CorpusRecord 241048

West Geauga Board of Education Meeting December 11, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / West Geauga Local Schools
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Geauga County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,842 words · about 50 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay can you hear mine we're going to call this meeting to order can you call the role please miss Sherwood yes Dr Beers yes Miss Le yes okay will you rise for the pledge please flag United States of America stands na indivisible justice for all okay we are going to program reports and presentations please all right so tonight we've got a couple of objectives to do regarding the bonds and kind of to take us through where we've been so far and uh where we're going to meet on the 16th so in January the master facility committee uh made the recommendation to the board for a 612 campus with a renovation of the middle school and an addition of of a Fieldhouse so that recommendation was approved by the board on the 31st of January and

002that's where we've moved forward so throughout the summer um Mark and Scott and Rich and I and Nancy we all met with the Architects we've updated all those pricings because the last time we did a price estimate was in 2023 all those has been updated they've looked at those again we had the addition of a another member of the GPD family that had worked for the Ohio facilities commission that um is the one that does all the state building and he's now working for them and so we were had the benefit of having that expertise as well well so that that was a good thing to have that relook at the numbers and kind of uh give us a good estimate so in September I provided the board with a enrollment projections what we're going

003to see in enrollment coming into the future plus what we've seen for the last 10 years and then in October we had a final project update number so that number is 128 mil2 200,000 for that project so that'll be the 612 campus the addition of the Fieldhouse and then the renovations here at the middle school so and we've over the past uh four or five months maybe six months the board had transferred 4.25 million plus another $2 million coming of additional funds for the Middle School renovations to kind of reduce that amount as we've looked at that going along so that's where we are from a cost standpoint so Architects gave us an update during this last month we've had another look at those estimates from our construction attorney to make sure that those are

004you know within the guideline we've looked at that detail and we feel comfortable with those numbers as of today now prices could go increase things could happen because this obviously if it's approved in May it won't be built until 2026 in that time frame so a lot can happen in that time so we're we're looking at estimates and so in November we are looking at the financing how do we Finance this project how do we go about the process of issuing bonds what are the ramifications where the resolutions and then what is also the purpose of the bond so we kind of have to get the language down today that we want to see on the levy on the ballot so that's going to be working with Katherine from uh Bricker and then in December

005you're going to take a vote that's our first vote that we'll have for that one for a special needs vote and then we'll have a necessity vote and then we'll send that over to the Auditors so I want to turn this over to Katherine Schwarz she's with Bricker Gren and our really our bond attorney that's working with us and she's going to go through uh a lot of great information so ask questions this is a good time to ask questions and we can stop it start it whatever you want to do hi hi oh that would be helpful there we go Katherine Sports again please stop me at any time I've got I'm going to just go through a couple of slides and then I'm going to turn it over to Heather who's going to

006who's the municipal adviser for the district who's going to talk about the financing and the different options which we need to um decide upon to make a decision about the interest rate that we're going to put into the into the bond legislation okay so here I think here no that seems to I'm not sure what is I don't know why HDMI is up there but that is that is the right slide okay so that's the that's good I'm not sure I don't think I'm doing that no you're not Scott what you doing got so Karen has walked you through what got us to today um and that was a great back background what I'm going to talk about is what we need to do from now until to get on the May ballot and we

007have a couple of deadlines we're we're working for May 6th 2025 the good news about the May election is that most primary elections in odd-numbered years are special elections and often times you the district would need to Bear the total cost of that election the state plans to go on the ballot as well and um they have an issue that's not asking for money so that's that's also helpful um but because they have an issue on the ballot they will at least split the cost of this of the election with you um and closer to the time you can ask the Board of Elections about that um so State consents because you we are asking for an amount that is more than 9% of your assessed valuation we need to ask uh we need to

008get State cons we need to get special needs status and that special needs status looks at at the estimate of the assessed valuation in the future and you can you can borrow up to 12% so we can this 1282 is going to fit within that it's just a couple of extra procedural steps you'll need to approve legislation um requesting special needs and then um and part one the part there is an application that we're going to be guiding you through that is um due on January 6 so that's why you need to have this uh app approval of the resolution at your next meeting because the your first meeting in January is scheduled for January 13th so then we have we're going to also approve the bond legislation on the 16th and that the first

009part it's a two-part process the first part is going to be asking the county auditor to certify what the millage rate is going to be we need to have three pieces of information to give to the uh County auditor we need the dollar amount we need finalize the dollar amount which I believe is 1282 we need the interest rate which is what uh Heather is going to talk about and we also need to know the maximum maturity of the bonds and we have done some analysis working with your architect who has provided information now uh generally you could go up to 40 years is your maximum maturity if you're just building but you have to subtract from that any Furnitures fix and equipment and Paving and sort of um shorter lived assets and I've estimated

010that your maximum insurity is 38 years so we can go up to 38 years you could choose to go less most most times you want to go the maximum allowable so those are the information that's the information the county auditor will take and then we'll determine your millage amount once you get that information at the January meeting you'll come back and you'll do a resolution to proceed say we know how much we know what this information is we still want to go forward uh your deadline to submit everything is going to be January 28th not February 5th because your special needs so uh outline this process um that um you'll file with the board by January 28th then we will have to look at the ballot proofs do a few things but generally you should

011be on the ballot um my you know if if you my recommendation is as soon as possible after January 13th to deliver the whole package to the Board of Elections and ask just verify with them that they have everything that they need there is a lot of um scrutiny over everything just to make sure that you have it right um and to if you can ask them verify make sure you have everything is is always the best course of action try and get that ballot form back as soon as possible and then you'll be on the ballot on May 6 so these are the four items that we want to finalize um and the piece that I wanted to talk through with you a little bit is the purpose Clause now your purpose Clause this

012is the language that is going to be on the ballot and it needs to be in the resolution of necessity and in the special needs resolution so we need to finalize this prior to your meeting on Monday now you can you need to describe the project you can be you can be very general there's 's no requirement that you get very specific we generally would not recommend that you go hyper you know that you go hyper um specific because things do change there are districts that may want to mention middle school high you know you may want you may it may be helpful to to folks on the ballot to have on to have in this language you know the construction of a of a high school renovation or construction of a 612 renovation of

013aid mid School however if anything changes your enrollment changes and you end up building a five something happens you really don't want to be splitting hairs as to whether you can still do the project what we generally recommend is that you go as general as possible on your ballot language and then um in terms of information that you put out to the community that your plans are to to build a 612 you can provide information to the community that's factual so you can provide that information um but not necessarily go go hyper un unless you think there's some extenuating circumstances why it should be there so here's a very general purpose Clause that I've I've put together so constructing renovating expanding and improving school facilities that covers the gamut and that is what you are

014planning to do right Furnishing and equipping the same now what I have in Brackets because this is something that sometimes is helpful and sometimes is not is if if you want to mention the Fieldhouse uh including a Fieldhouse for school and Community use if and again whatever you say here has to be your plan and and you'll be sort of limited so you you don't want to you want to make sure that you're you're being inclusive you could obviously have a school uh a Fieldhouse for school and Community use fits fits in there you can fits in the first part without the brackets you can definitely Finance the Fieldhouse that is school facilities so you don't need it if you want to call it out you can if you think it's helpful um we can

015definitely put it put that in there and improving the sites thereof we don't need to mention anything about acquiring real estate because you have all the real estate the other reason why you you be you want to be pretty General is it has happened in the past it's not happening as often these days I will admit but if you have an excess of funds from this bond issue you want to you want to make sure that you can you can use it for your school fac fa ities for in this you know this type of a a purpose so this is what I wanted to talk through with you see if you had thoughts if there's anything if there's anything you want to add anything you want to subtract and your thought about the um

016bracketed language um I have two questions well one statement one question I think my opinion is that the Fieldhouse should be in there for the language I think that that's an important piece to advertise to the community that it it exists think it's benici I do um because you know we're fairly Suburban out here there's not a lot of options for people and knowing that there's a central place where the community could use it I think it's going to the field has and it was important in the work that we did ours right so yes so I think it's important that that that language goes in there but if we are to raise a building is that oh demolition yeah um we don't you don't actually need to say demolition okay we we we we

017typically don't actually put that word in there it's all it it is it's encompassing it is encompassing yes um and most many many of our all of our almost all of our construction projects are going to are going to involve some sort of demolition okay has this kind of language been in general successful you know there's not a there's not a good um I don't I don't think there's magic language I mean there's there to say this will help or not I mean the the the I'm looking more at the legal side of it I mean and and I can it's also very Community specific I mean I'm not I'm not trying to sway you one way or another but there are time there are districts where a you know where someone could read the

018word say stadium and somebody would might vote for the bond issue because they want a stadium somebody might also vote against the bond issue because they think their stadium is fine you know so so it's it's really it's very hyp specific in a community and I think the reason why I put Fieldhouse separately is I why I called it out was because not not for any other reason than the you know school facilities sometimes you don't immediately think about a Fieldhouse as being school facilities whereas obviously your your 612 building that's clearly school facilities right um it is incompass that is is there but you know it's it's just it's part of your project that is unique there's no you know this is you know this is there's no you know magic to this it's

019it just comes down to sort of preference and and instead of us just coming up we don't know your community instead of Us coming up with with something and just you know putting into the resolution I wanted to make sure you had input and I think one of the things we were concerned about the committee was concerned about is as we demolished you know a building we lost a gymnasium so each time you know the high school you know obviously when we build a six you know 612 building we're replacing those uh gymnasiums but at the elementary school level we would have to add those and that's kind of what led a lot of people to a fild house right as I'm looking at this field house do you I mean I think it could

020go either way is Fieldhouse one word or two do you have a preference um I mean I'm now we're really splitting hairs but I wanted to to look at how you it is two words okay is our local gracian right okay perfect I appreciate that I'm I I did use two and then I'm like I wonder if it if it should be one we've been we've been using the term Fieldhouse sort of all along we have yes I just as I was looking at that I was wondering if that's a good word or good two words for what this facility would be or if there was something else but because we've been using those words that's probably needs to be consistent and and there's 100% you're going to have Community use of the Fieldhouse I

021mean we don't have to go in and describe that on the ballot but again this has to be your intent so that's that's why I just want to verify are several I just Googled there are several seever it could be one word I mean rocket morgage Fieldhouse is one word field in studio West and then it says why is a gym call a field house with two words if you're using Fieldhouse as two words I I I I I appreciate that it's I guess it could could go both ways we just want to be field or field English term I'm not recommending that we do this but I'm just throwing it out there for a thought I know that some of the musical elements in our community are tired of sitting on the bleachers in

022the gym and on those little wooden chairs uh in the middle school gymnasium should there be mention of an auditorium or should there not be in this I know it's included in school facil ities but a field house could also be just a thought for you to ponder that's a good question I was wondering that too Auditorium because we don't have one now we have a very small you know we have a stage in the gymnasium in the middle school and I know that um I know that some of our band students and coral students and their families would certainly appreciate I think that would be one of the reasons why they might be interested in expanded facilities would it be accurate to say a Fieldhouse and Auditorium for school and Community use I think

023you could say both yes I think that would be fair yes that's because it's also something that we talked about during our during our facility plan you want the auditorium I mean this is this is where we need to make sure you know we we can be as specific we can put the auditorium first audit Auditorium and field Auditorium first that was her voice not mine but came from this end um we need to no that's what we're doing now we got yeah I like the idea of alphabetical order it's nice and orderly that way but I mean I'm not committed to that long term well this is long term well but I'm saying if the two of you want to flip it I'm okay with that okay and and just to be you know

024ideally we'll have an answer I mean if something you know if if you somebody comes into the meeting on Monday we will have a resolution that we're going to propose with the language that you've decided upon if something happens you can change it there's just you know we'd have to go through the she'd have Karen would have to go through the resolution or or make note of it and and approve it as it is it can be done I once had I think a 45 minute discussion about whether we should have the words you know like something related to central air um in on the ballot or not I mean I think there it last at least 45 minutes on the day that they were approving it and we had to get the language perfect

025and then you know approve it it can be done but it's just it's ideal to have it done in advance so there's no no question for sure regardless of the order I liked the fact that you put both Auditorium and Fieldhouse for school and Community use I think that's important yes I agree that sequencing yeah I don't I don't care what the order is I suggest an auditorium in fi house okay yep I mean alphabetically it works right y does that make sense for you it does and I think again we're you know if anyone asks why are you not putting you know K12 I mean that if anyone asks the question is you want to be as general as as possible you're calling these two things out because they are somewhat you know unique

026or there they're somewhat unique to the project and some might not immediately think of them as school facilities and if people aren't familiar with our schools they might not realize that we don't have an auditorium because that's an assumption most most schools today of a significant size have auditoriums and I you know again when you put out we'll talk about this a little bit more but when you put out information into the community you know that that is that is a statement that you can you can share with the community the the the plans include an auditorium which the school district does not currently have we purp yes ma'am y okay all right I'll I'll make that happen we're GNA turn it over to Heather Arling that didn't even take 45 minutes well C still

027time still thanks alrighty again Heather Arling Heather Meyer Arling I'm going back to Meyer soon Heather Meyer Arling with Bradley Payne Municipal adviser to the district we're going to talk about some funding options all right we're going to talk the bond issue option the USDA option we're kind of calling it a blended option because USDA can only go to a certain amount um talk about costs and then a summary with pros and cons of each one more thanks thank you okay so if you would choose the bond issue route I have up here a lot of the oh thanks the options here let me see if that all right that forward button there we oh sorry everybody I got a little click happy oh no need to go back one it's not going back one

028there we go okay up here I have listed all the participants first and foremost and most important is the issuer which is the school district um will'll be selecting the financing team which Karen has got mostly in place with Bond counsel and myself and an underwriter and potentially USDA for the funding portion um then we'll determine the borrowing needs which you all have already done and then from there authorizes the issuance of the debt which is what we're talking about today and you'll be doing on the 16th um the underwriter which gives us access to the investors and the investors then pay for the bonds that they purchase and then those funds at closing come to The District in order to continue with the project um Municipal advisor which is myself I have the fiduciary

029responsibility to the district to ensure the lowest cost of funds um we also work from the beginning and put a schedule out for everybody to review which is post election and it's responsibility as everybody for every single step getting to the closing where the School receives the funds we also review all of the the documents that go out to investors and then on pricing day which is to me most important we help with the rating presentation and the most important is pricing day pric day is when you go to you know purchase the car purchase the house it's where the rates are set so we get together with the underwriter underwriter is putting out all the information to investors and potential investors and it's like an auction that you go to the more investors you

030have interested the lower you can make the the yields I was using jargon the rates um we want the lowest rat possible so we work with the underwriter it's an art and a science to go out to it is to go out to the market to offer the bonds and then we want the most investors interested and the underwriter also pre-market it a couple weeks leading up to it and talk to investors and answer questions about the district or the structure of the bond issue um then we're involved until the end which is the closing also included is Bond counil Council which is Bricker and Eckler or sorry Bricker Gren there was a merger recently my apologies Underwriters Council um sometimes Underwriters council is involved and they represent the underwriter um rating agency which I

031mentioned um it's either S&P or Moody's and we do a presentation to them that takes about an hour and they ask questions and we provide a lot of documents to them and then they come back with a rating which is just like our own personal credit score the higher the rating the lower the rates just like it is for a personal credit score um then we have the paying agent which will take the funds from the district for the semiannual payments and give them to the bond holders so the bond holders get paid any questions there thank you all right and this is post election what that looks like I think we went over this um a while ago maybe about a year ago um but wanted to revisit it since we're getting closer so

032start to finish about 10 weeks and what we'll start with here is again engaging the financing team we usually meet right after the bond issue passes and I come with a preliminary schedule everybody walks through all the facts make sure we all have everything in place and everyone's responsibilities are laid out and we haven't missed a step we get that finalized um I identify the sources which we already will already know this is from a utgo bond issue um information is starting to be gathered by the Bricker Graden group a lot from the county auditor and from financial statements from the district to get the preliminary official statement together which if you've ever bought stocks bonds mutual funds you get a prospectus the thing that everyone reads to get themselves to go to sleep at

033night from front to back it's called a preliminary official statement it's the exact same information a lot of information about the bonds themselves and then also about the district and a lot of focus on the financials so Karen will be helping a lot with that as well all of us kind of come together and work on it um and review it um next it'll be um I already went through that the rating agency that I talked about it's about an hourong conversation with the rating agency um usually the treasur and superintendent are involved in that as well as myself Katherine and an underwriter and they take about a week to review everything they go to a committee of senior analysts the analysts that we talked with will review all of the information we put a

034nice presentation together um which they use during their committee meeting answer any questions and write up a a press release and a full report on the disc District so instead of our credit report with all of our payments and all that it is written words and charts about the district it's very in-depth um after that you all have already approved all the bond legislation we sit down go to pricing sometimes we go to the under writers office so we're in front of all of their Traders I just think it helps them focus on the district's bonds that day of pricing versus any other bonds they might be selling in the market sometimes they're very large Underwriters they're the Wall Street firms and they have you know $250 million New Jersey Turnpike that they're focusing on

035we want them to focus on West chaga so I found that pricing day is more important than the rating agency and going to them I found that the pricing day is more important to be in front of the underwriter and the Traders so that they know this is what we want want you to focus on we're in the other room in the conference room we want you working your butt off to find those investors to help lower the yield so we found that that works really well um after that about two weeks later is the closing and we everyone has signed all the documents that need to be signed usually a week beforehand Katherine's team will get those documents together everyone will sign and then we get on a call and the funds are transferred

036any questions there as far as the the rate M you're going to show us later of as predicted rates yes and how it would affect payments yes but those are clearly estimates now and those wouldn't be um cast in stone until after week eight until pricing day the pricing Day pricing Day is when it's set and stone so we may think now that it's you know 5% interest rate and it comes pricing day and it turns out that it's 4% so then that affects all of the millage and everything payments right but you've already passed the millage amount so if you were a voter would you be would you prefer the school district going out with a 5% and you voting on that millage and it coming in lower or would you preferred to have

037it go at 5% and then when they price the bonds it's five and a half and your millage is higher which would you prefer I found that being a little more conservative with the rates on the ballad is better than having to go to voters and saying oops sorry Mage is going to be a little higher so I tend to lean a little more conservative on the rates okay but it also I don't want to muddy the Waters but it's a philosophy um we were talking about another school district that may or may not be somewhere around here um that is going on with a lower percentage rate the philosophy is you know the millage you want you make it work and you do there are some tools you can use short-term notes um to

038help manage millage and keep that millage where you want it so there are some things capitalize interest the first few years that you can do to help manage that millage if you know some bonds are falling off meaning you have existing debt out there and you know that those are going to be paid off in three years so there's going to be that millage drop and so you've built that into your projections and so that lower interest rate to get that lower millage kind of meets that need so you're being creative with notes or capitalized interest I know I'm getting a little jargony but you can do that to help manage the millage the first few years but there are unique circumstances like that so when do you do the optimization of these multiple factors

039well that's why we go out a little conservative on The Ballad language and then as we get closer to pricing day that's when myself and Zach Logan on my team who's a quantitative analyst he knows the bond market inside and out and he's working with the underwriter and they're coming up with that Art and Science I talked about of what you go investors for so you don't want to go out too low and then everyone says we don't want those bonds that's too low we can get a higher yield over here with the New Jersey Turnpike whatever it might be um and you don't want to go out too high where all of a sudden for each of the 38 maturities you have 15 orders and your you know $128 million bond issue you received

040gosh you know 200 plus million 300 million in orders you don't want that so it's this that's why I called it an art and science there's this fine line you walk in going out and we kind of believe that you go out a little bit stronger than what Underwriters can be comfortable with because they like to get all the orders in and then lower it down and we think we should go out kind of with our worth and what you think it should be you get the orders and then you can even go lower so it's that's when we finalize it and when we kind of put it together but right now we don't have all that information so that's why it's a conservative rate did I go too deep in the in the week

041there um you didn't answer the question that I was trying to ask that was my next question to you because I hate to use the word creative financing but I thought you were saying that there are different ways that we could play this as far as a aiming for a percent that we want to have by doing some other kinds of you said capitalization of the interest and some other such things so at some point or other you need to have that discussion and calculation of well what else could we do to try and get um the interest rate where we want it or where is reasonable to get and where we want it so my example with all of that was with the school district that's going out with a a lower interest rate

042yeah and I just assume that that's some of the stuff they might be doing and looking at that was my example right um and I think they have Bond millage dropping that's why I said that um but a lot of that you could factor in ahead of time in making your decision MH I mean Karen can tell you we've got this coming off or we've got this we're going to have to put on we've got these other sources of money that we could use to maybe I'm going to say buy down the interest rate like we' be paying points on a home mortgage type of thing right we can't do that but we have talked about all the different options which is why we looked at USDA right and that's in here as well yeah

043um so we've gone through a lot of different options um and come up with what we think is the best two options that we're presenting today we were talking about school district we don't know all the facts about that school district however I've worked with other school districts that have used a low interest rate lower interest rate because they were going through a reevaluation and so the county auditor was estim you have to estimate your your interest rate based on today and now we're in24 B but if the county auditor is estimating that the assess valuation going to go up by 25% you know they can can you can put in a below Market interest rate to try and get you to the mill that you're that you're that you think you're going to actually

044going out with if the bond issue passes also the mill rate is set every year based you know it's not this is an we're doing our best yes but it's not you're not going to just automatically get a you if you come out with 4.45 Ms County auditor is not going to just Levy 4.45 Ms for 38 years it's going to come down as as your assess valuation goes up that's going to come down and it's going to come to the amount that you need once it's the payment amount they're going to look at a number of factors so we we are putting our best gu out can do 38 years it's going to change so much so each year they're going to they do a new Bond millage so every year we submit information

045to the county auditor they come out and they'll give us a new Bond millage and say this is your new millage for the bonds that's what we've done in the past I mean and that's when we've done in the past when we did the um improvements right over the and lowered and then we ended up paying it off early too I mean because and then you not if you pay it off early you can voters you know 38 years but it's Poss you could pay it off year 36 and then the B zero nobody is and we did that yeah and so one of the things you know we looked at this in 2023 when we were first starting to look at this and that was before we had our 2023 revaluation so that we

046were looking in the sixes you know the Mills were in the sixes and now they're you know we're almost one milter you know so uh that reevaluation changes the Dynamics of the Mage so but the county auditor every year will come through and re look at it every year it's different and if you want we can complicate it more with how the county auditor calculates it and how it really comes out but I won't go down that that path no yeah I think we know that one but are we did I answer your question yeah go ahead okay all right this is where we rates were on November 1 um this the gray here shows you where they have been back to 1991 so this year would be your first Year's payment so year one

047that would be your first year payment that's where the rate is so we're still in somewhat of a Nike swish a normal yield curve is like this where the average is but you know unfortunately this is where we are where the short-term rates are a little bit higher and then year two three and so on so the gray bar is the historic the green is where we are it hasn't changed significantly since November one and then you have the average which is is the orange there oh thanks um here is what the county a county auditor millage estimate looks like so we've mimicked ours to look everyone in the industry does this to look exactly like the County Auditors and how they do it so the big points here are the assess valuation and then

048we have again this is just for the bonds we have the 4.75% interest rate over 38 years and then 128 M200 th000 and then we have the total payment of 6.2 per year and then the average of 6.5 I'll round it up which brings us to a mileage of 5.24 then down here we did some estimates for a $300,000 home the annual cost is just under $550 a year and then as everyone usually does is the the daily cost of your cup of coffee and then here we'll go through the USDA loan um the smaller amount of participants here um we would need to add in the underwriter as well because USDA only goes to just shy of a100 million because their system can only go that high sorry and they pay you in10 million

049increments you to have 10 checks issues have small bond issue the 28.2 million so it' be two different um issues um I will say that I was on a call yesterday with the USDA team with another school district their rate right now is 3.875 and they think it's going to be going up though to 4% in all my analysis um 4% on USDA was my threshold of breaking even between going to the private Market or the public market excuse me and going with USDA and a little bit of the the public market with the 2.8 28.2 million um because of the interest earnings with USDA you don't get the funds up front so you can invest them and make money um the public market you get all the funds at closing like I said the

050funds are wired to the district so Karen can invest those and I've estimated with kind of a generic construction schedule that the district could earn about $5.2 million in interest which can help a lot with overages and things like that I can't tell you how many districts did their projects got close to the end and said Heather we need to issue more debt what can we do um so that interest earnings really helps a lot I found thank you um so shorter time frame frame uh but Karen would be working months before this on an application to USDA um a lot of the other little work has already been done uh but the application is what she would need to work on which is similar information to the preliminary official statement that we talked about

051earlier with the public market offering um same things just a shorter time frame any questions there so Karen would be busy doing both of them if yes it is to do we'll have to do a you know statement and we have to USDA yes if you did kind of the the combination of the two that would be 10 million or8 million doesn't matter still the same information amount of work it's a lot of work and we have a Moody's rating already so I would moodies yes because S&P just redid their methodology and they're matching moodies now um so here um I already said that usda's ratees 3.875 and we have the current market for The Ballad at 4.75 it's a little bit lower right now but again we want to be conservative in case rates

052do go up we don't want to go back to the voters and say sorry the millage is a little higher um the fees with USDA which we'll get into are are lower um but they're paid out of either the general fund or the project fund so you have to keep that in mind where a public market issue it's paid through the production which is called premium um we can get into that another time but uh it's just where the market is you have a significant amount of Premium that goes into the bond retirement fund and help helps pay debt issuance the next few years but it also pays for all of the fees it's kind of like APR apy when you buy your car and you can I go back one more time you USDA

053one great thing is that when they lock in your rate if rates happen to go down before closing they will adjust it down to that rate which I thought would be the direction we're going except for yesterday when he said he thinks it's the rates are going up which was can't go up it does not go up once it's locked in it stays there it can only potentially go down but you could also refinance a USDA loan you can refinance a USDA loan at any time which I'll get into that with the pros and cons okay so the Blended issue we Blended the rate to four and a quarter everything else remaining the same the four and a quarter is the only thing we have changed the millage rate is 4.97 any questions there okay

054costs so here we broke out um all the fees on the left there it's the bond issue in the public market for 128. two and then in the second column we have the 100 million for the USDA and the 28.2 of the bond issue so the bond issue will I don't want to be in a photo um the bond issue the premium produced would pay for that 1.3 in fees and again these are just estimates um for example I think wait I think I deleted that I did um but the underwriters Council may not be needed um all of our fees are these are all estimates um and then for the USDA it's just shy of 600,000 and that would come out of either the general fund or the project fund any questions there but

055the 1.3 would come out of the bond fund not the bond fun the the production the premium because we right now in today's market and since I've been in the industry the bond holders the investors they want to purchase the bonds at a premium which is a compliment because they think your bonds are worth a premium so instead of at par which is in 2025 let's say were Sal just keep round numbers $100,000 in payment they would pay at par $100,000 for that specific maturity they're paying for a premium they're giving you more than $100,000 so that additional money has to go legally into the bond retirement fund but we also industry standard the way the market is right now what it's dictating is the cost of issuance all the fees get paid for by

056that premium my point was that it's coming out of that pot of money rather than out of our general fund yes or the project fund Okay now what's the project fund the project fund is the 128. two oh okay okay so here I broke out the pros and cons of each at first first blush what sticks out to me is that there's more cons on the USDA side right um I want USDA to be a lot easier I've talked to them about that um they're pretty much tied with the restrictions that they have um the pros are lower fees like we talked about um the downward rate adjustment if rates do go down after they lock you in and before closing you can pay it off at any time which is nice um and they

057can do interest only which is also called capital I interest for the first two years in the market you can do three um the cons are the you every time a contractor needs to be paid Karen's filling out a form in order to get that money to pay that contractor somewhat tedious um and then like I said we'd be working about 90 to 180 days beforehand on the application which is a pretty in-depth application um buy America build Amer America Act um it's kind of a stipulation that they have and it can increase material costs so there's that to think about as well um the other school district I'm working with was able to receive a waiver on that so we could try that um and then again the fees are paid for from the

058general fund or the project fund any questions on USDA before I move on to the public market okay so the bonds the pros are the immediate funding which then leads to the interest earnings of over five million um more flexibility on the structure we get to decide what it looks like we USDA here's your here's your 100 million and here's your rate and that's it um and again the fees are paid from the premium generated the cons are the fees are higher and you can't pay it off until 7 to eight years again this is a utgo bond issue this isn't you know a a water treatment plant where you know they raised rates and they have more Revenue coming in and they want to pay it off sooner for utgo bond issue for a

059school district utgo is unlimited tax General obligation and that means it's voted bonds um um there's no reason a school district for a building is going to be paying it off in s to eight years right right it's not logical I have not seen it happen I've seen about 10 years early and that's about it um and that was AV increases and things like that um the reason for that is refunding if rates go down you can refinance it or as we call it in our industry refunding you can refund it for a lower rate so is that really a con I just wanted to make sure I all cards are on the table there so the USDA loan we would get our funding periodically so we would submit a request for funding they would

060pay that so each time we would you know the contractor would sign off on something The Architects would sign off on something and we'd submit that payment so that's just how the funding that's the form she's talking about so we would just that payment and we be fed don't it takes to get that funding each time oh I'm sorry I I just don't know how long that funding takes for the each application you what do you think us USDA I'd say within two weeks but okay once it's set up I mean they it just is a process of going in and applying for the payment and then it being U transferred to our account y well the the rates have changed so the rates have gone up on the USDA before they were lower so

061as we look at the rates and we don't have to make a decision now that's why we're going to have the we're going to ask for the higher interest rate so that we're have that flexibility and we'll make that decision as we get closer and we have tonight we're gonna we'd like we're gonna vote on it Monday tonight is just the rate proposed millage that you've seen which is the higher one the worst case I guess that is all I have look at the photo up there but any additional questions regarding funding options you go back to the two charts uh you pointed out what the yearly cost was with the bonds um for a $300,000 house what was it for the USDA or the the there we go one how do they compare $521

062and the other was 549 yes 549 so Supply hardess it wasn't hard for the other District um but I will say that the USDA folks were a little surprised that they got it waved the process wasn't hard it's getting um the process isn't hard getting submitting the paperwork it's getting approved and giving them all the information you can to get approved um gosh this was about a year ago that they've got that approved because they went on the ballot last year um let me revisit that but I it the process wasn't hard it was getting approved that was hard I know I can't remember their circumstances that they used either um but that's a good point prices are set now for next year but you aren't necessarily building next year and starting to build next

063year next year's costs that are set for 26 that will be the yes okay Mr beers did you have another question no okay all right we're gonna bring it home all right awesome I uh any questions for me before I start I'm going to talk a little bit about campaign guidance and I know you saw my slides I have a much a fewer here and I want to just I'm going to go through them really fast just want to make sure you understand some of the uh requirements especially after the um auditor of State guidance that came out last year it's not necessarily self-evident um so basically the the guidance and and rules that are um statutory rules govern what administrators employees and school board members can do in terms of um campaigning for the

064approval of the bond issue now just to set the stage the administrators um have a harder time identifying when they are not working than board members that this all comes back to that public funds cannot be used to support or oppose a bond issue and so public funds include the use of facilities somebody who's being paid and for board members generally when you are being paid is when you are sitting in these meetings so you have a much broader ability to campaign and and I can provide this information because I'm trying not for you to understand what the laws are that's that's basically why why I'm here we would recommend the most conservative approach and um even though you are on your own time when you're not sitting here we would generally recommend that if

065if you are endorsing the bond issue or you are doing if you're writing a letter to the editor the editor if you're doing anything we wouldn't recommend that you use the title board member because that can also tie back to what you are being paid to do you in your own capacity have much more broad Authority so I wanted to just sort of that's not always clear to people and wanted to just bring that um that's that's the general piece of information I wanted to provide uh it's not working um so I'm going to mention just a couple of Hot Topics that we get lots of questions on please stop me if you have any any questions Communications you can provide the school district can provide Communications about the bond issue um and but they

066have this the the tricky part is what you can provide is neutral verifiable factual information you need to write communic oftentimes Communications are written by your Communications Department who might not be used to writing research papers which is basically what the information you can provide to the community is and the community needs to understand that this is the all they can provide which is why when you get a very sort of research paper sounding communication you kind of wonder why is why isn't it why isn't the school board why isn't the school information like trying to be you know know pro- endorsing this this bond issue because they can't that that's that's basically what it comes down to they cannot outwardly be persuasive so they can provide information and your information can come right out

067of board documents they can come out of any information you have on your the study The Architects you can provide information anything there but almost you almost think about it as every sentence it's like a research paper could I footnote this where did it come from and it's not just saying we encourage you to vote Yes it's you know that that it that persuasiveness could say we are replacing our old you know and and sort of using using opinion words about the facilities that you have um it's it's going back to elementary school fact versus opinion and you just can't use any words that somebody who might that that somebody might view as being persuasive and your test for that is really somebody who thinking about somebody who might oppose the bond issue and what

068would they think could be um something persuading people to vote for it and and it's a hard it's a hard standard um you can put information on your website you can put send information home with students you can use your um your email distribution list you just have to be really careful um so we've got some do this not not that you know it's it's not an editorialization um you um ALS o cannot um you cannot and you can give any information if someone asks you for information you can the best way to do that is through a public records request um that you can have Levy Levy committee members asking um so um we would also recommend that you not allow the levy committee to um have paid advertisements on at the school board

069um at you know anything regarding the school you the next slide um also just like to mention um Levy commun Communications the oftentimes the the folks who are going to run your campaign are going to be Levy committee it's important that those folks have some understanding of what these rules are as well um because you don't want somebody trying to help the district and accidentally you know causing causing problems I had I had a I live in a community that had a bond issue on the ballot just a year ago I was a PTO president and it was shocking to me how often these issues came up of what what people could and couldn't do the newsletters at the PTO has their little blurb you couldn't have you couldn't advertise a levy committee meeting in

070there because the those Communications were sent by the school district using School District time it's also challenging because the levy committee doesn't have access to your distribution list your email distribution list so getting that you know being able to distribute to people is challenging but that's that's the case so any communication with uh the levy committee again you can do that on your own time we would we we would caution you don't use your school email account um even though you transact all the rest of your school board business through your email account this is a time where you need to use your private um email account uh also had a situation in our own District where the levy committee took a very basic um a very basic video that the superintendent had done that

071sort of checked all these boxes and then posted it on their website and said we're so glad to have the endorsement of our superintendent and this the superintendent you know that you assume would endorse but the you know that what that was putting words into a into an administrator's mouth which you can't do as well so um just wanted to sort of um it it is helpful that the folks who run your Levy committee have some information on what they can and can't do um School District resources money is your this inability to use public funds that extends to your um even even your postage stamp um meter we wouldn't recommend that we allow that you allow one group to use your your bulk rate I think the main thing is that if you uh

072if somebody if if the Levy committee or anyone has a request to use to use space you can go on to the next one um you have to follow your business your building procedures and use policies um and and generally you have if there if the the preference is to just not allow any use uh the levy committee hopefully could meet in a library rather than in your space but if you're allowing any group to come and use your space you'd have to allow an u a anti- levy group use your space as well that's kind of the the general um um the general require requirement um use your school district email only for normal business and um and make sure that your staff and others know that these are rules as well it's the

073same thing teacher shouldn't be using their email um to talk to the levy committee although they can be participating in the levy committee on their own time um so I mentioned this that you do do have your own First Amendment rights um and the the challenge is when are you not working that challenge is much more much more sticky for administrators superintendent Treasurer who in theory it's hard to Define when when you are not um acting as when you don't have defined business hours um so you know the goal is again to let the levy committee do all the heavy lifting uh Levy any members of the community can use your regular um public records requests to get to ask request any information um outside firms and surveys the other thing to just um make

074sure that you know is we there years ago there were a lot of um PR firms that would have have a little thing in their contract for your their General work if you sign this contract we will help you pass your bond issue for no charge that you can't have you know Provisions like that um no vendors that you are paying cannot be required or uh encouraged to support your Levy campaign they can do it on their own accord um and uh Communications firms you just can't be used to to make persuasive material um also there are there are time there are many times where um schools like to to survey their Community you've got to be really careful that the survey can in no way be be considered something persuasive especially if you well

075in any case but especially if you're paying somebody to do it um that's it do you have any questions I know I get a I I I I gave this I gave a much longer presentation I think I had 25 questions there's because there's it it's not it's not the rules are not obvious so our board members they're on the clock or on when they're meeting in their meetings yes or Finance Comm but not a finance committee meeting or just it just depends how you're uh are you are they PA they're paid just for attending board meetings and and that means that at at board meetings you know you you can't come in here and say I I hope you know the the the being persuasive is I hope all of you know I hope

076all of you vote go in home and vote for that that's the kind of thing you don't want to that you can't use your time in your board meeting to do make sense it it you have to follow the normal the you know it's all about procedure so if you have the typically at the beginning of your meeting you have public comment if you whatever your rules are is it 3 minutes you have you have to sign in whatever your rules are anybody can use those Pro anti um as long as they're it's very open and it follows your general rules make sense yes ma'am all right thank you sir any any last any final questions for either Heather or me okay we'll find all right thank you so much for coming and helping us

077with this and I know we've spent a lot of time together already but we want to see kind of the 38 years right so I'm sorry the 4.75 that's the interest rate that's the interest rate but that's the Blended one isn't it no that's the um that's the public Oh I thought the public market one was 5.24 not the millage rate the interest rate oh we don't have to determine the millage rate for the for the resolution that's the county auditor will send that to us later that we just have to give them the interest rate okay and you think that the 475 is a reasonable conservative kind of number okay all right thank you thank you so much than careful driving back all right okay we have a couple of personnel matters resolution 384

078is the certified substitute list for the 2425 school year second any discussion hold on one second I'm sorry that's okay Kathy was first I second okay um can you call the rooll please yes this this is for what for a librarian sub this is a it's just a sub certified sub list just a substitute adding someone to the sub list General okay okay call rooll please Dr Beers yes Miss leworth yes Mrs Sherwood yes resolution 385 is to approve a substitute administrator for the 2024 2025 school year this is an assistant principal at the high school so move second any discussion I'm just gonna tell you a little bit about it um we were fortunate enough to uh coax Michael chaffy out of retirement to come in and assume the assistant principal ship of uh

079West giaga uh High School while Carrie is out on her leave and uh we were fortunate to get him I say that because he comes to us you probably knew him as the Newberry principal prior to the merger um consolidation I should say to be more technically correct I suppose of Newberry with West giaga so Mr chaffy was very respected there um I had the added Advantage after the consolidation occurred in 2020 with West giaga he served as the principal of the elementary school in Cardinal local schools and two of my grandchildren were there so I I got to observe him for two years acting in his role as principal when we knew we needed someone to come in to fill in for this year uh as Carrie leaves we were uh fortunate to get

080him to come out of retirement and I say fortunate because he has a a a longitudinal uh history and knowledge of not only the staff who came over from Newberry some of whom are at the high school but also the kids um so I guess the first day was filled with a lot of hugs and greetings from people who hadn't seen him for a few years but he comes in as a seasoned administrator he had I think 28 years in the classroom and he has multiple years experience as an administrator also he's an Ela former Ela teacher which appealed to someone in our central office staff and to our board president I'm assuming but he also comes to us with a significant history as a as a building level administrator and we're fortunate to have

081him here so I know he'll be a good fit he's here he came Monday and he started Monday um because we needed him here to we wanted him here for a week before Carrie leaves but she's uh she's going to be out of here pretty soon from the looks of her so and so this will be for the remaining of this school year yes call the roll please miss leor yes Mrs Sherwood yes Dr Beers yes resolution 386 is to approve classified uh classified staff appointments for the 2425 school year second okay any discussion call the role Please Mr Sherwood yes Dr Beers yes Miss leworth yes resolution 387 is to accept a classified staff resignation so move second any discussion call the role please Dr Beers yes Miss Lor yes Mrs Sherwood yes resolution

082388 is to approve an an additional Transportation Route assignment for the 2425 school year so move second any discussion call the role please miss lenworth yes Mrs Sherwood yes Dr beer yes resolution 389 is to authorize the award of service contracts for the 2425 school year so I'll move second any discussion we've got gymnastics program yet we have we what we have one yeah we have we have site gynastics no we still have okay we still have a small gymnastics program they don't practice here they're not here anymore okay we have no equipment here that was my confusion I guess call the RO please Mrs Sherwood yes Dr Beers yes Miss leworth yes okay and then we are going to be adjourning our next board meeting is a regular board meeting Monday December 16th 2024

083at 7:00 p.m. here in the board office community room do I have a motion to adjourn can I ask another question just before we adjourn um the the deadlines that that um were shared were of January 6 and and the 12th or whatever th those are just deadlines that need to meet that's not when we're going to have our votes your votes will be on Monday will be the necessity and then January 13th will be your will be the next board meeting okay we do have we're splitting I propose splitting the organizational tax budget hearing for the January 6th meeting and then having our regular meeting on January 13th so that would be two meetings in January I sent that out wait there'll be two meetings in January January yeah so the 13th is the

084first meeting in January no January 6 would be the tax budget hearing in organization and then the regular meeting will be on the 13th okay where normally we do them back to back on we do back to back but I normally but this time we're splitting them apart yeah just to give us time between our votes okay but we do have a meeting there will be a meeting on the 6th of Jan 6 and 13th right motion so moved yeah second call the RO please Dr Beers yes Miss leworth yes Mrs Sherwood yes

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.