CorpusRecord 234989

GCSD Board of Education Meeting - February 4th, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Greece Central School District AV
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Monroe County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,881 words · about 78 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right next up we have our Union comments I believe I saw Mr Mack here from GTA hi Eric welcome Eric can you swing to this one for me thanks all right good evening everyone my name is Eric mock I am a gtre at Athena High School and I work with our leadership on a number of initiatives uh net held a Rochester disconnected event last week highlighting the growth uh the growing need to address Technology's impact on student learning particularly cell phones our GTA leadership organized a panel of District leaders to share gree's cell phone policy implementation process the this event offered a valuable platform for sharing best practices Greece Central School District thanks to the collaborative efforts of the district and the Greece Teachers Association provided a compelling example of how thoughtful community-driven Solutions

002can address Technology's challenges the disconnected event showcased the positive impact of District Union collaboration in creating positive change and Greece's work is a testament of to that success it demonstrated how through planning and partnership we can create learning environments where students truly connect with their education teachers and with each other lastly I also wanted to take some time as a union member to share my personal perspective on the nid regionalization initiative I believe this Regional planning process while requiring careful consideration offers a promising path toward strengthening our schools and enhancing opportunities for our students the key here is understanding what Regional regionalization is and just as importantly what it is not it's not about Force mergers or consolidations but it is about exploring opportunities for shared services joint programs and other forms of regional cooperation

003that can benefit our students it's not a topown mandate dictating how districts must operate instead it's a collaborative locally driven process it's about districts coming together to conduct through needs assessments identify their unique challenges and explore solutions that work best for our communities this initiative recognizes that a one-size fits-all approach simply does not work in education it acknowledges the diverse landscape of our schools and empowers US to build upon our existing strengths this initiative provides a framework to expand on those successes and explore new innovative ways to collaborate we at the GTA are cautiously optimistic about the potential of this initiative by working together we can Leverage The Power of regional planning to create create stronger more Equitable and more effective education system for all of our students thank you for all of your work

004and supporting the G Central School District and have a great night thank you Mr Mack next up oh somebody so entertaining this evening Mr Jones entertaining you're always entertaining I could listen to you speak for hours you don't have hours though let's be clear man and I also got nervous when the screens are black I was like I need that presentation all right well my name is Brandon Jones um thanks for having me I'm here representing gasa our administrative unit and just wanted to take some time to update the board update our community on the stuff that our administrators are doing throughout our district um and really the focus of this presentation that you know I was told not an hour so I'll cut it down to 55 minutes to make sure um is really

005um kind of highlighting the focus that we are putting on instructional professional learning for staff as well as how we are working to address discipline when it comes to providing consequences but also aligning those consequences to interventions so districtwide there's a lot of trainings going on our um uh districtwide leaders are putting teachers through training in the in the areas of science with Discovery profess disc Discovery Ed professional learning in addition with the changes in living environment and Earth Science switching to biology and Earth and space science Earth and space science um our teachers are doing a lot of PL in that area as well those changes will take place next year but our teachers are doing the work to prepare so that when the fall Hits they're not scrambling to figure out what they

006need to be doing also you'll notice there's a lot of pictures of Olympia in here that's because when I asked folks for stuff they didn't necessarily give me pictures so I popped Olympia pictures in there as well so it could be you know a little plug for Olympia um our math 6th 7th and eth as far and as well as algebra and geometry teachers um have really been looking at common informative assessment data and thinking about where our students are falling short and what kind of instructional moves and what kind of curriculum moves need to be made to help kind of close those gaps especially for our students who are struggling again that's happening districtwide there was some curriculum work to think about where they can do those interventions where it would make sense um

007in addition to that districtwide department meetings um are happening teachers are collaborating with each other not just in their building but outside of their building as well and again that's being led by District Department folk English Village they're doing some great work on professional learning communities this is making sure they're finding time for teachers to get together and really really focus on again instruction looking at what our students need to be able to do what's getting in the way of them doing that what how are we going to know if they've met that goal and like if they struggle to meet that goal what do they need to be doing in order to get there what as Educators do we need to be doing to support our students getting there and of course they're focusing

008on our American reading company um curriculum art core they've also partnered with Center for Youth and genese mental health in order to teach our really young ones about their emotions right and thinking about like when I'm feeling this what are appropriate ways to respond we know if we get them early on with by the time they get older you know they've got skill sets to kind of manage those emotions and we call those zones of regulations so English Village is really kind of focusing on that homes Road see I got pictures from homes Road these are homes Road teachers okay um Mr Kean and Mr barbar are doing great work over there they are celebrating that 6 6% of their students are reading on grade level currently and their goal is 68% so it's looking

009like not only are they going to meet that goal but hopefully surpass it in addition Holmes Road is working on really finding ways for students with disabilities to be integrated into settings with students who don't have disabilities right like oftentimes our students with disabilities are isolated a little bit and the work is how do we find ways to connect them with their peers not just things like recess or things like lunch but with instruction actual learning experiences so they've been doing a lot of work at their staff meetings around how do we put all of our hands on deck to make sure our students with disabilities are having access to opportunities that their jined peers are experiencing so kudos to the folks at homes Road Arcadia middle now this is a picture I had to

010dig for on their Facebook page so this is Arcadia midle but I had to go in and do a little work um interventions and consequences um working together to change Behavior I know there's a misconception out in the community around restorative practices especially restorative practices replacing discipline in the way in which we know it but that is not the case right what we're doing in our buildings is thinking how do we use traditional consequences like detention like suspension especially in school suspension and instead of having kids just sitting in a room um and trying to get them to do you know their math work have them sitting in the room do their math work and then have time to reflect and learn skills that got them there and do differently so our Cadia midow is

011really working to figure out how do we combine those things in ways that make sense targeted skill building exercises that happen during lunchtime led by their restorative TOA and then as far as instruction goes really focusing on what we call specially designed instruction which is um and learning for staff in that area and hopes that they see kids who are kind of middle of the road moving from middle of the road to onra level Arcadia High School 259th graders working on kind of building up their leadership skills especially around this idea of combating drug use we all know and you've heard it at this very Podium around vaping vaping in schools vaping outside of schools just this use of overuse of drugs amongst our teenss and so yes as adults we can go in and

012talk all day to kids about why they should be doing something different but Arcadia High is really partner with the U ofr and they're above the influence program to provide students with leadership skills so they can go out and influence their own peers around why maybe the path of drug and substance abuse isn't what we need to be doing because it distracts us from what we should be doing which is really kind of living a healthy lifestyle and focused on instruction so kudos for Arcadia High Odyssey Academy M stumping grounds um staff have been really focused on the power of common formative assessments and using those comma informative assessments to really figure out where students are struggling right like what are they what are we dropping the ball on and what do we need to

013be um doing differently as far as our everyday instruction to help those kids level up and they're also anchoring into restorative practices as interventions for Behavioral violations right so similar to what I was explaining with Arcadia middle but this idea of really anchoring into coaching Cycles with staff right how can restorative practices look compare or combined with academics to kind of teach kids um high expectations but also providing them high support and then of course using accountability projects meaning hey if a student's going to spend some time in in school suspension like I said before let's give them a project to work on where they can study like what would this look like if I was older and I did this type of behavior what could be the outcomes in the real world if I

014made these type of mishaps and then of course Olympia my stomping ground so Olympia got a few slides I told you it going to be about 55 minutes this is where the other 50 minutes come in Mr mcab okay so listen we've been doing a lot of great work if I must say so myself this year we've been focusing really on differentiation right meaning what how do we provide kids with unique learning needs to fit what they need um and we've been really focused on things like providing student Choice when it comes to process product and content understand in the different co- teing models right so if there are multiple teachers in a room how can we maximize all of those teachers so we're really having working with smaller group of kids and really accelerating

015kids who can use acceleration and helping provide remediation for kids who need reteaching we've also allowed in our staff meetings opportunities for teachers to take what we're learning and apply it in real time so bringing their actual lesson plans and saying hey this is what we're learning we're seeing the theory on it how do we match it to what we're actually planning and then of course providing Choice professional learning right we've started a summer Retreat where teachers can come in for three days out of their summer and really kind of anchor in on instruction and then when it comes to discipline similar stuff that you've already heard me say but really focusing with staff on shifting our mindset from only punitive consequences to punitive consequences along with teachable moments and we've seen some great things

016around that celebrating kids who are doing the right thing because we heard that from parents and community members like we hear the bad we a lot of attention seems to be focused on students who aren't making the best choices but how do we then celebrate the kids who are so we want to celebrate the kids who are and so they can encourage them to keep making those good choices while also supporting our students who struggle and I'm just going to show you some of the data for Olympia specific to show you that when you match interventions and consequences you do get good results so um let me show you some of that data this chart is our referral data comparison from this time last year to this time this year last year at Olympia at

017this very time we had over 2,000 um discipline referrals this year we have 1,286 so we still have a lot but we've almost cut that in half by almost 50% there's a 37% decrease in behavioral referrals at Olympia because of the work that we are doing in addition to that we've seen a 40% decrease in referrals for physical altercations between students right so a 40% decrease in the amount of students who are solving conflicts by putting hands on each other to me that's a celebration and I certainly have heard people at this very Podium share specifically about Olympia and their concerns about physical interactions in that building 27% decrease in the number of students who have been suspended from school whether that be out of school or in school and 40% decrease in the number

018of students with 20 or more behavioral referrals so again it's important for me to Spotlight these numbers to show you that restorative practices combined with what we call traditional consequences do indeed get results and that is the work that we are doing as a district not just at Olympia it was easy for me to share that data with you because that's the building that I'm responsible for but districtwide we're seeing similar results with that said I'm going to dance for you a little bit and sing some show tunes and then I'll let you get back to it but in all reality gasta leaders are doing the necessary work to help staff flourish and for students to achieve thank you all especially our board member and our superintendent board members and our superintendent's cabinet for your

019support we need that support we need you all to help break down barriers that make our jobs challenging there's certainly a lot of things happening in society today that give that can take us away from Focus focusing on instruction and focusing on the social emotional learning needs of our students and while we're dealing with that building work we need all of you to help eliminate those barriers so that we can continue the work that we are doing so with that said thank you all so much gasa update is done and complete and I'm going to take my seat okay thank you Mr Jones I don't have anybody from acept Guster Teamsters all right moving in the residence Forum we have three speakers sign up for our res Forum this evening um our first speaker will

020be Mr Dan Perna welcome Mr Perna thank you members of the board thank you for providing me this forum my name is Daniel Perna and I am the commander of the American Legion Post for 68 in Greece and I oversee over 1,000 members and families at that post who are from the Town of Greece I'm a disabled Vietnam veteran who is here today in support of all veterans in the gree School District I am petitioning the gree School District Board of Education to provide the exemption on all school taxes to all qualified veterans residing in the gree School District the exemptions would follow Follow The Identical veterans tax exemptions guidelines as outlined by the New York State Monroe County for County and town taxes I'm requesting that the board resolve this exemption with a subsequent

021vote of yes these School tax conventions would definitely help many veterans on fixed incomes those with disabilities and also their surviving spouses in Monroe County the school district of the city of Rochester Gates chilik calonia Mumford and Brockport as well as a large number of school districts across the state already in gratitude provide these veterans exemptions according to the US Labor Bureau of Statistics there are 19 million veterans living today in America the VA estimates that that number will diminish 12.1 1 million in 25 years we are losing more than we are gaining how many veterans have we lost since 2013 when the real property tax law was expanded right now approximately 3,661 veterans reside in the town of Greece what will that number be if this partial tax exemption gets voted down and we

022have to wait again to bring this to a future board we are diminishing demographic mostly made up of 1,320 Vietnam veterans over the age of 70 and not all our property owners let's really mean thank you for your service and provide all present and future veterans the school tax advention thank you thank you Mr perno our next speaker is Mr Timothy Smith Mr Smith welcome this evening good evening I'm going to reiterate a little bit of what Dan said my name is Timothy Smith I've been here before in fact on January 7th 2025 it was I that petitioned the board to provide the exemption on school taxes to all qualified veterans residing in the gree Central School District as Dan said these exemptions would follow the guidelines already in place by Monro County New York

023state for Town and County taxes at that me at that January 7th I also requested the board to put this petition on the agenda for a public meeting to resolve with a subsequent vote of yes once petitioned the next step in the procedure is to have a public hearing on this issue the 2013 Amendment to the New York State real property tax law specifically States a public hearing on the issue must take place and is the required responsibility of the board with subsequent vote required by the boardi hopefully by prior to March 1st 2025 there is no argument to be made not to have a public hearing the residents of the gree Central School District must have the opportunity to provide to the Board of Education their thoughts opinions and even feelings on this issue

024of school tax exemptions for the veterans the board has already provided a study on the issue and determined that a public hearing must take place so what do you guys waiting for there are currently 3,829 veterans receiving their Town and County tax exemptions and would be immediately eligible for the school tax exemption once passed for the board study for the 2025 School tax bills this would cause a financial increase on each non-veteran taxpayer of the district a maximum of 48 cents per thousand of assessed value for example a 2000 200,000 assessed property value would pay an additional $96 a year or $8 a month what the study does not take consideration is that 65% of the 3,829 veterans are already senior citizens and are the combat veterans with ages between 60 and 90 having served

025during the Korean War of 1950 to 55 the Vietnam war between 55 to 75 and the gulf Wars of the 1990s therefore the number of eligible veterans and compat Veterans who reive the most exemption will decrease rather than increase so the financial impact impact will also decrease also the study eludes to possible negative impacts on various programs such as star and low income deductions these allegations are not fully realized and negative reference like this must be avoided and not cat also our state legislator has both recently passed bills State Senate Bill s 3982 and State Assembly Bill a 3199 which are on their way to the governor to be signed whereby the state will cover any cost Associated from any veteran exemption on school have wrap up so the board should cover these bill should

026take these bills into consideration and decision I believe February 18th or the 25th is the current schedule date for the public hearing let's make sure that the notice and the hearing takes place thank you thank you Mr speak [Applause] next up is Mr Ostrander welcome again good to see you finally huh yes you know I was running for the school board five years ago and then Sean said that uh I look forward to working with you and I said uh no my wife has cancer so uh I backed out um and I'd probably be sitting up here how we doing bill so uh I had stuff in front of me to talk about veterans and stuff like that today we had Mr Rosario Su five now he just left and I just had a quick

027conversation there's not one person in this room or on this board that will go up to a veteran and say thank you for your service am I correct we all say thank you for our service we feel good about it but we feel better with a little commitment from the board in town of Greece in regards to our taxes I came in here a little upset that my tax bill went up 31.7% from 20 to 24 but listening to this gentleman over here and some of the things that they're doing in the schools uh with the students makes me makes me feel a lot better but in the Marine Corps it's honor courage and commitment you have to find the honor and the courage and the commitment to say thank you to our veterans thank

028you for your service Let's help you out a little bit there's 3829 registered veterans in town of Greece that currently receive the tax credit I'm not as old as a couple of these guys over here okay but I'm getting close I'm 63 so you as board members have to find it in your heart you want to say thank you to a veteran say thank you we're all on fixed income okay 31 31.7% tax increase is a lot of money while you're on a fixed income okay so not asking to get it all back but a percentage follow the guidelines and the rules that Monroe County has and other school districts have have done find the courage find the commitment and find the honor to do the right thing to thank a veteran I do a

029concert every year at the Legion in Greece and one thing bothers me the most I have to go out and raise funds for wounded men and women in the military those suffering from mental illness drug and alcohol addiction homelessness we as a community go out there Mr Malone's my sidekick we have to go out and beg and plead for money from the community those people people out there would give you the last $5 they had in their pocket seems to be the ones that have the less give the most just ask that and it bothers me going out because that's something that the government should be doing to help our veterans there's too many veterans out there that are are stuck on drugs mental mental awareness is huge today it's as it is in the

030school district I believe so um I'll end it with courage honor courage and commitment find it in your heart say thank you to veterans say thank you to their families and I appreciate the time have a great night thank you Mr R strander that concludes our residence Forum we're going to jump to item 11.01 can I so I move to the table I'll just hit the first resolve therefore be resolved that a public hearing will be held in regards to the veterans tax exemption on February 25 2025 6:30 in this building Rocher New York 14612 received public comment on the matter of a veterans tax exemption can I have some move that to the table please Mr Maloney second by Miss farmer any comments questions or concerns on holding a public hearing on February 25th

031do you have a question or comment comment sure far away I would just like to make a quick comment I appreciate you guys for coming today nothing serves prouder than actually voting this in for you guys the military runs deep in my family gr from my grandfather on he was in the armed services uh the Air Force one of his siblings passed on uh since then he has given us the middle name Joe and we have carried it down traditions in our family for the first woman born so I I it runs deep in my family my father was a marine my brother went into the Marines as well he's now in the Air Force and a commander in logistics so I appreciate your service tremendously so I thank you thank you Mr Farah thank

032you thank you any other board member comments seeing n with that we'll start with we'll do a roll call vote we'll start with Mr Maloney yes Mr bagorio yes Mr Butler yes vice president farmer yes proudly yes yes yes yes and I may ask that passes nine to nothing so we will host a public hearing on Tuesday February 2th at 6:30 and just so you know so everybody's clear there'll be a sign up sheet that night you can sign up that night to speak up until the start of the meeting so at 6:30 I'll pull the sheet and there'll be no speakers after that so whoever gets here um sign up on the sheet if you want to do that or you can contact our board clerk Lori manhard ahead of time and she can

033get you on that list okay great thank you so much all right moving on to item 2.01 Staffing can I ass move the Staffing to the table please moved by Mr Maloney second by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on Staffing sing that all in favor that passes N9 to zero assistant superintendent Larsson thank you very much um I'm very excited to uh introduce some uh new folks this evening just been appointed first off uh our new principal of Athena Middle School Mr Todd wallenhorst seven years ago Todd had the opportunity to come back as an educator to the Greece Central School District where he grew up and lives currently with his wife Mo'Nique daughter Brier who attends Pinebrook Elementary and Son jet who attends the Early Learning Center over the past seven years he

034has had the privilege of working at gree Arcadia High School is an assistant principal where he's made tons of memories with his Titan family who he will miss greatly and who have shown him just how special the district continues to be Todd is a proud graduate of Sunni Brockport for his undergraduate degree in history and his administrative certificate he also received his teacher certification from Nazareth College Todd grew up in Greece with his parents Tim and Debbie and two brothers Dan and Nathan he and his brothers are all proud graduates of Greece Athena High School Todd expressed that being back in the building is a huge source of Pride for him Todd and his wife Mo'Nique moved back to Greece over 10 years ago and were excited to grow their family here and it's with

035great pride that his children Brett and Brier and Jet currently attend gree schools and will be fellow Trojans in the future Todd is excited to continue to work in the gree Central School District as the principal of Athena middle school he said quote it is a special place for me and I look forward to carrying on the tradition of helping students achieve academically as well as socially and emotionally with the dedicated staff and families congratulations Tad all right it's picture time um Mr Wen horse uh superintendent sming Deputy Fleming assistant superintendent zitz will be the first round family will be second round third round will be the new Athena staff and last will be the Arcadia staff that's here in support so four pictures your ocds on come on get that whole family in [Music]

036there that's all right I just like torturing people with the pressures all right Arcadia I I'm surprised we the same hairline I do like that the new hires though everybody's got a hairline like mine I kind of like that the criteria Mr ferson and Mr laor since you're the new team at the Athena campus yeah we all go to the same guy Mr Butler you that's right congratulations next up all right next up I'm going to invite a um kind of familiar face to us Mr Jeremiah Johnson who will taking be taking over the role for Mr Wallen horse at Arcadia as an assistant principal so um Jeremiah joined us in early November as a house assistant principal at Arcadia High School and is now being promoted to the probationary position uh he's made a

037great impression on the Arcadia community so far and he's really excited to continue in Titan territory so congratulations to you don't sit down we got to do more pictures he'll never be a principal Baker is it the turn gray have to go to my barber do you want to do a family picture sure okay great and then Arcadia I don't think she was here last time I'll thank you all right and last but not least I'd like to welcome Jessica mazikowski our new house assistant [Applause] principal come on up you got to come on down it's like the price is right come on down right in front right in front right front center perfect that way Folks at home get to see as well Jessica oh I should put on my glasses sorry folks used

038have to do this this is the woman's version of balding you get you get long enough to get the glasses uh Jessica received her bachelor's degree from Sunni asgo and her graduate degrees from the University of Rochester and St John F fiser University she worked as an ESL teacher for the last nine years at easd high school Jessica's favorite part of her job has been the connection she's made with all of her students families and staff gree Central is a large District that has a lot of diversity and opportunities and she is looking forward to learning more and being involved in the community here Jessica studied abroad in Spain and that has continued her love for traveling as a way to learn more about people and where they come from she looks forward to all

039the opportunities Greece has to offer and continuing to grow her career here in Greece Central outside of work Jessica loves competing in races learning new languages in the buffalo bills she's very close with her family and loves exploring new places with them congratulations and welcome to gree Central thank you hey she's the first one to get the picture thing Baker you might as well jump in okay that we do family yeah you're telling me I'm about half hour past M Sor than got one more we got to get all the B guys in pictures you're next I got to figure out picture you thank you congratulations to all of you if you guys want to sneak out I get it I wish I could go with you she looks how I [Laughter] feel thank you

040all congratulations all right moving on to 2.02 tenure can I somebody move the tenure to the table please move by Mr Butler seconded by vice president farmer any comments questions or concerns on tenure sing none all those in favor that passes 9 is zero and I just want to take a moment to recognize Stacy bendy congratulations on your tenure I think you've been here almost as long as I have all right moving on to 2.03 G Greece Teachers Association additional FTE can I move that to the table please moveed by Mr botler second by Mr Maloney any comments questions concerns on that sing then all in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on to the nonunit rate cheat can I move that to the table please move by Mr stencil second by Mr Butler

041any comments questions concerns on that sing in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on 2.05 the 913 exam can I have some move that to the table please move by miss m seconded by vice president farmer any comments questions concerns on that sing on all in favor that passes N9 to zero and 2.06 the Gus contract vote can I saw move that to the table please move by Mr stencil second by Mr bagorio any comments questions or concerns on that I just have a quick question assistant superer Larson do you know what the membership ratified the contract by I was going to ask earlier and I forgot um yeah it was uh 60 yes to 30 now okay awesome thank you so much with that all those in favor that passes N9 to zero

042moving on to 4.01 Transportation update superintendent SMY I almost called you gr upman again sure she's watching I'm having a little stroke I I got to keep touching myself uh I'd like to call up our um executive director of student operations Dave Richardson for this presentation thank you Dave all right what are you waiting for the music to start just waiting for the I don't know the TVs for the guest as [Laughter] well there it is all right good evening thanks for having me this is uh I'm going to review some uh some of the latest data regarding uh transportation to give you our annual update so we're going to talk a little bit about the Chang is impacted by the walking distance change that you approved back on June 4th and as well as

043our current challenges and celebrations and there'll be time for questions as well so our current state so as you look here you're going to see a three-year history of the current state of Transportation with how many students are being transported the First Column is is two years ago the middle column is last year and the uh column on the right is the current year so as you can see there a little bit of a decline as you are have been hearing about we we are seeing a decline in student enrollment U that is not the total number of students in Greece that is the total number of students receiving Transportation okay uh the number of bus runs obviously declining you've heard about the driver shortage we'll highlight a little bit about that at a little

044later on uh the number of regular drivers regular meaning full-time staff that are coming to work each day the number number of drivers SL office staff that are Subs so that fourth line there you are seeing a sub decline so there's 12 Subs that are working and roughly 12 office staff but remember office staff and Subs are not necessarily available every single day so availability uh and other commitments comes into play excuse me and then the number of Walkers which has pretty much remained at over the last 3 years continuing on the number of private parochial and Charter Schools continues to stay flat it actually Rises with then there's a few closures that have happened over the years as well the number of students that are attending these 51 current private parochial and Charter Schools

045remember all you need is one student going to one school and they need a bus so whether there's one student on that bus bus or 16 it's a bus Which eats up a driver um number of child care apps that's actually declining um and we continue to see that downward Trend the number of contracted runs this shouldn't be a surprise is has risen over the last three years because the number of drivers has declined so obviously we're Contracting out more which is something we wish we did not have to do number of outof District special ed uh locations that number continues to rise and that number and I'll talk a little bit about that in a minute and then the number of mckin Veno students this continues to be uh a challenge uh for us

046because of the 50 mile rule so if a student is designated mckin Veno status and lives within 50 miles of the district the district is obligated uh and required to provide transportation so right now we have 185 mckin Veno and 83 of them are are living inside the boundaries of Greece but when you look at that 102 are not walking distances so back on June 4th uh the board approved to increase the walking distance for elementary students to the bus stop from 800 ft to 1,56 Ft that's actually uh aligned with the guidance from s which is 1,56 ft is 2/10 of a mile um we have not seen significant SA we're talking about an additional 200 ft so we're not talking a significant change uh for our students where we did save uh quite

047a bit is our grade six through eight students who were walking up to a mile to school but be prior to this year only had to walk up to, 1500 feet to the bus stop so we matched that walking distance to school with the walking distance uh to the bus stop and then grades 9 through 12 the distance was uh 1.5 miles walking to school but again only having to walk 1500 ft um to the bus stop so that now matches as well so when you match that you get quite a bit of savings so here's some examples uh that I wanted to share with you here's a bus run that you can see on the left and those three green dots are the current three stops okay but last year due to the walking

048distance being up to 1500 feet that same map was seven stops so when you're able to consolidate stops you're able to put more students on buses as well as get to school on time here's an example from Athena again the same image last year was 12 stops for that bus and this year it's six so yes students are walking farther to the bus stop and then a middle school example for Arcadia middle school last year you're looking at a run here of 16 stops in that in that map snapshot which is now five uh uh stops for for our buses so some of the benefits as a result by matching the walking distances is we were able to eliminate five to eight runs now why do you say five to eight Dave it's because runs

049are not identical year to year so some of our runs last year were partnered with St Lawrence a private parochial school a charter school no longer uh are they partnered with some of our private parochial charter schools because we Outsource those uh due to the driver shortage so runs and the the combination of runs are not identical year after year after year so when you look at this uh we are able to save somewhere between five and eight runs uh when we all said and done buses no longer enter certain tracks uh resulting in fewer stops as I outlined uh just just a short time ago as well as um it's easier for our subs so obviously our buses are starting uh when it's still dark out and and our our buses in the afternoon

050are finishing when it's getting dark you know looking for house numbers uh looking for uh unique stops is very difficult mailboxes you're looking for those landmarks um and that's very difficult when we are able to utilize Corner stops much easier to identify that bus stop for our subs the persistent driver shortage um continues to impact our operations uh thank you to the Board of Ed and and Gina and her team for uh increasing the wage because that's definitely helped we prior uh to this year we would see anywhere between one to three maybe four uh people people in driver training and now we're seeing somewhere between 3 and five at any one time we're still losing some of our more seasoned in veteran staff uh due to age and health uh and in years of

051service and retiring from their second job so we're still losing drivers um at a at a greater rate uh than we are uh hiring them um supporting School requests this is a challenge so we try to keep field trips between 9:30 and 1:30 in that uh middle of the day window but some um extracurricular opportunities for students just start earlier than 9:30 and go beyond 1:30 so there are times when a a request comes in that we have to find a way um to to make it work but the schools and the um cabinet members and dcia directors have been very supportive and understanding of the challenges we Face our special ed sites uh continue to spread out due to staffing issues at Bose's um so we maybe four or five programs might have been

052housed uh and one academic center at Bose's one or Bose's 2 has now been outsourced to different uh locations in and around Monroe County so one bus taking several students to a location on Big Ridge Road for three or four programs now three or four progr programs are in different sites that's two or three more buses that you need so again it adds to the challenge um buses still travel outside a school's boundary for mckin venom for child care for school of choice and four special ed so those four areas continue to be a challenge and it's just a reality of what we work with um uh each and every day and our buses are full um so we're trying to maximize every seat uh we are calling parents uh of of students that we

053have not seen to say is your child no longer riding the bus that frees up a seat for us we're trying to look for ways to consolidate um and and compact our runs to meet the uh meet the driver shortage one of the additional challenges that we face is who we partner with to Outsource uh those private paroi char School runs uh wishful thinking I wish we didn't have to Outsource any of these runs but the reality of what we Face we do and it's hard to control uh the way that that uh service is delivered um you know who they're hiring uh when those drivers are going out because we're not they're not on our headquarters uh and we're not on site to monitor their work so when we find out about delays or

054we find out that there was a pickup of some sort often times that comes from a frustrated parent or it may come from you because someone reached out to you um it's it's definitely a challenge and it's something that we're trying to find a way to take back as many of those runs as as possible but ultimately it starts with our staffing and it starts with the numbers of people that we're able to work with and I appreciate uh the support that you have provided and the understanding that you have provided because it's not easy to have uh an outside company providing uh supports for students when when you are not there to manage how that work is delivered um so some of the positives that we continue to see uh Google forms for the

055child care private parochial charter school and the junior senior optins have been very successful those applications are currently open now for the 25 26 school year and parents we encourage you excuse me to get those in by April 1st which is the state uh deadline so those um those applications are currently up and running on the on the district website I mentioned before the high understanding and flexibility with the schools um we when unfortunately there's times when runs are not covered we're calling the schools we've got nothing but uh support and understanding and flexibility from from school staff and Personnel who are reaching out to parents even parents are reaching out saying I understand you're short uh we're doing what we can to help we're doing our best to try not to impact those same

056runs day in and day out uh because that creates an equity issue as well um fewer days this year when runs are not covered a little bit of a celebration um parents and Guardians are understanding of our situation um so we appreciate their support um and like I said before the minimal impact on extracurricular and Athletics as well as I do want to say the support all of you have provided so um you reaching out saying hey I I know you're short um I know it's difficult I want to make make you aware of the situation and working with the transportation department and sticking to the April 1 deadline and being consistent with that response to to parents who may be frustrated or community members or private parochial charter schools who may be frustrated because

057uh of the of the difficult situation that we're in so thank you questions Mr vorio thank you Mr Richardson and and uh I appreciate the the hard work that you all have been doing I know I know it's been an ongoing Challenge and you're doing a great job try under difficult continuing difficult circumstances right so thank you making a lot of progress um I'm wondering if you can Can Shed maybe a little bit of insight um we've we heard some comments about regionalization and gree is going to be participating in that process do you anticipate uh possible opportunities uh for regionalization to assist in this in this effort and and maybe how um so we're always looking at opportunities so I'm always willing to have a discussion um about ways to to work with our

058our neighbors um we tried to look at this just a side note we tried to look at this uh with gates in Churchville and Hilton for transporting students to uh some of our secondary private schools where we would all pick them up individually meet at a centralized location and then instead of you know 15 buses going to aquinus maybe it's six full buses that go and then those buses can return to their District to to transport elementary kids or do other runs um up here or globally it it's it's great thinking when you start peeling the layers and looking at um you know the the finer details like school calendars like pickup times like type of service some districts do door Todo like trying to find a regionalized location insurance um safety you know you

059start looking at those other things it it presented a a significant challenge so um always looking at opportunities I'm happy to partake in those discussions uh but there's definitely some some finer details that would have to be worked out and just a quick followup it sounds like you have been working on that kind of thing that collaborative kind of thing before the regionalization applied so we've been doing that right along 100% thank you I thought that was the case thank you yeah thanks uh Mr Rich uh great presentation I Echo uh my board colleagues uh congratulations for the for the progress that's been made I had one clarification and then one question you mentioned the McKinny vento students I saw the 185 active 83 in gree so the 102 is are those students who uh

060attend gree schools but don't live here correct they have go someplace else to get them I have to go outside of the gree Central School District boundaries to pick them up and bring them home each day great and that's intended to allow them to at least maintain the educational stability in their lives while they're navigating homelessness that is correct okay great thank you um the other uh thing that I was just wondering if you had any uh um data for us on but you mentioned uh I know you person you take it very personally when a student misses instruction uh because a bus is late and and uh you mentioned that we've had fewer instances of that this year do you have any data on that Dave to tell us how how how much improvement

061we've made there or is that information I would say we ended the ended last year uh prior to the high schools going into exams we were looking at delays three to four days a week and now uh were somewhere between one and three days a week and sometimes none MH okay yeah so the the delay there is a way there is a um a method to our Madness I'll call it um we try not to impact Elementary runs at all because we know uh parents are counting on those students the supervision issue Etc uh we're trying not to impact the same runs each time we're trying not to impact special education um you know we're so like today we had one run not covered and it was Arcadia High Arcadia middle and those students uh

062either found a ride home or took the Lepa so there was Transportation it wasn't at 205 it was at 320 um but the elementary portion of that run was Patty hill we had that covered so that's an example of you know trying to trying to meet the needs we we figure secondary students can either wait in the cafeteria if they don't have a ride and can be more self-supervised more so than our elementary kids great well thank you just the complexity of what you manage every single day with all of those elements is uh pretty mindboggling so put together a puzzle twice a day y kudos to you and your whole team yeah thank you Mr Maloney well kudos to you Mr DAV uh Richardson I mean you drive a bus I do drive a

063bus almost every day uh not every day not every day and less this year than last year so another another data point that I'm driving less so which is good as as far as our drivers go uh I know that the when we Outsource to Ontario we outsourced the first student you know they're paying their driver's unemployment during the uh off seasons is there a possibility I know Romeo is having a heart attack right now but um is there a possibility that we can do that or is there a state mandate why we can't do that or is there I mean let's face it I mean they're they're they're making a profit still and bilding us and paying the Unemployment uh is there a reason why we can't pay the unemployment defer to you or

064do you prer not to answer me that I mean that's a matter for Collective negotiations so I'm going to rule that that we shouldn't discuss that in a public setting that's of collective negotiations according to the Taylor law sorry that's okay any other questions Mr bonario so Mr Maloney's question maybe maybe Mr mck will R this one out as well but but uh Mr Malone Malone's question reminded me of uh a conversation that came up at uh the recent legislative breakfast uh where it was acknowledged that one of the challenges in recruiting bus drivers is you've got the runs in the morning the runs in the afternoon the downtime in the middle and just you know a life a quality of life balance to some degree um someone from another District was talking about how

065they use um their bus drivers to do things like bus cleaning and things like that that give that can fill in those gaps is that obvious that sounds like that might come into the question of negoti offer that we do okay so our drivers are offered with the work through human resources opportunities to to provide custodial work as well as work in our in Food Service during that middle of the day portion yeah so to an opportunity to to make additional income um and in acrw some additional hours should they choose and just fill in that Gap y absolutely thank you yep questions thank you Mr Richardson thank you moving on item 4.0 02 the 2526 executive budget state aid superintendent smallen I am going to invite Mr Romeo K thank you all right good

066good evening everyone uh I've got a couple presentations for tonight uh one is a short presentation on our uh state aid uh that was addressed in the governor's uh budget uh in about mid mid January and then we're going to also share tonight um an initial uh budget for the 2526 uh school year first pass but on the executive state aid um just some highlights uh to share from the governor's January 14th uh uh address um what's not on the sheet is one of the things that came out was that the New York State uh does have a balanced budget at 252 billion um it's up about 3.6% or about 8.6 billion but it is balanced at this point and New York State also indicates that they have a current fiscal year B balance of

067about $3.5 billion on hand for the current year most of that's driven by uh ex more than anticipated tax receipts that have come in uh for the year so they're in good shape for this year they're still projecting a couple gaps in over the next two years but they're smaller than what they had projected back in mid year around June or July a couple of the items that were addressed it's the highest school aid uh total for 2526 at about 37 billion dollar um it's increased about 4.7% or $ 1.7 billion which is a a request that most uh people advocating for schools was asking for somewhere in the neighborhood of 1.6 1.7 billion Foundation Aid increases about $ 1.46 billion do higher or 6% again a good number uh gets Foundation Aid up to

068about $26 billion and one of the items that was uh uh in controversy last year was the changing of how CPI was calculated when they did this this year they went with the current CPI of 3.1% so it was clean across the board so there was no arguing with that and the proposal for all districts is a minimum of 2% and there were some other changes incorporated into the formula and um one was to replace the current poverty census with a new measure that's updatable in more current and a second was to replace the free and reduced lunch measure again with a new measure that is updatable and more current so those have helped many districts and for those that it may not have there's at least a 2% increase expense based AIDS that's our

069transportation Aid our bosies Aid those type of things where you spend the money and get it back the following year um are fun are fully funded with no changes at this time um they're up about 10.5 Bill million dollars or two 2.2% the budget does include $376 million for Universal free School meals uh it's up about uh depending on where you read it 160 to $196 million over last year and that again would provide free breakfast and lunch to all students across the State Community Schools is maintained as a set asde um as it was last year charter school funding uh levels continue to the same amount no changes there no changes for Universal prek and the prior year adjustment queue um there was no talk no allocated funds um in the B Governor's budget

070for that I think we mentioned it last time um the current Q total is owed by the state to districts about $8 million for us in Greece it's just over $700,000 that right now there's no money in the budget to uh pay that out for next year as we look at what was uh proposed by the governor the First Column here uh is what the board and what we adopted for our budget for 2425 school year compared to the middle column which is the governor's proposed state aid um just talking through that the third column again is the variance between the two I'll point to the bottom of the screen with the red circle we at this point when you take out universal prek it's in the numbers but we have to back it out

071because it's not part of the general fund budget is $67.20 five million more than what we adopted last year or an increase of about almost five and a half% some of the items in the middle column just to uh bring to attention the foundation Aid at 100 almost $119 million that's up almost 8% um that is a uh significantly more than we had thought um part of that is is obviously due to the changes in the formula um and letting that run to full scale again so we're we're glad with that however we think that number could change we did make some changes again I want to back up one step I apologize these numbers are B based off a database that the governor runs the database date is mid November we were still making

072some changes in November December and even through January so when they rerun the database in February this Foundation day number could change slightly we're just not sure if that's going to be a plus or minus but it not going to be anything really significant we also look at building Aid you see that right now we're getting about $2.1 million less than what we got last year will believe that number is going to increase again this is run as of November 15th we sent in what's called final cost reports at the end of December when we complete a project that begins to generate Aid that is not reflective in these numbers at this point when they rerun in February those numbers should be updated for those final cost reports we also see a decrease of almost

073$600,000 in public access cost Aid we're looking at that and um hopefully see an increase in that when the legislative budget comes out could be higher Bose's Aid could also be a little bit higher based on what we had uh spent last year we're taking a closer look at those numbers as well and overall with some of these we're meeting with our financial partners this Thursday to review state aid each of these line items and to kind of hone in on a better number that we think we're going to get for um the from the legisl in March so again we think some of these numbers will change to the good which will help us a little bit on the revenue side I'm just going to have you swing right into the next one and

074then we'll do all question it's all related all right so as we have done in past years um this is our first pass at an initial budget uh based on very conservative uh Revenue numbers very conservative expenditure numbers and again um one note that I did want to make prior to the last three previous three years um we tried to stay true to that process which was we would take and do a true rollover with some adjustments in the budget and then show the revenues we anticipate on the first past expenditures on this on the first pass and show if there was any Gap over the last three years with the foundation Aid increases in the formula being implemented we really didn't have to do a lot of that because we had more revenues to

075cover everything that we wanted to do we're back to I believe um the process we were preco which is is we're going to see some gaps and we've got to work at closing those gaps before we get to the superintendent's recommended budget we had said that along over the last two or three years we think we're there now um so we're going to you know run first passes go back and look at things take another look and have a balanced budget over the next few weeks um but we're back to our traditional patterns just at bigger numbers and at a higher level so as we look our at our additional revenues um we pretty much held everything flat with the exception of a couple items that you'll see variances on here um everything again is

076re adopted revenues on the left with estimated revenues on the right looking down uh to the bottom line um we're estimating right now about 9 uh $3 million increase in revenues on those select lines for a total revenue uh budget right now at $317 million as we go on to the next page we talk a little bit about the variances that within each of them so on the pilot payments um we're shown an increase of $187,000 that's due to a new pilot coming on board it's uh from Clear Choice they are uh hearing and balancing uh business that will be going up at Canal Ponds uh that business that pilot will generate for for us an additional $187,000 for next year state aid again is from the governor's executive budget that we just looked at

077at 8.5 million the tax levy and the star um we did a preliminary tax cap calculation the only piece that was missing for us is our debt service number and again we won't know that better until Thursday this week when we meet with our financial partners to review that but initially keeping the items flat that we know and changing the ones that we know definite parameters on we're thinking the levy will be around 2.5 million or just about a 2% increase right now is what we're figuring the appropriated fund balance um went down uh $2 million last year's budget or 2425 budget did include appropriated fund balance to uh update five playgrounds and two outdoor Pavilion that work will get done um shortly and we won't need that in the budget for next year so

078it's been eliminated when we look at the summary for the revenues in a more traditional sense um you can see our state aid our Levy our other local sources um that you know in that number for $2.1 million is sales tax and interest earning and Bose's refund and Health and Welfare revenues Federal sources and transfers are being flat right now again until we meet with our partners but just to recap $9.3 million increase at re in revenues uh on the first pass as we move on to our expenditures uh a couple prenotes so this initial uh expenditure budget includes all current Staffing and vacancies brought over from the current year to next year it includes the impact the revenue or the cost impact of two recently negotiated contracts all the Sal all the non-salary lines

079have been held flat from 2425 to 2526 with the exception of some select align items um that we made adjustments for those primarily would be Health Care um fuel utilities and then FICA ERS and TRS uh as our salaries go up our payroll costs go up our ERS and TRS payments go up healthc care as we know uh we were informed by rash next year's increase uh is 14.4% increase that's reflected in here um and then some new or continued initiatives are also included in here there's some technology stuff some Bose's items that are non-technology as well as continuation expansion of the uh AR um r core implementation um you can see on this chart the specific line items um overall we are at about 300 almost 20 323 Million Dollar on the first pass

080uh for the expenditure budget up about $15.2 million or about just under 5% moving on to the next slide you'll see some of the larger variances and some of the explanations for it again as I mentioned salaries are up about 6 uh $6.0 million well we had shown that that was an increase of just over 4% it includes all contracted salaries vacancies extra work forms substitute estimates individual contract agreements and Staffing to support student needs and as we think about some of the contracts our salaries are up about 4% all of our bar not just ours but all of our bargaining unit increases these are contractual items they're all between 3.25 and three and a half% so being at 4% is not surprising or alarming for us uh given that we've got additional staff we've

081got some substitute costs in there we got vacancies in there um so it seems like a reasonable number the equipment supplies uh Contract Services utilities up $1.1 million those are increases in in those uh specific lines um that we talked about bosis were continuing to increase our contractual services with bosis um for instance money for bus you uh monies for additional Community Schools leader and me arts and education and other uh items that we are running through the Bose program now one of the big advantages for us to use this bosis uh line and to increase that is monies that we spend year spend in bosis in the current year come back to us as Bose's Aid the following year uh versus spending it in a non bosis coer and you get zero back the

082following year so we are constantly looking to move anything we could to the bosis line when we can do it and this is s sort of a reflection for that internal transfers um again U it was the one time the elimination of the one-time replacement of the playgrounds and the two Outdoor Learning uh environments uh offset a little bit by we've increased our cap uh transfer to Capital and we're going to take another look at that line but right now we've increased it from 100,000 to 500,000 and we're going to go back and take a look at that and come back to the board with an explanation on that ERS retirement system up about a million dollar again that's about a 177% increase but the rates have gone from 15.2% of payroll to 16.5% of

083payroll it's a significant increase and we've got more employees on in the initial budget than we had in 2425 healthc care and dental premiums up about almost 10% um again we were notified for 25 uh for 2025 which will impact the second half of next year rates are Up 4 14.4% we don't know what January through June of 2026 uh will come back with but internal discussions within the rashes we still see double digits uh for the 2026 calendar year as well looking again at more traditional um view of the summary again $323 million budget1 15.2 million in increase or just under 5% there are still some outstanding items we need to take a look at one is Staffing to enrollment which we go through in cabinet um and also HR does uh their Staffing

084reviews as well we'll get those numbers in mid-march to see if there's adjustments that need to be made to the expenditure budget based on that review process we have other Staffing requests that are pending that need to be reviewed by cabinet that may impact uh um the expense budget and then there are non- Staffing requests out too that we have in hand that need to be reviewed and go through cabinet as a process that we may need to adjust the expenditure number by overall again when we take our first pass at this we're looking at just under a $6 million um Gap as a first pass um couple uh things to know one um it's a big you know it's a big number but we will manage this uh by reviewing re revenues expenditures kind

085of going through things on a second pass and a third pass I believe we'll see some additional revenues come in from the state um and we'll update those next time around uh there will be changes in the revenues and expenditures and we'll keep the board AB breast of what those changes are when we come back for the update but one thing is for certain there will be no layoffs as a result of this cap for next year questions Mr Butler thanks Romeo for the presentation um you had in the second presentation you're on slide four where you broke down the uh initial Revenue there's a line of federal sources the dollar amount is I mean $450,000 is a lot of money don't get me wrong but as compared to our overall budget it's a relatively

086small number um are there other federal dollars that come through New York state that are that are uh included in our state aid numbers or is that that's all in the control they would all be in the special Aid fund okay normally this is a Medicaid Medicaid or Medicare Medicaid Medica Medicaid revenues that come in the 450 yeah and it does go to the general it comes into the general fund okay all the other Federal I'm sure there might be one an exception some but all the federal stuff even if it goes through the state goes into special Aid fund okay the general fund okay so again it it does impact the district it just doesn't impact the general fund budget which is what comes before the board so when the board when we do

087these presentations there's the general fund there's special Aid fund which are the grants there's the Food Service fund there's the capital fund the board reviews the general fund budget which houses um resident taxpayer money that comes to the district as a opposed to the federal grants Capital plans or food service so all the titles the ideas all those other Federal items fall in the special Aid fund which is not included here okay thank you that's helpful M like Rome did you say thank you for the presentation did you say that um they were covering Universal prek well the universal prek um funding I'll go back it's the same level as it was last year like $2.9 million so we get those monies in let me back up 10 second the state always includes Universal prek

088in our state aid runs but that money flows to the special Aid the grant funds because upk is a grant so it's included in the state aid and on the previous slide we back it off because it does not reside in the general fund last year it was $2.9 Million this year it's $2.9 million no change but that funds our Universal pre program Jeremy does that cover all of our citizens for prek do we have that for all of our kids Universal prek uhhuh they have access to it yeah I'll I can I um so I thought about that earlier today haven't gotten a I got a 90% answer for you um in past years upk because of the way the layers were structured um you had to fill out one bucket to get access

089to the next bucket to the next layer then you had to get so there was always sufficient money available was hard to get to it last year or the year before and the LA I think it was last year they changed the structure and they allowed it to be a lot easier to get to the funding due to that in Prior years I would have said this general fund supplements a little bit of the upk program in the current year the last year I don't think that's true any longer but I sent that out for a question today and I just haven't gotten a response on it but I think the answer is no we don't spend any monies but if that changes I will update you on that via email so every family that

090wants it can get it not entirely space is always uh an issue assistant superintendent fler Mary I'm sorry I think your question might be if we are able to support all of the families who are expressing interest in enrolling in prek is that accurate it's that's it okay so um it's not a funding issue uh it's a space issue So currently we have about 150 families on a weight list from last year that weren't able to be placed because our current programs both indust and then we have four community- based organization Partnerships they're all at capacity in terms of what we're able to provide currently but we are seeking to um continue to expand that which would be able to be funded through the current funds that we have it's a matter of making sure

091that we have um we have appropriate Partnerships with Community Based organizations and that takes time so we do have our hopes on that in the future another question sure um is that did I hear it was Lottery that yeah so um we're in that process currently so those who are interested can uh submit their interest through the application process and the application uh closes on March 1st and following that there'll be a lottery that occurs okay one more I'm sorry can I it depends on what it is because we're getting off of the budget here talking about prek so if it's a budget question you can follow the budget okay then we're going to move on all right thank you vice president farmer um thank you Romeo my question is on page three of the

092first pack packet that you had what do you mean by Charter School transition and there's a decrease 14.5% could you say more depending um in general depending on the number of students that go from us to a charter school there's a little give back back to the district for a transition aid for those kids going that's what that represents why is it like negative and red that means it's it's 49 almost 50,000 lower currently than what it was last year not number of kids this is dollars thank you any other questions thank you thank you moving on I am 6.01 can I move to the table a contractor award for reimagine grease phase six mve by Mr stel second by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on this sing that all in favor that passes

0939 to Zer 7.01 anticipated bids it's written information only does anybody have any questions on that seeing none moving along to the consent agenda can I saw move the consent agenda to the table please move by Mr Butler second by voice president farmer any comments questions concerns on the consent agenda seeing none in favor that passes 9 to Z we've got a 9.01 the robotics trip can I have somebody move that to the table please moved by V uh vice president farmer second up by uh Mr stel any comments questions concerns on this one sing none all those in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on to student board member comments Mr Alvarez hello um yeah so my comments today are basically around the superintendent advisory Council they met in January where they discussed

094and reviewed many data that we found from our focus groups that was conducted um or facilitated all the way back in December and the discussion was basically about finding common themes um from the data and then um finding the opport like basically finding the themes of different examples such as finding more opportunities to build relationships between studz and teachers or celebrating student achievements between like clubs and activities and that from those themes that was generated um the plan is to develop a presentation that myself and J Sarah Hunter the um the TAC chair chair chair member will share at the superintendent's um will share with the superintendent's cabinet and then um as Eric Mr Eric mock mentioned earlier today from the GT from GTA I along with other with six other Greece panel members attended

095the net um disconnected conference and it was not only an amazing opportunity to share about our District's implementation of the Yonder pouch but as well um as learning about how much our phones and technology kind of impacts our environments and impacts our educ educational outcomes and then today or throughout the week I had a conversation with our um with Miss Lorie Quinn who is the teacher on special assignment for lead for leader leader in me and we spoke about how um almost half the elementary schools in Athena Middle School have a Greece student Lighthouse team where basically the school is implementing um implementing ways for students to participate in various service learning projects or collecting donations from like lollipop collecting donations for Lollipop Farms or even riding cars to different nursing homes and then the

096highlight of it all is that it's all student l so students also have the ability to um facilitate and run announcements and help coordinate leadership day where students are able to highlight other students who exemplify the um seven daily habits in their school buildings and then um we I also learned that all elementary schools are implementing or setting wig goals which is widely important goals and those are all academically driven so I thought that was a nice thing to see and then as well as a lot of the schools are also um also implementing leadership notebooks or portfolios where they basically have all their leadership goals all organized into one um one binder in a sense and it's practicing the ability of staying organized but as well as taking the ownership of their own learning

097and then the final thing that I also learned from Miss Quinn was that um kind of like how Mr Jones mentioned today for the gas presentation that there was many leadership courses taking place in our district such as Phoenix Athena high school and Arcadia High School where they're all they're all applying the seven daily habits to their Teenage life but as well as um being highlighted by like different teachers such as a phoen a phoenix teacher who teaches a course and said that all the components of a profile of a graduate is also being emphasized in the leadership course as well so that's my comments for today thank you Mr Alvarez any other board member comments Mr suzel thank you Mr President good evening everyone I'd like to begin by acknowledging first that February is

098Black History Month it's a time to reflect on important parts of our history and one significant chapter I'd like to highlight especially as somebody who works both in healthc care and education/ Academia is the Tusk syphilis study thank you Tracy for that idea this is a deeply unethical 40-year clinical study that was conducted by the US Public Health Service from 1932 to 19 1972 the study involved 600 black men 399 who had syphilis and 2011 who did not these men were misled and denied proper treatment for their disease even after penicillin became the standard cure for this in 1940 instead they were told that they were being treated for quote unquote bad blood and were never informed of the true nature of the study the purpose was to observe the natural progression of syphilis without

099providing any effective treatment when the study was exposed by journalists in 1972 it sparked outrage in the community and led to significant changes related to research ethics including the creation of the Belmont report this report established essential principles for conducting ethical research on human subjects which are still in practice today and I think that the three principles that I'm going to talk about here for a moment are relevant to what we're doing here which is uh respect for persons which is emphasizing autonomy and the need to protect IND individuals the second is beneficence which means minimizing harm and maximizing benefits the third is Justice not social justice but Justice ensuring that all participants receive fair treatment based on need effort and Merit this event also led to the establishment of the institutional review boards or

100irbs which are now required for all research involving human sub subjects excuse me thanks to this we have systems of informed consent check for comprehension and literacy and voluntary participation and clear understanding of the risks and benefits this chapter in our black history in the United States is something that we're all impacted by today shifting gears because I'm talking about health here and education I also want to recognize that February is heart health month in the United States did you know that your heart is the only muscle on your body that never gets to rest it beats an average of 100,000 times a day without pause despite its incredible resilience the heart heart disease remains as the leading cause of death for men and women as well as for many racial and ethnic groups according

101to the centers of Disease Control and prevention that remind us that heart disease does not discriminate it's ubiquitous in fact according to the American Heart Association 23,000 children experience Cardiac Arrest outside of the hospital each year that's why it's important that we raise awareness of this public health issue through education and everyone who has the capacity gets trained with CPR all right basic CPR for you never know when you might be able to save a life also my last plug with this is that National Wear red Day is coming up this Friday the 7th all right so I encourage everyone to wear red in your support of heart health and help spread awareness about this vital issue that could impact all of us and lastly I'd like i' like to just express my heartfelt gratitude

102to the wonderful staff and you know who you are watching at Greece Olympia for your tremendous kindness and support to my daughter during a related health issue over the past week um whether through your personal messages or sending cards or your thoughtfulness has truly meant the world to me and to her I know it and I I want you to know I deeply appreciate everything that you all do and the compassion that you bring to people like her and the other students you serve every day it's your care makes a difference not just in my daughter's life but in the lives of the students you serve and I can see that and I thank you from the bottom of my heart thank you thank you Mr Borio thank you uh last week uh the national

103assessment of educational progress released its annual report card on student achievement it was another disappointing report card uh nationally and uh fair to say that it was also disappointing here in Greece uh where we saw uh performance for our students slip um several points in in um uh Ela performance uh proficiency and in math proficiency um it's really important for us to keep our eyes forward uh looking at yeah we have to we have to acknowledge we've been nationally and locally on a on a long trajectory of flat and actually declining uh achievement levels and uh and that's really disappointing and it really begs us as board members to pay close attention and really start to dig into what is behind that and what we can do to make an improvement um and I know

104our staff is working on it hard and I appreciate that and I I want to again call attention to uh what we've been doing with our core yes our our reading performance uh dropped we're in the First full year of our core uh looking nationally where we where we have States Mississippi and Louisiana stand out as as is two the I think the two states that bucked the trend in improved performance and they have had a multi-e uh dedication to the science of reading and evidence-based strategies uh um pedagogy so they're we're on the right track but it's going to take some time um and it's still as I said requires our us as board members to be uh V vigilant and diligent in in ensuring that we um we see fruits from from that

105all of that work um Natalie Wexler is a education journalist and um some of our staff did a uh a book study on on one of her recent books the knowledge Gap uh just want to quote from her for a moment here if I can find the right one she um she noted the results and she said reading scores dropped to Historic low for eighth graders nationally this is with 33% scoring below the lowest level of basic 40% of fourth graders also fell into that category the highest proportion in 20 years to make matters worse she says the decline was driven by the lowest achieving students in other words the scores of high performers stayed pretty much the same but scores for low performers plummeted certainly the um in a quote from um the chairman

106of the uh National assessment for Education progress uh said certainly the most striking thing in the results is the increase in inequality and just looking back at our own numbers and this this I think is a really important thing for us to understand among economically disadvantaged students in ela the numbers were down proficiency was down 5 percentage points um and in math down four percentage points a little bit better among not economically disadvantaged students we've talked about Equity quite a bit uh there's actually some mixed results when you dig into some of the other subgroups but I think this just calls us back to the importance of really focusing on this and we have to keep in mind 90% of our nation's students are educated in public schools there is no one else that can

107pick up that load this is our job no one else is even capable of handling that so we really have to make it work we can do our part here I'm I'm calling on us as a board to be extra vigilant extra diligent and really focus on on driving positive change thank you you just like when I ran for the school board um and when I used to speak at residence Forum I did it um because I felt advocacy was very important um and I joined the um at um our president's um suggestion I joined the legislative committee for Monroe County Schools um so every first Wednesday we go to lunch and talk about priorities um we just had a legislative breakfast meeting with our legislators um but the only thing we're about is getting

108money um the 10 position papers are all about funding and I just think that there are so many things we should be doing in Monro County in terms of instruction and we had some of our um senators from from the United States Senate um and they could be showcasing some of these states that are having amazing results um and Mark referred to Louisiana and and Mississippi Mississippi was 49th for forever they now are the seventh highest in fourth grade reading scores overall but they're number one for lowincome students number three for black students and tied for number one with Hispanic students and when you hear something like that that's so overwhelming that they could make that progress I and there's no reason we can't with the bright people that are working here um and and

109I'm so disappointed that our board doesn't have more time together to really talk about these issues um I know that several people at Retreats have said that our role is the board and I know that this is what Monroe County School Board Association says is to set policy and then to shut off um but the handbook that's the authority which was co-sponsored by the New York Bar Association and the New York um school boards Association says that the governance is in all areas of the district including academic and behavioral and it just gives a list um so I believe that you know we we do have a responsibility um and I see two more schools have been added to our those cited by the state meaning that they're five and in a short time it'll

110seem like a short time our board will have to approve these plans with the district plan we get the plan about 4:00 on a Friday and Tuesday we're asked to approve it the time I spent on those those plans um it was just it was overwhelming and I think we need more time and and it would be nice if we had time when we could discuss discuss the plans and the last thing I wanted to say I was talking to a friend um and we were talking about goals for an organization and um my friend said that um they should be smart goals and I thought he was saying I was stupid um which he might have been thinking too but that wasn't what he was talking about um and I asked for an explanation

111and I thought this was really this was really good um they need to be specific clear and unambiguous it answers who what where when and why they need to be measurable there should be concrete criteria to track progress and determine when the goal's been reached they should be achievable the goals should be realistic and attainable considering your resources and capabilities relevant it should matter to you in align with the broader objectives and values and time bound the goal should have a defined deadline or time frame for completion and one of the things we've learned um about these turnarounds um that states have done school districts have done is they are heavily um based on numbers they're doing assessments all the time even to the tune that teachers are assessing every lesson they do um not

112in terms of what their intention was but how that're translated to the students and they have ways of measuring that and I just was amazed that um I wish I had known those things when I was teaching because they could have made um I think my class is much more engaged so I hope that we can work continue to work on instruction and some of the things we've we've learned and um work together yes I just wanted to take a moment out here uh last month I had the opportunity with the grece Chamber of Commerce do a networking event at ja at Bown at Kodak Park uh it was a networking event so we didn't get to see this in action so I asked to see this in action when GRE was going to go

113Greece is actually going to be doing ja Biz toown I believe in the spring so I look forward to seeing that but what I did get the opportunity to see was the Spencerport class fifth graders they were in there and it's a very amazing opportunity if you ever get a chance to see this the students were actually engaged in the curriculum that they were learning although it was a field trip kind of a moment they were teaching things about hospital jobs at the hospital whether it could be um health related construction related all sorts of different aspects Airline rg& banking food industry they were working on a supply and demand uh going around to each and every little business that these kids were working on to sell their product so they also had to pay

114their bills they also learned how to vote and they also um they also voted in for a mayor of the city so it was nice to see the working relationship they had going to see what these kids are going to be doing in the future because this important stuff that they needed to know regarding the supply and demand and how to pay the bills it was a great thing to see I appreciate the opportunity also I had an opportunity to visit NASA's Challenger at codak Park with the fifth grade Longbridge school um we that was a very interesting simulation for the NASA Challenger to see Mars in action to see how we're going to redo the living on Mars and building the the soil and the rocks that they were doing to see about the

115magnet magnetism of this it was very interesting I appreciated the moments to go there um we did have the Monro County School Board lunch in I did get to sit with assembly assemblyman Josh Jensen we did talk about the electric bus issue that we're seeing that was not noted in the governor's budget at that time I had an opportunity to sit with Senator Schumer uh he had a representative in his honor um as we talked about safety issues within the school um which was a very interesting point um coming from him um I appreciate going with the tax the veterans tax exemption I am glad to see that the board approved that 90 was very nice to see and to pass off my last uh note here was foot loose on Friday I actually got

116to see Foot Loose with a couple of the other board members what an amazing show we were actually talking about this an exact session um afterwards about how the it was I I just can't even get the words out the lighting the choreo choreography the students that were involved we were trying to figure out if you could pair other uh students in other positions there was a preacher the farmer you couldn't really do it it brought you onto the story you laughed you cried it took you through the moment so it was wonderful to see that so I appreciate that thank you and the sets sets I got to clarify two things um just two things on Miss F's comments um number one we weren't talking about the play in exec session it was after

117exec session and number two um we didn't approve the veterans tax exemption tonight we did a we're going to hold a public hearing I just want to make sure that's clear I'm I misinterpreted your comments because it sounded like we approved it and that's not than for the clarification so I want to make sure we clarified that miss m um I also saw Foot Loose it's amazing one more weekend please go and see it um because you know I'm a music person Jazz 90.1 University is starting this month and it's a Community Learning events throughout and they pick a jazz artist and they have a discussion about it um you can find out more about it on www.j.com where this room was filled I could hear the giggles out in the hallway and this entire

118room was filled with children doing math problems and laughing it was fabulous um I also got to be with Anna and Elsa so that was a little tribute for me fun but anyway so nice to see families out please consider doing more events like that it was fabulous thank you thank you m Mo Mr Butler uh yeah just briefly I just want to say uh special thanks to uh the superintendent's cabinet um for including me in the district comprehensive Improvement team um it's been uh really I've been so impressed with the the the thoughtfulness and the the rigor that that group brings to and and the introspection that that group brings to looking at the challenges that we face as a district and finding ways to to get better all the time so that's uh

119there's a huge amount of effort that goes into that a huge amount of reflection and a huge amount of expertise in that room people that really uh know what they're talking about and I learn a ton from those folks every time that I'm there so I just wanted to say thanks for the opportunity to be involved in that and be part of uh Improvement here in the district so that's it Mr Maloney thank you Mr baller first of all I'd like to thank Romeo and his staff for keeping us updated on the budget I know it's a lot of hard work I know it isn't an easy thing to do and trying to Second guest the governor is always a hard a hardship uh and you've done well over the years and I also like

120to thank uh Dave Richardson for his uh Transportation update uh it was enlightening uh even though that uh we'll get things worked out I'm sure we will thank you thank you Mr Maloney vice president farmer okay thank you so I'm going to touch on a few different things here and it might overlap but um we were down at uh shot Beach on uh Monday my nephew participated in the Polar Bear Plunge and it was a source of Pride to see Greece buses there helping this whole beautiful day happen in terms of fundraising and um anyway it was good to see grace Greece there I also want to reiterate that Transportation applications are due on April 4 uh April 1st I'm sorry um so make sure you get those in so you can just have a

121seamless way of uh getting your transportation and I also want to focus on uh Black History Month and I want to uh talk a little bit about um what we are seeing regarding um diversity Equity inclusion and how that is beginning to unravel decades uh centuries worth of um this great country making striving to become even better and I'm just going to uh read off some things I want to start with um the disenar the the feeling of disenar regarding the um helicopter and the uh plane crash that happened the tragic tragic incident that happened and it was blamed on Dei hires that concerns me when we're looking at uh reading reading scores and future endeavors and what that means for different people who may not fit the mold for what Dei would like to

122um become um 1857 The Dread Scott versus Sanford decision the Supreme Court rules that enslaved people are not citizens and cannot Sue in federal court effectively upholding slavery in territories 1865 ratification of the 13th Amendment abolishes slavery throughout the United States 1868 ratification of the 14th Amendment grants citizenship to all people born or naturalized in the United States including former slaves and prohibit States from depriving citizens of equal protection under the law such as if uh an enslaved person would would uh via the Underground Railroad end up in a in a state where there wasn't it wasn't a slave state but were forced to go back so now all states um in 1874 the Henry Berg founder Henry Berg he was the founder of the American Society of prevention to animals through that Society we

123were able to remove a child from an abusive foster care setting based on prevention to the to cruy of animals this is when we began to see the beginning of uh American Society of Prevention of Cruelty to Children 1896 Plus plusy versus Ferguson uphold separate but equal racial segregation laws schools separate supposed to be equal we know that wasn't the case bathrooms water fountains public transportation we know that history we know the separate but but equal and we know that it was not equal um Jim the Jim Crow era was a period in American history when state and local laws enforc racial segregation the term Jim Crow was a derogatory term for African-Americans this uh Jim Crow lasted from 1865 through 18777 until the Civil Rights Act of 1964 Jim Crow laws denied African-Americans the

124right to vote hold jobs get an education and other opportunities they were supported by everyday objects and images people who defy Jim Crow laws often faced arrest fines jail sentences violence and death the Civil Rights Act of 1964 formally abolished Jim Crow laws um I went a little out of sequence there I'm trying to do a timeline but uh August 18th 1919 the 19th Amendment the right for women to vote was ratified in Congress making this a nationwide law Victory took decades of agitation and protest that put many women in prison and force fed when they refused to eat Alice Paul a not so known leader in the women's suffrage movement is shown in the movie Iron Jaw angels I I urge you I urge you to to take some time and watch that uh

125movie 1924 the Snider act Native Americans were given citizenship and voting rights does anyone else see the the irony in in that 1948 the integration of the military under Harry S Truman 1954 Brown V Board of Education declares racial SE segregation in public schools unconstitutional the Little Rock Nine Ruby Bridges who had to be escorted by the National Guard into the schools that were uh desegregating they were spat on and cursed this this then caused okay uh 196 4 Civil Rights Act abolished Jim Crow the Voting Rights Act of 1965 sought to overcome barriers for some to access the vote mainly in the South 1967 Supreme Court ruled unanimously that anti-ag ination laws were unconstitutional and interracial marriage was no longer illegal 1998 Matthew Shepard was tortured because he was gay and was left to

126die on October 6th and 2009 then Matthew Shepard and James Bird Jr the hate crimes prevention Act was passed um 20122 the marriage equality act um I have recently been reviewing I don't know how many of you are familiar with this online learning resource it's called the Con Academy to review my American history and my understanding of the Constitution and the Amendments um I failed to mention Carter G Woodson who was the founder of the we a week of um the first black history week he um I'm going to read this he said he wrote a book called uh he wrote several books but I want to just close with this quote Carter G Woodson if you control a man's thinking you do not have to worry about his action when you determine what a

127man shall think you do not have to cons concern yourself about what he will do if you make a person feel that he she is inferior you do not have to compel him her to accept an inferior status he she will seek for it if you make a person think he she is a justly outcast you do not have to order that person to the back door that person will go without being told and if there is no backdoor the very nature of that person will demand one Americans have benef all Americans have benefited from the passage of civil rights over the years instead of remaining victims or perceiving themselves as victims we instead use the rights our democracy and Constitution provides to make all people women and all marginalized PE people equal and free

128in this country that we love thank you I got everybody right I'm gonna be brief um I just want to thank Mr Rosario for his heroic actions his actions truly potentially Sav two of very young children's lives um I want to encourage everybody to come speak at the public hearing whether you're for or against the veterans tax exemption the board to make a smart decision is going to need hear from people on both sides of the issue so I encourage everybody to get signed up there'll be a signup sheet like I said earlier till 6:30 that night and to my colleagues on the board of education I think we need to take a moment and step back and think about truly what board member comment should be um and I'm not singling any individual out

129but it typically has been what our students are doing what we're doing in our schools and it's now turned into some type of political speak by some members that's not what board member comments are for we're 40 minutes in a board member comments at this point um and we're not there were very few comments regarding our schools and our students and what's going on in our buildings it was multiple diet tribes by multiple members so I'd like everybody to maybe take a step back and consider and maybe we look at doing something to clean up board member comments a little bit because if we're going to keep doing this we're going to end up with two hour meetings because everybody's going to go on a 15 or 20 minute diet tribe about whatever they want

130to talk about that's not relevant to the degree Central School District so with that I'm done superintendent small you're up um I just wanted to quickly um recognize Black History Month as well um in our schools um this is an opportunity for our our students um just to deepen their understanding of the count countless contributions achievements and resilience of black Americans throughout our nation's um history it's a time for us to engage in meaningful conversations and highlight the voices and stories that have shaped our society I am personally um very excited about our upcoming celebration of black Excellence that's on February 13th at the gpac I believe 6:30 5:30 6:30 start um where we will highlight remarkable achievements of our students Educators and kity members um this event serves as a powerful reminder of the

131talent uh resilience and Leadership within our schools and Beyond um as we celebrate this month I also want to reaffirm our commitment to equity and Excellence for all students ensuring that the lessons of History inform the progress we continue to make together so let us use this time to learn to uplift and continue working together um for a future where every student has the opportunity to thrive also want to mention that this is school counselor uh national school counselor recognition week I wanted to take a moment to recognize and celebrate the incredible work of our school counselors as many of you know uh our counselors play a vital role in supporting our students academic social emotional and personal growth uh they are mentors they are Advocates they are problem solvers and a source of unwavering

132um encouragement for students families and staff uh their impact extends far beyond schedules and college applications they they shape lives so I wanted to personally U thank them for their compassion commitment and their countless ways they uplift our students in our schools um and I just wanted to put in another plug many of you that are either listening tonight or we here tonight students staff uh family community members um the My entry survey is out I know as of Monday I think I had 700 responses um so just want to keep on uh requesting people take that seriously get that out to people and um provide us your feedback and with that thank you thank you superintendent SMY Mr Maloney I'd like to have a motion to journ this meeting Praise Jesus do I got

133a second board member Mar all those in favor that passes N9 to zero thank you everyone e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.