001I call to order the Westlake City Schools Board of Education January 13 2025 special meeting o call call to order at 6:46 p.m. fuken here here craft here lamb here lazinski here here not here is there a motion to approve the agenda so moved discussion roll call for the record I have moved by Pat seconded by lamb is the first I heard there Pat yes lamb yes pukan yes raft yes lazinski yes motion carries at this time we have a hearing of the public and just to get into that mode um I'd like to go through this statement the public May address the board during the periods of the meeting designated for public participation we the board of education do not engage in public debate especially do not have a public discussion about individual student
002situations in this setting each person addressing the board shall give their name and address if several people wish to speak each person's allotted three minutes until the total time allotted is used during that period no person may speak twice until all who desire to speak had the opportunity to do so period of public participation may be extended by a vote of the majority of the board president voting do anyone wish to address the board of this time if not we're going to move to the tax budget here the treasure thank you um and uh we are required to submit a tax budget or defend a tax budget to the county uh in Kaa County they ask for the alternate tax budget so that's uh what's uh presented to the board here uh in a moment
003uh tonight but I do like to give an opportunity each year for anyone in the public to come speak to the board if they have questions or concerns about our annual tax budget um there would be that opportunity now if anyone would like to come up and speak regarding our tax budget I don't see anyone jumping up to do that so um if it's okay with you Mr President I'll just move into the tax budget itself yes please and just have a quick discussion about that uh as I said annually the Board of Education in order to continue to tax uh the community and collect the funds needed to run the school district uh we are required to present a tax budget or in the case here of Kay County an alternate tax budget uh
004which is submitted approved by the Board of Education and submitted uh to the county for their approval um you'll see in this uh document that's attached to board docs I think it's only about four pages long maybe five pages long um we go through each of the different areas uh of our tax budget we start by going through each of our uh levies that are currently on the books um you'll see a combination there of your operating levies uh last one being passed in 2006 um you'll see we also have a bond retirement on there at what I estimate uh going for next fiscal year at 3.2 Ms and uh permanent Improvement uh funds of of8 MS you'll notice that on the tax budget they ask only for the maximum rate authorized not what it's
005currently being collected at so the bond issue can fluctuate every year because the maximum rate authorized is whatever is needed to pay the debt okay but everything else has fixed caps on how much you could collect so when we consider Bond retirement at 3.2 Mills on the books we have maximum rate authorized of 68.4 Ms okay that a lot of taxes okay but House Bill 920 passed in the 1970s says hey you know what when you pass a levy okay if it was originally intended to collect a million dollars you can only really collect that same million dollars on existing properties new construction is exempt from that but what what that means to a homeowner is as your property value goes up the millage that you pay goes down okay and that's intended to uh
006so that you are basically paying similar amount uh on your taxes that you were the year prior regardless of how your taxes go up now we've talked in the past there's some ex exceptions to that specifically inside millage okay but the reason that I discuss all of that is of that 68.4 Ms uh we're right around 26 Ms of actually collected tax uh for this year going forward I believe our general fund okay is down to 22 Ms uh to understand what that means exactly okay um I don't want to break down all the numbers and go into all the details of that but I will say that in reviewing the data it is the lowest tax rate for your operating in kyoga County now okay and when you look at uh your uh uh
007some neighboring counties I like to look at Lorraine and Madina okay it is one of the very lowest as well there's a couple except options specifically in marraine County but if you look a little deeper those are some school districts that have what's called a school district income tax open so overlin is one of them I want to say Keystone maybe it's another I think it's Wellington I'm sorry maybe um uh there's a couple I think there's three of them that have that school district income tax in luran County but um we don't have that our um our budget is built off of property taxes here in Westlake for our homeowners and our commercial uh property tax owners and uh we are able to operate the district um we've been very blessed to do so
008over the past uh come 19 years now without passing a new operating Levy and we're down to nearly the floor so you've heard me talk about the 20 mil floor we're at about 22 Ms now for operating so we're not quite at the floor but we're approaching it very quickly what the floor is is the state of Ohio says you have to collect at least 20 Ms if you drop below 20 Ms it automatically inflates back up to 20 uh 20 Ms so um I'm we are in an excellent position okay that's a lot of words to say that we're in an excellent position um when we look at uh our property values our residential property values when you look specifically to our neighbors I'm not trying to pick on anyone but if you take
009your home here in Westlake for any of you board members um and you take that home and you plop that same home into our neighboring communities the taxes would go up significantly okay even though the value would be similar the taxes would go up significantly and that's a credit to this board of education to the administration under uh the uh direction of Dr gagin and to the city the city has done excellent work uh under mayor kuuf and the uh City Council to allow long-term economic growth that has allowed our tax rate our millage rate to uh continually uh decrease and we're still able to operate the district uh with uh increased funding so we are very very fortunate so that the tax budget is deceiving because it's talking about your maximum rates authorized not
010what not what is actually collected uh as we go a little bit farther down there we talk about where I expect um our revenue and expenditures to be this is for next fiscal year so fiscal year 26 so we're looking at numbers when we're talking about an ending balance would be 18 months from now June 30th of 2026 it's a guess okay we work through that it's based off our five-year forecast that the board approved in November for your general fund uh other funds we just work through based on historical uh numbers um again we're in a uh a good place I don't see any uh cause for concern on our uh uh where we are for this upcoming school year and then finally the last page talks about our outstanding debt uh we do
011have a good amount of outstanding debt um but that's also because we've been able to rebuild um you know three brand new schools in the past 15 years you know give or take um and done have done significant renovations to dis uh as well as um facilities here and Transportation uh so we've been able to take on that debt uh we're in a good position repaying that debt uh we're uh our debt is rated very high through the rating agencies uh again I feel we're in a good position uh for us going forward and specifically for um fiscal year 26 which this tax budget is directed at so at this time I'm um happy to answer any questions you may have regarding the tax budget um if not we could ask for a uh motion
012to approve I'm the uh the 68.4 U toal maximum authorized rate you said ours is effectively 20 we about 26 when you count in your uh bond issue and Pi which is not part of your operating okay um now would you say that those go down as an aggregate one or two% or you know one or two a year or you know it it depends so driven more by it's going to be driven by your economy so as property values go up your millage goes down okay so we just saw a large re uh reappraisal right every six years they do a reappraisal okay um and then in the middle of those six years there's a threeyear triennial update um you know so the Rio appraisal was just finished last year effective this calendar year
013so uh you've probably seen that in your tax bills uh that you've received at home um property value uh going up significantly I believe that uh off the top of my head I think our residential values in wests like went up about uh on about 20% on average uh so it's a pretty sizable increase in property values um now we've seen across the state a a sizable increase in property values uh going forward um if we would get to that 20 mil floor um that's either going to happen uh based on a trienal update that would be another two years out or three years out at this point before it become effective or depending on home sales that may happen in the next year new home sales so new home sales including new business new
014opening not necessarily new home um because new construction is separate but home sales so home sales so if you sold your house and it was valued at I'm going to make up numbers here just $100,000 and a new homeowner came in and bought the house from you at $200,000 okay that home will now be valued at $200,000 okay okay it will not wait for a update a reappraisal or tral update it will automatically because it's a direct sale so when does new construction begin then so new construction is a little bit different new construction uh kicks in when the uh project is completed and becomes on the tax duplicate but it does not affect your millage rate directly it's additional funds for the district the reason why your millage rate goes down is because it's
015trying to balance for the people who existing homes existing businesses um as property values go up it's trying to balance that saying hey you know what we don't want you to take a big hit so we'll lower the millage rate okay but new construction they say hey you're new right now so you're gonna pay whatever the going rate is at that time so that's additional Mar unless to challenge it new construction is a little hard to challenge you're right new con but we are seeing uh the u a number of challenges for um uh transf the well the reappraisal that's happened and that's going to play out over the next you know months still it will take a while to get everything finalized thank you um I'd also like you thank the board you thank
016Dr gogg and I'd like to thank you for your fiscal responsibility and all of this big picture stuff too so thank you I appreciate it but um it's an honor to work for the board here and with this Administration it makes it a whole lot easier for me and so thank you absolutely thank uh thank you Mr treasure for your leadership and thank you and your staff uh for your leadership and Council we have a question uh the Q Qs CV Bond that's coming to at the end of 2026 so that's uh in schools we love to use acronyms so Q Scooby but I'm like I thought that was the Scooby-Doo one that's why I refer to it y so that is uh was sold for your uh uh high school project okay um that
017one is um a little interesting because it's a taxable issue so typically school districts uh uh sell tax exempt bonds uh this is a taxable issue and we're getting tax credits or we're getting a not a tax credit we're getting a rebate from the IRS so twice a year we get about $270,000 uh to help offset that interest for us this was done during um um the build uh was it build America America bonds I think the Babs yeah build America bonds that was uh right around that 2008 uh uh crash that they were trying to incentivize um projects so we were able to do that now the one thing that you'll see is um we set aside money to pay it uh this one has a balloon payment of the entire principal amount uh
018that comes due in December of 26 uh we are setting aside money through a what's called a syncing fund so while we're pinning each year it's going into a separate investment fund okay uh that is earning uh uh interest and that will help us pay off the full amount of that debt as well as any other debt we can use that interest earnings on so it works out fairly well as the the government is uh helping pay for the interest as well okay thank you so then when that expires in 26 that is then millage that would come off well kind of no not exactly okay so um what we've done is working with a municipal adviser um we've structured our debt knowing that that falls off and so that allows us to pay some
019of the other issues at a higher rate um or a higher principal uh payoff so it's not going you're not going to see a direct decline at that time with that specific issue other discussion Mr treasure will we move on to your recommendations and so uh the first recommendation would be the tax budget so if you'd like to ask for a motion is there a motion to approve 2 a the resolution to approve the 2025 2026 tax budget so moved second discussion roll call for the record I have fukin as the second piut yes fukin yes craft yes lazinski yes lamb yes motion carries I appreciate you doing that one separately I do have um one other uh piece on here a resolution to update State minimum wage I do like to put this on
020here uh recognizing the increase of minimum wage this year it went from 1045 an hour to 1070 an hour um you know uh I I just like to be tra transparent and up front with your board uh you know we put things in front of the board for your consideration uh if you tell me not to do this unfortunately I have to pay it anyways so uh it's one of those that our hands are tied with minimum wage but I do like to recognize it uh as there are uh different pieces that we do pay minimum wage mostly student pieces uh I will say working with Dr yagan and Mr maver um and Mr House were looking at uh classified substitute wages and I'm looking to put a proposal uh to the board here very
021quickly uh our classified substitute wages are close to minimum wage uh and we're struggling to fill uh classified substitutes and I uh do believe it would be the time to increase that so you'll see that here uh they're not at minimum wage right now but um it would be wise to increase that you an idea when that will come to the board uh if we can work through it it would be uh well I think even in January okay in a couple weeks okay we'd like to make the uh make it effective here with the new semester um and then that way moving forward we can try to fill our positions as best as possible the rest of the school year I move to approve 2B the resolution to update State minimum wage is there
022a second second discussion so do you have a um a comparison of uh other school districts we've been looking at uh other school districts we've also been just looking at what our base rate is for uh when we hire new staff and so we're trying to find what would be a a a good amount for that classified staff a substitutes further discussion roll call C yes lazinski yes fukin yes pan yes lamb yes motion carries moving on to board items and board comments I would like to congratulate Mr Hopkins and the entire Treasury Department on a clean audit and it was a great meeting and everything sounds like it's been going great I think what we'll do is uh in uh at our January meeting I'll discuss that a little bit uh further um and
023uh we did have that post audit and uh we'll be able to present uh everything to the the board hopefully in the in two weeks from tonight I appreciate that thank you we read to the CER or what do they call it the AER I you know again um I'm happy to present that to the board uh but uh there are parts of it that I fall asleep uh greeings so I would hate to you know waste the time of the of the m and it's up on our website uh we do load it up uh once everything's finalized we're still working through the finalization other board items or comments it was a wonderful season of by our music program with the choirs the bands and the orchestras I had the opportunity to attend the
024high school choir concert and Mrs Butler does always does an amazing job with that and then also the uh combined lbms holiday uh music program with uh the choir the band and the orchestra the all sounded very very good very amazing anything else I move to ajour to Executive session to discuss the appointment employment dismissal discipline promotion demotion or compensation of an employee or official is there a second second discussion roll call to adjourn into executive session at 706 CFT yes lazinski yes fukin yes P not yes lamb yes motion carries board will take no action during executive session nor when the board exits executive session thank you e