CorpusRecord 240354

Hamilton City School District Board of Education Meeting 1-9-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / TvHAMILTON
Date
2025-01-10
Location
Butler County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
2,725 words · about 16 min
Collected
2026-06-27

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e welcome everyone to the Hamilton City Schools 2025 organizational meeting it's Thursday January 9th 2025 please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for [Music] all I'll Now call the role Mrs Baker here Mr Davidson here Dr Copus here Mrs Matthews here Mr spray here i' like to make a motion I'd move that we appoint treasur U treasure as the president pro pro tempor to preside over the election of the president second Mrs Baker yes Mr Davidson yes Dr Copus yes Mrs Matthews yes Mr spray yes I'd like to make a motion for uh the president election of board president Mrs Matthews second that I would like

002to make a motion if I could for Mr Davidson as board president okay um s SAR to last year oh do we have a second for that second okay uh similar to last year when there's multiple nominations on the floor uh we will take a vote uh by naming the individual you'd like for president Mr sprag Mrs Matthews Mr DAV have a discussion first we we can absolutely discussion all right I I I last year you know we're were in same situation I nominated actually last year Mrs Matthews and she said she didn't want to be president but why all of a sudden now do you want to be president after a [Music] year because the time seems right um I have some comments I'd like to make um first thing I'd like to say

003is I wish that we as a board would have chosen to discuss these things in private maybe we're not allowed to do that but anyway we didn't do that um so if it has to be discussed in open for then so be it um I do want to say that in my opinion you know I'm for discussing everything openly and honestly and uh in my opinion the position as board president is something that's an honored position that's an important position and and I think that has to be earned and deserved and frankly at this point I don't think Miss Matthews has earned that and let me explain my reasoning for that um if you look at attendance and you can verify these things Mrs Matthews I'm pretty certain had the worst attendance last year of

004any board member um and I know for a fact that there were a number of meetings when Mrs Baker before the meeting would call her to remind her there's a meeting or if she's on her way or if she's going to be on time and and that's okay I mean I know Mrs Baker was trying to u u Mentor her and that's fine I I respect that but my stance on that is this I'm a practicing clinician if I can be here on time I expect everyone to be here on time um so that's one issue I have another issue that I have and again you know this most of us have experienced this at after hour events you know the board is invited to a number of these and even after Mrs Matthews had

005made some commitments to ATT turn attend certain events and the district had bought tickets or dinners or whatever we had to financially support uh she wasn't there and I know that to be a fact because I attended a number of those um so I I think you know I think that's an issue we need to consider also another thing I would say is and correct me if I'm wrong here because I'm not certain of this but Mrs Matthews was the board rep to 17 strong is that correct correct okay were you also the board rep to Butler Tech that's correct well I would tell you now I don't know about the other members but during the entire calendar year of 24 I never received a single update from any of or either of those organizations

006I don't know that doesn't look favorably I don't in my opinion um I think that's an issue that you need to look at also um I think the position of board President should be awarded to the person that is most capable and most deserving and right now I just don't feel that that's Mrs Matthews um and you know if we wanted to be honest about it and tell the whole truth and Mrs Baker I thought did a nice job of handling this we actually recently enacted a cell phone usage policy for board members and it was because of Mrs Matthews use of the cell phone during board members or I'm sorry during board meetings uh I think that when we are here we need to be fully engaged and you know we're going to enact

007a cell phone policy for our staff and our students I think board members ought to set the example um so those are those are issues that I have um and that's that's why I uh nominated Mr Davidson I think he's the most deserving and the most capable at this point do we have any further discussion well I think um you know you have your right to what you know your statement but I mean if we if we're being honest you know um if I would have been perfect all across the board and dotted every eye and crossed every te you would have never voted for me anyway and you've always made things um directed everything towards me anyway like you've always had a chip on your shoulder with me from the day you stepped on

008um this board if we're all if if I'm being honest so um with that said and then not getting into the particulars or um my personal life or my business to discuss that in an open form or or with you um because that probably wouldn't be any concern you know you probably wouldn't be truly concerned about me and my well-being anyway but um far as to sit there and say you know who's deserving and who's not deserving without having the full picture or the full story when you have my personal phone number you have my email you could have contacted me at any given time to have any kind of conversations or discussions that you would have liked to have with me or question anything that you had about me or that I didn't do

009so you could have made those you could have made that phone call but you did not as my fellow board member which is fine but um you know I've always and I agree with you to serve as board president is a very honored position and I do take this being to be a very serious um you know something very serious that I take being a part of my life because it does absorb time and um something that you'll never get back and I do you know um it's been an honor to be able to serve this city this district and U most certainly the the kids that um you know in our district so I I I I love being a part of this board and representing um Hamilton City schools in just my current

010capacity so this was never um being a part of the board was never about anything else any agenda anything to try to you know um you know do anything that was outside of the position was just nothing but just to impact the city and and represent my neighborhood and and and just the youth as a whole so that was all this was ever about from the first moment that I had a discussion um rest's U Beautiful Soul Mr Tom Al that he discussed with me about it um about ever even considering being on the school board so that was always my motive my agenda so um yeah I just want to just to state that but yeah it's definitely an honor to serve on this board and you know and and you right mag has

011been an amazing mentor to me and someone who I've always looked up to as well as you know um all of you on this board so I've looked up to you know everyone on this board in their capacity even yourself so I appreciate this opportunity just to be able to share that piece well and my last comment would be Mrs Matthews if you are under the impression that I am somehow inherently against you you are mistaken that's not the case if in fact you are elected board president I just want you to know I expect a high standard of conduct and if I don't see that I intend to call you on it so just be prepared any further discussion no Mr sprag this is Matthews Mr Davidson this is Matthews Mrs Baker Mrs Matthews

012Mrs Matthews uh myself Dr Copus I would vote for Mr davidon motion passes Mrs Matthews is the new president thank you madam president shows yours thank you sir I appreciate it um I like um like to n um take a motion for um board vice president I'd like to make a motion for Dave Davidson I second the motion Dr cop or any discussion Dr Copus uh yeah Mr Davidson uh Mrs Matthews Mr Davidson Mr sprag Mr Davidson Mrs Baker Mr Davidson Mr D Davids uh Madam president before we move on yes sir I'd like to thank Mrs Baker for the last two years yesh she put a lot of time in and I know it hasn't been a smooth ride uh but she did a a great job and I appreciate it and I know

013we all do take the opportunity to tell her thank you thank you Dave thank you I appreciate that it's been a pleasure and been an honor Sam I want to say thank you so much for your leadership and as I stated before being such a great mentor for me just a want to look up to just every day and just all your wisdom and all your knowledge is just everything and so I I really appreciate you and just your service to this board and just being such a great strong leader so I appreciate it you're absolutely welcome I love to Mentor women yes in particular um so thank you absolutely so we'll um move on to establish our um is meeting dates or yep establishing meeting dates for um our so D was in red

014yep so yep so according to section 3 3 313.15 of the Ohio Revised Code requires the board um of Education to determine a time of for holding its regular meetings regular meetings shall be held at least once every two months commencing January 1 2025 the Hamilton City School District Board of Education regular meetings shall be held on the dates and times provided to each individual in attendance all information is available on the district website and the board docs agenda all regular meetings are scheduled to take place at 5:33 Dayton Street Hamilton Ohio unless otherwise noted the president may change the meeting times and place by notifying the treasurer who shall immediately post the change and inform the media special meetings may be called by the president Treasurer or um any two board members by serving

015a sign written notice of the time location and purpose of the special meeting at least two days before such meeting in compliance with section 33 13.16 of the Ohio Revised Code um could I get a motion I'll make that motion I'll second I have a point of discussion about the board dates just a question if we and by the way um at our board retreat when we were discuss discussing these dates I do appreciate the board being willing to change some of the dates to accommodate Mr Davidson and I and myself since we're still uh working in the mornings during the summer but specifically let's look and maybe I made a mistake here specifically let's look at Thursday July the 10th I still have the board meeting time is 9:00 a. is there a reason

016we didn't change that to Friday yes if you remember uh Ohio Revised Code that is the last day that a teacher can get out of their contract if we were hiring so that was the only one that we could not move to Friday morning Mrs bevens thank you I know you're correct I do remember that thank you also um we'll have a nomination for our board member for our PL commission I nominate oh oh I'm sorry oh sorry I'll call the role i m you uh and this is for the uh meeting dates meeting dates uh Mrs Matthews uh yes Mr sprag yes Mrs Baker yes Mr Davidson yes Dr Copus yes okay we'll um thank you we'll take a nomination for the board member for the city uh Planning Commission I nominate Mr Davidson

017second second if you're willing to serve oh I I enjoy it okay I do any discussion Mr frag yes Mrs Baker yes Mr Davidson yes Dr Copus yes Mrs Matthews yes okay our next item on our agenda is um establishing our board members compensation and um this nomination just um discuss on a vote for uh our compensation for the 2025 calendar year I would make a motion that we foro any compensation I second that motion um just discussion I brought this up last year um we are probably and I and I don't have the numbers but one of the few uh school districts in the state that does not compensate uh board members it is um according to Ohio Revised Code that we can um if we would start to do that that it doesn't

018affect anybody here at this table um but I I do think um at some point it would make a lot of sense to um you know compensate um board members for for the time I mean it as everybody knows it it is a lot of time if you take this job and understand all of the intricacies of it so I I'm just saying laying that on the table do we have any idea um how much board members in other districts are believe the max is $125 yeah per meeting which is just you know a little bit more than or a little bit less than what the city council makes it $300 a year we won't go there yeah we won't go there now call the role Mrs Baker I'm gonna say no Mr Davidson yes

019Dr Copus well I want to make sure I understand how I'm voting if I vote yes that means I am supporting no compensation that's correct then yes Mrs Matthews um no Mr sprag yes motion passes our next item on our agenda is establishing a service fund for um board members it is recommended that the board establish a service fund beginning July 1 2025 for $20,000 for the fiscal year um 2026 to provide board members expenses according to section 3 three um 13.5 of the high Revised Code do we have any discussion I'll make a motion I have a question we have to the motion oh I'm sorry now you can have discussion you have discuss um question Mr Frasier that is the normal amount on an annual basis correct that is correct okay yeah that's

020something that we set up every year how much has used of that fund has been used in the past I want to say probably zero I could run a a quick report and share it with you but I don't think it's a whole lot is is there is there um leeway within the revised code that allows for a like a a a limit like if I know that right now it appears that we do we vote whenever there's a conference or anything like like that on somebody does is any do we have the flexibility that we can we can provide like 500 let's say $500 without it coming to the board for a vote uh I'm not aware of a limit um but I will say um in order to get reimbursed for a um

021an event that you would attend that is part of our policy that that does require a board vote okay okay you could adopt a new policy yeah that's that's where I'm going instead of yeah we we've set this up um every year since who knows when I don't know that we we used a whole lot of it because most of it comes in the form of like going to Capital conference and for the past several years um the members haven't actually attended Capital conference that's that's usually the major expense I was just thinking that there's workshops or or something like that that somebody would want to attend um and there's not enough time for a board approval or some or it seems if it's not a huge expense and whatever huge is you know that

022that you would have some flexibility to attend I mean you you could vote to reimburse at any point in time um you know after the fact if if you wanted to you wouldn't necessarily have to do that have that vote beforehand okay all right well one one thing that I will say about that um is that what when that did come up this year we kind of set a little bit of a precedent on that when um you know I mean there's national conferences there's all things that I think that we need as a board need to have a discussion on what what's appropriate you know if you want to go you know there's I mean that's what all I'm saying is what what is what do we think is appropriate for us to attend

023what if we were to propose on a future work session putting the policy on there and we can discuss that I think that makesense to see if there's any parameters that we want to look at reviewing I think that makesense subject Hamilton used to be really involved on a state level um micone well we be very involved on a state level um with you know the School Association Board Association and we haven't in the past few years and I think we need to do that again um and we used to be very active you know U twisting the arms of legislators too I mean I can remember uh Glenn sser going up and testifying the Committees and stuff and I think we need to get back to that um because it helps our district and

024that's where this fund would be you know the reimburse travel to go up to testify a um you know the State House on legislation I don't disagree I think part of the reasons we there's been a historical issue in the past few years um with the Columbus and I think that's that's why we sort of shot I think we started shying away from it for a couple years and then that just continued on instead of taking advantage of it I I I agree yeah and we can put those dates out very early they already have next year's Capital conference I think that'd be a great I know Dr Copus at one point asked me for a little information on the the capital conference maybe that's a good start for our board is to start having

025representation there I know that's something that Jeremy Mike and myself attend and get a lot out of um I think there's a lot of good sessions especially geared towards board members there there are many sessions breakout sessions are very important they are and there's a lot of networking and talking to other board members about their experience and working together so I I can provide that information but I will put on a future work session maybe we we don't have a building presentation at the January 23rd meeting so I can put that policy on there in work session and just have a discussion that makes sense okay we have a a motion in a second uh any further discussion Mr Davidson yes Dr Copus yes Mrs Matthews yes Mr sprag yes Mrs Baker yes um will

026um move on to item J approving um Consulting agreement with osba legal assistance fund um where as the Hilton School District Board of Education wishes to support the efforts of other boards of Education to obtain favorable judicial decisions and whereas the Ohio School Board Association Legal Assistant fund has been established for this purpose therefore the board hereby resolves to enter into a consultant agreement with the osba legal assistance fund for the 20 uh 25 and directs the treasurer to pay the legal assistance fund $250 for the annual consulting fee um I'll take a motion for that I'll make that motion second any discussion uh J you can call the RO Dr Copus yes Mrs Matthews yes Mr sprag yes Mrs Baker yes Mr Davidson yes thank you we'll move on to idem K uh District

027legal council representation it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the the continued use of Bricker Gren as its primary legal council for the 2025 calendar year um do I have a motion for that so moved second do we have any discussion J Mrs Matthews yes Mr sprag yes Mrs Baker yes Mr Davidson yes Dr Copus yes [Music] now um also our next item on is our tax budget um a motion to approve the fiscal year 2026 tax budget as presented um I'll take I make uh take a motion on that I'll make that motion second um any discussion you call the RO Mr sprag yes Mrs Baker yes Mr Davidson yes Dr Copus yes Mrs Matthews [Music] yes all right that conclude meeting yes yes ma'am that um concludes our organizational meeting our

028next meeting will be Thursday January 23rd at 4 pm right here at uh on Dayton street3 Dayton Street I'll make a motion of close second um call hello Mrs Baker yes Mr Davidson yes Dr Copus yes Mrs Matthews yes Mr Sprite yes

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.