CorpusRecord 235133

ICSD Board of Education Voting Meeting - Tuesday, January 28, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / ICSD Communications
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Tompkins County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,946 words · about 100 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001uh and Reporting I'm going to call the January 28th school board meeting uh into session and we will entertain motions I don't okay uh I move to enter into executive session for the purpose of discussing uh well it says for the purpose of discussions regarding proposed pending or current litigation ctive negotiations pursuant to article 14 of the Civil Service law and matters leading to the appointment employment promotion demotion discipline suspension dismissal or removal of a particular person or Corporation second move by Adam second by Jill any debate discussion questions hearing none we'll call the question all in favor the motion passes you here we will be back as close to seven as we can thank you good folks e e back from executive session we're returning to public session uh and I'm asking if there

002are any modifications to the agenda hearing none we'll continue with our uh agenda and that is brings us to public comment I believe we have two people sign up for public comment my apologies in advance if I mispronounce your name uh first we have someone joining us virtually Victoria craft locks and again please let me know if we've mispronounced your name hi can everyone hear me yes great thanks um hi my name is Victoria craft Lux and I'm a parent of two children at Caroline Elementary School I wanted to speak to the board tonight because I I do not understand why ICD did not delay the start of school today um I'd like to ask the board to update the policies and procedures Ford so that we do not have students and staff put in

003a dangerous situation like this again out on the roads the weather this morning was not extreme weather that had to our region unexpectedly which is what the text from the Transportation Department said when they announced all buses were paused at 7:20 this morning it was a predicted snow squall that the National Weather Service issued a hazardous weather outlook for Monday and again Monday night saying a band of snow squalls will move through the region overnight into the morning Rush Hour Tuesday a quick half to locally inches of snow could fall in less than an hour with blowing snow as well the National Weather Service then issued a whole series of snow squall warnings for Tomkins County starting at 5:30 in the morning um they were saying a dangerous snow squall is located along the line

004from Herkimer to near Newfield int Hazard intense bursts of heavy snow Gusty winds leading to blow snow and rapidly falling visibility impact travel will become difficult and potentially dangerous within minutes they listed Ithaca as one of the locations impacted and they gave more warnings at 6: a.m. and 7:20 a.m. um multiple districts around us announced a 2-hour Del delay as well DED and Lancing and Trumansburg all had a delayed start this morning we're extremely lucky that none of the school buses on the road were involved in the multiple accidents throughout the county caused by poor road conditions this morning um we ended up with buses with students on board pulled over for half an hour waiting for road conditions to improve and then students who had not been picked up yet were just told that

005bus service was resuming slowly and it was expected that they would wait outside indefinitely to get picked up by the delayed buses um the lack of information available on where and buses were or when they be arriving after Transportation resumed made it very difficult for parents to safely get their children to school um personally our bus stop is a 5 to8 minute walk from our house so all I can tell you about our bus is that it didn't get to the stop during the 40 minutes my husband and kid were waiting out there in our car before they gave up and drove in according to the stop finder app my child's bus this morning never drove most of the normal route um and the transportation number went straight to voicemail when I tried calling to

006understand what was going on I've heard reports from other parents of buses an hour late stop finder app wasn't working parents gave up waiting and drove their children in and some parents kept their children home because there was no safe way to get them to school um I do want to thank all of the bus drivers and School staff their best to keep our students safe during what I'm sure were some very stressful moments this morning but in closing I ask that you re-evaluate the ICD policies and procedures so that school is delayed or canceled when there is severe weather which makes it hazardous for students and staff to get to school and that the transportation clear Department clearly communicate with families when they can expect delayed buses to arrive at bus stops children shouldn't

007be waiting on the side of the road indefinitely in bad weather thank you thank you uh our next speaker is uh Jonathan Bates who I believe is inperson Hello uh Jonathan if you don't mind if we can have you come to the microphone just because people at home can hear you as well this right here please hello yes uh it's my first time here my name is Jonathan Bates I live in the town of Caroline um think I'm coming here with at least two hats the third hat I guess uh the first hat is a a child in the the school system um and the second hat is uh I'm on the town Board of Caroline um so I'm coming as a as a a public servant um like you all thank you for being

008here tonight um so a few people I'm connected with in community are very concerned about uh the threat of raids on the school system this is uh since the executive order has been uh put forth where schools and churches and other public places are now free game for federal raids uh I I noticed tonight there's a uh a resolution to pass a safety plan I don't know what part of that plan might address this issue but it's it's a it's a important issue to consider I did hear tonight that there were raids in New York on farms I'm I'm a I'm part of the extension service um and so it's already happening in our state it's already impacting our local businesses and people's families um and so just want to make sure that that's on

009your on your radar and that's an important thing to consider is a lot of people out there are very scared right now and uh I think it's important to address it uh as a as a school district so thanks for having me here tonight thank you John that is all the folks that are signed up to speak uh board responses fantastic uh part of this conversation we had so folks shouldn't think that there's no conversation going to take place part of it will be addressed in during the superintendent's report as well um and later in the meeting uh I'll give a a small statement about uh the question that uh Jonathan raised in regards to um ensuring the safety of our uh families and our communities and so uh both will be addressed it just

010may not be addressed right here at this point student reps welcome itha high school and Lacs hi um um I was also going to bring up something related to the buses uh this morning was crazy it must have been a true nightmare for the bus coordinators who had their hands very full getting every own safely where they needed to be um there were several bus delays which weren't communicated very well uh the messages that did go out were inconsistent and non-specific some buses arrived perfectly on time some arrived an hour or more late the people affected were not all specifically notified um and also notifications were only sent out to parents and not to the students affected um and lots of people's parents go to work earlier than the students got to school so the

011students were standing out there for a long time and they had no way of knowing that their bus would be late um this was chaotic confusing and a very cold experience um so if there's a default system for sending delay alerts to people uh I think it should be improved so that stud students received the alert themselves or at least a specific list of the delayed buses sent out to all students and caregivers because in that situation it's also nice to know if your bus will be right on time uh just to be able to plan on how to get to school uh Regents week went well 11th graders took the English Regents on Tuesday and seniors presented their math Pats I think on Thursday uh there were productive student Le conferences on Thursday and

012Friday and the sixth graders had a great week of half days I admired their science fair projects lined up in the upstairs hallway while I was there for my conference uh very sweet yeah um so going more into the Pats um recently English and science pbats have begun pbats are or performance-based assessment tasks are the ACs equivalent to the reg Regions exam um although you still need to take the English regions um so those are underway as Emily said seniors presented their math peats if they didn't to them last year Wednesday and Thursday I have quite a few friends who did it and they all p with flying College um so yeah and the Pat is it's a great opportunity to you know you know expand your learning and to really step outside your comfort

013zone and defend something that you created um so it's a very unique opportunity um yesterday we started our new semester um there's a variety of new classes underway specifically for middle school students um you know there's Shakespeare journalism food and culture and those are just a few of our humanities courses um and you know all things are looking pretty good as of now then finally um this week family groups have been reviewing slides around our mission statement at Lacs um for those of you who are familiar with it our mission statement is now 31 years old and I actually WR a proposal that would uh update it to better reflect our current Community um so those slides have been are being reviewed this week and next week and then there will be an ASM right

014before February break that goes more into detail um so as you might have heard the tech classroom trailers are done they're in and they're being used um we've received positive feedback all around but um one particular feedback is that the students who are in the band Orchestra and choir classrooms that have to walk to a building um are very happy now that the walkway is open because it was under construction and closed uh it just makes it easier and faster to walk to classes in the main building or vice versa um and also we are still unfortunately using paper plates and plastic utensils until more reusable ceries is delivered because they were being thrown out with the the trash um or broken by students so okay um just to add on to the technology classes

015so we finally moved in it's very happy and in these classrooms we have access to like waves 3D printers laser cutters and more although the printer is broken but it's currently getting fixed so um also the technology clubs in ICD like cod red robotics TSA and beex are hosting their open house on February 4th from 1: to 4:00 p.m. for all members of the community so for example code read as we're preparing for a competition in March we'll be hosting build tours so that kids and like parents can see us assembling the robot programming and doing CAD in real time there'll also be old robots driven by us and like open to the kids where people can ask questions about the robots and interact with them head on and um we'll also be setting up

016C cult stations volcano simulations and there's also be robots from Cornell coming up here and there's a lot more stuff so it's a great time for everybody to just like explore their potential interest in the stem field and so we highly encourage everyone to come we should have mentioned this earlier but midterm week went pretty smoothly um the four days there was a set schedule and I think it was followed pretty well and second semester started yesterday so um there's Al it's also peak season for a lot of clubs at iess um and so the music program there were there are students being invited um up at itha up um to itha college to perform um with students from all across our region and then they're going to put up put on a concert um

017so that starts on Friday and then um there's also going to be a Science Olympia tournament hosted at IHS this Saturday um so one of our teachers here is hosting for the whole Southern Tier and so we're going to have 20 schools come to our um school so uh that's great and we also want to say stuff about snow so it it was definitely a very snowy um and some like problems that my peers um were telling me about was standing at bus stops for 30 minutes um and having to go in nearby homes um just because it was so cold and then also barely arriving on time for first period when they were supposed to get here before zero period um and we understand that was hard to prevent because of sudden heavy snow

018coming around seven um but I thought that was just something um to mention and but I think the larger problem today was that the paths weren't cleared for um our school and so a lot of students are needing to exit buildings when they go to classes because of how our school is designed and the accumulation of snow especially in the quad was very difficult to get through in the morning and um also the sidewalks and the crosswalk between the parking lot and the bus lane um weren't visible this morning and so we're hoping just that area is cleared for safety and we were also G to ask um we were wondering what would happen if ice agents show up to our school or any building in the district and so we'll it we're we'd be

019happy to hear it talked about today hey everybody so couple things here first of all I finally have a recycling update we've basically been working together with Mr shine a tech teacher and Miss Hardesty our principal and it looks like we're going to be making a video shortly the outline has already been created and sent and it's going to be produced by a group of produ uh video production students within the next several weeks and then disseminated out to the entire School via a combination of the student Hub and asking teachers to pause class in the middle of what's likely going to be third period to show a very quick video about this the IHS Coral is soon to be taking a field trip to middle schools in order to spread excitement about music and

020join choir and these events are always really great and haven't been able to happen consistently since before the pandemic so it's nice to see them back the climate Justice Alliance will be attending a conference of other high school age environmental advocates in early March we will speak with New York State elected officials lobbying for the passage of certain specific elements of climate legislation there will also be a March in support of environmental reform and last year the district brought 16 students this year we'll be sending more than 30 students from IHS and Lacs combined so it's really blossomed into a bigger program the collaborative Solutions Committee of student council which I mentioned last time is uh has corresponded with counselors since the last meeting gained useful information about the scheduling process and is in the

021process of reaching out to middle school counselors in order to make that aformentioned instructional video to eighth graders about scheduling for high school and the general process by which you transition from your middle school schedules which have changed significantly over the past several years to a high school scheduling system great thank you student reps uh any board responses well just a question that we thank you all first of all a question that I guess we'll talk about later too is that what was brought up about um students telephone number being connected so that they can get delayed alerts and all so I I know that um we have like emergency numbers and caregivers on file but to put the students telephone number that's an interesting topic of discussion um I'll just follow up with uh

022my colleague Karen the first thing I wrote is like can we even text students uh but that raised a different question but there's other modes of communication so we'll follow up by that I'm sure we'll hear more during Dr Brown's presentation uh to Claire's Point um I I never miss an opportunity to say it um I still don't know why we built a California style High School in the Northeast uh it's been a topic of conversation for going on close 60 years now uh here we find ourselves but I can appreciate that thank you will follow up with that um I guess at this point in time it probably makes sense to say something about the question that Claire also asked in terms of uh what should happen should uh federal agents let's use that

023pH for the time being show up at ICD schools uh the Board of Education will be in dialogue with our legal council to figure out what is possible um at this point in time the commissioner of education and the governor has put out some guidance that law enforcement is not allowed to enter into school buildings without a subpoena however however legal Scholars are still working their way through the executive order to see if that guidance actually holds true so the question that I would say just as full transparency is we are working through it just like everybody else is we will figure out what our options are and we will find ways to let folks know as soon as um is appropriate and um is within the law of the land as folks who are

024elected officials and took a oath to the New York state constitution um it may not align with what our own personal values are but we're going to work our way through it and we'll have additional conversation as that as that arises um but it is without question on our radar and a number of us are actively engaged in conversations with Community organizations Community folks teachers who've been writing to us students parents caregivers um yeah this and some other of the executive orders are on our radar as well as impact students in our school district I just want to add one thing that I feel is um maybe a a source of happy and a really lousy day um yeah it's really snowy and I agree and that there are things that need to be cleaned

025up in our campuses and I want to also point out like when I am on our icsd campuses because I take my kids all around I see our administrators our building administrators I see teachers and everyone pitching in to clean up the sidewalks so I know it's in perfect but I also like that we have teachers and and and building leaders stepping up and and helping out and I think we should give them a shout out and show let them know we appreciate them definitely a difficult day and I'm sure we'll get to that here in a moment if there are no other board responses we'll continue on with the agenda um and that is brings us to the consent agenda and entertaining motions I moved for the approval of all consent agenda items listed

026in consent agenda consideration of accounts Personnel report students and minutes of previous meeting as presented second moved by Karen seconded by Emily debate discussion conversation hearing none will'll call the question all in favor I am uh abstaining and one exstension fantastic that brings us to the superintendent report uh Dr Brown there is a lot of questions that have been asked your way and so we'll rant as much time as as you need thank you for the opportunity to present uh Professor um first I we talked at uh human resource committee and other committees about our collective bargaining agreements and this year the need to negotiate with various um organizations and collective bargaining units um I just want to say publicly thank you to the leadership of those groups we've had very constructive conversations and dialogues

027and in some cases tentative agreement so thank you those are not easy to get to and when we get there um it's important to recognize it and a special shout out to uh kther Sena and her leadership team for the Etha Teachers Association we're in the midst of uh the process right now and I'll be the first to say I know she's going to follow up as well um it's a very constructive and Innovative approach to negotiations um we have agreed to have a open transparent and even public negotiations going forward and when I say public we mean public it'll be something I'm saying this very slowly so people will hear it it'll be something that would be live streamed and shared and recorded for everyone to see now that is and that's new and

028that's different but that demonstrates a commitment uh from one our teachers the leadership of their Association our leadership team and a community that expects transparency and want very open dialogues around these complex issues facing us all so that um thank you again for your leadership and I'm looking forward to the dialogues and I'm looking forward to folks watching Educators engage in constructive dialogues in a way that's civil and solving issues that are complex um I think we have an opportunity to model for folks how to do that in a way that is uh that's real and authentic thank you that's first thing we will the first session will be on February 13th from 9:00 am to 1 pm will be held in this room live streamed we will be sending out information about that session

029and others and get your popcorn ready all right um and give us feedback on it um give us feedback on the ways in which we engage with one another give us feedback on what you think about the deliberation give us feedback on all of that that's what a transparent open process is about and uh and we look forward to that and hopefully we will get to a good place in time for an agreement to be ratified by both parties that's the first one uh the second one if I may take some time to talk about uh because I think this will be the third time since the beginning of the school year that I've talked about uh weather and our transportation department and what Happ in the process that we uh we use to make

030determinations and decisions and let me step back um I I I carry the weight and Chris Horseman is another person the director of our transp the leader of our transportation department Mr van curan the folks we car the weight of traveling millions of miles with 64 routes and 88 plus buses every day it's fascinating to me having done this 15 years that we tend to only want to talk about those decisions on days when it snows or when it's cold but let's be clear what is predictable is that every day it's difficult to travel that much with that many people on highways often times with a bus load of young people screaming or steuding all right so every day I wake up with that pit in my stomach about what's going to happen or not

031happen on a bus there accidents on days when it's sunny on days when it's snow we can find ourselves in a ditch and the process that we use each and every day in particularly when we know there's weather coming or when weather comes in an unexpected way um we are talking to the Department of Public Works about whether or not they are we can travel or what they've done to prepare we're in touch with law enforcement we're in touch with the National Weather Service about what is predicted how long it will go when it will hit and if you're seeking Perfection from the National Weather Service and have you seen Perfection let me know all right um and we are talking to our custodians our maintainers we're talking to bus drivers who are up like

032myself sometimes 3:00 a.m. and for me I don't sleep on days when I know weather's coming and when the text come from Chris Horseman at 4: or 4:30 am we up very early out bus drivers who are committed to the young people of the school district traveling our school district in collaboration with a bunch of other entities as I said so the process is a robust one every day and particularly on days where we know weather is coming or where it's not so let me back up a couple of weeks because been it's been a while since we've been together and the last time I addressed this I think it was a part of our policy committee meeting when we were talking about the upcoming and at that time I think I remember saying if

033y'all want to take this one you can all right um but at the time we were talking about the policies of around emergency closing and I mentioned two things that are tough one around cold weather days and the other is around squalls because the squalls tend to happen I think I remember I'm saying at the time when those things happen I've been in 15 years if they happen in the hours between 6:30 and 7:30 it's a mess any other time before that or after that and I'll talk about why in a second is typically not a mess because well I me say now our buses we've already started by 6:30 and and when your buses have already started you have young people on those buses and we have a early start day where we have

034the largest geographic area as we're being compared to other school districts six routes versus 64 are very different and once you start 64 routes on that path it's hard to call that back let me back up even further when we are not in school or when school is delayed people don't eat people don't get paid and more importantly we don't have folks in front of our amazing Educators so I carry that weight every day on a cold weather day and this I'm going back five years now I think it was five years Emily when we did we closed for cold weather is it been five 2014 20 yeah okay I need my glasses and 2014 when we closed we had a long conversation about when we would close because of cold weather and it it

035was very clear the guidance from our health department and others around when we should consider it and it was because of windchill warning sustained winds of5 or below sustain winds of5 to below we talked about it and we would say we would then consider closing school because it was close cuz I knew at the time I had families in my ear saying if you close on these days kids GNA be cold all day at home because they need to go to school and in my house I don't have that much heat to keep them warm all day or I rather them be there or they won't eat so some people don't hear that I do so to close school because of cold it would have to be5 or below sustained I remind folks a few

036weeks ago when I was getting emails about why aren't we closing it was nowhere near neg5 or below so the guidance has been as clear as it can be on when we should do that when we should not and again I'm not referencing Facebook social media or any other place I'm going by the guidance and I've been clear about when we will consider it and at that time it didn't come close to us because and other school districts um have closed when their issues with their boilers or their school building had electricity issues or in cases like today when you don't have drivers to drive now this morning was one of those situations where a snow squall came in at a time that was problematic for us and our buers had already started and as

037I said at the last meeting this is not a perfect science I've asked even though I know I won't get it most times I've asked for grace and patience as sometimes we will make a decision that you may not like or sometimes it maybe just be wrong I wish I could be perfect here and today I was there's nobody in this community who was more emotional or upset or scared than I was when I was driving at that time knowing that I had 5,500 young people and families from all over the region who were on the same de on streets as I was so I feel you the day was if I had if I could look into something that would allow me to foresee the future I would have probably said two hours delay

038or closed but I didn't we didn't and it was based on the conversation I had with our transportation director at 4:30 then again at 5:30 and then again at 6:30 and that one at 7:30 was a tough one so that is the process I can talk about this with anybody who wishes to have a conversation about our processes the history the guidance we use the people we talk to and I will also say in this community I the emails I got today and the emails I've gotten over the 15 years there are folks in different places on this conversation and Continuum there are folks who want us to never close school and they had given me lectures as the person coming up from Virginia and the Southerner we don't close schools in this northeast because

039we shouldn't have to and some of those days when we at 14 or 15 so they still will give me the email saying you should never CL schools here some of you I don't want to call it old school but some people think like that and there's some folks who say Vis is a forecast of any type of bad weather whatsoever you close no matter what so we have folks in different places on this Continuum and I'm down for and please bring me the constructive conversation about all respective of where your belief systems are I want to hear that but what I don't want because the conversations and the emails today were very specific about me our transportation officials our director of Transportation who was out this morning was a great person that we don't

040care about kids or we don't care about your safety or we are doing this recklessly I'm going to interrupt that because that's one is not true and more importantly it's just mean so we care and I car that weight and I've been carrying for 15 years about safety of young people on our highways and byways and on trips and on snow days and I always will so I'm not going to listen to people talk about me or Chris or anybody else saying we don't care we do now we can beong wrong and I was wrong today thank you for the opportunity Mr Professor Bradwell thank you Dr Brown um folks know that I love uh silence as a pedagogical tool as a way just to not rush over from one thing to another and just

041let it sit uh today was a difficult day there's no other way around it we are greatly appreciative of all the bus drivers and bus driver AIDS greatly appreciative to our facilities crew greatly appreciative of the people who had to make tough calls uh at various hours of the morning it's a difficult day we'll learn some lessons we'll proceed from there uh but to that point hopefully as a community we can do this with love caring and empathy and provide it some some Grace and so I recognize that there are multiple factors that go into days like today um and so I appreciate you walking us back and giving us some kind context of the the process as well keep it moving board members fantastic uh that brings us to a uh busy evening for

042our school district business uh we have the Delight of introducing to our community and I'm not trying to steal anybody's thunder so I'll be quick uh but Dr Dom Ley the assistant superintendent for business um has recently joined the organization and will be joining us to have a conversation about budget and a brief intro so Dr ly welcome thank you very much thank you for that kind introduction I really appreciate it before I begin I I uh first thank you for having me I'm excited to be back in the itha community um what a fantastic place to be and I truly am excited to be here I do want to share before I begin I want to recognize some folks have been here a total of I think six days and uh I just want

043to recognize Zack Lind em Emily shy and the Business Office Team and certainly Amanda B for all the incredible work they have done it has been quite the immersive experience over the past six days and they have helped me gather so much information so I do want to recognize them and thank them for their for their assistance and help um with that being said as timing and luck would have it I think it was the second day I arrived the New York State executive budget was released with the proposed state aid runs so more case of here's the math have at it uh which was certainly fun um but before I get into that what I'd like to if uh if it's all right with the board I'd like to share our proposed uh but

0442025 budget calendar um actually maybe the other the other slide if you wouldn't mind I no no problem at all it's the budget calendar is certainly reflective of the the fact that the budget season is is certainly underway I guess one could argue that budget season is is an all-year event and and certainly uh a multi-year challenge but I wanted to provide this for your review I know folks were asking for us to to get this out as quickly as possible so we wanted to get that uh get that out for you for your your review your edits your questions uh and uh certainly your adoption um although these are often considered a living document one of the things that I wanted to share with you are some of the I know this has been

045a a format that you're familiar with but what I wanted to share with you was some of the legal obligations we have associated with the budget process and we've added those to the calendar uh and I'll draw your attention specifically to April 22nd that is not scheduled but Board of Education meeting it's we're hoping for a special meeting on that particular date there is a finance committee on that date as well uh because we have a uh tax cap um approval at that point the I'm sorry the the property tax cap approval that I can't read it I'm sorry uh the property tax report card uh adoption and so I could ask if we can get your approval for that also on the bottom of this page uh I noted on there that we're planning

046some Community conversations uh we did not put dates on there for those we will be adding those in after we have conversations about when those might take place so uh we certainly aware of the fact that um Community voice is important with that I'm going to switch gears if I can to the state aid if I can Emily if I can have you po that up for us we certainly intend to share a great deal more uh details regarding uh Revenue when we when we propose or provide our proposal of budget at that point but I wanted to share with you because this information is quite encouraging uh I wanted to share the uh at least the preliminary runs these are again are uh the first set of uh state aid runs that we'll see

047the finals will come out in April uh I'll start with Foundation Aid this was quite encouraging I know that last year when the foundation Aid uh finally came out was potentially flat for the district uh we're looking at about a 12% 12.24% increase in Foundation aid for the district and that's encouraging again not a final figure but uh certainly quite an increase over last year and that equates to about a $2.7 million uh increase for just Foundation Aid and just real quick and again we'll provide greater details when we do the proposal the state aid represents about a quarter of your overall budget Revenue uh which is certainly impactful uh the second set of numbers there are expense based AIDS these are AIDS we spend it in order to to receive that Revenue the aid

048we receive in that varies that comes on the revenue side of this but just going through this really quickly one of the things I wanted to clarify for you was the building Aid section it shows as a negative change that's because uh the information was frozen at a set period of time and with the within the governor's datab base that will change by April and we're probably going to see something that's uh something more uh palatable and probably something a lot closer to what last year's figure was I don't know that we'll see an increase there we'll have to wait for the final figures for that um our transportation Aid our bosis Aid and excess cost Aid all of those we're seeing increases which is certainly a great sign the last set of um Aid

049that we'll see there is our instructional materials Aid our software Hardware technology a and so on again uh we see increases in software hardware and Technology Aid um minor increase but again those are AIDS where we expend the money and we see that uh as reimbursed in the end and there there's a slight decrease in textbook and Library again our final figures aren't quite out yet so overall our total state aid we're looking at an increase of about 6% and I would imagine when we see the finals for the building Aid that'll increase somewhat as well again that's a fairly substantial increase over last year quite encouraging uh and our foundation a of course is important the last thing I want to say again we'll provide a great deal more details U Dr Brown mentioned

050that I get some dispensation this first meeting after being here five days but I'll share a great deal more with you uh when we go through this budget uh I did want to share with you that our technology department and our Communications Department I I spent a lot of time on the website looking at your budget development documents and they do a fantastic job putting information out there it was a great opportunity to learn uh about what you have and I just want to share this with the community the website has a a absolute uh plethora of information starting with the budget FAQs uh and I my understanding is these are culmination of many questions that come into the district it's kept as a repository great idea very easy to read and I would encourage

051folks to look there let's talk um again I highly encourage folks to use that we want the questions uh that come in through let's talk uh we want to hear your voice and we'll try to respond to those as quickly as we can and and a lot of those from what I can tell end up in our FAQ section which is certainly important and last of course board docs all of the presentations so on and so forth are kept there as part of the repository so again a wealth of information and uh and with that I will ask if there are any questions and I will end it for the moment this is our introduction we're gonna be grilling Dr Ley as the months go on but in the interim board members any quick comments

052questions for Dr Le just a hello and welcome and thank you for being here thank you my pleasure one question I do have is um and I know it's too early to tell right and so I really appreciate that we're still being cautious because we know the final State runs haven't been provided um but can we presume that the change in Foundation Aid um may be a result of the change in the foundation Aid formula um or there other factors that are playing a role I don't know that I want to comment on that yet um I think I want to look at our our factors first before looking at that I don't think it is but I'm not entirely sure yet I appreciate that right I don't want to comment I learned from the

053M any other board member comments responses yes please yeah I just wanted to uh say from the finance committee perspective that uh you are very welcome very glad to see you thank you uh and I also want to uh join in thanking Zack and Emily shy and others who have carried extra water over the last few months uh thank you to them as well fantastic thank soon all right uh brings us to our next agenda item 10.2 icsd metrics and accountability and I believe this is you Dr Brown and I'm gonna invite Lyn Clan Kowski down and to also remind Dom his uh honeymoon period is over now yeah was thank you l and I I'll begin by uh saying thank you to Dr crwi I think you were the inspiration for me to uh

054move forward with the state of this District website that I want to present and share with you all this evening and it goes back to last year um you gave us you gave me and US time on your curriculum committee agendas to talk about data and where we were and and at the time you asked us to focus in on equity and excellence and how we be meeting both of those districtwide goals and to put fourth metrics in uh data that revealed it so and we did that throughout last year um and as we did that it was it it it pushed us to reflect it pushed us to capture information in different ways to create new narratives um and then we had last spring and there were many public comments um we saw things

055written and again thanking you for your inspiration I heard people even after having those conversations at each one of your meetings about where we were as an organization people were using words like failing or um not doing as well with academic Excellence or our approach to meeting the needs of all Learners particularly our Learners who are the highest achieving was not the same and I and like all things we're good Educators we uh we validate and affirm first I I heard that feedback I see people who bring that energy um and I thank them for their engagement um I welcome that kind of conversation if you're taking time to look at our data if you're taking time to come to public meeting to talk about our data thank you because we need that type of

056Engagement that's validation information I'm I'm from a family I've went to board meetings beginning in middle school every every single Tuesday with my mother and she had that same energy and she said the same things at meetings uh your school are feeling my kids aren't having their needs met um they're not showing up well in your data they're not representing your curriculum so as a person um who's heard that all my life when talking about schools I hear you and I feel that energy and unlike Lucille um she would say it for three minutes at a public comment section and nobody ever said anything to follow up um I vowed from the validation and affirmation one say thank you for bringing that energy and your questions and your conversations about schools um thank you and

057I'm going to shift to and folks cther and others who've been through our program here we we get to the building and the bridging so now what will we do as a community to give information educate and make sure we're having the same conversation and a conversation that would be constructive and to build so that everyone can navigate this academic environment successfully that's the building and the bridging so after thanking people for saying things like we're feeling um that schools aren't doing as well and some folks said the exact opposite but everybody I want to say thank you and I as I invited folks last spring um when we get to the building in bridging I'm going to bring my data portfolio to the table and I will invite you to bring yours as well

058so that we can compare data points if that's what you wish to do or and no one's taking me up on that offer to building the bridge but that's not going to prevent us from coming to the table to put our data portfolio in front of you so this is the building and the bridging and what we were and we're doing it in the form of a state-of the district um I don't want to say state of District address but a state of the district website and what I was hoping to do and this is on our website very prominently we will send it out in our newsletters we will highlight it as a news story but I'm asking everyone to peruse the information and the data here as we will start to do tonight

059and with your questions please send them my way via the Le talk portal and with your Kudos we'll take those and with your questions or your concerns we want to hear those too that's the building and the bridging and so if I may and Lynn's going to hear she's going to help me with some of these data points and filling in some of these blank we will present to you our data portfolio which can includes a significant amount of quantitative and qualitative data points that gives you a sense of how well our schools are doing and it always starts with uh let's go all the way back up to the top there Emily uh to the vision and the mission and you know I've been asked often about our strategic approaches to the work and

060you know a strategic plan includes a v vision and a mission and we have a vision and a mission a very bold one I may add around meeting the needs of all Learners and 6,000 plus thinkers and so we start there with vision and Mission and as folks have seen over the years in lie of a traditional strategic planning process that typically involves uh cohort of people coming together to come up with a new vision and Mission then some metrics and some strategies and then it sits in a three- ring binder on a shelf and it's typically done every four or five or sometimes 10 years we've taken a different approach to strategic visioning and strategic planning we've come up with a vision and AD Mission we have some metrics as you will see and

061we over the years we've come up with individual Improvement plans or strategic plans for different areas we've have a literacy plan we had a special education plan for a while an inclusion plan we've had a plan for mathematics we have an annual professional development plan so as I'm thinking about this website we may want to link to all of those individual what one would call a strategic plan and in our case it's I would say it's much more Nimble and flexible because it's not something you're paying a bunch of money for a facility to come in and do every five or 10 years and you can't really change it the people who were doing strategic plans before the pandemic or right before the pandemic had throw all of them out the window because they changed

062overnight in ours we were able to be numble and more flexible and you'll see some of those elements here in a second so the first part of our what are we doing as a district we talk about vision and Mission we talk about the board goals we talk about culture of Excellence equity and communication and you'll see how our metrics that we are presenting to you all are aligned with those Board of Education goals and then the learning forward icsd that's uh in addition to our mission and our goals we have focused in over the last six years I believe on those key elements and we've also attend we've tried to align our metrics and what you're going to see later to those anti-racist curriculum for students as partners and learner and leaders educator identity

063working structures of support going down we have you can click on learning for each one of these things cck you can learn more about learning for fcsd you can New York State education accountability status is one indicator that we Monitor and I'm GNA ask ly to talk about where we've been and where we're going but that's we've had an interesting relationship with New York State accountability statuses over the last 15 years um the formulas have changed um how monies are administered has changed what we look at has changed but I'm going to ask Lynn who's an expert on it to share where we are now and give a bit of an overview about accountability status you want to share something yeah sure um and you can find more information towards the bottom of the page

064there's um links to our current accountability information and FAQs and so forth um but as a a broad overview um over the last four years accountability uh determinations have the the system has been redefined in New York state um after the covid closings and uh basically there are three metrics that schools are rated on each year um academic me me measures that look at performance on New York State tests in ela and Mathematics and at the secondary level that also includes science um we look at um graduation rates at the secondary level and based on those metrics alone our schools have been um assigned a performance level by ranking them compared to other schools in the state um schools that perform at the level one um performance level in academic achievement and at the secondary

065level High graduation rates as well um are given a a a designation as a school of in sorry a school um that either needs comprehensive Improvement if it's based on all students within the school or targeted support and Improvement if it's based on a group or several groups of students in the school and groups are defined by um demographic factors such as race um economic status special ed status Etc um currently are we have designations based on 2022 23 data um those are our current accountability designations for the 2024 25 school year that we're living right now and we have four schools that are um in different uh Improvement planning processes so edfield Elementary School is a comprehensive support and Improvement school they were identified based on the all students subgroup and then we have

066bjm Boon and DT who are all targeted support and Improvement schools based on um groups of students in the school you can see up on the website there um the groups that are identified in each school and I want to call out just the numbers of test results that are used to make these determinations so we can see that enfield's designation is based on 69 students and 123 test results bjm we're looking at 92 students and 121 test results Pointon 32 students 39 test results do it 32 students 41 test results I share this not as um not to minimize the need for improvement but also when we talk about a system um as a whole and talk about failure um I struggle to give that term to our system as a whole when we're

067talking about numbers this small there are school students that we are not serving well and we need to do better but there are many many many students that we are serving very well thank you L and again the ways in which the state formula has varied um we've also learned that uh our school district is a part of a small Court of school districts that um have the kind of demographic makeup we have and frankly enough students in some of these membership groups to be counted um and then when you're looking at needing to identify for federal funds um the a 5% of schools in New York state at times I've wondered if we have 5% of schools in New York state with the kind of demographics we have so anyway that's a deeper conversation

068and we can spend more time we've talked about that at other times we just wanted folks to know there is in in no way do the state even refer to schools as fing they talk about targeted support and Improvement and continuous Improvement so that's our Statewide accountability section of this website and folks can go there for more information and accountability information want to move up some more family moving along well you now we're in to some data points here and again going back to the validation and affirmation before I get into the numbers that I want to just highlight here um our young people are awesome they're brilliant our young people have thrived and survived a pan pandemic multiple pandemics um and nowhere in here do we have an asri saying that we're coming back

069after a pandemic but I just want to make it's important if you're going to if FKS are going to talk about need to continually improve or talk about what we need to have our targeted efforts at first start with how great our young people are and how much joy and Brilliance they bring and our Educators um who are doing this hard work every single day now I'll we drill down on couple of District enrollment for example um if you can click on District enrollment it's important for folks to see where we are and I can say correct me if I'm wrong then um immediately after the pandemic we saw about a 5% decrease in overall enrollment in our school district and that number has stayed remained flat around that so we have in some ways

070we have a new Baseline as far as the number of students in our school district you can look at the other areas here where we have our demographic makeup and if I was doing a noticing if we have could probably spend four hours on this conversation but but we were doing a notice and wondering as professional developers we be we' be asking folks what do you notice and wonder here and one of the things I notice and wonder is that um our demographics are shifting some um and I would say uh we have a diverse student bobly and our needs are more and more complex when you look at uh just that number of classification status right now about 30% of our young people have a 504 or an IEP that's significant that's very different

071from where we started when I was here in 2011 the number of enl students is significantly different so just we could spend more time here but our can you just make sure we say what we just want to make sure sorry English as a new language um Learners uh populational students who identifying as homeless so our population the number of students is 5% less and um the needs of our young people have become more complex if you want to keep moving Emily go to the next section before we move up I never miss an opportunity if we take a look at our enrollment and I'm sure you know where I'm going uh currently says 5,383 students um I never miss an opportunity to let folks know that there are uh roughly another 600 students that

072the Etha city school district is responsible for in some Financial form or fashion uh homeschooled students that may need some form of transportation or need a service students who are attending new Roots Charter School uh students who are at monori or at Waldorf but still require um financial support from the district and so while um the 5,38 83 are students within our building uh is a larger population that we are financially responsible for as a district and I will continue to say that because I think sometimes people have a I think it's an important data point for folks to know and we will get to Pro people expenditure at the end too that's a number that always people always ask about and it's based on the number of students we serve uh let's go to

073I'm GNA skip around some because we could SP all day um you can click on budget development we're gonna talk a lot much more about budget but you can follow what what we're doing where we where information is we'll be updating that much more in the coming weeks and months let me go back uh let's just dig into a couple of those notable happenings anti- anti-is curriculum for all you know last year Lyn and the curriculum committee talked a lot about the pilot programs and our need for a districtwide approach to final construction and comprehension you want to give an update on where we are this year and how that's gone sure absolutely um so teaching kids to read right is probably the most anti-racist thing we can do teaching all kids to be skilled

074readers and um the work that we did last year um in terms of Elementary curriculum U piloting and adoption has moved us uh I think in a in big ways towards having a common approach and um scientifically backed approach to teaching students to read um we have adopted a new curriculum in grades 3 four and five uh that is focused on reading comprehension so help ensuring that all students have the opportunity to engage with grade level complex text on a daily basis to learn how to read think write um respond to those texts uh magnetic reading was selected by our Educators after reviewing several different programs because of the quality of text and the engaging um and culturally responsive nature of those texts kids love them um they really do enjoy reading them uh teachers

075have shared that kids are asking for um all of the texts in this program are excerpts so you're not reading the whole text kids are asking teachers to purchase the entire book so they can continue reading it um so that's really exciting um we've had a an assessment in place in grades K through five called the Fontanel Benchmark assessment for many many years that um has been really debunked as a valid and reliable way to measure students um reading and there's lots and lots of uh information in the media that you can t listen to to to learn more about that um but we evaluated a new assessment last year it's called mclass it's based on Dibbles 8 which is out of the University of Oregon it has a many years decades of research around

076it it is a nationally normed assessment that is really allowing us to to get a strong handle on students um literacy skills at the K through five level or really the K through six grade levels um so that we can not only identify students who may need extra support but it gives us the tools to be able to provide that targeted support so it's an instructional tool as well as an assessment tool um and then finally at K2 We are continuing our really great reading our phonics based instruction for all students and um after visiting all of our K through2 classrooms last spring I am um we are at the point now where that really is happen happening universally for all kids so that is has been a four plus year um um commitment and

077initiative but all students are receiving strong foundational skills instruction in K2 and we are piloting this year uh two additional programs to identify um the curriculum that can round out um our K2 literacy program with uh comprehension work and writing instruction for all students thank you L and I want to underscore each one of these sections here has that level of detail about the work that we're doing um students as partners the leader you can read about our restorative practice work educator identity work you can read about the micr credentialing program that's well underway and we've had dozens of Educators participate in something that this community came to this board meeting asking for a decade ago as a wish or a vision for the work it's now in place and up and running structur structures

078of support you can read about everything from our project innovation which is grown and you've continued to support to free to the meals we're providing to young people for free and which our governor I recently read wants to have across the state so again qualitative information but the folks always it's one thing to see the numbers and the metrics we're going to get back to in a second but what is the work that's leading to it we provide some examples and we continue to provide some examples of how we're getting to that I'm going to be get to some more of these metrics so I want to drill down on a couple of these particularly around the culture of excellent and we have an annual survey a climate survey or cult a goals and priority

079survey we've asked very specific questions to give us an indication of how our young people our staff and our community think about our schools I won't go through all these we presented this once but I would ask folks to look at uh what people are saying about our schools everything from the ways which we're communicating to whether or not they find young people find the curriculum relevant to their lives and Beyond there's some areas for us to improve but I also seeing some bright spots and some improvements from the first time we administered s survey if we can go down Emily and drill in on maybe let's drill in on we'll do co-curricular first and then AP enrollment um co-curricular is a number that we would task a while ago to make sure we improve

080and you'll see at the secondary level those numbers continue we've had uh I miss little was in here presenting about our Athletics budget which hasn't significantly ex um gone up but we're serving many many more young people numbers like this are is the Envy of my peers to have that many young people raw numbers and 31% of your young people at the secondary level doing something with Athletics that many folks doing clubs we offer over 100 plus clubs and you'll see what we're doing with um theater and art programs significant and Elementary you'll see the numbers there AP and dual enrollment our AP enrollment and dual enrollment is up significant ly and I were we we've been searching nationally for a peer group that has that many young people 66% of the young people at

081our secondary schools participating in AP and dual enrollment program just that raw number alone is something that's noteworthy and then if we think about how many are taking the AP exams and how they're scoring our numbers outpace anyone we've been able to find and Lyn I think you had you can break it down even further as far as the average score and yeah the average score and the number of four and five if you can share some national and state data absolutely so you can see up there for itha City School District in 2324 we had 463 kids who took one or more AP exam uh 380 exams total with an average score of 4.0 when we look at the national um uh national average score was 3.1 or 3.06 and the New York state

082is 3.14 so our kids are outscoring others on the AP exam and then when we look at the percentage of exams that are scoring at the four or five level so that's at a very high level on the AP exam um I think traditionally three four or five can convert to college credit um we have 74.5% of our kids are of our exams taken we're at that very high level of four or five that compares to about 40% at both the national and New York state level so we have lots of kids taking these exams and doing very very well on them so kudos to kids kudas to the teachers um yeah and we've been recognized for 10 years in a row by the college board for for increasing the number of young people enrolling

083in these courses and increasing the diversity at the same time and having our scores outpace of others in the country we're one of the few that has had that on and I'm I'm we're underscoring this because a lot of folks when they're talking about Excellence they want to point to this data point and they also point to the number of young people we sent off to post-secondary education colleges and I've even been tasked how many have going to the elite universities now we've been thinking about whether or not we put that here because some of that can be identifiable but I can say to you we now sending more young people to the elite a league schools than we've ever done before and when talking to the Presidents of some of these universities the most

084prestigious ones in the world they're saying it's not because we're in Etha or location or our affiliation it's because of the young people and the Educators in our school district so I would I'm saying that for anybody who thinks otherwise it's not because we are in a college town and then we can see Cornell from here it's because our young people have earned it and anyone saying anything different I would say it's not validating and affirming the work of Educators and the young people we serve so again I ask fol if you're talking about academic excellence and you have a data point that you want to put on the table to show how it's getting better or how it's dipping or it's being the same just bring it to the table because I have mine

085and we have some others here we can keep going uh let's go to the equity one um because this is one as we monitoring what's happening across our state and our nation we we talked about reading we have a new Baseline now and we can talk about that number maybe a curriculum committee as we have more data and Trend data if let's we can graduation rate because I want to talk about this as folks are going to hear about a new graduation rate in the coming weeks and we have a graduation rate from last year and I want F if I was doing that noticing and wondering right now you may be asking what why is that number a little bit lower this past year and I want to remind folks there was a class

086that came in at the beginning of the pandemic and across our state and the nation we anticipated that graduation rates and some other data points we're going to take a dip and we needed to establish a new Baseline what you're seeing is represented there and we can break it down by membership group in other ways but again some work for us to do but I also want to note to folks that that was anticipated that particular drop because of a cohort that came into High School having sometimes uh yeah folks coming in during a pandemic we can move up we'll speed this up a little bit because I'm sure there's some questions can I'm sorry the other way communication you'll see indicators about our communication this board has committed a significant amount of resources and

087investing in communicating better that was one of the board goals and we had a lot of feedback about the need to do better and our numbers are shifting significantly when it comes to how we communicate in a two-way Manner and we have that data from our qualitative survey that we administer annually everything from opportunity to be heard to if the me if the information is Meaningful and maybe if we Emily we can just go down to that expenditure by student because I want to make sure we highlight that for folks because is going to come up a lot during the budget season we've been asked is it worth it how are you spending compared to other folks um how are you spending compared to other folks in our County across the state I've heard a

088data point here I keep pointing here because this is where public comment typically happens folks saying we are spending more per student than any other place in the state um that's just not true and they've asked us to produce the data and the number I'm here's the number here you'll see how it Compares we're spending per the people expenditure which is a number that is determined by our state it's below the county average and below uh yeah below our County average and below the state average you'll see what we're spending per student and you'll see from my perspective the board and Community has done a great job of producing an excellent School District that's striving to be Equitable and excellent at the same time uh monitoring the cost and doing it in a sustainable way

089so that was a lot again that's probably a 4-Hour session and we have conducted those sessions where we do noticing and wonderings and we have this conversation for about four hours but we wanted to just get present it to the community and you in about 20 minutes and welcome any questions going forward board members questions reactions comments thank you that was definitely in depth and detailed and um more to go through um for myself as well as the community and um you stated that we're sending more students to um lead Ivy League schools and all and it was a suggestion I made years ago it would be good if we could have some sort of development officer to look into that and how do we get alums to give back and so forth but to

090also look beyond the first year the students are in the schools are they remain in assistance data schools and and that's across the board for any student going on for continuing education to see if they are graduating within the four years and if they're remaining at the school of their first choice or whatever choice they went into because I've seen several shifts where they don't and um and what do we need to do as a community for post High School graduation yeah persistance data typically um the young people who continue to matriculate after their first semester in postsecondary education and we used to get that information from a national clearing house but they stopt it I haven't seen it in years now you know where that is now U yeah I was just I can

091pull together what our most recent um National Clearing House data is now that doesn't include all students right it is students that are collected through schools that participate in the National clearing house but we can definitely pull that together and share with you thank you for that and um the magnetic reading curriculum is it catered to all students even if they have some challenges around reading if there's um student that may be to select yes absolutely so that is one of one thing that um the research really shows that for students to become skilled readers even if a student has uh learning a learning disability or a complexity in how they learn exposure to grade level text is in and engagement with grade level text is really important because of the type of text structure

092language syntax VOC ulary that exists right so when we um out of well-intentioned sometimes we hold students back and and give them just text that as their instructional level or what they can decode or read by themselves that lowers the level of complexity of thinking of language that students get and when we do that we actually broaden or widen the gap between around reading so having a program that uh gives education grade level text and then scaffolds and supports to allow all kids to access that is is critical to helping change those Trends yes there is certainly work to do and um you know Educators have been providing feedback about ways that we can Contin continue to help more kids be able to access those texts more easily one thing that doesn't magnetic reading doesn't

093have for example is text read aloud um so that is something we are going to do ourselves so thinking about how we're going to create that collection so that students that are not able to decode it themselves can um be engaging with those texts repeatedly by listening to it while y'all thinking one more um Dr BR you noce my first central office position was executive director for division and school Improvement in Virginia and I was hired um to produce a state-of the district report and a website in 2010 and uh I had a department of seven people and we were told this your job is to come up with this annual report and it took us a year to produce the report and I almost feel embarrassed I went to Lyn and our Communications team

094two weeks ago and I said and I forwarded them the link to our 10 years of report from that division that was you know about a $2 million budget and a Year's worth of work I said I need it done by the end of January and I thought they were going to cuss or right write nasty notes and they said we got you and they did it in the week and we've been fine-tuned over the last week so I want folks to recognize the kind of excellence and talent we have here um to pull something together you can go to Almar County's website state of the district and you'll see the last 20 years of it and that's a department a research and development department that does that and that's the only thing they do

095and she's been talking about at the curriculum committee today we've been talking about how to get Communications out in in an imperfect way since 4:00 a.m. and these folks are doing this stuff because I asked them to so I say all that I welcome your feedback on how to make this better and different but I would offer up that it's already better than what we did in Alamar with the team so thank you thanks board members questions comments I'm looking forward to uh looking looking through what's included a little bit more I'm just kind of scrolling while we're talking um so I appreciate you sharing this and also making it and I think it'll be very helpful in answering a lot of questions and also kind of have a centralized place for people to look

096um and maybe there'll be some other things that might be helpful to add to the website as well and you know as we all look at it maybe we can make some suggestions but I mean I think it's a very great start appreciate that and and what's good too to um just add on to what Adam had stated in the accountability section it goes back to the equity report card right and and I was looking at the AP dual enroll moment participation rate because we as a board and this is pre me being on the board but I say we as a board came up with one of the goals as equity and looking at all of the student groups that the increase in AP duel enrollment across the board that's very impressive and unfortunately

097during covid yes everyone declined but they boosted back up so thank you for the historical information and how every connected appreciate that um hearing no more for our board I'll also say um this in connection with the uh Equity report card gives our community a significant amount of information uh look forward it probably means at some point time we should consider an FAQ page for this as well um it'd be helpful for folks who ask questions that may get asked repeatedly um and in terms of the culture of Excellence um I am constantly reminded of the transiency of our community um and I use this quote regularly right but I believe it's about 36% of the population has not lived in Ithaca five years prior and so it's a constant community in turnover which coincides

098with you know most academic calendars at the undergraduate level at the very least and so some of these culture of Excellence metrics that we've decided uh we tasked Dr Brown uh I want to say in 2016 or 2017 to increase the graduation rate and in part of that that research you and your team disaggregated some of the key metrics which actually were responsible for an increasing graduation rate and those were things like does a student have a positive relationship with an adult in the building those were things like do you participate in a co-curricular activity those were things like uh what whether do you you have access to uh lunch or food on a regular basis and so a couple a number of these metrics are here precisely because they were connected to an increased

099the graduation rate and so our Focus was not always on increasing the graduation rate our Focus was increasing students participation in co-curricular activities our Focus was making sure that our Educators had what they need to be able to create these positive relationships and so I think again because the historic memory is easily disrupted it's good for our community to understand the Strategic approach that was taken to a number of these things and we can say the same thing about AP and dual enrollment so it wasn't just increasing that number it was looking at what helped support and increase and those enrollment factors and focused on on that and so looking forward to as we continue to build out these programs understanding the financial constraints of which we're under uh but um love hearing the data

100about how well our educators are doing and how our students are doing and I'm certain that we will have questions as a board uh for additional information or clarifications or Nuance as well so thank everybody thank you for your work Lyn you've been doing this for a little bit of time time it's amazing work Katie as well thank you as well so yeah thank you both we will continue on with our agenda uh our next agenda item 10.3 is the discussion of the ideas from the revenue generation advisory Council folks may recall I believe it was on December 10th we had a presentation by Dr Jill trip who was uh the chair of the revenue generation advisory Council and presented the board with four possible ideas as a result of that work from the revenue

101generation advisory Council uh and uh we decided or and Dr trip has asked that we have a conversation about these ideas because we put them out there as ideas and with an opportunity that we would come back and have a full discussion so uh things that you would add Joe yeah um what I would add is that these ideas came out of a series of brainstorming sessions with a a number of people um um Dr Brown was often in attendance um Adam was often in attendance um Aaron joined us at least once erck joined us at least once and some people from the community as well oh and Todd was there once too so we had you know an opportunity to sort of cast a wide net in ways that the district might bring in

102more money um because of all of the reasons we all know about in terms of the difficulties with raising virtually all of our money from property taxes um so we came up with a a number of they're not really choices what they are is options with pros and cons and um what I would appreciate from my fellow board members at this point would be some sense whether that's through a a straw pole or nodding or consensus or whatever but some sense from my fellow board members about which if any of these they would like to pursue and then how we would go about pursuing that let me just provide one caveat and that's that anyone who wants a lot more information should be prepared to go and dig it out themselves because that um that

103was a Tim limited committee and we essentially feel that we've done our work by presenting these options to the board that's now up to the board to decide which we pursue so um I think we have yeah um if you want me to say them I have them here listed okay uh the The Advisory Council came up with four again these were ideas uh are they up there right sale and Lease of District property consider utility tax request increased donation from Cornell University um and a explore consolidation redistricting feasibility and so it probably makes sense to go through just one by one if that yeah I'll I'll explain my understanding and a sense of pros and cons and others can jump in because most of you have seen this at least once so the first

104option for consideration of getting Revenue would be the sale or lease of District property um the advantages of this would be that it could be done with Board of Education authorization we wouldn't have to go for a referendum we wouldn't have to um get any sort of State approval please correct me if I'm wrong on any of this um but it could be done fairly quickly and easily toward that end and we do have a request for proposals that has gone out or is about to g go out not yet we okay that is on uh on the uh what do we call it in baseball on Deck with uh to go out and find out what our properties are worth um it should we choose to um slim down the district a bit so

105that's one thing that's going on the disadvantages are that to sell or lease our property some of our property we would need to know what it's valued at and that's where the request for proposals um is going and also there's a there's a RFP about assessment of future District needs the demographics of our community um where we expect growth where we don't expect growth and how our current buildings are are moving toward our goals in that way and as far as likely income from that it obviously there's a wide range um we have approximately 20 buildings I could be way off on that we have a lot of buildings many of them very old um many of them with a great deal of property attached to them so I think um the question of how

106much we could make from this may become a significant issue if not this budget year than in the near future so there's all these things working together the valuation of the property the demographics how what we decide as to how we want our buildings to used so anybody want to add anything at this point or I would just want to add to the community so we're clear and when you're saying a property uh I would assume that this also includes property that the district owns places like the the former Danby School exactly right we have a facility on Hancock Street uh we own the block across from G Marco Splats uh there's additional property uh Enfield School District I believe I want to say is on 17 or 20 something acres of land um so

107those those are the kind of things I believe were being discussed like exactly what I hope we would have relatively soon would be a listing of all of those properties their current uses um the square footage what the value would be in different uses and whether we think we continue to need them in the way that we're using them now I saw interrup U just to clarify I think there a public vote is required if we wish to sell a property thank you Dr Brown okay we could lease it with simp Board of Ed approval I believe I'm pretty sure can lease but but to sell to sell it we would need to have a referendum okay thank you and Jill so you have rfps out you said they're about to go out okay so

108we are going to get we are going to get the information to answer these questions about the value of the properties um what our projected need for the properties is so Bas yeah so this is basically the discussion can resume when we have that information right it can we could also say in General I I believe we should be looking at this as opposed to no I have no interest in selling oring any property or finding any more about it so it's sort of like should we should we persist along this um line of inquiry or not um the next option let let's if we could sure right because you wanted to get some sort of not let say straw poll about we heard from one board member I want I'd like to hear from

109other board members should we do that now or should we wait till the end because I don't I think we do one at a time because they're vastly different and sometimes they may interconnect but I humbly recommend we do one at a time yeah well I mean this is actually my favorite option of the options um just to tell you what I've learned and what I think um I see relatively few downsize issues to this in that there'd be a lot of discussion before anything would be happening that there'll be a lot of fact finding before anything would happen and I I I like the idea of um a Slimmer operation where it's possible and where it increases efficiency so that's that's my take on and I welcome hearing other people's well welcome Dr ly

110and since we do have a new assistant superintendent in business I um would want to make sure that individual and the team are still connected and know and aware of what all of these options are because I I don't feel comfortable doing a straw poll at this point because there's still some missing links here with all of these but that's just my comment for an RFP though no the RFP is going through Oh I thought I mean that that's not the straw pole we weren't right I I guess the idea would be I think I we may be able to say it differently are board members in appoint time or say under no circumstance am I interested in selling or leasing any property or our board members sort of thinking like yes it makes sense

111to do this RFP find the numbers and then see where we may be at um but if we're not you know if we're not going to be interested in selling or leasing then we shouldn't be spending money to do an RFB to run the study right so if I maybe is a fair way of saying that's fine should we continue on this path I guess as a district so we don't have an RFP ready to go it's close this yes we do I thought we had this but it hasn't gone out yeah we don't have what's the cost disadvantage I mean is an RFP that expensive for something like this well the RFP doesn't cost anything it's it out there yeah well then I I see no reason not to proceed with an RFP that's

112so actually I mean I may say I mean Zach and I met yesterday with Dr lissy to go over it and uh think Zach put together a draft which to me looks excellent and it's very comprehensive it looks all these things all these issues and not withstanding the professor's recommendation take these issues one one it's hard to look issue one without looking at Issue four because they're two sides of the same coin and I would just say is the RFP is comprehensive in addressing both of those issues because obviously you don't want to sow land if you're about to expand enrollment need the land right so you you need the enrollment studies saying you know we anticipate a decline in enrollment say in this area and therefore we can afford to sell a building because

113we won't need it um so the two things have to go hand in hand uh I mean the last thing I say is this was a revenue enhancement committee but uh what may be more important than the revenue of sell in these properties is the reduction in maintenance costs so you know A reduced eliminated spending is not Revenue but it achieves the same names and the actual name of the committee was the revenue exploration committee right yes or just yeah because we've had a few names but it was a madeup name yeah all right I'm in support of this too just to in the straw pole nature of this thank you okay good next option this is utility tax proposal or suggestion and it turns out and again i' appreciate Corrections from those who know

114more about this than I do um utility taxes are in use in a number of school districts around the state quite a few actually we had a listing of about 40 of them I think um and what what the state law allows districts to do is to put a tax on it was it Communications um Services I think it's fairly wise it's not just cell phones although it's also some utilities as well okay um and that you know obviously there's a wide range of what the percentage could be and what would be included in that um the advantage is that this could be done with board authorization um and many other as I said many other New York State schools utilize this option and in some cases they they make as much as a you

115know a half million to several million dollars a year using this option um so so that the money would be an advantage obviously a disadvantage would be that it is a regressive tax um anybody who uses utilities and that's all of us would be taxed and this tax like any other additional tax is was unpopular with the group of people on the committee for the most part and we believe it would be very unpopular with u our community um nobody likes to hear about new taxes so um I think it was a sense of the committee that this is interesting and we don't believe we're at the point where we would need to do something like this um and I I would agree with that as a committee consensus if someone Erin I think you

116you taught us a bit about this as an option and then well I mean I we had this came up um in my six-year tenure and it's really contentious and actually I this is where I'd like to refer to Dr Ley not myself because it's I like I it just feels really I don't think it would be very popular and it is a regressive tax I mean Sean also has right the last time that board seriously considered a utility taxes in 2019 with much more debate taking place in 2020 the beginning part of that budgetary season one of the main arguments that we should identify and at least put out there the reason why people consider a utility tax is that it does not rest solely on property owners so the idea is that the

117wider Community is taxed not just property tax or Property Owners but you were correct at that point in time in 2019 it was widely un popular um a couple folks have done it depends on what you get um I think I've sent around to board members at one point in time earlier last year late last year some of the initial figures those are five years old I I you know they're not valid now um but the question was for the amount of return is it worth you know with $600,000 increase which won't solve all of our issues is it worth that level of tax on lights and gas or you know cell phones or whatever the case may be but but it so to the Committees and it was I feel compelled to say it

118was entitled the revenue generation advisory Council not exploration really okay at least officially in the minutes we'll go back and take um but the idea is that the committee was tasked with looking at all options not necessarily taking a stance but here is what can be done not the most palatable options but look at all options yes so then putting it forward for the conversation um I just want to add to that you know the the one other issue that I think is important to point out since we're having this conversation is that you know renters do by default pay tax in their you know uh in their rent right but the argument here is with so many college students but then when you look and you think well their bills are probably going to

119wherever their actual residents are so we're still going to double tax people if we do this and that's what makes it so hard we're not going to get the people who aren't really already contributing it also gets further Complicated by whatever their area code is of their cell phone true I'm not in support I don't hear anyone screaming out for additional exploration by the utility tax as as I pointed out it's it's it's unpopular it's unpopular for a reason um and I don't see any point for for us to pursue it at this at this point um Garrick you look like you want to site do you have any thoughts on that Dr lcy do you have any you want to add to Dr Brown Dr Lucy for example and I don't know the details

120but in each of those cases they have a very unique situation where that was imp and I think in most of those cases quite a ago this happened decades yeah if if I ask for a comment um if I'm remembering correctly it takes us about a year to even implement this there's a public hearing there's a conversation a data um to say we would not explore it would limit us I think um I would like to figure out I mean that number was five to two million that's a broad range so having maybe even staff exploring how much would it actually be giving you a hard number um sharing the process for it happening which could be a year and what will be the timeline that in my mind is a continued exploration not we

121won't be able to do it this year but to say we're not going to explore it ever I wouldn't want us to be limited when we can just be gathering information even if it's just St that's all I would offer uh I would Echo that stance uh I am not in favor of it um but I am in favor of exploring uh one what has changed uh two what are the circumstances by which it would be implemented what are the possible uh Revenue Generation Um again I'm not in support of it but I I am interested in the concept and the idea and that's we did last time as well to say to our community we are not looking to make this happen but we are exploring all options and this is one option that's

122out there that for me is at least worth exploring again and I keep saying it so for folks around I am not in favor of it but I in favor of the exploration agreed was there something where like this could be an opportunity to essentially tax Cornell um like directly you know through like utility tax because they have so many different buildings that are paying you know however much in utility fees did I hear that somewhere or am I am I making that up uh I don't recall that but again I don't know the particulars of this I think when we talked about it it was like well that might be a way to Target some of the student income but then we realized that that in itself was difficult since many of the students

123aren't are don't have their permanent addresses here their utility bills don't go here yeah okay yeah I'm I was just curious about that I don't know why I I thought that was a thing but well do we know if Cornell pays utility taxes if they don't pay property taxes they have to buy their util they have to pay for their utilities certainly so so essentially if you're able to tax you know and they they their utility bills got to be through the roof I I don't know how much they're paying every year but if we're able to get a percentage of that that that would essentially be a way to potentially tax Cornell um as opposed and I I don't know I I could be making this up I thought maybe I heard that somewhere

124so so I just point out uh the majority of the Cornell campus runs off its own water system and its own utility system so it's only off-campus Cornell buildings that actually purchase utilities or water okay to that point I I like the idea but it also remind me that if we're taxing a not for-profit there'd be we're taxing other not for-profits as well right so that'd be churches and you know other organizations so again I think some to think about even answer those questions that Todd's asking I am curious I hadn't thought about it that way so but again Mr Fox and others I would love to explore this further um I've been here long enough to remember when we were hit with a sidewalk tax bill and it had very little public input or

125conversation from my perspective um and I'm offering to have that conversation over the course of a year just to explore so would board members have a problem with us tasking this to Dr Brown's team just to get some basic information about what this could look like not taking away from the real work at hand right but let's just run by the option see what it what comes back and I'm sure we'll get emails from folks as well so I shouldn't have said sidewalk tax but that I'm still scarred about that we get that so again we're not saying um Go full forward on this but we're saying it would be if we gather more information it might be something to pursue at some point fair enough all right next up request increased donation from Cornell

126University advantages of this option it could be implemented at Board of Education Direction disadvantages obviously this isn't something we control we can control whether we ask or not we can't control whether it happens um and it would require negotiation and possibly a campaign to engage Cornell in the negotiations the income figures there are from um what I found and what others have shared with me um about other ivy league universities and their donations to Public School Systems so as as many of you know there certainly is considerable interest in the community in pursuing this option more aggressively um it would be something that the board could take a more active role in it um and I'd be interested in your thoughts anyone who works for Cornell is more than welcome to abstain at this point

127I should say thank you for looking at me uh because I do not work there so this is great uh I always feel compelled to say that and I know people make it seem like I'm against the idea and I am not I am for the idea uh how this happens is a question for me and as someone who is a proud graduate of the State University of New York at Cornell University I continue let to remind folks that a portion of Cornell is public whereas there are no other IV League institutions that are public they're all private so their endowments and their expectation to deliver to their local school district for me is slightly different than a public institution so in some regards part of it would be a double tax now with that

128meaning that as taxpayers were already paying to help fund the Sunni side of Cornell even while folks may not want to acknowledge the the Sunni side with that being said um while I Feel Again compelled to make that point um I think the real question for me is what does it look like and we already know a campaign has started I've already seen lawn signs so there's already movement uh within the community again for me the question is what would be the board's approach uh does it require uh opportunity for a conversation before anything else uh I I'd be curious to hear how board members think would be the best way to move forward well to replay what I've stated before is that um let's look historically how did we get to the 651 and

129at what point did we start with that and how do we go from here I would defer to the historian sitting next to me uh but I I believe the source of that figure derives from the direct cost of educating children who live in tax exempt housing on campus specifically graduate house and I think there was a point in time there was a calculation looking at kids who look who live in Hasbrook and other informally Maplewood housed uh graduate student children who lived in tax exempt property I think that's the historical Source yes part of it yeah um you know I I well just for the record I do work for Cornell um but I you know I think a place to start on this is I always like to mention Dr bradwell's dissertation which

130should be required reading for all board members and when you go back and look at the history of the school district uh and its historic ties to Cornell and things like the Culp Auditorium just over there the the ties between Cornell and the school district are are are long and deep and so the the idea that um sort of be sort of zero some money flowing from the top of the hill to the bottom of the hill I I just don't think is is maybe the best approach to this but I see rather that the the future of Cornell and the future of the school district are tied together and and I think rather than looking at moving money from one place to the other we might look at shared goals uh I've discussed this

131privately with a number of people here but um perhaps one of the the largest factors in Cornell's long-term success is its ability to attract and keep top academic Talent um and I've said many individuals in this room I I've been in many meetings with Junior faculty recruits where the quality of local schools especially in the absence of a private alternative was one of the Premier questions so I think the question is how can we better serve Corell by better serving the district you know moving both boats up and and so I think the opportunity for collaboration and further sharing of resources in a win-win sense with Cornell is an idea worth exploring um and I think it follows in the the spirit I think of of what the committee has proposed but I I I

132move away from words like donation and and and look towards like shared success and and try to engage corn and a collaborative discussion that would raise both boats I wondered too though and I've thought this often you know you think of top talent at crenell but I also think of everyone else in this town that's employed there right from you know adjunct professors who don't make much to you know people doing cleaning service or Food Service there and they don't get paid that much and it's very expensive for them to live here and your analogy of the top of the hill and the bottom of the hill just just is such an analogy for what we're seeing here is the people at the bottom of the hill historically getting the scraps from the castle and

133so I think it would be a really beautiful thing if Cornell could also consider all the other employees that work there whose children go to school here who are struggling to get by and buy them soccer cleats and maybe if they thought about contributing to the school taxes to take a load off of the community and also support it's you know Sister School here in the Public's area that would be a really beautiful thing too and maybe we should reframe it and think about everybody else instead of just the top of the hill well it's just I'm I'm really just referring to the geography literally you can walk out of this but I was I was being metaphor I'm not I was I really was not being metaphorical my response I know I know that

134was just me being ated with the state of the world right and it's a really good metaphor for just this town you know we're just we're struggling so Erin I you know we talk about you know normative statements and positive statements you know normative you know how the world should be and I'll leave everyone in the table here to make their own judgment as how the world bit should be but the positive how the world is is the Board of Trustees of Cornell University are purposed with advancing that institution's goals they are not purposed I mean I think that if if I was to put myself in their shoes they say our job is not to do X Y and Z our job is to further the objectives of the university and so asking them

135to do something that they don't see as honoring their Charter of their fiduciary responsibility to the university in the future of the University I I think it's never going to be tenable but asking them to do something that is collaborative and advances the the the charter of the University while also benefiting the school district through helping the district that educates the children of many of its employees professors from professors to Food Service I think is something that they can consider so I think if you go and say we'd like you to donate you know a large amount of money they're going to say that's contrary to our fua responsibility and in particular Sean is correct you know on the state funded side it would amount to double taxation but a a collaborative relationship is exempt

136from that concern and I think is more viable that that's all I'm saying I listen I don't disagree but I also I mean the morale if you're looking at this as a financial fiscal view it's actually a cost savings for them to just give us a little more and keep paying the rest of their employees what they do it's a show of like hey we see you and we're going to contribute to the public schools in general instead of just special programs that might be you know suited for Cornell and again this is just we can disagree I'm just stating I'm not asking you to do this I'm just I'm just stating how I see it in you work there you know the people I do not I'm just stating it as someone who's part

137of the community and sees us really struggling with a budget that can give our teachers the the funds they deserve the raises they deserve you know I mean I go back I I'm I'm making no statement as of how the world should be I'm always saying how the world is as as I as I understand it to be and and I think well the approach that I've outlined is is the one that would have the most traction that will have more traction it doesn't mean that it's right I guess that's all that I'm saying anyone else want to weigh in on this at this point NOP and U one one more thing is that the I know that advisory Council in reviewing this had given us examples as well as we saw from the community

138of other universities and what they do and how they link it to public education so I would say part of this would be a further discussion with the superintendent and porell and like are your interests here in ensuring that we graduate students a certain way how do we put a Financial dollar Link in that because um the other there are several other universities that have done that and we see in our um property development that's happening around the county and within Etha and it was increasing over the years to make sure we're bringing Cornell is bringing new staff in and new faculty in and to make sure that there is sufficient housing and that's impacted us I I think that's part of my frustration with this Karen is that I don't think we've had the

139channel of communication or at least if we have I know Dr Brown knows people on the hill and I know other people connect somewhat informally but I I I feel I would like to see the board um take a stand that there needs to be a a formal um path of communication with Cornell around this issue and I I don't disagree with Garrick in terms of how that's phrased or you know how that we understand some of their issues or many of their issues and we'd like them to understand ours um that that we are a symbiotic Community with Cornell um and that it would be nice if we could hear not just from our side but also from their side in hopes of moving Rising all the votes at the same time or not

140at the same time from but perhaps a bit higher um so okay I I'm not hearing anyone say leave well I want to okay go ahead Sean I think we need to have a a partially also a concrete conversation so yes there's been times where various Folks at this table or other past board members or you name it have had um uh relationships or modes of conversation and communication with Folks at Cornell um let's also not uh neglect the idea that there's been some significant change in their Senior Management we have a an interim presidents uh that will be there for another year uh the vice president of communication who has been active in Etha city school district is U no longer there they're vice president of communication there is a new person interum person

141I'm not mistaken for the time being um in that role and so the reason why I'm asking this question is um do how do board members envision opening up those lines of communication is there is there a suggestion is there an idea is there a recommendation that we want to follow it's and maybe one thing to say some folks support a shared goal or Vision making an additional um you know pilot uh whatever it may be but I guess I'm curious as one board member what does what might that look like or what do folks suggest if there is a next step to be taken what would that next step be it it seems to me the next step is to get General board consensus of approval to set up some sort of channel of

142communication that we have that we contact Cornell and say we would like to meet regularly or some subset of us obviously would like to meet regularly to discuss the shared goals of is that at a board meeting is that hey let's go have lunch and no I think I think it's a subset of of people who admin Administration and perhaps some board members as well or is this something that we task Administration with that's another to have the conversation or anyone from his team what has been what has been done in the past this is the history too and how that this has been approached previously y'all all look it at me so that's you made the mistake of moving I will say a few things uh I I promise to answer the question um

143I have met regularly and members of my team with uh the senior leadership team and others at Cornell throughout the last 15 years um that includes every president including the current interum President we meet and talk often about a range of topics if I'm hearing correctly we're talking about and I think it's important language is important now a voluntary contribution so a voluntary contribution conversation is different from a negotiated agreement to sheare money in somewhere I we would have to clarify what is it that we're seeking to do and I guess I can't I'm I'm looking at you because I don't know if you're gonna say don't say it or not say it but I'm going to say not all money is good money is what I was told by my daddy so we're talking

144about a voluntary contribution I've been here when we've had a voluntary contribution of one number and then one day someone came in and said that number is going to be reduced and it significantly impacted our budget conversations and thinking when I I see a number like $10 million and if it's going to be a voluntary contribution we need to know that that could go away one day pretty quickly and then what does that leave our folks we be laying folks off would it be onetime running would be put this into salary so as I think about what we are asking for let's just think through it is it a voluntary contribution or is it some kind of an agreement that we would negotiate that they would be bound to and I'm even thinking about what

145would that look like that would require a team of folks a negotiating team and it would get litigious so I think we need to have more conversations I'm down to do whatever but yes we talk to folks there often about a range of topics and it will continue and when we're talking about money it's been a voluntary contribution that is indeed voluntary and in the past I've said thank you for it and we can change the nature of that conversation if it's going to be that but they could come in here tomorrow and say we're going to remove that 650 and that would significantly impact our budget conversation for this current year so let's just navigate carefully um and I'm open to engaging with how they wish to engage on this topic because it obviously

146is not going away about did I say too much Professor probably probably and let's be clear um since I'm I've already dug a hole the kind of monies we're talking about would come with some requests or connections or collaborations that we probably have not had before not all money is good money so let's talk about what is it as we're negotiating and negotiating at a table when folks give you this kind of money they going to ask for something in return turn so what is it that we prepared to give up to say that folks are going to do this um out of the goodness of their heart we tried that and we're still here so I'm thinking that somebody's going to want something and is the board prepared to give me or whoever some

147Lee about what it is we're looking to give up or to partner with or to do in significant collaboration up to $1 million in collaboration with another entity so I thought about this a lot and I'm open to the conversation but I want us to be clear about what it is asking because folks going to hear it in different ways and all I've said so far is thank you for your voluntary contribution so do we have a concrete idea next step is it and this is not again something that's not going to go away so I don't want to for like a better word put it to a committee it's a whole board conversation so just trying to figure out what we're doing is the idea that the board says yes Dr Brown we want

148you to reach out and begin a conversation and come back to us and have that do we want to I'm I'm trying to see what sort of concrete step we we want to take with the assumption that many of us want to at least explore this option as well right we we talked about exploring the other options when we've assigned some tasks let's do the same thing here if we want to explore this option let's assign some tasks how do we increase the voluntary contribution I I I know Jill and I have had conversation about this before we went from one extreme to the next and but how do we it's more or less saying how do we get up to that point if possible so how can we increase the voluntary contribution over X

149number of years to have discussion so that's what I see that we're having discussion not saying that we're going from 650 today to 10 million three months from now but over time range there yeah yeah yeah over a time period so but how do we increase the voluntary contribution and to have have discussion on it so that's what where we want to do have discussion we may see it as a range here I will say in a number of various places people to me as the number so I want to be clear about that as well it's come to me as the number not a number and so again for me that's why I want to figure out what is a concrete next step of what is so I think I I I don't speak

150for either the board or the university I'm just conjecturing kind of on what my colleagues might think and and what my colleagues at Cornell would think um but I I I think the position of the university is that it makes an enormous contribution to the economy of this community through its payroll its contributions to teat and other means and so I I just don't think there's a sentiment at Cornell that a voluntary contribution is something it should or will do above what they see as their direct receipt of services I believe the historical basis for the number we receive is that children living in tax-free housing are sent to the school district and the university wishes to compensate uh the district for that I think that's the historical means of it if you look at

151the agreement with for example the city of Etha they don't pay the city to be nice uh you know because they want the city to prosper per se but because every time someone pulls a fire alarm in one of the Cornell dormitories a a City truck rolls out there's a cost associated with that and the voluntary payment is meant to be in response to the service provided so I don't think the view of the university is that a payment to the city of Etha is is a voluntary payment but rather a reimbursement uh and I think that's the same thought towards the school district which is why I think that a voluntary contribution above and beyond a reimbursement for what they see as more or less a direct expense is is a non-starter and I

152I think that the Board of Trustees would say that to do so would be violation of their oath but trying to identify strategic Partnerships that benefit the ability of the University attct attract top talent all of whom care very much about the education of their children is a completely different matter so can I build off of that and just say it seems like you know to Karen's point about how does it even get started and to the the points that you've been making Garrick it's and the fact that Dr Brown sounds like you already have an established relationship it seems to me that the first approach would be feeling it out like it seems like you would have a conversation it's not like they don't know that that there are Rumblings in the community and

153that the board hasn't been talking about these things like feeling it out maybe it would be helpful Garrick if we helped come up with a few bullets and talking points to help Dr Brown talk about the mutually beneficial uh goals that we would all like that we all have an alignment to be to as a starting point of like does that does that kind of change your thinking make you want to add any additional contributions blah blah blah blah blah and just kind of go from there at least it's like a he could walk in and they could just be like say what you're just saying right now which is basically like that's not our responsibility we have no interest in changing it or oh that's really interesting those are some good points maybe we

154should talk about it and then see kind of where it goes since none of us seem to really know and it doesn't seem like that would hurt too much given that they have a relationship and then this may be just like a completely naive this is like way outside of my wheelhouse but it also seems like the most likely chance that they would make a dramatic change would be because of pressure from the community less so from us or or Dr Brown I mean maybe they wouldn't but if if it was between one or the other is it like in the same way that you know people again I I I'm I'm hesitant here because I'm I'm just one person and again I don't speak for any of these institutions but if I was to

155put money on a successful approach it would be the Cornell faculty asking for it so either way I I guess I'm just saying like I don't know that it would be us either way no it wouldn't be us so I so what I'm suggesting is like we don't know we have no idea like if if faculty started asking for it the community maybe though what we may realize after Dr Brown has a single conversation is that it might have to be some sort of outside pressure if anything to get things to move and then it might at least answer the question for us that we don't have a lot of a lot more that we can do or maybe it'll help direct us yeah I just feel like we're doing a lot of like guessing

156and that maybe that's like a good first step and then kind of go go from there I mean what you have the relationship like does that seem like a pable step there's some smart people um that are leading that institution and they've been hearing this conversation and yes we've had this conversation about the need to talk about this and do something so that first step you're describing has already taken place and we're still here talking about Dem increas again so more concrete and more direct um if I can offer a suggestion um direct me to begin a process to engage in a negotiation process around this on a binding agreement if we will be so bold I'm struggling with the voluntary contribution piece because of the tenuous nature of that it being here one day

157and gone the next I'm thinking about the city they have an agreement in place and they've been able to quantify in some way why it's mutually beneficial um for our community I will be open and I think that may move us along otherwise we're begging some we're asking someone to give us a lot of or do us a solid when they can choose not to and there are off a contentious contract negotiation they have to rethink their operational budgets I've also been here when Cornell has laid off folks and they've been families that have impacted our schools because of budgetary issues so this thing is complex um and to hold people accountable we would need some kind of agreement in place and that's a completely different conversation instead of I want your voluntary contribution to

158exist is it the sense of the board that we would like to ask Dr Brown to enter into a conversation talking about a negotiated agreement with Cornell no one back that knowing that they could just say no well they can always say no yes uh I I I could support that um I also think a little bit of additional information would be helpful in this conversation uh we I'm certain we can probably find the history of the voluntary contribution um again in my time that that amount has changed and so uh it may be helpful for just hiso like as Karen saying what's the history we can talk about how that came to be uh we probably are able to calculate uh the number of students who are living in Cornell housing that may be

159attending icsd schools to get an idea of what that cost is maybe they're overpaying at 650 maybe they're way underpaying as well right but I think some dad would be helpful and to Jill your question about sort of asking Dr Brown or giving Dr Brown I don't know about necessarily the permission but um saying we would like for you to begin conversations about a negotiated settlement is um something that I would be much more in support of than a voluntary contribution whatever that looks like is a better process um because we've already experienced a drop at one point in time with the voluntary contribution from you know and that was a couple hundred thousand dollars but it was significant enough to have an impact on the budget so as one board member I would be

160in support of making that happen and then um I do have questions about where this conversation continues um I don't know if it's classified as being negotiations um in other words because they I I I'm just I'm also curious about the the conversation as well okay so you know I don't want to get out ahead of my skis but but but you lean too much there you know you could lose your balance uh uh there are governance mechanisms within Cornell that gauge the sentiment of the faculty and the educational needs of Faculty for their families um couple governance institutions uh that are also chartered with Community engagement and have funding for that uh s couple of uh sort of externally fa facing Community engagement governance institution institutions within Cornell so um I don't have the

161thing in front of me so I'm not going to try to say names and get the name a little bit wrong but I I I can tell you what they are I can check the or chart and uh so certainly maybe engaging with those institutions and particularly with the faculty Senate and trying to see whether it would be the desire of the cornal faculty to ask of their own Administration to work in collaboration is is one approach and if if others were interested I'd be more than happy to to work with Dr Brown on maybe engaging again I'm just thinking of hypothetical a governance institution uh like the coral faculty Senate thank you Dr B and I would also add you mention a subset earlier um I would feel more comfortable having this conversation with

162them with along with some board members too maybe some identified representative and I was reading some of the narrative last year that I was singularly in negotiating which I never negotiated and if I was I don't want to be the one person being held responsible for what happens or not particularly when people on the other side of the table could just not come to the table so having some of you partner with me to have this conversation provides uh me a little bit not that I ever need safety or support but I think will help us with our conversation well it be a demonstration of a true partnership and not just you're the person responsible okay we're good for now on option number three we've got a plan we'll come back with the specifics and

163Dr Brown will continue to share his thoughts about who he wants with him and how we might go about this but see this is what I wanted from for tonight was a sense of whether we're interested in moving forward in this and somewhat how so thank you um last uh consolidation redistricting feasibility um again we're looking at possible Revenue sources the advantage of us consolidating um either consolidating schools or consolidating some services with neighboring districts for example would be that the Board of Ed could implement this would reduce reduce costs by closing school buildings for example reducing costs by sharing Services costs of programs at Administration with neighboring school districts disadvantages are obvious everyone hates to close a school it's awkward to combine services or programs at times especially in the beginning it is something

164the state is encouraging which is interesting um and nobody likes to disrupt status quo so what are you thinking would do we want to encourage this do we want to continue to gather [Music] information so the um header should include regionalization yes yeah so that's a program on I never remember that agenda yes yeah so it's just we can I we can look into this and see how it's going to reduce costs and do a whole comparison my apologies I want to go I still don't think that we finished that last bullet point okay but but I'm not going to raise it now there's another time for us to have that meeting to raise that um I don't think I don't see regionalization and consolidation redistricting as being the same in fact they're vastly different

165uh in many regards we would be the Hub of regionalization um particular with our current TST Bosey construct so for me I would separate those two they would achieve different things in different ways um I am uh clearly uh against the idea of consolidation um with that being said I am not against doing research and and the RFP to figure out what the feasibility is and it's probably time for us to do a feasibility study and that's why we're going through this RFP so while I do not support the notion of consolidation I am support of exploring again having the information to make an informed decision now I'd like to push back and say regionalization because we have here reduced cost of by sharing services and costs and that's what we're doing would be sharing

166services and cost within our TST Bose so just for this to be that fourth header not to say all of these fall into this one is consolidation this one is regionalization I think it's different we're talking about taking two two elementary schools and making them into one or consolidation that's why I'm saying for me it's different so instead of bringing up a fifth Point what my suggestion is just have a topic consolidation or redistricting or regionalization whatever just keep it instead of us always adding on this is the fifth sixth and seventh point and need more bullet points in my life come on so this is another one where people are interested or not interested in getting more information talking about what we would gain what we might lose yeah defin don't we already have

167a study moving forward or enrollment and that the study is on enrollment and evaluations of District properties enrollment in the sense of um demographic Trends to inform yeah I don't think the RFP UMES looks looks at consolidation it does it does it looks at consolidation and property valuation but does not look at uh like county level shared services regionalization region it does not look at regionalization it's a tough one okay a separate stud uh I don't know that I would do a study I think I'd have a conversation with the district superintendent um who came to speak to us a little bit about but that' be for me that' be the starting point that the conversation and that's that the state um prioritization of that so there should be more and more information coming out

168on the regionalization aspect okay gosh it's getting late thank you that hit I um I hope I will feel free to come forward with um possible um proposals and I Su suggest that others do on these topics as well fantastic fantastic uh with that being said we have two more agenda items are we good to keep pushing through board members yes uh agenda item uh 10.4 is the district safety plan adoption remember this is something that we do annually uh there was a hearing that was done there's additional information can find here I think I link to it over the weekend to give people access to what the the plan was D Dr Dan bryman did a great job of uh giving us a presentation just before the hearing and so at this point in

169time uh I'm not necessarily anticipating that folks would have um edits or suggestions but if you do by all means let's hear them um otherwise we can call the question well I guess just a quick question to the um gentleman's Point who commented are we that we'll just have a discussion at some point if we needed to make a a change based on decisions thank you for that Emily currently the safety plan does include District relationship with local law enforcement law enforcement agencies it is not specific to the questions we've been asked this evening um and at this point in time uh I think we still need a couple days or two to understand the legalities of what's taken place before I would I wouldn't recommend making edits but with that being said we can

170change the safety plan at any point in time throughout the year so if we decide that there needs to be a change that could happen we'd have to go through another public hearing but that's right it is what it is so we feel like we have to add something great thank you so I can move I shall move I didn't know how to answer that question uh I move to adopt the 2024 2025 District safety plan as recommended by the superintendent of schools I second move by Adam seconded by Karen any discussion debate dialogue hearing none we'll call the question all in favor the motion passes unly thank you very much and then lastly for this evening is agenda item 10.5 this is a resolution for the appointment of board members to the negotiating as

171she say negotiating team um as Dr Brown alluded to and at the leadership of uh Katherine Sena and the negotiating team of the the teacher Association um an Innovative approach to negotiations this year uh very impressive and I do know uh Katherine and their team will be coming to a board meeting to present on this as well uh that will be happening next meeting or the following meeting I'll follow up momentarily we're looking forward to that uh what this States is that um since Jill and I have sort of unofficially been designated as uh representatives of board observers um that we would continue in that role and that we would be invited guests of the negotiating team um sort of on a regular basis so we wouldn't have to come back uh every single time

172that we were performing uh in this capacity so that's what this States here clarification there I believe there are there 10 scheduled sessions how many sessions there that's a great question I know there may be 11 so you and Dr Bradwell and Dr trip are agreeing to attend all 11 we're excited at the prospect right J high five in the hallway once we found out where the location was that's good the answer is yes we have both agreed to attend all the sessions board members would also be um discuss briefly board members would also be welcome to attend the sessions our only caveat would be coordinating to make sure that we had no more than five board members in attendance uh at any point in time but yes we're in agreement to attend the sessions

173wow yes okay thank you I'll just take the wow that felt good I am not retired like Dr trip but I will find I will find time that was an audible laugh we heard you Dr Brown had them all too how about we move it and then see if there's any additional questions and then go or folks are willing to move okay before anyone changes their mind I'll move to appoint Dr Shan eversley Bradwell and Dr Jill trip to serve as the board's observers and invited guests of the district's negotiation team during the current contract negotiations between the Ithaca teacher Association and the Etha City School District I enthusiastically second uh glad you have a lot of time move by Adam and I'm going to give the second to Garrick because of the enthusiasm that

174was expressed um additional questions board members debate colle or questions concerns hearing none we'll call the question all in favor the motion passes unanimously uh thank you board members uh while I know the hour seems late this is still very uh early compared to a number of years ago when we' have board meetings with that being said upcoming dates of importance I would ask the community to pay attention we have a break coming up in February that means that we have changes and alterations to our regular scheduled Tuesday board meetings for example we have a finance and a facility committee meeting that will be held on a Thursday no Finance is Tuesday February 11th facil Thursday the 13th that's with the assessment office and so uh we'll we'll make sure that that gets out to

175the community but just please pay attention to the meeting schedule proceed there any other orders of business or hearing none we'll bring the meeting to a close thank you very much we

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.