001us uh we will entertain motions I got something here okay uh oh no this is the finance that's the finance committee here here comes trer with she's coming she's coming all right oh let's see I should have this memorized by now okay I move to enter into executive session for the purpose of discussions regarding proposed pending or current litigation Collective negotiations pursuant to article 14 of the Civil Service law and matters leading to the appointment employment promotion demotion discipline suspension dismissal or removal of a particular person or Corporation move by Adam second by Jill any debates conversation questions discussion hearing none we'll call the question all in favor of the motion passes unanimously we will be headed into executive session and we will return as close to 7 PM as we can thank you all
002very much we're returning from executive session we will continue on with our agenda um are there any modifications to the agenda hearing none we will continue onward and that is uh the rece and hearing of delegates public comment period And I believe we have two people signed up Dr trip the first is Courtney Reinhardt and this is uh she'll be joining us virtually I'm about to start singing you all just to give you something to do something you don't any show tunes I do none actually should we hi my audio cut out for a little bit my apologies we can hear you thank you excellent uh my name is Courtney Reinhardt I have kids at South Hill and at Bon Middle School um the P I'm here as a representative of the PTA Council the
003PTA Council meets once a month as representatives from various PTA organizations across the district with members of The District administration Educators and other stakeholders in the system to discuss topics of Interest throughout our schools our meetings typically include representatives from the majority of our schools and participants often share the personal stories of their students in their classrooms and in their school buildings we also share out information across the district in support of the communications team at the district during our last few meetings we've met with Dr Brown Deputy superintendent Mary Grover Jennifer Gonda and the ICD Communications team today we discussed with ITA president Katherine sera's um various topics ranging from cell phone and Technology use to the upcoming ITA and School District negotiations we were excited to hear that the forthcoming negotiation process will
004be live streamed and recorded to allow the public to witness the discussions which have such an impact on our budget and on our children next month we're excited to welcome board member Emily Workman to speak with the council about the board of education budget writing process uh the PTA Council supports the work of all of our teachers staff and administrators by sharing information and resources throughout the district for the benefit of students we look forward to learning more about the proposed budget and encouraging our members to vote in support of passing that budget any school's PTA may join us or send a representative to our next meeting on March 11th we will meet in person with a virtual option at the school district office and we would like to thank you for your time thank
005you Courtney appreciate it next up Scott jeny hello everyone my name is Scott Yoni and I want to take a moment to address a critical issue affecting not just my family but many others in our district a communication or rather sometimes the lack of it recently my daughter's bus broke down at her school after waiting for 30 minutes with no update I called the transportation department only to learn that the bus had mechanic issue while still parked at the school there was no communication from either the transportation department or the school as a parent not knowing where your child is or what is happening is both frustrating worrisome and scary this also wasn't the first incident earlier in the school year in October November a different bus delay lasted for over 45 minutes after raising
006my concerns with the transportation department and having a conversation uh with them as well I was assured that caregivers would receive timely updates in the future however that promise was not kept additionally our transportation requests submitted at the start of the Year remained unresolved also until I escalated the issue the communication failes extend beyond Transportation earlier this year a German teacher resigned from the Middle School despite the class being an introductory course there was no communication from the school about how the Lost instructional time would be addressed it wasn't until I reached out that any explanation was provided to us these repeated failures highlighted a deeper issue accountability who is responsible when Communications break down who ensures that commitments made to parents are followed through right now there seems to be no clear answer Promises
007of improved communication have been made and broken with no consequence and if there's no accountability for these ongoing issues how can we expect real change when parents raise when parents raise concerns we expect at least an acknowledgement if not a solution yet after my most recent email on January 31st regarding these bus delays as well as a a a followup earlier this week I've received no response from the Transportation director or the district administrator overseeing Transportation or any guidance on accessing the GPS system report that's been installed on our buses this is unacceptable if parents cannot get timely answers to direct question questions how can we trust that critical issues such as student safety curriculum changes resource allocation are being communicated effectively this is not just about one bus route but it's about a pattern
008of pure of poor communication and lack of accountabilities that leaves family families in the dark our district should be a partner in our children's education and communication is the foundation of that partnership parents deserve transparency accountability and responsiveness when those entrusted with our with when when entrusted with our children's well-being our children deserve better and so do we thank you board responses attempt to response I think we're all dismayed to hear of your experience um I certainly was unaware that the system wasn't working that to that extent that you wouldn't know um that your student wouldn't be expected home or wouldn't be picked up until much later I I think we can all understand a five or 10 minute delay or um lack of following a schedule given all the all the data all the
009uh you know variables that go into running a bus route um but it is troubling to hear that you didn't get any kind of you know notification of that and uh we can certainly ask um Mr van curan to look into that and provide us more information at our next meeting um all I can say is I think we're doing a lot better than we used to but I think we're far from perfect and it is helpful to hear specifics about our failures um so that we know where the failures are and how to address them um beyond that I'll just say I'm sorry and we'll hope to do better and um thank you for sharing that and about your the transportation communication and thank you for you reaching out too and I would just
010like to encourage you as well as our community that we do have a communication protocol when it's initiated by a parent a caregiver and it doesn't stop right there at the head of Transportation but also to um reach out to the superintendent because that's in the communication protocol that we should reach out to the superintendent and if you didn't hear from the superintendent to bring it to the attention of the Board of Education and I always want to encourage encourage our community of what's on our website and the communication protocol is there and knowing that our administrative staff is down Personnel too to make sure that um to give time to to um for responses in your situation that it has been a long time so we do acknowledge that and and thank you Courtney
011for um just giving us an update on PTA counsel I was involved in PTA Council and just thanking you for your continued work and the work of all those in our ptas across the district uh hearing no other board response I also want to say thank you to the PTA for the work that's being done greatly appreciated it and we will then move to student reps and I'm not sure who went first last time so paper scissors is amazing yeah okay hello okay hi everybody good to see you again um so we have several IHS students that have set very very impressive new records in indoor track pull vating and weight throw another student was named the New York State sophomore of the year for her CrossCountry performances fall uh two other student two other
012IHS students were awarded as first team Allstate cross country Runners some highlights from other winner Sports include the boys JB basketball team they are dominating the season sitting at a record of 15 to zero um the boys varsity basketball team and the boy swim uh Varsity both have their senior nights tonight at IHS also an update we are still waiting for reusable plates to be used in our cafeteria again which also includes silverware um yeah we had winter formal Last Friday Night on December 7th and juniors and seniors from IHS and Lacs came together for some fun dancing and photo taking IHS signs Olympia traveled to Yale University last Saturday and competed among 60 schools all across the East Coast they placed third overall and were named on the podium among other very well-known schools
013and the team was recently crowned Regional Champions and will be competing in the state championships next month and code red also held their Ninth Annual open house this Saturday with guided tours of their our new tailor te Trailer Tech rooms and activities by Cornell project teams Community stem groups and other IHS stem clubs they also hosted the Vex robotic scrimmage and after a very long build season um the robot um that they're making is mechanically finished and they're currently working on testing and programming to compete in Rochester and Albany next month hi everybody great to see you tonight so following up on something that I talked about last meeting which was the instructional video for eth graders scheduling we're still making progress on that I actually have a meeting tomorrow down at Boon after school
014and we think that we can get it ready up and running before the end of the school year ideally late spring and we'll pass it of course through the counselors to make sure first that they're all go with that but we're hoping it can be a reusable resource for students over the summer when contact with people in school is usually a little more difficult especially for eighth graders who don't know the system quite yet we've had recent conversations with principal Hardesty about standards based grading we hope to continue those conversations and we had a question for the board that may be a little bit sensitive so we understand if you can't provide or don't have the information to provide us with the response but this had to do with if you have any knowledge of
015how the current Administration and the funding for the Department of Education would or would not trickle down to state level funding which could trickle down to local level funding and affect District functions at the ICD thank you Etha High School great thank you um so tomorrow we are doing trips rotations which is when um all of the spring trips set up a little uh information session I guess um each student TR picks three to try and they sort of cycle through looking at which ones might interest them uh we've got some really great um options this year so I'll bring up I'll highlight a couple examples uh canoe and bike trip our trip Staples they've been happening for years and years uh there are local trips like hiking and exploring itha uh and there are
016away trips like the cultural identity trip which is hoping to go to Puerto Rico um and hurricane Helen relief trip uh for many many years until last year actually LS did a Katrina relief trip finally it came time to get a new hurricane uh this trip came into being through student effort headed by a senior this year it's very exciting yeah um at the last meeting I talked about the mission statement conversations we've been having at ACS U that is contined for the past two weeks and actually tomorrow at ASM uh it's going to the full school um to really just continue this conversation so the mission the current mission statement we have was adopted in 1994 so it's 31 years old now um and that statement is our mission is to educate students to
017be Global Citizens in the 21st century um well it is the 21st century so you know it's time for a revamp um so a group of students including myself have proposed a mission statement that reads empowering students and student voice inclusive community self-directed learning and environmentally sustainable practices through active Democratic engagement then that is the current proposed mission statement um we will get recommendations that mission statement tomorrow and then it will go to a full vote for the school and then with any luck it'll be adopted um in other news uh last Tuesday we held an easm or emergency all school meeting uh at ACS surrounding the presidents of ice in itha many students were alarmed and was just meant to calm them down um we held a virtual panel discussion with our principal Deb
018Pac um icsc admin officer Dan bryman uh Mary Joe Dunley who is the director of the Cornell University Farm worker program and Thomas hobble who is a local filmmaker and released a film I believe a few years ago on immigration system and the immigration stories especially in local the local community um and the point of this ASM was really just to make everyone aware of the facts uh regarding the case and Etha um and then you know shared constitutional rights and then to answer questions so yeah fantastic thank you Lacs uh I'm going to do something I don't normally do which is to speak first in terms of board responses and then give it to my colleagues uh the film that you're referring to by Tom Hubble Are We There Yet will actually be screened
019at Etha College in a week and so I'll encourage folks to take a look at that film uh it was released I want to say a year and a half ago uh but folks that may be interested um this is awkward but in a moment of self-promotion I'll be doing a teach in Etha college called Federal impact on local education uh where I'd be more than happy to answer a number of cadman's questions uh with that being said uh I think what we're experiencing with the rise of number of executive orders uh is at this point in time words on a page and not translated necessarily into policy Andor action and so the board is following these executive orders carefully working with our legal team to see if they actually have any legal standing or
020legal Merit we know a number them have already been suspended or there's been an injunction or uh and so we are trying carefully not to for lack of a better word and I realize now I'm seeing press here but I'm going say it anyway not to overreact when we see an executive order but to actually identify what's being said and what's taking place what I will say and I'm Dr Brown may say something later on uh we are absolutely 100% committed to making sure that every child has their constitutional right to an education and that's how we're going to approach it and that's what we're going to do moving forward um mentioned about being the 21st century and the Lacs mission statement it was literally last century when I ran the bike group to Canada
021and back and I don't think that I could do that anymore but I'm looking forward to the trips uh that folks are doing um it's I know Lac Lacs trips are uh one of the more amazing um institutions that the school engages in and so I wish folks um a good deal of success moving that forward and so uh with my breaking protocols I normally do I apologize uh additional board responses oh I I wanted a question for cman about the eth grade schedule and video is where will that go up which website so we have to iron out some of those details with the specific Middle School administration which we're hoping to do once we actually have the video we are still trying to make sure that everyone's okay with what's going to be
022in it because we don't want to run into the issue of making a video too fast and then finding out that one counselor found it to not be you know what what they wanted Express to their middle schoolers and then we have an issue and we have to go back to the drawing board so hopefully my meeting with the counselors at Boon tomorrow will give me some more insight into the method by which we could disperse it but my thinking would be that sometime late in the year when I know that at the middle schools there's occasionally a couple of days there where there's not as much to do since education has largely ceased they could um you it wouldn't be a very long video maybe five minutes they could show it to every I
023don't know English class I'm just spitballing here right and then we could also send out in email form and one of the big things I wanted to focus on was getting it to parents also because you know I think it's great if kids see it but a lot of kids might not take the initiative to you know understand it and act on it but and maybe maybe they shouldn't be expected to but parents are often heavily involved in that aspect of their child's education and so I think they should have a right to have access to that so we'll try to find some list serve to send it through sorry that's kind of a long response but those are my jumbled thoughts thank you and I'd also like to recommend on the high school like
024their playbook and their connect with their PTA as and all so additional board responses fantastic as always thank you greatly to our student reps thank you to the work that you do and the preparation for these reports uh they're uh always greatly appreciated and very informative um that we'll move on to our agenda which is the consent agenda and we'll entertain motions okay uh I move to approve all consent agenda items listed in consent agenda consideration of accounts Personnel reports students and minutes of previous meeting as presented second moveed by Adam second by Jill questions concerns debate fantastic I will add a folks notice on the consent agenda a number of uh donations from the Etha public education itive that support the kids discover Trail another phenomenal program in our community uh that we know
025would not happen without the great generosity of that organization so we're very thankful uh that our community and our young people get a chance to experience the variety of uh field trips that they were to go on so thank you greatly for that and with that being said we'll call the question all in favor motion passes unanimously thank you very much uh we'll continue on with agenda and that brings us to uh the superintendent report Dr Brown hey thank you for the opportunity Professor Bradwell um I have quite a few items and first and most importantly um and and importantly uh thank you for your approval of the ratification or we have a contract with our ethical principal and Directors Association and uh shout out to the leadership of that Association and their support and
026it was I hope it was with to come we're going to have another successful negotiation with ITA but we had a great conversation with ipda and you have a contract for the next two years with them and that's of note so thank you so much for approving that this evening um also it's always good to hear from my high school students um to hear about the joy and the Brilliance and Excellence that's happening in your buildings if I may I would love to elevate the joy and Brilliance in our middle schools right now uh the math counts team I think they call themselves math math math they swept the awards that this most recent uh math counts um uh performance I think that was in down state somewhere so they I think first second third
027fourth fifth sixth seventh and eighth place finishes on our team um and that if you if you look I think we'll have a news story out there but to be a part of our math Council team is pretty important and to have our folks sweep the awards was pretty impressive over the weekend in addition and you know at Boon I hope folks had an opportunity to go out see go see how to survive a Shakespeare play and I think the house was packed on both evenings so a shout out to the folks at Boon um wow how to survive a shakes I wish there was a how to survive a Kendrick Lamar concert at halftime too for folks um as I was Jing with my team ear because a lot of folks need that right
028now too but anyway uh shout out to the bo folks for an outstanding job with their performances communication um if I may because Karen thank you you reminded me uh to speak more about our communication protocol which is noted on our website and you quickly went to uh the superintendent being there but I would like to highlight underscore for folks there many other levels prior to calling the superintendent um and I would also remind folks uh if wishing to say something about an organization whether it's an organization of five employees or 50,000 employees communication is something that you will always be able to speak to because it's something every organization is working to continuously improve and if you find a a or an organization that's doing communication perfectly let me know because I think they
029would be steady because I think often times we get caught up in perfect Communication in an era where communication demands or ever more present or evolving so I just would ask folks that provide constructive feedback and uh thoughts on how to be better and more timely as I think about the board's investment and Communications here and the metrics in which we track everything from website clicks to news stories to the ways in which we engage with families how those metrics have significantly enhanced and improved over years and I'm also thinking about how folks want more and as I'm thinking about uh just some of the things we heard this evening around Transportation I'm thinking about the transportation department I'm thinking about Chris Sportsman and about the three people who are running a transportation department that's
030the largest one in central New York 64 routes and about 85 employees in a little building that's about the size of this room right now and thinking about being down there uh when the phone is ringing and you can barely get through because the phone is ringing so often for folks want to know particularly on the day when it's snowing folks trying to get through and I'm thinking about ah yeah when we have breakdowns because with that many buses running at any given point you can ask folks that kecap this there going to be some mechanical issues and by the time a driver assesses the eal issue and what may have happened or is not happening with that bus make sure the young people on that bus are safe and okay then to contact the
031folks in the office to say yo we're going to be here for a while and then to radio down to the transportation department to get a bus on the way back up there or to get up there to replace the one or get kids trans we're about 30 minutes in already before we can even begin to take the 15 minutes to send out a text message to all families so if folks who are wondering where their baby is which I would be to if if there's a 30 minute or 45 minute delay you can call use a transportation protocol most of our families have a phone number a mobile number or text they can text the principal I'm thinking about uh Miss Granger Miss humble these administrators who give their phone numbers to people to
032text or call if you have a question particularly about where your child is those are things you can access in that 30 or 45 minute range or call the transportation department a lot of things you can do as far that are consistent with the communication prot call in of waiting to talk to the superintendent or the board so communication we want the constructive feedback but I will ask for folks as Grace and your patience as we try to get to Perfection knowing that we may never get there but recognizing we're we're doing the best we can and then I will speak we are getting a communication we've received I have and I'm sure the board has as well a lot of emails from community members call from Community MERS conversations in Wegman about uh responses
033or statements in response to Federal Executive Orders and I know we we spoke about it a little bit but if I could add a bit uh I remember a convocation two years ago on stage I talked about the academic Journey versus the authentic one and when on an academic journey in places like ours we do a lot of statements I'm coming from a town where we did a lot of statements typ I help a lot of folks in my former Town write statements about statute and the presence of statues in places in our community and after years of writing statements about those statues they finally came down and my dad who lived there who's lived there 80 84 years he said no statues came down nothing changed around here so I I believe in statue
034in statements and I recognize the need for them at times but please know that the authentic work which is about the instructional design the pedagogy the policy shifts the work that you do every single day to change culture and change the experience and create a sense of belonging that's the most important work and so as folks are writing to me asking for a statement I remind them about the authentic work that's everywhere including our website if you want to know how what is our response to executive orders that are asking us not to see the humanity of the young people we serve you can look on our website around the and and find the anti- marginalization curriculum that speaks to how we will validate and affirm your preferred pronouns if you have questions about the
035ways in which we uh select text to put in front of young people I would ask you to look at our website look at the New York State Standards look at the New York State culturally responsive sustaining framework and look at how we have on the covers of our text more and more images of people of color and from different backgrounds than animals see there's many ways in which we are validating affirming and centering the experience of our young people that is lawful because we're following the law it's compliant and it's consistent with the state standards and the Frameworks that we have committed to doing in this great organization in New York state so I hope our actions speak much louder than any statement and there will be a time for a statement but please
036know we're focused on and spending most of our time on the work and if you see us not doing something that validates and affirms the humanity and experience of every young person we serve let us know um and we will respond uh in a statement when it's necessary thank you Professor for the opportunity to share I appreciate that Dr Brown uh and I will follow up to the folks who have been emailing us you will get a response uh this is the first time the board has had a meet in two weeks and so uh it would not be wise for any board member to respond without us having some time to share space together to determine what our path forward is and so uh for anyone who has emailed please know a response will
037be coming your way shortly uh let's continue on with our agenda if we can uh we have the privilege of uh having uh TST Bose's presentation and welcoming back a longtime Community hero uh Lily tallits and I'm sure uh Tim Parson my apologies yeah that's what I said please come join us my apologies for messing up the me good evening hi everyone good to see you all again thank you so much for having us for those who don't know me I'm Lily talit I get to serve as the district superintendent for Tomkins senica tyoga bosies and with me is someone with a wonderful heart and who has been doing this work for many years a fabulous colleague as well let him introduce himself I am Dave Parsons assistant superintendant for the administrative uh services at
038TST bosis and tonight we're going to get to talk a lot about Bose's numbers feel free to interrupt us ask us questions that you may have uh because although this is really focused on a budget report we do a ton of programming up at bosis to support young people and to support our Brer community and we'd love to talk more about it if you have any questions oh thank you jve appreciate it all right Perfect all right so you're going to see a great number of numbers uh that I'm happy to explain that are throughout this slide so Rada raise your hand if you're familiar with Rada this is a real fun New York State term lovely I see some people in the audience thank you all right so this is resident weighted average daily
039attendance and so New York State the New York State education department determines this for every single school district and it's based on Resident weighted average daily attendance so there's a combination of wealth ratio Etc um in the number of students um who attend then you'll see that next number down that 43 3.08% that's the amount that Ithaca represents in all of the Tomkin senica tooga bosis region right so we have about 10,877 students um itha represents about 43% of that and then that next number down that 43.5% that's how much money Ithaca receives back on every dollar that you spend here through uh through bosis um for anything that's aidable a couple of other highlights here a great number of students who attend Career and Technical education or what's what you see up there that
040says CTE that's everything from culinary to welding to heavy equipment I mean you'll see the current three-year average is quite a bit lower than that so there's been some adjustments in terms of the number of students who are attending from Ithaca and that projected three-year average you see will be increasing um in alternative education and alter uh special education you'll see uh not fully whole numbers and those have to do with services that bosis provides to students who are Ithaca students in relationship to special education services that can really run the gamut in addition to alternative education yeah Cadman good to see you sorry about the bills this season please no I'm a hardcore fan man you know that I'm I'm gonna pretend I didn't just hear that so can you sorry could you describe
041the difference between special education and alternative education yes great question so special education so uh there's a federal law called idea uh idea so that's the individuals with disabilities Education Act there are 13 categories of disability that are uh within that and in New York state there are students who receive special education services uh through bosis not always through bosies it could be through District as well um but we provide programming for those students who have disabilities as per those categories um some of those are on our campus some of those are um in other places or maybe we provide itinerant services and things like that and then alternative education so we have a regional alternative school and it's a high school that's a smaller environment again it's on the campus that's right across from
042ditt middle school that provides much smaller class sizes but provides uh still a high school education does that help cool um and then pek is another uh program that provides a number of Pathways for young people in uh in technical careers and it's located at TC3 and kids take TC3 classes and uh many come out with and Associates the current contract amount for itha is about 22.2 million every year so that's how much Ithaca spends at Bose um and overall sometimes you will see the percentage of both services and that total percent of of ourada that second number you might see those to be exactly the same especially if we're talking about a smaller School District um but for a larger School District like Ithaca you're able to provide a lot of a wide range
043of programming for young people so you might not see those precisely reflect one another right any questions about this slide cool all right we're gonna keep going all right so this is the program budget these are all based on initial service requests so this process happens you may have heard somewhat about this you will see this is from all nine component districts and these are all of the requests that you'll see so career in Tech education you'll see there's some increases why is that up 6.67% that's because more students are joining uh career in Tech education also things like supplies have gone up U materials they're just more expensive and we have contractual obligations with our teachers similarly with exceptional education those are really with the teacher contract itinerant that's the third one there that
044tends to fluctuate it really depends on students individualized education uh plans or IPS so what Cadman and I were talking about earlier young people with disabilities um and sometimes those are um those are also for things like you'll see up there Spanish or English as a new language Etc um and then instructional Services has stayed about the same instructional support has gone down and non-instructional support has gone up we may see some of these things change these are initial service requests so we build the budget and then oftentimes what we will see from school districts is we'll see coer increase requests and then our job is to be super Nimble and try to and try to meet the needs of the young people and the educators um sometimes throughout the year um you'll also see
045some decreases in Cross contracts those are for services or things that are specifically offered uh by other bosies we don't pretend to be experts and be able to do absolutely everything um and there are some bosis that specialize in say um instructional technology um contracts Etc and they vet all of those so you'll see um the those are those are the bosies that that sort of take that work on questions here all right our total budgetary change over our entire organization you're going to see 1.97% change increase so that's a decrease in instructional support decrease in Cross contracts increase in exceptional education and an increase in career in Tech any questions about that I'm going to turn it over to Dave who's going to get to talk about the admin budget and more thank you
046sorry we tried to fix it so this one's a a tough one to read um it shouldn't look like that but uh as we know uh being in the service business uh people business our B biggest SU expense our salary INF fringes um because we are in that people business but if you see uh like the increase uh for salaries those are contractual our our inre increase for next year for our budgets uh for salaries is about a 4.79 and if you look remember back in the exceptional Leed that was about that same thing um so contractual was driving that our health insurance for next year uh I've budgeted for 8.24% um our increase for the health insurance plus any retirees so as as folks that retire that are uh entitled to have insurance and
047retirement I have to budget for that so that's what drives that number uh retirement for let for next year actually the TRS is down a little bit for next year so that's certainly helping our budgets um to drive drive some of those costs the other benefits that you'll see you'll see actually a decrease of a 045 and one of the biggest drivers of that is our uh unemployment or U workers comp insurance we're in the workers comp Co-op ethic is in that one and because we've had some pretty good years and we've got the money to do it we're now able to hold back on our rates so uh we actually had a negative rate increase for next for this year and for next um so that's certainly helping our budgets uh in the in
048that process any questions yeah da thank you very much my apology for I've been called worse H how is the um you know an 8.24% increase in health insurance is significant in an organization how has that been tracking over you know previous years or what projection is for future years um so our Co-op we're looking at a 6 and a half to 7% increase in in the rates um but like I said I also have the increase and you'll see in the next couple of slides for our uh retirees um but that's just what what the rates are um some of it's driven by the rates some of it's driven by people that used to have single policies or no and then because their insurance or their contracts say they can have it so I
049always have to look at where are we with that and we are we going to have enough for next year so it's not an exact science because it's not driven specifically on the rate increase yeah thank youate so our Capital bu budget uh is actually made up of two different sections one is the um uh rent uh that we pay so we do rent some space for our Educational Services uh we actually rent space next door in the ic3 so our uh young adults uh for the Early Child uh program they're actually embedded in that program over there and we rent a space from them the rest of the rent that's in there is actually for our adult ed program um there's about uh about a h 100,000 in there for our adult dead programs
050I have to budget it in this one but you actually won't be paying for it because when that bill comes the adult dead reimburses this budget and we pay it out but by Statute I have to budget it in this one and the other part of that is about 300,000 that we put in this capital budget for ongoing projects rather than to wait until we've got a big project we're trying to do the smaller ones as they come like Windows and things that we can do on a on a smaller scale rather than wait until we've got a big one to do our Reserve accounts uh actually on the next slide you'll see what Reserve accounts we can have but bosies actually cannot have an unappropriated fund balance so what the way it works for
051bosis is when we we we Bill all the districts for the services and at the end of the year we figure out what are were all of our expenses and anything that's left over we send back in a refund those come back to the districts in November of the of the year after so we close our books June 30 do all the calculations make sure all the bills are paid everything that needs to get done and then we do refunds to the districts in November of the following year so we have no unappropriated fund balance that we can use to try to help the budget the following year the reserves that we can have and these are the audited numbers from last jul uh June 30 uh because we are self-funded for the unemployment we
052have a reserve for that the flex and and insurance one what that is is uh when the when employees or retirees and keep in mind that this is as of June 30 of last spring retirees quite often when they're paying their insurance they'll give us their check for the whole year so that goes in this it's actually not a reserve but it has to go somewhere so that it gets stuffed in this one the other one that's in here is the flex spending so anybody that signs up for flex spending that our flex spending year runs from September through August so whatever money is setting there in the end of June that's where it has to be so that actually is more of a a liability than it is a reserve but that's where they
053tell us it has to be so the CTE Reserve uh actually when I started at bosis we had nothing in this one we had the reserve started but we didn't fund it and the way that one is funded is we use the depreciation of the equipment that we buy so we're always what we're always trying to do is make our budgets as smooth as possible to get away from the the spikes um it's a it's a killer to the districts uh in the in the business office and you don't want them to look like me um to try try to figure out what do we do about spikes so we're always trying to make our budgets as smooth and level as possible so with the CTE Reserve what we do is we buy a piece
054of equipment depreciate it over 10 years which is it's called depreciation but we use that money that uh is technically being depreciated and put it in a reserve so the next time we need to buy a piece of equipment that's expensive we don't just put it in the budget we can take it out of the reserve and then we re we fund that again over a level 10-year funding uh uh process our ERS and TRS reserves again they were uh not very much when I got here actually TRS didn't exist uh that actually was only created the last five or six years so we're trying to fund those when we can so when times are good we're putting money in those when times go bad we'll take it out again we're trying to keep our
055budgets as level as possible uh to our districts any questions with that one because that's our that's the reserves that we can have so the administrative budget is the one that you folks as board members and all of your colleagues in the other eight districts get a get a chance to vote on you will you folks vote on it just like your taxpayers vote on your budget for your district for your for your budget here so we spend a little bit of time with this one um and the salary in Fringe you can see that's certainly gone up we've got contractuals in there um the rest of them are pretty steady the the two that always stick out in this this budget are the the uh ran interest we do borrow our budget every year
056and thank you for a couple of years ago uh allowing us to to continue to do that and hopefully that uh produced a lot of Rand or interest money uh we we brought about uh 500,000 into the bosies that we give back to you in refunds uh in the following year uh because we're doing that and I know the districts take that money that they don't pay bosies until May and invest it and make interest on it so that's a way to get Revenue without having to go to the taxpayer uh so we certainly thank you for for continuing that process the retire benefits um anyone that retires from TST bosis that is entitled to have insurance and retirement by Statute has to be in the administrative budget so whether they retire from CTE or
057maintenance or I don't care where they retire from that expense has to by Statute be in the admin administrative budget so that's always a big one that sticks out um we will I will have to say that some of the things that we've put into place in our contracts has has started to make that not be so steep it's started to level off uh some things that we've done in our contracts to help help uh alleviate those that growth you'll notice that it's not a very big change this year and probably in the previous years you've seen some substantial change there every year or two or three I look at this and say do I really need that much anymore if you know folks no longer need the insurance and I hate to say it
058any other way but there's comes a point that people don't need it and at that point I can I can adjust that and not increase it uh quite so much so given all of that we're looking at about a 1.95% increase in that budget that's I think the if not the lowest close to the lowest I've done since I've been here and this is my 17th time doing this um the interest like I said five minutes ago we made about 500 but I don't budget that much because my crystal ball is broke and I don't know what it's going to be for next year so I'm always going to budget for the worst case scenario and hope for the best uh so I actually only budget around 200,000 in that one another 3,000 in miscellaneous
059revenues so if you take what we've uh looked for for uh rates for next year for the budget itself subtract out the revenue that I can pretty much plan on uh we're looking at about a 2.01% increase in this particular budget but like I said this is the one that you folks get to vote on so any questions by all means ask so that you're not wondering what what's up with this one all set so uh sometime between April 16th and April 30th you folks will vote just like your counterpart and all of the other districts uh you'll vote on two things one is the administrative budget that we just went over and uh representatives for the TST bosies uh board from cander dren and George Jr um so th those will be out for
060you to vote on on the 23rd of uh April any questions well we certainly do appreciate you folks allowing us to come in and take some time out of your board meeting for TST bosies and we appreciate everything you do for all of our kids thank you before just make sure any questions board members we would probably be voting on this on April 29th uh which is just under the wire but that's our next scheduled meeting in between our breaks and everything else but this is the opportunity to ask folks right if we can do it earlier we will uh this is the time for any board members to ask any questions and D say it's also an opportunity to ask any questions a little more about the amazing programs that bosei supports ICD students
061well I had to go back to last year's presentation to do the comparison and it looks like um the expenses increased by like 6.85% from the year before to last year and now it's just a slightly over 1% right this year so that looks good some of that some of what's Driven that is the um the TRS rates not going up actually they're they leveled a little bit TRS is uh their rates are based on a fiveyear rolling average so when the when the stock market is doing well then the rate that we all have to pay into the TRS levels off and and goes down so but the nice thing about TRS is it's on a 5-year rolling average to get away from those spikes RS is not um so I anticipate if the
062stock market does a little bit better again next year we may see a reduction in our ERS rates but they dropped like that much from last year not not a significant amount but TRS did drop enough to to see an effect in our budgets Dr Brown just a quick thing thank you all for such a clear and concise presentation I've sat through quite a few of these and and your year- toye increase um is welcome as we're putting together our budgets right now so thank you and also thank you to Mr Granger Brad you put in hundreds of hours of work um on that board and in that community and I see what you do I just see you in general after spending close to two decades down here you then volunteer now to do
063that work so I appreciate you thank you hi everybody I'm G to try to word this correctly because a lot of people ask me how the funding of students works you know itha has a budget we pay bosies for students so is each student a different cost pending needs like how does that actually work out when you do a breakdown of what icsd is paying I think I understand your question can I try I'll try to reflect it back so are you asking about how each program slot is essentially generated I guess so right like we and if you go back to the slides and you look at like the 43% that itha is part of your budget right was that remember that number correctly 43 something uh to of the total arada but it's
064only about 35 in change of the toal total budget so Ithaca accesses 35% of our total budget okay across the nine components and So based on okay I guess that's and So based on student need right so if we're sending a student over there and I like an example would be one of my own kiddos right and say they need one toone support so does each student that you send is it a different cost that participating districts pay per student like how exactly does that break down if an ICD student is accessing Bose's services at Bose yeah so each program uh so if you see the guide to Services we'll send you more if you need them but each program is attached to uh coer code so you might see you know professional development is
065is in the 505s and it's this is how a district can pay pay into it um so it might be uh connected to ourada it might be threeyear rolling average um and it might be specific to the particular program and the particular student need um so something like um I'll give an example so for ptech uh gosh but TST started a PTEC program was it 10 10 or 11 years ago now eight it was eight years ago perfect so eight years ago um we said okay here's going to be here is the cost per student to start and it's going to shift over time because we're trying to build a program um so everybody would buy in and there was a base cost plus the cost per student and that started to shift once we
066built up the program so again it totally depends on the program it totally depends on the student um and for students who receive special education services there's high cost Aid there's stack there's there are things that are specific to the student that the district actually ends up billing through Medicaid um and then and then receives that uh money back I think maybe it's a complicated question like it's there's a methodology of splitting the bill for every coaster so the administrative budget is based on our W so we say that Ithaca is 43% of the budget so you'll end up paying about 43% of the cost of the administrative budget when you get into CTE it's tuition-based it's how many students did you send times the tuition the tuition is the same for all same way
067with the exceptional Ed the tuition is the same per student it's just a matter of how many do you send um with garbage it's based on how many tons we pick up and take to the to the dump for you so that's a that's a a use charge the print shop is a use charge how many pieces of paper did we run through it's a click charge so each coaster has its own cost methodology for billing the to to charge the bill um so there's our y there's percent use there's FTE there's um tuition there's I and I'm sure there's more that's those those are the ones that I can think of but there is a methodology of everybody that participates in a particular coaster how are we going to split the bill right so
068each program is really different and Staffing is different in each program so the cost of each program is different yep okay and it and the people the districts that are participating are the only ones that are paying I will add to you that the money that uh districts receive back Can Depend as well so there are some services that are aidable and there are some that are not which you know I've been in this job for how many days now I don't know like 120 maybe uh and um and so I'm I'm still learning all of the all of the ins and outs of all of the things that are are permitted you know we're permitted to uh put through a coer that is then that generates that 43 cents on the dollar back so
069things like rubbish pickup that actually can't generate any Aid that's just a Flatout cost and districts never re receive anything back on it Dave was just talking about click charges for printing that's aable but the physical paper because that's not shared can't be right so there's just a whole slew of fascinating laws uh that we get to follow to AED because it's stacked Aid um transportation is not Bose's Aid because it's better to have transportation Aid it's higher you get more money back does that answer your question I mean I think it would take a few more years to answer all my questions that answer can always invite us back I'll text you well I think it's thank you for the presentation I think it's a good reminder that we're talking about New York State
070and Bose is a New York state entity and since we love using acronyms right the board of Cooperative Educational Services and so you both are using kosers which is a Cooperative service program and the idea being that oftentimes it is much more economically efficient to combine resources to provide programs for folks and so that's what Etha does with our eight other fellow component districts is use those services and I'm more talking to our community to make sure folks understand how this operates and so part of the ICD budget to support Learners within ICD is to cooperate with other eight other component districts to give them the services that we need and that's the total $22 million while we are being asked to vote on the administrative budget of6 million and change um so I think
071it's important for our community to understand part of that process as well of how we get there uh other states don't operate with uh iosis as we do it's a you know we know for folks who work with other people from other states know that this is a very New York approach well with that being said thank you all very much I'm sure if we have questions please do send uh the uh document you mentioned I just forgot what it was called guide to service guide to Services thank you very much appreciate it thank you good folks good to see everybody again absolutely we will continue on with our agenda which is an update from the finance committee that happened earlier today at 4:30 pm uh we had a finance committee led by Dr block
072and I'll ask Dr block to give us an update uh from that meeting so this is an update from a meeting as Dr Bradwell said that took place just a couple hours ago I haven't had time to fully let the information percolate through so I'm going to for the benefit of those who weren't there and many of my colleagues were there so I'm going invite them to jump in if I'm misremembering things uh but it was a a finance committee meeting that's centered on a visit by Mr Jay Franklin who runs the assessment office in topkins county and he had some to me at least some unexpected big news on how assessments are going to be done uh for the next four years so forgive me I'm just going to back just say a little
073bit about just to remind everybody about the finance process what this board will do in a couple months is propose a budget that we're going to spend this amount of money uh we will then take that budget to the voters the voters will approve it or not approve it if the voters approve the budget then from the budget Federal and state aid is stripped out and other Aid and what's left then is a bill that goes to the residents of this community and that bill is divided up amongst the residents of this community based on the fair market value of real estate assets they own okay so as a taxpayer so there sort of two things that could come at you one is the size of the tax levy the total bill that we're putting
074on the community and that's approved by the community Through the vote and then of that tax levy your share as a homeowner right or as a renter through your through your rent uh that you're going to Bear generally the part of the bill that's attributable to this board and the public vote is modest meaning in the single digits we might increase our budget 3% or 5% or 6% but you at least in my knowledge it's always been so 1% right not not not single digit single yeah sorry sorry sorry sorry single digit increases um what happened last year though is that the way that I think initially our budget was like a 6% increase but the way that budget increased by 6% was going to be passed on to homeowners changed a lot because of
075changes in the assessments some people saw saw their real estate assets go up a lot other people saw their real estate assets Hold Steady or even go down so that caused a double digigit change in many people's Bill particularly if you were a single family homeowner you saw 20 25 30% increases in your bill nothing to do with the budget that this board proposed and the public voted on but because the way that bill was divided up uh those of you who are winners in the real estate market kind of got hit with a heavier tax bill so that Cate caused a lot of understandable concern uh the volatility the tax bill something that people have difficulty preparing for I think in response to that in response to other factors um the assessment office uh
076is going to go a different direction for the next four years uh and what that means is that for the next four years the assessment office is not going to attempt to measure what they call what it calls Market changes so they're not going to go look at the southill neighborhood or the Northeast neighborhood or this neighborhood or that neighborhood and say well houses in that neighborhood went up this amount or that amount and then update everyone's assessment based on market conditions they're not going to do that at all between now and 2029 so the only change not that it's a final decision as Jay said it has to go to the legislators and he was given an idea due to the new software that they're getting in place yeah thank you Karen so the
077the asteris on this is that this is what Mr Franklin as the Director of the office is proposing and it's subject to approval by Tomkins County Legislature uh he's proposing a transition to say short a better system which will be online in 2029 so between now and then then he is not planning on overlaying Market changes to properties now he will make changes to properties that are based on physical changes a demolition a renovation a new construction merges of properties things like that but my understanding of what he's saying is that if you own a house in the neighborhood and it's worth assess today at $300,000 and it doesn't fall down and you don't improve it for the next four years years it's going to be assessed at $300,000 even if you sell it for
078$400,000 that that the sale is not going to update the price so unless you renovate it or demolish it or make a fiscal change to it between now and 2019 2029 the assessed value is not going to change so what that means then going back to people's tax bill is taxpayers are still going to be subject to variations in the budget propos and the voters approve but again that's typically single digits but unless you renovate or demolish or do make a physical change to your home you're not going to be subject to what is your share of that new budget you're going to be protected from that until 2029 now if I can editorialize on that a little bit there's good and the bad in that perhaps uh the the good on that is that
079it gives you predictability your bill is not going to change that much because unless you know unless this board moves away from single digigit changes in the budget which I don't think it's going to do you're probably looking at similar changes in your tax bill so the predictability is good what's arguably bad about it is the Precision you know if we think we want to be precise in measuring the value of homes to be Equitable and charging people what their homes or their properties are worth we're not going to see that Precision I mean even if your own home sells for you know $100,000 more there's not going to be an update so um Dr Bradwell maybe I stop there what am I forgetting to say is that a is that is that a fair
080summary did others who were here want to summarize that differently the only addition I would say is that uh Jay Franklin said uh without changing significantly assessed values uh with new properties for that were coming online quote unquote with abatements that may be ending that there could be an expectation of the overall tax base increase of about one to one and a half% so with no additional just with new construction new development that we that the board or the community can anticipate that the completely assessed value of was it 7.4 billion dollar I may have the number wrong I apologize but somewhere 7 something billion dollars that that number itself would increase by about 1% over the next couple years that that would probably be predictable but beyond that you are correct that no significant
081additions to assess value as we've been experiencing for a little bit of time Adam I thought you you were were see no no I was just agreeing and nodding my head and then just thinking that um but then in 2029 when there's then there'll be some new data out and it's possible that people could see increases at that time but that there'll be some stability until then yeah and I mean Dr Kant wise asked a question about you know the house that goes up $200,000 in a hot neighborhood and it was good question and the answer is no right it's the the assessments are not going to change until 2029 I would just though I want to second time tonight want to put a bright Line in the Sand mark your calendar you heard it
082here if I am on this board on July 1 20129 please do not come and stand here and say I didn't see a change in my assessment coming I'm tell right now there's probably going to be a big change in assessments I don't know what there'll be but there's going to be a big change if if he holds everything steady for four years when the clock ticks 2029 for sure there's going to be some big changes and you know he he can't pause the volatility forever so you know if if if you can't take that risk don't own property in Tomkins County you know get rid of it between now and then but with one additional cop he he did make mention of the um housing bubble bursts I believe he used your 1988 where
083between 1990 and 1997 uh housing assessments actually decreased in Etha what we've experienced since covid is a significant unsustainable increase in housing prices and housing values so I say that as to say there's nothing to say that houses will maintain this current level they can in fact go down that is a possibility unlikely but it is a possibility and we've already experienced in the past 30 years in our community but to Dr Block's Point uh it was very clear that as they are able to uh as they are able to transition to this new program which Jay Franklin seems to be very excited about to be a much more accurate program and modeling for the staff to be able to assess homes in various ways that for the time being they're going to be spending
084their time populating that new software and then there will be some changes in 2029 whatever that may look like and I would also like to Echo I will not be on this board in 202 um and I will put a mark in the sand uh so you did hear that Nicole that's my spouse um uh I we we the community should be prepared for whatever that is or be paying attention to the market as that takes place um and then lastly what I'll say is we know we have some conversations that was one of the finance committee meetings meetings that I absolutely recommend folks go and watch uh board members asked phenomenal questions uh garri did a great job of facilitating that meeting and giving space and Jay Franklin gave some pretty clear and precise
085information about what that looks like moving forward it'll be essential for our community to know that as the board plans a budget with that particular factor and not just this year if that's the factor moving forward for the next couple years that will have a significant imp impact on the tax levy that the board puts forward as well so it is um I think we spent about 45 minutes maybe 50 minutes on that conversation alone it's 50 minutes of the community's time that is worthwhile to better understand that assessment process and he did go through how they assess properties as well which would be instructive for people to know and again not just homeowners it impacts rent it impacts a whole host of things so I I would I would recommend that any additional comments
086from board members so that was part of the update we wanted to make sure folks have knowing that everyone will be watching that finance committee so we wanted to give an update at the board meeting and a plug to go watch that finance committee it it's riving television I'm telling you fantastic thank you very much Dr BL I appreciate it um that will bring us to our last agenda item there are two policies that are on the agenda we're going to ask Dr Dan bryman to come down and join us um and this is policy 1 15000 public use of school facilities uh this came up from a number of folks uh been having conversations I know Jill and I have had some conversations uh I know Karen and I have had some conversations Adam
087and I have had I'm sure other folks have had conversations together as well uh there's a little bit of not a little bit a lot of community questions about the use of public facilities with uh Dan bryman's help we are trying to look at this policy and my colleague Emily Workman who's also on the policy committee is not able to be with us this evening um but we are having a conversation about how can we rewrite a policy that is not operating from a lens of pro being prohibitive but being from a lens of being welcoming and that is sort of a both a shift in language and hopefully a shift in policy and practice with that being said there's a lot of nuances like any policy is and so we've asked Dr briman to
088come here for board members if we get to a point in time where we're okay this would be for a first reading for a vote which means it would go back to policy to work out any additional questions we would not be voting to adopt this policy this evening no matter what takes place if it's not ready for our first vote tonight we still send it back to policy to do some work and we're anticipating um that there would be some questions that were asked to to Dr Brian specifically about some of the more nuances about how we make this happen so with that uh Dan welcome thanks my apologies let me say one more thing I interrupted you as you were talking I also want to thank you for the amount of work uh
089not just on this policy but we ask uh a very uh we're asking folks to do more work let's let's just acknowledge that we're asking a lot of folks to do more work you're one of those folks who are asking to do more work and you have spent an awful lot of time looking at the legalities the insurance the practices uh on this policy specifically so I wanted to acknowledge and honor that work in thank you for the time thanks Sean would you like me to summarize a little bit sure okay so uh for, 1500 public use of school facilities we wanted to write this more to welcome groups more to utilize our spaces so basically what we're looking at for not for-profit groups is if you want to use our space during existing hours
090where staff is present um that will come at no cost or very possibly minimal cost but if it's outside of contract hours which is predominately on our weekends because our custodians uh work very late um we will uh for not for-profit groups uh we will be charging a fee to cover um our cost for having a person there uh custodial Staffing um and we'll also have to find an employee to work uh on the weekends as well for uh not for profit groups uh we also I also have a companion policy here 1500r which talks about the process for reserving the space um we've uh we have added some more langu uh welcoming language about that you know we want to be available for the community for supporting educational activities um and ser serving the
091public good of course but of course uh events that don't interfere with educational activities and then for-profits I know I talked a lot about not for-profits but for profits they can use our space um um but because of uh our requirements um if they do do that 100% of the fees have to be donated to an educational charity of their choosing um so those are kind of the basics for the first policy and I can uh talk a little bit more about the second policy if you want me to as well would it be helpful for board members to hear both the policy as well as the procedure right or is it a regulation for us this is a regulation but anyway the idea being that that's actually how it would get enacted that's would
092you like to hear both of those simultaneously please do I know it's really exciting I'll be really brief okay um for the for the um it's it's the nuts and bolts of the policy but basically every organization that uses our space has to use a Master Library the ml system and in that system they create a login um they have to provide an upto-date insurance and then it's sent to uh our approvers throughout the system throughout our system system uh we have approvers in our athletic department in our fine arts department every school has approver um one of the things uh through the policy committee um there's been some great feedback about some things we could be a little bit looser on um one of the things was do we really have to have the
09314 days um so we added some language to say that we can make exceptions on a caseby casee um basis we do this already um we also talked about um we also talked about that even though um a group may use uh put in a reservation for a space uh District staff can till can still take priority in unexpected situations that have happened um with maybe field conditions where um if the field conditions aren't good on sweet field that maybe um the athletic event has to move on to the turf or something something like that so um those are the basics that's really probably as uh short as I can be about both policies happy to answer any questions I I have one I was I just was just having trouble coming up with examples
094or maybe you could just kind of explain this just the one part about the for-profit organizations yeah um like what's an example of a for-profit organization that would want to use District space to do something and then they would have have to donate all of the fees and proceeds to an educational charity like what I I was just trying to come up with an example it's if they're benefiting off the event say that again if it so a for-profit um let me try to explain this if a for-profit is using our space but then they're they're collecting fees to be on our property they're then profiting off of uh the taxpayer dollars and that is why that legally we're asking for them to make a donation because you can't profit off of um our fields
095and our that maybe that part I'm sure you understand that part yeah yeah but like what just in in historically what type of organization would come here and then make a profit and then I'm just was wondering that's hard because I don't want to name I don't want to I have I I think Doc is trying to save me here I have we have Den we have looking he's hoping no I understand I understand don't get in trouble but I think um I think I don't want to name organizations but we have certainly we have certainly talked through thanks D we certainly I can save you here I'll give you an example of a not for-profit organization okay that could easily be a for-profit organization so one of the joys of my family is every
096summer that there is a three onree basketball tournament that takes place in the high school parking lot okay that is a not for-profit organization but that could easily be a for-profit organization saying I want to hold this three onree basketball tournament and charge every team a fee to pay me and therefore I'm them profiting from it that that's an example for me that we may not currently face but could easily face or a for-profit theater company that wants to use our blackbox theater or you know you name it there's any number of organizations that would like to use District spaces because they're beautiful spaces and they provide the amenities that folks are looking for I don't think that this is a response to an exact issue I think it's protecting us should that ask ever
097come okay and that and that they couldn't profit from does that answer your question Adam y I think in a generic maybe a generic answer for me would be like um maybe an individual who is profiting off of their expertise um using our to it's very generic uh um through Co in or something and then just collecting a fee for that um that would that might be an example I'm not saying that has happened no that's a good course but that would be one example thanks yeah other questions board members may have comment yeah please Dan again thank you for your work on all of this I don't envy you having to do the work but um oh that's okay I I have no problem with what you've got at this point as far as
098groups I continue to struggle with how we as a district can be more welcoming to individual community members who want to play tennis on a Sunday morning who want to play pickle ball on a Saturday afternoon who want to run on the track at a time when school is not in session um because I think most of us grew up with that kind of facility AA able to us in our communities and it just felt right and I don't I don't know how we get around the liability issue but I hope we can continue to look at that as a way of opening at least those facilities the outdoor facilities during times when we're not using them in a way where we can continue to protect the facilities against misuse and perhaps uh also protect
099the people who want to use the facilities by I I don't again I know the particulars but I'm saddened that people who are walking by and see an unused tennis court during a time when school is not in session don't have the opportunity to use it um I have worked with some of those not to name which groups I'm working with but um obviously we're not going to play tennis at this moment in February but we are we are I mean maybe we would who knows but um I challenge you Dan no we won't we won't but um I am working with some of those groups um to figure out some solutions we can come up with um to have u a better better use not to not to get uh not to get into
100the specifics of it that would allow individuals to make see that's the problem group with with the with the tennis um I do believe we have a plan uh to have it more open when the weather gets better great as long as this approving this policy doesn't preclude looking at more creative ways to use I've met with representatives from the tennis community okay thank you yeah and um and then in terms of the track that is something we'll be working as well okay yeah if I may follow up with Jill's question so I'm not I have not been to a policy meeting I know you've talked about it so I don't mean to be redundant sure but I I'm just I mean I'm used the track at Lancing so I'm just confused and would like
101to know why it's such a difficult process when other districts allow use of their facilities um I think our facility and this has come up in some of the other meetings uh our our the track facility has a unique fuel site behind um the stadium that that we have to figure out how to we have to think about how to secure um and some vehicles but it has been that's one thing for why not we haven't just left our facilities completely open on the weekends when there we don't have any staff members um but those are some things we'll have to have to figure out um not I I don't believe you know a lot of our track facilities have that same maintenance area in the back okay um but I do think we can
102come up with some compromises um and it it would probably be easier for us to think about open time s when our staff are here during the weekday when we don't have to when we don't have to figure out um or or um identify staff who want to work as a volunteer on a weekend um but instead building on the Staffing levels we have Monday through Friday and thinking about times that our community uh can use the track during during the work week if that makes sense can I a little bit though sure sure I mean it feels like this is so overly complicated yeah and I wonder about like fencing in a lock yeah just because I mean with the amount of money that our community members pay in taxes not being able to
103go for a run on the track or play tennis or whatever seems absolutely ridiculous and I feel like we should be bending over to to making this more accessible for people sure agree um and I if I can I think I mentioned some things that our um policy committee meeting early on having the 15E look at this because 15 years ago um the spaces were wide open similar to what you describing in another Community um and things have changed things have evolved we also had uh front doors open in most F buildings at the time and at the high school 120 of them are open at the time things have changed and I got I need to remind everyone in the room and who's watching that um the tennis court the track the football field
104their learning spaces they're primarily used for physical education um and just like other learning spaces in our school district um it's our responsibility to make sure they're secure and I have been aw awaken in the middle of the night and someone has stolen a piece of equipment from the track I have been awakened in the middle of the night when someone has done something significantly inappropriate on the tennis court and if a young person were to see it on a Monday morning it would have been traumatic I have been here while things have happened during the school day well folks thought that that space was open like what you're describing and it became harmful to young people that I sered so yes I I wear that burden that we have to secure the space first
105and that will that requires us to make sure there's staff and there's coverage and uh yeah and uh there are liabilities I've been here when we've received notice of claims and have been shamed on Facebook because someone fell on the tennis court on the weekend and hurt their ankle and the school district is now liable for at the time I think that notice claim looked like $2 million so this issue is complex um and that's why when you say community the community and communication goes both ways I would be asking our community to help us and these spaces also right next to a state highway that has and you know I'll remind folks I've been here long enough to know that there was a swwa incident that happened on that state highway right next to
106that tennis court that could have impacted the adults and young people and had it not been secure there would have been an issue so not to be the downer here this thing is complex and we're trying to be as accessible and as inclusive as we can um next to a major highway at a time where there are all kinds of inappropriate things and dangerous things that happen in learning spaces so this policy is complex I think that's how we we got here right um I am much more aligned with Jill this is part of the conversation we had talking with individuals wanting folks to be able to have access to it at the same point in time as a school board we bear significant fiduciary responsibility primarily against some of those liabilities uh we've had
107our football field uh not just torn up before uh we've had folks throw rocks at the uh the scoreboard and and break pieces of it so the goal is it not is not to swing from one extreme to the other um and Aon I appreciate when you say it seems overly complicated I think we all agree it is overly complicated for a public space and at the same point in time I had to say to somebody else uh we don't allow folks just to walk into our schools which is also taxpayer funded folks pay a lot of money to have nice elementary schools and we don't say you can come in whenever you want so it's not I wish it were simpler I I honestly do I wish we had just hey we let's make
108this happen um I like Jill's approach let's not let's not write a policy that precludes us from being creative and thinking about how to get around some of these yeah um I think there are some solutions Dan is proposing some been exploring them talking with our legal councel I think what I want the community to realize is that the reason why we're even revisiting this is to try to find that compromise to say we recognize that folks want used to it and we want to make that access possible and we want to do it in a way that protects the district from liability and protects the spaces and protects our students and our staff and so I I wish it were I wish it was a more simple solution and maybe it is and I
109will say to people say to me all the time well um school districts around us all open their spaces and I say no some school districts do that around spaces there are plenty of school districts that also lock down their spaces more so than even we do so we're not we're right in the middle doesn't mean we're doing the right thing I just want folks to know that we're right in the middle of what you'll find across the state for use of a public school district spaces how we find those Solutions um that's why I was saying thank you to Dan who's been on the phone talking with other folks talking with lawyers talking with local school districts say how can we make this much more accessible um and I agree I want to see
110this tennis match between Jill and Dan on particular we don't take questions from them I'll just say d Susana Valley varsity tennis 1969 through 71 so you're quaking in your boots I can tell all I'm gonna say is Jill was this far away from taking the microphone out of its stand and just dropping it that that was quite close but to the community so maybe we'll do is we'll hold on to any first vote because we're not sure we're we're still working through this yeah we are hearing our board say that we want to try to find as much as much accessibility as possible yeah we'll continue to work on that we'll come up with some more solutions and bring it back sure to the board to then sort of vote on after we continue
111to do some more creative thinking and we will ask our community including students to give us some suggestions about how to do that moving forward as well so please do email me and we'll we'll take a look at what that can look at that can happen sounds great does that work board colleagues fantastic there are no other agenda items discussion uh upcoming what do you mean discussion items I I have a comment yes please comment at our um finance committee right before this we had the budget presentation on transportation and at that time we were informed formed that um a bus driver that we had had passed away thank you due to an illness and when I heard the name I had to go and verify if it was the correct name and it truly
112was this is a bus driver I won't say the name out publicly but this is a bus driver who has been with the district for over 10 years this was a bus driver for both of my children that my husband and I got to know this bus driver um this bus driver would greet us when we were at Wegman's during covid this bus driver was one of those individuals that drove around to make sure children got what they needed and families got what they needed so I just want to share my deepest condolences to the family of this driver and to the transportation department for the loss because it truly was a loss when last year when there was a lot of discussion about um student face in staff every staff member in this district
113is a student facing staff member bus drivers custodial staff cafeteria staff and and this bus driver looked out for my children when they came off the bus and I truly appreciated this individual for all they did and I am at a loss and I will definitely share with my children of the loss because they continued to talk about this individual after they had this person in middle school and it is definitely a loss for our district so my condolences to the family and to the transportation department too thank you yes thank you Karen we Echo those sentiments and we will bring our meeting to a close for tonight we'll see you all soon than thank good