CorpusRecord 235822

BOE Meeting 1/21/25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Midlakes Schools
Date
2025-01-22
Location
Ontario County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,917 words · about 78 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001would like to call to order the January 21st 2025 regular meeting of the Board of Education of the Phelps Clifton Springs School District Pam would you lead us in the pledge I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all the Phelps Clifton Springs Central School District Board of Education meets P to publicly conduct its business in accordance with the law the public is invited to observe these proceedings but is not entitled to respond or disrupt them especially when such disturbances run counter to the district's code of conduct and the welcoming Spirit of our district the public is reminded of the context of board meetings board members are volunteers audience members are visitors to

002school grounds and student and staff well-being is at the heart of board operations visitors are reminded of the courage it takes to speak up as members of our community and the importance of encouraging Civic and civil engagement the board strives to hear all Community Voices during its public meetings in a safe respectful and orderly manner the behavior that we expect of all students in our classrooms is also expected from visitors at board meetings in an effort to ensure that community members concerns are heard the board reminds speakers to address the board in a civil manner refrain from discussing specific Personnel or students limit outbursts and Li limit unnecessary noise the boy the board encourages an atmosphere of respect and tolerance and strict adherence to its code of conduct roll call Lynn Le board member lindsy

003Marino board member Mike door board member Matt Goodman board member Carl dasos business administrator Nick ganster superintendent Tracy Elman board member pamelo man district clerk is there a motion to approve the agenda as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of the agenda as presented say I I I all those opposed motion carried uh is there a motion to approve the Board of Education regular meeting minutes from our December meeting so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of the meeting minutes from our December meeting say I I I all of those opposed motion carried and the consent agenda items is there a motion to approve the consent agenda items a through e as presented so moved is there a second second any

004discussion all those in favor of the consent agenda items as presented say I I I all those opposed motion carried all right presentations Miss fnck hi Rec good okay great I oh thank you so much so thank you so much to the Board of Education my name is ly ratnik I'm the district superintendent for Wayne fingerlakes bosies and um your superintendent is uh truly one of the best he is a partner in everything that we do here um at bosis and in our region and um I just can't say enough about his leadership um as well as the business official Carl and I have great conversations about rent and how to continue and strengthen our partnership so um I just wanted to say thank you for the invite and also um thank you for the

005partnership that we have together um so I'm going to talk a little bit about um our bosies this year or last year when I came on board we worked Under the Umbrella of making success possible which is kind of our hashtag and our mission about what we do and why we do it but um as I came in and did my entry plan around listening and learning I found out that making success possible was very different to every person that I talked to so we really came together and unified as iosis around our core commitments and um I will not read to you what they uh what they are but I will just quickly review them um our commitments so when you talk to people we want you everything that we do at bosis we

006want you to remember that this is why we we do what we do so we are incredibly committed to our Workforce we believe that the passionate people that make up our bosies are why we are so great and why we can deliver the services and continue to grow the supports for our region um we want to be future forward in everything we do as you know um a lot of conversations about everything in technology and everything in Workforce and everything around academic Excellence um we believed that our organization needs to be ready for the future and needs to be thinking about the future to support our component school districts um leadership we want you to look at us in every component District as a place that we cultivate trusted leaders so if we don't know

007how to do it we will find the answer to how to do it and then we will bring it to our region and we will hopefully excel at it and we do believe in excellence meaning everything that we offer we want to make sure that if we're saying yes that we can do so and it is we are providing excellence in our services um belonging was the commitment that came out loud and clear um everyone from our csos to our students to parents to our Workforce really recognize that if we don't cultivate uh a feeling of belonging in both our students when they walk through the door our parents when they call us or come to visit us or csos and what they ask for and getting answers that without that piece of belonging and

008feeling like they can reach their Highest Potential that U without that we don't have much that we don't sustain and retain the very best staff so this year was all about belonging at bosis and um last but not least and I know that this resonates with Nick which is our super against her which is we want to be unified in our approach that we truly believe our region is stronger together we serve 25 school districts um and with with each one of them it's like a puzzle piece you know we are very different and we are a very large region but when we come together and we unify in our Collective effort we can be better for the students that we serve so those are our commitments that we rolled out and people feel a

009great deal of ownership and pride in them and I hope you will connect with them as we do this presentation so in 19 1948 the legislator came together to create what is now known as bosis the board of Cooperative Educational Services and this is really to make sure that we have an opportunity to to provide shared services shared resources for this the districts that we serve um one of those is editech it is um it is in uh around safety security uh Innovation anything from computers to providing professional development and we served 47 districts with our editech um and we actually cross over what's called our joint management team to Monroe and to um GV bosis and collectively editech while people think and it is a Wayne fingerlakes Uh Department it also spans over 47

010districts um we have two Career Tech educational centers and you're going to hear from one of the amazing students very soon talk about all the things that he is learning there we have five special education centers that provide effective learning opportunities and special services for the students who are exceptional uh we have over a thousand employees so we are one of the biggest employees in the region and we have 25 component school districts that we serve and are very proud to collaborate with so you might say well that's nice so what do you do for us what do you do here at Midlakes to make sure that we feel like we belong and um come together to unify and really uplift our entire region um you participate in the regional summer school opportunities you um

011are a member of our editech services you um we you get telecommunications from us professional um do we still do is there PR I know we were off it and back on it as far as our Communications commun okay but you have you stepped off and you might be coming back on or maybe not um spelling bees tutoring Services distance learning opportunities the central business office um you have 84 students in our career in Tech and we have uh share 36 students here from Midlakes and uh we couldn't be prouder of the progress that uh they have achieved just as a little side note uh last year we were almost um providing for BOS Aid almost 3,000 three million sorry three million and the rent Aid which we cannot thank you enough for the partnership

012that we have with um having our students here on your campus you are welcoming you talk about belonging I mean you guys hold the flag for that you always say how can we work with you how can we create more shared services and every child who comes here to Mid Lake truly like feels they are they are part of bid lake so thank you from the bottom of our heart for that and so to really demonstrate and show you um what belonging looks like what success and Excellence looks like from a student that uh we just get to have in our CTE Center but you have really had here so for the Long Haul we are going to introduce first Shannon Brown who will introduce her student thank you so good evening everyone uh my

013name is Shannon Brown I am the director of CTE and Workforce Development for Wayne finger lak bosies and I have the honor and privilege to introduce to you this evening one of your very own um Dylan white Dylan is currently a senior in our diesel technology heavy equipment repair and operation program at fingerlakes Technical and career center just right down the road from here Dylan um is a Midlake student who in his 10th grade year made a decision along with his family and his school counselors um and any other advisers to him that he would attend a program at Bose's for half his school day and so for half of Dylan's day in his junior year it was the afternoon he attended fingerlakes Technical and career center and now for his senior year he attends

014in the morning so I am honored to introduce to you Dylan so he can share with you all that he's learned um at his time time at fltcc come on up Dylan good evening as previously stated I am dlan dlan white I'm a senior here at Midlakes and I'm also a senior at the Wayne finger fingerlakes technical career center um as stated I did choose the hero operation hero heavy repair heavy equipment repair operation um that was the program because I have a heavy interest in mechanics and working on the larger vehicles um I've heard good things about the program it gives a good start uh good hard head sorry apologies a good head start on mechanics and I will also receive my Class B CDL as part of a program within ltcc which is

015an additional program um next slide please and thank you after actually hold on uh after this one maybe yes please um oh no sorry no apologies go back sorry I um in my first year of the diesel program I had the opportunity to learn how to how to tear down in the entirety a diesel engine as the first things we were introduced you know first after we got all of our safety programs done which was a um requirement in our training we were straight into the shop and the first thing we did was tear down a smaller but still a diesel engine it was the the very first thing and throughout the years we've acquired other um knowledge of Maintenance um understanding machinery and understanding Machinery operation it's a program that works for both mechanics

016and operators in the diesel field the hope is to have um operating mechanics but the program can help you know just operators or just mechanics by giving us ample opportunity to work on our own personal projects um to use the vast amount of equipment such as that back out not back out sorry bulldozer see the background it's currently in the shop for a broken linkage on one of the tracks so that's something we're working on currently to work to get back on the hill but we have uh plethora of other machines bulldozers tractors skid steers small a small um e excavator and just other machines that we can learn how to properly work on um I we're allowed to have our own personal projects which is the truck right there it's my personal truck it's

017a 2006 GMC Sierra I've had a lot of help on that from my teachers in the diesel program but also the Autotech because it is a gas but since you know they're lenient with what we're we bring in we're allowed to bring in our own personal equipment as long as it's something mechanical that we will learn on I've had to do an entire engine swap which I'm currently working on building um and since we didn't have school today here at Midlakes I was there all day which is a nice uh opportunity to have I was working on getting that uh finalized to get it out of the shop um I excited about the class bcdl because it's something that gives you a head start on mechanics you know being able to move the equipment that

018we work on and I've uh I've gained quite a bit of Knowledge from this program next slide please so I choose um I've chose to go to Alfred State College of Technology well I've been accepted there by them um I plan to continue my studies of diesel mechanics um I was able to learn basic understanding of the diesel mechanics from this program to get my foot in the door it's uh the the program is very good to get a basic knowledge and you can get a job out of it but if if you want to be more specialized I would recommend you know like a a college but it's a it's a great program for our community to have to be able to learn these trades which all over the country we're in great need

019of these trades that we learn there thank you thank [Applause] you did you have any questions for Dylan dyl did you guys have any questions for sorry I didn't I'm so sorry think of that I'm not gonna put Dylan on this do you do you folks have any other questions sounds thank you apologies for that that's okay so I'd also like to if you don't know the infamous um Mr mcnam my vice president at fosis he always um he is your liaison so he wanted to say a couple words in case you have any board questions and if you have any questions afterwards for myself or for Shannon we're here to answer any questions that you have well thank you for having us here as Lynn said I'm Joe mcamera I've been uh on the

020B's board what 10 plus years uh proud of what we've been able to accomplish I want to thank you first for your support and we try to support you as much as we can if board members have a question as ly had pointed out you can give me a shout if I can help you with them if I would and if I can't I'll get you to somebody that can um I'm proud of our programs and uh you know that's my job and it's it's a i' I've really enjoyed working with the bosies that's been a uh a real pleasure uh I've been on the sen fall school board for going on 20 years so I understand I have a board memb understanding of Education which was helpful and and be patient with yourself because

021it takes a long time to learn it and as soon as you learn it it gets changed anyway right and uh I'm also would like to thank the board for your support for the four counties I'm the current president who moves on this year from that position but uh appreciate all your support I know Tracy really involved with it and thank you Pam for giving me dire on how to get here any questions okay thank you Joe is there a specific email address that I should provide board members uh I got a card I don't because I'm counting and I hear senica Falls 4 County Wayne figer so I just want to make sure a little bit connected guy yeah sorry a little blame here but all right thank you I'll make sure that they

022get thank you yep thank you Joe yes any other questions for us how we can serve you better be better Partners we're going to have some conversations I think tomorrow about some some items so yeah no wow okay and go home sure I know yes always available always available right down the road thank you so much thank you than okay who's next summer school y all right summer school thank you thank you take care folks yep present full screen there we go okay so thank you to the board I find it ironic that probably on the coldest evening that we've had in a few years maybe a handful of years um we're here to talk about summer school but um you know it it seems like it's way early to be thinking about um you

023know those those months of July and August but uh the planning is certainly have has already started in fact the planning really starts early in the fall especially when you're looking at um making changes to your summer programming to better fit the current needs um so tonight we're going to we're going to lay that out you're going to hear from quite a few of us um about um some of the history behind summer school and I think it's important to understand that because um as your needs evolve as in a district as your resources evolve as a district and certainly as the student needs academically evolve in a district you have to look at how do you best fit those needs how do you best leverage the resources you have available to you how do

024you best um identify and then address the needs of your student population to really design summer programming that's going to um stay committed to the focuses of what summer programming is and the realities of what we're trying to accomplish and so tonight you'll hear a little bit about the history um you're going to hear about what are the focuses primarily of the three distinct programs that we operate in in the summer and then you're going to hear about what those programs are going to look like in the summer of 2025 so when we think about uh the three distinct programs we're really talking about what we refer to as our extended school year right um our elementary program and then our secondary program and when we think about that extended school year piece we're primarily

025talking about um our students with abilities who have um individualized education plans right um it's those students who need um a higher level of support through the summer and primarily that support is focused on ensuring that those students don't regress over the summer months right those students need access to some um significant interventions or significant um um I would say instruction over the summer um not only academically but sometimes also with some physical and fine motor things too um so we'll we'll address that the aim really is to reduce or eliminate that regression over the summer months for those students of our um that have some high needs our middle and high school program um when we think about that we have to think about 78 and 912 right and our 78 program is really

026focused on maintaining and continuing to build skills often times maybe in specific content areas um at that 7 e level we might not necessarily be looking at Ela Math Science Social Studies across the board we might be really just focusing in on um languages other than English for example right or we might just specificly focus in on one particular content area at the 912 level um we're really talking about advancing the regions we're really talking about ensuring that our students are meeting the criteria and staying on track to graduate on time right the ultimate goal of any school district is to make sure that our students are College and Career ready when they walk out of our door out of our doors as they graduate high school right are they ready to enter the workforce

027are they ready to to go on to some postsecondary goals um and so that 912 program really focuses on making sure that students are meeting those graduation requirements and getting the the credits and the pre prerequisites that they need to continue to advance in their studies at the 912 level and then our elementary really that k6 level focuses on maintaining continuing to build the skills that they need to be successful um to stay on grade level or to approach grade level as they are moving into the next grade level right um I would say primarily targeting um math and literacy when we're talking about that specific k um six or k6 program and the idea behind it is really to boost that knowledge um or maintain the skills of that knowledge so again like some

028of the summer skills there's not some regression in those pieces so um throughout this evening I want you to keep those Frameworks in mind three distinct programs each one has a specific purpose us um each one has some goals um that align with some of that those focuses that I just articulated um and you're going to be hearing more of those themes throughout um right now we're going to talk a little bit about the history of the science program and again I can't re reiterate enough that there's there's sort of no right or wrong when it comes to the history or advancing our program it really is about given our current resources given the focuses given what our students need how do we best support those needs so we're going to talk a little about

029history and then we'll move forward and talk about what the program is going to look like moving ahead okay so I can give you the history like back to the early 2000s that's all I can do for you um but in the early 2000s at the elementary level we had a K2 summer reading program where parents transported their kids they came for about half an hour they were in they were out um and our 3 through five until we became a 36 building students were busted in um for ELA and math skills we kind of call those if you remember when early State Testing came out our bubble kids um those kids we really wanted to get from that level two to a level three um and again some of those kids were bust some

030of those kids were brought in by their parents then let's see that kind of carried over into our 6 through 8 which was again the same summer summer skills program um around 2018 we added in um an seal component so our social emotional learning component and we provided bsing for all of our students K8 they all came to this building actually starting then in 2013 at the middle and high school level our high school students transitioned from a regional summer school back to or they started our Apex Credit Recovery which is what we've been using up until this year so that's where our students come in it's a computer-based program and they work independently we have about six staff members who work with those kids on any course that they need um and our seven

031through eight kids again joined in with that seal component um in seventh and eth grade around 2018 2021 we added in a Spanish recovery program for our seventh and eighth graders so we could make sure those seventh graders who are going going on to eighth grade we're ready for that next step in Spanish and that our eighth graders were getting that um checkpoint test that they needed so that they could go on to high school level Spanish um again we are still busing all of our k through eight kids in 2020 we did not have any programming for K8 but we did offer the Apex credit recovery for our 912 students and that's when we began busing 9 through 12 students in 2022 we started busing everyone districtwide um any student that needed to come

032in for summer school was offered offered District transportation we have our esy our extended school year program um those kids have been coming that whole time those are kids who are typically our IEP students and this is mandated by the committee on special education state aded says we've got to bust them because they have to be here and the whole point of that program is to make sure that those students aren't regressing and Andre will touch more on on what they do with that um but again those students are also bust in so that's what I got for you for about the last 24 years okay I don't know Carl bsing all right thank you so as we consider Transportation um as as uh Laura eluded to in about 2022 we started transporting all students

033to summer school and I think it's no secret that we have lost a healthy amount of bus drivers over the last handful of years and right now the transportation department has been um kind of um being held together um by duct tape some days with with bus drivers being out for a variety of needs but when you look at the summer programming the variety of Summer programming we offer um our bus drivers are 10-month bus drivers there are two mechanics there used to be a bus dispatcher and a director of transportation we still have a vacant bus dispatcher position there are four individuals that are there for 12 months everyone else is there for 10 months when you look at the bus drivers that are there for 10 months there are 22 of them there

034used to be more but we're down to 22 and some days we're barely staffed at one point we were down three bus drivers this past summer and the summer prior we had 10 bus drivers we had to hire in order to fulfill summer programming while that doesn't sound like a lot when you say we we need 10 bus drivers in order to make summer school or summer skills or our apex program work doesn't sound like a lot what that means is we need 45% of our department to volunteer to come back and drive over the summer when you put it in that perspective that's significant you need 45% of your employees who are 10 month employees who have signed up for this job because they want the summer off to volunteer to come in and

035get and get compensated for their time and drive and that has been a strain especially this past summer because a lot of our bus drivers for a variety of reasons at the end of 10 months they want to be on vacation they want a little break from their typical 10-month jobs um and you know quite frankly they deserve it just like teachers deserve that break over the summer so asking 45% of our employees to come in has been significantly challenging out of those 45% there as Andrea is going to describe some of those and Laura eluded to us already some of those are State mandated we cannot avoid those and some of those are as a result of options we have provided families since the pandemic so that kind of just gives you a little

036nutshell of where transportation is as of this summer any questions about that okay all right so just to give a little bit more information regarding the extended school year program itself so the extended school year program is you know Jeff and Laura both did a very nice job on explaining it is mandated based on the committee on special education recommendations to prevent substantial regression for our students who need more support um within that program we have state approvals we have a state approval to run a halfday program so it's a minimum of three hours for 30 days so our summer dates for example this coming summer are July 10th through August 20th where we'll have kids on campus from 9: to noon um our IND District programming that we run we have special class programs

037we have an 811 program a 1211 program um we ran three sections of that last year and we ran one section of a 15 to1 one program as well um years past we've those numbers depending on how many students we have have fluctuated how many sections we we need at each of those but we do have state approval to run those programs um this past summer we ended up with 35 students between those three programs um we do have more students that are able to come based on their IEP needs however parents might elect to op out and that is their their choice um for the summer months we might recommend that they attend but we can't State you must attend um so sometimes when we're planning especially in the early stages we we're planning

038for how many students does the committee recommend and then we we continue to scale and fine-tune as the spring goes on so out of those um in order to support those students last summer we needed five teachers seven teaching assistants six AIDS and then to help with our program as well as our related service only we have a state um approval to run occupational therapy Physical Therapy speech therapy um as well as other services such as teacher for the visually impaired or teacher of the de for um select students um we use the two speech pathologist um for the district typically we asked for three but knowing you know as Carl said some elects you say I need the summer off and that's okay so we we manage and make do um but we have

039two speech pathologists last summer we've had three occupational therapists and two physical therapists the to help support our program for IND District programming as well as our related service only so for related Services only if you'll see the number of 41 up there for students so some of those students do attend those IND District programs but there are some students that do not they might be going to the summer skills program but they might not if we as a district are recommending or we as a committee are recommending that those students require that service in order to prevent regression of skill then we are stating we're going to offer transportation for that so that's where sometimes those transportation needs do come into effect as well um in uh so we have 26 students for physical

040therapy and 30 students for speech these providers also including the special ed teachers are phenomenal when I say hey we have an evaluation that needs to be done they're the they're the staff that are doing those pieces as well so not only are they fulfilling those needs IEP based needs in the moment for programming they're also there to help support students and through the evaluation process um that you know either new referrals that might come in over the summer referal that were closing out students who've moved in that were um in the process already we have to continue that process so those staff members are assisting with that um L rutnik mentioned earlier all of the um sites that we're sending our students to Across the component districts we send our students to those programs

041um over the summer as well and last year we had uh 28 we out of 41 students that we have uh attending those types of programs 28 of them attended uh an off-site location to help support their learning needs um and as Carl alluded to I mean that takes a lot we're going to Rochester we're going to um new work we're going we have students who are going to the Marcus Whitman campus we have students that are going to you know offsite so it's it all of those are factors in our planning as well Andrea fima sure um that's quite a list of locations as Andrea said so when I talk about we need 10 bus drivers uh just for this past summer six of those are for these Services right here so six of

042our bus drivers were going to IND District out of District programs and one or two of them were shuttling students back and forth as a result of their related Services because some students as Andrea mentioned were only coming in for their related services and then were being driven back home so six bus drivers were responsible just for that thank you uh so we you know look forward to continuing to find tune our programming for based on our individual student needs as we go through and find efficiencies where we can um but knowing that we want our students best prepared to then enter the following September and by doing um you know all of the programs working on math reading working onal needs in um having a little bit of fun in the summer as well

043um they're better prepared to re-enter in September and have a smoother start to the school year which is our goal um so thank you so even before uh even before we um started to acknowledge some of the transportation challenges that we were seeing we had already begun the process of evaluating what we were doing over the summer for our middle and high school students specifically we were looking at Apex and Apex has a lot of advantages it's a really convenient platform um it's it's very accessible to kids we had a nice team of teachers who would work with um kids in any subject area but help them along as they're kind of um moving through the apex program um but as we Ed to talk about it Apex felt a lot more like a like

044a tapin than it did like a long range um remediation program so it's a great program especially when kids are close so when kids are you know failing courses but not by a ton Apex might be a great uh great opportunity for them but it might not have the same type of educational uh value that being in a traditional summer school program would serve so we started to explore what it would look like to join the Ontario County Consortium through Wayne Finger Lake bosies and uh you know Lynn actually spoiled that for everybody that was that was going to be my announcement so um so we we started to look into the Ontario County Consortium so it's a group of schools in the area in Ontario County so it'll be us canona Victor Bloomfield honey

045oi red jacket and I think that's all of them um and it'll be hosted at canona this year and it looks a lot more like a traditional summer school so you have certified teachers in each of the content areas is uh they're running a full program they have a two-e regions prep course um so that be able to offer a heck of a lot uh more specific instruction on each of the content areas than we would be able to through that apex program apex program has its values and it has its its positives but it's just not the same as learning from a teacher in a classroom in the same kind of traditional way so we've already we already were beginning this conversation about moving towards uh this type of summmer school program prior to

046uh acknowledging those Transportation challenges um I did want to talk a little bit about because this is for 9th through 12th grade it could include some eighth graders if they're taking some accelerated programs uh but it's for 9th through 12th grade so uh I wanted to mention a little bit about where we would go with middle school students too uh I don't know who's got the clicker all right so with middle school students uh historically and you see these percentages on the left and right side or I'm sorry on the left hand side of the of the screen and uh we are doing some skills with math Ela andal and those percentages are the number of the percentage of the students who uh attended now those percentages are a little bit deceiving because we only

047invited about 5 to 12 kids every single year so of those five or 12 kids 70 they attended 75% of the time 64% of the time 72% of the time so you weren't getting a a a real uh a real bang for your buck with it with all of it right it's serving a small population of students attendance isn't required so attendance is sometimes spotty um so what we want to do is move towards a um something that's focused on meeting more graduation requirements early and so focusing our attention in house with our um seventh and eighth grade foreign language which is uh we only offer Spanish now so as seventh graders if they're not meeting the standard for seventh grade Spanish they can come in for some remediation and prepare them for e8th grade

048Spanish and if they don't pass 8th grade Spanish they still can get a high school foreign language credit if they pass the checkpoint a which they can do at the end of a summer school experience too so it's another way to make sure that our kids are coming into high school well prepared for graduation when they get there so that's um how changes are happening at the on uh Ontario County Consortium Su School summer 8 summer program that's focused on graduation requirements all right our elementary summer school or summer skills that we had um this past summer 2024 we had 110 students that came grades came six so the way we worked it out is that each grade level um there were two teachers one of them was focused in literacy and one of them

049was focused in math so the students would come in in they would get thanks to our great food service staff they have breakfast they'd come to their to classrooms and have their morning meeting um they' get an hour of literacy instruction or an hour of math instruction and they'd flip-flop teachers right so they got exposure to two different teachers um we also had three great um staff members that were in charge ofal at certain grade levels um so the social emotional learning aspect focused on some physical activity um team building skills and so social skills as well as you know coping skills with their emotions um you know the grade level teachers did fantastic we had a really great turnout wise um not a lot of kids were absent um running through the Monday through

050Friday or Monday through Thursday schedule so and they were there for the three hours as well so I'll talk about Transportation sustainability so as we look at as we look at a going to a regional summer school model especially at the secondary level we have to remind ourselves that at least we're going to need it Mo most likely about six bus drivers to run just our extended school year model just to take uh students to in District programs to out of District programs but we also have to acknowledge that um a regional summer school model may not have the exact start time that we've typically had so if we're transporting students to a new location and we have to now dedicate a certain number of bus drivers to that location to bring that those students

051to and from do I see us reducing um there being a significant reduction from 10 drivers not necessarily depending on what the start and end times will be of our regional summer school we may need 10 drivers but what we can't do is be transporting students at the secondary to a regional program and students in our summer skills Elementary program and our esy students because at some point we just don't have enough dri that want to volunteer to do so so in terms of our sustainability as we move to this model at the secondary level we have to be mindful that 10 is really where we want to be or less I just don't know how much we can minimize that so that's one of those pieces to take into consideration go back please yep

052there we go can we just think about the benefits of being Elementary in the secondary program and some of the shifts we're making there I would I would classify this as proba not making significant shifts sort of pro prog programmatically at the elementary level right um we're going to maintain that focus on literacy math and the seal skills that we know makes every student successful as they progress up we're going to focus on um trying to reduce that summer slide for those students that are on that some um some of those needy students that might have that summer slide at the secondary level I would say those are where you're going to see some significant programmatic changes from what's been done the last few years but not significant when we think about the history of

053our summer programming right we've been a part of this Regional summer school um there was a time where the district moves away from that um to explore Apex and think about that there's still a place for apex apex excuse me as as Dan talked about you know that idea of some students are really close and they just need to tap it in um and and that's going to maintain a piece of it sorry inside joke with the team on that one um but there's also a recognition that we have other students who um aren't nearly as close sometimes at meeting those requirements and to have them go through the Apex process doesn't necessarily give them the depth of content that they need and that they're going to need in future coursework as they continue to

054advance um to those graduation requirements so a little bit um of a larger overhaul there so any questions from anybody on the team so this is a tough problem that's why I asked all the administrators to come and present a comprehensive look um at our summer programming from the actual academic programming who we're targeting what we uh are mandated to do through um the committee on special education and some very real human resource constraints that we have because the reality is is we want to do everything for everybody and we want to help everybody and get everybody body to where um they need to be but if we over overextend ourselves we'll start making promises um that that we can't actually follow through on so it's important for us to take a very real look

055at the problem and uh when we took a look at it you know it's it's not a financial resource issue it's it's a human resource issue where we just don't have enough Human Resources um to get everything for everybody done so I just wanted to make sure the board OD why I asked uh for this comprehensive look at the summer programming and I wanted to make sure that the board had an opportunity uh to ask questions this been a problem historically has it got progressively worse I I think I think as a result of the pandemic the district has several districts uh provided transportation for several different levels of programming and this was a trend across our region and across the state because um you know students I think there was a significant slide in

056um you know how much information students retained the hybrid program we wanted to help kids get caught up and so we provide a Ser provided a service simultaneously during that time a turn started to happen of folks not wanting to be the not so many folks wanting to be bus drivers anymore so you can't pass by a district office of any school district without seeing a sign of bus drivers wanted so this is the perfect storm where since the pandemic we've provided a service that right now we're struggling to provide so has it been there historically it has not it's it's something that was created within the last four years and something that we're struggling to sustain I have a question so the information that that's been provided tonight from from admin team um are

057these where are we in the decision-making process are are we tossing out ideas um or is this stuff that we're actually we're saying that we're pursuing the these options pursuing okay gotcha so there's going to be no more of the Apex and then every kid in summer school will go to can right so to clarify um Apex is really good when a student is really close to passing that CL class so we would actually leverage Apex as a way for them to finish just that last little bit say they have an overall average of like 61 in a course and we know they just need a little bit more to get over that Finish Line Apex is a good vehicle to do something like that that's that's the joke of tapping it in right you're

058really close computer program yes you go to school and you do the computer program you do it at home gool y go to school you show up yeah um but for students who have such wide gaps in their learning in whatever course they may be in um Apex doesn't do a great job of of just helping them learn the content that they're supposed to have learned which can create future gaps right so if you're not um if you're not making the grade in freshman level Algebra 1 the chance of your math Gap widening becomes more significant as a result so we want to make sure that our summer programming um helps fill those gaps in as best they can as early as they can Laura Lindsay like okay so when Natalie came that one Summer

059she did an apex program we're not looking to get rid of accelerating those six go7 kids those couple of kids that need to still get that class over the summer but there's two different programs for Apex one is the credit recovery and one is the full the full course so the full course program that we did with some of those kids that need to be accelerated will still be there the Apex programs that we use during the school year that are the full forr will still have those but the credit recovery that we were doing with some of the kids just wasn't Meeting those gaps so water down to be able to get it into the five weeks that we have kids for 20 days just different parts of the AP program just being a

060summer school teacher for 12 for almost I'd say 11 years I'll I I'm going to make an assumption that may be true to Mid lakes and these people can either say yes or no but when you look at students that are seeking Credit Recovery there's there there's a small percentage of students that are right on that edge between passing or failing then there's a healthy percentage of students that have really not made the cut and for those students doing a self-directed program is almost uh it's it's it's it it takes away from the learning and there isn't substantial learning that is truly gained to prepare them for the next course in line so please correct me if I'm wrong so so Apex will still exist for a small percentage of students that need that credit

061that are right on the fence but we're looking at the larger percentage of students that need to go to a regional summer school model to get a more robust comprehensive 5we or 6- we crash course of the entire course again I I have a question and forgive me because I think my brain is a little Frozen from the weather maybe but can you connect the dots for me a little bit more as far as how um folks going to the Ontario County Consortium reduces our need for transportation like like I said it I'm not sure it will reduce our need if we need six bus drivers to do our extended school year special education program I'm hoping that four or fewer bus drivers may be enough to do the secondary summer school Regional program what

062I want to make very clear is there's no in my prediction there will be no other bus drivers that volunteer because even this summer it was pulling teeth and begging people to come work over the summer we won't have more drivers to do any other programming whether it's Elementary runs or any other thing we can't fit that in so my hope is that we stay at 10 or fewer but once again it depends on Logistics it depends on who are these kids going to the regional summer school program whereabouts do they live what time does that program start what time does that program end so I'm trying to keep it within 10 bus drivers or fewer I'll be thrilled if we can do it with nine or eight that being two bus drivers manage the

063entire secondary um secondary shuttle between Midlakes and the regional program so Mike I feel like there there's two things that we talked about programming and transportation so I think that's you know I mean so to be clear the transport like those are working simultaneously but kind of separately so high school have to look at their programming which then also feeds into Transportation so no longer having any transportation for the k6 summer scills and hopes of still maintaining better for kids at the high school level so I just feel like I don't know where we clear about that okay so so the last sentence is what kind of what I was getting at so so I thought I just heard you say no transportation for the K through six program and that's and that's how we're

064going to save as far as busing or at least create equilibrium gotcha okay so a program for kids with the resources we have right you know so so that would be parent drop off and pickup correct yeah was that said earlier because somehow I somehow I missed that part I said we talked about there has understand that programing to then understand like what because I mean at the elementary one of the aps like that's a hard that's a hard hit because we we've seen some success for it but as we you know something has to give with right okay I just that's what I was looking for was the clarity on how we actually reducing the number of buses we we cannot sustain all the program still y something had to give schol is drive

065you let them drive that is not a question that we have answered or asked or answered we would also we would want to check with the hosting District so canadaa would have to weigh in on whether or not they would allow for kids to drive to summer school uh but we haven't we haven't uh gotten that far yet so I'm not sure if they do or right and most of them would be nth and 10th graders too for sure oh this is just kind of a random brainstorming thought is it possible to also partner with districts to like because I know every district is having transportation issues is there a possibility to work together and have like if there's kids that live in neighboring kind of right next to neighboring districts to have that District

066support and make a plan that way or would there be liability in kids being transported by other districts so that that is something that we can look at um we do have agreements to do ride sharing essentially with other districts um with a shortage just last week or the week before we leaned on waterl to get our uh fingerlakes Tech and career center students down uh to the Flint campus so yeah it's something we can look at um I I I don't want to naysay it but it often it doesn't pan out as great as it POS as you would want it to I guess what I'm trying to say yeah yeah we we we use that feature the intermunicipal agreement is used in special education runs because with special education runs there are fewer

067students on the bus so districts are more inclined to say yes to a special Leed run involving one or two students because you can add those to the bus and you don't significantly increase the numbers but when it comes to not knowing how many students you're going to need for a regional program most districts are they don't want to commit and then back out of the deal yeah so how do we how how is it determined um like the cut off yeah we're looking at about a 55 as like I overall course average is from 55 to 64 uh that would be kind of in that tap it in range anything below 55 would be more of the um Regional summer school R attendance during school it could uh you know it certainly could um

068usually two things are connected like how how successful kid is is generally connected how frequently they show up so yes it could be connected um but it it wouldn't necessarily be an exclusion because of an attendance issue I don't really want to speak this into a question like I'm afraid to but if money isn't the restriction is there any incentives for a summer school bus driver financially are offered or is that like a negotiated wage throughout a union type of thing I'm not aware of a lot of bus drivers get their yearly rate so uh bus driver starting salary is 2248 an hour so we have bus drivers making uh 2248 we have some veteran bus drivers making over $40 an hour so bus drivers make their 10-month wage during the year and they're given

069that same exact rate to carry over into the summer um so our lowest bus driver makes about 2248 an hour and um we are when we look at our salaries with the region we are somewhere I'm going to say in the upper half of salaries um but I know that we're not the only District facing this challenge every other district is facing a similar challenge may I take that over when you're done sir thank you all right yes please thank you sir all right folks um I tried to fit this into a PowerPoint presentation and was uh very much unsuccessful in squeezing this data and so I'm going to toggle between several tabs as I try to explain um this long- range financial plan this is the first time I've ever created a longrange financial

070plan there are some forecasting tools um the fr the Frontline company offers this feature of longrange financial planning I had actually you know heard from a rep on uh using this feature and they showed me a very cool feature of what they do behind the scenes in Excel and it came with a price tag of $10,000 so I'm too cheap to to use that so I decided to make one on my own so essentially what a longrange financial plan does is you look at your salaries and expenditures um so I've looked at what kind of money are we bringing in and so if you don't mind this is not on your this is not on your packets this is on the screen um I took our revenue from the 1920 school year to the 2425

071school year so cuz I I wanted to see a 5-year snapshot how much how how much money is coming into the district from 1920 to 2425 and then I looked at our expenditures from 1920 to the 2425 school year I took every single account code so there's about 700 lines of account code and then I broke those up into categories so you've got a category by the way I these future tabs there's something wonderful in in Excel called pivot tables that I taught myself so I used pivot tables to pull all the salary codes from those 700 lines between 1920 and 2526 so there's salary there's equipment there's contractual obligations supplies and tuition textbooks bosies benefits Debt Service and when I take all those tabs and I tally up the sum it has to add

072up to where our current budget is so when I go to the forecast feature of this document every one of those things falls under column B under column B you see our 2425 budget and all those tabs from the Excel document add up to what our current actual school budget is of 46 m429 58 along the way if I take any one of those tabs and I'll look at salaries for example I want to highlight salaries so the pivot table helped me draw every single salary code from those 700 codes the next thing I did is I looked at how have our salaries changed over five years what was a 5-year change in our salaries 5-year change is about 22.2 6% how much we budgeted in our salaries over 5 years is that alarming not

073necessarily because if you think about it typical contracts have changed at about 3% per year typical contracts along the way there are some other contracts that had to change very aggressively as a result of minimum wage compression as a result of bus driver salaries if you look at our current employees Association contract that first year we had to put at least $2 for every person in that contract and so that was almost a 10% change so is it alarming that over five years our salaries the the amount we budgeted changed 22 26% not really over 3 years 16.78% so along the way for every one of these tabs I've also done over five years over three years and over one year what's the change been like does it make sense is there a reason behind

074it or is there absolutely no Rhyme or Reason behind it but chances are there's a reason behind every one of those things so it brings us to the forecast tab because we use that data to try to make some predictions so here are some predictions I've made for the money coming in I made predictions that our real property taxes once again it's just an estimate over the next four years I estimate that maybe our real property taxes are going to go up by 2% our payments in Le of taxes are going to go up by 2% our charges for services will stay flat our use of money and property 3% and as we keep going down the big ones our state aid and Bose's Aid going up at 3% now transfers and balances those are

075our reserves our use of reserves I put it at 5% so I put an increase from the prior year at 5% so do I can I predict the future not necessarily but these are estimates these are conservative or reasonable estimates if you look to the right hand side of this screen one of the things you'll very quickly notice when you look at percentage of budget and I'm going to highlight column I for example because most of the other columns to the right follow the same pattern column I 58.4% counts for state aid or Foundation Aid another 4% counts for Bose's Aid so when I look at the largest parts of what brings money into the district it's state aid Bose's Aid and our rail property taxes or what we Levy in taxes but hopefully that's

076no surprise because you see that year after year at my budget hearing presentations as we forecast the next four years once again those percentages don't change drastically now let's go down here to how much we spend so when we look at how much we spend what what assumptions have I made I've made an assumption that salaries are going to go increase by 4% year-over-year why because right now I'm in the prior presentation I talked to you about a shortage of Transportation Drivers I talked to you about I've also mentioned minimum wage compression we also talk about where our other collective bargaining units are somewhere in the vicinity between three and a half and 4% is where most of our collective bargaining units are so I'm making an assumption that salaries will go up at 4%

077contractual the cost of doing business with various contractors across our campus whether it's contractors associated with Transportation facilities Food Services the cost of doing business is going to go up by 5% textbooks another 5% both Services we are constantly the Partnerships we have with Wayne Finger Lakes bosis we are constantly looking to further those Partnerships but often times there are services such as special education where we don't have the services for a child in the district and we have to look at Wayne Finger Lakes bosies to to help help out with that service and then finally employee benefits at 7% I put down seven even though if I go to the benefits tab you'll see a 5-year change of about 26% in employee benefits we're already predicting a double digigit increase in healthcare um the

078Saving Grace is the standard plan across the district is a high deductible plan the premium may change by 10% but how much we contribute to the health savings account remains at a flat fixed rate so that typically brings down the overall cost slightly so as we look at this here's what we notice and here's where I'm going to minimize the screen and do a quick comparison when I look at the column in blue the 2526 school year my projection for next year a very raw rough projection is that when I compare the money coming in to the money we budget in terms of going out we show a surplus of roughly 307,000 as I continue to forecast that that out one year the following year in 2627 assuming things change at the percentage rate I

079put down we're noticing when you compare the money coming in in 2627 to the money going out end of year negative 452,000 the following year 2728 money coming in money going out negative 1.2 million lastly 28 29 we're at about -2 million now let me also say this I have to say this right here right now this is if we spend every single Dollar in our expenditures a budget is designed to prepare for uncertainty there are certain contingencies we build into a budget but should we spend every single penny of what we budget it's forecasting a negative balance in years two three and four and as you can see it's only further compounded so a longrange financial plan should give you an outlook for the future of what could happen if some of these assumptions

080and estimates come true once again I don't have a crystal ball if I'm right I'm going to go buy a lottery ticket I'm telling you right now but chances are we're always off because we can't predict what's going to happen in two years three years or four years but we can make uh educated guesses of what might happen so how do we avoid being in a tough position in years two three and four as we look at I think the board has seen this document before and I'm going to just zoom on this document a little bit Zoom too far the line in blue goes back to 2009 as a baseline since 2009 the line in blue represents how our staffing is done since 2009 so it starts on the halfway line and then it

081proceeds to go pretty sharply down if everybody can see the line in blue going sharply down between 2009 and 2012 that was around the time what's called The Gap elimination adjustment the 2% property tax cap where several districts laid off folks across the state not just at Midlakes across the state this happened and then in 2012 the enroll the the Staffing started to pick back up between 2012 and 2019 you see an incline but then from 2019 you see a very steep incline between 2019 and about 2023 I will tell you as well that graph looks very similar for districts across the region and many districts across the state anybody want to guess 2019 2020 what happened in our across the globe the co covid-19 P pandemic but also we got Federal stimulus funds not

082not just us 600 other school districts across the state and the theme was spend spend spend so we had to hire staff in certain key areas to support our students so our staffing um grew significantly between 2019 but now let's transition to the Orange Line the Orange Line once again going back to the halfway Baseline since 2009 that's our student student enrollment so the orange line as I look from left to right there's a decline in enrollment between 2009 and 2023 we've gone from well above 2,000 students to right now we're at somewhere between 1484 1482 or 1484 is our current student population so our staffing declined but then grew significantly but our student population has been on a steady decline when we look at the next slide this talks about a live birth data

083the live birth data is something um one of the state agencies conducts this data so essentially here's how it works um for folks that are born in hospitals around our area whether it's Rochester General strong you could be born you know at any Regional hospital or across the state you give your address as to where you were born so they record that as a live birth and then they try to make predictions between children born today and four to 5 years from now how many children will enter upk and kindergarten respectively so that live birth data goes back to once again 2008 but here's what we notice along the way along the way as you look from left to right you start to look at some Kindergarten enrollments of about 120 130 students but as

084you get closer to 22 23 and Beyond you start to look at the numbers hover closer to the low 100s we currently have a fifth grade class that's going into sixth grade that's got 130 students the class after that has 107 and the classes after that have somewhere close to the 90s so what does that look like eight years from now when that class of30 students graduates from Midlakes and most of the classes Left Behind have anywhere between 95 to 100 students some even fewer if you take 13 grades and multiply that by 100 that's 1300 students currently we're at 1484 in eight years my best guess would be we somewhere between 12 to 1300 students based on live birth data provided by New York state so how does that impact a longrange financial plan

085let's look at I'm going to highlight the percentage of our expenditures as we look at our expenditures in the second half of the table as we go back to this document there's something pretty evident about 39% of expenditures come from this line called salaries another 27% come from the line called benefits that should be no surprise we're here for teaching and learning so the bulk of our expenditures are based on staff staff to teach our kids staff to make sure we operate staff to make sure our our kids are transported to school our uh our facility is maintained the way it should um staff to feed our children and staff to educate our children but when you look at Staffing and benefits that makes up any expenditure but our enrollments gone down and our staffing

086has gone up so how do we prevent ourselves from being in a position that maybe these predictors are are suggesting we might be in in terms of being in the red in years two three and four um the way the way is attrition and when staff leave one of the one of the key things we've talked about as an administrative team and none of these folks on our administrative team are surprised by this when staff leave we have now started to have the conversation from this summer do we need to F do we need to backfill this position do we need to go out and hire how critical is this position um because for every instructional staff member and I'm going to be very deliberate about that phrase instruction teaching staff member a rough salary

087on a sta on a on a teacher is about $50,000 if that teacher is on a family health insurance plan that's another $25,000 if you take into account FICA Social Security workers comp that's another $5 to $110,000 so just looking at an instructional position if you don't backfill an instructional position one position can save the district potentially $80,000 or more and as our enrollments dropping that the work we've been doing as a district working with our building administrators and our district administrators to say do we need to backfill this position do we need to go out and post or can we absorb this position based on our current enrollment and those those are the ways we we we want to do this with dignity we don't want to be a district and I know this

088District over the past 25 years there's been at least two events that I can tell one in 2012 and one in the early 2000s where we've had to lay off a significant number of employees so if we can start taking these steps right now we put potentially I'm not guaranteeing this by the way we potentially avoid us being in that position for a third time in since the 2000s so that's that's the purpose of a long-range financial plan I will also say this once again this is forecasting the future this is also a worst case scenario you plan for bad times so that you can so that so that if you take the steps you avoid being in that position so a long range fin this this plan was not meant to tell you everything's

089roses this plan's meant to tell you that we are going to take some steps as a district to avoid being in this position in the future so I'm going to stop rambling and just I I want to see if you folks have any questions for us sorry this was not meant to be light-hearted no so I think it's important to recognize Carl's job is to give us the worst case scenario right which provides us with an anchor point to make sure that we're asking critical questions about our budget about how we're staffed um because if we turn a blind eye to what something could be and don't focus on it and try to avoid that scenario then I don't believe we're doing our job properly um so you know attrition is in in my opinion

090right I think about it is uh folks retiring right um being able to to ride off into the retirement sunset with their pension and then us us sitting back and asking that question how many students do we have at that grade level how many students do we have in that building what would our overall class size be if we choose not to fill this position and if those class sizes fit within the level of service that we feel is necessary for our community um then we don't need to fill that position if it's another position um where it's the only teacher we have in that certification area well it's a different conversation right so we just have to evaluate each opportunity to manage our budget uh in the way that makes the most sense um

091in order to avoid those events that happened back in 2012 which I know there's folks in the room that experience that um I have a personal connection um to economic decline back in 201122 when my wife was laid off so I know what that's like um so it's important to avoid that scenario for our families um and provide the same level of service that we can to the community so that's that's how I put the rose-colored glasses on your uh long range financial plan any questions or comments I'll say this again this is not do Gloom this is this is let the data let the data help you make informed decision right but once again we want to know how bad things could be right because if we don't know how bad things could could

092be we're going to delay making some decisions that we should be making right now and I can tell you right now in my work in just this this year's budget development with with the two building principles they're they're on board there's no there's no question the data doesn't lie so so both of them you're going to see some retirements that the board is approving but you're going to you might you may not see all those positions reposted and that's what's going to that's what's going to change and we're we're doing it slowly over time so the steps are already being taken I appreciate the time and energy and knowledge that you put into this and yeah presenting it to us in a way that I think for me at least is easily understandable hopefully thank

093you hopefully everyone yeah thanks Carl what just quick question what is the jump from 19 to 24 do you know how many proximate head count that is um I don't I know there were quite a few hirings I came along in about 20 I came along in November 2021 and uh I know that at that time through one of the federal grants I was already managing at least eight or 10 different folks salaries at that time because we had haded pupil support staff whether it's counselor school psychologists AIS providers reading teachers so there were there were significant um there was a significant increase in hiring but I just remember having to manage those grants at that time so I can't give you a specific number but um once again pretty steep increase in that graph

094um the the other piece I'll add to this um this is just the presentation I'm going to I'm going to put a write up along with this because like I said I've rambled quite a bit the goal is to digest it at this board meeting by the next board meeting I'd like the board to approve a long-range financial plan because should a comproller the com trollers have started to say that this is a best practice for a district there's two best prti practices that are not mandated one is a reserve plan that the board approved in the fall the second is a long-range financial plan just so that we can make informed decisions for the future if we finish every year under budget we're still going to save money the goal is not to spend

095every penny the goal is to finish under budget because we have these things called reserves and we have to fuel those reserves because we need to continue buying buses for the future every 5 years we want to continue Capital Improvement projects to continue to maintain this beautiful campus so we want to finish under budget so once again that's also part of the conversation anything else all right thank you Carl thank you everybody so are you you're saying we would be looking to approve at our at our February meeting we'd be looking to approve a long range financial plan that is correct okay all the data you see today will be part of that along with just a written summary so essentially it will look like a Word document that the board can approve and we're

096going to post it to the district website under the business office part of the web page okay yep all right much like the reserve plan and our audited financial statements right look forward to see that okay Mr ginster superintendent's report all right I'm gonna like always do my best to keep this brief because I also have uh a policy presentation during our um during during another section of the agenda so um real quick uh emergency pool project over the uh holiday break the old dehumidification unit was removed from the top of the pool the new one was set in place uh all of the plumbing and HVAC necessary to tie it in was complete and the unit is now operating um and dehumidifying our pool so that's excellent that we've um gotten through that first

097phase of the emergency pool project um we are going to begin draining the pool the week before President's Day uh or February uh vacation and it will remain closed for pretty much the entire rest of the school year um it will be drained there will be a full resurfacing um of the mar site which is a specific kind of concrete that is that floor and lining of the pool we will get a full um reconfiguration and modernization of the filtration system there's going to be a pool cover added over the top which further reduces evaporation and maintains warmth for the pool so it will be more um uh sustainable in the way of energy conservation and in addition to that we're going to have new HVAC controls to better regulate the water and air temperature

098in the space so the the project is is coming into shape it's it's you know it's an emergency project for a necessary piece of infrastructure but we did it the right way and it's going to be beautifully updated and um I'll let you know on when we can actually do a some kind of ribbon cutting uh for the opening of the pool because it'll be nice to to reopen it um and I'll just keep you posted throughout the uh winter here so we do have one midyear retiree um this person um decided to retire uh her last day is January 25th it's um Katie Herman she is a fax teacher currently at the Middle High School um I didn't want to let the meeting go by without acknowledging her um but we will invite her

099back for our traditional June retiree recognition and celebration at our June board meeting um but I just couldn't let the moment pass without at least acknowledging that um she is retiring midy year um another um upgrade here in the district is uh we have replaced a an aging and increasingly unsafe bus washing system down at the bus garage um our our drivers and mechanics actually have to walk this giant brush around the entire bus and um the wheels of the old one weren't functioning properly so it wasn't getting used as much as it should nor was it uh as safe as it should be so we did um replace that unit and uh throughout the installation process um the the old bus wash in addition to a few mechanical larger tools like a um a

100wheel balancing machine and a couple other larger mechanic tools were identified as Surplus um that no longer get used all four of those items uh there's three or four items on tonight's agenda that came um from that bus wash replacement uh they're on the agenda for Surplus tonight and and they either will be or have been posted to auctions direct to try to recoup some of that value all right let's see here um today we had our third instructional council meeting um there are 35 members of The District's instructional Council those are our grade level and Department uh teacher leadership in addition to some counselors and psychologists as well as our administrative team um we had an hour and a half meeting and the the intent of this year uh for instructional council is twofold

101it's first to create a maintain a a main maintain and sustain a focus on our District's uh 3 through eight and Regents exam data and make sure that we're continuing growth with those metrics in order to work ourselves off of any of the state lists there are various um designations based on subgroup um I won't go into all of that now you've seen Jeff's presentations um but uh sustained focus on bettering that data for and and outcomes for our students and families and also um taking a minute to learn and reflect on leadership here in the district both at the administrative level but also at that critical teacher leadership level so we spent some time with that today we'll have one more meeting we have four a year with the entire group and I look

102forward to continuing that process um next school year we have on tonight's agenda um a one-time commencement award that will be awarded um this June during commencement and I wanted to make sure that I gave this the respect that it deserves so um Rose copper brown mother of uh Katherine Ingraham which is her married name her maiden name was uh Katherine copper brown she's a class of 2009 she passed away um in February of 2022 so uh the copper Browns established a onetime uh scholarship uh entitled Katherine's compassion scholarship and the descript is uh it's given to a student going into a field um reflecting compassion of people cathine was a case worker and counselor in the fingerlakes area she had a talent for uplifting people and getting them to recognize their own worth and

103strength she was an advocate for her clients so the great that kind of encapsulates who she was as a human being um and the award is going to go to a student uh who has not had excellent grades however is going into a career of compassion this may include Clinical Psychology counseling social work etc um and the person must be per uh pursuing a two or four year or a trade school uh as appropriate so we look forward to being able to accept this award tonight and then be able to award it uh to a member of the class of 2025 uh finally we have uh a small Scoreboard on the agenda tonight donated by the PTO uh and that is specifically uh to be used by our athletic department when we have a competition

104somewhere on campus where we don't have a scoreboard for folks to uh to refer to so um those are my updates for tonight any questions on any of the uh items that I updated you on tonight yeah a little bit lighter than the financial plan Carl thank you yeah you're welcome as to how we want to determine who the student is um so this is a uh student rep that will give reports to the board um student must have attended our Midlakes High School for at least one year prior to the selection um there's a suggestion that we consult student leaders and poll members of the student body um maybe to to determine how or where that student comes from how we determine who that student is um the revised law lists six ways that

105a student can be selected so we have some leeway some room to figure out how we want to select them but we also have to follow these it has to follow in accordance with the um the law and there will be a of course a policy coming soon too that will reflect the law and our procedures so um so one of the six ways um student has that has been duly elected as student president of the high school so I don't think we really have a president of high school we have a student council president correct and then there's like a president for each class right okay um so potentially like a a president at the student council um a student duly elected by the student body so this could be someone who's just elected

106as the student board rep um not necessarily offic you know officially um part of student council or a student government Association um it could be a student that's selected by the high school student government so potentially the student council could select um a person that's either on or not on student government student council um number four a student selected by the high school principal so it could be the sole responsibility of the high school principal to select a student um a student selected by the superintendent of schools so Mr Ganer could be um the sole uh selector um or a student selected by the majority vote of the school board now I think ultimately it seems like well I guess maybe not I was going to say it seems like we would have some say

107in that anyway and we would probably vote on the student but maybe not like if if I guess if the student body selected someone we would accept them without having to vote on them so so lots of lots of ideas out there I don't know if anybody has some ideas on or thoughts about where they think um how we want to go about the selection has to be by July so we do have to have a way to um determine this student so they can start with this in July um the part of the intent of the legislation is to give more students an opportunity to be involved right so we may want to consider having a student that's not part of student government and not part of the um student body uh Student Government

108I guess um and and then there's like thoughts about well if if that one student is not available to attend a meeting how do we determine who the replacement would be so do we pick two students one knowing that they're they're like the backup um and then yeah so there's lot lots of things to consider Mike thoughts so I don't have strong feelings one way or the other I'll start by saying that um and I'd be flexible with whatever the board decides but I do kind of feel like um we' remove some of the subjectivity out of it if it was just an automatic that it was the student body president to me that seems like a simple um way to just make that decision without having a lot of question marks thrown in any

109Direction Why did we choose that one over that one you know who put forth these name this you know I I can I can see it getting a little muddy MH um but again I I'll go along with whatever the majority thinks we should do I mean on the other side of that I think it would be good to have someone who's not involved um in all these other things too because a lot of times the student council president is also involved in sports and and I don't want to overwhelm them or or get them get their load so um so much that that that it gets to be too much for them either I I hear that but I do think it should be somebody who has a kind of you know has a

110clear understanding of what's going on in the school that has their you know they their finger on the pulse kind of thing should be somebody who's invested in informed about things that might be brought to the board and one of my thoughts um was to if it is somebody who's not part of student government maybe they attend um maybe part of their responsibility is to attend the student council meeting every so often so that they have a pulse on what is going on um from that end and they bring that to us I mean I think that could be um worked into the plan Lynn do you have yeah I was just thinking I I do like the idea of having it you having the possibility um out there for it to be someone maybe

111who isn't a a president of the student council currently but I also wondered is it possible if if we do have kind of that scenario where we do have multiple students interested um Can it can it be broken up by quarter or does it have to be the same student the entire year do we know like I feel like something that I read along the way was that they had to it had to be a one-year term a your term okay um we might have more details on that when the policy okay um stuff comes out um nisba is supposed to be issuing a sample policy here soon um but I I feel like it had to be like a one-year commitment okay I think inclusion is a great reason to have somebody but I

112also think there should be some functionality to it um have it you know it needs to be purposeful right yeah right yeah Lindsay do you have any thoughts or well you have to make sure the kids are like a child that would be part of the board is interested as well so why not put something out there for students to fill out some type of application you have to apply for everything else you you know want to become part of and then I think that we don't know these kids right so I think it would make the most sense for the high school staff to decide or the student body or the student body somebody I don't know that we should be the deciding factor right yeah I mean a lot of us have kids

113in this district and I don't think that would be fair either right to be part of the voting process Matt do you have any thoughts yeah I I I agree with what everyone's kind of chimed in from the board so far I think it part of the process to get to that point is is should mirror somewhat how all board members are elected right so they should have the opportunity to um put out their bias and maybe get endorsements from people who know them better but definitely um you know maybe keep the board out of choosing people that you know that one stipulation that you read off I I don't think that we should necessarily choose like Lindy said yeah I don't I don't really have any have any strong desire to be the ones

114to I mean maybe in a smaller District or I don't know there might be some districts that have that that would feel better about doing that but yeah not not totally keen on that idea myself I do like the idea of having them follow kind of a similar process as board members get elected to I mean that's kind of a kind of a cool idea they could you know get 15 signatures from uh their classmates and and so that's that's it would get you know the more it would and I hate to say this it weed out it would get the people who want to be engaged in this right it would you know make them have skin in the game so to speak lack of a better term 11 and I think there's something

115yeah I'm pretty sure there's something in there in that I read too that has to be 11th or 12th grade student so we're looking at you know I think that's the other piece is making sure that whatever process we determine is sustainable is is replicable year after year um so okay any other thoughts we'll continue this discussion as we as we move along I'm there's some things from for County um some districts already have student reps and they um have shared how they um how they get how they've selected the student reps have been selected um and I'm sure as everyone is trying to figure out what the best thing is for their District I'm sure a lot of ideas will continue to be shared at 4 County so um as I hear those things

116I'll certainly bring them back all right thank you um and on to committee reports legislative committee is coming up soon right they canceled this month so in February so and it's yeah the first no third second second second Saturday can't keep track of all those second Saturday okay so we'll hear from legislative committee then um policy committee we keep chipping away um we'll hear more from Nick um about that and I don't think there have been any other um committees since our last meeting um the other only other piece I have is Nick and I attended the legislative breakfast on Thursday morning um it was an interesting way just to kind of um for us to for us as a region I think and as as a bosis to promote to our legislators what we

117do and why it's so important um there was there was um music by I think it was sodas right sodas Coral group um and there were uh two students from um fltcc or Wayne Tech and career center I'm not sure which anyway one of the tech and Career Centers I'm not sure which one it was um that presented as well and um so there's a lot of representation I think from the from the area as far as students and um yeah and why why what we're doing is so important to provide funding for essentially so um there is a 4 County General membership meeting coming up um I think everybody's got a flyer for um for Thursday February 6th um so let Pam know if you'd like to attend um I encourage you especially if

118you haven't been to one of these meetings yet this year um try to make it to one um this one is going to be a good one I think I mean they've all been great this year but um it's all all about the regionalization conversation that's happening so um some local superintendant speaking anybody else have anything for board discussion tonight okay on to public comment so the Phelps Clifton Springs School District Board of Education invites public comment at this time to those who have signed up in advance with the district clerk please limit your comments to two minutes or less written remarks may be provided to the board if time expires before a speaker completes their remarks we ask individuals to State their name prior to comments and to provide the district clerk with their

119contact information for purposes of follow-up although the board will not respond directly to individual comments at this time items brought to the attention of the board may be taken under consideration for future response action or followup with the speaker issues related to specific District students whether positive negative or neutral must be brought to the attention of the superintendent of schools privately in order to safeguard student privacy the board reserves the right to terminate a speaker's comments if their comments are in excess of 2 minutes are repetitive or are not appropriate for discussion in an open public forum all visitors are reminded to abide by the district code of conduct and to be respectful and courteous both as speakers and as audience members we are a community focused on bettering public education for our students some

120of whom may be present thank you none okay no public comments all right on to new business um if there are no objections I would like to block items A and B this contracts and agreements and the resolution for Rick one risk operations center Roc this is lots of letters in this one um can I get a motion to approve items A and B as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of items A and B as presented say I I all those opposed motion carried item C the policy manual modifications Mr Sir we're going to start by taking a quick trip down memory lane um so our section five ,000 um will be done by our next meeting so that's our first big chunk from our policy

121committee um so here's where you know by the Numbers 65 policies in total in this section 44 policies in the draft manual are identical to our existing manual so no action required on those policies and 22 policies have differences in comparison to our current manual and require us to go through through the process of a first read second read and adoption so remember this section includes budget income expenditures purchasing fiscal accounting and Reporting non-instructional operations and transportation so far we've reviewed uh the 44 policies a couple months ago we reviewed them uh the ones that were identical to our existing manual we at our last meeting we retired three policies that we no longer require um and we conducted a first read on 17 of the remaining 19 policies that have differences in comparison to

122our current manual so um those are our retirements corporate sponsorships transportations and child safety zones and vending machines that happened at our last meeting so for tonight what we're going to do is we're going to conduct a second read on um 17 policies and we're going to do a really close look at again the ones that required heavy modification which were the wellness policy um and our policy for privacy and security for student data and teacher and principal data so after we do that second read we're also adopting those 17 policies and then we're going to conduct a first read on our last two policies in this section the first one is uh 560 which is meal charging and prohibition against meal shaming and policy 5231 gifts uh recognition and naming of facilities all right

123so these are our second reads these ones uh for all intents and purposes carry the same uh outcome as our current policy manual but had minor upgrades or minor tweaks in specific words that were used however there aren't any real changes in uh in terms of impact to how we do business or impact to uh how we operate in the district so those are all right there um board members had these in hand for a number of weeks uh with an opportunity uh to review and ask any questions so I would right now just pause and and see do any board members have any questions on any of these specific policies U before we move forward okay all right so for tonight um we're going to take a look at these three policies that require

124a more significant review so we'll start with our wellness policy so um the new policy has the athletic director assigned for oversight um our athletic director assigned for what is called a triennial assessment every three years we have to conduct an assessment of how well we're implementing our wellness policy so U the athletic director was um listed there um the updated policy cites the USDA smart snack in school as a standard um and that standard is used to maintain limits on Foods available to students during school um including lunch fundraisers and classroom parties as well as vending machines and we went through those in in more detail during our first read um and nothing has changed since then uh the new policy prohibits the sale of energy drinks on campus for any reason whether that's

125um uh within a uh vending machine or within a fundraiser of some sort just we're not on board with energy drinks uh and then finally um requires the USD smart snack foods uh be available after school hours whenever other foods are being sold so in another Ward having some healthy options during concessions at athletic events is really what that distills down into um any questions on the updates of our wellness policy okay so the second um large overhaul was our privacy and security for uh student data and teacher um and principal data that's policy 5676 so this policy is structured at the new recommend policy uh from Erie 1 um it establishes the nist framework or the National Institute for standards and Technology um as a framework as our standard for maintaining network security so

126anytime we're wondering if our network is secure we're going to um consult the most Uh current version of the nist framework to uh start answering those questions um it establishes that District practices will be compliant with Ed law 2D um establishes how uh data collection and with transparency and restrictions establishes our District's data protection officers uh establishes District uh data privacy and security standards including formal relationships um with thirdparty service providers both private and public now coincidentally um there you approved right at the beginning of our new business section you approved um an agreement with Rick one and um essentially what that allows us to do is it allows us to lean on a Bosey service to UM Vet and ensure that our data privacy agreements with thirdparty vendors um meet the level of criteria

127established in Ed law 2D so here we are updating this policy and also making moves to ensure that it's implemented properly um and efficiently for um those who are in charge in the district for reviewing those um provides a tool to make that job easier um the policy also establishes a parent Bill of Rights for data privacy and security establishes a process for reporting investigating and notifying uh of an unauthorized release of private data or a breach of our Network establishes related training for staff uh on data privacy and network security and uh this policy really is is rooted in both regulation and law um so having it in place uh ensures that we are um following those law laws and regulations appropriately okay so that concludes our second reads so any questions on any

128of that because later on in tonight's agenda you'll be actually adopting those policies okay so now we're backtracking and now we're going to have a first read on two our last two policies in the 5000 section um the first one this one um meal charging and prohibition against meal shaming This falls in that bucket of minor changes in language and no change of intent compared to current policy uh the reason this one is a little uh late to the the policy approval process is because there was a moment where we were considering not adopting this policy because um we qualify and utilize a community eligibility provision to supply uh free meals or we are reimbursed for the the meals that we provide uh to all of the students here in the district however uh given

129the outside chance that uh in the future if we were not able to qualify for Community eligibility provision um we would have this um as a backup because at this point really the spirit of this um policy is it outlines criteria for um keeping track and communicating with parents if a student begins to owe our um Food Service uh Department money because they haven't been paying for their lunches but we're also not going to deny those lunches to those students right and then in addition to that um outlines um how we will minimize distress for those students who are leveraging um a free or reduced meal process by um using a digital service that allows um those students to basically hide in plain sight um and that's probably the easiest way that I can paraphrase

130it but all of the um specifics when we'll communicate how many days how many meals have to be charged prior to us reaching out to the parents are identical to our current policy So This falls in that that minor upgrade um bucket of policies and then our last one uh took a little bit more time but um not extensive so our our policy on gifts recognitions and naming of facilities um are the the new policy will just have a couple minor tweak so first our current policy does not reference um the mid lak's response to tragedy and crisis manual which is the manual that we use to follow all things involved with trauma illness and grief um and within that manual uh it includes an application to commemorate uh a student or staff member who

131who may have passed away um while here so our current policy does not reference that um and the updated policy does reference the um response to tragedy and crisis manual um the current policy permits the use of plaques um as a memorial however um contemporary practice with trauma illness and grief really urges districts to not allow plaques to be um placed around schools especially for those who have passed away and and it seem it can seem a little cold um but when we think about these things um school is a place for students to come and in a lot of ways we want our students to be able to enjoy school as innocently as possible and we what we want to do is we want to avoid having our hallways turn into memorials for the

132loss of life right so it helps our students stay centered on what's the original intent of school um so the new policy actually removes the language surrounding uh using plaques as memorials for those have passed away and that's consistent with the response tragedy uh manual so any questions in terms of this policy here okay so the um gifts recognition and naming and the um meal shaming policy or charging and prohibition against meal shaming are up for a first read um which will be up for approval in a moment so we're finishing the 5000s but we're going to start the 7000s which the policy committee is underway uh extensively actually we've done a fair amount of work including um a full work day over the summer with our admin team um that policy section has 79

133policies 54 are identical to our current manual 25 policies have differences 10 of those actually require significant review so it's going to take us some some time um and I'll be as efficient as I possibly can when we do this but 10 of them are going to require us you know me to really highlight the changes because we need to make sure that the board and the the public are informed of what's in that policy manual before um they're finally adopted so uh it'll take us you know the better part of the next few meetings to accomplish that but um the 5,000 in 7, thousands collectively are two of the biggest chunks of our policy manual so hopefully after that point we can begin to really uh uh you know update these sections quickly um

134and efficiently so we can get the entire manual uh updated all right so that does it for policy if there are any questions let me know but it's okay if there aren't and if not we can move up good so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of it I yeah sorry um so item D amended annualized hours for 2425 uh is there a motion to approve item D is presented so moved second thank you any discussion all those in favor of item D say I I I all those opposed motion carried all right if there are no objections I'd like to uh block items e f and g establishment of the scholarship that uh Mr ganster mentioned earlier um donation and uh of the portable scoreboard and the Midlakes

135fundraisers can I get a motion to approve items e f and g as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion I would just like to say I'm so excited for this scoreboard cuz the modified baseball games we were like we have no idea what the score is so I'm I'm excited for that um all right all those in favor of items e through G as presented say I I I all of is opposed motion carried and item H uh items for disposal is there a motion to approve the attached list of items to be auctioned that are ABS obsolete Surplus or unusable by the district so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of item H as presented say I I I all those opposed motion carried

136all right on to Personnel uh if there are no objections I'd like to block items a through C so appointments substitute appointments and mentors is there a motion to approve items a through c as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of items a through through c as presented say I I I all those opposed motion carried um item D unpaid leave is there a motion to approve the unpaid leave requests as presented so moved any dis uh oh is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of item D unpaid leave as presented say I I I all those opposed motion carried and if there are no objections I'd like to block item it e through G so retirement irrevocable intent to retire and resignations

137is there a motion to approve items e through G as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of items e through G as presented say I I I all those opposed motion carried and on to adjournment is there a motion to adjourn the regular board meeting to enter into executive session to discuss the employment promotion or demotion of a particular person and current litigation updates motion to adjourn is there a second a second any discussion no all those in favor of adjournment say I I all those opposed motion carried thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.