CorpusRecord 243869

2-6-2025 Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / North Bend School District
Date
2025-02-10
Location
Coos County, OR
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,797 words · about 99 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001we'll get on with it okay this is a call to order if you're here for the regular meeting of the Northbend School District Board of Directors on Thursday February 6 you're in the right place and I'm glad to see a big crowd has turned out because there's some pretty interesting topics so thank you for coming uh okay we will have the flag pledge the flag is to my right if you don't stand please flag of the United States of America and to the repu for it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all all right let's have a roll call Dallas Pon Brink Julie pleas Carol Yardley your host this evening Jim Jordan got Nathan mcclint talk Michelle Roberts and Mary schi we got seven for seven okay agenda item two uh

002approval of the agenda before someone makes a motion we did have uh at the ESD at the request of the ESD superintendent uh and concurrence with oh okay okay oh do I no I think it's me more better oh there it is I might get carried away okay um so on the agenda uh the ESD superintendent has requested to remove agenda item six the ESD local service plan so I'm going to request we uh have a motion to approve the agenda including that deletion so move second okay there's a motion in a second to approve the agenda and removing agenda item six all in favor say I I okay 70 Michelle okay public participation and I'll be reading from the agenda on this board the board welcomes comments and questions from the public if you

003wish to address the board please fill out a public participation sheet available at the table and give it to the board secretary we ask that you limit your comments to 3 minutes if more than one person will be addressing the same topic we ask you we ask you that you appoint a spokesperson to speak for the group speakers may offer objective criticism of the school operations and programs but the board will not hear comments regard regarding individual School Personnel so Michelle what do you got we have one more semester okay two okay so good I let's see I would like to talk a little bit about public comments it's great to see so many folks here because it's uh we live in a great community and um I'm thankful for it it could certainly be

004made more better than it currently is but um I think everyone that's here must be interested in the community and in particular I'm going to specul urban renewal perhaps so anyhow um for public comment the governing document for the uh the school board that we have approved for Northland school district is uh called bdh and it is public comment at board meetings so um I'm just going to read a couple sections that kind of uh lay the groundwork and perhaps might clear up any misunderstanding that currently exist um the board will establish procedures for public comment in open meetings the purpose of these procedures will be to inform the public how to effectively participate in board meetings for the best interest of the individual the district and the P patrons the information will be easily

005accessible and available to all patrons attending a public board meeting so has that been made available that you that information that they fill out fill out card and okay great um under procedures for public comant meetings uh item three any person who is invited by the board chair to speak to the board during a meeting should State their name and address and if speaking for an organization the name and identity of the organization a spokesperson should be designated to represent a group with a common purpose and the last thing I'm going to read out of here is uh uh item six at the discretion of the board chair anyone wishing to speak before the board either as an individual or as a member of a group on any agenda item or other topic may do

006so by providing the board secretary with a completed registration card or sign-in sheet prior to the board meeting in order to allow the chair to provide adequate time for each agenda item so so that's a reading from that I guess the the board chair has discretion to set how this goes so we have in procedures we have essentially was if you have a group of common purpose elect a spokesperson for one one for each one pro one con I believe that there is a lot of passion and interest around this topic so I had uh suggested to the uh City administrator that we allow five Pro Ur and five against and that's in the interest of managing the meeting and completing our agenda items so um see I would like to read from a recent

007communication from the uh City administrator not the one from yesterday not the one from yesterday the one from today so and this is under a heading looking forward together the relationship between the city of Northbend and the school district has historically been one of mutual support and collaboration we believe that by working together on these resolutions we can achieve outcomes that benefit our entire Community particularly our students and their families I respectfully request the board to consider one on expanding opportunities for public comment to ensure comprehensive Community input now that's a reasonable request I mean that's something I can get behind so uh personally you know coming up with five Pro and five con I'm I'm an 8020 person and after hearing five of each I pretty well have the main themes for the pros

008and cons but uh this was a very respectful letter that came today from the city the administrator it's a reasonable request so I think we'll have all the people that have signed up shall come forth and and speak we've got uh just to summarize it you'll be given three minutes there is a buzzer Michelle can you work the buzzer Joe's on it Joe you on the buzzer just give it to us okay never mind sample can you sample Buzz or no sorry okay so it'll be surprise yeah so this is an interactive this is your time to speak before the board and your fellow community members and and have your say and be heard on a very important topic so um with that I think we will start on we we are going to do

009there's two students here and there is an agenda item for agenda nine and that is for the school to go from the uh essentially trimester to a semester calendar and um I think that's what what is it 95% of the schools in Oregon are on the semester system something like that yeah at least that at least that so we're we're a little odd and that we are not so but anyway along those lines we have our first public speaker will be Marissa mlto thank you for coming out here today Mercy um yes um Jim can I um add one more I guess she was in the hallway sure sure sure I was thinking of like little stands like I can't you can't hear I can't is that on your microphone okay keep the voice so

010speak loud I'll be loud um good evening members of the school board my name is Mara Clint talk and I'm here to urge you to vote against changing our school from trimesters to semesters while understand the reasoning behind the proposal and that other schools may be making similar changes I believe it will have negative consequences for our students and is not in the best interest of our school Community our schools always place a strong emphasis on student attendance and I fear that changing to a semester system could lead to a drop in attendance under the trimester system students experience more frequent breaks between terms which helps to keep them engaged and motivated to come to School longer terms under the semester system could make students feel less connected potentially leading to increased absenteeism another reason

011given for this proposed change is that some believe there's a wasted time in CTE classes specifically with the need to go over safety procedures at the start of each term I want to stress how important the review is safety training is not a waste of time it's essential people do and can go seriously get hurt even even killed in certain fields and we cannot afford to be locked about safety going over the pro procedures ensures students are prepared and safe no matter how familiar they are with the equipment Additionally the claim that safety training is repeated every ter for the same students is not really like a reality some students may forget key information during breaks or between terms or new students may need that information to prevent accidents safety training is a non-negotiable part

012of the CTE education and cutting this out in favor of a longer term system isn't the answer the trimester system gives students the ability to explore a wider variety of electives which helps them discover new interests develop different skills and meet new people switching to semesters would limit these opportunities leading to a more rigid less engaging schedule students could find themselves stuck in classes that no longer interest them for exp extended periods of time diminishing their motivation to attend school testers also allow for greater academic flexibility students have more opportunities to make up miss work or recover from failures ensuring that they don't fall behind switching to semesters could reduce this flexibility making it harder for students to catch up if they struggle in a class this can lead to increased stress and academic burnout

013I understand that many schools are switching to a semester system but that doesn't mean it's a right need for us every school is different and we have unique needs that aren't always met by following Trends we shouldn't make decisions based on what everyone else is doing but rather on what works best for us the trimester system is as successful here and changing it is just just because other people are doing it could disturb the positive learning environment we built that trimester system benefits our students in many ways it supports High attain rates ensures safety in CTE classes offers more chances for academic success and allows for greater flexibility in electives the semester system may seem like a good idea but it takes away many of the advantages our students currently have I strongly urge you

014to vote no on this change minutes [Applause] thank you barisa oh don't mov closer to the one that's speaking at the floor mic but yeah it work okay all right next speaker Nick Preston also speaking on the semister system hi my name is Nick Preston I have three kids in the district and I'm not necessarily for or against this change but I don't think the background summary that you that was put out I think it lacked the the depth and the substance for such a change I have a a whole lot of questions um that I I'd like to see see addressed um the decision-making process what sort of Outreach was there to the parents um input from the teachers how this affect the class sizes or the student contact hours I I have one

015son in the tag program which is uh unfortunately really constrained by resources how will this affect him on his ability for dual credit or or electives I also have another son that needs a little additional help so if he fails what are his chances in retaking the class how will the classes be will they be longer how will this affect Sports eligibility a lot of questions so i' asking you guys to um table this until you could come out and present more thorough research to the community thank you Nick thanks for the good testimony thank you sir okay I did have one this is first this is a uh please read aloud dug Gil and Doug Ferell urban renewal question urban renewal creates debt for future generations to pay is not a [Music] transparent two

016tax to the many unfairly in favor the one we say no way because the bait and switch nature of urban renewal okay that's the first I think I think the first the next one we have in person will be Dorene Kelly [Music] hi I'm Doran Kelly and um I live at 139c Gate Avenue but I'm here on behalf of South Coast Hospice and South Coast hospice thrift store which is located at 1955 me here in North Ben and we would just like to say that we were the lucky recipients of a UR um an urban renewal Grant um for facade Improvement and it has really made a big difference not only in the appearance of our facility but we found that the fencing that was part of the deal it has actually improved safety and

017we were for a while getting our gas lines on our vehicles we're being cut on a regular basis which cost us quite a bit of money and downtime um for our services and we rely on these for um patient care that's what the store is um all about is being able to provide more funding for patient care um but many of you may know we also donate to a lot of different organizations including the school district um the Northbend police department and so forth to be able to help the clients that you serve and so that in itself has been helpful also we were very excited about the annex to have that become Workforce uh housing when our director came here he could not find a place to live for all almost a year and

018had to commute until he could find a place having something like that to be able to um house our nurses our um people who we recruit into this area that are in professional positions until they can find a place or their own home is so important plus we realize that having more people in that area living there'll be more eyes on the streets that will help pretty much all of the residents and businesses in the area so we urge you to consider um voting for that to continue so thank you so much for this opportunity to express our opinions thank you duy Diane Rich good evening I'm Diane Rich from northbound and I'm a capitalist I do not agree with urban renewal I do not agree with you going into the business of real estate

019you are a government your business is to write laws and collect tax money you're not supposed to be renting out spaces you're not supposed to be building ice skating rinks you're not supposed to be doing the things that public does and I think you're way way Beyond what you should be doing you've gone into a situation with a restaurant where you are making only $1,300 a year but you're funding their building this is wrong it's unfair it's not capitalism it's socialism and I think it ought to be stopped thank you thank you Diane Jean Cassidy good evening evening my name is Jean Cassidy I live at 1440 Butler Road in KZ Bay and I came here because I feel like we're actually one big Community um when my husband and I moved here we actually

020wanted to live in North Bend and we couldn't find housing that was suitable so of course we moved into KZ Bay and it turns out we do love KZ Bay uh um but we always talk about we live in the KZ Bay Area like this is all one area and um I have a couple talking points here um oh and by the way I am a retired educator and volunteer uh and I might be helping volunteering I just met the principal a couple days ago for the high school um at a swim meet if the school board votes yes the city can proceed with the planned improvements and secure 4 million dollar in federal funding I know that it's very hard I've lived in eastern Oregon it's very hard to get funding for small towns

021and get the services that are needed for the town many public services and having people attracted here who can come and can find a place to live and we need Educators and we need good health care providers and I know I've had an issue getting a primary care person it's been a problem for about five years here and I've been here for more than a decade um so I think this is very important for our community the health of our community um I also see that it's a way to take a building that's using valuable space and to give it new life and to give new purpose I do appreciate people speaking on both sides of the position and that's the wonderful thing about uh being able to speak so thank you and thank you

022all for serving uh I also noticed that taxpayers will uh be paying less money with this and there are a lot of things that our federal taxes go to and of course each of us agree with some of them and we don't agree with other ones but you know the money that goes to the federal government it's from the people it's from all the people and a lot of times the smaller towns really don't have the support that they need we don't have the higher paying jobs we don't have the same kind of draw so we don't have the same kind of tax base it's a lot harder to support the citizens in the same way that a a bigger Metropolis can and I think it's actually fair that we get our share and anyway

023thanks thanks so much thank you Jean Ron cooch good to see you Ron sit stand whatever you like yes can you hear me if I stand I can keep your voice up hi I'm Ron cooch at 3828 Chester Street in North vandoran uh I've been resident of the Bay Area since 1985 and talk about three things tonight and talk about tools and talk about my recent dental procedure and talk about my high school teacher Tom mag Tom Magnus not Thomas Magnum um magnuson's different guy so I'm a tool guy my grandpa's a tool guy my dad is a tool guy I'm a tool guy so I bring a tool tonight what what is this anybody knows pliers pliers okay cool what's this it's a tool if I wanted to hold on to something like I

024did today when I'm working on my wood stove I use fliers I want to cut down a tree and then use pliers what would I use saw good so tools are good for some things maybe a few things that they're not good for everything um the the urra the urban renewal agency is a tool it's a tool that's used for economic development it's used around the country maybe around the world I don't know it's used for economic development folks that know about Economic Development know about uras um I believe that the urra is largely responsible for the city of North Bend looking the way it does now when I moved here in 85 it was a little sketchy it was a little sketchy downtown some some abanded buildings some things have been torn down since

025then it's looking pretty nice now with maybe one exception so recently I had a dental procedure and I went to see Scott Roberts so I didn't see Michelle because Michelle is not an oral surgeon but I saw Scott Roberts because he's an oral surgeon and I know that because there were diplomas on each wall that says I'm an oral surgeon so I went there because he's a guy that I needed to see so if I wanted to build maybe a petroleum plant I probably wouldn't see Scott Roberts over but I probably would talk to Jim Jordan if I were to start a riot at a school board meeting and it up to jail I would probably want to talk not to Jim but to Nate and Clint because he probably has diplomas on his wall

026as well it says I get people out of jail he's the guy that says I don't do that just pretend he does that all right um if I want to know about uras I'm going to go talk to somebody who knows about uras in this room I don't know who all here because I've been head in the hallway um David mil knows about uras other city managers know about you is that three minutes minutes I think it's great idea thank you Ron thank you sir I did get the th B next up Rob Taylor hello members of the board thank you for allowing me to speak my name is Rod Taylor cous county commissioner live in Bandon and uh I am here speaking on behalf half of the Board of Commissioners we had this Ur

027issue brought before us by the city of North Bend as you have and uh as I'm sure that you're all aware we unanimously voted no uh to uh to join that effort the reasons were were many uh one reason that we voted no was certainly not because we don't care about low-income housing in cous County we do very much uh I support the idea of creating lowincome housing however I do believe that uh government's role in that creation should be very limited and it should not be ongoing that having been said I'll tell you one reason that we did vote no and and that is because this this project will take $65,000 a year out of the County's general fund budget every single year and if you're not aware CZ County just recently on a

028two: one vote uh I actually voted against this but our County Commission voted to close the second pod of our jail and that was closed on December 31st there were about 35 uh law Breakers that were turned back out into our community and now our jail is full again and every day the district attorney and the sheriff talk about who they have to let out today we laid off 15 employees at the county not because we're mismanaging our funds but because we simply cannot pay Revenue with inflation inflated costs and uh all of the unfunded mandates that the state has continued to descend upon us as a county I know you're familiar with that Dynamic so I would urge you to to consider voting no on this Ur I would cons ask you to uh

029consider how uh how a community might pull together without uh without creating another burden upon the uh incomes of us all let's figure out a way forward that actually capitalizes on the private sector rather than on public monies thank you very much thank you R John Gibson good evening John Gibson Cruz Bay um I have a business right across the corner from here and one of the things we found is that uh the difficulty in keeping Talent when we hire someone and retaining them here has a lot to do with the local community and what's available to rent so many times we've had people driving from Myrtle Point driving from coil and it makes it super difficult on them um to be able to retain a job and they can maybe they can do it

030for a year but they can't continue to do it and the turnover creates additional issues for us so the housing piece to me is maybe one of the largest factors um of my business and has become more complicated over the last three years with the increase in rents so I would urge you we desperately need housing here and the housing will positively impact the school district itself so hopefully you'll vote yes thank you thank you John Rob Taylor Rob Taylor from Bandon Oregon you might ask yourself why is a guy from Bandon here well I'll tell you why I live in several of the countywide districts that pay for the debt on this Urban renewal agency every single taxpayer is affected by urban renewal that's why I've been fighting it for over 30 years I've

031seen the debacles the boond doggles all the mismanagement of our funds and the reason that managers love this is because they make salary off this in fact about $100,000 worth of salary goes to the city of Northbend for managing that urban renewal agency of course they don't want to give it up but I want to give you a couple reasons that I just jot it down why I think you should vote against it number one the C County Commissioners they voted against it and I can assure you they understood exactly what they were voting for no matter who tells you otherwise two people should have been able to vote on this why wasn't the people brought in to vote on this if we're going to have an increase from 11 millions dollar to a $45

032million debt you sure as hell bet the taxpayers want to hear this your city just lost and I know this is the school district but your city just lost a fee increase because the taxpayers has told you no those are the people who put you in this position and those are the people you need to be thinking about when you're making this decision number three government should not be in real estate business or any other business four some economists believe that government interventionism is what's driving the high price of housing right now it's causing and contributing to the homeless problem here's the funny thing you urban renewal you want to take money from people who can barely afford their their housing now people who can barely afford their mortgage barely afford their rent and you

033want to take more money from their tax dollars to pay for people who can't afford housing it makes no sense you're making the poor poorer but you know who you're making richer oh those developers out there they love urban renewal because this is a lot of new money rolling into their pocket but what they don't tell you and I can tell you I've talked to several of these developers you could talk to Heidi sauce you could take talk to Drobot you could talk to Mr Michael Kaiser I know Mr Michael Kaiser and him and all of those others have said every single one of those Urban Development that they had a part in such as the cheese factory such as the Dunes golf course such as the Waterfront all of them would have been built

034with or without urban renewal money so why are we doing this now why are you going to make me a business owner outside of the urban renewal agency pay for the facades of business is I'm competing with on the inside of the urban renewal agency let's get some common sense back and stop spending this money and I can tell you right now no matter what you get from the feds you may regret it because there's a lot of streams attached to it and the city already loves Dei like nobody's business so I would be protective of that thank you all very much thank you robt Gail Elber that was my my name is Gail Elber I live at 2680 Myrtle Street I'm a musician and I've always been told you should never follow a child

035act or an animal act so uh this is um a tough position to be in but I'll do my best we have a housing we want to know which one you think is we have a uh a uh housing and infrastructure problem here in North Bend and uh and just like Diane rich I I yield to no one in my admiration of the private sector but the private sector is not coming to save us I have lived here for 18 years and I have seen so many proposals for Workforce housing and low-income housing and whatnot be presented by uh Developers and none of them has come to fruition so I um I don't think that we are a very attractive place for investment uh without any uh incentives the the urban renewal districts let cities

036leverage a little bit of property taxes into a large investment in in infrastructure by drawing in private investment and federal grants and state grants and we would not be getting that money uh when when Rod mentioned unfunded mandates he's absolutely correct that's the second time I've I've ever in my life agreed with robod Taylor about anything we have a lot of unfunded mandates they are not sending anything to help us um so please support uh the expansion of the urban renewal authority to make this Workforce housing and other projects happen because because we really need to draw some more money into town thank you thank you [Applause] Gil Lexie Woodward good evening board thank you I work at 2110 new Mark Avenue in cbay I'm here tonight to recommend that you vote Yes on the

037UR resolutions I grew up in a suburb outside of Portland and my mom retired from in elementary after 30 years of service in the Oregon City School District I'm the executive director of the South Coast Development Council headquartered on a North bendz Bay property line I have been working in economic development for 11 years in Nicaragua Illinois Arizona Texas and now my home state of Oregon and I'm certified nationally and internationally I tell you that only to demonstrate that this type of project is excellent for Community Economic Development it would be an amplifier for downtown revitalization property tax revenue which all the taxing districts needs more of to pay for the infrastructure Public Safety and other community needs and wants and employers would be better able to keep attract and grow their Workforce I can't

038stress enough how hard it is spring projects like this even to this point it's so hard to develop housing on the south coast we lack a lot of the factors that would make us attractive to developers investors just some examples include our hilly and swampy land means higher cost it's harder to find Qualified contractors who have the capacity we have a comparatively low income rate rate of job growth and availability of child care slots we have a comparatively high unemployment rate in crime because of these barriers projects like this require Partnerships and cooperation to succeed Private Industry alone will not bear the cost and when development stalls vacant properties become a drain on Community Resources tax increment financing which is the financing method used to fund urban renewal areas are a common impr proven Economic

039Development tool that leverages Partnerships for the good of the shared place the housing that's been built and the housing that's starting to be built here have required Partnerships Developers and private investors will not do it on their own failing to support this project tonight would be a significant lost opportunity one that we should not be passing up we do not have opportunities like this banging on our doors they have to be cultivated over years we need Creative Solutions and common support not roadblocks to address our housing shortage and further economic devolopment thank you thank you Lexi Mark matek Mark M North Lanes inch by in Fitness and just a quick comment our restaurant is open late little B longer yes thanks for your volunteer as I really appreciate it we're a longtime business um this

040this issue is relatively complex hard to go through the paperwork and look at it my thing from our side is um I've had to build housing um I have four houses now that I've had to build I have employees in all those houses um I cannot find uh employee housing for my 36 employees um I'm trying to get another house built for another employee that can't find a place to live it is a serious problem for the businesses in the area and especially in the restaurant business Staffing gets extremely hard so this this project um I'm not really in favor in government uh you know doing these type of projects that's simply I think it should be private money but in this case it's not going to happen if it doesn't happen this way and

041I this is Workforce housing not low-income housing there is a there is a low-income housing project over at Banker so to make sure everybody kind of understands that this is Workforce housing so my employees could live there and work at my facility so I just think that's real important and I think as a city of Northbend we've been here a long time we've helped the school board in a number of issues raise money pass Bond measures when it's needed and we've gone through some tough times together and this is a tough decision and and I will I will go along with whatever decision happens here but I I do want you to take it seriously that this what's good for Northbend what's good for the school district this will bring kids and people into the

042school district I have five kids in my three housee development that I have done that all go to North Bend and if that house isn't a available they're not going to Northbend one house has three kids they'll if they have to move they'll they're not moving in North Bend there is no houses I I have a property manager looks for me it is it's a really a big problem for a business so appreciate it take to look at this um hardly and and and think about the business in Northbend and what's good for Northbend and the the only other thing I have is um I hired 26y olds from North Bend um they can't write they can't sign their name I would really like to see you put writing back into the school that may

043be a tough request and I know you have budget constraints but um serious I've I've never seen a lack of writing skills and and we need um writing skills so you know in our business so I know it's something that everybody thinks everything's digital but that that's not the case when you get on a job so I request that too but thanks for your time and uh hope everything goes well I have bowling tonight so I'm leaving I don't want anybody to give me a bad name about that but it's it's so we're in second place it's very important apolog thank you Mark Chris Castleman good evening I'm Chris Castleman from CZ County um where did it go so I'm going to talk about something a little different tonight um but first you know they

044they handed out this nice piece of propaganda and they're making it seem like it's about a housing project um and it's to pull at your heart strings and to make you vote for it um but before I get into that are there Republicans in the room if there's a republican in the room put your hand up don't be shy I'm going to read from the Oregon rep Republican Party platform uh section 4.5 it says for a prosperous economy to exist the Oregon government needs to aggressively manage their spending and reduce all forms of debt urban renewal the whole concept is debt that's all it is but when you hear the word debt normal people go debt debt okay like a loan or a credit card right no a credit card you spend a little you

045pay it off you spend a little to pay it off and it goes on and on a loan you spend a lot usually and then you pay it off this isn't that this is a gift card it's a gift card from taxpayers all over Cruz County and they don't have to pay it all and it's a one-time thing they were given $1.7 million back in 1998 from the taxpayers in CZ County and it's a gift but it's a stolen gift card because the the taxpayers of CZ County did not vote for that it was chosen by the Northbend city council to be awarded $1.7 million so this is not about housing it's about the possibility to increase that gift card balance to 40 $6 million that's a $34 million increase that's insane without a vote

046of the people if they're so confident that the taxpayers of K County are interested in this endeavor they would put it on the ballot it would be a ballot measure they would gain consensus they'd come here with the clerk's print out and say we have consensus from the people we have a 60% consensus 51% something and they'd show you that this is what the people want they haven't done that because they're sneaky and they want to put this in your face and tell everybody it's about Workforce housing who doesn't want housing for people we're not evil we want housing we want the economy to improve we want people in our community to have a place to live places to work life liberty Pursuit of Happiness everybody wants that this is about how we get there

047this is about how we manage our finances how we spend money this is not about Workforce housing this is about giving the city of Northbend management over a $46 million gift card that they have stolen from CZ County residents so I'm going to give you guys a print out it's from the northb city council's own uh consultant from the summer she did a presentation um it explains a little bit about tax increment financing and urban renewal thank you thank you [Applause] Chris oh Tracy Pierce thank you CH hello my name is Tracy piis I live at 68 593 uh Ridge Road in North Bend over the past two or three years we have we as a community have convened panels committees focus groups and brought in outside Consultants to tell us what we already know

048we are facing a housing shortage we must F while we much of the focus has rightfully been on our unhoused population who who are in urgent need we must also remember the often forgotten workers are Educators Healthcare professionals and First Responders these hardworking men and women dedicate themselves day in and day out to the well-being of our community they earn too much to qualify for assistance but not enough to afford the increasingly inflated cost of housing projects like the Banger School lowincome Housing Development are important steps toward addressing this challenge I commend the city of Northbend for its commitment to a comprehensive approach in tackling the housing crisis here on the south coast I sincerely hope the Northbend School District School Board votes yes to continue the progress and economic Prosperity that Northbend has worked

049so hard to create thank you [Applause] Tracy Mary Joe Golder good evening my name is Mary Joe Golder I go by MJ or Mary Joe I am the daughter-in-law of former mayor Lee Golder who was the mayor in 1998 and was the mayor who signed the original urban renewal into place so I'm at a Crux because in the process of becoming an owner of golders Napa which has businesses in cbay coill murtle point Bandon Brookings and Gold Beach I crossed two different counties so we are faced with two different counties policies urban renewal programs all kinds of taxes I can tell you in property taxes alone my husband and I with our businesses paid an excess of $80,000 a year it's a lot of money and taxes my father-in-law Lee who put the urban renewal

050into place believed in the beautification and edification of Downtown North Bend this curban urban renewal includes a couple of our buildings which are dilap itated and we do our best to maintain them with very high property taxes sometimes it's hard to come up with the cash to put back into our buildings I am at this point not in favor of this because I don't have enough information okay it's not that I don't believe in housing I just don't I I don't have enough information from this flyer I am for it because I do believe in my father-in-law's Envision of bettering the the the community but is housing it and my question is do you all have the information on this housing because I hear lots of people talking about I have a heck of a

051time I'll interview 40 people and maybe two will show up for the interviews right I I'll offer 40 interviews and two show up for the interviews my employees make minimum wage to $20 an hour I'm in automotive retail I I I compete with Amazon I compete with rock auto I compete with all the big boxes but our NAPA store we've been in business since 1921 Lee Golder and his father car Golder started the business in Northbend in 1921 we're an independent owner it's not a franchise it's Napa Automotive Parts Association so it's not a franchise we have employed people in the North Bend and cbay for since 1921 and housing is hard so my question is says Workforce housing for educators healthcare workers Public Safety does that include my employees have you guys been given

052schematics on the size of the Bill of the apartments is there going to be Security on the apartments how much will my employee will my employees even be considered for this housing will his employees the gentleman that spoke before me will his employees be ConEd because the way I read it says Educators health care workers public safety personnel and Logistics to me that's not golders Nappa Auto Parts employees so please consider the entirety of it and maybe get more information thank you for the time thank you [Applause] MJ Al pedit thanks for giving me this time um my name is Al ped I'm a business owner down in CRZ Bay and longtime North band resident my two daughters attended School in North band graduated there i' like to share the following City Charter with you

053the city and urban renewal agency's Economic Development focus is on investments that support the business Community these Investments include Workforce affordable housing infrastructure and utility enhancements public parking facilities Transit and EV charging stations placemaking public art safety Investments That is not North Ben's economic Charter but Lincoln cities a city whose population has grown 72% since 1990 from 5900 res to its current 10,100 a city that is currently in the throws of two urban renewal affordable housing projects they're just the beginning of a development plan that will meet Lincoln City's affordable housing needs of at least 1,500 housing units by 2042 with a number of additional housing projects already in the planning and finance stage including a 29 unit housing complex for individuals with severe and persistent mental illness those people in our communities are literally

054dying on our sidewalks as a gentleman did in front of my store 2 years ago in the last 35 years North Ben's population is grown by 298 people that's 8.5 people per year since 1990 and our population has decreased every year since its record high in 2020 shrinking by an aggregate 3.5% and we're getting older the average age of a Northbend resident in 2000 was 41 years of age we are now approaching 50 this doesn't bode well for the future of the businesses schools and residents of North Bend because if we're not growing we're dying and 3% population growth over 35 years means we have efficiently flatlined here and don't be fooled by the Bayside development as the old saying goes that's simply a reshuffling of the deck chairs on the Titanic Decades of resistance

055to change and resistance to adapt has culminated into Financial challenges at the county at North Bend and KZ Bay and trust me Mr Taylor I appreciate the County's challenges I deal with the crap The Fallout of that every month the latest being my shop truck being stolen over the Christmas holidays and total it's every month something from that but the choices we are now faced with is either to maintain the status quo and continue down this slow but steady path to decline or we make the difficult choices necessary to get this thing thing turned around is there risk attached to voting yes of course no business decision ever made to requireed a step to the right or the left or step forward came without some degree of risk your F future school funding is at

056risk because of shrinking attendance which is the result of a Dying Community a no vote will simply put another nail in the coffin of a community that's been fling economically since DC killed logging I encourage all of you to vote yes thank you [Applause] Rod Schilling hi I'm Rod Schilling I'm a taxpayer and I live within the north B school district and uh I dug my tax bill out and I looked about 1,430 and it's under North Ben School South Coast ESD and Southwest Oregon Community College uh that comes out of my tax money for the schools and somehow through the magic of urban renewal These funds can be laundered and turned over to uh politicians and unelected bureaucrats to spend on what they want to spend them on I don't understand that when the

057Northman school district has to go out and beg people to add to their taxes uh to get bonds to fix their schools that are dilapidated in lots of places and falling apart and the fact that they can take money that the state takes our school money and can send it down here for City officials to spend on whatever they want to spend it on and for some reason they need you guys to sign on to it and then you have absolutely no say over it after that the city will do what they want to do and if they screw it up they're going to come back and say well you guys were part of this you gave them all this education money uh I don't get it if the school if the state has money

058for the schools let them spend it on the schools um it's just crazy and the government has a primary job and that's to keep its citizens safe and I don't have a high degree of confidence in this city because it's not safe around here people aren't even feeling safe in their own homes anymore and if they can't do the one job they're supposed to do I can't imagine giving them millions upon millions of dollars to go out and become Real Estate Investors landlords um it just doesn't make any sense to me and especially in this economic climate a lot of the federal funds are going to be drying up that were sent out uh like candy in the past and you know they say oh well these will be backfilled through the state well what

059if they don't have it to backfill what if you know what if something happens and you guys are tied into a and the other thing is a thir 30y year term really I mean most of us in this room aren't even going to be around here in 30 years so I don't have a high degree of confidence that they can do pull this off and I urge a no vote thank you thank you Ro Jeff langing good evening my name is Jeff Lang I've been a resident of North B for six years my wife works in the district and I'm a budget Committee Member for the school district I currently serve as the CEO of Kil Valley hospital and coil Valley Health these two organizations employ approximately 260 employees and over the last year uh

060between these two organizations we've hired right around 75 employees um I'm here tonight to speak about a serious problem many Healthcare organizations have in our community community and how the Northbend school board can help support us in meeting uh our mission of providing highquality comprehensive services to the patients of the South Coast speaking as a health care provider I want you to know that all care providers in our area struggle to recruit and retain essential health care workers at CV hospital and CV Health we've had applicants turn down offers of employment because of an inability to find suitable or affordable housing in our area these problem exist for high wage earners such as Physicians um and are even more significant for our mid wage earners such as nurses lab techs Radiology technicians and many others

061I'm guessing everybody in this room would agree we're approaching a crisis point in our area as it relates to access to health care services there's much greater need for services than there's the ability to uh service that need consider this when a HealthCare Employee employer is unable to fill positions uh we're not able to provide the services that our community needs weight times increase test results take longer and the distance that our patients need to travel are increased in some cases patients go without the needed Services um that they need the city's urban renewal project will build 72 Workforce housing units for healthcare workers and Educators public safety personnel and others these units will greatly enhance Area Health Care Providers uh or employer's ability to recruit and retain the medical professionals needed in our community

062to provide the necessary care right here on the south coast it's impossible for the healthc Care Community to address uh these issues uh on our own uh we cannot and will not be successful in filling positions when it's impossible for potential employees to live in our area I ask you to support the city's urra plan and pass the resolutions presented tonight support of these resolutions is a positive step the school board can take to stem declining enrollment increase the funds available to provide future programs and services to students and provide assistance to the Healthcare Community as we do our very best to ensure that the community has sufficient access to Healthcare Services thank you thank you [Applause] jff Joe bolig III thank you so my name is Joe III and I am your 2024 City

063Northbend citizen of the year and current cous County board of realtors president I am here on behalf of the cous County board of realtors who represent the cous County realtor Association the cous County board of realtors endorsed a yes vote on your proposed amendments to increase the Northbend urban renewal agency's debt ceiling remove special Levy power and the current tax levy the citizens of northb currently pay this will allow the Northbend ur8 to secure 4 million in funding to move forward with the development of approximately 72 units of Workforce housing according to the city of Northbend housing needs analysis from 2022 which I was a member of that committee at the time we needed roughly 260 new housing units by 2042 per their findings over approximately the past 40 years no large scale housing operations

064have been developed the Housing Authority is currently underway with its development of Northbend family housing at Banger school which will supply Supply a total of 176 units between Phase 1 and two to economically stress citizens who pay rent with some form of assistance Northbend Housing Authority alone currently has a weight list of approximately 1,000 applicants for their housing programs and that's between Airport Heights and Hamilton Court which house around 110 uh people or households the housing needs analysis is constrained on data and their number is extremely low in relation just to one data point that the Housing Authority is able to provide the approximately 72 proposed units by the Northbend Ur upon completion coinciding with the completion of Northbend housing would give the city of Northbend 248 new units across a wide soci economic range

065of tenants economically an increase in housing units overall brings more tax revenue to the City brings more spending and in this case potentially more students in the northb school district which increases the funding for the northb school district which is approximately 10,500 per student factor in the Pacific coast Intermodal Port development on the horizon and we are in desperate need of housing across all spectrums all socionomics socioeconomic spectrums housing availability is necessary for these three things to happen and it is the first thing that needs to happen some of the developers mentioned earlier tonight GRE robot Michael Kaiser if you ask them why nothing's came here why we haven't grown in population because we don't have housing that's flat out what it is why don't why didn't Home Depot come here why didn't this come

066here those are the main reasons why over the last 40 years we have relied on private developers to meet our housing needs if we continue to rely on private developers the city of North will continue to fall behind and run at a housing deficit on behalf of the cous County board of realtors please vote Yes on proposed Northbend Ur amendments allowing this housing project to move forward and lower the current property taxes of the citizens and Future Special levies by the Northbend Ur the Kus County board of realtors is in support of the development of the cous County Annex site by the UR thank you thank you Jo okay as as Boomer comes up uh he's our last speaker I would like to talk the the Northbend School District uh we hired a new superintendent

067back in one July 202 23 and we had a uh the board met to determine some goals for that superintendent to work on number one goal was academic achievement the second goal is student Behavior and the reason student Behavior was on the list was because of its huge impact on academic achievement and U it also incredibly impacts teacher retention and job satisfaction so we we have a certain structure here on what teachers are allowed to do with uh student behavior issues and uh it's a little bit limited and uh I want to recognize Boomer has come to North Ben schools and uh interviewed some folks in in some group sessions and put the time in and he is working on some legislation to make sure well it's around instructional time and it's approaching the problem

068such that every every student in Oregon in Northbend is entitled to a good education and one or two kids in those classroom should not be interrupting the education of the other 22 or 23 kids so Boomer I want to thank you for the work you're you're doing that's uh it's a long-term change to try to change the system in Oregon takes a long time so with that Boomer well thank you for the opportunity to speak um thank you for the kind words first off I'm not here to tell you what to do you've had plenty of that tonight and and previous what I am here to express my uh appreciation for what all of you do uh you're in a tough spot uh you make decisions daily for our students in this community and you're

069underappreciated I I want to tell you how much I appreciate you this job uh that I have by the way I am Boomer Wright and I spend most of my time at the capital and it's nice to be somewhere else tonight after spending the week there I think it's it's inherent in all of us that we want to take care of our kids that's why we're parents that's why we're teachers that's why I serve on the education committee the higher education committee and I also serve on the Ways and Means Committee for Education that takes a look at funding those are exceptionally important things tonight you're going to make a decision uh as it relates to the city uh and the future of North bent which you you are a major part of I know

070you've had good connections and have worked with the city and my understanding that the city appreciates working with each of you and the school board so whatever happens tonight whatever vote you take I know one thing for sure that you'll make it in the best interest of your students and in the best interest of the community so I want to thank you for that vote before you take it but I also want to uh encourage you to keep the lines of communication open with the city uh without the city there wouldn't be a school district because there wouldn't be services but without a school district there probably wouldn't be a city so as you move forward I encourage you continue to work with them and to do things in the best interest first off of

071your students and then for the community so thank you for your support and I look forward to working with you for thank you thank you Boomer I I've reached the bottom of the pile was there anybody else have we got everyone that wanted to uh make a public statement and be heard all right thank you for that okay next up on the agenda item four Communications 4 a board reports and communication oh I've got one I'm I'm happy to report that strategic planning uh is nearing completion a lot of hours have gone into that so I'm happy that we are we're just about there great thank you yeah we've got uh is it March I think our March work session we'll be reviewing that thank you for the members of the core team and the

072instructional team that uh yeah big commitment for you for you folks 4B student representatives to the board High School representative Taylor Thompson there he is all right Taylor Taylor I I had two freshman with me but uh they were standing and I decided to send them home because it it was it was a long time so it was I am oh this is a comfy chair that chair back there's not comfy okay um I'm giving you some updates about school um it's going good we've got a good system um we're in the spring times we've got basketball going on we've got wrestling going on right now I think we just got we just had some good wrestling meets inside of our school um it's kind of interesting seeing they have like they have like one

073Spotlight and they got like one mat so everybody's just watching the same show so it's like a little theater watching them all go around it's a little crazy um for uh music uh funksgiving is this Saturday um at 6 pm at the northb high school cafeteria um we also have sweets and songs which I'm blanking right now but I would look up sweets and songs it should be somewhere around our school ask your kids about it if you can uh that's a fundraiser for the North High School choir which is very good also uh like I said basketball's been going very good looks like we've been having good Seasons I just been playing pet fan in there so I'm just usually one playing music in there um yeah I mean nothing much nothing too big

074as at this moment we're just kind of getting through school um I definitely will say I I was just part of the I just went to a meeting for the senior parent committee this guys I'm a senior now it's my last year with all you guys so sad moment but I'm joying until now um I I went to that meeting and it's it's impressive just all the fundraising that's got to go towards um that different stuff so if anybody in here wink wink has a business that would like to sponsor the seniors of 2025 wink wink just saying um reach out to people specifically Drew Hood's Mom thank you guys very much um bulldog pageant has also been uh on the uprising we just made our cans today so I got to get those inside

075of a restaurant or bar figure out somewhere um also sponsors for Bulldog pageant lank wank uh anybody out there wank WN um that's a good foundation for the children's Mir uh Miracle Network work we are trying to raise money for preey babies in uh riverband went to riverband actually to go visit and see the um units that they put the premie babies in which is definitely an eye over for the fact that I had no information about it originally and then we went to that and then just now kind of a whole new world to me um besides that uh I think we got like an assembly we had an hourong lunch today which was amazing you know we Pendleton kudos to him the man was creating this like amazing like halftime show thing where

076we had like tug ofar with teachers and students that was entertaining right there um and it was just and he was you know was like oh you know if you have 200 students come show up and I think it was like 26 teachers show up um then we would have an hour long lunch and then I also got to see like eight teachers get on top of each other in the pyramid for a competition so that was also entertaining um as always uh I'm Taylor Thompson so I'm the guy with the jokes because I feel like we get really serious in here but I'm here to bring the laughter hopefully because what else is there so I've got three jokes I just got to find it in my notes here so what does corn say

077when it gets a compliment ah Shooks uh where is it why were the fish's grades bad they below sea level what do you call a pig that practices karate a pork chop uh besides that my other thing um I I'm like I said I'm see you this year I also want to talk about stalls um for wearing I was uh informed about a few months back that um stoles are not allowed apparently um and so I'm trying to get uh got an excuse for military um I'm a future en listy of the US ghost guard and I'd like to wear my sto at graduation and so um to be told no that I'm not allowed to do do that um just kind of hurt a bit you know I've got one day that I've just

078gone through 12 years not is it 12 13 years kud in kindergarten 13 years just to have this one day where i'm you know showing my future on my whole family coming in like this going to be crazy but I just I was want to bring that up and uh have you guys possibly discuss that too um I have a bunch of my friends we kind of got a little group chat going on and we're all just discussing that uh we would like to wear those stes as a form of just showing um you know our proudness to enlisting and you know giving you know uh dedicating these years to the uh United States which I do believe uh is a proud thing and should be able to be exemplified in the way of a

079stole so that's that's my stuff so I really appreciate you guys though Hey Taylor what one thing you know I've talked to other meetings about North Bend being a destination school and known known for academic achievement it's a journey sounds like Mark matek has a couple folks we need to help them along with there but um also the richness of our offerings in CTE music choir the other things that make uh North Bend a potential destination so um I've said it before school can't be all things to all students but it needs to be one thing to each student to get them in the door so with that I understand that you chose to come to northb you actually live in K Bay and you made a decision to come here because yes uh we

080uh what was it I went to I was going supposed to go to uh Marshfield but um I discussed with my parents that I want to be heavily involved in band and uh the band program we have here has been first in state in the 3A district for the past two years mind you um so not only our Band program but our choir program you know exceed both of the teachers Mrs Lei and Mrs Yer and also Mrs Massie nor Middle School have a way to welcome you in but also teach you you know Miss yester I think every like a drill sergeant she's like she gets to the point you get in there and you like you get music down she gets to the point but there are other kind moments where you have

081a heart to heart and that's scary stuff when you have a heart to heart with her but that's when you know she loves you and she loves all of her students so uh yeah I was meant to go to Marshfield and uh was meant to go over there but I came over here for our music program which is amazing I mean I'm we have a guitar class I'm currently looking right now um the school has offered to pay for um rudimentary snare lessons so I'm going to be performing a solo on March 1st for soul and Ensemble um the school has also offered to pay for an ensemble piece so me and three other percussion kids are um have a quartet where we have this Bas from the middle we've got four Bongos all around

082it and we basically just do a bunch of rudimentary stuff and so we're also taking that Soul Ensemble and we have made for the past 3 years also we have which we started in my freshman year um we have made state so we've been going to State over and over again um so the school just offers a wide opening so definitely out of uh coil Bandon North vano Bay I to be looking for a music department to go into it would definitely be North Ben from all that so that's my definitely you're here all right thank you too thank you I'm going to go eat thank you okay 4C Fish Hatchery project Wade Lester we all like salmon right well it could be in the near future that our high school kids and middle school

083kids get toow on the pony I was approached in late August um from a gentl odw CO tribe the step program um England Marine Josh had approached me about constructing a Hatcher on Pony to be shared between the high school and the middle school now Co for those of you that may know have had a program there and I I know that the former principal and he remembers as a kid it was need for kids to go down they trap them adult salmon 20b they rear them and they acclimate them and then release them and so the hope is to get this thing going so that our eighth graders now as seniors we would have our first batch ofur fish um there's possibilities of our middle schoolers more most likely high schoolers to have kids

084from North band Hill Crest come and fill there down to the Hatchery our kids are actually hosting the film here it it's just a really cool deal um chairman Jordan and I actually met um the Cil teacher last week she gave us a tour um on our own time it was really great it's pretty complex um there's a lot of pieces to it and we think that there's going to be some differences how we would run it here on Pony slooh as opposed to Cunningham Creek there's a title effect so there's saltwater there's um I met with the odf andw fish biologist earlier this week and he's doing some tests if the egg fry can survive a certain salinity and and so there's a lot of things to troubleshoot so I just kind of want

085to present the board and Mr Swagger's been super supportive and we've had a couple of meetings um with some other administrators there's a lot to like about this project it's just one of those that there's going to be obstacles no cost to the district um I've talked with Mr Holmes about our CTP program building the 20x30 P structure that would house the fish traps and so it's kind of a community thing plus there could be fishermen from the school all the way down to the bridge you know so anyways did you have any questions about any of it the next board meeting that I'm on I'd like to have some pictures and like where the site might go what it might look like we need to how it's going to affect our lower Fields um

086because our PD teachers use those fields um there's but there's power down there those old tennis courts it could be easy it could be hard when I and and I'll probably apply through the step programs proposal that way we can avoid any water right issues if we do it that way um and and I can take that on and I think I'll just keep you updated and if we get to something hard um he'll help me chis will help me and then we bring it to you with a good plan excited to hear about this cool I think I think it's a great deal it's uh St we talked to Julia scor who's the EG teacher at kill High School on you know the Cunningham Fish Hatchery and the students learn so much about what

087you know Samer referred to as a foundational resource or foundational species here so you know you learn about stewardship of the fish the students have a great opportunity to learn um I think it's great resource if it works out and we have good runs you know you increase fish and I was a terrible fisherman when I used to fish but you know hey people people it's great for the citizens here to catch a salmon and then for people come visit the area so it's just a it's a win-win everywhere so you have my backing and the the CTE idea of building whatever little structures we need is is great big structures yeah thank you wa yeah thank you 4 d Association reports North band educational Association report Eva Varga hello hello okay well I had

088a really long presentation plann for this evening but I'm going to scratch it um uh one of the things that is happening across the district is Oregon Battle of the books and February marks the beginning of hosting the obob teams um from all grade levels at Northbend high school so the high school will be hosting grades um 6 through eight um tomorrow um in the morning the third through fifth grade division on Wednesday February 12th and the uh High School Division on Wednesday February 9th in the afternoon and so I know that um the the teams the Ali Lan caster and the other uh the Librarians that are working with her to um kind of coordinate that are really excited to to see how our kids perform and um in honor of of their work

089I thought I would bring an obob themed question for you so every year the way obob works is uh the state has a list of books for each grade division um that the students are uh that they read and work on all year long and then when they come to these competitions they're asked like little trivia questions now I know you haven't read the books that are on this year's list so I picked some books that I thought you probably are familiar with so we'll see how well you can do okay ready all right question number one in which book does a character survive in the wilderness by making a home inside a hollowed tree Winnie you know guess do you know oh you know yes my side of the M My Side of the

090Mountain a second I I object I didn't know there was going to be a PO quiz I didn't get a study okay all right question number two um ah in Charlotte's Web what is the first word that Charlotte writes in her web to save Wilbur oh my good I terrific no if you know it just shout it out we need audience help on this to some pigs some pig some Pig all right and the last one this is for the High School Division in the book sometimes A Great Notion by Ken key an Oregon author what is the name of the river that plays a significant role in the lives of the Stanford family anyone name of the river the wakonda alga river a u g I'm not sure that's anyway thought that'd be just

091kind of fun my okay evil what this says is you need ease your question easier question uh we we'd like to play are You Smarter Than A Fifth Grader I know it may have been some time since you have read all right so now we come to my um monthly presentation are um extra M nominees so for February the first nominee is Danielle Howard uh Danielle is a health room Aid at Hillcrest and she was nominated by Michelle britz um Danielle spent her day uh supporting the students at teachers students and teachers at Hillcrest and we recently had a significant like shortage in the nurse room recently uh short-handed and the hilr staff had expressed to Michelle how much they appreciated Danielle's uh work her diligence and I just wanted to you know bring her

092to your attention uh because her efforts have not gone not gone unnoticed the next two um are my personal um educational assistants these two work very closely with me Vanessa Raina and Yan um Yan also works in the life skills room at Hillcrest and and H Vanessa uh works with students K through 12 so um both of them assist me in working with students the multilingual students and their families um for example Vanessa just this evening called one of our new students um or called the parents of one of our new students um just to kind of explain the program and you know coordinate Services um but without them we would not in many cases be able to communicate well um with our Hispanic and and Chinese speaking families and so I owe a lot

093of uh gratitude to each of them um they also help to encourage our multilingual families um to continue to work with their children to hold on to their home language uh because because as you may know as students are in the public schools here in the United States um they improve on their English skills but oftentimes what happens is they will lose their their home language their ability to read and write um and sometimes even to speak in their home languages and so they really help to encourage the families to to work on those skills at home uh because we we don't necessarily have the resources as a school system to provide teachers in all the languages that are that our children speak um and similarly we we've been talking about how North Bend is

094the pride of all the West right and one of the things that I think that we can celebrate and um and really um lift up is that we have students in this District who will be um earning the Seal of my literacy again this year um there was uh four that were honored last year at graduation and this year there will be a larger number I don't know the exact number yet because there are some who are still testing um but the the one student the first one who tested in as a junior will be graduating this year and um so it's just really exciting that um we have that opportunity for our students that they um can demonstrate their proficiencies um in their home language did you have a question about that I was

095going to say can you explain to the the audience what what that is and I think you started to there yeah uh so the seal biliteracy is an Oregon honor in fact it's a worldwide um but in Oregon um you can earn a seal of biliteracy if you are proficient highly proficient in two languages um so English being one of them and if they can demonstrate proficiency and in a second language um and usually it it doesn't have to be their home language um like I myself as a native English speaker could earn if I were student yet in school earn a seal of biliteracy in the second language right I could do that um and so the encourage what we want to do is encourage our multilingual students to hang on to their home

096language and we want to encourage the native English speakers to broaden their perspectives and to to gain the skills that come with learning a second language in Oregon there's also a seal of multiliteracy and there is one student in student this year at the high school who has expressed interest in taking the test she um in Russian and um of course in English but also in um Rian and German as well I think for the languages that she speaks so we may have a multiliterate uh student to present that graduation as well hope hopefully so anyway I did not expect to talk so long anyway I'm done thank you thank you Eva [Applause] 4E superintendent report Vince swaggerty I am very happy to say that the state recently came out with our official graduation rate

097for 23 24 school year um and and North High School increase 5% uh to this year last school year 88.8 % graduation rate um we were really pleased with that it's a remarkable number because that freshman the last year senior group for freshman in 2021 as you recall 2021 they started off at home right and then in April of that year is when the governor said you got to get everybody back in school in a hybrid and so they came to school um part days and they were a home part days and then from that point in time till the them walking across the stage um last June um our high school staff um just dove in and made it happen with those kids and those kids actually had to do the work they had

098to make it happen themselves but um at the end of their freshman year 71.7 of them 71.7% of them were on track to gradu and 88.8 across the stage which means that that 177% is the work of the high school um to make that difference to catch that many kids up from a place where they weren't going to graduate to the to the place where they walked across the stage so I'm uh I extremely happy and that that particular group had that greater rate um the state increased from 81.3 to 81.8% so we were 7% higher than say so but it's not good enough we there's 12 or 11.2% we're trying to get there we go okay we have but but I do want to celebrate the success absolutely um I also wanted to mention

099strategic planning so I just have that just I'm I'm basically M saying what I said of my thing here is we're coming to the end of the process we appreciate everyone being a part of that I also want to mention that in case you haven't heard heard that um we did finally select someone applied that was qualified we selected a teacher for bidy Bulldog 2.0 um we started this year uh with a preschool for the first time in about a decade um and they came to us it's preschool promise funded Grant funded program uh they came to us and said would you be interested in opening opening a second classroom and Dana and Bruce looked at each other and said uh gu yes and so we talked about it and said if the money's there

100then we'll give it a shot um and so uh they said sure and so we've been working really hard we've had them shift some classrooms but um I think Dan we're still on target for May 10 or March 10th March 10th we're on target to have kids coming in in our second classroom the original group was 18 kids currently I think we're expecting 21 kids scheduled to come in and remind those kids are not chosen by our district um those kids are chosen by Del which is the local agency that will think that happen so so they don't they register with us but we don't pick them there are a lot more out there that that need services but we're just happy that we can get these two so that's that's happening as well so

101um and then in the athletic side all I wanted to add was a couple of big things um if you like swimming and you want to see The District swimming uh tournament me that's the 14th and the 15th we'll be hosting that we weren't supposed to host it supposed to be hosting the Cottage Grove and something happened and ail couldn't and so they asked Mr Forester if he'd be interested he said sure So we're back on this year for second year in a row to host and then as usual uh in March we're going to be hosting the 3A State basketball tournament so a month from well today um so in a month we're going to be hosting that so um because there so many distes here who are going to help sponsor things wink

102win um we appreciate your support in helping with the 3A basketball tournament and making that happen it's a true a collaboration with our H business Community as well as in the school Community both both distri obviously since we're both coost thank you great hey we've been at it uh an hour and 33 minutes so we're going to take a 7 minute break use the restroom and uh get out of my way if you see me running toward the men Talk Amongst yourselves thank you yes okay I think the board's back seated we will resume with agenda item five action consent agenda item and before I ask for a motion I do uh notice that Mike Forester is retiring after 36 years of service and he has provided great leadership he's the he's our athletic director

103the man's got a heart for the the kids and I worked for Mike personally as a tennis coach for a little over three years and he is a great leader so a a race well run for Mike yes for Mike so okay with that is there a motion to approve the action consent agenda as presented I still move second okay there's a motion in a second uh for the action consent agenda all in favor say I I I 70 okay item six is not there and item seven proposed urban renewal agency plan action resol there's two resolutions and I think what I'll do is I'll do a uh Jeff you want to say something um I had asked him you know generally we have the interest right and you told me that too I had

104a senen your moment yeah yeah good evening uh Mr chairman um board members and community members I have a statement I'd like to read and then I'll turn meeting back over to you if that's okay yeah sounds great um for those of you in the audience and listening online my name is Jeff bridgin and I am the finance director for the city of North Bend and urban renewal agency tonight you have before you two resolutions for amending the North Bend urban renewal agency and a choice about whether to support the north B school district and your community the amendment has been thoughtfully created Created and is being presented to you in good faith with the well-being of North Bend in mind we would not have brought it forward if we did not believe it makes

105sound financial sense for everyone involved My Hope Is that you as you my hope is that you approach this amendment with a focus on what is truly best in the best interest of the school district and its future I encourage you to set aside personal biases and political distractions and instead decide on what will support our students teachers and the longterm long-term stability of the district this is about what is doing right for North Bend not any outside influence this is about our home home to the district's 3500 students and their families home to where we shop entertain eat and live our lives the question you have before you is straightforward to understand and it is simply this should $250,000 of the school district's taxes stay here in Northbend to support our home each year

106or would you rather send those funds to Salem for redistribution to other school districts across Oregon to be clear the amount of funding the district receives from the state remains unchanged whether you choose to keep those funds local or to send them to Salem your funding is based on School enrollment this is an easy choice to make keeping local funds local and using them to support new housing in our city directly benefits the school district by aiding in its enrollment over the past five years enrollment in the school district has rapidly declined with the addition of 72 new housing units comes a reasonable expectation for enrollment growth increased enrollment directly increases the district's funding from the state ensuring sufficient funds for future School budgets funds that will allow you to pay your teachers attract talent

107to the district as it grows and support our students if that isn't Justus justification enough let's talk about tax relief this proposal will lower property taxes tax bills for our residents let me repeat that saying yes to this resolution will directly benefit taxpayers because the urban renewal special Webby will sunset immediately with the approval of this amendment when was the last time you heard a government come to you with a plan to lower property your property tax burden this is an opportunity for the school district to show taxpayers that you chose to reduce their property taxes when given a chance this resolution means putting real dollars back in the pockets of our citizens perhaps the citizens of North Bend will remember this gesture the next time the school district seeks future support for its School

108bonds at a time when many communities including cities and school districts are in Decline we can stand together and proactively move in a different direction to help ourselves in the face of so many economic uncertainties here is North Bend's chance to do something for the betterment of nor North Bend nobody can do that except us we're the ones who live here and care most about North Bend C county is not going to present solutions to strengthen the city's budgets ensure delivery of essential Public Services maintain our streets Foster a Vibrant Community for our residents and businesses to thrive likewise C county is not coming forward with ideas to increase your school enrollment or stabilize the Northbend School District's budgets each year all they have done is taken a position of opposition without offering any alternatives

109we would not have brought this to you if we believed it failed to have the school district's best interests at heart the city of North Bend stands proudly as a champion for our schools and students just listen to the blaring siren parades escorting our students out of town on their way to state or observe your City library summer reading program for children that Foster an improved academic environment for academic achievement instead of saying no let's look for reasons to say yes because there are tangible reasons to do so here's a summary of the main point supporting yes this amendment cost the school district nothing your funding remains unchanged supporting this amendment keeps $250,000 of the school district's taxes here in Northbend to be used locally rather than sending to Salem for distribution to other school

110districts around the state this amendment directly benefits the school district by helping to stabilize and grow School enrollment by adding new housing for families in North Bend growing enrollment means increaseed state revenue for the Northbend School District's budget this proposal immediately reduces property taxes for local citizens putting money back in their pockets your vote means standing for lower tax taxes supporting this amendment supports the local economy and downtown revitalization supporting this amendment will provide housing that is Affordable with a preference given to those in education this is a chance for Northbend to be self-sufficient and support its own growth rather than relying on others we can take control of our future I urge you to approve these resolutions and invest in our community our schools and our hometown keeping our resources local is the only

111sensible Choice sending more resources to Salem changes nothing for the school district financially and only takes away from what we could be doing right here to strengthen and support our own Community all while lowering the tax burden uh the burden of property taxes you have nothing to lose and so much to gain let's focus on what truly benefits us and ensures a brighter future for our schools our local businesses and our residents thank you I have a question or two sure I mean you're a finance guy um I've been reading you know needless to said got things in the mail and Gmail and stuff like that um with the city owning and operating this the the units there it would it would basically be be back on tax rules because you're a commercial Enterprise at

112that point in time um is the uh how are the property taxes pa um so the the housing units would be it would be a you know a housing uh operation obviously would be paid out of the rents that you know cover so the rents rents paid would be covering the operational costs of the building so that would be coming on like the general fund kind of dollars it would not be coming on a general okay all right okay and uh I just s I'm clear on this um the as of 2033 it appears based on the information that some of the the the tax in increment financing um above the Frozen level will actually be dispersed to the why is that that is correct so there is a spending cap on how how much

113the urra can pull off from the other taxing districts each year it's projected to hit that level in about 203 2034 where anything above that cap gets redistributed back in um back to the districts that it came from and so um it's called Revenue sharing and so anything above that cap goes directly back to um the school district to the county to any of the taxing authorities within within the urban rural agency but but then I saw in 2047 it takes a dive and starts going back up again what's that all about um I'd have to refresh my memory on the di that it takes and I remember somebody talking about the the tribe something about the tribes is that there there is something to do with that but I would rather like get you

114a better answer the correct answer on that okay I just had a few questions I appreciate yeah no I appreciate your question so my question would be does this generate tax revenue the building has if the city develops this is that is there tax like a property tax from that building so the hope is that there's economic development that happens and it raises property tax values I'm asking about that building specifically the building itself yes would have components of it with uh property taxes associated with it I believe components yeah well City Hall wouldn't be tax right I I get this building would but the residential portion of that building would pay tax is that what you're saying believe the commercial portions of it would pay tax commercial portions so and I I can get

115you a better answer on that if it would help you with your vote residential well my view would I don't know is isn't the rental commercial as well it be commercial making a profit for the for the urban agency I'd like to have it I'd like to just make sure and get you sure the correct answer on that and voting tonight we don't have so we're voting but we don't have answers and and my next question is you said it's going to lower the taxes can you give me the percentage that it's going to lower taxes that 1% 10% 20% % yeah it would actually lower the uh percentage of taxes for taxpayers by about 38% of what the UR is currently taking so it's this Ur special Lev 30% of what 38% of what

116the UR is taking I don't know what that is per person like if I'm paying taxes on me what what's what's my percentage I understand the UR but I'm talking about what's what's the return on for the taxpayer so if you looked at your tax bill I mean I guess is anywhere from $100 to $200 um per taxpayer it might be more if it if you have a higher higher value it's going to change by each person you know I looked at my own tax bill it's going to be about $100 $100 yeah okay that's what I there was a statement about questions um and not having the information for the votes tonight as this governing body is aware we've responded to 49 pages of documented questions and answers this particular question was in there

117no different than the North Bend hotel that has housing it is on the tax roles they pay taxes the commercial Enterprise of anything that is involved with the urban renewal agency is taxed it's back on the tax rules and so this property which has been said from day one from the over renewal agency and the city council of Northbend was the intent that after a hundred years the project would be back on the tax roles and would be generating funds as it was stated about the city hall offices that is pie in the sky as I've said uh on our prior discussions there has been no decision there is no designs there's no layout uh we have in here a resolution that would allow the urban renewal agency to consider putting in City Hall offices

118if this building was demolished and it would create about 40 additional units so we would actually increase there are things that have to occur for that to happen we don't own the building that's in between us so the UR would have to consider that uh the grade from mcferson to Union is significant enough so the parking as I've mentioned in the past would be on the parking garage which would allow uh under the parking garage an area long Union that could be used for City Hall offices we are spread out um in a lot of areas that's very inefficient this building needs an excess of 8 million dollar of seismic upgrades the city taxpayers are not being asked to foot this this entire plan was put together so that it was a win-win for everybody

119that could solve problems give tax breaks help with housing issues Revitalize our downtown have uh walking foot traffic that could support the businesses and move Northbend forward so I'm sorry um if you didn't that Jeff could answer that question um but you know there's another room and group of us all listening so I apologize moving from one room to another but uh that's why I was intent on listening to the questions I have a question you were talking about a building that you don't own yet what one's that uh that is uh the former Theater which is now a church uh the urban renewal agency uh does have uh first right of refusal in writing from the church so it could uh exercise that option um it has not done so the church currently has

120it advertised on the market at $1.2 million um and so uh uh we do not own that building so the physical 72 units would be on the existing footprint of the property that is owned which is the annex um however we as I mentioned have options to extend that and create additional housing downtown yeah you wouldn't be thinking about building around that sh would you no okay no it would be on the existing that's a great question it would be on the existing footprint of the existing property we own the annex the annex any more questions for Jeff for David actually we're we're not feeling questions from from the audience so thank you for asking I I I guess I I might as well just ask one question sure um I I actually had a

121couple but um I'll leave it to just one um on page 12 of of well it's our page 25 but it's page 12 of uh understanding urban renewal at the bottom it says upon request of the agency the city council of the city of Northbend may as necessary to achieve plan objectives issue Revenue Bond certificates notes for local Improvement or special assessment districts and seek General obligation bonds to assist in completing projects earlier or in financing the plan General obligation bonds will be considered last as a funding method would this go to the voters or is this something that you you guys can just issue a bond the uh City cannot unilaterally issue a bond the urban renewal agency would seek bonds and the bonds would be backed by the good faith of the repayment

122of the existing tax increment that it's off already receiving uras by law are supposed to be in debt and so you have a project um the largest portion of that project is the NX project um so there are projects that would be done throughout the 30 years but yes we would seek indebtedness um very shortly in order to move that project forward okay so those bonds are not specifically to the taxpayers of North Bank any more questions for David or Jeff okay thank you guys um little little introduction um you know the city of Northbend presented the case for urban renewal answered questions in meetings and work sessions or in we had a big work session in January and the board would like to thank uh administrator David milon and Jeff bridgin for their answering

123many many questions on this and there was multiple um multiple uh requests where where those were asked so so like to thank those guys for that um you know there's many different opinions in the community regarding urban renewal and how best to improve our town um speaking for myself I believe that all the citizens of North Ben want freedom economic prosperity and Public Safety and Public Safety to me is fire police and jails so um with that is anyone from from the board would they be interested in Reading uh resolution 20252 on page 129 sure thank you uh resolution whereas glasses whereas the north band urban renewal agency pursuant to the requirements of or chapter 457 prepared the North B urban renewal plan Amendment reviewed by the agency on January 23 2025 and whereas section

124four of the plan authorizes increase in maximum indebtedness of the plan from 11,800 723 to $5,500,000 and whereas in accordance with or 45747 sub7 this increase in maximum indebtedness must rece concurrence of taxing districts imposing at least I think it's actually composing at least uh 75% of the amount of taxes imposed upon permanent rate limits in the urban Ral area of taxing districts who are estimated to forlow for glow the most property tax revenue must concur with the expenditure of funds for a public building project as required by OS for 57.0 8973 and whereas the agency has requested concurrence from the city of North Bend the Northbend School District 13 and the Oregon International Court of KZ Bay and whereas the northb school district 13 concurs with the increase in maximum indebtness of the northb

125urban renewal plan thank you that's good that's it okay there's another okay is there is there a motion I move I move to approve resolution 20252 accepting and authorizing the large increase in maximum indebtness for the urban renewal agency is outlined exhibit A and B okay so there is a motion I will state it I move to approve res resolution 2025-the a large increase in maximum indebtedness for urban renewal agency as outlined in exhibit A and B is there a second I have a second okay there is a motion and a second and I will restate the motion I move to approve resolution 20252 accepting and authorizing the large increase in maximum indebtedness for the urban renewal agency as outlined in exhibit A and B uh with that we will have the discussion debate section

126so board members are free to express their opinions on this I guess I'll start so I I think speaking of of the board all seven of us have put a lot of time into this and this is above our pay grate we're doing something that is not a Schoolboard common thing and we were just presented this um beginning of November um we've spent a lot of hours researching and it doesn't no matter what we decide know that we all love North Bend and we all want the best for this community that being said um something that I said in a work session that we had concerning this is this is a lot of pressure for the Northbend school board for our city of Northbend and we are um asked to approve something um going from

12711 million to $44 million over 30 years many of us won't be here and we're put we are asked to put our stamp of approval on something that once we do um figuratively we are being handcuffed and have no control once we do that and that's that's where I'm coming from specifically um I love the idea of housing I love the idea of wanting to make our city better but um we don't have control on how the city manages their money and that is something that I'm concerned about specifically um and yeah um and and then just to add one more thing um a a a citizen of our city um called me yesterday or the day before as a um he has a rental property and his concern is the city is buying a

128property and they are going to be um they are in direct opposition with private Enterprise yeah yeah so anyway um that that's a concern from people who own rental properties within the city of Northbend competing with our own City yeah so that's what happens well piggy back on that a little bit Michelle um I uh we we can't control whether that type of housing would be all Workforce or not uh there's not going to be total control like one would think ideally it would be great everybody is caring and does care about housing and you know living wages in this community growing no one questions that we care very much for our students or we wouldn't be here this cost us many hours guys to do what we do that's fine we've stood up to

129do that and we are but um something like this I I don't like the fact that it's going to get into the county funds you can have an argument any way you want on that I don't like that we need our jails we need our sheriffs um I don't like the fact that it's not put before the voters okay now I'll tell you what right now half the people are going to be okay and the other half of the people are going to hate us okay so you can't win there so you have to go by just basically you know what you feel like but I I I totally agree I don't like the there's no impact I I mean no input uh and changes can be made there's constant anybody who's done anything in

130building my God you know CH things change every time you turn around and so now it's all left to the government to make those decisions I am not a fan of the government being in the the rental business I'm not a fan of the management skills of our money with the government so um you know it it that's just how I how I see it like I said everybody has their own position on this and I you know what we have to do is respect the position whether you agree with it or not uh we're the ones who are put here to unfortunately make a decision that I think is not really fair to this board board okay it is not at all fair to this board so anybody else I got some comments Mary

131so um my tax bill bill clearly states that my tax dollars go to education districts when taxpayers contribute to education funding they do so with the understanding that their money supports schools not other projects redirecting These funds even if the state has backfilled them in the past is not a guarantee that funding will continue from the state in the future this decision should be in the hands of the Northbend School District citizens who elected us not just the seven members of this board yep if this plan is truly in the best interest of the community then it should go to a public vote taxpayers deserve a direct say in how their school funding may be diverted elsewhere and lastly uh the Commissioners vote uh had a big impact on me and I don't do not

132like the fact that the county is losing money I believe it was stated $65,000 a year for 30 [Applause] years yes and as you guys probably understand I I'm I'm in favor of this um because forious Reas first off that's a blight and that's exactly what Urban R was designed to address is blighted conditions and we've heard from uh information has been provided that private parties were invited to come in here and and address this uh to take it down and build something that's going to be you know Shining Light here in in North Bend and no one was interested in doing it because it doesn't penc private point of view that's exactly where urban renewal purpose is is come in and do things that the private entities can't do um if if we don't

133pass this I don't see how that building is ever going to come down or how we're going to be improving the the the area where it is now I understand the concerns that the voiced here and I respect that and and and people out there who voiced their concerns about uh UR in general and such but I have seen Ur work very well at K Bay and here in North Ben and at the same time I've seen it that not work that well so um someone said earlier you know basically that um there is no status quo either you're moving forward or you're falling back and I I think we need to move forward we move forward with u putting a workplace housing there taking down a blighted area um as far as the Count's

134concerned you know I hate I mean right now they're not getting the money and I guess uh whenever the current plan would ex would would expire that's when they would start getting the $65,000 $65,000 is not going to open another B there it's not going to pay for another share um so the reality is I think we need to do something that's why I made the motion uh it sounds like I'm probably going to lose on this one but hey you know we're all entitled to op respect your else thank you um I do want to say you know every decision that we make is definitely in the best interest of everybody who lives here I mean I've lived here for over 30 years myself and uh um I joined the board because I care

135about the community and the people and uh I never thought we'd have to do this this is something huge we were here for students and uh um this makes you have to think outside of your area again we have to worry about County and the other districts that this does affect so for me and I wrote down some of mine I'm concerned that we haven't done an exhaustive enough search for private Investments there are things that we can do to make this are are there things that we can do to make this investment more attractive like can we offer them tax incentives maybe we give them no taxes for 30 years to come here and build I don't know um if it's a project where money can be made I can't see an investor coming

136in and saying I want to make any money I just won't do it I can't see that um I'm concerned with the city competing with res residents for rental income um the city would have the ability to affect the rental market prices so um if they think that it's too high here they can set the price low and that prices other people out so then they fill up their building but empty everybody else's houses um tonight I heard uh many people talking about uh and everybody was set on the number 72 I don't know that there's anybody on this board that thinks that we're going to build 72 units because we were never told that there were 72 units we were told 30 maybe 70 um we're not sure uh was the most common answer

137that we got but everybody that sat right there tonight was very sure that we were building 72 units so um I I caution you to just accept the numbers you've been told um because that scares us right we don't know again tonight we don't know those those kind of things when you have a don't know um I should CAU anybody especially when we're talking about 30 years and $45 million um I'm concerned that the real estate values in the UR would be affected by the modernization of the building and could price some current residents out of their apartments and businesses here in the local area um I know that some of these uh restaurants down here operate on very small margins and if their rental prices went up for the buildings that they're in I'm

138not sure that they would survive um because they the taxes are going to go up that building isn't going to pay taxes the city owns up I'm also worried that the Frozen tax base and I don't know if everybody knows how one of these things works but uh I think Chris is the want to pass this out it's a great little graph this is the tax base when it starts and it literally freezes the tax base everything in the blue is what the urban renewal eats up as your taxes increase it gets all of the increases your city has to keep operating on where it started for 30 years now many of you guys are going to wonder how the heck are we going to pay for all the additional purs and everybody's raises and

139all the additional fees and everything else it happens to to uh to manage your City on a frozen tax base for the next 30 Years I don't know the where they're going to get it either but I do know that they sure like using the waterboard um I know that they made the the city mad when they asked for a provisional vote and then didn't listen and did it anyway the city got so mad that they stuck their nose into the city's business I think we went a little too far on that one but uh it showed how mad they made everybody and I think that uh doing this and having to go back and do the same thing and find another way to get funding to fund this city after they do this because

140this one doesn't really affect us right but eventually it's going to in 30 years it's going to Yes um so I'm worried the Frozen tax base will not adequately fund the city government and services and their Pur obligations I keep hearing the UR the UR doesn't cost taxpayers any extra money as it just pays for itself with the annual increases in the tax base over the 30-year life of the UR we see seen just in the recent past where in order for the city to pay for essential Services they've added in the waterboard fee the implementation and increase you know we we went through all that so I believe the UR uh if approved those fees will continue to increase providing more of a financial burden on citizens and I don't think the citizens of

141North B need any more financial burden right now right [Applause] that's so I let everybody else talk so they literally covered 75% of what I already was going to say so thank you for that limits what I have to say um so from what I can understand um the ur's tax money that we have all paid into this pool that the state has to hand out and redistribute as at their discretion um if the state was to stop harvesting this money from this from us so that they can redistribute it and let us keep it we have more power to do with our money what we want to do um we don't know the economic future of the state being the sanctuary state that it is and it wouldn't be fiscally responsible to take that

142risk um I don't think that the federal funds for the schools will get um because of this because of the sanctuary status of the state I am worried about the backfill that we're supposedly promised um um let's see the city has been a great partner in all of this for the district and I do really repres appreciate that I think the parades that they give the kids in and out of this uh town with um escorts and um the parades for the the sports teams and everything um it's just really sweet and amazing um but that's that's the city and this the school district working together and just respecting each other I don't see how that has anything to do with the actual Ur So to leverage that in an emotional way is a little

143bit manipulative I think um so I anyway everybody else covered what I was thinking about so I that's about the side of it [Applause] okay I'm last um I was a little bit of two minds on this I I look at the pros what's what's in it for the school district is increase in students in in a state Statewide environment of declining uh enrollment that's truly what's there it also uh it cleans up old infrastructure blight however you want to call it um the cons as I see it I have a philosophical preference for private Enterprise to perform construction and manage uh an apartment plan of this and I don't like to see the city to be in the in the real estate business competing with with private citizens I don't think that's the place

144I do I'm a bit of a control freak my family's sitting right there they can probably vouch for this but I do see you know this is out of our scope typically you know we're we're a school board we make educational decisions but hey we're we're in this taxing district um you know I think our fingerprints are going to end up on this if it if it was passed and and I do like having control over outcomes uh in the world I I lived in when I worked and and currently um my metric is the outcome not my intention not the intentions so I just see some risk in the costs the execution and then the management Property Management who gets to live there yeah so those are my big big concerns I do note

145that the KZ County Commissioners and this is a loose restatement of the world uh article unan unanimously voted 30 not to approve the second resolution on December 3rd the majority sticking point of it was uh the current Revenue issues leading to the Pod closure at the county jail and layoffs of County Employees um the idea that it goes to uh a public vote yep kind of there there's some romance to that with me so that that's my my comments any further comments from the board I had one more um one more thing that I observed out here that uh I think was uh I don't know if it's dishonest or just the way it was presented is uh that the folks here we were told that this would be long-term housing and I think most

146of the people that sat here and talked to us uh the way you were explaining it or the way it was said sounded like it was transitory housing we're going to bring people in so they have time to sit and look for a house in the area if we don't have houses in the area sitting in that building is not going to make them appear right right so it just means you're going to be living in that building so it's either long-term housing or it's transitory I think and here it was presented Again by most of the folks who talked about it as transitory um the housing that we need is not that building that's not where people want to live clearly it's not where people want to live because when people were talking about

147it you're talking about getting them in to get them out um so um for me if we're want to build houses we need to make the area more attractive to people who want to invest in our area um and it's not by hi am from the government and I'm here to help yeah right so um for me I I just I I can't support the idea I don't know very many people like I a I would I would like to suggest one thing for the powers that be if we would release some of these ridiculous burdensome building regulations yeah people could build some houses it's ridiculous so well stay However Boomer help us out get this we're getting you Boomer he's outnumbered list okay any any further debate before we move to a roll call

148vote okay we'll start to my left Carol it's a Noe okay Julie no Dallas no Nathan hi Michelle Roberts no Mary Schilling no no [Applause] uh board chair no okay so uh Michelle bricks it is six Nos and one yay the motion fails okay I want to thank uh thank everyone here I we have another one to do but I'd like to thank everybody for their thoughtful particip in this and care one will be easy we don't no we if the first one fails I don't think you take up the next one it doesn't matter okay right yeah because without the first one the second one exist do we have to vote on that should we even let's vote on it okay um or or make a motion if we don't if we don't no

149one seconds it dies anyway so okay yeah do that okay all right I 20 2-03 does anyone want to read it Nathan you you read one already you don't have to someone else's Dallas thank you want me to make the motion okay um here we go okay all right number two resolution 20253 whereas the urban renewal agency pursuant to the requirements ORS chapter 457 prepared the Northbend urban renewal plan Amendment reviewed by the agency on January 23 2024 and whereas the section three of the plan authorizes certain project activities within the northb urban renewal area and whereas these projects include funding for rehabilitation and replacing the current city hall as part of the housing project considered a public building project under osss 45 or 457 010 and whereas the addition of a public building project

150requires concurrence of taxing districts in accordance with ORS 47.8 Niner and whereas this public project is shown in section three of execute a North Bend urban renewal plan Amendment and whereas the governing body of taxing districts representing three of the four taxing districts who are estimated to forego the most property tax revenue must concur with this expenditure of funds for a public building project as required by ORS 47.8 ners and whereas the agency has requested concurrence from the city of Northbend the Northbend School District number 13 cous County and the cous County Library District and whereas the northb school district 13 concurs with the inclusion of the public building project for rehabilitation or reconstruction of north city call in the north Urban re plan action requested the city Northbend request the board approve or denial

151of the resolution 202-0324 approve resolution 20253 accepting the listed urban renewal projects in exhibit A and D so are you making a motion I just did motion I'll second it Michelle seconded it okay there is a motion and a second and uh I will reread the motion I move to approve resolution 20253 accepting the listed urban renewal projects in exhibit A and B um debate no none okay we'll go with uh R roll call book yeah couldn't get it out all right all right Carol no Julie no Dallas nay Nathan no okay Michelle no no Mary no no and me no so it's seven NOS okay thanks for all the time thank you for the public coming out here um yeah and the participation and uh the work that was done on this okay agenda

152item 8 appoint budget committee members number eight that's the action item so yeah there is uh hey we're thankful we got two thank whoever who are they here anybody here or one of them oh there's one yeah are you here in awake sorry if if we BL Van Gordon that is me hey BL thank you for that and we'd also like to thank Rodney stalkup and uh so anyway action requested it is recommended the board approve the threeyear appointment of candidates for zone three and seven of the budget committee names for consideration position three live Van Gordon position seven Rodney stalkup I move to appoint the following for the northb School District budget committee positions three and s for threeyear terms ending June 30th 2027 I second that okay a motion in a second I

153will repeat the motion I move to appoint the following for the Northbend School District budget committee positions three and seven for threee terms ending June 30th 2027 discussion we're glad you're here um thank you let's have a a vote all in favor say I I I 70 thank you thank you for that it's exciting work we appreciate you it's necessary work thank you for that get some free food also true yeah they do feed catering is okay all right moving on to agenda item nine academic calendar semester calendar at the secondary level Vince do you want to discuss this one yeah as we uh we talked about in the board work session two weeks ago um thank you for uh for discussing that with us at that time we have for uh quite a period

154of time talked about the concept of aligning our entire district with one uh type of system as you may know uh the elementary schools have been on a semester system for a number of years middle school the high school of state with the trimester model um trimester model is one that we U that sets us apart from nearly every other high school in the state U it brings with it a series of challenges one of those challenges is inter District alignment maybe intra District alignment um so uh for example our elementary schools um have have days that that don't line up with triesters because at the end of a trimester you got to have a grading day and you got to do all those pieces and and so the challenge of providing professional development that's

155aligned that's trying to put a calendar together that actually has a district level alignment has been frustrating um also the state of Oregon has um maybe not for the first time the first time in a long time started making requirements that include Half credits so when they required um the State Board of Education decided to put personal finance back on as a state requirement it hadn't been a state requirement since essentially I was in high school um and so covered wagons you know so um so at some point they pulled that off and and and and so it's back on that it's back on as a half credit unfortunately we have a hard time doing a half credit when you're trimester um so to get a half credit you really essentially got to take twoth

156thirds of a year and so you're getting 67 credit if you will and so they did the same thing with that college prayer Readiness as well as requirement of civics a half a year of civics so to meet those requirements um we're having to over which is not very efficient the uh some other things that we thought we would share we put together a prototype calendar that we gave to our calendar committee yesterday to review um and in that prototype calendar we counted the hours of instruction because one of the main focus points for us was hopefully to increase the number of hours of instruction students have throughout the year and in fact um when we had noie Mohler who is our our state reporting person she's the one that counts the hours at literally

157every level so that we can report that to the state the comparison of the hours that we have this year and the hours we have next year uh are different in this way 15 additional hours of instruction on a semester schedule on the calendar that we created even though the elementary schools are currently on a semester schedule the efficiencies that we create give them 15 additional instructional hours at the middle school level they have seven additional instructional hours which is more than one day of instructions at the high school level uh six additional instruction hours um we also looked at instructional efficiency uh for example um uh we have every every term um we have kids that want to change their schedule and so when you change your schedule you get a new schedule and

158then you go through a week or so where you where every seems like every student from sixth grade to 12th grade wants to change at least one of their classes and so what ends up happening is that takes up a lot of time students are not actually getting instruction because they're trying to to swap one for another and end there's a lot of distraction in that in those times well instead of having three times a year for kids get new schedules you talk about twice a year so you reduce some of the inefficiency that happens every time you change your schedule um we are reducing at the secondary level the number of days of grading um we are also moving forward with the notion if this is passed that instead of having a grading day

159at the end of the nine weeks because the nine week point is just kind of a fancy progress report time uh we're just going to actually make sure our teachers are up to date with a grade book and they're going to push the button in Synergy that says progress report and so um we'll actually reduce the number of days that they actually have this gradings and you think about finals um instead of three different weeks where we focus on finals you'll have two weeks where you do that which means that you have more time to actually provide direct instruction rather than having kids go through a finals week that is um that is positive it's good to have that accountability in terms of your grading but it's also um it it's it's also kind of

160distracting and weak too takes away from that correct instruction um we did have get input from our staff especially the high school staff um the survey was created that we had a chance to our district leadership team had a chance to review um and almost overwhelmingly they were at least neutral in fact most of them were it was pretty much like yeah okay we can do that um and there were a few U that generally speaking were against it um but pretty much everybody else and I say a few like percentage wise there were several different questions it kind of ranged into you know 15 to 20 to 25% range depending on the question so it's pretty safe to say without just staring at the data right in front of me that about three4 of

161the staff were at least okay neutral to to definitely War um that also also included an a special look with our CTE programs um in fact one of the things and uh you heard ml talk referenced the concept of of safety training um every time you a group of kids in our shop classes basically you need to do safety training over um if uh when you take a semester long class um essentially the group is going to stay together for an entire semester and so um so both Mitch and Garrett have both and that's Miss Garrett welding and and Boop have said that they support it just because they'll spend less time having to do safety training for every new section of people so um uh professional development I think one of the things we

162talk about is we're able to align a professional development better um one of the things we continuously run into with the differences in the schedule is that like our PLC time on Frid days it's uh uh professional Learning Community time on Fridays uh we're kind of robbing one because we're trying to do something with one group and we a different group and it's hard time aligning those because our develop this and necessarily line working with our leadership team who just did an amazing job and kind of conceptualizing this and putting it together um we believe that that we're going to be good to go and be much more efficient in terms of of that time and those hours so um for all of those reasons um I believe that I would recommend that you um

163vote in favor of switching from a semester to a trimester I will say this mean I said yes you got it trimester to semester we know that every school around us is in a semester system one of one of the things that is real is that we know that we have students that go back and forth between school um so every time a student comes from another school and comes to here we've got to go through this conversion process to figure out how many of our credits and conversely what our stud go to other schools they've got that school's got to go through a conversion process to figure out what to do with the way we do credits um and because right now of course we get one credit per trimester per class and so

164what will next year if you approve this be one credit of social Stace I'm the social St teacher so if I teach us history for an entire year that's one credit right now in our system that's three so when I I have a student with us history that goes over to another school and they got to try to figure out what those two credits or three credits add up to and and a tri or semester system uh there's challenges there it's not insal challenges we've been doing every years but that is there's some efficiencies that thoughts or questions you hav't inlisted do able to create an algorithm to take those three and turn them into one um Talk Joe Joe's um Joe is all things Synergy um and that's one of the big questions we

165had what kind of a difficulty Factor would we have the beauty of synergy in most of those student Information Systems is it's really just very mathematical so the challenges are not necessarily going to be with students who are passing all their classes all year okay because it's easy to take that one year of US history that says three and turn that into one the bigger challenge is what happens when you have a student who passed two of those three and you still have one left over and they need that but from a mathematical standpoint for the next three years we would have a um we'll just be doing the math like if you have two out of three credits that's 67 of a credit and so um that it's going to most difficult for the

166juniors because they have the most years under the current trry system our fresh be pretty simple the sophomores are going to be a little bit more difficult because they've got two years into the system but um but in conversation with the counseling department and and and principal Pendleton and which we made sure and had those conversations of well what do you think what you think that transition is going to look like the migration of those numbers they don't see that it's going to be particularly because in in wor case scenario we sit down and we literally hand enter a number into the system in the transcript and then that that historical information is there a motion I'll move it I'll move to approve the Northbend middle school and Northbend High School transition from a trimester

167system to a semester system beginning in two 2005 the 2006 school year 25 25 you said 25 2026 school year so there's a motion and Julie second I'll reread the motion I move to approve the Northbend middle school and Northbend High School transition from a trimester system to a semester system beginning in the 2025 26 school year with that is there any further discussion my my daughter will not talk to me she will your daughter did a fabulous job you better bring her an ice I did enjoy her her argument was actually and on the spot minutes app definitely she did very well and it was very compelling almost changed my mind okay any further discussion okay all in favor say I I 7 Z okay with that okay agenda item 10 board comments thank

168you everyone for coming out just really quickly I mean for for this whole thing with the uh Annex and everything I would hope that North would kind of reconsider what they're doing how they're doing it um maybe look at a private uh public U option uh to to I still I don't want them to give up because I don't want that building standing there and I again I respect everyone's decision here and the people that spoke here um I just there's got to be another way get nothing taken care of I would agree I agree with that I think they just don't give up move ahead see what we do maybe cost a little less money to the city to I agre any further comments okay with that just information only agenda item 11 just

169want to tell the board we have a work session two weeks from today February 20th we will have an executive session with that um one of the things about that if we recall we're going to have that training yes talk a little one of the modules IAL with person from at two modules and one of them includ self evaluation there's not enough time between now and then for them to go through that process would be sending out a link survey then put the data together so ssmh 101 training refresh is that all right yeah that'll work we can all use the refresh and I want to recognize m Michelle bricks got us a scholarship for that for them to come down and do some in-person training with the board and uh we all benefit in

170some training I'm a big fan of continuous learning so thank you for that the of Champions is that's a problem we'll we'll figure something out we take back those Kudos don't we have CL what all right I guess not all right with with that said hey we're adjourning the meeting thank you for everyone that hung in good with us all right

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.