all for coming tonight. This is our first budget presentation for the 25 26 budget. Um, we're just gonna do, uh, a brief overview. Um, we're gonna discuss our spending plan tonight. You know, as a district we rely very heavily on our community involvement and investment. Uh, we have partnerships with the community in many ways. We have our PTA, our athletic partnerships. We have parents

013reinforcing instruction at home. And of course, we need your investment in foreign property taxes to help us reach our mission and our vision. So tonight we're gonna look at, uh, an investment recap of some items that were new in the 24 25 budget. We're gonna talk about the factors that are affecting the planning of the 25 26 budget and talk a little bit about our strategy and where we're going. And we'll review the initial revenue and expense numbers. So new in the budget for 24 25, uh, was the purchase of robots at Cherry Lane. And with those robots, our first graders created maps. They programmed directional codes on iPads, and they were able to program the robot to give a new student tour of the building. At Rushmore, uh, we have Peace Academy, which was

014new in the budget. And based on the New York State Math assessment scores, sixth graders were invited to participate in that Peace Academy Enrichment Program. Uh, the program process, critical thinking, deep mastery of math concepts through, uh, complex problems and puzzles. The picture there is not of students using Beast Academy. That is a picture of students participating in the math olympiads, which Beast Academy helps prepare our students to be successful for those competitions. Also in our 24 25 budget is the redesign of the home at the family consumer science room at the middle school high school. Um, we redesigned the space to accommodate multiple forces and student workstations were outfitted with new appliances. So that's the four picture. This is while we were under construction and after, so you can see on the left, um,

015those are the workstations where all the original cabinetry was to accommodate our sewing plus. And then in the middle, um, they the changed out the tables and the chairs for a peninsula style workstation that our culinary arts students could do prep work on. And we got a lot more storage, um, out of that space because we switched to that, that design. And then lastly, uh, all the new stoves and ovens. So what's affecting the budget this year? Proposed tariffs and uncertainty in in federal aid. Um, we have enacted and proposed tariffs on our range of imports. They're gonna continue to have a ripple effect on school district expenditures. As costs go up, it's gonna put pressure on all school budgets. So in planning, we have to anticipate those increasing prices and ensure that we allocate

016resources properly. In addition to pressure on the budget, it can also cross shortage in supply. Uh, we've already taken steps to stay ahead of these tariffs, uh, specifically as it relates to laptops and desktops. So laptop prices are projected to increase as much as 45% with the tariffs. As a country, we import about 88% of our computers. So we accelerated the purchasing timeline of our laptops and desktops and incorporated them into the 24 25 budget. And part of the reason we were able to do that is because we received about $50,000 in grant funding from the Senate to do with what we saw fit. We also saw already a temporary pause in federal funding. And the overall impression from our professional organizations and the state education department is that there will be similar occurrences going

017forward. Another big topic this year was changed in the foundation aid formula. Um, in the 24 25 school year, the governor passed the Rockefeller Institute with recommending changes to the formula. The foundation aid piece is the biggest piece of revenue for school districts in the, in the state aid category. So the governor's proposed budget includes several changes to how foundation aids distributed. Um, these changes didn't result in a large change for call place. So the minimum guaranteed increase under the governor's proposal was 2%. That's what we're projected to receive. And that's similar to the increase we saw for 24 25. And we don't know if these changes will be accepted by the legislature or if they will make further adjustments in the final state budget. On a more positive note, our educational vision is also

018impacting the budget. Uh, to ensure success, we have to develop high quality curriculum. We have to have professional development, build strong assessment tools, strong leadership. We have to foster that family community partnerships, prioritize safety, academic achievement, all while making fiscally responsible decisions in our budget and our capital plans. So where are we going? So we want to provide ongoing opportunities to engage all stakeholders. Uh, we started this year with our four committees. We rolled out the budget survey, which we'll talk about. We've had focus groups, we have parent university. We want to continue all of that. Of course, we're gonna nurture the roots of academic growth at the elementary level to promote future success. We wanna expand the traditional educational paradigm through active learning and authentic learning experiences for all students. So what that looks

019like, it's project based learning, which we've seen through presentations on our Smart Start grant. We Beast Academy, which we talked about earlier. And it's increased internship opportunities for our high school students. And then we wanna maintain a continuous cycle of success by graduating students that are prepared to make the best choice for their college or career journey. So what that looks like is gonna be developed by the portrait of a graduate committee. And that's an ongoing process. The skills and portrait of a graduate five years ago are different than that of a graduate today. And if you're not on the committee, you can still get involved. Uh, we're gonna be having upcoming a fraud exchange and you'll receive a more information about that. So stay tuned. And I just wanna point out that although this

020is a graphic of a road, which is a path that we all understand, uh, these items, they don't occur sequentially and many of them can and will be going on simultaneously. So how is the budget gonna support this loan? On the revenue side, we can see about 80% of our revenue comes from the investment from the community and formal property taxes. The other 18% is made up of state and federal aid. Our pilot payments, our appropriate reserves, and other miscellaneous revenue. And even with the changes proposed for state aid, these percentages are relatively consistent with the last five years. The tax levy, uh, the graphic is there just to remind everybody that the formula is not straightforward and that the 2% that we hear about is just one piece of that large formula. With that

021calculation, prelim, preliminary declaration, these numbers will change. We don't have all of our final inputs yet. Um, as it stands right now, our allowable levy cap and proposed levy is $47,960,443. That's a 2.37% increase over the prior year levy. And again, that will change on the expenditure side. The proposed expenditures are $58,689,234. About $1.5 million increase from the prior year. Budget to budget percentage increases 2.63. And if you look at what makes up those expenditures, 76% of that is salary and benefits. 17% is our mandated cost, which we'll talk about on the next slide. And all the other items are 6.7%. So what's driving that increase? The categories below show the areas of greatest change between 24 25 and 25 26. Uh, the amount of the dollar value changes in each category. And if you're

022doing the math, they don't add up to the 1.5 million from the previous line because we also had a decrease, uh, in the area of facilities. Projects not funded through our capital reserve because we completed the consumer signed terms. So we don't have that large expense again for 25, 26. So our mandatory costs the biggest driver this year so far. Um, they include our district insurance policies, our legal fees, transportation, audit services, utilities. Our contractual increases are the expenses were required to make based on our employee contracts. We have materials and supplies, that's our program. Materials, uh, textbooks, field trip, transportation, and then equipment for us as any individual item over a thousand dollars, uh, that we are required to capitalize and depreciate for our district policy. And so as we go through the remainder

023of budget meetings this year, you'll see in greater detail what makes up those increases. As a jury heard before New York State mandates the school districts present a balanced budget each year. So expenses can't exceed our revenue. Uh, to meet this requirement, sometimes districts have to draw on a reserve fund, which is, uh, a mechanism for legally saving money for future expenses. While using reserve funds can help balance the budget in the short term, it's important that we closely monitor our, uh, use of our reserves because, uh, we do need to maintain that long term financial stability. So this year, to balance that $58 million expenditure, we have the almost 48 million we talked about in property tax revenue, 10,365,000 in non-tax revenue. And we would need to use, uh, 363,000, uh, bar reserve funds

024to make that balance. So coming up, we have the rest of our budget meetings. The next meeting is district wide expenses. That's facilities, uh, transportation benefits and debt service. And we have our related arts on March 6th, that's technology fine. And performing arts and athletics. Our instructional programming and staffing on March 20th, the board will adopt the budget on April 3rd. And of course the budget vote is May 20th this year. Please also be on hook out for opportunities to learn more at other community meetings besides our budget meetings. And as you probably saw when you came in, um, this year we rolled out a budget survey. We do encourage everyone to participate. It is anonymous and the goal of the survey is really to highlight the common foundation we share for the future success

025of our schools, our students, and our community. Um, the QR code is there, it's on the website, it is on our social media account, and it will be available here, uh, for the rest, for the rest of the budget meetings. Uh, if you're doing it on a mobile device, it's best viewed in landscape mode. And, um, those are the, the other areas you can find a survey if you do have trouble with the QR code. If at any time throughout the process you wanna know more, you can visit our website. Write can email us at budget 25 26 at cps, K12, NY US and we'll just see you all at our next meeting on the 27th. Thank you. Could you just say those topics again and the dates? Sure. I'm sorry, the dates, topics. Um,

026so the next meeting is facilities, both cs, transportation benefits and debt service. Then on March 6th, technology fine and performing arts and athletics. On the 20th, it's uh, instructional programming and staffing. So that's our building level budgets and special education. And the budget adoption is the third and the August of 20. Thank you. Appreciate it. And we'll make sure that we have this posted up right on the website so that everyone can access it that way. And as questions and things come in, we'll make the FAQ page and we'll also share results from our survey. So please, please respond to the survey. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Joanna. If there are any comments from the public on agenda items only, please come to the podium. Give your name to the district clerk and you

027may ask a question or agenda only. Hi everybody. Hi. Can You hear me? Yes, I, I talk loud. Anyway, I'm sorry I walked in a little bit late. I apologize. Um, budget. Um, but on campus that you guys are looking at, are there any for us to look at? We don't have printed copies, but we are gonna post it up tomorrow, so it'll be up on the website. Okay. Okay. And what, I'm sorry, what did you say? The, um, increase is gonna be this year. Right now the expenditure increase is 2.63% and the tax levy increases 2.3. But you said it could go, uh, It's, it will change. I don't, I can't say whether it will go up or down, but it'll change once we have our final. Oh, so you can't say whether it'll

028go up or down. Okay. Um, We're waiting to be clear, we're waiting on numbers from os, which we have to include in our tax cap calculation. And we need to incorporate the, uh, debt service that we'll be taking off the HVAC project, which I'm working with capital markets. So once we finalize that, we'll have final. So the HA, that's, that's a different increase or that's gonna be rolled into this? No, it's part of this, It's part of this. So it's probably gonna go up then? I don't believe so, but again, I can't concern we are, we are operating on the sumption of the debt service level. The debt service unit, which is part of the, is going to remain the same as I have heard the latest from the capital markets. It will be the

029same and that will not change to the form. But I haven't met them to not go over it. So I don't wanna say that it's definitely not going. Okay. And, and what about the aid from Dear State? How does that look? Well, it looks right now for us decent, we fall under that 2% additional increase in the governance quote, which is similar to the increase we got last year. But we don't know what's gonna happen if the legislator's gonna incorporate per changes or make adjustments. Um, the main concern of The business Official community is that these changed the formula drew a lot of pain from New York City uhhuh. So they are significantly down under these projections. So the legislature may try to adjust that. Okay, thank you. Question. Well, we're, right now we're questions

030on the agenda and then you'll have a second opportunity for open questions in general. Wasn't She just talking about the question? Yes. I, I simply stating Facts. So that's on the, perhaps one or two of my comments are slightly off the budget. Um, my comments as usual, are we heard about the increases we didn't hear where you could eliminate expenses that are extraneous, uh, not necessary. That could be cut. Seems to me that 20% cut would be very nice. Um, we have an extensive, the, um, our faculty is very, very generous. So somewhere in there, since that 76% of the budget, something needs to happen. Last year we were like a, I dunno, 44,000 plus per students. And this is on the way up what you told us tonight in our overview, we have robots

031for the first grade. I don't think we really know how to read yet, but those very nice, expensive toys to have. So how you're thinking about what you spend, it's, it's very, very luxurious. Now I got this in the mail, which says we have an educational foundation and it since 2005 we provided $50,000 in scholarships to college bound seniors. That would be like 2,500 a year if my simple math is correct. And if you cut the budget by about and 15% every family in Power Place could have 2,500 a year to put in a fund that they could multiply times all the years that children are in school to send them to college. Is, this is getting extremely expensive. Elvis may make a comment on that, please. Yes. The education foundation is separate from districts,

032right? That that is a organization of community members that does its own fundraising and then grants scholarship money to students. That money does not come out of the district's pocket. Yeah, I understand that. But how much did we pay to send this out as sort of pr To send out the newsletter? Yeah, I understand. Okay. So if it was 50 cents a household, that would be like what, $1,500 it runs the sub month, something like that. Mm-hmm. Which is more than half of what one of those, what those scholarships is. When we did some cutting, people could have some money in their own pockets to put into their, what do they call back? Fifty two four. I don't know what the number is because those funds, um, meanwhile when we elected the board, my questions

033of course were about their interest in the budget and they had little interest in the budget. Little, I hope that they are taking more line by line by line interest in the budget. And now Dr. Duney Duney Duney, um, his main pitch was about his skills at grant writing. So I was wondering if we could expect a few million in grants to lower this budget. Yeah, uh, I think we're, we're looking at all those possibilities. Some of it depends on what the legislature does with things like pre-K, which has been mentioned the last couple years, if there's gonna be additional funds there for the taking for us. Um, and then there's other, other Opportunities. But they, they do come with some strings attached sometimes. I'm sure whatever our governor is doing, it has strings attached.

034Elise? Yes, thank you so much for your comments. Just tell me the enrollment. Each person has a limit of three minutes. Oh, we're only going to take questions right now on the agenda. After this, the public will have the opportunity to make a comment. Alright. I just wanted to express request that the board should take this very, very seriously. And I would like to know my question is what's the enrollment? Yeah. Okay. So can we take this back when we return to com? Public comments? 'cause right now we want to just focus on the agenda. Thank you so much. Is there anybody else who has questions on the agenda? Only items. Okay. We will now continue with the business of the meeting. May I have a motion to approve the minutes of the Board of

035education business meeting of January 23rd? I motion All in favor? Aye. The minutes of January 23rd are approved. Now for the approval of the consent agenda, may I have a motion to approve the consent agenda? Second. All in favor? Aye. All are approved of the consent agenda. Any questions or comments from the public? Not regarding the agenda? Please come to the podium. Give your name and address to the district clerk and each person will have a limit of three minutes. Thank you so much. Hi everybody. Um, I wanna talk about Dr. You mentioned, um, the, uh, the math and the science, which I appreciate. Um, unfortunately I'm still getting feedback from parents that nothing has changed in that teacher's classroom. You're talking about geometry. Correct. Okay. And I'd like to know what I, again, I

036appreciate that you're doing something right. If you can maybe elaborate on what that is because it's not affecting the classroom. Mm-hmm. Which in turn is not helping these kids. And these kids shouldn't have to go get tutors because their teacher's not teaching them. And next year my son's gone into this grade. Mm-hmm. This cannot continue. Mm-hmm. So I, again, I appreciate you addressing it, but nothing has changed yet. And obviously I'm a teacher. Yep. You can have all the meetings you want, doesn't mean they're gonna bring it to the classroom. Yes. So No, no, no, go ahead. So thank you for that. First of, I would say if a parent has feedback or questions or concerns and they're talking to you, I think that's a great thing. Please, please urge them to contact us directly.

037Well, I think they have tried to talk to the teacher and she's that Right. Told the children, I'm gonna teach the way I'm gonna teach. I don't care what your parents Say. And that's not okay. Right. And if, if someone is getting that kind of feedback that they need to contact the principal or the director or assistant superintendent or me, right. Like that's important. Very important. Absolutely. So what are we doing? This is also a key important thing. One of the things that I have directed is that we need to make sure that we know for all of our unit tests, for the midterm, any test of any substance, right? By topic or by standard. What's the composition of that test? Because you know yourself, right? If a student gets a 73 on that test,

038then that's all you know. Well you know that they understood 73% of it and they didn't understand 27% of it. So what, what standards or what topics are we succeeding at? What standards or topics are we failing at? How can we reteach them? How do we support the students in those topics? How do we support the teachers Right. In the professional development or the extra help they need themselves to get that across. That comes down to methodology. If the method I'm using isn't working, we cannot, and we must not say, oh well two bad kids, this is how I do. But that, and that's what's so frustrating. 'cause we talked about this. Everybody was here at the meeting two months ago. We addressed it, the numbers were not there. There's facts. This is not just

039somebody making it Up. If you're telling me that I believe, and, and I I would ask please, that anyone who has absolutely has that concern absolutely gets in touch with us directly. Right. If you're not getting traction at the teacher level, we talk at the administrative level. If you're not getting traction at the building administrator or the director, assistant superintendent or deputy superintendent for curriculum instruction, if not there, then me. Right? Please. Please. So then in that by topic bystander, I want to know exactly what's going on by topic and bystander. And then for each unit that goes forward, how that's going. Where do we need to reteach a topic? How are we giving support to students on specific topics for the grade, for the classroom, for the individual student, right? And then I want

040to be able to know, six weeks amount of time has gone by whatever the length of the unity is. What has changed? What do we keep doing because it's working. What can we change in what we're doing as we get closer? Have students grades gone up on the test as a whole? Have they begun to get better in specific standards where either the child or the class is showing the deficiency? What changes do we need to make along the way? And then finally, as we get closer towards the end, who do we need to really double down on? Extra regional support, extra assessment and then go and take the test. Right? So it is assess, diagnose, prescribe. Start that again. Right as we go. And you know, as we all know on paper, that sounds

041great. It does. But I'm gonna tell you right now, You have to actually do it. You have to monitor it and you have to change as you go along. I, I don't want to interrupt, but like I have made that clear to Ms. Reds, Mr. Re, Mr. Poland. And they have carried that out to the teachers. So we will absolutely monitor it. We can't just take it on paper. Right. And unfortunately geometry, 'cause I know the course mm-hmm. It is extremely challenging for every child. And there is no time to reteach. The curriculum doesn't even fit in the course for the year as it is for the teachers. So there's no time for the reteaching. Although that sounds ideal. If we had a ton of time. We don't. And it's really not fair after what

042I saw happens to these kids last year, especially with chemistry, this should not be happening in our district. Absolutely. And we're allowing it though. I I you are addressing it, but it's still happening and nothing's changing. Mm-hmm. And again, my son's going to geometry yet next year just 'cause he has me to help him. I'm a math teacher. He shouldn't have to need me. I agree. A teacher should be teaching them in the classroom. I And, and and I, I really do genuinely agree with you. And I can say to you as to everybody else, this process that I just described, that is a change that is not business as usual. Okay. And it's hard here. I would tell you because we are such a small district, they don't have colleagues that teach the same

043course to bounce ideas off. Did I do that in my district? And it is very helpful. Sometimes we have four or five people who teach the same, the same course together. Right. Not here. That's what I'm saying. Yes. I part of departments where we have 34 people in a department. That's not how we're in corporate. And I just, just changing it for a second, I just wanna ask, we've mentioned something about the hvac, I think Eloise was asking that is not in the budget for this next year. Right? That's, we took a bond for that. We voted on that. So no, none of the money for next year should be taken for hvac. If I'm understanding correctly, the only piece of the budget that is related to the HVAC is the debt service payment that

044was approved with the authorization bond. It's the, it's going to be almost the same debt service payment that we were carrying on the old bond, which was also in the budget because we already increased it. We shouldn't be increasing again for hvac. That's what I just wanted the budget Not touched by hvac. It's the cap calculation and cell factors and debt service, which is related to bonds. That's why Thank you. Um, also wanted to talk about that. So currently we, there's a change to doing more independent practice in, we've seen a lot of the city schools, from what I understand by state, there is an advanced for uh, this group of people that are taking out crew this year who are struggling extremely in that class. Uh, most of the kids that are friends with

045my daughter used to go to after tests, walk out in the hallway and brag about their grades to each other. And it was a competition. They don't share their grades anymore because they're much lower than they were. The ones that are sharing are sharing about what their tutor is teaching 'em and how they're getting help. Mm-hmm. Um, very worried that we're looking at their scores, looking at the results, measuring it here to year. We're not measuring what's being taught in the classroom anymore because the majority of the kids have tutors and we're getting tutor aside at $500 a month. So I'm upset hundred, $2,000 now on my budget because of this new independent practice. Mm-hmm. From everybody that I've talked to. State schools, city schools on Long Island. They hate the program. They don't like

046where it's going. Students are having a lot of trouble. The tutors are saying it's great for them because they are happy they can, it took us two, three weeks to get tutors. Advice to us was come to more extra help classes. My daughter spends every single extra help session with one of her grant students. One of her, that's what she does. So she can't go to that class every single day, which is what she did about the same test grade. Mm-hmm. Has the same type of curriculum the same way each was done, have extra help that was done. Now that we have a private tutor, she's starting to understand math. There's less tears at home, there's less frustration. There's must desire just switch over what she wants to do. Mm-hmm. Very, very concerned that we're

047gonna be looking at this test scores with a jaded view. We're gonna see the test scores being a little bit higher only because we're going to that we want make sure that you guys are aware that that's going on and the frustration and it's just, we can't measure our grades because it's not Right. Because it's an Artificial measure tutor Right. Center. I dunno if it's the same situation, but it's that way. Same teacher judge. Thank You. I appreciate it. I just have a question about the reference size math. Is there any practice in place that at some point the average of a class is checked? Yes. Sarah? Yes. So when does that happen? I'm just curious. I don't know. So that, that happens on an ongoing basis and particularly what I said tonight. Right. I'm

048glad you asked. I'm just gonna, I just wanna write down my note of what you said. The class, um, When the class takes a midterm, for instance, we had midterms a week or two ago. I asked for the averages on the tests across the board. Right. And if we see a place where, let's take geometry again or algebra two where we have a concern about a particular class. What we want to do is when those kids take the unit test, because the unit test is meant to be the same for all the students, just like midterm, we want to look at what was the average on the midterm for the entire grade. What was the average classroom by classroom, right. Section by section. And what's the average for students who are at risk? Right? So

049like one of the things that I said enough going from macro now down to micro said, I need to know for any item where more than 30% of the students have a problem with the item. Mm-hmm. What's that standard? Do the standards start to show a pattern? Like we're having success on 3.06 but we're having a real problem with 4.02. Those are made up standards by the way. Right? So I know for the grade, like the course for the individual sections and it comes down to the student for the student. So when it comes to the big tests like midterm, smaller tests like unit, what is the average and what does that mean as we go down, down, down to the student level? Does that answer the Question? Yes. Because what my concern, I think

050it does. Um, 'cause what my concern was that I, it hasn't happened to one of my kids. But what the main theme that I was hearing is that the parents were sort of advocate, were sort of blindsided by what was happening because they were, the kids were pulling a 90 something average in the class itself and then failing a region, but at like a 50. Right? So something's not lining up. So I don't know if it's grade inflation, let's say during the classroom time and then when the test comes. Right. So I think that's a super important piece of information to know. Um, so that we don't need full history. Because I would imagine if just for example, 40% of the classroom felt the midterm for the region. Um, if you saw, that's why I

051wanted to know. Do you, would you see if 40% of the class was failing? Yes. Yes. You would be concerned. Oh yes. But if you say, oh, they all, you know, the average class, the class average is an 88, were saying that Right. Average media, but something average. Average, okay. But all of a sudden it's 40%. Well, something's wrong. So, so like what you're Talking about the grading of the class, It is a real thing, right? Yeah. That there can be a disconnect between the grade I'm earning in my class. 'cause my classroom basic get up a bunch of things. Mm-hmm. It's my test, it's the work I'm doing in class. It's homework. There's a whole bunch of components. When I take an exam, the exam is the exam is the exam. Right. And like

052we've probably all had those experiences as kids ourselves. We've probably seen those experiences with our own children. Where I'm getting this grade in my class, I took a test and the test looks markedly different. Or you know, for argument's sake, if the test, if the teacher made the test, it could reflect what's going on in the class and the kids can be okay. Right. But then when they take a even a midterm, that could happen with, but then when they take the regent and this is the real deal, well if that didn't reflect what happened all the year and they failed that regent, then why does that kid have an 90? Now you're gonna have an outlier that here and there that happens. Right. Whether test anxiety or whatever. But if 40% fail, 'cause last

053year, like I said, I, and I'm making a percentage, It's okay. Yeah. I'm with you. It's like a Hypothetical. But I've heard so many parents say, I had no idea that was coming because they had a good grievance uhhuh. So that is something that obviously we just want make sure that it doesn't get repeated because, because you need to look at the teacher and like, why do they have this grade if they can't test the test? You know what I mean? Which accurate portrayal of what the students, the extent which the student needs to See. Yeah. 'cause trust me, I'm, I'm a tutor. Like I don't want to, I don't like that idea, but I do. But if like it has an 90, why would I, why would that ever be on my radar to

054get them help? Right. So we're not even giving the parent or the kid a fair chance to tutor if we needed to. If not that we should have to. Yes. But in it's not a perfect world right now. I hope to be improved in that area, but at least let's get the information to the parent if they're not learning or preparing. So we have the opportunity to help the kid and fix It. There should be, there should be a close alignment between how I'm doing class. Like if I, right. Let's say that my, my average on my report card for the class is a seven. Mm-hmm. When I take the Regents exam, I ought to be scoring somewhere between like 80 and 90 on the Regents exam. And even if it very rude, if I

055scored a 98, close enough for like 40. Right. We should be, that's way out of way out of whack. Right. Degrees. And, and I know, I mean like no looking at Ms. Rubenstein here, like I know that a lot of conversation and analysis happens in your departments with that. I asked at midterm time to see all of the midterms, right. For the middle school and high school. 'cause I wanted to know, are those tests aligned to the regent's exams that the class terminates in or are they something else? So like I can say my hand on my heart, I read all of those tests. They are aligned to the Regent's exam. They are made up essentially of regent's questions. That doesn't mean that they're perfect or that methodologically instruction is happening exactly the way you

056want it to happen. But you have to start with saying, are we testing the same things that kids are going to be held responsible for at the end of the year? And we are. So And the average of the midterms lined up with the average of the first semester. Can't talk about every single, I can't talk about every single subject right now. No. But like, not That I want to, but is that information look like Yes in the math? Not, and and I hate to say in the math, I don't want to keep ping the math and science part, but if that's where the problem is right now, that's where An important question to ask. Right. Like as as administrator just in The classroom that we have issues Teachers two is, are the grades that

057kids earning are the grades that students are earning matching up to the grades they're getting on assessments? Yes. If yes, then you know that there's an alignment. If no things are out of alignment, how do you Correct. Right. Right. Yes. That's a fundamental important question. Okay. The question we ask. Okay. So we're in, in math and science department where we're doing it, We are, We're do it or are we working on it? Or we are doing it. Yes. Yes, we are doing it. Okay. And yes, we are working on it. Awesome. I I want you all, I want you all to know that you, we have had very serious conversations about this because you know, I have a lot of, lot of respect for teachers in general. For our teachers in particular. We're not where

058we need to be. Right. And that's not to blame anybody or make anybody feel ashamed of themselves or bad about the work they do. We're just not where they need to be. This is the only product we have is we educate. Thank, thank you. Are there any other questions? Um, last year I mentioned that there's only been one year when at the end of the season, along with the pictures of the graduates, I gave us a nice list of, you gave us a nice list of the schools that they were going to and of course that didn't happen. But for this 44 grand a year, it would be nice to know what schools they're going to for maybe if they're gonna learn plumbing or something useful. What didn't happen, I'm sorry to interrupt you. That

059was well I did mention it in passing, uh, to have to in, in your flyers that you send out at the end of the year when everyone graduates and we have a picture of the graduates to have a, a listing of the schools they're going to just the schools not their names. Yes. That's ation. Yeah. You can't get the names. The schools you mean. So just to know what schools get to go in, doesn't it? Well that would be a parent's preference if they wanted it out there, Information like that. We, we could list this Fordham, NYU Michigan. But we can't say Bill William Smith, Michigan. Right. We can list the names of the schools, but we can't match students to schools. Um, we're prevented from doing that. I very sorry to hear that. We

060have so many issues with teaching important subjects. And in terms of budget, I would just say that there's, you know, in doing deep diving into the budget, it may be that we have too many extraneous classes. We, we condensed, we we changed the time length of the classes a few years ago. Mm-hmm. So there would be more subjects taught for less time and perhaps that was an idea that's not working. Maybe you need more time and more basic things and consequently a lowering of the budget. Um, okay. I did want to say that about showing, it would be nice for us to know the schools and know what kind of grades we're getting for our money. And are we going to have handouts of the whole budget or is that all only Pre presentation handouts?

061Yes. And the budget. I'm not a hundred percent sure I understand the Question. A budget, it's like Pages and pages. You entire, entire budget. Entire Budget. I follow what you're saying. I'm not sure if that's a thing that we normally do. I, Yes, it's always on the website. We're walking a fine line between saving sources and reducing our spending. But we can go back with handouts for everything. Well it would be nice to know that everybody is maybe we used to have the appropriate section at the appropriate meeting so that it is not just a PR exercise. Right. Um, that would be be very good. Okay. Thank you. I'm sure. And Once again, I want to know the enrollment. Yes, we will. We will get that next time. We'll get it to you. Thank you.

062I am now going to close the public session. May I have a motion to close the public session? All in favor. We are adjourned. Thank you everyone. How are you?

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.