001everyone to our Tuesday January 21st 25 Board of Education meeting if I could have everyone rise for the Pledge of Allegiance which will be led by board member Terry mure followed by a moment of silence for the following Carol Blakeley she was a retired teacher from Greece Olympia uh teachers Aid at Greece Olympia she had 30 years of service she retired in 2005 she came back as a sub and then she were as a Kids Care Aid working until 2021 Santina Sandy Shay worked at district office for many years after retiring she went to substatus in March of 2010 and Mary Lennon passed away she retired from the district after more than 20 years of service so if you keep the Blakeley Shay and lennin families in your thoughts and prayers that would be much
002appreciated alance to the flag of the United States of America to repu for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank You Can I some move the agenda table please moveed by Mr stencel seconded by Mr Butler any additions corrections to the agenda I would like to add 6.06 uh resolution for architect design services with that can I have all those in favor of approving the agenda is amended I pass is 9 to Z my student leaders from Phoenix Academy welcome this evening come on up can I start you can oh um here are the Phoenix proposal system encouraging leadership opportunities and empowering Phoenix students to use their voices Oh wait um students have students have a lot of ideas but we had no formal way to record
003them and follow up following up the proposal system The Proposal system was created to help with this they are submitted to student council and they present presented to miss Hawkins during a student council meeting who will be involved the cost and the benefits of having the event and the costs of not having the event once approved student council members organize what is needed the date of the event and Etc we have successfully completed four proposals Spirit weeks fun days gratitude trees and smoothies so far this year and have had Sever and and have several that are are sorry and have had several that are in process vending machines lockers and continuing to get better choices for lunch Friday fund days we gather all the students and adults to join in on the Friday fun day
004every month we have two Fridays that are skinny days so students can have a break at the end of the week when students have an idea they are required to complete a proposal form and submit it to the student council for approval the Gratitude tree students are trying to create a warm and welcoming affirming environment at Phoenix Clem's Tree of Life painting in the inspiration of work yeah okay um sorry um where was I okay okay um Clint's Tree of Life painting is the inspiration of this work removal believes in other objects seasonal dependent will be filled out by students body student body and staff and placed on the hooks uh dispersed throughout the tree the idea came about as a way to connect our leader and me work leader and me emphasizes the importance
005of gratitude as a key leadership quality encouraging individuals to actively Express appreciation for others and acknowledge the contributions of their team the lining with the idea that a true leader recognizes and values the efforts of those around them fostering a positive and supportive environment most of the student council members are in art Club 2 students will be using this time to construct and paint the Gratitude tree installation once completed all the students and staff will have the opportunity to read a gratitude statement and hang it on the tree the installation will be in the front lobby for more information about Al things Phoenix [Laughter] yep we're gonna have we're going to do a picture I was going to bring everybody up for a picture um Dr zitz Deputy Fleming superintendent small and the board the
006staff from Phoenix come on down jeal no Gina you get to salute you're the only one to kids the salute so be in the middle Fant your not your first day in a picture right middle thank you guys so [Applause] St all right can I sun move the Staffing to the table please moved by Mr bagorio second by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on Staffing sing onone all in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on to tenure tenure area changes Can I some move that to the table please moved by Miss L seconded by miss mure any comments questions concerns on this sing then all in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on to 4.0 one compliance Assurance plan superintendent smallen good evening um at this time I'd like to call up
007our executive director of pupil Personnel Services Stacy bendes and our director of pupil Personnel Services Melanie Stevenson okay thank you good evening uh Melanie and I are grateful for the opportunity to provide uh the board and Community with an update regarding our compliance insurance plan tonight so as a a reminder we came in the fall to share information about our two District citations they're listed on this slide um the first one uh represents a significant discrepancy in the rate of removals for 10 or more days for all students with disabilities and that's compared to um all students uh our indicator for B citation represents a significant discrepancy um within that subgroup of students with disabilities for an over over representation in the number of black students removed for 10 or more days um and both
008of those are ongoing citations for us a little bit of new information as of this evening we were notified by the state education department it's not another citation it's just a different level of citation um so there is 4A in our um New York State performance plan and there is 4B and then there's overall four indicator four where it talks about an overall um disproportionate outcome for multiple years so um if a district is cited for a specific subgroup for a specific outcome and it's ongoing with no improvement um we sort of move up into the level of monitoring um and a a district identified as having significant um disproportionality has a couple of of mandates that they have to put into place I'll explain those in a second um right now we are at
009risk because we're in a citation for two years for black students with disabilities so we were previously also cited for Hispanic students with disabilities but not again this year so if we were to end up on that list again next year for disproportionate outcomes for Hispanic kids that would be our year one again and year two and so on so the 4B Citation for the specific subgroup of black students with disabilities has been ongoing for multiple years um and we're on year two which in one more year we would be considered having sign significant disproportionality by race and ethnicity um what I can say is that the business office has been really supportive in planning knowing that we have been on and off a citation list for many years as long as I've been here
010so two of the things that happen is an action of the increased monitoring is one sort of that review of records and and more oversight on campuses but then also as you'll see in this slide it talks about um our requirement to reserve 15% of Ida funds to provide early intervening services so if we get another year the state Ed department is going to tell us that we need to redirect 15% luckily we already do that every year so we take money out of our idea funds and we um allocate them to General Ed providers reading Specialists uh school counselors and staff that are hopefully really targeting our kids with disabilities and providing some of those supports prior to to some of those outcomes so that's an ongoing citation but we're prepared if if we
011don't have the um outcomes that we're hoping for this year so the focus of our compliance Assurance plan has been a shift in um notifications and procedures in addition to outcomes for our kids so while we're really working to create Al alternative outcomes this is our major shift that we talked about in the fall when we were here and really what this visual represents is the shift in practice between previous years and the current school year so previously in Greece and in any other district and frankly in most districts right now that aren't cited um practices that a behavior or an incident occurs a removal in school out of school alternative to suspension occurs um and then following that students are provided their procedural safeguards with that series of meetings and what we talked about
012in the fall which um continues uh now is our focus on shifting that practice to providing all of those procedural safeguards and notifications prior to a removal and this is for students who have already reached 10 or more days of removal so this isn't for every student but once a student reaches that disciplinary change in placement DP which I know is another definition than what you're more used to once they reach that level this is enacted and and kids are not allowed to to be removed without the series of meetings so this has been our major work um thus far this year and it's been a learning cve for all of us to to put the new procedures into play um we we do however have I think really great results that you uh were
013provided uh late last week in your packet just go over a couple of key points in some of the graphs um that are provided in your presentation so overall shows the Improvement between last school year and this school year in the first four months of school September through December and the total number of incidents resulting in removals and this data includes in schools out of schools and alternatives to suspension so you'll see obviously a marked decrease there uh this slide here um breaks it down further into our first uh cohort citation which is 4A for students with disabilities and it really is looking at the number of students with disabilities who have been removed um the comparison between last year and this year on each of our secondary campuses so you'll notice also every campus
014has gone down um and you'll see a really significant increase in the totals between last year at this time and this year um 598 incidents resulting in a removal to 180 and I think we put the number up later but it uh represents about a 70% decrease in the number of incidents resulting in removals which is just amazing um this year versus last year so this is our next citation uh is indicator 4B which is a specific cohort group within the larger cohort of students with disabilities this is our black students and this is our second year in a row fac with that third year where we really want to make improvements we have shown some improvement um between last year and this year um in incident resulting in the removal of a black student
015with a disability and these are specifically black students with IEPs so for some of our work for our compliance Assurance plan and some of our procedures that's applicable to any student with a disability some um as far as some of the more the reporting structures to the state are just students with IEPs so that's why we broke it out into specifically IEPs that's what our citation is for and our final data point um just looking at comparison thus far this year is the number of students with disabilities with two or more removals so as part of our work um with the compliance Assurance plan and the level of monitoring through the State education Department we are monitoring ourselves we are monitoring ahead of time before we're reporting so we know what we're reporting we know
016where our areas for growth are um and and we're really able to track in advance so we're flagging any student so that we can get ahead of those procedures and start to make sure we're prepared to support kids if they're to the point where they're getting to 10 removals and then we have different uh procedures that we have to enact um you'll see that the number of students um at each secondary campus with two or more remov this time last year um versus this year has significantly decreased as well so that was uh the number that I had shared with that total number uh from slide eight so overall the number of incidents resulting in the removal of students with disabilities has decreased um by 70% overall so I'm going to turn it over to
017Mel to share a little bit about change in process all right so as you know um we had shared in the fall that we were required to change um some of our our processes and procedures um one change that is not directly related to the compliance insurance plan and suspensions of students with disabilities is the proposed suspension letter we're required to send a letter to parents letting them know we're proposing a a suspension excuse me and that they have the right to an informal conference and then following that informal conference a suspension can then be imposed additionally we're able to remove students with disabilities immediately if they constitute a continuing danger but only if they're not over that 10 days in those instances where they're over 10 days we must conduct a series of meetings
018and notifications like the pattern determination manifestation on potential CS Etc we've also begun to schedule program review csse meetings following a manifestation where a manifestation was not found for the express purpose of discussing the special ed services that will be provided to the student during their suspension um following the csse we're providing the parents with a copy of the prior written notice which is a summary of the recommendations of the csse and the rationale for those recommendations we've also implemented a new tracking system for purposes of documenting the special education services that a student is receiving while serving the suspension um as just providing attendance records showing that the student was in attendance at the re-engagement center was not sufficient documentation we actually have to show that they received the service um that was recommended
019by the csse um and then lastly on this slide um Greg and uh Jess compile weekly documentation for the removals that occur each week um which I then review and then um submit to the regional associate at the State education department that we've been working on through this plan um we really continue to be so appreciative of the Board of Education support with regard to the additional Staffing um that we've added in order to support the implementation of this plan um as we've shared we've added the two assistant directors for Behavioral response systems Jess and Greg who are in the audience today um so that we're really able to consult with principles regarding the removals of students with disabilities and conduct the pattern determinations manifestations and csse as quickly as we're able to additionally we've
020added um District behavior interventionists and crisis interveners for a net ad of three total in each group um we're still in the process of hiring for those positions so schools will hear more about those as they're filled um but we're very excited about the additional supports um District Behavior interventionists consult with buildings and teams regarding challenging students Behavior they help with a plan for addressing that behavior and also to build staff capacity with implementing those plans so as to shape the students behavior our crisis interveners are the folks who not only support students directly um but they also build staff capacity with regard to implementing behavior intervention plans and modeling the use of those TCI strategies for staff one of the main priorities of our work with the compliance insurance plan as you know um
021was not to simply just reduce the number of removals and suspensions for students with disabilities but it was also to build staff capacity around addressing challenging behavior um we continue to provide regular TCI training for staff as well as professional learning with regard to restorative practices we've also added some additional in-person trainings that are listed here as well as some that are asynchronous and we also have some digital badges um some of the digital badges that we have currently um accessible for folks are addressing tough behaviors ABCs of behavior um gcsd behavior intervention plans data collection for behaviors functional behavioral assessments progress monit monitoring of a behavior intervention plan and using effective praise so we're really um proud of all the offerings that we have currently for folks again to build their capacity with working
022through those challenging behaviors so now I'll turn it back over to Stacy for next steps all right and just uh finishing up and really kind of our Focus has been on our goals for this school year um it's been a learning curve for everybody there's new procedures we are uh figuring out channels of communication across the district so it's really been something that we've been dedicating a lot of time to um so our goal is to get to compliance we of course want to get to Quality um but our goal is to get to at least compliance so that we're able to really focus on kids um more and procedures less um and we have all of the tools and forms and procedures and protocols to be able to do that it's just us figuring
023out the timing of that um in light of incidents making sure the right people are are keyed in um and really moving through this with our attorney who this is her first time working through these procedures um with any school district so we're really Reinventing the wheel relative to the letters the mandates the compliance Assurance plan um I would bet my next paycheck that if you um had a conversation with administrators in in another District they know very little about this um because they're probably not um implementing the the new procedure as required um and unfortunately we don't have that luxury of of flexibility so we're kind of building building the plane in Flight um and everyone's been really really wonderful about um moving forward with it so a couple of things again we want
024compliance um for sure but we really want to figure out what differently we can do um when supporting kids um so Saturday school is a a solution that we're trying to really figure out if there's a a benefit to that and starting small and then applying broadly we're hoping the kids take advantage of it and we're able to get some buy into that and it will be something that kids are hoping to to avoid um and uh shift behavior um the intervention toolkit for schools so this is where I think the most of our work really lies and we're trying to focus on this every leadership meeting that we have the ability to talk about the plan at our principal monthly meetings at all of our special ed team meetings in schools we're really trying
025to focus on what are the different alternative interventions for kids um and that's really where our work is um increased tcis training so we have 12 trainers currently I believe maybe 13 um some shifts in job duy so there might be a change um next year but we have the ability to train a lot of Staff um so far this year we've had 171 new participants in TCI um and we have a total of 401 certified staff so our goal is really to continue to increase that number we also have um connected with hundreds of people through staff meetings where we offer little TCI vignettes or little scenarios for staff to just get Snippets if they're not able to take part in the full three or five day training so that's really um improved too
026and that's really our primary Crisis Intervention um those are our strategies that's where our toolkit really lies in dealing with kids in crisis um so our goal is to recruit and hire additional Behavior support staff and secondary building so M and I are consistently bothering Jess and Greg someone applies they're interviewing they're really trying to fill these vacancies with um staff who have experience and are able to to uh hit the ground running helping our buildings um and then the continuation of professional development opportunities so we're finding some things work better than others um with teams we're trying to figure out how to shift what we've offered based on feedback um we're we're open to different sort of um opportunities across the district and we're just trying a bunch of different things that's why you'll
027see the synchronous asynchronous badges um we're just trying trying different things to to see if we can get some traction with the most amount of people um but it's tough to leave classrooms too so that there's an impact to that too um but those are our goals and areas of focus moving forward and that's it for us questions m m um do you actually have Saturday school now or it's going to be starting first week in February I think we're go for first week in February yep perfect Transportation everything's worked out oh great yep vice president farmer could I follow up Terry um so kids have option tell can you tell us a little bit more about that part please and I'm also wondering about evening school has talked about it all and I'll just
028be quiet and let you them listen yeah so we're really open to to really kind of process through any creative solution so um it's not an opt well so it's our first time through it I guess we're going to have to kind of figure that out right we're going to work with families and and kind of talk that through um our goal would be to Institute that as one of our set of consequences that we're able to deliver in lie of a removal so we're hopeful that with conversation with parents and having really some conversation specifically about their kids and wanting to keep them in school that we can kind of share our purpose for creating this alternative to solution and we're hopeful that parents will want their kids um you know to to not
029be removed and and participate and hopeful they they might not want to come back either um so we have the best laid plans and we're starting small at Arcadia um we're collecting some some data and then we're hoping to really uh expand across campuses um we're also really looking at primarily low-level behaviors first so right I report that there's a 70% decrease that might not be what you're hearing all the time right so we're really looking at an overall decrease in behaviors that result in removals right so we're looking at some of our lower level behaviors and really aligning to the code of conduct more Progressive discipline more creative Alternatives not going to the end um for an initial infraction of a behavior so that's really our initial Target and then if we can get
030to the point where we're able to really create some systems and some teaching right because skipping takes a different intervention than a kid who um is engaging in threatening behavior or is really struggling with mental health there there's some things that we just need a different skill set to to support um so I think it's going to be wait and see to see what we can um Target as far as alternative consequences um you know we're really hopeful that something like skipping where we want kids to be in class we wouldn't be removing them from class that seemed like an easy target um as far as just an initial one to to look at a a different alternative to see if it it takes shape um we were have been a little bit more flexible
031with the cell phone policy too I think was shared with you as far as just like notifying parents and involving maybe a different step in between adhering to our policy but like not going to to the um most severe uh consequence thank youo thank you for the report can you clarify for me the difference between removal and suspension because it sounds like well so in in in a case where a student is being assigned Saturday school is that student removed from other classes or is Saturday school in addition so removals for the state ad Department are in school suspensions out of school suspensions alternative to suspension any time that results in a student being removed from academic instruction that's what the state ad Department would consider a removal for us we're hoping to have the
032Saturday detention in lie of a removal right so there's nothing to remove them from on a Saturday we can Institute a suspension or uh A detention um and it's not removing them from class they're able to serve whatever alternative or not um and just address that low-level Behavior at a delayed time during Saturday school that's what we're talking about that initial sort of lower level behaviors but does that mean they're not in their General Ed classroom in in that they're in school business as usual throughout the week and as a consequence instead of going to in school right if a same kid skipping multiple times a principal may have a lunch detention then an after school detention now it's an in school now it's an out of school we're really trying to prevent that um
033and and there wouldn't be the need for any removal they would continue in their classes throughout the week be assigned a consequence their consequence would be that Saturday school where we would partner up either a teaching or support based on um whatever the issue is so it's an add-on it's an add-on yep okay well it's it's replacing too right so we're adding it on to our work to our school week but we're not instituting a removal during the week and adding it on both things wouldn't be happening so it's not really an add-on I guess I should clarify that it's an add-on to the menu that yes add-on is an alternative to the menu not for kids though it's an alternative to what they previously would have had a removal for from a class or
034something during the work it's an add-on to their schedule it's not I'm I'm guess I'm not understanding yeah no so really this is a student has a behavior infraction in school right they're skipping again low level behaviors we're talking about is just our initial sort of Target a kid has been s you know has been skipping multiple times we don't want to remove them from school so they miss more classes right we want them in class so we're keeping them in class during the week when they're skipping we're talking to them about their what their consequence may be sending them back to class hopefully that's our expectation and then addressing the skipping behavior on Saturday when there is no school to miss or no other uh class to be pulled from okay thank you sorry
035if I made that more confus I just want to follow up on Mark's question and then I'll get you Mary um but it's the the parent has to agree that a Saturday detention so if I say my kid's not going what are we doing in that same situation for that kid that's progressively skipped if I say yep I'm not sending my kid to Saturday detention now what are we doing yeah we're playing it out really as a add an initial partnership with family so we're calling and offering that and hoping that they'll be in agreement but yeah we can't force them to send kids on the weekend and we also understand there are things that are more exciting um than right being at school we're hoping that's a deterrent right so the kids are able
036to participate in family activities on the weekend and not be um taken away from it so again it's really just trying to be creative um we're not sure if it'll take we're not but we have the staff uh available to do it the buses to get them there and we're going to try um and see and then what the team is prepared to do is just get a ton of feedback from kids right what's working what isn't working what would make this a valuable use of your time so we're hopeful Mary I'll try to shorten my three-part question um these are astounding um results um but I know how numbers can be played with um so um do you have a sense of like how the classroom teachers who are involved with this and on
037the front line um do they feel this is improving the safety and the climate in the room rooms and hopefully in the schools yeah I think you're going to get a mixed reaction depending on the school the teacher skill set and abilities and comfort level in managing behaviors because we have Behavior across all of our classrooms not just special out in the district so it's really about that Comfort level and that's the the PD we're trying to offer with the additional District behavior interventionist and crisis interveners to provide that in the- moment training for people that might not be able to to be pulled out for extensive training what I would say is that we are really our data um demonstrates that we're still removing kids for similar behaviors as we have previous years so
038we have a ton of removals for kids with disabilities a lot of long-terms already um suspensions and they're really for those behaviors that you would think that a student would be removed from that hasn't changed or stopped we're still suspending kids long-term or shortterm for unsafe situations and those those bigger deals um what we're trying to do is decrease the lowlevel behavior so I think that I would say that no not all teachers are happy about that because kids can be disruptive if I don't know how to immediately address a behavior in the moment and they're also worried about their content and teaching so that's why we're trying to partner up that in the moment support knowing that it's their right to be there but it's also everyone else's right to that education we want
039to keep an orderly environment and we're not going to be perfect with that but uh we have a lot of supports that that are available to teach people that's excellent thanks um and the the last thing was I found this re resarch just amazing with um when they started older kids later and of course when you have buses that have different runs it's counter to you know it's the custodial care issue as opposed to educating the kids but um how the behavior just improved astronomically and so did the academic performance I mean could there be any way of um having a third run and having a pilot maybe and as long as you're doing this work maybe look at that as an alternative um so that you'd have your your high school kids then you'd
040have your Elementary and then after the elementary you'd pick up and just and just try to see how that went for Saturday school specifically no for the regular school I'm sorry I got it Chang and maybe you know have core of teachers that say I'd like to you know I'll stay later and I yeah the research does uh suggest that I know my home District uh went to that switch that's above my pay grade Mary well maybe it's a place to um we can advocate for that yeah thanks Mr Butler thank you for presentation and congratulations on the really strong results it's very rare that we see numbers with with that kind of year-over-year change and uh I wonder if you've and there's it's interesting when you look at it there's some spots everybody's doing
041better period full stop and there's some spots where things are better than others like on slide eight uh which is uh uh secondary students with disabilities at Athena went from 107 down to 16 so it's like an 80% decrease in that as compared to some other places where maybe it's half we've cut it in half or something so I just wonder if you've got any suspicions about why you've got some of those bright spots in different areas I would just be surmising if I if I said what my suspicions were because I I'm I'm not positive there's still so many variables that I wouldn't be able to isolate it to one thing to say what it is what I do know that has been more effective in um some buildings um more than others is
042just the really direct conversations with staff and teams um honest and transparent conversations about what consequences might be instituted what staff expectations might be for instituting consequences and what may happen and I'm not saying other buildings aren't having those conversations um some buildings have more Alternatives already inhouse than other buildings so at Athena High and Kelly could you know comment that there's like a creative sort of structure that they put in place as a pilot to try some things as a space to be proactive whereas Arcadia High School they have some followup on the back end that's really really creative as far as identifying the skill deficit and offering direct instruction afterwards that's really targeted um other buildings are don't have the the similar specialized programming so some of the incidents are more rare and
043unfamiliar to buildings and I think that adds to to some of the um sort of responses right they might be slower to come around a little bit to some of the more traditional responses um overall everyone is just I mean this is this data is you know although we partner and and we're collaborators this data is a direct result of principles just really leaning in and um instituting changes when it's tough um so I think it's just about the culture in the building and how long it takes to kind of chip away and roll something out over others um certainly not for lack of trying in any of the campuses yeah yeah I I did like as I said I the results are impressive everywhere just wonder if some of the conversations we've been having
044about professional learning communities like where those bright spots are identified that maybe that's an opportunity for those professional learning communities to dive in and say okay what's working it's working well everywhere it's working great over here what can we learn about what's working really well there and apply it in some other Spa spaces well the nice part about that is because you um have all supported our assistant directors of behavior response systems Jess is only on two campuses Greg is only on two campuses so it's really helpful they work collaboratively then they report out um to our department on their work so it's really I think it's been nice to improve consistency and it's also been good to share ideas um to say this building has this figured out where are we with this could
045we try this and that's oftentimes how we redirect professional learning or how we might get a crisis intervener over we're trying to kind of um problem solve and build capacity so that it's job embedded so that some of the things more successful in other buildings will take in in other ones too great last last thing on Saturday school give it a shot right and see see what happens I'm glad to hear that you're working with parents on that because obviously there may be situations where there are students who have child care responsibilities or jobs or things like that that Saturday would get in the way of which could even escalate the behavior problems that you're seeing during the week so I'm glad you're talking to parents before that just gets imposed so thanks Mr bar
046so I'm looking at at the numbers on on page seven and so this is this is General uh change in number of incidents resulting in the removal of a student down about 45% um we know that if we pass a law that says you cannot remove a student for whatever reasons and if we follow the law which I'm glad you're doing we should have reductions in the numbers of students removed I'm wondering and and I appreciate that you're making a distinction between students removed student behaviors like skipping where we want them in class removing them is Contra it contradicts the purpose and there you said you're my words you're holding the line on other behaviors violence behaviors disruptive behaviors things like that because we really need to give everyone their access to a good education
047so what I what I see here is a big reduction in the number of students removed but what can you tell us about the instances where students are are removed has that number changed are we seeing a reduction and are we tracking the numbers of incidents and particularly I'm thinking of those situations that are disruptive or violent things like that what are we seeing there so yeah that's that um number that I had shared is similar to in previous years we're still removing kids for those types of infractions so before I forget though I just want to clarify the the law piece because it's not that we can't suspend them it's just that if we're going to suspend them we have to have the series of meetings beforehand so I want to be clear on
048that too and we are suspending them um we are suspending students with disabilities for less than 10 days for more than 10 days dependent on the behavior demonstrated and cabinet makes that decision based on all of the procedures we'd always have in place previously the difference is about the timing of the removal um which is significant it's not not significant um we are just getting to that stage if we're looking at reporting ongoing to the state with the number of kids that are at DP right 10 or more days it's mostly our long-term kids one or two of our cumulative kids so we're not at that point yet where we have a ton of kids at that level but that's why we're tracking that every week um knowing that it's any kid that has two
049or more removals this here on slide seven is the number of incidents resulting in removals not the number of kids um who were removed um and that's for all students so I think what we're seeing too is just a shift overall if something works well for a student with a disability as far as a creative solution or peer mediation or teaching right those are the things we're hoping to try with General Ed kids too and I think that's a little bit of what you're seeing um in that overall number too and I think um it's also reflective of some of the capacity building that we've done like for example when we've done the TCI light trainings with secondary staff it really um helps them take a look at the conflict cycle and how to not
050engage in that with a student so we have staff that have shared that you know phrases like drop the Rope where they've stopped themselves from engaging in that conflict cycle and then sending the kid out of class and hoping for a removal they've had more strategies and tools in their toolbox to really um engage with that student um and get them deescalate back into class participating Etc vice president farmer um do you know if charter schools have to follow this as well so the um the procedures regarding the meeting structures is just the new way of doing business that's the interpretation the state Ed department has of the regulations so that is applicable to every student in any school in New York state um if they're suspended 10 or more days those series of meetings
051as well as private uh private schools no that private religious those wouldn't um fit into to that but our private um schools that we pay tuition for um Charter Schools anybody that receives public funds they would be under the um regulation in that way there's a followup to that before I go to Mr bagorio the charter schools go can can send you back to your home District if you're a discipline problem they they have the ability so they don't have to follow it because if you're a problem they can say thank you very much go back to gree Central and do that they have have to follow the meetings they can still remove a student that's what makes a difference is in the end after the meetings they can remove a student we're a public
052school district we can't do that so that's a big difference there but in eight days they could ship you back if you're a problem they can ship you back I mean we all know they're doing that yeah they're they're not dealing with the long-term issues and problems sorry Mr baroro thank you um in the past well I think it was in the past two weeks there was an article uh in the ncet news regarding uh the teachers Union's advocacy for better workplace violence pre prevention citing the workplace violence prevention act and a teacher recently also Direct Ed my attention to um an article from the United Federation of teachers regarding the save act save schools against violence in education and both articles pointed out we have idea on one side that's protecting the interests of
053students with disabilities and then on the other side there are these laws that require us to pay attention to the safety of our staff uh and in the case of save there are uh opportunities for staff members to invoke rules that require removals or might require removals so there's a balancing act not only a balancing act but we have to we still have to abide by the rules right we it doesn't mean that you get to choose one or the other somehow we have to make both of those work generally only hear this this one side of it but what are we doing on that other side are we is our staff aware of their rights and how are we safeguarding our staff and and our other our other students as well in the process
054so I would just say at a baseline level um we've distributed an FAQ document that really talks about save relative to our citation so while um teachers and staff do have the right to invoke they do not have the right to do it Beyond 10 days so just like a principal so if you have a a student who's been suspended for8 days 9 days and a student um is presenting an issue in Kelly's classroom and she decides to invoke save and it's the 10th day she cannot do that and we've communicated that to GTI so it's not just a a a cart blanch removal of a a student from a classroom the same procedural safeguards which is the point of the state Ed Department we should not be removing kids for multiple days for disability
055related needs if it's not then it's a removal just like they a gened kit but that's those questions we have to answer um so we can do it but it's really about the procedures Mr stel thank you Mr President um thank you for the report this is very enlightening and uh I can really appreciate and see the hard work that you guys are putting into this so thank you for that I was curious on page 15 you were talking about the professional development sorry slide 15 um I wondered if you could kind of unpack some of it a little bit further so like the unlock the code understanding the why behind student behaviors is this like a a class that you developed as Greece to teach teachers about or like I guess where did that
056curriculum come from and then I'm also really curious about the book study with Beyond Behavior why this particular psychologist like what informed that decision that book um where's the data behind it I guess yes so Mel and I have charged Greg and Jess with working uh up a menu of professional development we had a lot of standard offerings so we're trying to get creative like I said trying new things so I'll let them talk a little bit about um the book study and how the uh books were selected if you don't mind they'd be able to better answer that okay all right so to answer your first question the unlocking the code um professional development was something that was was um developed by Greg and myself based on um some research around function-based thinking which
057essentially is identifying the function of a student's Behavior so that it can be prevented ahead of time um and we initially rolled this professional development out to the leadership group um a couple of months ago and it was really successful so um some of the feedback that we received from principles was that they wanted their buildings to get this so um we are making that available to all staff um we have a pretty good group signed up it's going to be held next week actually um and then the book study is something that's actually run by some of our Behavior interventionists as well as our um special education tosas and I have not read the book so I don't have a lot of information on it what I can say is the reason they chose
058the book was many of them have um most recently gone through the um behavior analysis program PR at the University of Rochester and this was a text that they felt was very relevant to what we're doing um that they was a a major part of their their degree so they wanted to sort of pair that down for our staff and make it app applicable to what we're doing in classroom so that's how they chose that and they're also the people that are Consulting and intervening with those um crisis situations and also with students that are demonstrating some really challenging Behavior they're the ones that are in the building building working with teams modeling you know giving recommendations seeing how it goes coming back in looking at the data figuring out is a plan working is
059not working and then making adjustments and recommendations there thank you Mr bonario so I realize you're reporting on the compliance Assurance plan and maybe this question goes beyond your scope but I me I'm wondering if we can receive the data that that um reports on that those incidents that go beyond those things like skipping Etc the the the things that really disrupt school for our kids and put put teachers staff and and students at risk and I know the data on page seven I at least from my how I'm understanding it that goes beyond students with disabilities so maybe it's a more of a generic general question but I'm wondering if we can get that data from a an oversight perspective um in your next board packet you're going to get a detailed attendance and
060behavior Report with I think what you're looking for some of details around what types of behaviors are leading to the actual removals okay um so there'll be a lot more detail coming in that and also on attendance and some of the interventions that we're doing into more detail there okay I'll look forward to that thank you I just got one and all actually I got a couple questions so I mean I appreciate the fact that we're extending the clock on the 10 days where more nickel and diming instead of taking bigger bites on the 10 days how many students districtwide are knocking on that 10day window right now less than 10 nine nine yeah nine mhm um and so once they get just so I'm clear once they once I get to my 10 days
061MH what happens so you get to your 10 days and business as usual until a behavior happens that might result in a removal and prior to you being remove from school we have to deploy Jess and or Greg get notice to families and convene meetings that is the ask from State Ed so basically so I'm clear no matter the offense once I've hit the 10 days I can't be removed until I we have a meeting and if my parents can't happen to make a meeting till next week I'm in school yeah so those are caseby case basis if the parent is a no- show and there's some other delay tactics those are different conversations than involving parent voice which is what we've been charged to do is having parents be at the table when we're
062making these um decisions for kids um so hope hopefully we'll be addressing that but yeah essentially um and that's up to and until we make a determination it's not a manifestation because if after 10 days we make that determination this also was disability related then they do need to go back and we have to decide what do we need to do what do we need to do differently to support the student in school so that could be a variety of things that could be them going back into the the classroom and um receiving additional adult support that might be or it might be a recommendation for an alternative placement there are alternatives that we have through Phoenix and and and different supportive sites so it really depends on the kids scenario um and the number
063of um disciplinary infractions their behavior plan it's so many variables that um but I think from an advocacy standpoint from a board of education perspective and I'm going to give you a scenario I'm at my 10 days I've done a host of things through the three months I decided I'm going to beat Jeremy up Jeremy's getting Jeremy hit me back he's getting five days I've hit my 10 days my parents can't come in tomorrow they can't come in till what's today Tuesday Wednesday Thursday they can't come in till Thursday so I'm in school till Thursday those are some of the scenarios we're forced so from an advocacy standpoint that's something the board should be advocating on that there's certain I mean I get if I have my 10 days and I skip Kelly's class I
064get that that I shouldn't be but if I'm violent or I bring a weapon to school or something along those lines so I mean obviously the weapon's going to be an LTS situation anyway but if my behavior is bad once I've hit the 10 days I'm in school while the person that we fought he could be out for five but I'm in school the next day I mean that from an advocacy something I think that's and I'm not criticizing you guys we got you know I mean I think from an advocacy standpoint from a board of education that's something that with this cap needs to be tweaked a little bit because I mean I do think based on the nature of certain events that there should be a now this Rises to this level you
065should be out of school even though you've hit your 10 days already and the state ad Department wouldn't say it as probably I'm saying it where we can no longer remove for disability related needs they would say something along the lines of if it is a pattern of behavior then we have to figure out how to address in a different way well I mean the commissioner doesn't want to suspend anybody I mean a commissioner I've heard that right from the commissioner's mouth that nobody should be getting suspended from school which right I mean I think you've been a long time since you've been in a classroom not the farest shot the commissioner but I I think you have 3% of your population that lead to most of your problems in any school district so I
066mean I think that's unrealistic there are some Provisions for um significant incidents um drugs weapons um serious bodily injury but it's really tough to meet that threshold and it still would require um Jeremy um he may Institute something quicker but we'd still have to have those meetings so there's some Provisions if it fits into a specific category but not um a relief from the meetings just um a little bit of a relief in in the timing of them and then just for clarification as well sorry that's okay is so once I've hit my 10 days even LTS me like a long term we would have to have a meeting and go through the whole process and we would have to offer as a distric alternatives to a long-term suspension clearly yes and and what they're
067really saying too is so so also what the state department wouldn't say is kids have to stay what they would say is you have to have a meeting before kids could be removed right and that's really what our citation is is we have kids who have been removed and we haven't had a CSE to say what their services are going to look like so with that so as long as we check that box we're good I mean in theory is that what you're telling me so if I check the box we had the meeting we're good and we cany before the kids remove that's so if we have a meeting tomorrow I punch Jeremy today my parents come in tomorrow morning I'm in school tomorrow morning we check the box we had meeting I can
068be out for 5 days starting tomorrow yes if it's not a manifestation of your disability then you would be suspended like a general education kid we wouldn't even really need to have a CSE we would just talk how our service is going to be delivered during your suspension and we would move on the kid might come back and then it's again the same scenario another incident we're still and that's why we've um put so the biggest issue is checking the box that's the biggest timing of it so it's the series of meetings and the timing of it so that is what the state ad department is pushing us to say is you can't send a kid home until you've had all these conversations and what we're saying is the impact in a culture and you
069know just people feeling comfortable in classes when they're bigger issues is the impact why it's taking so long which is why Kathy advocated for some time um additional time well I appreciate I appreciate you guys you know answer my questions jerem yeah um I think it's important to note and you've said it but to say again that the cap does not at any there's no part of the cap that states that students with disabilities can't be suspended what what it's doing is just ensuring what they call their procedural safeguards that after 10 days what what the state is saying and this is what we shared you know with our administrators and with teachers is that when you look at the sole purpose of the cap it's procedural safeguards with students with disabilities to just ensure
070that we're not removing a student due to their disability at the heart of this at the heart of this citation is really to ensure that a student that has a disability is not removed due to their disability that's what those meetings are for for um and and so the this kids can be suspended but it's just ensuring their procedur safeguards take place before you make that determination for them to be removed to your point it's the timing yeah is that we're bound to have those meetings before you can make that determination but sometimes that translation gets lost as it gets out into our buildings that the messages are students with disabilities can't be suspended after they can't we just got to put Pro procedural safeguards in place with that and I guess just one more
071question so we weren't doing any of these meetings before like when we were suspending our kids with special we were but we were doing it in this order so what every other District does now and right this is what and it was permissible before the new interpretation came last year Mel and I have been doing this for over 20 years um this the regs have said the same thing for many years and they haven't changed which is our push but it's the interpretation and the the Clause that they're interpreting says that only the CSE can essentially determine what services look like during if there's a manifestation so you have to have that meeting first and what would happen in some cases previously for like a short-term suspension the student would be removed they would serve
072the three days then we would hold a manifestation we'd say it's part of their disability so then they serve three days that they shouldn't have served and that's what they're trying to do is not have any removals without those questions answered so basically and I think you guys hit on this a little bit like some districts aren't even looking at this because they haven't been cited so they're still doing it this way so when we hear from Neighbors friends whatever that well my school district still does it this way the rationale is because we've been cited AB with our students with special needs perfect my colleagues that have been cited are the only ones that are enacting these procedures this quickly is everybody working on it have been told to shift practice yes but not
073given the timeline that we've all been given um they're definitely not moving great thank you oh just one other thing regarding what you said Jeremy however they can't be if it's a if it's a part of their disability if it's a manifest 100% yeah so it doesn't matter about the meeting then but that's all I guess that has always been the ca like that part is not changed that if you once you've reached that threshold which was no matter when you have it but once you once you've determined that that behavior is um connected to their disability 10 year you know when I was in the building that would always be the case yeah I just think that that's such a problem for the code of conduct and for the um the climate in the
074school you know it's it's hard for kids it's hard for anyone to understand how they do do the same thing or in this case Sean's the one that beat you up that wouldn't happen though you I don't know could go either way I I think then the question becomes when we determine that it is connected to their disability the question becomes what needs to be different for the student and that's where we say do they need adult support have we done an FBA and a behavior plan do they need a different program right do they need an additional related service those are the questions that we ask and we need to we figure out what needs to be different for the student so that they we shape the behavior they don't um repeat that behavior
075thank you and to act in a timely fashion correct yeah well and so just to kind of comment on that we Mel listed and and I share too some of the outcomes and many times we're continuing to refer kids out we have more kids awaiting placement than ever than right we have 27 students right now some are in their programs waiting and some are um actually in tutoring waiting but we are referring kids out um it's just that we don't have a lot of places for them to go um so um there's different perceptions on that too I think depending on where the kid stays after a recommendation Mr yeah thank you guys for doing this you may have answered this question but when you have a student the teacher in the classroom because of
076this so we're saying the student may go back to the classroom while we're waiting for this or while they're in a holding periods how is the teachers handling this so that's what we're talking about is what we're really trying to get that job job embedded professional development there are very few kids this has happened to I do not believe this has happened in any scenario yet where there's been a significant safety issue where kids returned right away um we're trying to create alternatives to support kids and we're we're trying to utilize common sense right to support kids who are in crisis we're trying to engage families to come in and have conversations and we're trying to convene our required meetings so we're really hoping that the partnership continues to sort of support all of this
077work together um because it's a learning curve for all of us and there will be circumstances based on this where we'll have more kids who are getting into that deip 10 or more day range who this will apply to um the rubber is going to to meet the road soon um so I do anticipate things you know um bubbling up a little bit more and we're prepared to support um we unfortunately can't change the regulation or the the state interpretation of it superintendent small ohop sorry I'll come back to you or go ahead it's okay I just had to follow up to Sean's question the nine children students um that you were having a problem with those are students that have more than one infraction they are repetitive is that where we're going with that
078one yeah so if you look at slide um uh 10 those are all of the students in secondary schools who have two or more removals um we have students who are bordering that time time frame so they're adding on to infractions one was an LTS one was an LTS yes so we do have a kid Beyond 10 days for an LTS good superintendent sming I just wanted to end by first just recognizing the incredible work that your department has put into this starting over the summer it's significant work it's work you know you're not in buildings you're working with building principles to uh focus on this and that takes a lot of work so I want to recognize your department for the work that you're doing and I also want to recognize the building principles
079and assistant principles that are learning this taking this work on along with running the buildings this this you know what you're seeing in this data doesn't come easy it's been a lot of hard work there's work to to continue to do um but you can see us moving in the right direction but there still is work that needs to get done and I wanted to publicly recognize you for that appreciate that thanks Mr brel I I just need a little bit more clarification on the rule so in this instance you shared with us two citations both of which involve students with disabilities and that I think is the key thing in these citations so if these scenarios here the situations that these that this data refers to did not involve students with disabilities would there
080still have been a citation or was it exclusively because there this process was turned around we we didn't reorder it and I guess a question is we you started that new process at the beginning of the year so yeah so the citation is not based on our procedures the citation is based on disproportionate outcomes it's based on those consequences and then the compliance Assurance plan has us enact policies and procedures that are systemic that deal with that over representation of black students suspended they're not disable or students with disability stud with disabil so any state performance plan indicator is through idea and that's completely students with disabilities we were just showing the frame of reference of all students um and that we've made marked improvement across the board including gened students and that was slide
081Seven's representation but the citation is all for special education students um our now it's going to get even more confusing our procedures as far as holding those meetings in advance are for any student with a disability so that's 504 and IEP the students we report to the state aded department compliant records are just IEPs and that's the state performance plan so these procedures once the citation goes away aren't going to go away they're the new Norm the new regulations those are different than the actual compliance Assurance plan so even if we do the the manifestation um determination report and we identify that the behavior was not a manifestation of disability would disproportionalities prevent us from taking disciplinary actions or removing a violent student yeah that is the question that we're charged with answering right so
082there's some certain circumstances for really egregious Behavior drugs weapons bodily injury serious bodily injury those are outside of sort of the realm and there's some different pres um Provisions but we also would have to have those those meetings the difference is anytime there's a manifestation that student cannot have that uh con uh consequence instituted that is the difference so if you're just looking at janad kids right we don't ask those same questions they don't have that same procedural Safeguard so yes it's strictly for students with disabilities and it really is about other students with disabilities in the state so it's not there's a relative risk ratio but they look at two standard deviations um above above the mean of the suspension rate across the state um and that's significant for us for our black students
083with disabilities over a five where um the the Statewide average is around a two um so more than two times the the rate of suspensions for those students and just a last clarifying question can can those numbers be driven hire by students who by a single student who has multiple suspensions so it depends on the data report we report the number of students who are at 10 or more days so yes if a student if a multitude of students have 10 or more days we're reporting all of those to the state just because you have a disability if you've been suspended five six days over the course of a school year these Provisions aren't in place and we're not reporting on you you have to get to the DP where is the rubber meeting the
084road with these circumstances thank you all right thank you both thank you moving on to 4.02 budget development process update superintendent small I'm going to ask uh Romeo Ki to present good evening everyone I'm going to have uh our Executive Director of Finance uh join me as well on uh this for tonight um we're going to do a quick budget update uh where we are in the current process uh we're going to take a look at some of the State of the State highlights talk a little bit about some advocacy priorities that are out there and then round it out with just a budget timeline so that we know where we're going to go uh one of the things I wanted to to bring up again is we do each year is the Strategic plan
085um this is our anchor for decisions we making a cabinet and recommendations that we bring to the board um all our budget decisions will be based on the Strategic plan or the reach 2027 uh framework which is based on our three commitments of igniting learning cultivating trust and expanding opportunity for all our students throughout the district so want to speak to process um I want to take us back to 2425 budget development because we looked at that process in terms of coming off of ARP funding coming off of big increases that the result of increases in Foundation Aid and we developed a process that would allow us to have sustainability in the budget so we did some things we right-sized a number of budget lines and we really saw this as establishing a new base
086um for this year the process started by looking at um the Strategic initiative that are part of the Strategic plan and then we met with superintendent smallen and Deputy super uh Fleming to get a sense of ongoing and new initiatives that are going to drive the budget um including such things as leadership development and mentoring among others and then we took that and moved to the next level we looked at cabinet and uh started to look at Department initiatives that they're seeing for consideration things like curriculum development initiatives technology infrastructure replacement of systems at or near U end of Life Community School initiatives summer programming Etc and then from that we took those initiatives that are the new initiatives that are generally centrally budgeted and funded uh to look at what that would mean to
087the buildings as we go forward the next step was to complete those department meetings uh for Budget planning we focused on closing the loop so that buildings would be aware of any changes that are coming through that they may not be budgeting for in the initial phase but would be part of their requirements for years two or three out um we looked at again we right sized a number of budgets but we we knew well that the right sizing that we did was probably wrong but we did our best shot and in part this year's budget we really looked to hone that down and make Corrections where necessary um we we would adjustment curriculum equipment Bose's expenditures to assure the proper alignment um the next part of our budget development process we take all positions
088uh in the district and they're rolled over into the 26 budget we increment them based on contractual agreements uh we complete analysis of our major expenditures benefits being one of them and we did that by looking at a census of all employees based on open enrollment in December and we used the new rates that are going into effect or that have gone into effect and then projected forward increases to get a detailed look at what those uh benefit expenditures would be from a district perspective excuse me for operational departments in conjunction with HR we looked at uh Staffing requirements those requests are not part of the initial rollover those are things that we will look at as ads as we go through the process again looking at the budget development process we start to look
089then at the revenue side um governor hokel gave her State of the State address last week and today she presented her budget initiatives we actually got uh state aid runs we're in the process of looking at those to review and scrutinize that to make sure that those are numbers that um are consistent with what we believe to be accurate especially or on the uh expense driven AIDS um the legislative budget will be developed in conjunct or the enacted budget will be developed as a compromise between the governor and the legislative budget and that comes at the end of March historically it is more favorable than the go Governor's proposal um and it's also being framed with with through the lens of the Rockefeller Institute review of the foundation Aid study so a number of proposals
090were um identified in the uh Rockefeller study uh that may some have have been incorporated into this budget that was shared today uh there may be others that in the long term May factor in and could significantly change the funding formula so again recapping last year the governor um to put in perspective uh changed the way in which CPI was calculated uh it would have been 4.1% she manipulated and I choose that word properly manipulated the formula so that the CPI was 2.4% and eliminated the hold harmless provision that had been in place since 1976 which impacted 50% of districts again putting in perspective the way in which the enacted budget is favorable the cpri was restored to 2.8% and the hold harmless uh changes were rejected so looking at the um some of the
091metrics um the tax cap will be presented at the February 25th Board of Education meeting the tax based tax-based growth factor in the tax cap is z 1.21% the allowable growth factor is at an excess of the or is 2% based on the CPI being an excess of two um the CPI d data uh scheduled for release in January released today is 3.1 and we'll be reviewing our debt service budget with our uh fiscal advisers on February 6th okay as Janine had mentioned last week the governor uh provided her State of the State we just wanted to touch on some high some highlights uh that may be applicable to the district uh one area that she spoke about was restrict restricted cell phone use in K12 education uh she mentioned that again uh this morning
092um she's looking to create or I should say this afternoon she's looking to create a new Statewide policy or standard for distraction free uh instruction within the classrooms um so we should be seeing some further recommendations coming out from that another item she spoke about was expanding youth Mental Health Services to provide funding to support high school students to strengthen their mental health uh Wellness skills uh and initiatives to equip the Next Generation with critical media media literacy skills um the funding in this uh initiative is to provide students with tools to identify understand and respond to signs of mental health and substance abuse challenges including bullying and school violence couple of the things that we're speaking of this evening and to connect Mental Health Resources to after school programs so hopefully we'll see more
093on that as we go she also has an initiative regarding the Early College High School program uh to streamline the funding there are currently three uh streams of funding um her initiative would uh combine those three uh programs and focus on economically disadvantaged students for college credits and to provide those credits free to families another ISS initiative is to engage students in positive activities like Youth Sports art programs uh Community Building uh again she's looking to increase funding for these initiatives there's inti an initiative called New York plays initiative stands for what's in parentheses places for learning activity and youth socialization again competitive competitive grants to fund playground development and maintenance across the state a big item that was spoken about and we heard again today was Universal free Universal School meals uh across the
094state um for all 2.7 million students um the addition was about $120 million to close that Gap from this year to next year to provide Fe free meals across the state uh and a couple times in her address she did mention that it would save roughly about $160 a month for families for about $1,600 a year uh and breakfast and lunch costs so again that was one of her strong initiatives as well and again she's also looking to add assist businesses by Pro promoting some collaboration between the Department of Labor school districts and businesses to recruit high school students for summer work in high demand fields and also to uh provide funding to registered Apprentice ships uh in high demand occupation to help cover wages training and wraparound services and then the last item um
095kind of related more to us is our tax cuts and rebates and she spoke about those again uh this afternoon she'd like to uh has initi an initiative to reduce middle class taxes and provide about up to uh $3 billion in inflationary rebate checks to all New Yorkers um the rebate checks would be about $1,000 for every child you have under four years old there a rebate back to the families uh we're not yet certain how this tax cut and rebate program may have on the level of school aid at the time we wrote this last week um the current s estimates were about $ 1.7 billion increase in in education Aid back in the midyear New York State reported was about 1.0 billion however as an epilog and Janine mentioned that the uh a
096the school aid runs came out our foundation Aid looks like it's up over last year we're still taking a look at that and um we'll see what the legislative budget comes out with in mid-march next we'll talk about some advocacy uh priorities so there are numerous groups that have uh agendas for advocacy um we did focus on the business administrators and the number of items that came in that were incorporated into the uh Rockefeller um report um change the slide uh one of the major items was to allow expense based aids to run at current law levels and not to manage those or manipulate them um second was to implement changes to the foundation Aid formula that are consistent with increasing needs of students and the increasing cost to address them so a couple of
097the things that uh did get Incorporated uh or recommended rather was to use current census and that was in fact incorporated into the um Governor's proposal another was to modify formula for data elements that are no longer accurate uh that too was incorporated by Reduce by you not using the free and reduced lunch and using another measure in its place uh recognizing student need changes um one of the recommendations was to adjust the elll adjustments based on proficiency uh and to look at funding special ed in in an entirely separate form um there are other initiatives that uh were Incorporated was to use multi-year averages to decrease volatility in the formula rather than having a one-off year totally skew the aid that comes through to eliminate Set asdes uh for instance we have a community
098school set asde that ident if x number of dollars that need to be allocated for Community Schools and in our district we certainly use those and then some but set aside our limit will limit a District's ability to have the flexibility to put funds where they need them and then use uh another recommendation was to use the CPI for the Northeast region rather than the F uh National CPI we are I think I did mention we are using the current census uh that was part of the governor's proposal compared to the 20-year-old Census Data we're using the small area income poverty estimate to determine student needs and we're using the New York State economically disadvantaged count to replace free and reduce lunches so that does take some of that pressure off with not receiving data
099on free and reduced lunch but it doesn't eliminate the benefits that families would receive when they do in fact file for that another recommendation was to restore growth Aid in the current year um districts that experience large increases in enrollment would not have any of that factored into the aid they receive until the next budget year which in many districts could be a hardship um there's been advocacy for years to increase the CT uh the Staffing rate from $30,000 to $60,000 for both these aable salaries um that would make it far more available for CTE programming and then to look at kindergarten uh or pre kindergarten transportation and pre kindergarten specific capital projects to be aable and to merge all the pre kindergarten funding into a simple needs-based formula uh based on student allocations a
100couple further uh advocacy points um districts are currently filling critical positions with uh retirees there is a advocacy for the governor to extend the authorization to utilize retirees for an additional five years without any penalty to the district or uh to the employee uh two Charter Schools um as everybody knows tuition payments for Charter Schools can be a large portion and in our district they are a large portion uh of our budget and this enrollment sh shift beginning of the year during the year between charter schools and the public district is uh unpredictable so there's some advocacy around eliminating Sunni uh authorization of charter schools and only allow s to be the authorizing Agency for any new Charter Schools establish a new funding stream to reimburse districts for charter school tuitions again it's been out
101there for a couple of years or a number of years but we haven't seen it um and the whole Charter Schools uh to the same accountability and transpar transparency requirements uh as are held to the public districts we'll see where that one goes in terms of electric bus um since the initiative has come out districts have not identified a number of districts have identified challenges uh that were not considered as part of the initial uh law um the law applies the same across all districts and as we know it's not the same for all districts in terms of trying to implement any type of an electric bus initiative and um one of the things I read that was kind of interesting is unlike electric cars where the prices are coming down electric buses are not
102they're going up which is a little contrary to the initial law as well and then there's a bunch of uncertainty around the federal support for the program as we go forward so there's advocacy that you see on the uh screen here is to establish a Statewide policy to address what happens when your voters fail to approve a bond for uh your electric bus initiative whether that be for buses or for the capital work that needs to be done update the building Aid allowances uh required for the infrastructure needs include garages and parking lots and other infrastructure items that are in there ensure State over site of infrastructure needs outside the district's control this is refer referring to uh Municipal infrastructures and things like the grid um we don't have control over it but we have
103to be bound by it we have to do whatever someone else tells us to do and we don't have any local control over that and allow districts to move to either a hybrid low emission rather than a full zero emission bus where zero emission project products are not uh entirely viable um or do you don't have enough adequate power or the distances of your routes just don't work out well with electric buses so uh more to come on that and then lastly to incorporate uh the following rision to the property tax cap make the allowable growth factor 2% or to change in the CPI which is just another standard instead of the regular CPI uh the U is the urban consumers price index as instead of the general Consumer Price Index and then address some
104regulations regarding taxable status and calculation of the tax-based growth factor the big one here that comes to mind for me would be the pilots as we know Greece has a lot of Pilots uh independent and living uh Senior Living centers that are in Greece they're growing all over the place however they're excluded from the growth factor our growth factor stays lower than it should have the advocacy is to include that brick and mortar building in the growth factor to provide some additional room for school districts and then finally uh just looking at the Timeline we're January we have uh the meeting uh for this evening um going into February we've already mentioned there are two meetings we'll do the budget rollover and the state analysis that came out today at the next board meeting we'll
105look at Debt Service and the tax cap calculation and the bus replacement proposal for February 25th March 4th uh we'll look to uh have the resolution for the bus replacement proposal to be approved followed by the second meeting in March which would be just a budget update in April we're looking to present the superintendent's recommended Budget on April 1 public hearing will be on the same day uh legal notices will be published to throughout the month adoption of the uh budget proposed budget and the properity tax report card this year will be two weeks later the last couple years we've had to do it backtack weeks this year because of timing we'll have two weeks in between uh the superintendent recommended budget and the formal adoption by the board uh ballots will be mail on
106424 and um the budget book will be available to the public by April 25th in May we'll do our official public hearing on May 6th uh budget notices will be mailed to all residents on May 7th and then the final budget vote in Board of Elections will take place on May [Applause] 20th questions Mr money since in in the past we have invested some money in some honor pouches does that mean that the way the Govern the governor has put it that there will just be no cell phones allowed in school or will the honor pouches still the H exist I'm sorry okay I am not certain I haven't read anything more on how that's going to be implemented have you seen anything I haven't I haven't seen anything but she did say from the
107start of the day to the end of the day so they need to be off whether there is going to be direction as to how that is managed at the district level um that's not clear yet but she did say that there will be funding associated with that okay 13 million right that what I wrote Today 13 million I can't remember it's to but she did indicate that it would be up to the districts to figure it out but there was no requirements or guidelines provided at this point other than they they need to be disconnected from the time you come into school to the time you leave Mr bar I may have missed it but were there any mandates in that list that were that were funded by the state I think there was
108a grant that was included in one but there were a couple competitive grants mentioned and some additional funding behind some of the U initiatives um but I just didn't know the dollar amounts on them okay um anything in particular I I didn't do the calculations I don't remember what the savings estimated for for families was on shifting meals from homes to schools um but over 10,000 students I imagine that starts to add up yeah she she had indicated 100 about $600 per year per family okay um the savings to a family um but the total amount that she'd be adding to the free School meals on top of this year was about 120 million Statewide and that's funded that's funded that's funded okay correct so there'd be no no cost to to to parents children
109and U taxpayers and andbody District be I think so we we'd see our well I'm sure they'll be away but uh we would just use our uh School Meal reimbursement program the same way we have always but it should all be funded okay anything else Mr Butler um thank you for the presentation um one thing I've always heard about advocacy is that the legislators uh generally recommend against coming in with a dozen or 15 or 20 priorities they always want to say I got to be able to hold it in my hand the number of things that you uh that that you want to advocate for I wonder if you uh there's you know a dozen here we talked before about uh uh students with disabilities related advocacy needs I wonder if you could uh
110if you had to pick just a couple of these things that you could have be successful what they would be go ahead if you so so one of the so I'm actually on Asos government Relations Committee and we actually have a meeting this week but one of the things that is high on the priority list is the uh the transportation related the electric vehicle um the revisions to the formula a very uh high priority and the recommendations that came out from the Rockefeller study um were were largely informed by um the hearings that were held and asbo did participate in all of those so those corrections to the formula and implementation of additional changes that would um make the formula more Equitable are a part of it um one thing that didn't come out of
111the Rockefeller study that asbo U advocated for was to level up the funding rather than to redistribute the existing pool in different ways so um really looking to look at the true cost of educating students in New York and what that takes to do it right everywhere MH I would as as opposed to just a headcount based and changing changing the distribution um you know where there are winners and losers I would I would I also add to the foundation Aid piece um maybe the growth Aid formula there's a lot of districts including us where we've seen increases in elll and other folks in the year and we don't have any we don't receive any additional funding in the current year we get the funding the following year we've already incurred the cost so that
112might be something where the growth growth a formula uh might be helpful for us um the other piece I think would be important would be the expension of the retirees for an additional five years we can continue to utilize them rather than letting it expire it set to expire June of 25 if that were not if they were to expire it would leave us uh with some challenges um they don't think we need so expanding that would could would be helpful and as Janine said the electric bus uh mandate is just a struggle on everybody's mind and it's chewing up resources in time of people within the district and and one final one is the repayment of pass to Aid that had been um initially either incorrectly or um not submitted timely so that pool
113of funds um has not been there has not been a pool of fund allocated to repay that queue of unpaid Aid ours is about $718,000 um so a recommendation is to fully fund that pass do q and then to allocate resources every year to continue that as a current appropriation okay great Mr Maloney uh first of all on the universal School meals that she's proposing we're already doing it right we already have because of income base because of our we're all c pro we're all C schools so there are some districts that there spillings are not C where that doesn't apply with her change even if you're not C there would be fre free meals across the entire State C is the community eligible right right uh um do but does it cost us any
114money right now do we get reimbursed fully correct right also on the uh on the electric bus initiative I know we've been dragging our feet on that for certain reasons uh but the new president it says drill baby drill uh so is that going to affect New York state in your estimation over a period of time I don't know there I I can see it go both ways I can see it where loss of that funding could impact us but I I also believe this just my own personal there's just this initiative is is something they the Govern Governor wishes to do and whether she'll put additional funding behind the money that won't be that may not be coming from the feds is yet to be seen um personally I'd like to see that the
115the Mandate ease up a little bit in terms of zero admission timelines uh be extended out a little bit further um and maybe change a laot to near zero as opposed to zero emission so it allows for some uh propane and some of the gas buses and some of the new diesel buses are are near zero um but they're not even a consideration right now the only thing you can do is electric bus starting in January of 2027 thank you any other questions I do shot M like I guess microphone thank you I think it's more for the superintendent but thank you very much for your for your presentation um a couple of things um she talks about the governor um apprenticeships I think that could be phenomenal for our kids but so many of
116them are based on students academically prepared especially in math um when I was at Edison we were not getting the ninth graders who were doing well in these amazing shops where they could graduate and get very highp paying jobs so I think it's more critical that we make sure that the reading and math scores um you know we really focus on those to prepare our kids and when they talk about media literacy first they need to know how to read and write before they start getting Knowledge from computers any other questions thank you both thank you all right moving on 6.01 can I move to the table accordly reporting of professional service contracts greater than $50,000 moved by Mr stensel seconded by vice president farmer any comments questions concerns on that sing that all those
117in favor that passes 9 to Z mov on 6.02 tax seary settlement refund can I so move that to the table please mve by miss m second by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on that sing none all those in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on extra classroom activity funds quarterly report can I have some move that to the table please move by Mr bagorio second by vice president Farm are any comments questions concerns on that I do sorry um vice president farmer yes thank you I just want to make sure that um we recognize that the uh different amounts of money that are being uh saved or raised in various different schools and what that could mean for our students having the ability to participate in various activities thank you any other
118comments questions or concerns on that all right sing all in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on to 6.04 authorization for emergency replacement of the warehouse floor to Transportation Support Services Center service facility can I move that to the table please moved by Mr stel second by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on this Mr Butler I feel like I remember at one point there was uh some discussion about uh who is at fault for this for this defect and that there might be a lawsuit is that still pursuing and we're where this authorizing this payment doesn't restrict our ability to rec we have filed uh the necessary papers for the lawsuit okay um the warehouse floor uh repair plans have been sent to St they're looking for uh the emergency um resolution in
119order to pay it back to us quicker okay so it's ear formality but the lawsuit has been filed and so if we we'll we'll make the repair and get reimbursed for it if we're successful some point yeah we yeah we'll take some time but yeah we'll do this and then we'll come back to the board for an appropriation of funds to start the work and then we'll start the repairs uh shortly thank you Mr Money uh the appro appropriation for funding for this floor is those it's good to come out of other Reserve funds right the initial correct we'll appropriate fund balance for it thank you up to the 92,000 that's listed here any other questions all right all those in favor that passes 9 to Zer moving on to updated yearly appointments can I
120move that to the table please move by Mr stencil second by vice president F any comments questions concerns on those sing none all those in favor passes 9 to Z moving on to 6.06 can I move the resolution for the architect design Services moved by miss m second by vice president farmer any comments questions concerns on this Mr Maloney uh is this is is this the one were s swbr sent in uh quote for there was only two correct there were two exp there were two proposals submitted were recommended and the other one was uh PDG hopefully Design Group they're new though right to us they've been around they've been around yeah and the reason why we CH just s wbr is even even though they were more money is our director architect came from
121s wbr didn't he correct but that wasn't the reason why we want to with us wbr there were a number of reasons that we hashed out um at the committee meetings um mostly notable around s swbr um they've got the skill and the capacity and the bench to do it they're very experienced in multi-year multiphased projects um they've done our uh 20 2021 BC building condition survey they participated in all the walkthroughs through the buildings for which level up is reflective of those conversations um so we decided uh made as a consensus committee uh to have the recommendation go with us wbr versus pbd I know you said that uh there was 11 or 12 people that you different agencies that you would sent seven information seven informations out and then and S swbr was
122the only one well originally just to clarify originally The Proposal went out to seven larger local firms of those seven um six said they would not participate in submitting a bid that just left one bid for the architect work we then revised the scope of work and the phasing of the project and put it back out for bid and of the six that initially said they would not submit a bid five said we're still not submitting a bid but s swbr who initially said yet no decided to say yes which left us with two bids although we tried to solicit bids from seven of the largest uh architect firms in the area thank you very much Mr bonario thank you uh following up on uh Mr mone's questions I just want to say first off
123that I appreciated the the opportunity to participate in that process Terry and I uh both participated in that I'll speak for myself but uh I I found it to be a very impressive process I thought the the the entire procedure of vetting um a a large number of experienced staff in the room participated uh interviewing teams of of um uh candidates and I thought first my it was my first experience in that uh and I was just very impressed I thought it was a very thorough process um and I think we're we you you all are to be to be commended I understand uh Mr Malone's concerns and and I want to say also there that those concerns were also brought up uh with among the committee members and you know kicked around and I
124I again I think that speaks to a recognition of um the circumstances at play in our community in the uh in in the broader economic uh environment uh and and I understand that there is a desire to find ways to to broaden uh participation in future work so I I understand the the concerns of that but I again speaking for myself and as someone who clearly lacks the technical skills to be able to evaluate uh it was great just to see a lot of really competent people very conscientiously uh approaching that process so uh I I just want to say thank you and it was a privilege to be part of it thank you for the comment Miss lake is it a legal requirement that we have an outside architect even though we have an
125in-house Architect no no but we internally we could not do the work project uh with this is a whole team of Architects uh that would have to design all five or six phases of the $72 million project okay thanks any other question that all those in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on to 7.01 quarterly reporting of professional service contracts exceeding 20 but less than $50,000 it's written information only is anybody have any questions moving on to anticipate bids it's written information only does anybody have any questions and budget and revenue status report it's written information only does anybody have any questions on that all right moving on to the consent agend move consent agend table please move by Mr stel second by Mr Maloney any comments questions concerns on the consent agenda I
126would just like to thank the extra classroom um activity funds at various buildings they did a host of things for our buildings throughout the district I'd like to thank Richard and Linda grman for Their donation of memory of War Bowman class of 72 at Arcadia um Shannon hickin and Brenda deona their donations in me memory of jilan Bri Brian Forte um the Greece Teachers Association for Their donation to the new teacher induction Jason mincer for his donation Joe Presta jmo for his donation austar and ker Williams realtors for Their donation district office HR for their donations for gift cards and sah Howard for a donation of a trumpet and Mission share for their holiday gifts and foods that they donated for 16 families it's much appreciated by the school district with that all those in
127favor that passes 9 to Z moving on to 9.01 student trip approval can I move this to the table please move by Mr SEL second by vice president farmer any comments questions concerns on this I have a couple questions um the cost of this trip how is it funded I know most of our student trips are there's some fundraising components Etc that I see in them in this one I don't see that Sean over here sorry Mike it's uh funded out a title title four okay and I guess my question in the timing we don't have school on a Friday why didn't we go like Wednesday Thursday Friday as opposed to Tuesday Wednesday Thursday I'm not sure I can get back to those who had the finer trip plans and I mean it would just
128seem to have students Miss less instruction days as opposed to three instruction days out of it that any other comments questions or concerns sing that all in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on to uh 11.01 I'd like to lift from the table the coalition to oppose the regionalization of New York Public School article 78 proceedings can I have so move that please move by Mr stetzel so second by Mr Maloney all those in favor of lifting from the table can you explain the Pro the procedure there what we're what we're doing when we do that sure basically the motion was tabled so to bring it back you have to lift it off the table so to even discuss it we have to lift it off the table before we can discuss it so
129this is basically a procedural process to lift it from the table to bring it back to a discussion Point thank you okay so I have a motion at a second are there any other questions all those in favor those opposed so we won't revisit if we're opposed correct correct we're not lifting it from the table correct all right I thought you had that the other way around if you're if she's opposing it she she's against lifting it from the table no to vote Yes is lifting it from the table so we can talk about it so we can talk about it and she said if she voted no we don't talk about it gotcha okay are we clear now yeah we're going to vote again all right all those in favor of lifting from the
130table to discuss to put back back on the table the regionalization those opposed that passes 7-2 now moving on to coalition to oppose the regionalization of New York Public Schools article 78 proceedings it's back on the table for discussion you um received an email we got from the attorney today she talks about um the whole thing um basically just so everybody's aware the article 78 proceeding is passed that was filed um two days after our last meeting so we missed a window to join the article 78 proceeding but our attorney um highlight some other things that we may be interested in doing or could do so it's back on the table so can I get a motion to discuss the regionalization of public schools motion by Mark seconded by Mary all those in favor that
131passes 8 to one all right all right so we're back on topic who'd like to start I think Mark this was your cup of tea so I'll give you the opportunity so I thank you for um contacting our attorney and Gathering some information the information was really received this evening so kind of late although I think it was helpful information um maybe my suggestion is going to be contrary to what we all just voted on but I think it would make sense for us to digest that information in light of our our options which are probably broader than what was in the initial uh recommendation correct so I would like to revisit that and uh likely propose an alternative uh possibly possibly withraw the the recommendation but I think it makes sense to consider options
132and and a best way forward with it okay any other discussion M like I think it's clear that even um Regent hail was misinformed about what they voted for when they thought they were voting for an amendment because indeed the the language has not been changed um that is a real problem for me that there the state is very aware of the opposition but they won't change the language and I want you know there has to be some reason that they're not and I think it's because it can be used in a way that none of us have any idea the same as the medical interment camps are right now in court being fought over because of an agency regulation can I say something first if you're good um just as a point of clarification
133four of us from the board last week met last week right my got my dates right last week we met with s the commissioner Regent hail their Council and I'm going to agree with you miss like they told us they were going to forward us all the information about the change in regulations and the change in language and we've yet to receive that so I am concerned that there is you know more to the story at that point um that they haven't because they told us oh yeah we're going to sign it to you we're sign it to you it's been a week and I keep expecting an email to send all of you guys with those things they told the four of us that they were going to send and just so everybody know
134was it was on board member Farah vice president farmer myself and Mr bagorio we attended a meeting along with superintendent's cabinet so there are some things that came out of that meeting that we were supposed to get that we've yet to get so I'm going to follow up with Regent Hal on that does anybody else want to talk about this I have an idea that I'd like to throw to the board unless we want to keep kicking this around for a bit well I I'm sorry I I guess I would like to make an additional comment sure and it agreeing with with Mary's comments regarding the regionalization um what I would like to emphasize is that the language in the Reg ation has is very specific and what the commissioner and her team assured us
135was oh despite that the language in the FAQs and what we're saying are what really is driving this but that does leave a big concern about what the actual language says and and uh the same I I shared with uh all of my board colleagues uh a uh another district U a rural District Southwest of or southeast of Buffalo um much smaller District poor district and in fact had essentially the same conversation not directly with the commissioner I think we get have a little more uh access in that regard for some reason but um they were re they received the same assurances and came to the conclusion thank you very much we choose not to participate um because they were still concerned that the language of the regulation is different so I share those same
136concerns not backing away from that I'm just wondering if there is a better approach especially in light of our options to deal with it and I turn it back to you if you have some some thoughts on that do anybody El any comments before I jump on this um so I would like to do and I'll basically tell you what I'm thinking of doing to get some feedback before I do it because once I make the motion it won't be debatable um according to what the council said today the board does not have to make a determination any action immediately as the court is likely to issue a scheduling order that will extend the normal timelines provided for in the statute this allows the board to more fully V its options and have a discussion
137about participation once it understands what it's what each alternative might entail so what I would like to do is table this as a board well I guess before I make the motion is there any discussion on what I just said any comment all right so what I would like to do is make a motion to table taking action on the article 70 we'll call it the article 78 proceeding just for ease here the article 78 proceeding pending um I think our attorney needs to come in and explain to us what our options are as a board for getting involved in this litigation once this next steps occur so I'd like to make a motion to table to have our attorney come in and present once the next steps in this litigation are decided is there
138a second point of information sure let's get the second Mr stel point of information um is is there a timeline that must be in place for that or can can the issue be brought to from the table at any point yep we can bring it back at any point for's a point of information it can be brought back at any point lifted from the table I just don't want to put a timeline on it because you don't know some of the times that's why I didn't put a time limit on it but okay um there's no motion to a motion to table is non-debatable all those in favor those opposed passes N9 to zero all right so the motion is tabled we'll come back to this at some point again in the future Mr President
139M Lake I thank you and I appreciate the followup that you've done with the attorney that's been involved with this thank you thank you all right with that can I get a motion to adjer Mr Maloney got it for almost forgot it we were doing so well here can I have a motion to adjourn please yes sir Mr M i' like to make the motion to adjer all right I give is there a second all right all those in favor that passes 8 to one thank you for