CorpusRecord 235823

BOE Meeting 12/16/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Midlakes Schools
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Ontario County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,971 words · about 45 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] I would like to call to order the December 16th regular meeting of the Board of Education of the Phelps Clifton Springs School District Pam would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all the Phelps Clifton Springs Central School District Board of Education meets to publicly conduct its business in accordance with the law the public is invited to observe these proceedings but is not entitled to respond or disrupt them especially when such disturbances run counter to the district's code of conduct and the welcoming Spirit of our district the public is reminded of the context of board meetings board members are volunteers audience members are

002visitors to school grounds and student and staff well-being is at the heart of board operations visitors are reminded of the courage it takes to speak up as members of our community and the importance of encouraging Civic and civil engagement the board strives to hear all Community Voices during its public meetings in a safe respectful and orderly manner the behavior that we expect of all students in our classrooms is also expected from visitors at board meetings in an effort to ensure that community members concerns are heard the board reminds speakers to address the board in a civil manner refrain from discussing specific Personnel or students limit outbursts and limit unnecessary noise the board encourages an atmosphere of respect and tolerance and strict adherence to its code of conduct roll call Lynn liebre board member lindsy Marino

003board member Mike door board member Heather Rockefeller board member Deb Galler board member Matt Goodman board member Carl dush business administrator Nick ganster superintendent Tracy Elman board member Pamela Man district clerk okay I um wondering if I can get a motion to amend the agenda to add an adjournment to Executive session so move is there a second second any discussion all those in favor say I I I all those opposed motion carried all right so on to approval of the agenda can I get a um motion to approve the amended agenda so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of the amended agenda say I I all of those opposed motion carried can I get a motion to adjourn to Executive session for the purpose of entering into uh to

004discuss matters pertaining to the employment of a particular person so moved is there second second any discussion all those in favor say I I I all those opposed motion carried we will be right back e e e I would like to call the meeting back to order we are um get to the right spot here consent agenda can I get a motion to approve the consent agenda items as presented so move is there a second second any discussion all those in favor say I I I all those opposed motion carried and on to presentations so the fall athletic recognition Mr Lombardi yeah are we good is it on okay all right uh good evening thank you for having us here tonight to recognize some of our fall athletes I want to thank the Board of

005Education and superintendant ganster for supporting all of our 24 fall modified JV and Varsity Sports this year um in the fall we had 352 student athletes participating in grades 7 through 12 in our athletic activities um out of the those 352 just over 125 of them competed at the varsity level we had 35 athletes receive all League recognition additionally our very own Aiden Bryant earned first team allg grader Rochester All-Star honors this year um we also had 62 individual scholar athletes and seven scholar athlete teams um the teams were boys volleyball girls volleyball game day cheer girls soccer girls tennis girls swimming um girls cross country um and I said and girls swimming and Diving um we're incredibly proud of all who participated in athletics and represented our community so well um I did have

006a slideshow but if not that's okay okay no worries not a big deal we can we can I didn't I just wanted to make sure but that's fine um uh first up we would just let we also have some of our individual Award winners and um some special honors we like to honor tonight um first up we would like to recognize Kaden DeMarco um Kaden come on up so everybody can see you uh Kaden was named fingerlakes golfer of the year for the fingerlakes he was just one stroke away from winning a league title um he's already qualified for sectionals this coming spring um Kaden's been a leader on the team and he's a Ste a steady player on the course and we're excited to see what he can achieve moving forward yeah [Applause] next

007we would like to recognize our 2024 Class B sectional Champions coached by Kyle Salsbury and Josh Delgado um the players that were on Varsity this season were Declan Reed if if you're here at least stand up so you can be seen or even come on up braxon wils Liam Killian Decker Jesse Bennett Aiden Bryant Teddy Altman joah Bennett and Toren Lane coach saly can you help me hand these certificates out okay thank you this year's team finished the season with a 14-10 record playing a challenging schedule they capped off this year's season with a win over the School of Arts in the class B2 sectional Championship Braxton wils and Jake Decker were named to the all tournament team and Aiden Bryan earned um tournament MVP honors um this team made many of the victories look

008effortlessly I swear sometimes I thought they were cheating out there because of how crazy it was out there and how quick they took advantage of their opponents um but we couldn't be more um proud of their accomplishments so congratulations [Applause] I you the ctif Y the old switcher room thank you uh now we would like to honor Thea Lewis Thea come on up this year she received the Roger Medway award from the fingerlakes coach association um this prestigious award is awarded to a student athlete who shows leadership and sportsmanship and stands out to coaches across the leag um Thea was uh first Midlakes tennis player to ever receive this award and this recognition um as a senior leader she Thea played both singles and doubles to help her team find success this season um and

009we just congratulate theia on this well-deserved honor conratulations and then finally could I have Coach Dave Wickham come on up [Applause] this year coach Wickham reached a remarkable Milestone finishing the season with 230 career career wins in section five this achievement placed him at the very top of the mountain with the most wins in section five history and it's truly an outstanding accomplishment uh on a personal note I want to say how grateful I am to have known Dave for so long when I first started coaching football here at Midlakes we had joint practices with Geneva and pal Mech and I remember soaking up as much knowledge as I possibly could as a young coach I remember trying to purposely fin angle my way to some of the stations that he was coaching so that

010I could better take some of that stuff back steal it and um bring it back to my young athletes that I was coaching I recall seeing Dave many countless Sunday mornings at St Dominic's church and just the envy him like knowing that he was on his way to do some film breakdown and I just you know I envy the time and effort he had put in um for that fast forward to today I'm currently in the current role as athletic director I feel fortunate enough to have Dame answer my phone call when I asked him to return if he wanted to coach back at Midlakes again and be here for our student athletes as a district we are incredibly lucky to have someone like Dave leading our teams I was equally fortunate enough to have

011his presidence presence in the building regularly um when I face challenges that I've never seen before I could bounce ideas off of somebody who had Decades of experience I cannot speak highly enough of Dave's work ethic character and Leadership and I have nothing but the most respect and admiration for this man congratulations Dave on this Monumental achievement and you truly deserve it um thank you for everything you've done would the board like to ask any questions of anybody that we have recognized tonight I know we usually zip through this but I if you want to have any opportunity to ask the kids will you have them in front of you please feel free to do so not trying to put you on the spot or anything but or do you guys as students have anything

012you want to say probably went in sectional for the second year yeah anybody else have a favorite memory that they'd like to share of their uh very accomplished uh thank you thank you very much thanks Mr lardi thank you all right on to Elementary National Honor Society Mrs Bradley and Mrs Elman do you guys here reason yeah is I don't know what yeah if you're going to speak yes that would be the place with our nhhs pledge ready and count of as a member of the national Elementary Honor Society I pledge to be a strong student achieving the most from my education demonstrate responsibility showing enthusiasm and working hard in all that I do learn the skills of leadership practicing them in all aspects of my life be of service to my school and Community

013showing that I care and be a role model for my peers helping us all achieve our best Heather and I have had the pleasure over many years to work with the cream of the crap out here in the middle of the corn fields at Midlakes the national Elementary Honor Society is usually comprised of fifth and sixth graders which leads us to some great news so we had so many incoming fifth graders who were nominated that we made the decision to only include sixth graders this year and we still have 32 members which is great 32 sixth graders clearly we have many leaders who exemplify the core values at Mees and just like our Midlakes core values NS has four pillars that we stand for which includes scholarship service responsibility and Leadership um last year we

014presented the details of many servage projects elfing stuffy grams pencil Pals and real life for life this year we want to focus on the impact of our students service and to their school and Community as well as they recognize the con contributes of students in particular studies show that we have an anxious generation of children going through school systems all over the country as nhh sers we have the opportunity to P practice public speaking with uh which is an essential skill for college career and Readiness our annual induction ceremony at our High School auditorium in November each NH NHS member presented a short biography of an incoming sixth grader this past weekend members personally thanked our local businesses in Phelps and Clifton Springs and presented them with a card and candy in June Mrs Alman

015and Miss Bradley took on new roles in the really for life of the fingerlakes by being part of of the leadership team which means we any Hesters have more responsibilities as well with Mrs a being in charge of the games and NHS members recruiting participants we had the best participation of adults and children in years we also had the largest fundraising year with our Midlakes NHS team collecting over $119,000 for the American Cancer Society the am highest amount raised by any team at last year's event Miss Bradley reles the troops by joining with the mees student council to supply canned goods to weigh down hundreds of luminary bags which are later donated to local food banks nhh sers then set up and take down all the bags transport the can goods to cars and switch

016on and off the candles which light them on the first Saturday in June nhs's will be in charge of the entire luminary ceremony at the Relay for Life of Finger Lakes please come and support the cause and see Mid Lake students in action don't worry we will remind you as part of the leadership team Heather and I attended the relay kickoff last March which was unfortunately underwhelming there was a lack of community involvement and it all seemed very scripted this year we will be appealing to the board to empower and support us by allowing the Midlakes NHS to host the kickoff right here in the elementary school with some family games homemade appetizers with recipes from our society members yes you're doing that and more publicity we hope to involve more of our fingerlakes community

017members resulting in more participation at our June event so above in beyond our core pillars is the connectedness that our students are awarded through their service to others they thrive on bringing joy to others and being leaders in our community and they continue to impress us year after year he can read the last page but this is kind of a surprise to these two right now we would like to recognize Sam Bishop this is Sammy right here come on up Sammy Samy uses his connection to the Phelps American Legion to make and sell cookies for a dollar a piece his mom's in the audience too so um having raised over ,000 already this relay season yes he and his mom have baked over a, cookies already this school year last year Sam raised himself $2,300

018for our relay team and inspired by Samy's efforts our friend James Stratton here organized a fundraiser this past Thanksgiving at a local school trk earning $500 for our team and what makes these efforts so impressive is the demonstration of our Midlakes core value of Independence these gentlemen had their own ideas pursued them and are crushing goals on their own time and we would all like to say that we are so proud we are so proud of all of our 32 nhhs members and all the great things that they do and thank you and happy holidays thank [Applause] you thank you for being so inspiring um get hang like yeah yeah it's awesome to be inspired and inspiring all right we're going to take a brief break to enjoy some um treats over there you've been

019eyeing up the cookies HH so guests help yourself e e e like a giant real estate lawyer essentially all right let we come back together it looks like our uh guests are moving been on so all right so on to reports our superintendence report Mr ganster okay uh I have a number of things to talk about tonight um so I'll do my normal update we have several policies to go over and I'm going to put the policy update in the agenda where the the policies are going to be so then I'll I'll start like a second presentation then if that's okay um all right so the first on my update uh list is recently the foundation Aid formula study by the Rockefeller Institute was released Statewide um I was fortunate enough to go to a

020professional development session last Friday uh over at Wayne Finger Lakes bosies where a handful of folks um were present to kind of give an overarching explanation of that study so uh the folks who were present we had um Brian fesler who is a lobbyist for the New York State Schoolboard Association he was in the room uh Julie Marlet who is a uh a lawyer from Hinman stra who uh works with the superintendents in the Wayne Finger Lakes bosies to provide advocacy at the state level for things that impact our region and also um a retired Capital Region Bose's district superintendent by the name of Anita Murphy uh she's recently retired but those three were available just to present their thoughts on the Rockefeller institute's study on Foundation Aid so I just wanted to give a

021quick overview of of the study so the first thing that um that the presenter said is pay attention to the literature review the so it's a 314 page document um the literature review pretty much outlines uh the various different approaches that certain States across the country uh use in order to provide funding from the state level to District school districts in their state so uh their advice was to to dig into that a little bit and we might be able to get some Clues as to the direction that uh Foundation Aid could be heading um secondly um they they said that the recommendation section is just that these are just recommendations that uh the Rockefeller Institute presented and you know in my brief reading of the study they are uh they they don't appear to

022have much of a political agenda if I could put it that way because there are certain suggestions or recommendations that would support one school of thought and there are others that support a completely different school of thought uh politically speaking um so the caution there is is um they believe that our legislators will begin to pick and choose certain recommendations that might be advantageous to uh whatever their political agendas are um throughout the spring so they advocated for us uh as superintendent to get to know some of those recommendations and really pay attention to which recommendations our local uh legislators are grabbing on to and think about how that could either positively or negatively impact our region and our individual districts uh with that being said because these are just recommendations none of them are

023actually binding for the legislature or the governor they are simply recommendations so what that means is is as we move into budget season uh next time we meet it it'll be 2025 and we'll be going full steam ahead uh talking about the 2526 budget uh the normal sort of song and dance at Alban is going to play out the governor will put out her executive budget sometime in January that will then be received by the legislature the the two houses of the legislature will then pick that apart and begin to Advocate uh for C in increases and decreases across all of the lines uh of the entire state budget not just school funding so we will have to wait patiently Carl I'm sure will do his homework from a budgetary perspective on on what can

024be anticipated uh with Foundation aid but we don't expect there to be a huge change in how Foundation Aid is actually um doed out with the exception um of it's very possible that um be well let me backtrack our governor did come out on the heels of the Rockefeller study and say that it is not her intention to um remove what is called save harmless or hold harmless and what that is is is it is a promise that each year schools will not have less Foundation Aid than they did the year before so it's important to understand that when she says that um she could be indicating for a flat Foundation aid from year to year so we would actually experience that in the district as a cut in Foundation Aid because of contractual increases

025and increases in health care in the district so if we don't receive an increase in Foundation Aid to keep Pace with inflation and uh uh increases due to collective bargaining agreements that we would actually feel that as a potential cut so we have to be very aware of what flat Foundation Aid looks like and um hope for the best I guess I should say so uh let's see anything else yeah we're just going to be talking about Foundation Aid pretty much at every meeting from here on out uh especially with Carl's um budget presentations um beginning shortly um so somewhat tied to the rockfeller Institute and the foundation Aid um but not explicitly linked is the regionalization initiative um the regionalization initiative from the state um you know really is founded on this idea that

026we have to become more efficient so if the state is saying hey schools become more efficient please uh that is another Tea Leaf of potential you know budgetary strain at the state level so that being said um the commissioner of education did come out and say that the submission of the um regionalization survey tool within the state portal and engaging in the regionalization conversations in your local bosies were optional um we in Midlakes did submit the survey and do plan on engaging in those regionalization conversations uh with our local Partners um because I I do believe that you know part of our job is to be good listeners right and if we're not even willing to sit at the table and hear what could potentially be a good idea regionally um and and possibly inspect

027ways to become more efficient and do what's best for our students here in Midlakes then I don't believe we're doing our job so we submitted the survey um we'll sit at the table we'll we'll collaborate with our partners and then it's safe because it's not binding right we can still decide which pieces of the regionalization plan that we're going to engage with and which pieces we are not so what that means is is if none of these um ideas really serve a purpose for us and our students we could choose to engage so there's there's uh safety with submitting that that um survey and being a part of the regionalization process um another large update came from the state in the way of uh the zero emission bus initiative um report all right so one

028of the departments at at at n said collected all of the data from all of the districts across the state regarding the level of implementation uh for the zero emission School Bus initiative now I'm saying zero emission on purpose we've colloquially begun to call it the bus electrification initiative but technically it is a zero emission bus initiative electric buses happen to be the only option at this point okay so I just wanted to make sure that I pointed that out so if there's another invention that comes along in the next couple years we might be able to use that but for the time being it's bus electrification so that being said um we're going to begin to have a lot of conversations about this um in the near future and as we move towards the

029deadline of full implementation of 2035 um so I wanted to make sure that that I brought it up tonight um we actually have on Wednesday Wendell energy a contractor coming here to begin our electrification study here in the district and what they will do is they will give us a report that says here's what here here's what Midlakes has and makes them great for electrification here's what we don't have and we need to remedy prior to 2035 right so we're talking about the power grid locally and all and all of these things that would make um charging upwards of 35 school buses of reality um each each day and evening so they're going to come out and um I talked to Carl once we get the wendle energy survey back we'll we'll do a presentation

030here at the board so we can have all of those details uh for our board and for our community members all right all right let's see now moving into some more celebratory news uh we did have a successful Capital project vote last Wednesday night the proposition for the 35 million project passed uh with 206 yes votes and 107 no votes um I just want to take a moment to thank the facilities committee um and also Carl here uh for doing a ton of work um additional Partners to thank um Edge architecture our Watchdog building Partners uh mangle metzer bar and um the law offices of William Mar cour Who oversee the bonding of the project um and Pam for doing a ton of work behind the scenes um to prepare for the vote and to

031actually execute the vote um properly so thanks to everybody and you know the next phase is not going to be a lot to talk about because we're going to move into that design phase which is a lot of behind the scene work and then um once we have a solid design will'll report that out and uh then it would go out for SED approval so we're still looking at you know a good 18 months to two years before we even break ground on the project all right but we will move as quickly as we can all right um let's see here recently we did have our uh annual RPO concert over at the high school um there were nice numbers there uh one Community member who caught me at the secondary concert said it wasn't

032enough and we need to get more people to the RPO so you know we'll have to advertise it a little more strongly next year but I do want to thank GW Lisk uh for their generosity in making uh that annual event possible um the Clifton Springs rotary club for um handling the tickets um and the logistics for the evening our facilities department for handling Logistics of the evening uh I have to mention Amy Connor the high school course teacher who goes out of her way to create this experience for the kids um and it's it's not actually normal for students to perform with the RPO that doesn't happen in every District but it happens here in Midlake so was amazing to see our High School chorus students actually singing with the RPO um it really

033helps them kind of rise to that professional level and see how far they can take their their art so uh I think that's pretty amazing so thanks to Amy and then thanks to Amy Amy Vander Joe Godfrey Todd Claus and Chris Marc cour and Pam uh for additional help to make that night a success all right that does it right now for updates just a quick update on the emergency pool project as you know um the pool will go through its first shut down uh at the end of this week and then um we hope to open it mid January for about a month month and then we would have our second shutdown uh the week prior to February break so we're still on track to make that happen all right and I'll do policies

034when we get to it on the agenda y thank you Nick yep all right on to board discussion topics um so first um our Board of Ed goals for the year are on um the agenda for approval tonight does anybody have any last minute comments questions anything are we good with our goals okay all right and um Mike and I attended the 4 County membership meeting um with Brian festler um from nisba as the guest speaker he was talking about the foundation Aid study as well and that was just before it was the like Tuesday before the study was supposed to be out on the following Sunday so um I think just the biggest takeaway I had was kind of What U Mr Ganer spoke to that just because this study was done doesn't mean

035that the governor is necessarily going to go forward with all the recommendations which I think initially when we were hearing about it we thought she was asking for this because she had a motive but then we realized that she could decide to not abide by any of the recommendations so it is interesting that some of the recommendations kind of fall on one side and and some fall on the other and it'll be interesting to see how it all falls out and plays out but I don't Mike did you have anything you wanted to add [Music] from the one thing I noticed was the um in the room that night we had um board representation from all across the region and um everybody seemed to be uh kind of cohesive in the in the way that

036they were were talking about things and looking at things and it seemed like a a pretty unified group across the region yeah I would say yeah I I would have to agree we're all kind of just waiting waiting see what happens so interesting it'll be it'll be interesting couple months so all right um the only other thing I have is just to um check out the December 4Count newsletter if you haven't read it already um Su Wyatt sent it on December 4th um there's some save the dates in there and some information on that zero emissions School Bus progress survey um that Nick was referring to as he said we'll be talking about this more in the coming months so if you can take a a minute there is a link in that newsletter to

037read that um the survey results it's a long long document but if you don't read it's there's like the introductory part which doesn't take very long and then the the the real bulk of the document is like um how many areas was it broken down to like nine different areas of the state so you can you can just get down to our section where it talks about our area because I think that's where it's most relevant for us it is interesting to kind of pull some pieces from the other areas of the state you know I mean Long Island is dealing with a totally different bus electrification set of issues um and and so it was interesting to just kind of look at pieces of that but um I would encourage you to check out

038that um that link because it's it's good information for us to have as we move forward and and have discussions about how this is all going to unfold so can I ask a question on this yes what is the wendle um study do do they give us kind of a time frame of when they would actually have something that we could read um so wendle energy we actually through Wayne Finger Lakes bosis uh collectively several school districts put out a request for proposal uh for an architect firm that's specialized in electrification studies Wendel won the bid so there's several school districts that have gone with Wendell along the way in order for Wendell to do the study they're doing the study through nerta which is an approved organization that works with school districts across the

039state depending on your Aid ratio the nerta study can be nearly it can cost you 25% or it can cost you it can be absolutely free for us it's absolutely free now along the way nerta has project managers they had about three to five project managers several of them either resigned or got reassigned Nera was down to one project manager across the state so everything came to a grinding halt as far as the um the electrification study and Wendell couldn't do their part until nerta first approved the school district that only happened last month so as far as Wendell's concerned they're itching to get on site they have all our bus fleet information our routes the number of miles we drive the number of uh gallons of diesel we consume they're coming to take a

040look at our site but they hope to bring um NYSEG to the table in a future meeting and then finally conclude their study where they're presenting either to the district or to the board our hope is that by June 30th 2025 that study is entirely Complete because we're kind of hopeful and we want to know exactly what they have to say in terms of how many buses how many Chargers what can we support so um I would have liked the study to have been done already but unfortunately the Nera piece was entirely out of our hands thanks for that question because I hadn't I that question came up in my head earlier like why aren't we talking to niag but it's because Wendell is the architecture piece that does the study and they cons right

041to get okay all right thank you any other questions or comments or okay goad one quick thing as I'm thinking of this um So within that study did you say they're going to be looking at routes would that include distance of routes and all and time to charge in between runs or emergency evacuations you are absolutely correct so they're going to tell us um so the way when when we sat at the table when several districts sat at the table Wendell said by the time the study is done we'll tell you how many Chargers or one how much power consumption can you afford how many Chargers will that get you how many buses will that get you if you buy a bluebird bus how many miles that Bluebird bus will give you versus the Thomas

042bus versus the International Bus how long you you can you can go between charging depending on the level of the charger so the study as far as Wendell said is incredibly detailed and they're not aligned with one bus company or one manufacturer they'll give you options and let the district make an informed decision from that point on so our hope is that the answer is yes to all your questions that we will have a very comprehensive understanding of what we can actually achieve wonderful yeah thank you anything else all right on to public comment the Phelps Clifton Springs Central School District Board of Education invites public comment at this time to those who have signed up in advance with the district clerk please limit your comments to two minutes or less written remarks may be

043provided to the board if time expires before a speaker completes their remarks we ask individuals to State their name prior to comments and to provide the district clerk with their contact information for purposes of followup although the board will not respond directly to individual comments at this time items brought to the attention of the board may be taken under consideration for future response action or followup with the speaker issues related to specific District students whether positive negative or neutral must be brought to the attention of the superintendent of schools privately in order to safeguard student privacy the board reserves the right to terminate a speaker's comments if their comments are excess of 2 minutes are repetitive or are not appropriate for discussion in an open public forum all visitors are reminded to abide by the

044district code of conduct and to be respectful and courteous both as speakers and as audience members we are a community focused on bettering public education for our students some of whom may be present thank you no comments okay thanks Pam all right on to new business items um so the first item a budget calendar for the 2526 school year is there a motion to adopt the Phelps Clifton Springs Central School District budget development calendar for the 2526 school year as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor say I I all those opposed motion carried okay if there is um no objection I would like to block block items B and C the capital project vote results and the bond resolution so these both have to do with the

045capital project um is there a motion to approve items B and C as presented so move is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of items B and C as presented say I I I all those opposed motion carried okay item D the election Services agreement so this is for the elections in May is there a motion to approve the election Services agreement um between the school district and the county of Ontario as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of item D the election Services agreement say I I all of those opposed motion carried item e the 20242 Board of Education goals is there a motion to approve the Board of Education the four Board of Education goals for the coming year um as

046presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of item e the 2024 25's Board of Education goals as presented say I I I all those opposed motion carried okay policy manual modifications Mr ganster you want to speak to these so so there are I believe exactly 19 policies for us to talk through um so what I've done to best capture this and and and really uh balance being thorough um with also being efficient and respectful of people's time is I've tried to organize this in a in a certain way so the first thing I want to do is just do talk about the 5000s uh if you remember we're currently focused on our section 5000 uh of the policy manual non-instructional SL business operations the the draft policy manual

047has 65 policies in total 44 of those policies are identical to the ones that we currently have those are the ones that we reviewed at our last meeting um 22 policies have differences in comparison to our current manual now within those 20 there are varying degrees of differences okay and we'll get to that in just a second so uh to review um this section includes policies on budget income expenditures purchasing fiscal accounting and Reporting non-instructional operations and transportation all right so I'm actually going to zip through several of these because the first batch of slides are all of the policies that that are identical to our current policies that we've already looked at okay so actually so there's our budget income expenditures purchasing fiscal accounting and Reporting and our non-instructional operations as well as Transportation

048all of those are identical to our current manual not only that Erie one bosis recommends that they stay as is no changes because they're predicated on law as well as the comp trollers um rules for how we manage business here in the district okay so are there any questions based on any of those 44 policies that we have no room for changing okay I I had to phrase it that way because there we can discuss them but we really can't change them all right so now we're going to move on and focus on the 22 policies that we have that have changed uh and like I said there are varying degrees of change within those 22 all right here we go within those There are 16 policies that have minor changes in language and are

049representative from irie1 um TC Faro is her name she said that as uh Eerie one gets new lawyers who draft policies and work for them they end up with um different interpretations on certain language on how to express policies that are are based on Law and regulation that we don't have much wiggle room in terms of changing so what we see in those 16 policies are minor language changes that the lawyers at irie1 bosis believe is a better representation of um the law and the regulations that back the policies in other words very minor changes almost to the point where I we could have potentially grouped them with those 44 policies from the very beginning of um the presentation so there's not much wiggle room and discussion with those policies all right there are changes

050but there are minor changes so because there are minor changes that don't match our current policy manual we do have to technically do a first read of those policies a second read and an adoption so that's why they're here in this section all right so there um is one policy because we were uh it's a policy on meal shaming and I'll get to that in a minute but there was um a question as to whether or not we should retire the policy or adopt the updated irie1 policy and that's because we currently have the community eligibility provision for School meals um which in some ways does make our meal shaming policy uh a moot policy however because we still do have students that purchase food beyond what uh Community eligibility provision provides uh we found

051it we thought it best to maintain that policy um the the current policy from irie1 does differ than our current policy so it does have to go on a on a first read second read an adoption um but that decision was made just a little bit too late to get that policy onto this agenda so it'll be on the agenda for next time so there are three policies um that required significant time to review that had some choices and decisions that I want to go through with a a more fine- tooth comb with the board um none of the changes are um I would say controversial or anything like that the essentially assigning people assigning how frequent uh committees will meet things of of those nature of that nature so we'll get to that in

052a second and then we have three policies um that we're actually going to recommend for retirement uh two of them are on the agenda for tonight for retirement uh one of the policies we can't retire until we adopt the new policy because if we retire it too early then we'll actually have a gap in time where we don't have a policy that addresses um that item so so here we go these are the ones that have minor changes so administration of the budget um essentially outlines how the dist it's incumbent upon the district to uh develop our annual budget with responsibilities to the superintendent and the business administrator um policy 5240 School tax assessment and collection of property tax and exemptions um basically says that the district has to um have rules for tax assessments

053and how we're going to collect taxes and then certain exemptions for elderly folks uh the 5321 use and safeguarding of District credit cards uh that was a policy of focus within recent memory uh and that has essentially remained identical um 5510 accounting for funds more fiscal policy uh 5530 petty cash funds and cash in the school buildings each year at our uh reorg meeting we do authorize a number of petty cash funds across the district this is the policy that that governs those um 5540 publication of the district's annual financial statements something that we have to do say what's that we just did that so it'll be published with fiscal advisors in in a matter of days okay so following those policies uh 557 5572 uh how we will run our audit committee um 5573

054internal audit functions we do have an internal auditor so this policy outlines how uh we operate there uh 5630 facilities are inspection operation and maintenance of course um that outlines how we manage our facilities uh 5710 are Transportation program 5730 school bus safety 5740 qualification of bus dve drivers 5741 drug and alcohol testing for school drivers or school bus drivers those are all policies um that again have been updated from our current manual in minor ways but in many ways are uh non-negotiables in terms of what the laws and regulations say so they've just been updated uh to match and then finally the meal shaming policy which uh we will have on our next agenda does everybody know what meal shaming is no okay so a quick explanation so uh probably within the last five

055six or seven years um districts were required to have a policy against meal shaming which essentially um requires the district to have practices and procedures that don't highlight um someone who may be receiving free and reduced lunch services so um a long time ago when I went to school students actually had physical tickets in their hands so that would be an example of meal shaming we wouldn't want want to um have have people have to feel that way uh in the lunch line at school um so in this day and age every student punches in their code and nobody knows who's receiving free introduced lunch services and in addition to that there's specific guidelines in the meal shaming policy um about um how we would recoup any uh balances due to the Food Service uh

056SE fund so uh that's that's kind of the meal shaming policy in a nutshell all right all right so there are three policies in this group that required significant review we're going to go through two of them uh fairly quickly because there's really there're significant re review but there's not a ton to talk about the first one is our policy on Wellness the district does currently have a wellness policy um we used the updated Eerie one wellness policy uh and customized it to our district um and in reviewing that with the policy committee um we realized that this was an opportunity to to essentially reboot the wellness policy and start more open discussions about the wellness policy so we'll go through that in a moment and then uh policy 5676 is actually a new policy

057um and it has to do with privacy and security for student teacher and principal data all right and this outlines uh how the district will operate from a a networking and and Technology perspective in terms of protecting uh personally identifiable information of our students teachers and principles um that we we house on our Network um and then the last one that the policy committee has not had enough time to adequately um uh read and recommend any changes is 5231 gifts recognitions and naming of facilities that'll end up on our next agenda for a first read so let's take a quick look at we'll start with our wellness policy so the wellness policy ha uh directs us or requires us to have a wellness committee um the outline of the wellness committee is here the policy

058committee did recommend uh three meetings for the wellness committee a year one in the summer one in the fall and one in the spring um to come together and oversee our Wellness initiatives in the district it has a list of of recommended folks um our current wellness policy does not have an administrator in charge over the you know to oversee the policy um John I see you over there uh John Lombardi has been assigned through this policy as the person who's going to provide oversight for the wellness policy um we do have two Wellness coordinators that he will work with who will do a lot of the nuts and bolts kind of work uh currently Lindsay berneski and uh Britney Sullivan um a little bit here about Community engagement an annual notification of the policy

059that we would run in our uh annual school calendar uh another piece was what is called a trienal assessment which is every three years um the person overseeing so that would be Mr Lombardi um overseeing the wellness policy would do an assessment of how well we're implementing it and make recommendations to make our implementation of the policy even better all right uh a little bit on how we're gonna revise and update the policy additional Community involvement language um recordkeeping for the policy a lot of this is uh identical or very similar to what we currently have in place and then the uh policy has a large section on nutrition which governs how we are going to um provide nutritious meals for our students for breakfast and lunch and it lists lists the various programs that

060we are a part of for Food Service we'll have water available um language about the competitive food and beverages that are available for um food service and then we have a handful of sections that govern foods that aren't really available or aren't provided through our food service department and the the the language is a little weird so first it's food and beverages provided but not sold to students during the school day so these are classroom parties classroom snacks brought in by parents or other Foods given as incentives um these should me or exceed the USDA smart snack and school nutrition standards and be low and saturated fat and have zero grams of trans fat pres serving that language is with the exception of the USDA smart snack and School nutrition standards uh already part of

061our current policy so it's actually not a change secondly for fundraising um fundraisers uh all food and beverage made available to sale students through fundraisers on school campus during the school day will meet at a minimum the USDA smart snack and school nutrition standards so that that is for sale during the school day so that doesn't preclude fundraisers that don't match those standards to occur outside of the school day um and then food and beverages available for sale at uh events outside the school day so think concession stand uh for an athletic event or another event on campus um that we would have food it would include options that are low and saturated fat and have zero grams of trans fat preserving in other words um there have to be some healthy options available when

062food is being provided or sold on campus so that doesn't um take away the the the tacos in a bag or a pizza on a Friday night um uh football game or or another athletic event or concessions at a theater production okay we just have to have some healthy options available make sense all right uh and then finally we are actually one of the policies that I didn't mention for retirement is our vending machine policy and that is because we're going to merge vending machines into the wellness policy and simply say that uh all foods and beverages sold in vending machines need to be consistent with this policy and then specifically uh one prohibition on energy drinks um to not be sold in our vending machines on campus all right there's a section for um

063food and Beverages and how they could be marketed at school um schools aren't allowed to Market specific things um now there are certain things so if you could imagine like um a a name brand um bottled water on a vending machine that could be ConEd as marketing in school but that would be a tolerable level of marketing in school so we're not going to um you know have the scoreboard in the gymnasium called the the Coca-Cola uh scoreboard or anything like that so we're not going to Market specific uh unhealthy products in school overtly all right so um promoting nutrition and education so this is fairly simple for us because it is already embedded in our health curriculum physical activity we're going to encourage physical activity not only in PE classes but in all um

064classes to the extent possible and in a little bit of uh language on our PE this language here is very similar or identical to what's already in place in the current wellness policy so that's why I'm skimming through it um we're encouraged to have Community Partnerships uh Community Access to District facilities for physical activities we do make campus available for the community to walk um outside after hours so we do uh have a little bit of that and then there's a little section um on professional learning for wellness so that's the wellness policy in a nutshell it's pretty lengthy um we're considering this a first read so uh board members if you'd like to ask any questions now that would be great if you'd like to ask questions next time we come together um or

065you know a email in between now and the next meeting that would be fine too so any questions on the wellness policy okay we're going to take a look at another policy um this is new so this one I'm going to make this one as simple as humanly possible so educational law 2D um was new about 5 years ago and it has a lot of requirements for a district to handle personally identifiable information of students and staff all right um when this came around uh there there was a day where districts were implementing Technologies where students had to implement or input their name and grade level and other information uh into to a web-based application without any oversight whatsoever and it became pretty clear that um we didn't want students forfeiting their personally identifiable information

066uh to companies that may have no protections for that personally identifiable information so edlaw 2D came around and said districts you have to do better you actually have to engage with these companies and um develop data privacy agreements in order to do business with these companies and there was kind of uh some painful growth uh Over The Last 5 Years with With Private Industry when it comes to providing schools with software programs uh in terms of uh certain companies embracing at ludd and making these privacy agreements and actually following through and some said no thank you and actually withdrew their business from New York State because they didn't want to have to bother with you know hardening their networks in order to Pro protect student information so the good news here is is um even

067without this policy in place we've been following the law with data privacy agreements and any formally adopted technology platform that we have in the district there is uh a data privacy agreement in place so we're compliant uh with Ed law 2D um so that's one piece of the puzzle um let's see here let's start going through so this policy begin oh the nist framework so another piece piece of this puzzle is that um the district is agreeing um to use what is called the nist framework which is uh nist stands for the National Institute for standards and technology so it's it's basically a a giant rubric that allows the district to to assess our own quality of network and cyber security for our Network here on the district all right within the district so are

068we protecting that network from folks who might want to um try to hack into our system and actually breach the the system and steal our students information right no different than hackers that this time of year try to get into any retailers um you know uh Network in order to steal credit card information right so the nist framework uh allows us to reflect on several different dimensions of cyber security and then ask ourselves if we're doing um good enough to protect cyber security here in the district so the basis of this entire policy is that law 2D and the nist framework okay all right so there's a ton of definitions that exist and those are uh because there's lots of different terminology within elud and terminology within uh the nist framework so we're going to

069scroll right past all of those uh still going so then um there are statements as to uh how we are going to be transparent with our data collection and how we're going to restrict data collection and that we actually want to take steps to minimize how much personally identifiable data that we're collecting on students right and right now we collect the same information year in and year out right in terms of of pii with um students ident ities their grades um per perhaps their status as a student with a disability things like that we're not really ramping up the amount of um pii that we're collecting year in and year out um so the commissioner of education has appointed a Chief privacy officer that we're accountable to all right that's a state level position we're

070accountable to that person and they have certain rights to come in here and request information and that's what this section um lines we have two data protection officers in house whose job it is um to ensure that we are doing our best to protect students uh staff uh personally identifiable information consistent with edlaw 2D and consistent with the nist framework and that's uh Lydia shadler and Bill Gowan this section lists are St standards in terms of uh data privacy and security there are responsibilities for third-party contractors what the district is responsible for what the thirdparty contractors are responsible for and then if it's not a private organization how we would engage with our local Bose so they're part of this policy as well um a click wrap agreement this is a technical thing um when

071somebody clicks something like you agree to the uh terms and conditions of your iPhone or your your um you know device this says that when you click that it it matters all right but they call it a click click wrap agreement so if we as a district click on something like this that we are actually accountable to those things um there is a parents Bill of Right bill of Rights for data privacy and security outlined here which is required um based on Ed law 2D rights of parents and eligible students to inspect and review their educational records under furpa that is uh furpa is the federal education rights to privacy act um that is a federal law that we are compliant with it outlines how we would handle complaints of a breach or unauthorized access

072to our Network where pii could be in question how to report a breach or unauthorized release and then how we would investigate a breach or unauthorized release and then finally how we would notify the uh the impacted parties of said uh breach and then finally um providing annual training to our staff on how they can keep our Network secure which we do through our safe schools training each year and how we will provide notification so two policies in the weeds right um and I would offer the same opportunity for questions uh now in between now in our next meeting and at the next meeting so does anyone have any questions now about our data privacy policy okay let me cue up my presentation just to make sure I don't leave anything out oh yeah we

073have to talk about the two policy retirements that are on the agenda oh come on network don't fail me now you know what I'm going to go like this I'm just going to scroll down so these slides are what I just talked through so we're going to skip right to retirements so we are going to retire tonight uh 5235 corporate sponsorships this is a policy that outlines if the district actually entered into a business agreement with a corporation to sponsor something here at school so I kind of made that that poor joke about the Coca-Cola uh scoreboard in the gymnasium if we did that we would have to have a policy on corporate sponsorships it's not something we do uh therefore the policy committee is recommending retiring this policy because it's we have no corporate

074relationships or sponsorships nor are we planning on it uh the second one uh 5721 transportation in a child safety zone so this policy uh is relevant to districts that have students that walk to school um I won't go into it um but it's a it's a way for a student who is required to walk to school because they live within the walking Zone if there is some unsafe thing between their house and the school uh a parent can appeal and ask for a child's safety zone to be established and then that way we would provide transportation but because we provide transportation to all students it is not uh a relevant policy for us so we would like to retire it so that actually should say because we only have buers oh oh that's we don't

075have any walk I don't know if Busters is that's the right terminology but we're going to leave it because that was a mistake thank you for picking up on that that was just a mistake uh and then uh finally uh vending machines we're going to retire the vending machine policy because we have dovetailed vending machine language into the wellness policy so that does it for policy updates thank you for bearing with me um there there was a lot of work that went into this uh both at the policy committee level and my head around how I would efficiently present it to the board so thank you yeah thank you so moved is there a second second any discussion I G G thank you do I have to resay that all no okay um is there

076a motion to approve the fundraisers as uh sorry is there a motion to approve items G and H field trips and fundraisers as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor say I I I all those opposed motion carried all right on to Personnel items um if there are no objections I would like to block items a b and c so appointments substitute appointments and coaching Appo appointments um is there a motion to approve items a through c as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of items a through c as presented say I I all of those opposed motion carried and if there are no objections I would like to block items D through f is there a motion to approve

077items d and f as presented so moved is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of items D through f as presented say I I all those opposed motion carried and on to adjournment ah it went away um um is there a motion to adjourn the regular board meeting for the purpose of entering into executive session to discuss matters pertaining to the employment of a particular person information relating to current investigation or prosecution of a criminal offense that would imperil effective law enforcement if disclosed and discussions involving pending or current litigation motion to adjourn is there a second second any discussion all those in favor of adjournment say I I I all of those opposed motion carried

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.