CorpusRecord 236057

Rome CSD BOE Meeting 1/13/25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Rome City School District
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Oneida County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,821 words · about 83 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001ask everyone to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay we're going to mix the agenda up just a little bit um so after the superintendent report we will have an opportunity for public comment to sign up for public comment please fill out a speaker card they are available over to my right with uh Miss Sandy Russell we ask we ask uh that your comments be limited to 3 minutes additionally any public comment should not include student or staff member names or profanity the Board of Education will listen to your comments but it is our practice not to immediately respond to public comment this affords

002us the opportunity to gather information where necessary and to consult with appropriate District officials if your comment requires follow-up the appropriate School District official will do so as long as you provide your contact information on the speaker card and with that I will start off with a motion to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of December 9th 2024 and the special meeting of January 6 2025 moved by Kirsten second second by Sue all in favor I any opposed minutes approved uh superintendent Alam any additions or deletions to the agenda there are no additions or deletions okay uh for board recognition uh first we want to thank uh the transportation both first student and our Rome City School District transportation staff uh superintendent onam work very uh closely with them so that we could afford

003um some of the Walkers within the D uh catchment Zone um transportation during the very cold snowy week that we've been having so thank you to all the dedication and staff and getting those kids off the sidewalk uh second I'm going to pass it over to you to give the first student recognition sure we also had an opportunity to talk to um some of the leaders of for first student and they came to meet me in my office and they were so generous to offer us about $22,000 for each School to for us to be able to afford transportation for when we want to take students on trips um you know they made it clear that since we started working together this summer it is truly a collaboration they're doing they have improved in terms

004of the transportation issues that we have been faced with for a number of years but at the same time really wanted to give back to our students for them to be able to go to trips so when you think about the nine or 10 buildings that we have $2,000 is a lot of money and each of them are able to to receive that and in addition um for stra they offered to pay for that Safari for the transition when students are transitioning from six uh to seventh grade so kudos to you thank you to K mrey as well who made that generous offer to our district all right our third recognition is uh sticking with the snowy weather theme and that is just a uh huge recognition for all of our custodial and building workers

005as well as our ground staff and Tim saen who did an amazing job making sure our sidewalks were cleared off for our kids and making sure that the buildings were safe to enter thank you okay with that we are going to kind of mix it up a little bit and uh on half of the board uh I'm going to go ahead and make a statement so on behalf of the Board of Education we would like to address recent comments in regards to the recommendation presented on December 9th it is important that we come together as a community to ensure that facts and transparency guide guide our conversations and decisions first and foremost we want to reaffirm our commitment to open communication and the Integrity of our leadership the Board of Education holds the superintendent in

006the highest regard and has full confidence in her dedication to serving the best interest of all of our students staff and Community under the direction of the Board of Education superintendent anal was charged with the creation of a district long range fiscal plan which includes facilities planning this was to ensure better fiscal planning and needs as well as um sorry better fiscal planning and needs so that as we moved forward to address our space issue with the stale FEMA Aid it was something that was not only met our academic needs but provided stability and sustainability we understand the strain that prior school closures redistricting and this daily flood have caused our community the recommendation presented services for all students in the district ensuring access for all to preschool without requiring parent transportation and with the

007additional goal to reduce overcrowding in the classroom as well as getting music art Steam and our supported Services the much dedicated space they deserve our role on the board of education is to hear the recommendations and make a decision that achieves academic success for every student of our district we believe it is critical to ensure that our all community members have access to accurate information to that end we encourage anyone with question questions or concerns to reach out directly to the board of education or the superintendent's office our goal is to Foster constructive dialogue and address any misunderstandings promptly spreading misinformation not only distracts from our shared mission of providing quality education but also undermines the unity we strive to build let us work together to ensure that our actions and conversations reflect respect accuracy

008and a shared commitment to the success of every student to that end thank you for all the time uh to attend this meeting and I would like to ask superintendent anal at this time to speak to the district's proposal that was originally presented to the board at the December 9th meeting sure um as you have spoken on behalf of the board I'd like to take a minute to also speak on behalf of my team at the district level good evening members of the board and also the community at large on December 9th and January 6 my team and I presented recommendations to the board aimed at addressing two two critical priorities the first was long-term fiscal planning can everybody hear me still okay great and the long-standing issue of space constraints specifically at the elementary

009level I want to emphasize that the recommendations made to the board are firmly rooted in The Guiding principles that drive every decision that we make at the district level educationally sound for both students and staff fiscally responsible focus on a long-term Horizon and ensuring opportunities and access for all these principles serve as our Compass guiding us to make decisions not only to solve immediate issues but also to create a strong foundation for sustainable success in the years to come the recom recommendation the team and I have brought forward are the result of a thorough review of data and stakeholder feedback gathered since the start of my tenure here in Rome one occurring concern raised by stakeholders has been the significant space constraint at that level an issue that predates the closure of staly Elementary School

010the flooding of Staley only exacerbated these challenges further limiting our ability to deliver Key Programs and services effectively one example of how the guiding principles come into play is addressing access for our youngest Learners currently not all eligible students can participate in our prek program leaving many of our children less prepared for kindergarten this disparity impact their Readiness and long-term academic success these proposals that we brought to the board aim to eliminate this Gap by expanding capacity and ensuring that every eligible child has access to early intervention this foundational support will better prepare our students for kindergarten and set them on a path for lifelong success to provide clarity here are the two recommendations currently being considered the first we presented the board three options for exploring a location for this new added Elementary School

011the three locations that they will have an opportunity to choose from are renovating our current clef prek Center on Bell Road renovating the stadium Support Facility on turn road and even if you disagree with that it's still an option purchasing and renovating the nearby Rome Catholic school on Friday my team and I wrote um a letter to the entire family um families and also the School District staff to really provide Clarity in terms of we know that we have a space issue so while we're s uh um alleviating the space issue and then we need to build an elementary school it also Al provides other key advantages and we outline what those key advantages are even our first student transportation they are aware that that's our plan and they are on board with us to

012work with us 3 years from now when we build that school to make sure that the transportation issues are also outlined without taking more time our president already outlined some of the key benefits so I won't um bore you with more of that but moving forward together while I firmly believe these proposals align with our guiding principles and represent the best path forward I also recognize that the final decision rests with all of you board members should you choose a different direction the team and I will fully commit to implementing it to the best of our ability however one of the things that I would encourage you and also the community at large uh to remember is to M focus on these guiding principles that I just shared earlier as they must take precedence they

013must take precedence over any temporary disruption that change may bring so now I will pass the Baton on because the last meeting the board asked um our teammate Dr Georgia Gonzalez and of course our partners lebella and CNS the construction um crew to be able to put a side by side kind of comparison in terms of what clef look would look like and Stadium support and in addition we've asked the construction team to really kind of talk to the design features and and to make sure that we reassure individuals that while we're thinking about that 46 we are prepared to do what's right for kids and to provide the right conditions not only for learning for all students but also the right working conditions for the staff as well cuz currently some staff members do

014not have that opportunity to teach effectively especially in the special areas thank you so Dr Gonzalez and the team uh Del tell I need to turn it on [Music] Hold On Da the mic here just take mine you got to hold it but good evening tonight I'm going to provide a quick um overview of our summary with a side by-side comparison [Music] there we no Qui here we go thank you as we had discussed last Monday cloth is expected to be approximately 73 million versus Stadium support at 74 million in Roman Catholic School which was originally approximately 59 million since we went through the modeling process LaBella actually came up with revised numbers at approximately 84 million that has to do with some additional construction that is required but I'll also let lebella expand on

015that when they come up to speak again we have various Financial plans for each building all of them include enough students for 1175 students to be on the property right now that would allow us to move the 800 that we believe are currently overcrowding the current buildings from Staley and still give us some room to be able to grow we expect based on current maximum cost allowances because KF already is on our um state aid that we would receive 9,500,000 approximately in maximum cost allowances and approximately 22 million for stadium support in Rome Catholic uh schools our aided ratio for cloth and Rome uh Catholic school would be probably about um the same or pretty close to the same at 30 and 26% with Stadium support currently receiving the lowest amount part of that has

016to do with the the property itself currently being associated with the RFA um I provided a variety of the different funding sources that would go into to helping to pay for those proper uh for either building or any of these three buildings um currently as we mentioned um at our last meeting KF has um almost $14 million set aside as part of the 2024 project all three locations would include approximately 15 million for FEMA again as we spoke about last Monday that number may be a little higher it depends on how much of it we need to use to demolish some of our other uh spaces such as daily and then we looked at our capital reserve and approximately 53 million would be required for KF approximately 68 million would be required for stadium support

017and approximately 64 million would be required for C uh Rome Catholic school that is assuming that we have no voter impact we would not increase taxes at all this is the reserve again once we go through this process and we start to refine things we can determine how much of this we want to be out of reserve and what we' be willing to do on a tax basis um to reduce cathal reserve requirement um clu and Stadium support currently would be approximately 42 months with Rome Catholic school being 48 months uh Rome Catholic School would also possibly require us to uh purchase the building which would take longer um so we're using that as a conservative number but it could be a little longer than 48 months all uh three buildings would require some type

018of an addition or um infrastructure element Stadium support support would require some Stadium construction um to the bleacher elements that are currently there when we talk about renovating the properties we're talking about not only taking the building that is currently there renovating the inside spaces to make them suitable for whatever grade levels you decide to put in those buildings but then also adding additions to that space so that we can truly include all 11 almost 12200 students the benefits regardless of which building we're looking at is to be able to um not only have our students in one space providing us with the opportunity to open up some of the spaces in our elementary buildings but also would um potentially have cost Savings in staff as we consolidate some of those spaces we're expecting to

019have additions regardless of which building we go with with either six or seven buses these numbers of 324 to 378,000 is based on what we're using currently at the um bus rate um those numbers obviously will fluctuate a little bit because we're talking 3 years down the road but those numbers are based on our current numbers um I did speak with our um custodial um head custodian uh Tim saan and he helped to provide me with some numbers uh for maintenance costs KF already has some maintenance staff in there so that number may be slightly high but we expect approximately 450,000 on an annual basis regardless of the building that you go with and that would allow us to be able to provide all the maintenance on an annual basis um all of our labor

020all those types of costs that would go into maintaining and operating those buildings at this time I'm going to pass the Vuitton over to Craig Daly who's going to provide you with some ideas and concepts for each of these three buildings oh okay great hi can everyone hear me okay I apologize my uh my voice is quickly fading as the night go go on um I want to I guess set up um the story this is a process regardless even if you knew what you wanted to do there's a process that's followed to make sure that there's stakeholder involvement there's a lot of program needs staff needs all these things come together at this stage it's the prenatal talk okay um so the purpose of what we did which is basically conceptual there's nothing here

021that's really of like oh that's what it's going to look like when it's done no it's really just to have a talking point to make sure that the site that we're looking at has the capacity to support a building to support a program um so the purpose of this exercise was really to review the pros and cons of each of these from an architect engineer construction manager perspective um the hope is to develop uh enough information answer enough questions that you have the ability to make a decision to what you're going to do number one uh pick a site a location and number two decide on how we're going to structure the grades basically volumetrically if it's a k through PK through six or if it's a 4 through six um the building volumes are

022basically about the same okay as you can see with this draft model we did for cloth um looking at these you can see that these are wings there's Wings to the each of the classrooms the intent is to really try to control how the grade structures are in the buildings you know we're not going to mix a wing of K through six or 4 through six uh the fourth grade will have its own individual Wing fifth grade sixth grade for example um just as a means of being able to maintain the efficiencies of the staff at those levels provide some areas for cross communication so these are some of the basic assumptions that we took when we started looking at this uh again disclaimer uh these concepts are based on spatial needs for the programs

023um so there's a lot more work that would go into this once a a choice is made um and I mentioned about the reasonability of it so some of the initial presumptions we made uh we looked at a student population of 1,200 we looked at the grade levels and the contractual requirements of class size which is why this building is probably a little bigger or you know you're looking at bigger numbers because you're going to have more classrooms CU you tend to have a contractual obligation of uh less than New York um state will give you as a maximum for a class size which is 30 kids uh we assumed it's going to be twostory that's probably going to the most efficient for the three sites that we looked at um parking uh we looked

024at approximately 100 I mean this is at a schematic level so you could probably have more we're thinking at a minimum we can get 100 uh spot parking we accounted for about 24 buses in a Bus Loop and then we also took consideration for parent drop off we also took into consideration uh age specific playgrounds and outdoor activity spaces um and as I mentioned the grades are housed in the wings separate from each other um when we looked at sizing of gymnasiums and cafeterias and those types of things we made the assumption that if this was a 46 that the fourth grade would all go at lunch at the same time fifth grade would go in sixth grade it's the most efficient use of the the space to M minimize the number of turnovers for

025lunch so uh based on that we we have a cafeteria based on that size all right so here we go pros and cons uh some of the things we've discussed as a team um the location is favorable for our neighborhood school I me you you already have a school there right it's in the neighborhood it's it's formed its function as an elementary school in the past and um we feel that's an ideal location uh the existing building can incorporate into an addition um as we'll talk about when we talk about RCS our building at kth was built based on New York State education standards so there's a lot of ability to integrate an addition into that building with minimal uh impact um there's approximately $12 million in the construction at this facility that has already

026been voted in the 2024 Capital project um so it's added value to whatever we do here that money is already compensated and how it could um meld into a future project is definitely a pro and you own the property uh the cons of this location uh the potential site challenges um you know having the parking the Bus Loop the parent drop off the playgrounds all those types of things with the amount of land that's going to be required for the additions and providing a proper sized gymnasium and cafeteria um there will be challenges in in the design of that in fact it'll be incorporated into the design as an emphasis it's not to say we can't do it it's just going to be one of those things that's going to take some focused effort and

027making sure we're all in agreement as to what is it we need how many do we have okay we don't want to run into a rigal um let's see so that's it for cloth any questions on that so the Orange is basically the existing facility and the green is where we're proposing newer spaces just sorry I just had a quick question um do you happen to know off hand um how many students if if the if the existing clut building was open and available now um without any district offices how many students would um clut hold um I'm going to go based on mem but I will get you those numbers because we do have them uh you know renovating the district office back in classroom spaces and uh updating the other spaces it's about

028a third of the classes that the full building would be at 1200 so let's assume 400 gets okay and but I can get you more better information on that F no no I think that's good enough thank you okay so when we do this I think I'm loud enough for everyone can everyone hear me I'm pretty loud oh oh they won maybe step back a little bit sorry [Music] okay so do do we need to make when we make this decision do we need to know what grades are going in there for sure before we can make yeah so the first thing is we need a site and that is um imperative to how we start going down the more massing for that and yes it would be preferred if we could also as quickly

029as possible know the grade structure of it for example elementary schools with PK and kindergarten in first grade we had to put bathrooms in it uh kindergarten and prek rooms tend to be a lot bigger than a general classroom that would be for 46 um so those things definitely need to be part of the consideration I apologize I figured oh no that's okay thank you anything else okay RCS get my cheat sheet so Roman Catholic School um the biggest negative about that is it was not built to New York State Standards right so the floor T floor elevations are not what would typically be built for uh a school there's no Ada accessibility it's an old steam fed uh you know there's no air quality exchange so we're basically looking at that existing facility as

030basically a total gut you know um you know the exterior walls there's some terazzo in the corridors but the the majority of the building would have to be um gutted um but some of the pros uh the location again is favorable for a neighborhood School uh it has decent site acreage for all the type of site amenities plus probably some additional uh field use that could be used districtwide um and it it meets uh it meets some of the standards for New York Elementary Schools but the biggest issues are the mechanical infrastructure of the building there's no elevator so it's multif flors so a lot of the Interior would have to be dealt with um the cons the existing building requires purchase uh so buying a building that you don't own is taking away available

031funding for programs uh and the construction uh requires a whole public vote you can run it simultaneous with another project but you have to get the voters to approve even purchasing that and there's a whole process that goes so it's kind of a lengthy process that can extend excuse me extend time uh that you may not want to expend on that effort um existing building was not uh made to the standards uh and I mentioned the floor floor but potential site challenges uh with designing the parking Bus Loop and parent parking especially with the traffic that comes off the main road by the uh supermarket and those types of things so there's we'd like to pull a lot of those types of um pedestrian activities away from that street as much as possible okay any

032question on so I just want to make sure that you you said something that I probably didn't even think of quite yet so in the prek 3 configuration with a one upper element area 4 through six you mentioned the prek requirement of bathrooms yes so I know we're talking about picking a site for either another Elementary or an upper elementary but it sounds like there are going to be to put prek into every building there will likely need to be Renovations um not knowing um the other buildings there may or may not so as you're transitioning populations and distributing them it may free up those rooms that have those facilities already in them so you're you're basically and you're you got to remember you're also dividing your PK population to be Equitable among all the

033elementary schools so um it would be definitely something we would research and parallel to see if there are any impacts on those buildings but I don't think it was anything that of major um proportion that would be an issue you know budget wise okay is that just prek that needs the bathroom prek and kindergarten too yeah sometimes we see them in first grades depending on how the kids are grown okay all right and then Stadium support again it's a a favorable location central to the district um the pro of this it's basically a clean slate right we're not trying to meld new classrooms into a building that has existing classrooms you have the existing facility there that has a lot of the athletic support type um spaces um but the whole classroom Wing would basically

034be brand new from scratch and consistent um and you own the property some of the cons the site layout and the ability to incorporate the existing building will be challenging with the addition uh potential site challenges with the design of parking bus Loops Etc it it looks like there's a big site there but you have a stadium you have a baseball field you have some other ancillary spaces that you use for athletics so we're trying to balance what that could do we did look to see yeah we could probably fit 100 person or 100 car parking lot a Bus Loop and maybe some uh parallel Street side parking or workout some kind of parent Loop to minimize any impact on the Main Street um but it will be challenging okay so of the three I

035think um architecturally and constructibility wise our suggestion would be to consider cloth so just a question on Stadium support So when Dr Gonzalez when you put the slide up there it said that part of that renovation was that part for the stadium as well so I know that it's connected to RFA so why would we have to if we built the School on that site have to renovate the stadium as well well we'll have to do that anyway for safety reasons right so either way so part of that part of so it's really not it's not parallel though those three because really we put so I guess I would want to know what money is going into Stadium support um which obviously we have to do anyway but to me those three it's not it's

036not side by side because we're putting that in there so whether it's 2 million for I don't know the the price of it but I would just like to know that number before our vote okay and the only thing excuse me I can add to that is s is really going to be the one that's going to prompt you to do something with it right now you have control over the schedule of when those repairs and Renovations happen but if s gets a preliminary submission that's on this site they go back to the building condition survey and they look at all the discrepancies and they're going to make that so the budgetary wise to be able to plan for that which I believe is in there right Nate we've accounted for some of those things

037and we can get you that value of what that is is um but accounting for that make sure that if s does drop that bomb on you you can say yeah we have that included and and considered okay you sure yeah so to piggy back off of Kelly and we know that this one's my baby I know I'm sorry but again and I don't want to beat a dead horse but so Stadium support is now joined with RFA okay if we put a school on there do we un join and now we can get the aid and fix this the whole stadium we can't untake it away from RFA Nate or whoever I I know of when they decided to move ahead with the project where they're doing right now with the um baseball field

038softball fields and everything they I believe and again we'd have to check with fiscal and maybe the but I believe the a ability on this was drastically minimized if not removed okay so at this point if you did something you're probably paying more for dollar for dollar okay and one other thing again there was 800 and something students in that school or more whatever there was we had buses we had student parking and we had teachers of just that size of that building how all of a sudden are we saying it's challenging to have a Bus Loop and to have parking when there was actually more and we used the stadium more and more people came to the stadium for all those years just based on our conceptual I think we did we lose some

039land when we get did any any part of that land get bought out by anyone not to my knowledge okay cuz we had a full Bus Loop like I'm saying and student parking and I mean no parent pickup I don't know if they did or didn't and but no I mean that wasn't a big issue well is it because it was three stories before maybe before our was okay I was just getting all those questions out there because I know a lot of people want to know that because it did have you know we had the room before oh I totally agree and I I think with the addition being for two stories for the size of the classrooms being sized for today's standards versus the original building um I would be remiss if I

040did not at least put that on as something that we really need to be careful and look at and congestion it's not saying we can't do that we did lay out on here 100 spots for parking a Bus Loop um but it just based on the stadium and the baseball field and everything it looked like it was really cramped thank you and it was three like you said I didn't think of that the the only thing I would add there is that you're evaluating the use of that site to today's your [Music] and I think I said this last Monday you're evaluating that site to based on today's standards not the standards to which it was built on right so they are dramatically different and that is likely going to to have an impact okay

041thank you I appreciate that and that's based on 12200 mhm correct another 400 the um the 100 parking spots is that like a standard number number that you use for the size school or where did that 100 parking spot number well we went through and based on the number of classrooms that we had and assumed a number for administration and visitors and things like that we we came up with that as kind of a a basis um the goal is always to have more uh especially with functions and and uh use at the elementary level uh tends to get a lot more use but for talking points we thought we'd at least hold to that standard among all three facilities to try to make sure it's Apples to Apples the best we could yeah I

042guess uh the reason why I asked cuz one of the uh questions that keeps coming up in considerations is the traffic flow as you kind of related to and um I really like the CL location um because of where it is in the city and because there's already a school there but the traffic flow does concern me because I am part of the prek drop off and pickup every day and I don't know how many students exactly but I'm guessing around 150 MH and everybody's parked on either side of the street because there is no there isn't enough parking lots so I feel like and that's just with 150 I know of course you'd have more busing and less pickup drop off hopefully but it just seems like that would be an issue that would

043need uh to be well thought out if a school did go there into helping the flow because and I haven't heard anything from the the families in that area but if I live there it would be a concern of mine um having won that much traffic and then also people parking on the street right alongside your house yeah and I think in in all three schemes we would definitely have to make that uh a high priority especially with parent drop offs I mean it becomes more and more you know you get three or four kids off a bus that holds 40 and meanwhile there's 20 cars behind Ray to drop their kid off for the day um so it you know having the Bus Loop having it separate so it's safe from pedestrian traffic maybe

044in another area you have the parent drop off at another part of the building so you're not you're minimizing the amount of conflicts and things like that but at all three sites we're going to have to spend again that next level is to get into some of those details and what works best okay great thanks and just one more question um the RCs um estimate that we had I think last meeting was 59 million and now it's about 884 million can can you provide a little bit more detail on that yeah so when we had that initially it was based on paper napkin sketches of what we thought we could do on that site and what the number of rooms were we've gone through that next level with these three examples from that meeting um

045to really say okay we need to make sure we have these classrooms the right sizes we need to know how many we need to compare it to the contractual requirements so the actual volumes of the spaces got bigger from what we originally thought um also part of that was when we started looking at the existing facility RCs similar to how I was talking about it's a total gut and originally when we did the field observation report on that and thinking about how that bu building could be used it's move in quality with some ventilation issues um but as you're bringing in additions and things like that you want everything to be of the same caliber you don't want the kids that are in f-wing the existing building um to go into the next wing and

046go wow hey look at the lights and everything and I can breathe um so that kind of added to the cost as well again keep in mind these are conceptual so the goal is at the next level is every time we change and get more detail um our construction manager goes through and re-evaluates the budget because he has something more tangible that he can look at a little more accurate so from this to the schematic phase to the design development um to the preconstruction each of those steps gets an update in the budget so what you're seeing is a conceptual if you don't want to you know stay up all night worrying if we have enough money it's usually got a lot of contingencies and escalation considerations and it and that that part kind of

047is like wow I could build this building for this well at this point I don't want to tell you you can build it for that you know what I mean so thank you that just made me think sorry one more question um so we used to have our prek like subcontracted out to RCS and obviously the New York State Standards didn't apply I'm assuming as stringent as us having an in-house what would the difference be or would it be possible to own the property and subcontract out the prek program is that possible or or because we own the building that's where the extra requirements come from stay at that's a good question I don't so if you were to buy our yes you still have a lot of accessibility issues you still have a lot

048life safety issues they have to go into the building um so you're still paying a considerable amount of it um the room sizes there's um I don't recall seeing the bathrooms and the rooms for the kids so that they're not leaving the room to go or have to be escorted out by the teacher and have a second or third person there um and honestly I don't know how the contractual obligations would work between a private company providing services that you own um if you own it you've got your you're bound by state requirements if they own it as long as they're meeting their their state requirements as a a daycare facility or uh PK facility it's on them okay thank you you just overa the crit yes it y one question my question would be

049on the C site there's a p there's a piece of land behind the CL site that I believe the county owns so my question would be have we looked at possibly and there is a road it's certainly not a road that you could use to bring buses on MH at this point but there is a road back there that leads to a baseball field MH a softball field so my question would be is that something we could actually look at then to find out because I'll be frank I have a hard time visualizing this school on the amount of plot of land that's there currently belonging to the school district but if you were to expand it backwards MH maybe you would have enough land so I guess that would be my concept is is

050that something that could be looked at and referred to then to add cuz then it would give you more space all MH for your playground and all your other elements that you'd have with it and maybe even put a Bus Loop in the back of the building rather than in the front so I just wanted to put that out there could you share what you gave me a sneak peek of can the board see the the ones that you showed me yes I'll leave those for you if you like Comfort I can also for them just so the he has renderings that show a potential Transportation Lane and some parking so so I think important for us to be able to see before we [Music] leave go over once the site is complete at RFA

051and there's some new sports Fields going in and what the plan is for that so would we what would the baseball Fe field for example on you know I I like Stadium support a lot it's in the middle of our city it's right next to you know it it takes a place of a school that's already been there Fort staring is literally three blocks down the street um but I worry about when RF was there what Kirsten's saying parents didn't really have they didn't have the drop off it was high school we walked we Kiren drove um but so there was you know parking back there there was different things but not like a parent drop off but there is that baseball field over there but would we continue to use use that baseball field

052when that the site is completed RFA I think I think director was here the chances are he would say yes um and even the football field is very pretty I don't see any changes with that so again we would have to contend with all of those spaces that already are being used for other things um in addition to making that location in elementary school so I think that's why he was saying of today plus on top of that with all of the parking that is needed today would be different because we're I mean we're looking at three sites and they're all presenting many challenges it seems when you look at you know we could move down you say we get a little bit further well we could say well Stadium support now it's not going

053to it might not work we might need to move remove the baseball field or like Sue's bringing up points with k then you have Rome Catholic I mean the that's the one street so they're all presenting no matter what is chosen many obstacles that we're going to when we move forward have to see is it going to be viable when you move a little closer and a little closer what happens if you move a little closer and we chose one I mean are we choosing a backup I mean are you because we could all vote on Stadium support and then we go down and say no we it it doesn't work I mean when you think about Stadium support too there's the houses in the back I mean to have that loop I mean those

054if I owned any of those houses there's no way you wouldn't be able to leave your home um so that's what I worry about is once we any three that we P whoever anyone we pick out of the three they have seem like they have major challenges would you is there any of the three you think would be the least of the challenges the is cloth is that what you're saying and Nate will be able to also add to that piece too cuz we talked about that from a Construction St standpoint so both Nate and leella go ahead okay um so my personal opinion based on how far we've gotten in this so far because I always had to put that disclaimer you know when I start sitting up late at night at the board

055chawing and sketching and doing all those things then I get a better feel for these things um in my preference it goes um cloth Stadium and then um Catholic school if I'm looking at it for the potential of less headaches I would probably look at uh the Catholic School cloth in the stadium um I think there's a a lot more challenges at the stadium than than we're really seeing now just in this preliminary stage um and I know that the Catholic school has a lot of property um so there's a you know there's a little bit of a breathing room but I feel it's really close to cloth too so I have a couple quick questions on that um with Stadium support I'm worried about turn Road that's a busy road and if we're putting

056in elementary school there you got to think about the number of kids that are going and what dangers those pose but then um you said that Rome Catholic would be the one with less headaches can you why why is that less headache I'm saying just because the available property that that has that's um they have a baseball field in the back they have basically I'll call it a football field um that's to the back right of it there's a little bit more flexibility not much more than cloth I mean there's still going to be challenges um but on a rating scale um working there now would I prefer to have it there with the uh commercial traffic that goes up and down the street and um the market across the street and some of the

057other businesses I think I like the the coziness of the cloth setting cuddled in the neighborhood um versus having that larger commercial area right next to the school yeah I I don't know my opinions are dramatically different from what Craig shared I think right that as I mentioned last week the added challenge with RCS is the purchase and the timeline that is going to have to associate that right it's um it's another step in the process all right that you're going to have to go through um and I I mean to me that's it's a challenge that we can work together and overcome but it's I I wouldn't undermine the like how much effort is going to be required to to take that and purchase that building so that that's the only thing I would

058add to the to what Craig offered so with clu being the least amount of money per se as we show could is there a way and I don't mean this disrespectfully at all we can do it right the first time maybe take a little bit more money it may be the least amount right now okay but take the differences here and use more money to make it right the first time and look at the longevity instead of saying oh let's do this because it's and again not saying this to you at all I'm just saying in general everyone looking at it saying oh this is the cheapest one we want to go this way because there's you know this way this way this way I like what you're saying about CF I do but I

059do see the other challenges so maybe we take a little bit more money and say we can do it and make this better whether it be parking um the the playground something that's we can utilize because right now we use in the back of there KF has does I actually have a softball field that is not being used for anything but yet we pay and I and listen I love Rome girl softball my daughters I we I run it and I'm a volunteer but we're paying to use their facilities when we could be using a field there if you fixed it the right way and done it right the first time so again I mean there's a lot of things that I think maybe if we you know look and say I mean is that

060possible to do too well I I want to definitely um say that the charge that we've been given uh by the superintendent and the district has been we're doing it right the first time and that's kind of why this process takes a bit and um you know not many people get the the ability or the experience to plan a project like this you know a lot of projects are Renovations and maybe a few additions here and there so the step-by-step process is what's going to help develop getting it right the first time you know there's there's a lot I didn't take it that way oh no no I totally get it and you know I'm I'm going to be honest with you too we will get it right 99% you know at best there's always

061going to be something that maybe could have done better that you're not even going to go hit yourself in the head for until you're like oh you know kids are in it you know they're running into a column gez well probably shouldn't have put that column there but you know to have the process to have the stakeholder input you know to have this type of setting with the community listening hearing asking questions being able to be involved in the process even if you get it 95% dead on that other 5% it's like yeah but I was a part of that you know my grandkids are going to be going to this building that I asked questions on when it was in the early stages so but but definitely that's the charge we've been given it's

062like we don't want to get anything missed in this if we uh drop it from 1,200 to 800 at any of these sites will alleviate the problems that you have just recommended or have said so a stadium support goes to and I can argue all day long that that's a a busy uh Street um we have schools Stokes is busy uh Rich Mills is busy there are busy streets so I could argue that all day long but um if we alleviated if we if we went from 1,200 and did a k to 6 and put it at 800 would that take care of some of the issues that you've brought up CU are you when you talk about land you're talking about land for a school for 1,200 and I'm listening and processing it all

063I don't want to say I'm not I'm just to put it all in perspective take 1,200 to 8 is that going to diminish so add a slice that's the other component is going down to 800 in that building does that alleviate our space issue in the existing building okay so mathematically to your question it would help you with the site but you're eliminating your future and to answer your question it will not because you you've been your um population your k student population has been pretty steady 95% of the state's been in Decline okay um I know that with Micron coming into the Syracuse area in central New York um future developments at the base and and these types of things coming in are going to bring in more families so there's a potential like

064you could build a building for 800 and all a sudden you're adding on to it and you're impacting those types of things so at this stage again the concept ual we felt it was best to look at the space for not only what you have now but what could possibly be in the future reasonably you know 5 10% population growth over the next 10 15 20 years um would be a feather in the calf to the Rome Community but you'd also be able to have the spaces for it so when we when we took a look at this a while ago was 3 years ago the reason why in obious viously some of us had um you know the k6 model was important that was my first and foremost was the k6 model I like

065the that model the best it was told to us though that that model couldn't be done because of the space issue so so that's still the case and that's why we had said okay then let's move to the you know we had we had two the five sex at Stadium support so then we had already discussed us Stadium support at 56 and that was going to be what we were moving forward with and I didn't hear but we didn't hear any of these issues is it because we weren't far enough along or because that's what we had that that's what that's what I keep going back to is that we already had decided it was 56 and and if it is 56 can you put prek and so I I know we have all of

066this to to discuss but um I mean it just sounds like we're going to run into some sort of issues building 1 1200 at at some of these sites I'll jump in you're we're going to run into issues if we build 800 right I like the process Craig said we're prenatal I think we might be at like courtship like we think we want to go down this path but we're not really sure yet um right like if even if like we still have to work through Seeker right like the process this is going to be the same um and I think when you talk about Stadium support the challenges like what's going to reveal itself with Seeker I think is still significant at versus versus 12 I I think they're very similar like obviously yes

067trip counts are going to be less R so there will be less impact but I still think it's a significant hurdle to try and overcome and it to be fair those challenges may present themselves elsewhere I just right with where we are in the process today I think that's a significant challenge for that number one I I don't have a number one I I just candidly like our job is to take your direction and then figure out how to make it work based on whatever um that direction is right I think from an options standpoint and the ability to potentially phase a project in over time I think cloth presents the most flexibility and the most options over time um but I don't disagree with any of the points right that you've brought up about

068Stadium support or RCS or or CL so could so again and I might be really asking this question I just they just think it's so important because this is such a major thing so if we were to do clu I'm just going to use this 56 what that are now what can every school handle did we ask this can every school handle prek through for if it was if we had that extra cool we did a um I'm going to say quick but we did a review of each of the buildings and their utilizations and they would be able to absorb that getting the actual building Aid units and the and the population counts we could go through that um but I think we looked at that uh as one of the phases like if

069we would have we did the additions you know you're just doing it for the right but it would be and that is in the cost of the club correct like so when we talk about that the cost of clu would be for this to happen right so the cost for cloth is for this building to happen nothing happens at the other buildings but we still need things to happen in the other buildings we'll we'll look at um you know through our capital projects that we do and the you know the other forms of construction even with facilities and putting and providing some of the renovation type things okay but I think part of the process that runs parallel to this is looking at those buildings and trying to work with how they're going to uh

070how the classes how everything would map out and that will allow us to have the opportunity to see what those buildings need and how we can approach it correct me if I'm correct me if I'm wrong but I know the road that Sue is talking about that County Road behind clu um which I think could pose like a good opportunity for additional traffic but you're going through the parking lot at mbcc so do they own that parking lot like how how is that work around does anybody have that information I I think if you'll see that you'll see if there's a fence line I believe that's your property line but I'm talking about the road behind that leads to the softball field that leads behind the softball field is technically the County's Road um the

071parking lot that you go through to go there but they could cut if you had if we got part of that that fence line goes you could open that up you could drive through where you currently park over here and get back there and it would be that road you know what I mean you wouldn't even go through MV you would not even utilize that space so you say we you know where we park when we go to the meetings just drive down the back of that and go to the fence line that way we wouldn't even have to utilize if if it went that way um because that's the way the road is it's not the county has that road and that's it it's weird how it was cut up so for clarity for

072everybody you're talking about you would as if um you are going into the parking lot at the district building you're going to take a left into where that parking lot is and go straight back to where the fence line is in the back and that additional parking I I think any of these options you're going to have to collaborate with the county the city the county in the state right I mean if you choose K there's probably discussion that has to happen if B Road can be extended in tie and 825 if you choose RCS there's probably a conversation about where the light is right on turn road and so I think any of these options are going have required you to collaborate with the local municipalities and and likely the state as well okay

073and then just so parents and Nate this question is more for you just so parents know you've mentioned Seeker before and utilizing them for studies can you just explain to everybody who's here what that is so that's Craig's expertise Craig sorry that's okay uh Seeker is for the State Environmental Quality review act and basically there's a lot of requirements so in plain language to me is whenever you do a development especially if it's by a municipality a state school um you have to go through the approval process of telling them what you're doing how you're going to handle a 100-year flood all these types of things for drainage and impervious services and things and we send that to them so it's a back and forth with them they're part of the process and they issue

074a permit saying yeah you can do this and then during construction there's certain things that they also require be monitored and supervised as far as like quality and those types of things so Seeker is one of the agencies uh we also work with shipo who's the State Historical preservation whenever you're touching a site expanding a site they want to be part of that if uh the building is over 50 years old they want to be part of that as well so those types of things um we have you know this may also prompt no matter where you are uh a transportation study you know so we have a a crew of Engineers that would come in and evaluate looking at the population considering transportation bus all those types of things to see what the impact

075is going to be on on the neighborhood um you know and what the times are so your buses you know I'm going to stay in the house until 7:30 when all the bus is clear and then everything's like on a Sunday afternoon so um there's a lot of steps and our hope is once you select one once we start moving into that we actually start outlining the meetings that we have the stakeholders to be involved uh the different agencies that we have to jump through hoops uh regardless of where you go we're going to have to do uh a preliminary submission to SED and that involves basically taking the drawings uh providing the student count Pro program use all those types of things and they have to bless that um so there's a lot and

076that tends to be a process before we even get to developing the drawings I want to give kind of a last call for board questions and you know in advance of that obviously thank you both uh for answering um all of our questions thus far yeah thanks yeah I don't have any more questions at this time but um I just want to kind of piggy back I want to thank you guys for all the hard work you've done and um superintendent ons and Dr Gonzalez and your all your executive team I know there's been a lot of work going on behind the scenes so just to clarify as Cassie mentioned at the opening remarks um none of this was meant to be sprung on the public we learned in the December meeting but um when

077we originally got presented these um options but this was something we knew a year ago even before we hired the new superintendent that we were going to be looking for a long-term plan and this was going to be a part of it so um the new superintendent didn't come this was something that we tasked her with and no matter who's sitting in her seat sorry um this was going to be something that we needed to address and so to be transparent the December meeting was the first time that we got presented any of the information of the options so we're learning at the same time that the community's learning and the parents are learning so we're trying to digest all this information and come up with the best solution so we appreciate all the feedback

078we receed some emails and and um it's all very helpful but I just wanted to clarify that nothing's being pressured upon us this is something as a district we needed to address and as a board this was one of the tasks that we that we gave our superintendent to prepare these options for us thank you very much can we just go over uh the timeline of what's going to happen what we need to know what you know between date is it the next board meeting I know that we have to do we have to put it out to vote all those anything that needs to happen can you just go through that for us so we know and everyone's prepared me take it so um assuming whichever option you choose right um Craig mentioned the

079um um thank you the preliminary submission that has to be submitted s so you will go through the preliminary submission SD will respond with their aid ability that will drive the financial considerations and give you sort of some finality to what's going to be aided how it's going to be aided from there you will assemble a project or maybe projects it could very likely be multiple projects um that then you will be brought back to the board right here are Concepts um and different options the board can then weigh in and say we like this over that or proceed with this um and all of those are going to have financial implications as well right so you'd be voting on on sort of both of those then you will take that out to voters for

080referendum assuming the voters said yes then the design process starts there's a submission to S to approve the design of that and then construction would start so that is sort of the preliminary submission is roughly a year to do that work and get SS feedback on that the vote you know depending there's there's theories on all of it right um but the the vote in the design time frame couple days so probably another realistically what 18 months plus or minus right to to assemble all of that and then you need the time to construct it which is probably a couple of years in all of these scenarios talking three to five so I think what Kelly's question was more addressing is what do you need the board's next actions to be so at the January

08126th or 27th uh whatever that day is what are you asking of the board gotcha so LaBella and um CNS we've been having meetings once you pick a location then they can start that process so that's really what they need to know what is the location and are you moving forward with a 46 because because that is when they start working on their design and all of the stuff that he just outlined so that's what I'm asking to at the next board meeting because it's not just about the location because in order to move forward we need to know how many we're building for right and what that looks like so we need to know two things and explain and Su I know you had said this before when does it need to be determined

082and then does a vote have to be had on the location or the amount that needs to be spent for May how does that work Dr Gonzalez would you speak to that more of the referendum please so ideally what we'd be looking for on Monday the 27th would be for you to provide us with information on what location you'd like to move forward with and which configuration because of that configuration that will help guide our numbers for the financial piece and then as we move through the preliminary then we can let you know what that's going to look like so that we can move forward with the referendum preferably we'd be looking to do a referendum in May of 2026 because it will take us that long to move through the preliminary n is that

083accurate that's 100% so I mean I will I will ask the honest question is this is obviously an immense decision yes and you know we do get more information each meeting so I think you know I think we can steer towards that but I fully anticipate next meeting we might need additional discussions and questions so I think I'm I can't see you all in this configuration but I think if I'm guessing on behalf of the board there might be more comfortability in targeting our February meeting probably realistically just need we just need to discuss and and verify and clarify I guess one in any reconfiguration like it had been said 3 years ago that nothing we do if it's a k to 6 or prek to 6 would eliminate our space issues one I want

084to know that 100% that that is definitely off the table um and I'm sorry I just forgot uh the other um oh and I want to know that if we choose to do um a different configuration if prek can fit so if we say at whatever site prek to four can fit prek to five can fit what can fit in all of our schools to give us if we say we don't we don't want prek to 3 but okay prek to 4 or or will it fit putting preek I think that's our question and one thing he said about bathrooms and I'm just thinking at at just a couple schools that we've toured we are going to have to renovate some of those if we're talking about prek and kindergarten need bathrooms I don't I

085don't see how that I mean we would have to put bathrooms so that's going to be that's going to be a cost um so just those things I think would help me move along forward with a decision and also enough space for parking is what you're saying as well especially at CF so here are the things that I'm hearing um would that eliminate our existing issue of space once and for all the total number of students if we chose a 456 and is there a different configuration that we can come up with which will also consider putting prek in the existing buildings right are these correct I want to know if we chose a prek to 6 y that 100 and I think I already know the answer CU I think we you know we

086we talked about this before but I want to know concretely because we're bringing this up again a new configuration that there is no option for us to put a prek to 6 or a k to 6 into our school district to eliminate the space issues because that was last time we discussed it was really important um for myself and for many of us keeping when we talk about Community Schools and and having you know these schools there was no way as we looked at at last time I sat in the room and and we had said there's no way you can put a k6 on another site and eliminate your space issue of what you have right now and that's when we had decided we had two other options which was 56 on the site

087or we are going to do two 58 which we decided not to that it was the 56 so I just want to make sure that when we're relooking at this that there's no option for that and that the secondary option for some of us would be to look at okay is it is it then in all of our CL in our schools we can put fit if we adding prek which I think is really important prek to three yes prek to four yes prek to 5 okay you can't they don't all fit so then you would have to do an additional 56 does that Mak that sense I agree I I have add to that though because it isn't just PK prek to three it's also talking about music rooms and it's talking about art

088rooms and it's talking about giving special spaces for PT and OT because all of our schools right now do not have those facilities and if we're going to do this every single School in our district has to be Equitable against all of the streams not just the classrooms so you have to build that all together not just talking about a grade level but talking about the entirety of a school building I agree with that but you could argue and say I'll put a huge K to six and 1,200 students at one of the schools then it would free up tons of space as well so I mean I agree I I'm looking at the same thing I'm just looking to see what our options are and and what I feel comfortable with too I think

089we need to we need to make that known though that this is not this is not easy at all I mean at all for anyone um but that like those other aspects so when people say oh well this is a done deal you guys are doing it anyway you're going to do it you you know you feel we are looking at a bunch of things and it's not there's no easy answer to any of this um no matter what we do not everyone's going to be happy unfortunately but we need to realize that we need these other programs we need music in the schools I don't want to see a cart and and again I want these things for your students cuz my kids are my olders are graduated and my other one's going to

090graduate next year I want to see your children have music not on a cart I want to see those things be able to be put into these schools and those things are very important the extra the special needs all these things should be in each school every school should be exactly the same and also when your child gets on a bus or leaves for the day it shouldn't matter what school they go to because each and every school in this district is going to have what they all need what your child needs what his child needs what every child needs it's not just going to be one school is better than the other no one should say oh my God I need to go to Stokes because that's school is the best school it's going

091to be that we're trying to make sure that each school has these things so that everyone feels proud of the school that they go to and at the end of the day no one feels that they don't want to go to a different school because of the other and I think that that's very very important that we need to make sure this is what we're trying to do we're not trying to make things where it's anymore um for one child than the other go ahead nland I'll say it also in general I think um earlier we talked about Consolidated staff and I want to address that to make sure that people are not thinking that they won't have a job so let's be clear about that um the number of students will not change regardless

092of whether we build an addition right now we have 5200 students we anticipate that there will be more so adequate Staffing we also have to take a look at that so everything from bus routes adequate Staffing start and end time all of these pieces need to be looked at and so I did not want that word Consolidated to mean that people are not going to have jobs just remember that okay I'm going to I'm going to break us let me just real quick um so Kelly's question I think is a good one and one that I hear often so it would be good to just have an answer is so um before we lost Staley that was an additional K through6 building I know I I think uh from what I heard space was tight

093then but I think most schools had the extras the um the art art room and music so I guess the question I hear a lot which would be good for the community to be answered is we lost to K through six can we just build a k through six to replace it so it would be helpful just to have um information for the community on that thanks so I think nand has you have your charge and I took I know you take that very seriously I will just share with you I talked about this with the Community member I went to Stokes we had music on a car way back then so this is not new uh for some of us so the point is I think we all feel very passionate that we don't

094want any of that moving forward if we can come up with a plan that provide that so I'm going to I'm sorry do we have any idea like any study or anything how many prek students like we would be able to house that's one thing that I would want to know at the next meeting I don't need it now but because that's going to make a difference too are we talking about five kids new added to this school or are we talking about 20 kids cuz that's going to affect the classroom configurations as well okay I'm going to wrap that up and then Miss Sandy uh we will move on to public comment all right we have Miss Sarah linkton on rcsl triangle project United County bad hello everyone um I know some of the

095board members here have received my email actually you all have thank you for taking the time to speak with me for over an hour the other day I appreciate it Mrs I um after that conversation I did more digging and um some of you board members know that I don't take what has been said by the Consulting groups um as the gospel truth so I will start with a cluff We Are One Way in and one way out we are looking at 1,200 students you are saying is and how many vehicles if there is an emergency what are we doing R to Bell Road on the chestnut you can only go out through Floyd F you are landlocked on the backside by the Softball Association you are landlock to the left of You by mvcc

096and then you have Chestnut to the right at the location where the airplane is that is being developed it has been sold there is a large industry going in there Mr panti has stated on a radio conference with wibx that they will not be opening up either end of Bell Road and there will be a circle going in there that study needs to be done and that needs to be looked at before anything is decided at klef if we have an emergency what is happening that needs to be your number one [Music] thought secondly I made some phone calls today to the realer of RCs that building is under contract [Music] you guys need to make a decision ASAP that is your best option you have 26 building you have 26 classrooms existing I understand

097that it does not meet Ada standards but you guys need to get on the ball with this you have 15.1 acres of land at RCS you have 14.6 Acres at kuu yes it's not a big difference but you have more ability to get in and out okay we are looking at currently today 4 through 6 1,178 students today next year if we were to move into a 4 through six location we would have 1,153 students we're looking at more that we need to look at more than 1,200 yes our numbers have gone down but if we continue to do the study over over the years our numbers are going up they are not decreasing in our district what is the cost if we do a building for sixth grade only at our RCS location or

098at a c location we are looking at students this year of 389 for sixth grade and next year 405 so we will be eliminating on average 2 to three classrooms per building so let's say 18 classrooms can those students if we do just sixth grade Annex could we go and have them moving around as they would if they were at stra so they would go to English in a classroom science in a classroom history in a classroom so on and so forth that building at RCS has a stage has a gymnasium has a music room there's a chapel that could be turned into a PT speech room there is a full science room in that building already I understand that there's other things that go into this but we have the structure that's there they're

099looking at 1.2 million as their purchase price my understanding is the Das came to Rome district and said you guys want it and we didn't come to them and we didn't give them an answer if we were interested or not interested correct or incorrect bored do we know this I do because I made the phone call today have you guys made the phone calls have you done the research that's my question to you I did it four years a three years ago whatever it was in 2022 and I presented you with the data then I will be your data Searcher if that's what I need to be but I will not sit on this board you guys need to start researching things it can't be us in the public that's doing it all and presenting

100it to you Stadium support my opinion there's not enough room my kids go to Field Hockey Camp there in the summer I can't even find a parking spot to pick them up and there's a 100 kids there and we're going to go and try to put a school there how are we going to have functions those are the other things we have to look at if we have 1,200 kids in a building we need to have enough spots for those families as well to park to be able to come to see their kid in a concert and it's just not the mom and dads it's the grandparents and the aunts and uncles so we need to have enough room for everything thank you thank you Sarah you're good here right you're good all right moving

101on on to our student board member report so with our break that was um a two weeks ago now we don't have much to share with you but the little bit that we do we would like to just let you know that region week is up and coming it is the 20th through the 24th well not the 20th because it's Martin Luther King day but that week so that's all at RFA and then we also have our show choir that is called rap city is starting to perform and we do a tour that goes around to all of the elementary schools and that will be starting January 17th and our final tour is January 30th and then our performances that are open to the public are January 24th and January 31st and the tickets for

102that are $10 and we have some exciting news that we would love to share with you guys the RFA musical was announced this past Saturday at the Cabaret performance and we will be performing the musical foot loose thank [Music] you thank you both okay next up we have our workshop for program and service review based Budget Building budget overview that is a mouthful thank good evening I wanted to give you a quick overview of what our base budget is looking like at this point um the finance committee will be meeting um next week and so we'll start digging into some of these numbers a lot more which will then allow you to start seeing some of these numbers when we're coming to these meetings in a lot more detail our base budget is based on

103basically three different things they're based on our fixed costs which include salaries utilities insurance benefits bonds those are things that don't really change at all they're going to um be set in stone either by contracts or um given to us by vendors we also have our operational costs which include our supplies and materials maintenance and contractual costs those are what we need in place in order to be able to make sure all of our buildings are up and running every day for all of our students and then you have the core programs costs those are the costs in order to continue to maintain the programs that we have in place they include our general education special education Library technology and Athletics it does not include any new initiatives that we're looking at including for next

104year such as the tutoring program um or some of the other things that we're looking at doing this is just the base budget our Revenue sources in any school district come from four five main things state aid which we're all aware of which is your foundation Aid your building Aid Transportation Aid bosis special education and categorical that's usually provided to us by the state sometime in February as a preliminary and then finalize sometime either in March um we've had it as late as may but we try to have it by the end of March we also have What's called the local Revenue which is the tax base that's the piece that we send out to all of our taxpayers and they pay a portion called School tax we also here in Rome have several Pilots

105that we receive which are payments in lie of taxes our school district has several Federal AIDS they do not count as part of a general fund but they do help to alleviate some of the cost on our general fund budget currently we have title grants IDE grants and our Child Nutrition program helps to alleviate those costs on our general fund we also have in this District because we have a larger general fund we have a lot of miscellaneous Revenue our interest income from having that money in our savings accounts um is somewhere between1 and and $2 million on an annual basis so that is um beneficial to our district we also have um things like prior year refunds when we um allocate certain funds this year to bosis and they don't use all of those

106funds next year we receive that back in a prior year refund we also have the benefit of being able to Bill out for Medicare reimbursement we have several staff members that are clinically based so that they can build for those things and the district benefits from that so those are all part of our miscellaneous revenues we also here in the last several years have used fund balance and reserves to help balance our budget last year we had reserves or fun balance that we were planning to use for the 24 25 school year of approximately 11.5 million the goal would be to reduce that Gap so that way we're not using our fund balance and our Reserve balance as much that way we can start putting money aside for other reserves I put together r a

107rough estimated expense base budget for next year this is based on what our current salaries are what our contracts are in place um right now we're expecting salaries to be approximately 66 million our utilities to be right around 4 A5 million insurance and benefits to be roughly 41 million and our bonds um approximately 8.3 million our operational cost between all buildings would be roughly 1.2 million contractual costs are almost 11 million and our maintenance costs are probably um 3.4 million core programs currently are going to be 4.1 special education is approximately 11.9 Library costs are just shy of 600,000 technology is going to be approximately 1.8 and our Athletics program is less than half a million we're expecting our total expenses for next year to be roughly 154 million now that's not to say that

108there may not be some opportunities to have some cost savings we're still working through some of those things but that's looking at what our current costs are this year and looking at what we expect with escalation costs with contracts in place and so forth for next year again that's just the base budget um what we're expecting for estimate estimated revenues is approximately 103 million almost 104 million um that is guessing at what the governor run will look like um I'm estimating somewhere between 0 1% and that's based on what the governor has put out there as part of the Rockefeller study that um came out recently that's also going off of things that's been said for the last 3 or four years that they're going to change this foundational aid for us um so that's

109roughly what we're expecting currently um in local Revenue we're expecting if I just did a flat 2% cap um we can expect to have local revenues of approximately 4.1 4.2 million and that includes our Pilots that we currently receive in terms of Federal Aid I did factor that in even though it's not part of our general fund we at least wanted to make sure that we were aware that we do have almost $8.6 million that we receive in federal aid that number May fluctuate CU a lot of that is based on enrollment um our miscellaneous Revenue again I want to emphasize that we receive quite a bit in interest income and that's going to be approximately 1.8 and that's just assuming currently what we receive on um interest rates in the bank currently for fund

110balance reserves based on what we think is going to be the new um estimate budget not base budget but with everything else that we're including of 160 million we're going to have a gap of approximately 13 million that we're going to have to fill with fund balance again that's at a high um high level expectation there are some areas where when we start sitting down with the finance committee those numbers may actually be a lot closer to that 154,000 so it reduces that Gap but I wanted to make sure that you are aware of what that kind of looks like so my next steps will be to um obviously wait until February to get the preliminary from the governor to know what we're looking at for a true Revenue piece um we will also continue

111working with our principes and directors and um our different facilities in order to finalize proposals the cabinet as I mentioned before is going to sit down with all those proposals over the next several weeks and begin determining what of those things we want to include which things we're not going to include and putting together a really tight budget um from the standpoint of making sure that everything we want is in there and then we can start backing things out of that um and then as I mentioned I'll be meeting with the finance committee starting next week and we'll really be going through these numbers line by line to determine what makes sense what doesn't make sense and what things possibly we remove out of that budget or what things we need to add into that

112budget that maybe we haven't been thinking about are there any questions for me okay thank you sorry I do I do have one question um so you're saying you're saying we're 13 million in the negative yes so it would be filled with fund balance yes so I'm expecting approximately 160 million in actual cost remember this year's budget is approximately 157 million so I'm taking that number and extrapolating that over next year and we're expecting roughly um 147 million currently in actual Revenue that number may change once we get the governor's run but I'm looking at worst case scenarios as to what I'm expecting okay I guess I'm thinking back in my question last meeting on how we can come up with the enough funding to fund the the building a new capital project for a

113new school absolutely so what we're going to have to start looking at and this is going to be a task of the finance committee is starting looking through these numbers very carefully in determining what makes sense for us to continue adding um or not adding um we have some costs that I believe are built into the budget currently that probably we can remove there are expectations of looking at some of the proposals that we have with some of our vendors and seeing if we can get better pricing there's options for looking at um some of our insurance cost and trying to work that out to get reduced costs some of those bigger um meaty things that you know I think we can probably save on that we haven't been um that also goes to our

114Five-Year Plan if we start planning some of those things out we can start looking at how we can save money and where we can save money and then putting that money aside for the reserves in order to build the building that we're discussing you welcome anything else I can help with all right thank you thank you all right moving on to our consent agenda um a resolution to accept uh that upon a recommendation of the superinten of schools the consent agenda be accepted by the Board of Education I move the resolution second by Kirsten any discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes moving on to page nine of our agenda uh is Su car Val for finance resolution one to approve 11.0 ILO contract using Bose's cross contract whereas the Board of Education

115of the Rome City School District entered into a contract with the IL group for strategic planning support services for the 2425 school year on December 9th 2024 whereas both cross Contracting has an additional cost for administrative fees requiring an increase in authorization to 89,1 19688 for the Bose cross contract now therefore be it resolved that the Board of Education of the Rome City School District authorizes a district to enter into a contract with bosis for services with the ILO group for the provision of strategic planning Support Services with an amended total cost not to exceed 89,1 19688 effective honor about January 14th 2025 and concluding honor about August 30th 2025 I move the resolution second second by Kirsten any discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes resolution to accept donations where is Dollar

116General Hanford crust and Blackbird giving fund has generously offered a donation to the Rome City School District in support of its educational programs and initiatives and whereas the Board of Education recognizes the importance of Community Partnerships and the positive impact these donations can have on enhancing educational opportunities for students and where is a donation in the amount of 5,000 from Dollar G General denty $362 4 from Haniford John Joy $200 from Cross John Joy $50 from black Bond Mills and 200 fund to RFA is designated to support school programs and now therefore be it resolved by the Board of Education to accept the above mentioned donations I'm the Board of Education expresses its sincere appreciation to each Organization for its generous support of the district's educational initiatives I move the resolution second by Nadia M

117seconded by Nadia any discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes resolution to accept Savina USA tax ciary settlement whereas Savina USA Incorporated FKA East Coast Olive Oil Corporation petitioner filed a tax seary petition challenging the assessment of its property located at 650 donston Road in the city of Rome tax map parcel number 2 43.00 d001 01.03 the property for the 20242 school year tax year whereas petitioner has proposed settlement of such proceedings upon the following terms discontinue the 2425 tax ciary proceeding with no reduction in assessment set the properties 2627 and 2027 28 assessment at 8,400,000 whereas the board of education is willing to settle the proceedings pursuant to to the terms outlined above now therefore be it resolved the Board of Education agrees to settle the tax ciary proceeding commenced by petitioner

118in accordance with the terms set forth above and in the form approved by Ferrari fanza PC and hereby delegates to Fiera fans of PC the authority to execute such settlement documents this resolution shall take effect immediately I move the resolution second by Kelly any discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes resolution to accept the reserve management plan whereas the reserve management plan was presented to the board of education on November 18th 2024 for review and consideration and whereas the reserve management plan outlines the strategies and procedures for managing the district's Financial reserves ensuring the sustainability and fiscal health of the district and whereas the board of education has carefully reviewed the reserve management plan including its goals recommendations and projected outcomes and has determined that it is in the best interest of the

119district to formally accept and implement the plan now therefore be it resolved the Board of Education hereby accepts the reserve management plan as presented to the board on November 18th 2024 the Board of Education expresses its commitment to regular review and evaluation of the plan to ensure its Effectiveness in alignment with the district's Financial objectives I move the resolution second second by Kirsten any discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes um our audit committee meeting will be on March 13th of 2025 at 3 p.m. and May 15th 2025 at 3 p.m. and our next finance committee meeting will be on January 23rd at 4:30 at the district office and that concludes since we didn't have a committee we didn't have a finance meeting due to weather so action item number one under educational

120programs resolution to approve comprehensive counseling plan resolve that upon the recommendation of the superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby approves the comprehensive counseling plan for the 2024 2025 school year I move the resolution second by Paula any discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes and on to Miss Kelly KY action item number one resolution to accept retirement resolved that upon the recommendation of the superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby accepts uh with regret the retirement of the following individual Patricia McCarthy teachers Aid at Stokes Elementary effective 630 2025 I move the resolution second I think we have threeway tie let's go second for John Melina I need any discussion all in favor any opposed resolution passes and congratulations Miss McCarthy resolution number two to accept internship resolved that upon

121the recommendation of the superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby approves an internship for Trinity Ward with the Rome City School District this will be an unpaid internship from January 6 2025 through April 30th 2025 I move the resolution second second by John any discussion all in favor any opposed resolution passes number three resolution to accept internship resolved that upon the recommendation of the superintendent schools the Board of Education hereby approves the internship for Violet cabit with the Rome City School District this will be an unpaid internship from January 13 2025 through April 29th 2025 I move the resolution second second by John any discussion why don't to approve an inter a student internship Dr Carney student internship the question why do we have to approve student internship because of the access hi be

122because of their access to confidential information working with records of the district and students and or families that they're associating themselves with so they have to be approved to have permission to be able to come in and work with our kids and families they'll be taken on the same types of respons responsibilities as a hired employee would be so do Rome City School District students who do an internship through bosies is that different a different a because I know there's a lot of bosei programs that do internships as well yes that's different it's a different caliber these are students coming out of a university or college that are seeking professional support gotcha a lot of them have requirements necessary to be able to earn the certification and or accomplishment of their college programs thanks other

123discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes tenure resolved that upon the recommendation of the superintendent schools the Board of Education hereby approves tenure for the following individuals Megan Ray teacher one effective dat 1119 2025 and Athena Hoffman teacher effective date 124 2025 I move the resolution second seconded by John any discussion all in favor I I any opposed resolution passes number five resolution to accept termination of employment agreement resolved that upon the recommendation of the superintendent schools the Board of Education hereby accepts with appreciation the termination of the employment agreement for the following individuals Jeffrey Bryant interim Human Resources administrator effective December 1st 2024 and Michael who interim Administration for administrator for special projects effective December 31st 2024 I move the resolution second second by John any discussion all in favor I any

124opposed resolution passes number six resolution for district treasur contract for 2425 whereas the board of education has negotiated a contract with the treasurer for the 2024 2025 fiscal year and whereas the treasurer Kimberly seir has agreed in the to the terms and conditions outlined in this contract which includes compensation responsibilities and other related provisions and now therefore be it resolved by the Board of Education to accept and approve the treasur contract for the 20124 25 fiscal year as presented the terms of the contract including compensation job responsibilities and other Provisions shall be effective from July 1st 2024 to June 30th 2025 I'm the resolution second second by John any discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes and on to Mr deanis for policy all right action item number one resolution to accept the

125second reading and adoption uh action it number one resolution to accept the second reading and Adoption of policies resolve that upon the recommendation of the superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby approves the second reading and Adoption of the following policies as outlined on page 13 of tonight's sub minutes I move to resolution second by Kirsten any discussion all in favor I any opposed resolution passes action item number two resolution to accept the first reading of policies resolved that upon the recommendation of the superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby approves the first reading of the following policies as outlined on page 13 of the of tonight's minutes I move to resolution all right now that Jeff has moved it Jen all right second by Jen any discussion all in favor I any

126opposed resolution passes and our next meeting is February 5th at 4:15 at the district office wonderful great progress all right miscellaneous business action item number one resolution to approve superintendent conference resolve that the Board of Education hereby approve the following conference for the superintendent of schools nand onal March 25th 2025 superintendent Summit La I it's like laala La Hoya La Hoya California uh at the Hilton toward Pines March 26 2025 March through March 28th 2025 at no cost to the district I move the resolution second by Kelly all any discussion all in favor any opposed resolution passes and we have no additional discussion items or old business so we will move to public comment part two thank you and I am going to go ahead and turn over the um the mic to sue Carelli

127I do have to step away from this board meeting for a personal work travel commitment so I do need to leave a little bit early so I'm going to let Sue go ahead and take the lead until I have to depart Dave and I'm sorry I cannot pronounce your last name that's Paul I'm sorry Paul c c sorry you could pronounce your name when you get up there please uh good evening everyone my name is Paul chikowski uh thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight um couple things I had thought about so I think one of the biggest hurdles that we all have it doesn't matter whether it's Christmas time or birthday parties or finding a new school for kids it all comes down to money right if we said here here's a billion

128dollars go do what you want with it that would make the decision making a little bit easier right okay so some ideas on how to generate Revenue all right as well as some questions that that I think the community is looking for and it may have already been spoken on so the first I want to talk is the clarity so um what grades are currently in all the schools right now and how many kids are in in each one of those grades right now and you go to see the i81 project you go to see any dot project that's going on okay there's boards that they put up here's the proposals this is the current this is what we're going to propose the people vote and they make suggestions we need to see that information

129I can't stress that enough I feel like I'm kind of blind here tonight on that what changes would be made so are we going to go from a clu school that's prek and it's going to be turned into into a 4 through six but it's going to have 200 kids in fourth grade 200 in sixth what are those numbers for proposals we need those numbers we also need to know if you're going to take kids from one school and put them into another school how is that going to affect classroom dynamics as far as the sizes go okay um and we also need to think about this was orally started with was the long-term fiscal planning and working to create a sustainable outcome okay so really thinking growth longterm okay it was talked about with

130traffic congestion on Bell Road right now for KF okay um I went to school I did Civil Engineering all right one of the things that needs to happen is current traffic studies and proposed traffic studies with that mindset though you see right now when you look at a map of Rome okay right now you've got Jervis AV you take gford Road up and then you got to come back down on jurvis AV to get back up 26 you've taken all that traffic that's trying to get out of the city to go to the suburbs and shoved them right back into the center of Rome we need to start thinking about like Syracuse right now where they have a the 481 Loop that goes around the city how hard would it be to have from gford

131Road having a loop that goes up to I don't know um Potter Road maybe to help to take that traffic off of 26 the other thing is and I drive this way on my way home is Ridge Mills and stoke they're perfect setups right now and it wouldn't take much you have the old Jones Nursery property on Madison Avenue you could have an entrance there that goes around and dumps the kids on the backside of Ridge Mills and so it's a one-way Loop and you're coming out on the 26 and you can only make a rightand turn the other problem with that intersection is and this also invol involves talking to the mayor and the common councel because this is not only just a school problem it is a city transportation problem where when you

132come off that intersection around only flowers there right people try to make a left-and turn into the gas station and they try to make a left-hand turn onto Madison Street okay so maybe it's something to talk to the city and say hey look can we have a sign that says you're going to go on Madison Street you're going to make a left onto North James Street and then you're going to use that little I can't remember the name of it that's going to be your little road that you're going to use that comes on the north North George Street tees into it that's how you're going to get to North Madison Street and the gas station to alleviate congestion there Stokes same thing Cemetery Road we've got our a roundabout we can utilize there so

133I'm sorry for growth some of the things I thought of um with with um what's the one here in Rome right in Rome where the old RFA is a community garden having students um grow crops we can sell crops to the community we could put a Christmas tree farm in at RCS to help offset some of the cost at RCS um at at the old RFA we could look at doing lights in the city instead of Lights on the Lake lights in the city we've already got the stadium that we can have Crafters come in we can do Refreshments to help generate Revenue if we charge $10 a person 100,000 people come through the door that right there is your $10 million to offset RCS okay so those are just some options right you're getting

134your time limit is reached so I'm sorry it's okay you can follow yeah mean almost done okay yeah I'm I'm pretty much done okay thank you next is Katie decastro who's addressing Community concerns addressing Community concerns um Katie decastro thanks for um the time thought and energy that um has gone into the current proposal and your intention to do what's right for our family um our families here in the community I voiced my concerns in a detailed lengthy email on Friday to the board but would like to voice an additional concern in the letter um about the proposed grade reconfiguration that also went out on Friday evening and attempt to clarify the proposal many parents myself included have raised serious concerns about class sizes uh going against New York State's curriculum grouping model impact on

135teachers and the disruption additional transitions will cause um for our children and their providers among others OTS pts their instructors I'm especially concerned about the lack of response regarding Transportation chall Alles and the realistic strain uh regarding logistics for families with multiple children attending different schools it will be nearly impossible for us to do what the district is asking us to do it uh quite literally feels like this prop proposal is dividing us these concerns despite being repeatedly shared both now and in 2022 were not addressed in the communication here um tonight or in that letter in fact the letter addressed uh improved Transportation um and tonight we heard largely about the parking spots and bus circles not logistics for families numbers are important absolutely uh finances are important absolutely building plans are important publicly

136addressing Community concerns are also important you mentioned no one's pressuring us but the statement in the letter quote once the board selects a renovation option and accepts the proposed configuration end quote implies that approval is inevitable uh leaving little room for the possibility of rejecting The Proposal this wording and this development presentation on buildings tonight um makes it difficult for families to feel like their feedback um is being genuinely considered while you've stated the board is committed to doing what's right if this proposal is not per per um approved which we appreciate uh it's very much sounds like it's already been decided and no alternative plans other than those that have been addressed um and provided to us tonight um have been presented to the public and it leaves families concerned rather than feeling included

137in this process I would just ask that the board pause um and work with the community to find a middle ground um that addresses both facility needs without uh sacrificing the needs and wants of the families in this community if families can continue to feel unheard and unsupported they will begin seeking stability in neighboring districts um ultimately weakening our community also also risking long-term and uh enrollment and funding losses for our schools thank you down yeah at least it's downhill all right hi guys I'm Christina I just had a couple questions to go along with the reconfiguration um I'm going to have to look at my phone cuz I won't remember everything without looking at it um but I just want I come in peace uh and I really don't envy any of you we

138appreciate everything that you've done to get to this point um but I just want I don't know how you guys are going to make a conceptual like building decision without knowing that reconfiguration and I think that's really important um and I just as a parent am wondering what ever happened to the five six or sixth grade Annex I think that that's kind of important for you guys to review only because that seemed to be something all the parents really wanted um and then as far as putting preate into the buildings just some questions that you might want to ask yourselves um or that maybe I know you can't answer questions right now but um would this still be a universal prek um would we get the funding for that you know do you get the

139funding for the car seats for the the buses that the kids would need to have is it going to be three and four-year-old prek or just four-year-old prek um have you guys surveyed the current prek principal to see what she thinks about putting that age group with these older kids I mean not I know they're not that much older but there is a really big developmental difference between a a four-year-old and a five and six-year-old um and then I know we have a see it resource person for the supported learning in prek and and so they're responsible for that one building um if you move prek into all the buildings then are you going to have one SE it person who has to then deal with all those buildings or are you going to put

140a SE it person in every building um and then just I just wanted to say as a parent who's had a kid at Bellamy kids at Bellamy and at Stokes I personally feel like the equity and the um what you addressed about having somewhere where all the kids want to go we're now at Stokes because of a move and I would have never left Bellamy or ask to go to any other school they I feel and I float to all the the buildings and I feel like sometimes you guys don't realize that the parents don't I maybe you have one or two that are like oh I want my kid at Stokes I want my kid at Ridge but we have such amazing teachers at every school especially Bellamy that's my that's where my my

141kids started so I just want you to keep that in mind and um yeah so those are my questions I really think that that prek thing is concerning to me just because that's a that's a big jump to have those little guys in that school with those bigger kids even though they're only first second third grade I think you really need to keep that in mind so thanks question would you like to follow conversation oh yeah sure if I can have one all right thank you yeah Tara artel to discuss if we close clef where will the second current students go during I'm sorry I'm having a hard time reading these where will the 206 current students go okay hi did you want to speak or you just are looking for a response I mean

142chrisa sorry hello um Christina asked one of the questions I had was is this going to be a three and four-year-old prek program brought into the schools just because that is adding you know are we adding one or two pre preschool classes per school or is it one preschool um and also if we're leaning towards the CL I think a question would be when we're in the middle of construction if we're adding a second story where are these 206 preschool students going to be displaced for sounds like maybe two is years during once we initially start construction I guess that would be my biggest concern is do we have a place to put however many preschool classes that we decide are going to go on CU I I know there's a wait list for fours

143and right now those kids are waiting and they probably aren't going to get into the preschool and they're going to get back into kindergarten but if we if we shorten and make our preschool classes less there's even more four-year-olds that are going to be missing their preschool experience and then the kindergarten teachers are now having more students that have missed learning the social cues the behavior cues CU that's really important for four-year-olds um you know we're obviously academic as well but they're missing the social cues they're coming into kindergarten brand spanking new and that's going to be harder on those kindergarten teachers if we're going to be limiting how many preschoolers are going to be making it into the programs if if we're only giving one or two classes per school because even if we're

144taking out fourth fifth and sixth if we want to have art rooms and music rooms and and things that is going to limit how many rooms open up for preschool and are we focusing on only bringing the fours are we bringing both threes and fours so that's really my concern are the little guys sure okay that concludes our board is second by Nadia all thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.