CorpusRecord 235928

December 11, 2024 Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Ravena-Coeymans-Selkirk Central School District
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Albany County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,719 words · about 77 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening 602 we'll call to order a regular meeting of the Board of Education let's please stand for the pledge pledge United States of America to the Republic for which it stands na indivisible liy and Justice so do we have any last minute additions or deletions to the agenda okay thank you is there a motion to accept the minutes of the November 6th meeting Jackie second Jenny all in favor I I is there a mo could I have a motion at this time to enter into executive session to discuss the employment of a particular person Jenny second Jackie all in favor I all right next uh we have a special presentation tonight from Jennifer Murphy on the fall sports program welcome Jen good evening everyone thank you for having me this evening just at if

002this goes till 6:25 we'll need to take a break to head down to the auditorium for the word ceremony of course yep no problem yeah thanks thank you thank you for the opportunity again to share with you this evening I know the Board of Education and the public have had the my presentation um so again we won't read every slide but we'll just um highlight the focus you know a few Focus points from our teams and our our program this evening just a reminder more in-depth information will be available in our fall Sports wrap-up article which will be shared uh Michelle Ki assisted me again and that will be shared before the end of the week fall Sports in review we had 295 student athletes participate on eight uh different sports teams that we offer

003here at RCS which actually total to 20 teams starting with girls varsity soccer in addition I just wanted to mention that we just received the section to class A Allstar list in addition to the Colonial Council Allstars so I wanted to recognize Katie mcfar and hati wolf sorry Hayden wolf and Maddie Wilcox uh Madison was also selected as the class a section 2 goalkeeper of the year I also wanted to mention girls modified soccer had an undefeated season this fall again I just wanted to highlight an additional recognition Katie mcfarren scored her 100th career goal this fall in her senior season she scored that goal at away at lansingberg so we were able to recognize her at home on the CHF her own home field um with some flowers and a game ball boys varsity

004soccer girls varsity tennis boys varsity golf I also wanted to recognize senior Aurora Wagner she was the only female on all of the all boys Colonial Council golf teams this fall and she contributed to the success of the program she's also a tremendous student girls varsity swimming and Diving not for girls not for girls okay Greenville I will highlight that um our our girl swim team does an excellent job always doing either a bonding event or Community Service uh this fall they participated in the walk to and Alzheimer's at Sienna College and raised over $100 towards the cost boys and girls varsity cross country cross country have we had the opportunity I know I say the numbers are going up which is great it's always tough to get kids out for that are they Fielding

005enough kids to to get team scores right now they have enough for complete teams for our LEL for for the girls not for the boys not for the boys yes okay thank you you're welcome girls varsity volleyball again they hosted their annual go green tournament to benefit the Leukemia and Lymphoma Society and I also wanted to mention the girls modified team also had an undefeated season for volleyball girls varsity cheer boys varsity football just highlighting again they were reinfor division Champions they had seven first team student athlete Allstars for their division so there's different divisions within each class so that's just one side of the the bracket okay and again we have our New York State Public High School Athletic Association scholar athlete teams this is 75% of the roster has an average of 90

006or above so these teams were all recognized we do get recognized on the Nisa website for those teams the schools and the coaches also receive certificates for the scholar athlete teams and the individual students that have a 90 or above average will receive a Nisa scholar athlete how many fall teams are there was that the first slide I missed that there is total teams that we had I had 20 total teams and then eight different sports or eight Varsity Sports eight eight varsity teams yes okay so we did seven out of eight really yes because we were missing yeah but but still that's pretty impressive that almost all of our teams are getting that academic award yes so our athletes are doing the class work too it's great absolutely it's excellent thank you goals for

007next fall of the app like the merge programs or is it just like an ongoing kind of sure I was going to mention that Jenny okay um specifically um we are in the middle of obviously the winter season and we have our first first merge program for the boys varsity swim team with Greenville we have one student athlete from Greenville so he's very excited and his family is very thrilled to have that opportunity uh we are going to revisit that conversation with uh Greenville in the fall for girls varsity swimming and Diving and possibly Kaki Athens as well I know those were the two initial teams that we had um discussed last fall so we're going to revisit that over the summer for next fall well cook saki Athens for swimming as well yes Jen

008the yes the increased online presence sure what steps are we taking there um Michelle KY and I are just trying to work together and trying to gather the information from the coaches if the teams or certain athletes are doing a specific you know something really positive for the community or if they receive a certain achievement we want to do a better job of pushing that out there with CL in social media so for for Katie's 100th goal we put something out um for The Undefeated seasons for modified for girls soccer and for girls volleyball things were put out so we want to continue to to do more throughout the year instead of just our fall Sports and season wrap-up articles we'd like to continue to gather that information and get as much recognition out to

009our community as we can yeah okay thanks association's helping a little bit with some of that right we're doing senior banners now last two or three seasons is a newer thing so they get the big banners for every sport so they play three Sports they get three banners they get to take them afterwards which they really like yeah that's great just wrapping up I wanted to again thank all of our coaches our families our administrative team our board of education for their support and of course I wanted to thank our Sports Association as well for everything that they do you know running the concession stands just supporting our athletes uh equipment needs and definitely the senior banners that our students receive at the end of the season on senior nights and I know our fall

010sport athlete senior Banners are hanging in the gym so please feel free to pop down and take a feek they really are beautiful so I wanted to thank everybody for their help with those if you have any other questions no thank you thank you everyone all right looking at the time right now it's 6:22 so I think it makes sense now to take a break head down to the auditorium and we'll be back after the award ceremony all right 7:02 we're back on we are now on to the business considerations this evening we have 61 through 612 is there a motion for one or more motion for all motion for all all Ed second Matt just like to First note here that we have two donations this evening we have one from sadic thank you

011very much for $2,000 to be split among the four buildings and then we have a donation from the aw deer PTA $220,000 uh for new playground equipment that's fantastic thank you very much p uh do we have any discussion on the items tonight I do yeah um can you explain to me what 6.8 is the stipulation of settlement and order yes so uh there's a more of a detailed if you look uh if you go down this a detailed exactly what happen so so what that is is uh when a taxpayer or company has an assessment uh that they're challenging okay so they're able to challenge their tax what's on their property um this Albany water board challenge what they were paying for taxes and uh what happened was they the courts gave them um

012a portion of what they were asking for okay so it wasn't anywhere near what they were asking for very small it was a very small yeah we were very fortunate what happen when uh when any entity is successful at it they uh pay less which everyone is entitled to of course they pay less and everyone else in the community fills the Gap they had asked for over $8 million in relief and they were only awarded a million in change so it's not great but it could have been a lot worse so we're grateful that at least U it was significantly reduced so yep right also challenge to okay and then I assume that the 6.8 6.9 is just a transfer yeah that is to pay for that amount well we do when we see those

013we get heads up that the motion has been filed um so we we try to put some money in our reserves okay uh to offset that uh once we get the final calculation I'm going to ask the board to um take the remainder of money out of that Reserve because it was no longer needed so is this going to happen again or was this a onetime thing and now it's going to be corrected uh I right now they don't have any other court things but I'm sure they will do it again in the future what do they what does the what do they have like what property do they have do we own all the property around the AL pres Bo okay okay so they got a whole bunch of Acres okay and it's a

014it has an assessment attached to it some big number and they challenge it every year oh so they're likely to challenge it again yeah oh yeah oh yeah yeah and when he challenges every year they go back three years the current year and the two previous years but it's not only these guys yeah it it could be anybody in town anybody could do it well yeah I mean business in town any this is this one's significant that's why it was brought so I don't okay and again there's some more detail below that if if you want how we got to that point okay thank you very much I just wanted else yeah 611 y um I'm just wanted to thank the administration it something that came through in my other role as County legislator I'm

015sure they got it sent to in Fr the county but I'm glad we got something in and actually this is the first time I'm seeing we actually got awarded something so even better yeah we didn't get the contracts that contract yeah so that's great that we're getting money for anti-bullying programs through the county so will this money just be used for any anti-bullying programs that we choose to participate in yeah they had to put a was specific in our grant we actually asked for about double that so we have to figure out where we're going to divide the money up so do we have a program that we're planning to use for that purpose yep okay okay cool any other questions or discussion all right all in favor I I hi Personnel considerations we have

01661 through 634 is there a motion for one or more 71 through 734 sorry is there a motion for one or more yeah I would like to make a motion on through 724 but hold out 712 for for further discussion I believe we have 34 total tonight we have 34 total tonight what did I just say you said 1 through 24 7 point 71 through 724 do you mean 71 through 734 it is very small right okay for all 34 okay except for 7 .12 is that it now and um we're not going to move the table it we're just move um to postpone it for the time current motion just right now is 1 through 34 excluding 7.12 second second okay any discussion I I have one question yeah I just noticed I didn't

017ask earlier is it a change Dr B that in terms of putting all the like approving the shaon I don't remember ever approving shaon on board agenda is that something that we started doing more recently or because it's a contractual thing so we actually have gotten a lot more efficient at trying to post every job you're right exactly we would we send out emails or we do other ways to invite people to do things so we are now trying to close the circle you see the postings on the right hand side we've never posted before so when we fill a posting we try and follow through by putting what we doing that like for football games and everything else because he's it's like every football game is a chaperon and is this just for is

018this for the non sports things it looks like it's for this one looks like the non non-athletic ones right but we just had a discussion today about ensuring that all of them are okay because the other component is um they have to be if they have to be employees of the district that's relevant too yeah and um it's really with the board authority that we're again not against that just is Chang and I didn't know I didn't see any the sports so is a new changes that we're going to be addressing going forward that sufficient yes okay it the whole thing is everything should begin with a posting and with an appointment got it getting in that moving in that direction got it okay anything else all in favor I I so we have left

019for Action 712 is there a motion in relation to 712 do we have to motion before we can discuss it yes I yeah i' 712 I'd like to postpone okay postpone until until we have more information okay for the time being would you like to postpone it until the next meeting till the next to next and hopefully the next meeting we you know prior to that we'll have the information that we need okay so we have a motion to postpone until the next meeting which I believe is January 8th is there a second second second all right any discussion can I ask my questions now or no yeah okay how is that different than his current role I I don't know what his specific job title is but I thought he was serving that purpose

020and I didn't know what the difference between the role in that position so the role is instructional coach and transition coordinator okay um and which a lot of that work h i mean most of that work does happen during the school day because the coach positions are teacher positions they have to their job responsibilities have to fall within the school day a lot of the transition coordination that happens with families with outside agencies happen after 2:45 um so evening events coordinating families meeting with families helping them navigate the world of um what is available to them outside of school once they graduate um so this was a for my understanding and my research this was a stipended position prior to this position going into place um a a teacher was paid a stien to do

021this work because it was outside of the school day with I believe there was a portion of release time and a send for the teacher who was doing the work at the time one class period and a stipend I think so yeah is this only middle school do we have a high school elementary ones as well transition really the transition coordination really happens I mean it begins at age 14 but then it needs to really kind of ramp up as students are getting ready to exit um and it's we talking about I'm sorry we're talking about exiting special special education yes yes sorry I should have clarified that yes make sure everybody knows yeah that makes a difference so there's the high school one then too they would be doing that it's it's mostly focused

022on high school because the TR those transition services are for students who are exiting High School right so there's so there's only he just happens to be in the middle school but that there's only one his his position is secondary instructional coach for special education so it impacts Middle School through high school that's his instructional Coach position the transition coordination is for mostly for high school students okay it just said middle school that's why I was confused on on the do Middle School oh that's where his home base is yeah okay that's all that's saying thank you good question when did his title or or duties move from middle school um instructional coach to um transition coordinator transitional coordinator for um student support services this the position has always been secondary instructional coach for special

023education and transition coordinator it was originally posted as that it was posted shortly before I arrived he was appointed I think maybe at the same meeting I was um so the position has been the same the job description has been the same since he was appointed did he have a role here before that position he was a special education teacher at Peter B okay oh couple more sorry so facing what you said so before I'm trying to remember because again I would have been I forget this one it's a newer one I think it was the covid or postco kind of position I don't think we had this previously but I recall but um so we saying it was it was um part of the job and it was release time so is there still

024release time and now it's sement as well or is just place of the releas time the full-time position is instructional Co secondary instructional coach specifically for special special education and transition coordinator for students who are exiting high school it's has always contained all the work the the part that wasn't captured when the person got the job is that some of the work happens outside of the day so they still release time and then the after that's just understanding they're a teacher and special assignment yeah yeah and then so so so you're talking about instructional coach for special educ right yes but what he's doing is [Music] chairing CSC meetings anyone in the district can huh anyone in the district can yeah and it's freeing Colleen up so she can do some of the great work

025that she's put out in the last um six months or whatever eight months what I I mean it's it's just been great for her but this guy is an instructional coach that is now chairing these meetings and these meetings go on and on and on I mean as we've heard from Colleen and Kate over the last couple of years that once these meetings start there's no stopping them until the end of the school year so that that's what this guy's doing he's not instructionally coaching anybody in Special Ed I'm uh I'm not comfortable talking about the individual we would gladly give you the job description for the position I think that would be a good discuss a basic discussion for us because it would entail all the things that you're talking about Mike that it

026shows from from suuts what might happen from U September to really what is September because the position also has summer days where there's training and planning um as well so I think that would be the most important thing if we saw that we'd be able to have a richer conversation so I think the best way to handle this right now we have a a motion to postpone on the table uh if there's additional information that you're looking for or anyone is looking for in relation to this item before the next meeting uh please send it to me uh Dr Bailey both of us and we can collect that information if the motion carries this will be pushed over to the next we the grant funding part how long that lasts grant funding later I think

027yeah the grant funding is that one year Grant is a three-year Grant it's Ida Grant so it's we get it every year it's it's like a title one kind of something a special ed version yeah okay yeah if there if there's more specifics about the position itself and the duties and former duties and that's best handled off offline in advance of the next meeting if the motion doesn't carry and you know the motion to postpone is denied then we have to act on it otherwise tonight so unless there's anything further I'd recommend we go offline with additional questions we can put it to a vote uh whether the motion carries or not to postpone so all in favor of postponing I I I okay okay that brings us to you Dr B so you have

028a copy of the budget calendar draft budget calendar in front of you Jesse has done an excellent job of trying to take our Concepts and trying to commit it to print one of the ideas that we had had that I I mentioned to the board I believe um either at the last meeting or in between when I sent this draft out is we currently have two board meetings scheduled January February March April and May um what Jesse and I had suggested is that the second meeting in January February and March become just workshops what that allows us to do is we come in there is an informal agenda it's just discussion about budget presentations dialogue we're not really uh we're not making decisions about the budget until all the way into April we're just gathering

029information so we thought it would be time appropriate to do meeting Workshop meeting Workshop meeting workshop and then when we get to April we will go back to our two meeting J Fe yeah when we go back to April we'd go back to two meetings a month um but we were curious about your input on that and we did you notice that they're colorcoded when you're supposed to show up the gray ones are the ones where you're physically supposed to be here the gray ones are the ones where you're physically supposed to be here that was one of the suggestions last time it was an awful lot to look at so you can just yeah focus on the gray only thing i' like to point out there is one we did try to organize it

030in a way where we weren't doing budget presentations during a board meeting uh but unfortunately there was one meeting that we would like to do the building grounds it transportation and cafeteria presentations uh that is uh 312 but all the other ones would be off um off board meeting days just budget workshops I we talked previously about you know what kind of information you guys had asked and we had offered some of the things we're looking for when will that kind of stuff be coming to us as we do these we'll get it ahead of time so we have time to yeah yeah I mean we we're we're going to try to get them out ahead of time I'm also with more of the finance thing like to have Finance meeting ahead of time because

031to go into a little bit more detail uh I think it's better in a small setting to be able to go through some questions a little bit more d into it a little bit more and look at some of those charts that uh you maybe you and I might like to see but uh might put some other people to sleep yeah I just question where that F fell in here yeah no we'll we'll we'll set up Finance meetings generally we like to do it like a week or two before these so we can get questions out and if it's things that I need to bring up at the board meeting then I will okay than them in case people want to of course the workshops right yeah right comment or ask me questions so okay

032yeah I'm I'm good with what's laid out here anything else oh sorry yes so my turn um last time the uh the board had asked uh about CT enrollment the process by which students um enter the program other selected for the program I did send a a detailed description of that to the board um on the 4th uh knowing that the the most typical things it begins with u the discussion from with counselors and the students at the school level and then visitation to the school in uh 10th grade uh some representatives of CTE come over here also and speak to them in ninth or 10th grade and then students um select the two programs they're interested in we send that list to bosis knowing that we have 72 potential slots and what they send

033back is they collect those numbers from every school district every component school district and then they come back and they say you RCS you only have 10 spots in welding you have five spots in cos ology they tell us how many spots that we have that isn't the way that it used to be um used to be that um they made all the decisions around that but instead it comes back to us and um if the top two also there's a rubric I shared the rubric with you um which covers attendance uh discipline and there's a third one um really it's trying to focus on the employability qualities of the students it isn't heavily weighted on academics you have to be uh have achieved 11th grade status that's the only qualification you don't have to

034be an a student you don't have to be a d student you just have to have achieved a junior status and you have the capacity to graduate in two years and even that is sometimes ref flexible on because if you're in 11th grade status you obviously have the capacity to graduate in two years um so those lists come back to us um and then we know we had eight kids select welding but we only have five slots we're forced to prioritize who gets into that program then we have discussions with well there's your second choice you can or you can't have that and then they we also know what other possible um career paths are available and we would slot them into that there is also a waiting list for each of them the other

035thing that I shared with you is that with the bosis expansion which they are building at record speed uh they broke ground a month ago and it's St slated to be done by September it will open up a significant number of slots so it'll double the cosmetology that they're offering at Albany it'll increase um all they're going to add heavy equipment in alany which we've never had before we've always had to go to burn Knox at har right um so I think we're all agreed that um that will significantly help to relieve the overcrowding areas and they were strategic they chose programs that are constantly over full uh in order to uh create more opportunities for kiddos um and of course also we have started our own in-house CTE programs we're very fortunate to beun

036so students can can leave with a CT credential without ever leaving our school SCH campus uh it is right now um human I'm going to say Humanities Human Services Human Services and Building Systems and uh we're working on a third I thought we were trying to bring in when we B that redid the culinary rooms down here sorry not culinary weren't we supposed to be bringing that trying to bring that to our district again when we did the room down here The Culinary room or were we trying to bring that program here no we we ended up not doing a commercial kitchen that's what we would have needed it was about a half a million dollars to build it here and uh we decided the time that that wasn't the best place to allocate our

037money we did build a beautiful fax room but it's not commercial kitchen level what's the third one genene that we're in pursuit of right now do you remember for CT uh right now we don't have a new a new CTE pathway we are just looking at another um the Seal of Civic Readiness just as a credential okay y um did you have any other questions about the CT all right thank you uh security officer um the board had asked for more information first of all we did update the job description to eliminate anything that looked like they were working during the day we removed things about remove uh attending the students in classrooms sitting with students and lunch that's been removed so it's just what would we extensively see in an evening position uh we

038put out a survey to the public asking um we explained what we were doing because even though we explained what we were doing in this meeting uh there was unquestionably some public stir thinking we were going to get rid of sro's and obviously we we began in our description that we are not getting rid of our sro's we are looking to augment our program with evening security the four responses that we got um were do it um I love this idea someone asked have there been incidents after school there have not been incidents after school that would require security um in the way that we've seen in the media and the news and we never want that to happen that's the reason why we're moving in this direction we we always say that uh a

039perpetrator almost always purposely selects targets that are weak we don't want to be weak and then uh someone else asked why we couldn't use the SRO at the evening events um why would why create another position but we we should consider uh using SRO for that those are the only four comments that we got um from the public um and I I did share with the board between last meeting and now the perspectus on all three possible models the first one being the model that we had suggested uh hiring retired law enforcement or uh certified security officers with um an expected annual salary of about 35,000 which would be under the cap for New York State we had a dialogue around what would happen if the person asked for insurance because it's everyone's right if

040they're a full-time employee which is why we say uh you know retired law enforcement are attractive because most of them have insurance from their service if we were to add insurance to a $35,000 position presume it's between 23 and $28,000 if it's a family plan which puts it with $50,000 Mark in the mid-50s the the benefit of having uh our own employees there exactly that um any of us that have worked in organizations that have their own employees and people that they borrow you always almost always get better service from those that belong to the organization they get the same training they have the same experiences they have access to all the same tools um but it would be between 35 and 55 the uh hiring of of the security company we got quotes from

041them they estimated $49,000 a year to provide someone for the hours that we're speaking of 180 days a year plus overtime and uh they would take care of oh and I'm sorry I left out the training part that same company would be the ones that would help us with training training would be less than $5,000 if we chose to do that we trained our own person if we hired theirs they would train the person obviously they would continue to upate um their skills that price was 49,000 um the one of the weaknesses that we've talked to some other school districts that have used and other businesses that have used outside agencies is there isn't always a guarantee that Jean's going to be here Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday and Friday it could be Jean today and

042tomorrow and then Jesse the following day and then Mike um is there not our employees we don't necessarily have a say that it's the one person who's who's uh here so that may be a tradeoff and then the third option was the AL County Sheriff they estimated $70,000 to add an Al County Sheriff SRO for the second shift and as I mentioned the benefit of that in my communication with you the full force of the almany County Sheriff's Department behind them ongoing training carrying a sidearm di um the uh dialogue that they would have with the day SRO there lots of benefits to that as well um so that's really the full scope of what we're looking at and and Jesse and I been talking in the last month we would recommend that we make

043the effort to try and hire what we were looking for and if we can't find exactly what we're looking for then we go with a different option so not settle not not have someone who's unqualified but to try if we find the right person we hit the $35,000 Mark we will have accomplished something good we ideally we have a Criterion there that they're um former law enforcement which could also include Corrections Officers or they are trained neark State Certified um security officers so we and we're not going to make any movement on this meeting we want to talk to you about it obviously but we we would like to create the position and if we can't fill it then have another discussion about what we do next how many hours would be expected to be

044worked by the second shift um security officer for the 35,000 salary we were estimating 35 to 37 a week Mike we wanted a little overlap during the day so you'd be and in our sro's uh leave here approximately 3 o'clock to go to the elementary schools and we know that's a very hot transition time for students going into Athletics and their clubs after school clubs and things so we estimated approximately 23 to 10 7 and a half hour shift we think that it's possible that we could shave off sometime at the end because the light other than evening events like purposeful like a basketball game we already have a police presence there um the benefit if we went the SRO route uh the benefit right now is they are they give us one SRO for

045free for those evening events the second one we pay overtime for at $74 an hour so uh we had a second SRO here we've taken care of all those overtime matters uh we may even say that with the security officers we have to make a decision on that just the large scale events where we have 400 people here and other things going on in the building we want multiple you know people covering so between 35 and 37 and a we thinking so we touched briefly on it the last time we talked about this um but if we were to go with an indust person um what would our plan be for when that person needs to take a day off we would ask we would hire a substitute too the positive is we almost always

046we attract a pool of candidates and as we mentioned our target audience is retired law enforcement or those in security that they would be willing to go through the same process they would already have training we familiarize them with the district and we'd have a a roster of people who could f fill in when they needed to the other option uh Jess and I talked about is that could be a time when we use a security firm so in other words we have our person on an ongoing basis we know next Thursday someone's going to be out we could actually hire The Firm on narrowly basis to come in and cover I guess I'd be interested also in what that that cost would be you know what that that hourly rate is um and I

047mean as far as as far as as substitutes that means that we would then also need to be handling our own internal training of substitutes if someone's expected to step in so I guess kind of what what would be the the plan there because I mean we can't start off big saying we have these five people and we're going to provide training to all of them but only one of them is actually our employee and the others will be potential substitutes yeah we wouldn't let anybody work until they had gone through some type of onboarding process right okay I have concerns about we would we would potentially have gaps in a a single individual being the agreed the employee of this which makes me slightly more inclined towards using a firm because we would be

048guaranteed that we will always have someone some someone there who is already properly trained even if someone calls out two hours before their shift as opposed to if we were to go with an in-person one and say you know a month and a half after that person start someone gets sick and needs to be out for a week we then have to train someone right now in order to choose a substitute option so I I have concerns about where we would have gaps if we only have a single person as an IND District person which makes me personally lean more towards the idea of having a firm where we are ensured that we always have that coverage and it is someone who has already been properly trained just talk about or see the pros and

049cons one of the the pros about um with the AL County Sheriffs um they're the same two or three two officers that are here all the time the kids know them the staff know them and um going with the outside firm even for security where you could get uh multiple people on multiple days in multiple weeks it may just be filling that shift um so that's a that is a little bit of a concern for me going strictly with an outside firm especially I'm just throwing out out ideas especially when um uh the students get used to seeing the the same people in an authorative role every day um and they have relationships with them and everything and I I get that during the day but this isn't after shift this is this isn't after

050hours this is not someone who's going to be constantly interacting with students they're going to come in contact with them especially uh during Sports Seasons um you know from between 2:30 and and and 4:30 um there's still students in the buildings and walking around so it's just um if it was an employee you have more um a little bit more control but there are downfalls to like you said if someone's out so um i' just like to weigh the pros and cons sure no I I certainly see your point I just I I guess my concerns lean in the opposite direction that's all I um I'm a retired law enforcement Houser you guys all know that I'm retired lieutenant when I retired from that stuff I um got involved with security firms on the outside

051a little bit and I got to tell you there there was a number of them that I got involved with in the capital region they didn't they they they pay their people minimum wage and they don't do a lot of background work on getting them through you know getting them licensed or you know filling in here and filling in there hey look guys when somebody's getting $17 an hour $15 16 what is it 1550 January 1st 1550 or $16 an hour just there's there's no competency there there's no commitment there from them and you can to end up with because I was a contract Security Supervisor for several of these firms and I just know what I saw and and I know what I did and for and and I know what they do they

052charge 49 bucks an hour and they pay the the employee minimum wage or a dollar over and then they've got a obviously Social Security and uh Medicare and and taxes so forth but I I don't know I'd want to be real careful on hiring a private security firm and I don't know which one you guys have talked about you doesn't matter right at the moment we can talk a little bit more um I don't know our own employee if we hire two so that we don't have to put two on all the time just so that one can cover if the other gets sick or one could have a vacation while the other you know it it can work better that way are there any job responsibilities that we anticipate with this job that would

053be beyond the purview of a sheriff's deputy or or could a deputy do everything that we expect here meaning are there certain things spefic to the school district that are beyond their normal scope um we unquestionably wanted customer service directing visitors to the building I don't think that I don't think there's anything uniquely um uniquely that would be adverse to what an Al County Sheriff officer does the it would be a redefining of this type of Sr I mean even they are going to have to help us with the how to land on the right job description because it isn't as you alluded to it's not exactly the same as during the day there'll be a lot of same students every day doing the same activities but it won't be in a classroom in the

054hallway in the cafeteria I was going to say Jackie the other thing that u in in addition to training other staff to be backups Aly County Sheriff if we really wanted or needed to on the days when that happened on short notice we could ask them to provide over time to do the work it's not the perfect plan and I told you the price point mik mik spot almost spot on I think they're $45 $47 an hour to pay security that we would pay and the sheriff would be 74 for our SOS but at least we know we know who the people are they're highly trained and U and and the reason and the reason the sheriff is quoting you $74 an hour it it's it's it's not because he wants more money it's because

055he's given the officers more money and he's given them more retirement and he's given them more health insurance and he's giving them lots of training lots of certification and vacation time and sick leave and it it's for me it's the the price difference isn't huge here between the options no I think that the simplest approach honestly is extending the duties of the sheriff's office we know we have certified police officers who have the most up- toate training equipment uh job dedication right they're committed to the Sheriff's Office the sheriff's office is committed to them if they're assigned here they're committed to the district and they're not even not not to interrupt Mike but it it's not like they're forced on an assignment here they love oh these are desired assignments the yeah the SRO jobs

056they love the SR so the sheriff gets to pick who or one of his captains or whatever gets to pick who he's going to send to RCS and I would say mike um after um after the first time we went through the process uh when we through the process the second time they selected and then they brought three candidates to us we interviewed them so I would anticipate that the same process they would find eligible officers deputies who were willing to do the work and then they would interview with us that's how we ended up with the folks that we had so there's a I I want that that may not be true with other organizations I was going to say that the a security company that we spoke with is one that we've worked

057with in another district and they prove to be reputable that's why we asked them so we had some experience with them but Allied Universal okay no it wasn't okay I think Jenny had a good point last time she or time before she asked about would they have a car or something CU When there's a presence and and people see that with the Aly County Sheriff's the car is going to be there right um that's a plus it's a deterrent and and another factor in my mind what I like about the sheriff's better is in the inv in the event that something happens they can intervene immediately if you have a security person they're going to get on the radio and they're going to call the place to come that first responder right there and and

058and able to act on something and not have to just radio and call um is a big um is a big benefit for me spot on the the SEC security posts that are unarmed they are trained to do nothing but observe and take notes until law enforcement or proper backup gets there so that's something else we got to think about too if they're going to be unarmed people and they're just going to be taking notes observing taking notes time started who was involved and this that whatever it's an entirely different thing than having now um hiring a police retired police officer that could be different and that could be very good but I think I'd be willing to do it for 35,000 a year I don't know and our proposal would be um unarmed at

059this juncture if they were not currently officers if they if they were not currently officers we would select unarmed as an option yeah but if they're retired and and it's within 10 years that they're the their status still holds for for that 10 years after they retire but I mean again that's up for another discussion that's you know I don't know sounds like the sheriff's department maybe we could talk to CRA and just come on man that's i i a couple things U I need a little more time to think more about it too myself just in general but two two things along those lines one is um the SRO program if we're talking about using those officers that's fine but if they're in the role of SRO it's very clear that unless is a

060very immediate like dangerous threat they're not allowed to do any of that physical touchdown so that's an adjustment to the program we have to make for after school and then the other thing that concerns me too being a county guy is every time the sheriff comes to the legislature he talks about how horribly under staffed they are and they can't fill what they're doing now and that's uh they're picking up more and more municipalities that they're covering they cover Albany help Albany they do queman and many other places so I just be concerned if they have enough staff to do it just don't to throw out there but I i' to contemplate myself a little more which one I think is best but just too concerned about those issues I and I would uh in

061all due respect to the Sheriff's Office what would happen is we would likely get one of their best officers they would be here and not on patrol U because for the reason that Mike alluded to this is a very preferential job it's it's and if someone has a interest in doing it this versus the airport yeah it's a question is whether he gives gives it up to us that's the whole question well yeah that's true also but um the thing we have on our side is all of us abide by contractual rules and I think that and I wouldn't try and you know take someone of value from the sheriff's office but I I don't think that we wouldn't be the ones inheriting the problem it would probably exacerbate the pro at there we don't

062want that either but um I think that we be benefit we would benefit if we chose to do that I think one thing that would be wise is uh to I talked about this with the U supervisor in generalities I talked about first about evening security because I wanted to make it clear that Our intention was not to replace the sro's so they knew that what we were trying to do we I talked about what some of the job responsibilities would be and I I said that talking about a deputy would be a component of our discussion what I didn't talk about is all the bullets on the sheet that we talked about before I would want to make sure that they could be and do those things in other words be in a crowd

063at a a football game and then greet people for concerts and then help us make sure the doors are locked interface with members of the community it's it's a little different than SRO so I want want to make sure they could actually do everything that we're expecting um and then I I could come back with that but what other uh questions U might you have that would be valuable before we come back the next time to be able to answer do we have an idea of what we have paid in overtime costs for the second officer that we would avoid if we had the SRO last year oh is it okay all right that that cost yes we paid approximately 3,000 overtime last year is what it says here for certified for the deputies for

064Wheel police officers but that would that would serve to reduce the amount that we right have to pay net to Sheriff's for a third officer because we wouldn't be paying that over time yeah so instead of 70 it would be 60 and and what did you say uh uh Brian that that he'll give us one for free but then the second one we'd have to pay 79 a year for some our um in our SRO agreement it states that they would provide one Deputy for free for evening large scale evening events so a Friday night football game they provide one officer for free the Second Officer and because usually both of our sros go and which is relevant because the students that are there it's their relationship with them is valuable yeah so for one

065of those sros to go and and the sheriff is they're always good Patrol is also always on campus during those large scale events they're out of their cars or they're in their cars so that's a that's been a fortunate thing like like you said Matt they're covering a lot of municipalities we're fortunate to have the the satellite station down here that gives us that extra presence and they're also in our parking lots in the middle of the night and you know in strange times um not necessarily free just part of the contract we have with them that is part of cont I want to make that clear included included what we already get that's part of the include in what we we pay for already okay okay uh and the last thing was uh we

066had our security audit done by NM and um had talked about the results of that at the uh health and safety meeting and the board asked us to find a second firm to do a do the same type of audit from perhaps different perspective we have a appointment with the uh Team from Quest R3 over the December break and uh that's just for them to get to lay of the land and see you know what they may be able to do for us see if they can uh uh address we all talked about finding the holes right finding those areas that might be of weakness to us um I also I had a check with capital region bosis to see if they offer the same service so the only hiccup would be is if Bose

067our bosis Capital Region Bose's offers the service we would have to give first tips to them but either way we know that um we've got we're making some Headway on that um any other piece of it was we asked that we'd have a little bit of time between the first audit and the second one so that we could address some of the concerns from the first audit and I think that um construction is a component of it some of the things that we're going to do for construction but some of those things are already in place so uh a January February 2 audit is a good relevant time and we're we'll talk about that a little bit more at our health and safety meeting next week we're looking with going with a private firm now

068you're but now you're exploring Bose or Quest R3 doing it at the last health and safety meeting we looked at two quotes uh Jesse got um one one quote was reasonable but it was the exact same thing that NM did okay it was there was no value added it was up $9,000 to do the exact same thing the other quote was $45,000 which may have been better but it was $45,000 that sells yeah and it was a company that actually manufactures and sells the equipment they would recommend for us to buy so we we shied away from it we thought that was a not a very good investment um but um the on the plus side Questar and cap reg and bosis have no stake in the game they are not our advisers they don't

069give us um advice on our safety protocols you want someone who isn't doing that to say this looks great and this is not right um and they the both of the bosies work with numerous schools in the Capitol District to ensure that their districtwide safety plans are being actualized so I don't think I think that they they will be um they will offer a good service to us but we'll talk about that at the health and safety meeting as well sorry I can we go back for one minute to 8.6 why is the Alban County Sheriff's donation under FMLA student teacher and comprehensive counseling plan and not under business considerations say it again item 6.8 says notice the board is aware the Alman County Sheriff's donating new books that's a wonderful thing that's great but

070I don't know that that's where that belongs I appreciate their Their donation to us it's a dollar yeah it's a dollar oh okay so if it's under what amount 500 okay perfect thank you um did we've got an FBI headquarters here have we thought about reaching out to one of those guys that may be just retiring that has spent a good chunk of his life or career or her career doing Safety and Security stuff for like you know airports and this and that I mean they're good at what they do and they when trying to quanico that that that that's no joke and I also know the state police have got a few guys that are good um that are higher rankers that are that are you know Tech guys that are that are really

071good at that Mike to your point um I actually when uh Becker was doing their lockdown a month and a half ago I I was up there there were six uh state troopers there one of whom our children happen to grow up and he and I were talking afterward one of his responsibilities is doing an oversight safety audit obviously would be free included what does it matter there would be no charge for them to do the audit it is nowhere near the depth uh the depth that the other companies would be doing is more of an observational audit but I plan on asking them to come in and why not do the walkth through he's in dozens and dozens of schools in the area he has experience with school issues we're going to put the

072third eyes on it too but the outcome will not be uh 25-page report bulleted with all of the suggestions it's more just going to be like I noticed that the front door camera wasn't pointed at a wide enough angle so you could see people standing on the side of the door it's not going to be highly detailed it's just going to be observational stuff um this the state the state police may have someone who is more in-depth than that but I I think truly as many eyes as possible to look at the problem is a huge benefit to us because uh you know we could all look at the same thing and each one of us find something a little bit different that need fixing thank you else Ela yeah thanks all right thanks J

073um so just a couple of things uh we had a board of ed cni meeting the minutes are linked in the agenda back in November on the 14th two things that came out of that um one uh Colleen presented the comprehensive School counseling program so she provided some context for uh the review and process that led to that final document um and I believe that should be updated every two years um so if you want to take a look at that it's in the informational items in um uh 8.1 I think so if you have any questions feel free to reach out about that we also had um Department ccss share out their Department goals that are linked back either to the building or the district goals um and you know they were really helpful

074and some common threads that we saw across them were um everybody needs more time um but really time specifically to address the the skill areas that they've identified as areas of need based on um item analysis from exams and when um assessments from classrooms the other two areas that seem to be very um prominent across their goals were writing across the content areas and vocabulary development which are really it it it was almost like I had planned it um because it's a nice segue into the science of reading work that we are starting to explore and understand as as a school commit as a school uh community so um we didn't get to a couple of the Departments so and I realize I'm always revising my thinking um I try to break it up as

075Elementary and secondary Focus the next two meetings um well we have a meeting next week that will be an elementary Focus then in January we'll have a middle school focus and then in February a high school focus so the folks who didn't get to contribute and share their Department goals can do it at that time um the other thing I wanted two things I wanted to update you on one is uh we started the process of an elementary math resource advisory committee we're looking to adopt a new curriculum resource for math instruction K5 so we started actually back in September and we're working through we're about two-thirds of the way through the process which involved soliciting teachers to be on the committee we have 19 teachers across schools um we have done sort of a

076desk audit of materials and resources they sent um some samples we just went through product presentations um and in January we're going to send teachers out to go visit schools where we can to see some of these products in place um so our will be re making a recommendation about an adoption of a product um and I'll be incorporating that into my budget requests for next year um but where we end up will be shared at the at the board of ed um curriculum instruction committee meeting either in February um and then the last piece I wanted just to um talk to you about last year we did Taps updates the school targets and action plans by trimester so it was December and March and June um given the variability in this year's Taps some

077of them are one-year goals some of them are five-year goals uh we talked as a leadership team and agreed that it probably made most sense um to do an update mid year and then again at the end of the year as far as our progress on those that isn't to say that at the building level they aren't working with their BLTs to look at some some more discrete data about progress and how they're doing but as far as what is front-facing with the community and having stuff on the website so we'd be aiming to have by the end of the second quarter beginning of the first this the spring semester so beginning of February having those updated on the website and that's it thank you you're welcome good can I yes quickly um the board

078of region and the and the commissioner what was it yesterday or or the day before said you know we're hooked on phonic so what do what and it's like and everybody's GNA do this you know so and I'd be happy to do a brief presentation for the board that is a common misconception around the science of reading that it is about phonic it is about a body of research around highquality literacy instruction and what students need in order to develop their literacy skills phonics is a big part of it that seems to be what a lot of folks are hanging on but what they're complaining about is is the memorization thing because they thought that that was how they were going to take care of this and from K or prek through grade four it

079was all done in memorization and then when they got the grade five they couldn't read because they didn't they hadn't memorized these fifth grade sixth grade words they weren't given them and they weren't given away to break it down through phonics so that's what these guys were I couldn't believe it's it's a piece of it there's there's there's a lot more there's a reading and writing connection there's about being able to connect what you're learning to the real world reading is understanding so that you really have to have that development to vocabulary development so so I guess the question that I'm asking is is that going to be considered for our curriculum here in the next school year or we have a we have a robust Ela curriculum and actually we'll be I'll be responsible

080and Brian will have to sign off on it um around our language arts curriculum is aligned with the science of reading so we'll be doing an audit of our existing curriculum right now the the study that we have and I feel very confident B even on the short time that I've worked with the teachers on the work that they've done with that curriculum we're in really good shape and currently the elementary teachers are in a book study around the science of reading and making those shifts small shifts in their curriculum and instruction to align with what is in that body of research that says this is how kids learn to read okay thank you you're welcome yeah I have a lot to say about that but um in 8.7 you have the comprehensive School counseling

081plan yes I'm just asking if you could um in the end of that there's three Maps could I get hard copies of those you yes you can thank you because you I don't have access to printer anymore like not for that many pages I can just let me know when they right I'll stop by and pick something but yeah do you want me just to email them to you oh want that's what a hard copy is J yes I can do that I appreciate that that's it all right thanks Jean Jesse welcome uh I'm going to start off with a playground update uh so Peter B uh has their new swings installed uh we also have the new uh Mulch Rubber Mulch in there uh we're going to leave it as is for now uh

082and then uh over the summer I believe we're going to set it so if you've been there you'll see that the the new structure has this set Rubber and and the new swings have this loose rubbery mulch uh so over the summertime we're going to set that so it's the solid and it gives a nice little protection for for the students there um I don't know if anybody's been over there during these rainstorms but every time I drive by there I I like to look and the draining is working awesome there's no pooling on the surface uh and and Bill mentioned they are going to be working on grading it away from from the play structure so you won't see as many puddles around the structure as well um but they haven't got to that

083to that point yet um aw Becker uh structure the new uh prek one is going to be coming tomorrow so and they will be a installing it immediately following that so the day after they'll be starting that yeah so we're uh yes they're trying to I mean weather pending um they they want to get this done uh as soon as possible so that should be in very soon for just a second absolutely um the the new equipment looks great I'm glad that kids are able to use it can I ask about the one piece of equipment that is still wrapped up in uh like caution tape yeah great question so when they when they installed the swings uh there's a certain radius that needs to be away from other um equipment and that piece of

084equipment is too close to the swings so there are radiuses that where they need to be away from one another um are they're too close they're they're inter interacting with one another so they need to um do make an adjustment with those so that's why they close those one set so so no one can use those so is that set going to be moved and I'm sorry I don't mean to sound a why why wasn't this considered before we installed swings there I I I came I I had the same question okay okay that feels like you would plan ahead of time Bill is following up with the contractor saying what you know where where did we misstep on that because I agree with you I was a little frustrated as well so when will

085they when will they start doing something about they they will be either uh moving it or decide on what they're going to do with it very soon because uh in all of our playground experiences thus far the retailer of the equipment is almost always mared read or or at least on site during the installation so that we're sure that everything is in compliance so we don't have any idea how that particular yeah we we were a little frustrated with it as well so so so then are we just moving that piece of equipment that's that's the conversation that we need to have with the the building uh and the committee to see if that's something where the kids still use it or if it's something we will get rid of but it will be up

086to the committee but there's nothing wrong with that piece of equipment it's just literally the proxity we can't have yeah I understand uh because it's a liability uh so that's why there's nothing structurally wrong with it um but it's for safety reasons we had to close one of them and we we thought that one was the one to close okay thank you yep uh again so the aw Becker will be uh installed and and ready to go here pretty soon um to kind of review some of the the capital project the 155 millionar project uh we had a building grounds meeting today uh couple the High ticket items not a ton going on right now yet um they are working on the roof over the pool um they have been delayed a little bit one

087with weather uh and they had a I believe a safety meeting uh with the whole company for a few days so that kind of delayed the thing but um they should be done here in a few weeks uh there is a little lag with the metal um flashing that goes around it the the order is not in yet for that so it's a little bit delayed from that too so they should be done here with that roof in a few weeks smoke alarm twice yes yeah uh I think it was only once that it set it off but it did yes we had a a long conversation with the bill and I with the construction company about U you know where the things are the dust is coming and all that kind of stuff so

088there shouldn't be any there's no real issue with our system no absolutely not just with how their proximity potentially yeah yeah we shouldn't have any issues going forward okay yep um so a couple other things uh over Christmas B uh break they're going to start doing some abatement work in the Middle School uh they're going to take the univent out and do some abatement behind there and then put them back in uh and also uh December 20th uh they're going to start doing second shift work in the elementary school some plumbering work to get those HVAC uh in the art room and uh the music room so we can get going on that uh I'm I'm being assured sure that that HVAC temperature in those Elementary classrooms will be ready to go at the latest

089uh by the end of April break uh so the increase in temperature you know in May and June and July they those those classrooms should be covered um also winter break uh they're going to start doing some more uh uh UV abatement and replacing some of those units in um in those classrooms um so we all we had a finance committee meeting uh last week uh we did we had a long discussion uh we looked at uh the fund balances and the future targets we'd like to see uh in those fund balances uh I think we had some great discussions um and uh we went through that draft um uh Reserve plan and uh the committee gave some great recommendations I'm going to make some updates to that re uh from those recommendations and I'm

090going to bring it to the board here uh in a few weeks and I will do a presentation explaining on what what we came up with and why we came up with things uh we did have a long discussion and uh the committee brought uh to my attention their concern of using fund balance to balance the budget uh we feel like the 2.5 uh million that we've used in the past is a little bit higher than we' like uh so they we would and and I agree with them that we'd like to lower that to a little bit more more manageable level um to more of a 1 two% or a million to a million five level um I did Express uh with this upcoming budget season uh with Sky rcking expenses and uh not

091a lot of uh state aid expected it's going to be very difficult to lower that but I will do my best to uh make that a priority to uh uh uh decrease that as much as possible um we also discussed just about uh some of the future uh what we see from the district some of the aid that we might expect be getting or where the district will be in five years um I this Reserve plan will be included in a larger five-year uh projection um that I will present first to the finance committee meeting get their input on it and then eventually down the line bring it to the board uh for your approval uh that plan will be a bigger high level um kind of where we see where we see ourselves financially

092uh in the future and some of the concerns that that uh you know I might have uh what what's going on now uh finally uh Transportation uh as some of you might have noticed uh on on your app that we are starting to take digital attendance uh you you will see that uh your student will be getting on the bus at the school and then off at your location uh for the most part the drivers are doing this manually at this point uh we have an order out for swipe cards so all the students will have swiped cards so they'll be able to swipe on and off the buses um and uh we' like to eventually once we get that mastered um kind of do work on something for attendance in and out of the

093building as well so you'll get a uh a way to say you know if you're picking your student up this is be a way to work with that too because other districts are using that as attendance uh process too so uh that is definitely down the line we'd like to master the bus first which we've had some hiccups but I mean the transportation Department's been doing great uh working through those um other thing I'd like to point out I don't know if anybody else was at that queenan's uh Christmas parade but those three those three buses that that transportation did was was amazing um like they went over the top and I think there was seven or eight of our employees on those buses making them out there throwing candy and really being out there

094in the community so um I I was super happy to see that so thank you very much that to um truck they're always they're like always decorating their buses always talking and we've gotten bus drivers because they were out in the community and they've talked to people so I encourage them to go do these things all the time time so thank you very much to Amy and her team that was awesome awesome is there any video that we could I have a video I don't know you might see me yelling at my kids but get out of the road I think Facebook I've seen it all over Facebook the town certainly poed quite a few photos rock and Par in general it was a lot it was it was pretty cool to see so thank

095you very much to the department also p smartly i don't they want to discuss it now but the potential impact of what was called the cirk reserve the affordable housing in Selkirk its effect on Becker in particular but the whole District uh because they're going up very quickly and we think they'll be probably fill up and having there by September and um and it's now what is it called Hudson on N I think they said they Chang the name so if you see Hudson on N is the cell CK Reserve but the impact of that fiscally potentially on the district as well so yep yes we did here important part thanks do you anticipate that the year projections will be available around the time that we're having the budget work I will definitely have yeah

096there's going to be a lower level not this whole packet plan but Absolutely I'll do that with my fiscal um one the first part would absolutely be a form of uh where I see ourselves in five years yep absolutely all right report from was the Rockefeller Institute yeah Foundation Aid Foundation Aid yep and all that I mean none of that has been accepted yes so what Mike is referencing is the the governor um assigned the Rockefeller Center to review our foundation Aid and how it's calculated um and because they wanted to redo it um the the Institute just came out with their report it's a 40-page report uh I I've read through majority of it I've got some summaries from it uh it does have does make a lot of mentions of uh talking about

097hold harmless schools um where they with this calculation um have been getting more money than they should have been because the calculation hasn't been run correctly um they are mentioning things where uh these schools will not be getting funding in the future um they shouldn't be anyways these these are all just informational there's nothing it's the go this is just information for the legislator to make decisions on uh we are not one of those districts we we are still in the formula and what I mean by that is we still get calculations and when we do the calculation we get the amount of money we should be getting um so I don't have a lot of concerns that it will affect us my one big thing that it did when reading through it uh they

098did there was some mention about looking at uh the available fund balance that districts have and that may come into account with the calculation of your uh fund balance I mean our foundation Aid so we we did have a long discussion about that in our finance meeting that we definitely do have con some concerns without that because we are currently right now over that uh 4% un assigned fund balance which is is not um is not uh legal um so we we did discuss about ways that we might be able to move that in the future because because of this concern of us possibly losing uh Foundation Aid so when looking at reports at the end of that study we had a 10% reduction in our population between 2012 and 2022 and in terms of

099the Capital District Schools it's basically the middle of the road there were a very small handful maybe three of the 24 schools in cap reg and bosis who had an increase of some kind and there were schools that had decreases up to 26% um 10% isn't horrible but it's not great and uh the way one of the factors in the foundation Aid formula is student population so as students reduce we get less Aid just like the kind of a myth but how student attendance is directly related to that's why we don't have snow days because if students are here then we get all the money um there's a su truth to as our student population reduces so does the aid that comes from the state um we've been more stable in these past three or

100four years than we have in a while you look at the populations of our elementary schools the high school it's gone back up which is a blessing I think there were 650 in the high school when I came in 2010 and uh we were down to about 500 a few years ago and we're back up into the mid high fives now is it possible I don't know if this has been done but um Mel is saying that some of the construction workers are parking in the student parking and it's creating some issues for the students I don't know if that's been mentioned before or if that's something that can be this is the first time heing of I can definitely look into it though she just said it's causing some of the students to be

101laid or taking others ass signed spots I will find out I don't have any firsthand knowledge I'm just sharing just piggy sorry just a piggyback on where are they supposed to that's fine yeah I mean where are they supposed to so the only only instructional I mean the only area that then that they're taking up at this point is near the the um the pool that's the only area over there so I'm not really sure where she's indicating where the thing is so I just need to do some more research on it yeah I'm No it's it's a good question I'm just curious yeah I mean this is no that's fair they need yeah park somewhere too all right thanks any new business items I have one item to request is there at some point

102can we receive some information on what type of training the bus AIDS are being given when they're on a run with special needs students in case it's creating any issues generally speaking the taas in those classrooms have some level of training to interact with behaviors and uh transportation and change es in those can be upsetting to some individuals and um the reactions can also impact how that proceeds and I wouldn't expect them to know independently because it's certainly not their area of expertise as it would be expected of a teacher in that role um so I would wouldn't want them to be unduly frustrated and and Unsure how to handle the situation right it seem a disservice to them for our training for our deescalation training for this year all the Tas and Bas including

103the bus AES were invited okay I don't know everyone though so I I don't know if and for the full day for sure um being able to have access to that at the beginning of the year um and I don't know if people have come in that missed it like I don't I don't know any of the intricacies of that so if someone did miss it is there some type of remedial is the wrong word but like yeah yeah yeah like a catchup that they could be provided more trainings throughout the years it's not just one training uh I don't know particularly what the training is called or anything like that I can definitely ask Amy uh I know there is some kind of form of of I don't want to say deescalation but um

104working with students I don't know if there's anything specifically for special needs students I will definitely find out I know uh Colleen has come down at our request to help some of the uh monitors that requested it uh it is something it is something that we we uh would like to improve I I will agree with you yeah I just I'm an issue has been expressed to me and I think that I would like to recognize too that the bus AIDS are not or the bus monitors are not trained specifically for those types of interactions and sometimes your gut reaction isn't always and if there's a particular helpful even though you want it to be if there's a particular incident I I would it would be you know let us know when we can definitely

105it's a particular person and they need additional training we're more than happy to make sure that they're adequately trained to do their job so right and I want them to certainly be feel confident in the situation because it's not a comfortable feeling as an employee to be presented with something that you're unsure how to manage and you want to do the right thing but for whatever reason what you picked wasn't the right one you know no absolutely I'm that I'll get some more information for you guys okay thank you all right an old business so we can remove the last two items I also have I'm sorry I have something under new business as well I'm sorry I emailed you guys uh maybe two weeks ago um there was a recent in uh issue with

106one of the Middle School lunch periods um in which the entire lunchroom was assigned to assigned seating for approximately a week maybe a week and a half um personally I saw the direct impact on my own kids mental health he wasn't allowed to sit with his friends for a week during their only time that they're kind of allowed to just socialize and eat their lunch um it definitely had an impact on my kid I understand that a number of other parents also reached out to the Middle School um about this issue so there were a hand from what I understand there were a handful of kids who got in trouble and the resolution was that the entire lunchroom was punished for a week um they were told they'd be allowed to go back to their

107regular seating after Thanksgiving break um I I spoke to the the building administration myself um on behalf of my own child um but also for concern over all of those kids this impacts social emotional issues with kids um it's one of their very few times in middle school that they can just sit and communicate with their friends um as opposed to sitting with whoever they are assigned to sit next to who may in Middle School especially may or may not be people that they speak to um I literally saw the impacts on my child every day when he came home I knew instantly that something was wrong um he came home upset every day he wasn't allowed to see his friends in the only period of the day that he sees his friends um that

108has a serious impact on kids social emotional health and I want to make sure that we are not making wide sweeping punishments when a handful of kids are causing a problem and I understand that specific incident has now been resolved the the building Administration was very um helpful in understanding um but I have concerns over WID sweeping punishments being given to an entire room of kids when a handful of kids are causing the issues can can we speak to this at all can we speak to how this may be happening in in other buildings or in the Middle School in general as far as I know this was only one specific lunch period but it went on for a whole week and um I mean by the time I was able to get in touch

109with the administration we were able to resolve it for one day um in which they they were able to revert back the day before Thanksgiving break to be able to sit with their friends otherwise I think my kid went five days without being allowed to sit next to his friends who he doesn't have any classes with he doesn't otherwise get to to see during the school day this gives me really serious concern has a very serious social impacts on kids and we've had a lot of conversations about social emotional health this is the first parents spoken to me about it I can't comment I don't know about the specific incident I would say from good instructional practice you're your instincts are good um we learned from very early on it isn't usually beneficial to give

110a consequence to an entire group when individuals own we know that as adults right we don't like being held accountable for other people's transgressions so I would say it's not a common practice it's not something that we philosophically would believe in or or do purposefully so I'm glad that your phone call was able to correct it quickly and I'm sorry that that happened oh I mean unfortunately it was not quickly it was after it had happened for a multitude of days no I'm saying they were able to react and take right I know but even you know I I appreciate the response from the administration and I know that they get a lot of questions but it also took more than one email for me to to get a response um and by then it

111had been going on for multiple days and you know like I said I saw the direct impact on my kid but I also understand I'm not the only parent who reached out um so I'd like reassurance that this is definitely communicated to all of the buildings and especially whoever is supervising um lunch periods or the other things like that of what is and is not appropriate punishment for students and that we are not making any wide sweeping punishments of an entire group of kids over a handful of of students those students obviously I those should be directly addressed but that whole class that whole lunchroom was punished for a full week and it also gives me concerned that the administration was not aware of it until parents notified them and you are still not aware

112of it until I am bringing it up here that also raises concern for me um so I want to make sure that that is being communicated back to all of our buildings and all of the people who who are in positions that they could be placing punishments beyond the students who need to be addressed yeah thank you all right we good to move into Old business all right the last two bullet points there Sue uh can be removed we approve the uh sub do we approve the the TA rights tonight or just the teacher is it ta done ta is done okay okay so that's done uh we have the information on CTE student selection so we can remove that uh Gan are the subcommittees still working through the code of conduct review we don't

113have any um I don't have anything on the agenda on my calendar for code of conduct I just made a note to myself to touch B with Jen to see if there's any you know a quick review any changes that are being recommended um we had talked about um updating definitions and making sure that the board policies are updated in the code of conduct so I've been just kind of tracking that progress from the policy committee um but in the meantime I was going to save this because it just happened but um based on the work that we did last year and some feedback from apparent um regarding adasa appeal recently talked about our website um not having a lot of information information so I did some research uh from neighboring districts and around and

114tried to I worked with Michelle kti our communications director and just updated some information so that if someone is wondering about what the process is I mean the link to the regulations is there but also if you do file one here's what you can expect to happen so if you go to the district website and you use the little um magnifying glass type in the word dignity you can see the updates and it also has a link that takes you to board docs to the policy doc MH okay all right we do have a motion under policy review tonight well there there's one thing that's I brought up last time but it didn't make it onto Old business in regards to just a followup because we talked to brought up in the finance committee meeting

115last time it was about budgeting about the like the non-instructional coach job and things like that more information on how are we measuring that what metrics are we using to see if we're getting the return that investment you know I think it was at the elementary so um have we have we pulled the teachers have we found out their direct input if it's something that's useful to them that they're utilizing or not it's great to have but we need to have a way to measure that to justify to make sure that it's what are the results we're looking for and number one what are the metrics and are we getting the results to continue on with something like that sorry I I meant to talk about that so one the instructional coach positions both at

116the elementary and the and the secondary level um what I had planned on doing is because we're talking for the new position we're what four months into into the work that that person is doing um and if you remember last year during the budget presentations Colleen had shared a number of data points as far as contact time with teachers contact time with parents meetings that they were shairing so that same and so and that was for the secondary position so we're in year two um and with the the newer position we will be doing the same thing but what I had done was in order to kind of free up time and we need the time to gather the data I want to I put that on one of our um agendas for Board of

117Ed cni either in the May at the April or the May meeting depending on you know when they can gather the data so I didn't have anything to report out um but it would be the similar kind of categories if you want me to share those sort of touch points I can would there be input directly from the teachers as well I mean I know you're looking at the metrics and you can see the contact time and all that but as far as the the coach are are they are they utilizing it are they reaching out and and and is it beneficial to them that aspect of it so are you suggesting a survey of teachers like did you work with the coach or just number of teachers that worked with the coach because that's

118I mean that's part of what was the data was from last year well was my understanding well maybe I'm I'm my understanding when when we created that position it was going to be available for teachers to reach out to that was going to be a key part of it so how are you measuring that is that happening um whether you survey or or how you do it it's up to you but just so we get feedback from the teachers it is it actually a useful thing if they're not utilizing it and if they're utilizing it infrequently um is that aspect of it you know yeah we're getting the return on it is basically right and um messing about right and and and I think part of we talked and I maybe revisiting the the description

119of the job coach will instructional coach will be helpful too um but one of the things that you think to do about building capacity in a coach over years and we talked about this last year there has to be some level of building trust and understanding and relationships nonevaluative all of those pieces in year two we're really trying to emphasize building in coaching Cycles which is more formalized where the coach is working with a teacher they have identified an area of need they build out targets and they Implement instruction for a limited period of time they do a pre and post test how are kids doing and that kind of coaching cycle is something that could happen over the course of a unit over the course of a couple of weeks um just around particular

120things that teachers want to kind of develop their skill set around but we didn't expect this coach to be able to do the first year to be able to do something like that so we'll be looking at seeing how that has worked in the year two for the secondary coach that's that's those like really in those relationships with teachers where they're working side by side as opposed to walkthroughs identifying good practices offering suggestions those kind of things which are happening all the time okay I just I guess I just I'd have to I'm having a hard time I guess grasping what what this this person was hired for and what we what they were actually going to be doing okay um um just going through all the budgets in every season last year and trying

121to think back because I mean it's a year ago on what the purpose of this coach was um I thought it was more going to be uh working with the teachers right right right from the start um but it doesn't seem like that's happening yet oh no they are it is oh yeah so there there will be some data on on on on um how many interactions how many teachers are utilizing the the uh the assistance of this coach how many teachers are actually reaching out to this coach how many of these teachers feel it's it's a benefit to them or if they feel it's not a benefit right I think those are things that we also need to to know well and I think probably for me the underlying and the critical piece about

122having the coach is the impact on student achievement so we're talking about building those relationships with teachers making sure that they're you know implementing some of the instructional practices the coach is um requesting but then those coaching Cycles really get to this is a group of kids I want to be able to teach them how to do X Y and Z better help me with that let's measure it and then if those things work then those become institutionalized practices in that teachers classroom that's ultimately where you want to get with your coaches as long as there's metrics to measure along the way yeah to because it it's a big expense okay thank you s okay uh we have a uh propose motion here to remove policies certain policies from the current manual 13.1 I'm going

123to ask before so when I make the I'm going to make a motion for it but I'm going to ask that there's one particular policy uh 6411 use of emailing the district um that we pull that out that we are not removing that policy um when we were in the policy committee meeting there was a big list in numbers of of these policies that nisba suggested and uh after I got this sheet I looked at it um I I I think uh email looking at other districts Miss un still has it in there bethleem still has it in there with uses nisba in a in a different section and the board has talked about the use of email in general and which direction we may go so I think that we do not remove that

124policy we keep it as a policy that we could rework so I would ask that we just we take 6411 out of this meaning that we're not removing it from as of right now apy CH we talked this earli so I see I'm with you I'm pulling it out tonight I don't want to say necessar it's staying in I think I want to pull it out so to review it more closely that's what I'm saying we're not we're not taking say we're tonight necessarily it may still come out but not tonight just to clarify yeah well I know if it's the same to keep it in I say we take we take it out so we're not moving tonight so we can look at look at it again and we can we can have the

125discussion the board are saying the same thing correct yes yes it not in the employee handbook now or is it just policy right now it's a policy I think that's why we have to policy it's not it's not P your handbook no we're gonna pull it out tonight so it's not we're not removing it and we're GNA I understand that I'm asking a question it's just policy right now it's not in the employee handbook right it's no it's it's policy it's imp policy it's ridiculous it should have been an employee handbook that in the employee handbook you're you're asking me obscure okay our point is we want to pull it out there's really not an employee handbook there is a faculty handbook so to speak but it's a generic thing because we have a contract

126say still saying we teachers have a contract so there is a handbook that addresses things somewhat I'm not sure it's even in there it has been updated probably I can't tell you last time that handbook has been updated so we'll the point is we just want to look at it and we'll come back to you with it again y the question well is smart taking out is I don't recall what that one says either so it's worth looking at the policy okay so I will motion yes to sue which one would you be good with the current attachment on the agenda and removing the reference to that policy I can put an X and also put in my minutes so we can work off this attachment but we'll just make those modifications okay all right

127so now that it's do I need to make motion to take it out or just to approve you need to make a motion to approve 13.1 and just specify that it will be with the exception of okay make a motion to approve uh 13.1 with the exception of policy number policy number 6411 okay any further discussion all in favor I okay Ted you still awake all right we got a hearing petition from Mr Ted Smith this evening welcome good evening everyone real quick here um just a couple of items here you know I like to uh shout out some of our members for their contributions and I don't know if this was mentioned in another setting or not but I just wanted to note public public L that Brandon herwick was uh recognized as a

128physical education teacher of the year just a week or so ago which is awesome I mean he's got to leave some accolades for the rest of us but he keeps racking them up and he's a credit to our membership in this district and I just wanted to shout out to all the wonderful music that is being made this holiday season by our music uh teachers and all of our students and children uh so just by name that's Kermit Wamsley and Debbie McAllister Casey Capello Dan aler Elizabeth Diaz Emily Warick Chris Dobson and of course Shelley McLaughlin um one other quick note as we start talking about budget stuff um we've talked about this at at a district leadership level and LR level but I just wanted to uh say publicly put in a plug for

129considering that phone Yonder bag kind of policy for our secondary level um we know there's a lot of talk at the state level about getting some sort of uh Bell tobell cell phone restriction in in public schools I'm not sure exactly where that's going to land if there's going to be funds for that kind of a legislation or not but I can tell you that some of our neighboring districts have been just absolutely glowing about the results they're seeing from that kind of policy if you don't know I'm talking about it's like when you just get a little bag you put the phone in it at the beginning of class kids get to keep it with them um but they don't they're not on their phones all the time which really you know eliminates a

130lot of problems just today at middle school there was an issue with a cell phone recording something and it had to be addressed and and all of that stuff and this just takes it away Bethlehem loves the program too as they had the swatting issues earlier in the year when the cell phones were taken out of that equation everything went much more smoothly for that whole uh that whole District so just something to consider as we go through the uh budgeting process to uh see if we've got room we'll go room for that kind of thing if we want to go ahead and do that and um I think that's it so thanks again go back to the PE teacher go back to that did you say he got PE teacher of the year yeah

131for New York State it's um oh I forget what the acronym stands for do you remember Dr Billy we just call it nbg is that physical education Health uh Dance I'm just curious how does he how does he win that or what does he so Brandon was selected for the regional uh award teacher of the year I believe last year yeah and then the winner of all the regional regions and Nic bird is the one that oversees all of those programs I just tried to mention they uh they the people from each of the regions goes into a final selection process and there's a committee that does that and obviously Brandon has been he's extremely active in that organization and in National organizations uh and um he has done an excellent job of keeping RCS

132on the map I think his question was more like how do you is that something that parents or staff Administration Nom you get recommended by someone in your region and then that the regional rep then in turn recommends that person to the National that's how it works in most organizations I presume that's how it worked in this one too but very well deserved yeah yeah very nice be nice for the board to recognize that at some point absolutely he was here at a meeting last week last year we had a big celebration we could do that again or even if it's just a a letter or something that goes to them but I would on behalf of the board like to recognize I think you should come and do a 45 minute presentation and he

133would he would gladly do it he could do with you could all engage in phys activity yes uh he um we did a feature on him on our website uh he was in our news uh our letter to families and staff that went out last week so we did at least we share that with our community I should have mentioned it tonight as well so thank you for doing that Ted let's keep celebrating them yeah that's a great accomplishment yep all right at this point I'm just going to ask for a motion to enter into executive session to discuss the employment of a particular person as well as matters that are confidential under state law motion motion Ed second Matt all in favor I and we'll be taking no further action when we come out

134thank you yeah mat

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.