CorpusRecord 235138

ICSD Board of Education Voting Meeting - Tuesday, December 10, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / ICSD Communications
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Tompkins County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,224 words · about 85 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001on our December 10th 2024 meeting uh we will get right into our agenda uh with that being said actually I lied we will not get right into our agenda we understand we have a a large number of students who are here joining us uh thank you for joining us we will make this as entertaining as we possibly can so with that being said uh we'll call the meeting to order uh any U modifications to the agenda hearing none we'll continue we begin with the receiving and hearing of delegates including public comment and I do believe I thought we had folks who were signed up public summeran you can come up if you would use the microphone it helps people at home listen and hear better for recording purposes thank you so much okay okay thanks

002everyone does that work okay hope so yes okay okay uh good evening everyone thanks for the opportunity to share a public comment tonight U my name is Summer Killian I'm a former Beverly J Martin Elementary parent having lived down the block from the school since 2011 um my kids went there um starting in 2018 um and attended the school until the end of last year and this year they began School in second and fourth grade at Bel Sherman um so tonight I'm asking the board to closely examine some of the circumstances which vary from most of the other at bjm which vary from most of the other elementary schools in the district and which may be prompting families to requests to move their kids out of the school similar circumstances have also caused teachers and

003support staff who are desperately needed and beloved at the school to make the same decision and leave there were other families who open enroll out of bjm at the same time that we did and there are more families who are considering leaving at the end of this school year it's important to understand why so many families are leaving but it's also important and even more so to understand what life is like for students and staff who do not or cannot leave the school after all no one should have to and it was a really difficult decision for my family to go I mve my kids due to inconsistencies in the areas of supervision communication and special education bjm can not afford these types of inconsistencies the State education School data website will tell you that

004a third of the kids who attend bjm are students with disabilities my kid was one of them 10% of students are homeless 67% of the families that attend bjm are what the state refers to as economically disadvantaged over the course of our five years at bjm we met so many dedicated School Employees they are probably not in a position to report on the issues that they see on on a daily basis but I can tell you that if they had an anonymous way to do so or a formal way to do so you would be hearing from them I understand there's been an effort to communicate the needs of the Educators to the district recently and that they are receiving some support this is really new and it's crucial that it's sustained in the past

005when I personally have asked about differences between the elementary schools in our district I've been told that some schools have a wealthier PTA or a different demographic bjm has some bad kids um but I can assure you that there are some differences um there's a solid framework for day-to-day function that we've noticed at Bel Sherman that has been really difficult to find in recent years at bjm at Bel Sherman for instance caregivers receive a weekly letter from the main office we get ample notice about school activities we know who to call if our kids are going to be sick or absent we spent a couple years not knowing at bjm the school called us over the summer to get to know our students if one of my kids has trouble during the day and they

006do uh we hear about it promptly we received a printed family handbook over the summer in the mail um this is so simple so accessible so Equitable so vital to ensure that a community of families has basic access to information about the public school where they send their kids and this kind of firm fitting has se footing has seemed difficult to establish um over the last couple years at bjm so you may be asking why I still care so much when I'm no longer officially affiliated with the school and that's fair enough what I'm hopeful for is that my presence tonight will help to open up and continue a dialogue among multiple elements of the icsd and the bjm community I wish I just want you to please talk to families and employees at bjm

007those who are still there those who have left um I'm really grateful to the district for the support that they that I've heard that they're now providing um but I please consider that the issues that are just now being addressed took some years to develop and will probably take just as much time to reform and every single day caregivers leave their children to walk through those doors with a certain expectation that of a free comprehensive high quality education that's on par with the other schools in this district and which prepares them for life in this broader Community as they grow so please all eyes on bjm thank you thank you any additional uh public comments tonight that's it that is it uh that would bring us to any board responses I'm somewhat puzzled about the

008request for um an opportunity to let the board or anyone else know what's going on on um I would like to remind everyone again that there are numerous opportunities here at board meetings many of us have published our phone numbers our emails are read every one of us reads our emails usually daily um and I'm I'm saddened to hear that there are people who didn't feel they could share this um we rely on members of the public students and staff telling us What's happen happening Dr Brown keeps us up to dat as much as he can and we each have contacts within the schools themselves of course but it's vitally important that people share with us what they're thinking um and I can honestly tell you that this is other than a discussion with Dr

009Brown last week this is the first time I've heard of any widespread discontent so thank you for coming in and please encourage others U when they have a concern to do that if they feel like they cannot take care of it at the school level they need to be sharing it with other at people with other levels thank you any other board responses thank you summer for Sharon um aside from your Sharon I just want to remind the community and our community that um we have a communication protocol for parents and caregivers on the Ithaca City School District website why I keep bringing people back to the communication protocol because I was involved in a community group at that time that created the communication protocol and we wanted to ensure that parents and caregivers know

010the different stages in which to um communicate in case of um their child being out or anything like that or if there's any concern concerns or issues and all of the schools are listed contact information are listed for elementary and secondary schools so I would always encourage I know every year at the beginning of the year each School tries to put that in whatever backpack notices as well as well not each school elementary does backpack notices secondary doesn't do that but yet it's it is on our website and is updated on an annual basis any other board responses um just thank you for coming appreciate that um and we will have uh some conversations about uh some of your concerns and try to address them uh I'll just add also thank you for coming and

011we will continue our conversations that will move us to student reps uh I believe Lacs went first last time Etha High School Claire good to see you you um well our first thing is that the this past week 10 selected students traveled to Rochester to rehearse and perform as part of the nisma All State performing ensembles um where students across the entire state were invited to perform in instrumental ensembles and choirs so we re we rehearsed nine hours a day for three days and then put on a great performance in Kodak H at the Eastman School of Music on a similar note the IHS music program is also having a very eventful month last week the IHS Orchestra has put on a successful concert and um the choir will be performing tomorrow in cul auditorium

012at 7:30 p.m. and the bands will be performing next Wednesday December 18th at 7:30 as well the IUS Jazz Cabaret will be in the choir rooms this Friday at 7:30 p.m. okay um the bathrooms have been pretty clean with the teachers occupying a table on the outside to survey students and the Vapes and lunch trays have stopped presenting themselves in places that they shouldn't be um however we've noticed the continuation of lunch drings being misplaced so we'll work actively to solve this uh speaking of food people have been budging lines because more preferred options run out faster so there are admin who reinforce people at the head of the lines but people just like cut in the middle to resort to not being caught um cutting but another incentive for line budgers is that the

013library seating is very limited so they must rush to the front of the line until like arrive first for a see at the library also sometimes times food like portions are not sufficient for students so a solution could be to replenish the sad bar more often but Miss Hardy also said that she would talk with the nutrition folks and let them know that we need more food um there are also many initiatives around the school to help communities in need first IHS Key Club recently held a 12-day food drive donating to Loaves and Fishes they're also partnering with the American Red Cross to host a blood drive next Tuesday during the school day Global alliances is organizing a book Drive in support of the family reading partnership through December 20th and a new food drive

014is also in process right now for first class first period classes across participating teachers with a pizza party as a reward all right the NHS ceremony was planned for this Thursday from 6:30 to 8:30 p.m. at the IHS cul Auditorium however it was just canceled by Miss Harley uh just now so it will likely be rescheduled for this month um NHS ceremony is where students will officially become a part of the National Honor Society and parents will get the opportunity to watch as well to become a member of the society each student is required have completed a total of 50 community service hours by the end of the school year and moving on we had our first Fall Festival on November 26 at the end of the school day which was organized by the Ambassador

015Club it included a lot of arts and crafts activities snacks and sports and a talent show and overall it went well and we plan on doing it again next year um meeting with Mr briman and Miss Hardesty about recycling yielded very positive results so we're going to be attempting a paper only recycling program and last year's pilot program that we run seemed to result in decreasing recycling contamination but there were students who were tossing unwashed cans into them um and even a trace even Trace Amounts of nonwater liquid can contaminate the whole thing so we're putting a pause on the wholesale recycling efforts and instead focusing on paper and cardboard for an early start and unfortunately Cadman could not be here today but he wanted me to pass this on I'm grateful for the opportunity

016which I had today to attend a restorative justice training session at du it Middle School many thanks to Mr bman and Miss Hardesty for making this possible thanks um oh sorry about that so Stella's at a game right now and was unable to come um our second annual Winter Carnival is this Friday starting at 5:30 the winter carnival was born out of a small fundraising project I was in last year it's a fundraising night where we all come to the school families and community members anyone is invited family groups offer bake sales craft sales auctions performances activities and games it was a huge success last year and we're hoping for the same this year um this year's student directed Shakespeare play The Tempest was a success we held it in the Boon blackbox there was

017good turnout and it was a lot of fun um speaking of the theater department has settled on a musical Hades town and they in the beginning stages of that Solstice lunch is approaching Solstice lunch is a multi-dimensional celebration unique to LS and one of our very important community experiences we all Gather in the gym and feast each family group decides what they're eating the setting of many fond memories we just voted in all school meeting to extend poce lunch through the last two periods of the day so that'll be the last Friday before break uh Middle School scheduling began this week for second semester classes and we had three girls that made it on the Middle School modified basketball team yeah um I'm battling a cold so if I cough apologies um so Lacs we're

018facing an issue it's pretty hard to ignore um and it has to do with the capital project um at oacs bathrooms were renovated and we had a brand new front entrance done and while we appreciate what's done there are some projects that remain uncompleted um so number one being there's a set of doors from the main entrance to the blackbox that have haven't been hung yet um keeping in mind it's been over a year um there's a set of doors near an interior staircase and elevator to the vestibule which leads Outdoors into the blackbox which are not operable as well um lighting and heating in the principal and health offices are also not operable the Heat and the lights they go in and out they they flicker every 10 minutes um and in fact our

019principal has had to go out of her way and buy lamps on her own dime to keep light in the room at all times um and finally uh the living wall so we had a living wall installed in our main office um the workers did a fantastic job installing it and it was agreed that a portion of the budget um would be allocated towards a one-year partnership so the students in the green thumb committee which basically is the plant and maintenance committee um could learn how to use the water system could learn how to replace the plants change the fertilizer Etc um then admin was informed that a partnership was no longer available even though it had been previously agreed to as part of the budget um and then admin was told well there's an

020instruction manual so just find the instruction manual and um we found the instruction manual it uh it wasn't clear um and people are rightfully upset because there was an agreed partnership and now it's not happening um and if you go to ACS you go to plant well half the plants are dying um because we can't maintain the system because the committee cannot maintain the system um so yeah thank you student reps uh board responses once again this is the first I've heard of the living wall problems um as well as the doors not being completed um facilities meets on Thursday and next week the overall group of Architects and construction people and Facilities meets and I can assure you we'll be talking about this thank you additional board member responses thank you to our student

021reps and I am looking forward to learning more at facilities 4:45 on Thursday I'll be there at 5:16 uh that brings us to our consent agenda uh we can entertain motions and then open for discussion I move to approve all consent agenda items listed in the consent agenda consideration of accounts Personnel reports students and minutes of previous meetings is presented second move by Adam second by Jill uh discussion conversation questions debates yeah yeah I just the only thing I just wasn't sure um that I really understood the question about the resolution to approve the 2526 program Services cost allocation methodology for shared services unit unit cost determination at TST bosis I read it but I just I wasn't 100% sure like what what we were uh moving forward with that and I didn't know if

022it was any any more clarification about it or I just didn't do a good job reading it uh I am unable to provide more information at this time I don't know if anyone for the admin team is able to provide more information pulling it up here to make sure I have it just a second hi everyone I'm Zach Lind um what you're looking at is uh when we contract with bosis um uh bosis is our our regional shared Consortium um that we participate with to access lots of services that uh school districts may not um offer themselves and so what what you have there is just a list of how they're charging for each different service in the methodology that they're using for it um you'll see the term for example rwad which we we

023kind we use or we'll say as arada that's you know when it says that that's a per student ratio so they basic on the number of students enrolled in our district um at a specific point in October called beds day um so really all it is is just a spreadsheet that's that's explaining how the cost methodologies work out and if you um you know Bose actually comes in later in the school year and they go through a lot of their different programming but um it's really depending on how the service is used if we choose to access it um it's going to be at a certain cost some of the uh Services we pay into no matter what I mean they all have different sort of formulas for how it works so that's sort of

024the general overview and does that change like on a typical year or is that something that yeah so um uh depends on the formula that are used some of the some of the methodolog well the methodologies are are generally the same but our cost will change year year to year for example um sometimes they'll average multi-year engagement with the coer and that will then you know based on how much we spent the previous years in a certain area of our budget that um there'll be a new rate for this year and then if we have more students enrolling um in our schools overall our per student rate will go up if it if we have less students in our district overall it would be less if um so that's where you see those uh fluctuations

025and you know this is all the districts in the region are access these services using those same methodologies okay additional questions no thanks and I presume that this is the very document that allows us to participate in coers yeah yes it's part of that process so if we sign on then we're able to join with other districts and use TST bosies for funding of the services you listed here that are here um that's what I thought it was I wanted to make sure I heard from Zach to make sure I understood it correctly yeah I think we got it okay thank you yep additional questions board members may have um I will say now I had a email exchange um with Adam um it this is something that I would like the HR committee to

026look into uh and reading our Personnel report I for years have wondered and questioned why in some categories we list a reason when there are times when I'm not sure that that reason is generally necessary to be public a couple of examples were someone who just um leave and it will say medical or will say whatever it may be and so if it's required by law then by all means then it is if it's not required by law and I'm looking to Jill as just so the committee the community knows as the chair of the HR committee but I'd have I'd like to see a question about what we're listening what we're listing and what the the value of that is um under what circumstances just something I've been thinking about for again for years

027as we've done our Personnel reports sometimes people should have a right to privacy um but I also don't know what that what that means so just want to put that out there before I voted on on this um I also want to recognize that uh we had uh uh Matt o o Donell was able to secure a grant from uh the Caper Center um which is seems like an exciting opportunity so we want to thank uh Matt for that work um and also one of the things I found interesting the board put out a bid for cheese and pepperoni pizza you know it's interesting to see that we received only one uh bid back so um that something it was interesting to read as well hope you all enjoy the pizza any other discussion items

028board members fantastic hearing none we'll call the question all in favor of the consent agenda motion passes wey thank you very much um we will continue on with our agenda for this evening uh and that is School District business um we should make mention that uh Dr Brown is not with us this evening I don't know the exact number but I believe in 14 years this may be the fourth meeting that he's missed it's a pretty impressive attendance record uh and is presenting at a conference uh that is happening today so we'll have Dr Brown with us next week I'm mentioning that because normally this would be the time we would hear our superintendent's report that is not on the agenda uh because our superintendent is not with us and so that will bring us

029right to board uh School District business and our first uh agenda item is a discussion and conversation uh about a pass a possible Capital project and I don't know if that is um amongst the board if uh I know the board is ready to have some of that conversation I assume or if there's additional information from uh Administration anyone Central admin is been Reed to present anything and don't it's all us fantastic if we have questions you all are ready here to make that happen so board members um to set a little bit of context particular for those who may be listening at home to understand the conversation um there's been some dialogue at oacm meetings uh owner architecture constructure management meetings there's been a con some conversations at facilities committee meeting including the last

030facilities committee meeting and the question is about whether or not the District should consider um another Capital project uh or reconsider a capital project that um in terms of what that could look like what would be the offices what would be the time frame what would be some of the things that we consider in doing a capital project and uh that's the reason for this conversation uh here this evening at this point in time nothing has been determined um it's an open conversation and dialogue amongst the board where it's trying to get an idea of either how the board feels information or feedback we may receive from other folks where we want to go um and I know because Jill has been um very much involved I don't know if there's anything that you'd like

031to say Dr trip about this as well I i' set the stage just a bit by saying that um I have been privy to these discussions and I think our general consensus has been that what we would like to suggest to the board is a relatively small Capital project this year perhaps that would be voted upon at some time other than the school board election time because it's now getting fairly close to when we would have need to have that together if we were going to have that vote in in May I'll remind everyone that the capital project um budget is separate from the operating budget for the school district and how it has been used and how it is I think supposed to be used is to handle both routine maintenance of our many

032school buildings our many elderly school buildings and um for new projects that the community and the district see a need for So currently we're looking at between a 30 and 40 million um proposal for this upcoming Capital project and it does include a lot of things that those of us who've been talking about it see as um necessary for for example new electrical um Transformers I guess new electrical things at goingon and dit um because the ones that are currently running the electrical system at those middle schools are well past their their normal expected age and if we don't deal with it sooner we end up having to deal with it later and having it be much more expensive so that's a bit of what's going on I would just add two things to that

033conversation in terms of setting the framework when the school district went out in May for its capital project that was not approved by the voters I would like folks to know that that is part of a a long-term planning process particular fiscal responsibility and the the goal has been to keep a certain percentage of the School District budget um dedicated to Debt Service and that debt Services all connected to the projects that Dr trip is talking about so whether it be a project at Lacs whether be a new stem Wing that's coming to the high school whether it be a new entrance at South Hill and then whether it be other things like a new roof for the high school uh boiler systems a geothermal at Enfield um those are some of the new construction

034and sort of not just regular upkeep but what some people would call deferred maintenance and if you look at the itha city school district building condition survey which were coming up I think in the next year on a new one um there are literally hundreds of millions of dollars referred maintenance projects that the district should consider some are much more essential like need to be done next year some we can fix like our excellent maintainers and facilitator uh do as as we speak and so uh part of this conversation is in context of that conversation about long-term fiscal planning uh to make sure that we are not only keeping the district and its facilities in uh usable space but also trying to save us money long run so we don't have to do a major

035repair we can fix some small things now um and so that's part of the conversation as well that folks should know so whatever the amount may be and whatever the time may be at some point in time the district will have to do a capital project because we will have things that we need to fix or as a school Community well things that we need to fix So Adam I to thank you oh no that's okay no I was just gonna add two things just to Logistics I guess that when we ask for a certain dollar amount in these projects it's just it gives uh the capacity to to spend up to that amount it doesn't necessarily mean that we go out and spend that amount right away and also just to remind people that

036um because of state aid that's associated with the capital projects um a lot of the funding for the capital projects um gets offset by the state at a 58 cents per dollar I think so for every dollar we spend 58 cents comes from the state um so although the price tag seems large and is um just wanted to put that out there for for people to remember that a lot of that has comes from state aid and for folks who really want more information our last joint session between finance and Facilities um delved directly into this very project both in terms of facilities but equally so the finances of what a capital project should and could look like um so that was part of our conversation so uh Dr trip mentions um you know folks

037looking at between 30 and $40 million I think the another question would be one what's the board's capacity to go out for a capital project or the community's capacity and then um equally important to me would be a timeline because part of this is that we are agreeing that this should this that going out in may may not be the best time then the conversation becomes we have longer term conversations to say what is the amount and then what is the desired time frame uh for the community's perspective and my time on the board this we've gone out four times for a capital project all of those votes have happened in May uh attached to the budget vote as well as the vote for the election of Schoolboard candidates with that being said um I

038just went back to look at my notes from um nisba um within the past month we can count six School District across the state who have had their Capital project vote in December so it's also very common for people to have a capital project vote at a time other than the regular may vote that would take place and so that was again just in a quick look of what our Nisa Eclipse were saying so this would not be um a an a different practice a number of districts engage in December votes or August votes or whatever the case may be so can you remind us how much a it cost to have a separate election or a separate vote well that raises a number of questions um the average cost is between I want to

039say 35 close to $35,000 for an election with that being said that is uh assuming that we would have um this be follow the exact same procedures uh you are not required to have a certain number of polling places you always could um it depends on the number of ballots that are produce it depends on the number what our work is with the Tomkins Colony Board of Elections um so it could be the same um and it could be um more efficient as well there there are things that could be done to consider um I think the biggest question I have Sean and Jill and everyone goes back to what you said about the cost and and having this be part of long-term planning and already the deferments of Maintenance we have on our buildings

040I I get that no one wants more taxes but not having a robust Capital project from everything I've learned as a school board member is fiscally irresponsible um and so I'm just concerned with not getting enough and and what what that can cause and then another thing that really concerns me as well is I understand we want to go Bare Bones but we just heard about bjm and I'm hearing that there aren't going to be funds for a playground there well playgrounds are really important to learning and to our students and for teachers and schools and communities so I just really am concerned with you know we're saving money but what is that going to cost us in the long run uh and I I I I I need some figures on that and I

041mean without having a financial person who's been guiding us all these years I feel like I'm a little bit there's no guidance here at the bigger picture and and that's my concern that we're not looking at the big picture in the long term eron I realize you asked all board members and so folks can respond let me say a couple of quick things just so the community um understands that question um because I think it's a phenomenal question one that we have to address when I make mention of fiscal long-term planning and being fiscally responsible this is precisely what I'm talking about in terms of uh if we were to go out and say the voters would approve a $50 million Capital project for deferred maintenance if that were the case not saying that we're

042look at that let's sa him $40 million in $170 million budget because the district has such has done such an excellent job with our current funds and has an excellent rating we would end up adding approximately last time I think we saw the numbers was about $400,000 to $170 million budget total per year so the idea is do we spend $40 million to do deferred maintenance projects for an additional $400,000 to our budget significant amount of money please do not mistake what I'm saying right that's a significant amount of money and at the same point in time we get to do take care of some things that may cost us much more than that long room you know I forget what the number is for the roof someone help me I'm looking at Chris do

043you remember couple million dollars that I know um but I don't know the exact number right but there's an example you need a new roof on a school ground say it again what 11 couple million 11 right you need a new roof on a school um that's going to cost you a couple million dollars what a capital project would do is what Dr kramp Weiss had said is would authorize the school district to spend up to a particular amount and at no point in time does the school district have to spend that amount it's sort of a a rainy day fund to try to make sure we get out ahead of some of these projects but the purpose is yes we can definitely have a financial conversation I would recommend folks go back and watch

044that Finance meeting chaired by Dr block um to get an idea that we are we would not go out in a way that would have significant harm to the community into our budget we we that we would not do and we've already started running some of those numbers as well and I know jul you probably something yeah two things I want to address one is that this is far from a Bare Bones um request it it deals with priorities yes but it's very much in keeping with what the district spends and has spent on capital projects in the past in that we're not going for a 10-year Capital project here we're we're looking at a two or threeyear Capital project so we're looking we're staying around that 10 million doar a year um so it

045it continues our habits just tightens up how closely we look at them and they are the priorities that were recommended by the people who take care of facilities for the most part the other thing I do need to address is it's not that there's not money for the bjm playground playgrounds like many other things take a lot of planning um and the bjm playground is the next playground up but we wanted to get going on decision making about Fall Creek playground where there are plans and I believe some of the planning for the bjm playground has already started that some parents have been meeting with the Cornell professor so I I wanted to disabuse anyone of that notion that we're saying no bjm can't have a new playground that is not this that is not

046the case it is it is in the pipeline um and just to chime in about the last Finance facilities combined meeting we had fiscal advisor marketing um group here and they advised us and we looked at the local shares and looked at the opportunity and the opportunity is around 2027 to 2028 for construction costs to start and where the representative had stated that if we go we can go for a capital project referendum next year next year may or or the fall but we it wouldn't be beneficial for us to go beyond spring 2026 because then we have to look at when do we start construction costs so they did mention and I'm looking at Chris they did mention that um that the um project scope which is a pie chart that we currently have

047and we have let's say an option out there now for 30 million they had mentioned that um they usually look at the project scope and to determine when is the best time for us to proceed with that so I'm get it guessing verification that they did review that option or we are or are we due to send them a project scope for them to review we haven't received Direction so so so therefore going back to Jill youd said like okay if we look at a short-term um for two to three years 10 million million we do not know at this point we have to get together the different options because the way I I interpreted it from the last meeting that that might be a bit low because we might not be able to start

048the construction at that time or something is uncertain around when construction time will start because the local shares there's that opportunity between 2028 and 2029 yeah thank you for bringing this up Karen this is um it's pretty complicated um and I I don't pretend to understand it all but I think the thing we have to keep in mind is that the projects we even if we were today approve a certain slate of projects that then people could move forward there wouldn't be any construction on those particular projects for at least two years so you have to you have to get the money ahead of time you have to get the ideas out there ahead of time and then the Money Follows and then more planning happens and then more approvals happen through State Ed department

049so it's it's a long process but if we were not to do this for example and we were to lose our electrical systems at e either Boon or dwit for example we can imagine the kinds of or lose a major boiler somewhere um we would be forced to deal with emergency funds um rather than the nicely State aided Capital project funds for construction process-wise Bo colleagues I think there are a couple of quick questions for me um and I'll put all three questions out so we can sort of rank them in whatever order one again is there um an appetite to put forward a capital project back to um our ICD voters uh two is there a preferred time to which that happens if it's if we're talking about May then that means probably a

050couple of extra meetings over the next month and a half to get that ready um and then three um what would be under the scope of those projects and so um I think last time we saw two different ones one at 30 million one at 40 million there may be one ready at 50 million um so we can think about all those things and I think the purpose of this conversation this evening was one is it's probably most importantly to have it on the agenda as soon as possible because if it was the board's will to go out in May then we need to know that probably by next Thursday or last Thursday or last Thursday and we need to make some things happen um or if there's a decision saying yes we know that

051we're going to need a Capital project but we doesn't need to be at the mayote then we can still push those things along in an expedited fashion but it would from my perspective it just give us a little bit more time to have some of those conversations about how we want to proceed and it also gets to Aaron's point it would cost it would be an additional expense to not have or to have a second well that's just the the reality of it would be an additional expense so those are all the things I think that we're trying to play I don't know how much of our time want I mean we should try to get some idea of how board members are feeling this evening we don't necessarily have to need to make a

052decision but we we are coming up fast on a decision deadline if if May is our time line Chris would it be possible to to throw those pie charts up on the uh or is that yeah is that oh great could we do that then so everybody could know what we're talking about thank you and not to start to influence my boy CLE colleagues but to slightly influence us is that um it behooves us that we need to get a um Capital project going because we have age buildings and I'm in favor of doing one like the latter part of next year unfortunately as a community we don't always recognize there's a cost with everything like even when the budget was voted down in May there was a cost to do a a revote so

053there is a cost that we will incur if we choose to do a capital project vote next fall there's a cost to incur in our infrastructure if we choose not to do anything whatsoever and especially when we do get the buildin a TR I take it we're trying to bring up a couple scenarios I of course memorize these party charts but not everyone has had an opportunity to look at it so closely details while that's Tak place any other questions comments conversations board members if if we as a board were supportive of a capital project and decided tonight we were supportive of that could it be a Mayo to save like would or would that just be a colossal amount of work and not quite possible no we're still within the the window where we

054could get it together for a may vote whether it's advisable or not depends on whatever yeah I I personally like the idea of separating it from the main budget vote because I think that's confusing to people um right it makes it seem like we're distri is spending an additional 40 right right why wouldn't we just ask for you know however much more if that's what we want but it's it is a separate rightly or wrongly it's a separate situation so I like the idea of separating it in time but yeah I'm looking forward to seeing some of them I am also a favor having seen and participated in that last meeting I would also be in favor of separating the votes um one just to provide a little bit more time for input and dialogue

055to see if we can come to some consensus of course some people will want some other projects or what one person feels as Bare Bones we'll also need some feedback from you know Architects and other partners um and then the other idea was that um we're going to be uh soon we will be very much focused if not soon we already are very much focused already on this upcoming budget and I think that's going to take a lot of time and try to do both those simultaneously I feel we may not be able to do them both well as one as one board member but Chris you're here to join us from tetratech you've been involved with our current capital projects so and I see a PowerPoint which means you're ready to go what do

056we have up here if you want to share so thank you for the opportunity again here's a schedule that I've shown before uh with the red line kind of now we're in December but we do still have time to have some time for communications Katie is up in the back corner who helped us last time um with the backpack of T stuffers and whatever the whatever you know the pieces are that you'd like to use for communication so we do have some time for that um there also is time before the March 25th date which is that last date that the Board needs to act to um to make a couple resolutions prior to the vote date of May 20th so there is time to do that if we get some decisions made um again

057some basic uh historical sort of references points um Jill's referenced the 10 million a year that was that you know 2019 Bond 120 million over 10 years or so um it's about 12 million a year um um you know inflation happens so the last Bond vote was about 12 and a half million so now we're contemplating another vote all right so here are three graphs so these are the most recent iterations of thinking uh along with your Administration uh about what capital projects might be I'm happy to these are different slightly different inter uh iterations than what we've seen to date um and we can make more of them the reason I keep providing them is to try to get to you know a collection of scope um and a cost that resonates with folks

058um that we can hear back from you saying yes this is this is we're in the right direction uh we're either very close or yes this is exactly the combination of scope items we want I can go through these quickly uh if we want or if you want to just sort of look at them for a minute but there's a 30 there's a 40 there's a 50 million in um with different scope items on them Chris let me just give an example of some of the detail that we're having a conversation about that I believe would probably be reflected here and if it's not let me know one of the conversations is a geothermal heat well for itha high school correct right so uh moving away or not increasing lak Source cooling but trying to

059find other ways that are also carbon neutral to be able to heat and cool the building one idea would be that we do it for the high school another idea that's been proposed for other folks is saying well what if we had the same well that would feed both the high school and boy in Middle School yes so one I do be for whatever amount of money that would be and I don't know what it is to cost there for ethic a high school or if we go out with a capital project that we do both at the same time um as possible cost savings long term even while upfront it would be it would be more money and so that's what people those are the kind of differences that people may see reflected and

060the 30 million the 40 million and the 50 million are conversation similar to that is that fair yeah so I'll say in these specific examples both that complete system that that provides itha high school and boon with cooling is is assumed for all of these examples perfect yes uh right conversation about bjm playground that would that may be is that in all three examples yes it is it's the sort of magenta slice around 12 o'clock so because I can't see it I know last year when went out for the capital project there was a lot of conversation about um not just the increase of infrastructure to prepare ourselves for the electrification of buses realizing that's a contentious issue not just in our community but across the state but if that were to be the case

061then there would need to be some infrastructure update and then the other conversation we're having simultaneously is an Aging bus garage and what kind of either uh modifications or what or we were at one point in time considering a brand new bus garage right so what can you just tell us some of the differences that may be up here I can't it's pretty consistent across all three of these it just includes the electrification of the bus fleet in all three examples um can you sell uh what's wellness and and the increases we're seeing in each slide there Wellness represents your nursing Suites basically um in the 30 million it's just bjm we've talked about the sort of structural situation that's happening there so that's a baseline uh the 40 million ads dit Bon and bjm

062or and Lacs excuse me um and then the 50 million adds the rest of them okay and that's that's basically a refurbishment to allow them to be handicap accessible and have uh appropriate storage and and things like that like meeting ada8 requirements basically yeah um and then the fire alarm for the third slide third graph yeah the fire alarm uh so that would be replac the remainder of itha high school and the remainder of South Hill Elementary School which have older analog many of your schools have older analog fire alarm systems uh but those are two buildings that have a portion on a new system and a portion on an old system and they don't always play well together so that's why those two buildings are are priority and then I don't mean to bogur

063this but um HVAC can you can you explain the differences in each and how important this is I mean especially yeah I'm thinking climate change pmics wildfires all of it I'd like to hear more okay so the 30 million starts with like I said before a geothermal system for the high school and the and Boon Middle School uh the 40 million adds to that uh building Control Systems so you may have heard of these pneumatic systems which literally are air you know through little tiny tubes running all around your building controlling your mechanical system kuga Heights and bjm are the two buildings that have uh what we think are the oldest and most problematic systems um you might remember uh the two middle schools were were updated um in that regard a couple years ago

064um so that's what's added in the 40 million um and then the 50 million includes that as well as a similar system at Bel Sherman and there have been some air handlers around the district that have been um identified as being uh needing more attention more frequently uh so IT addresses those as well so before we ask more questions I want to be efficient with our time and our purpose for this evening right this is a an opening conversation and so trying to gauge uh the board's interest if the board is wanting to go out in May then we should continue this conversation right now if the board is not if if May is not our definitive sense of urgency this is a conversation that can continue in facilities and other areas to get into

065the details to drill down in that way but we knew and also recognizing that we're minus two board members um but the goal was to sort of gauge the want and the will of the board um not saying that understanding the the amount of money the kinds of projects aren't essential they actually are um and this has been some of the ongoing conversations already been taking place at facilities and without question oacm which all board members can read the minutes for if you are unable to to attend so I say that in a say my apologies a lot of talk thoughts about what do we think our timeline is first I think that's a question for us to answer as a board Sean I'd like your earlier um framework for this is there an appetite

066for going forward with a capital project this year that can be yes and no um when which would be May or some other time and then I don't think we're quite ready for how much but we might so maybe we should follow that fantastic for for those who are ready to decide is there appetite on the board for putting forward a capital project this year well I have a couple maybe a few thoughts about it that I could add to the conversation maybe um yeah I mean I I guess personally I don't really like the idea of the extra cost of the 35,000 that kind of just troubles me a little bit um second of all I feel like if these are projects that I mean I I think these are needs um and things

067that we that we need to do we're not really looking for um some category of special spending for some interesting projects or something like that these are things that we're going to need um my understanding and maybe I don't know gck might want to talk more about this or maybe not but just about you know the way that we pay off the projects and my understanding about Debt Service and you know that's kind of an interesting part of the conversation from my understanding of of going to the meetings and not being a finance person um it seems like uh part of our budget every year is dedicated toward paying off these projects and we try to keep that percentage of the budget at 7% which is a pretty small portion of our budget um and

068as we take on more capital projects the way the formula works is we're not really increasing that piece of the pie of our budget so it's not EX exactly an additional cost if we didn't go out and request money for many years the 7% could dwindle down to six or five or 4% I guess over many years if we didn't do that um but these are all things that we need um so so I'm kind of feeling if there's an urgency to do the projects I'm not sure um maybe why we'd want to wait I'm looking back at the you know not to bring up too much Trauma from from last year but I'm looking back at the numbers from the the budget last year um and at the first while our our budget only

069got 29% support um the capital project got almost 44% support which is almost enough to pass last year even in a year where people were uh you know uncomfortable about spending so I'm just putting those things out for some additional uh consideration because you were called out by name would you like to speak Dr sorry sorry yeah so I mean there's a lot here uh a couple thoughts um the first of all in from one perspective I'm not sure this really matters when when I say that you know there there's nothing in the scope of the capital expenditures that's out of the ordinary you know we need to heat our buildings we need to cool them we need to put roofs over the heads of children uh we need to repave parking lots there there's

070nothing in here that's radical or unusual it's just a question of when we do it and whether we go out and ask for 30 million this year and 30 million a couple years later we ask for a bigger amount now so I I'm not sure that we're really debating anything that's we're debating timing and and the Public's sort of appetite for this but I don't think we're actually debating the projects themselves so much except maybe the maybe with the bus depot I think it's the one issue the bus depot aside so in that sense I think it's it's a little bit doesn't matter um you know I I was in strong favor of the 125 million uh you know Capital project that was what how many months ago seven months ago so if I supported

071125 million 7 months ago you know now I'm asking do I support 30 40 or 50 now well I supported 125 and I still support5 and I think it's in the interest of our students and it's in interest of the taxpayers to do this I mean the reasons are many you know Adams pointed out that this is just a credit limit not an expense the expenses are all debated individually one by one uh Karen pointed out we are advised by Specialists uh state aid formulas are very complicated we have experts who tell us how to time these things and how to uh align them up in a way that uh keeps our uh capital u or rather our borrowing at 7% of our budget and maximizes our state rebate so I think we're doing this

072in a very responsible way so having said all that I I'm leaning towards Dr bradwell's uh I think a suggestion of maybe calling for a special election in December um Adam I'm aware that that's SP that wastes 35 million uh I'm also I'm sorry I'm sorry sorry 35,000 that's why get turned around the students taking notes make sure 35,000 I'm sorry now it seems good now it seems good so I was saying 125 million and I meant a 30 125 million but 35,000 for the budget forgive me thank you um and I also uh you know I'm I'm aware that it is a burden on citizens to understand the issues to to research them to go out to the polls and vote and I like to limit that to once a year all else being

073equal at the same time though there's a lot to absorb in this and I think it's maybe too much right now to ask the public to to to to weigh in on what I think are going to be some difficult issues on the budget difficult conversations and also understand the capital campaign so I think separating them allows the public to look at the budget and look at the capital uh projects as separate issues digest them separately and I think the public will have a better understanding so I think in in the in the interest of the public having the best understanding and I believe these these projects are in the public interest uh I think we should separate them and go for a I would say a larger Capital project to a year from now

074but that's it's not a strong feeling that could be swayed otherwise but that's that's how I I'd like to add as well in the interest of the public and not telling them to go and watch another meeting I want to ask one more question about the graphs because I think for a lot of people they have not been watching our facilities and finance meetings and perhaps this is new for them and maybe they're watching this meeting and they'd like to also know what is the difference in the three graphs what would the science section in graph the the second and third graph add to our schools that would renovate nine science classrooms three at dwit Middle School upstairs the three at dit Middle School that are downstairs and three at Bon Middle School that are

075upstairs the three that are downstairs Appo Middle School have already been renovated or recently been renovated thank you that also um would fix some uh Gas shut off safety issues I should mention as well um and provide new gas and other safety equipment for those uh for those science labs as well so there's a definitely a safety component in that as well Chris a question I'm not sure that you let me just ask the question right so one of the conversations are having about timing it I would take it I generally feel that the board generally understands that we probably need to go out for a capital project just in the best interest to maintaining classrooms I think Garrick said it beautifully we have to heat buildings we have to keep roofs over people's heads

076we understand that that needs to take place if the time were to change right if the board were not to go out in May but to go out in say October or December would that have an impact on when shoves are in the ground it might potentially so seven months makes a difference in in the process y um especially when it comes to um having a good bid um a bid cycle so you want to get out to bid around this time of year to set up for the next summer um so what that might mean though in practice is you might want to do an expedited review potentially with s to get that first one sort of going and sort of catch up on a six-month lag and a vote from May to you

077know around this time of year and again you know the details are always important right even with the $120 million Capital project over 10 years that project has been done in phases and we would anticipate even if it's 30 million a very similar thing that it all wouldn't be done at one time there would be a phase or two probably to make that happen right so could there be a delay I'm hearing yes um and uh we still would have some time to do some other things to keep things moving and we're still not complete with our current capital project like we we'd still be working on that one as well um I would suggest that uh since the Transportation um electrification of your Fleet is one of those um being able to bid that

078around December would be great for the following summer that work's already been done we should have SED approval by the time you know any of these votes dates roll go so going going back hearing uh Joe reminding me of my own suggestion seems like the board generally agrees that we probably need to move forward with some form of a capital project is that fair as a sort of a straw pole we'll make sure we have a conversation with our two board members who are unable to join us tonight as well uh then the next question we're talking about is leaning towards timing uh is there a general with everything and that that we have all the information right but is right now is there a general lean towards a partic one time over another all

0792025 I abstained from that one I disagree but you did you say may yeah I I don't want to waste people's money or people's time and we talk about Equity you should not be asking people to go to the polls more than once it's you're going to ask them in the fall and then they have we want them to also vote in like the actual election you it's too much that one I would challenge slightly just given just given our Democratic process we already asked people to go to the polls multiple times our school board vote is not aligned with our Senate vote our primot ridiculous right like New York state does it differently and I think that's also wrong but so I think that us as a school district asking voters to yet vote

080yet again is not okay and it's also an additional cost that we could work around sure thank you yeah I mean I'm I'm slightly I'm still a little more on the May side but but I don't feel very very strongly about it and happy to you know be supportive of the majority of the board if that's the will of board um so right and we're not taking an action this evening oh sorry please my apologies Jo I do feel strongly that we should separate them um I I think it's confusing I think it's too much information and I think delaying it a bit gives us a chance to really refine and inform people about exactly what we would be getting what they would be getting for that money that makes sense that's turn please and

081it seems like I keep reaching for microphones can we shift some of these microphones down somewhat thank you yeah and um I I agree that we just need to separate it um and it's unfortunate but I thank you Erin for asking for the questions and all but I would advise our community to go back over November 19th Finance facilities combined meeting because we had um our investment company we had fiscal advisors here and we have a summary which our board clerks do an excellent job with that tell you where to go to and what pinpoint so that you could refresh yourself on getting a better understanding do we expect everyone to have 100% knowledge no but to make some attempt that we can have more conversation and at these public meetings because don't wait until

082May because come May we're at a crunch period with vote that we're we have to go out to start the VOE in process and getting information out let's say five or seven weeks in advance I agree with separating it so that we can um bring a clearer picture to the community as to this is not a dollar amount that we're saying we're getting at this point we can go for the amount and then spend up to that knowing that we have um buildin Aid that allows us to spend and even I know maybe not at this time but we did a big disservice to our transportation department knowing how old that building is that we're not doing any major improvements especially around the size of um staff that we have there so we need to

083um this will give us time to go through the different options go back to fiscal advisers to see the project scope and so forth to say okay when do we start the process for construction and and when does s approve of it makes a lotes a lot all right so if I'm trying to synthesize some of our conversation not that there's consensus but a a general leaning in a particular direction would be that uh to the community yes the board is going to be doing some work around a capital project uh understanding some of the needs that we have as a school district around our facilities uh that there it would there would be support from some board members to separating these and maybe going out in the fall of 2025 though again not unanimous

084um and that the amount um that we would have additional conversations if that were the case there would probably be a number of meetings over the next couple months that would help us both clarify the scope of the project as well as have additional communication with stakeholders Partners about what is the best thing for this particular project as we move forward so the amount will will happen at a later a later time not too late well there still would be a sense of urgency but it wouldn't be we're making decisions and final things tonight or next week that's my read got right Trisha I'll work with you about how we capture that in the minutes we'll figure it out so thank you for the discussion I imagine it's going to be on next on Thursday's

085agenda as well I believe it is yep it is so for folks who may want additional information including board members uh Thursday we have a facilities committee meeting 4:45 pm. to 6 PM in this room so we'll continue this dialogue and we'll probably put on another future board agenda as soon as possible so thank you thank you Chris for giving us the options thank you board members for engaging in that conversation uh uh this is how democracy works next uh presentation on our next agenda item is 9.2 a conversation about the revenue exploration advisory Council update this is a advisory Council that was approved by the board uh I want to say in August if I'm not mistaken um and has been for the most part uh chaired by uh Dr Jill trip thank you

086wow this is I don't even know what just happened there's been a [Laughter] coup please well that discussion went so well let's have another one yeah on another weighty topic um I'll give you a little history here and that is I wonder if this will work let's see okay um the revenue advisory Council or the revenue exploration Council came about approximately 6 months ago um in response to a resolution um that I proposed to the board that was to request that Cornell up its annual donation to the Ithaca City School District by a considerable amount at that time it was felt that that was premature um and we needed more information and it was decided that needed to put together a group of people who could talk about um where additional Revenue might come from

087including Cornell but looking at other options and so that happened and we've met approximately six times since then can we show the presentation on the iPads please um there have it was kind of a roving cast of attendees although a number of us were there each time um the attendees for at least one session were Robert Van curin Katherine Sera Adam crant Weiss Todd Fox Margaret Fabo myself Ross Tate lvll Brown Aaron cyle Aurora ro ro and Peter wher and about half of those people are community members who brought information to us regarding other options for possibilities for revenue for the school district the next slide is about our process let's see and that is basically it was an extended discussion about options for additional Revenue we focused on short-term options there was some overlap

088with the legislative advisory Council for example we were all interested in doing some advocacy for the district at the Industrial Development agency regarding tax abatement but we realized that was a more long-term issue than what we were hoping for which was a shorter a shorter run at some additional revenue for the district um and we focused on options without a large upfront cost for the district although there are a number of things that would indeed bring us more Revenue in the long run if we have to put a lot of money in Upfront for example um if we had talked some about developing a solar farm on District property which is an appealing Prospect but it would involve a pretty large upfront cost for what would maybe be a good payback but so that's those

089kinds of options we did not discuss in great detail what we did discuss in considerable detail where these four options sale or lease of District property something called a utility tax that we would request increased donation from Cornell University and consolidation or redistricting as ways of saving money for the district so as I go through each of those briefly um sale lease of District property the advantage is we could do that with Board of educ ation authorization disadvantage is that it does require evaluation of District property and an assessment of future needs we'd want to be prepared for future um influx of students or other needs for example new school buildings um and how much we could make for that is a question although we do have a new request for proposals is that out

090yet Bob the okay we're working on a request for proposals to to receive valuations of District properties and so what they're worth now what they might be sold or leased for and because we don't yet have that valuation we don't know what the likely income from this would be um the next one is something called the utility ta tax which was new to me um and a utility tax is something school districts are authorized to do um and a number of school districts around new New York State have done this often on cell phone bills they they put on a tax of 2.5 to 7.5% on cell phone bills and the disadvantages of course are that that's a regressive tax um and that it's likely to be extremely unpopular both among our eles and with

091the general public however the school districts that are doing it around the state um are receiving anywhere from $500,000 to $2 million a year on that utility tax Dr Trump when it says unpopular with Council what does that mean I mean there were a couple of us on our Council that were going like no no no we don't want to deal with that want to make sure it wasn't common Council Y no uh another possibility request increased donation from Cornell University advantages this could be implemented at implemented at the board of education's Direction disadvantages it requires negotiation and a campaign to engage Cornell um the income on such a donation should Cornell um choose to engage and agree with us would be approximately 651 th000 to $10 million a year although that may sound like

092a pipe dream let me point out that there is there are comps for this and here are some current donations from other IV league universities to their Public Schools or in two cases to the cities in which they reside University of Pennsylvania 10 million to Philadelphia Public School schools Brown approximately 1.3 million a year to the Providence Public Schools and Princeton 4.5 million a year to the Princeton Public Schools so this is not either unique or a radical proposition to request additional funding from Cornell they currently um gift us 650,000 a year in the final option consolidation slash redistricting feasibility advantages again the Board of Education could implement this would reduce costs by closing school buildings reduce costs by sharing Services costs of programs and administration with neighboring school districts disadvantages obviously disruptive to students

093and staff so those are the four options um and if I'm misstating something or misremembering something I hope the people were who were present in the council first will point out to me where I've made my mistakes otherwise all errors are someone else's okay um and now we can we've all got the same basis of information and we can discuss fantastic uh thank you Jill and to the uh Committee of folks who put this together and who have been meeting every Thursday for pretty much the past six months um board questions comments reactions there's nothing for us to it's this is a a discussion item this is not an action item so this is just a discussion for this evening so let's discuss thank you to the committee um I guess this is on board

094doc so any updates can be made and put back on okay good good because um one of the we should probably add to this pie chart why you explained why we started the revenue advisory Council but to let the public know where do we get where does public education in New York state especially a small school district as itha where do we get revenues from like the state local taxes and show that pie chart so people can be aware of instead of waiting until May when they they're here that's when they're aware of it and um and on a regular basis where they're um staff members participate in in every meeting Bob was present at every meeting um I think I can't remember who else oh Dr Brown was was a regular attendee yeah because

095I I would rephrase that redistrict in feasability slide on page nine um Erin and I are involved in TST Bose small business small small Public School Association uh Schoolboard Association schol ass SBA sorry too many acronyms in this industry Schoolboard Association and um and we're we are scheduled to hear about regionalization so that's where the shared services and cost of programs with neighbor and school districts the regionalization where it may not be disruptive to students and staff we'll hear more about that next week and um it would be good to I I just quickly did a search at at UF pen they the university contributed for hazardous waste or environmental issues they were specifically given to remediate that with for that public school so was that the case were there specific funds earmark for any

096action points and and and what we're looking at funds to help defay the local taxes yeah the the 650,000 donation that Cornell currently um gives us is unrestricted that's yes and and I don't know how each of those plays out the ones that I um but it's it's right for research if anyone wants to look further into it um and certainly we would be grateful for any sort of additional funding even if we you know if it involved uh some particular project that Cornell was interested in or and and how did we come to the 650 was it always at this amount I'm still not sure it changed over the over the years so the history would be great to find out like when did we start that and that's just with Cornell there different

097options I know that we're looking into yeah uh just to answer make sure that we don't leave uh the community out there um 68% of uh ICD budget comes from local local property tax 22% comes from from state aid uh 5% last year came from fund balance so that actually is additional ICD property tax and uh 3.8% from other which usually means federal funds as well as uh grants that our uh team has been able to secure in a variety of ways and so um if you look at the same sort of uh budget chart for neighboring school districts a neighbor of ours that we share property line with it's almost a direct inverse uh they'll receive a about uh 68% of their budget from State dollars and about 25% from uh local property tax

098value so it depends on what community you live in that would make that happen so part of the reason we were having this question I think that Dr block uh responded to when we first began is we know that we uh it is not sustainable to continue to heavily weigh upon local property tax dollars to fund our district so we were thinking about what other ways can we make this this work so um just want to follow I sorry you as well I just want to make sure we got to that point yeah I I can't remember at the moment because you know no no no ADHD man um then I would add a couple quick things one the conversation about regionalization uh folks should know that next week we have a board meeting December

09917th uh we have uh the return of one of our rock stars who is uh no longer with us but the district superintendent for for TST bosis Lily talit will be joining us to have a conversation about regionalization um and then this the idea about possible consolidation for me while not Revenue generation I understand why the committee was talking about it um the board has uh asked that the district engage in two different studies one was already mentioned uh the first would be sort of a demography study or an enrollment projection study getting an idea of where we're headed as a district our last one I think was 14 years ago so we overdue for that um and then um including with that part of a building condition survey would be evaluation of the properties

100of all the and usage space how are all all spaces being utilized simply for information gathering only I want to make sure I stress that point but we're engaged in those two processes as we speak and with that I remembered um Sean I mean um you know options for consideration I I think it's important I mean to clarify we are kind of exploring all of these options as a board we're not formally proposing them anymore but I is it do you all think it's fair to say like this isn't just options for consideration maybe one this is we are considering all of these kind of together as options that we're going to likely have to utilize in some form to keep the schools running right like I think it's important to really point out that

101this is where we're at because this isn't just like a fairy thing that worth hoping to generate Revenue this is real things that we are looking at that we're going to be discussing in the new year and heavily considering and it it's very hard conversations that we're having yeah and and the flip side of that of course Aon is that we're looking at Cost cutting all the time right um so it's not just we're trying to bring in more money we're also where we can cutting our costs but as Sean has pointed out um the bulk in the past the bulk of our expenditures are contractually um set so something like 70% of our budget is what we've promised our employees uh the sale and Lease of District property um we have 12 schools but

102the district owns more buildings than that the prime example that gets used pretty regularly is Danby former dby elementary school it's a 12 say a 12 acre plot of land 13 acre plot of land including a building uh that's one example there are other buildings as well um and I'm just and I'm not saying that this is going to be doing that but when folks hear that that just get some example a utility tax the school board uh looked at I want to say eight years ago nine years ago and decided not to go with the utility tax even while a number of our neighbors were also considering it and yes oftentimes on cell phones but also could be on NC bills and lights and gas that's something that um we've had a conversation about

103before uh and then obviously the request uh increased donation from Corno university has been a topic of conversation for uh our board for uh a little bit of time and the last one I think we were talking about I think that's a conversation for us once we have our demography study to see you know what anything may look like so you I might add that we'll be looking at some of the issues on the last slide um this two days from now Thursday in the finance uh committee meeting um I'm glad we're going to have the conversation about reionization um one thing I think I would throw out there and Dr brother you can correct me I get this wrong but uh the state uh would like to see consolidation of school districts and there

104are pretty strong financial incentives to see that take place and here's why I'm looking for the correction but my understanding for example is that uh our building Aid percentage is like 58% something like that and some of our neighboring districts have much higher Aid ratios um so I believe for example if we were to merge with one of our neighboring rural districts that I believe it's for five years we would inherit their building Aid ratio uh so which is a you know a powerful incentive um the difficulty of course I mean whether you think that's a good idea or a bad idea the difficulty of discussing it is it's not something that we control on our own I mean I believe then neighboring districts would have to even if there was a plan neighboring districts

105would have to vote to approve that plan and so it's it's difficult to know how to consider an option that we can't unilaterally enact but of of all the ideas on the table um I think District consolidation is perhaps one of the most powerful in terms of cost savings uh in state aid but um you know again how do you consider an option that is relying on voters in another District to approve see if I got that wrong tell me no you I think the part that you're most accurate about is that the state is providing Financial incentives for districts to consider the sharing of resources Andor consolidation probably the best example would be Transportation right that sharing Transportation amongst multiple districts has the potential of uh saving money um and generating money for one

106District at the same time right and so there are a lot of nuances like that that we'll hear a little bit more about when uh superintendent tal joins us uh next next week those do not require a vote referendum right so no no that's not my understanding at this point time so those you mean I think those were more modest but but also perhaps more something that you would be in control to us and another board I think as uh Jill and the committee indicated where the board could decide something uh the majority of these things do not require uh going out for a vote as I look at them if I'm looking at them correctly right that um doesn't mean that we wouldn't have significant conversation with the community input feedback dialogue listening sessions

107um but for any of these uh but yes that the often times the Board of Education or Boards of Education would come to decision yes please I have a question like seeing that you pen giving like 10 $10 million compared to Cornell is there like a comparison between the student population size of universities like upen and their taxable property compared to ours yeah that's a great question I I just looked up uh Princeton would probably be the best example there are about 4,000 students so a little bit smaller than ICD which is just about 5,000 students um the additional questions I think you're asking are legit like what is the house valuation what is the medium income with people within the district property lines what is the medium value of homes within the district property

108lines as well and it's also New Jersey um what I mean by that that's not a dis to anybody um what I mean by that it's not New York state right so the laws and how we fund education are slightly different in New Jersey than they are in New York but those are all questions that we should ask if we're comparing apples to to Apples or apples to oranges this would probably be a good time for me to thank the council members and note that this is the end of our involvement in this process it's sort of back to you as the whole board at this point the count of us yes all of us the um council is by its nature um looking at a particular issue and it's temporary unlike a board committee

109so you know unless I hear you know um please to the contrary um our our job was to look at other possibilities and present them to the board for either further exploration or you know a sense that we're not interested in doing something so additional questions comments thoughts anything we want to move forward send to a committee rather than ex councel how would the board like to proceed part of it could be to take it in and bring it back to a another board meeting just as a reflection give some people time consider the ideas we have a we Al have a buffet of options in front of us well from that Buffet I will choose that we we bring it back to the board because I really want to go back and see what

110the charge [Music] would additional comments thoughts reactions would that mean bringing on in back in January for a conversation also identifying that we have two hope not can't be with us that may want to weigh in as well yes General consensus sounds good fantastic thank thank everyone to the committee that participated greatly appreciate the time the ideas the Innovations we'll put this back on an agenda item uh sometime in January either the first meeting in January the second meeting in January uh for another extended conversation where um whatever we're going to do we can start at least planning to move in a direction we just wanted to give people an introduction so thank you for leading that group as well Joe appreciate it uh that will move us on to our next agenda item which

111is uh committee updates uh folks may know there are summaries I say it every time our communication team does a great job of creating committee summaries fairly easy to find um they are so well done that as Karen said they um are hyperlink to the exact minute of the video if you were looking for a particular issue uh and we know that we need multiple modalities and mediums to talk about our committee work and so we'll just go through our committees um and uh not trying to rush the conversation um but be succinct as well and we'll do it unfortunately in alphabetical order as I can remember them or not remember them which would bring us to curriculum and instruction Dr crwi okay yeah thanks um so we've had a lot of um different conversations

112happening um in curriculum and I think we we didn't really talk since we had the last couple of meetings so um you know one topic that we started talking about and will be continuing during the next meeting um is the way in which standards based grading has been used in the school district um for those who don't know standards based grades are used in different places in the district but entirely in the middle school for all courses um and in this grading system students are graded on a scale of one to four uh with each number corresponding to the extent to which students are meeting different standards that are covered in each class um next meeting we're going to spend some time talking more about the implementation of that grading system and the professional development

113that's been available to teachers um to talk about how we standardize that across classes and schools um we've also talked about the grading of high school credit bearing courses taught in the Middle School um some students take algebra earth science um or foreign language in the middle school but then uh the high school credits are earned for taking them and the grade counts toward uh High School G pa um and those grades are included in college applications um a few different concerns have been raised about that grading system um for instance students taking the same courses in Middle School versus High School are graded differently um and standards based grades are used in the Middle School level and then grades are converted to a scale of 0 to 100 uh for the purpose of being

114included in high school transcripts so some concerns have been raised with the conversion system um we've had a discussion about Elementary report cards uh presently we have three different grading systems across the district one for high school middle and elementary school there's some pros and cons to that um a change to the elementary school report cards was made in 2021 that kind of ushered in the the current grading system um there's been some mixed reviews from teachers and families so we've decided to take that up and discuss that and the committee plans to hear more from teachers about the pros and cons of that system um we've talked a little bit about students who opt out of taking New York State standardized tests in ela and math in grades 3 through 8 um just a

115few key facts that we talked about um we have about 18% of students opting out the opt out rates are generally higher from math and Ela um ICD students tend to opt out at rates um that are higher than the state average um in some instances where where test scores were below the state average one of the reasons given for that in the past was that high achieving students were opting out disproportionately and artificially lowering scores um we had some data presented by Lynn kenowski who did a really great job um showing some of that data which didn't support that assertion um we found that class grades in ela and math were lower for students who opted out than for those who took the exams um and knowing the reasons for lower scores is very

116helpful um especially when we're looking at um Improvement plans um and implementing those with the intention of improving scores but also just looking at standards to see if students are meeting those standards regardless of uh test data um and the last thing we talked about were uh some conversations surrounding shared curricula um this would be instances where many teachers or all the teachers are using the same curriculum to teach a subject um sometimes that's across a grade or within a grade um Mary Grover has done a really great job this year and over the last couple of years trying to get some common curricula this year Eureka math squared is being used in grades K through five it was rolled out two years ago um and this year Desmos is being piloted in the middle

117school and related to that we talked about some professional development provided to support the implementation of those curricula um and quite a few opportunities have been available over the last few professional development days and outside those days as well so I know that was a lot um but we had talked about a lot over the last few meetings um and our next meeting is uh this coming Tuesday the 17th at 4:30 thank you Adam appreciate it uh Jill HR I think F comes before H that's why I said don't make me okay that in public all right Jill facilities all right facilities um we have received on a regular basis reports on regular maintenance and updates on ongoing capital projects um we received an interesting report from Armen Huck on his attendance at the New

118York State School environmental health conference and he provided information on impacts of climate change um increased heat waves and their effects on students and suggestions for lower cost or low cost mitigation measures or increased heat due to climate change he also provided information on the status of electric School Bus deployment in New York state um in combination with the oacm group meetings have been held with the principles of DT Boon and Enfield about their facilities priorities for the coming year um and I think that pretty much takes care of it for facilities we'll be back to you in a moment all right Garrick Finance yeah so uh we had the finance meeting on the often mentioned November 19th date uh we discussed three things uh interest rates are higher now than they have been historically

119well I should say historically meaning in the last recent years I should say uh historically compared to recent years and so it makes a lot more sense for the district to look at where it's putting its spare change uh we collect Revenue in October mostly through taxes and we spend it throughout the Academic Year and so parking that money where it yields the highest uh short-term uh interest rate is important we have an outside advisor who helps us with that so we spend some time with that and that is a bit of good news for the district we are getting money uh from interest short-term interest uh that is really helpful uh we then went on as to mentioned else at other times in the meeting talked about capital projects and then we had a

120discussion uh with Zack Lind uh looking at expenditures and Staffing and what would be optimal levels of Staffing at at various facilities um I want to put a plugin for the facility uh the finance meeting uh two days from now this Thursday we will be joined by Rich John who is the chair of the Ida and he will be talking to us about the abatement process and how that uh affects the district and in particular uh the South Works project which has been in the news so we'll have that discussion uh this Thursday and then time permitting uh we will be presenting some sort of broad strategies for future budgets different directions we could go on future budgets and then trying to hone in a little bit uh on what is the sort of most

121efficient economy scale in terms of enrollment which leads us to the third issue which is the RFP for the enrollment study and the RFP for the valuation study um you know those things are are are tied together we think there may be efficiencies in looking hard at enrollment particular at the elementary level and so we need the study to help us understand that U but um you know there's potentially from some savings uh in that Arena thank you appreciate it uh I know education is full of as many many acronyms as you can imagine an RFP means request for proposal so we're asking folks to come do the work for us where we'll get those rfps out soon Jill back to you if my alphabet is correct for HR it's kind of the Jill night

122it is um I do want to go on record saying I wrote to Jill last week saying this is going to be heavy meeting for you that I appreciated heads up on that um Human Resources meets on a monthly basis the human resources committee we have regular updates on staff vacancies um vacancies are currently being filled by either overages teacher overages teachers working more than 1.0 full-time equivalent um and also on people who've been hired under an Mo MOA so per some in some cases teachers who are not yet are not yet credentialed in an area um are being hired under a memor random of agreement because of the teacher shortage we've also had a presentation on student staff ratios throughout the district presentation on staff benefits and what that consists of and very recently

123a presentation of how stipend and extracurricular renumeration of teachers for extracurricular activities um are managed and that is contractual so most of these presentations came about because of questions by committee members and um I think we've had good luck with better understanding of how various processes happen excellent thank you Jill uh legislative advocacy Council Aaron greetings um just uh a refresher the charge of this advisory council is to engage with legislators on the local state and federal level in order to advocate for laws and policies that support ICD employees and the success of ICD students so we had a resolution um that passed that um request a school board voting seat on the Tomkins County Industrial Development agency board I have to return a phone call for confirmation but I my understanding is that it's

124time for us to start discussing uh what board member might be the best fit for that position so I should update y'all via email and we might uh have time to discuss that at our next meeting next week um the our group has not met because of various timing issues um looking ahead the uh the election in November given that our charges what it is I we're going to start exploring not just issues that um to help generate income and work with legislators on funding for public schools of course that is at the top of our list but also exploring what change is to the doe might bring to you know state public schools and really starting a conversation with our legislators and building those relationships given what we could be facing um in January

125so that is going to be a focus of our work as we sort of shift um given the changes coming thank you like to add something please um tomorrow at 2: to 4: um the Ida is meeting and on their agenda is a resolution their resolution to add a school representative to their their body of decision makers so um anyone who's interested in tax abatements or specifically Tomkins County Industrial Development um might find that very interesting I'll be there I suspect others will be there and I may be completely wrong so please but not to correct Dr trip I thought their agenda included a discussion of icd's resolution to add a school board member it's unclear on their agenda gotcha so um I think they're going to have a conversation about the resolution that the

126school district passed um but again I could also be wrong as well their uh I believe their agenda is public information so um if not we'll we'll get it out there um discussion they're having a discussion on the resolution on our resolution on our resolution okay it's Miss leading on the agenda then at any rate y I'll be there and it will be interesting I'll be there I'll be joining you good um so and then and then to follow up with that on Thursday uh Rich John who chairs that committee will be at the finance committee meeting to have to continue that dialogue and and provide some additional information for us as well um the last policy or the last committee for this evening's update is policy committee uh which I chair uh we have

127a couple policies one which we're going to be reviewing um this evening in a few minutes uh and that is a uh policy on the distribution of Flyers advertising materials announcements I'll hold on to that one for a second um we uh have been in review of a policy um that is uh the banishment of corporal punishment um it may come as a shock to folks but it's only recently that the state has officially banned corporal punishment in New York state some states still allow it but more importantly our conversation has been um held up slight by trying for us to gain clarity as a district in terms of practice and policy about the use of the word timeout um our policy includes the standard policy includes the word timeout we are trying to gather

128clarity about what does it mean some people have an idea of what a timeout is it a timeout room is it a timeout space we just providing students a break from instruction to be able to gather themselves um that was partially led by questions asked by uh Dr trip as years of experience um as a school psychologist um and also a number of us wanting to understand how best to make that happen I think we have that Clarity of language we'll be bringing that to folks soon um it's not going to change what we do we just want to make sure we codify and policy uh what should actually happen um we began last meeting a conversation about public use of school facilities sort of re-evaluating that things have changed uh since the policy was

129last passed especially uh postco and so we're having some dialogue about what that looks like we thank Dr bryman for helping lead that we also thought it would be a good idea to update our policy on emergency school cancellations early dismissals and delayed openings um we have all this on the website already but we're going to now turn it into a policy including procedures for how that happens folks should be on the lookout for that as well uh then the last two items is the policy committee has been engaged in a couple month conversation about cell phone policy at a districtwide level understanding that each a number of our schools already have various forms of a cell phone policy uh we've been waiting on the state uh Governor hawle went on a listening tour this

130summer thinking that the state may have a Statewide cell phone ban which I believe 17 States currently have um a number of other ones are considering it uh and at the same point in time two of our colleagues Aaron cyle and Karen Yearwood working with TST members of other school districts um we're also making the ask one that I will support that the governor recommend that it become a local issue and not a Statewide ban so that individual school districts could decide what they want to do I hope I captured that correctly um and we'll go through a process uh Carrie Burke and Mary Grover have been leading that work uh Mary Grover sent to the board something earlier today last week the Department of Education uh put out at the federal level while we

131have one put out a guideline I'll let that sit for a minute uh the Department of Education put out guidelines about how to engage in a cell phone policy procedure we're most likely going to use that it's all standard practice it's a very well done document very easy to find via Google uh and to the students in the room uh for us that would mean significant participation from you all like what is a cell phone policy look like um in schools and so more conversation to come about that we envision that's going to be for another couple months and that we would not have a district-wide policy this year but we'd be working that with parents caregivers teachers uh and other folks um and then lastly as a general review of our Board of Education

132policies um I was on the board when we created the policy committee uh because I recognized that our policies were significantly outdated um the policies are numbered from 00000000 to 9999 and so we are going through each of those uh and trying to make sure we updated them just as a frame of reference um thanks to some work with uh Emily Tracy arm and Trisha uh we have at least 12 policies that are currently active that were last updated in the 1970s and so that's probably not a good idea so we're we're going we're going to start going through each of those policies see which ones are outdated sometimes they're just very well written and they should stand they stand the test of time other times they are uh outdated and should either be deleted

133or updated and we'll be going through all those uh again in a much more methodical fashion so that's the policy update stay tuned more information coming your way soon all right board colleagues uh the next we'll continue on with our agenda oh and my apologies for those folks who are listening to that again anything that spark your interest that you want to know more about please check the Comm the committee summaries again it'll give you uh sort of a a shorthand information about how to find additional information for folks who are interested um the next couple of items are a little bit more just sort of proor items uh at the beginning of each reorganization meeting we identify people to carry out certain tasks with the district uh one of those folks has taken a

134job in the Vestal School District which means we now have to reassign someone else to do those tasks and that's what you're going to see for the next five agenda items so we will entertain motions for agenda item 9.4 I move to authorize District Treasurer Emily ship to sign agreements contracts or any obligations with vendors Consultants contractors or other service providers for the 2024 2025 school year second I heard Jill first I hope there wasn't a competition move by Karen second by Jill questions conversation debate hearing none all in favor unanimous thank you very much agenda item 9.5 oh do you want to move okay I'll move I move to appoint assistant superintendent for human resources Zack Lind as purchasing agent for the itha city school district itha New York for the fiscal 2425 school

135year second move by Adam second by Jill questions conversation debate hearing none all in favor unanimous again thank you very much agenda item 9.6 I'll keep going I move to approve assistant superintendent for human resources zacklin and District Treasurer Emily ship to represent the Ithaca City School District on the workers compensation Cooperative board for the 2024 for 2024 2025 second move by Adam second by Jill discussion debate questions hearing none all in favor pass unanimously 9 point 7 I move to authorize Trisha barisford Clerk of the Ithaca City School District Ithaca New York and Zack Lind assistant superintendent for human resources to sign agreements reports and claims to the State education department in connection with the operation of the national school lunch program in the schools of the city school district itha New York for

136the 2024 2025 school year second move by Adam second by Jill questions conversation debates hearing none all in favor unanimous and 9.8 I move to authorized Chief investigations officer Robert Van Kieran and or assistant superintendent for human resources Zack Lyn to certify all payrolls prepared on behalf of the city school district Ithica New York for the 2024 2025 fiscal year second M by Adam second by Jill questions conversation debates hearing done all in favor passes hum minut thank you very much uh that brings us to agenda item 9.9 which is policy 1145 the distribution of Flyers advertising materials announcements for a first reading uh we had great help from uh I want to say Katie um that's not correct it's a long night teaching um the main purpose of this uh of revisiting this policy

137and please correct me if I'm wrong wrong Katie was to make sure that we are in compliance uh with ADA requirements particular around materials that uh are used in a digital format and I know there's something in addition to that yes um so actually the initial reason why we wanted to look at this policy um it's actually around the disclaimer piece um and so right now when um outside organizations submit their Flyers um they include these materials are neither sponsored nor endorsed by the Board of Education um the superintendent or this school um and I get several complaints a year about organizations not wanting to include that um and actually um in speaking with Carrie Burke um her request actually is that we don't have it included on anything from um local and state governments

138uh particularly as it pertains to Public Health um there's not really an there's been a few times we've waved um like you know especially during Co when those buers were given to us we did not put disclaimers on them um we worked with um Tomkins County Whole Health last year that we waved the disclaimer for um so that really is the only instance that we are thinking of making the exception for and wanted to have the discussion of whether or not we just state that in the policy um but then in reviewing the policy um there is no mention of any digital sharing of the Flyers um so we made those changes question so what you're saying now or proposing now is that disclaimer beond all materials except for those that have originated with the

139Tomkins County Department of Health or the state yeah or the state okay thank you other questions yes so where does it state that so actually we didn't add that in oh you didn't add it yeah we just wanted to have the discussion of whether we agreed and then we DED in but I'm having a very hard time reading what is the disclaimer or hearing rather what is the disclaimer um it's on page two these materials are neither sponsored nor endorsed by the Board of Education of the itha city school district the superintendent or this school okay and so the the idea is that you want this to be clearly visible on so that's what it is now yeah so every flyer needs to have it on but whether or not we want to make the

140exception for public health entities that don't to not have it on oh okay so making the exception for public health entities and what did Carrie Burke advise she would like to see us not have to include it it just seems weird especially you know around when we were masking or you know we were did an anti vaping campaign it's a little weird to say we don't endorse this it it implies a disagreement right yes thank I mean Co provides the best example we are sharing information that came from the tkan count Health Department it did not seem to make sense to them put a disclaimer on hey you should that you know you should wear a mask at that point in time if that was the expectation um and there and there are other instances

141When government agencies or uh may ask us to share something oftentimes even you know another example would be sort of Roc Flyers that would be out there we may not put a disclaimer on as well I I would disagree on that but because I know that goes to through at the high school um families can have to opt out y of receiving that and if they don't make that effort to opt out which I am totally disagreement about so when we get to that discussion I'll disagree at that point but I'm in agreement with the health I mean as it's written now we say we can make exceptions so if that's enough that's enough Sor just above just above that paragraph unless an exemption has been granted by the superintendant all flyers and advertising material

142announcements must include the following disclaimer right okay so we don't need to make any adjustment for any health relate since that's the question becomes as a matter of practice does the board want that codified in policy or is this disclaimer enough that the superintendent has the ability to make an to Grant an exemption I I think given the shifts that we're about to see in our government I'm not I'm not sure I'm not sure I want to change this right now to make it specific I I like the idea of it in a in a in a normal system but um I I don't want to get really political here but the change is potentially coming to the Departments of health and that might trickle down I don't know if we necessarily will want to

143endorse some things that might come down the pipeline in the next years and so leaving it a little more General I think is is the better option that is generally what the argument is used in policy that you want to be specific enough to cover the task but not so constrained and so confined that it has to be reviewed and updated every single time when something happens that we cannot anticipate so right now we're talking about the Department of Health I can Envision another situation where another government agency may be asking us to do something that we don't want to put the disclaimer on and we want to leave that as a option to to do so so that it's not in conflict with each other I should also recommend that or I should also

144state that this is a first reading right and the process is first reading back to the policy committee for any review additional information investigation back to the board for a second reading and then adoption so we are not adopting this policy this evening we're just giving the framework of of it if we so choose be okay and we'll take any feedback and questions that you want us to explore move forward I I have one more um please so the um the middle paragraph uh sorry so proposed policy content and the second paragraph in for digital distributions agencies and organization must ensure that all materials are 88 compliant and include accessible text content and support for screen readers my concern with this and this is something I do in my professional capacity is that ADA Compliant

145does do not mean it's actually accessible um and I I wonder if something we need to explore as an as a district which is something I'm implementing again professionally are um accessibility best practices and I wonder if we can explore that as a policy team because ADA Compliant does not cut it in many many cases and Screen readers are a really great example and unless you have someone on staff who can test something with a screen reader before it gets sent out you're sending a bunch of mumble jumble most of the time um and so these best practices don't exist you have to develop them and I think we should do that as a district this is when I love when Two Worlds Collide so I'm in complete agreement with what you're saying at the

146same point in time as someone who writes policy I'm also trying to make sure that we don't write policy that lands Us in court so if we say that we're going to do this is vastly different than say we're going to try to do this right so you need a Le you need some legal room you still want want to hold folks accountable right but if we did and at this point in time if I'm not mistaken that there are regularly that there is no alternative text sometimes that comes and so we're trying to at least hold to that minimum standard while say at the same point in time pushing folks to do something more than that so I'll look to you about what that language could look like so we're not we're not holding

147ourselves to a legal standard but encouraging best practices yeah I hope that makes sense no it makes total sense because it's very very complicated and changing and Evil y so I'll work with you about a sentence that could make that that work additional questions board members may have about the policy it will be on well we'll entertain motions if folks are willing or interested at the next no what motion a motion for a first reading okay I move to approve policy 1145 distribution of Flyers advertising materials and announcements for a first reading second moved by Adam second by Jill again first reading If This Were to be approved it'd go back to policy and then back our way uh any additional questions debate conversation all in favor unanimous fantastic I'll connect with Aaron we'll work

148with Trisha about some of that language Katie thank you for all your work on this policy as well we'll follow up uh I'm certain we'll be working on it great at the same time at midnight later on tonight thank you any additional uh dates I know we have a lot of things taking place uh again we'll repeat it again facilities 4:40 p.m. On th 4:45 on Thursday trying to get home uh Finance is a change andate we also have a uh public hearing for new Charter School uh this Thursday at 6 PM uh and then finance will take place at 6:30 with that being said uh we'll bring our meeting to a close thank you all very much have a good evening thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.