CorpusRecord 240355

Hamilton City School District Board of Education Meeting 12-12-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / TvHAMILTON
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Butler County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,330 words · about 52 min
Collected
2026-06-27

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Hamilton City School Board of Education to order Mr Frasier will you call the role please Mrs Baker here Mrs Matthews here Mr Davidson here Dr Copus here and I will make a note for the minutes that Mr sprag will be running just a little bit late correct thank you okay um I believe we have lynon here to give us tell us all the wonderful things going on there yes president um Baker tonight we do have lynon Elementary here and and we we have several members of their staff led by um Brandy Hazelwood and I'd like to introduce her and let her tell us some of the great things going on at Lyndon Elementary Brandy thank [Music] you good afternoon I'm Brandy Hazelwood I have the honor of serving Lindon Elementary as building principal and I'm

002Michelle conman the assistant principal at Lyndon my name is Debbie Shadrach this is my 27th years in educator most recently taking on the role of instructional math coach at Lyon we're blessed to have all been in our roles together for the past three years um before we get started we would like to take a moment to acknowledge Katie cook our literacy coach um who is unable to join us today due to the loss of her father um she is a vital part of this team and her impact at lynon knows no bounds so she's with us today here in spirit um we are thankful for this opportunity this afternoon to share with you what we get to experience on a daily basis at lynon um when we sat down um to plan out our presentation

003we kept kind of coming back to um the questions that we get asked all the time we are seeing that uh positive movement happening at Lyndon and people continually ask us what is going on at Lyndon what are you doing what's happening um and so that brought us to the lyen way the lynen way is made up of all the areas you see on the slide here when we were brainstorming how can we share our annual update with all of you we really wanted to bring our staff to to share their voices unfortunately this is their work time so we were unable to bring them with us however we have created video clips today so that you can hear their voices and they can share their stories of success with you all right it's important

004to take a moment to acknowledge the hard work of our incredible staff and teachers and instructional team and what they do with students every day just wanted to start off as we are seeing when we first came in 3 years ago our main focus was growing our students and focusing on that student growth we believe if we focused on that we aligned our arrows and fostered that teacher efficacy we would be able to push lynon forward we're happy to share as you already know um that Lyndon did grow to four stars on our report card this year with one notable area of making strides which was our chronic absenteeism um we have we know there's room for growth always within our report card but we're very um encouraged by the data that we are seeing

005at London so let's talk about Ela first our teachers are seeing the benefits of the consistent daily rigorous tier one instruction when it comes to the recent curriculum shifts at Lyndon we've been intentional on having explicit vertical instructional conversations here are two of our teachers sharing their experiences with implementation of our new reading curriculum hi I'm Caitlyn Smith and I'm a first grade teacher at Lyon and I'm Alexis Gallagher a fourth grade teacher at Lyndon I have really enjoyed e because not only has it helped my students with comprehension and vocabulary and has helped me with integrating both social studies and science and daily lessons but also I have led that my students are learning how to communicate with one another and be respectful and respond to one another they are using words like responsibility

006and collaboration perseverance Integrity in all of their daily conversations and I'm just really excited to watch them continue to grow with E and I have embraced the challenge of implementing the El curriculum and let me tell you I've been amazed at the transformation it's brought to my classroom my students haven't just learned they've thed their engagement soared as they tackled meaningful real world topics and embraced Community Partnerships some of their favorites like being able to write a letter to the author of Love That Dog and receiving their very own poem in response to also seeing our informational text come to life through Butler Tech veterinarian students bringing their animals in to demonstrate their defenses my students excitement in combination with their excellent test scores are a testament to their hard work and this curriculum's Effectiveness

007it's been an honor to host colleagues in my classroom both from our own districts and from surrounding districts in order to share how El's approach Fosters deep learning and connection elel is more than a curriculum it's a pathway to empowering our students and strengthening our community together we're preparing them for not just AC success but for a lifetime of curiosity and contribution on to math um I feel teachers at math uh at Lyndon have fully embraced the engaged New York math curriculum although there was some initial hesitation with adopting a more rigorous and challenging program we're now seeing impressive results and are excited to celebrate the significant growth reflected in our student data hear from two of our Math teachers as they share their insights and experiences with the curriculum hi I'm Kelly Wright and

008I teach fifth grade math and science at Lyon Elementary hi I'm Elia deit and I teach second grade at L Elementary so Engage New York offers a comprehensive range of resources that make a really well-rounded math curriculum with its blend of application problems fluency activities and problem sets I'm able to tailor the format to suit my teaching style and the needs of my students so the curriculum's depth allows me to challenge even my most gifted and accelerated Learners ensuring that they stay engaged and grow while the rigor of the problems sometimes makes the learning process feel challenging um the results have demonstrated its Effectiveness so over the few years the past few years since we've been using this curriculum I've seen my students consistantly Advanced to higher levels of achievement absolutely um from a primary

009perspective I completely agree with Kelly uh it's especially been interesting because for the past few years I've only been teaching Ela and this year I've come back to teaching math um and it's interesting to see how much students have changed in their math thinking since I last taught math here at Hamilton uh and it's really cool to see we started at engage New York the last year that I was teaching math um so to see the changes in students and to see the change in their thinking and their ability level has been really cool uh to jumping back into that yeah [Music] next we are pleased to highlight two exceptional after school clubs both led by dedicated teachers that have made a significant impact on our students each Club Fosters both personal growth and collaboration

010while encouraging creativity and overall are a positive influence on our students hi my name is Teresa I'm the music teacher here at Lyndon Elementary and I also do the after school Cranium Crushers Club our Cranium crushers Club is for our gifted and talented students and it gives them a chance to explore steam principles but in Hands-On ways uh we do right now board game building as well as we're going to be doing some video game building um it givs them a chance to unleash their creativity and really just enjoy each other's time and um share ideas with each other my name is Caitlyn saor I'm the ESL teacher at London and I also do El Club El Club is for current and former ESL students so it's an opportunity for them to practice all four

011domains of English and we do themed activities every month so we've done leave art we have done Escape rooms and going into December we're going to learn about holidays around the world every day Lyndon students participate in what we call the roar block every grade level kindergarten to sixth grade has a daily schedule block of time designed to provide targeted academic support to small groups of students the roar block wouldn't be possible without our entire team elll teachers intervention Specialists Title One teachers and Home Room teachers the groups and instructional decisions are data driven and the results speak for themselves as the two teachers in the next clip will share I'm Nikki Davidson and I teach kindergarten at Lyon I'm Lauren M and I teach third grade um we want to talk to you about

012roblock and roblock is just lyndon's version of aim block um we've been doing that for a few years now at lynen um our kindergarten team has been able to meet the students where they are and um give them intervention that is research based and um where the students need to be academically and we've seen tremendous growth throughout the years that we've been doing it so we're excited to keep it going with ralk I love love Roar block because um it doesn't take anything away from our tier one instruction um there's no interruptions from tier one and we're really able to dive deep and not have to constantly be reintegrating students back into our classroom um I also love that we get to meet as a team around the table every six weeks or so um

013cycle and really just talk about the child as a whole and dig into that data and really make sure that they're moving and getting what they need um I just bumped into one of our title teachers in the hallway the other day and she was like Bittersweet crying because um they had just they were just able to move um a tier to kindergarten kiddo out of her group and back into tier one instruction and she was sad that she couldn't work with them anymore but she was just so proud um and that's that's what she wants for our students and that's what everybody here at Lyndon wants for our students we want to keep moving them and growing them we are thrilled about the progress being made by our instructional team team at Lyndon this

014year marks an exciting Milestone as we combined our math and literacy committees into a unified team with a shared Vision to guide and support all staff this collaborative committee is focused on key District initiatives including implementing explicit instruction fostering instructional leadership and enhancing data literacy currently we are diving into the 16 components of explicit instruction with a particular focus on strategies that elicit student responses we all know how important it is is to encourage all students to respond and be engaged in their learning here is one of our teachers practicing Coral responses with her class thaning 20 cm or 9 cm which is [Music] shorter as an instructional team we strive to cultivate instructional leaders among our teachers by encouraging them to implement these approaches in their classrooms and share their experiences while leading morning

015professional development sessions another key priority is increasing staff data literacy by analyzing the district report card exploring its insights and examining map and OST data with representatives from every grade level on this team we aim to ensure the this important information is shared effectively creating a deeper understanding among all staff members as far as coaching this year marks our second year of the coaching cohort this is a voluntary program where teachers commit to meeting weekly or bi-weekly with Katie or me we're proud to share that 74% of our classroom teachers are actively participating in the cohort many of these teachers are engaged in reflective coaching Cycles where we work together to set student- centered goals and highlight effective instructional practices that Foster growth for both students and teachers within the cohort our work includes but

016is not limited to lesson planning C- teing modeling lesson conducting observations with feedback organizing peer observations analyzing data and reflecting on best practices among other things beyond the cohort we've introduced backward planning sessions with each grade level team to ensure that we are reaching all of our teachers additionally we support teachers with Roar block planning and through the mtss process helping make informed datadriven decisions for students Katie and I take immense Pride in the coaching work at Lyon where we feel fortunate to collaborate with such dedicated staff and administrators to us coaching isn't just a job it's a privilege supporting this talented team is both an honor and a source of gratitude every day at there we go a little delay at lynon um this year we have the honor and excitement to Pilot the

017adopted class program for the elementaries um through this Mentor program our third through sixth grade students are getting to explore potential career Pathways that are right here in the city of Hamilton and we currently have classrooms partnered with First Financial Bank Butler Soil and Water Miami University fit and YMCA um inspiration Studios connect it um and the Ohio State Highway Patrol not only are students beaming with excitement on adopt a class day the adults as they come in the building they are just as excited to see the students Mentor the students and share more about what they do every day in their respective businesses and organizations um as you can see here there's some pictured examples of our groups um right in the middle is inspiration Studios their very first day that they came out

018um to get to know the students in Mrs hines's class third the third grade class um they worked together and collaboratively built the lynon logo through a mural mosaic tile process with paper um to to get to know them and ex uh share that art with them so it's been a very exciting process we're very thankful um to be able to Pilot it and we're looking forward um to the Stu the businesses and organizations that are still going through the training process to continue to um impact all of the third through sixth graders at London when we initially created our Five-Year Plan at London when we first came over one of the big areas of focus for us and me personally was Community Bridging the community of the school of Lyndon with the greater Lynden

019World community and what an amazing Community it is um what started with participating in a few Community neighborhood meetings here or there has grown into wonderful Partnerships that benefit our students in the Greater Community together lyed wal kaanas is our Adopt A School program and while we've grown that relationship the past three years this year I've been able to um join the organization and continue to grow that with a group of of wonderful individuals who are truly all in for children and lynon is a wonderful benefit of that our sixth grade students as fifth graders last year um lynon was selected as the 17 strong nanog grant program um and so we had students um who got to listen to the 17 strong team come in and tell them about all 17 neighborhoods did you

020know there were 17 neighborhoods in Hamilton and um share with them the nanog grant process and then from there they let the kids go and the ideas just started to flow um and so we ended up with four finalists um of groups of students and they all presented to the board and they were Overjoyed with excitement when they found that all four projects are going to be funded um from simple um a neighborhood cleanup that we actually did earlier this week at Lyon before got too too cold and the cube had to get some um winterizing done um to we had a two students come up with the idea of having a wishing well at lynon and that where we could showcase different organizations in the community every couple of months and the funds that

021we would get um receive in the wishing well would go towards that organization so learn they that was how they could give back in a simple and exciting way for them um they're pictured there with our really it's one of those cool swirly coin ones that the kids really love um we had three gentlemen who initially wanted to create um toiletry bags for people who are were experienc homelessness and that got that project grew um I've never seen 227 bags get filled in 23 minutes by three sixth grade boys there were objects going everywhere they were having a blast um we were able to reach out to caring closet and make that a donation directly to them so then it went back right into Hamilton students um the boys were very excited to know that

022hey this is just this is going back to kids that are like us right um and so that was a Wonder wonderful experience for them and then over the summer I don't know if you've driven down St Clair lately um but there is a new colorful crosswalk that a group of students um you that intersection we have a lot of Walkers and a lot of community members that walk the streets of lynen Wald students as soon as the bell rings they walk home put their backpack down grab their basketball and they walk right back to school to play every day um and this intersection is a very busy one and so these students said hey what else can we do to make it safe for us but also for all of lynen Wal and so

023they came up with this idea of a colorful crosswalk so if you haven't driven down St Clair lately and seen it head on down and you'll see this wonderful red white and blue colored they all summer they had to closed the road down and the kids themselves dipped the paint and they they painted the road and in the crosswalk it was a wonderful experience for them um I think the coolest thing for the students were it wasn't just a project they talked about they came up with they got to actually see that project in action which was a wonderful experience for them also in the community this year we were we were fortunate to join the Hamil turkey initiative and so 200 Lyon families got um that needed it got a box of Thanksgiving food

024to cook and a 20 lb frozen turkey um so they had what they would need for a wonderful at home Thanksgiving dinner we were able to during Thanksgiving break we had a community Buffet um at the school where Kanis members came out to serve food staff members came out and it was just a wonderful time of fellowship with our families um from London in the greater lindenwald area um we are fortunate to continue our um partnership with Butler County ESC and their compassion project through our breakbox program I don't remember last time we talked last year we were piloting that program we're like hey what can we do and they're like let's try it okay lyen we'll be the we'll be the ginea pigs and so from that just last year to now it has

025grown to 14 other schools in the county um and we're very excited um for that partnership as well to wrap it up we just want to emphasize that none of this is possible without this amazing staff um built on a culture of trust their commitment to fostering a positive learning environment support supporting each student's growth and striving for excellence each and every day we are just so deeply grateful for their tireless efforts which enable lynon to thrive and reach New Heights our Collective Strength lies in working together with a sh Vision when we align our arrows our goals our strategies and efforts we create a powerful energy that drives students success and strengthens our teaching practices we feel we are moving mountains at Lyon we want to take a moment to express our heartfelt gratitude

026to you the school board um Mr Holbrook Mrs blevens Mr Wright um for the continued support that you have and the trust that you have in us in our with our respective roles and our school community it truly is an honor to serve the students staff and families at Lyon and we are very um thankful for that opportunity this evening to share with you um about what's happening at lynon so we ask you just to continue in believing in lynon and the Lyon way thank you well Brandy uh Michelle and Debbie thank you very much what a um I I love I always say this every time how much I love hearing about what's going on in each individual community and how and how each um Elementary School is kind of involved and has their

027own uh interaction with the community at large uh congratulations on a four star I mean great great great job and to see where you've come from over the last several years it's just a uh it just congrat congratulations you've done a fantastic job and looks like you have a lot of fun while you're doing it feel like to have a little butt yeah same I agree um again it's always great to hear from you guys at Lyon and all the great things that you're doing and thank you for all the pictures and the visual the visuals and also the videos because I think that just it's great to hear from the teachers themselves and their excitement about it and the things that they're doing and their different units and the different grades and also you

028know I believe seeing is believing so being able to see th all those pictures and the smiles and the interactiveness with all the teachers with the students is always a great you know display and um again like Max um shout out to four stars that's always amazing to see you guys um achieve that I know it was a goal so um congrats on that and again just appreciate you and your um awesome team and staff for just making learning fun making the environment Pleasant and you know the kids giving them a space in a place where they you know um seems as if they want to be and definitely it's inviting so again I just say thank you um um definitely for for all that you do and also um first Miss Cook as well

029so remember um her family first off I want to thank you uh for hosting Dr Copus and I a few weeks ago on a tour of your building and totally enjoyed it um my wife used to uh teach down at uh linen so I'm familiar with the building it was great to get back there I love what you're doing you're you're challenging your students you're growing your students and and I love this uh this Roar block concept that you have and now it's working I love how you're also pushing your teachers to be better and helping your teachers get uh better and you have a great staff down there but you're you're you're helping your teachers and giving them what they need and and I thank you for that keep up the good work uh

030principal Hazelwood and staff just a few comments first of all thank you and I want to Echo I think what uh president baker said congratulations on the four star report card and and while that's impressive to me personally what's more impressive is is the amount of progress you made um you know whether you wind up with a three or four or five star you know that's that's one thing one way to look at it but to me it's the amount of progress that you've made that's what you should really be proud of uh and I appreciate the fact that you give credit to your fellow administrators and to your staff also I mean the teachers are the soldiers so to speak they're the ones fighting the battles and the classroom and and congratulations to them

031and and I particularly during your presentation I particularly liked your after school clubs I think that's great for for students um and like Mr Davidson mentioned a moment ago talk with me again for a moment about the roar club or the the roar block I'm sorry uh that occurs during the school day yes well go over that again for me just so a districtwide initiative is that aim block that designated time of students to get receive the intervention need or the enrichment they need so at Lyndon our PBIS program U we use a roar acronym and so it made sense to us to call it Roar block um and during that you know dedicated you know 40 minute block of time um students who are re working with an intervention specialist working with a title

032teacher working with an elll teacher that is their designated time for their intervention and their their services right and so what we within that block what we have the opportunity to do is those stud students who don't get pulled out for those Services we able to look at our data choose a focus for what whichever grade level it happens to be and then we leverage those four classroom teachers that are still in the grade level and those students left so that you know these this pocket of 20 students that are up in the higher achieving gifted group okay let's put them in a in this classroom and they're going to have an enrichment project that they're going to do with this teacher and the students um that are left we divide them up based on

033you know their um whichever data we're looking at when we start started we used map in the fall because very fresh um and we looked at their percentiles and we group them and and use that data to really Target those those students so with the four classroom teachers this group might have a group of 13 this one might have a group of 15 and this one might have a group of you know 12 depending on the great level and those receiving services and it is truly a sacred 40 block minut at a time and with by doing that that's the only time that those students are getting pulled out of the classroom and so the rest of the day is all TI one instruction and those students are getting to experience that tier one instructions

034the teachers as um Mrs merch mentioned they're not constantly having to re intergrate students back into the room during that tier one and they're able to truly dive deeper um with their tier one to make it rigorous um for the kids okay well thank you and and congratulations on your success thank you Brandy I think one of your first slides that you showed us um talked about the lyen way I also think there's a square missing and it's culture enthusiasm and you and Michelle for the last three years have brought such an energy and such an enthusiasm to an already great group of teachers and it's contagious when you go into that building you feel it you feel it with your parents this summer I did have the opportunity to attend the the the painting

035of the crosswalk and the excitement that the kids had in doing that you know I I don't know if I can properly describe it but but that's all a part of the educational piece that I think is really important a and you and your staff should be really really happy and need to be complimented on all of those things and I appreciate your leadership over these last three years Belle I appreciate your leadership Deb and I know Katie isn't with us from the instructional lens a and you know we always here to support and look to get better but we also need to sometimes take a step back and look at the accomplishments that we've had and and kind of acknowledge those too because we're always so focused on pushing forward and continuing to get

036better and we're all like that but there's so much to be thankful for and there's so many things that you've done and your staff have done so well that that I just want to publicly say thank you for for all of that and thank the entire staff thank you so much um enjoy the rest of your evening oh Mr sprag um next on the agenda is uh some things that we've talked about I believe the cell phone policy and your group uh Mrs bevens that has gotten together to make recommendations to the board okay and let me give some background on this earlier this year it was mandated that every District in the state of Ohio at least review their current cell phone policy if they had one which we did or in some cases

037districts did not have a cell phone policy and they were to create one a and so um Mrs bevens eagerly um said let's form a committee and you know she's The Mastermind behind forming the committee but I think that's really important to get the input from everybody involved from parents to teachers to students to community in what can and cannot be successful and what do we need and I'm going to turn this over to Andrea she facilitated these these meetings with with um her her committee and I think you're going to hear from some committee members tonight on on what what the recommendations of that committee are so thank you Mr Holbrook and the board for allowing myself and my uh committee aka the people who were nominated from the committee to speak tonight um

038as you as Mr hook mentioned Governor dwine asked can you hear me okay if I'm over here okay govern DNE asked or mandated each School said no how about now okay mandated each school to adopt a policy as Mr Holbrook mentioned we already had one but it was time for us to really look at that and make sure that our one our practices were aligned to our policy and that what we were doing was working in buildings there are a lot of different feelings on this particular piece and so the best way that we thought to do this was to form a committee and we were very blessed to have a robust committee we had representatives from every single building both on administrative side as well as the teaching staff um the teachers that were

039nominated to be a part of this committee were chosen by our Union leadership that was really important for them to be a part of this team so I just listed up here who was on our committee from our administrative side we had Mr Brittain uh Miss Brandy Hazelwood Mr maram from Garfield Mr Zary and then Mrs Fuller and then on the teacher side we had Mrs Green from Bridgeport in sconia Mitchell from Crawford Woods Karen boltman from Fairwood Kayla Hawk from Highland jennif hafley from Ridgeway AKA Union um Lisa Burton from Wilson Melissa Peterson from The Freshman Campus and Amy Kelly from the high school uh we've met a number of times if you remember when I proposed us forming a committee I talked about a timeline and so our committee has done a lot

040of work in a little bit of time and I think it's really important we talked a lot about this in our committee that this is just the first FA phase of presenting recommendations to you one driving notion that came up in every conversation we had was it's about getting Buy in it's about enforcement and communication it's making sure our parents our students and our staff are all on the same page with what expectations are moving forward so while tonight is a recommendation you will not have anything tonight to vote on this is just to give you their our committee's findings then from there in January I will bring a proposed policy but if you look at our timeline January through May is really focused on that next phase the communication and the implementation of that

041particular piece our Target goal would be to implement an August full implementation okay so instead of hearing from me you guys hear from me all the time I thought I'd bring up the rock stars the soldiers in our classrooms to talk about what our committee did and so that's what we're doing this evening let me put this back up here so you don't have to hold it like Vanna White all right hello I'm Jennifer hle um I a 30 plus year educator uh over 20 of those being here in Hamilton um it's weird for me thinking back like I didn't even have a cell phone when I started teaching so this is really weird but um you have seen and aware of the current policy um and if you looked at it it was very

042wordy very vague um which led to a variety of practices in our different buildings as you can see basically K through n the policy current certain PR current practices are that the cell phones are out of sight during school day and then in our high school building it's at the teacher discretion um allowed in the hallways in and lunch which sometimes leads to a little bit I don't know how the best word to say it chaos or whatever but so it's just not the best best way of that it's happening okay so then we had our committee and you know it was a v a variety of people but we knew that there was a lot more um opinions out there so we did um come up with a survey as Mr uh hob alluded

043to that we asked staff students in grades 5 through 12 and parents and Guardians to answer questions about cell phone use in in the schools asked a bunch of different questions and then we went back um as our committee and looked through those and you can see on this slide um the amount of responses that we got um so our parents um we had 443 responses which I'm thought that was pretty good um you can see most of them are 7 through 12 which makes the most sense because most Elementary School students don't have a cell phone or don't bring them to school at least anyways we do have some but not as many as in the older grades and then uh our staff oh 78 about 70 some per of the staff responded which

044for me as an hcta person is fabulous cuz we usually get like 60 people so to have 70 over 70% was like wow this is great um and then for the students like you said we did the elementary only grades five and six and then the middle school high school um and the Freshman Campus as well and then we will talk about some of the responses that we got on this service yes 244 and I know like a lot of the teachers gave at least in our building I know gave the students they said open up your Chromebooks we're going to take this survey so at least I know that's how we did it in our building so all of us of the committee but at the same time we knew we were just representative

045of the larger community so our first piece of business was to get those survey results from everyone before we really got into conversations about what does that look like moving forward for our district okay okay I will hi everyone I am Amy Kelly and I am currently at Hamilton High School I have been in the district since 2003 however so I have watched the progression of the cell phone epidemic and I'm going to call it an epidemic um and it is time to be addressed and it's not about banning the technology per se but it's providing an environment and an opportunity to have a phone free environment so that the student students can have that opportunity to have more you know interaction and face to-face communication um and the drama that's she hit it on

046the head because that's where it starts with the um social media the staff takeaway overwhelmingly the staff um voted or not voted but the survey indicated that the staff is on board with a phonefree environment it's already implemented in the lower grade levels and the high school what we typically the obstacle for us was the large age band you have 15y olds and you have 18y olds and so the staff waffles with an 18-year-old that has a job or that has children or you know they're in a different circumstance than the 15-year-old so we've kind of stuck with the teacher discretion um model at the high school but it is it's just it needs to be um reformatted and our structure needs to be different because the uh mental health component is at the top

047of our list yes it's a distraction but the distraction is a part of the decline in the mental health of our older students here in the district um 87% of our staff they don't use the cell phone because we have the one toone Chromebook and it's not necessary to use the cell phones and I know that that has been a a um concern you know but we use the phone in art class or we use the phone to take pictures in digital media or for yearbook and that's absolutely fine to be able to speak to those different courses you know to use the cell phones but this is for the overall you know just use for QR codes or for surveys you can use your Chromebook for that um yeah we talked about the distraction

048these statistics are how do I want to say it um secondary to the feeling that the staff has that we have lost the connection with our students we have lost a connection to other human beings in our classrooms and we understand that you know it is all about you know we hear the distraction and from the parents side it's like well we want to be able to communicate with our with our you know children okay we understand that and we will absolutely provide you with opportunities to be able to you know stay connected to your child but during the 50 minutes that we have them we really want to be engaged with them you know it's like our top priority I've had um the unique opportunity commercial break okay um I've had the unique opportunity

049not only can present the um survey results to you but obviously the the high school is our priority right now to modify the free you know phone free policy and I've had numerous teachers that have come to me personally sent me messages um we've had conversations in department meetings and overwhelmingly the teachers want to have that you know human interaction with the students again and we want to see the students interact with each other you know it's very disconcerning when um you have a room full of young people that can have Dynamic conversation and be able to participate in in each other's learning and lift each other up but their faces are down in their phones and or you know they're distracted by who's saying what on social media overwhelmingly I hope I didn't use

050that word too much but overwhelmingly the staff wants a uniform policy and so you know our discussions are how can you know we combine language you know how can we clarify language without it being too um generalized and um I think I think so too yeah I think so too do you have any questions for the staff kind of surprised that the that I'm kind of surprised that the it's only 41% of Staff feel that phones disrupt classroom dynamics I would have thought that much be my and that are they distract from lessons um I know going back a few years that I was seeing that much more in classrooms happening more frequently as as I was walking around so I'm I'm kind of surprised is there a a reason behind only 41% I think

051that it's more the question the question like if you see um I don't mean to jump in the like the next statistic 40.9% feels phones disrupt it was like what do you feel phones are doing in the classroom and so a portion of them said that they distract from lessons and within that same questions 40 more per said that they disrupt class all part of the same response well you also have to remember some of the responses came from Elementary St teachers who don't have cell phones in the classro or middle school went over the current practice and many of the okay so we asked all of those students but and all of those teachers so you know you got to think of that K12 continu I was thinking more of the secondary yeah and

052that's why I'm speaking and as a singular answer not a okay thank you so it to speak to the secondary teachers um it's all in the terminology is the phone the disruption or is it the um the emotional turmoil that it causes as a result of the phone does that make sense okay so basically you're saying that 80% of the staff feels that it's a not good yes okay thanks um we did ask the staff to put where did they feel it was okay um because when we get to parents you're going to see they want to be able to reach their their children wanted to to know where that some of the places that they did say before and after school obviously for any medical or safety reason and then the bus the bus

053was one that they discussed how did between classes I don't see that classes was not an area that that staff would like to see okay more towards what you probably expected there was a question that really asked about in the classroom should they have them with staff and it was 89% so that's probably more what the percentage you were looking for on that that question just had so many options I think that if they weren't bothered by it because they already have them put away in their class they probably didn't say yes on that the question where it said should they have them in class 89% said that okay thanks J Mrs blevens I have a few comments first of all I want to say that I support your plan and the steps of the

054plan I think that's extremely well thought out and I also agree very much with the Blended composition of your board and I'm impressed that you've sought any type of Parental input I I think that's important and you made a comment earlier about where every person myself included we have our own feelings about what the policy should be um but I I personally want to say that more important to me than what I feel would be what the teachers feel because they are the ones that are going through it dayto day and what it what impresses me up there about those statistics is 70% of our staff thinks and by the way I think wearable technology should be included with phones talked a lot about that's our the um but I mean they want them strictly

055prohibit and you know that's to me that's a strong statement from our staff and uh but anyway I I think what you are doing is great and we look forward to further information and and ultimately voting on this okay Lisa hello my name is Lisa Burton and I am this is my 26th year teaching art over at Wilson Middle School um so I have taken on the parent statistics here and I also wrote down what that doesn't show because I think that also informs what the survey shows is first we have 78% know that they have a phone at school um 12% said no they don't and 11% said no they don't even have one so they're aware they take them to school um 61% a child uses at school 40% Say Never No not

056my so you know take that one where are you but uh 61% say definitely they know yeah they use them um 56% of parents say there should be a uniform policy and that I think that number looks low but the remaining 40% said maybe and I think maybe there was just more of a hesitation of okay what does that policy look like um what are the parameters so not necessarily not on board but yeah let's look what that looks like so I I think that it's more of a a positive that more are on board but some are a little hesitant and want to see more um what the details and then 43% of parents believe that there is not a positive impact um and 40s had no opinion at all so that was that

057was kind of yeah I thought that was kind of interesting that they just did have an opinion didn't think but being a parent of teenagers I know when I say my child's name and how many times I have to say it and their faces looking down um it's definitely yeah they agree with us 50% believe there is a distraction um and 43 again there's not a concern and the minutia of the remaining percentages was how are they using it is it cheating is it misuse in the classroom um but it seems like most are on board and the ones that are saying yes I know my child is using it and I think this is the biggest part is they want their child to be able to be reached they want them to have them

058before and after school for safety purposes on the bus for safety purposes and I think that plays into some of the um the numbers that we're seeing and and I think we can agree with we want our children to be safe number one of course um um and then I'm not going to take up too much you'll see in our recommendations that we also talked about that we'd like to empower and inform our parents and how they can be uh better guardians of this cell phone epidemic in time and give them some tools and resources only about 64% said they had resources to be able to help them navigate cell phone use and parental controls I know often times in conf es where parents are like I'm really busy I don't have time to look

059at progress book and I'm like you have where you can just set parameters on there and you will get a notification if your child gets below a c in math or misses an assignment um and just giving them and they're like oh that just makes me so much happier because I don't have to constantly be the bulldog and look this is going to for me and I tell my own kids no news is good news if I get a noic vacations something's not going right so um I think that's going to be a big help Al also just to have parents know that there are some resources and things out there to make it a little bit easier any questions for me I get to do the student um first off I'm Karen boltman I

060teach at Fairwood Elementary um this is my 26th year in the district been in the the one and a half mile straight line the whole time Buchanan Grant and Fairwood um love the community um and um but I am like I bring a kindergarten background but I also bring a mom of young adults um and a mom of teenagers and a can you believe it an almost 13-year-old that does not have a cell phone yet um he reminds me of that all the time but our rule in our household is ninth grade um it's a it's a big responsibility um and also so like I don't want to add another thing onto my bill um but just real quick about our students our students told on themselves that's exactly what we said as soon as

061we opened it up um they did tell on ourselves so that's awesome to see that they were um very honest in what they wanted to share with us um and one of the in the classroom they felt that it was inappropriate to have their um phone in the classroom um I think some of us kind of took that kind of surprise but um I kind of look at it as a Viewpoint like they're either trying to say well yeah of course it's inappropriate we're talking to the school we don't want to tell them that we think it's appropriate but I also think that they do want to learn everything that they can here um excuse me sorry kindergarten in December is a lot of fun um okay um there is only 37% of the students

062that believes that student um cell phones enhance their school day um and then 51% say that they do not use their phone at school we'll see we're hoping that they're honest um and then the majority feel outo outside the school hours are okay um one of the biggest things that the their survey said is they wanted to be able to wear their devices so they wanted to we all kind of took it as their headphones they want to listen to music I get it we all probably I mean last night I was rapping gifts I wanted Christmas music on you know like we do better when our music is on um but I know that there's what from after listening to other um schools in the district we all have wired headphones on our Chromebooks

063and that they are have that opportunity if their teacher allows them to put on music you know um which I think is good because even in my kindergarten classroom right when I need them to calm I put on classical music you know whatever it is and that's just all through my classroom so I can see that as they're getting older with that Independent Learning um but they're allowed to have headphones that are wired um as what we're um proposing um and then let's see I think I think that's all I had the one thing that was impressive to me is there was 2100 students that took that survey and when you read through the comments a lot of them took it very seriously which was really nice to hear about our students can I ask

064um first one going back real fast what what grade levels are we talking about oh I'm sorry I wanted to start with that and I forgot um I know it that's why I asked we only surveyed um fifth grade through 12th grade okay on this I I just wondered how that stacked up as they got yeah and then when we looked at it we did um divvy it up between five fifth and sixth and then 7th through 12th yeah thank you spent a lot of time if you can tell has done a really nice job of being extr hold on here I'm GNA take mic with me um of being extremely thorough I'm not used to sitting over here anymore um but we had a lot of purposeful conversation of making sure every voice was

065represented in this um I we do want to thank everyone who did it and our committee I mean that we had good conversations both as parents of adolescence I learned more about these amazing ladies and gentlemen and their their children um but also as Educators and and hearing from our students and what are those those concerns all right here's the drum roll here's our recommendations yes L just quickly can you go back one slide this one yes the the bottom bullet point there where Mo the majority of the students feel that outside school hours is okay that pretty much coincides with what the staff feels also that was yes yes yeah that I think that's great us the recommendations as we looked at the policy for changes it all lined very nicely yeah that's impressive

066all right throw it all up there if you would like um so um we heard loud and clear that um across the board we would like to look at having a universal cell phone policy um that prevents the use of that cell phone um during classes the hallways and restrooms with the exception being made that it is a reality um some students need their cell phone on them with a medical device my son is one of those people um and and sometimes there's specific situations that would um require prior permission you know given that situation um allowing students to keep the their devices on them but remaining out of sight out of use um during the class time um so we don't see it it's put away you can have it on you it's but

067it's we don't it's not disrupting what's happening in the classroom is that powered down yes off and Away off and away that was the number one that was the number one piece that the parents asked for is that their children have it on them in the event of an emergency that was the number one comment we heard time and time again so we're allowing them to keep it on them but off and out of sight but off off being I mean if you think powered down but off being on silent is that what you're saying because I mean if it's off off how does the off off it's here's here's the other thing too I know Mr Copus keeps mentioning that we want to help the teachers out because they're obviously going to be the

068ones immediately dealing with these issues um we don't want to police like we see the outline of a phone in their pocket like go put it in a box or go put in a locker or something like that we don't want our teachers to have to have that battle if they keep it away and they're not on it acely using it we're not going to fight that fight and I think when we're talking about an emergency they mean like an emergency at school where the kid would have to get a hold of the parent because there is some you know lockdown or whatever not an emergency at home because if there's an emergency home they can still call the front office right okay I'm clear clear on that because I yeah thank you for clarifying

069um the main message um it with this is going to be enforcement and and communication and consistency is going to be key um it's going to take you know the first person who interacts with that student when they walk in the door if they see it remember off and Away um because we want to make sure we're we capture at them not at fifth period when you know it's like well this has gone on all day so that's it's going to take it's going to take a village of of both teachers and administrators and School staff to work together to communicate and enforce this with the students I'm training our staff on those expectations and and the students to know what the expectations are we can't hold them to that expectation if we haven't explicitly

070talked to them and communicated that with our students um providing tiered consequences for violation in alignment with with our code of conduct and then providing that annual notice to parents and students on those technology expectations um through final forms handbooks Class Dojo um Friday connections as well as reassurance of ways to reach their children during the school day um they can always call the front office that there's an emergency that they need to speak with their child um and just reassuring the parents of that and then again providing those resources um as we mentioned earlier um various members that educating the parents on some of the um impacts that we're seeing with our students and cell phones in the cell phone epidemic and just equipping them with the knowledge and resources to be able to

071support their child um at home so our suggested new policy um I'm just just to sum it up with a a couple simple statements is K12 cell phones are prohibited in the classroom hallways or rushrooms we should not see them um students may use personal technology before and after school for an academic specific purpose um on the bus and during extracurricular activities an example of a specific academic purpose and band um a lot of the music teachers have their students tune their instruments with a tune app on their phone that's a specific academic purpose um but outside of those um examples off and Away across the board great I mean input the having all of that the the members of the team and all that one question um what about teachers and so I'm a

072firm believer in leading by example um so are will the teachers try and follow that policy as well we we talked a lot about that um and our teachers do sometimes use their phone for that educational purpose just speaking from an elementary lens right you know we're walking to um specials we're walking to lunch and maybe we're doing a restroom break and we're looking for students showing their Roar at Lyndon teachers might be giving uh dojo points okay with that app but again having that education mindset we're using it with this during you know during the work day with the students for an educational purpose okay thank you even another thing like I have to use mine sometimes to communicate with the another teacher about a student that's having an issue and so we text

073for that reason well you all are adults you should know how to and and I'm sure this was discussed as well but if a teacher's on a planning Bell in their classroom and there aren't students there I I I don't see a problem with with the use of it in that in that rent uh one of our committee members was um I'm gonna keep this out one of our committee members was Mr Marram I'm G to bring my own mic next time I'll write that down um but I asked Mr maram to come because when he if you remember he came to Garfield last year was his first year and he saw cell phones were really impeding on the learning at Garfield and so he put some practices in place and I think it's important

074for you as a board to understand the implementation of this will be bumpy at times it's a change for some of our students we're going to get some push back at first however I will tell you I think the metrics that he's going to share with you it was a slam dunk to our committee to to go this direction after we already felt that way with the survey results so Mr Mar I'll keep this out just in case yeah um so uh yeah we kind of want to put our money where our mouth is uh because the only thing we don't really mention in that policy is what happens when the policy's broken um so we put that into practice we actually uh so if you want to post that first one there this is

075what we kind of implemented at Garfield so um our rule is uh cell phone out of sight in all areas in the building um and if that is violated um a parent picks the cell phone up um we call the parent parent has to pick it up from school um so we implemented that at the start of fourth quarter last school year um so it was partway through the school year um and to give you an idea of how that went right away um the first day we implemented that I called 19 parents to pick up cell phones um so I was like man I might have messed up here um because 19 parents had to come get the phones um two date and it's 22 now because I had to take one today um

076they messed up my numbers um but uh to dat uh the first semester uh we have taken 22 phones um so in one day last year when I first implemented this it was 19 in one day and now you can see we've gone through a whole semester of school and we've only taken 22 phones um kids have responded to this those eighth graders that are now there that experienced this fourth quarter last year know they don't want to get their phone taken away and mommy and daddy having to pick it up um and then the kids that are now seventh graders don't know any different um if you come to our school and I invite you to do that if you come to our school and you watch in the hallway even when they're transitioning

077class they won't be walking down the the hallway like this anymore um because that was a problem um it was especially bad in those transition times the teachers were doing a pretty good job of managing it in the classrooms but those transition times when they walked to and from class you wouldn't believe what they can do in three minutes on their phone um and what the reason we implemented this is because uh we found out through many investigations in the first part of the year that many of our serious physical incidents that occurred at the school um not only were they started on technology during school hours on those phones um there was people posting stuff about them after they happened on technology um we were having to suspend kids when those incidents occurred because

078they had their phone out recording it um that has reduced tremendously so if you want to show this last school year um we had 699 incidents in the first semester of interference disruption in the classroom um this school year first semester same amount of time we've had 240 incidents of interference or disruption um in our classroom I attribute that to the lack of self phones causing more interference or disruption not putting my own personal opinions into this but uh I'm a firm believer that these do more bad than good I actually one of the nights I left the committee ironically I teach a Miami class uh of Juniors studying to be teachers and they're 20 21 years old so they've grew up in a society where they've had these things their whole life so I

079took back some of our survey data and showed them some of the survey data and asked them if any of it surprised them including the students over over 50% of the students saying that they shouldn't have at school um and we made a list and what what we said what we found out is if you make a list of dangers of these things in school and Pros actual benefits I don't care what group of people you're talking to whether it's the parents the staff or the students no one can give more positives than negatives about these things being in our classrooms um and I think that's important for us to note and that's why I talked about it with those college students too and some of them were uh self-aware enough to even admit we

080know they're bad for us and they do more harm than good we're just addicted to them and I think we're all guilty of that as adults too but well Josh go ahead two things real fast number one I applaud you for taking that on taking on that that um that policy and enforcing it in your school I would assume as an administrator knowing that it is a district policy puts more teeth into what into that Pol into that gives you a lot more back backing and what happened so I I plud you to do that the second thing I was going to ask and this is I guess to Andrea Mrs Bens excuse me uh your majesty um is my own is have we seen this policy adopted at other school districts of similar size

081and characteristics and and and how has that worked out for them what can what can you tell us about that so I did uh some informal research of calling all of the local school districts around every school district in Butler County has a policy that limits the use of cell phones um there are some that still allow some teacher discretion here and there but the the a majority of them over 75% of the school districts in Butler County limit the use of cell phones um in the same vein that we are to this degree I mean yes because we are going to get the push back 100 speaking of teeth I forgot to mention this I I know one of the concerns about the parents having to pick up the funds if we took them

082from the students um I no concern I heard was that parents were going to be upset by that our survey results showed that our parents supported that and actually every parent I've had to contact about this has been very supportive of that policy um they they've actually said themselves like oh you can keep it as long as you want which I'm not going to um but they they're pretty supportive of that policy if their kid has that out and they and their kid knows they're not supposed to the parents have been supportive of that okay thank you and I think for us that's why we put back up the the plan and you can kind of see you know I want to thank this committee and all the members who aren't here tonight we really

083try to be very thoughtful of this of understanding the the biggest component of this is communication is working with our families our students and our staff to understand this we do want to allow the autonomy for our buildings to figure out what that communication plan looks like and that system for instance you know in an elementary school taking the phone that might be a better piece you know there were some buildings that expressed concerns with actually confiscating the phone themselves versus you know different tiered consequences that's why our committee made the recommendation to tie the consequences to our code of conduct we already have a code of conduct that allows for warnings allows for different consequences um but I am a firm believer and and someone said this before that when you set the expectation

084High kids will rise it they will rise and you know I I know that there will be some push back with this but I do want to reiterate at the beginning almost all of our buildings already are putting this practice in the place and so this is just a matter of bringing us all in alignment bringing the community on board educating our families that was a big push of our committee this just can't be a no right you can't have it here we also have to help families understand the consequences of cell phones because they're only with us for eight hours a day there's still a lot of things that happen outside of that day and so that's really um when we come to January I will bring that draft of the the committee we

085went line by line line by line line by line and we have a uh a Redline master that has new language as well as crossed out from the old that I'd like to bring for a first read to the board at our second January meeting and then from there we can have discussion but we just thank you for allowing our committee to do this work um and have a voice and helping to Define what this looks like moving forward well and to you uh Mrs blevens and your committee thank you I mean that was a huge undertaking and I think you've done a a phenomenal job um and and actually you know numbers don't lie when you look at what Josh um the turnaround that you see um and just on a side note I

086can remember this dates me a little bit when I was finishing up my Capstone course at Miami when the information Super Highway was uh first discussed and I can remember coming home from that um and I said to my husband this is going to be bad and I think I'm right I mean there's good things about it but it needs to be used properly and that's our goal as Educators is to help navigate help our kids navigate this new world we've done that you know another topic is AI that we we're discussing right we don't want families nor kids nor adults to be afraid of it but we do have to teach kids what those boundaries are how to use things where does it work um and this is a nationwide you know I know

087that Governor dwine is signing this in Ohio but you know on all the educational newsletters that I follow this is a nationwide conversation I would argue worldwide but I I do believe in our nation this is a a timely conversation so thank you Mrs Levin's committee I I think that's tremendous work I I I think one of the things that that needs to be considered with all of this too is that if we have consistent policy regardless of kids moving from building to building if the if the policy is generally consistent it isn't going to be a surprise and and and I'll use our Freshman building as example every year the entire student body is new so whatever expectation is set from the year prior to the next year it's a new student population in

088seventh and eth grade the student population turns over 100% in 24 months you know and if we're consistent at those grade levels and then the high school is also consistent with enforcing those policies when those kids come in there it really shouldn't be much different and I think that of consistency is helpful as you look at this holistically so I know this looks like a large undertaking and maybe I'm a little naive but I think it might go a little better than maybe we anticipate because of some of those components absolutely well thank you guys for letting us present thank you so much great job look forward to seeing the final first reading M bger Mr Davidson Dr Copus yes Mrs Matthews yes Mr Sprite yes we'll move to Executive session e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.