001excellent thank you everybody we willall our December 17 2024 meeting to order and uh first item on our agenda is to entertain motions for possible exec I motion to enter into executive session for the purpose of discussions regarding proposal pending or current litigation Collective negotiations pursuant to article 14 of the Civil Serv service law and matters leading to the appointment employment promotion demotion discipline suspension dismissal or removal of a particular person or Corporation second moveed by Karen second by Jill uh debate discussion questions we will call the question all in favor that is unanimous for the folks who are present um we are going to do our best to be back by 7 it will most likely be 705 or 710 just giving folks a heads up and we will see you shortly and we
002are going to the board when we come out St right uh we will continue on with our agenda are there any uh modifications to the agenda hearing none we will continue on with the agenda which brings us to public comment um I feel compelled uh to remind F of our public comment I'm sure everyone has read the policy uh but uh we avoid names and uh if folks go over the three limits I will do my best to politely interject though will'll never cut anybody off if they're close to completing their comments um we would ask if folks would come down to one of the microphones so uh folks could hear online uh it helps with the recording and for posterity uh my colleague Dr Kamp Weiss will read names please give Grace uh names
003are often times difficult to read depending on pronunciation but you may have all these we'll find out in a minute Adam yeah me too um and uh before people speak please also understand that there are times where the board is not able to give a response uh this evening um but at some point in time someone will get back to you to let you know uh that we have uh heard what you have spoken to us so with that being said uh Dr crar okay and if I Mr pronounce your name when you come down you can just uh say it correctly please um Justine boso is the first name I'm here to speak about our P initiative my apologies we want to make is the mic on my apologies thank you there we go
004okay um so I'm here to speak about our PTA initiative to provide air purifiers to classrooms at South Hill Elementary School as parents and teachers we know how often our kids get sick at school it's a lot and it's disruptive both to us as well as to their learning experiences we can significantly reduce Airborne illness by increasing the number of times that air is changed out in classrooms these air changes can come from bringing outdoor air in through ventilation and can be effectively enhanced by using portable hea air purifiers research has shown that increasing the number of air changes per hour to six by adding air purifiers can help reduce a transmission of illness by over 80% in a classroom six air changes per hour means the air is changed over every 10 minutes or
005so and coincide with the ideal air change rate specified in recommendations by the Harvard healthy buildings program dated back to 2020 the American society of heating refrigeration and air conditioning Engineers also known as ashray released the ashray 241 guidelines in June 20123 that recommends six air changes per hour as a minimum Target for Infectious Disease Control in schools and as of last month November 2024 the EPA and the CDC and California Department of Public Health all recommended at least five air changes per schools per hour um to address infectious disease yet our schools only achieved three air changes per hour adding air purifiers can provide these two to three air changes per hour needed to help us reach the minimum Target of six air changes per hour upgrading HVAC is costly and we are not
006asking for that in fact we're not asking for any financial support from the district instead as a PTA all we ask is approval from ICD and the Board of Ed uh to allow our teachers and staff to be able to use the air purifiers that we will provide in their classrooms if they desire that air fires are A lowcost Accessible tool that can be deployed to improve indoor air quality for classrooms immediately school districts around the country have been using air purifiers to help their kids uh stay healthy for example Boston Public Schools who upgraded HVAC systems and added air purifiers to every classroom to reach the six to seven air changes per hour as recommended and they also implemented real-time indoor air quality monitoring that can be accessed by parents and the state of
007Connecticut recently approved over $1 million to provide an air purifier for every classroom in their state given that these recommendations are proven to be effective evidence-based and acted upon by districts around the country parents be would be within their rights to ask why not for our kids and why not for our schools and so I stand here to deliver the petition to you all uh asking you to please approve our initiative and permit teachers to act and to be able to use the air purifiers uh in the classrooms to provide a clean and healthy learning environment for our kids thank you thank you thank you our next speaker is Steve Manley on my way here good um good evening everyone uh thank you for this opportunity my name is Steven Manley uh I am a
008parent of three students in and throughout the district and the parent of a sixth grader who made the decision uh to try Waldorf education this year a parent of a third grader at bjm and a parent of a kindergartener at Bel Sherman I'm here tonight to speak to you and ask you to give your support to bjm as well as you do to all of our schools last week I was inspired by a co-parent and a friend Su Killian who spoke to you about her experience in various schools I've had a similar experience with my kiddos across the district students and their families across the district I believe deserve to know what they can expect from their schools and I believe that our schools look like the communities they serve but there should be some
009balance in the expectations of what our teachers what our schools what our staff and families all can understand in expectation and I want to talk for a moment especially around communication parents at bjm have asked what can we expect from our building leaders and I've been a parent there since 2019 and we've asked every year parents have said what can we do to help in communication in sharing information about the great things that are happening in that building and about the times where the building and the classrooms need support the parents want to help the teachers are amazing the staff care about the school but the wildly different experience of communication that I have received with students at Bel Sherman with students at bjm and now with a student in a Waldorf School are so
010varied as to feel Beyond something that is simply leader driven it seems as if there is not a clear expectation from our district to help our new leaders or all of our leaders know what they can do what they should do what they could do and improve on to share information about our schools about what's happening the tough and the amazing because both of those things happen every day and every building across our district some of our building leaders are amazing and practiced at communicating both of those things others of our building leaders are new to doing and becoming amazing at those things and I would ask that as a board you work with Dr Brown Excuse me with our superintendent and his team ask questions and develop expectations and supports so that teachers and
011families students and parents can enter into any building and have in general a guided understanding of what communication can look like with the aster that every building looks like its community and every building leader is a different human with different skills different talents and different methods that they use I am incredibly impressed by the staff of bjm and by B Sherman and by so many of the other staff members that many of you know I've had the opportunity to work with and next to thank you for your time I encourage you to help set some standards to help us as families know what we can expect more consistently in every building our next speaker up is Haley Jinger yes it's Haley dsinger with a e oh dsinger yes is this guy on okay okay yes
012okay hi I'm Haley dsinger um I have been working at bjm in either A+ which is the bjm after school or as a sub in the building um certain times of the year for the past 18 years I have been a parent of two children who are or were bjm students for the past 14 years um we live just two and a half blocks from the school bjm is our neighborhood school and part of our community um I recently bumped into a new neighbor who has a schoolage child and they have open androll their child in another school because they heard bjm was struggling this saddened me um I do not want to keep hearing stories of teachers or esps or families who have left or planned to leave bjam I love bjam I have
013for the past all the years I've been involved with bjm um I want all kids at bjm to thrive not just survive I do not know the answer nor do I have a clear picture of what the solution ution would be but I ask you as a district to help us find the path to the bjm we all choose the dedication I see every day I walk into the school is immense staff working to get subs into the right places teachers working to keep students engaged and learning and feeling seen and loved um ESP is going above and beyond to keep keep their students safe and happy and having a smooth day as smooth as they can as we look forward we need to look at teacher retention ESP retention and keep our families in
014our school um we need experien teachers as role models to the new teachers coming in we can't just have a school full of new teachers we got to keep the teachers we have that have been there and are dedicated school and do everything we can to have them be happy we need to fund building Subs because they know the students the best they watch the students as they grow from K to fifth grade we need to value our esps because their role is as important as any in the school building let us move forward to build our bjm community and strive for the best we can thank you for being here our final speaker for tonight is Michael Hayes good evening my name is Michael Hayes I'm here to ask board um to put on
015the agenda for next month um approval of the new Tomkins County lowincome scale for property tax um similar to a year ago um I'm a taxpayer my wife's disabled we are lowincome and every bit of that helps Tomkins County made a lot smaller adjustment this year it's only a $1,500 change so the economic impact to the school district is likely to be minimal and I'd be glad to send all the materials in advance of January for you to review and to speak at the meeting in January that's it ad our speakers yes thank you uh board responses fantastic uh thank you to everyone who's come to speak with us this evening um we will be following up with additional conversations into uh the last request um I think my immediate recommendation would be that we
016put that on a finance committee agenda to start not to put that work on Dr Block's table uh but that would be the best place to begin that conversation for us as we move forward as it would have budget implications so uh I assume the two of you will connect and we can have that conversation there um and any additional information you want to send will be our way as well thank you uh that brings us to our student reps evening our first thing is that the choir concert was last week and it was absolutely magical I've heard and the IIs bands have their Winter concert tomorrow in cul auditorium at 7:30 p.m. featuring several chamber groups concert band and Wind Ensemble and our director Miss sa was Al also recently named the music teacher
017who makes a difference of New York state by the school band Orchestra magazine and 15 members of the new of a new club music Kore performed at beach tree this past Sunday and then talked to Residents and helped to serve lunch they even honored requests after performing what they had rehearsed and the students specifically started this club to bring the joy of music to those in our community who cannot attend it uh who cannot attend concerts and after a very memorable first show they hope to reach out to other senior centers in the coming year and as we've entered in the winter season there's been a rising need for substitute teachers in our classes and so yesterday on the Monday we had a lot of fail to- fill classes and an overwhelming email sent out
018to our teachers about covering for other classes as well and so we understand that it's very difficult to solve this issue quickly um but we do hope that there are efforts made so that all of our classes get adult supervision um and we want to recognize the staff in our Welcome Center who have been stepping up to cover some of these classes everybody good night or good evening so we have a new recycling program that's going to be going online hopefully in the next couple weeks it's for paper only I know I keep mentioning this but the reason is because we're going to be making an instructional video soon which is going to be disseminated to the entire student body we're in the process of writing several versions of a schoolwide announcement so we hope
019that by the next time we speak with you guys will have at least a week worth of data on this to share another thing we've been doing is uh the reading up on the Blue Ribbon plan that's hopefully going to be discussed later tonight I see it on the agenda and you know we may have some questions during that presentation especially about the timeline and the certainty of the changes at the state level as well as how much Authority we would have over the specifics of their implementation and then lastly I had another rep mention this at the last voting meeting which I unfortunately could not attend but I'm very grateful for the opportunity last week to visit dit Middle School along with the high school restorative justice team and Dr rman to receive training
020in conflict resolution from Dr Win hopefully I'm going to be able to attend a training at the elementary school level soon also and I look forward to having some more conversations about these restorative justice practices with members of my school administration and potentially the board as well thank you student reps board responses well I'd like to say thank you CLA for sharing about the um student group who sang at beach tree I heard them and it was very good thank you very much for them doing that hear the board responses thank you to our student reps we look forward to additional information moving forward uh it brings us to our next agenda item which is the consent agenda and we will entertain motions and we will entertain motions and move to move forward to speak
021I move to approve all consent agenda items listed in consent agenda consideration of accounts Personnel report and minutes of previous meeting as presented second mov by Aaron second by Adam uh questions discussion debates uh I would like to identify that the consent agenda includes um a number of uh support from the Ithaca public education initiative we are always greatly appreciative of the work that IPI does thank you greatly for the long list of Partnerships that are in included on this agenda again we are very appreciative of all of that uh if there are no other questions or debate or discussion or comments we will call the question all in favor is unanimous thank you all very much um that is fantastic uh that will bring us to um uh superintendent report Dr Brown uh thank
022you for the opportunity Dr Bradwell so nice to be here and I too wish to uh thank IPI it's been 14 years I continue to look at uh the amount of money that has come to our school district from our community and the leadership of IPI Mr Manley I recognize you too for your leadership for so many years um just thank you um this is uh as I've said many times before um I am not accustomed to being in a school district where people bring you money like this so U whenever I was brought up when people give you something you say Thank you so thank you all and more importantly and and equally important um now the time of you one I want to highlight andore our district communication channels um our icfd Insider
023will be coming out tomorrow and I'm asking folks to look check out the web page um the events that were mentioned already um the folks from ACS aren't here but they had their winter festival on Friday all these amazing events are posted there in advance and then the highlights and the pictures and the News briefs are also posted on the website and as we come back from our break uh we will be intensifying our budget deliberations and conversations so I'm going to be asking folks to go to that instance on our web page where the meetings like last Thursday's evening's meeting finance committee was one of the more impactful ones I was not here but I was able to watch it online and then I had my friends and family actually go back and um
024assess you in the ways in which it was facilitated and the information that was shared and and you said it earlier um Professor Bradwell folks all over the country are watching our meetings for the ways in which it flows and for the information and the ways in which we um engage in constructive dialogue all of that can be found on our website um timestamped and by category and by subject so I'm saying this and I'm underscoring it tonight because when we get back it's going to be a lot happening in January and February and March and I want folks to know that you can follow it or get to it whenever you have time um and if there's any other feedback on our communication channels and the ways in which we do it um we
025welcome that too um through our let's talk portal so thank you again for the opportunity thank you greatly appreciate it um an awkward moment for me in this time is we have uh two phenomenal presentations uh one with a returning uh phenomenal uh administrator who's going to be joining us momentarily and then uh two others administrators have been working diligently on a cell phone policy uh and with that being said I need to excuse myself from this meeting and so I am handing the Reigns over to Dr crant Weiss and my sincerest apologies uh for missing these two presentations I be look forward to watching them soon board colleagues good luck this evening thank you that was the next one okay picking up uh we have agenda item 10.1 regionalization and blue Riven commission uh
026with Lily telit joining us back at the table for the first time hi everyone I have to say it was uh surprisingly emotional to walk back into this building um you know I spent 19 years in the itha city school district uh and to get to come back and talk with you all this evening uh was was a lot and it's a real honor so for those of you who don't know me my name's Lily Kavanagh talit and I have the great honor of serving as the district superintendent and CEO of Tomkins senica tyoga bosis and I have been there for 99 days uh so clearly I'm nailing it you know all the pieces of it right yes um um but it's been uh really exciting 99 days to get to work not only in
027our region but also at the state so just drove back from Albany this afternoon so we're going to talk a little bit today um about both regionalization and the Blue Ribbon commission I want to start with this slide um because Dr Betty Rosa the commissioner of the New York State education department she's an incredible leader incredible human and all of the work that she has been leading uh first as Chancellor and now as the commissioner of the New York State education department is firmly grounded in equity and Excellence everything she does right so every initiative that you see is going to be about raising both of those right you cannot have one without the other um and the State education department is very clear about that and so you're going to see a lot of
028threads a lot of similar themes around promoting Equitable access and opportunities for young people regardless of zip code regardless of um opportunities that have been given um while also lifting up some of the standards and the learning experiences for young people to prepare them for a world that does not yet exist right so uh I'm I'll start with blue ribbon commission head to regionalization and I'll talk a little bit about the process moving forward I will also say this presentation was exceptionally long and I hid a number of slides that you can go in and you can take a look at later if you would like to all right um so back in 19 we met all across the state at the 37 different bosies some of us who are in this room now we
029actually in the room at Tomkins senica tyoga bosis um because the then commissioner was asking us to think about the ways in which graduation measures should shift what do kids need and how do our systems need to change in order to reflect those changing needs um there was a pandemic in in the middle there so things kind of got thrown off a little bit but um ultimately four Transformations have been recommended honestly from school districts from kids and staff and Educators and administrators and families and community members this has all been crowdsourced um and the Board of Regents has adopted these four Transformations um ensuring that kids have they know they're going for this portrait of a graduate that schools are redefining credits and learning experiences so we're not just locked into the 22 they're
030going to Sunset exit exams that's right Sunset Regents requirements and move to one New York State diploma so these are the Transformations from which the timeline and all of the activities that are coming from a lot of text on this slide I'm not going to read it all but I think it's important to understand that there's there's a really clear theory of change that all of us who work for the Department of Education are operating from um we're trying to change a really old system in order to like I said better meet the needs of kids for rapidly changing world um and so operating from a common theory of change can be extremely helpful so here's the portrait of a graduate has anyone seen this you seen this I'm sort of looking at some of
031the students like have you seen this yet all right great um so this portrait of a graduate um is going to be finalized relatively soon but um I'm going to ask the board what are some of the things that you notice about the portrait of a graduate what do you notice this is where you get to talk I'll start us off by saying what I said when we had um School Board business meeting it's the first line New York State graduates are ready for college career and Civic engagement that that includes every aspect of them being part of the their community thank you certainly cultural competence as a big as a big section of what we expect of our graduates is relatively new to me thank you anything one thing I notice that a number
032of people bring up when we're talking about this is that out of the seven literate across the content areas is is equal uh we spend a lot of time on content making sure that kids learn things and stuff and this is certainly focused quite a bit more on the ways in which students will be prepared for Life After High School so this is linked um I think for some for some of us who for some folks who serve on boards um or who may be newer to boards to get a sense of what it actually could look like for some of these Transformations I wanted to share this and it's it's linked in there um to get a sense of some of the ways that we could move Beyond standardized testing so you'll see the
033current model that we have right now everything over that's over in blue um and this chart is helpful because it really outlines exactly what some of the shifts would be so instead of having um uh different levels of diplomas instead there would be one but districts could select seals and endorsements to allow students to follow an area of interest and demonstrate their knowledge and understanding in a much more performance-based type of way as opposed to credit requirements in the Regents instead New York state is talking about moving toward this evidence-based system um so that there are different ways for kids to show what they know or learn or the ways in which they've learned lecs did does something like this and has for for five decades um and so the state is looking at doing
034something that is more aligned with those kinds of assessment practices um and this last one is districts can't require things in addition to you know one of my colleagues uh across the state um has a district where they require all students to take and pass a swimming test before they'll give them the their diploma right New York state is going to say you can't do that anymore right kids uh need to meet the bare minimum um which is actually relatively rigorous um and you can't impose further requirements so here here's the timeline and if you go to the New York State education department website they're actually Linked In the notes here you can see the New York inspires timeline that goes through very specifically all of the actions that are related to this but ultimately
035we're talking about fall of 2029 so Cadman great question before um this is going to be a relatively long process when you see 2029 plus we're actually talking about another four years after that because some of these changes are for fresh freshman right in 2029 so I'll pause there any questions about the Blue Ribbon commission there's a ton of other slides that are in there U but I wanted to be cognizant of time yeah two good questions so first of all do we know if the complete rollout will be starting after fall 2029 do we know what elements will be included in the 2025 to 27 installation or the initial implementation yep so all of that is outlined on New York inspires and so it's linked um in that and uh so for example finalizing
036the portrait of a graduate and ensuring that there are rubrics to help folks understand what what that actually is um what's really interesting about this process uh is that it's iterative to Cadman so instead of saying okay the New York State education department is saying this is exactly what it's going to be instead it's very crowdsourced as I said before so Educators and students and families and business owners and community members and administrators those folks are actually the ones who are contributing to all of this um so it takes a little bit longer but it's done in a way that is so much more inclusive and allows more voices to come to the table so it would be more District dependent in a sense more community driven than a state mandate no this will definitely
037be a state mandate but the way in which it's developed is is yeah through those local convenings and connections and forums and things like that so it could vary by District slightly in the implementation it it may but again if you see the full timeline you'll see there's very specific actions Lily what what it's a diploma for all and but what about the students who do not meet those rigorous requirements yes so what Erin is talking about are um students who are Nisa eligible so New York State alternative assessment eligibility is determined through the committee on special education or the csse and Nisa eligibility is uh typically for young people um you know I say the federal government suggests that about 1% of students across the country um qualify for for Nisa in New York
038state it's 2.9% so we have a a little bit of a higher higher ratio there um and so that's part of what the department is also seeing the ways in which it needs to be shifted so they're listening to the field what needs to change about that potentially as well thanks sure other question questions so one more just because we talk a lot about standards based grading here does this mean that there's going to be a Statewide shift to that what are we seeing there we're going to see a lot of things that align with standard space grading for sure um you know grading is still in in in regulation it's still up to school districts um but it's it's going to be because of the shifts in teaching and learning and the ways in
039which we're assessing students not through traditional sit down get out your pencil and take this multiple choice test um that things will be much more performance-based and that proficiency is going to be determined instead on how you show what you know um that you know I think it aligns with a lot of those principles but standards based grading is not you know what New York state is saying that's exactly what we're going to do perfect thanks all right so regionalization if you've been reading certain articles from Long Island you may have been hearing about regionalization in some interesting ways um in the rest of the state I will say it's really about Collective planning um and so in in a lot of these conversations I like to start with this concept um this South African
040and West African concept of umuntu I am because we are so our region is 10,877 kids about half of those kids live in itha and attend the Ithaca City School District there are things that happen here that don't happen a neighboring school districts there are also lots of things that happen in our neighboring school districts that kids in Etha don't have access to um and so in our conversations in our region with our superintendents and with our assistant superintendents with our principals and all of these Regional groups that we have we're talking a lot more about the collective we and that's really the idea behind regionalization so um you know Dr Jeff Madison who is the senior Deputy Commissioner for P20 policy who was the former district superintendent at Tomkin senica tyoga bosis he has
041really been leading the charge around regionalization and he's really clear there are a number of challenges that we're facing right um and there some of them are great challenges like graduation meure initiative that's really exciting um but a lot of districts and districts in our region are are struggling with some f fiscal constraints and some challenges it's not the way that it used to be right um and then that's then impacting kids ability to access awesome programming um whether it's through Regional Transportation or it's through sharing classes um kids kids are missing out um and so we want to have these conversations to ensure more kids have more access um so these are you know certainly some of the um the ideas some of the ideas and possibilities that are within regionalization I will say
042that within our superintendent group we right now are having a lot more conversations at the very beginning stages around operations so we're talking about commissioning a regional transportation study right we're starting with these things that are very concrete um that would allow for more kids to get to school on time right throughout throughout our our community um so you may not see some of those things yet but they those are some of the um sort of some of the bones I think um in terms of how we're we're thinking about regionalization um I will say Just One of the guiding principles uh regionalization is often conflated with reorganization or mergers those are actually two very different things right there's a ton of Regulation around reorganization mergers annexation Etc I'm happy to talk to you about
043that another time um but really specifically re uh regionalization is about having those conversations around kids having access to high quality programming so there's a 10year cycle that districts um have the option to participate in um and really it's just having conversations and working together among our nine school districts to engage in some planning together no district is required to do it um and every district has to sign off on what parts of any plan that's designed they want to participate in so say um if it a new Fields want to share something right say it's a uh Regional Food Service situation right um and Lancing doesn't want to participate in it that's fine right um I will say that and if um if we look at some of the enrollment Trends so I pulled
044your data um over the last 10 years so you could understand there's you know if we look at the 20y year um overall enrollment uh it's dropped 11% but the needs um and the population and the fabulous humans that walk through this store to receive an education that's also shifting so the number of kids who are considered to be mckin vento or or who are unhoused right now increased 47% this data is actually really similar across the region so in our nine school districts you actually see some really common elements very similar to this so I know having been in Ithaca for so long that itha can feel really different from a Trumansburg or a south senica or a new field but in a lot of ways there are a lot of similarities and we're
045trying to meet the needs of kids across these nine school districts in some different ways and boy we could work together right probably in some other ways in order to really meet their needs ultimately what we're going to have is a regionalization report and it's going to have three sections those key priority areas say we're going to do something around transportation and um you know both these we're applying for a food infrastructure Grant um to support the preparation and storage and distribution of healthy foods right um so it could have specific ideas and areas for regionalization it'll also have very specific support requests so we might come up with something like hey we don't get Transportation Aid back on field studies or field trips we'd like that regulation to shift ultimately the State education department
046needs those in order to design the legislative agenda and the and the funding requests for across the street from from uh the State education department right so bringing it to the governor um and bringing it to state government um and then there will be some very specific actionable uh next steps I'm G to pause I could probably talk about this for like five more hours um but I would love to take any questions thoughts ideas Lily the first question that pops to my mind and has been when I read about regionalization is that I love it in theory I love ideas here but I fear that the state is already looking at this as cost-saving measures I do in in your work are you seeing that this is something that like is the state looking
047at this as cost savings or just a way for us to utilize what we have because if we cut any more you know of State funding so we're we're in this really interesting position the New York State education department like I said is literally across the street from the capital so the commissioner of education is not in the cabinet with the Govern the governor right we're a SE we're a separate entity um so we put forward proposals and they may or may not get picked up so when the governor indicated that uh Foundation Aid save harmless all sorts of things were going to go away she was very clear about that um and she also commissioned a study put an RFP out for organizations to do the foundation Aid study that you saw that the
048Rockefeller um Institute revealed in the beginning of December so the New York State education department offered to do that study but it would take two years and it would be about a million dollars the Rockefeller Institute offered to do it in less than half the time and for twice the cost um and uh and that's what we went forward with and then um I would say within hours the governor of that release of that report um indicated that she was not interested in eliminating safe harmless so I'm sure you saw um you know uh her her statement and relationship to that so so I'd say all of that to say the New York State education department knows that the capital is looking at at shifting funding how do we do that in a way that's
049respectful of the human beings who are actually trying to do the work um actually thinks this is a great solution yep we have to have we have to engage in conversations what where are we duplicating efforts and how can we share not even necessarily through bosies right but share more in order to better meet kids needs and also yeah save money may I ask question always if so to have you at this table uh more importantly it's nice to have you in this leadership role um and I think I'm uniquely positioned to ask this question or to make this statement um I've sat through at this table um as one of the longest serving superintendents in the state with multiple Governors and multiple Commissioners let me be clear um Jeff Madison and Betty Ros are
050two of the best leaders I've had an opportunity to work with I would agree and uh I've worked with the others their predecessors now you I I saw the time to act is now and I've been tasked to help our community and Lead this board through a lot of acting now coming from your seat including I was making a list uh race to the top engage New York APR culturally responsive Frameworks engage New York all things that um when the folks in those two seats I mentioned shifted um we were left holding the bag so I asked this question um I think I'm asking on behalf of all superintendents in our state um and a board in the community what's been mandated and what's not because I didn't hear what's been part of the law
051and what must we do and what is optional because some of these things right now the culturally responsive sustaining framework was some of the best work I've seen come out of the state ad Department in a decade that could change the lives of young people across our state if not the nation and when we've pushed and when I pushed to make sure it was um at professional development in front of every student and on every desk um when the Heat and the resistance came which we knew was inevitable I didn't have anybody from stay there looking at me to say no this is mandated so we're talking about regionalization sharing Services we're talking about um a lot of stuff that's going to as we're seeing is getting a lot of resistance already a portrait of
052a graduate um that would change everything from standardized assessments to um how we engage with families in a good way but when I and we step out there and I look for stay there what are y'all going to be doing and what have you already been done to give us some support in these efforts that can you know have survive to many of superintendant many of superintend have lost their jobs because of the things I mentioned earlier including APR um so I don't hope nobody else watches this later but I do want I'm positive people will but I don't want to be quoted in this B Clips tomorrow either so I'm asking a genuine question about what am I gonna have some trouble for yeah no I think it's a fair question and especially since
053what we've seen in relationship to regionalization um you know so I I heard someone say well Long Island did regionalize they were really they were really excited about it they regionalized and hired lawyers to sue the state um over it so um and when you when you're receiving $500 per child um in Foundation age because you actually don't qualify for any but that's the minimum um you know there's there's a lot of wealth that's that's in those in those areas and um you know folks are feeling really good about what they had in their school districts and they weren't interested in sharing and so that's when we saw the the shift to yeah it's optional because we also have districts in the state that are like help us now we have school districts that are
054tuition out students to high school be to a neighboring high school because they can't afford to run a high school anymore um so we've got a really really wide swath we have some school districts that have 150 kids in the North Country right so we've got to figure out some sort of solution that addresses that and I I can understand I wish I could predict the future and say Yes Betty Rosa Dr Betty Rosa is g to stay forever and she she is going to stand her ground I will say she is one of the smartest strongest leaders I know and um I know she believes in this I know we as District superintendant believe in this um and what I can promise you is that I'm going to continue to push for whatever backing
055um we need so that our kids get what they deserve thank you now have we done any of this on a um small scale I I recall it last month um the German Educators were here talking about the German trip that we um approved for July and they said that gron used to participate and gron has no longer participating I believe because they may not have that class there I remember some agreements we side where um a athletes may come and join here because they don't have enough students on their soccer team or cost to more something like that so is that like a small scale of that whole regionalization yeah absolutely I mean Bose's Mary Grover and I were talking earlier Bose's is regionalization right those are those are the things that that we
056we already do we provide um you know garbage removal for school districts um we support professional development we support itinerant teachers we have special education programming ptech High School Etc right and there are some of our districts that are already doing some sharing um and that is through either intermunicipal agreements that their that their boards have voted on or um they're for they're through some sort of informal agreement you know if there's two kids that uh want to take calculus in the entire high school at South senica they may not be able to hire a a math teacher in order to teach that um but Trumansburg may already have it um and so there are some possibilities and things that people are already have already started um and what I think is really helpful and
057at our last superintendent meeting um I think you were traveling but we were talking about um smaller scales exactly what you're talking about where districts that are physically near one another may be able to share something right and then share out that that example I will say our region we have really strong superintendent we have a really good group of folks um and um there there's there's a willingness and an eagerness to try to do better for more of our kids um so they're they're excited to find possibilities that may be may seem really small in order to help build up our muscles around that kind of sharing did I answer your question Karen yes and when you said that it could be operations focused too and I think of um this whole mandate with
058electric vehic and how would that work do we need to do some sort of Transportation study across all TST and charging stations and located different places and then it was brought up when Jill did the presentation on the revenue exploration committee now where is there what is the financial benefit for each school so is that going to be outlined in like the process in the early stag lny you should ask a couple of weeks ago we just got a quote for a regional transportation study uh to take a look at the current bus garages and systems mechanics Roots all sorts of things Transportation supervisors all of those kinds of things EV charging um we did one about 10 years ago um not every District participated in our region um so we're looking at full participation
059this time around and including some others as well uh so the superintendent and I are going to talk a little more about that in January um and decide what we want to do in relationship to that it's a lot more expensive than it was years ago to do the study um but it could it could certainly help so yeah that's exactly what we're talking about but is this a matter I mean is this it to the point yet where it's Financial incentive to do this or a budget necessity like where are we at are we at the Tipping Point already because I think it's a budget necessity not a financial incentive I mean the the wish and I think for some is that it would be both so if our if save harmless goes away
060our region stands to lose $7 million in one budget cycle that's a lot of money um and so yeah for some of our school districts we you know certainly need it um and for some school districts they want to figure out how to create a ker um or a shared service through bosei so that they can get Aid back on it the following year so that there is a financial incentive and I think that's where some of the regulatory changes or proposed changes could come through um so are there ways to shift a ability or um some of the regulations around Aid return if you're a wealthier school district versus a school district um you know some of our districts get 90 90 cents back on the dollar right and others others don't so maybe
061we want to put out some possibilities for very specific coaster that they shift that structure one of the subtle shifts I've seen this iteration versus others and Mr gr was with me when we were talking about fiscal sustainability when we talked about mergers and all those things and what we found was no one merged even though there was fiscal solvency um on the line I'm hearing now subtly which I'm hoping would be much more explicit um is instructional solvency when folks see about the offerings here in ethical City School District and they are two three four miles away from us and they have a significantly different experience both instructionally and now financially now they're raising questions about the um instructional programming and that's different I had not heard that in previous situations I just hope
062that but but I'm also another critique I had a lot of critique I guess I'm I'm an elder and an old guy now one of my critiques has been um we started that conversation around instructional um needs and it it is quickly shifted to the financial one so I'm hoping that we can Elevate that part again for folks um yeah yeah with hopes that this will be different than the other ones yeah I mean that's part of the power of superintendent attending the curriculum instruction and assessment committee as opposed to just um assistant superintendents and directors of curriculum um we're trying to connect everybody to teaching and learning yeah more so at bosis um so that we're facilitating those kinds of conversations go ahead Claire I was wondering so like as as a whole state
063we're like interested in Cross District learning for students right like sharing instruction and so I was wondering if we would be relying on um like the instruction to happen jointly over the Internet or like using computers or if we would be like transporting students across one District to another these are excellent questions that we don't know because we uh each region or each [Music] um bosis so there's 37 of the board of Cooperative Educational Service or bosies and um each of those 37 plans is going to look different yeah so would it be potentially the case that we'd have one nearby District let's assume they had a class that we didn't or we had a class that they didn't that we would be somehow sharing students across those two districts for this one class if
064there was enough interest or something like that potentially so those are some of the ideas that some folks folks have uh floated you know itha doesn't have uh an a program right um and so and yet a number of our neighboring uh the neighboring school districts do um there's a uh fabulous steam center that's already built in groten where kids have access to a number of different career oriented learning experiences that are a lot more fluid um I know here in Ithaca you all are building a steam or STEM Center and might be able to create something like that um but those are the kinds of opportunities that are really Innovative and really exciting um and I think those are some of the sharing opportunities that more folks honestly Cadman can kind of get behind
065as opposed to okay we're going to share a very traditional geometry program and we're all sitting and and doing a traditional uh geometry program although who knows what that will create again it's they're going to be through the plan development is going to be through convenings of our region our community so the people doing it actually will decide so last question for me hopefully then um so hearing this then putting the financial cynicism that I am bringing to the table aside realism yeah thank you for this um that's the painful part but so let I guess looking for the hopefulness of this there are there is a lot of opportunity so things from like arts and Sports and Outdoor wreck and all sorts of is is it kind of like our do we have an
066opportunity to shape this then if we start getting in now as a district totally okay and what would you then recommend as someone who's on the ground floor we as a board start thinking about in in using this to our advantage I would say when the invitation arrives show up for the convenings contribute your thinking to the collective any other board comments or questions okay well a lot to take in and think about thank you so much for coming tonight presenting thanks for having me okay our next our next item of business tonight item 10.2 cell phones in school update we're going to bring down Mary Grover and Carrie Burke that glad hi good evening my name is krie Brook I'm director of health services and wellness for the district good evening Mary Grover assistant
067superintendent of teaching learning thanks for having us all right so we're going to frame how any potential shifts in cell phone use what's happening and the impacts to teaching and learning so um next slide Trisha think oh where's there oh oh it's here awesome thank you I get to drive that doesn't happen much um this is a timely topic many of you know um one of the issues one of the reasons that we're here talking about this today is that the governor this summer went on a Statewide listening Tour on this on this very issue um collecting feedback from stakeholders in districts and in the community students parents and Educators around the issue of cell phones and their impact on youth mental health and well-being so late um August this this past School year um
068we decided to convene representatives from every Union leadership and some some school board members attended to talk about what this legislation means for us in far in so far is what brings us hope about it and so some of the collective thinking on that was about um increased opportunities to connect with students face-to-face communication uh the part ership that this conversation could lead to with students staff caregivers reviewing some of the research on Mental Health um those were some of the topics that surfaced we also discussed as a collective what brings us concern and so some of the things that surfaced were uh the use of cell phones um as far as supporting universal student needs we have you know students using these for everything from medical issues students and staff um and that was
069something that Rose to the top fairly quickly um that I hadn't thought about before um the other uh concerns that came were what would this mean for starting and greeting students um so what kind of structures or supports would be needed so we don't welcome students to a classroom and and starting with conflict um an approach that wouldn't result in increased discipline or disproportionate suspensions of students um and then another comment um around caregiver access and wanting to be able to connect with their children and the need of emergency and so here's where we're Landing right now in subsequent meetings um one we're really looking at how our own personal experience and approach might impact how we're looking at this and how we how how do we want this to end um who isn't at
070the table that needs to be and how the issue might be affecting them and then some things that surface for example uh in Communications we set out a communication um earlier this year referencing a Snapchat threat um and the question we got most back was what's Snapchat so that's a feedback loop that illustrates an opportunity to have conversations with caregivers about what's on phones how kids are using phones um one thing I really appreciate um Katherine talks a lot uh Katherine Sara um talks a lot about the culture of accessibility that we've all grown really used to and and that's surfacing and our conversations as well sharing a quote with you here from the governor um hearing from young people and educators will allow us to develop effective solutions to address this Mental Health crisis
071deliver results for our kids in school so as we mentioned uh the governor has completed a listening tour um over the summer continues to meet with stakeholder groups uh I think this is instructive too in part our desire to move forward our desire to Center the voices of students caregivers and staff in considering what ultimately a a district policy might be on this topic um to the end and this is a very long quote but essentially what the governor signaled is uh her desire to go big to introduce a Statewide policy so um if if you've been following the news at all there are currently 19 states that have some sort of either restriction or outright ban or requirement that school districts have policy so it really varies what this sort of indicates or signals
072that the government is not going to leave it up to districts to themselves to decide whether or not to have a policy how far she may go with it is not clear U I'll be paying close attention to future communications including the State of the State in January um but it doesn't seem like this is an issue that's that's going away or that uh she has an interest in um she certainly expressed interest in moving forward on so so um with that said we would like to engage in a similar process we want to create multiple opportunities venues and channels for people to provide their insights to provide their input on uh current state uh future State uh concerns to elevate those voices of of persons who are otherwise maybe not at the table um
073we are putting a prompt in our uh ICD Insider to invite comment we've uh tagged or created a featured topic on our let's talk page specifically around the cell phone policy uh we foresee an opportunity to collaborate with our ptas and Community groups to organize forums for listening for feedback um and we're also looking to add questions to our annual end of the year survey which is completed sent to and completed by caregivers students and staff alike which presents again a unique opportunity presuming we have more information from what the governor intends to do um to help shape uh future policy I would point two to this guide I just want to reference this guide um has been was published earlier this month by the US Department of Education is a wonderful wonderful um resource
074and we've been pouring over it in our conversations and discussions about this very topic so here's just a brief snapshot of what exists and where we we are right now at the beginning of the year um we did some information sessions with administrators that they could use with their communities at the their opening conversations around custodio which is an app that every device is on so parents receive a report when students are using a school device on where they're spending time and they can register for free uh their students personal advice they wish so that's one structure that exists engaging curriculum thank our Educators for creating Project based learning opportunities the other ways that they're getting student input on the the lessons learning opportunities they facilitate uh we also have talking circles and restorative justice
075work specifically around cell phone policy and the talk portal for people to give us input in the middle column you're going to see a link to Communications that have gone out um to community members at Pointon to it itha High School you see examples of what's happening right now and then further collaboration with the parent and teacher associations and our icsd communication team the document that Carrie referenced is one that we're pouring over to to work with the policy committee on drafting something that's going to work for our community I would also add um in a in a shout out to uh thank you Karen for sharing those resources this afternoon and Aon the letter that went out with the TST Board Association and that Collective approach is we have a draft um and one
076similar to go out and the slide deck you shared I'll add onto this slide from other districts who've navigated this right what questions do you have I just have one um so if the governor makes a policy that would kind of supersede anything that we would do as a school district like if right if yes and we have the opportunity to implement it and I think have an opportunity right now to inform and dictate what that could look like because even the practices that we've seen so some of the practices for example at point and doitt and speaking with the building leaders said we've seen a reduction in discipline referrals specifically related to cell phones just simply about asking students to put them away collaborating with caregivers and talking about it I may miss where
077is that information that you collected about what's happening at the schools right now oh it's in in that um system structures and sustainability the middle column it's hyperlink and the middle column on the first it's a folder with the communications I I would just say one more thing I was at you know at least one of the meetings where we were sort of talking about um you know all of the different um I guess hopes and concerns I like that terminology um I I don't really have an answer to this and I don't expect anybody to have the answer to it I'm just sort of interested um that when we're choosing the policy it's really it's really a big part of that is choosing which criteria to Center when we're making the policy because just
078going to one of those meetings and hearing all the different perspectives and hearing all of the different reasons you know to do it or to not do it I think the interesting part is going to be sort of which which criteria are going to sort of rise to the top to orient the direction of the policy because there's so many ways that it could go so I think that's going to be a big question and maybe helpful in the conversation but trying to figure out like what are the top priorities as opposed to trying to include everything because I was looking at the last thing where it said like creating a policy that works for everyone which I feel like would be amazing but I think probably some people will really like certain aspects of
079it some people won't um so anyway I'm just kind of interested to see the the direction that it goes in but I I I recognize the complexity and I think um having participated in some of the conversations I would only just say that um the complexity becomes more clear as you talk more about it with different people whereas I think people come into the I I came into the conversation on a certain side and by the time I left the conversation I felt like oh wow yeah I'm not sure now um so just just wanted to make that comment I think we're um we we're going to benefit to from the fact that you have sort of this like natural experiment playing out across these 19 States so in the months ahead I'm anticipating more
080reporting or maybe even more research about what's working and what's not working I would say in that that Playbook that the Department of Education published um there was a case study in there of a School District that had a policy and then over the course of the school year engaged in these iterative processes to figure out do we need to change it what's different so I think to that end too knowing that we may pursue a certain direction allowing ourselves the possibility of revisiting and making changes based on where things stand I I think it's important too that as a board and and when we're talking to the community about this something something that works for everyone isn't necessarily everyone's preference and I've even have to shift my own views as a board member right
081I personally wish there were no phones in schools at all because it's so distracting but that there are other people's needs that need to be considered and just hard work doing that and the harder thing takes more time and the slide that that I shared this afternoon with um Mary and Carrie is the same slide that I shared with the board my colleagues after Erin and I went to nisa's convention in October and it was a slide of a school that said that their best policy included input from the students they they weren't the um the caregivers yes they wanted provided input and they did hear from the caregivers but they need to buy in especially from secondary students that they are involved in the process to make sure the cell phone is this policy
082is adhere to and um with regard to the governor um that's why on we're on Erin and I are on TST Bose School Board Association and the group of representatives from school boards throughout TST signed a letter to the governor to assembly member Kellis to Senator web just saying make sure it's localized that each School District can provide an input into their policy not a mandate because we know where the mandates go at times and and the impact that have has on us thank you for the presentation um can we talk a little bit about timeline because this is also you know collecting information we could do it forever also and there also is we know that there is to to some degree urgency I think almost the major certainly the majority of the policy
083committee meetings have had one to several members of the community come and speak about it and we've certainly have received a lot of emails so how can we both balance the very important need of getting feedback from all members of the community students families Educators Etc and you know assure folks that we aren't going to be doing in that stage forever and kind of what those next steps might be like or what um what deadlines we might be kind of setting for ourselves i' i' I have I don't want to predict the future or make any declarations but I have some degree of confidence that the governor will determine that timeline in part um as as to when uh districts either have to develop a policy or begin implementing one that the state hands down
084so I think some of that will be out of our control that being said um there around the um there are opportunities to potentially do things sooner rather than later um I was sharing with Mary earlier one of the districts we were reading about uh enacted like a two- week ban you know as a as a trial as a pilot to sort of sus out any concerns or issues uh to hone their Communications so there are certainly things we could look at to do to do this year in advance or Preparation of a a future policy implementation is there anything you want to add yeah I would add we can add a specific timeline to the slide deck is a good question um and that I foresee a concentration of getting student and caregiver input
085in January and February with making some recommendation in March that's great that's very helpful I I appreciate that um and I think you know while mandates do come down from from the governor and can feel sudden it also you know we are we like to this District likes to tout itself as being kind of ahead of the curve and so we also you know I think that they might also be sending down a mandate for districts who haven't even begun to have these conversations and so I I I think it's great and I really appreciate all of the work that both of you and others are doing to collect that now and just look forward to kind of continue continue having it move regardless um of what comes down from the state but really really
086appreciate the work that you're doing any other comments questions thank you very much for joining us and for the presentation thank you okay moving into the tail end of our agenda we have item 10.4 the appointment of Records management officer and I will entertain motions motion to appoint District Treasurer Emily ship records management officer of the itha city school district itha New York for the 20242 fiscal year second second moveed by Emily second did by Jill with a delayed reaction second by Todd um any discussion comments questions just a discussion that um we've discussed this at the finance committee last week and also this was part of the whole reorganization and since there's been a change in the business office that's why we're appointing em okay thanks hearing no additional discussion we could uh move
087it to a vote all in favor it passes unanimously um okay moving over to item 11 other business bus we have 11.1 some upcoming dates of importance um we have our next full board voting meeting um on January 14th 2025 um January 7th coming up we have a policy meeting at five and a human resources meeting at 6 of course we have a long break coming up from uh for the next several days last day will be Friday from school uh coming back on January second in case people don't know that um any other important dates that I'm forgetting okay uh moving to item 11.2 other discussion items hearing no discussion items uh we can move to adjourn this meeting thank you very much for attending and we will see you in the new year
088whoa