001truly appreciate how informed he keeps me so I feel quite confident in the presentation today um Jim I know you have a lot to share um and there are several presentations that we're going to be looking at so um I look forward to your updates and Madam superintendent I'm gonna hand it over to you okay thank you I um could say ditto to everything that you said we absolutely have a wonderful uh chief financial office officer um tonight I believe that you know some of the goals are to continue with the transparency that we've always exemplified uh keeping this board updated and engaged and you know we really just want to reassure you that you know the work that we're doing with the finances is being done very delicately strategically and courageously we are keeping
002the main things the main things so with that I will turn things over to Chief Financial Officer Mr Barnes thank you superintendent thank you uh Cindy uh so I'll be presenting on three topics tonight before we start I just want to stress in my weekly meetings with the superintendent uh we spend hours discussing the financial and operational challenges facing our District both in the current year with an $83 million projected deficit and an upcoming tough budget year so we're not viewing anything with rose-colored glasses so to speak however the presentations tonight are all positive in nature and that we're operating within our budget and two big projects that have long been discussed are moving forward so I just thought I'd say that um add me our next slide please so the first presentation is on
003the first quarter Financial results um I'll be talking about the financial results and then a financial update on the commissary and a financial update on our capital budget and financing all of the district's financial planning is constructed within the full context of our general fund operating resultss and the projected cash flows for all our funds general fund grants uh food service and capital projects so before updating uh you on the commissary and the capital budget it's critical to understand the current year results and the projection for the remainder of the year if we encounter any unexpected financial problems within the general fund it could impact the commissary capital projects or any other decision because both of those projects and everything else does rely to some extent on general fund cash for the funding so this
004presentation on the first quarter results and projection will only focus upon a few key areas that were included in the full report which was distributed to the board about a month ago and then it was included in last month's board meeting ad next slide so I'm going to start with the executive summ I just pulled it right out of the first quarter report um it provides an overview of the budget process a Contex uh the context for our results to date versus budget and it takes a peek ahead at upcoming Financial issues that we're seeing that'll play out in the last three quarters um I think a good place to start is really reflect upon all the work that we did to put this current Year's budget together two factors had a dramatic impact on
005the current Year's budget the loss of 90 million in ressor and the need to align total staff counts and cost throughout declining enrollments the superintendent constructed a two-year plan that mindfully addressed these issues uh while also ensuring that all student needs are met avoiding disruptions to the Investments that we've made in sec security Health and Welfare Athletics and that utilizes 83.5 million of our fund balance during this transitional year keep in mind because we're going to be dealing with it uh in the upcoming budget year but also what we had to deal with in the 24 25 budget were the implications are the consequences of the decisions uh of the superintendent's very unique 2-year plan to address the financial cliff um during the first year of the two-year plan we cut 226 mostly vacant positions
006from the total District budget but increase the general fund FTE by 158 um the net impact on the general fund will be large increases in salary and benefit expenditures and a relatively small amount of what we've come to uh call vacancy SA because we cut the vacancies from the budget and that was a really courageous necessary and long overdue First Step um this year's results are also impacted by the third year of the BTF contract and contractual increases for all the other bargaining units on the revenue side last year 23 was the last year of the full phasing to the foundation Aid formula so Incorporated in this year's budget was a much more modest and historically consistent Foundation Aid increase also what was communicated during the budget and incorporated into the board approved four-year plan
007was uh the construction of a new commissary and the lease of the same facility and uh well organized wellp put together capital budget plan for $64 million 10 million in cash and $54 million into a bond offering the debt payments will be largely offset by corresponding building aid over a 15-year period at the end of the first quarter that we're still projecting that $ 83.5 million deficit it's too early in the fiscal year after the original budget to really update that but we will be getting an updated projection for the remainder of the year at the end of the second quarter why it's a little too early you're not paying full salaries to the teachers until like the middle of September so the first couple two and a half months aren't representative of the full
008year run rate plus you're just getting back to school the principales are submitting additional requests for things all that will be fully reflected in the second quarter report um I'm going to on the next Pages I'm going to have you take a look look at the FTE charts uh based upon the date available September 30th these three charts visually explain the large net changes in total FTE and the allocation between the general and the grand funds uh this those three charts really show the main impact of the first year of the superintendent 2-year plan um there will be increases in spread related FTE and other costs during the second quarter due to increases in spread enrollments and or EP IEP services and will'll be incorporating those into the second quarter projection and as noted above
009the 24 25 year which we're currently in is going to be one of the most eventful in many many years it includes the superintendent's first year of for two-year phasing which by the way reduce the total FTE count and produced maybe five playoffs tops um and we'll also be making the largest investments in facilities in 30 years so with that background adir could you turn to the next [Music] slide here's the uh this first one shows the total FTE count on both a budget and employment in all funds you see the big drop that's the 226 vacancies that the superintendent and her staff and this board courageously cut from the budget they finally bent the curve and almost zero lays it's a big start to addressing the staff to student imbalance add here next slide
010now here's the same data but just for the general fund you see that went up 158 positions were added to the general fund budget this was the superintendent's mindful approach she didn't do 300 layoffs we moved quite a few positions from the arser F fund into the general fund to avoid layoffs and keep in place all the support and programs that the students needed security guidance Council social workers Tradesmen school-based people so that's the impact on the general fund this is why you're going to see increased salaries and benefits and lower vacancies lower vacancy savings add next slide okay here's the same data for budget and employment but in the grant funds you see that thing just drops off the table that's the end of our besser we had to deal with the loss of
011funding for 400 positions that we had in our besser we moved about 152 to the general fund and we finul cutting vacancies for the balance and here next slide now back to the reporting here's our enrollment data as of October 31st we break it down into various categories the two most General and let's say most important are the beds K through 12 and the beds prek the first two I'm just going to announce the number and I'll let the superintendent maybe add some comments here this chart if you go to 2425 beds K through 12 shows an increase of between 3 and 400 students that is look at the the trending here that's the first time that's happened in years now we'll gather final data in January just to be cautious but unequivocally our enrollments
012are up this year super would you like to make a comment you know I just want to say that that is really exciting you know I am thrilled over the moon happy about it you know I I wish I could take credit but but I can't it really is a lot of the work of the board it's the work that our principles our assistant principles our teachers our staff our Athletics that everybody is doing I believe that the community is beginning to trust the Buffalo Public Schools the work that we're doing and that we are bringing some pride back into the work that we're doing so this is really something for everybody to Pat themselves on the back and feel good if we need evidence that what we're doing is beginning to um take storm
013this is it good work for everybody thank you super uh and AD next slide please so the the next critical part of that first quarter report previously distributor was our cash flows um the single most important Financial report that encompasses every fund and every dollar in and out um if you go to the column called the original projection one two three four five over and you go down to the end the ending cash our beginning cash was 444 million we're projecting an $83 million deficit that's real cash so our ending cash Investments was supposed to be $353 million but through the first quarter we're running about $55 million ahead of that cash plan if we continued at this pace we would end the year at 48 million the first quarter does not guarantee the next
0149 month results but again I'm just reporting right now and it's good news things are running according or a little above budget and here next slide quick summary through September I pulled all the data I showed you tonight from the quarterly report but we've already analyzed and processed the October results we're tracking right on the 2425 budget in terms of operating results revenues expenditures cash flows the quarter 225 report will provide a more specific and reliable projection for the remainder of the year and during the second quarter we also hope to report on significant additional progress on the next two topics the commissary and the 2025 capital budget and financing so that's the context of where we are I'm going to report on uh I give you a commissary update next admir if you could
015pull that out okay ad your next slide please thank you um again the big picture this one goes to both the commissary and my next presentation capital projects uh all this data and projections are included in the board approved fouryear plan we've reported on both these projects numerous times the BSA bfsa the mayor's office our expert Auditors um and in projects this big and it's time so emotional the superintendent I just wanted to continue to present factual updates it's all it is so number one on the commissary all designs and construction documents have been submitted to the state the state requires the submission of a lease prior to giving final and full project approval we're confident we're going to get the lease them and soon after that the state stamps everything approved we're currently in
016lease negotiations with Maguire on a new 15-year lease we're going to be leasing this facility the current estimated cost of the project $43 m164 last time we reported it was $44 milon um a couple of key lines and I know this might be hard to read the first line are basically the construction costs this is from the Maguire's construction budget from 1018 this amount is to be paid by Maguire I want to be clear about that 3,890 we already paid the architectural and design fees for 1.9 million there's going to be some BPS direct cost has reported like six prior times for furniture fixtures and equipment for 5.3 million because the superintendent and I are loans to surprises and always uh want to be on a conservative side we put in $5 million in unknown
017cost bringing the total project cost of 43 million keep in mind Maguire pays the 30 million 890,000 so bidding and updated construction cost will be finalized after the lease is signed we may engage with a construction management firm to update the construction cost estimates in the upcoming weeks if we haven't finalized the lease by that now this is next one's important there are currently two alternatives for funding for this project utilize the ex exsc fund revenues reserves that was the original plan communicated to the state and it's still a very viable plan and B fund the new lease through the general fund based upon receiving a positive response from the state regarding our request for lease Aid this request is currently being processed by the building Aid unit not fruit service and the State's Attorneys
018we cannot project cash flows for this alternative at the present time we're waiting on an answer here next slide so what we can do is give you an updated projection using that first alternative the C fund use of access fund reserves this is based upon our current lease negotiations and the impact uh on the general fund so per updated cash flow now and the status of our current lease negotiations we're projecting this project may require approximately $10 to15 million in general fund cash over the next 15 years and all waited toward the end of the lease this is consistent with previous models calculations and presentations myself and the super have been communicating this from day one this project no matter how it's finance will not be S all funded through the C fund it will
019require some help from the general fund so there's nothing new or shocking here and the amount being reported here is the same what this basically shows are the projected deficits and the beginning food serve bill it's at 39 million it goes down each year by the amount of the deficits so the reserve would be used up in say year 10 and you'd have about no year 12 you'd have about three years where the general fund would be required to fund those deficits just an honest realistic uh financial analysis of this project under almost any condition uh Andre next slide so summary remarks the cash flows I presented today for the C fund alternative it shows this is an economically viable project IT projects an estimated use of 10 to 15 million of general fund cash
020over 15 years all weighted in years 12 13 14 and 15 and this is consistent with previous models calculations and presentations we do not have enough information or data or feedback from the state to project the cash flows for the general fund lease Aid alternative so that's just a factual update on the comiss uh adir next slide please oh next slide next uh presentation please okay this next one is uh a report on the capital budget and the financing um there's been some misinformation about this whole project and the financing uh the information I have in here has presented to you previously and it's pretty much the same uh the super I felt it very important to present it again these are the facts uh ad here oh thank you had the big picture so
021here's the plan plan described below was included in the board approved 4year plan it's also been reviewed and approved in quotes by the control board our external Auditors there's 27 projects totaling $64 million in cost The Buff State D Vinci project is 34 million and there are 26 much smaller health and self safety related Windows letter bait man roofs uh lighting uh that total about 30 million this plan will be financed to a $54 million Bond sale and 10 million in District cash the bond proceeds are used they're taking in they're used to pay the vendors and then the debt payments are offset almost dollar for dooll by building Aid it has a zero Financial impact on the district and the City of Buffalo this is a New York state preferred method of financing large
022capital projects the plan has received a favorable response from the citizens planning committee chaired by Skyler Banks the CPC noted that historic ly BPS requests are considered and approved outside of the controller's debt cap they have never been considered part of the controller's debt cab and that the BPS related debt has no impact on the city's finances and they're are they're 97.3% aidable so that Aid we received offsets the debt payments for a zero Financial impact the mayor's recommendations to the com common Council also included a plan request without getting into the weeds but because misinformation has been spread I want to stress this again we went through the full SE uh citizens planning committee Skyla Banks and all their board members they even wrote a letter to the controller stating these projects have always
023been excluded from your C they're much Ed by the children of Buffalo the controller did not respond to that request next we met with the mayor's office and certain common council members and we explained the facts of this type of financing this isn't some uh unique Creative Financial tool that came from me or anyone in my office we went by the New York State and Playbook this is you supposed to do it um so the mayor is all on board the common council is all on board we presented them to them but getting over the final hurdle of this cap uh we'll probably take a couple of more meetings um ad here next slide so the financial impact plan debt and state a I'm going to explain it one more time uh the city sells
024a $54 million bond for the aable amount of our projects we take that money we put it into the H fund the Project's actually called h281 that money is strictly used to pay the vendors the construction cost then you have to repay the debt all projects included on our Master list are aable up to 97. 3% because Buff State was a complete renovation they calculated the building Aid in a different formula which is called a maximum cost allowance so they gave us 70% of those total [Music] costs the district uses 10 million of cash to partially fund The Buff State project again the annual debt payments will be offset by annual state building Aid the net financial and cash flow impact to a BPS will be almost zero and it is guaranteed to be zero
025to the City of Buffalo the beauty of this project again it's just pulled from New York State's Playbook it can be repeated year over year uh aded next slide please so you're going to kill me for being redundant but I'm going to show you actual projections uh pulled from deck tables and and St tabl below are the annual p on the left based upon a 54 million 15-year Bond at 3.6% interest this is the bond that we will issue to pay for the capital projects if you take a look at those the first four columns see the P plus I column that's the principle of Interest we'll pay annually on this Bond 4,724 519 building a is projected at 97.3% for 15 for 15 years from the date of our final cost submissions you see
026on the right see that First Column it's got zero in it for building Aid you always miss one year because you're finishing up the projects and then you're submitting your final cost reports so there's always a oneyear leg so the net amount is 4.7 million we got to pay the debt but we don't get building Aid now look at every other [Music] year the debt payments minus the estimated building Aid they will act will actually be getting more in building Aid than we're paying out in debt that's because we paid 10 million in cash and regarding that first year where we didn't get building Aid look at the bottom line there's no debt payment but we still get the building a it's zero cost to the district um next slide please so our next steps
027this is important but again previously communicated to everybody in west of New York controller's office Count Council mayor the plant team is working with the architect and engineering firms to submit the design and construction documents to the state by January first it's in progress um the state is aware of this and informed us of an 8-week review and approval process so our implementation plan calls for receiving all project approvals and the building Aid calculations by March 1st of 2025 this will allow enough time to include these projects in a $54 million bond issue on or around April we are monitoring the progress of each project and the overall plan on a weekly basis uh we we know right now and we still got a month left Buff State divin looks like a slam dunk that
028will get it to the state by January 1st uh Joe deera who I'm going to mention a little bit later he's probably got two or three that are ready to be submitted Brad uh galin who I'll mention later he's got 10 in projects he's pretty confident that most of them will get submitted so we're doing really well but these are the goals we've been communicating and been tracking t uh aded next slide I'm going to end the summary remarks by mentioning some of the guys who to on the fourth floor that I are doing all that put together the plan that are pushing the A&E firms uh and providing all kinds of expertise so the plan project management team for these 27 projects consists of Kelly elhadad Brad melin Joe deera Jim Deora and Derek
029Nelson they've done an exceptional job selecting and managing a list of projects 27 that address the most urgent needs of our building that state aable it can be completed in a relatively short time frame to avoid that debt building Aid delay and that will make substantial health and safety improvements for the students they've done a great job managing through very tight timelines while dealing with the typical issues surrounding Capital budgets this team's efforts have been supported enhanced by working closely with Jennifer lempo and finance to expedite the processing while ensuring all procedures are followed and proper budgets and funding are are secure it's the first time in a long time that Finance purchasing and plant have worked this closely together and David Hells and Mel they deserve a round of applause for persistently leading both
030the commissary and the capital budget project through years of ups and downs and twist in terms I went down and got involved with the capital project I don't know maybe a year ago the stories I've heard and the meetings I've attended these guys have done a amazing job persistently staying the course when everybody wants to go this way that way doubts this those two guys have done a great job on the commissary and the capital budget plan so we haven't crossed the finish line yet for the commissary or the capital budgets but guys we are really really very close and as the super mentioned at the start we know we're in tough financial times we've got a tough budget year but good things are happening and and and the board should is part of all
031this and has done a great job supporting all of this stuff so just for a minute I think I think we can all say Pat each other on the back and say good job that's it uh vice president Scott I understand you'll be uh starting the Q&A with the board uh chairperson mcken has had to log off because of her uh time at the airport so thank you uh Mr Scott thank you Chief Barnes for the very thorough presentation um on a variety of important Finance Financial issues um let's start with board member Woods any questions or comments board member Woods uh as you said is a very thorough presentation uh I appreciate that we're moving forward on the the projects and I appreciate the superintendent and and Mr Barnes is including all possibilities and
032also it was very necessary that you pointed out three times that the capital project is not going to cost the City of Buffalo a DME so they have no reason not to move forward and cooperate with a very thorough thank you thank you m well well said board member Woods uh board member Shuda any questions no I would just Echo what pette has stated and uh again compliment uh the superintendent and uh Chief barns for giving uh the thorough uh background of what's Happening thank you board member Shuda board member herd any questions yes uh first I'd like to just commend the superintendent on such a fine job along with um Jim Barn for uh really really taking close personal detail about our our staffing making sure that we're able to minimize our cuts and
033um and and really really worked on our um General budget uh you know that that we does we do have the savings and and also you know applying close Aid to the needs of the district so so that's that's that's the first thing um do have a just a couple of quick questions um I know we mentioned um our capital projects several of our capital projects but where we at with our other Capital project seeing that we're going to have a saving for the first time in 10 years and um and there's a number I'm going have to run them off but you know there's a number of other capital projects that we're that we're looking into let's see how how those are going within this um budget uh the focus of this update is
034on the brand new 27 item World design Capital project list I I'm aware that there are other projects older that have been started and then process I'll get you an update on that and I'm also aware that we're not included on this list but two things that seem to be of big interest to you all high and Riverside work is going on I'll get updates for you okay and also you know I would love to see I'm GNA repeat this one more time uh about the food commissary about having a restaurant there for the community uh maybe a breakfast lunch spot and I'm using our students as as training programs for them and I would still love to see that being active somehow and U see some um drawing plans with that is since we
035have a $5 million um that's set aside by the district for unknown I shouldn't put that in there okay I hear you Mr okay thank you so much again all right uh board member mcos any questions no questions that was um I guess thorough is a popular word the day but um I just want to give you some props Jim because your cander and how you just make this whole presentation so digestible for everybody not just us board members anybody watching um hitting all the points that need to be hit making sure people know that yeah there might be some rhetoric going on but here's the real deal and that you're accessible to people who have any further questions so I just you know I I hear you giving everybody else props but I just
036I just want to hand some to you and to the you know of course the superintendent everybody else but you're the one making the presentations it's not you know numbers are not necessarily my thing but you make it so easy to for me to be able to ask questions and your presentation was so thorough that I really didn't have any so kudos to you and and I look forward to your updates thank you all right um vice president Kathy Evans Brown any questions well I just did all everything um my colleagues have um noted and and Jen took the words out of my mouth Jim you make everything seem so clear you know even though I have a ba math background you just make it clearer than what I could ever do so thank you
037for that kudos to you and the superintendent thank you and it is me and the superintendent there were a couple of revisions she made before I presented this tonight she had me take some things out and reward some things and comes out like this thank you and president Belton Cotman any questions no thank you for your presentation uh appreciate it I I would like to know what's going on with middle Early College um since you are there and the superintendent is here uh particularly since middle Early College was the school that was earmarked to go to um Buff State I want to know uh what the plans are for for Middle early college and so I would expect in the future to hear very soon about that uh I'm getting a lot of uh feedback
038from middle Early College about H about this so I'd like to make sure that that is uh addressed thank you yeah thank you m all right the uh Chief Barnes only question I think I have is we know that the city is in a tough Place financially and in the past they have borrowed our money um to fill holes um any update on that and you know how frequently that's happening how much money's being borrowed is that do you have any uh recent knowledge on that yeah uh based on a knowledge of their budget and our budget and the cash flows that flow out of there and I frequent conversation with the Controllers Office in the city they'll probably have to dip in three times again this year uh that that's the best answer as
039I could get you uh three to maybe four times this year okay and and I assume no progress on getting more interests paid back to the district that we pursued last year at some point no progress but uh we'll give you an update at next meeting okay all right thank you very much um Chief Barnes superintendent Williams knight any closing comments before we transition to our next committee um I just want want to say that Jim Barnes is a very humble humble leader he you know and David Hills have really done a lot of work with respect to this Capital project piece and I know that you know usually the finance meetings deal with numbers and and dollars but I'm always thinking about faces of our children and the opportunities because you know the budget
040that he works so delicately with with is really what drives how many teachers we have in schools how many assistant principles we can have do we still have security officers I mean and so you know it really is a very very tough job that he has and you know I don't know just as an aside if you've had a chance to ride by Bennett but the stairs the stairs look amazing and that was done in a real short period of time because for years those stairs didn't look like anything any of us would be proud of and so you know in a very short period of time it took a lot of work though it took a lot of work behind the scenes and that's why I'm glad he took the time to name people
041to show you know gratitude to them and Grace to them because we don't see the faces all of the time of the people behind the scenes the wind beneath the wings on how those steps you know uh got handled how we were able to move the children children out of duville and over the school age so I I do appreciate when you take the time to do that so great presentation we're going to keep keeping the main thing the main things so and we will share an update on um middle early that's the one thing that's the one thing that you know we're still we're still trying to get that to you know when I sat in the seat we had three schools we had three schools in one school now we got two I
042mean and so you know there were some things that happened prior to me being here whereby buildings were sold and so we didn't have extra buildings to you know just relocate the children too so it's a process but we are moving forward and we do want middle Early College to have their own home we do I wish I could snap my fingers and have a place but unfortunately I you know that won't work so we're moving forward on a lot of projects and that's still one that we have to you know get some some steam going on Madam superintendent respectfully I want to say since 2011 I've been on this board and I've heard that over and over and over again and it was seven years in 2011 that they were waiting for their own
043campus okay and so at this point particularly after madii campus is off the market now which would have been an excellent choice for us to do multiple things on it uh but the but the vision was not there or the lack of vision or the desire to do it uh our slush fund $5 million $4 million okay was ail but at this point the middle early college is I'm is frustrated they are upset about how they've been treated and they feel that there is no light at the end of the tunnel for them and I feel that and when I go into that building I have nothing that I that and it's frustrating for me since 21 to see it and understand it you got to remember we were told that school 8 was not
044even an option for Middle Early College because it was too expensive to reot but it became available for Da Vinci so I'm not trying to be d a downer here but at the end of the day to have those kids all together and not be able to grow the bened project and not to do right by a middle Early College is very upsetting to me this is one of the reasons why it's the need for me to step down from being president of this board and start being the fairies District representative in a big way and it's just not fair to them at this point and I'm not going to back down we should have a solution uh we should have had a solution a long time ago but it was seven years in 211
045okay and so now we're looking at 20 years of how they were treated and it's not fair Jennifer you were the one down here blocking us from moving to school to a middle uh to MST when we were going to give them a whole section at MST now that don't you go there because you know you know in the aisle you know we were almost was upset with me about that because there was I mean I I will say this I will say this uh everybody knows two of my daughters went there and now my son is there so I have a strong relationship with many of the staff many of the faculty there and the principal was the principal at Waterfront so I've known him and and the sentiment it's real it's real there
046is frustration it's a consistent um it's just consistent no my daughter moved into three schools in her four-year career at at middle Early College three different schools clear across different areas of town and still had to attend a college at that that's a lot of stress and pressure on the kids I don't want to be labor this but I know the opportunity there was opportunity at ECC there was opportunity in all the different areas and when we project the possible opportunity it gets everybody excited just to be let down and some of these staff have been there since day one so they're just kind of tired of going through the ringer so whatever you know I'm not I'm you know I I get it I get it and and I'm trying to appease folks too
047and Sharon being the um board member for that school but me being a proud parent you know you got two board members that may not see ey to eye on much but we D sure on the same page with this all right um thank you everybody I think we are now transitioning to the next committee which is Dr Vice President Kathy Evans Brown um I'll turn it over to you for our next committee thank you board member Larry Scott um vice president M Larry Scott oh hold on feel like I lost something what happened okay there we go all right good evening welcome to the December 4th executive uh session uh for those of you who don't know me my name is Dr Kathy Evans Brown um the representative for East District but also the
048vice president of executive Affairs so as we move along this journey of student outcome focused governance sponsored by the Council of great City Schools under our esteemed President Sharon belon Cotman we have adopted the 2425 goals and they are smart um in the guard rails for the district uh the superintendent along with her staff her team has executed the process and knowing the superintendent she's already in the throws of doing the work so the goals I just want to remind people what the goals are for the 24-25 uh year goal one career in college readiness goal two literacy with a focus on third grade economically disadvantaged students goal three numeracy with a focus on third grade economically disadvantaged students and lastly goal four numeracy for grade five economically disadvantaged students we have made great strides
049in this process of student F outcome focused governance uh for example um the superintendent her team last month I believe uh produced and submitted a progress monitoring calendar to the board in a very timely fashion and it was very awesome because that will help us and help the district put in um uh systems where when we're not here that would be there at all times um so that progress monitoring calendar will uh take us through you know the goals the data the progress Etc as we move along this journey today I want to discuss the superintendent's evaluation so as you recall an ad hoc committee was formed that included board member uh board members Terry Shuda and pette woods and myself um we met uh since which time on probably two or three occasions the
050first one we met with um Bob Harts who is vice president of the super evaluation that we used for the last two years um the super eval evaluation is used um in many districts uh with superintendents um in New York state including um you know Williamsville kinmore Etc it's a great tool and we all agree to continue to use it for those years so when talking with Bob hars um and you know with our goals and uploading the goals and guard rails that's an easy thing that they can do I also talked with the super intending about um what we have met about so she's aware as well so Bob will upload the goals and the guard rails with no problem into the 2425 evaluated year secondly there was a lot of thought and discussion
051surrounding other areas that are critical to the superintendent evaluation to include a relationships with the board and this is you know a culmination of our meetings with the ad hoc committee um Community relation relations that would include the district image um communication with the community to include um all of the quadrants of the city so for example um the West Side the East Side the south side and the North Buffalo Arena area and then um the other area that last year we thought about as an ad hoc committee was to include business and finance so that um that would include budget and budget development um and maintenance facility all the stuff that Jim Barnes just uh presented you know to us because that is critical um to the sustainability you know of the district along
052with um the superintendent's ability to maintain uh a budget and not get us bankrupt so thus I had a conversation with the superintendent as I mentioned surrounding the 2425 evaluation and she is in agreement that all of these factors are critical and should be part of her evaluation it should be waited we didn't wait it yet in terms of of um you know the uh what do you call it the uh it wasn't weighted and um and it should be quantifiable as some of these areas is when evaluating can can be um subjected so with that I wanted to at least um uh provide the board with where we are in terms of the conversation and I want to open it up with the board for a discussion but before that um Dr Williams I
053want to include you um with um uh any thoughts or Insight that you have on what I just um spoke about because it's your value um you know thank you for uh earlier reaching out and us having a very um candid conversation and uh board member Woods thank you also um just you know to to um secure just some feedback and what my thoughts were on the evaluation because I think for a board that one of the most important things that the board is charged with you know is hiring a superintendent and evaluating the superintendent and helping to make sure that that superintendent has all of the opportunities possible to be successful I think that's what the board wants that's what any superintendent that I've ever spoken to also wants and so this is this
054is a very very very important high stakes uh piece of a superintendent's work and so I'm glad to hear that the goals are important important but as you just heard from Chief Barnes there is a lot that encompasses just like you know a principal work or you know an assistant superintendent work it's in order to meet those goals there's a whole lot of things that have to happen um from District staff from communicating with the whole community and so I hope that you know all of those things I've shared it with both Dr Evans Brown and with a board member Woods I hope that those are things that will be taken into account when looking at the evaluation tool and the waiting of it okay thank you for that Dr Williams so I'm gonna open
055the floor um now from uh first the ad hoc committee if you have any additional uh items that you want to note um in addition to what I indicated and I'm going to go around and um do a poll of everyone else okay Terry Terry show you're up I I think what's really important and I think that when we had um our discussions through the committee um we know that with our new student Focus governance we're really looking at students results and what we we find attractive is that we can still incorporate these other areas that are crucial to the superintendency and they'll keep in the weighing process keep perhaps the student um uh the student goals as really the Crux of the evaluation but we didn't want the other work to go unnoticed so
056I think that we had a good discussion we had some we had good meetings and uh Paulette and I had some pretty heavy debates but we can uh we we were able to shake and we're we're it was good discussion and so uh so I appreciate uh the opportunity to serve on this committee thank you board member Shuda um what remember was well um everybody knows meia I'm a legal bego we have to S stick with what the law says we're responsible for and I am just happy that though we are focusing on the big picture the outcomes and we put that in there we didn't neglect and exclude what the law says we going to pass a budget we we have to balance that budget we have to take the vision from the community
057and report to the community and we have the board um we need to work with and have a relationship with our superintendant so those three things got in to the evaluation so I'm a happy camper it's a fair balanced uh evaluation and as long as the criteria is objective and measurable not subjective we can't do any better guys we're in good hands okay thank you board member Woods all right so I'm GNA go with uh vice president Larry Scott you're on uh you unmute Larry sorry about that um just one more question uh chair Evans Brown um I'm trying to catch up here because the agenda is different than what we're discussing um so let me let let me just in let me just Infuse something what had happened was it originally was going to
058be what you see about goals Cindy and uh Leslie were going to do that and so when I talked to uh Dr crestes um it changed because Lesley now is out of town and we didn't have an opportunity to change that so you know okay so am I correct in that we have a drafted revision of the superintendent evaluation is that is that what I'm heing no no no we don't have one that's why we're discussing it now now um we what we have is the goals that we adopted as a board right those four I just mentioned along with the guard rail so those will be uploaded in super eval as part of her super her the evaluation along with other criteria that both uh uh bort member shoter and B member Woods talked
059about um to include relation ship with the board uh community relations and business and finance those are real succinct similar to what was included last year and we just eliminated some of the other stuff but we thought but we Haven that hasn't been shared with us yet those changes no that's why we're talking about it nothing's been since uh solidified we want to bring it back to the board first all right that's all thank you oh you're welcome uh let's see board member uh makusa um I mean I don't have any questions I just I wanna uh I'm glad that there is an effort to actually have folks come together on what this means and what it looks like and I really 100% you know give all the props to having the conversation with Dr
060Williams Knight and you know that's as part of the puzzle I think we were missing because the conversations were happening in silos in the past but there was an actual committee put together had the conversation we're moving forward as a board this is it's nine years of now you know regardless of the tool we we are going to have an understanding of what this means from her perspective as well as ours and we're going to come together do a cohesive evaluation and I'll be honest that's kind of far from what we've been doing in the past so I'm really looking forward to you know having this process go down with some real you know I'll feel good about it so thank you all for creating the committee thank you Dr Williams Knight for being understanding
061and working with everybody this is this is good stuff thank you U board member cus we want this superintendent to be successful we want to be successful you know as a board and so we're we're in all we we are in this all together uh thank you for your comments board member herd yes so um so so we're discussing the goals and guard rails for the superintendent today that's what this is based upon well okay so I heard heard what you told um vice president um um Scott lry Scott yes yes okay so this so This is actually will be the agot committee report that you given to the board correct for for what super evaluation because we I haven't read any notes or anything like that from the ah ahop report or committee meeting
062so this is the first time as a board I believe that we all heard of it uh what was desired and um doing a ha committee so so so with this um uh I had you know I have a couple of questions I at the last um committee meeting I I discussed some of some of the things that I've seen that that were um problematic for this district and I believe that the board need to take a step back and and and take a look at what the Council of great City school is and what they stand for and what they represent and the influence that they have here in our district I really believe that um there's some huge challenges that's before us and I know that we made some strides as a district
063but I believe that all the strides that we made as a district was due to the superintendent and administrative staff members working and working together I believe that we have great leadership here in this district and um I would like to sustain that leadership here in this district and and and keep them on the on the pathway that they're on but also take a deeper dive into what the council grace these students are who they represent what super packs um possibly that that they affiliated with and people and what's the goals um I believe um that this District you know is is very very important to all of us and and as as a board we should really really take a deeper dive into um the history of the council great City Schools before we
064move any forward with it um I I he this warning and U I asked before that we can go to council with this or we we can go into um maybe a workshop to to get a better understanding because um this was put put before the board the board agreed to support the Council of great City Schools but there was no time to do investigation about the history of the Council of GRA City Schools who's leading it um and who's representing us or or or preparing us um I got calls from from school board uh members across Ross this country you know said you know about allowing a nonprofit to come into our district and represent us and take over our school board meetings and also you know what their goals were and things that
065they were going to accomplish once again so we can go deeper into that if you would like but I urge right now for the board just to take a deeper dive take a step back and see exactly the harsh the harsh terms that that's being used on this District um we know that we are working for student outcome and we always did that and we always had student forus governance here with this district and that's why we've been so achieving uh for student results okay thank you um uh board member heard um duly noted uh President Sharon Cotman so I I guess um in reference to what Mr herd had to say we had four board members to go through the training that I took back during covid and um I believe each one of
066them did Express that they were better for the wear and that they leared things that they did not learn is that not correct okay because our relationship with the Council of great City schools has been going on for upwards of over 40 something years and um when when we had a situation on this board where we were working to have a board member removed they were one of the uh affiliate partners that came to the table with legal uh Force to assist us as well along with the NAACP uh new uh National Association of school board New York State School Board Association the Urban League uh excuse me the NAACP as well and so one of the reasons why and often times what happens on with this particular board and certain board members is the
067message because of the messenger is killed is destroyed we had a a board that was functioning without having any direction and without having any Focus or purpose moving forward and now we can all be proud of the fact that there we have goals we have time schedules we have monitoring um uh schedules put in in place our next steps would probably be to get some um in my opinion to have uh a reporting of certain um reports that uh we would like to see maybe uh paet Woods the vacancy report uh should be a regular one that we take a look at uh Etc uh there's quite a few that you know we can talk about but in trying to move this District forward we could not continue to spend the money we were spending
068and not put some sort of format in place and get some sort of assistance as to whether we will we will accept everything that a uh consultant brings to us that has never necessarily been the case but I think we've done well as a district the fact that two African-Americans males are running that organization at this point um basically are not running but one is uh Ray Hart uh who has respect we I just attended their conference which was attended upwards of over 4,000 School board members who were in presence uh who were there to learn more about that so the organization uh is certainly well respected and as with anything you're going to have people that find fault with it and that's the way the world is so I think we've done a phenomenal
069job of in in embracing uh new ideas and I'm look forward to the new leadership uh for next year uh and moving uh things forward so that we can make sure that the money that we're spending is being directed to the needs of the children and so um I just want to commend again the four board members that took the time out of their lives to uh learn more about being an effective School Board member and I don't think that you're any worth for the wear if anything you're more you're better for it and I think that's the direction we should be going into and uh as we move forward I'd like to see us continue to uh grow in that area and and be smart about not just about our goals but about everything
070that that we do and I think we'll we'll we'll have great results keeping in mind that we have we're over a billion dollars now in uh that what we're spending almost at a billion almost at two billion if you want to know the truth we had to do something better than what we were doing for the past uh um what is it uh 80 something years 90 something years we had to try something different and I think um this opens a uh open a path for us to do additional things it's called transparency and it's not pretty and it does take some work and you guys talked about your your commitment and I would never have made a recommendation for for anyone to attend it if I didn't think that it was worth it uh
071it was a nine Monon session and I'm proud of the board members that went through that Pat yourselves on the back you did a great job and so we're moving forward in this district and that's what that's what we're about so I'm proud to be a part of this team at this point Thank you thank you uh board member Cotman and then just to add you know the Council of great City schools have this framework um each district each City this you know it's focused on urban areas right and so you as a board have we as a board have to be smart also we have to customize you know this framework for our district right because the you know their Consultants we know this District this superintendent has been in this this district for
072over 35 years so if anybody know it it's her and so if it doesn't work for her and the district she's going to open her mouth and say that um so I think with any evidence-based um project like uh um this school focused outcome governance we have to customize it to work for us and that's why when we this this presentation is being presented today about super evaluation and the superintendent evaluation it will include the goals but that's not all that we're going to evaluate um the superintendent on so you know it will include relationships with the board it will include budget and finance which are all of them are critical and it will include uh Community relationships um board member herd I see your hand but I want um to also acknowledge um board
073members who have not had opportunity to speak and I see Cindy mckin is here Cindy you're up thank you Kathy can you guys hear me okay yes okay I'm sorry it's been very spotty and I've been in and out of service but I just wanted to um one thank the committee for their work in doing this uh and bringing together um I think some changes to your point um Dr Evin Brown I think that we need to make this our own and we fit right this into our um our culture right as a district and the way we function so kudos to you guys for um engaging stakeholders and having conversations um to open up that dialogue and create that opportunity and I also just wanted to address the conversation that you know was had
074with regard to the council I want to just caution you know board members and my colleagues from making accusations that you may or may not know to be true right the council represents nearly 80 urban districts across the United States having attended the conference separate from what we're doing from the student focused um governance model there are 80 urban districts that are part of the council's Coalition right and they really make sure that these districts are as prepared as possible to provide right a stellar education to its students and we're part of not just the Council of great City Schools but we're part of the big five we're part of cube we're part of different entities that serve the same purpose and we are just a member we're a member of an organization that then
075allows us to receive some of the perks right which is trainings education conferences things of that nature for both us as board members as well as dist District Personnel so I want to make sure that that's just raised up and I want to just highlight that there's we are one of nearly 80 urban districts that are members of the Council of great City Schools um and I do just want to you know uplift that as well but other than that I want to say kudos to the team um that brought this together today um and before we do close out I will want to pop on pending I'm not lost again um and just go over um a couple things for January Ary if possible okay thank you board member mckin uh Tom I mean
076uh board member her you're up yes um just a couple of things um uh some comments were made that this board didn't have any direction before the Council of great City schools and and and I think that's uh a very fraudulent remark to say that uh this board had direction we had great leadership under uh president lupas KUSI and and presidents before then and that um and that it's really a slap in the face to say that this district and this board didn't have any Direction they worked very hard and I can go back to co to where uh something happened you know to this country and as a board you know we responded very very well as a district we responded very well and that was and that was still under the leadership of
077the previous superintendent and when Dr t Williams Knight took over her leadership in this District it excelled even further you know moving forward you know and that was direction of making sure every kid you know had had some education making sure we had instruction at home making sure that our teachers and the union vient and soling these these contracts um you know here in the district so this is stuff that was done by uh this Administration and to say that this board didn't have a purpose we had a purpose we had a purpose was to educate children that's all we always did as a board to educate children and and and and make this a better community so um our our board job is to educate but as in this city as the third poor
078city of in this country we did a lot more than education we we help homes we help communities we we got mental stability um within our communities our children are suffering even to this day from from the effects of covid then this this district is is combating that there things that the Council of great City Schools didn't afford us or or teach us that's something that we knew on our own to do and and and as in spending money we spend money very very very well in this district and we have caveat our our our um Capital um projects and we also have um looked towards education for our children you know making sure money SP no directions and by the CH work very well with that the past several years and this to say
079that we ain't have no purpose Direction um with such great uh administrators here in this district is really really a slap in the face um one thing we have to do is go by New York state law we can't have no Outside Agency or nonprofit coming and tell us that we can supersede New York state law and and that's even far as this thing that we talking about this um uh um this aha committee that's New York state law with the counc council Grace scho said that we couldn't have but this Council but this Ahab committee was handpicked so it wasn't as if other board members can come in and intervene in it it was handpicked so and transparency distri has to no transparency even with cash revealing um um was we spoke with um
080and our board meetings about about transparency and we put that on our website that the public hand access everything that's going on within the district fires side grades fires aism fire suspensions fires long and short-term suspensions of fires attendance everything was plac in as apps we had been very transparent this is without the Council of great City schools and we was the first um only um District in New York state to come to seclude with the CC City school rules by Ving and working with them as as we started doing and now I understand um I guess it was mentioned last board mean that Rochester is now being involved and that was influenced by the Buffalo School District so I mean so many different variations here and um and I just know that this District
081was moving in in a very very Equitable means um before our relationship with the Council of great City schools and before we decided to work with them and the leadership CRA the schools can be brought up at another um um session uh that's not for today but I will would love to address the leadership and and the knowledge that they have um and how they you know their past history and record of of the sing schools and I think our school district is way too important just to have a nonprofit to come in and and come in and guide us and what we're supposed to do and I do not want to see the Buffalo Public School District turn into a charter District thank you thank you um board member herd uh board member makusa
082you're up okay I feel like this is something that uh we need to work on and something that the Council of great City schools has really kind of taught us is that we need to have some more conversations offline right now as a somebody who is in the community if they were to listen to what's happening right now it's a confusing mess what we're talking about right now the Council of great City Schools was brought in to do what no other board has done in the Buffalo School District which is we have chosen to have ourselves be governed we recognize that we had some stuff going on and whether or not the entity that we chose as Stellar top performing number one they are somebody they are a group that we decided to work with
083in order to better ourselves that's the bottom line yes there are you know you can't deny that people talk and there are rumors and whatever but as one of the people who have taken the course there's a difference between the actual course that you take with the Board of Education and then the individual track and I have grown from the individual ual track in ways that I couldn't even imagine and I am a trainer I am a trainer in in the business and social justice trainings but I do want to point out two things before we should move on from this conversation and we should if I um Dr uh Evans Brown I would suggest that we have maybe a a conversation or maybe a call or something amongst us board members offline that's not
084public so that we can really digest and understand what we're doing as a group before we take it to the public because I'm confused and I'm getting crazy texts about how confused everybody else is bottom line this board of education has decided to better themselves that is the truth that is straight up regardless of what you see or may hear this is what we decided to do and these are the people we decided to do it with and some of us took an extra track it doesn't make us any better or any worse that just means that we were hungry to do better after nine years I wanted to understand more and the Rochester was doing this well before us well before us so this is we are coming in kind of late all the
085other districts that have been doing this theyve been we're learning from them they're not learning from us we didn't influence anybody's decision we're learning from other districts as well so I just want to say everybody's got an opinion or whatever but here is where we are now and we have invested too much time too much money too much effort and we have brought this Community together in ways that has never been done before we need to start looking at this in the positive light that it is and will continue to be we just started this this isn't something that we're 15 years in and we haven't seen any results I feel I've been able to produce better just as an individual based on this training so there there's issues that I see but that doesn't
086mean as as far as uh Dr Evans Brown has said let's just be real about the fact that we can take in a training we can do what we want with it and we have we have altered poor Leslie has gone back and forth with us on how we would like to see Buffalo uh represented we are unique we do our own thing and she has definitely heard that we are no cookie cutter District that's right and individuals in these other trainings have heard we stand our ground so I need the public to know this is an effort that never took forth before we are you know nobody's perfect you took people from all different districts all different walks of life and you put them together in a space where we're dealing with a billion
087dollar budget a year we needed some help so let's start focusing on how we're doing what we need to do and if anybody wants to help come on board see what we're doing there's presentations coming up about what we're what we've been doing how the council great City schools have been working with us those are coming up in the near future look at the website um I'll be presenting one on December 14th other board members will be presenting as well let's just let's just take this into another direction we had we were on time we were doing great let's let's cut the negativity and let's just move forward thank you board member mcusa and I really appreciate you know that that um uh conversation and you know I've been on the board for five years
088and I don't remember anyone going out to the community to listen to what the community wants what children are able to do they have been supportive of this process every time when we did a listening tour people were interested in what the board was doing we got surveys completed um they were a aggregated into um why we're here this is how we develop our goals and prior to that our superintendent went out to the community that has never happen so if you look at the strives that we have made we're trying to put systems in place that will be here beyond our tenure on this board and so I'm GNA be proud about that to hang my hat on to something that will will work be sustainable it's almost like a road map right um
089a blueprint if you will well that this board will function without you without me and without you so thank you for that uh I thought I saw uh board member Sha's hand up yes I just want to clarify uh something um by no means was this ad hoc committee handpicked you had offered it to anyone and no one said they would do it and then twice you asked we were not handpicked I'm already on the implementation team I stepped back because I thought someone else might want the opportunity to be part of this and no one volunteered so we needed someone to go in and talk though I personally was not handpicked I think I was taken by default but I just wanted to clarify that thank you you were I also volunteered everybody was
090asked and management issues are important to me so I volunteered yeah so thank you for that Clarity um yeah yeah we weren't they weren't handpicked I I volunteer I I asked for any of the board members to be on this Ana committee on two consecutive executive committee meetings so just gooll back the tape and review it all right any other um comments from board members so we can wrap this up and as a as a the ahoc committee we will take all of what we talked about today um meet again and um some of you want stuff in writing we can do that I don't have a problem with it um but we have to get to a point that we agree to disagree okay Cindy did you have anything else that you wanted to
091note all right go ahead I did thank you um I just wanted to and I'll be following up with an email so everybody will get this but um we're hoping that January 17th um time not secured yet it is a Friday that we may be willing to go into a half day Retreat um Leslie would be coming up as we are welcoming two new board members um to the table and it could serve as a refresh for the current board members and um kind of a mini onboard for the two new board members but um is to do a um a small work session or training uh Retreat I have to come up with the right word apologies uh with our new uh our new board going into the 25 year um Leslie is hoping
092to be able to arrange it and she did ask us to consider a Friday only because um contrary to popular belief um she does not work for the Council of great City Schools exclusively um she does have a another job and so she does have to ask for time off in order to come so we're really striving for a Friday if possible for that reason um and it would be an afternoon um a few hours that board members would come together so I wanted to throw that out there now I will follow up with email likely tomorrow um to everybody just giving y'all a you know a heads up and an opportunity to respond to the email um if possible but um kind of get our marching orders for 2025 if you will but um
093thank you again Kathy um and uh you know everybody for your thoughts tonight thank you board member m catchen we'll look forward to that email all right any last minute thoughts concerns because that's all I have at this moment Dr Williams nice no it looks like people are going to get some time back U we're early so so that is good um I hear that the weather tonight is gonna get kind of nasty so you know I'll be working with David into late hours of the night to see what that looks like but you know mostly I'm just glad to hear that um you know there will be other things important things that are taken into account when looking at um you know an evaluation of the superintendent one thing to keep in mind is
094that uh the board selected for goals um New York State assessments and normally the evaluation process happens over the summer but because those scores will not be back and I'm not sure if anything needs to be approved or documented for the board to know that it's likely that the evaluation wouldn't take place for next year until sometime into the fall maybe winter for 2425 superintendent I think that was something Leslie had brought up sorry Dr Evans Brown um she did address that with us and told us to make sure that we're keeping that at the Forefront of our minds that that is further conversation that we need to you know we need to have so thank you for raising that yep absolutely yep thank you okay with with with nothing else being said this will
095conclude the executive Affairs committee see you next time have a good night stay safe be safe be blessed everyone all right Cindy be safe out there be blessed stay blessed