CorpusRecord 234513

FCSD Board Meeting Jan 7 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Fredonia Central School Board of Education Meetings
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Chautauqua County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,944 words · about 50 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001welcome to the pedon Central School Board of Education meeting for Tuesday January 7th 2025 uh we start each meeting with the flight pleas Allegiance United States of America and to the for stands one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for [Music] all um so we uh we have a proposed agenda tonight uh with a consent agenda uh it includes Personnel but excludes A1 uh B1 and B2 2 and C1 and includes all of your business um is there anything anyone would like to pull out of tonight's consent yes we pull the item hold on let see what number it is thank you item e subsection a today new bu1 thank you okay thanks so you'd like to pull that out of consent then all right um so we're going to pull out a consent

002uh in new business e one a which is the approval of a pilot program for those modified flag football uh so we'll discuss this when we get to it in the agenda uh is there anything else that would be anybody would like to call out tonight yeah if we could call out 7 [Music] C1 7 C1 do new business yeah um yes C1 which is the approval request for an overnight Retreat trip request Nike track and field Center okay so we're going to pull out new business uh C1 um out of consent T me tonight okay so see okay all right anything else okay um so could I have a motion to approve the consent Mr for and second Mr keny thank you all in favor I proposed great okay uh so we're going to

003move right into our first public comments Set uh comment uh for the night um the board has reserved the uh time to hear comments from the audience those wishing to address the board are ask to stand give their name and address limit their comments to five minutes or less per individual group uh concerns and comments during this session should be directly related to the items on the agenda if they're not uh there's a a second public comment at the end is there anybody like to address the board tonight we have a lot of students here tonight welcome um oh you your name is that public comment or hello hello okay all right um well we'll move right on uh next next we have the approval of the minutes of the regular meeting for December 10th

004uh could I have a motion to approve those amends Miss Gullo a second second M for thanks any comments or questions on the amends from December 10th all in favor opposed all right we can move into Financial so uh first up is uh the budget status investment revenue reports kind of do those all together and include comment on the dashboard so for Revenue during the month of November we picked up 80,000 in Lottery Aid we also booked in the final of three payments for our teach retirement system contribution and that is a double entry where you book it in as an expense and also have to record it as a revenue you never see the money just kind of flows back to the state so that's in there we adjusted the dashboard to reflect the

005fact that we're continuing to make additional interest above what we budgeted currently through the ones that we have out that we haven't received the interest back yet we're at 128,000 where we have budgeted 50,000 so that's going to be a good thing at the end of the year and actually in the month we booked in 40,000 which was maturing treasury bills from September and October so all good stuff there okay great uh any questions from the board on that we'll move on then to the treasures report can I have a motion bring that to theable Mr Marshall a second second Mr supports no comment on that everything is in order any questions all in favor oppos all right next up um so we also have the need uh to award a bid for tutoring a

006service to Shaw academic Institute have a motion to bring that to the table so was that for Miss fora second second just thanks anything on this oh yeah I'm going to touch base quickly then I'm going to ask Mrs phoh to chime in uh from a special ed perspective um as you know um you know we have a variety of students with different needs and we're always looking for uh different Services different providers who might be able to best meet those needs and recently we became aware of a relatively new program that's actually housed in the Dunkirk school but is not part of Dunkirk school it's just renting space there uh Mrs Farah went over and took a look I thought you could maybe just share some of your perspectives and uh again this is

007really all part about trying to match our students um with the best available services that meet their needs and we think um in at least um two scenarios um that bring us this resolution tonight um we found a location that is really going to be a nice fit so so well said thank you um I was really looking in terms of special ed for to place a I would say a hardto place student I reached out to some of my colleagues in um the count or the OES area um somebody said hey I have a student very similar to yours who's very successful with the sha program which I had not heard much about um so I reached out to them thinking I could fill a niche for one student that actually works for two

008students that I um kind of have that are in um just not in their placements right now for different reasons so um I spoke to Amanda mered who is one of the program directors at length and I went over to visit her on uh December 20th in the morning and they occupy two classrooms on the second floor of school in dunker and they have a sensory room up there and they're um currently hosting students from dunker schools as well as Brockton so we the Third District that they would be partnering with um it's very small right now but they're I think they're going to grow and um kind of meet some needs for Unique scenarios in the local area and um they're expanding and are going to have the the whole upper floor in that

009building next year is their plan so um it's reasonably priced they're Charing rate that we would charge our that we would pay a non FDA member for um twoing services so it's cost effective as well great great any comments or questions um you might have mentioned it maybe I missed it but transportation um we could transport if we wanted to the in this particular scenario I have going on right now the families are willing and interested in transporting on their own so um but if we needed to transport Mr fors and I could work on that okay great all those in favor I okay thanks um our first item under Personnel tonight is the approval of tenure for J Carroll who's in the physical education tener area I have a motion to bring that to

010the table Miss second second Mr Marshall thanks um yeah um Jake is here tonight thanks for being here Jake um again as I mentioned in my weekly update I apologize for being a little out of our typical routine with this particular tenure appointment um that will not be the norm um but there was a oversight there and that was my fault but um Jake um I just want to make a couple comments and turn it over to miss Paul heus um just in terms of being a polite positive friendly welcoming outgoing um really accommodating young men man um meets all those uh checks all those boxes so to speak and uh we're really happy to have him here um he has a really good connection with students and adults and has also done a very

011nice job outside of his teaching responsibilities um working with our tennis program and has been able to sustain that program and carry a tradition for many years of excellence and Tennis um continuing um under Jake so thank you for all of that it's good to see you tonight this PA yeah I mean his his enthusiasm and his energy are just simply contagious he's highly motivated um he's always perpetually positive um he works hard to plan with his department and his colleagues he Taps into their resources as veteran um physical Educators and health Educators um always willing to learn seeking PD opportunities he's very reflective he's always looking for suggestions and ways to improve his instruction um ways to continue to engage students so that the format instru of his lesson is um both instructional and

012um hitting the content but still getting the kids actively involved um so they have really responded well to the structure that he has during that that health education in particular but he is truly passionate about physical education physical um personal growth health education um and as Dr zilak says he's been um an asset to the athletic department as the varsity tennis coach um really immersed himself in our community I remember hiring him over zoom and I think it was the very next weekend he came down to apartment to hunt and um within just a few weeks he had totally relocated from the Erie County area and has not left um even a part of now a pickleball Club in our area so he is you know again fully immersed in our community which I very

013much appreciate he's truly an asset a positive asset to our building we're excited to have him continue right any any comments just you received such a glowing recommendation and we're very pleased to have you in our district thank you yeah and I I have to say that my father was long-standing tennis coach here back in the 60s 7s early 80s my wife of course was tennis coach and she's so thrilled I'm thrilled that You' taken it on both the boys and the girls and kept it going so we really appreciate that um all those in favor congratulations anything you want to share J yeah Pi it official well thank you everybody I really appreciate it uh once again a part of the fed and Health Department here at fonia boys and girls varsity tennis head

014coach and thank you for giving me a chance for years ago to my colleagues and to the administration and I'm excited to continue being a teacher and being a part of the fonia community for years to come really appreciate it thank you thank you thank [Applause] you free to go anytime you want uh the other part of personnel is this time of year uh sadly we have to um uh announce resignations uh for retirement purposes uh to some longstanding Educators the first resignation we can do approved tonight is uh for Teresa Noles longstanding science teacher in high school uh for the purpose of retirement uh could I have a motion to bring that to the table someone m a second second thank you Dr yeah I'll turn it over to Mr paski in a moment

015but uh you know from my perspective uh Teresa is one of those people that's willing to get involved in a number of things uh Beyond um her classroom work but in terms of just um instruction um science instruction just so solid and really experienced and um I think did a fantastic job preparing um our students um for exams as well as next steps within the department um as part of the group that greets students in the morning um each day at the event entrance and uh just a nice positive way to start off the day um and you know roughly 30 years of experience in the district so between Teresa and Laura who we'll speak about next you know a little over 60 years experience um so that will absolutely be missed and uh at

016the same time we wish them well it's always Bittersweet um and we appreciate everything Teresa's done for the district Mr pashy it's been hard uh she's been here since 1994 um sadly I was here before that but but um she's she's just been a staple a perfect example of what a great teacher is um she's prepared for her kids every day she keeps her kids first place and just beyond the classroom where she's incredible she puts in a lot of time behind the scenes a lot of people don't know about um she she's on our pride committee um she she's been super active in in our freshman orientation program and just developing materials for our entire staff to use um when when we went to advisement in the black schedule she she and another teacher

017worked together to make uh PowerPoint presentations and videos to show kids that on how to be successful in high school and and ways that you could be successful in life in general so it's just like really great stuff that a lot of teachers still use and and incorporate in their classes that she was really an instrumental part in bringing to our school and so that that will be the lasting Legacy hers um it's going to be sad to imagine the school without her being there but she will be missed thanks any any comments from the board well regretfully we have to uh vote on this all in favor the post um we welcome her uh in her retirement uh we thank her for her commitment or dedication to the district it's it's hard to replace

018veteran teachers like that that leads us another veteran teacher that we have to accept uh resignation uh for Laura Dew other valued high school teacher in the business department um I have a motion to bring that to the table so moov okay second second Mr Marshall thanks Dr Z yeah same I'll turned over to Mr pashi um Laura um absolutely um really is in tune with what's happening uh in the workplace what's happening in um the the larger markets around us and what does that mean for students who are building skills that we want to be transferable through a variety of scenarios in the real world and that has really been her Focus um here in fonia um a lot of work with JCC and offering college courses um as well as an outstanding internship

019program um which we um will do our best to keep moving forward but um she again roughly 30 years of experience in the district will absolutely be missed and very much appreciate especially you know that that thought about how do we prepare uh for the workplace how do we prepare for next steps and what are the skills that we're building um to be successful yeah same situation with Laura uh Laura feels a very Niche area I mean that there aren't many business teachers out there anymore um it's it's hard to lose that position and she does so well um just the the care and concern she gives for for our kids and ensuring that that there are programs that help them to be successful in in the workforce when they leave school the internship program

020that we have she built and and she made it what it is today and we we have you know 30 sometimes 40 kids participating in internships in area businesses she did the leg work she went to these businesses and and worked with them to set up agreements to have kids go and work with them and uh she just non-stop she she's always looking for ways to to get our kids Awards and scholarships and opportunities to go and and Shadow even before they can be in the internship program just setting up opportunities for them to to be with area businesses and find out the things that they like and and don't like which is equally important so um she's going to be sorely missed and and difficult to replace thank you any comments no like like

021Miss Noles um you think of the thousands of students that um they impact over their career so uh they've impacted a lot of lives and we'll miss them and I wish both them well in res in retirement regretfully all in favor opposed uh the next item under Personnel tonight is to approve the appointment of Gregory Holberg to a probationary teaching position in the science 10 10 area I have a motion to bring to the table a second second Mr Kenny thank you Dr zil oh yeah just a quick reminder for everyone and then I'll ask M paulus to make couple quick comments um so Greg uh initially student taught with Jeff ksky at the high school and then we transitioned him into a somewhat new and unique um agreement through sun in which he came

022on board at the middle school and finished his student teaching while taking over the classrooms that were um vacant as part of a full-time position um has he finished up his degree over the last couple months um he successfully did that at the end of December has now been fully certified so we are transitioning now from um long-term sub situation into a probationary certified teach scenario which is always ideal and what we um strive for um with all our um hiring processes and um you know Jeff trinsky spoke very highly of Greg so did um all those individuals uh who he interacted with at Sunni fonia and it's nice when all that plays out because he is certainly delivering and doing a nice job and uh really has jumped into the middle school world and

023kept things moving forward and uh any other comments from from you miss Paul no I mean he's a hard worker he's too like Mr Carol has really tapped into the the support from Mrs laow and Miss e in the science department at the middle school so um he's developing great relationships with his kids and he's like it's almost like he's was always there um so we're glad that he can continue with us too but he's doing a great job great this is backdated to the date of his certification great any comments we welcome uh Mr homberg to the science tenure area teaching position uh all those in favor I opposed than okay that ends personnel and uh but we do have uh some things that have been put out consent right so that brings us

024to the first item which is uh C1 uh which is the approval for request for an overnight Retreat trip uh track team to attend the uh refuel with chocolate milk that's miss their name invitation at the Nike track in field Center um in the armory in New York City on January 10th and 11th as submitted uh can I have a motion to bring that to the table Mr alri second second Mr Marshall uh Dr Zill anything to elaborate on before we um I don't think so I'm just looking at what was in the uh backup um regarding the proposal not sure I just pulled it out because it was a chocolate milk and poast chocolate milk is one of my favorite and uh I couldn't help but it one more time some more milk okay

025all right there I don't want to speak out of term but there's a possibility that that's not going to happen there's been some difficulty with transportation and the cost of it so unless they've done something in the last few days I don't know if they've got anything arranged Transportation however it is a potential great opportunity and we're hopeful that uh that can work itself out okay I like hot chocolate but don't put that in the paper just out of curiosity was it a late planning or I mean this is this weekend was it just late to us or it's been planned or I don't have a whole lot of detail say it came in for this particular agenda but it didn't I might not yeah they approached me to assist with the transportation Before Christmas

026okay we didn't have a lot of options and they were somewhat significant costs so right do that okay so there's really nothing to vote on approve it in case yeah okay all those in favor opposed uh the another item that was pull out of consent was from Miss H um which is agenda item e1a Miss Han is requested this to be pulled U with regards the approval of a pilot program for the girls modified flag football team for the spring have a motion to bring this to the table on second second just call thank you U Dr Z ask before we discuss it can you can you anything to expand on on this um yeah I'll just summarize real quick I had a few paragraphs in the um backup um this is a unique opportunity

027through the Buffalo Bills actually and I think we all know that um there's definitely been um uh interest and um increase in flag teams in the area over the last couple years and it's really become a popular sport with a lot of participation um you know the bills are trying to promote and enhance um those opportunities so they made grants available um in $3,000 increments um for anybody that either would start the program or expand their program um since we already had a program in place we were looking at potentially um adding a modified team and uh in this first year it would be a pilot we kind of see how things go um and kind of uh Monitor and adjust from there um I know there were some concerns about potentially um having the

028team play at the Orange Bowl and that um could be a valid concern each spring brings a little different um weather conditions um sometimes the fields are very dry that happened last year um sometimes um they're difficult to get on especially in that early part of the season so um our thought is that um we would and adjust and um luckily um flag football without the use of goal posts um can be played at almost any of our Fields um and we can practice on almost any field um including uh the field uh over on the baseball field at Chestnut where I think our football team practices most of the time um and you know in this year we would definitely you know be looking at you know the amount of in interest and participation

029how does that impact um Sports and uh just try to move forward in the most appropriate Direction at that time so discussion um well first a question after the um I understand that the bills would be underwriting the initial year after that what's the approximate cost to our district of this program I think in the so we would run this how we've done it we we ran it as an inter mural um so in terms of uh coaching costs they're minimal in this first year but beyond that um we would look at um and an agreement with the FTA to add coaches so that would um substantially increase the cost I think in the backup it said it would be about 10 $10,000 roughly each year run run the program thank you well my comments

030are that regrettably uh as everyone knows our community voted not to approve proposition two and three of our Capital project proposition three would have entailed the replacement of our unsafe athletic fields um and so as a result the unsafe conditions will continue uh into the future Additionally the $10,000 per year we now have to look at building up Capital reserves um which are decimated and uh at what we can do to maintain and hopefully make our Fields more safe so I until we speak with young and Wright regarding possible alternatives to our Capital project I don't feel comfortable approving another Sport and that's I would suggest that we table this until after we have met with young right any other comments discussion I I agree with the approach I think have not circled back with

031the Architects to see what the next steps are or what the opportunities are to fill those gaps um so I think we have some due diligence to complete first so I would support tabling um this motion until we have more information on um next steps from our field perspective okay any other comments this question I assume there'd be two coaches like varsity that's what's in the proposal both paid positions okay so under so so under inter murals they be paid both of them yeah okay anything else I agree with with these two ladies I don't think in good faith right now I can say I would support that program that kills me to say that this is a new program we can yeah I don't know where they would play I don't know how we

032would pay for this right um so I would support tbling it as well let's have more time and then maybe hopefully I don't know if it be own possibilities to check with sun fonia seeing that they don't need gold post if it did get approved um the boys varsity plays there so right so look for Alternatives other comments I think uh I mean I agree and I think that and all of us who've been here I mean certainly we are not ones to say no to sports or any activities but I think we're in a unique situation right now where we don't know what the future holds the reality is it's a safety concern I wish that we were trying to improve the fields just to have a luxury but we were trying to improve

033the fields because of safety concerns right so we can't dismiss that and we have to be I agree we have to just see what direction are we moving in in the next trunk of time and then revisit this okay any other comments I think I would just like to share you know as we kind of mold this over over the next couple weeks and I think the young and right piece is is relevant um but you know there were decisions made by adults in the community I don't want to see that negatively impact the students um in our district and I would just like just to keep an eye on the thought that we want to offer addition opport we want to expand um offerings even if the capital project had passed we'd still be

034in the situation right now not being able to play on any new field for two three seasons um so in some ways even with that there wouldn't be a change in the current um dilemma that we find ourselves in but I would like to think that we're trying to offer as many opportunities as we can I guess my my uh take on it is uh again I I hate to deny opportunities right I mean we're I think we want our kids we want to expand our our students opportunities um but at the same time I I hear what you're saying and I I fully agree you know the orange bowls under stress uh adding another team on that field uh could be really problematic this last year we're lucky we had a really dry spring

035uh that's not normally the case who knows what it's going to be like for flag football this spring and then we got to get it ready for the fall um but I would hope that we could come up with an alternative solution uh another field in our school perhaps it's not under stress during that time which obviously won't be this you know great shape either uh or off campus so I hope we can revisit it um and uh but we do have to talk with young right I think and go from there and sry I I would just like to reiterate that again I think this this is a pause we have not regrouped to understand implications and so I I know several said we're not looking to deny opportunities but I think we need

036to do that in an informed fashion and and right now there's there's questions about how this would play out and we need we need to at least explore that um before we can move this forward in good faith so not denying I think the cuse to have the conversation okay yeah and what I was going to say is that it's not it's not you're absolutely right nothing's going to change with what they tell us however I think because now we know we're we're in a period of time where we don't know what the next several years look like when we want to bring a new program like this or even as we look at each upcoming season we have to be really strategic as to where everybody's practicing and playing and I think now we're

037to a point where we have to know well where are they going to practice and how is that going to impact because we don't want to stress the Orange Bowl any further for the girls book farity fly football who will be playing at the orange ball so I think if this had come with even a little more information like they'll practice up at the field of the practice at Chestnut or whatever that would be helpful because I think that's where we are now we have to be more strategic and mindful of our of our fields and their condition yeah that's early days you know we are hoping for a different uh outcome but now we're going to have to regroup and work out what we're going to do um and you know I I know

038all of us here are always for the students and uh we do want to uh expand as many programs as we can as possible so so is a matter of housekeeping uh if this is table we have two meetings to pull it off the table otherwise it has to be uh brought back as a motion second I'm not really sure is that what I'll double check and let not that that's an issue we could just bring it back as a motion just right just as housekeeping okay yeah and then um is there a deadline for accepting the grant what happened I think we might lose 3,000 from the bills um sure if the deadline deadine what that deadline I think we're going to be okay what what this allows us to do is look at

039shared resources who in the community can we share with can we use another field can we play somewhere else can we that's that's the idea the pause okay any other discussion or so we're going to table uh item under new business e1a uh for the pilot program for the girls modified flag football team for the spring uh all in favor I propos can I do that right okay everybody hesitated so I wasn't sure all right uh that leads us to our second round of public comment tonight um thought I saw a hot hand there at the beginning that is that hand okay we're all good we're gonna move on uh so next we're on to the superintendent report yeah a few items for tonight um you may have noticed um we had on the agenda

040tonight for a first read uh one of our board policies number 7220 equal educational opportunities um this is a very small tweak to a policy um but it basically talks about how everyone everybody should have access to um everything a school district has to offer and how we should be treating everybody equally and then it went on to have a paragraph specifically about students who might be married or students who might be primate um which seemed to be kind of counter to this like everybody's all inclusive and the opportunities are available to all and then it goes on to talk about two separate groups so the recommendation from our policy service was to to um delete that language and just keep it focused on all these opportunities being available to anybody who attends our school

041so that is the adjustment there um if uh there's any curiosity um I did want to touch a little bit on the um Capital project um I wanted to thank everybody who did come out to vote um the um turnout um was impressive and um what we had said here several times as we felt it was important um to take the feedback that we were getting about what a capital project could look like and I think we did and put it out to the community allow the community to decide um and that played out um and you know every once in a while I'll see a school district where a very small number of people will turn out and maybe people in that Community question was this really what the community had to say um

042and in our case um we had a a big turnout and um you know I think you know that's why we have the vote um allow the community to decide and um even with proposition two and three not passing proposition one did that's about $22 Million worth of work um we are moving forward with the young right planning and thinking about exactly how does that look exactly what the plans are for that um there's a lot of work to be done um eventually plans will be submitted to New York state for approval um um it'll come back to us after that for a bid process for those who might be interested in doing the work and then we'll beginning work um ASAP although that is a process um so if anybody's looking for a new

043re roof um anytime soon we're not going to be quite there yet um at the same time with proposition two the expansion of our music Suite uh proposition three the multi-use field these problems um and issues that that um were raised and expressed um that resulted in those propositions still exist so we are now in a process of regrouping um at this moment about what might we be able to do moving forward how will we address uh these concerns how will we create the space that we believe our music program is very shortly going to need to continue to um expand and uh how do we put our student athletes on the the surface we possibly can um so all that is still in the mix and um more to follow there part of that

044is um meetings that we have with young and wri um we've done a couple different things um up till this point with that there are occasions where it's just myself John Forbes Kim bingenheimer um and a group from Young and Wright that meet to meet to sort of brainstorm and process information we've also had meetings with young and Wright and with just our policy committee which is two members of our Board of Education then we've also had meetings here as workshops with the entire board and the community to participate again I think Miss H has a suggestion for how she might want to tweak um how we're handling those meetings and I want to give you a chance to express your thank you thoughts uh my thought is simply that I would like the facilities

045committee to be invited or the full board to any meeting with young and Bri particularly the debrief of the capital vote outcome well actually I think we're due for facilities committee meeting um because we didn't have it in December so we could go with that any other comments or on it I think we have let me just double check here I thought guess I thought we had the facilities scheduled for 21 but it must be maybe it's February 4 yeah it's February 4 right now we don't have anything on the prior to our meeting on the 21st if that's something we want to um consider well we also have to consider the pe's pilot program modified football and we have two meetings to approve that can we do the 21st with facilities and then well

046if we could accommodate at least an initial meeting and and young and right before the Bill's Grant expires obviously that that would be ideal I mean again the the idea would be to get additional information and be strategic so if if that's possible um is there a time of the day that would be firmed facilities committee if that's what we're saying maybe we find out when that Grant expires um make sure that we're ahead of the game on that have the facilities committee meeting so that we can get the information back to everybody so that we can incorporate that in our decision with the flag football um so you just want to do that ASAP is there a meeting with young and bright schedule for this Thursday there so I'm wondering can the facilities committee

047be invited to that meeting sure what time is that meeting one one PM okay and those are by zo so okay want to do that okay so this this Thursday facilities commit uh committee meeting you get you good thank you okay good all right any other anything else on superintendent oh yeah a couple things uh my bad uh just wanted to let you uh Mr paski made me aware that the response to the Greece and Italy uh proposed trip that was approved at our last meeting has been massive I think we have 44 slots filled um and also 15 on a waiting list so um we are looking at maybe making some slight adjustments to accommodate everyone um that may result at some point and US revisiting um just that proposal and I would just

048like if if things shifted slightly to make sure that our approval is accurate to the plan uh at the time um I felt like the board has overwhelmingly supported these kinds of trips in the past I don't think there's any issue with it but we might just need to on the back end sort of make sure that we're aligned exactly what the trip will look like and that we're approving what it will look at so that's exciting again we appreciate Mrs nudy taking lead on that and really um looking to offer students um a great experience just as an FYI if you are interested um on Tuesday January 14th at 1M our governor will uh release uh or make her 2025 State of the State address that usually include some information um about um School

049budgets so we're anxiously and closely keeping an eye on that um there was a link in the backup if you're interested in in seeing that um also just wanted to um note that our board will be having a retreat on January 23 um as part of just operating as efficiently and smoothly as we possibly can so we look forward to that thanks to Mr Johnson and Mrs forner for their work there and also that um as the board knows on uh the first February meeting in executive we'll be talking a little bit about my mid year evaluation and just wanted note that that will be happening and uh we're on schedule for that to happen that's all I have good any comments on the report no um hopefully good news with the governor's address and

050uh thank you to M spner for taking on board the retreat she's done the Lion Share on it so I get no credit for it thank you for doing that and uh we're looking forward to I think we have a pretty good agenda set up for that so great uh the next uh Board of Education meeting will be on Tuesday January 21st at 6m here in the high school library uh also uh on announcement there's also correspondence and I actually uh have some correspondence uh I received um a letter from Joan laer who is the chairperson for the Harvest Moon Cemetery tour here in fonia over Halloween um Joan wrote a very nice letter praising some of our students that volunteered their time for the tour and she asked me to read uh the letter

051to you so uh I I'll just briefly read very quickly and take one or two minutes here her letter but it says I'm Joe low uh she's the event chairperson for the hot Harvest Moon SE Cemetery tour which is down the road for me uh she said she goes on to say I'm passionate as I am about the SE Cemetery tour I don't know who to recruit as volunteers or who to outreach I listen to season members who suggested asking uh fonia Central School students to participate and um I thought that was a great idea it's been years since my sons attended fonia school so I really didn't know a whole lot of people today not worked with at the school uh but I did know Mrs Gullo so she reached out to Mrs gulow

052and Courtney was a wonderful contact she says help me connect with all the right people from your school Courtney suggested Conta contacting Ben wle at our school and first of all within hours of contacting Mr Wendell I had a potential list of student volunteers what a pleasure it was to give them Direction and they were so compliant when some had track practice they made sure afterwards to come to our rehearsals that's commitment and responsibility I want to thank their parents for helping make my job easier and you as Educators for helping those future adults obviously there was a cats there were they were fed mounds of food all night long for two nights it was well worth to exceed my festival's budget believe me I hope next year I can again encourage these students to

053act in the cemetery tour these children represented their families their school and their Community they will build a better future for all of us like truly from the bottom of my heart I was in awe of the respect I was given I as a former educator for 40 years forever a parent and a grandparent and now as a volunteer regard manners and respect as a priority taught as a lifelong lesson and they were extremely respectful it was my pleasure to reconnect with the staff at the school my experience was very positive I hope this is the beginning of a wonderful relationship between the school and the cemetery tour committee thank you ladies and gentlemen for your attention and I think this uh this letter reminds us why we put in all these volunteer hours as

054board members it's it's always heartwarming to hear about our students and them helping out in volunteering in the community so thank you Miss L um all where are we at we are at I guess uh we're we're pretty much done and we could hear from the floor any general comments from the board to Mr yeah I have I'd like to take some time of of some of your time to make some comments um kind of a postmortem as it were the capital project um I've got a lot of things I don't understand and I want to talk about them share them with you um I wanted to start with the things that I can understand I can certainly understand why proposition 3 didn't pass I knew it would be a big ask but I felt

055strongly I know other members of the board felt strongly and so we decided to ask it didn't pass I have no bitterness I understand I can also understand and I even appreciate uh the community members that came in and spoke both in support of and against the increase um especially those on a fixed income I had those conversations with my neighbors and other community members I can understand that I wish my understanding continued but it doesn't um I can't understand why proposition one barely passed 43% of our V of our voters said no to providing basic crucial maintenance things like roof repairs the cost to the average taxpayer was less than $5 a month we nearly left $7 million on the table we would have lost had that not passed I can't understand why proposition

056two failed it's a project that would have cost the average taxpayer $3 a month the majority of our taxpayers looked at that and said nope not on my watch we we did leave believe $7.8 million $7.8 million that will now be in another school district's building not ours I cannot understand some of the comments I heard from members of this community regarding the capital project I had conversations with them and they told me things like we should have asked private business is to support project this is a public school or we should have fundraised this isn't the Little League not selling candy bars to put up an athletic field for students fundraising may be a great way to pay your medical bills but it doesn't work in public education I also heard that we should

057have asked New York state to help us out paying for this mindblowing to me willful ignorance of the facts and how things work and I had conversations with people we did ask the state said yes they they gave us $7.8 million all we had to do was come up with 2.2 of our own we didn't do that I can't understand that I cannot understand the Community member who came in to this meeting and said that although they had just purchased a $1 million property in this community they couldn't afford the extra $100 a month taxes that was going to be a terrible thing for them in fact they suggested that proposed increase was going to be a thing that could stop them from doing business here in chiaka County imagine that I can't understand it

058I have a friend who just bought a big truck and he drove it for a month and he's griping to me about his gas bill crazy I can't understand it and I'm certainly willing to bet that most of our community can't understand buying a million dollar property and not being able to afford an extra $100 a month and that by the way would have been if all three propositions have passed I cannot understand The Observers December 7th opinion piece a piece written with such ill-informed disingenuous information it it was mindblowing to me if if you follow the logic it told readers that Fredonia has too few students were shrinking but at the same time we have too many music students so the the solution would be let's get them into a different school district and

059use their facilities mind you their facilities may be at occupancy already or at capacity those facilities are smaller than ours it would add I could only assume hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of debt or I'm sorry hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of busting fees to our budget not to mention take away at least 30 minutes a day of instructional time from those students I can't understand that I cannot understand the actions of this board over the past 20 years when it comes to zero% tax increases as a point of Pride I think it was precisely that lack of forethought that put us in this position right now that's why we're here year after year no tax increase no tax increase imagine if you tried to run your household that way you told your

060spouse I'm not making any more money and I and I don't plan to I know everything else is getting expensive but I'm not bringing more money past boards prioritized 0% tax increases and look at at the cost and finally I'd be remiss if I didn't address the biggest thing I can't understand and that's a board of ed member who came here at the October 17th meeting and at the absolute last minute came out in opposition to all three propositions after nearly two years of working on project two years that were mostly under his leadership as board president but at the 11th hour and 59 minutes and 59 seconds literal minutes prior to our vote said I'm not going to support not only three which to be fair wasn't a surprise but one or two and

061the reasoning stated was because the District needed to be more business friendly we should put businesses before our children that's a chamber of commerce thing that's not a board of ed thing I don't understand and in defending those actions he said we should share services and share resources I think all of us on this board agree with that we should do that but that leads me to next Point another thing I can't understand in May of 2015 that same board member is quoted in the paper is saying my concern here for the district is solely looking at the future in the next 10 to 20 years I'm interested in some type of longterm strategic planning where we continue to look at sharing services that was nearly a decade ago here we are other things I

062can't understand the last thing I can't understand at the moment I don't know where to go I have all kinds of emotions um I'm sure others do I've talked briefly with some of you um I think we need time as a board to process we need time to uh go out and speak to taxpayers and District residents and ask and and listen um but I don't think we have that luxury because sitting and doing nothing doesn't address any of the issues that are still facing us with overcrowding in music or our shoty athletic facilities we don't have that luxury so just some random thoughts I've been thinking about here and I think we need to we need to have an honest conversation I don't know if this is forming the committee I don't know what

063this is but I think everything has to come into play now um do we shut down the Orange Bowl and move games to ches street do we move games back here behind the field for football behind the the school I've been at the Orange Bowl on rainy days on cold days I've watched people in Mobility School going down the hill I've helped people push one up a hill I think we are seconds away from a lawsuit that could potentially cost this District's taxpayers millions of dollars I'd rather take that money and put it into a multi-use stadium when it comes to the girls football flight football team my daughter was part of that first team but there's nothing more like to do then approve that but I don't know where they would go I don't

064know how we pay for it in the future maybe we can play at the Orange Bowl do we limit Spectators no Spectators these are all things I think we have to consider do we need to work with the music department to curb enrollment do we cap instrumentation do we cut back on individual lent times things I think are are important and do we reach out if resource sharing is a thing if we are truly talking about this what's the next step we've had years to look at this and we haven't do we reach out to dunk Kirk and say what can we share how can we make our two districts function together three miles apart makes sense to me more than it does n miles to get to BR 8 miles to get to Forest

065I could go on and on but I won't for now um I appreciate all of your time listening to me rant and I thank you all for everything you do for the board I had to say that any other comments thanks for speaking thank you very comments I also want to thank Aaron for his comments and just add on to that that I think our board faces a lack of institutional memory we we are know that our current leadership is working on a strategic long-term plan um I think we're we were in the position that we were in having to put together this expensive Capital project because we were lacking in information and memory uh I don't know how it was possible that we were not all kept AR breast of the fact that all

066of the roof maintenance and these other maintenance projects were going to come up at one time um that should not be something we're informed of at the moment um I don't know why there hasn't been a strategic plan in place for years where we know what expenses are coming up I don't know why we haven't had a capital project in two decades um and so I just want to mention that I think those are real problems including the fact that previous board leadership had us spend down our Capital reserves um don't know why we did that we obviously needed those so I too have a lot of questions um and I too was disappointed in The Observer editorial I think it was Ill informed um the person who wrote it is not at these meetings

067uh has not as we have met with young and Wright to discuss our options um is not here to hear our community members and coaches tell us that our fields are un safe so yeah I would say I too like Aaron have a lot of questions um perhaps I'm a little more resentful than he is um with the public many of whom kept themselves purposely ill informed um because as Aaron said prop two was going to be covered 78% of that by state aid um and we heard from our music department what the justification were for the improvements to our music facilities here and with regard to the fields we are I believe the second largest school district in Northern Chaka County we have a reputation I believe as one of the best school districts

068in all of shiwa County and yet our community doesn't seem to prioritize keeping our students with the facilities they deserve so I'm very sorry about that and I am angry about it and uh we moved here because we love this community and I would like to see others have some fonia pride so thank you thanks any other time I I have to say I I agree son I think you know we have to look to the future we have to develop a long-term strategic plan uh for capital projects so that long after we're probably not on the board we set those boards up for success and uh you know I tend to deal in facts opinions I disregard a lot of opinions but the fact is 8 million is going back to the state that

069will go to other schools including schools in this area $8 million out of the 10 million um in fact uh last five years uh we've been increasing in population student population correct last five years we've increasing our population not decreasing that's a fact and uh another fact uh last 10 years we've increased on average in our budgets in May 1% uh think if we had gone back 10 years and increase 2% over those 10 years that's the 10% rate there and we could have said y doesn't cost anything to the to the but we had something that wasn't done 2% when you look at inflation over the last few years 9% it got up to uh look at local areas entities and their tax increases uh we've been I think fiscally responsible at 1% over

07010 years that's a fact so uh yeah so we're going to have to move forward and the process and you we're going to have to dig in and continue working to see what we can do to you know better the uh the facilities that are that our school for our students all right if there's nothing else from the board we'll move on Mr Pash thank for going to be first I know we need to cut the um I would just stand after break uh not not a lot of updates since we last met but uh we do have some pretty cool stuff coming up in the very near future we only have eight days left before we start our midterm in Rance exams in January uh 13 days before we end the second quarter so

071it's it's uh coming to a close uh the first semester will be ending um I just wanted to make only one other comment the um you know our cell phone policy has I think been going quite well um I did have to put email out to the staff to inform them that I was allowing one specific student to use their phone yesterday um and and that was Andrew Cowan because he was expecting a phone call from West Point to be accepted to West Point um and so did received that phone call um and now he's just waiting for a letter from the president of the United States to finish that process so he's it so so congratulations to [Applause] that's great news going west um West Point middle school that's um we had a successful

072first couple of days back in fact um and I'm out back every morning for arrival and usually after a break they are like crawling out of the car and maybe not as thrilled to see me as I am to see them but I will tell you on Monday they were all so excited to come back to school and the two weeks they just felt um you know invigorated and ready to go but um you it was very exciting to to welcome them back into the building on um Monday we ended our modified girls basketball season right before winter break and now have just begun our boys modified basketball with coaches cirle and kakam Meer and Bonnie Brett has started her cheer Club back up to cheer for the boys during the season so those are

073some exciting opportunities that are beginning for our kids as of Monday great great that's rare to have a two we break Christmas for weeks students and teachers and administrators well not completely two weeks well that's great u m Mr Dr nice um yeah so we're just easing back in as well but uh today Dr Wright and I had the opportunity to um really attend a really um wonderful workshop with the big five school districts and all the regional boies because the state released a document um it's PK through grade three literacy instructional best practices so what this is is is it kind of um puts into writing what they think the science of reading is because it's been so buzzworthy for so long um this conference that we went to today for four hours it

074started off with a doctor who um kind of talked about the science of learning and the importance of how our brains are actually wired and then she came full circle and talked about what do best practices in Reading look like and for school districts uh we have from now until September to look through this doc this document and in September we have to compete and uh at a station Forum where we answer some yes or no questions are we doing these things in our classroom so just the initial look that I had it today I'm I'm very proud to report that we're doing a lot of these things very well because of the work that uh Dr Wright and the curriculum Council has done over the past couple of years with the uh literacy Pilots

075that we've been running and things like that so um I'm excited to to it just became public to today last week it's Public public today public was today early released um curriculum directors and people in my position um like literally over the break like after Christmas what it's so well written it's it's probably one of the most um easy to understand documents from State ad that I've seen in my career so I would encourage you I I would really encourage the board to look at it because it's not um a lot of it has a lot of acronyms and things that I don't understand but this is a really easy read and it kind of summarizes what is the science of reading so um we can share the link with you guys but I really

076want I I think you should look at it it's a quick overview but you can talk more about it do you want to or it was just a really powerful meeting we had today do you want to talk more about it sure okay no okay well thank you if you could showare absolutely be Fant that's fantastic news that's great Mr girl I feel like it shouldn't be my turn though well I will say one more came back from that Workshop he said that was the best four hours I've spent so it it must have been really powerful and I will also enjoy reading that I don't have a whole lot of new news um just because we're getting back into the swing of things after the Break um you know New Year I start to

077turn my thoughts to planning for next year so that's kind of where um the special ed department is headed we're still working on our targeted skills group for um Dropout prevention so we have some meetings coming up on that just moving forward great thank you Sam W welcome again um you're welcome to speak during General board comments um you hopefully we can connect so that you can you know give us an insight into the students and what's going on and some of their their interests and issues so welcome again thank you for coming yeah um so uh yeah just right um yes it was funny because Mr drer and I were like wonder who was g called on first to be able to talk about the literacy for you so like most of what he

078said so everything Mr Jinger said and yeah so in 30 years in education I can tell you that this document from the state is the first time it is a usable discernable document that actually puts all districts on the same page typically when something comes down from the state it's very big Broad big language with a lot of eded you speak in it and it always tries to pass the buck on and we're going to defer to the local education agent agency the Lea we we'll leave it to the Local District to decide what are their measurements how will they measure what will they do what will they this and so it's like here's this big thing but now go create it and then report it to us and then we'll tell you what not

079right and it becomes this back and forth and it doesn't allow you to work with other districts because everybody's doing it on their own in this case um it was very interesting how our new commissioner is is handing things down because they're requiring bosies to um host so what this was is the New York State education department got a hold of all the district superintendents and let them know that your bosies has to host the component districts on this date at this time because we're going to be live streaming and announcing and sharing these things so this was all live with everybody and and so that's not typically how things are done and so it was very interesting to be in the room with our area districts and um and it was for administrators only

080and to go through this and to have speakers and different members from the state to present the different parts and talk about the why behind it and this really allows us a vehicle for looking at the horizontal alignment which is one of our goals we know you have to have horizontal alignment before you can have vertical alignment right now it is for prek through third grade and it is focused on literacy which is another one of our you know Focus areas for the district so it's very exciting to see those things come together it's also very exciting to see the science of learning which was a term that was really new to hearing and it went through all of the different work that's been done um to talk about how how is it that students

081acquire learning what are the conditions that you need and a tremendous amount of that has to do with the social emotional learning the relationships with the teachers the environment the want to come to school again all things we've been discussing and talking about um and working with um the leader and me Second Step um all the different pride and PBIS throughout the district so it was really exciting to sit there and know like we've been doing these things we've been working on these things and that felt really really good the document itself went through a lot of things about and again as you said the buzzword of the science of reading and it really helped people to understand that the science of reading is not a program it's not a curriculum it literally is how

082do students acquire the ability to read the acquire the ability to have vocabulary skills phonological awareness all of those different things so it really broke that down and showed how this document that every District in New York state will have to do an adastation that and it just simply is how are you doing in these key areas from grades upk and it was wonderful also to have pre kindergarten included typically that's not the case either so up PK to third grade and you you have to go through this rating so we're going to be getting more information this was the original document the actual attestation how you'll have to fill that out and what will be required has not been released yet that won't be released till February so I don't know if they're just

083doing a really positive thing today so we're all like looking forward to something and then we actually look at the document it's like not so great but fingers crossed it's not the case so um it was wonderful because Mr draer was there um along with Andrea Marsh our Middle School assistant principal and um who is part of the science of reading Consortium that's going on right now at Bose along with two of our teachers um April powers and Aaron Henry so it's really wonderful to have all these facets happening huge shout out to bosis for the way they presented us today they were it was wonderful the environment the conversations the collegiality um that was all fantastic and this is um all tied to education law 818 this isn't um some kind of a hey

084we'd like you to do this this is an actual education law that we all every District in New York state will meet need to abide by also this reporting this will be the first year we have to report we need to begin the work once it's opened in February reported by the deadline of September 1st and it was fun to map out a plan to have a team with um both U Mr jander and Mrs Marsh to do that with and um we're talking you know now we'll be talking at administrative Council about this and kind of cluing everybody and I'm sure that you know Mr Pas was like what is this all about because again this is all just today um today was the first one of these um presentations by the state but

085this this is a report this edlaw 818 is going to be required annually of every school district and we are all taking bets this is the beginning the upk3 will get set and done well then we're expecting to see this this you know Branch up into grades four through six likely then our 712 so we feel like we're in really good shape to start this you know foundational work here with all that we've been doing so it was it was it was very exciting we got to nerd out on curriculum and um feel really good about it and be excited about what we're going to doing next step of it and yes and I grabbed all the extra packets there all the because it's a big document I was like may we need these oh

086I'll take all these extra copies so I have copies for people I really appreciate all your enthusiasm for this you can see it permeates um you know a teacher always a teacher right yeah you know science of reading um that's part of our strategic plan it you know as is as frustrated as we are with the capital project so excited about the Str strategic plan which is really going behind the scenes right now that's a big ticket issue item that we're work that you're working on um horizontal vertical alignment uh science of reading not only are we digging in on that but the state is um these are these are big issues that I'm really excited about really I can't under you know tell you how much I'm excited so thank you for that work

087thanks thank you very much uh Mr Force anything January is also exciting for me because start of the budget process so speaking so uh just want to let the board know that the we're beginning to accumulate the documents from the building levels for the budget the first major expense to drop is the bosei services which will be getting that packet on Friday and I like to put that in first each year uh challenges that we'll have this year depending on how the negotiation process goes we're going to have two contracts which potentially can go on into the next school year and that always is challenging to try to make sure you budget enough to cover there so kind couple different things there plus we'll be gearing up for the project finances as well good keep

088us updated thank you thanks this Mor say anything I'm just excited that Mr Forge is excited think I've seen otherwise know I think everyone here has said everything that needs to be said so everybody great there's nothing more to be said um we'll close out the meeting tonight there's no need for executive tonight um thank you all for attending students thank you for attending it's always great to see the students here uh you're welcome to come up and get your form sign by anyone table have motion to Second all in fav

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.