CorpusRecord 236741

ECSD Board of Education Meeting 1-14-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Ellenville Central School District - ECS TV
Date
2025-01-21
Location
Ulster County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,572 words · about 43 min
Collected
2026-06-30

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001call a meeting to order please rise for the pledge allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all just want to say that our ourth and prayers go out to the hundreds of thousands of people who have been affected by the wildfires in the state of California and those that have lost their lives and homes um it's our sincere hope and certainly we pray for those and thank all the uh First Responders and everybody that's contributing out there call for the a motion for the acceptance and Amendment of the December 10th 2024 meeting been moved in second discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries call for the motion uh for

002the acceptance of amendment of the December 18th 2024 meeting been moved seconded discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries public forum for this evening uh just to go over some of the ground rules uh 3 minutes U to speak and no specific uh students may be mentioned or Personnel call to the podium Patrick desan talk about grade [Music] waiting did you clap know that I would say thank you but I don't want to name a specific student but I appreciate it uh good evening everyone I appreciate giving you uh giving me some time here I'm here to speak tonight on behalf of a concerned group of parents and students about our grade waiting policy and class rank our District's policy for waiting grades for advanced placement classes and college level courses is

003lagging behind other school districts in the area and thus hurting our children's ability to be competitive in the college application process our children were identified as being candidates for Accelerated coursework almost six years ago at the end of their Elementary School this means that they've worked harder and achieved more than is required to finish high school at the top of their class the students here tonight are the cream of our crop since 9th grade they have been enrolled in AP courses and college courses offered through Sunni olster Sunni news and Syracuse University these courses are not required for graduation but they have had their minds set on higher education since junior high and they have not faltered when we first began discussing this issue as a group it was based on class ranking and how

004our District's policies surrounding it are hurting our college-bound students to quote the school board's policy on class rank the weighted grades average is used to calculate class rank for college admissions and the determination of Honor graduates the New York science technology engineering and Mathematics or stem incentive program provides tuition awards for students who graduate in the top 10% of their High School class and pursue a degree in stem at any Sunni or couni college being in the top 10% is an achievement that will save our students tens of thousands of dollars over the next several years we were very disarmed to learn that this past summer some of our students who have taken these accelerated courses since 7th grade were pushed out of the top 10% by the inclusion of the PCH Academy whose members

005are transitioning to Sunni olster for grades 13 and 14 of that program this has had serious Financial repercussions for some of our families and we do not see the logic in including the PCH Academy in class rank calculations due to the lack of colle AD missions as stated in the board policy having had several productive meetings with our school superintendent and assistant superintendant we were able to gather information about other school districts course waiting many schools had waiting systems that are multiple percentage points higher than Ellenville that means our students are sending college transcripts with equally rigorous coursework as rondout students for example but with lower gpas this puts them at a disadvantage right from the start Merit Scholarships and honor awards are also linked to GPA calculations so once again our students are facing

006Financial hardships due to this policy we urge you to bring our District's class Rank and weighted grade policy in line with other districts and help our students who have risen to every challenge we've offered them they are our best and they deserve the best thank you for your time thank you Mr [Music] Donan call to the podium Johanna Neville hi my name is Johanna Neville a senior in elville Senior High School um it was previously stated that it is impossible to um measure rigor and therefore it cannot be could not be argued that ptech classes are not as rigorous traditional students are given eight periods a day taken by a teacher instruction where PC students are given specific periods where they receive oneon-one assistance with their teachers sorry um right now I am enrolled in

007AP Government and politics English composition one through Sunni news algebra and chronometry and biology through Sunni oler while PCH students are taking robotics cyber security and Manufacturing courses through boies gym classes an elective and an engl English class at Sunni oler every other day and they also have an academic Workshop dedicated to helping them with that class PCH also is a place with uh also places heavy emphasis on presentation as business and technology are Central to the program so while these students are being graded on their elevator pitches I've been studying for five exams I have this week for each of my college classes I have been in the same classes with these students up until high school but the day they enrolled in PC the standards for our separate academic performances shifted dramatically thank

008you thank you Miss nille want to call Kayla sorry barbaria barbar barbari that was close I am one of two students who took the initiative in 8th grade to take the Regent exam for living environment and algebra during the pandemic where my fellow accelerated classmates took the option to opt out due to the pandemic this means I've completed a total of 10 region exams since I was 133 double the five required region courses ptech students completed and while they take intensive courses of their own the two are not comparable PC students are focused on a specific pathway and have equally specific assistance where they focus on technology and business my courses focus on preparing students for higher education PTEC is bringing career experience and tech-based education to them so they do not need to attend

009college or grad school there's something to be said about where we are headed after graduation I'm applying to competitive schools scholarships and honors programs in which rank may help me and students like me achieve better PCH already has a plan and courses set for them if they so choose to continue it it is not nearly as critical that they get the titles the rankings and the numbers under their belt when they've known they've had a set path for 4 years thank you Riley Donan short since seventh grade we have taken accelerated courses such as honors Math and Science Supa US history and all AP classes offered at Ellenville world history and Goen politics during this time we were led to believe that if we worked hard we would be recognized for our efforts however we

010were blindsided to learn that students enrolled in PC have a special Advantage which has bumped many other students out of the top 10 or 20 in class rankings the p tech classes are not nearly as rigorous as our classes fundamental ptech courses are taught through hands-on experience rather than lecture and exam their students spend half the day at bosis collaborating in workshops and the other half at Ellenville in the cafeteria gym and study halls they're taught to convince people to buy their business pitches we are taught to use formulas recall world history and understand the world around us even though these classes are not nearly as rigorous they are marketed as college level classes these classes are much easier than say calculus or chemistry because they're considered college classes but the PC courses have an

011extra waiting attached to them therefore many PC students who take less rigorous classes have pushed students out of the class ranking that would have worked incredibly hard over the last six years to not only take but also excel in actual college level courses we would argue that higher level region classes such as physics and geometry which have zero extra waiting are more rigorous than the pizza classes additionally all of us here have taken AP AA and other college level courses these courses are weighted at 5% Mrs W's office office did research and discovered that elville waiting system is at the lower end than the vast majority of area districts the majority of the other districts weigh their classes as high as 10% when asked if Ellenville would consider changing the waiting policy we were told

012probably not this year because it wouldn't be fair to students who may have taken more college level courses had they known they would be weighted higher we would like to argue the reverse what you're doing to us this year is not fair for 6 years we have worked and excelled saying you will change maybe change this policy in the future is not doing the right thing by us you're letting us down the class ranking is impacting us as we apply for colleges scholarships honors programs and internships we were told the rankings shouldn't matter that much instead colleges will also be looking at the courses we took and the effort we gave but how holistically a school will look at applications varies from place to place and also can't be measured this belittles the hard work

013we put into place the last six years and puts us at a disadvantage against students with more academic opportunities what lesson does this send to students coming after us that Ellenville is telling younger students is that if they take easier classes their GPA will be higher and they will move up in the class rankings I would ask that the board please reconsider evaluating linville's class waiting system please do right by all students not just the p tech kids thank you r first and foremost I want to say to the young ladies that came up here and and spoke not an easy task to come up and speak in front of an audience especially when you're on TV um certainly proud of each each and every one of you very very very fluent and very eloquent

014in your presentations and we thank you for that and we take everything that you say to heart um we we've listened we hear you um we are I have um directed to this issue be taken back up by the policy committee it's being referred back to the policy committee policy committee will take a look at exactly what you have said they will examine everything and they will report back uh to the to the whole board once they have met uh we have um Iris uh Freeman we want to get a meeting together um of the policy committee as soon as possible and uh that will be one of the issues that the policy committee tackles amongst others well certainly they'll be looking uh at that is there anything you like to add superintendent no I

015I think um marisel and I spoke today about getting a policy uh meeting set you know in the next couple of weeks and probably set quite a few of them there's various policies that need to be reviewed but this will be the first one that we so just want to be clear so you understand there's a process to this right we cannot as a board arbitrarily make a decision here when we have policies in place uh the the correct procedure is to refer something back to the policy committee have them make the recommendations to the whole board it would be um it would be improper and certainly not prudent for the board to make an arbitrary uh decision without referring it back to the policy Committee in light of the fact that there's already a

016standing policy ours I just would uh like to ask the superintendent when we convene the meeting if she would have the list of the schools in the area and what their weight waiting policy is and their and their weight percentages um we did put out a uh request from certain districts to let us know we did get information back from a few not all so um Mrs White will make sure to put that back out again to see if we can um compile some additional schools that were non-responsive and we'll hear from arisol about arranging a meeting for a time yes we talked about that yesterday thank you and if there's any other information you need please don't hesitate to ask is there anything you want to supply uh to the administration for the policy

017committee to take into consideration I can't hear him can't hear you Pat I'm sorry yeah go back up there please so I would just ask that if the board could look at the current policy that one of our positions um the board policy is that weighted grades are used for the purpose of college admissions and honor graduates so that certain students that are in the class of 20125 cohort in the PC program which is a New York State education approved program that is a Grade 9 through 14 program that they are not looking for college admissions they are already part of this dual program with Sunni ster so they from our opinion would not be included in that weighted average because they are not applying to colleges so thank you for that Pat and the

018board the policy committee chair is here and they will definitely take that into consideration Jody can we also get information with other schools that have the PTEC program how they wait their grades and how and if the top 10% is affected yes so there's one other school that we know of that has a school within a school um the other PCH program we'll ask the question we'll ask a question to see how included any other board members even if it's not within our district can we check with PCH programs throughout New York State how how it's included for those students if they're with school within a school yeah Miss Neville I just I had a very unique experience where I have I'm sorry I can't understand you I'm sorry could you speak a little more

019clearly yeah I've had a very unique experience where my entire life I have worked very hard to excel in all of my classes and with in these past few months I have been looking into colleges and applications and soon the Sunni program sent out a top 10% promise which I was qualified for but I was pushed out of because of the PTEC being included in the top 10 so before I have already um committed to a college I've already lost hundreds of dollars in application fees when that would have been already promised to me which is very FR frustrating which I understand that's not something you guys can control but it would have been prevented by the ptech not being included in the top 10 or them having something separate as in a different R

020ranking that's all I'd like to say thank you thank you m anybody else to be heard on this matter John yeah Phil I was going to wait till the uh board comments to say this I just want to say to the students and the parents I'm completely in awe of what you've done and uh how high you've achieved uh I was not capable of doing that in high school um and and I think it's really amazing I think the thing that I or but nobody else wants to get into here is a ptech students versus honors or Advanced college students um you know competition I'm also in our of our ptech students who have made such progress coming out of the um coursework that they've had and made a six-year commitment to do what they

021do I will say this uh I've mentioned to the board members before my concern that perhaps we mishandled this and I'm not above make you know admitting to making a mistake I think our job is to to correct those things I was told that this is what the state has always done and it was from a state decision and my point of view is that we didn't handle it properly in notifying you folks with enough time to get that done I can promise you though I will Advocate to justify by the um weighted grades going forward and uh I understand the frustration you have with colleges when you've uh worked so hard to achieve what you have and uh I I can promise you that I'll will do my best to try and take care

022of that and I am sorry that you got to your senior year before you found this out thank you Mr Burns anybody else okay thank you thank you parents um very proud of you guys for coming in and uh we will definitely the policy committee will take a serious look at this and they'll dig into it as fast as possible and we'll get back to you okay thank you if you want to stay you can I'm sure you don't want to but you're more than welcome to stay so for uh we're going to move on the reports and correspondence so for myself and speaking with the superintendent and also with some of the board members um there's been a lot said about the about the Arts as you know we went through a lot with

023the uh with the referendum and and different things uh we want to make sure that the every aspect of the Arts um and not just music is heard right there's different components to Arts it's not just about music it's about all the Arts when we talk about the the Arts um so we want to uh in in confirming with the superintendent we feel it's prudent to establish an uh an Arts committee and um I would like the people the board members are following board members to um sit on that committee and um if this is a surprise which it is um I'm not going to apologize in advance so I would like uh if Iris Freeman would sit on it Lisa Ramirez um Willie Bruce and jod and if jod would take the the uh

024chair is that good sufficient and then I'm going to refer back to the superintendent because there are going to be some administrators on it they'll talk about you guys will meet at this committee to talk about initiatives what's going on I want to be perfectly clear that and the superintendent wants me to make sure I drive this home as well going to be uh extremely clear about what the the purpose is we are not there to negotiate with art any form of the art any art teachers or um staff that's in there if any of these initiatives or discussions even borderline that that's why you'll have the superintendent there you'll have any delegates that she see deems fit there uh those uh discussions will be halted and they will be referred back to the district

025and to the union for the proper venue for negotiations so while this committee is important in its job and what we want what we expect because we want to hear what the initiatives are and we want to hear what goes on in our school district we want to see that to be uh successful as well and the recognition to be there and I know that I had talked a couple years ago and established a um an Arts Hall of Fame we wanted to do an Arts Hall of Fame it really never took off it really never got its you know never got its uh mustard so to speak um but um this could sort of uh roll into that you we have this kind of uh this kind of committee and everybody puts their heads

026together and maybe we can get something like that so the recognition that um our different um components of the Arts takes place can also be recognized as well as Athletics because John does a superb job with the athletic Hall of Fame and all the people that he has the support we could also have something similar with the Arts it's part of this initiative but we'll see where it goes um you guys will establish a meeting superintendent will be in touch with every everybody and we will go from there I just want to also make a comment we will have we will have um representatives from The Faculty on you know working with the committee also on ideas thoughts their initiatives I just to go back to what Phil says I just want to make sure

027we don't discuss anything contractual at those meetings really initiatives things we could you know possibly fund other activities so really a a brainstorming um a committee for how we can you know uh promote the art in our district and enhance and um expand just make sure it's an equal playing field basically is that everybody gets heard and and and we can promote where we can promote so I I'd just like to share an interesting little aside so there's a um chamber music concert tomorrow night um with the um high school and I think Junior High and um I I knew about it and I looked on the calendar and on the calendar it just says that there's this chamber concert no place no time um when I looked on the front of the website down

028the side there are a lot of writeups about different events not a mention so maybe that's would be one of the places we could start is to get the information correct and get it out there about what they already are doing um I I was surprised because I looked at other events on the calendar on the paper calendar mind you and they had times and places for all these events and that was missing so it's odd to me that um I I don't know why those kind of things are happening but that's part of what we have to really look at I also want to make sure because we do bring in you know we bring in the fall Athletics we bring in the summer you know the spring athletic uh those that are you

029know teams to be recognized I want to make sure that we bring to the board superintendent if you can make a a point of this any of those students who um have achieved some special recognition with the Arts programs and any component of the Arts so that we could recognize them as well in this form just like we recognize everybody else so let's make sure that we make a point of that Lisa your enion go this the beauty of just you know in a in a one sentence Mission what what do we see as the problem and the goal that that we're forming a special committee I don't think that there's a problem I think the mission or the charge of the committee would be to go back meet with the administration and the faculty

030and faculty different faculty members at at the discretion of the superintendent and her staff and to um to come up with uh what in it what can what can we do like what can we do to have some initiatives for the Arts and to be re more recognition what is there what do they need and what can we help them with um to make this program and any of the components of the Arts more successful in our district so so so essentially raise the profile of our offerings the recognition of it right and raise the profile CU obviously there's there's work to be done and not just in the other side of it right there's work to be done for all components of the Arts and there's work that and and we can help and

031we can help in whatever way we can the administration can help let them be heard let people be heard unless see what we can do to work together to collaborate to bring more uh attention and more focus and success to the program and maybe get more participation in it as a result okay that's all I have other board members John and by the way thank you on the job you're doing um Hall of Fame well thank you uh I I want to um just congratulate you and Lisa for bringing forth this initiative about the Arts um I know everybody on the board really enjoys celebrating any of the achievements that our uh students do and I think that will help us continue our efforts there I did want to mention speaking of the Hall of

032Fame that we are working on the Hall of Fame wall display for the upcoming building improvements we're going to have a Hall of Fame wall uh where where the current athletic director's office is and so we we're beginning to start to chase down some pictures going as back far as we can I'm working with our athletic director Tim Lucas zesi and The Architects and putting this wall together so anybody that even wants to contact us and and has pictures of the past going backwards uh we'd like to take a look at that and while I'm mentioning the Hall of Fame we are currently open for nominations for next year's uh class and I'd like to encourage anyone who thinks they know of a Hall of Fame worthy candidate team or coach to nominate them you

033can find the forms on our district website or call the athletic director's office so we can have another great induction next fall thank you thank you any other board members yes Willie okay we promise there'll be snacks if you want to come Willie is your mic on please is it working now can you hear me now can we have the um I'd like to understand when the Top 10 rankings are published I'll answer good the Top 10 rankings are calculated and published at the after the end of the second semester in accordance with the policy that we have after the end of the second semester second quarter first semester okay thank you so then around this time uh right probably the end of January after all the tests and grades are submitted so usually it

034it's not the end of January it'll be sometime in February after it's calculated usually the end of February I I would ask that the board be provided with those rankings when they're available please of course [Music] um tonight was the first time I seen public session handled the way it was and I'll just leave that there so so in the future I would expect public session to be handled in a very similar manner as tonight can you elaborate please uh uh certainly so uh typically in public session people who want to speak are given a certain amount of time to to present to the board or address the board usually there is no response from board members to the folks who uh who are addressing the board in addition to that people are not allowed

035to return to the Podium to the podium after they have used their time so I would just like to understand I would just like to make it plain that I would expect now in the future that public session be conducted the same way since it's been a change thank you Mr President thank you anybody else I I'd like to I'm sorry I um I'm not sure about that willing I'm not comfortable with it that's what happens I I like you know the way that when it's more organized I don't know why it was allowed to proceed this way tonight um I guess that's a question for the chair well I don't I don't I'm not questioning it I just want to okay well I I'll leave that for you John uh in the past we've

036been told that the ments back to people who come to the board would be handled by the president and the superintendent and I can respect that I think that to to lock ourselves in I mean i' I've been around a long time Willie I've seen a lot of board meetings in a lot of districts get really out a hand with stuff um the three minute limit you know sometimes you give a little bit more on that and if you have 25 people speaking we're here till tomorrow morning so it's it's kind of a difficult thing I think the one thing that we we' put out to the public Mr President and Madame superintendent is that we will listen to people when they have concerns it's their District it's our district we all do the best

037that we can and I think that sometimes Willie you might have to just give a little bit you know the young man that spoke to us a couple of meetings ago we gave him you know more time and I thought that was just a great thing we did so I'd like to see us continue to evaluate situations of course again that is up to the uh president of the board but to evaluate situations and make sure we continue to let people know we hear them out when they have concerns about our district and our kids I do not disagree with that trusty Burns I'm in 100% support of that thank you all right Mr Jacks didn't mean to put you on the spot there pres it's okay it's okay feedback is always important and sometimes

038when we're in the the moment I will just say that uh we were in the moment I think it's important to hear from our students and I think sometimes um when issues like this come up I don't think that as a board um we should shut it down I think the dialogue is important I hear you Willie I think that it has to be applied equally and consistent and consistently across the board um but I do not want to be a board that's known to shut our students down and I think it's imperative that these young people have a voice I think they went about it the proper way I think they want it to be heard and I think it's uh incumbent upon this board to hear from each and every individual student and

039um member of our community whether it takes uh whether it takes a in the whether it takes the shape of a curveball now and then it takes the shape of a curveball this was a little bit of a curveball but uh I thought that um in uh sitting where I'm sitting I thought it was very important that we listen to our uh our our young people our young people are the Future Leaders uh who are going to be sitting in our chairs someday and Abraham Lincoln said that very eloquently when he delivered his uh speech um several times uh from his uh podium in Washington so I think that um the more we continue to hear our young people maybe we'll get more people to come here and speak so um we will I definitely

040will take that under advisement thank you thank you Jack thank you for the explanation Mr Jack Henry speaking of hearing from our young people oh good evening so for happenings and events um school will not be in session next week because region week will be next week I think you need to clarify that Jack um the high school or the high school the junior senior high school because all of a sudden you'll have all the elementary staying home oh so rehearsals for both shows bom Mia for the senior high is now underway the junior high production of Beetlejuice will also be in early February tomorrow night for uh Iris here the senior high band will perform in their evening of chamber music at 7:00 in the elementary Auditorium so it's only the senior high at

0417:00 in the Ellenville Elementary music assembly room for athletics last week the boys basketball team won 65 to6 triple overtime last Tuesday they have a game against Highland at 6:00 on Friday at home the girls varsity basketball is on the road against Liberty tomorrow and on Highland on Friday and then both teams were at home this past Friday to raise money for the American Cancer Society as well as honoring three people in the district who are currently battling cancer the three people that were honored were Isabella Neville Mrs dams and Mrs scko both teams won decisively against do in the back to back finally in the for the fundraisers class of 2026 has finished a bun Kake fundraiser which is due tomorrow and because it's a new year there's new merchandise for sale if you'd

042like to buy blue Devil's merchandise you can go to tinyurl.com ecsd merch or you can use the QR code thank you Jack move on to assist uh superintendent Lisa WS a few things this evening I just want to remind the board that next Tuesday uh at 5:30 we'll be having a construction Workshop um the first one to lay out some timelines and expectations of the capital project that was approved in December uh there's information in your packet about it it'll be 5:30 in the media center there's no it is not a public meeting in that there'll be no action taken is just a workshop and we will have the representatives from um our design team and so forth there uh we did have the opportunity to meet with the town of aing uh with regard

043to the grant that they have with the pool and the timing of the work that's going to be done on the pool through the Grant and the um and the building of the concession stand slash multi-purpose room that'll be um utilized by the town for the summer time so uh they are moving forward with the Grant and we are in close contact with them um they've been to some of our meetings to make sure that we are coordinating and collaborating on the on the timeline uh next Tuesday no excuse me next Thursday the 23rd um there's going to be an ster County School boards meeting the invitation in your packet in at Kingston I believe at the um Best Western I don't know of the time but it's in the invitation this is um an

044annually they have the legislators that represent um our school districts there to talk about legislative priorities and um what the Outlook is with regard to the upcoming uh budget process uh School uh board members can submit any questions or clarifications that they want so take a look at that um flyer I think it's it would be great if anybody wants to go just let Marisol know and we will respond for you along the same lines um we are waiting patiently um with high expectations hopefully that we're not disappointed on what the governor's proposal is going to be for the state aid uh for the 252 School 26 school year just remember whatever comes out that's not the final number there'll be negotiations that happen during the process where kind of used to this but um

045the governor should be releasing The Proposal that she has sometime at the end of January so we're waiting for that just one comment I want to make about the website I know um while the just really live time um Vince took a look at the events um and we've been struggling with the website a little bit remember this is a new website and there's a whole section on events um and it's driven by our building use forms and other information that gets fed in there so we're going to take a look at this and really try to see how we can feed it because if you go down and click a box it says all events things are listed there but we also have things that are listed there that might not be meaningful to

046the public to look at it we're not sure we have we're going to have to reach out to Bose's and apigy to see what other type of um options we have to highlight certain events and not others but we have been working on it we have been struggling with it you know we don't not only is the concerts not on here but any of our competitions are not on here so like we want to look at everything to see we how we can make it um more user friendly for our parents because I don't think we need a little work on it so you know we'll get on that tomorrow so it's there but it's buried so we have to and what happens just so you all know when we have a building use form

047that comes in let's say I'm looking at this the YMCA schools out before and after school that's every day and that's there right so does that really have to be there not necessarily so we just implemented a new building use form and on it we have does this want to be on the website or not on the website so that we can we can we can enter it in the system and have it have it either show or not show depending upon what we have so we're in the process of putting that together but uh we are going to take a look at this I just want a quick question um I I noticed on the right hand side of the homepage there it says live at the top and then there there are writeups

048about different things who who does that who does the writing for that and and submit that so live feeds can come from anybody right so comes through the administrators it gets submitted to olster bosies and they'll they'll add a live feed we can add it also sometimes we'll call um Tim and Allen and say I'm not sure if they're doing it anymore but they used to do it mostly it's ster bosis that does it we don't have a full-time PR person here on staff that does it we contract so someone sends them the information and they write something up and then and then put it on the I see okay thank you and you get to pick on the website we got to pick different formats that you could use and we we picked the

049most what we thought was the most user friendly but how we're feeding the information in we've had to modify a few times since we went live with this doesn't mean that we won't modify it again thank you assistant superintendent for business Mr Vincent ay thank you we've been patiently waiting to see if the governor would um kick down the road the can about the electric school buses and that has not happened yeah so we've been patiently waiting and watching other schools um Venture down the roads of Grants and so we met with Beacon Mobility they're the company that purchased rolling V and we decided to with them or through them apply for an electric bus Grant there's no obligation on our part if we get the grant but we want to see how much money

050we could get for electric for an electric school bus or school buses once we are notified that we got the grant then we'll take a look at how that will how many buses and how that will impact our bus routes which bus routes we might want to convert to Electric school buses if those routes if the bridges can handle the weight of a school bus all those things that are instrumental in determining whether or not electric school bus um implementation will be successful so more to follow on that they did apply for the grant um we endorse their application then we'll see where it goes from there so I just want to make a comment we don't have to accept the grants funding um but we put in for it and in a so it's

051done in a timely manner so we're not going to be owning buses here right Beacon Mobility will own the buses but One Way Or Another We're going to pay for it whether it's in the contract that we have to enter into um because we don't have our own Fleet so there will be a cost to the district it's a matter of can we secure funding for with Beacon Mobility to minimize those costs to us so more to come um but we have to look into it as Vince said this is not it doesn't appear that this is going to be changed or going away Danny it's a little disappointing that our governor is stated a unfunded mandate but have we done anything internal to see if our bus garage can support X number of Chargers

052have we looked Nationwide to see what the safety record is of some of these electric school buses um there's there's a lot I think we can probably do as a district to see if this is even feasible to maybe even present something to State leadership that this small community cannot support this that's part of the study that has to happen to see through um through Beacon Mobility they have to work with the municipality I'm sorry the the supplier the utility Central Hudson in this case to see if infrastructure in the village can handle charging school buses and how many how far the the route is whether the charge of the school bus can handle it so th those are things that all the school business officials and as well as um nerta and the contractors

053and bus manufacturers have been looking at all of those variables are what make it difficult to implement this but what they are being looked at and across a couple of years um so yeah there been I also want to add that there are associations like the New York State Council of school superintendents that are heavily lobbying um those concerns to the legislative branches and the governor because we are concerned about it the problem is is we don't want to lose a funding support or opportunity so nothing lost if we apply we don't necessarily have have to move forward with it but if we can if we can minimize the cost to us and we have to do it we were hoping that this was going to get you know delayed so that there would be

054more time for the study and really the infrastructure to be put in so thank you John yeah Vince I think the governor has kept all of us in the dark on this um nothing's been spoken about the deadline of when this all has to be done um and Lisa you just mentioned cost at a workshop I went to um they said that the average gas bus will cost you 125 150,000 the electric buses will cost you between 350,000 and 400,000 uh again all the questions that Danny raises on Space they have to be so far apart because if one goes on fire it just goes down the road and uh nobody so far has said from any of the utilities company that they could handle the charging the last thing that the governor has not

055mentioned is that this needs to be approved over by a referendum of our voters and I have a hard time believing that our voters are going to go for that nor would I feel comfortable asking them to spend three times on a bus what we already do when we don't know what the lifespan of that bus is and the continued cost so Madam superintendent when you talk about increased costes we're clearly going to use the brunt of that and I'd rather have cost of 150,000 a bus that's reli than 350 or 400,000 that we don't know cuz the bus company isn't absorbing that themselves thank you Iris um yeah I just I guess I'm a little confused for a change um so we're we're applying for a grant but we don't own buses we we

056contract with a bus company we are not applying for the grant we endorsed or are in support of Beacon Mobility applying for this grant through ni okay so they need our support in order to apply for the grant if we said no we're not interested then I mean we have no intention of owning our own buses and Building a garage and having a fleet or any of that absolutely yeah okay I'm sorry being contracted is the way we have been working for 20 years but I just want to say to go to John's point we're going to pay one way or the another we're not going to buy the bus I understand that but the cost of Beacon or any other cont will pass it back down onto us right thank move on to personel

057resolutions no I'm sorry I'm not done oh you're not yeah I I have I have one more thing really you're I I do I'm usually very quiet I know and you'll get to hear me over over the next couple weeks doing my budget presentations but but there is a topic in here that I hopefully everyone had a chance to read did you change your name to Willie and that there was um some legislation past where we can extend to firemen and ambulance workers uh First Responders to get a discount on their property tax we have to pass a resolution by March in order for this to take effect for the next taxing period we've done this for the veterans and for the age so we've done this before firefighters too I think at it right

058now I said firemen didn't I that's just now yeah thank you so we we don't have to decide tonight but we have to decide soon if we want to move forward and pass the resolution we have we have um exemptions for some for who for um veterans and also um senior citizens have a fireman too I don't have the l i I think we have firemen also but we'll double check I thought we did too but I don't know we'll get the list for you for the next meeting and check out the information that's in the packet that he included I think that's what just Vince um I just want if you could help me with this one so when I would be in in favor of helping anybody with tax relief but uh we

059would lose do you have a ballpark on what it would cost us in the tax revenue that we collect and is the governor going to reimburse us for those costs okay so um it doesn't work that way if let's say that I'm a fireman and I get a 10% on my property tax and I see a $300 savings the district still levies that $300 but it gets spread out among the other taxpayers I don't think I understood what you're talking about so you have assessed valuation right and then let's say you have a I got it now you have aund you have it but you know for people watching yes goe if the more people that are exempt right the property burden Falls to everybody else it's not exempt that's the easiest way to put

060it and I'm 99% sure that we have have an exemption for firefighters I think you we should look it up on board dos but I think these are for First Responders so EMS and and other things but I we'll get back to you on that all right thank you move on to uh personal resolutions for this evening under 5.1 upon recommendation superintendent of schools Mr President I I know that uh Kelly and Scott are not here if we had a question or anything that they put into their information can we ask that or do we want wait till after I think we want to wait for them since they're I had a general one about it for for Lisa if she could help sure uh Lisa under Kelly's uh document at the bottom of her

061board report she talked about and and listen I know that Susan Ireland and Kelly and Scott and everybody have been working on uh trying to reduce our uh absenteeism rate our chronic absenteeism rate and we've dropped that by about 23% from what I could see since last year I think that's great but is this to bring in attendance mentors that are teachers to work with kids so my understanding and we can clarify this at the next meeting um when we were looking at the best practices of a school district Upstate the Johnston School City Schools or School District this is one of the initiatives that they had where they had attendance monitors not only teachers but um staff members that would work with let's say three students get a stien for it that would be

062funded out of the school Improvement um Grant so when we wrote the school Improvement Grant we included that initiative that doesn't lock Us in um we surely can modify the grant um but they we did try to set aside some funds that could be considered for this and I believe that um they were modeling this initiative after um the Johnston City schools that saw really a a big um an impact from from this from students having connections and people following up this is very preliminarily preliminary there has to be expectation set there has to be negotiations that go forward and we have to see if if we even want to move forward with this so I I guess just because I saw that Kelly put in that this had been board approved but it was

063the plan not necessarily this this hasn't been board approved so to speak but the the school Improvement plan did come to the board with all the initiatives we were looking at but that could be employ a attendance officer right we do okay thank you move on to Personnel resolutions for the evening 5.1 final recommendation superintendent of schools be resolved that Aaron Army's request to extend her unpaid leave of absence through February 14th 2025 be approved second moved in seconded discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries 5.2 upon a recommendation superintendent of schools be resolved that seia Stubblefield be appointed as a long-term substitute teacher so moved moved and seconded discussion Lisa oh okay all those in favor opposed no one motion carries 5.3 cafeteria monitor upon recommendation superintendent of schools be resoled

064the resignation of Kiana Francis as cafeteria monor be accepted effective December 11th 2024 and moved and seconded second discussion why the uh previous date December 11th that was the date she submitted her letter of resignation okay anybody else all those in favor opposed no one motion carries 5.4 B recommendation superintendent of schools be resolved the resignation of Audrey ottero cafeteria monitor be accepted effective January 14 2025 moved second discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries teacher Aid resignation f a recommendation superintendent of schools be resolved the resignation of Harriet stio as a teacher Aid be accepted for the purposes of the retirement effective January 3rd 2025 with regret second I moved in seconded discussion all those in favor oppos no one motion carries teacher a appointment a recommendation superintendent of schools be

065resolved that Zia Parvin be appointed a 1.0 full-time equivalent teacher Aid position at a pro rated contractual rated 28137 step one pro rated effective January 15th it's been moved second seconded discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries 57 final recommendation superintendent of schools be it resolved that t castio be appointed as a 1.0 full-time equivalent teacher a position and a contractual R 28137 step one pro rated effective January 15 2025 moved second discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries 5.8 substitute Personnel upon ation superintendent schools be it resolve the following substitute Personnel be appointed for the 2425 school year list has been moved is there a second second second glad to see one of our retired uh teachers coming back there a couple of our three of our retired

066teachers coming back back very nice um all those in favor opposed no one motion carries 5.9 extended day upon a recommendation superintendent of schools be resoled the following Junior Senior High School extended day Personnel be approved contractual rate for25 school year it's been moved second discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries 5.10 professional development upon a recommendation superintendent of schools be resoled that Ashley Aliano be app approved for up to 12 hours of PD as described in the attached proposal to be completed between January 15th and April 8 2025 it's been moved is there a second there's a second all those in favor opposed no one motion carries 5.11 co-curricular upon recation superintendent of schools be it resolved the following co-curricular Personnel be approved the contractual rate move the list the list

067has been moved and do I have a second it's been second discussion is this start has this started this year they did not start the club yes they did not they're not going to be able to get in okay but they should be able to get in after it's proved to excellent when did we create a ski club we've had years years how many people are in the ski club I think it varies um last year we did not have one I I think um when my kids were there was two full buses right definitely one full bus thank you anybody else all those in favor opposed I am upstanding as the one of those are one of my officers 5.12 upon a recommendation superintendent of schools be resolved that Ryan McIntyre be appointed as

068AP World History review at a contractor rate of $55 per hour work not to exceed 2 hours per week effective March 17th through May 8th so move been moved seconded discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries interal Sports fin recation superintendent of schools be res the following individual be approved for interal Sports for the 2425 school year at a rate of $47 per hour work it's been moved seconded discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries psycho educational evaluations upon a recommendation superintendent of schools be resolved that Teresa Shey Julia Cruz and Aubrey Cara Caro how do you say her name car car car car car car that's a tough one we approved to conduct and compete up to uh complete up the total of 50 evaluations at the contractual

069hourly rate before and after it's been moved second second discussion John so does this go to one of the shortages that we have in that area yes we're missing uh we're missing FTE psychologists we've been advertising we haven't gotten any applications just in in the times that we're in probably we'd rather have those positions filled uh have we taken any extraordinary steps to do this um I I'll double check thank you anybody else if not all those in favor oppose no one motion carries budget resolution somebody want to move those move 61 through 63 un moved second second discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries IPS for this evening be resolved list of attached list of two 90ps be acknowledge as appropriate there are 60 move list has been moved and second

070discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries somebody want to move construction resolutions Mr President move 81 through 85 I'm moved second second discussion all those in favor opposed no one motion carries under other for this evening 91 through 912 been moved um can I just ask a question about 91 sir well let me get it on the table first it's only been moved second moved and seconded discussion Iris I just don't know what this is um it's 91 intermunicipal arrangement RTC o n e risk Operation Center what is this for what give me a minute to read it please this is a it is it is an agreement um to work with the Mid Hudson Regional information center regarding student privacy and entering you have to have an intermunicipal agreement to authorize

071uh them to look at our privacy agreements with regard to data and the network so you have to have a resolution to work with the giving the Rick permission to to facilitate our privacy agreements in accordance with the regulation okay okay M Mr President do you think that if you read the entire six paragraphs it would clear it up more I don't think so but I appreciate you John um no further discussion all those in favor voting for oppos No One motion carries mark your calendars we have a meeting set for next Tuesday it'll be construction meeting to kick off um getting ready uh getting our plans uh together to start going forward with our uh you know our uh referendum that was passed by the taxpayers so we look forward to that we're going

072to get moving get our feet on the ground and get going um our next meeting after that regular meeting will be January 28th 2025 Mark your calendars for that is there anything else Mr President will that meeting be covering all of the capital projects or just that one Capital project it's the upcoming Capital project all we're going to be talking about is the timeline and the pacing of the schedules and the submitt of the plans thank you thank you Mr President would we consider going into executive session for one minute after this to address a question on Personnel um yes we can uh we can definitely do that we have a motion to retire into executive session not to reconvene in public session moved and seconded discussion all those in favor oppos no one motion

073carries thank you we are in executive session and we will not reconvene uh you want these kids to leave yeah we will not reconvene

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.