CorpusRecord 235926

January 22, 2025 Special Board Meeting Budget Workshop

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Ravena-Coeymans-Selkirk Central School District
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Albany County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,150 words · about 51 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening 6 o'clock pm we'll call to order a special meeting of the Board of Education let's please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Pledge of Allegiance flag United States of americe uh one quick item of business agenda item 3.3 uh is there a motion to appoint Jesse as the uh Protime district clerk for this evening J any motion second Jackie all in favor I congratulations Jesse uh up next we have a presentation from bosis on the superintendent search process welcome I should have tested this before I yeah it works there you go um good evening everybody I am Lauren gel the district superintendent at Capitol region bosis and joining me this evening is Elizabeth Wood our coo and Deputy district superintendent um so it's our pleasure to come and speak to the board tonight

002about the superintendent search process that we utilize at Capital Region bosis when we're supporting school districts in search for their next superintendent um um I always make the point that when I'm here talking about superintendent searches and working with Boards of Education I have on my district superintendent hat so as the district superintendent I have two roles one of them is the CEO of bosis and running all of the programs and services and supports that we provide to our component districts and districts across the state and then the district superintendent role and as the district superintendent I am a representative of the commissioner of Education in the field and so when I do searches it really is under that hat any of my formal communication is under my State education letterhead um and it really

003is with the purpose of supporting districts boards um with whatever they need at the moment um so tonight we're here to talk about the goal of Recruitment and retaining the best candidate and your next uh Superintendent at uh Ravina Coan cerk um and looking for a new superintendent is a really important role there are times where board members will come on a board and serve a series of years and get off the board and never have the opportunity to select the superintendent as you know a board of education has one employee the superintendent of schools all other employees in the district report to the superintendent and as elected members of the school board it is your Collective charge when you have the need to hire for a new superintendent to go through the process and

004work on behalf of the community to select your next superintendent of schools um so tonight I'm here to talk about our process I'm uh want to start with talking about two different types of searches that we do at Capitol region bosis um and I always say that and people laugh and you know if you work with me through this search process you're probably going to spend more time with me in certain weeks than you do with your family um but I don't love the names of these two searches and if somebody comes up with a better name I am more than ready to use them but at the moment this is what we've got so confidential search and traditional search and really both searches are highly confidential throughout the process the difference between a confidential

005search in a traditional search is one round of interviews um I'm going to jump ahead and then come back um that involves stakeholder groups so if you look at this chart in front of you it shows that of a confidential and traditional side by side and you will see that they mirror each other except at a certain point in the process if folks decide that they want to do a traditional search there is is a time when the board works with District leadership members of the district to identify members of the community that would be invited to be part of the search for a round of interviews and that would serve in the capacity of recommendations and feedback to the Board of Education I'm going to jump back for a second so why do we

006have two different searches right because again when you think about stakeholder groups you think about community involvement Community voice and that is something that we recognize and that we value in any school Community um and it really does come down to the candidate pool that we have right now in superintendent searches so just like you have Workforce issues filling positions such as bus drivers Food Service workers teachers um we have Workforce issues when it comes to robust pools with superintendence and so what we have seen over the past six seven years is that the number of candidates has declined we're not talking about pools of 2530 candidates applying for a superintendency we're talking somewhere we hope cross the fingers that we get a solid 10 candidates for a position and a posting so then if

007you think about who are those candidates it really plays into the type of search that a board decides to go forth with if the board is looking to attract um a group a diverse group of leaders that have served as superintendent that currently may serve as a superintendent in a district and have a very successful seasoned experience we see boards gravitating to the um confidential search and the reason for that is that I what I just said these superintendents are sitting in their Community they're working with their Boards of Education they're committed to the students and the staff in their district and so if they decide to look at another opportunity and it's not a confidential search they need to go forth to their board leadership and say I'm really happy here I'm very content

008and we're doing great things I'm committed to the students and staff and the board but I'm just going to go look at this opportunity Unity over here and the minute that conversation happens it changes the Dynamics between the superintendent and the board and if it gets past the board it changes the Dynamics between staff and certain community members that does not mean that if you don't do a confidential search you will not have successful sitting experienced superintendence in your pool there could be many reasons why a superintendent is looking for that next move alignment to the goals and the priorities of the district it may be a bigger District it may be in a geographical location that they are looking to relocate to in all of those instances it is very plausible that the superintendent

009would be having open dialogue with their Board of Education about their next professional move in general what we see is that in confidential searches you have less sitting experience superintendent supply for the reason that I just said and you tend to see more candidates who potentially are uh leaders at the building level or at the central office again I use Elizabeth as the example when I'm doing this if Elizabeth comes to me and says that she's ready to move on and she wants to be a superintendent I'm going to do everything in my power to help her to support her to grow her to do all the things to get her to move to that next um position in her career ladder that's natural that's what superintendents and leaders and districts should do I would

010never hold it against her that she came to me and said I'm ready for that next position it's just a different Dynamic and it's really an expectation that throughout their career path leaders will move into different positions um doesn't mean they have to but central office administrators very often look and say you know what I want to be a superintendent and thank goodness they do because we need we need superintendant that are committed to serving their communities and students and staff so a traditional search again typically has more candidates in it that are sitting administrators um that are looking for that next jump in their career path and are are able to be really open and honest about it um the other thing I will mention and I have absolutely no Intel about your District

011whatsoever but if you have internal candidates confidential searches also protect internal candidates through a search process so if you have someone who internally is interested they apply they go through the process and it's confidential the board knows right and if by any chance that person isn't the successful candidate it's not known throughout the community they don't have to get up the next morning walk into their building and have everyone looking at them like oh I'm so sorry right um and so uh sometimes when when boards know that they have some internal candidates they'll go that route as well um because it it really is protection to them throughout the interview process I'll keep moving and then take questions at the end if that makes make sense okay um so regardless of what search the board

012decides to do we have a heavy input with community members stakeholders internal and outside of the school walls um you have a timeline that I drafted in front of you as well at your seat and you will see a number of forums listed in that timeline they don't have dates on them and they're just drafted we obviously would work with board leadership to identify the exact groups that you would want in this process but regardless of which search a board chooses when we do a search we start it with a community survey and also Community forums that is all focused on getting Community input the survey has five questions they're at the bottom of your timeline what are the strengths of the district what needs to be improved what characteristics and personal attributes should the

013new superintendent have what will the new superintendent need to work on First and additional comments which is really that catchall we work with District leadership to send that survey out any way possible within your community right so we push it your normal way of communicating to parents we push it to your internal staff we push it to your high school students we will ask you are there Community groups grou that you want this push to so that you get as many responses from community members across across the community to answer that's really great information for the Board of Education to have the forums are in person sometimes we do virtual honestly we end up sometimes with better representation in Virtual because people are really busy and they can just jump on their phone and participate

014in a virtual meeting the forums are conversations with the same five questions so when we do the forums we usually start with a very quick slide deck that gives an overview of the process for the search and then we open it up to the five questions and we solicit the feedback from the groups we then take all that information the Board of Education sees every single survey response in all of the notes from The Forum I do give them to you on a weekly basis so you don't have them all Landing in your inbox right before we meet and then our Communications Team Works across all those groups and identifies common themes for each of the five questions those themes end up being information that we use both in the search materials the invitation to

015apply and also that the board can utilize to craft questions during the interview process so so clearly you as a board have identified District goals and priorities that you work on and this is another layer of hearing from the community about feedback around the superintendency and the district that you then can take that feedback and bring it into the process um and so now we're back to the chart and really those are the two searches and they're side by side you will see that the um confidential search I have typically is a four to five month process the um traditional search adds about a half of a week so it's about four and a half months to five and a half months um and here's why the survey and the forums are a full month

016we leave the survey open for a month and we do the forums in the first couple weeks so we can get all that data to you um we then meet as a collective group review all the information that you received um from the survey results and from the forums we craft the materials um for the invitation to apply and then we open the application process that's another month right there so during that month we use social media I communicate with the 36 other District superintendents across the state we use nisus and nispa to advert ize the opening and um tap different leaders and different folks and have I have conversations with folks who have expressed interest um so that during that month we get as many people to apply as possible during that month I

017am doing individual screening interviews with anyone who applies and in those screening interviews it allows me an opportunity to have a conversation with the candidate why are you interested in Ravina quean selker what have you done how does your priorities and goals align with District all those things and I can also offer highlevel information that we have openly talked about as a board and that you have identified in your search brochure materials for example throughout the community forums and throughout the you know meeting with the board they're very focused on X this is something that you will need to bring forth your experience and expertise in through the interview process right so it's general information that if they visit the page that you will have on your website it will share that information anyways but

018it's just a really good opportunity for me to have that one-on-one conversation so the windows open for a month applications closed I've had one-on-one conversations with everyone in the applicant pool I bring all the applications to the Board of Education nobody gets taken out unless they are not certified to be a superintendent so I I say this all the time it never perplexes me that someone who has no certification or background in education will take the time to apply for a superintendency um I will share with you that they applied we will not review their application because they cannot be a superintendent because they're not certified to be so we will walk through every single applic and the Board of Education will decide who they want to invite for those first interviews the goal is

019that you have 10 folks you want to have a conversation with 12 folks that you want to have a conversation with and so the board then does screening interviews those interviews are 30 minutes they are the same five questions you get to feel a connection and understanding of who the folks are are and hopefully after those screening interviews could bring it down to six to eight candidates that you want to interview again this is all based on the applicant pool and who applies what those numbers are based on how many people you pick to invite for that first group of interviews so you'll notice we're still Row for row here right so all of this is boor all of this is confidential the board then has a round one maybe a round two again we

020put them both there because this depends on how many candidates you have and continuously meeting with them to be able to bring it down to a smaller number if you are going to do stakeholder interviews we stop for a minute we invite folks to participate in the interviews we have a meeting with all of those individuals they will come in we will do confidentiality statements we will do bias training we will craft questions so that everybody is on the same page we then will have the stakeholder interviews if the board does not choose to do the stakeholder interviews they just go from round one to round two to round three and then when they are at the place where they have their candidate we start the second part part of the process um if the

021board does a traditional search and has stakeholder interviews the board still comes back together one more time and likely interviews the candidate or two that have come to the top through their interviews and the stakeholder meetings because remember what I said at the beginning stakeholder interviews are providing the board with direct feedback around a few candidates it is still the board's decision and responsibility to come out the other side of the stakeholder interviews and decide on who they would like to have as the next superintendent if it is a confidential search formal reference checking I'll use that word again formal reference checking happen at the end because the candidate needs time to be able to tell their Board of Education that they have gone through this process and that they are a finalist if it

022is the stakeholder under traditional that happens before the stakeholder meetings so we will do the formal reference checks before we have individuals come meet with Community groups once the board has identified their select did candidate it typically takes about another 30 days for a contract to be negotiated this is when things go quiet for the board and your attorney and the candidates attorney have their back and forth in conversations and develop the contract once that is done then the Board of Education announces that they have selected their next candidate they do the traditional meet and greets so that folks can come out and get to know and at that point the candidate would give their current employer notice if it's a sitting superintendent you are looking anywhere from a 30 60 or 90day Clause if

023it is not a sitting superintendent but a building leader or a central office leader you're looking at anywhere from 30 to 60 depending on the district and depending on their contract look at the timeline on this so what I did was I just put some ballpark dates like months so that the board knew about how long this was going to take and where we would end up we're looking at the end of June realistically of the announcement of the next superintendent it's summertime and so that person is going to let their Community know that they've accepted a position and then they're moving on that next Community is going to have to get an interim in place because they won't have time to go through a full process if it's a sitting superintendent um before the

024person leaves and so in summer months you typically have Boards of Education that release candidates before a 90day Mark um and again this is a ball park this depends on the time between interviewing round one and two you're a nine member board your schedule my schedule um if we do the community stakeholders again just accounting for the night that we do the training and then the night that we do um the interviews I should also say that all interviews happen at Capitol region bosis because even if we're doing the traditional search there's still an expectation that people have signed confidentiality agreements and that the process is coming confidential um I say this with love you bring 45 community members into stakeholder you know interviews the next morning somebody knows the names of the candidate you

025know no matter how much we stress that it happens it just happens and again that's why there's the two different searches and the reality of the two different searches I think I've gone from the beginning to the end I'm sure there's a some questions um that you may have for me and I'm more than happy to answer anybody have anything or not no that was incredibly thorough thank you you're welcome um okay so if the board decides to go forth with us um we'll have a meeting with board leadership rather quickly and then we would work to put a Time timeline together to be able to open the survey and get the Forum dates identified in a quick turn around so that we would be able to start that process remember I said it's a

026month that we have the surveys open for um what we typically ask of a district is that we get a page on your website that is dedicated to the superintendent search for Community Information so we would start right away with um the survey link and also the community Forum dates up on that page so that Community would know what their opportunity was immediately to provide feedback um and then from there we would put updates about the Big Ideas you learn through the survey um the application to apply also happens from your website so when we are ready to do the application process it's right on the very front of your website click here and it takes them to an online application process that comes to me so uh when candidates apply when they get any

027information about it it directs everyone to um Capitol region Bose's district superintendent Lauren gel are there other ways to get to the same application no besides no so it's a link so when we uh advertise at nisus when we advertise at nisba when I use and push social media off the community Community page it's all link based and it will take them directly there okay yep all right thank you thank you have a good evening you too so the one official item that we have on the agenda tonight is uh 5.1 is there a motion for 5.1 I make a motion second Jenny any discussion all in favor I I all right bis is appointed thank you both for taking the time to come out this evening we appreciate it uh same same here thank

028you one thing I'd like to do tonight if we can is just have a discussion about the two different models that can be followed doesn't require a resolution or a formal vote of the board but rather a consensus or will of the board so it's an important decision I think maybe the best format to do it is just just have some kind of open discussion for a few minutes if anybody would like to share their Viewpoint and then maybe go around uh person by person and just see you know which model you prefer um I I've I've kind of mulled this over a lot and I'm I'm very torn because I I do want our community to be as involved as possible um my concern with that for one is the candidate pool as as

029discussed you know we we will anticipate likely some additional candidat if we go with a confidential search um my other concern is trying to coordinate so many stakeholders um and that it may delay our timeline um and I think honestly that's the part that I think is going to be my biggest hangup is is the coordination of so many people and trying to get that done in a timely way um which is making me lean towards confidential um but I want to make sure that we have a very robust Community involvement um you know and obviously there's a lot of community forums um to do so um because I think that that's going to be a really important piece of us um but I think I'm still leaning towards confidential I agree with what you've

030said and the concerns with a smaller candidate pool and coordination of the schedules however I lean towards it's worth the time personally so I personally lean towards traditional but recognize that it could potentially affect the candidate pool and that is a concern to me and as I've been thinking more and more about it I have a concern that we get all these stakeholders together and somebody has one candidate in mind and then that candidate is not selected what does that do going forward with say candidate B is selected but this stakeholder wanted candidate a is that setting them up to start off on the wrong foot with the superintendent and I love our community but we all talk and if that person is not happy with the candidate is it going to spread further and

031we want this person to be able to come in with a fresh start for everybody in the community and I think that that's going to be something that I'm concerned about Fair completely so while I was originally leaning towards traditional I think I am now leaning towards confidential I don't know why no I why so I definitely different Viewpoint yeah I have definitely a different viewpoint on it I I definitely appreciate you know what you guys brought forward about the confidential and and there's nothing wrong about anybody else's what you guys are saying and timelines are really important I think is important for the new superintendent to be able to start as early in the summer as possible to be ready school time so those are all definite concerns but by the same token I've

032been on it on the other side helping you know uh select people and and being part of it and as we all came out and got elected and we all said we want to have the most transparent board and have transparency one of the worst things I think in our community that you can do is not have them involved I know these Community forums are there but in their mind for a lot of people I just think they'll do that and then I where that paper go nobody really paid attention to it um and that if we want to really have that true Buy in you know for for employees and the staff and the community to buy in they want to feel part of it uh rather than even know they elected us I

033know want you know come the concept is hey you guys elected us to do this for you right so we should you know trust us to do that but I really think having people involved is really important you know to your point I get I know the dates are horrible thing but something like this you pick the dates and if they can come they come if they can't they can't we're not going to shift around 100 times you pick your dates who can make it can make it but that's just where I stand on it I guess I'll share next from my perspective um as Lauren said I think the most important thing that we're going to do in our time on the board is pick the next superintendent uh so the the biggest responsibility

034thrust upon us is making sure that we get the best person for the job and the highest chance we have to succeed in that is having the most robust candidate pool that we can uh having gone through a mid-career change myself you know I look at where I am now now I would not be in the position I'm in now if the process that I went through wasn't confidential I never would have applied midcareer for a different position knowing that before a decision was made it would be uh publicized that I was seeking that position so I think we need to put ourselves in the uh mindset of the candidate pool that we're looking to draw from and Community input and involvement is incredibly important we are you know we've held ourselves out as being

035the most transparent board I want to be the most transparent board uh but even more than that I want to do a really effective job as a board and I think to do the most effective job we need to follow the confidential model and have the highest odds at getting the best candidate in the door that we can on that one I think our our best bet is to go confidential just for the candidate pool um I do respect uh the uh the community's consideration in this uh I do also want to remind anybody that there are board member three seats up for the uh uh school board for anybody who is really really motivated to be a part of this process right would be seated after that is I I don't even know who's

036up I know I'm not out though I I I um you're [Laughter] um I I thinking about everything and I thought about it a long time I I lean towards I'm confidential just for the fact that I don't think I would apply for the job uh if I wasn't 100% sure that it would be confidential and we need to get the most robust and qualified pool um the community involvement you know I I hear it and but I still think there's there's a lot of opportunity for input with these forms um for for different community members along the way so I I lean to our C Dan do you have anything you just want to go around and see where we're at confidential all right let's just go around Melanie confidential confidential yeah confid tradition

037traditional confidential confidential traditional confidential confidential confidential carries thank you okay thank you thank you thank both thank you thank you um before we conclude the special meeting and move on to the budget Workshop I just wanted to ask for a motion to enter into executive session to discuss matters pertaining to collective bargaining negotiations Jackie second Jenny all in favor okay uh do we have a motion to adjourn the special meeting Matt second Jenny all in favor hi all right meeting adjourned from executive session did we have to have a motion to come back first we don't vote on that we just come back start the meeting okay it's what happens when Sue is not here everybody have M what we went through oh my name's not the slide I don't have to talk I'm sorry

038yeah um I've mentioned before when I came to the district here in 2010 High School had uh just over 630 students in it and um just before the pandemic it had dipped all the way down to uh below 500 and you can see um we call a survival rate I know it's not a very attractive name but when we look at statistics birth rates um and uh um population um across from 1415 to 2425 you can see we've lost about 160 students overall and um and like I mentioned around 2010 we were just over 2,000 so there's a drastic drop there um that I can't really explain and and there are some statistics we use Albany County birth rates when uh looking as we look into the future and I'll will tell you that the

039at this time um the last three uh predictors that we've seen is a continued slow reduction and enrollment which is what's happened throughout New York State and you can see on the uh the next slide a change in um population uh per building with the percentages notice that Peter B queman is the one that's continues to go up that's not a negative 4.95 um so and as we make Staffing decisions and you'll hear through our discussions over the next few weeks uh sometimes and we've talked about this in past budgets sometimes it requires us to move staff in order to meet uh some of the student population needs and some of the programmatic needs so that may be part of discussions in the future as well uh economic status yes yeah Dan so it's it's

040a little it it uh it doesn't follow common sense because we look at uh Construction in various areas of the district it does not follow common sense because there there hasn't been a lot of large scale construction in the southern part of the district so we can't explain it that's not something that ALB county is able to explain to us other than potentially uh there are more uh rental properties in this part of the of the uh community and it's possible that we just may have attracted more families and that's an easier place for them to find residents at this time out of the elementary sometimes people will decide to move their kids to a Catholic school or private school or whatever so it may just because one goes up the other doesn't necessarily go

041up because they often go other places yep that is true is a very small percent change those other buildings so it could be or change yeah and he said small small change it could just be one or two kids uh next slide it talks about um uh enrollment by economic status and um we unfortunately have continued our poverty rate has continued to rise in the community our students with disabilities has gradually gone up but I will uh openly tell you that 20% is not recognized as being good in New York state they like to see numbers 12 13 14% um and for a brief time um we were around that I think again I like come back to 2010 we had a very high special education population it was 1819 and um from very concerted

042efforts um from all staff uh that number had gone down and we've seen a slow increase over time that's the expectation across the state do most school districts meet that expectation I mean you can't necessarily make someone significantly different than they are well if you think about it remember we we've we say that um genetically a student in Ravina is no different than a student in Bethlehem is no different than a student in Kaki if all things were equal in the universe the state would say how can one District uh Bethlehem have 12% but Ravina have 20 if if there's no change in if students are student or students right so I think that's and this will we all agree that the state has some metrics that maybe aren't always easily explained I disagree with

043this one department and I don't think that was a negative thing I don't think it would ever people were purposely moving into this district for a while because of our fantastic special ed so I don't take issue with what you're saying I just take issue with what the state is proposing as reasonable just to clarify sorry so what what would happen is it would be an indicator where on the state report card they would flag us for and and we probably will soon be flagged for that based on the percentage of our population that has been um designated as special education for students with disability districts are so I'm sorry just to clarify the economic status ones are those people who are in like poverty lines like that's for people who are around yeah I

044just want to make sure I was understand it correctly and we've always said said um especially in the last four years five years that's line has lagged or may have lagged a little bit because with free and reduced lunch being given free lunch being given to all students it's less of a rationale for families to fill out those forms sure and our demographics haven't changed significantly um over those last five years thank you Dr Bailey uh now um I just like to point out one thing with the enrollment enrollment is very key one is one of our biggest indicators for our foundation Aid so dropping and Foundation Aid is our biggest state aid funding so dropping enrollment does have an effect on that so when you hear about different District talked about hold harmless uh

045thank God this is not one of our districts um they have dropped their enrollment has dropped significantly to the point where um and the and the their Foundation hasn't changed so they could see a large decrease in their amount of state aid so thank God we we are still not one of those districts that are on hold harmless um and it looks like and I'll get into a little bit more of this later on uh that that's not going to affect those districts this year from what the uh the budget uh the uh Governor sent out yesterday so little side note sorry um first off I want to kind of review some of our uh historical Revenue information I think it's a good starting point to see where where we've been uh then I can

046talk a little about where I see us going in the future so the bar graph on the Le hand side there is our district revenue and you can see generally it does increase steadily year after year uh last year we looked at uh 49% of that came from a local taxation um and about 36% of that being state aid uh and then other Revenue about 11% a majority of that is our Pilots uh payment a of taxes we have some larger Pilots uh within the district uh that um do fund uh quite a bit of it uh and then we also uh last year's 4.2% of our fund balance so what that means is when we were budgeting for our our our budget last year we actually did it as a deficit so we plan

047to use uh $2.5 million uh to balance our budget um and uh in the future I think that's something that and and we've talked extensively with the finance committee that's something we need to take a look at uh because I don't believe it's uh we can keep up with it so uh we are going to in the future try to reduce that a little bit Yeah the uh tax levy change or does that usually run around 49 to 50% generally that's that's words meaning comparison of the whole Revenue yeah so generally we we kind of right around that being around 50 50% um 50% local and then the rest you know the other majority would be the state aid yes absolutely it's a great Point uh Dr Bailey said uh if there was a significant

048drop in the state aid um that then that would generally increase significantly so that is a that is a great point I was hoping for the opposite yeah yeah well I have some good news I'll I'll talk about later in a slide that we heard from yesterday so determined is it determined on like the beds day where they take y so all that enrollment that we talked about before okay that was all based on bed stage numbers and so they adjust it yearly I mean I know it's probably not a significant number but I I don't know for state aid like they oh yes yes so that yeah it is we do there's a whole bunch of reporting things that we do to um to uh they take all that information and then they do

049the large Foundation calculation so like for example if that development down that's going to be in aw Becker has a large student population and increases I use the term large lightly because I know it might not be significant but 2030 students they'll know that with the next yes so it is the previous year's enrollment so if it was we we wouldn't see it now but in the a year out from then yes we would have an impact on our foundation okay yes thank you m okay clear any other questions on the revenue part thank you so next we're going to dive in uh with the historical expense uh again set up the same way uh the bar track uh tracks over year over year over our expense increase uh you do see that one significant

050um bar a little bit higher than the rest that was 22 23 uh and I believe that that was the year we took we plan to take some money out of our unrestricted fund balance to help um either fund a capital reserve or pay for one of the larger capital projects so that was a board action to do a a transfer to Capital um during that year so that's why you see a big increase there other than that you it is a steady increase year-over-year there's a little dip uh during those covid years in uh 2019 and 20 and 22 uh 20 21 um I think we all know why with the the lack of kids being in here a lot of expenses went down um the bar graph on the right hand side I'm

051sorry uh for people that are sitting here it's a little bit hard to see um but you'll what what it does show this is from last year as well that 46% of um our expenses uh come from an instructional cost 20% is from employee benefits and that's employee benefits for everybody uh and the other big topic is the 11.37 which is that inter fund transfer uh which includes uh transfer to Capital and uh that is we do a $100,000 Capital project every year small capital projects uh so we can get funded in our Point uh 7 uh percent we get it back in the previous year and not over 30 years oh following year I'm sorry uh and then transfer to Capital uh transfer to cafeteria fund uh before we we got this extra funding

052um from the state our cafeteria fund was running in a deficit so the general fund would have to help fund that cafeteria program by you know over I think it I believe it was $15,000 but now that we have this where they give us extra funding we we're not no longer going to need to do that we're we are fully funded in that cafeteria program and finally there's also in that transfers about $100,000 for the special ed um summer fund any questions on the historical uh expenses special uh special uh so the way that the state AIDS sped um summer school is we they pay 80% of it and we get we pay 20% of it so the way that we have to put it in our budget is this transfer of uh to other

053funds and that's where we budget it and then we move it to a federal fund we pay it out and then they yeah otherwis this is this is where we budget for it okay perfect thank you yeah any other questions on uh historical expense all right uh I always like and I know I keep you know slamming this into your guys's head but I always like to go over the fund balance um I do have a little description on the fund balance because I'm not going to go through each one but there's a few of them that I want to point out that I think is extremely important for the future um first off uh the the Employee Retirement Reserve is at 1.8 uh million and uh we have uh a bill about 850,000 a

054year so that can only only be used for about two and a half years um that's a little bit concerning uh I think we could do a little bit better with uh you know increasing that Reserve to be a little bit more healthier uh we have been working closely with the finance committee and we will be putting out a reserve plan to some new suggestions on where we could increase that fund a little bit teachers retirement Reserve this is for the contri employee contributions for instructional staff uh and this is fully funded by law this is the most we can put into it at this point um but this wouldn't even fund one year of a employer employer contribution for um the retirement system uh last year we paid over $2 million um that so

055that is a little concerning but like I said uh this is fully funded by law we're only allowed to have 10% of the of our our previous year's uh instructional salaries capital reserve uh we did increase this at the end of the year we're at 4.2 that consists of two different Capital uh reserves we have one older one that's at 1.1 million and and a newer one that's at 3 million so with that capital reserve uh we we could do a a project up to about $14 million uh and have no local cost through our state aid so our state aid is is 71% so every time we do a project we get 71% back um so that's we are able to do at least A4 million project I wouldn't recommend uh doing one that

056large it is significant work for a large Capital project like that but a smaller project in the future uh we will be bringing to you guys a small security Capital project in a future budget presentation um well we're still working on that right now so I'm going to jump down to the unassigned fund balance so this is the the uh fund balance that talks about 4% uh so right now uh at the end of June 30th or end of the last school year we were just below 6% uh the by law we're supposed to be at 4% uh again I I'd like to see it be at the 4% I think we can strategically put it into reserves that can be moved if we needed to uh again we will uh come up with some

057recommendations to the board um in a future meeting and finally the assigned fund balance uh which is that 2.5 million that is that that number I was talking about before uh we use that amount of fund balance to balance our budget um so again I I feel like that's a significant number because if we do start bringing that down or using a lot of that we need to fill that fill that amount to be able to get back to where we were so I like to I like to use like a hole right so if we use a a hole to fill our budget I fill it with that $2.5 million all of a sudden next year the hole might get a little bigger and we're starting to use more all of a sudden the

058hole gets so big we can't we're we're we're snowball snowballing out of control um so we would like to see that more at a little bit at 1% a little bit one to 2% uh and we'll be working hard to try to um lower the expenses and stop relying on that as much um that we have in the past um I I know I understand what you're saying obviously on this we've talked about a little bit but in the the last I know let's say say four years I know you haven't been here four years but if you know the answer have we actually had to tap that money I know we're using to balance of budget a paper thing but we haven't dipped into that have we actually actually had transfer to do that

059no uh since I've been here no I I haven't seen that um I believe in the one year I want to say 20 2021 there was we did dip into it a little bit but nothing significant at this point I just want to make sure point to the rest of the board to say that I don't want them to feel like oh my God are we going to be in trouble we don't know what's going to happen going forward with money and everything else but that's why we feel this is a number we can bring down because we haven't had to tap it so if that's the case and let's start our expense savings there before we have to start before cut anything else or do anything like that my question is is there a

060Max on the total fund balance that the school district can carry so in other words from a town and Village perspective if we have too much in fund balance right the state says you either have to lower the levy or lower the the taxes or you have to use that money for capital projects does the school district governed by the same token so the only thing that they have by law is that Underside and fund balance they they they give you recommendations but they won't put anything in in in writing saying hey you can only have you know 10% or 15% there is nothing there um what what I like to do is really have a robust uh Reserve plan that is approved by the board every year so it's we're being as transparent as

061possible about why we have these reserves and what we we plan to have them for so I think if it the com controller has uh comes and audits us and says hey you have we feel like you have too much fund balance uh well we sat with the finance committee and we sat with the board and explained why and they are realizing and they approved us having it and reasons why so it's a good defense if if someone comes knocking because if we had a $50 million budget we had 25 million in fund balance to me it seems like it's too much fund balance right yeah I understand that's but that's the the local thinking that I'm coming from oh it's a good question it's a great question thank you for that y seems like

062a lot there any other questions on uh fund balance or reserves so this is a breakdown of a revenues and expense over uh the last uh see uh maybe 19 years um you can see generally for the most part our revenues have been higher than as expenses so Matt this might be a good answer to your question um for the most part our revenues have been more than our expenses but there are some a few years where they haven't been um a concerning part to this is how low back in 2007 2008 our fund balances was that's scary if you're looking at $30 million budgets back then and you have less than 10 million dollar in reserve that that's an issue it's an issue on many levels if if you know it affects cash flow

063it affects um if we go out for financing affects a lot of different things um you go ahead Matt okay but even in this case it looks like 202 or 23 our expenses were greater than our Revenue but we still didn't have to tap that 250 so we had it's like pretty close there yeah this is only looking at general fund that could have been a uh increase in um federal aid as well yeah all right thanks so I do want to point out that uh it was a steady climb but we are starting to reduce the fund balance because we do believe we at one point had a little bit more than than we needed and we're scaling back on on the our fund balance so next we're going to go through the tax

064levy uh this is I like to start off with the historical tax Levy uh percentages uh and you can see the green is uh what our limit was and uh the yellow bars are what our actuals went out with um so the again the Liv uh the green bars are what we could have went out with uh and the yellow ones are what we actually went out with so please notice in 2122 uh we went out at zero uh but we could went up uh 2.53 uh this has a a an effect on future t tax levy calculations and I'll get into that a little bit in the future um we do kind of do a little bit of ups and downs I like to see steady uh right around 2% increases as much as

065possible um because the dips uh you know the the hills and dips really have an effect on taxpayers I like to see small increases and not you know big increases and not as much increases so in the future we'll we'll try to do our best uh to try to keep it steady um but some things are sometimes out of our control and we need to look at raising local um local funds a little bit more so that you you will see that there's that in 25 26 there is an amount in there that is the um early number that through our calculation is definitely not a final number yet so this is the uh preliminary tax levy limit or cap um again this is very early there's still some numbers that we do not have

066but I like to give you guys a ballpark on where we expect to be um as most people here know that our taxes are not capped at 2% like some people may think it's actually a complex calculation um couple things I I like to point out is that CPI is is at is Max at 2% this year uh the inflation Factor was at 2.95% so the highest that we're allowed to go out is at 2% and in this in this calculation couple other things um to point out that has a kind of a factor on it the first part of this calculation as I mentioned before is the previous year's tax levy so if you were to go at a lower level that has effects on everything below it and in the future years so

067really looking at what to go out doesn't just have an effect on the current year has effect on future years and I'll get a little bit into that later on another key one especially in a district like this is the pilots so you'll see that the prior year Pilots are added back on in the pre in the um the previous years previous years are added back on and the current years are added into this so that that has an a large effect and we're going to see one of these larger uh Pilots coming on in the future as in next year and this could it really has an effect on these tax levy calculations because it's going to possibly put us in a negative so it's we we are in the future not going to

068be able to go we actually have to might have to decrease our tax taxes if if we don't go over and again I'll go into that a little bit uh in the future and future slides so right now with the current information we have and I I don't expect it to swing that much uh we're looking at a tax levy uh limit and this is the highest we could go out of uh 3 0.13% or 886 th000 again this is early this is not final numbers um but this is around I expect it to be around this number any questions on on that so this is going into a little bit about where if if you don't go at the max at your tax levy how it affects future years and again I apologize the

069numbers a little bit small for people that don't have it in front of you um but if you look I went back to about uh 17 18 school year where um we we went at the limit but there's there's one year I think believe uh 201920 that we went out zero and that really had an effect that bottom line where it says difference between that money added up here is where we could have been at our tax levy so if if we were to go at higher amount we we would we we could have uh been up by $2.6 million at this point I know it's very important to be fiscally responsible when we're deciding on on taxing the community but we really need to think about future especially with the talk of people reducing

070state aid uh and being able to tax at a higher number if we need to any questions on that all right so this I always like to do this this year and again this is a very it's an estimate because we we're using assessment values uh and um assessment values for last year but this is what the increase would be for $100,000 house uh if we were to go out at that 3.13% uh and again you'll see that the there's different like new Baltimore has a much higher rate uh and what that is because they haven't done a reassessment in many years so a lot of the values in in that Community are much lower than um what the market value is so what the state does they put it as Equalization rates and these

071Equalization rates will change the individual's rates to make it a little bit more even so it does look like that it is significantly higher than the most the rest but you got to remember those houses are assessed at much lower so for example if you had a a house that the market value was $300,000 but the assessment was only 100 because no one's reassessed it in many years you're really not paying your full share so this is the way that the the state comes in and gives Equalization rates to to uh even it out I see what you're saying yeah well we I it wouldn't be that significant because the generally it's pretty close because what we're only asking for a certain amount of money so $28 million so and then it's divided out by

072you know the number of people to assess so Bethlehem would have a certain amount and quean would have a certain amount so it would definitely wouldn't be that significant if they were all at 100% so we wanted to try to see how this was affecting the community as a whole um so one of your board members went to a uh board training and one of the business officials there used this in their in their presentation to to them and I think this is this is great and what this is showing is the First Column is the full value of District property so that if you took all the assessments of all the build all the all the uh property in our district that would be the number uh and then we take our tax levy

073and we do a percentage comparison of them so if you were to every time you increase your tax levy and the property values and if you had a high high percentage that means we were we would be stressing our economy uh yeah there's different there's different things some people individually might have a little different a different experience but what this is showing is the economy as a whole is not having a large effect on the the overall District so our tax Lev even though we're increasing every year the percentages are actually decreasing so we're seeing less of effect on the economy of the whole of the district so this is this is really good to see and and the next next kind of uh chart does very something very similar but it uses AGI which

074is adjust to gross income and it it's the same kind of concept we're looking at the overall income of the district uh household incomes of the district and we see again how it's increasing our tax levy but it has a it's actually decreasing the percentage of the impact so this is showing that we're not we are not hurting our tax base as a whole so this is good to see and this is I think this is an awesome two graphs to look at to kind of see the health of our economy of the the the area around us and how our tax levy impacts that so projected uh tax levy uh so now we we talked about the the past and now I'm going to go into the future a little bit so you'll see

075that one uh point 13% increase that is what we're estimating for next year um you also notice in uh 2627 that we're seeing that 1.47% decrease uh so what is happening next year is we we are going to be receiving a $1.2 million pilot um there is a gas line coming from electrical line or electric line coming from Canada down to New York City and they are doing a lot of work uh around this area so we we are are due to get a a pilot for that $ 1.2 million and that's going to increase for about 30 years so it is a great um revenue for the district it's it's a lot of money so but what that does is that has a negative impact on our tax levy limit so what that does

076is actually adding that on when you do the calculation actually puts our our limit in a negative so that means we the highest we could go out is 1.47% lower than we're going out this year so like I mentioned before that's going to have some impacts on future Levy calculations and future ways to be able to ra raise local funds so what what I'm proposing and this is just a first conversation and if something where we're going to really have to do some some talking about the situation is I'm I'm going to uh suggest that we go out at zero next year and what that means is we're going to go above the cap um and we're GNA we would need a 60% vote on that and I think it's very important to take into

077account future levies because if we do take it the decrease it really will have a a lasting effect on our ability to raise funds in the future uh again this isn't something we need to discuss now but I wanted to put it in front of you to know that this is something we will be discussing um down the line in the future so you're saying that the pilot is 1.2 million per year yeah so it's years it actually escalates so it does get more but for 30 years we're going to continue to get this pilot absolutely and then do you know the rate at which it increased uh I don't know off the top of my head no I'm will that impact the project like the tax levy as well like does it so the

078way it works is once it's only really going to affect the first year it comes on and the last year it comes off right because you add in you take off previous ones and you add in the ones that are coming in the next year so really it only affects it the one year that it comes on because you're only going to see a small increase year-over-year okay so there's not a big swing one way or another so it's not going to be a significant amount it's not going to jump to like 2.2 or anything so I think Dr Bailey just said at at the end of the 30 years it was oh 60,000 per year increase increases 6 okay yep so that the 60,000 after the initial year will not have a large impact

079on some of the tax levy calculation but it is I just wasn't sure if it was like a flexible number but that sounds like it's a yeah it's a pretty steady number yeah so it is it don't get me wrong it is a great thing for our district to be receiving that kind of money uh and it's what's a little disingenuous about the chart and Jenny's asking good questions you see the one point negative 1.47 in 2027 when we go to 3.06 in the following year that's actually only 1.5% of this year or this coming year so it doesn't bounce all the way back up to above the line it's just happens to be 3.6% higher than negative 1.47 um so that if you were to look at it more linearly it would be more

080of a gradual Rec it's also projected because you're suggesting potentially that we go out at zero right yes this is projected using that negative number yes absolutely yep uh but Dr Bailey made a great point that it we we were trying to stay that steady amount do we have a question if we go out at less than 3.13% this year what does that do to the negative next year it it makes it more negative next year yeah Okay negative because that pile is not changing and we're just G to have less money that's a great Point Mike and if we're if we go out at zero next year what is that 3% will actually be lower do we know how much not off the top of my head it's too early to really I I

081could give you if the board would like I don't have those numbers in front of me but I think definitely there's going to be more discussion about exactly what we're going to see and um what we expect I'm really hoping to see uh the state aid get a little bit more predictable once we have that it will it give us the ability to make a much better decision about our local you know tax stuff so is it potential that state aid will become more regular like you're saying okay if you know that answer let me know I just I just wasn't sure if that was a realistic hope or you just it's a hope it's a hope okay follow the other that's probably going to happen in 27 is we know there's gonna be changes

082in fixes Foundation Aid you know which is the main thing she's already pledged it won't happen whatever is going to happen and be changed won't be affecting us in 25 26 but it probably will go in 20 so you're gonna have for one big factor for the state with the change in Foundation Aid whatever happens and then for us locally we're going to have that issue on top of it so yeah it's hard to say now how that's going to mesh but yeah that's a the second part work there's a lot going on but I wanted to let you know that this is definitely going to be a future conversation uh there'll be a lot more presentations around it when we have more information um but I do want to put it in front of

083you that it is definitely a concern uh for the next uh next year's budget conversation any other questions on that so finally I I wanted to do I'm I'm doing a projection out for the next five years and what what this graph shows is the blue blue is uh Revenue amount uh and the green is expense uh I did some projections the farther the farther you get out um the more projections they are um the first few years have some actual numbers in it um we do have some you know estimates where state aid will be some estimates based on that graph where we believe our local ly will be but what what I'm seeing now if we continually to um use we budget with a deficit um we will see our fund balance decrease

084significantly in in the next five years uh it's definitely concerning um the only real way to stop that is to either reduce expenses or increase Revenue uh and we really don't have a lot of control over the state aid uh some of the expense driven AIDS we do but um we're kind of stuck at the foundation calculation um so the only other way to raise revenue is raise taxes and I told you the complex nature of that um so right now I I will be giving a a future presentation and our fiveyear plan getting into a little bit more detail but I think this is very telling about some of the future um expectations uh we could see in the future if we don't do a little bit of changing yeah the mic was off

085um I know we talked about in the finance committee meeting also just looking the further you go you go out the variant starts coming further apart so there's projections but I think looking I think we have to take a good hard look from the the top all the way down on on every department on what we're doing what is are we getting the return what is working what is not working because um if we're still spending money on things that we're not getting the return that we want it'd be foolish to keep spending that money so I think we have to look take a good hard look on what's working what's not working are there cuts that can be made uh I'm not saying in staff wise I'm saying other cuts that could be made

086in and things that we're doing and how we're spending money because I I looking at this it's it's a very concerning downward Trend yes I mean there there are some projections on here and I will admit that my projection for the the next year was at uh 1% for our state aid and and I'll show you in a second it's significantly higher than that which is great news so that that alone pushes some of this out um but it could very well go the other direction where you know my projections were not as good but you're absolutely right Ed and I think we do that all the time I think we're always looking at things to be if they're working or not and um is it worth investing or not so any other questions on

087that and I I promise I'll finish up here um so finally uh we did get some numbers uh from the governor uh and I am happy to say that um I was wrong with my projection and uh looks like right as of right now this is in final uh we're looking at a foundation Aid increase which is again our our largest driver of $1.2 million or or 8.86% increase from last year um that is significantly higher than what I was expecting uh I do not have any backup for the reason why of this increase um so once I do get that in a future presentation I will give you a little bit more information on it but that was a great number to see Dr ba called me very excited to see that number so

088um it's gonna you know I was I was at 1% I was hoping for 1% so seeing that kind of number is great I think it's going to be a great uh thing for our district uh the other ones uh on here are expense driven AIDS uh nothing really really change much of that these are they're very high estimated numbers we put numbers in estimated at the end of the school year for this current year so I will be giving adjustments to those numbers um in the future presentations but I did want to make sure that you guys are aware that we are looking at a significant increase in our foundation aid for next year board with other districts uh I didn't get a chance to go through a lot of them I did notice

089that I think it was a minimum increase of 2% for all district okay hopefully it's not some type of error and that would be I well again you're right because this is not final this is just her proposal so the legislature could change it right uh I haven't seen significant change unless there's some kind of you know pandemic or something like that happening so uh I haven't seen significant changes um from uh executive budget to you know final budget um so I'm I'm very excited about this so generally I would just say with that too two things one usually like when it gets to the legislature if anything it goes up usually but you never quite know yeah and I and I really think what's Happening Here is we have the state has excess of

090money right now they didn't want to put it in rainy day fund which I think is silly but um they're put in a lot of different places including the schools because I think this is the last big bump we're going to see anywhere and then as you see those Foundation a changes is going to be flat for I don't know how long I'd say at least two or three years after this one you're going to see a lot of flat flat numbers so and so this is probably just to get us to a place that maybe you know just pump us up a little bit before they cut us off yeah I hope you're wrong but uh I I think probably right all of our all of our funds gu this before but just to

091refresh my memory those are all interest earning accounts yes absolutely the unassigned fund balance all the individual yeah so any cash we have on hand so you know after our tax season there's a large amount in our um our bank account we do have two different accounts we have an operating account basically that's with kasaki uh and then we have another account that's within uh it's called New York class it's a little bit different and that New York class one has a much higher uh interest rate than kasaki does uh they hold aot a lot more of our money okay good so we're we're getting competitive interest rates on on New York class yeah okay good uh so that's all I have tonight uh any other questions no thank you all right thanks a lot

092guys all right that's it it I never really opened it so yeah

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.