001Richard Fuller passed away on December 16th 2024 and to the uncle of our superintendent of schools Jeremy smallen his uncle Michael Deo who passed on 12 2924 and whose funeral service was today so if you could keep the Smalling dvaco leis and fer families in your thoughts and prayers that would be much appreciated thank you I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you and before we go to the agenda we have several new faces at our table this evening and some older faces nothing personal Mr KY um so I'd like everybody to go around we'll start Mr cly and they'll tell us their title and introduce themselves to the community
002and to those in attendance good evening everyone Romeo Kil assistant superintendent for finance and administrative Services Gina Larson assistant superintendent for human resources good evening Mark Fleming Deputy superintendent good evening L Manhart district clerk Mike zeit assistant superintendent for student achievement and Educational Services Christine Baker assistant superintendent for achievement and accountability Kelly Flagler assistant superintendent for student achievement in family and Community engagement chair me smene superintendent thank you everyone welcome uh so can we move the can I someone move the agenda table please move by miss m second by Mr stencil any additions Corrections collisions to I'd like I'd like to add something to the agenda sure um a recommendation that the board joins nisma the new New York State Association of school board uh or Schoolboard Association for $112,000 a year providing legal repres
003providing legal representation also well I'll just make the resolution that we join it okay okay perfect all right anything else I'm going to remove 1.05 board recognition and I'm going to remove student board member comments 12.01 with that all those in favor of the amended agenda that passes 9 to zero moving on to GTA comments Miss Cara manovic maner manic I'm sorry that's okay welcome my husband's fault mine was better sorry but people that know me it's true good evening Happy New Year to you Board of Education members super intendance small that's nice to say huh my name is Carman jeric I'm here representing the Greece Teachers Association as the unit's vice president for educational programs this is my fourth year in this role and have served our Union and other capacity ities as a
004senior rep and also as a member of the gree Teachers Community programs with Terry mour I am the chair of the policy board as well as chair of professional learning steering committee where integral collaboration between district and Union occurs most importantly I'm a first grade teacher at Autumn Lane this is my 26th year if you can believe it one of my responsibilities is to help facilitate access to professional and continuous learning for our GTA members what's most exciting about this is that GTA now have the opportunity to participate in Choice professional learning Grace teachers may choose up to 20 hours of professional learning so this item in our contract allows instructional staff to access areas of specific interest and broaden their own learning to bring back to the students in their classroom so some of
005the highlights that I highlighted this year were the GTA women's Network book club introduction to Project based learning which I think is in cohort 2 AR core unit unpacking enhancing uh your teaching with classroom non-verbal communication classroom management with Michael grinder which a bunch of teachers in this room took and it was excellent the most veteran teachers ever took that course it was so good harnessing the power of AI to elevate student learning and engagement with Monica Burns which I went to in um Lake George that was excellent cognitive coaching developing self-directed leaders and Learners and a summer Tech camp so the Greece professional Learning Center invites teachers to take advantage of all of these at no cost throughout the school year and Beyond they offer accessible relevant and impactful professional learning that can truly
006enhance teaching practices using the latest in classroom research collegial collaboration and evidence-based practices gcsd Educators developed the skills that they need for their students and bring it back to the classroom while preparing them for the future so we're invited you're all invited to go directly to the pl catalog which is right on the professional learning tab in class link so so you can see exactly what teachers would be offered as well um Margaret dimba the director of professional learning right here in this building and I write a newsletter three times a year which includes all of the pl information and within this collaboration we attended the teacher Center fall form in Lake George so we engaged in the AI workshop with Monica Burns and literally right at that Workshop she was like you can create
007this with AI and this with AI for your classroom and I wrote like a Jeopardy game about um animal behavior it was fantastic um so just some data which I feel like is important Greece teachers so far this year have completed 11,37 hours professional learning we have 6,143 hours that are currently in progress our Greece catalog alone we have provided more than 578 PL offerings and we currently have 9,936 registrant because they can be from around the state or country in those 578 professional learning courses so it's really exciting for teachers I feel like everyone's kind of hit their stride this is a couple years in now and so people are really getting interested and talking about all the professional learning that's going on so thank you for your time know that Greece teachers appreciate
008your continued effort and support on behalf of our students and ourselves thanks thank you Dr Henley good evening my name is Jeff Henley and I am the vice president of gasa and the assistant director of accountability for the district so we're going to take a look at some of the things that are going on in the buildings uh so far this year specifically around one of the three goals that we focused on um this year and that is the plc's the plc's really are the foundation to everything that we do um it is where good instruction starts but good instruction leads to increased achievement so plc's are very much related to that first goal as well as the third goal because good instruction leads to deeper student engagement mitigating behavior issues in class so plc's
009really are the foundation but the foundations of plc's really is trust trust is important in this environment for folks to have what we call psychological safety this creat creates an environment in which true professional collaboration can occur cross-pollination of best practices allows for teachers to learn from each other and feel the safety to try new things so this is an example of what a PLC could do and and what many of our buildings are working on right now they look at uh questions or um uh they look at uh different um exams that the students are taking and they look and see what are the teachers students doing on those exams so teacher one as you can see had a 46% proficiency rate on question one an 89 on Two and a 92 on three
010so they need a little bit of assistance with question one so they can look to teachers two and three on that PLC and they can say to them what are you doing that's working so well and this is where that trust comes in play to be able to try new things and to learn from each other teachers two and three can learn from the other teachers as well as you can see so this is focusing on shifting from addressing learning gaps to addressing instructional gaps but what we have here in all of our buildings are what we call guiding coalitions and these guiding coalitions being led by the principles of all of our buildings are building the foundation of the PLC all buildings are conducting needs assessments with staff to gather feedback on the current
011state of plc's they are visiting plc's across the building to review the effectiveness using rubrics rubrics developed by Richard defor and they're grounding themselves in Richard de's text called learning by doing this is the sacred text of the PLC this is one example of one of our buildings using the work of that book this is a question from that book our learning team has a process for giving and receiving critical feedback among team members uh 50% of the group disagrees but 50% of the group also agrees that we're ready to do this work now so what this shows is that yes this is difficult work and it requires a lot of trust but it shows that we're gaining that trust and that we're ready to do the work the soil is fertile for this work
012our learning team takes actions based on the trends that we spot in student learning we are as you can see here we are ready for this now and we're already doing some of this work this is a different uh building that we got information from and did this survey so the guiding coalitions are also receiving parallel professional learning on the 4dx model of execution and using this work to facilitate the PLC process by focusing on wildly important goals acting on lead measures keeping compelling scoreboards and creating a Cadence of accountability for for All in This PLC work and lastly I wrote this down because I get emotional on behalf of gasa I would like to congratulate superintendent Smalling and his cabinet as we enter this new year you have surrounded yourself Sir with the very
013best and we are excited to serve under your leadership and look forward to where the future of Greece takes us now let's get to work sir thank you Dr Hunley all right I don't think I have anybody from aopt gos or Teamsters all right moving on to Residence Forum we have one speaker Mr Smith welcome this evening good evening board thank you for providing this uh residence form for me to speak tonight my name is Timothy Smith and I am a 31-year resident of the Greek Central School District I was a sergeant in the army with a t in Vietnam and I'm a member of the American Legion Greece post 468 and a member of the VFW Post 4658 I'm here today in support of all veterans in the school district pursuant to the expanded
0142013 New York real property tax law section 48- A I am petitioning the Greece Central School District Board of Education to provide the exemption on school taxes to all qualified veterans residing in a gree Central School District the exemptions would follow the identical veteran tax exemption guidelines as outlined but in New York state Monro County for County and town taxes and I've included them in the handouts I'm also requesting the board to put this petition on the agenda for a public meeting to resolve with a subsequent vote of yes these School exemptions will definitely help many veterans on fixed incomes those with disabilities and also their surviving spouses in Monro County the school districts of the city of Rochester Gates Chilai calonia Mumford Brockport and also a large number of school districts across the state
015already provide these veteran exemptions the financial impact on the non-veteran property owners would be negligible approximately 3,700 veterans reside in the gree Central School District including about 27 H combat veterans a school tax exemption for these veterans would impact the $125 million in school property taxes collected in 2024 burdened by less than 2% surely not all 37 V veterans our property tax owners the information I get is probably half there should be no need to raise school property taxes to cover any loss of Revenue caused by a veteran School tax exemption the district has the money with 28 million net excess that already exist in the 2024 budget which Grew From $20 million excess in the 2023 budget after a $3 million property tax increase the Greece Central School District is the second largest school
016district in Monro County with approximately 11,000 students every year somebody these students will go out and serve in the military and return to be a part of the Greece Community let's really mean thank you for your service and provide all present and future veteran School tax exemptions thank you thank you Mr Smith that concludes our residence Forum moving on to Staffing and I move Staffing to the table please moved by vice president farmer second by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on Staffing sing alls in favor that passes 9 to zero assant superintendent Larson thank you very much I'm pleased this evening to welcome a few um new administrators uh first let's start with our new principal for Athena High School Jason Fulkerson everybody's favorite part thank you Jason Jason earned his undergraduate degree from
017St Bonaventure University before pursuing his M's in administrative certification from Sunni Brockport Jason comes to this position with a tremendous with tremendous experience he has been the Principal at Athena Middle School for the past 11 years but before that he taught in Rochester city school district for seven years and went on to become an assistant principal in the Rochester City School District for 10 years Jason's favorite part of the job is being part of a school excuse me part of a school team that works hard to create and sustain a positive School environment where students staff families and the Greece Community can take pride Jason is looking forward to Leading Athena High School and being part of a larger system within Greece Central one that looks for constant Improvement while exploring ways to make our
018school campuses a positive place for all stakeholders outside of work Jason is a proud father and husband he enjoys spending time with his family and going to support them in their activities outside of the school day Jason's leadership style is through the lens of a parent when working with students and staff he strives to make the school experience a standard that he would want his own children to be part of and his wife to teach in congratulations Jason Mr ferson you're not going to get away without pictures so we got to do a picture with superintendent smallen Deputy Fleming and assistant superintendent zff I'm getting out of the way [Applause] all right next I would like to welcome our new principal of Patty Hill Elementary School Shaina Valerio Shaya received her bachelor's degree in elementary
019education from Robert Morris University in Pittsburgh PA she earned her first master's degree in literacy from Nazareth College and earned her educational leadership degree from the Rochester City school districts Rock urban legend excuse me rock Urban Leadership program through Bank Street College this unique leadership program was designed to build equity center transformational leaders Shaina began her career in the Rochester City School District as an elementary school teacher teaching grades 1 2 third and fourth she then became an instructional coach in math and reading interventionist Shaya joined the gree Central School District in 2021 as an assistant principal at Autumn Lane and last year became the acting principal shaina's favorite part of her job is the relationships that she has built with the staff students and families in the Greece Community she also cherishes the time
020she spent working alongside principal Mr Michael Ferris in which she learned and grew as a leader Shaya is honored to build on the tradition of academic Excellence at Patty Hill and looks forward to continuing the great work already in progress developing our Learners into leaders Shaina is deeply committed to fostering strong relationships with students staff and families she is honored to be the newest Patty Hill Bulldog Shaya grew up in Greece and lives in Chilai with her husband James and two children Jimmy N9 and Maria 6 she played division one soccer in college and now enjoys watching her children's sporting events and musical concerts Shaya loves to cook and to spend time with her big Italian family congratulations Shaya conratulations picture time Flagler you're it up [Applause] yep family sorry I forgot the whole family
021Fulkerson threw me off with no family here bring them all up everybody yo absolutely he loves me way [Applause] all right and last this evening please welcome our new assistant director of student services Kate d gorio Kate earned her undergraduate degree from Nazareth College before pursuing her master of social work from the University of Buffalo and a certificate of advanced study in K12 leadership from the University of Rochester her experience spans a range of settings including a day treatment program inhome supports a mental health outpatient clinic in a psychiatric emergency room Kate was employed at Hillside Family of agencies in the unity University of Rochester prior to joining Greece Central in 2015 Kate's favorite part of the job is building relationships with students and colleagues and combining mental health and educational interventions to empower students
022to reach their potential she enjoys working with others to identify innovative solutions to help support Student Success and witnessing individual and team growth Kate is looking forward to collaborating with others to identify and Implement best practices that will reduce barriers to Student Success outside of work Kate enjoys spending time with family and friends and being active Outdoors she enjoys gardening cooking meals and canning the vegetables grown and using her artistic side in various home projects she is excited to begin this new role supporting the multitude of individuals and departments that Encompass student services congratulations [Applause] Kate yep picture time effs you know so that's where you family family [Applause] congratulations to all our new hires in their new positions moving on to tenure 2.02 can i s move that to the table please moved by
023Mr stencil second by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on this one sing none all those in favor that passes nine to zero moving on to GTA Mo MOA additional FTE Can I some move that to the table please moved by Mr Butler seconded by Mr Maloney any comments questions concerns on that sing on all those in favor that passes 9 to Z moving on to separation agreement 2.04 can I move that to the table move by Miss Mo seconded by vice president farmer any comments questions concerns on this seeing none our whole audience is leaving separation yeah separation it's over um all those in favor that passes 9 to zero and moving on to the Frontline individual contract can I saw move that to the table please move by Mr czel second by Mr
024Farah any comments questions concerns on that seeing none all those in favor that oh all right before we vote sorry Mr Maloney is is this a one-year agreement or is this a a total agreement this contract one year it's just one year okay any other questions all right with that all those in favor that passes 9 to Zer moving on to presentations 4.01 superintendent entry plan superintendent small good evening so um I know the board had uh had an opportunity to hear my entry plan but I wanted to have the opportunity to share with public today so I apologize that you have to hear it twice it's a bridge version of it um so I like to to start by um sharing with everybody the honor it is to stand before you today as we
025embark on this exciting journey together since Jo Greece uh Central School District in 2005 I've had the priv privilege of serving this community in various roles today my commitment remains rooted in fostering trust collaboration and transparency this entry plan which I'll share with you today is is designed to guide my first six months in this role it focuses on understanding the strengths the challenges and the opportunities within our district while engaging with all stakeholders board members students staff families and the wider Community to ensure we align our efforts with the goals of our reach 2027 strategic plan my entry plan is structured into three distinct phases to ensure a thorough and thoughtful transition it's designed to provide a clear road map for my first six months as superintendent focusing on collaboration understanding and planning phase
026one uh the listening phase is committed to listening and FOC and focuses on building or strengthening relationships and trust with the Board of Education staff students families and the community phase two or the learn phase I will continue to engage with stakeholders to deepen my understanding of the dist District strength strengths and challenges as we begin to synthesize feedback and identify priorities to align with the district's reach 2027 strategic plan and finally phase three the lead phase will be developed will be the development of a comprehensive action plan to guide the 2025 26 school year the plan will be collaborative data driven and aligned with stakeholder feedback My Hope Is that this plan reflects my commitment to listening learning and leading with transparency it ensures our path forward is rooted in shared values and aspirations
027I identified four goals for my for my transition into superintendent the first develop a trusting collaborative and transparent relationship with the Board of Education I believe building trust with the board is foundational to Effective Government and Leadership transparency will be key as we work together to prioritize the district's needs and make informed decisions next fostering and strengthening positive relationships across the district this includes students teachers staff administrators parents and community members strong relationships are the Cornerstone of a healthy and thriving School District next understand the district strengths challenges and opportunities a comprehensive understanding of what makes Greece unique is vital to building on its successes in addressing addressing its challenges this goal ensures that decisions are data driven and Teller to the district's specific needs and finally gain insight into safety climate and District needs
028evaluating safety and climate is critical to fostering an environment where students and Staff feel secure and supported this goal ties directly into creating systems that support the entire district and help Drive long-term success these goals reflect my commitment to listening learning and leading in collaboration with all stakeholders to create a positive and sustainable future for the Greece Central School District so over the next six months I plan on visiting every school and apartment this these visits will provide me a deeper understanding of the culture the strengths and challenges of each school and Department I will engage directly with key stakeholders through individual or small group discussions including students to hear their voices and understand their experiences with parents to gain insight into their priorities and their concerns and community members to foster a shared vision
029for the district's future I will actively engage with the community by attending school and District events Community meetings parent exchanges to strengthen ties and ensure open Communication open communication channels and finally we are in the process of finalizing a thought exchange survey to solicit input from a diverse range of stakeholders including the students staff parents and Community organizations this survey will go out to all stakeholders within the next couple weeks these actions are not just about gathering information it's about forming the Partnerships and building the trust that will help guide our work together in the months and years ahead and finally phase three the goal of phase three is creating a clear actionable plan to guide the district's work in the coming school year this phase represents the culmination of the listening learning and relationship
030building efforts of the first two phases together we will use this Foundation to create a brighter more Equitable future for the district any questions thank you superintendent SMY thank you before we go to our next presentation I just want to introduce a special guest we have here this evening um Regent hail from the State Board of Regents is here this evening thank you Regent Hil for attending moving on to 4.02 enl dual language presentation superintendent small I almost call you [Laughter] growman I'd like to call on Mrs sweep for this presentation thank you hi everyone um I'm Shauna sweet I am the director of the Department of multilingual education happy to be here to talk about our bilingual program and share some updates for this year um so firstly just going back to our commitment
031statement from our strategic plan and thinking about how bilingual education really connects with the work that we're doing in Greece um so we have made a commitment in this District to adopt curriculum that provides culturally authentic learning experiences that mirror students diverse identities and ways of understanding communicating demonstrating curiosity and knowledge um and we'll highlight a little bit about how the bilingual program um Works in service of this um so what's our evidence of success so we're really thinking about how are we tapping into our students assets such as sharing Traditions cultural assets with staff to support integration of these values in the curriculum as well as engaging in activities that improve School climate and culture for students of diverse backgrounds so this trajectory map might look familiar if you saw the presentation last year
032but just to get everybody on the same page I'll just uh go back in time and talk a little bit about the history of our bilingual program in Greece so we did have a dual language bilingual program in Greece from 2008 to 2017 um at the time it was a forward thinking um idea um and uh the program existed at English V in Lakeshore and at the time it was paused um due to the fact that signature schools were going away and um there was an idea that students were going to be placed in their home schools um fast forward to 2021 a new program proposal was put into place to reestablish the program with a gradual implementation um so our biliterate bilingual program advisory committee convened um convened in 2022 and um made a
033lot of recommendations regarding um program Logistics and curriculum so uh this year I'm proud to say we have our first year of implementation um so we have our first cohort of kindergarteners um who have begun class at uh English Village this fall um and the goal is to increase the program one grade level at a time So the plan is for next year there will be um two classes of kindergarten and two classes of first grade and so on to be scaling up um when one grade level per year so it's important to really think about who our students are here in Greece so um we have almost 20% of students in our district um and families are Hispanic and Latino um and that's how how they identify um so that's actually the highest subpopulation
034of ethnicity um after white which is 50% so we have a significant population of students um who are Hispanic and Latino so what do the regulations say about bilingual education so uh commissioner's regulation part 154 which guides um education for English language Learners um requires schools or districts to establish a new bilingual education program if 20 or more students um who are English language Learners speak the same language at the same grade level um and that's across the district so if we have 20 students in any grade level that speak the same language we are required by New York state to implement bilingual education um and I did link some some documents there um so where are we at in Greece so taking a look at our kindergarten subgroup which is where we've started our
035program we actually have 19 students um who are English language learners and speak Spanish at home so we didn't quite hit the 20 Mark but you know we have uh new students enrolling every day so we we could certainly hit 20 this year um but I think uh this is a great way to show uh how um our English language Learners who speak Spanish are spread across the grade levels um some grade levels have more than others um but it's important really to be thinking about the fact that we are right at the place where um New York state would require us to have bilingual education so what we are doing as a district is being proactive and trying to really think about quality implementation before something is um required of us so um and
036this is also a recommendation from the State Office of bilingual education and World languages that we are uh being Forward Thinking with our planning um so besides the fact that there are some requirements there are a lot of benefits to bilingual education um so the the benefits connect directly to our strategic plan by igniting learning cultivating trust and expanding opportunity so Studies have shown that students in bilingual programs perform better on reading and math assessments they developed greater understanding of language structures which is correlated to enhanced reading skills research has shown that schools that have implemented bilingual programs have created an Avenue for parents who are multilingual Learners primary advocates kits to engage in their children's education which leads to improved attitudes about learning and higher academic achievement so we are more culturally responsive by
037implementing bilingual education um and I'll share there's a link here that New York state has just put out this year some guiding principles in education for bilingual education so there's some briefs um along with a glossery and another thing I'm proud to share is that New York state was just highlighted um at a national level there was actually a national um bilingual education um uh guiding document that came out about two weeks ago and New York state was highlighted for um the way that we Implement bilingual education in the state so what does our model look like um so here in Greece we have a program model called dual language it's also called two-way by langual education so that means that there are students from two different language backgrounds who um part participate in the
038program together um so some students come from homes where they pre predominantly speak English or only English some students come from homes who maybe speak Spanish or a mix of Spanish and English and the goal is for all students to equally become bilingual biliterate by cultural all while while improving their academic achievement so uh these are what the students look like in our program this year uh this year we have 40 students who enrolled in the bilingual program at English Village across both kindergarten classes um so out of those 40 students 17 of them are students who use Spanish at home as a as primary or Heritage speaker so their parents identified on their home language survey that they they spoke Spanish and out of those 17 students 10 of them were identified as English
039language Learners so we have a nice represent presentation of students who primarily speak English at home um almost half the students have some Spanish at home and 10 of the students probably have stronger Spanish so they were identified as English language Learners so we have a nice mix of both and uh this is what a typical day looks like in our bilingual program so as you can see um one of the theories of bilingual education is to strategically use colors um uh to identify the work that you're doing and different languages so blue is for English red is for Spanish and purple is for things that are done in both languages um so we have two classrooms of bilingual education of bi of the bilingual program so um for example on one day um the
040class will have um the first part of their Arc Core lesson in Spanish um followed by a little bit of math and then they have the second part of their art Core lesson in English um they have specials and then they do reading lab or what I need win time based on what their languages are um and uh what they need the most so it's a mix of both languages there um and then the other class is getting the same thing in the alternate language and they switch um on a daily basis um and one thing I'd like to share is that this um particular schedule was developed in conjunction so we've worked very closely with American reading company um to develop this uh schedule based on um what um American reading company supports and
041um their expertise for bilingual education oh sorry I may not be able to watch it oh my apologies well I know I I'm not really quite sure how that happened well it looks like it's there um so I I can share the link and in fact I would love to be able to share this um with other people so we actually have a YouTube page at for bi for the bilingual program so um we have a a language and culture coach uh who supports um Spanish instruction she works side by side with both teachers including um the Spanish language arts teacher and she uh provides a lot of support to the bilingual program so the the video that I was hoping to show you um actually highlights um a lesson where the students are um
042completely engaged in Spanish and even though more than half of them are um are P predominantly uh English speakers at home they're able to pick up the Spanish within a couple of months of school so she's giving them directions based on animal sounds and they're able to do it and what's exciting about this is that the way language is learned uh students are anybody actually learns language receptively first so they take in what they hear and uh in this video which I'm hoping to show you soon um you will be able to see the students really um engaging in Spanish like right away and it's the opposite uh for English um following uh another thing on the YouTube channel uh is um direct uh instruction with how to support Spanish literacy at home and information
043to parents that's shared in Spanish so um it's really neat and I'll make sure that you all have access to that link so what's new what do we have going on this year um we have been provided with funding for an instructional leadership Network so every department has um a a group of instructional leaders who meet with district office staff and be able to plan and support instruction so we've been able to launch that this year to really get a handle on um communication and planning for the bilingual program um as I mentioned we have regular coaching um American reading company has provided us with a bilingual coach who actually is a former principal of a dual language school she's incredibly knowledgeable and we're really benefiting from the regular meetings with her um we have
044a toosa so a teacher on special assignment to support World languages and bilingual education and the great part about this is that she support Spanish at the very top levels so really thinking about the trajectory of our students from kindergarten all the way to 12th grade and how they're going to be able to develop their bilingualism throughout again I mentioned we have a language and culture coach um who supports Spanish language arts and family engagement um we have some assessments um so some of you might be familiar with the NCIS lot which is a test for English language Learners well the pre-loss is sort of a simp similar tests for early childhood and it enables us to get um foundational literacy and oral language assessments for all students in both languages so we can monitor
045their growth um we have a Latino family program that right now is targeting kindergarten um but we'll begin in the spring with our pre students for uh Recruitment and that meets um on Thursday evening so that's a really great event and um another really exciting thing is our program commitments so our bilingual advisory committee had worked for a whole year to collaborate and co-develop our commitments for bilingual education um we actually use the Greece strategic plan The Guiding principles for dual language and combine them with the feedback from the school and the district to develop our commitments um and so our commitment one is the value of bilingualism biliteracy and biculturalism commitment two is expectation for student achievement and preparation for the future and commitment three is um being Community oriented and involving the community
046parents and families in the program um and Laurel's office was able to work with us to um create these beautiful Graphics so I'm happy to share that we'll be able to uh have that uh poster size up at English Village in both languages uh this week so I know the the print Shop's working on them right now so what's next um so what next is really um planning for implementation for first grade um Jason Rosa I and myself Ashley I give a shout out to my team we've been working on this already with thinking about what the scale up will look like next year um our bilingual program advisory committee will be meeting soon to really talk about some of the planning and take a look at some of the feedback and and um things
047that we want to look forward to next year recruitment so for our incoming kindergarten as I mentioned we'll offer our Latino family program um in the spring um and really thinking about how the loss links which is that pre-loss assessment scaled up because we want to be able to measure students literacy and language skills in English and Spanish um every year um hopefully by literacy pathway Awards so students are able to be encouraged and um feel the value of becoming biliterate um from kindergarten all the way through 12th grade and uh working on school visits so we're also um uh working a lot with districts from around the state Buffalo um a lot from the Hudson Valley and Long Island so we're planning some interschool visits whether they be virtual or in person is yet
048to come so uh so that's a lot of information I'm sure um I'd be happy to answer any questions if there's anything that I can address right now Mr thank you for the presentation um I am fortunate to have English Villages my one of my liaison schools and so principal Lewis gave me a tour and I got to go into those two kindergarten classes and it was so cool to to see these students learning in Spanish and in English so real kudos to the team that are doing that work every single day and uh to the um to the district for investing in this it's a real point of Pride for us I think as a district one of the things I'm interested in is the um the increased achievement that that's talked about is
049one of the justifications for for doing this and and I know we we're only uh a year into this uh iteration again and I just wonder if you could share a little bit of what you'll be on the lookout for to demonstrate some uh increased achievement by students through participation in in a bilingual program yeah um so we do have multiple data points um so just like um everybody's familiar with the earla um we have the earla that is being done in the bilingual program there also the anal which is the Spanish version of the ear that's done at different times um so January is a benchmark month for that and for I ready so our students are able to access all of the math materials including assessments um in Spanish so we'll be looking
050forward to those benchmarks um sometime after this month I'll be working with Todd on that um we also have the pre-law so that's like the oral language and the pre-literacy um so we're planning to do another assessment in the spring just to measure students language growth of how they're able to um communicate in both languages um but you know research shows with bilingual education that you know overall bilingual education has a positive impact but typical um students accelerate um at third grade and Beyond so that's when you really start to see that the more time on language instruction that metacognition or that deep understanding of language typically happens um third grade and Beyond I know last year when I presented I showed a chart that was like 30 years of bilingual education research and I
051can share that again but it's third grade where you really start to see the impacts that's great thank you so we'll hope to see a a bump a couple years from now with this cohort then absolutely and in the meantime we'll have the regular Benchmark data thank you very much yeah Mr bagaro thank you shaa nice to see you here again um I want to just dig into on page 11 you have the the colorcoded chart and I just want to dig into that a little bit and understand it a little bit better so there's kind of a back and forth or maybe a in tandem interplay between English and Spanish going on uh oral languages the the languages that we speak and that we learn Ty as children we learn them before we go
052to school typically it's called biologically primary and it's different than learning a written language so and I know we've we've struggled with that for quite a while in not just in our district but all all over uh so we're we have different rules uh phological rules for example between English and Spanish are we trying to teach both at the same time or are we like with our core is that are we using like a a two language version of it yeah so how does all that work yeah so that's a simple answer yeah um one thing I can say is Ark core as a curriculum is incredibly beneficial for the bilingual program so way back in 2007 we had an English curriculum and were recreating everything right for Spanish um Ark core it's kind of
053the Envy of the other bilingual program administrators that we use that because the entire curriculum is available in both languages so you see students um you know they're actually um engaging in the same text in both languages um and in according to the phonics like you mentioned or the pheic awareness um arore promotes and supports us teaching language how it's learned learned um naturally so in Spanish for example um you know you start with the the vowels where English you start with the consonants and all of that is very well um mapped out and they've even identified where there's some overlaps so for example um the letter B you don't really have to teach that um very you don't have to focus on that very deeply in both languages because the sound is the same
054in both languages um where I don't know the letter y is different in both languages so strategically there's a plan for how that will be covered in English and how that will be covered in Spanish language arts so it's not we're not just expecting kids to absorb this we are directly teaching them showing them how to do it in English and in Spanish and I'm speaking particularly of the literate Parts the writing and the reading yes exactly any other questions Mr Bago so then in math and that's a third language now you've got Reading Writing or uh English Spanish and math and um and it's more conceptual and it's and we're able to and there too our kids have struggled um but we're able to do that integrate two different languages simultaneously yeah and the
055math classes um you I I showed you it was purple um initially we were going to have a very clear definition of uh languages for math but um what we ended up doing is what works best for the teachers and the students um I think the the main lessons are primarily in English and they break off so they start whole group they're kindergarteners they work into small group so this group of students who really needs this type of foundational math um maybe they primarily Spanish speakers at home so they'll get some targeted interventions with the bilingual Spanish teacher um on exactly what they need so they they try they start out whole group working together and then they're trying to now divide students based on what they need specific to math so I'm hearing that
056we have direct supports in their maybe primary language yes okay yes great thank you any other questions thank you shaa okay thank you very much 4.03 Reserve funds presentation superintendent smallie I'm going to ask Romeo kly to come up and present thank you all right well thank you everyone um tonight we're going to speak a little bit a lot of bit uh regarding our Reserve funds so um what we're going to review tonight is what our Reserve fund balance was was as of June of 24 uh when we ended the 23 24 School year and I will say up front we've continued to have a strong Reserve balance and a strong Reserve uh contribution as of last year um primarily due to a couple things that I want to just keep pointing out one is
057with the state implementing the foundation Aid formula implementation we received base Foundation Aid significant increases over a three-year period and two at the same time that that came out we received Federal grant dollars ARP funds and some other uh federal dollars that we spent a lot of time talking about and figuring out how we can strategically use those funds to one fully utilize the funds and two offset some of the expenses where we could and properly do it and where it's eligible from other um from our operating budget so fortunately or unfortunately depending on how I guess you could look at this um it's it's resulted in further additions into our Reserve plans that we want to our Reserve funds which we want to review with everybody uh this evening so use of the reserves
058uh basically uh it's a mechanism for legally saving funds for future use some of the ways that we can use uh the funds are listed here reducing long-term borrowing costs we basically do that when we do our capital projects or bus purchases we pull from the capital or bus Reserve ve in order to pay for the local share so that the residents don't have to have additional uh uh expenses added to the levy we also use it for any fluctuation tax rate midyear budget cuts or another big uh uh ADV uh Advantage is for emergency projects although the finance office is responsible for the day-to-day operations uh of the finances of the district the board of education is responsible for appropriately managing the financial affairs so that's why we come to the board each year
059and throughout the year and try to explain where we are and why we're doing things only the board has the authority to transfer uh to voter or board approved reserves and only the board can appropriate fund balance for the tax levy for the ensuing year and then we try to make that clear with the board when we come back in August each year with our fund balance recommendations on where we'd like to place the fund but again it's up to the board uh to make those decisions so Reserve balances also have uh this might not be something that everybody knows but they do have an impact on uh a direct impact on our borrowing in this District we have capital projects going on every year uh been here 15 years our senior architect been here
06020 there's capital projects every year we issued that every year we pay off debt every year one of the critical factors is our Moody score and a favorable and a positive or a strong Moody's rating gives us better rates and what you see on the district are some of the positive comments on the slide is some of the positive comments that were in the Moody's report from September of 23 and then some of the credit straints that they also list in that same report so why does that make a difference so I asked our financial consultants can you give me a couple kind of quantify what this means and I was able to get that so back in June of 21 we issued $26 million in serial bonds our credit rating is aa3 which is
061a good credit rating and what they did is they compared to to similar size Bonds in June of 21 with a lower with an entity that had a lower credit rating of an A and see what that difference was was for that $26 million Bond there was about a 15 point a 15 basis point difference in the rate well what does that translate to it translate that we were able to get roughly the same funds for 355,000 Less in interest costs over the life of those serial bonds than somebody who was rated an a because we're in aa3 in June of 22 we issued another $31 million we were able again rating that against a a credit rating of a versus our a A3 um difference was about 21 basis points which translates into about
062$550,000 Less in interest cost to us because of our credit rating which directly is a result of what we have not only in our Reserve but how we manage things as well that's just over $900,000 in interest costs for those two issuances we have a $17 million serial Bond planned for June of 25 and we're expecting that we're going to get favorable rates as well um so it makes a difference it's just not an item that is uh visible to everybody out there but it does make a difference for us uh in the finance office the next slide here just shows you where we are as an aa3 and where that compares non-investment grades are on the bottom you move up the chain you got lower medium upper medium we're in the high GR range
063you can see a couple notes there New York state is rated in aa1 um we're rated In aa3 Mono County is in A1 um city of Rochester is in A1 Town of Greece is in A2 aa2 I'm sorry so we're in good company and we're in a good uh place with our uh rating it's very strong and it's been there and we would like to keep it there um going forward so as we look at our funds last this current year June 24 to June of 23 um you'll see uh the balances and all the different reserves most have gone up some have come down at the bottom line our Reserve uh balance when you include not only the restricted reserves which are above but when you include the appropriated fund balance and the undesignated
064fund balance we're up about $28 million um in our Reserve fund funds and then as we look at some of the other non-general fund I look at Food Service Food Services fund balance went down by about $181,000 um we were hoping that that would come down uh further but they did spend roughly a million three but because we're all Community eligible programs for food service and the state was making up the difference between the federal rate and what we would normally get uh it closed that Gap so we got increased revenues on top of our increased expenditures so our net change in fund balance was only $181,000 but it's uh um it's still a balance of 2.8 now in the past if you recall in some of the management letters um our food service department
065would get cited for having too much fund balance as relation to uh the number of months for operating expenses and then we would devise a plan to spend that down the state finally has changed that from a three-month balance to a six-month balance so that helps us even at a balance of 2.8 we aren't anywhere near being over the compliance threshold any longer because they finally made the change from three months to six months of of expenses in the capital fund uh for 24 you see some negative numbers there it's only due to timing when we issue our bonds in July July of the or June of this year uh those will those negatives will go away those balances are there because they're only temporary financing mechanisms and for Debt Service um went down about
066$650,000 we use that Debt Service fund to keep our tax exclusion at that $2.7 million level when we do the tax cap calculations looking at our appropriated fund balance uh this is the money that we would take out of the current year Surplus and apply it towards the next year's Levy you can see in past years uh we've done that to the tune of s or $6 million starting in 22 and we started to get the foundation Aid increase the first thing we started to do was to not appropriate fund balance for the tax levy any longer so in 2223 and 2324 um we were at Z you see 2425 we did appropriate $2 million but it wasn't to apply towards the tax levy that was to do the playgrounds in the outdoor uh Pavilion
067so we're still basically at zero for the tax levy which is a good place to be unappropriated fund balance history you can see five years here uh this is the rainy day fund it's capped at 4% we're at 4% uh each year um for the last 10 or 12 years as we look more at our Reserve funds I want spend a ton of time on this but workers comp we're self-insured it's a flex I've talked about this before it's a flexible Reserve so we have intentionally placed funds in here um similar to our unemployment Reserve because it gives us the most opportunity to move those funds to another Reserve or to use them in a different man manner than any of the other reserves and I'll speak to that uh closer to the end of
068the presentation but we have a balance of 27.8 million um and if we wanted to transfer These funds we would just need board authorization to do it and we need to do it within 60 days of the end of the school year so we have some flexibility there similarly our unemployment Reserve has a a a good balance of 20 21.6 million in it uh there's no limit on this Reserve similar to the workers comp Reserve um it's flexible similar to the workers comp reserve and again 60-day rule to move those funds as we need them our insurance Reserve um this is to cover insure uh student claims uh deductibles um and we put money in here to cover ourselves adequately for any uh child victim act claims that may arise uh on us and for
069any cyber breaches uh that we may see um one item that I I I've noted is uh reading uh some some literature o over the last few months that in uh 2024 the average breach for cyber cost entities about $5 million as a result of being breached on Cyber so we wanted to make sure that although we do have some insurance coverage with nicer or insurance broker we have some additional funds there to cover things uh for at least a breach um should we need it so that's why we've beefed up this Reserve to $9 million and if we don't need it going forward we can always do something with it uh with the approval of the board our tax seary uh Reserve um this is this is the reserve uh that we established um
070in order to pay for those claims were uh organizations um um companies um are challenging their Assessments in the amount of taxes they pay they file a tax seary claim against the district um we follow a fixed methodology which we've been using for the last 15 or 20 years this seems to work out well for us uh the balance in this account has been stable we believe it's adequate and just as a note uh the B the trend has been coming down since about 21 2020 um last year we had 28 owner claims um compared to 35 the year before uh so in 23 the number came down and in previous year year ago the claims our exposure was about 7.1 million now it's about 5.2 million so we're seeing a downward trend on that
071and that's why you see the balance go down uh to 1.8 two years ago it was about 3. 2 million our liability Reserve uh is limited to 3% of our budget which is somewhere around $9.2 million we're currently at about 8.7 um which is about 94 95% of the limit and um this is used to cover liability losses when the court orders it or to help us with any 302a or section 75 claims or e r s Reserve is the Employee Retirement System Reserve um we have a balance of $ 29.3 million there uh the current rate for this current year is about uh 15.2% we're expecting that to go to about 16.5% for 2526 our ERS bill is about four to $4.5 million a year this covers about six or seven years of paying
072that bill if we needed to do it in the operating budget we could draw funds from here and use it in the operating budget or if we need it in the teacher Reserve we can move monies between this and the teacher Reserve as well in the teacher Reserve we have about 9.8 million dollar um this is kept at a contribution of 2% a year and um to a Max of 10% of the administrative certified administrative salaries from the previous year we're pretty much at the cap so for 2425 you will probably not see any requests to put any funds into the TRS um Reserve because we're at the uh cap our building Reserve this is our Capital fund Reserve uh you'll see the balance there is $10.7 million most of that will go away 10.3
073million will go away or 10.4 million will go away with level up when we move those funds out of the reserve and into the capital budget to pay the local share of the recent uh level up uh Capital project we are going to need a new capital building Reserve established um and whether we do that for this upcoming May or um the following May uh we still have to make some decisions on but I bring that up because I will touch on that uh near closer to the end of the presentation similarly we have a bus Reserve we use this Reserve to pay that local share of bus purchases um so if we when we we get five years state aid back on our bus purchases uh at about 80% it leaves a gap we
074use this to fill that Gap so that there's no local expense added to the levy and again this Reserve is down to 4.7 million it is maxed out we're going to need another bus Reserve established as well and then in total uh just summing it all up over the time period on the on the slide uh We've deposited about $170 million $171 million into all these reserves um we've earned interest to to about $6 million we've pulled out or utilized 53 million which leaves us a balance of about 123 I'm sorry 123.5 million in our reserves are our restricted Reserves at this point in time and then finally this is just similar to the one of the first slides but it shows you if you're looking at our financial statements and you're looking to see
075where all these are they're listed in the items in blue a total up to the balance of the $23.5 million so at this point I did want to add a couple notes that I didn't put in the presentation but I wasn't sure how to do this yet but I'll speak to it uh for a couple minutes um one point is um although the balances have been increasing over the years we are not out of compliance with any of the reserves as far as legal legal compliance goes those reserves that have no limits on them we have increased those that have caps we have stopped and those that were approaching any type of cap it's on our radar and we we'll make sure that that gets capped out and stopped and that's probably coming up at
076the end of the current year um we know our workers comp reserve and our unemployment Reserve have uh higher balances than some of the other reserves but again that was intentional because it's flexible and we've got some thoughts on how to move those funds and where we're going to need I'll speak to that in a minute um our bus reserve and our building capital reserve they're low compared to what we need we're going to be you know we've probably got uh three or four years of bus Reserve right now in left and maybe in zero in capital um and as we develop those plans we'll bring them back to the board in a more formal basis so just some thoughts on what we're thinking we want to do with the reserves one as we build
077out our budgets if we need to pull reserves into the operating budget we can go to the board request trans transfers from the reserves to be used in our 25 26 26 27 future budgets as we need that's always going to be the case couple other things that we're thinking um and probably likely that we'll end up having to do one is the capital reserve the capital building Reserve we don't we don't have a balance in there we need a new Reserve that is going to require voter approval to establish the reserve and there are two things we got to start we we are we have been considering for Capital um one is the remaining work in the buildings and throughout the district after level up Capital project so we did a walkth through of
078all the buildings there was like $125 million worth the work identified in the buildings plus we had the building condition survey to have to deal with and level up we had to take a mix of both of those and we couldn't do a lot of the work that needed to be done in the buildings we are still having that work cost it out and we'll know how much we're going to estimate what that is and we'll need a local share contribution into that Reserve in order to make it a zero additional cost to our residents what complicates it a little bit is the possibility of the electric bus mandate so if we have to start moving forward with the electric bus mandate it's going to going to require two pieces purchase of the buses and
079infrastructure work that will be considered Capital work when we go out to Residents to ask for the establishment of this new capital reserve we still got to decide how much is going to be for Building how much could be for uh infrastructure for electric buses but the electric bus piece we still don't really know how that's going to work so I'm not sure where to do that but assuming that was approved we would then take and come back to the board and ask from a transfer from the workers comp Andor the unemployment Reserve right into that newly established capital building and EV bus Reserve to make sure the funds are there to make it zero cost as we go forward whenever we have to start to do that okay second and that could be in
080our in in in our planning um we're thinking if we have to do a if we're going to do a$ million Capital project for the buildings plus BCS work that we're going to have to do for next year we may need 2530 million to cover the local share there and we may need $20 million to cover the start of the electric bus so we may come out with $445 million reserve and then transfer a good portion of those funds out of unemployment in workers comp get it into that Reserve so we know when we have to start moving on it we've got our residents covered for the local share we don't need to add it to the tax base similarly for the electric bus we need to establish a bus Reserve but our new bus
081Reserve we can't buy gas buses after January of 2027 and we've planned out that we're going to hold off on any bus purchases for one or two years but if things don't change at the state level and they still hold us to the January 1st of 2027 we can go probably a year and a half but then we're going to need to start thinking about buying an electric bus we're going to need that local share in the reserve so it doesn't cost our residents any local piece or additional burth on the tax levy at least in the short term and the problem is or the caution is we don't know where this electric bus mandate is going to go as of today um some will say that it will change others will say you got
082to do it um there's other issues in between both those and it's hard for a district our size to make any movement on that um and I would like to really kind of to hold back until I don't want to start moving down the road until we know what the road is I don't want to be a third quarter or third down the road and it changes and then we've kind of um caused a problem for ourselves so again I know there's a lot in the reserves but those are the three items that we're going to work on figuring out how to use a good portion of that balance will will bring down it'll keep the balance the same but unemployment and workers Comm will be significantly lower than what it currently is hope that
083helps Mr baller thank you thanks Romeo for uh uh the presentation and thanks for excuse me the Insight around feeling like we're not overfunded in a lot of areas a couple that you mentioned where we're a little bit light um and that leads me to one of my questions which uh is I'm sure something you can explain to me but you mentioned that we have a building Reserve fund now that's going to be depleted and then we're going to have to vote have to ask the voters to create a new building Reserve fund can't we just fund the existing building reserve it has current when we um when we did the the current Reserve that's being depleted it had um a dollar cap and or a time limit okay and we've ex we we hit
084the cap okay so usually we'll set it up to say $10 million or 10 or 15 years well we didn't have to wait 10 or 15 years but we hit the 10 million in deposits okay we'll take that into account when we do that's why I think the next Reserve if it's got to cover building BCS classroom changes and electric bus infrastructure it's going to need to be a bigger reserve for a longer period of time in case things don't work out but you're always going to be capped on dollar limit or time Li limit okay on on the bus and the capital um we were Max at one or the other okay and I do have one more question no we'll go to Mr Maloney first of all thank you for making us fiscally
085responsible second of all um our credit rating is a A3 correct why doesn't that move to a A2 or a a A1 because I know we're never late with a payment and we haven't been for we have uh asked that question and in order to get to a double A2 we need a lot more in reserve lot more really is really what they want so you're saying the the reserves in the in the city and the county are are that much better they know how we budget they know how we manage and we're conservative on things but uh in their reports they will say uh here's the things that could make your credit rating go up and here's things that could make your credit rating go down and the big one that makes your credit
086go rating go up is increased Reserve funds and on the other side and we've had this discussion on our team uh a few times I'm not even sure I want to go to aa2 even if we had it because you'll get there for a minute you'll come down before their threshold and now it would look like a downgrade to the district from aa2 to aa3 I'd rather stay where we are and be stable and know that the credit rating because whether you're aa2 or aa3 you're still very strong you're still very good but it will appear to you you'll see a nice uptick for we got upgraded to an 882 and five months later we had to use the money to do our electric bus infrastructure work we just now depleted one of the reserves
087downgrade in place for well thank you for explaining that other questions like so I took Romeo's college class in finance this year and um I've listened to your presentations for going on three years now and I understood this one so I really appreciate it thank spil so if the so you talked about maybe having to transfer up to $45 million uh out of the uh workers comp and employee uh um Reserve funds you mentioned that we feel like we're in a pretty good spot with most of our funds now if we were to make that size transfer would we be in a riskier in a risky position would you say or those for those other two funds know we'd still be sufficiently funded yes okay thank you another question and and I will say when
088we started down this road actually before we knew just before we knew what was coming in terms of the implementation of the formula and uh we didn't know so much how much grant money were we did set our team set with uh our external Auditors and like how do we do that we know we're going to have access at the end of the year what do we do and how do we mechanically make sure that we can move it around as we need so we had had that discussion several times and then we' stayed to that plan and that's why you've been seeing larger deposits to unemployment in workers comp if we put them in another Reserve even if there's no limit it's restricted and you can't move the money out of those reserves like
089you can with workers comp and unemployment so it's been intentional and strategic and I just have um a question in regards to the reserve funds we talk about the great unknown with the electric buses the cost of the buses we know but we don't know what the infrastructure costs are going to be what risk I mean obviously we're going to need a significant amount of money to fund the buses and the infrastructure how what's the risk to the taxpayers depleting those reserves to fund the electric buses because the electric bus mandate what's that going to look like for our taxpayers and are we at risk of jeopardizing program other things in the district by taking that reserve and and having to dump it into the infrastructure for the electric bus so we have thought about
090that because once you um once you move it into the reserve that's a really restricted Reserve you can't get it out without using it for its an intended purpose so that's part of the reason we've been thinking about a capital reserve with a larger amount than just for the building because then if we figure a two-part answer so if we figured the building local share would be 25 in the infrastructure would be 20 if we did them in separate reserves and the one came in higher or lower than the other we'd be stuck got but by putting them in one Reserve if the building Reserve really needed 30 we only that only leaves us 15 for the bus infrastructure that'd be fine because it's all coming out of one pot of money but I guess
091it gives us that flexibility now putting the money in there that we may need for program and operating budget similar to the bus numbers my guts is we've always been you know I think the sweet spot for uh the reserves is probably 6570 million even by moving those funds out we're still okay we're still going to be fine with plenty um plenty funds to use in the operating budget if we need it and I mean with with the delay we're facing with the infrastructure cost coming back to the district District what is in that you just explained if we spend 25 on the capital and we have 15 for the infrastructure and the infrastructure comes in at 20 that would have to go to the taxpayers we would probably cut back the scope okay so
092so let's assume we said 25 for the building 20 million for infrastructure for 20 buses and then we budgeted put money away in the bus reserve for 20 buck bues but the building work came in at 30 instead of 20 buses we would just go 15 okay as our first phase and then we would figure it out what we're going to do going forward so we have that flexibility to adjust either the reserve or the scope of work but if we put them in separates it becomes more difficult to to manage thank you all right moving on thank you thank you moving on 6.01 can I ass move the change orders to the table please move by Mr stel second by Miss like any comments questions or concerns on the change orders uh the only
093thing I will say is the change orders amount to $59,800 with that all those in favor that passes 9 to Z moving on to 6.02 approval of the 2425 property tax collection status can I move that to the table please move by miss m second by vice president farmer any comments questions concerns on that sing none all in favor that passes moving on at 6.03 the acceptance of the 2324 internal audit risk assessment report can I son move that to the table please by Mr L seconded by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on that sing that all those in favor that passes 9 to Z moving on to 6.04 the Seeker for the transportation Warehouse renovation project can I ass you move that to the table please move by Mr Butler second by Mr
094stencil any comments questions concerns on that sing then all is in favor that passes N9 to zero moving on to the capital project Bond can I move that to the table please 6.05 moved by Mr bagorio second by Mr Butler any comments questions concerns on that seeing none all those in favor that passes N9 to zero moving on to to the discontinuation of standardization of inter Scholastic sports uniforms can I sun move that to the table please moveed by vice president farmer second by Mr Maloney any comments questions concerns on that do you have a question sure yeah absolutely Miss Farah I just a quick question I had asked I just kind of wanted to get an understanding um and those that don't really know what this was um or what we're moving into can
095I just wanted a little understanding and we talked about this um superintendent smallen can you just give a brief um synopsis of what this would inail or what what's going to change so just a little history on that um years ago I don't have exactly the date but years ago um there was some very clear inequity when it came to our uniforms across schools um and so at that point um some of the schools that that didn't have the funds to purchase of nicer uniforms uh we what we did in the past was we standardized it so that it was Equitable across the school so that it was the same brand that they all used and so that the same quality same type of uniform since that time we have corrected that that um inequity
096across the schools and what this and now what the what the problem now is with the standardization is it limits the bidding so now um when it standardized the the bidding process now limits the competing companies putting forth their bid that so it lessens the variety of quality um and the different U organizations or companies that would put in that bed that would allow for I guess more competition for that so right now it's limiting some of the schools that would like to go out and get a variety of offers quality coming in and so now since we have the is across the schools removing that would allow for more competition really Mr and I think the other thing it did is in the past whether we were buying baseball uniforms or football uniforms or
097lacrosse uniforms because it was standardized it all had to come from the same place well now I think you've got we like the football uniforms from this place but the lacrosse uniforms are much better with another organization but the standardization is limiting us from doing that so current bid put out specifications for all types which now we've got a variety of firms organizations that meet the specs and we're not tied to one unit or one organization or one brand for football lacrosse baseball soccer we have more flexibility but the standard has already been risen for what Jer had said good it would be nice to get rid of those scratchy uniforms that we used to have back 20 years ago all right any other questions that all those in favor that passes 9 to zero
098moving on to budget and revenue status report for October 31st 2024 that's for information only does anybody have any questions moving on 7.02 anticipated bids does anybody have any questions on that it's written information only all right moving on to consent agenda can I you move the consent agenda the tail please move by Mr stle second by Mr Maloney and comments questions concerns on the consent agenda singing on all those in favor that passes 9 to Zer moving on to 11.01 the C certified Capital project vote results can I have somebody move that to the table please move by Miss mure seconded by vice president farmer any comments questions concerns on that sing that alls in favor that passes 9 to zero moving on to the regionalization resolution be resol Board of Education degree Central
099School District approves the district to participate in regionalization plan can I sudden move that to the table please move by vice president farmer seconded by miss mure any comments questions concerns on this Mr B Orel yes thank you um I have quite a few concerns that I have conveyed to the board um in over the course of the past two or three months um I think I'll just give a a short history uh of what we what we know the um uh the State education department issued an emergency regulation uh I believe it was in September that was not uh the emergency wasn't very well defined citing basically the general welfare but the impact of of applying the rule as an emergency rule meant that the rule was implemented immediately um to be followed with
100some comment periods um the the rule is in effect it's been contested and and um districts across New York State have raised a lot of concerns about it uh partly about the vess of the rule well I maybe that's not correct the rule is very uh very direct in stating that there is a shift there would be a shift of authority from the statutory authority of school boards under New York state law to the supervisory District authorities under the um the superintendent uh the bosei superintendent and that's a significant shift that uh is of of significant concern relating to local control of our of our individual excuse me of our individual districts there's been a lot of concern raised superintendents our our local superintendent uh had a uh a discussion through the Mono County school
101board's Association that uh he acknowledged yeah there's a lot of uh uncertainty about what this really means I know that's not what they really mean but the problem is the language of the regulation departs from what everyone including the commissioner of education and and uh even the governor of New York say what it really means the intent they say is to have a conversation a voluntary conversation among our districts to find ways to rationalize resources and yet the language is very very clearly you shall the commissioner has discretion to impose un named criteria so there are there are a lot of concerns that emanate from this the idea in my in my thinking is really good as a voluntary participation we do collaborate as districts across our region that's a good thing collaboration there's there's
102something or well in about the idea that collaborate that voluntary collaboration is mandated and that's what's what seems to be happening here so I just want to begin this we're going to consider this this uh resolution to participate I think we have to understand what we're getting into in the process Mr Malloy uh this actually from Mr bonad Dario do you want to make an amendment to that uh resolution I mean do you want to uh accept the resolution with terms um I don't know how to put it [Laughter] so I would like to hear what my board colleagues uh think about the issue as well M slake yes thanks a couple of things um going along with what Mark said um that emergency was issued in September and then reissued in November and that
103emergency changes timelines and these regulations once the time passes they have the force of law they have not been legislated they've been placed by unelected bureaucrats and yet they have the force of law I'm very concerned that we're talking about 37 Regional districts in New York state they're hu they'll be huge and yet one commissioner will be have domain over that region the big five cities are EX from this how does that work how does this help with Equity are the cities going to be divided now like a pie um there's nothing in the regulations that would prevent that and they've had from September through the end of December to change the wording if they say well that's not what we meant well then say what you mean and yet they haven't why would that
104happen if they were sincere and there's been there have been a lot of people um criticizing this sending letters to them and the other thing um it was mentioned that why are only a few districts involved in this this um article 87 to place an injunction on this 78 78 um because people don't know about it it's not something that was widely publicized unless you read the New York state Register so um those are just my comments I would add about this this whole situation any other board member comments M Farah I would have to go along with what Mark and Mary say we spent probably last month a good hour talking regarding this before a board meeting several of us had many questions regarding what this actually meant in asking the director of superintendence
105um what he was supposed to bring to the table and what we were really buying for this there's a lot of questions that could not be answered money's involved um it's very concerning that in order to have a conversation which this is what it is you have to sign a resolution to continue a conversation a conversation should not have to come with with um a mandate uh to participate when you should be just participating if you choose so um I I don't think that this is a good idea thank you any other board member comments Mr Malo I'm just afraid that if we're we're not at the table we're going to have to sit back and take whatever they doou in my understanding now correctly if we vote no to this resolution and we opt
106out of it we can't say a word I mean everything is going to come down if if it should pass um I I I just I just have some reservations I just it's a trust it's a trust issue you say one thing and you write about something else and that's a trust issue and I have that trust issue I don't have a trust issue with the nine people on this board but I have a trust issue with the state of New York I'm sorry [Laughter] uh and you're more than welcome to chime in anytime to you can do this one region H do you have something you want to say before I Regent hell speaks or no I have the opportunity after speak no we're gonna have opportunity oh no please you I mean finish
107if you have a question or comment it might no question or comment but what I do want to say is I hear what you all are saying in terms of language what I also heard tonight and what we saw in our board packet is that we have four teachers who are retiring at the end of this year we're seeing a bubble where teachers are we're going to be losing more and more teachers resources how are we going and that's the part that I am focused on how are we as individual districts going to be able to offer these beautiful opportunities that sha spoke about earlier and a million other things that we do in this in this District if we do be if we do continue to see a a a um uh not a
108decline but a less people going into education less teachers want less people wanting to be teachers what will happen with our school districts and I know people say that this isn't about resources yet I saw a video of a person in Long Island saying that it is about resources that it's their tax money and they moved to that school district so they could they could educate their children in a way that they felt you know they'd be spending all kinds of money on their taxes so that's my point of view and I'm looking at this farther down the road not in a mistrustful way and I hear you Bill but it's the same time we're in a a position right now that we I feel that I have to watch out for the children in
109our district as well as the children throughout our state region H that's everybody for now there's probably going to be more all right so first off for the record for those of you who don't know me I'm Regent Adrien Hill I represent the eight counties on the New York State Board of regions and then 72 school districts included within them including Greece which is the second largest District within my district thank you so much president McCabe and vice president Farmer for allowing me to speak to the board here and I want you all to understand that I get your concerns to your point vice president farmer the majority of the objections to this regionalization package is coming from downstate Rockland Westchester Nassau saoke counties and it is about resources but just to give you all
110a little bit of historical context last year we all sat and were a little bit tooken a back when saw the executive budget that was proposed which will come out next week sometime and it had threats to save harmless now the great majority of kids outside of big five are in the rural and Suburban districts that are already covered in these 37 supervisory districts or both these districts who are already cooperating to ensure that districts such as your own do not have to fully shoulder the burden of providing these services and programs to kids given the differences in populations throughout these most these districts to the vice president's point we want to make sure and I'm not sure if you are all aware of this but we ask the governor last year to give us
111just a million dollars to do a study on what a foundation Aid formula would look like to include safe harmless what it would look like if it was brought up to date right she gave that to the Rockefeller Institute gave him $2 million they just gave us a 314 page report that now she wants nothing to do it we all can pretty much guess there's an ction coming up and no one wants to touch this now but to your point board member Maloney you have to be aware down the road that if threats to that funding does come back up and you p no role at the table mind you Greece is the largest District in Monro 2 then you would somewhat be subject to whatever other districts decided around metrics and contributions to the
112regionalization package that isn't being imposed just to be clear the package that you mentioned uh I don't want to butcher your last name Mark I don't want to butcher your last name but that September regulation was modified By Us in December to change the word compel to request and to deal with your concerns around trust to even offer an opt out option for districts that don't want to be involved the reality is close to 80% of districts are already signing on to this resolution to be involved the majority of the objection is coming from down state and it is about resources but with lowering enrollment there at some point is going to be a con a constructive conversation around funding that you all have to be aware of and that's not us trying to impose
113ourselves as much as it's us saying districts have to collaborate and cooperate if we don't want to change offerings to students and there's a whole bunch of other stuff going on busing and and all these other issues that I'm I'm beyond supportive of you all on those issues but you should should be at the table to play a constructive role in deciding what this looks like we haven't been trying to regulate from Albany as much as we're trying to hear from the field what actually works and then the senior Deputy Commissioner who's overseeing the whole project he's a DS so he's overwhelmingly he's sympathetic to these concerns and these reservations and I hope you know the board of region are as well any questions for me directly I have one oh goe Mr Bonar I'll
114let you go first thank you uh Regent Hill uh I would like to come back to your your comment just now that some of the language was changed I am aware that there was one item changed and that was the requirement to participate in the planning process and that was changed to voluntary participation which in fact is what we're going to vote on here correct I have consistently heard State officials say that talk about this being a voluntary process but the word compel as it as it was stated with regards to the commissioner's ability to compel districts to abide by the plans was not changed there there was talk about it and that in the spirit of it that that is what is meant and that will change but but as of yet it has
115not been adopted am I accurate in that or am I inaccurate inaccurate I guess you don't watch our meetings okay so at our last meeting in December we actually did change and I could provide uh the superintendent and the president with the new language package that we were given at our last meeting that had that in it we did change the word compel to request and then the opt out provision was also put in there and I think to also address your concern board member Ferrera or was it uh like who talked about Big Five districts so just to be clear in that last updated package in December Big Five districts are also invited to be a part of the process as well and so are Charter Schools being that s does have a portfolio
116of charter schools locally we have about 12 so my question Regent hail is there was an amendment from s December 2nd the moment the amendment basically does not mandate the regional reorganization such as mergers or consolidation nor does it require districts to engage in specific activities under the regionalization plan it establishes a voluntary framework for identifying opportunities to share resources address common challenges and improve student outcomes throughout the 60-day comment period the department has engag with stakeholders across the state and gather feedback on a proposed amendment the Outreach reflects the Department's commitment to ensuring all students have Equitable access to high quality educational opportunities while respecting the unique needs and priorities of local communities through the hosed Amendment school districts are invited to participate in their local regionalization conversations in the final regionalization plan participating
117school districts are only required to implement activities that they have agreed to work in Center to for their local context the DAT amendment pass at your December meeting yes thank you any other comments Mr Butler uh I guess I would say that's that was my understanding as well what what you just shared was that that it is voluntary participation and I would much rather be at the table than not at the table to help shape I mean Greece Greece being a large District having uh the the weight that we have of of program of experience and of expertise on our staff to have that be missing from the conversations I think likely makes the the the result worse or or weaker and so I I'm in support I I I know you region hail I
118know district superintendent putam who came and spoke with us um I know that the uh that our local superintendent would prefer that we be at the table uh as well and so given my trust for those individuals I'm I'm in support of the resolution and just to exclamate that point right we're talking about the fourth largest District in Upstate New York right you guys have a lot of expertise a lot of insights and I think you have a lot that other districts could learn from as a part of this process but this is in is this is by no means trying to threaten local control just to be clear we are only trying to ensure that districts are prepared for two things the first is graduation measures which you all know is coming right Blue
119Ribbon commission recommendations and also that if there is a serious threat to funding for students that you still can provide the services and programs that you are now I'm sure you all would hate to be here in a year when we have to wait for a new executive budget post an election and there's real threats to funding that we know will probably be in there next week when we see this executive budget that's coming out during the State of the State Mr stel thank you Regent hell for coming and um answering these questions I think given Mr President with the revelations that were brought here it's kind of updated my thinking process about this as well I was wondering is there any way we could table the vote so we could have more discussion and
120learn about the new changes that have been made since our last meeting with uh superintendent putam I believe the deadline is the we must they we must move forward by the January 15th oh my goodness so there's so it be that's why we're voting tonight because it's it would be next Wednesday what I oh if I may what I could do um because I let the commissioner know that I was going to come out here tonight um I could have her or the senior Deputy Commissioner who's overseeing the process schedule a meeting at a later dat and really help you guys in a more detailed way understand the process for participatory reasons right like how can you get the most out of your participation within this process if that would be sufficient it would we
121would still have to vote tonight to participate and that would come after that we're in we could have that further but I'm not hoodwinking you or ding you I hope ad um Mr bonario can you just uh tell me when when did that vote take place I think it was just before Christmas no that was at our December meeting our December board meeting when in December early mid it's all public knowledge just like your it's public knowledge so may I make a um and there's it's on video right our meetings are all recorded in archived on SD's website as well so you'll see David Frank who's Like Chief of Staff to the commissioner he's assistant commissioner and then our senior Deputy Commissioner give us an updated brief themselves about changes and regulations after hearing feedback
122from the field and I really want to make sure um board member Maloney you understand that right that as we have solicited feedback from the educational ecosystem we've made the necessary accommodations and amendments to the language so that folks understand on our end right on s's end we have the most noble of intentions and we have to be prepared for in Aly talk what might come from across the street right that's what we want to make sure we're prepared for thank you thank you Mr M I'd like to propose a five minute recess with Mr hell or Regent hell has offered to share that information with us I'd like to request a f minute recess to take him up on that offer because I think I agree with my colleagues that it's really important for
123us to be at the table but we need to do that with a a sure understanding of what we're getting into all right we can do a five minute recess with Regent hail and just I'm just going to fire a shot at your Regent hail I'd rather gouge my eyes out with a spoon than watch a Board of Regents [Laughter] meeting let me and I'm sure you feel the same way about s through our meeting tonight e e e after our five minute recess several of my colleagues had an opportunity to speak to Regent hail again thank you so much for Regent ha for availing yourself to us this evening does anybody else have any questions or comments they would like to make Mr bagorio I'd like like to propose a resol an amendment to
124the resolution stating essentially that we would join the planning process under the understanding that the uh the changes that Regent hell described to us are in fact uh in the regulation and I think you have the language for that um so I think the language is and correct me if I'm wrong in the final regionalization plan participating school districts are only required to implement activities that they have agreed or consented to for their local contact Perfect all right is there a so there's an amendment to the resolution is there a second second by Mr stencil is there any comments questions concerns discussion on just the amendment farmer oh thank you I forgot um false start yes okay so this amendment if we were to go through with this and say whatever happens what happens then
125can you I mean I I I mean I'm not trying to be complicated here I just I don't understand your question okay that's fine that's fine I I'm a little confused so say we vote Yes to this and and the state and the nice it says doesn't uphold what the what's in this paper what happens next I mean we're in the process and you know I guess we would we really wouldn't have much of a leg to stand on at the end of the day if s and you know region h i mean he's made it clear tonight that you know this is going to be an optional thing at the end of the day and that's the Regent the board's position at this time so I mean taking him for his word I mean
126I'm expecting this to follow through at the end that this is a voluntary process so I'm hoping that your question never comes to fruition I guess would be my and I is that a correct assumption on my part Regent Hal basp you already committed to whatever or certain metrics or however you want to that would be and that's the language comp requ allows is what this is all question any Amendment no okay that's what we're considering we yep we're working on the amendment right now so we'll be back to the full resolution is there any other questions or comments just on the amendment all those in favor oh let's do this by roll call Mr President can you just reread the entire Amendment do so the the basically the amendment says in the final regionalization
127plan participating school districts are only required to implement activities that they have agreed or consented to for their local context and that comes my apologies can you read the entire resolution with the amendment oh so the entire resolution would be with the amendment included if it gets adopted that the Board of Education of gree Central School District approves the district to participate in the regionalization planning in the final regionalization plan which this is the amendment participating school districts are only required to implement activities that they have agreed or consented to forther local context good okay um any other questions comments just on the amendment all right we're going to do a roll call vote we're going to start with Mr M Mr Maloney this is just on the amendment on the vment on the amendment
128I vote Yes Mr bonario yes Mr Butler yes Miss Mar yes Mr SEL yes Miss Lake yes and nice job board working on this together thanks yes Mr Farah and vice president fman yes and I may ask that passes the Amendments adopted unanimously now back to the full resolution any other comments questions or concerns on this Miss Farah is this where your question comes in sort of uh maybe off topic here or close thereof does this have anything to do with maybe possibly the lack of federal funding that we may see obviously yep please reg h that is a major concern right um and I don't know if you've seen this too but the New York Post acts for the incoming Administration to even investigate SED in the board of regions as well so New
129York is already kind of being I think targeted uh what we're potentially planning for is there could be everywhere from a hard repeal so if you think about the US Department of Education that's Title 9 which is civil rights that's title one that's idea and then that's pel grants and whatnot hard repeal could be removing those programs reallocating those dollars and giving States a lot more discretion at how they use those a soft one could potentially be reassigning idea and Title One to labor a reassigned Title 9 to civil rights under Department of Justice and depel grants and College funding to uh treasury right that could be a potentially soft phone where they reallocate those programs they still St intacted but they're under different US Departments that is how we're trying to anticipate this but
130obviously with the incoming Administration we don't know what to expect but we're trying to plan for that as well the biggest ones that you probably would see is idea which is special education and the other one being obviously title one right those would be the big ones that you probably should be most concerned about um so yeah that's how we're anticipating it but right now now that's not so much a part of this as it is State funding but just be aware that if we do see a decrease in federal dollars then we're going to go across the street to the state legislature and to the governor and make harder asks because we're not going to want to see students in New York state go without thank you any other questions or comments all right
131on our resolution as Amendment as amended we're going to start yep just a procedural question sure I do have another proposal that I would like to make in in this context and he spoke about it during the recess is that an appropriate point to bring up this point or after the vote it would be after the vote all right yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes and I'm ask that passes unanimously all right can you do you want to do it under your board member comments or do you want to do it here is it actionable under my board member comments I don't know if it's going to be actionable here but we'll give it a shot all right I'll give you a I'll give you the courtesy go ahead Mr Bago thank you
132um and and I also want to thank Regent hell and I I I do want to just say I think we all understand this process is very this collaborative process among school districts for the benefit of our students our families our teachers everyone our taxpayers is really important and yet this concern about how this has all played out is also very important there is a um a movement by a number of of districts around New York State to um uh file an article 78 injunction against this regulation and I'd like to propose that we join that that uh that uh filing on the on in the sense that the the voluntary participation in these efforts is critical it's what has always sustained our our work as as uh as a region with our Bose partners
133and I I'd like to make a a motion that we join that is there a second second by Mr stencel is there any discussion on joining the article 78 litigation could could I hear it again please what what do you want to hear what the proposal is that we joined the article 78 injunction it hasn't been filed yet it is expected to be filed on so if they file it we would join yes but they're looking for people to participate it to participate in it now is there any comments discussion go Mr Maloney first uh personally I would like some legal counsel in this uh I I hate making these decisions uh within only a couple days left to make it I would uh uh like to have our District's attorney uh sit and address
134us I know there's probably not enough [Music] time so I understand where you're coming from I just don't know if I could support it or not without some legal councel Mr Butler uh yeah and I guess maybe I don't understand it well enough and I would welcome some additional education on it but if the concern and the reason for the potential legal action is because of compelling participation and I think what we've just based our approval of this resolution on is the change to it not being compelled but being voluntary and anything that you might agree to implement would be only would be voluntary I guess I don't see the point in the in the legal action unless there's something I'm misunderstanding about it yep he asked you y so there there is as my
135colleague here and some several of our colleagues have have said there's different perspectives on on the language and I haven't as yet seen the final actual regulation and what is in the final regulation is is really the critical piece uh I don't expect that uh a filing would be made if in fact everything has been um adjusted to voluntary participation uh but if it is if it if it uh has not been adjusted then we're in a position to participate in in a uh a filing to protect our rights as a school board and a school district so uh I agree that uh that we should we should request our council's opinion on it and uh maybe we can do that hopefully in short order in order to potentially participate just like the other implication
136might be Tad that with the injunction it would be more a localized thing as opposed to 37 pieces you know New York state divided into 37 regions with one commissioner you know overseeing each of them anybody else have a question then I have a question for region ha I don't have a question well maybe it's a question but my understanding when I was reading this is that our district would have to hire our own attorney is that correct I no the the the Coalition uh districts who are filing the injunction have made their attorney available to any any other districts who want to participate to pay that yes yeah they would be sharing the cost and it it becomes I don't remember what the amount was but it was fairly small in the you know
137yeah less less than we spent on anything else today it's all it's all subject to that I suppose right that's too many open I think it was $6,000 with the number they had already last week or sometime so I guess my question Regent hail to you is has the board of region because my understanding of an article 78 is that an article 78 can't be I mean if you haven't has the board of regions officially adopted the regionalization plan is it totally complete and adopted I mean it's an emergency just to be clear it's an emergency regulation so it's been adopted so in article 78 so an article 78 would apply it went it went into immediate back in September an immediate went into enactment and then it was amended in December when we took
138that subsequent vote on amending languages and processes within that original emergency procedure all right so what I'm going to do is I'm going to make a motion to table um the article 78 pending our attorney giving us an opinion on whether we should whether it behoves degree Central School District to participate in this article 78 litigation or not I agree with my colleague Mr Maloney we should be getting a legal opinion so I'm going to make a motion to table a motion to table is non-debatable I need a second second by Mr stel we'll do a roll call vote on a motion to table pending legal review we'll start with vice president farmer a yes vote is to table yes M Farah yes just like yes Mr stel yes Mr M yes Mr Butler yes
139Mr bagaro point of information sure did you say that that you will be inquiring with with councel yep motion table to it's review by legal councel yes Mr M yes and I yes so it uh issues tabled pending legal review by our attorney so once I find out from her I will let the board know all right moving on to 11.04 our colleague Miss Lake proposed a resolution tonight be resolved that degree Central School District joins as a member district in New York State School boards Association any a motion minut a second Bo by Miss F second by Mr stel any comments questions or concerns Miss L since it's I'm going to let Miss L go since her resolution um there were three reasons that I thought it would be in our best interest one
140is that um we would have legal representation with the state um as a school board separate from our representation for with the district um secondly we would they have a department that can investigate things so if we wanted an abstract of the Rockefeller study um we could request that of them or if we wanted to look up something that instructionally they've been the district's been kind of working on um we could do that to um push initiatives and then thirdly we could um go to the conferences New York State conferences at a lower rate and be able to network with other school boards throughout the state so those are my reasons to request joining all right Mr Money I guess I guess I need to know uh the total cost of all this I mean
141it's fine to it's fine to become to there's a reason why we got out of New York State uh and I think it was a cost got a whole list of reasons I'm going to tell you them oh okay then I'll I'll shut up does anybody else have any comments miss m I'm also concerned about the cost do you have that number um when he was here and when he met with us back in the fall he quoted $122,000 but that was for the current year the rates have went up so I don't know the updated but I know it went up so it's a little more probably a little more than the $122,000 annually any other question just all for the entire District any other comments Mr stel thank you I'm just going to
142play devil's advocate here I know that cost is a concern I'm very fiscally conservative myself but thinking about the things we just approved tonight in terms of cost 12,000 is peanuts and um you know thinking about it when I put on my academic cap having more resources at our table and our disposal as a board is better than no resources and I know that we have the county representation but I'd like to see what the state has to offer and I think I would be willing to say can we do this in some sort of way where we preliminary try it for six months or a year and if we hate it and it sucks and we we don't want it we can always vote to get rid of it right so that's all I
143have to say thank you Other Board member comments uh I'm I'm not I'm not opposed to uh exploring the idea I guess I feel a little uh surprised by the by the resolution here tonight and I would we especially since we not that long ago heard and had a discussion as a board and decided that we didn't want to uh pursue the the New York State School boards Association membership we we we did maybe it was before the three before the two of you joined the board but we had we had a presentation uh a discussion about nispa membership versus Mon County School boards Association membership and the benefits of each and so I think i' if if something has changed and we want to have that conversation again I'd be with having that conversation
144I just don't feel like I I'd like to look at what the benefits are how you know ask some questions about we get do we have inadequate legal counsel at this point are there inadequate resources for conferences and so on at this point as opposed to just it's been suggested so we have to do it or not do it that's my opinion um I just want to add comment we did actually discuss this it looks like in October of this past last year now we may have discussed this before you two got on board we usually kind of discuss this every year um but it wasn't really that long ago it was two months ago that we had our meeting with the New York state representative that came and we spent an hour with them
145we did actually ask a lot of questions and at that point it really wasn't discussed uh further that's why the resolution is brought to the table uh regarding going forward with it so um a lot of us have discussed it it looks like a lot of people have comments they're they're pretty um excited to go back to New York state to see what they have to offer off but we we really did have that conversation again not that long ago it was it was very long it was great that the New York state representative and I apologize I don't remember his name at the top of my head bar Ur whistle yes thank you um but I thought he did a great great job of what does offer uh what New York state board does
146offer he went into extreme detail I thought it was a very good uh presentation he offered thank you Mr V I would I would appreciate if the board president would share his thoughts and maybe we can you normally have the last word but I was wondering if you could share those and and it may raise other questions absolutely my point Thank you so um so our Monro County School boards is a tremendous local resource they provide above and beyond what the state provides we were we've been members of the State Association in the past um the State Association in you pay $112,000 and you're coming about like the legal they bill you for all that anything that you ask them to do you get a bill for so you you have access to it but
147then there's a back charge like if you have them come in and do a board of development if you have them come in and do superintendent board relations if you have them do any legal work for you you get build for that it's not just they give me that they do you so you end up being you end up being paid for you pay for that service through them um having attended Schoolboard conferences the last one that was in Rochester I don't remember when that was Terry um it was a total waste of time in security measures all their updated presentations they were 5 to seven years behind where we were in Greece their Dei was five to seven years behind they just talked about when Barry was here oh my God this new student
148board member thing we did that a year ago where we put a student board member we've always been light years ahead of the state school boards the we created a policy to open up conferences and other things for board members to go to I know vice president farmer taking advantage um board member M's taking advantage of going to conferences outside of the school boards Association um you know yeah the trip to New York City is nice and everybody wants to go to New York City but it it's you're not getting your bank for your buck it's you might as well take the $113,000 and throw it in a parking lot for what you're going to get out of school boards they were a total waste they f failed every school district in the state and
149I know some of you are extremely passionate about Co they failed in their advocacy they had a responsibility to Advocate and they didn't do anything during Co nothing they have taken no action on the electric bus issue so for all this advocacy that you're getting from them you might as well take your head and slam into the wall because there there's nothing there you're destroy money away this is ridiculous I mean we can have other conferences and have board members go to conferen is each of us have the opportunity once in a threeyear period to basically attend any conference you want if you want to go to New York State School boards you can go to the New York State School boards and we'll pay the little bit of difference but the membership's not worth
150it you're we're not getting anything out of it there's a reason this board pulled out of it and the reason was they failed us on multiple levels they took no action their Education and Training was we brought them in for an out nor biller Terry remember this we brought that man back with barbar Dean they came in and did a superintendent we were having some issues before I was president with some of our colleagues on the board and this current and the superintendent at the time on barbar Dean Williams and they came in and they made it 10 times worse I mean it turned into more of a fiasco and it ended up costing us $99,000 to have them come in for four hours and do an evening session with us with the superintendent so
151at the end of the day I think this is a terrible waste of money we have a policy that we're going to have to revisit because was 2320 basically we fund policy 2320 with the money we had set aside for the school boards Association so now we're going to have to figure out where that money is going to come from and every action we take with the school boards there's a cost in addition to your dues so I'm a hard no on this I think it's a terrible waste of taxpayer dollars granted I agree with Mr stel $112,000 is a drop in a bucket in a $300 million budget but I I would rather spend that $112,000 someplace else and I just don't think it's worth it, well no it's not it's it's going to
152be more than $12,000 but the $112,000 is the figure that we were talking about just for joining and being members and you get a newspaper every I don't remember what it was once a month you get a little newspaper from them highlighting what school districts are doing across the state and you read everything in there and we did it three years ago so that's my that's my position on the school boards does anybody else have any questions or comments Mr bagorio so microphone please thank you Mr Maloney and Mrs farmer both I believe have experience as well do you care to share your thoughts y okay so I too was very when we um stopped stopped being part of New York State School boards and we may have talked about this I kept saying listen
153we need to be able to do this we need to be able to interact with the different distri throughout the state etc etc I will say based on what I heard when Barry came and what Sean has said and he said this in the past too that it doesn't it it it doesn't hold that promise that I once thought it did and I and the idea that we can still go to this uh conference or other conferences is I I thought was a good um a good um match compromise miss m so I did attend a few of their conferences and the last one in Rochester was embarrassing because everything they talked about literally we were doing we could take that $112,000 and send some of you to the convention and you could see for
154yourself as opposed to doing it and they did always slap us with fees every time they came to talk to us it was ridiculous and we just decided it was just too much money Mr Maloney I went to New York uh on my last conference that I went to and I went with Mrs farmer and I don't know if Terry was there or not no I guess not and uh I did meet a lot of people from other districts but I could do that normally I don't even have to go all the way to New York City to meet these people I could actually go to their districts and was invited to some and without without the New York State School boards I went to some of their conferences I mean some of their talks
155and it was like stuff that we had done two or three years ago and it wasn't beneficial whatsoever I thought I have a great time I had a fantastic time but other than that I mean stories Mr Maloney but as far as education wise it it really wasn't that wasn't all what it was cracked up to be Miss like Mark when you got you talked to a lawyer through um did you I I did speak to someone uh it was probably two years ago um and we were not members and he answered some questions on a a gratuitous basis was it your understanding that we would have to pay for legal advice if they were I don't know okay in the past the legal advice the issue is is if you have your own legal
156councel that'll give you an opinion if there's an opinion that's been litigated if it's something that's happened like if you're looking into consolidation if you're looking at things along those lines merging schools closing a school they can give you an opinion on what's happened in the past they're not doing new legal work for you you have your district attorney that's going to do that that so that's the that's where the legal comes in but again if they spend the time with you they charge you I mean they charge us do one year we spent almost $40,000 on top of our dues in fees bringing them in for a couple things so Mr stel this questions for I guess Mary and Mark and Megan it sounds like based on everything we've been talking about here the
157real is issue here is not really the association but access to an attorney related education am I wrong on this or well because it's been brought up a couple times so I'm I'm trying to tease out is is there something else we're really asking for I don't know I mean I guess I'm going to comment and I think if I understand and please correct me if I'm misinterpreting what you're saying what you're looking for or what you're asking is is there a way that all nine more bumbers can reach out to the attorney and ask questions yes in part I I know when you and I have spoke long time ago when we first talked at Dunkin Donuts you had said something about um there used to be two different attorneys one for the district
158one for the board I'm and I know I remember your reasoning for why you squashed it but you know why couldn't we entertain that having our own board dedicated attorney and then one for the district this way there's no conflict of interest we can have open honest discussions with this individual well there is 100% a conflict of interest when you get two different decisions when the district school district attorney makes one decision and the board's attorney tells them something differently respectfully Mr President I would I would just say the law is the law right the lawyers should all come to the same conclusion based on what the the courts have decided and whatnot there shouldn't be these Mr stel I mean I I'm going to try to be sensitive here but I think I'm not
159going to be very sensitive in regards to the fact that when you pay an attorney the attorney works for you and wants to he's going to the decision you want him to get to if I call an attorney tomorrow and tell him I want this guy to be purple he's going to do everything in his power to make the sky purple in my world I understand that you know so I mean again attorneys I mean they have to work they litigate they get do billable hours that's what their goal is I mean I think it would be absolutely crazy and even when the board did have two attorneys or when the district had two separate attorneys that you're referencing in the mid early 2000s um they it it led to constant conflict and the board
160members still didn't have access to the attorney everything went through the president if you have nine people calling the attorney I mean I would sign up tomorrow be the district's attorney because I'd be like oh hey Jordan what's going on I'd be whacking CH ching ching oh Terry how are you so every phone call you're getting whacked I mean I don't know if you look at legal bills but I mean they nickel and dime everything nothing against attorneys I love them that's their job they got a job to do like everybody else in the world but that's their position and I don't think it behooves the district I think as soon as you look at hiring a board attorney that's different than a District's attorney you're establishing an adversarial relationship between the Board of Education
161and the school district that they're representing if you have a reason to hire an attorney for a separate issue if you are going to like we have attorneys that do some of our real estate work we have attorneys that have represented Us in other issues that you go out and you look for an attorney to represent you in those issues and potentially you could do that we could put if we had a concern with something and wanted to have a legal outside legal counsel look at something the board can make that decision to do that but at the end of the day that's not where it's not it doesn't behoove the school district I mean and we're so far off the resolution at this point I think it's another time yeah Mr bagar I'd like
162to move that we table the motion for now perhaps uh Mr stenzel can do some additional research on it if he chooses to no need I'm I'm good so resolution's been Ted wait yeah I guess I'm confused what's tabled I guess here I'm I'm proposing tabling the school board's resolution the resolution that he didn't make a resolution he was he was asking a question I'm sorry it was more a comment and discussion Oh I thought it was a resolution we okay thank you Mary's got the resolution all right so getting back to the main resolution on joining the New York State School boards or not is there any more discussion on that I think we beat beat this horse to death anything else all right we're going to do a roll call vote on this
163one voice president farmer oh like to table it for the time so you're making a motion yes to when I mean usually a motion okay so there's a motion we table the New York state school board's discussion indefinitely it's a non-debatable motion is there a second Mr bagorio all those in favor motion to table that passes 8 to one I'm a no um all right moving on board member comments who wants to go I'll go first all right happy New Year everybody you guys loved this first meeting didn't you look at how tired they all look um real quick signed up for this buddy um real quick I wanted remind families that come out we have a winter perception survey to understand how families feel about our work it's going to be coming out please
164please everybody let us know how you feel I also want to remind everybody we have lots of sports going on and it's a great opportunity especially to bring some young ones to see a basketball game it's great entertainment and it's musical season and I will be singing the next few months some of the songs from the musicals have a good night okay all right other board M Mr Maloney I've got three all right one Mr small e thank you very much for being our superintendent and your staff the new staff and the old staff thank you very much second of all I don't need an attorney I work with the smartest people that there ever was this board is unbelievable and and if I have any questions I ain't afraid to ask any one of
165them and it doesn't cost me anything but that's all I've got for now thank you thank you Mr Maloney Mr Butler uh I want to add my congratulations to superintendent smallen to uh assistant superintendent Baker and Flagler and uh Deputy superintendent Fleming he for your new roles congratulations this is an exciting time for this district and uh we are in good hands with the leadership team that we've got here so uh congratulations to all of you and I really look forward to to partnering with you uh for the uh over the next period of time um I want to uh recognize uh the passing of President Carter um who who was eulogized today I was listening on my way here to to some of those and he sets an extraordinary example of selflessness and commitment
166to values and and community service that I think we could all uh live by and uh and so I didn't want the meeting to go by without uh without mentioning that and uh I also want to congratulate this board for wrestling with some tough stuff tonight and uh and I think we did it in in a spirit of collegiality and uh and teamwork that bodess well for the future thank you thank you Mr will Mr F just quickly uh I do want to thank our resident speaker Mr Smith uh first off I want to thank you for your service I know that they all left um thank you for speaking on the veterans tax exemption that we are looking into um I also want to thank the retirees there were a lot of them some
167board packets there seems to be a lot to a little um so I won't go through all the names but I am sad to see a few of our longr teachers they are leaving bummer um also Mr sming superintendent sming uh I appreciate you taking the time to do this so when I first asked you if you were up to being this superintendent I thought you were crazy uh you still may be but that's up to interpretation yet uh I look forward to you bringing the trust and the transparency to the table and I would like to um go with Mr uh Butler's comments I think we did a great job today uh I think the transparency is definitely working with the conversations uh we kept our cool all of us um and I think
168that was a great rendition of what we will see coming 2025 thank you thank you m pH M like um I repeat what everyone said about the welcoming new people to the district and the table um and Lori congratulations and it's nice to have you here um big shoes to fill but you're doing a great job so far anybody else Mr I do want to add my congratulations to superintendent smallen and I look forward to uh working with you and the rest of the staff that new and and old and I will Echo uh Mr Butler's comments uh and and as you know a lot of people have asked me you know how how do you like being on the board and I a common response is they're all good people and we might not
169all agree on everything but we get along and that's you know we haven't seen that all over the country but we think we do see it here and that's nice and a Happy New Year to all of you and to all of uh all of our families in the Greece uh Community thanks fmer okay everybody said welcome congratulations to all of you who are new to us this year Romeo with your expertise and your team how you continue to hold us up in ways that allow us to do these wonderful programs that sha was talking to us about I attended the um one of the evening uh events with the the Spanish parents and it was just so beautiful to see people talking with each other and caging and the kids and and then I
170was asked if I spoke Spanish and I said and they were oh you know excited that I could even just speak a little bit so I could just more and more and more um is that there I think I lost my my so I said oh happy New Year happy New Year thank you VI president farmer um I'm just going to be brief we have a legislative breakfast next month Regent hail made a comment today about advocacy advocacy is going to be very important at the state level when it comes to Foundation Aid and the state aid especially after we see the executives budget coming out next week I believe it is right Romeo next week yes uh state of state is the 14th 14th yeah so next week so her budget will be out
171next week so it'll be interesting to see so advocacy on that and some of the state laws especially this electric bus thing um so advocacy and then we got a lot of budget work to do for this gree Central School District so it's going to be a busy between now in the end of the year a lot to do it's going to fly by and thank you everybody it was a good meeting tonight yes absolutely superintendent SMY all right um I also want to thank everybody for our work tonight uh we wrestled some uh difficult issues and I think we did a great job coming together um and I appreciate that especially in my first board meeting so thank you for for that um I also wanted to take a moment to extend my deepest
172gratitude to the veterans who joined us earlier today and thank them for their service um and I'll just end with um you know as I step into this role as uh your superintendent I wanted to begin by expressing my gratitude for the trust and support I received uh just throughout this entire transition uh thank you for welcoming me into this role and for your ongoing dedication to our schools and I'm excited for what lies ahead and confident that together we will continue to inspire excellence and create opportunities for every student in the gree Central School District so thank you very much for your support looking forward to our time together thank you superent smallen Mr Maloney yes I'd like to make a resolution that we adjourn this meeting I imagine you would is there a
173second Mr Butler gets the second all those in favor yay and just so everybody knows our next meeting we're going to run till 10: so everybody Buckle in 10 my alarm e