CorpusRecord 236504

Buffalo BoE Work Session 2/5/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Buffalo Public Schools
Date
2025-02-06
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
20,527 words · about 115 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001and uh other issues that are upcoming for the uh for for the board so I'm going to give it to the superintendent so she can have any remarks and introduce our CFO thank you so much chairwoman Woods um I know that you have been meeting along with uh Chief barns um you know on this very challenging year that we have coming up on us budget year um last year we made the decision to uh eat the elephant in a smaller you know portion so we split it up over two years rather than um addressing our fiscal cliff in one year and so he's going to I think share a little bit about as a reminder some of the things that we did last year and then talk a little bit about the state a um

002that we are expecting to get this year and what some of the plans are with respect to that and so I will turn things over to Chief Barn thank you superintendent thank you m WS so I'm going to cover three things but they're all interrelated um I'm going to give you the second quarter financial report and projection for the current year and we're going to go into a budget update for next year and then I'm going to touch on essential components for our four-year plan so aded next slide please sorry the wrong you don't want the second quarter you want the budget process I want this thing the presentation for and there be bringing that up in a minute okay so our second quarter results through 12 3124 and a full year projection as the

003superintendent noted uh it we need context uh to properly digest this uh the first six month results so remember what we develop during this current year 2425 budget two factors had a dramatic impact on thisr Curr year budget the loss of 90 million in ressor and the need to align staff counts and cost to the declining enrollments the super constructed a two-year plan that mindfully addressed these issues while also ensuring that in the current year all student needs are met she avoided disruption to the Investments that we made in security Health and Welfare and Athletics and in order to do that we utilized 83.5 million of our fund balance during this transition year uh the first year of the two-year plan this was unprecedented cut a net 226 mostly vacant 99.9% vacant from the total

004District budget but in order to do that we had to increase the general fund Fount by 158 the net impact of those decisions and avoided lay off that kept in place security social emotional welfare as the superintendent noted in their remarks will be a large increase in salary and benefit expenditures and a relatively small amount of vacancy savings unlike prior years so how do we look at 1231 as of the second quarter the district is projecting a $ 73.5 million deficit for the full year that is $10 million less than the deficit in the approved budget but however I do want to mention these projections they're exhaustive uh unlike previous unlike the prior previous few years we will have a general fund deficit in 2425 don't quite know the exact about yet but there's going

005to be a deficit and we need to understand that as we proceed into next year's budget next slide edmir so we're talking about the current year results we've received the 2425 state revenue output report showing that state revenues will be approximately 99.3% of our budget abouts I'll show you a table on that in a little bit but that's an excellent job by the revenue team the FTE charts uh that were that are included in the quarter 225 report I'm going to review them real quickly below they're based upon data available 3124 you'll see the impact of the superintendent's two-year plan and the job that we still need to finish up in year two why we focus so much on FD it's 66% of our expenditures salary overtime benefits as noted in the first quarter report

006we're expecting vacancy savings to be considerably less this year as of 1231 uh we are only expecting vacancy Savings of 8 million that's why we're going to have a deficit thiss year as we we begin looking ahead at next year's budget that this current year is one of the most eventful in many years it includes the superintendent plan to deal with the financial course maintaining all security athletic Health and Welfare needs of the students and we're past the beginning stages uh of the largest investment in facilities in decades commissary the capital budget board the quarter three report as we progress through those projects I'll give you a more thorough and accurate projection and your next slide so we're still focused on the six months results I just thought I'd show you this uh snapshot of

007our Spate a the third column over is our 2425 budget $939 m223 that's what we had projected in in the current Year's budget process the blue column next to it these are our state aid revenues that's posted by the state saying this is what we're going to give you the bottom line it's 932 million so that's $7 million less than our budget but it's 99.3% of what we are expecting so revenues are in the current year a rock solid we're not going to have any various from Budget on and next slide okay I'm going to go through the FTE again one more time here's the impact of the two-year plan the big grass to the left you see the Orange Line got 226 positions we cut the vacancies there was no impact to the children

008or anybody else by doing that no one has done that the superintendent did it last year the current year sorry but we're such a big organization you got look at where those FTE were cut from on the right side these are the top table is the grand font you see that precipitous drop that's because we had almost 400 position in arbesser and we cut the vacancies associated with him and moved the balance uh over to the general fund which takes us to the last chart on the bottom right you see the increase in that orange line those are positions that almost any other District would have cut when our are ended we didn't we vot security social workers guidance counselors and others over to the general fund uh ad next slide I should note that

009can't be sustained in the general fund that that's where we are so last comments on our second quarter report this is uh projected cash flows for E end of year if you look at the green column we started off the year with million the bottom of thatc we're expecting the end the year at 389 million if you have a $73 million deficit that means you your cash balance is dropped by that amount uh definely are serious uh they have a serious impact on the uh on the district's finances so we're going to drop this year we'll still be very healthy the difference between this drop uh we collect grants in the current year from the prior year and we collected the last bucket of aress Grants this year so that's why the drop into cash

010balance isn't as precipitous as the uh estimated uh deficit shows so we're going to end this year rest conern with 389 million okay and next slide to switch topics we're going to talk about the 2526 budget process which is underway the three items highlighted on top have been completed we got the governor's budget propos proposal and the school launs superintendent sent out her kickoff memo with budget instructions which clearly outline the challenges ahead this year school-based budgets have been distributed last Friday I know Maria had meetings with t of principles and others today uh we reviewed a bunch of things in the school based budget with Mrs Woods yesterday everything is underway uh some of the items Bel the beneath the yellow items which have been accomplished there there training session starting tomorrow running through

011the end of next week for Department non staff entry all departments this is another that I discuss with Mrs Woods our budget process is completely transparent and bottom up the Departments enter their budget request uh they got a turn in by March 14th then uh the school based budgets uh are on 317 so March is a very busy month after we get those two things we'll collapse all the data and issue reports uh in numerous ways current year versus prior we'll see what the deficit looks like just based upon this initial data and then the super and the board will go to work to uh chop the deficit down uh one other thing we don't get our final state aid numbers until like almost April 7th the legislature always tweaks their Governor's budgets a little

012bit adir next slide please okay here's the governor's budget proposal this is what's in our level two budget right now want to point out a couple things um the green column that's what was published by a bunch of organizations as the governor's budget and what they're given to Buffalo um the superintendent myself and richer Nyland met last week on the pink C there was certain data that the governor's budget Drew upon that wasn't updated so the the pink column is the results of Rachel and my staff making adjustments to what was published by the governor that's the orange column was about $19 million less than was published the last two columns show that orange column versus what we got this year I I'll go to the percentage column we got a 5.2% increase in Foundation

013aid from the governor about 36 million and then overall we got about a $28 million increase or 3% but I want to just mention one other number you see building Aid a decrease of 12 million that's expected building Aid is primarily used to pay your debt service so as that goes down building Aid goes down so building Aid is going down 12, 900,000 our principal and interest on our debt is going down 15 million this year so that really doesn't impact anything uh right now I would consider the governor's proposal pretty good for us and we next slide so two sides that The Ledger the revenues and the expenses so got the governor revenues pretty good however right now with those revenues plugged in we're showing $117 million deficit before school based budgets are submitted

014before departments ENT enter their uh specific staff request so we got to keep in mind the environment we're dealing with just based upon contract step and Longevity increases for our 11 unions our salaries are going to go up $32 million next year guarantee must we cut bu based upon these salary cost and other factors our benefits are going to go up about $12 million next year then based upon a very small increase in Charter enrollments but a manth tuition change formula Charter related expenses are going to go up 15 million but again based upon our new con Transportation contract we expect about a 10 or5 million actual increase in transportation expenditures so we did okay on the revenue side but built into to our current Staffing and operational model we have all these different cost

015increases that are going to happen somewhat offsetting these increases good that increase in Foundation Aid which I just showed you a $15 million reduction in our debt service payments which I mentioned and the increases in transportation cost they're approximately 90% reimbursable through State through State end in the following year so in that first year there's a you got to pay the difference out of your cash flows but you get it back in the following year um the next steps in our budget process are the training as I mentioned and level two Department uh so we'll be back in a couple three weeks with updates on that when we gather additional data uh from the school-based budget and Department entry ad almost last slide guys next slide please all right A fouryear Plan update fouryear plan

016is the most important financial planning tool we have the budget provides a detailed oneyear Outlook the 4-year plan incorporates important Trend data and a multi-year projection of our current decisions and the impact on our fund balance so I'm getting underway at doing the trund data and setting up the template but I won't have anything really to report on this until we approve a budget but issues that have to be addressed in the fouryear plan and initially Quantified the structural deficits uh we we can't keep approving budgets with 30 40 50 million in deficits uh especially when we know we're no longer going to get the vacancy sa and school closing uh we put it in the last four-year plan we took a oneyear pause on implementation we are going to have to implement school closings

017in order to get to a structural uh balance in the four-year plan will be a rather complicated if that's the right were Capital project plan I only say complicated because the timing of the cost and the revenue have to be carefully considered over time that'll include the debt in the building aid financial impact of the commissary got to keep that in there um a very very high level over view of what I'm talking about here appears on the next page and I need to begin communicating to the board I know you're aware of all these decisions but we also often view them in a vacuum so I just Tred to P in the superintendent and I went over this on one page sort of a worst case scenario if you don't manage your cash flows

018through a period of structural deficits and spending on a commissary and capital projects this is no way shape or forms say says any of that is unwise at all yeah next slide [Music] please this is really hard to see but you the Top Line starts at what we're projecting cash to be at the end of this fisal year that's that 389 billion this is very simplified so you lose $83 million this year that reduces day cash I threw in for next year's budget deficit what I include occur for your plan and you lose another $35 million a commissary will cost us $50 million by the time it's at the end of the 15year weas there capital projects 94 million new debt payments to fund the capital project will add 60 million now offsetting those things

019the updated projections which I gave we're not going to lose 83 million we're going to lose 73 so you add $10 million back the bond s that's going to add 404 it could be 54 I always want to give you guys sort of a worst case then we get building Aid on these capital projects that'll be at least $40 million but when you ring it all out it brings your cash balance down from 389 to about 161 million after 15 years um there's an awful lot we can do within that period of time to address our structural deficit uh more and and more unique financing for the capital project that could increase that projected 161 back up to over 250 uh I just wanted to sort of show you a worst case situation and to

020get you sort of familiar with that these are great decisions there are transformational decisions that have been put on shelf for 20 years but to implement them cost cash and you're going to have to uh get used to not save $400 billion in cash but if we wisely manage our operating deficits we can find T and some of the other factors below we can get through all of this so that'll be in the foure plan that thank you that's all I have [Music] just okay um I want to I want to mention also that um for the new board members we uh are requesting and talked to superintendent Mr Barnes that the orientation on the budget and the finances and the revenues and the expenditure areas and the different GR grants that every old board

021member was given so that we would be able to look at this budget and know exactly what uh Mr Byron is talking about we I've asked for that to be given to all the new board members so that you're looking at this budget we're sending you the school-based budgets but you'll also have be given the knowledge to know what the alphabet soup soup letters are and what the revenues are so I know this is your first time through for the new board members and we also have two other board members who are fairly new uh we're we're going to be bringing you some assistance on understanding School finances buff Public Schools uh budget and um that should be helpful for this but uh given that um Mr Burns I just wanted to address that uh

022the school-based budget have gone out to each of our principles and uh the principls did not receive in case you've been getting calls they did not receive any kind of 10% across the board cut that position cuts or any of that that's not in the superintendent's letter nor in the budget instructions and you you you can speak to that and also that uh basically it was supposed to be a status quo for their expenditures so if you're hearing a lot of other issues that's not factual and the only other thing that was sent in the budget instructions so all of us know when we're talking to our schools is that the psychologists and social workers know they did not disappear they're just not in their school-based budgets right now no they did not lose other

023social workers we all know we're addressing mental health so it was stated clearly in the instructions that those things weren't in there so I know you've been getting a lot of feedback so I want to open it up to the four for any uh any questions thank you for that Mr wood uh I don't see let's see the hands on this side it's not showing up okay um uh fairy member Sharon Bon Cotman thank you for the presentation I have a couple of questions here um in your projections did you include the reimbursement that the state gets from Transportation yes it it's already included this year's uh included yep it's uh 57 m900 44 25 sorry 53,1 15, 341 but that's on a lag payment so that figure is probably lower than our actual expenses

024right no that's yes that's based upon the prior year expenses but that's cash we received this year for okay all right and what page is that on please um four okay thank you um I'm just curious the to uh year to date figure for the unfilled uh vacancies within our schools how much has that been please8 million I'm projecting it to be $8 million uh through the end of the year right you're talking about the end of the school year correct so I was one do you have a year to date figure I tell you no I get that for you I can't remember from the template right now I saw the projection of $8 million I saw that I was just wondering if uh what percentage we are at this point of that $8

025million get now um Food Service my understanding is every year um Food Service um clears or they're able to make a deposit a substantial deposit um of over a million dollars do we account account for that money and anything oh yes it's uh it's it's Revenue to the general fund and that uh the federal money that food service is a grant we have to charge that indirect cost perur terms of the grant okay okay charging direct cost yep okay since the status name one other question so it was presented I think a while back that we were looking at closing somewhere between uh three to we needed to close three to four schools in order for us to be in compliance with the state it did I misunderstand that or not yeah uh only the

026part about that we'd be out of compliance with the state it was put into the current four-year plan which the board approved has another step to get us toward a structurally balanced budget uh we're not how much more we can ring out of like a school-based budget without changing the physical uh uh footprint is getting smaller and smaller we have to close buildings as a method to get to a balanced budget okay and so so with the um need of Bennett and U Middle Early College bursting at the scenes um are there any plans to address that need this year for Middle Early College originally last year not originally but there was some conversation last year that we would consider possibly uh using uh one of the schools School 37 uh and moving the children

027from school 37 over to macowski has anything happened with that or is anything moving forward with that no not for this year that's really a two-year process because placement always works really on a two-year process so the applications that will come out this spring will really not be for this coming fall but for the fall beyond that so we are looking at um closing down a program but I wanted the opportunity to meet with the board before we move forward with that but it would not be school 37 for September okay all right so we you do understand that um that the middle Early College situation has existed now for over 22 years okay and somehow or another they continue to be put on the back burner and I'm little a little concerned that that's

028going to continue to be the case without some definite plans put in place thank you um if there's other board members who have questions could you raise your hand so I could see it U Dr Kathy Evans Brown board president oh thank you chair woman was so thank you again Jim for a fantastic budget presentation so my question is when we talk about a fund balance is there a formula or is there like a certain amount of money that we need to show that we're fiscally solvent um and also is that related to when you talk about a structural balance budget sure oh yes there definitely is a Formula it's like 4% of your average expenditures over a three-year period for us it comes in about $200 million um it just for some perspective our

029payroll every two weeks is $23 million we are a monstrous organization so you need that might sound like a lot of money but we're very big so we're expected to have more the structural imbalance is every year when you do your budget back in the old days I guess before all these extraordinary needs it wasn't very hard for school districts to know what revenues are coming in and just keep hiring the same staff don't have any programs and the revenue always ended up equal in expenditures the world's changed the kids needs have changed uh our expenditures that but it's our decision we don't have to do this always exceed our known revenuers that difference has to come out of fund balance and that's called a structural deficit well thank you for your complicated response Cindy

030M mchen your hands up thank you um I have more a comment um it's not a question um but I just wanted to put out a friendly reminder as we're going through the budget process and I know I recognize we're still earlier in it but we do have our 2025 um goals that will go into effect and you know as we're going through and presentations are happening and we're getting a little bit more um fine-tuned um it would be awesome if we can just see how some of decisions we're making conversations that are being had tied to supporting kind of that the goals and what what it is that we're looking to start doing and again I don't not looking for anything right now but I think it's a great opportunity for us to kind

031of um pilot going through this process and what that could look like um and work but as always Jim you're Rockstar thanks so board member mcken if I can just share that last year it was a part of the kickoff memo and we did prioritize um positions and programs that were supporting the goals and it was also uh you know included in this year's memo to staff and it again will prior will be prioritizing to make sure that we have what we need to support meeting the goals thank you superintend I appreciate that yep um excellent presentation Mr CFO two two points that uh that I'd like to um uh share and and and request every year when we're doing the budget the question of equity yeah Equity is still real for New York State

032at least uh we asked for vacancy seats by school so that each board member can see what positions are vacant in their schools so they know what their principles are dealing with uh and we also know what schools are bearing the brunt of whether it's 14 million as it's been in the past or eight million in this case who is is not receiving the teachers the Staffing that they have requested and paid for so uh I'm again asking that that be provided Madam superintendent uh with your okay that that be provided to the board members so they're knowledgeable what their schools are facing and then the other thing that I would like to say to you uh to uh make uh available and and direct and guide since the second largest expenditure that we have

033that's increasing by 12 million is friends benefits that there is a firm that we'd like to recommend to Mr Barn that can address that since we need to con reduce contain expenses reduce expansions in expenses in our largest areas friends benefit being one that they can assist us in that and we'd like for you to meet and uh provide some information so that we can tackle that we know we have have to tackle Personnel that's 66% that's our biggest but uh French benefits is next and if we can save any positions by reducing French benefit costs I think that's a prudent management perspective great points great points uh I did see that Chief Holly McGee had uh jumped on for a few seconds and I just want to give kudos to her team and to

034our Cai team uh I think that we have far fewer unfilled positions this year than we've had in previous years they've done a lot of work making sure that you know as much as we can our classrooms are filled with certified teachers uh teacher assistant and you know teacher Aid so Chief Holly McGee I don't know if you want to say anything regarding that uh sure uh you're right it was a lot of work you know my staff worked really really hard the board made a called to make sure that schools had certified teachers in them there were fewer vacancies despite um the crisis that we were facing with the budget the first and foremost um priority was to make sure that we had certified teachers in the classroom so um our vacancies are a

035lot fewer than before um Chief Barnes and I um have conversations on a daily almost minimally weekly basis in regards to filling the vacancies and so forth so I stay in close communication with him on that um I go through his office before I fill a vacancy to make sure it in fact um is EV there's evidence to show that that classroom or that school needs that CL uh a certified teacher in there there's no need for a combined classroom there is actually um a need many times people uh mistaken vac ancies um it's really a leave so we have very generous leave Provisions in our contracts so many teachers are out for whatever reason majority of the time they're for medical reasons and so it does feel like a vacancy if I was a

036principal in a school and I didn't have a teacher for an entire year or for months at a time it would feel like a vacancy but in fact it is truly an encumbered position by another teacher and we do fill those classrooms with temporary teachers so we have come down you know drilled it all the way down to make sure that even when a teacher is on a leave we do our very very best to work with Cai CIA and um try to fill those classrooms with temporary teachers until that teacher returns we do our very best it's not 100% um you know a fill rate but we do our very best we know you're doing a Wonder wonderful job but is is it going to be difficult for you Pro to provide to the

037board the vacancies by school so we can as we begin this budget process know what we're dealing with no it will not be difficult uh Chief Barnes and I work together to make sure our data um is we're seeing the same information we have uh the data you know uh assured that it's factual clear clean and accurate data we want to make sure that the information we give to you is accurate and it shows you a distinction between a true vacancy meaning that there is this is not an encumbered position by a teacher and versus the ones that are not filled because a teacher is on a leave of some sort so we want to be sure to make sure we give you accurate data that so you can decipher between the two and you

038can uh you know uh do your assessment that way that's wonderful I met with some of the staff yesterday Maria has excellent information in the school-based budget so uh yes um I'm sure the board will be looking forward to that uh last thing Mr Burns uh on on the budget presentation at least uh you sent something to all the board members can you tell them what you sent them I sent them the school based budget book handbook y so that they can know the rules that everyone is um oh I'm sorry yes which outlines all the rules all the formulas all the processes okay and you'll see it's very clear it's very thorough it's based upon enrollments and student needs within the building and it's all very transparent now the other thing that the board

039members need to be aware of in previous years because enrollment was dropping and we had lost 4,000 students a number of our schools a number of your schools their budgets their school-based budgets were allocated based on enrollment in their schools and if they lost a lot of students then they would see oh my God I didn't get an A English teacher or I didn't get this but this year after listening to our CFO we had a 400 increase in our students so the student count did not significantly drop so we should not have a big problem of oh my God your school got cut and there's nothing we can do about it if they lost students so that was the good news that that I was told yest sir am I am I stting that

040correctly Mr bars yes formula dtive and moments go up 400 kids over 60 buildings it's a lot to spread but it's fantastic news haven't seen that in 10 years so yes you s right could I I want don't tell I what Tammy said uh we're getting great results working closer and closer together at two of our departments and then regarding leaves this is not teachers this is all there's 400 people out on leave and every day then there's three 400 who take off every day uh everything about our district are big numbers and they have an impact okay Terry shoa board member Sha has her hand up you have a question yes um first of all I want to thank um Chief barns uh for the update but my question is because we this came

041up uh last week how do we make a determination during the school year that we're cutting a a position is that how like what data or how do we make a decision that a position is going to be cut mid year mid I can give you an example like from central office if I've had a vacancy my and my staff has stepped up and I'm nailing all my reports I'll take that uh position out of the budget because I don't need it anymore and money can be better used in another place okay but what if it was a filled position a filled position so we work with uh our Chiefs our you know department or division lead s and there certainly are sometimes um that they may feel that the work you know can be

042accomplished without that position we are facing a $73 million deficit and so you know the days of us just keeping positions just for the sake of you know keeping positions if there's a feeling that you know the work can be accomplished in a in a more fiduciary way then they would make a recommendation they would there been several positions has there been several positions that we've done that with there have not been several okay I don't know if Chief belli is on here or not but I know in the special ed dep Department I know that they do um have reviews and um I don't know if she wants to speak to some of the special ed um classrooms and some of the special ed adjustments that we've had to make HR with um some

043of the positions being cut and so some of the teacher aids have been moved around and or um because those positions were cut and so I know that my staff um in the recruitment Department have worked closely with uh Chief belli staff to make sure that people had another landing spot okay when uh positions were cut due to um New York State special ed okay okay thank you so much folks thank you m Mr BRS I believe you have another area you need to present well uh I think I caused some confusion I C I covered the overview of the second quarter results in this first presentation and I think I touched on all the San points so I can save this all some time and I don't need to give that okay uh I

044see another board member our newest board member uh you have your hand up yes thank you chair woman woods and I appreciate the um the information I certainly not a finance expert I just want to um lift up concerns about special education every single day special ed teachers are pulled out of ICT rooms to cover positions I mean I spoken to parents when teachers are on leave not special ed certified Subs are in classrooms which has repercussions for students and the sub sometimes so I would I want us to be mindful of the special education needs one more from a staffing perspective that is our priority so one of the things that we've changed in this District um since last year we're really focusing on hiring special ed teachers so that's one of the areas

045that we have had a hard time filling all of the vacancies for so we wanted a responsible um adult in that classroom and so in many cases I understand what you're saying we've had to put a sub in there but um we're working really hard we have our teacher pipeline programs and what we're doing is we're honing in strictly in the curriculum and um the tenure area of special ed we're going out for Teacher recruitment day out in Niagara Falls where all of Western New York school districts come together to hire teachers um for the upcoming school year our focus is on special it so we're only accepting applications at this point right now for special ed teachers one thing I can tell you that they have signed up and we have I think it

046was 13 that was reported to me today that are already signed up to meet with our um pipeline program uh Miss Elizabeth Campion and Joel blazel um for that teacher recruitment so we're we're trying to pull them out of the woodwork but again we want the best and the brightest and the really good uh talented teachers to come in before our students but that is our priority it's a very very tough um vacancy to fill but I think we're doing much better than some of the other districts so I'm I'm grateful to that we do the best we can if we you know and we've even had to take teachers that are certified as fizzed teachers that are willing to work with our special ed students and it's worked out some have even gone back

047to get their special ed start because they didn't realize they were going to enjoy it that much so if we didn't have a fette position for them this year we um were offering them opportunities to work in our special ed class rooms and uh we have seen that that has been very successful and it has opened up their minds and their eyes to uh group of students that they now want to go and get their certification so it's been very helpful to us you know and again that's kudos to the work that your department and the Cai and principles you know are doing with our folks and you know I know that the contract contract was a you know it was lucrative for teachers but it also shows I think across Western New York how

048Buffalo values the teachers and I think that is a big part of you know us being able to fill some vacancies we're in the game now we are in the game and we've had some that have left Suburban districts and charter schools to join our district so it's just something to keep in mind well if there's no more questions from the board members then this concludes the fight finan and UPS uh section we're a little bit early no no we have a transportation [Laughter] presentation no pressure there there's nothing like going on after everyone's been told they're [Laughter] done so um good evening board members uh thank you uh vice president Woods I appreciate it and um just wanted to get started here we're um doing a transportation update um and uh this was a

049late ad so thank you to woman woods and uh for advocating for that um I'm here Chief Operating Officer I'm joined with by Joe Goan who's our director of transportation and we also have on the call for questions and followup the end of the presentation from first student Rob humble um who is the area general manager can you introduce the representatives from first student who are on the call yep uh we have Brian Fitzgerald our senior Vice President we have Sean Albright our region vice president Jim uck our finance director Andrew ryell our senior location manager who oversees the five Buffalo locations and uh CJ who is our customer service uh representative good thank you very much um ad mayor can you go to the next slide please so we are still um working to

050resolve our ability to transport students in the middle of National bus driver shortage uh this graph shows from a peak in 2010 of around 300,000 bus drivers emplo employed in yellow school bus transportation throughout the nation um we are now down to about 2third of that number um steady declines in both private sector School drivers and also public sector School drivers we of course have a third party vendor so we are mostly P private sector and that's impacted Nationwide the ability to transport students um we are in our routine cycle of renewing our five-year contract so Joe Goan is going to review kind of the timeline of how we prepared that contract and how um where we're at now Joe uh add me next slide please Joe could you review yes so currently for student

051is under contract contract through the rest of this school year and we're working on the 25 through 30 contract which we already sent out you know nice that has strict guidelines on how the rfbs go out and how they have to be filled out and we've already been through that process we had five bids for those who don't know we have five different bids for home to school is one special needs two field and sports trips is three General summer general education is four and summer special needs five so we need trans that covers our transportation for the whole school year those five contracts and the number of um buses that we bid out for this contract was 500 in the past 10 years our bus count has ranged as high as um 684 but

052after the pandemic we've settled down into the mid um 450s 460s as our bus counts we went with 500 buses for this contract and we hope to get up to that number eventually and this is also for this another fiveyear term like our last one was from 20 to 25 so this one's 25 to 30 and the bid closed in June uh 24 so and the reason for splitting it into multiple contracts is so it does increase incentive for maybe um a another company to bid on one of those contracts um so there's separated out to allow for um increased opportunities for various siiz bidders next slide ad there so there were four bids total for all five contracts only two bids were complete so the other two bids out of the four didn't actually

053have any price estimates they were blank bids but it allows the vendor to take look at all the documentation and everything there were other um companies Nationwide where we did get inquiries from um did attend the question session uh but the only bids we received were those four and first student was the lowest bidder on all five contracts for the first year the first student bid the cost is 82 815 to20 um the which is up from the actual cost effective rates from last year and the next bidder was student transportation of America their bid was for all five contracts from 12372 317 so that was the next closest bid and on none of the five contracts um were they even within a couple million of the lowest bidder the contract does include it included

054a 10% bid Bond and then it also includes a 100% performance bond uh which protects the district uh there have been times in the past that we have not secured that performance bond but that that is secured in this uh cost the end of the current agreement will be J June 30th 2025 so July 1 is when we start the new agreement can I just say one thing on that par if you don't know we there were a lot of bids from other states and other regions but in New York state you have to have a CDL to drive students home to school and in other states they can use Services more like Uber or bus you know different they have different Services they don't require CDLs for their drivers but New York State requires

055a CDL for every single driver that drives a student from home to school and back and vice versa and all four of the bids were um already two were local they didn't put a compe complete bid in and sta already has contracts in New York state so they're very familiar with doing business in New York state next slide admir so Joe's going to kind of review kind of a transportation distances this is more just to let you know that oh not not quite admir uh just let you know that Buffalo is very aggressive and the board has positioned itself to support students in an urban environment to um get to school with provided transportation and that we stand out in in comparison to other big five districts um but it also it's beyond what is

056reimbursable by New York state so that there is a cost not all the cost um the a lot of the costs of running Transportation um are reimbursable and it's not the actual per student amount but the per student amount is not always reimbursable based on our distances we have so Joe's going to review these numbers yes so when we look at the reimbursable number I think um we said before was about 90% of the transportation budget was reimbursable if we look at Albany for example everyone in Albany has to be 1.5 miles away from school or they don't get a ride Albany is probably 100% reimbursable because that's the state limit is 1.5 miles so I bet in Albany their transportation is probably completely covered by the state and if you look at Rochester and

057Syracuse they're like high breads that's 1.25 one mile it's a little bit different you know they probably their reimbursements are probably about you know 93 95 % you know New York City a lot of the students ride the public transportation that's their only option you know I think three to six they ride the Metro their Metro System they don't even get yellow busing and they have to be more than a mile from school so I'm just saying out of the big five um way they can part of the way they control their cost or the reimbursement is with the mileage and like I said we provide busing for a lot more students and there's actually you'd be surprised on the amount of students between 7 and 1.5 miles from our elementary schools do you remember

058the number for that was it like 3,000 it's 5,526 about 2 21% of our students so you know very often when I'm watching the routes coming in in the morning I'll be watching a bus that's you know 10 blocks away from a school and should be there in two minutes but because they have multiple stops before the school they're going around in um around the school to pick up students that are very close that 21% besides reimbursability adds to the number of buses we need um on any given day next slide adme I just want to talk about some of the key comparisons you know like I said we've you can see the buses has increased slightly you know from 23 after the the pandemic you know we're still in that range we're within like

05920 15 20 buses of one another the routs have gone up considerably now that we went to the three beler system and our number is higher in January 25 because that includes the elt buses giv an idea of the number of buses that we have doing elt you know a rider ship has gone up which has been good and we still have trouble recruiting and retaining bus AIDS you know you can see the elt numbers there um we're transporting about you know 2700 kids for the elt program and even though um last year our average time on the bus has dropped 3% that's because we have so many more routes now and the distance is also dropped because there's more Roots doing every school now and that that's that's a good part of that but

060also you know the more buses that we have doing every school the more chances that buses are late and if there's a problem with a bus that can Domino into all three tiers now instead of just two tiers so we you know that's an impact of that but for the past few years our system has been pre- staed bus number wise student R wise and grot wise and if you'll notice that increase in um buses um we have had some where we thought a route would work and we've had to split the route but also a lot of that is we are getting pretty regular um IEP student requests um very often an IEP will say first on first off or a FAO did I get that right loo last last last last on first

061off last down first off so um which we have to write do the route around that and we are getting increasing numbers of solo Transportation uh which we have to devote a whole driver to so there are um increasing stresses next next slide oh one thing about after school we have more students in after school than we did in 2018 that have requested Transportation now that doesn't mean that they stay every day it's just a number of buses that are arranged for Transportation uh very often a bus that's supposed to have 40 kids on it may only have 15 so um but those those are the numbers for requesting transportation and counterintuitively we've have we have a lot of Transportation requests for tier three um even though it's um 61 it's very very late so

062we were not expecting that next slide admir so our month next slide admin thank you our monthly averages for uncovered buses um I don't have numbers going back to 2021 because after the first week it again so um increasingly uh difficult um but we were averaging in the afternoon 48 uh buses uncovered 48 so that would be up to three routes uh because the bus does of two at that point two schools impacted um in 2022 which is our last year with two tiers um we had first five days we had very high uncovered rates particularly in the afternoon which it steadily did go down throughout the year in December we did have um about it was over 20 um outo District drivers came in and that relieved the um stress of the system a

063little bit um so that went down in 2023 we um started out September we had zero in the morning and in in 2024 zero in the morning in the afternoon we had about five or at average a day 3.5 um on average a day in 2024 um those have increased now the we are still trending for the up until December of this year compared to the past two years we are trending better definitely than when we had two tiers even better than our first roll out of tier one um but we do have January as we've been addressing we have had a a spike in uncovered routes in January um let me pulling up to these are C these Pages stuck together um in January up until I didn't I haven't done last week's numbers

064yet so I don't have the last week of January but up until um the first three weeks of January in the afternoon we are averaging 6.53 uncovered in the morning 5.78 so we are we are addressing that um and every year we have some bad months but that one we cannot will not we won't continue with having that that Trend so overall are uncovered we've been able to service schools with the number of drivers we have instead of getting back up to 650 we have been able with 468 buses um get to schools and service them and not have the kind of uncovered routes we had and in the in the past and bear in mind those uncovered routes were when we had routes that were 90 minutes long and we're packed with students a

065maximum number of students we could get on the bus next slide admir so just to for the the committee's information the challenges that are persistent are increasing costs the costs of um running school buses the cost of paying drivers the are they're increasing um there's an increase in system load we're not up to 400 68 routes um from 465 at the beginning of the year 456 at the beginning of last year it's slowly edging up and every new route added introduces an added possibility of an uncovered route um and sometimes we've had to add routes for students who are out of district for mckin vento um which right now we have 268 students who are out of district for mckin vento that we have to send the bus to pick up and many of those

066routes are significantly longer than our our regular route and we're required to transport out of District bikini vento students up to 50 miles so we currently have a student two students living in dunker that we are transporting we have students in niga Falls Clarence um a lot are in Camp Road in Hamburg a lot are in in chaga so we have we have those buses and there every time we have a bus going that route it means maybe one or two schools that can't be covered so that's that's an issue and um we have a persistent shortage of CDL Drivers we are still trying to hire our first students still trying to hire but it is um getting a CDL is challenging and there's still a shortage Nationwide of CDL drivers um bus Aid hiring

067and retention and along with that um the roadblocks for civil service and we are working with human resources to to address some of those roadblocks and I think there's a a brighter day coming on that um 1.5 mile reimbursement boundary New York State can and should change that um and distance students are transported for school choice is a challenge that's persistent um if you look at some of our schools we have school 72 is kind of a test case we have buses going all over the city to service that school um and it's a challenge having buses able to go all all over the city because students aren't necessarily clustered so that bus may be making 30 stops before it gets from North Buffalo to school 7 too um also there's a bus going up

068to dager Falls Boulevard for that for that um school also so the distances between the school and um the residents are a challenge and then we have the challenge of reliability consistence and consistency and communication that is always we are working to make sure that we eliminate those but if there is an issue with a students route families need to be able to know the the main source for that is the first view app that we have been seeing a lot more usage of um but there are still things that we want to see improved there in reliability consistency and communication both with the family that is sitting at home wondering whether their students should go out the door and with the school waiting for the students to be picked up at the end of

069the day and the family wondering when their students get home we also have a persistent challenge of students who are supposed to be met at the bus not being met which um creates almost every night there's one or two students where the bus has to go around wait at the stop um and then return to the stop later and that that introduces a lot of time friction into the routes next slide admir so thank you board members and thank you chair chair wman woods and um if there are any questions for students on and we can uh address them um thank you for the presentation yes I do remember they added that item uh I was uh wasn't aware who was going to exactly present it but thank you for the presentation uh I'm hearing

070what you said and what you presented so just a couple quick questions then I'll open up to other board members um you said a $13 million increase in the contract 19% increase in the contract and the question is that's a lot of money and is it because can you some uh what I hear what I'm hearing you send in summary is that we're going to move up to in your new contract 500 buses where you just presented 468 buses so is uh you can answer this you know at is this the summary of your significant increase in cost 500 bus not it is not the entire uh amount of the significant increase that okay I just want I want I want to give you the four things I heard you say and then you can

071uh 500 buses driver's Personnel is always a sign significant cost so is there some significant increase bonus or something you're giving the drivers because you're saying you're having a problem recruiting them so Personnel cost is always a significant increase uh and can you answer that also you're saying longer bus routes because we have the mckenny vento people uh children out in dunker every every all over the place so it's gas a significant uh significant cost and longer bus routes also making up more time and last question uh about the spread of expenses we had wanted to have a Aid on each bus that was something from the community so are those the basically the reason why we're looking at 13 million more and 19% increase because that's not what the CPI is yeah so and

072it's not what the PPI is either so the bus AIDS are paid by the district for a large number of them uh first student does employ the AIDS that deal with medically fragile students special ed students so those AIDS are employed by first students so those costs are in the contract um so the drivers for the in increase is some of the costs that were absorbed by first student over the past five years and some of the costs that the district made other agreements with first student such as supporting the signing bonus such as supporting the higher wages are now folded into this contract so this contract now has all of those short-term emergency measures that have been in place over the past few years um I will ask first student to speak to um

073what drivers they have on their end as far as cost drivers um that are behind that increased amount yeah David first of all good afternoon David and and and Joe and team and uh Dr Williams Knight and board and committee members so it's Brian forel I I can take that one one of the things that just is uh you know preco when this initial contract was uh put in place everything made sense and we had some fixed increases in the tail end of this contract I believe and my team could check me on this we had put in fixed increases of 1.8% for all the years of like 20 21 22 Yeah Yeah so uh obviously that at the time sounded like it made sense right and then covid hit and you know even CPI

074was double plus the 1.8 and and candidly CPI didn't come close so just a couple things we've already gone up 40% in driver wages over the five years of the contract I think insurance has doubled it's 90% so what what has happened and David said this is over the course of the five years this thing just got completely upside down and um you know so some of this is things that have already happened to answer your other question we do have another driver wage increase on the horizon setup here for July so it's it's a little bit of things that have already happened on top of some future expenses like uh additional driver wages but that is what's driving it I I will say this and if I sound like a Salesman you know somebody

075could virtually slap me uh most of these pre-co contracts around uh New York Pennsylvania New Jersey when when they need to come back up and all the math gets redone with the current state of uh what a carton of eggs costs uh we we have you know 35 40% here so um yeah when we went through this we we were as aggressive as we could be due to the nature of the partnership with Buffalo but a lot of these pre-co contract it's just a world that you know it's a different world than than we live in now so a lot of this stuff has already been happening the last couple years with some future increases in labor baked in as well I I hope that helps David and team you 500 more bus 500 you're

076increasing the number of buses so we can anticipate uh better better service to our schools I mean if we're going to pay the increase we like to understand it you know uh delays that our some of our parents are saying that bus is not being there whatever you we've had the discussion at the transportation meeting of the problems so I'm hoping that the increase in buses and drivers Etc will address some of that improve service and if we do not have if it's a bus isn't provided out of that 00 we do not pay for it so we don't pay for buses we don't get in service um but it's also an expectation that we will get that number of buses in service um so every year we are routinely under the contract amount and

077what we actually pay uh usually around 10 million under in what we actually pay because when there is a lack of service when there isn't uh provided we don't pay for it uh we only pay for What's actually provided what we get inor for but we have a contract for the entire amount we do a bid for the entire amount okay well those are my questions board members uh let me see if I see any hands uh any hand I don't I can't see it on here any hands up any questions Cindy McCutchen thank you um and I it might have been tied to this but I know there in one slide you said that uh in the new contract there's a 100% performance bond and it was just kind of one line but I

078guess my question is can you expand upon what that really means is there a performance bot in place with the current contract that's ending um and is it tied into what you just said in terms of only paying for a particular service right um but I just I guess I wanted to understand more what that means um so the 100% performance bond was not um included in the last contract um to cut the contract costs down that was because first student was established had Terminals and we um we did not require that Bond it was in the bid for the last contract but it wasn't required five years ago um and given what the kind of uncertainty of the past year the things that are going such as electrification such as it was wise to

079it is standard practice in New York state um it's to include the 100% performance bond because student transportation is so Mission critical that if there's a lapse you need to be able to recover the lost costs um so that that was changed this year as an assurance the district felt we needed to have and that's in relationship to a much larger scale changes right when you're saying the performance bond that's not in relationship to we don't have drivers to fill the buses on a more micro level correct yeah it's more on the massive level okay okay I appreciate that Clarity and so on a micro level um you know there's continued Improvement but I think it's just it's hard for us and I can't speak for my colleagues but I did sit with them at

080a transportation forum and and many of yall were present right and just hearing the stories and the realities of what our teachers are saying and what our our families are saying um you know it it is a big deal so while we're seeing numbers go down and then not you know discrediting that element of it um it's still very real and present in the moment on a regular basis uh and so I think that's something that is worrisome to me so it is worrisome to me and to the transportation department too it it it drives a lot of conversations we're having and daily um communication with first student to make sure that we are hitting a standard of service that the district expects thank you David fellow board members any other questions about Transportation because

081you're going to hear it it's winter time so if you have some questions raise them now let's see I see Sharon uh uh ferry district member Sharon Bon cotton more of a comment than a question um this is a lot of money that we spend with this organization what type of community benefit are we getting for our children as a result of our relationship with them I Rob hmel I mean I I think if I'm well David I don't want to jump to that I'm sorry David if I jumped ahead on this well no jump in and then i' got I've got something to say too Brian go ahead my apologies I was actually gonna defer to to Rob because I I I think we have some pretty good Community ties and activities there so

082apologies to everybody if I got ahead of my skis there so uh I don't know Rob if you wanted to talk about some of the things that are going on good good afternoon um so as far as community events uh first student is very involved in the local community we participate every year with the Special Olympics Polar Plunge uh first student is a major donor of that event that's attended by uh 1500 high schools uh students uh on day one of that event every December uh and then several thousand adults on on on sat on the Saturday event um this year they raised over a half a million dollars uh we also participate at the Erie County Fair with their sensory day we bring buses out there for the children to get on uh it's

083like a touch the truck type of event we also are a big sponsor of the gay lesbian Youth Services Program uh in Buffalo that many of know many of the high schools uh in Buffalo are part of that uh we support their annual conferences and do the transportation for them for that uh we attend their Gala every year uh we also sponsor the channel 7 Super 7 athlete of the week uh that is done every weekend we participate with the Taste of Buffalo every year uh and those are just some of the the local events that all of our uh our managers participate in I participate in and and several of our drivers and monitors right okay thank you but that is uh that is a um I'm specifically concerned about what's uh benefits Buffalo

084Public School students we have an urban population we have children with different needs than our surrounding area and I'm particularly interested in knowing particularly since our contract is I'm sure uh probably the biggest contract that you have what specifically are you interested or prepared to do for buffalo Public Schools independent of all these generic uh these generic activities that you're doing um because um by us being such a poor District our children have uh needs and we'd like to understand that we you know that we're benefiting uh in in a big way and um this is not a new question I ask this question often don't I David yes you do and student student transportation contracts are unque they're governed by 3054a um and because they're fiveyear contracts and they're reimbursable to such a large

085degree we actually don't do a standard contract the contract is actually submitted on a state form because the contract is essentially we're a pass through for the state so we um we really it's it's more of a worksheet than a contract now we do have um we did during the crisis make kind of side agreements with first student but the contract we do for the bid amount that the reimbursements based on that is a standard um workbook that we have to upload to the state separate than how we would typically do a contract so it doesn't really leave much room for narrative where there is uh some narrative is in the um in the RFB packet and um that does that is specifically targeted on what the district needs for safe and reliable transportation so

086in the RFB there wasn't um and the RFB was written by a consultant in working with District because it is a five-year contract it's outside of the normal procurement limits so they expect us to turn to outside professionals now we don't feel we were served well by the consultant in many ways um but that's the community benefits would be difficult to integrate into the existing workbooks but I am not opposed to a separate agreement with per student of some kind well I would appreciate that um I think um my constituents would appreciate it I just think that uh if you look at this I it surprises me uh the uh super athlete of the week is sponsored because our children never really benefit from that and it's interesting that uh our athletic department is not

087actively doing things like that so I guess there some onuses on us as well but I just feel that with the amount of this money that there should be some additional consideration for what's going on in the Inner City of Buffalo uh and I just would appreciate some additional uh resources and and things provided for our children and the Bible says we have not because you ask not so I'm not going to get caught with not asking this time okay thank you appreciate it member Shuda you have your hand up just real wait no first first first we had someone in city hall and then uh board member Shuda oh okay go ahead board member Shuda okay uh real quick um when I was principal of South Park and I guess it was 10 years

088ago um first student came up very generous and big for us when we won the state championship so I want to recognize them for that and I think the same thing is when I think that when you ask or you have conversation they were very kind to us well 10 years ago right right but I never asked them for anything after that well we have not because we ask not that's what that's the issue right there thanks I'm glad to know they came to the rescue thanks vice president Larry Scott I'll let board member zul go first and I'll follow her oh I'm good oh I thought you had a question to myself oh all right um so thank you for the presentation it gives us uh a lot of good data to kind of

089get a gauge on where we've made some improvements where we've had some bumps um I think the first question I have Chief Hills um we hear a lot about just buses being late not so much much uncovered but being late you know arriving late to school arriving late home in the afternoon um and it seems to be the third tier that is most problematic do we have any data on those times as far as late buses arriving especially in that third tier so the um I've been starting to assemble from about two weeks ago um late arrival data for the morning and we in those that time and and uh for stent those they've been hearing from me we've had about between 10 to 20% of our buses in the morning arriving late I haven't

090done the same thing with our late arrivals uh with our afternoon buses and you are correct it is exclusively the uh really the third tier schools so you know you look at a school 93 at most they have one bus that's late any given day half of the days that I've been looking they're at zero um but then our later tiers uh particularly our tiers with a lot of um long routes School 81 has a a large number late School 32 so we are looking at that we are me meeting with first student and we're reviewing that um I don't have anything that's cooked up yet but that is something that I'm starting to track that specifically delayed arrival at school um so that we can start to have those conversations and I asked this

091question in the operation Sunrise meeting about overtime I know it's a small expense compared to the overall expenses for transportation but any sense on how much we're paying in overtime when buses are late we are working on that it's increased this month because we've had more late buses U Maryann Dixon and I had a conversation she's actually going to be pulling that together for me and then as far as us providing busing for S miles we'll just take take it for with that for that but both let's do the K to K to 8 and 9 to 12 our reduced mileage I think that was before I was on the board H how did we arrive at reducing what was what was the rationale I think I remember it but what was the rationale for

092reducing s miles was a resol was a resolution uh I think it was 2017 um and it went into the transportation policy in 2019 um the resolution for for the 0.5 um miles was for 9 to2 for nfca was I believe in 2022 is based on our fesser funds um and loss of learning um and the need to attendance crisis we had so at that point that was very recent in a resolution but how come we decided to provide transportation for students that live that close I if I'm remembering I thought it was weather related and because there were concerns about neighborhoods and them walking in in particular neighborhoods is that accurate it was it was that is correct and the resolution is very clear it's oh sorry Dr [Music] Williams the resolution is very

093clear it's because students who are walking through dangerous neighborhoods who are walking in um Urban environments are simply not getting to school and that it's not only exposing them to D but that it's creating an attendance hardship they can't learn if they um are afraid to walk to school okay you can read the resolutions more clear than that I may not have summarized it fairly Larry I just want to say the board board the board made those resolutions in your remembering correctly it was because parents complaining about dangers the students were walking through areas where they there was uh sex TRS all kind of situations we had the problems with snow that were endangering students the curves weren't being cleaned off we had medical situations that are facing kids it was the board pushing for

094the safety of our children that right requested that okay so there was a time where I wouldn't ask this question question where I wasn't comfortable asking it but we when I saw that we had I think over 15 buses that were picking up students from my street with two blocks and transporting kids all around the the city um I and just hearing from people across the city about being invested in their neighborhood School schools close in their neighborhood and our how our community schools have really taken off being open on Saturdays having more access to them um what type of H how much and maybe you really can't answer this but how would it relieve um the transportation demands if there was some consideration to having more of a requirement I'm not saying so much

095neighborhood but attendance zones Rochester has attend dep zones I've done some research on Chicago they guarantee a spot in their neighborhood schools um and a resolution was just passed by their board to increase the amount of students that are going to Neighborhood schools and I know and I also read through again Dr Gary orfield report from 2015 2016 and the evolution of segregated schools to desegregation and at the height of when our schools were integrated what he indicated was that we had these magnet schools there was still there were still neighborhood schools where students were guaranteed a spot in in an attendance Zone and there were there were Citywide magnet schools and Regional magnet schools so there was some choice but there was also some neighborhood um preference that was still built in and I

096I'm just you know we we talk about the risks the environmental risks now of busing um and just wanting more access to our buildings and if there was also reduced cost that's going to transportation and if I'm estimating right we're looking at over a 100 almost 100 million for first our first student contract at the end of this fiveyear new contract um and we invested that money into our buildings and had them open more in the evenings and on weekends um I just what are are any thoughts any insight on whether this is something to consider and if if looking at registration and Stu parent choices and whether there is some sort of preference coming from parents wanting a neighborhood school and them not getting their neighborhood school as well so sorry that was that

097was a lot we we didn't include we actually ran an example uh test sample on school 72 um and Joe's G to discuss can talk about what we didn't put that slide in for the sake of time but Joe just briefly give a thumb just very briefly I looked at school 72 as an example if we decided at school 72 that we didn't want to bus anybody to school 72 that was north of Delan we could say five buses out of 17 just to give you an example and you know Delan is down to school 72 that's like what almost n Miles saying if there were some kind of zones or borders just right there that's almost a third of the busing to get cut out if we just made some better decisions you know

098we have kids from Riverside going to 72 up high school 80 going to 72 you know up at North Buffalo going to 72 and those are the buses that are late that's also why the service isn't good those are the buses that because if you live on Vulcan it takes you 45 minutes to get to 7 too if you're just getting going in a car so I mean these are the kind of decisions that we I would like to look at as far as zones and distances and placement we also had a sped example for school 72 how they have like a whole bus in Riverside going down to 72 you know like said that's the bus that's also going to be late and overcrowded so there's certainly some I would love to have a

099subgroup meeting and we could I could bring a whole bunch of examples of different ways and just to show you what is actually out there because I don't I think everybody even has an understanding we're busting students from every part of the city to every school it's just not sustainable especially with the increasing sped numbers and everything else just something at some point that's much more than that oh sorry go so just to be clear the uh operations office transportation department we believe in school choice we just want to be realistic and clear that that it puts a strain on the system so um and I think a counter example School 33 only has nine buses um draws has a very tight pattern of students and they in the past four weeks have had one

100bus late in the morning one day so so there are benefits and we also believe in operations and transportation we believe in reliable timely transportation if I can just inter if I can interject just to say that I know that the dollars and cents you know are real and I know you know I hear about um lake buses when I look at the percentage based on the number of children that we transport every day and the number of routes that percentage is is pretty small and for us to have the kind of weather that we have but as we're thinking about dollars and cents let us all Al really consider the children the children and buffalo is you know documented as a very segregated City it continues to be and you know there certainly are

101certain zip codes or attendance zones where crimes are higher 911 calls are higher um there are more Health disparities uh and we're trying to prepare our children to be College and Career ready to live in a integrated Society so I just want us to just keep that in mind you know as we start to look at how do we address certainly um you know the financial increases and you know the late buses and that kind of thing there's a lot to consider there's a lot to consider there's a reason that we went to a full Choice uh District so I was one of the kids that got you know caught up and being bust and and for me it was a good thing thing it was a very good thing to get me outside of

102my catchment area my ZIP code and to go you know to it was about an you know half hour 45 minute ride but for me it proved to be a good thing so it's just something I want the board to consider and uh thank you so much superintendent thank you uh Larry are you set as said because we have Terry shoter hand up I am thank thank you everyone for your input and your responses to my questions I appreciate it Terry Shuda and then Dr Evans Brown president uh I I really um uh am interested in the conversation and um the one of the things that we need to uh to be aware of that with that early schedule to have school children starting to leave their house at 6:30 in the dark they had

103really concerning to me uh is as a walker another thing that maybe we could could consider is taking a look at the elementary level for zones and then have open enrollment for all high schools uh there may be something uh there could be a uh something we could look into the same uh Dr Williams Knight I was one of those kids but I got to stay day in my neighborhood but the whole process was so enriching to me and uh I really think that that is uh also helped shape me so I can see both sides but I think it's something worth exploring and I agree uh board member Shuda I meant to clarify Elementary only not high schools because I think we have such Innovative high schools that are unique and should certainly remain

104open to all students Sharon um Elton cman you have your hand up to go on the record to say that um I had especially with what's going on in this country at this time um where there is so much emphasis on um um I want to say this tactfully uh people being um kept in their proper place and perspective um that anything short of providing that the problem in my opinion is not in the uh system that we currently have because there's a need to improve it from my perspective as far as using probably additional technology to help us do things in a more efficient way uh it is uh being used uh AI is being used through other um through other school districts and they have uh streamlined some things but in this day

105and age particularly with what's going on nationally to even have a conversation in probably one of the most segregated cities in America to continue to try to perpetuate that myth okay and it is a myth because at the end of the day if we're preparing children to be Global Citizens they ought to be able to go seven miles away from home 9 miles away from home they ought to be able to see what a real nice Community looks like and things like that so I would like to remind this uh board that we are still under the guidelines of the office of civil rights because we are still a very segregated City and that my constituents and my community contrary to what some opinion leaders may feel that they have support I can guarantee you

106that I have support that will have a problem with any child being denied access throughout the City to any school that the federal and state dollars come in for so uh I need for you to be very mindful of what's going on in this country at this point in time and and to make sure that we are not playing on into the uh right-handed right side of politics in this nation thank you Dr K uh president Dr Kathy Evans bro Dr Brown you had your hand up M it um I just want to add that it is about the children of this city of our school district so when we talk about uh neighborhood schools that was one of the reasons why you know Board of Education 1964 or 54 was implemented to give children

107an opportunity to attend um schools that were integrated um and then if we talk about neighborhood schools we got Criterion schools in these neighborhoods so you know you have to consider that if if some of these children are living in in the criteria in schools they get first bids so it's a lot of variables it's not just a cut and dry you know kind of thing to cost cut cost for buses and the bus situation you know people on this panel you don't make the decisions really the superintendent make the the decisions for what needs to happen with these contracts and the board backs her up and so yeah you can explore all you want for possibilities um I agree with but going backwards is not going to happen thank you thank you m president

108and any other hands up chairwoman Woods I just would like to respond so I just want to make it clear that none of what was said was my intention it was just to explore whether this would imp make any improvements and we have to acknowledge that there are inequities when students aren't getting to school on time um they're missing instruction and we have to acknowledge that that is problem problematic and is also contributing to inequities and I want to restate that when Buffalo Public Schools according to Dr Gary orfield when they were most integrated we had attendance zones we had Regional magnets and we had Citywide mag magnets and if you look at some of our Criterion based schools not all of them but some of them are the ones where you have some disparity

109in race it's not necessarily the neighborhood community based schools that have the disparity only so it is very complicated and I'm not in any way suggesting that tomorrow we start going to Neighborhood schools I'm just asking the questions because we hear over and over the concern with transportation and how it's impacting our students and their ability to access their schools Beyond just the school day as well okay uh I I think that discussion is something that would have have to go to the transportation committee or the superintendent can form a committee uh we are well over the time for the finance and operations uh section uh we' taken up 45 minutes of your the uh student achievements presentation the last hand up I saw was uh board member Cotman and hopefully that will be the

110last comment so we can move on to the next work session I I choose not to speak on it at this point um I think that uh uh I've said what uh I I've said enough in regards to this and I do feel that we there are things that we need to fix we certainly need to fix the registration process I have uh there are a lot of things that we need to fix as far as probably updating our transportation system to have a a a more efficient AI uh program in place to do some uh some things but what um um we cannot do is go allow this District to go back okay to go back and if we take a look at some of the requirements that exist we can take School 50

111for example if you take a look the layers that are have been put on school 50 that make sure that no one can get within that building over two miles uh two mile radius which was never presented before the board I have the original presentations that was presented to the board never was there an additional overlay that had been since added so we need to take a look at registration period to make sure that people are getting their choices and that there is um a fairness associated with it but there are schools in this District that if you don't live within a two mile radius of it that you can't get in and it's certainly not on the east side of Buffalo okay so we need to make sure of that thank you we our

112newest sport remember um Geneva everard had her hand up I'd like to give her the last question thank you first student I'll be brief um I just want to know you said that there will be an increase in driers pay next year next um budget cycle so what are they getting paid right now um what will the in the exact dollar amount and what will the increase be to and what are the incentives for hiring new bus drivers do you guys like Metro offers CDL classes is there a career path yep I can take that if you want to take it CER so our our current starting rate for a fully credential driver is uh 2950 per hour uh if it's a driver who who is not fully credentialed it's uh 2550 we offer full

113paid CDL training uh we offer A3 to $5,000 sign on bonus if they're not credential it's 3,000 if they're fully credentialed it's 5,000 fully credentialed meeting that they come to us uh with with a commercial driver's license already with the uh passenger and school bus driver endorsements uh most of those are coming from uh you know we're luring people over from from competitors other companies Metro um and then there's Progressive wage increases based on their collect and do you offer CDL training like Metro y offer full paid okay and what about um do they work 40 hours per week is that what it is they are able to work full time it it's it it varies based on based on the routes that they bid on so each driver every year bids on a run

114with the hours posted and they base they they bid in in order of seniority uh you know how many hours they want to work okay and so just a quick suggestion because I know that Metro lowered their rate their hourly rate from 25 to 3 with benefits and so just a suggestion when you're looking at that to kind of be more competitive to offer them 40 hours a week and so that when they are off during the summer that they are able to still have you know some type of Li Lial wage or uh however that works um that's just a suggestion maybe look into that to be more competitive um and so that for many of them are able to work many of them are able to work over the summer um either you

115know through summer routes our sped terminal uh runs a full service in the summertime um and and some drivers opt to collect unemployment because being that we're a private company they are able to collect unemployment okay thank you very much you're welcome okay um thank you board members and thank you um Jim uh David Hill and um president um Albright for your information your presentation thank you board members for moving this District forward not backwards this concludes the finance and Ops presentation and we can move through Larry uh vice president Larry Scott you have the next uh pres uh work session thank you before we transition I just want to State again I I've done this repeatedly we have several Community Schools and for enrollment they follow the same criteria 50% % of the school

116population consists of Walkers .1 to. 7 miles 30% of the population commiss consist of community 71 to 1.5 and 20% are districtwide that's for all of our community schools across the across the district um and Discovery by the way has a neighborhood preference and it seems like that school never gets critique but School 50 does for some reason all right um with that said we have our next committee work session on um the student achievement and we are going to be talking about assessment changes superintendent Williams Knight I'll kick it over to you to introduce Chief B charie Al righty thank you chairman Scott um we do have some nuances for our New York State assessments that are coming up as well as our region exams and it's important for this board to know what

117those differences will be so we have Chief belli who is our chief academic officer and she is going to go over what the changes will be that are coming up for this year Chief belli good evening I can't hear you you can't hear me okay now I can hear you okay um I'm just going to give him a second to get the PowerPoint up but I also wanted to let everyone know that um because there are so many changes to our science assessments I did invite um director Tatiana mer here from the science team just to talk a little bit U more in depth about some of those changes at the elementary and secondary level so I'm going to start out talking a little bit more generally um about elementary I'm going to turn it

118over to Tatiana for Science and then I'm going to conclude with math because there are some changes to the math as well next slide please so as always we are moving to the next level one voice One Vision One mission we did highlight rigorous Early Elementary education which I'll start out with but we are also going to be talking about some of our high school changes as well next slide please um so again we always talk about the the particular goals that we're addressing and for um most of our academic world it's number one and two so we're going to talk about elimin achievement and opportunity gaps and a access to educational excellence and accelerated learning next slide please so briefly I just want to address the fact that the elementary test the 38 tests

119have gone over to computer-based testing um so what does that mean exactly so we previously administered test paper and pencil and then over the past couple year starting last year we started phasing in computer-based testing at elementary um so in Spring of 2024 it was required that grades five and8 switch over to computer-based testing instead of paper and pencil um so that applied to English Math and Science because we we have those tests at the elementary level this year in the spring we are required to switch to CBT for grades four five six and eight it's optional for grades three and seven and then in the following year in the spring of 2026 it's required for all grades 3 to8 um so what does that mean for us so this is the uh phase two

120in a three-year implementation of CBT again that includes English math and the science assessments they were required to administer CBT in 5 and8 last year and other grades were optional so this year we are going to be administering our computer-based tests in grades four 5 6 seven and 8 so we went with seventh as well this is based on feedback um even though it's not required schools Express that having seven and eight administer with different platforms would be um much more of an a challenge than we needed to do so they asked us to include grade seven so all the grades four through eight will be administering the computer-based test this year um schools were given the option of administering the grade three Ela and or math as a computer-based assessment um so 14 Schools

121chose to administer grades three Ela and math via computer-based testing one chose to administer only grade three Ela but not the math all the other schools are going to continue with the paper based assessments at grade three um so small deviation from what's mandated by including grade seven and giving that option for grade three but by the following year all grades will be required to switch to computer based testing so what does that mean exactly um so obviously instead of the paper and pencil kids will be taking these assessments on the computer we already use a plethora of digital platforms so our kids are very computer savvy so it's not as big an adjustment as it might seem although in the world of math it's probably a little bit of a change so students have

122been practicing using digital digital tools for their math assessments um so protractors rulers drawing tools um we use e doctrina to practice that so kids are being exposed to the types of items that they would have seen on the state assessment but using digital tools um so this will be our second year at several grade levels um overall there could potentially be a slight dip the first time but we haven't seen anything enormous you know that our math assessments did not really suffer last year even though we had multiple grades um go to the computer-based tests um so that is the biggest change in the world of Elementary although um direct Merck is going to talk a little bit about science because that is a change um so I'm going to turn it over to

123her right now okay next slide please okay so what you see on the screen currently is the New York State uh development adoption and implementation map um so Buffalo Public School science department has been um implementing this map with Fidelity um it's split up into three different phases um it be it began the phase one in 2016 when New York state adopted the New York State science learning standards or nist which is the new standards um then we went and that was the um raising awareness and building capacity stage phase two was the transition and implementation stage this stage was very important because this is when we uh began a adopting um Secondary School um curriculum that aligned to the new standards so during the in um phase two we've adopted a biology n l

124align program and an Earth and space science n l align program okay so this gave teachers plenty of time to get familiar with the curricular resources and to really understand the um the three-dimensional framework before they take the new exams which will um the first Administration is in June this June for biology and Earth and space science um similarly um now we are currently on phase three um so next uh of June 2026 is when the transition will occur with um with chemistry and physics so the exams are going to be aligned to the new to the new standards um we are currently at the um in the last stages of um review ring a physics uh program that aligns with Nas and uh with chemistry um teachers have been teaching uh this year um

125with a new curriculum that is aligned to to nist okay so um throughout this entire implementation map we have offered professional development for our teachers um what does this look like or what passes look like um they receive professional development not only in the new curriculum but also with the understanding of getting a deeper understanding with the DU standards um this occurred through superintendent conference days early release days uh We've also um given them the opportunity to have job embedded training um in the new standards and the new investigations um as well as Saturday sessions um the science department has developed wonderful collaborations with uh the teacher Center which allowed for teachers to take courses that will increase their understanding of the science standards um in addition to developing Partnerships with for example UB Buffalo

126State College reinstein Woods um they have all provided professional development to our teachers RIT is the last uh uh the last professional development that we have solidified um uh they will be um offering professional development to our teachers uh for renewable resources which is now part of our uh standards next slide please okay so the major um difference between the old the old tests and the new tests for all of the content areas in science is the fact that the new standards are now what we consider three-dimensional so what is three-dimensional the way that I explain it and that's uh you see the visual um on the slide is uh the new standard is like a rope and the Rope consists of three different Dimensions so before while the teacher just taught the content now

127the content is one of the three dimensions that make up that standard or now it's called a performance expectation okay so one standard is the science and engineering practices so that's how students learn are they analyzing are they discussing are they creating questions right the cross cutting concepts are what students look for so what do they look for they're looking for patterns they're looking themes and the disciplinary core idea is the actual science content next slide please thank you so um here is uh just a side by side of the old standard which was the old standards were from 1991 um compared to the new nless um biology standard as you can see the old standard which is um on the left it's very just content driven whereas on the right you can see it's

128much more dense um and really in order for the child or the students to reach Mastery of these Concepts it really is uh you know the teacher does need to break down those uh those standards into the three dimensions um uh in regards to their instruction next slide please thank you so uh with New York State changing the expectation with science teachers actively teaching three-dimensionally they needed to make some changes in the framework of the exam so that the assessments are three-dimensional as well so here in this slide you see the side by side of the old exam frame the framework for the old exam compared to the framework for the new exam so for the old Core Curriculum aligned assessments there was it was always 85 questions when I say the um so the

129exam was siloed when I say siloed it there part A was always multiple choice Part B was multiple choice and um part B1 was multiple choice as well B2 was multiple choice and some constructive response there they were much uh shorter constructive response part C was a long response section and then Part D was all about the legs now when we look at the new assessments they are now cluster based so they are no longer siloed there are a total of for 44 to 55 total questions so if you compare that to the old 85 questions really the kids will have le the students will have less questions to answer but really the depth of knowledge is much deeper uh with this new assessment um so there are are multiple choice and constructed responses but

130you will see um in a couple slides that um the multiple choice really is uh they're written uh much differently um also there is no lab D there's no part D there is no lab based section anymore those lab questions and those lab performance expectations are embedded throughout the curriculum and that's going those questions are going to be assessed um through the investigations um and I'll get into the investigations in just a bit next slide please so what is a cluster a cluster is five to seven uh questions that follow a storyline around a phenomenon so what is a phenomenon it's anything that the students are exploring it's a scenario a phenomenon can be um beavers and their environment or the coral reefs and uh the organisms that live in and around the coral reefs

131so with clusters um each question will add to a developing explanation and a de developing model a um or the design of a solution so one cluster is five to seven questions but they assess several different standards next question um next slide please could you just go one more please okay so this is just an example that I wanted to um just pull out uh comparing uh one multiple choice question in the June 2024 exam versus um a three-dimensional question that was uh released by New York State um they released uh several groups of clusters that um that we have really been uh doing uh completing professional development to ensure that teachers have an understanding of what the questions will look like so when you look to the left really you the question is an

132abiotic factor in this ecosystem is so really it's a vocabulary type recall question right so if they know um the definition of ab biotic they essentially get that that point for this question so if you look on the right it's starts which claim best described so already we know that not only it's not a recall question you are making a claim based on whatever data graphs pictures or text that they are giving this the student so really it is a um a much uh uh the depth of knowledge in the multiple choice questions is much deeper when it comes to the three-dimensional threedimensional uh questioning could you please go one back not forward back thank you um so another um major change to the assessment piece is the New York State biology herb science uh

133required investigations um so these investigations are locally administered performance-based tests so it monitors student learning and provides real time feedback for students and for teachers right so teachers should be um doing these investigations in biology and Earth space science they are mandatory um and they count towards the 1,200 minute La Minute requirement so this is new biology has had mandatory labs in the past but earth science has not have uh has not had mandatory labs in the past so this is something that is new but it gives um the ability for the teacher to really um assess the understanding of the performance expectations of their students and then um really have them inform their instruction uh moving forward um so that um next would be the chemistry and the physics investigations those have not been

134released yet but chemistry and physics are the next um exams that are transitioning um so they are going to have uh chemistry uh investigations and physics investigations um as well um all of the science teachers in the district that teach these courses have been they have received all their materials uh Buffalo Public Schools has provided this to them uh tentatively that will occur with chemistry and physics as well um I would like to say that uh Buffalo Public School teachers have been very present and vocal um when it comes to the creation of these investigations making sure that Buffalo Public School students have a voice and a choice what it comes to uh these investigations and that would be it for the science changes you can skip two slides [Applause] now thank you director and

135just as an as side you'll notice that she she showed the example where the students had to make a claim and find evidence that is aligned to what we do in English and social studies as well so the state is definitely um looking across the subjects and trying to help students understand the concept of reading a text of any kind whether it's print or photo or graph but reading it making a claim drawing an analysis finding the evidence to support that um so the new science tests are in line with the type of assessment students see in other subjects next slide please again one oh sorry one more thank you um so math likewise has been going through um a phase in of the new standards although the application will not be quite a atic

136as it has been for science um so you can see phase one we began to raise awareness back in 2018 and then in phase two we built capacity um and phase three the new assessments began so last year we actually introduced the new algebra exam so in math it's a little bit more of um a refining of the standards as opposed to changing the entire assessment um so this year the kids will take the new geometry assessment which I'm going to talk about in a second and then um in 25 they will be taking the algebra this looks like it's a year old oh 25 26 sorry they'll be taking the algebra 2 um so again last year was the first year of the new algebra assessment this is the first year of the new

137geometry and then the following year will be the first of the algebra 2 so we have transitioned we've been working with teachers we've trained them in the new standards for several years um so nothing is going to be um you know shocking to to teachers who've been working with these standards and have worked with the students to make sure that they are comfortable next slide please so just a quick overview of um the geometry changes so there's actually two new standards for geometry um one has been removed and there are multiple uh 19 to be exact highlights or instructional considerations so I'll talk in a second about what that means um but the test design itself has remained the same so part one two 3 and four a same format as as we previously experienced

138and the same percentages apply um so each content or domain will have specific percent of questions um addressing that that content so when I say that there are instructional considerations what do I mean um so in math they have reworded clarified and better explained the extent to which some of the standards should be addressed um so in some cases they just clarified the wording of a particular standard in other cases they narrowed down the scope um so sometimes some of the math standards were very Broad and it led to questions uh on teachers behalf of you know exactly how many things am I supposed to cover under this particular standard so just as a an example it's not a real it's not a true standard but I'm just going to give you an example that

139seems pretty clear to me so if we said students will be able to um find the fluid volume of 3D solids I would take a step back and say wish solids right well that's not very specific at all so instead they have clarified so in this instance they would say something along the lines of you're going to teach the volume of these specific solids and they would narrow that down and tell you what to cover in class so that's what they have done when they say that there's 19 standards um that they have addressed with highlights and instructional changes and you can actually see the link up top um if you clicked on that it would take you to some further explanation but basically they've helped teachers by clarifying exactly what the particular standard entails

140um so there haven't been major changes to the geometry assessment although because it is new we're offering it um a little bit earlier than some of the other exams and they'll be sent um so the state can do standard setting um but the framework of the assessment itself has not changed just a little bit of the nuances involved in the standards themselves um next slide please so that is actually the conclusion for us so again we're moving to computer-based testing at the elementary for science math and English um there's been significant changes to science standards as well as science assessments and though there's been some changes to the math standards it hasn't been as dramatic an impact um on the reg's exam because the format has remain the same so we're happy to take any

141questions that you might have oh sorry go ahead board members um I'm wondering are investigations conducted outside of the lab time and is there a minimum or maximum number of hours um for investigations that could count towards the lab minutes no let's let me see if I get this right so the elementary they're embedded within the class they're EMB yeah and secondary because of the regen requirements they would be separate time periods yeah okay so they're they're embedded within the actual uh lab class or it can be done in instructional time as well um each uh investigation in the teacher guide has a maximum amount of time that that in investigation could account for so there's some investigations that can only um count up to 280 minutes um as opposed to others that can be

142100 60 minutes but it's clearly de delineated for the teacher thank you okay board members at home any questions I had one vice president Scott um so when you say that it's optional for third grade to opt in from pen and paper to the computer and we're focusing on on third grade I'm the immediate questions that come to mind is is there going to be a lull in the uh the learning process of the folks that are going to catch up eventually because you said this is all going to be computerized in the next couple years so those folks that are did not opt in compter um to me that's worrisome since that's such a focus that we're looking at especially in ela uh that we're not requiring a power that everybody learns at the

143same you know kind of the same level pen and paper computer and then the second question is is there an equity issue around you know the folks that did decide to opt in the schools that did decide to opt in are those are more well resourced schools um is there a hindrance with the other schools that didn't opt in was it because they may not have all the technology and that those resources available I mean it may seem like they're they're kind of pointing in questions but I I immediate it almost focused you I almost lost sight of some of the other things that were being brought to the table because our goal setting is so focused on grade three and if we're not if even if it's the standard how are we as a

144district expecting you know and this for you superintendent to meet these goals when you're going to have some students learning on different levels than others not saying that they can't learn interet this you know they're not all supposed to learn the same thing and they get there but we're creating a barrier if we're allowing them to learn at different speeds with different different you know platforms I can share from my stance it's certainly is a a big concern but as I'm going out I started my tour now going to schools and um you know I think probably because I'm older school and you know I like paper pencil High cover books but our children are technology driven um the principl feel that you know some of the kids they're using the technology more to familiarize

145themselves with the skills of reading something online and you know being able to highlight I'm used to highlighting writing on paper notes and that kind of thing but um the schools that I'm visiting the principales feel like the children are adapting very quickly um so in terms of well resourced um so every student would have a device accessible to them as well as all the programs that we provide they are provided to all the schools we don't give some to this school or some to that so they all have access to those I think the decision at the school level probably had different variables but some people might have just felt more comfortable going a little slower because they're younger but all the kids going up through the grades have had access to movi Max

146they have access to our new math program um they have access to Lexia so they're they're using devices on a regular basis um you know I I typing is a little different when you write an essay so some of the schools might have wanted a little additional time for some of the younger students but others felt very comfortable that they could move forward I think my question wasn't as much as whether or not they have the devices that's the thing that we you know we required for everybody to have devices we have schools that don't have the same amount of resources just as far as people power as far as you know their reading aids and and things like that so when I'm saying resources are on the equity level it's every school might have

147the opportunity because they have the the device but is everybody in place at the same level of each school to be able to assist those students you see what I'm saying I'm not saying that all I'm saying is that if I can see that this could be a roadblock and we are focusing so hard on grade three that even if it's a state mandate I would have thought that maybe we would have um encouraged everyone to learn on the same you know to to focus on the same platform I guess is what I'm saying so I appreciate the answers you've given me thank you but I I still reinstate my concern I understand what you're saying I think um some admin ation and and teams at the school level felt very strongly one way or

148another um but I will say that they definitely all are practicing um because they know that moving forward they will be taking CBT so the younger grades have even started talking about it they're looking at different keyboarding programs that we've made available so they're definitely everybody is focused um and they they will be making that transition as soon as they hit fourth grade in thank you board member mosy board members if you have a question please raise your hand virtually or physically board member Woods you have the I was looking at the questions that were asked and my observation is that the new style or new standard is requiring the students to actually think now uh for a long time our criticism on education has been that children memorize by root and they can't analyze

149they can't think so what I noticed in those questions were that the child would have to actually analyze and come up with an answer which I think is an improvement but EV as long as I've been here what I've been told is every time these standards change that the school districts wind up with a lot of students proficiency dropping that we we get a a big drop until this is uh that the change is is uh transition is made successfully so are we anticipating that uh next year's test scores may not be comparable to the years before because of the challenges that uh the new style or New Generation learning is going to present to our students well they will do standard setting at the state level and I I believe that that will help

150address some of the concern that you have um but definitely with teaching differently right so to meet those investigations and to help students anal make claims and analyze evidence in a science classroom the teachers have had to make a paradigm shift um students fortunately for us they started getting exposed to that a few years ago in elementary as they work their way up so it's it's probably more of a shift at the moment for the high school teachers than it is for the kids that have been exposed to that on their way up through the grade levels um but you know it's the first first time we' we haven't seen these assessments yet it'll be the first time we're taking them so thank you board member Woods I don't see any other HS um I

151have just one question in regards to ma the state math assessment especially being on computer based is there any expectation or is scoring part of showing your work in any way uh the act when they enter their score when they enter their CH they still have to show I I wish I had brought it on but I believe they still have to show their work because that's why they have drawing tools and things like that so even if they somehow arrive at the correct answer they could lose points for not showing paper and pencil as well you have to show your work depending you it is a requirement on state assessment okay not not for multiple choice but for constructive responses even if so even if you arrive at the correct response somehow some students

152are able to do their constructive response okay thank you I said that wrong you know I was gonna start T all right um superintendent Williams knight any final thoughts no I think it was a thorough presentation far be it from me to prolong um our meeting tonight it was a good presentation thank you both for the presentation and we will transition to board member Shuda and educational support okay um first of all uh today's a special day for some of our students uh it's national Signing Day for our scholar athletes so I wanted to start today uh uh and I know we put um emphasis on making sure that our kids had the platform to be NCAA eligible and so I'm hoping to hear more about how we celebrated those athletes today and how many

153students we did have that have qualified so kudos to their families the students in the school buildings um I think today is like a great segue to have the it uh Department here after our discussions so uh we're glad to have the chief and the director here and I'm going to turn it over to Dr William snight to get us started all righty thank you so much I think it was at the December board meeting that there were some questions that were asked um from our it Chief and we agreed that we would come back in a work session and be able to address some of the questions and so that's exactly what we anticipate um will happen tonight we do have chief shelino uh with us and her uh very competent rightand director Thompson

154and um they're going to be talking with us a little bit about you know inventory and the management process of our technology items thank you Dr Williams uh good evening board members uh we're excited to be here tonight kind of go over some of the things um that we started to discuss at the December meeting um after talking with uh board member Shuda a little bit um I have crafted a presentation that gives a little history uh some context for the conversation and then if you want to dive into uh some of our possible solutions that we're working out we can go down that road if you would like but uh admir if you go to the next slide please thank you a little history to put it in context for you before covid um

155all the devices were kept in building carts that was uh prior to my time but there were carts in every building um where they were housed uh students use them on campus very common in most those school districts um across the state in about 2023 as I looked at some of the data that I could Garner from um the system we have been using over the last uh six or seven years um we had about a 6% average replacement uh per year meaning that damages loss Etc would need to be continually budgeted for for Replacements um last year or this current year um approximately we did a little bit better because we kind of buckled down just a touch trying to put some new processes in place um that we had identified we are about

156down to a 5% average replacement cycle per year as of January 2025 um and that was great because Dr Williams Knight did ask that we try to um restructure our budget after uh the decrease in Esser so we are relieved that some of the tools that we try to use during the course of this year have been effective um marginally we have some hopes for the future we are designing the new asset inventory and management program we have procured a new system which we're very excited we've been working on currently to get up to speed for next school year we'll have a new data collection process uh tracking reporting and inventory reconciliation so that we can track and have better data and set some goals for the upcoming uh few years as I do and

157develop a longrange budget adir some of the questions that a board member should have had were regarding you know are we really using these devices are devices going home and they're being used that's really important for putting the money in there um we hope that that's what's happening so I did a little bit of a snapshot thank you to director Thompson um after school usage for approximately six months and this is just the top I think eight um sites that kids are going on that are students are using uh you don't have to really go into the numbers specifically but what you need to know is that there are a tremendous number of devices that are using our um students that are using our devices after school over the last six months so that last

158column kind of shows you that that's the number of devices that are hitting some of these websites and are being used after school and then we do still have hotspots I know that was a question um they are available we have greatly reduced them over the course of the last uh six years uh so that uh we have a targeted approach to uh looking at data seeing if they were being used and then determining approximately how many we would need to have on hand out of those we have homework hours that are considered right after school up until 11 o'clock at night the hotspots are available to be used so we hope that our students are going to sleep at night and not using um the hotpots during the evening when they should be sleeping

159but we are using them and they have been garnering um quite a few number of hours and this is only one week's usage of hotspots for the targeted group of students and families that have indicated they don't have internet access so I hope this was it kind of gives you an idea of we desperately need to be continuing using devices for learning adme next slide please our inventory process has been communicated consistently for years it is in the weekly bulletin and we have done presentations so the buildings do know how to report to us what students need need devices that are in their building so typically we have a lot of teachers who know the process they submit the device swap replacement there's a loss form and it gets sent to BPS inventory at buffaloschools.org

160that goes to director Thompson site over at um 1515 South Park the center for innovation technology and training they receive it they evaluate exactly what the requests are they look up in our system you know did the student have a device what happened to it they prepare a new one and they schedule replacements for the buildings um since director Thompson has come here she has redesigned with our uh vendor our building technician's assignments so that they are able to go to buildings more frequently than they had in the past and they deliver device swaps to the buildings during their weekly visits it's communicated specifically with their itc's their coaches if they have a coach or with someone at the building that has been identified as the point person for technology so if someone does not

161know about this process that would be surprising um if they do not and we are notified director Thompson calls principles directly she has conversations to assists them with how do you get this process going what are the problems that you're having in the building add me next slide please okay so this is was the big slide that we probably will have a conversation on I would like to review with you some of our current replacement processes so on the left hand side the claims process when someone makes a claim for a device that they are in need of if it is a damage or if it is a loss typically and this is on the website and has been on the website for years the cost to replace a laptop is a $15 that is

16215% of the total of the actual cost of the device only so $75 is the iPad replacement cost and that is also 15% of the iPad device only cost that particular cost for iPads has been reduced by $25 since director Thompson has redesign the configuration process this year so those two items are 15% of the device cost only if there is a second claim a second piece of damage or a second loss the price of the cost goes up to 20% we know that that's a lot we also know that the responsibility of a device and taking care of the device is uh important so at this point that cost is 20% 140 for the laptop device and $100 for the iPad a third claim if that so happens and it does um same as

163the second claim that's the same pricing structure and the Chargers the Chargers are $35 for replacement I know that's a high cost we get asked a lot can I just buy some knockoffs we tell people you really shouldn't um they definitely cause problems with devices and they can cause devices to stop working so we really do try to promote that you buy the charges that we have that being said we have payment plan options uh currently there's a cash payment plan offered director Thompson has designed these options for uh families that have said you know we cannot pay all at one time uh if you have questions on that she can go through how she works with each individual family that comes in personally um we are going to be offering credit card payments the

164system will be up the target is for March 2 so in approximately a month we've worked with the audit Department through Finance on getting this system available so that we can accept credit cards that's something that director Thompson has been working on with them for the last quite a few months if not a year as of 2024 this current year all device Replacements offer an option for a device to stay in school so once director Thompson realizes this might be a consistent problem or if there is just no way someone is able to afford to pay for something um we do work with the building to offer a device in the building that the building takes control of and says we are responsible for this device we will house it here in our building um

165and if there is homework that needs to be done the family will work out how they would do that work after school because it may just be too much for them to take care of that device moving forward so these are options that we have in play currently right now um director Thompson has redesigned with feedback from the community and from our our teachers admir next slide please the current Insurance possibilities been looking at this for the last six to eight months um we've come to a place where we've been discussing with audit and finance that we found a system where an annual $27 per student would cover all damage and replacement for the device and includes Chargers so this is one of the best options we found that would cover any piece of device

166any replacement for the device including chargers for $27 per student it covers stolen if a police report is filed and determined to be a legitimate crime and I write it that way because the police department has called director Thompson and had long conversations um about avoiding having families coming to the department unless it's truly determined to be a stolen device we also have a loss form we put into place temporarily this school year to elim to redirect families from having to go to the police department while we are working on this insurance plan they need to report that they have lost their device within 10 days of the last time they used it so that we can really put into play an attempt to find that device that includes the family looking for it the

167building looking for it and US looking for it with our technology tools before we determine that that device cannot be found admir next slide please I would like to pause here uh board member Shuda if you'd like to start to have a conversation around the first six slides unless you would like me to go into a prevention like some of the solutions that we are working on to redirect loss in the next couple months I'm sorry I cannot hear you sorry um I would say Let's uh let's keep going and then we'll have questions okay all right wonderful so we have a few solutions that we are working on and have been putting into place and will be putting into place in the next few months ad me next slide please this particular option is

168something we have that I did talk about just briefly uh a few moments ago additional building assistance when a building calls us and says you know this family you know we just can't they they not afford it also that it's been multiple um maybe loss or damage the building just signs off on keeping the device in the school we call this a device managed assistance program that's kind of how we're we're putting it the building follows the BPS inventory process by submitting for it and they also might use some of our loss form um that we enacted this school year like I mentioned where they can fill out a form for loss instead of going to the police department so this is how we've been working with um letting buildings have what we consider a

169loner device for the year for that particular student next slide please a cart model um this is something that we're looking at doing again we know that carts do work or did work in the past and have worked before covid um came into play again the device management assistance we have looked at uh quite a few Target buildings buildings that have a very high level of loss or damage we have data on that um we're looking at developing and delivering carts for those school buildings during the school year as well as looking at what we're going to be doing for summer school I know in the past summer school and in the summer students were encouraged or directed to keep devices at their homes we may want to change that around that conversation will be

170happening um with our principles as well as we have really been successful in keeping devices in school and carts with prek 1 prek-k in one I should say um those devices don't always uh get a lot as much usage as some of the higher grade levels and so we are going to be looking at really putting into play a definitive shared card model for prek-k in one next slide please prevention so end of life and surrender so when devices are end of life as they have become very uh we have quite a few that are aged and are aging out over the last few years which is why um our replacement cycle was uh presented last year to our finance department and approved for future purchases so that we can keep a refresh cycle for

171devices at a rate Which is less than five four or five years so that the devices aren't old enough just to break on their own or just kind of degrade um senior handin process we were successful last year getting those sen most of the buildings to hand in their senior devices by the end of May uh many buildings do require that they hand them in to receive their cap and gown or diploma uh so that was kind of an enticement to get the majority of those devices back grade level building graduates uh we did try to put a process in place for those buildings in grade four that are moving to the next building or in grade eight that are moving to a high school so any of the buildings that were movement of a

172grade to a different building that has seemed to be a challenge um over the last few years that devices are left in buildings and then students are moving on to other buildings and their devices was left were left in other buildings and so that system is something that we've been looking at very very specifically as a root cause for loss and we are really really targeting that this upcoming year the Outreach for students who unenroll that has been something that we are working on developing reports on how to reach those students who have been um deactivated from our registration they don't go to Buffalo Public Schools anymore but we need to receive their devices back as well as the charter and private school summer school loaners that we are required to give out to our

173Charter and private school students who come to us for summer school so those are some of our offboarding challenges that we are working on the plans for currently admir next slide please and this is uh one of our newer Outreach prevention programs which we're working on with our new system that we were able to acquire this year we are working on monthly reports being sent out to buildings this is something that we're going to talk about with the principles that we are going to be device tracking for 10day check-ins and that means if s if a student has logged into a device within the last 10 days which hopefully they have been we should be able to track that device and pretty much Target where it was left within a 10day time frame right now

174we're getting some folks that said oh I I haven't seen my device in like six months I know that sounds shocking but it is happening and so what we're trying to do is generate we're looking at how we're going to be scripting to generate those reports and send a notice out to the buildings and also the families to say hey we've notice that your child's device hasn't been logged into within the last 10 days perhaps you should take a look maybe under a bed or somewhere where you may have gone recently on a trip or to someone's home to try to find that device and if we can pinpoint where that devices by the Ping system that we have we could really help those families find those devices before it becomes 15 days 20 days

17530 60 90 days so that's what we've really um been working on with our programming team to see how far we can get for the next school year to do that work I think this might be the last side adir can you move one more slide yes that was the last slide I'm gonna start uh with uh board members that are did have any questions or comments do we have anyone uh no um what city hall oh City Hall okay go ahead uh board member Scott board member zulich yes oh I'm sorry so for device tracking we have not been tracking before recently the device tracking we only track devices when we have been notified that a device has not is not available or has been lost um up to this point in uh working

176in the department that had not been something that was able to be done to be frank um so that's something that we're developing so that we can be able to be a little bit more proactive okay um how many devices is does the district own for public school students and then including Charter private summer school looners and I mean there is there anything like a find my iPad a remote shut off or disable it if somebody claims it's lost I mean do we have any any options like that yes we do um and that's what we have been using we do have um a mobile device management system for the iPad where you can ping the iPad find where it is if it's still on that's why we really need to get notified right away

177um before it dies off and isn't connected and we do ping it that's the word I'm going to use for you which means we find out hey where what IP address might this device have been at and we are able to do um to turn that device or send a message to it say it's in Lost mode no one can log in the same with the laptop we can freeze the lap laptop um so that cannot be logged into so those protections are in place um for devices that are lost so we don't have any uh intrusion into them by another an outside entity as far as the number of devices that we have available currently um I don't have uh the inventory process and I will say that every year before the replacement cycle

178started which was last year I had calculated it over the course of last i''s say four years we have approximately purchased 50,000 devices mobile devices for students okay thank you okay president uh Evans Brown did you have your hand raised yes I did thank you uh chief for that presentation um um just a thought so you mentioned that seniors hand in their devices and my question the question that came up to me have we thought about offering the device to the senior at a discount of price because they'll be going on to college or some kind of meaningful employment or just outright give it to them just a thought that current Curr ly I would say that the devices that seniors are giving up right this moment are not something I would give to a

179senior to Take Along they are too aged out at this point which is as we're as we regenerate our replacement cycle that could be a discussion that we would have the board could have a discussion technically um we do are required to do some kind of surplus so we would I would say that I would have to ask uh legally what the responsibility is for the board release those kinds of devices and that is something we can look into in the future as device uh a replacement cycle that we put into place means that a ninth grader any student that goes into ninth grade I believe that started this year um gets a new device so that their device will be four years old by the time they graduate which is the goal that they

180don't have a seven-year-old device anymore when they graduate so when they graduated would be four years old and for those students who would need them I would say we should discuss you know the legality of releasing that device to a student thank you thank you a board member Bon cman thank you for your presentation uh do you have a a percentage of the uh or or data that uh uh can tell us how many devices are lost per year I could tell you how many devices are lost currently um por part of the reason that this is a challenge is that the system that we had prior to just buying the new one this year did not have data points set in the way that would help us move forward with exactly what you're asking

181and it's frustrating for a CIO like myself um which is why moving forward we will have those numbers explicitly but currently as of today I have some numbers to tell you that got approximately 231 devices this school year that have had damages that we had to replace uh 117 of those are firsttime damages where 114 of those are second time damages um we have approximately 300 devices currently in the loss queue saying that they have been lost those numbers equal approximately 531 which is um from last year's repurchase that we had to make that is dramatically lower than what we had last year at this time which was closer to 900 so things that we the minimal things that we've put into place and the awareness that the principles have currently since um director Thompson

182and I have been communicating with them have made a huge difference in terms of um teachers and principles recognizing how much uh the computers are important in the building as well as the requirements for the PSAT the SAT that went digital and CBT that has made a huge difference in people being aware boy I need my device okay so it's it's really a very small percentage isn't it say we have 50,000 50,000 and only 531 are are it's a very small percentage and so um my phone has been being text telling me that there should be no cost to students if every year we're purchasing uh new laptops so we uh recently what did we do was it a $2 million purchase that went through okay so how many so how many laptops did that

183buy that was the replacement cycle uh that was half of the replacement cycle that we just purch the full replacement cycle cost $4.8 billion um that includes three grade levels of purchases annually that's the budget that we put into place last year so we buy ahead so that we're prepared in the summer to prepare the devices and make sure that they're available for September so you may not see like 4 million coming all at one time however the number I gave you really is only six months and I don't want to be misleading I'm very very honest and open about where our numbers are I will tell you that even though that 531 is in front of my face I know I know that that is going to increase over the next month before CBT

184happens that people have not reported their loss um that the damage have not been reported so a lot of times near the end of the year like at this time last year we got an increase so I'm waiting for that so what are you doing knowing that you previously had this information and you know that there's a cycle that it happens what have what have you done to try to uh uh reach out to parents or whatever what exactly are we doing to um assist our parents um in regards to um educating them or keeping them informed on things because one of the things that hit me hard is the charger for $35 and and four years um to have to it's very it's not uncommon when I was in uh Corporate America that my

185charger uh uh left I mean destroyed I mean just died okay because they they make them so that they die so that you can buy them again and it's my responsibility if something just wears out that I have to replace it I can see if it was damaged but it's but where do the oness uh from the district uh ties into this because it's only $35 but only $35 may not be a easy number for some people to come up with and I'm looking at your total um cost to replace and I appreciate the fact that you have uh set up some ways for people to um pay for this but what my main concern is is that uh a lot of people don't have the ability to do that and so how many students

186now is my question do we have that are out there that currently do not have devices that are are that are that we that should have devices that are functioning in our school system particularly when we know that we are working on trying to get our grades and our scores up and everything so I'm concerned about how many students are out there who don't have them the other part to that is is that I've been told that some principles would prefer that they had classroom sets at least a a building set and that we no longer even have a a building set for our buildings at one time we had multiple sets in a building but now they they don't exist and so I'm I'm a little confused because we had a lot of money

187with ARP and for us to go from having at least a a set in the building that that a universal set I think there was at least one or two in every building to not having any concerns me that what's going on here you understand what I'm saying because how do how are we supposed to increase our grades our our data and improve our numbers if kids don't have what they need to work on I'm just and we don't and and we had a lot of money we had a lot of money for computers and we went from none in the building I mean uh set two or three sets in a building to none in the building now is what I'm being told yes you are absolutely right and we've been working on that

188uh for the last two years we have since covid and everyone thing went one to so a lot all of the devices really did leave the building um we have been replenishing certain buildings who are requesting based on conversations with asls uh carts in certain buildings for backups we have taken every single device we do not Surplus devices until they are dead and gone and we have created um bins like a a takeout sets that we deliver to the buildings during PSAT time sat time CBT time remote kits we have so many different kinds of loner kits that are out there for exactly what you're talking about while we regenerate and get this replacement cycle going because a lot of the devices we have available that we would put out there are dying at this

189point we are we are desperately trying to keep them alive the other item is for the for the chords that you've talked about I'd like to point out that all of the carts that we put back into play last year and the ones that were going to put into play this year for CBT we wire those carts on the district district budget so if a student has their device that's home they have a cord there they come in and put their device in the slot and get it ready like for CBT or for housing it for whatever they just plug it in they don't bring their their C cord in again so essentially we have been giving buildings cords and carts we've wired the C s for them for every building who wanted them um

190and I asked director Thompson because she gets most of the requests we have given them the Cs they have been asking for and we have wired them with all of the car cores that we had in the warehouse that we purchased ahead of time knowing that loss happens a lot so okay yes so how many buildings have cars how many buildings have a universal set a universal set of cars because here's where I'm going with this a lot of effort is going on on the academic side to elevate the students okay to a certain level and so if you have a let's just say uh it's probably not going to happen in the more uh affluent schools but it's certainly going to happen in in some of the other schools so you have kids in

191a classroom who don't have any computers because they lost it their mama can't afford to pay for it or whatever and that child is not getting the same opportunity as another child that's not equity so if this district is about Equity okay we need to have some resources to make sure in every class in every building if it's a loner computer you get 10 or whatever if you can't do a whole cart but I don't see how you can um move the um the grave or or the Scholastic needle if they don't have what they the tools that they need in the building and it just seems like we should have that my and and and I'm disappointed that we don't at least h building has at least 10 looners or something to make sure

192that somebody's getting educated in an equitable way my final thing is is that why is it taking so long to get the insurance in place that's my background I started with insurance my first job out of college so I happen to think I know a little bit about it why is it taking so long to get it in place it's $27 okay and we haven't rolled it out I'm just curious absolutely we started this last year we of the insurance process last year um where director Thompson was researching Insurance things do take a little time I mean we're working with audit we're working with the remediation program to say what would be the best interest of um the district up until this last year when we started looking at Insurance the Sesser funding did Cover

193um the loss the Esser funding every time we would go to Chief Barns and say hi Chief bars we have loss we need to buy more we have all of these um SATs we have all of these assessments that need to be done and we have a lot of student loss this year can I can we look at the budget and see what we can do and he was there because Esser was budgeted for devices for students and so we have been giving as much as we possibly can as a district and I'm proud of what we have been structuring this is the time where insurance is available now uh we found an excellent option we think it's very Equitable I've worked with the Council of Greater City schools to have conversations with other like

194my like districts to say what have you been doing what insurance policies how has this been working for you so that we can give the best option I didn't so yes insurance is desperately needed I'm intrigued to see how many people might buy it and how do you plan to roll that out to let them know that this option is available have you planned that yeah no we this is the first conversation we're having about insurance in a public form with the board um we would love have you decide if that's what we want to do this is an option where it could be uh sustained by families which is very uh families pay the $27 per student that's very common outside of this District but that might not be what this district will be

195doing so that's a that is one of my questions for you is to say um some of the options are to have it paid for by families other options are is this a District budget item that we're going to budget for um those are conversations we would have before I would roll that out to the public well I certainly think the board would uh be U uh would like to hear what the superintended presents to them in regards to that before we have an opinion about it um I just want to make sure I want to reiterate again that if we are talking about equity and for whatever reason that little computer is broken okay sorry the kids still has to be educated in the classroom and if we don't have computers in the classroom

196for children to be educated We're Not Gonna achieve our goals as a district uh uh scholastically that's just my uh last uh comment on it and thank you for the work that you're doing I appreciate you both thank you thank you any more questions comments okay I think this is going to be a discussion that will continue uh we're uh I've received several calls from different parents and different uh staff members and I think it's just what we just need to do is open up the dialogue and work together and see how we can uh what get our heads together and see what what needs to be done uh that supports children and families so I'm going to turn it over to you uh Dr Williams Knight as we finish up this evening all right

197thank you so much chairwoman Shuda and all of the board members um I think you're absolutely spoton it's going to be a continuing conversation um you know technology is something that is fairly new you know in our district um have all students with iPads and laptops and all of that but I think what you heard tonight from Chief shelino was a very honest and transparent uh presentation sharing you know exactly where we are with um some of the great things the strategies that her department is implementing but also sharing that you know we've got some work to do so I do appreciate that um thank you very much Chief shelino good presentation and thank you for being with us to director Thompson and we'll just keep working at it and getting better and better thank

198you thank you thank you is that it that's it keep moving forward that's what my daddy says onward and upward we're done have a good night everyone all right everybody have a good night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.