CorpusRecord 236505

Buffalo BoE Board Meeting 1/15/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Buffalo Public Schools
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,513 words · about 59 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you everyone I'm going to do the of acknowledgement the Buffalo City District respectfully acknowledges theen old sh Confederation onal territory are SCH built we honor and take to theend ancestors of the land we we acknowledge the historic intergenerational Pras that have endured an offered hope and opportunities for healing reconciliation as we go forward together one key Holden show me principle is to live in all life should be respected and car therefore because what happens to one living thing affects all living things we are grateful for the Abundant natural resources in this land of the hen uh people and for all who work to protect these resources we acknowledge as in the

002past the present and future caretakers of this land and watch and we are grateful for for the opportunity to live work and educate our children on this ancal land the board held an executive session to discuss number one appending litigation matter before the New York state supreme court with index number 2024 number two matters related to employment of potential discipline and or the a specific District district employee and number three for the purpose ofing legal advice no official action was taken so board recognition we don't have any okay speakers okay so speakers okay so we're going to add right now for the sake of time because the weather doesn't look great out there so speakers at all times you Corum you have three minutes um and we're going to start with Selena parent Native American

003C competency for BPS staff is she here I don't see her she here considering the weather maybe you can give her come back to okay we'll come back uh little job Little T we Sports and City honors administrators um first thing I'd like to come to the sir can you hear can is the microphone working or no um thank you for giving me the opportunity to address the board and I think this is going to be my last time I taking my children to the athletic program never been in Buffalo all my life my son attends City hon my older son attend City honors thank you but he plays for hutte thank you hutte has has had a losing record for years before my son went to City honors I had an opportunity to speak

004to the principal and I explained to him not only do he excel in academics he excels in and I was assured at that time that it would not be an issue when he attended the HUD football team I was flab I spoke to the athletic director I sent out several letters to the athletic director to the coach to the princi they had the kids actually practicing in is this FR Park something over here water park and there's about three Ines of geese pces they put their hands in they rolling overing each other and I spoke to the coach about it and he said that's what the board gave him so I was really alarmed and I caused a lot lot of issues with the athletic department as well as the coaches just to be shunned

005away as a troublemaker and again C I mean HTE haven't had a winning season in years my son carried that team hisself and I tried everything to get some assistance but not just my son everybody else that's on that team I don't know if this a money where they take five schools and put them all together and nobody does anything no coaches but I have never seen a team like this ever I was surprised that his literally team played in a better field and had was better organized than the high school so instead of you know a continuous arguing and fighting with them I'll just move my kids out I'm not happy about it so I'll just take them out and it seems like you know unless it's particular sports like volleyball baseball there's not

006a lot of attention G to those uh Sports where primarily black kids are football basketball there's no real emphasis from City honors in that and this a city honors so I have a real issue with those that Excel academically why do they have to have the poorest Sports um program if anything I would think that if you Excel academically and you excel in sports that your program for the those that work hard would be a little bit better but it was terrible and nobody can give me any answers thank you Mr Clon um littleon um the superintendent will address you um at the close of all the speakers thank you so much next speaker Asel Revolutionary War that's just first I'd like to congratulate the new board members and hope they have the wisdom uh

007and the ability to make the toughest decisions that benefit our children the most um I'd like to thank Dr Williams for last month giving me an opportunity to meet with the athletic um Team to hopefully push cornhole forward and I asked this board um we have a committee for a commissary I ask this board to please appoint uh one more member from the nutritious nutrition team so that we can round out that committee um I'd like to take this moment to thank Mike house for the work he's done over the past few years and wish him the best of luck and wish Aubrey Lord the best of luck moving forward for our students thank you thank you Mr next speak they're all they're all sick Meen and her kids are home sick through the next

008five sorry all right we them um so I'll address um the two speakers that we had um present tonight Mr Littleton is he still here yes um I'm really sorry to hear the experiences that you shared um that your son has experienced during his time um particularly with the football piece because I didn't hear you say that the academic piece was something that you were concerned about at City honors or at 156 but really with you know with the football piece and with the field and some of the conditions of the field um that they're practicing on I know that for the past several years um that that field has been used um I wasn't aware of you know the waste that was there it's difficult for us to kind of you know control that

009piece but I do hear your concerns and what I would like to ask is if Dr Reynolds who is our chief of Athletics she right behind you um could make some time to speak with you I know you only had three minutes um tonight you know and that's not really enough time to go as deep into all of the issues that you have with respect to the athletic program that your son is participating in we want to work with you you know I don't want us to lose students um and it sounds like your sons are excellent students I mean they're at 156 and at um City honors we would hate to lose them um without at least having the opportunity to work with you to see how we can work together and get them

010you know what what they need and what would satisfy you so I would just like to ask if you would just give her the opportunity to have a meeting with you to hear all of your concerns and to try to work with you to see how we can support addressing your concerns and thank you for coming out tonight um president spidell um thank you for welcoming uh my new board members um very classy thank you and it is always my intention uh whenever I hear a concern you know that about me to listen and to see how we can work together you know we've been working together for the past several years and so I'm glad to hear that you are working with Dr Reynolds on the cornhole piece uh you know I got to

011play it for the first time last spring had a all enjoyed it and I know that you know she's already met with me and told me that you know she's looking at that piece I know Dr caress has work at lightning speed to make sure that we had cornhole at um our parent Summit last spring so you know I think you know we're interested and seeing how we can expand that sport so thank you very much also for coming out tonight superent night um next we'll have to be representative report uh good evening everyone thanks for coming here today even though we have left so friendly of weather outside uh I'm excited to share the plans we have for the inner High student conso this year uh there's a lot to cover so let's go

012right into it um first I want to remind everyone that our in High student ccil meeting is uh scheduled on January 28th this is an important meeting because it will set the tone for everything we plan to accomplish this year looking ahead to February we plan to attend a summit on teen relationship violence prevention this event is incredibly important because it address issues many students experience but don't always feel comfortable talking about the summit will also help students recognize the sign of unhealthy relationship and learn how to build healthier and safer Connection in March we plan to attend the youth leadership conference at Nigo University this is a fantastic opportunity for students to step out of their comfort zon and develop leadership skills and connect with their peers from other schools it's about learning how

013to lead efficiently effectively and bring back ideas that can make a real difference in our own schools during our upcoming meetings on the 28th we will also have a special presentation from the Western Newark District Court about the First Amendment this presentation will explore how the First Amendment impacts our daily lives as students and as Citizens it's not it's not just about knowing your rights it's about understanding how the rights apply to real life uh situations like freedom of speech freedom of religion and more this is a great chance for us to ask questions engage in discussion and walk away with deeper understanding of one of the cornerstones of our democracy additionally during our uh upcoming January meeting we would love to invite board president Brown and former President Sharon belon cman to join us

014in our inner High meeting to address the student body uh this is an important opportunity for students to connect with them and hear about their Visions for the districts and learn how they plan to address the need of students in may we plan to attend a mental health uh youth conference hosted by the division of student Support Services uh mental health is a critical topic for students and this conference will provide valuable resources spark open conversations and help break the stigma surrounding mental health it's about empowering students to recognize that it's okay to ask for help and ensure they have they know that they're not alone events like this Fosters more compassionate and supportive environment for everyone we're also going to be launching a Conta a logo context for inner High student console this is

015more than just a design challenge it's a it's a chance to give our console a fresh identity and something all students can feel connected to by involving students in the process we're engaging encouraging uh creativity and pride in being part of inner High another excite another exciting initiative is our district service project this is a chance for us to come together and make a tangible impact on our community whether through volunteering fundraising or other acts of service this project is about showing the students can lead the way in making positive change it's also about it's also a reminder that our influence extend beyond our school finally we will address the attendance of our secondary schools at our monthly meetings right now our attendance is at 40% as at this year we are committed to increasing

016engagement by involving Communications making meeting more accessible and ensuring every student still welcome and included inner High thrives when we have variety of voice and perspective contributing to the conversation so boosting attendance uh remains a top priority for us also I want to take a moment to thank the Buffalo board of education for the unwavering support of the inner High student council their engagement allows us to thrive as a console and we look forward to continue to make the most of the time together during our each monthly meetings uh thank you all for your time and patience [Applause] thank you ran that was uh very robust it sounds like the inner high school council is in great hands and you have a nice timeline um for students um this year so I'm excited um to

017be involved as well so with that uh we're going to move on to the update all right so I will have Chief academic officer um and belli come forward you all know that we have a monitoring calendar um and we're sticking very closely to what we say we're going to be covering in our meetings that helps or to be prepared um prior to the meeting um um to you know delve into whatever it is we're covering and tonight we're covering instructional priorities for the district so sure thank you good evening everyone um I'm here today to talk a little bit about our instructional priorities which are very closely TI can everyone hear Chief and the people in the public here yes okay level one voice One Vision and one Mission um you can see that

018R's Early Elementary is highlighted because that is one of the tenants that we address with the superintendent goals um but we will also obviously be considering um the work that we do at our high school level next slide please so of the five goals the first two are most remain to conversation so we'll be talking about eliminating achievement and opportunity gaps and providing access to educational excellence and accelerated learning next slide please so I'm going to talk a little bit about our instructional priorities and just a bit of background for those who may not be familiar with these they are available on our website in the curriculum division um so we've established priorities for both mathematics and literacy across all content areas we've created coaching tools to use to collect data on implementation of those

019priorities um so I'm going to talk a little bit tonight about the different priorities that we've established and I've pulled out key indicators for each priority that closely aligned to the superintendent's goals um so these particular instructional priorities Target the most important elements of instruction so we tried to whittle down the millions of things that we consider in a classroom on a daily a daily basis tried to whittle those down to the key priorities and within those priorities the key um indicators that would tell us whether things are working effectively um in the classroom so again we have tools that we've created one for literacy in all areas so science social studies Etc and one strictly for mathematics and what we do is we use those tools when we visit classrooms so the asls can

020use it principles can use it I can use it my team can use it when we go into schools and visit rooms we're looking for certain instructional priorities we can collect the data back and then obviously tonight I'm going to be able to share it out with you to so you can see the progress that we're making um so we use that data to drive support for schools um provide professional development to take a key look at our instructional initiatives and see if we make need to make tweaks in the um current process um and these particular priorities connect the goals in several ways so first we talk about um classroom culture so strong classroom culture obviously enables learning in any setting um so that will address all of our goals so if we we

021know that if the classroom culture is in place learning can take place use of District materials is another one of the things that we talk about um so using District materials and curriculum ensures that our teachers are hitting standards aligned uh instruction in the classroom so again that would address all of our goals as well a particular one on the literacy tool is foundational skills so we know that the foundational skills of reading are directly tied to interim goal number one and I believe number three um related to dibles daily reading and writing are two more of our instructional priorities for literacy um obviously that's necessary success in pretty much every class across the district um so that will be a key tie-in for our literacy goal and our grade n goals um students who

022can explain their thinking part of our mathematics collection um demonstrate understanding so if they can talk about the math it tells us that they understand the math and how to process those problems um and then differentiation addresses both literacy and Mathematics so we talk about differentiating instruction in the classroom providing scaffold for kids to access learning and we know that if we're meeting that Target um it helps us achieve all of our goals so I tried to pull out key indicators tonight that would show you the direct alignment between the priorities we've previously established and this year's instructional goals next slide please so here are the results from the first um priority which is the culture of learning so we talk about the culture of learning in both mathematics classrooms and classrooms that um address

023literacy so the the key statement that we're always looking for is are all students involved in the work of the lesson with the appropriate level of support so we want to make sure that we are addressing that that question in the classroom so some of the key indicators would be that students are involved in academic work from start to finish so when we walk into a classroom from the minute we're there to the minute we leave kids are engaged in academic work so there's no downtime in the classroom there's no busy work taking place this is academic instruction um we like to see that the learning and criteria for Success are communicated to students so students should be able to tell us or um demonstrate that they understand the purpose of the lesson that the

024teacher is teaching so do they know what they're doing and why in the classroom when appropriate we expect that a teacher would model the particular skill that they're trying to to help the students understand um they might demonstrate um we want the kids to participate in guided practice meaning that the teacher helps them walk through whatever activity they're doing so they understand it and they can do it with the teacher teacher would provide feedback about how the students are doing and then allow them to practice independently we know that that model the gradual release model is going to support student understanding so they've seen what it looks like they've discussed it with the teacher they've practiced with the teacher they've gotten feedback on how they're doing on that particular skill and whether they understand the

025concept and they get to practice independently they'll get additional feedback on that independent practice but that is that is key for us so they've seen what to do they've practiced what to do and now we're going to assess whether they actually were able to do it when they work independent um we also believe that equit Equitable participation is very important we want all kids um to have a chance to participate in the activity the lesson whatever they're working on um so that might be um the way the Teacher Calls on students she may have a of particular students she wants to address in the classroom to make sure they understand or she might do it a little more randomly but we want we want all kids to have a chance to participate and it may

026not be that they're verbally participating if that is um something that they're nervous about but there's other ways that they can demonstrate and the teacher can work with that student to make sure they understand which ties into the last indicator I pulled out that they are deliberately checking for understanding so throughout the course of the lesson the teacher has to build in checks for understanding to make sure that kids um do actually understand the the work that particular skill that they are learning so to the right you can see the data we pulled out of the system the numbers will always look a little bit different there are definitely more entered for literacy more classroom visits because that's so many different classrooms that science and social studies and reading classrooms whereas mathematics is strictly for

027the math classroom so those numbers will always look lower you'll also see that at times it might not add up to you because one of the categories isn't really listed well sometimes it's not applicable sometimes you walk into a classroom and you're just not there at the time when they would be doing something so the the person using the tool would just select not applicable which won't appear here in okay so we have several categories um culture of learning that green is what we're looking for it means yes it is established in this classroom so those indicators off to the side holistically we're seeing those in the classroom it's not a checklist they're not counting that the teacher had met four of five targets or something like that we're looking holistically at the instruction um

028a yellow is mostly so it's mostly in place it could take a little bit of tweaking but it's pretty much there um blue is somewhat so we saw evidence of some of the things we were looking for but it wasn't completely established in the classroom and then red means we thought we should sell it and we didn't see it so it's not yet in place um so we use this data to support the teachers we want to make sure that it doesn't feel like an aacha so they get feedback um they can get it in an email directly generated through the system or it could be a verbal conversation with the teacher but we want them to understand what we were seeing and then have the opportunity to to provide feedback if they want to

029um so you can see culture of learning is fairly established in most of our classrooms so of the rooms visited for the most part they had a solid yes so the the people visiting the room felt fairly confident that the culture was established in those classrooms there are other indicators I didn't include here which include things like um students understanding behavioral expectations smooth transitions things like that I tried to pull out the most relevant indicators for the goals so culture of learning is again in both literacy classrooms as well as mathematic class next slide please using District materials is another thing that we talk about a lot so we want to make sure that District materials are being used and curriculum are being used effectively and with skills Fidelity so we're looking to see teachers

030are planning and using the district curriculum and materials the way they're intended to be used which might be an inquiry based approach for example in a science classroom or a math classroom or it might be a more explicit approach in a reading classroom where kids are practicing phonics so it would depend on the context of the situation um but you can see our data off to the side for both literacy and Mathematics this has been a large emphasis for the district over the past three years um I don't know if you'll remember but a while back there was a study conducted and they we came to learn that even though we had District materials and District curriculum they weren't being used in most classrooms um so that was a push for us because we've vetted

031these materials we worked on the curriculum we know these are effective we want to make sure they're being used in classrooms so again that is probably one of the raisings you see such a high um rate of yeses for this particular indication next slide please differentiation is actually our weakest indicator this is where we have to put a lot of emphasis um so we're looking to see that all students have the support they need to access and engage deeply with rigorous culturally responsive grade level content um so some indicators related to differentiation the teacher is continually adapting the lesson so when this when the teacher realize us the students don't actually understand the concept can take a step back address misconceptions try to clarify any misund understandings um we're asking teachers to scaffold instruction which

032is actually a really difficult ask um so a lot of people need support in this area um so basically we're saying they're teaching grd level content they're not watering it down but they might need to provide access points for some kids who are struggling um so there might be students who um for whatever reason do not exactly understand what's being asked they they might need sentence starters um if they're learning English it might be a scaffold that we would apply they might need graphic organizers if they're struggling a little bit with executive functioning or something along those lines so there's lots of tools we can use to scaffold instruction so if you're picturing a building under construction and you see the scaffolding around the building that's to support the work that's taking place it's the

033same thing with a scaffold instructionally we're supporting the work to make sure that the student learns we're not making it easier for the student we're just giving them an access point so that they can achieve the same way another student would achiev again that is one of the most difficult things to do in education and you you will see that we sometimes need additional support in this area um we ask that teachers pre-teach retach and or reinforce important skills during teacher-led small group we call that differentiated time a lot um so we expect that teachers might have some students working independently on important activities while the teacher pulls other students into a teacher-led small group to reinforce skills um perh perap they're pre-teaching vocabulary to some students they might be reteaching a skill that some

034students didn't understand the first time um but that small group time is really important for a lot of our kids to bolster their skills um and then we also ask if the teacher differentiates activity for groups or learning areas so when students are working independently they may have differentiated activities as well with different scaffolds for example one student may need a graphic organizer to access the activity whereas another doesn't one may need to have a partial outline um established to start writing the essay whereas another one does not so it would depend on the activity in the student so when we ask teachers to differentiate we're asking them to do a lot they're taking the lesson that any student would receive and and maximizing access points for particular students so you could have five different

035scaffolds in the same lesson depending on the needs of those students this will always be an area where we need um additional support because we want everyone to be effective and we want kids to receive that kind of instruction so I'll talk a little bit about at the end about some of the things we can to help me that next slide please foundational skills has been a huge push to us with the science of reading um so we check to see that foundational skills are taught explicitly sequentially and systematically um meaning there's no guessing we don't ask kids to guess the sound a letter makes we teach them explicitly what sound a letter makes what does c say C says what does t say t says T right we teach that very explicitly there's a

036certain sequence that we use when we teach like which letters come first which sounds come first um we would teach for example C we would teach that is the sound to a younger student before we add different sounds for C or different spellings for example um so we want it to be explicit we want the teacher to model provide that guided practice and then later that independent practice and corrective feedback all along the way we want it to be systematic so we're following set routines that have been researched embedded um those are outlined for teachers in the curriculum and kids are given the opportunity to take the skills that they're learning right so I've learned how to read these words and now I'm going to apply that to a text so I'm going to practice

037fluency so I can read these words in isolation because my teacher taught me explicitly how to sound that word out and now when I pick up a text like a paragraph a decodable book a trade book I can read those words because I internalized the phonic skills and now I'm applying them to Connected text as well we ask them to apply it to writing so I've learned how to form these letters I've learned how to write words I've learned what a sentence is now I'm going to apply that skill in my own writing so we want kids to not only learn the basic skill of letter formation or phonics but then to have chance to apply it in their own writing or their own reading so we move from one word to Connected text which

038is just a fancy way of saying book or article or something like that and we talk about letter formation and words writing words moving that to longer text than they compose and spelling is built into them okay so foundational skills in this instance is only looking at um reading instructions so you wouldn't see that across all grade levels you'd see it typically at lower grades or in in RTI or intervening with students but it's been a huge emphasis for the district so you will see that when administrators and other people are going in they are seeing evidence that teachers are teaching explicitely next slide please all students read sounds really strange every time I say it I think it sounds strange we're telling teachers the kids should be reading that seems very obvious and teachers

039will tell you that's very obvious but the catch is sometimes it's not always happening independently so there are times when we might hear a text being roud which is appropriate at sometimes but not when we're practicing how to read um so we want kids to routinely engage in independent reading of grade appropriate text and for the younger kids the grade appropriate text might be a decodable text it might not be a trade book yet depending on the student so they might just be using little books that practice The Sounds they've already learned so if I learned short a short e and short o the words in my text would use short a short e short o but not short u which I haven't learned yet right so that's a decodable um we ask teachers to

040chunk readings and assign accountable tasks so you would never just hand a 10-page article to a student and say read this you would say read section one answer this prompt read section one highlight the five vocabulary words most relevant to the topic read section one write the gist of that section off in the margin to the right so you give them them an accountable task so when you circulate even though they're reading silently you can tell that they understood because they're able to address the prompt you gave them or the task that you gave them it's one way for teachers to monitor because we need kids to read silently we can't always be reading out loud when you take a state assessment a reg exam you're reading that material silently so we need to kids

041to have those opportunities but we want to make sure that they're actually comprehending what they read which is why the task is so relevant and older students May Simply Be reading a text and transposing it into an essay right or a paper that they're working on so it just depends on the particular grade level and the skill level of the students um outside of foundational skills so outside of those times when we're teaching phonics or we're teaching explicit writing we want kids to spend the majority of their time reading and writing about and talking about appropriate text so as they go up through the grade levels the teex should get more rigorous the conversation should get more rigorous the prompts should get more rigorous at the same time don't forget that teacher is differentiating for

042the kids who aren't quite there yet right so she's scaffolding these activities for the students as well which is why it's always such a challenge but when we say all students read we mean we want to see these things happening every day so in every day student should be asked to read not to always just listen or watch but to actually physically read text next slide please same with all students write so we want students to be writing on a daily basis in this particular indicator we're asking that they're writing about the text that they read not just writing an essay about you know they wish they had more time at the locker we want them to write about something in response to what they read in class we want to know that they understood

043what they read and they can engage in those conversations um and in this case it's a written conversation um so we want them to have daily opportunities to write independently related to the text that they reading um so if it's in a science class they're perhaps writing about a lab that they read if it's in a social studies class they might be writing about a primary source or something from the textbook in English class they might be writing about a novel but they're always writing about something that they're reading in class and then we ask that students respond to higher order thinking questions targeting the standards so how deep can we go into the standard to make sure that the kids are being pushed so again some students might need access points to get to

044that they can answer the question but they might need a little support to collect their thoughts on paper but that's okay they're still doing the activity they're still answering that rigorous question next slide please um specific to mathematics we talk about all students engaging independently in grade level math and we talk about appropriate depth because sometimes there's conceptual understanding involved sometimes you're just practicing the clency of math so you know your time skills right and sometimes you're applying your learning so there's different levels of rigor so we say you might be doing skill fluency practice you might be working on a conceptual understanding of math or you might be applying your understanding so those are three different levels of rigor in a math class but we want kids to do this independently for grade level

045math so we don't want the teacher always modeling we need them to let the kids grapple with the problems if it's okay to be wrong they just need to talk through their process so we want to start by making sure that they get the opportunity to do the math independently so that we can share the feedback and learn how they thought through that problem we want to make sure they have opportunities not only to memorize their times tables right but also to apply their understanding because they've learned the concept so that means we don't want to teach tricks um because then students don't usually get the conceptual understanding an easy example is foil I don't know if remember this from algebra first out or in or last right the trick it only works sometimes it

046won't work if you get to more complex problems and most kids would not understand why they're doing it they just know procedurally it's first outer in or last right so that's a trick it can help a little bit but they have to understand why they're doing that so if you only give the prce but don't explain the concept behind it you're short changing the kids which is why we talk about aspects next slide please so explaining their thinking is the chance to talk and write in a math classroom it's very specific in this instance mathematics we want to make sure that kids have the opportunity to not only explain how they got the answer to a problem but justify the way they thought through it so we ask kids to challenge one another and not

047in a rway we just mean ask how the student got I say I got this how did you get to that here's what I did what did you do but have those conversations about the map um so we're asking them to consistently share explain justify the strategies they chose to solve a particular problem it could be through a discussion board in schooo it could be through an assignment they submit there's lots of different ways um we want kids consistently asking questions and talking and thinking about the math we want to use precise language because if you've been in a math classroom anytime in the past few years you know that a reflection in English is not the same as a reflection in math right reflection in math is a very specific skill that students have

048to learn for mathematics whereas if I'm sitting in an English classroom I'm reflecting on my day their terms are the same but used very differently so we want kids to be able to use precise mathematical language in the class this last one is very important kids need to persevere through problems they're hard a lot of the problems are challenging they were written to be challenging but we need kids to keep trying and not to give up so one of the things we encourage in a mathematics classroom is talking about how you arrived at a solution and then trying to step back if it it's not the correct solution trying to step back and see why and talk about it because when they can talk all this through and they don't qu it they will always

049do better than that um you can see this is not our strongest indicator um getting kids to talk about math is not easy and the teacher has to be very um purposeful in how they approach this so this is one of the other areas that we we tend to work on next slide please so you saw our data we're we're doing fairly well under many of the priorities but we do have a little work and our biggest need is differentiation um so we're going to share guidance regarding teacher-led small group and opportunities to work with the students we' started having those conversations at the building level with administrators what does it look like when you're pulling students for a small group what are the other kids doing what are you doing how are you choosing

050the skill that you're working on what data is driving that decision and how do you know that it's purposeful so we want to share some additional Guidance with the schools um we always want to support the use of relevant technology so you know we have a lot of tools in our classrooms like Lexia iel um um Mayan so we want to make sure that they're being used effectively in the classroom they're not to kill time they're supposed to be used um just bolster skills so we just want to make sure they're purposeful and then we need to continually maximize our co- teaching opportunities we're very fortunate in the district that there are many times when there are two adults in the classroom we have co-teachers for special education we have co-teachers for enl so there

051are many opportunities to maximize um instruction in those classrooms because there are two adults to support the students so we want to work with teachers to make sure that they are doing that um in addition we are bringing iny in they are the vendor for Orton Gillingham so we're bringing them in to do coaching in the schools they've already hit uh several schools this week they'll be going for follow-up visits to those schools and then starting a new round of schools a little bit later in the spring um so they can provide a lot of guidance for schools on what's working what's not working and where they can tweak um their instruction in terms of Orton Gillingham morphology we are analyzing U middle of year data at the next principal meeting and AP meeting so

052we'll be able to look at our Dibbles um I already won't be completed but we'll at least be able to start with our Dibbles data and we'll be working with the secondary principles to look at um grade reports how our students doing so far this semester uh and lab minutes as well and then we're going to continue our school walks so you guys have heard me say this a million times pretty much out in schools uh about four days a week the asls are there with me Andor on their own at different schools supporting the staff um so we're going to continue those walks we'll continue to use the coaching tool and the instructional priorities and we're beginning to schedule follow-up visits so now we've mainly hit the U majority of the schools at the

053elementary level for the first round of visits starting to schedule uh return visits with the asls to follow up on some of the guidance we shared to see what additional supports are needing next slide please and this I think is the best so the superintendent I don't know if you are aware she shared prompts with grade three students across the district and has asked those students to write in response to the prompt they send it to her and she is individually reading each student's response and comment so every student in third grade is getting feedback from their superintendent I don't think there's anyone in the world who is doing that besides so each student is getting individualized feedback if they're a third grader um submitting and the p and the P get as well and

054they love it by the way um and then in addition and I don't know if everybody is aware of this the superintendent is going to visit 60 schools in 60 days to reinforce the goals and instructional priorities so she limping you know in April you'll know why but I think it's important for me um to model what I expect and if I'm expecting my team to be out in schools I think it's important for schools to see me and when I'm out you know I want to walk around the school I want to go into classrooms I want to see some of the priorities that are being discussed here I certainly will be publishing it so that if they're board members that would like to come with me to some of their schools you know

055you'll be welcome to I've asked the asls to come out with me and I have every single Cabinet member also including legal coming out with me budget is coming out um you know so there will be really two members of my cabinet an ASL and another we don't want to overwhelm our principles um but I also in addition to the cabinet I've asked division head members um to come to some of those visits because as we're beginning to build our bench we've got to start preparing some of the folks who are in our division head at that level to enter into cabinet level positions on one day so I I'm really excited it will be a lot but um you know I'll be looking to see some of what I'm seeing here and um you

056know I want to visit classrooms the nurse's office uh you know talk to the parent education leaders just you know I'm not looking for a dog and pony show oh yeah I'm really looking no I'm really looking and and because I'm a seasoned principal I can tell you know staff may put it on but the kids won't the kids will not cannot you know prepare the kids so I'm I'm really looking for forward to doing this um it's not an iig gotta it's more coming out to provide support and coaching so I'm excited 60 schools in 60 [Applause] days so you all are welcome to come to some school I do I'll out so does anyone have questions I'm sorry I know I talked a lot the channel I just have a question for one

057of the slid I was just curious for all student rights uh are we including typing in it as well or just they're composing that was my question because a lot of students do struggle to type and their typing speed is very important because I know before I came to BPS one of the important thing was we actually had a dedicated class for typing cuz it's such an important for our f then or whichever your voice always typing I just want to make sure that we're the yeah so you're making a good point so I I should have said composing so it's not just manually handwriting it's also Ty we just want to make sure that they are composing responses on that point do we have typing CS because I'm being told it's being taught in

058some schools outside of the district at grade three you don't have a specific course that the elementary teachers can embed that we recommend sites like um typing.com and BBC which has a typing um program we actually just shared it recently with principles as a reminder so have we shared it with the parents don't know two things that comes up it's typing and and script uh writing C courtesy so the schools have been very conscious of it because of CBT their computer-based testing because the kids have to type their essays so I know the schools are very on top of that but I don't know specifically what they might have sent home so I think that's something we should look at not on the basis can I ask a question to So when you say you

059go out are you talking about you you talking about your directors who are you talking so I go out about week and what about your other has to be in 50% of the time 50% of the time that's been non- negotiable okay so how do you how do you select the classes you go in are you using data to go select them or you just going in no it would depend right now we so Dr B is focusing in Dr and um are focusing on mathematics instructions so when they go out they're looking at mathematics classrooms right but how do they select the mathematic classroom in other words there's only a few of them okay and so are you using data from within the school school to see what exactly is going on in this

060particular class versus what's not going on in this class we always review the data at any site visit but also it's a little bit driven by who's teaching math so if you're not teaching math at 10 o'cl I can't visit a classroom but we will hit as many in that instance as many mathematics classrooms as possible including RTI when I go I'm focusing right now on literacy so I'm trying to get into the literacy classrooms to make sure that I'm seeing OG morphology instruction um grade specifically I'm trying to get into um they're doing a lot of CTE walks so they're going specifically to CTE classrooms um so and different directors have a different Focus depending right but we have the data for for our buildings right and if we're going to move things forward

061and we know we're going into a building and we know that the data is there this particular classroom is struggling or whatever wouldn't we spend time so miss obviously well no I'm just trying to find out because um so I review the schools and I already know if there are specific things I want to see but I also want to see the good things I'm not only looking for someone who might be struggling I want to see exemplars as well so we try to hit as many classrooms as we can we typically go in for about 10 minutes um if it's not an AP situation if it's just a visit so we can see a snapshot of what instruction looks like in that classroom sometimes you might see um a situation where it might need

062a little support and we can send someone back to provide that support other times you see an Exemplar lesson in fact I just saw two special classrooms that were outstanding and I sent Kudos out to their asls um so it would depend we want to find model classrooms in the district that we can send other people to see and we also want to provide support when it's needed so I can't only look at a struggling classroom but I do look at data we sit with the principal and the administrative team and review the data before you go into the classroom or after both okay all right so my next question on here is uh with the district material um when you look at a struggling classroom does the question come up are they using the

063district material oh okay in class uh because I remember one time um we were talking about the SC uh the science modular that um Kelly uh Dr Baldo uh offers or provides and uh I think she had told us that they found out that the that they were providing the material and they saw where the teachers who were not using it were getting lower performance than that and so they eventually I guess you instruct people that the superintendent and the board has paid for this stuff that you should use it I guess sooner or later that comes out right commit right okay and so how do you know that that's being done do the asls monitored or what so buing administrators use the coaching tool which and one of the priorities you saw was District

064materials and curriculum okay so everyone who uses that tool is looking for that when they're in classrooms um coaches can provide support to teachers who are struggling sometimes we have new teachers who haven't been trained in a particular method so we do need to provide a lot of supports along the way but our expectation is that people are using District materials and following ccul and with the keyw there is with skilled Fidelity because we can't blindly follow curriculum if you have a group of kids with specific needs you need to scaffold right so there's things that we expect happen within the instruction even though they're using a culum the one main exception when in a Norton Gillingham classroom you don't deviate from the script because that is designed a very specific way it has to

065be explicit and sequential and so one of the things we're looking for in those rooms is that the teacher is using that scriptor manual um because it is written very specifically to support those skills thank you I do want to share it I have two grandsons and a granddaughter who are writing very well and they are products of uh Buffalo Public Schools and uh so what you are doing you're doing uh well and they're reading well also but we started them reading too but um I just wanted to share that that I was very impressed to see how they were writing so you are doing some great work in that area I appreciate that thank you thank [Applause] you so I had a question um I know that you just you had just said and

066I know that there supports for teachers but I'm looking to see is it a consistent support or is it only support when you see the data and when you see um you know what I mean like every teacher is we just we see it here even in next steps the teacher is required in the specific gingham approach a teacher is required and they're also required to do the individual work and they're also required to make sure you know I mean so that's a lot for a teacher and I get the coaching supports and I get if the data you know um is necessary to to bring supports in but our teachers um encouraged or is there uh a study check in not just like a meeting where you're in front of everybody and you don't

067want to exess you know State what your issue is but what supports are there that's consistent that the teachers know that they can rely on other than going to a PD if they know that that's where they're struggling I get the curriculum but where is the moral support for all that they're expected to do on top of it and I get that's what they're there for and that's their job because I know that's the next thing that people might say but that's a lot of pressure it is a lot ofure other than just the people who are doing well like they also need support because they're holding a standard and if they're consistently being looked at as like the model that's pressure too so I'm looking for that like moral back bowner support that's consistent

068so teaching is probably one of the most difficult occupations that anyone could enter into because not only are you working with students at varying levels in the same classroom but they also have emotional needs that they bring to the table there's lots of things going on in kids lives that impact what they're doing so teachers are asked to do a whole lot at the same time with you know the resources that they have so um we do have as many scaffolds in place for teachers as we can as well and for administrators right so we start by providing training for administrators they come to monthly meetings we answer their questions um we can provide many lessons just to model something for them we have explicit training for all teachers on the basics and then we

069try to graduate them into more advanced trainings as needed um so for example before we put people in OG we started most of them through letters because letters gives you the understanding of why you're going to follow the OG scrip right so if you just put someone in OG they may not know why they're doing what they're doing but if you give them letters first it helps them understand like oh that in OG is going to address this I get it right so we try to have that balance as much as possible we have coaches in many of the buildings that can go in and model co- plan with teachers um support them with additional professional development at the elementary level they have grade level meetings every cycle so they can come in and analyze

070the together the coach can provide training the administrator can provide feedback to that team team so it's like the grade level team the sixth grade teachers together fifth grade at the high school they usually have common planning so all the social studies teachers come together or all the English teachers come together so that's an additional opportunity to provide support to have discussions about what's working and not a lot of schools will collect writing samples bring them to grade level and analyze them what trends are we seeing they obviously have the testing data that we use um so between builtin time after school opportunities professional development coaching support we're bringing MZ in to provide coaching we've brought reveal math in to provide training um so there's professional development there's embedded support at the school level when

071we go through and we identify an issue I I'll call someone and send them to provide additional supports so I hear what you're saying about the consistency there's a consistency at the building level then there's extra layer that we try right right I and and you're totally addressing what I'm talking about I'm also and this is not to be answered now but I'm also addressing something outside of just a curriculum like what if a teacher is struggling with you know the understanding of the child not just based on that but because there's there's issues maybe with language or maybe you know what I mean like there's other layers other than the the coaching that has to do with the curriculum in general so it's like the outside that's what I'm asking is like yeah teachers

072Provide support for each other too that's that's what I'm and I'm asking that because I'm receiving text around you know is there support outside of the curriculum for Teacher morale to as they are pressured to do this so Sharon Brown's team actually provides a lot of emotional supports yeah that's that's what're but then teachers within a building often support each other so you know teacher might have a more innate understanding of the needs of the multilingual Learners she can work with the classroom teacher to help them understand you know this is what is going on with this particular student here are some scaffolds you can use with this particular student um and then we have Mentor teachers so Statewide the law reads that the first year of a teacher career we have to provide mentoring

073but we provide it for three years and we also include people that are new to the district um so we provide additional support So mentoring is separate from coaching so coaching is more um directed like but mentoring is confidential between the mentor and and so they can question to ask someone else I'm only saying this publicly to address that but I also do want to state that as my daughter is her first year teaching she feel so welcome because she know she could talk to other people whether just in second grade in another school as the second grade teacher so that was a personal but I just wanted to address that she get chance to go to the Saturday um math mlc I'm forgetting to say this word math community so every Saturday um staff

074no every Saturday she's running math learning communities alternating teachers one week next and they spend the day planning out the next month of instruction thank you question thank you for a robust as always exed thank you thank you ra okay um action on minutes from January 2nd 2025 motion Follow by Mion all in favor thank you uh consent agenda so the consent agenda will motion to accept for consent what I want to do is um it without line 79c okay motion a motion to accept without n c all right we've been trying to do that for a while are you gonna do aoll agenda this is to the agenda sorry order this is to accept the consent agenda without that particular item since it has unfold by the superintendent so this is just clarifying consent

075yeah accepting the consent agenda that now it'll be open for discussion on the whole agenda all in favor right this was this was strictly the motion to accept the conf agenda as the board understands correct okay just so that everything is [Music] reflected no question com of this okay yeah credit to Dr car I okay before we vot to approve um there's a scholarship um acceptance of honorable Jennifer M scholarship in honor of Mr johnon the district is putting to announce the designation of an annual $500 scholarship awarded to two graduating Career and Technical education CTE students by honorable West District Board member Jennifer mosy in honor of Mr Johnny Bruce Fenderson one female and one male student will receive will each receive a $250 monetary award toward the cost of postsecondary Education or training

076in the construction a trades additionally each awarde will receive a $250 voucher toward the purchase of tools to support their career choice for a total of $500 each and an annual investment in our students totaling $1,000 the district requests acceptance of the scholarship by the Board of Education Mr Fenderson established a legacy of support and education for individuals pursuing careers in the Construction Construction trades he was recognized for helping to create better Pathways for those who sought to improve their lives through successful career choices a veteran buried with military honors Mr Fenderson exemplify the characteristic sought in the CTE awardees which include leadership qualities eagerness to help others and commitment to continuing formal education in the trades After High School the district's Career and Technical education department will administer the scholarship and consultation with honorable

077board member moli we are grateful that she has honored the legacy of Mr Fenderson with this loving Act of generosity toward our skate [Applause] approve agenda [Laughter] move the board with respect to the motion to with respect a motion to approve the consent agenda which outline seven of agenda item 9C is that has been pulled and again just for clarification the board resolutions are separate from the consent um how do you vote board member belon yes board member ever yes there you say us um vice president yes board member MOSI yes board member sh yes board member SC or vice president SC No Ex board member Woods no exceptions and board member Z yes and president Evans Brown your exception and the consent agenda is approved better I have Mo so we have the commissary

078yes I am um Madam chair respectfully uh changing the name of my uh representative from um uh uh Dr Stephie to uh Jessica bow Barry District um I made that decision with the understanding that it was important to me to make sure that there was someone um on this um advisory committee that understood um what the parents in this district and what the community expects and I think she'll feel that need for us uh and we'll Avo additional criticism as a result of it all right thank you and I think respectfully most of these people that were um representa our board members at this board our parents um in some way I know mine was is a parent of a former graduate from BPS and in okay so thank you for that um motion to

079approve the commissary instruction advisory committee family board member Andrea zif by board member Sharon belet motion car2 30 rules and will have and we've been over this several times [Music] so a motion to consider the recommendations for the 2530 goals and D rails um then okay mchen second by all in favor okay discussion I just one thing I just uh appreciate the work that's been done uh I uh sit on the implementation committee and I get to see really the work that that brown and board member mchen and i' leared to um and to add um I would like to similarly have the same sentiment along with um the superintendent her team who came up with um you know and I think we're you know at a point in a Jun juncture where we where

080we came from what a year and a half ago we've come a long way and we're seeing the the work you know work that we put into this um and so every District can't say that but we can um so I'm excited about it I know you all are too um we're going to support because it's about the kids you know case our our priority is that about don't change until student outcomes don't change until adult change so that's our Mantra and we're going to stick with that um so any other discussions about the Goen Arts you know remind us we have toat on Friday um with our coach from the C wait a minute wait a minute you're not ending the meeting yet are you um could you remind us um board members to

081send in their food recommendation oh yes thank you for that uh Lisa and Ruth has sent out an agenda or a menu for your uh it's tomorrow it's du tomorrow she sent an email so make sure you we you sent it like Monday no Friday Fray last week which was the 8th something like that so make sure that you go back and look at the email put your your your your your choice in otherwise you will not be eating with us I I respond to food request immediately so can I have a motion for approve gold rails okay everybody okay [Music] firstart and follow by J M all in favor all right motion Carri [Music] all right so January 16 2025 unfinished I have a motion authorized in the district to fully Shadow pending litigation

082forting New York state supreme court with index number 811 d224 am $28,000 uh board member uh Woods uh board member all in favor all right any oppos all right so okay last vice president cheers before you Mo and finish business may I ask um um uh for the request that I've had on the table about uh receiving an update on the board pass uh the ID badges um we have up I have six or seven of old ones but I don't have anyone since 24 okay and so we've always had badges um that will allow us to go inside the schools our schools I was told that um uh in the policy it says that we don't have the right to go into a school unless the board gives us um uh permission to do

083so and so what I'd like to do is tweet that board policy um to uh include because I went uh a week ago to a school and the principal intentionally did not tell anyone I was coming because he did not want to see a pony and he didn't want me to see a pony and dog show and I I appreciated that but we've always had a pass our students and we don't have that anymore since since uh 24 and I think it's a great tool I I can give you the update uh Madam president if it's okay if I can respond to that so the board policy and I can send you all a copy stipulates that as an individual you do not have any rights greater than an ordinary citizen when it comes to

084accessing the school uh and if you did want to access a school you make an appointment with the principal and then you and the principal can decide what your activity will be in the school if you were ever given a swipe card that gave you unilateral access to our buildings you should not have received that that has never been authorized by a superintendent or a chief of staff so if it was done for you know in any other way it was done in error you should a swipe card for City Hall you should have I think we're we're getting updated ones because the fobs were changed so we can get those to you and you should have and you should have a regular district ID that does not give you uh access to our buildings

085so if you wanted to change that policy and Grant yourselves uh that authority to do that you would need to change that policy that's our interpretation of how that policy is implemented with just can I also say that it's never been abused by this board so I got on the board in 211 I had a a card I have one every year after that up until 2024 so if we were never supposed to get it okay then we were it was a standard practice and under maintenance of benefit like the unions can do we should be able to get a bit we should president I had in 2019 you have one now re for clarification we receive a separate City Hall and a board ID even if it's not to get in the building cuz

086I have my board ID but I can't I used to be able to access City H with my my city I'll answer your question minute mad president there's a question and I'll answer so uh thank you Ruth Ruth has just handed you the city hall uh slight passes that you're entitled to have um if you have an ID card it shouldn't work to open buildings and if you do I'll just repeat that you received the ability to do that in error for your opinion because checked with the previous Chiefs but I think there was some changes made in that policy because it's always well the policy is being implemented with Fidelity to the policy if the board wanted to change that you know you'd have to pursue that we how soon can we put it

087on the agenda to recognize the fact that we are elected officials to represent in our district we are not just ordinary citizen we have and if you don't have it appears to been the precedent because I have all those passes but if we don't have it by whatever change in this policy how soon can we get it on the agenda to change it back next mon thank you for the explanation I just want to ask the body what would be the reason that you would want I mean so when I go out I do have one but I always call ahead and I wait I ring the bell because I want to see how I'm going to I don't go into buildings without you know that respect for you know the building so I'm wondering

088what would be the reason that you would want a cast to be able to enter the building without just ringing the bell being welcomed and going in and I don't when was was a policy actually changed it didn't sound like the policy was changed I think I think there were quite a few changes done probably I don't know but since day one being on this board we had a ability to get in City Hall and we also had the ability for our schools if you wanted to use it now um the purpose for whatever reason okay that there should not be uh uh uh and I'm going to go back to something that The Honorable Crystal Barton told one of my our principles that board members are elected for their schools to represent them they

089are citizens but they have the right they should have the right to be able to access their buildings if they so need so and most of them were set up that it was over by 6 o i I visit quite a few schools and I never go into a building without Pro uh making an appointment to go into and visit uh that but it's just the principle at this point that you're going to qu qualify us as ordinary citizens who has a responsibility of a 1 point of a billion dollar budget and and and to think that because you we have always had this that all of a sudden it's not available it it is offensive never so you've never had it so you would know president respond to the to give Clarity to the

090point so the policy that you passed when you reauthorized your policy book in 2019 is written to state that you do not have any extraordinary Authority Beyond a citizen unless you're convened at this table and you have a quorum so I'll send you that policy and I I don't need to argue the point it's a policy that you've approved if the board wants to change that policy then you take the steps to know proceed to change so it's not about arguing but it is about this point it says in the policy that unless the board gives you the authority to go on behalf of the of the U District it is written like that that's not exactly what's written there what's written is that conceivably the board could vote to send an individual board member

091to a school for a specific purpose uh an assignment for example given to a board member and then you do have that extraordinary Authority because it was voted for you and then you have a mission you have a job to do you have an activity at a school that's completely different than having unblemished authority to walk in and out of schools at your leisure so if you wanted to change that you would take the steps to change last question the listening tours that I've been conducting I wasn't I I didn't I guess I I didn't pay attention to that policy because I didn't get approval of the entire board to go and do those listening tours every year you know the ones where like I spend a whole week in each of the schools um

092is that how we do that moving forward no you're listening to are completely different those are activities of a board member you're interested in getting information to and from your constituents you you worked that through me I usually check with an ASL with the principal if they're good with it and you're giv that you're not doing you're not doing full board work you're doing your own work as you know of Education thank you thank you forward to that email the Poli and the one before that before 29 particularly the new members take a look at the policy and uh we'll do what what's needed if you need to twe um so thank you for that um anything else under unfished business I I just wanted to make a statement to answer the superintendent's question since

093I do have 17 schools I do visit them I do let my principls know that hey I'm going to be coming through the school but they do not require me to come check in with them and guide where I go and I do visit my teachers I called them I set in their classes I don't feel that I have to be constrained on I'm not going to be able to see what people are doing you don't have anything to hide I don't want a dog and pony show I want people to build comfortable people know me in my schools invite me in their classes I do not feel that because I did have a pass and I was allowed to go in there that anybody objected my principles were happy and before I left I

094did go and talk to my principls and and if the if if somebody didn't get something that they were really looking for and they hadn't had a chance to get it up the chain I could bring it to my principles we work together and that going in those schools is is is what I feel is part of my responsibility to know what's what's happening and I don't slap anybody or tip up I'm not tipping I'm not creeping but I do uh full disclosure uh I'm an accountant an auditor I don't believe anything I don't see from three different ways myself and I do think it is an effective mechanism to go in your schools and see what's going on and talk to talk to some of your teachers and teachers do invite me in I

095do think that um board members you know certainly you know your principles your teachers however you you have to be careful about just showing up and going into classrooms it could feel evaluative because you are a board member and we do have one employee that is me um and again I I call ahead and I ring the Buzzard because for me I want to wcing you know I want to know so I purposely don't just ease in and try to catch you know what's going on I don't so I guess you know again and I've been a principal and it it can feel a little disruptive when you have people that are in your building and you may not know you know such and such is on the second floor and you're trying to princi

096the b or no I tell my my princi knows but I don't I don't authorize me to go why would a car be NE if they know that you're coming and you ring a buzzer what would be the reason for a don't have to come down let me the one time that I did only one time I've ever used my SP TI it was um at 5:30 and I there was an emergency or something and the principal was not at the um no one was there and um I had gotten a call I had text the principal I can't remember it's been a while that there was a problem in this school and when I got there the principal had ran up to the problem cuz somebody had called and told me there was a

097child or something that shouldn't have been in the building but the child was having an attack or something I can't remember it was really complicated that's the only time I've ever used a Swip C other than that but that time I did go in there cuz it was just me and him in that whole building and that child that child the mother had said the child had called her and said she was having a meltdown in a classroom and that's the only time but it's just the some sooner or later you know what I've watched um and I'm concerned is that um we're we're everyday citizens until something goes wrong and then it's the board okay um and so we need to make sure we are are consistent with our practices that's all yeah and

098I think once we read that policy you know maybe we could twe the language I don't know but I think it's beh us not to at least um revisit and uh see what we can do we got to take into consideration to the safety measures that we've put in place in the past couple years which regardless of any policy would definitely affect anybody's coming and going including our own so how would we if we were to if we were to look at it you know I go through the the detectors on purpose even if I'm told to go around because they know me because that's just how it is so even when we go through it I don't think the policy would reflect all of the steps we've put in place which we you should

099be commended for that we're doing so I think when we look at it we got to really look what I do do see she was talking I don't want ability to building so we'll ID Etc okay so with that we'll please stand December 16 Thomas Allen father of t shedric associate superintendent of school leadership grandfather of Jasmine koh's teacher assistant at build community school and cousin of Marilyn Nixon retired teacher of McKinley High School Kim Nixon Williams temporary principal of Harriet Ross Tubman school and Christina Nixon Douglas teacher at Waterfront Elementary School December 17 Daniel leis father of Laura leis account clerk typist for the division of multilingual education December 20th Alan rosuto father of Lawrence rudo music teacher at middle Early College December 26 Judith saola retired art teacher at South Park High School

100December 29th President Jimmy Carter 39th president of the United States and longest lived president in the United States history reaching the age of 100 January 12th Nelly B King former teacher principal and superintendent of lacana City School District Mrs Nelly b king passed away peacefully Saturday January 12th 2025 she was also the founder of the unlimited possibilities overcoming poverty Incorporated and spearheaded the women touching the world initiative which recognized women in the City of Buffalo including many who work and attended Buffalo public schools January 14th Richard Sahar Kesler beloved father of honorable Dr an Rivera former board member at large take a moment right here [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.