CorpusRecord 236507

BPS | Work Session 12-11-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Buffalo Public Schools
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,846 words · about 89 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right good evening everyone Welcome to our first work session tonight student achievement and we are going to be um doing our First Progress monitoring of our literacy data as well as one of our other goals regarding our ninth graders and regions credits um before I turn it over to superintendent Dr Tanja Williams I and staff I just want to quickly recognize um the department of student service support services um and our crisis intervention and prevention division um for all their hard work in allowing our McKinny vento students to get gifts this holiday season I just before I came here I stopped over and dropped off some things and it was just a massive operation over at West hurdle um amazing all the items that already have been donated and everything that they're assembling for

002each of our families over 1,400 students um will be touched by this so and that is I'm hearing a a record amount of students that are falling under mckin evento uh displaced from their homes homeless um living in other places other than um a home so I just want to recognize all the folks that are working so hard everybody that has donated and helped in supporting our mckenny vento students with with that said uh Dr tanin Williams Knight um go ahead it's yours all righty thank you uh chairman Scott you're absolutely right about you know mckenny vento is a small team of folks and they really really really um oftentimes are not scene uh they work a lot behind the scenes to try to make sure that the children that need the most get exactly

003or as much as we are able to um to offer and so that department is really led by Sharon Brown Dr Brown and um assistant superintendent uh Tina Jones and really the daytoday um operations are led by Andrea Sanders um but they've got you know again a small team of folks Marva Brown has been a staple um in that department and she's been working there you know for a long time and you know somehow or another they just they make it all happen and at this time of the year which you know can be a difficult time for a lot of folks um that either don't have the means to have a happy holiday or have suffered losses um it can be difficult and so the work that they're doing is really really meaningful so

004thank you for recognizing that as we kick off uh this committee meeting tonight um just another quick note we're keeping uh close tabs on the weather um you know it's always difficult because in Buffalo we're so close to the lake that it's often A Tale of Two Cities and uh some times you know we can in the city not experience um much halfhazard weather and just five miles down the road you know in the Southern Tier it can be a completely different um situation so uh Chief Hills is keeping close communication with the city on what it's looking like how streets will be looking and you know all of that so as soon as we know something I'll make sure that I send something out um to the board members so that you all know

005what it's looking like for tomorrow um that being said I will uh just kick off that Chief belli um who you see on the screen our chief academic officer is going to share um kind of a review and an update on our goals you may remember that you all received this document from me oh it was probably back in September and it's something that we sent out to all of our schools it's just a quick little cheat sheet so that all of our schools are reminded every day of what the Su what the superintendent goals are what this body has charged U me with leading in our district and you know we call it La the last time or last year we called it the 999 goals and this year it's the L NH H

006and the L you know stands for literacy but we call it L that's something that the kids you know they use when things are lit you know they're exciting and they're happening so the L stands for lit Focus that's our literacy goal the end is because we are always nurturing you know as we're trying to meet these goals we want to remember that these are children these are children and this is our staff and we will be nurturing and how we do it but it also stands for numeracy so in addition to A literacy goal we have a n numeracy and then the hpce discusses our two high school goals there are two high school goals that um the board has charged us with meeting for this year and tonight I believe that Chief belli

007is going to focus on uh goals three and four those high school goals that uh the board has charged us with and I won't steal her Thunder I won't go too far into it I will um turn things over to her so so you've got two presentations and I see that you've got your interim grade three beginning of year economically disadvantaged reading or our lit goals that you're going to be discussing and our goals three and four I'll I'll talk about our lit literacy goals and Laura simy Peters is going to address our high school goals so we'll be covering both um both of those schols so uh next slide please ad so as always we are moving on to the next level one voice One Vision One mission tonight I'm going to focus on

008rigorous Early Elementary education next slide please and we always want to tie things into our 5x 25 and so specifically tonight I'll be discussing how we are eliminating achievement and opportunity gaps and providing access to educational excellence and accelerated learning so goals one and two next slide please so our lit literacy goal is that the percentage of economically disadvantaged grade three students who are proficient on the New York state grade three Ela assessment is going to increase from 17.1% in September of 2024 to 19.3% in September of 2025 so in other words we're looking for a 2.2% Improvement on our grade three state assessment in English next slide please I'm going to talk quickly about the impact that Co had on the current grade three cohort and then I'm going to talk about our interim

009assessment goals because those will support our growth um in meeting the main goal on the state assessment so first just to contextualize our current grade three students were actually not even in school during the covid closure back in March of um 20 their prek experience was a combination of remote and hybrid in kindergarten we were still laboring under covid restrictions if you remember the three feet apart and um it was very difficult for teachers to do small group instruction Etc we also experienced Omicron in that January and there were many many students teachers staff out um with Amicon grade one and two for this cohort was a bit more normal and this has been a more of a traditional um grade three year the skills that were taught however in k um so their introduction

010to literacy that we just have to bear in mind will have um long-term impact on their uh growth and success so during grades K to2 students are learning their foundational literacy skills so in this case we're specifically talking about enic awareness um decoding or phonics and letter formation so those things things are taught to students during grades K to2 and this particular cohort of students would have had an impact during their kindergarten year so we really spend a lot of time with things like letter formation how do you shape your letters when you're printing um so a lot of kindergarten is devoted to this very foundational skills so this group of students would have had a slightly unusual experience in kindergarten although it would have been a little more consistent in grades one and two

011um folks if you could please mute we're getting some feedback I think there it is thank you I also want to point out in grade three which is the current year for this particular group of students um we do a lot with Advanced decoding so when they're younger they're learning to do CBC words right consonant vowel consonant they're learning the short vowel sounds they get introduced to the um long vowel sounds but in grade three they approach decoding in a different way so they're learning prefixes suffixes and base words as their foundational phonics um so that advanced decoding does come in in a much stronger way in grade three so multi- slabic words um really focusing on prefixes and suffixes and understanding Greek and Latin roots so just to give you some context next slide

012please so here's our data from the state assessments for grade three we're following that green line at the bottom which is the economically disadvantaged group of students in this particular grade so you can see last year 23 24 um the results on the state assessment for this group that economically disadvantaged students was a 17.1% proficiency rate our goal is to get to 19.3% proficiency um when we take the state assessments this year in grade three so for that group of students who are economically disadvantaged in grade three we'd like to see a minimum achievement rate of 19.3% so approximately a 2.2% growth from the previous year so when we talk about the state assessment we have to bear in mind that that is more than just decoding so we can't only focus on Phonics we

013need to include things like comprehension vocabulary writing skills so all of that will come into play as the students um take the state assessment so obviously we'll focus on those things throughout the course of the year next slide please so our first interim goal will help help us keep focused on those skills that um will appear on the state assessment so we're looking to see that the percent of economically disadvantaged grade three students who are at or above Benchmark on our I ready Ela assessment will increase from 30% which was 20124 to 32% in June of this year so we're looking for a 2% increase for this interm measure on our IR assessments for English in grade three next slide please so you can see how we've performed over the past couple years we haven't

014had um already available for English for that long um if you look at the 16% circled um that is where we're starting the year um with our economically disadvantaged students in grade three on the I ready assessment it's about 2% higher than the previous two years so we're starting in a slightly better place but again we've increased the targets so we're we're hoping to get up to 32% so we're looking for um a 2% over the previous year so last year we ended at 30% for that group this year we want to end at 32 but overall it's um it's about 6% from 16% to 32 so we're looking for a minimum of 6% growth from the beginning of the year to the end of the year on the I ready I ready measures more

015than simply phonics it will also include vocabulary and comprehension on informational text and literacy text um excuse me literature next slide please and keeping our Focus sharp we're also setting two additional interm goals uh goal 1.2 is the percent of economically disadvantaged grade three students who are proficient on the Dibbles assessment will increase from 40% to 45% by June of 2025 so we're looking for a 5% increase in proficiency over the previous year next slide please so you can see we ended last year at 40% proficiency on dibles for that group of students that economically disadvantaged cohort we're looking to end this year at 45% so a 5% increase from the previous year but because of all the hard work the students and the teachers have put in we're actually starting in a better place

016so two years ago you can see we started at 29% last year we started at 33% this year we're starting at 35% so you can see that the work they've been putting in um to improve phonics improve decoding skills has been paying off so we're looking for a 10% overall increase from 35 to 45% so from beginning of year to end of year we want to see a 10% increase but that would again be a 5% increase over where we ended last year so Dibbles measures um basic literacy skills those foundational skills so it tells us in a takes several tests and makes a composite score for us which is what we're using to assess proficiency but it'll tell us if students can hear the sounds in a word so if they can segment that

017if they can look at a a CDC pattern or a more complex pattern and decode it so they can look at letters and sound them out hopefully blend them so when I look at c a i can say or cat right so we're then we add in um a second layer with fluency so we want the students to read a passage fluently and correctly and then finally we add in comprehension for The Maze assessment so dibles takes those scores and puts them into a composite for us next slide please this is our third interim for literacy so we want the percent of economically disadvantaged grade three students who are well below average those students often shown in the red um section on the Dibbles assessment will decrease so that percent will decrease from 47% from

018last year to 43% this year so we're looking for a 4% decrease in the number of students who are well below average so again seeing that red band shrink we want fewer students performing at level one next slide please so if you look at this data you can see two years ago we started at 58% so I'm still following the green even though it's above the dotted line this time because we're looking for a decrease so two years ago we started at 58% and ended at 54% in the in the red or the Intensive group of students the last year we started at 54 so we ended at 54 the previous year and actually started the beginning of the year at 54 54% and dropped down to 47 this year we actually decreased even more

019at the beginning of year we're starting at 49 and we want to get down to 43% so we're looking for an overall decrease of 6% in this group so we want to uh we want this group to shrink by about 6% but you can see Year over-ear we're starting in a better place and that is because of the hard work that the students have put in the teachers have put in to make sure that the kids can decode so we are really working hard to make that those phonic skills are solid and that's why you're seeing that year after year that percentage of students well below is shrinking so we're starting in a in a much better place this year than we did two years ago next slide please so I just want to talk

020briefly about some of the things we're doing um in terms of implementation and monitoring of the goals um and I will be talking more about this in the future so I won't go into too much dep um but I want to point out that our schools use the coaching tool to support teachers so they go into classrooms and use the tool um to determine where support might be needed in terms of reading instruction um personally I visit schools pretty much every day of the week with my ASL counterpart and so we go in and walk with the administrative team and we um use the coaching tool and come back and look for Trends in the data and try to help schools determine what PD needs to take place whether shifts need to be made instructionally

021um whether tweaks need to be made in terms of who students grouping Etc the special ed team is also um monitoring OG implementation in our special educ special education classrooms so they go out daily as well so everyone in the office of instruction has a mandate of spending 50% of their time supporting schools so you will see the special ed team going out specifically to look at not only specific things like students um who have autism and what supports they're getting but also to look at that OG implementation to make sure we're solid the reading department is constantly in schools supporting staff walking with principes uh working with coaches making sure that the literacy program is solid at each building imy is our partner with our Orton Gillingham implementation and they come out periodically to

022visit with schools and we're also going to be talking to you in the future about bringing them in for more coaching opportunities we constantly look at the Dibbles progress monitoring you know uh talked about it a million times how schools will follow a schedule and periodically monitor students using dibles just to make sure that there is no um backsliding or anything in between the benchmark assessments of beginning middle and end of year we provide ongoing professional develop in the language of teachers of reading language Essentials of teachers of reading and spelling in Orton Gillingham in morphology which helps Target that advanced decoding in grade three specifically um and a step up to writing which is very important for our kids as they sit for State assessments we've ensured that reading teachers are assigned at our

023elementary total one buildings um and that was a very purposeful decision that was made HR has prioritized the hiring of elementary teachers to fill vacancies as quickly as possible and they coordinate with the LF Department to fill leaves um with certified temporary teachers whenever um that is needed especially at grade three we we hold regular literacy coach meetings support reading teacher meetings to go over instruction and data with those teams and just make sure that they are able to support the students and the teachers back at the building we monitor RTI scheduling just to make sure that it's been um conducted properly at each building and we visit those classrooms regularly to watch the implementation and action Extended Learning Time many of the schools have focused their efforts on grade three and grade six um

024specifically trying to bolster these particular goals but a lot of schools are definitely supporting literacy in after school you've heard me talk about our higher order thinking questions this year we added multiple choice opportunities for each reading selection um grades three four and five so it's additional opportunities for students to practice the type of items they might see on a state assessment but aligned to our own reading selections so we're not pulling them off um into separate track we just finished our curriculum audits last month and so the teachers um will have access to the data for the district in comparison to the region in and in comparison to um the district itself so they can look at their building how they're Building compared to the district and how they're Building compared to the region

025on particular items and then they can take a deeper look into those items to see what might have held the kids back the superintendent has gone on a wonderful initiative um where she is asking schools to submit writing samples so we've provided prompts to the third grade students at different buildings and they have addressed those prompts and submitted their responses to the superintendent and she is going student by student and providing feedback so I think it's a really powerful way to help students see the importance of staying focused and getting that feedback from your superintendent I can't even imagine what that feels like I need you to see the principles when they get her emails they're over the moon um we we hold ongoing exec level data meetings because we are always looking at the

026reading data and we want to make sure that we are staying on track and identifying any gaps or trends that need to be addressed um we're in the process of filming some video clips for parents um so we'll be providing those online short sweet little uh vignettes but teaching little tips to parents they can use at home with their students um and as always our clri team provides training and support to teachers and we make sure that our um our curriculum is available to students in such a way that they can engage with it um no matter who they are so I know that was fast much faster than usual but I'm happy to address any questions very clear so I'm going to suggest that we take questions now and then we will transition to

027the next presentation um we'll go in alphabetical order president Belton Cotman any questions thank you for the update no I don't have any questions but I something I was pleased to hear that you say you're in the process of doing something to help parents teach tricks uh to their children when they're at home do we have a districtwide initiative where we are encouraging reading or um some sort of literacy um in every school or um to try to make sure that children are are doing it after hours or something Have We progressed to that point because um we know that if the children practice when they get home they'll be better do are we doing anything we had it at one time I think when I first came on the board we had like a

028campaign a reading campaign or something and and whatever so what are we doing definitely at the school level I know they strongly encourage it we send books book bags of books home with our prek andk students so they can sit and read with their family um and we always encourage reading we're going to be looking at schools to send home some um decodables over the break so that the kids can practice with their families I actually was just talking to Dr Reynolds she's got all her teams engaging to support the goals so the athletic department is going to be doing some um little activities with to get the kids excited about reading and I know the face department is working on that so there's a lot of things going on but yes always we want

029students reading at home oh thank you so much thank you continue to great work thank you all right vice president Evans Brown any questions for chief bie I don't have any questions but thank you for that robust presentation um you guys look like you're on your way um with lots of um opportunities for children and teachers and staff development so poodles to you and continue the great work I'm looking forward to great things in this District or additional great things thank you all right board member herd any questions uh I don't have any questions but ID like to say Kudos thank you um for this team for putting such a a great first a great presentation but this this body of work that youve put together to help our children is is outstanding I also

030have some teachers you know um teachers on like with Administration comes into the classroom or come into the school they get nervous when they teaching and and and um you know it's it it's common it's common when you got your bosses or you know sitting in the classroom or peeking in and asking questions or or you know you know just taking the time to be there and uh I had a couple teachers told me that it was great it was wonderful experience you know to have you know Administration there in the classroom and to talk about you know access to data that's going to be coming in the future and also a plan moving forward how we can um better ourselves and they can see everything that you're saying you know these um uh percent

031is going up you know they they see this happening because of the work of this Administration so thank you so much thank you board member mcos any questions no questions I would like to say though that it's encouraging to hear how different departments are coming together in your presentation um you bringing up clri you bringing up other departments that you're working with so you know you always wonder whether or not the burden is solely on you um Miss belli I know you do a lot of work so I um I'm encouraged that there's you know a bunch of entities coming together to make this work um board member Rivera have any questions but I appreciate [Applause] uh board member Shuda I don't have any uh I do have a question I guess um I'm just

032wondering uh is you devis a plan of support for for the schools uh to reach these goals what is the input that you get from teachers and administrators have we asked them what they think um about what specifically sorry pardon me about what ask them you know through all the planning like as you do um you know for the the literacy goal have we had teachers and administrators uh building level administrators at the table at in in the planning of the strategy to uh get the work done well the schools are the ones who are devising the strategies to get the work done so we provided the training the method excuse me methodological training the programmatic training theoretical training right but they have to implement it so they're in build like obviously in their own

033classrooms administratively um looking to see where teachers need support we train the coaches so they can support but they've targeted like they've identified which particular groups of students that they want to work with to help meet those goals so that was at their discretion we gave them guidance like about approximately how many students they would need to move in order for the district um to be successful but each building is approaching it in their own way okay so if they if the the buildings and um the teaching staff think they need more support they come to you and we're able to to get some things to them it would depend on what kind of support they needed we could definitely always provide um more professional development we can attend grade levels we can help them

034analyze their data but I can't necessarily provide a new staff member if they feel like you know they want an extra reading teacher so it just depend on what they're looking for specifically but our team is always willing to go out and um support in any way we can on site okay okay Dan it thank you board member Woods I'm glad to hear you're spending 50% of your time actually at the schools working with the uh teachers and the administration to make it happen good job thank you and with that said I think our goal is that we spend 50% on student outcomes I think we just spent 100% of our time on on student outcomes and did it very efficiently and in a way that understands where our students are starting the year for

035literacy so Chief belli thank you for the great presentation and for all the work that our students and staff are doing to devote their time and energy into improving literacy across across the district um are we just going to transition to our next presenter or I turn it back to superintendent give it the superintendent but then all right superintendent Williams Knight um great presentation and um you know board member Woods hit the nail on the head when she said it really is a coordinated event um you know us meeting these gos I think you heard that from Chief belli that you know even Finance HR everything is very intentional and it's very strategic um you know I met with Chief belli yesterday along with um our executive director of public relations we're working on these

036videos we've even pulled them into it so that the parents will have tips on how they can support students and we've got 37 schools that have third graders and so each one of those schools has a schedule and they have been sending me hundreds every month of constructed written responses uh from their students and for every single students paper that I get I put a comment I read it I send it back so that the students know that at the highest level in our district that they matter I'm reading their responses I then respond to the principal to let the principal know where I see the strengths where I see we've got some areas to grow but it's really modeling for them that if I can look at thousands of these I know that principles

037also can look at you know the construed responses in their buildings so we'll see if it's a best practice this is the first year we're doing it but um certainly it's giving me some insight into where our students are with their reading their writing and those kinds of things so great presentation thank you all right Dr Williams Knight do you want to introduce our next presenter yeah I think I got a little ahead of myself before we have assistant superintendent uh Dr Laura Sosi Peters and she has been an intrical part both she and Dr bulock um to helping us pull together data and um staying attuned to that data and helping to make some recommendations for the board to consider and setting goals and so she's going to be talking tonight about the two

038high school goals that we have kind of where we are right now what are some things that we've done and um you know our ASL she's working very closely with um our chief of student leadership and um all of our asls have some high schools with um Miss Watson having the majority of them but we pull together a team every month and we sit and we're looking at all data including including suspension attendance anything that could impact students from you know um not meeting these goals or is serving as a barrier we sit and we problem solve together so I will turn things over to Dr sski Peters thank you Dr Williams Knight good evening board members um I think I'm just waiting for the presentation to be up this isn't the right one so

039while I'm waiting for the presentation um I'm just gonna Tee It Off by saying that tonight I'm going to go through the two high school goals and their interims with you thank you very much that is the right one um and we are going to riew our first quarter progress towards goals three and four next slide please so as always um in kind of um echoing what an said in the last presentation um we are uh working on moving to the next level and for this presentation we're really focusing on High School next slide and uh also as Ann said for the 5 by 25 goals this presentation will be focused on goal one and goal two next slide please so for goal three the goal W is the percent of cohort 2024 students those

040are the students who entered High School this year who passed at least one Regents exam by the end of their first year of high school will increase from 38.5% in August of 2024 to 39.5% in August of 2025 so we're hoping to increase by 1% with this new cohort next slide please so uh we really don't have any kind of dipstick uh checks going on for exams because we have to wait till they take the exam each year but we do have um when we set that goal we talked about the fact that we want to increase the number of students who are going to be eligible to take their science exams so in order to be eligible to sit for a science exam in high school you uh a student needs to meet a

041minimum lab requirement so for interim goal 3.1 we uh settled on the percent of cohort 2024 students who would be eligible to take a science exam based on lab minutes will increase from 54 54% in June of 2024 to 60% in June of 2025 next slide please so after the first quarter 75.1% of the cohort 2024 students um are on track with their lab minutes after the first quarter so when the quarter ended this past November um we calculated this uh I think on the next slide let's move to the next slide it it shows that a student needs 1,200 lab minutes by the end of the school year in order to to be considered eligible to sit for a science exam so if I divide that up by the four quarters that means that

042a student at the end of the first quarter should have had 300 lab minutes under the belt in order to be eligible to be considered on track to be eligible so that's 75.1% of the cohort that H had 300 lab minutes after the first quarter and is on track most of our schools actually offer over 3,000 lab minutes to our students so they don't just budget the year so that there's only 1,200 minutes available they go well over that so typically we say that by J January most of our students if they are present and completing their lab work should have their eligibility requirement completed by the end of the second quarter so by February we should see that students who are coming to school and doing their Labs appropriately should have enough lab minutes

043but if not the schools are offering um anywhere between 3,000 and 3600 lab minutes by the end of June by the time the exam comes up so if students do fall behind on their lab minutes they do have opportunities to complete uh to to make up those labs teachers are offering students the option to do virtual labs to make up minutes so they can work from home and uh make up a lab and turn it into their teacher and that would um count towards their minutes and also we offer students during our elt our after school programming the opportunity to come in and make up lab minutes as well so there are lots of opportunities for them to reach this 1,200 lab minute um Benchmark that we have in order for them to be eligible

044next slide please then for um our last goal which is goal four the percent of cohort 2024 students who earn 5.5 credits by the end of their first year of high school will increase from 59.9% in June of 2024 to 64% in June of 2025 next [Music] slide so the interim goal was that we would check um each quarter to find out how many uh students are on track to earn 5.5 or more classes at the end of each quarter I know it says quarter three on the screen but the official interm goal will be measured after quarter three we want to increase from 69% last year to 74% at the end of this year but we did do a dipstick check at the end of quarter 1 to see where we were next slide

045please so this is a little chart that shows for each of the cohorts for the last couple of years where they were after quarter 1 so two years ago with cohort 2022 we had 74.3% of the cohort um passing five six classes uh which would be 5.5 worth of credit by the end of quarter 1 for last year's firsttime ninth graders cohort 2023 they were at 76.1% passing and then at the end of this past quarter our cohort 2024 students we had 74.8% of the cohort um passing at least six classes by the end of quarter 1 next slide please so I will um that was the goal update I'll go ahead and take questions all right thank you Dr SM smolski Peters we will go in reverse order this time so board member Woods

046any questions um you said you're at 74% right now what was your goal for which goal I'm sorry for the students having 5.5 classes at the end of the first year for the cohort 2024 the second last ride 64% yes and you're at 74 right now yes so why is that a drop that could drop if they start if their grades start declining and sometimes that does happen with our ninth graders as the year goes on they start strong we got to keep them motivated we got to keep them inspired because you know we'll take a look at second marking period and hopefully it'll either maintain or keep going higher but we know that there are things that interfere you know with them coming to school um weather related and just being high schoolers so

047I I mean I'm just I just don't understand I I thought we were trying to push for stretch goals but if your goal is 69 and and you're at 74 I don't see stretch or any I don't understand I'm sorry well I don't think we ended the year last year at 74 this is just where we started this year so it was an increase from last year where we ended with our U ninth graders obtaining 5.5 credits we didn't have 74% that did but for this year you know they' started the first marking period strong and right now they're passing 74% are passing those 5.5 classes we want to keep that going because that usually doesn't happen unfortunately it starts to decline as the year goes just like you know the graduation rate we have

048the largest number of students in ninth grade by the time they get to 12th grade that cohort has shrunk you know we lose students they start out strong but if you start the year with 100 ninth graders in four years you won't likely have 100 that are seniors that are passing yeah if you the data um on that last slide showed that last year we were at 76% after quarter 1 and then by the end of the year we dipped down to 64% so it it does decrease as the year goes on okay so you consider 69% of stretch go yes okay for our first year this the first year we're monitoring this okay no more questions thank you board member Woods board member Shuda um I would say that um I really like the

049close monitoring I uh Laura and I we worked together at some point uh during the uh when she was at Riverside and you know the kids that we lose so many times are the kids with the way of minutes and um not keeping you know from the get-go on credits and so um I I I appreciate the fine tuning thank you yeah thanks and also I I didn't mentioned during the presentation but this is uh last year was the first year that we had built the mechanism to monitor lab minutes at the district level we typically had left it up to the schools to monitor how many lab students were getting um and and so last year we built a dashboard that um the science director Miss Mrs Merrick she is on that every day

050and if she sees anybody starting to fall behind she's reaching out to principles and ensuring that they get with their teachers and come up with plans to get people back up on their lab minutes so it's really working out well having a district level ability to monitor lab minutes crucial thank you so much that's good news thank you thank you uh board member Riva any questions no I don't have any questions although I think monitoring is a really good idea because SLB minutes becomes really [Music] complicated or haven't been able to Monitor and then it interferes with students graduation so I appreciate this um board member mosy um no questions I do want to State though that the I really want for the community and our listeners to understand and realize that this is true

051growth it's growth for the district it's grow for everybody involved the fact that steps are being taken in order to look and monitor and see things that maybe you know for how many decades we were doing in different way um I just really would love for folks to really see that this effort is the entire District right all departments are doing some sort of monitoring and please you know keep asking questions and keep doing what you're doing and bring suggestions to us as to what you would like to see because in nine years I've seen more fine-tuning happening in this past year than I think I've seen in my entire term on the board so I appreciate it well said board member mosy um board member herd any questions yes I just have one question

052great presentation and a great initiative uh from the district to monitor this from the higher level uh my question is with with lab minutes I know that my son had difficulties when he were was going through in high school and understand the the understand the um when the superintendent states that you know throughout the year it tends to drop a lot of things happen we through co uh hes uh kids get sick um uh teachers get sick a lot of things happen that that might take a children direction away from educational part of it but how are they handly catching up or making up lab work or or work for it so that they can catch up I think that one of the biggest cavity as because once teachers move on it's hard to go

053backwards and uh have those children catch up or or get a a W for some of that work so the students are given opportunities to make up lab minutes and work in the um PLT at the school programs um there's also some with Labs there's Virtual Lab minutes that they are allowed to work on so they could those from home um and then um you know many teachers will just have like uh makeup assignments that are available in school that the students can do and turn in at a later date that they'll accept for a grade so there are many opportunities for students to make up both labs and then work um and I think that this year now that we're really keeping a close eye on the the ninth grade cohort we've never done

054that before we've always looked at seniors now we're looking at brand new ninth graders and we're giving principles and teachers information early enough in the year that they have time to put in additional interventions where they're needed Peters what I was saying is that maybe since the district is looking at this from a higher level now maybe it could be a constructive plan for all teachers to follow that could be presented just in case a child does Miss so it'll be the same from building to building except for individual teachers trying to you know trying to uh make up in different ways because uh I know that's fact some reason it's hard to catch up and once you get behind you know it's hard to understand what you working on future so we can try

055to find some kind of way that from a higher level and thank you so much for your presentation app thank you all right vice president Evans Brown uh I just have a comment thank you uh Dr Sosi for your presentation an update um High School Dropout rates has always been one of my key uh concerns our young people so I think as a board we were trying to capture that group this year you know making sure that you know these kids um you know continue with with good patterns and attendance um I think that I don't know what that is um I think the board was really interested in looking at our children stand in school and getting at least 5.5 credits by the end of their um nth year because that shift from eth

056grade to ninth year is very you talk about you know teenagers you talk about adult stuff that they have to endore you're talking about you know um girls and you know so on and so for us to uh be monitoring um this process is so critical I love that we have included it in our goals uh this year and that really works um for years to come thank [Music] you all right president president belon C thank you for the presentation dror uh I don't have any uh thing to say other than I'm glad to see that we are monitoring things and um it's it's it's great to see us going in the right direction um we we have benefited from the Council of great City schools and our involvement with them thank you um and

057I don't have any questions either another great presentation thank you Dr smolski Peters um just echoing what was just said that we this is again data that is 100% focused on our students and their outcomes and it's impressive to see data that's almost real time on where our students stand in 9th grade right now so thank you again for all the efforts in focusing our agenda our priority on student outcomes and really delivering that on that on that um expectation so thank you Dr Williams Knight I'll turn it over to you to close out all righty thank you uh chairman Scott and esteemed board members um you know not a lot to add to it but Dr Evans Brown certainly had it right when she said that the Dropout piece does not start usually in

05812th grade uh we know that and so it's important for us in ninth grade to really and even earlier you know make sure that our students stay motivated and engaged and all of that um and sometimes our parents will think that because their child has been in high school three years they're automatically 11th graders and so we've got to do some work with educating them to know that it's really the credit acrel that determines what level of classes they're taking 10th grade classes 11th grade or 12th grade and you know when you think about those science La minutes even though there are many opportunities for students to meet that when you think about things like immunizations and you know how that has impacted you know many of our um high school students from being able

059to attend but I got to say again Dr Brown's office has done a a phenomenal job I've tried to keep the board updated on you know just how many students and parents thank you for making sure that your children are immunized and and I want to give a shout out to our principls and assistants and you know their staff because this work is really really hard it's a little easier to make changes when students are young you know they're like sponges and they just want to please their teachers but when they get to high school it's a little more difficult to keep them motivated and engaged so I want to give a shout out to our high school principls to their assistant principls to all of their staff and all of the work that they're

060doing I'm pleased to see we're on track we are doing better um this year than we did last year and you know it's my goal and my mission to keep that trajectory going I have a great team I think you saw two folks tonight um that um gave great presentations but they work as a team you know it's not any one person it's everybody that's pulling together and and helping to make this happen so that's all I have chairman Scott um you can close out that concludes our student achievement work session we are about four minutes ahead of schedule no pressure board member Shuda I'll turn it over to you okay uh tonight uh we have two uh topics that we're going to get updates on uh during the past uh I would say couple

061months there has been some questions about modified Sports so we're going to have a presentation so um I will turn it over to Dr Williams Knight to start us off all righty thank you um you know the board has asked for an update on um you know specifically where we are what's happening with modified Sports and you know as the superintendent the board asked and it's my goal to deliver and so um I've had conversations with Chief Dr Reynolds and she was very pleased to have her team present tonight to to share an update on exactly where we are so I will turn things over to Chief Dr Reynolds to uh begin our presentation and introduce her staff Dr Reynolds you are muted are you having some technical difficulties with unmuting okay and in respect

062of time we'll go ahead and get started I see that we have um executive director um Lloyd and supervisor rickon um I'm not sure which of you will be taking the lead on the presentation probably D director Lloyd okay you can go ahead and you should be good now uh thank you Dr M Knight and Miss Shuda and good evening honorable board members superintendent and colleagues thank you for the opportunity to present our Buffalo Public Schools modified Athletic program overview before we get into this presentation I would like to say thank you to our buffalo Athletics staff Dr Rona Reynolds do Mr Patrick Ricky Mrs Heather Rogers and Mrs Paul Williams for their contribution to this presentation I would like to provide Clarity on the history of modified Athletics in Buffalo Public Schools since the

06320 6 2007 school year Buffalo Public Schools has participated in section six modified Sports offering seventh and eighth grade students opportunities in modified cross country basketball swimming track and lacrosse programs were supported with Nike uniforms certified Sports officials District transportation and hourly paid coaches however due to unforeseen circumstance ances in the impact of covid-19 the modified Athletics program ceased operations after the fall of 2019 the program was brought back in 2022 tonight we will share with you our modified Athletics philosophy its benefits and the requirements for participation we will also review current Sports offerings analyze participation data from 2022 to 2025 and shed light on the challenges and needs in the athletic programs in addition we will conclude with informing you about a survey Buffalo Athletics is conducting districtwide next slide please okay thank you

064director Lloyd uh my name is Pat Ricky for those of you I haven't met before I'm the supervisor supervisor Athletics here in Buffalo um I'm going to talk to you a little bit about the modified Athletics philosophy can everybody hear me okay I sound all right you can go ahead and pass the slides please yep our program philosophy emphasizes opportunity access fund and equity for all seventh and eth grade student athletes it aims to provide a positive introduction to organized Sports fostering personal growth and skill development on and off the field our key goals in include increasing po participation maintaining an academic athletic balance and offering competitive opportunities our focus is on teaching teamwork sportsmanship communication respect responsibility and the fundamentals of each sport and the essential athletic skills by understanding the game rules next

065slide please there are many well documented benefits of modified Athletics program modified Athletics prepar students for the transition to high school by teaching fundamentals game strategies and teamwork in a structured inclusive environment the focus on skill development over competition promotes growth at an individual Pace while fostering physical health social emotional growth academic engagement sportsmanship and character building every student has the opportunity to participate emphasizing inclusivity and belonging next slide please thank you supervisor Ricky New York State Public High School Athletic Association and Buffalo Public Schools have clear participation requirements students in seventh or 8th grade are eligible for modified competition if there are a Bonafide student at the school they represent parents must register and gives consent to their child to participate through final forms have an updated physical on file and adhere to the

066Buffalo Public Schools code of conduct once students meet these minimum requirements and any other requirement by the building principal they will have access to the modified Sports offerings next slide please thank you Buffalo Public Schools currently provides a variety of modified sports for both boys and girls in the fall we offer cross country and flag football in the winter we offer basketball swimming and wrestling and in the spring we offer soccer and track next slide please since the reboot of modified Sports in 2022 we have experienced a 10% increase in participation in 2022 bual public schools offered flag football basketball and track with a total of 751 students registered in 2023 the offerings expanded to flag football to include flag football basketball track swim and soccer with 831 students registered for sports based upon final

067forms data this represents a 10% increase in participation this year we have further expanded our Sports offerings by adding cross country and wrestling notably flag football saw 133% increase in participation numbers from year one to year three and 170 students participated in the cross country program with the addition of cross country and wrestling we anticipate a significant increase uh this year in participation numbers moving forward next slide please thank you director Lloyd some challenges and needs for our modified Athletic program um to sustain a competitive and effective modified Athletics programs Buffalo Public School must address several critical critical challenges Transportation field and facility availability and the recruit the recruitment of certified and qualified coaches and the provision of stiens for modified Sports coaching currently BPS transportation department can provide only eight Sports buses for us

068daily with over more than a 100 athletic teams in each season that's fall winter and spring this severely limits our ability to transport student athletes to games while many high school students have adapted by using NFTA buses middle school students do not receive bus passes Mak an NFTA an unviable option for them for their a athletic Transportation needs the district has just three Turf stadiums which are in constant use for daily sporting events as a result many of our teams are forced to practice and compete in city parks where condition conditions are often inferior to the facilities available in neighboring Suburban districts Additionally the modified Athletics program faces difficulties in attracting qualified coaches unlike High School coaching positions that offer seasonal stiens modified coaches are paid hourly requiring them to log their hours daily this

069process is not only only burdensome for coaches but also creates administrative challenges for athletics department these factors contribute to a lack of interest in modified coaching roles further impacting the program sustainability next slide please thank you supervisor Ricky to expand program offerings and boost participation Buffalo Athletics is conducting a survey among students in grades 4 through S districtwide the survey Gathers insights on current participation interest in additional Sports plans for future involvement and preferences for fall winter and spring Sports as of today we have over 360 responses data will be analyzed and shared with um our our athletics department our chief of Athletics and our superintendent this survey will help guide us with future programming decisions regarding modified sport s if you will if we take um the the information from the Aspen Institute they

070say that we should often ask the students what they want to do instead of having the adults tell them what to do thank you honorable board members superintendent and colleagues for your time and attention thank you for your commitment to supporting student athlet Athletics in Buffalo Public Schools we are happy to address any questions you may have [Music] all right um we can start with questions uh Dr Rivera do you have any oh I'm sorry Dr Rivera do you have any questions no I don't have any questions but I am glad to see us moving forward with modified Sports and increasing opportunities okay uh Mr herd yes I have several questions um we spent countless hours working with our Community Partners and um the district principles coaches Community coaches uh teachers uh community members and

071um parents you know and students about the modified Sports over the last several years and um it was also included in UniFi Sports so they was running conjunctly hand in hand um hav't heard report anything about the UniFi sports but we have coalitions with other neighboring districts to support UniFi Sports and modifi sports here in um the City of Buffalo um I mean it's where do we start um we work with this community programs about bringing in um um low League football here to the Buffalo Public Schools which ENT the coaches here in City of Buffalo coach the league football would bring in um their children back to the Buffalo Public Schools and they work with their parents and this was something that we was correlated that we we grew up uh we also offered

072transportation we worked with uh Robert Harris um director Robert Harris about transportation and and ordered buses so coaches can have transportation to alleviate Transportation issues uh with this and those buses have been ordered so um um I would like to know what happened with the the football program in which I know that equipment uniform things were ordered and how could that wasn't um launched this year that's that's one of the first questions about the about the L League football and the coaches and materials for for for the coaching and also we had a slop of coaches that was ready to come on board that were um going to Coast to lot le football programs through the Buffalo Public Schools we also had uh Lance Lance space Also for fields and um that was our preworked

073out and um none of this have manifested so can we can we start there yes sir uh thank you for the the question I think you started with unified you want me to address unified for you first please okay so Unified sports is um is a special program that started with the Special Olympics okay so UniFi Sports is the combination of students with disabilities and reg reg regular education students working together under um in a school so we currently have that program um in our in every single one of our schools that want it we have bowling we are in Bowling season right now and then after this we go right into basketball season so we currently have that program that is available to students in grades 7even through 12 if they so choose to

074participate um I'm happy to report that we're expanding uh we did expand uh this particular uh bowling season we added Emerson uh Mr um Carlo is over there now and uh he uh we're looking to rebuild their athletic program so we're starting with Unified sports inside their building another school that um that uh we reached out to uh we're looking to reach uh to uh add unified basketball to South Park um so we are growing the unified program in Buffalo Public Schools um does that answer your question sir uh for unified uh we we have coalitions with other neighboring districts I don't want to mention them here online but we had um um like handshake agreements with with these other districts that we're going to move the unified program because it's very important that that

075these children that feel left out of other sports but feel left out of society also you know have a plan that will keep them in school interest in education but also build that Cary that they can work we PR with one another so um this has been a huge gap uh you mentioned bowling and basketball uh those were two of the things that's that's that was very very important working together and also work with the NFL who want work unified with the flag football fo program also for those individuals um that that had um that had um uh financing um in place that that help support their programs um we work very closely with the Buffalo Bills at equity and looking at an equity we want you know for all children not not just like

076several building or seven different programs um that's been the problem with this district for for denza years is that it doesn't fit all children in all programs now if we went to club sports you can see where club sports defate um defate between um our our some programs and other programs because want to call everything out but U but what we looking for is equity and um trying to make sure that all kids have access to it and during this presentation um I believe you mentioned that um that um it was I just took some brief notes but it it it it we talking about all children in equity and what I'm trying to get through is that we had um we have a very very distinctive difference between our children and education here we

077have Criterion kids we have kids that's in in regular uh schools and but some of our children or parents like our kids are being left out in certain different programs and how do we build equity within that and we can start with the modified okay I agree I agree well a unified program just to clarify is available to um every school that wants to participate in the unified program um and as I mentioned we are growing and we are creating a plan that um we include all schools like I mentioned with South Park and Emerson now section six New York State recognizes two sports right now which is bowling and basketball um they are piloting other sports in other schools um so for example willville is piloting unified volleyball um other school districts have was

078new pilot unified bot ball so as we get interest based upon the interest surveys that we put out we will be adding those Sports the second thing that you mentioned sir was um about modified uh football um so and you mentioned about um you know several items such as Transportation through Rob Harris's office um coaches from the community we as the athletic director of Buffalo Public Schools none of this information has crossed my desk that this exist um is so as a matter of fact it was it was just an idea of a football program um so I have identified that anticipated this question coming up so I kind of just drafted some notes here and I'm gonna ask Pat Ricky to jump in so just in case I forget a few things okay so

079we did start um as soon as Dr Reynolds notified my department about the topic of FL of modified football we went to work on it so we checked to the City of Buffalo as Pat Ricky already mentioned we Ed three of our stadiums for soccer football um during the fall time okay so we checked with the City of Buffalo Mr Andy RAB there was no agreement with the City of Buffalo to use any of their property to for for modified football the City of Buffalo is willing to sit down at the table with us to discuss those options but as of this past year he identified and he he's happy to you know mention this that no one has approached him about using any city property for for football and addition to that there was

080a survey done in 2022 okay and the survey included modified football in during in that survey only 17 people responded to that survey about wanting a modified football program so another point was there was a lack of data supporting a modified foot program we checked with many principles a lot of the principles had no knowledge of any kind of football program or their students participating in any kind of program in addition to that I I know the little league people one of the people that that said I can use his name is Demaris Johnson there was no communication with little leagues about the potential combination merger takeover of modified of of of um modified football in addition to that lack of storage during during our findings during this past year of studying modified football we

081asked the City of Buffalo once again if we were to put a a a container on your property would that be allowed the City of Buffalo said at no point in time is the Board of Education allowed to put a container on their property for storing football for these reasons sir we paused football so we can put um um systems in place and um and get everything in motion for a modified season we we are happy under the leadership of of Chief um Reynolds to create this survey to ask every single um building around our school district who's interest in football we're going to use that data we're let we're a data driven District we're going to use that data to decide how many football teams that this District can actually support we're going to

082continue our conversations with with the little league about what what it takes to run this league I've already started those conversations we're going to identify the school buildings that have the students in there we're going to talk to those principles first about gaining their support okay um well first of all Deus Johnson isn't a coach he hasn't coached LLY football he's a trainer and also a former football player So speaking with him has will not give reflection on what the coaches uh have set it forth uh many coaches have set in Riverside High School foot low League football coaches we had at least 40 of them that that that I can tell you name names that came in and sat down and said they wanted this program with the district and that would afford more

083kids to come to back to the school he was looking at bringing the kids back to the public students with this so it's not it's not um this conversation I already have happened and they had and there was previous administrators of athletic had did surveys previously and worked with Community coaches and we had um weekly and monthly meetings um about this and some of the other programs um that was talked about was U the wrestling program uh for the modified and also the boxing program we had boxing coaches want to come in and um and bring rings in into to schools at our Elementary programs boxing is a very good tool to teach kids discipline um so we were working with that also and those were AB would have been under club sports because they

084would have been within the Buffalo Public School System and some of this was designed to to bring children from Charter programs back into the Buffalo schools uh to build our base back up here with the Buffalo schools so it it was a very definite designed way this was working and working with Community coaches and we had a slute of coaches that was really ready and and wanted to work under a Buffalo Public School program because having the structural leadership and also having a a base of uh rules and regulations to provide will will suit them better for for these fields and U Pat himself he was um there at many of the mean he can contest to him also I believe just about about 90% it means that you're at P so these conversations has

085happened and like I said we have coaches in boxing and wrestling uh track soccer also the boy swim and girl swim programs that were ready to come aboard and uh work here within the district and one of the biggest things was soccer because of our indigenous population and our town was coming back to City if I can respond quick we did add modified wrestling this past winter for the first time in District history and um we did add for the first time in District history modified soccer last spring we had six boys teams and five girls team it was very successful so I don't know if um if that's what you were referring to but yeah under the the leadership this past year for the first time in the history of Buffalo Public Schools we've

086added those two sports so it's been a phenomenal success alluded to when he was reporting the data and you know I can just interject for one second just for one second because I I don't want it to turn into we're not discounting anything that happened before at all we're not saying that some good work you know didn't happen but I think what you have here is a team that's saying you know they're interested in continuing to grow um it's hard for them to answer for maybe what happened you know three years ago two years ago but you do have the team here that is willing to you know hear the questions hear some concerns the historical knowledge is really important so you know thank you for sharing that some of those things you know were

087in play but you've got a team here that is interested in you know continuing to grow our modified sports program program and in some areas they already have but you know certainly there's always room for us you know in everything we do to continue hey can we go someone else an opportunity understand because let me finish please I just don't understand because we ordered the equipment for the L football but somehow that and I understand that it was delivered to the district but it somehow disappeared or went some place so so I'm just not understanding I can answer that how did that work okay I can definitely answer that and and just for clar it did not it didn't disappear again there was no real plan in place and and and apparently there were meetings

088that were held and and so there was a plan in place we worked on understand and I'd be happy M Mr her if you have the plan I'd be happy to meet with you tonight tomorrow morning and get that plan if you have the plan and sit down and review it but I do not have the plan so without a plan it was an idea and there was 300,000 you're correct there was $300,000 and the board should know this $300,000 worth of equipment ordered based upon an idea okay so what we did was it to be fiscally responsible we reached out to the vendor and said what can we do so none of this stuff went to waste we were able to return most of it and the rest of it we purchased helmets for

089the JV Varsity program we purchased shoulder pads girdles we purchased flag football um equipment for the growing flag football program that we currently have we the speciically gave an order for this equipment to be ordered for let him finish Mr herd thank you we ordered flag um football pants practice pants for all football teams and in addition if you go over to Riverside we added a scoreboard over there so all that that the the materials were returned and and everything else was put to good use with our current football program did the board give anybody permission to repurpose that money that was funded for the program I went through proper channels through uh the purchase Department to take care of that sir yes but did the board give anybody permission to repurpose the monies for

090that program I followed the process I reached out to the board of educa I went out to the purchase department for the proper protocol and they advis me the process that's not the proper process if if it's a part of their process to reach out to you then I don't then they didn't do that but the process they gave to me was to reach out to them and work through them to return the items or to repurpose the items I file that and the modified you can continue this uh uh director Lloyd has given you the opportunity to have a discussion I think we need to move on to someone out and we can continue d uh Dr Evans uh Brown do you have something I have nothing thank you uh miss miss marosi board

091member marosy yes very briefly what I would just like to point out is there is a clear um clear kind of miscommunication so a lot of what was discussed of many meetings and countless hours and all of this as someone who was on the Athletics committee at one point and then all of a sudden not a lot of this was stuff that was discussed but not only brought to the board maybe during a board meeting if this was communicated all of these meetings and all of this in the proper process as this Athletics committee currently or the athletics department is trying to put forth some process where everybody is engaged everybody meaning everybody down the line if we had all these coaches and all these people and all these community members and we would have

092all been more informed of everything that's happening so I just want to clear the air that we spent a half an hour of back and forth around obviously a miscommunication of what was talked about that might get done and what's actually being done so I suggest as a board member and I'm hoping the support of my colleagues that we are all updated on the plans that were to happen whether or not our current athletics department feels that this is where we need to go and then we can advise how this money is spent um I don't believe that purchasing or anybody else would have taken $300,000 and mishandled it I actually am feeling a little better about the fact that there was efforts being made in order to take what might not have ever been

093used and repurpose that for what we can use and what we do need so flag football is something that a lot of our students are just excited about and I'm excited that a lot of our our our female students are excited about it so I just want to put to rest it's a new day it's a new year it's a new time I want to put to rest all of the back and forth and let's move forward with clear communication around what we're doing if anybody is heading up a committee please report back to the rest of us meetings and things that are happening because it almost makes me feel like I wasn't included in something that apparently the entire community and all of the free world has been included in and I'm feeling a

094little lost because Buffalo's one big living room we all know other yet I didn't know of 90% of what was being discussed so moving forward I would like to you know I'm hoping that you do uh Mr herd reach out to Mr Lloyd talk about whatever it was you had discussed and you know Chief uh Reynolds if you could just kind of let the rest of us in on what's going to work what's not going to work what do you all are thinking when it comes to you how you decipher it it's not on us to be able to make those decisions so so um I'm just trusting in the process and I apologize to the public that that display happened but there's no negativity here all moving forward app thank you for letting me

095speak Mr Scott if you would like to have questions or comments yes yes thank you thank you chair woman Shuda um just first want to say that my younger son uh played foot flag football for the first time this past fall and it was a great experience they have all the games at one field so you can see the sixth grade the seventh and eighth grade teams compete and like board member mcos said there were many female students that were participating the referees were excellent as far as I know Transportation worked out for that and the culminating event at High Mark was fabulous so just really appreciate that opportunity and all the work that's gone into flag football and seeing it R uh is telling that our students are interested in it um director Lloyd

096how are the surveys being administered how how are the students actually able to take those surveys thank you for that question so um um Dr Reynolds a little help here so I know this the surveys were sent out to every school that has fourth through seventh grade in the school district um this principal is is is leading the charge on this one but we' asked them to do it during home room so every single student has the opportunity to respond to that survey we do have a deadline yeah we do have a deadline um of when the survey is due I forgot the deadline is it uh next week 19th and we're asking all students in grades four through seven to complete the survey because as director Lloyd has mentioned we want to make sure

097that as we're planning for next school year that these are datadriven decisions based upon the interest of our student thank you just just two more things that's okay two more things I'll be quick hopefully um can you the folks from the athletic department can you share do any of the charter schools have modified football teams no they do not they do not yes which ones Health Science Charter School Mar time Health Science charter school is a school they do not have a middle school modified only they do not have a modified team they it's only seventh and eighth graders they talked about it and then um it was quickly shut down at the section six meeting when um they were informed that modified as seventh and eighth grade students and they didn't have it so

098then Health Science tried to start a freshman football team and it never ended up coming to fruition they didn't play a freshman game this year so I they're going in the in the a route of um freshman football at Health Science none of the charter schools have modified football see what we call the modified would would be classified as a club sport because it would be within the district and they operate within theirs so it been actually a club Sport and not modified if we were bringing the low League footballs here to public school yeah so that's a good point uh board member heard Little League football and modified football are two completely different things and a lot of the and a lot of the conversations here have been convoluted to mix the two together

099I want to make it I just want to make it clear modified Sports as governed by New York State and section six are for seventh and eighth graders literally football is for five year olds through um I think it's 16 year olds and there's no class weight class and you know it's well documented there's there's lots of great little leagues throughout our city and lots that are struggling and there's you know um a lot to unpack there with little league football but to my knowledge we are strictly speaking about modified Sports in our district so um yeah to answer your question board member Scott no there are no Charter Schools whatsoever with modified football currently and just one more thing and then I I'll be done um and forgive me because I'm just going to

100get on my baseball soak box as I usually do at this time when we're talking about sports but at hurdle North Park youth baseball baseball and softball is at record numbers South Buffalo is growing their program they have a new turf field out there Riverside has reignited their program as growing it Willie Hutch Jones and the boys and girls club are really growing baseball and softball I know we need to wait and see what the survey says but there are now thousands in my opinion of of Buffalo Public School students playing baseball and softball and I hope to one day see a modified program for baseball and softball I hope that's also on the radar so thank you for the presentation and thank you for answering my questions I just want to make can I

101make another comment about the data the survey data because this you know we want to be really transparent with the data once it's completed um and just to provide a little bit more context um in terms of survey questions we have the fall winter and sports um or fall winter and spring seasons and we ask the students to rank order their preferences from top to bottom so you all once the data closes or once the survey closes we'll share that with the Board of Education and you can see and we can disaggregate it by grade um although we're asking students in grades four through seven to complete it we can disaggregated by school by grade so it should be pretty compelling data thank you thank you Dr Reynolds okay uh president bman kman thank you

102um um I want to um just say that there were a lot of meetings and people Mr herd myself took time off of their out of their day and rolled over to um the West Side to attend these meetings and there was a presentation that was presented to the board by the then um uh associate uh leader whatever assistant or whatever associate or whatever so there were some expectations that were put in place now as to whether um the plans were uh solidified or whatever there was a committee they formed they said what they wanted to do and what we wanted to see and it was presented to the board that's how I remember it now as I hear you speak my concern is equity when I hear every a statement that says um we

103we provide any of the requirements that you're supposed to do and then in there it says and any other requirement that the building principle fills is is is pertinent I don't understand how a district can function with every without having clear rules on who and what can participate that that concerns me because it becomes an issue of equity okay and then the other statement that was said was every school that wants it you know how do you determine how you want it okay do the principal determine how you want it you know how is that determined are you meeting with the parents in the building and the SST teams to determine it I'm just trying to get some clearity because I want to make sure that the wealth is spread it across spread across the

104district okay and if teams are being organized and it's contingent upon a principle saying I don't want it in my building and children are denied resources that is not what Equity is about so I'm very concerned when I hear those two statements and I would like in the future to have something presented as to what's going on in the various districts and zones in this District to make sure that resources are being uh adequately shared okay because if if every school that wants it is a criteria okay and every principal and the principal is allowed to put another layer on as far as what kids can do we saw that with the city honors lawsuit I mean the criteria School lawsuit where the state came in and said to us you don't have the right

105to have uh certain things not unified across the the district so I'm concerned when I hear those things because I know that typically the teacher the principles that have the most difficult schools uh and oftentimes are spending a lot of time working and their F focus is more on academics than letting children have extracurricular so I would like to see uh something in the uh that make sure that Equity is happening uh and these programs are being implemented throughout the city in the zones four zones that are or divided by zones or whatever but I know you can't necessarily do it by the districts but by zones to make sure that we're we're reaching out to children and the other thing is is that we were uh impressed or thought that that Athletics the modified

106Sports football program would be a way for us to get more students uh and to keep our students with us if we if we allowed the coaches to groom them and move them forward so I was surprised that the modified uh football sports didn't happen but um it is what it is at this point I appreciate the work that you're doing but I definitely want to make sure that the resources are being adequately shared in this in this in this District thank you okay as um we're running um over but we're going to give uh Miss Woods an opportunity do you have anything you'd like to add before we go to our next topic uh yes V you on your list you had swimming it said 2B to determined now I just got beat up

107a bunch of constituents who said to me how do we expect to have lifeguards and everything for the City of Buffalo pools or whatever if our schools don't teach the children swimming and they specifically beat me up because my city outter schools has an Olympic pool and what does that have to do with Equity every school should have swimming and every child should have extracurricular activities and I just want to know what you where you going to tell me tell me okay yeah what's going on with the swimming because I don't have an answer that's a very question answer that only city outers has the pools okay because we refuse to let you take the pools out of the local schools so give help me out absolutely not and that's that's good question very good

108question I apologize uh TBD does not mean that it's to be determined whether or not they're going to have a program or not we don't have the data for this year's program that's that's why it says TBD but um let me just give you a little brief history prior again to 2019 we had a very healthy fifth to eth grade swim program in the in Buffalo Public Schools a lot of students participated I I mean I want to say approximately 200 250 kids it really helped fuel our high school program okay that's how we were able to create that very successful um all city girls team that had 27 girls that went to sectionals two years in a row okay after the pandemic that that program went away um and other decisions were made okay

109swim was brought back last year at the seventh and eth grade level okay last year the data was kind of light I'm not going to lie to you it was about 25 to 30 kids this year I'm happy to report and I can give you more data as we get the program started we start in February we currently have eight schools that have signed up and we're still signing up schools for um the fifth through 8th grade U swim program so we plan on having swim again this coming year and we've expanded the program to fifth and sixth graders so do you have a lot I mean I want to make sure you do the surveying because the parents are on my case and I know there's a lot of demand out there don't let

110me face this demand for the swimming by myself okay guys get your surveys out there if I had to distribute some to the people who are beating up on me get get me out of the situation no you know definitely last summer was very telling we held a swim Clinic um at at the at City hter Pool we had approximately 60 new swimmers learn to swim swimmers in that pool those students have continued that's how our program is going to continue to grow um the Board of Education the superintendent superintend made it very clear last year that I can continue that swim program and thankk you for that we had 60 new kids in that pool wanting to learn to swim that's going to fuel our our Athletic program in addition to that we are

111working with physical education on making sure that uh fizet has a swim program so we have to partner with physical education we need to make sure we offer swim over the summer and then provide opportunities for um Athletics you in athletics for kids to compete well I know School 31 I demanded that they fix the pool uh I was asked how many pools we have in the local schools and I also said to this these people that City honor shares that olympic size pool to anybody in the district it's not just their pool so yeah uh I would be happy to tell them that you said we are moving forward everybody's gonna learn how to swim including I can't swim so help me too thank you hey Dr Willam and one last point just we

112have partnered with project play of Western New York and they are helping us train our trainers as well and board member Woods you can learn how to swim at our Family Resource Center at South Park we have a y on thefly swimming program for families and for any of us so please participate in that Dr Williams Knight believe I just wanted to um just jump I'm very sorry I'm on the phone talking about some weather related things to see what we're going to be doing tomorrow what's the question uh I'm I'm wondering if you'd like to close out okay okay so just so you know Terence excuse me Terence herd has something he wanted to say please be respectful respectful of time because of the weather as well okay thank you um uh we had

113had conversation with Andy Rab in the past and um just want to just just just make a correction about Andy rap we had talked we had talked in the past uh this this district has talked in the past about field usage and it worked out very good for the for the uh football program for the little leagues and that to track more kids back to the Buffalo schools that was the whole mission about bringing kids back to the schools wasn't about um coming to a commit meeting and bringing in confusion or anything like that and um I heart go out for these kids and we want to make sure they get every opportunity but with Equity also uh so the board knows that we also talked with the PGA the um the golf and NFL

114that flag football program we started three years ago and also with the NBA about bringing money is here to help support our kids in programs and building Fields with the with the modified program for elementary and that would that would be with um taking six district schools and converting them to athletic programs here within the district so I just wanted to say that but it wasn't about wasn't about being conflict with the district but it was more about being Progressive off for our kids because the history of our of our children being being neglected for decades and not giv um these these these um Outlets you know it's been going on for a long period of time and this this this Administration here you know I'm not going hold everybody accountable so so even at

115at gravat when we talked about um giving kids Awards you know those criterian schools it wasn't all our kids that that's deserving to have opportunity to advance in this so thank you again thank you so much uh Dr William S if you'd like to close out this uh portion to say thank you to the team um I know that I knew that this would be a very passionate um discussion uh there are lots of feelings about you know Athletics and making sure that Equity that all of our children that want to have the opportunity to participate um you know do so we know that you know for our students that participate in athletics we expect them also academically um to be strong and so you know it's a win-win it's a win-win and certainly um

116we saw at grabars for you know all of our students that were uh supported in their participation in um Sports you know for all of our kids it's a win-win and I knew it would be a difficult conversation and I just want to thank the team I want to thank the board for sharing some things and I hope that everybody is leaving with the understanding that you know this is a team that is willing to hear the concern ter that the board is bringing forward um can we deliver with the snap of the finger every single thing that's being asked maybe not but at least they're willing to hear it and whatever we can do we were you know we work to do so thank you to everyone for um for hearing the concerns for

117addressing the concerns thank you chairwoman Shuda for having this brought before um your committee tonight uh and we'll go into the next part uh uh the pathways and Technology Grant known as the PC Grant and I will turn it over again to you Dr Williams Knight as you um all right introduce Dr har or Mr Harris I was gonna say doctor huh so um not yet not yet but it's coming I know it's coming but uh we have Mr Harris who is the director of our Career and Technical education program he works in Chief of chell's camp with um very closely with Dr Balo and um this is another one that I believe you know board member Shuda asked us to share specifically about our PC program and so um I'm excited to hear more

118about the great things that are happening because you know it really is um a really good program that we have at some of our schools so I'll turn things over to director Harris thank you Dr Williams Knight and thank you Bor for allowing me this time to um uh present to you our CTE Middle College offerings um my name is Robert Harris I'm the director of Career and Technical education um and I'd like to begin by letting you know that this is stated working access equity and Community engagement but it's via the CTE Department you can move to the next slide I want you to know also that our work is grounded in moving to the next level under the rocks of innovative high schools as well as Extended Learning Excellence for all of our

119students you can move forward the slide move to the next slide as well thank you so much um and in our 5 by 25 we fall under um uh uh number one number two and number five with a focus on number two specifically for these programs that we have um which is access to educational Excellence excellence and accelerated learning by assuring that all students have access to high quality instruction that is in that is cultural and linguistically responsive in all classrooms and all BPS schools move to the next slide please so with uh State EDS access equity and Community engagement services they are um administering approximately $175 million in Grants to and contracts and scholarships to colleges and universities schools and school districts and bosies alike as well as for our students as they are

120the beneficiaries of what this programs has to offer these programs seek to assist students in their preparation for access to and support during and the success for completion of a post-secondary program certificate or degree Buffalo schools is awarded um CTE is awarded about 1.3 million per year for our four Middle College Programs move to the next slide please in this overview I want to give you uh information about the grants and the schools participating the program purposes and Designs the grant partners professional development and meetings um budgets and costs covered teachers involved student participation data and graduation and Credit Data you can move to the next slide please SCT Buffalo schools manages uh four middle college grants one of them being uh smart Scholars which is the only one that we operate of this kind

121uh is over at hutte and it's under the information talk Technology Program uh and the other three Pathways and Technology programs we have PTEC 2 be green at McKinley which covers Green Building Tech trades we have ptech 3 B solar at South Park which covers mechanical electrical technology and then we have pte 5 bit at LJ Bennett which is covered under Information Technology with a software Focus next slide please I want to give you an understanding that these two grants are similar but different in that their similarities are that they have college coursework that is accelerated in high school for both programs so there's a little difference in between smart scholars in that the students are not moving on or have the uh opportunity to move on to college they're basically paying for college on

122their own if they move forward or through their fasta um uh applications uh as for the pathways and Technology our students move on and have the opportunity to move on to college if they choose to do so next slide please in the smart Scholars it is in Early College High School program where the institutions of higher education partner with us Buffalo schools to create early college high schools that provide students with the opportunity and preparation to accelerate uh the completion of their high school studies while earning a minimum of 24 but up to 60 transferable credit hours at the same time uh Buffalo schools chose 24 as it aligns to our program that we offered there at hutte um the state calls it extra learning time we call it um Extended Learning Time U that

123was the term used when the grant came out is extra learning time to be at grade level and ready to participate in rigorous high school and Collegiate coursework that is Grant uh that is the Smart Scholars Grant next slide please under the Pathways and Technology there were a few extra things added to the ability to maintain these uh particular grants um there has to be a rigorous relevant costree education from grades 9 through 14 particularly in stem careers it had to be designed in partnership with industry and college Partners it has to have workplace learning included with mentoring by Professionals in career are areas um it had to have intensive individualized academic support by the K12 as well as the college facil faculty an associate of applied science degree in a high-tech field completers are

124first in line for a job with the industry partner and Industry recognized certifications are taken care of for those students that are enrolled as well as the tuition is taken care of for dual or concurrent enrollment for acceleration in this particular Grant next slide please so in talking about the grant Partners where there's a little difference as well smart Scholars only has to have a college partner in that the students are only receiving the credits for their uh High School um years so the only partner needed there is Sunni Erie but we have some subsidiary partners that are not in the grant that work with us in order to ensure that our students meet and um can maintain their success as they move through the program as for the PEX there has to be three

125distinct things happening within those PEX one they have to have a college partner they have to have an industry partner as well as we have a work-based mentoring partner um for ptech 2 the college partner is Alfred State the industry partner partner is montante solar and construction exchange and the work-based mentoring partner is Blue Sky design for ptech 3B solar at South Park Sunni Erie is the college partner Tesla is the industry partner and blue sky design again is the work-based mentoring partner and then finally at ptech uh five bit at LJ Bennett Sunni Erie is the college partner the industry partner is IBM and our work based mentoring partner is themo you can move to the next slide please next we want to talk about the professional development that our teachers and uh uh

126receive as well as some of the meetings that we have that are all included in the um budget cost uh area so monthly partner meetings uh most of our meetings happen at night so that's overtime hours so monthly partner meetings happen uh on a monthly basis for each and every one of the ptech programs uh as well as the um smart Scholars a monthly curriculum and imple implementation meeting is taking place curriculum alignment meetings are taking place with the college professors that means that they're meeting with our teachers in order to ensure that they're meeting the goals they need to meet for Student Success um teacher training is taking place by our College partner there is also occupational professional development for our teachers we know that they've been out of the industry for a while

127so we want to make sure that they're on The Cutting Edge of what's happening in their industry in order to help our students be successful and then finally we have state program convenings in Albany where we go out there and we share best best practices and we ensure that everybody's on point with their particular programs and share ideas about how to improve about improve improve upon our programming um next slide please let's talk about the budgets and the costs smart Scholars um has a budget of approximately $65,000 it is mostly taking care of dual credit tuition as well as equipment books and computers particularly for the students um Extended Learning time is taking care of our staff um and our administrators who have to stay hourly after school as far as the PEX um ptech

1282 has a $500,000 budget pte 3 has a $440,000 budget pte five has a $230,000 budget these particular amounts are because our programs are at a particular year it involves amount the amount of students that are in the programs and the amount of credits that they are receiving both D through dual enrollment as well as in college tuition so dual enrollment and in college tuition is covered High School equipment supplies and elt and work-based learning opportunities are taken care of partner and college liaison implementation cost we pay our partner and our College those implementation costs that they need for to have staff um working with us and our students in order to implement the programs stackable credentials our students receive stackable credentials based in their particular areas for this uh in in addition to the

129tools books and computers that they receive as well as room and board that is only for the ptech 2 as Alfred State College is an hour and 45 minutes away so that particular Grant and only that Grant in the PTEC um is covering room and board um transportation we make sure that we Supply transportation for our students to go to the college that of choice um with Sunni Erie they're receiving bus passes and we also have uh transportation that goes out to the school so students can check out the college and see what they're going to be getting into that happens about two times a year um for uh Alfred State and our students receive many other opportunities at Sunni Erie in order to check out their facilities and their program that they're going to

130check out when they um complete the program uh and then also every one of these program has a work-based learning coordinator our work-based learning coordinator is a major part of any CTE programming as our students need work-based hours in order to show completion of understanding or Career Development and occupational studies as it relates to each one of their courses the next slide please so let's talk about the teachers involved in the grant implementation smart Scholars at 304 it has three Information Technology teachers one English teacher one math teacher and one way work-based coordinator um please note that each Grant requires a different piece because of the different programming so there's a requirement for English and math teacher because of that specific program there at Sunni Erie College and then you'll see the changes as we

131go through some of the PTEC programming um ptech 2 at 305 has six Building Trades teachers and then a work-based learning coordinator only um PTEC 3 has an electrical mechanical teacher um and one English teacher plus the work-based coordinator um and ptech 5 finally has two Information Technology teach teachers one English one math and one work-based learning uh coordinator reminder is that those particular programs because of their design and the school the college that they're working with design of the program it requires certain particular teachers to cover certain things at certain times next slide please so I would like to talk about current snapshot today data um uh smart Scholars offers 48 seats per cohort there are currently 133 students that are currently enrolled in grades 10 through 12 receiving dual enrollment coursework um in

132PTEC 2 with 50 seats per cohort there are 97 students currently enrolled pte 3 48 students per cohort there are 73 students that are currently enrolled and then finally ptech five um there are 48 seats per cohort there are 107 students that are currently enrolled in our dual enrollment programming next slide please so now I would like to go over some graduation and Credit Data for our programs um if you uh can look at this you will be able to see there are different requirements for the data and how we report it to the state so smart Scholars has a little different reporting that we have to send to the state particularly because the students are just completing their 24 hours um and making sure that they access those college credits that are available to

133them through this grant um if you look at our starting enrollment you can see that we have some attrition particularly because every year our parents have to sign um an application for registration and some of our students may be unsuccessful in some of the class so then they have to drop out of the program um in order to move the program forward um and then in the final column you can see the total college credits that were paid for by this grant to this date from 2020 to 2024 I just want to give you a moment to check those that data just in case you have questions at the end next slide please as I was stating there is a different way of reporting um that we have to send the information to the state

134particularly between the smart Scholars and PCs um this PTEC um uh information is sent the same for all three PCS but there you what you are seeing is a snapshot of the information there are uh 50 more columns that we have to take care of that uh talk about the demographic and the needs of our students um individually per each student and then it will uh do some of this um data that we pull for full groups um if you look here you can see the total numbers of students that started the totals of numbers of students that earned college credit um taking into um consideration that remember there is a requirement and prerequisites as well as student and students have to resign up per year um the percentage of the students that earned the

135college credits um based on uh the data from uh their participation um then we have to uh divise and let them know who the students are that graduated from The High School portion of the p Tech particularly they wanted that number because that tells them that we've met our 30% um reasonable accountability for students that need to move forward in the program and 30% for uh the uh 48 students is going to be 14 and for the 50 students is going to be 15 so we uh we really um move and we accelerate at that particular point uh the issue area is completers that move on to the associate degree to me it's an issue area we we they still have the opportunity but our students have the opportunity and they have to make the

136choice in order to move on and they some of them move on to different choices or different colleges or they move on to right into the world of work but then at the end you also see the amount of credits that were paid for during this Grant and you can see where our current um uh students senior Juniors and sophomores sit at this time you can move on to the next slide again the same data we're sending the same data to the state you can see the numbers of students enrolled the number of students that earned college credit the number of students that completed the High School pte portion and then those that move on to Sunni Erie and then the credits that are paid for in years one through six for the students you

137can move to the next slide please and our last graduation data for ptech 5 over at 363 please note that this is a brand new program program we've had our first couple groups of students go through the program and begin receiving the college credits um as you can see that the first 48 received all of the college CR credits that were available to them and we're working on 22 and 23 and we haven't had any completers as of yet this is our first graduating class coming up in 2020 next slide please in 2021 stated toward reviewed and evaluated our grant programs um they reviewed our expenditures our student performance data they identified program design strengths and weaknesses they made recommendations for extension applications and I'm happy to say in 2022 they approved the extension and

138continuation of smart Scholars which has an open-ended extension um PTEC 2 and three are extended to 26 and 27 respectively both will be re-evaluated around 2026 just because they'll be in the Buffalo area at the same time to do the review and then ptech 5 uh had an early review when it at its Inception as it was awarded during the pandemic so we were making arrangements to deal with the pandemic era and make sure that our students will still gain the successes that they needed um by this 2025 next slide please if you like any more information about smart Scholars uh or our PEX you can go to the state Ed website um you can look up the smart Scholars these links will get you there but if you go to the state Ed website

139and you look up the smart Scholars or you look up PTEC you will be able to go right to the sites of information and then ptech um organization has a nationwide network of pek um you can go to pc.org and learn more about what's happening Nationwide with our PTEC grants um and uh move to the next slide please and I'll take any of your questions concerning smart Scholars or Pathways in technology grants hey um we can start with h board member wood you have any questions uh yeah I have I have a question for you in your PCH programs that that grant program not the second one have you have are have you heard about a program called build and soar it's a stem program that ECC is interested in and supporting as as the

140college but it they actually teach the children to build an airplane and they teach them about flying it's a it's a very interesting unique program that sounds like it could be another one of your your grants and I would very much like to have uh uh ly lenan and this and and the professors and the people who are interested in this program meet with you to see if if if this could be something that you could add to your grad program uh because it it just is a very exciting interesting program that I think uh Hut Tech would probably be a great school to uh implement it that would would could I uh set up some kind of meeting so you can get information on this flying building a plane stem program called um SAR

141um build and S we can set up a meeting but uh uh um we had a meeting concerning uh air pting building um that we were working on with uh Miss belli um and then we were uh trying to figure out exactly what the needs of the district are concerning that particular type of program um we used to have aeronautical program over at burgard um it was cost prohibitive for the Stu for the district um and a lot of this programming like that you need upfront money um before you get into the grants building the grants and it has to align to um particular curriculum that we have so that's one area uh that we probably uh need to work for years on in order to get it to the right place that's one and

142then second these um grants that they offer us they offer an RFP every few years um if you saw that we had pte 2 pte 3 we skipped year four year four we didn't receive a a grant for that year and then uh ptech 5 is the the last one that was offered so we're waiting on to see if there's anything coming out remember the last time I talked to you um uh we said that we we're going to work on something that is in the medical field because it is a area of need um so we're looking into that for the future I'm still looking into that we actually applied for that Grant last year we didn't get it because there were some things that we didn't meet but we're going to look for

143another grant that covers that area because it is such a wide um needed widely needed area and it falls in the our high uh top programs of need in the buff Buffalo area well if you um would keep an open mind of the presentation that I attended last week as I said people are always presenting in additional information uh exciting designs and the cost for the flying plane is not assembling and building the plane is not prohibitive as far as the budget the budget is is is uh uh as they present it now is not cost cost prohibitive plus there are existing businesses that are interested in covering the costs because you know may I'm the finance person for the school so I'm always looking for somebody else to pay for it so I would

144really appreciate if you could since you are at least aware of the existence of this I would appreciate if we could have a meeting and have these PR people present once again the program because my understanding was you were excited about it at one point and now with the modifications uh I believe HTE is GNA be excited about it ECC is excited about it so I I just like to um go over it you know absolutely I'm I'm definitely willing to have a conversation about it definitely willing I appreciate that President belman C thank you for your presentation I really don't have a a lot of questions other than Paulette thank you for find finding a program for burar because they have the automotive department there to help build engines so thank you so much

145for looking out for burgard haa but anyway anyway that's ex that's exactly where the aeronautical program was yes that's exactly I I know that that's and and they and they and their alumni have been talking about trying to see if we could get that back uh personally I'd like to see an art program near uh similar to Pimp My Ride where we uh uh what is it uh coat uh cover vehicles and stuff but anyway that's just the artists in our district but anyway I want to thank you for this effort um I think considering the challenges that we have if um we are able to expand these programs we should be able to expand our enrollment in our district and take some of our students back from uh uh other uh the charter schools

146and so I look forward to seeing how how you move that forward uh thank you for all the work you're doing thank you Dr uh Evans Brown ditto I yeah I remember that program uh building planes years ago uh one of my uncles theore Banks worked over at burgard high school it was a phenomenal uh pro project and program but thank thank you um Mr Harris for a robust presentation I've been on this board this is my fifth year to have listened to this presentation is really uh a treat because I didn't realize how comprehensive uh the uh Pathways CTE program is so I appreciate that our kids are getting um some of the tech techological um things in place because that is the 21st century stuff that we need and you know similar to

147what uh people have said we need to expand these kinds of opportunities in in some of our other um high schools so I'm looking forward to that okay um board member Scott I don't have any questions thank you director Harris for the very comprehensive presentation board member marosi I also don't have any questions but I appreciate the diligence over the years of just expanding and continuing to look for the opportunities that are out there you know things are changing on daily when it comes to technology and all of the trades and again for our listening audience you know we realize is that a lot of our students aren't really heading toward that college you know path and we do have these opportunities and they're available they're plenty they are plenty and this is just a

148few of what we have to offer so I really suggest that folks get on the website and check out our CTE programs and you know what there is as Alternatives in case you know like myself academics were not my strong suit but if I would have had something like this growing up I might be in a completely different place right now so thank you again for all your hard work and all the years you put into growing this this particular part of BPS Dr Rivera like my colleagues I don't have any questions and I want to Echo my congratulations I know Mr Harris that you know how important I find dual credit and giving Early College opportunities I've been happy to continue to work on some of those things with you this is the thing

149that allows our students to move forward um academics training all of those things because they can see their future and I appreciate the work and also the careful tracking you did about the outcomes for our students as well and I would like to add I was one of the I was the principal uh when the uh the grant came to South Park High School and uh uh I was uh at the opening of Tesla and it was just I think all board members if you have an opportunity to visit one of the programs I know the program at South Park the the equipment and the opportunity the kids have and the exposure uh to the field is just phenomenal but what I really love to see is the transformation into uh college credit so I

150they that's very that's it's a really good thing to see so I appreciate that and uh on this uh snowy night that will happen in South Buffalo I don't know about the rest of you I will uh turn it over to Dr William nightnight you're muted I was on such a roll on such Ro um I want to say thank you to uh director Harris and all of the good work that you lead with the CTE um Department I don't know how you keep a handle on all of it but somehow or another you know you do and you know you're working with all of our principles great presentation everyone tonight please stay safe try to stay warm um that's all I have good night thank you bard thank you Dr Williams Knight you guys

151have a great evening thank you everyone good night thank you thank you a meeting with you good night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.