CorpusRecord 240353

Hamilton City School District Board of Education Meeting 1-23-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / TvHAMILTON
Date
2025-01-24
Location
Butler County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,640 words · about 21 min
Collected
2026-06-27

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good afternoon we will go into our work session for um meeting for the Hamilton City School Board today January 23rd 2025 uh roll call Mr Fraser Mrs Matthews here Mr sprag here Mrs Baker here Mr Davidson here Dr Copus here all right thank you um our first item on our agenda in our Open Session work meeting would be board member reimbursement for uh PD xmes yes uh thanks president Matthews um this was a conversation if you remember at our organizational meeting um and we discussed reviewing our current policy on I believe Mr sprag brought up the IDE aide of do we want every piece of PD to need to run through the board do we want to set some thresholds with that and I know earlier this week there were some conversations about what is

002the district going to prepay uh for board members to attend on the district's behalf and not so this is really just an open floor um for conversation related to this yeah I oh I'm sorry man that's okay I actually I had a circumstance this week uh I was going to attend a webinar actually I don't know how it didn't go through but I was going to put it on my own credit card and then I started looking at this policy and I thought oh my gosh $50 and I would have to bring if I want reimbursement I'd have to bring it through the entire full board and that just doesn't make any sense so to me also I think on some of these you know community events or whatever that if we intend on going

003there's nothing that says just pay for it yourself you know we're all adults we don't need Melissa tied up with you know scheduling things for us that we just go ahead and and do it and then um bring it to Mr Fraser and and he'll reimburse us for it so I I I think that you know anywhere from 250 to 500 I think makes sense I I'm fine I wouldn't go any less than 250 I wouldn't go over 500 that's my my thought you know my thought is your school related functions like state of the school um the you know we have the um academic honors dinner Scholars all that uh Melissa's already making reservations for Andrea and Mike and and Jeremy I don't think it's more of a hassle for her to do it

004for us I I I think any school related um function should be covered under this that we don't need board approval for it um I would like to see Lang language in our policy that if you do sign up for something and you don't notify um you know Andrea within 24 hours that you must reimburse the district for that if you don't attend if you don't attend um it's there's been a lot of events where I've been at and I shouldn't say a lot maybe three or four where we've had a board members tag still there at the end of the the function and Andrea even said that's kind of embarrassing for the district district and if if you're not going to go let's not waste taxpayer money uh and pay for it it should

005come out of your pocket so I'd like to see something we do have emergencies that come up um and you usually know those and there may be extenda circumstances that day family member gets sick and and has to go to the hospital well then the board as a group could then you know say no that that's covered but on most part you know it should be 24 hours my I I I don't disagree with what you're saying um I don't disagree with what you're saying but in my mind is if we if we go ahead if I decide that I'm going to go to the chamber dinner and I can go ahead and and do that then at if something happens at the last minute and I can't go well then we don't have to

006go back to Jeremy and reimburse them we just lose the money because it's coming out of our pocket and and I just think that it you know we're adults we don't need to we can do our own take care of our own reservations that's my opinion I you know my whole career I've always made my own reservations well but at some events we are seated at the same table I I I I can sort of see where Dave is on this with the if for C doing reservations already just do the reservations and I I don't want the district to lose money what I'm but where my concern was was those situations where do we have some leniency like mag wanting to do a a webinar or if I want to do some professional development

007instead of coming to the board for a $50 reimbursement and let's remember we are not being paid to be on this board but having some reimbursement for some sort of an activity that we either represent the board in some capacity or we are doing it as a PD for our ourselves then I I think being reimbursed for those type of expenses with without going through all the the hassle I won't say hassle because jerem is usually pretty easy to work with thank you very much Jeremy but having but having having that ability to tap into let's say $200 $250 is fine with me I don't see us abusing it I don't think we've abused it in the past but having that ability and that that to me also encourages us as a board to do

008things that we may not uh not always have the thing like I know we had the 17th strong conference coming up uh and maybe have I don't know if we're going as a as a uh if there's I assume you're going maybe not you're not going I don't know what you're do presenting you're presenting well then I'm going but uh but having that ability to make those reservations without having to go through the board I think is something and then if if we then if Melissa says hey does anybody want to go then we can say oh I already made my reservation so could we sparse this into two because I think we're having two different that would fall underneath this policy so one I think the first discussion is is whether or not the

009district is going to purchase and I hear both sides of that coin um it is nice when we're able to sit together as a group and to make those and block reservations it also helps us to make sure that you get those tickets quickly um in those pieces so I I definitely see that side as well um but I do believe if the district is going to frontload those then building something in like Mr Davidson has referred to where if the employee doesn't attend they have to reimburse the district and maybe that's even something that if we're going to V you know vary from that particular practice they could bring that to the board to explain reasons I don't know I don't know if we want to get that much in the weeds or what

010that looks like yeah I think it's good and I think makes Point too like her webinar y that we had we have a $500 or2 250 or something for that I and I think that's great that they're all pre-approved I'd also like to see something in there encouraging the board to go to Capital conference we we need to start attending that again in district meetings you know I agree some of what Mrs baker said Mr spra and also Mr Davidson but I'd like to see Mrs blevens something where you know you pick the three or four events that you feel the board members absolutely should attend and then maybe Melissa could you know contact us are you going to attend yes the district buys those tickets I agree with Mrs Baker there should be some

011leeway there where the board members have flexibility to kind of pick and choose what they want to do I agree with Mr spray you know we shouldn't have to wait for board approval to to register for a class or something that you want to attend and I also agree with Mr Davidson that if if I tell you I'm going to go and I don't go I should be held responsible for that uh and whatever policy we do finally agre board policy we agree on I'd like to see us try to keep it easy on Mr Frasier so he doesn't have to track down my nickel he thanks you for that I can see that smile thank you any other kind of discussion well what I'd like to propose is at our next work session bringing

012a draft policy that captures some of these to give us a starting point you know we threw this on the agenda just for an open discussion I wasn't sure where the board wanted to go with this particular piece building in the language and then we can kind of pick and choose from there and and go from that piece makes sense sounds good sound okay perfect y okay the next item that's on um our agenda is the proposed athletic Fieldhouse update um so I am not sure if our entire board I I kind of came to this conversation a little bit through the backside through this transition um but there were some conversations that were happening about a possible High School athletic Fieldhouse and I I believe that Dr Copus approach Mrs Baker as president and

013just said hey how can we discuss this what is a good piece forward and U Mrs Baker directed our team to put together a committee to start somewhere where are we almost doing the first part of a feasibility study so I did share this first memo um that I received from the committee on their initial findings um to open up and and my question to the board is where would you like me to advise the committee to go from here so that's kind of the the conversation on the table well you know part of the my biggest concern with it and I totally do not think that I'm not objecting to us being able to do this but we need to be fiscally responsible we need to make sure that you know we're working with

014funding that that's kind of long range and very unsure um um so I think you know tying down the sources of of funding um and the timing on that because as I think was pointed out we certainly do not want to be spending $10 million and then go into teacher contracts and say we've spent $10 million and then we don't have any money for your raises so that that certainly would not be a good look nor would it be appropriate I think but but I think this is a good start and I like that they've given us these options and some of the the um uh costs associated with it but I I I think they need to continue to do some more due diligence I agree I mean I I um I I would

015like to see maybe reforming the committee a little bit bring some Outsiders in some business people in the community because for this to go at sometime within the next few years we're going to need private funding for it we can't do it 100% you know through the district we're going to need chamber uh or um Community Foundation involvement um you know Business Leaders in the community um you know um ask alumni who may be interested in uh you know being involved in this uh kind of like how bayen did with their facilities you know and get maybe expanded other than just within our central office and our administrative staff get community people involved because I Envision this also to be a a place for Community functions still yeah I and I think the committee is

016open to you know they wanted to do that first layer of what are those options that are out there what are the considerations and I think um you know some of the trepidation before the committee was meeting is you are correct we cannot fund this Fieldhouse under hcsd dollars and keep us in a nice uh fiscal uh position and I know that came through some of the considerations that were in here I know Mr Frasier has been a part of those conversations so I don't know if Jeremy you want to speak to any of those pieces sure um I mean Dave you're you're exactly right um there's no way that we have $8 million lying around so just to be clear this this would come out of a pot of money called Pi money permanent

017Improvement so it it would not be the same dollars where we would provide uh raises for staff in in our general fund which we uh you know we do the forecast twice a year and that's only on the general fund so this is a separate pot of money um but we use those dollars to upkeep all of the assets that we have throughout the whole District um for example um we're we're going to buy three buses buses are now $125,000 a piece um if a if an elementary needs a new roof which we have plans for all of that um all those elementaries were built the right around the same time and they're all going to go bad right around the same time so if their heating and cooling units go out that's a quar

018million dollars they need a new roof that's A4 million dollars we've got eight of those buildings so we've got plans for that stuff um but we use those monies right now to upkeep those assets so just to give you a frame of reference right now uh we have about5 A5 million dollar of unencumbered monies in the pi fund and that's on the uh the treasures report and it's it's we look at it every meeting um but we spend almost that much money we're trying to save a little bit just for we know those things are coming down the line but spend $4 million the next three years we're going to we're a going to average spend about $4.3 million in planned Pi expenses and we all know there are things that come up um so

019there is a a nice pot of money in there but it's all allocated so to your point we don't have it so it we do need something extra whatever that is whether it's it's grants whether it's business involvement individual involvement whatever that is um if we want to pursue this we're definitely definitely going to need some help I would agree with the with your assessment be well David too uh that the op when we're looking at our general fund and what we have to do over the next few years and the the Optics are just wrong because most people um don't always understand the difference between a Pi the pi funds and the general funds it's all the schools that have this money and they're going to spend they're going and and I would much

020rather and I'm not saying this because Katie's here but I'm I would much rather see money's go into salaries than into into a Fieldhouse and I and I'm I'm I love the idea although I think we have a really crowded footprint already and I wish we bought that one building on the corner but uh years ago but that beside the point um I I just I just don't when I saw that price tag I went oh there's no way we can handle that right now unless we go to a and unless we are the citizens and but I agree I think you know I've I've seen how Bon has has raised their money to to do some of those things and that's maybe what we need to do and I think that it's appropriate to

021expand um the the committee to um you know particularly like the Community Foundation could be can be very helpful and and and you know can be an exciting project for the community um but you also want to make sure that you don't get it so big that you that you weigh it down so I I just say you know keep moving forward and and whoever we think should go onto that I mean Joe are you currently on the committee no no I'm not I thought you were on the committee okay well I want to be so if I can be I will um but a couple comments first I want to say I agree with what the all of everything that you said but Mrs blevens you know I I support this and but you're

022right Mr spra right now may not be the right time um and I agree with I'm not sure whether it's Mr Baker or I mean Mrs Baker or Mr Davidson that said you know we need to start now planning forward I agree with Mr spr's comment about I would rather see money go to the staff as opposed to this and I recognize that this is a luxury not a necessity um and by the way if Mr Holbrook is responsible for putting all this together which I think he is yes I appreciate that this information is very helpful when you look through here and he mentions this you know what's currently occurring in the prinston district we do not want to do that that's that's a horrible look and and as Mr sprag points out our

023our community would not appreciate that at all uh and I also thank him for the information on the comparisons about how we recently six years ago updated our turf just in the last year or two upgraded our Press Box and added a press box but he points out correctly that those things were planned long term cor and I think that's what we need to do we need to have people now that can plan for funding and let me just to me this is the perfect picture um I would say we negotiated favorably our four contracts in 24 M and I think our staff would agree or they should agree I for us to be able to do that again in 27 would look very positive I think that and I I think we will be

024able to do that alluding to what Mr spra mentioned as I read through this information here I hear in 29 you know those financial commit or burdens if you want to say taxes that we've put on our citizens could be eliminated what a great situ ation to be able to say hey look what we were able to do for the staff in 24 look what we were able to do for the staff in 27 in 29 we can reduce your taxes and still build this Fieldhouse um if the community wants it uh so I think that needs to be part of the equation in addition to what Mr David said about getting other community elements involved too but we need a group of people now starting to plan for that down the road Mr Fraser

025can you speak to the 2029 I know this came this was actually something Mr Frasier suggested on when um some of our millage falls off correct so we currently have Mills on your property tax if you're if you're a resident of Hamilton you are currently having a piece of your property tax go into a fund on our books that in effect pays the principal and interest the mortgage on those eight Elementary buildings that mortgage will be paid off in 2029 meaning that money those monies that you are paying will fall off the tax bill um there is a provision where we could go and you would have to go back to the taxpayer and say would you allow us to keep this on for two years three years whatever the amount would be um in

026order to build this great facility right um it would be a non- increase to your tax bill or you could potentially say you could go the other way and say well we'll still reduce your tax bill but it's not necessarily going to fall off would you allow us to do that for two years and maybe generate a little less money so there there's a couple different ways you can skin the cat um and I'm not exactly sure right now we'd have to talk with Bond count on if we could put on a 2-year Levy or if we would have to uh put on a 5year with a promise of repe repeal after two years I'm not quite certain of of how that law works just yet um but you would if if that's would be

027the recommendation that we would want to go we would have to plan for that and you would have to go to the taxpayers and get a yes vote yeah for but I think that's something that the committee that we're going to form would would look at different funding sources sure and then because I think it's premature to even think about doing any of that right right I'm just just saying that that is a a thought down the line and you know if you get a bunch of money from the community maybe you don't have to do that or maybe you could go back and ask for half a mill yeah whatever whatever that may be well I mean I'm a taxpayer here in Hamilton um I'm all for lower taxes I guess as we all

028are but you know if I knew that this was going to be a 2-year my taxes are going to go down but this is going to be on for two years then are going to go down again I think I would be more inclined to support that and I by the way I want to make sure I don't forget to say this I want to say thank you to Missy Harvey our athletic director for putting this you know being involved in this initially and putting some of these four options together that's pretty impressive um and I certainly don't want to put the burden of funding on her or or whoever may be in that position uh as you said and as Mrs baker said you know that needs to be a strong committee that has

029time to to work that issue um and and I know you would do this Mr Frasier but let's imagine we get to that point down the road and we we're going to do that let's do whatever is necessary to make sure the community understands as Mr sprag pointed out where this money is coming from you know this is a different pocket than what pays our teachers and um I I think if they clearly understand that and they clearly understand how long it's going to last I think they'd be far more likely to support it I mean I would be I agree Joe thank you very much uh I have two questions real fast okay how how much does our our current uh that Levy currently generate it pulls 6 point I think it's 6.25 Ms

030so what that means now the valuation in the city of Hamilton is over a billion so it's one mill pulls just over a million dollars so we're paying a little over six and a quar in principle and interest is what we're doing the second thing is I know that build into the into if I remember correctly in the in the state law when that when we passed those Pi that Levy um and so people remember that didn't pay for the entire buildings that only paid like 20% we use tobacco monies uh for those for the majority of the buildings um state law had us Reserve or part of that went to not building but in the replacement funds the facilities and maintenance fund that's a half a mil that's a half Mill so when that

031comes so when this Levy comes off those funds dry up too right yeah and so that's another consideration we have but those those funds are actually more restrictive than our PI monies so for example in our in our plan we have these are all the things that need to be done it can be done out of Pi or if it's like a a water heater we're allowed to use that facility and maintenance fund for that and because that's more restrictive that's where we'll we'll use that money I agree and but at the same point we will not have that funding source to help pay for some of those issues down the line but we do get a little bit of money in there from our state Foundation we get a half Mill Equalization but not

032as much so when the levy Falls I guess where I'm going is When the Levy falls off that's another fund it's not only paying the mortgage it's paying for some of those replacement things that's correct even though even though they're restricted we still have will have those expenses does that make so right we so it's it's not just paying off the mortgage it's paying off it's helping us keep up with all the that would probably shift the general fund exactly that's where I'm going with that well we we would use Pi in that case um we would fund's going to be gone the facilities of Maintenance fund we we'll still have some monies in there just not as much coming in yeah we'll still we we're still going to pull four four Mills in change

033into the pi fund and those expenses that we're currently paying out of the facility and maintenance that really restrictive fund we'll throw those into Pi we will try to never ever ever touch the general fund with any of those expenses if we can help it because that's where we pay our staff from but that's one of the problems with having all the schools at the same age too is correct everything goes wrong at the same time if Chiller goes wrong here you know it's going to go wrong at two other buildings correct and we have plans in place specifically for that facilities and maintenance fund for Chillers um as they come du so um like we have a plan for to a year and that's starting here in the next couple years because I mean

034they're almost 20 years old which is kind of hard to think about but um we have plans in place for those and to use those funds but um anything where where those funds dry up we're going to hit the pi fund if we can and never try to touch the general fund for any of that stuff what I'd like to propose I'll go back to the committee and ask them to expand that committee to see where the community interest is in helping partner with this we understand that as a district we cannot take on that expense right now now but that we want to start some long-term planning towards that possibly related to this 29 2029 well and I would encourage board members I know Meg has yeah uh influence with some business people I

035deal with business people we all do and maybe throw some names to to you or to the committee that so and so would be an ideal person to to tap for this what I can do is put out an email to you of who are those points of contact and um kind of ask you to to make that initial introduction for the committee to know and and to be a part of that process and then um you know Dr Copus you said something that is extremely important if we go um this route in 2029 campaigning and and our community understanding what this is for and being a part of that including our kids needs to be a massive part of that whole approach to getting this done I agree Mrs Bens I'd like to throw

036out two names as big donors Steve cwell and Dave Davidson I wrote them down yeah yeah good point well I will follow up with that with the committee and then get an email out to you guys of of key business or stakeholders that you think should be a part of that next fundraising is really the next piece is casting the net to see what kind of money in the community is willing to help support a project like this so we know how far off we are or what where to go next great perfect those are all of the items for me and work session president Matthews thank you so much any other um discussion anything else that's it so I would like to consider a motion to um adjourn into executive session to discuss one

037or more matters identified in our Ohio revised code 12122 g yep second roll call Mrs Baker yes Mr Davidson yes Dr Copus yes Mrs Matthews yes Mr spray yes e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.