CorpusRecord 243870

1-23-2025 Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / North Bend School District
Date
2025-01-31
Location
Coos County, OR
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,586 words · about 93 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation God indivisible withy and justice for all thank you all right post Jordan just Dallas there it is look at that Dallas P Dallas I always got a venture out there Julie the Carol Yardley we we have every all seven board members here okay agenda item two approval of the agenda is there a motion to approve the agenda as present Julie any additions little discussion no all in favor say I I I 70 okay uh agenda item three urban renewal so this is our work session on it um we had a go we had some training or information presentation uh we have had questions that were gathered by Michelle bricks from board members and forwarded over to David M and

002Jeff brigin and they have answered quite a few fact I think there's I've got two print outs here pages one to 26 and in addition uh 1 to 11 was some some followup questions so quite a few questions I hear there's been some questions that came in after that you have that paper too I have that so those I don't those not David I want to thank you for your uh Lucid very lucid uh comments from the questions and answers it was very good app you represent City uh that so um I'm going to open up the table to the board members to ask David and Jeff unless you guys had any open comment I'll leave opening comments to job yeah no I've gota love to pinch my sandwich sure good um well first I

003want to thank you for inviting us uh to be at your work session tonight appreciate the opportunity to have discussion with you answering questions or additional questions they might might have um have to admit that um in preparing for tonight's meeting I was surprised by the number of questions posed by the district um given that the district in my opinion is the least impacted by any of the taxing districts within the urban Ral agency boundary um by far the and so um the number of questions was surprising to um just give that that the impact um financially is is seems so minimal or non-existent and the potential of the project that's being contemplated by the urban renewal has a direct impact to help the school district we know that enrollment is a problem it's an

004issue it was stated in your budget you have five years of declining enrollment new students are needed so it was stated in the budget that loss of students equals loss of Revenue I have to believe that increases in students equal increases in revenue and so the project that's being um clearly stated in the urban renewable agen plan um has the ability to directly help with enrollment and to help Stave off that decline that your experience in um your superintendent wrote um something something I think very telling um in his comments about the the budget and about the North School District and he said I'm continually appreciative of the support participation and viable Solutions provided by the community families District staff and school board members as we all share a common vision and so in thinking

005that I kind of starred that because I thought about how the city is a part of the community and part of a good partner with the school district and so one of the things that um we've put together is you know kind of how directly or indirectly does the city like benefit the school district like what is it and then what like kind of cost to that and we're I think they're be able to provide that information to you um but when you stop back and look at the totality of it the fire department they show up school they show up at events they support the um athlete athletic uh Endeavors that are are being put forth they do parades out of town um we've got a public works department that undertakes um projects um

006that directly benefit the school district's property I think the the school Bridge um is is one of those projects um and so I believe that the city is a good partner and is a good Community member with regard to the districts and I think that we all want the same we all want to have the best school district um in Oregon and like the best great Community to live in um and I think we all have a vested interest in seeing that at least I hope that we do um in fact I live in Northbend got kids that go to Northbend high school and um you know definitely want that for them and want their experience to be um the best it possibly can be and so just given all of the questions that we

007received um it made me stop and think and want to ask you some questions as well and I hope this is an opportunity for us to hear from you as well but I really want to know what your concerns are to have them for this project or this amendment um are there things that we're overlooking like to hear that like to know how best we can address that what steps can we take to build your trust if you were mistrusting of um the urban renewal initiative or the or the project itself and if the project that um is being described um is not aligning with the needs of the school district how can we align those I'd like to hear that from as well and so I hope it's a an opportunity to answer any

008more questions but also an opportunity for us to hear from you um really your real feelings Behind The Bu just given the number and nature of questions there a lot you did not receive that level of questions from any of the other districts that we spok so with that thank you for the opportunity I can read these questions may be easily answered or do someone have something from the I to say I'm kind of shocked a little but you didn't receive the number of questions other as C citizens I mean we represent the school board but also every one of us is an citizen so that affects us outside of this as well so I would expect that anyone be affected by have a lot of questions so there's a lack of questioning on something

009so large the change from s years 30 years that's a that's a big ask I with a lot of questions okay I'm gonna read some questions for you guys uh that came in subsequent to you guys answered these so more questions regarding the original 11.8 million ual plan were all goals accomplished um all goals are not accomplished nor in uh vast majority of the urban Reno agencies in the State uh they are not uh there's not enough money to accomplish all of the goals and so when you look at projects and funding um when they get aligned they do not all get accomplished for instance uh at the last meeting Jeff had a welcomed you all to go out and uh look at the uh model out uh in the hallway by the restrooms and

010I joked you know just look past the giraffes and the other animals because that was an original concept plan of what North Bend could be however plans are just that uh you plan and other things happen so for instance uh the bulk of the property for redevelopment on the waterfront was acquired by uh the tribe and so that you can Implement that section and so the plan gets revised and amended and so this plan um has been um in existence and uh revised a believe three times uh since its Inception um and um I think you mentioned seven years this plan in the funding actually significantly goes back further than that um and um uh so so the simple answer is no and the answer would hold for uh the majority of the 250 uh

011uras in the state I rarely answered yes or no to any questions that have all every okay just maybe add one piece of it to you it's just something I think I've kind of learned throughout the especially looking at the Historical piece of it but there's a lot to digest with the UR rules and um I don't think when it was set up maybe there the intentions were there to do to do things the right way but I don't think it was set up correctly from the get-go there was no debt taken out at the beginning at the Inception to do those projects which normally should have happen and that would definitely have kept things much more accountable I think for the agency um and so just to add that bit of history at least

012from my perspective that's that's what I've seen with it that's salent point because North Bend's different um and had been different than than other municipalities in fact they were always PID as you go and unfortunately um if you put money in uh the bank account hoping one day to buy that car uh by the time you're ready and what you thought was the price it's escalated and that's what's happened with a lot of the uh projects uh whereas uh for instance um you look at our sister city north kbak um uh they went out and spent their money which is exactly what a UR is supposed to do it is supposed to implement those projects that are in there uh and then uh use the revenue coming in to pay down uh whereas um our

013city has done a little differently we have leveraged the urra uh against grants uh matching grants so that we could actually extend the money and so it was a different philosophical way of life um prior to um uh maryi and her Administration um coming in if I me but this plan is more tuned to the the way Bay has coming correct yes will be basically get the loan to do the work and then the urban will pay for over time correct yes which is the way the law says that it should be doing you are supposed to be in that's what the law says I have a question so um the the building you want to renovate and and get tenants in one of the things you guys have spoken about before for people that

014you were trying to attract to those or one of the reasons you wanted to build those those transitory healthare workers here in the city that's you guys about Area Hospital and all the folks that's come in all that kind of now the hospital is changing that they they're saying that's the one of their Le C ders that they're trying to cut down is that going to that's an incorrect statement so uh this is not for their transitory this is for Workforce housing for folks that actually live in your community this is not for rentals uh shortterm uh for traveling nurses um so let's let's dispel that right away and I like dispelling things someone actually posted a rumor and said is the rumor true that the North Bend pool was heated that was an actual

015and so I like to dispel those things because no uh uh these are annual leases it says in the document and I don't expect you all have gotten this that's a lot of information to digest and so very much like some of these questions we probably will have follow up more detailed answers and we'll tell you that because you got to digest it um just because we answered them and handed it to you um that's 37 pages of of answers and uh uh there's a lot of information in there uh that uh but yes it is uh long-term um annual uh leases uh for folks that are in the community are coming uh for instance um I was just at a South Coast development council meeting uh this week they hired a brand new economic

016development manager and that person is living in a hotel and they said they have to find uh housing by April before the hotel rates change that's a that's a real life issue real life person uh moved here from Virginia I I have something to say just before you I I think probably speaking for a lot of the people here just to kind of answer one of your questions I think part of the fear I I'm for it a for a lot of reasons in some but I'm fearful and the reason I'm fearful is because we are voting on something that affects the future of our town for 30 years and once we vote if it goes through then our hands are tied we have we have no control what you guys do with that but

017yet our names are our our school district is kind of attached to that and so we're kind of protective of our school district and that's where a lot of probably the questions are coming from and a lot of the fear of what are you going to do with what what if people don't agree with what you decide to do what you do or don't do and yet our name is on that part of that and so I think that's that's part of the reason why we are very cautious going forward and asking lots and lots of questions yeah see I I was a journalist for 20 years I love question because I was on the other side asking tons of questions yeah um and and I respect that and uh it's exactly why the law

018requires a detailed audit and Report annually to be produced and you know I'm not one to look back but since the Mary inco Administration forward the reason I keep pointing to that is because I was hired here in six weeks it was changed and this gentlem actually helped us with the technical broadcasting out of the community center um when she was sworn in with the others and so that's why I always reference that forward and uh I'm not one to look back and I'm not one to say maybe their cards were different and they played a different thing however we abide by the law I'm across the. thee uh uh person we publish a specific budget for the UR and we hold accountability of our actions under the law and we produced that report they're

019available to the public they're right on our site if you go to Northbend oregon. usur you're going to see the budgets and you're going to see the annual reports and it tells you exactly all the plans are there and it shows you exactly what we're doing it's no different than the accountability that's required um that you have for your use of your funds and your uh sort of think of it as a grant Administration where you actually have have the reporting back and show what you're doing and you can't do anything outside that plan that's illegal and so um just joke I don't look good in Stripes okay all right so um you know if you ask my mayor it's like we don't do anything that's uh illegal immoral or unethical and I won't work

020for anyone um that does that and so I've had some falling outs with Mayors in the past and got fired from two cities for just that reason because I'm just not going to do it because I don't look good in Stripes I kind of like my lifestyle and so um so I appreciate the questions and I understand the commitment um the first uh plan uh same thing was voted on and uh we all these years we've gotten to this point uh where uh uh the funds uh under the maximum deadness which was increased once um uh prior so it's only changed twice over all of those years um the plan was tweak the law has changed and so when the Law changes um things can change for instance they um did one uh they were

021allowed one um expansion of their urra District it was done Brier I got here it's because the law changed allowed parks to be included so they went down in easan uh or or right away and brought in Simpson uh Park so that they could do things and so when you see park that's the park that's in the UR that that's the you know you have U Branch Circle here that's you know in the district uh if you want to call it a park but the real Park is uh Simpson I guess I'm going to jump in uh I'm curious about if we have to build a new school say in the next five years where do the funds from that come from um you as a governing body have a number of mechanisms to get

022money for a new school district um that's you know I thought that was restricted in this uh this has nothing to do with the UR no that was the unclear at first and it was clarified I think in our last meetings that it doesn't affect our ability to go out for Bond or at all so that absolutely no effect whatsoever okay okay because that that was a question I had heard um now for the loss of funds for the districts that are affected here yes yes we're not okay that's great but many are um who's going to pay for those Services um actually those um we've communicated all of them um in fact it's kind of nominal I think the the port of international Port of PE Bay was less than $40,000 of of loss

023they actually see a huge benefit comeb back because they're benefiting from um Logistics housing in future development for housing so the um uh each of the authorities um have seen positive the only one that we've had negative push back although I think um based on conversations I had this week we're going redress that and that's with the county and so um they had just gotten off the tails of their budget meetings with the jail and the sheriff's department and so when we walked in they're like and and they told me the Commissioners were very honest about about it they're like David it's a heated room and um don't be surprised Anything Can Fly here and so they actually thought they were voting on one thing but again education makes the difference and you guys um

024uh understand that more than anything if you don't sit down and get a great education on the urban renewal agency it's a lot to understand in fact just today Jeff Jeff saw me in action I'm literally working with the states foremost as we're like pulling together parts of the law and and threading it because it's very complicated and it has changed multiple times um the county thought that if youas went away um they get a huge windfall of of funds and that's just not the case when you actually look at the dollar amounts because you're only talking about the portion of of County tax money within the small district and then it goes out and parts to everybody else and so uh they thought they were voting on one thing and uh actually all they

025were being asked to do under the law was vote on the public building portion within to allow City Hall offices to be incorporated because that's going to allow us to add about 40 additional units to this development so so what you're saying is none of the county funds whatever that dollar amount let's say 40,000 a year is not going to be uh rerouted um if the UR um were to go away uh um it gets that money that is coming into the UR gets redistributed to all of the taxing authorities yours is different where your dollar for dollar actually sort of passes there's no net gain for the school district well for instance let's say the international Port of Cruz Bay they would increment by that roughly $440,000 annually um however each of the taxing

026authorities um have saw fit to allow this plan to go forward well my direct question was involving the county so I I think I think what's what's the impact of the county is in place and what's the impact of the county in terms of what they lose an operating in place so we have that figure in the plan 2425 it was 42974 does that sound right it's nomal it's very small that's PR year but over 30 years you're talking like one million I defer it 60 65 M or 65,000 excuse me in 2024 and the total life of the urra would be 2.8 million I will preface that was saying that um if the UR Amendment goes through it actually changes um the UR um I guess rules of like distribution somewhat where there's a

027cap on how much they can take then that there's Revenue sharing that occurs in about I think it was around 2035 that a portion of that annual amount above the cap will have to go back to the county and so it's capped and that's a change you that doesn't happen but a few years down the road 65,000 is a lot of money for our County to give up when they've had to close a pod and let uh police officers Sheriff's go absolutely and if they felt that adamant about it they could close their own Ur but they have not and then they could give that money back to us and your school district as well but the county has its own urban renewal agency but no projects so yes absolutely I would I would go

028and ask them and question that but they haven't sawed bit to close their own Ur So well I I was at that meeting and I was at the meeting when they had to uh lay off a lot of people so I uh I have to say I I stand with the Commissioners on this one and what is the Commissioners because the Commissioners haven't voted on urban renewal uh with the maximum inde deadness two um here's here's a very they haven't voted they're not required to they were asked on the resolution to allow the they were County and School District there's a lot of misinformation out there being sent out okay well County had a vote and you're saying the county did not vote at that meeting the county did not vote on maximum indebtedness because

029they don't have a vote on the maximum okay yes however um but they would vote on the second okay yes and so here's a salent point okay you have a CPA um we both um have um uh Finance certifications um and you're absolutely right we have communicated to the county on a lot of their cuts the other question that you might want to ask the county is why are they sitting on $200 million worth of timber that's not on their books as an asset an asset that you could actually take a tax anticipation note against so as Timber goes up and down you can move it into their fund 103 and actually fund services and so now that they have a new commissioner sitting we met with them this week so that we can actually

030bring new ideas and new views because the prior commissioner that seat would meet with us talk about um how to actually leverage um and so yes um there's lots of questions we like questions we like questions too because we're asking the same questions because it affects our city and our ability for our officers to you know when you have to arrest someone a school district or something they actually have a jail to put them in so it's a very valid question and so we have questions too the I know one of the questions that I personally had was just about how many units and what the makeup of those units would be you think about the potential of how many kids could be in seats um I know that with the with the Banger site

031they know how many two and three be there they they have AAL Studio or one bedroom type units they're not expecting to be down because they're providing specific services so that trans sort of situation of that group so we're on the accounting the two three they have so they've given us a projection I I think I read in here that you're looking at 40 to and but then like I have to admit I was I was under the impression that was more transitional housing people came in find a place to live as they searched for other houses and then and then Mo out those those areas so I'm I guess I'm a little confused about kind of the nuts and bolts of um I I know that you said you know a Needs A needs

032assessment would happen to help determine what the actual capacity would be in terms of how many units of each three bedro units two bed etc etc but from the from a standpoint when we talked internally about our cabinet you know we could say well it might be as as 10 it could be as much as 50 right so um can you help us kind of process that that's bols of what that looks like and and what what as you're thinking about drawing up plans and what the vision is for how that looks and how it's going to make a difference in terms of the kids sitting and suits so um in the documents we referenced this uh uh and and this has been from day one if you were to ask our mayor should um

033say oh yes I visited the site in Hillsboro um that it's modeled after because when you look at the size and dynamic and the uniqueness of of this um U we had to be able to go into our Ur board and show them vision of what is possible and so so um uh and and we used that as the start model and that was a great partnership there as a public private partnership and from there um uh we then worked with the state and then um three developers one actually in read sport to say okay this is the footprint this is the base model that we're working at um we have a unique situation that we have a huge great issue here and so uh they came up with the estimate of how many units

034could be in there uh and so we know from what we call and that's why we say a conceptual because once an architect sits down and they start doing things and they applying things that we all don't do in day-to- day which is all the code stuff like you know for instance if you you know you learn so much as you go through this you put daycare in there well then you have to have so much per child of of green space and so we worked with OHS um on uh the actual numbers and that's why we know that it's going to have a minimum of 67 units um we actually know that Workforce housing is about 30% it's a sliding scale but 30% of uh your um uh actual uh salary medium household income

035uh wait what is 30% of the of the seller uh the rent the rent the rent yeah um and uh and so but we can't tell you exactly what the current rent is um for each unit because we create and and Jeff can give you some numbers everything's been modeled at this point that in this area for this position like teachers uh logistic workers police workers the salaries are in this range so potentially the rents could be from here to here once you fill it we don't beyond that so it's it's modeled on that purpose and then we know that if we uh are able to incorporate uh the city hall offices we actually gain a larger footprint and then can actually put additional units and that's why we know we can get about a

03640 additional units in the development because our physical footprint in there is some of the most um well it's not the best laid out you all have been in you know um that it's kind of a colossal mess um and so those are everything and then we worked with our federal legislative team where we actually had to give them all that data and they worked through their team to actually fine-tune it and that's where tud got involved and actually got it certified and put in and that's where Senator Merkley and Senator ween with um uh B hoy's office represent Hoy um went and got the 4 million um we're at the point of is it going to be the existing footprint now or is going to be the larger and so we knew that it

037didn't make any sense of beans in our world to go out and engage architector Architects surveyors or anything to then go ahead and do all the cad models because we had worked with the housing authority on their project and kept very very close on them and we know exactly what that project is costing them at every level the reason is because we're gauging those on our prices and our models for the project um and so uh Matt vross and I um communicate on a weekly basis um and uh it was very very exciting to see them start demolition yesterday so that's why you get the answer because um I could give you a number but it may change um right now you know code AS Now versus code when they actually start building may recall

038may call for larger elevators it may call for larger hallways it may call for lots of things that only at that point are they going to design it based on whatever the current code is so we just haven't engaged that far to do all of that yeah well I think it's a good point though Vince because when I just sat down to look and like un I had the same thought like okay two two bedroom three bedroom that's what's going to bring in families with students it's not going to be your Studios and so like it was valid and so when I was like just kind of doing different mixes to see that was one of the con like one of the points I had because I was thinking about you guys like okay how

039many students could we realistically you know look at is it 20 students is it 40 students and it does depend on the overall like footprint of it but like I mean we know kind of like how much you get per student per year and so you could kind of I wanted to do the math say how many students would we need to bring in realistically that would help match that amount that's being forone and so I don't know when I looked at it it seemed like around 25 you know new students would kind of get up to that level and anything above that se when the house presented we asked him the same BR asked him the same question and they essentially came back with BR help me I think for three bedro units that

040there were probably two children for twoed poor [Music] kids I was going one and two one two that that's yeah I was just just think yeah I just wanted to get a gauge on like potentially what what the impact would look like I feel like that was that's a very bid question and the nice thing is is the reason you got that answer is because they're working obviously with a outfit out of Portland um and so I got here in 2020 uh when Mark Turner was the executive director of the Housing Authority uh and then she left and Matt came in uh and we have been uh hand inand with the Housing Authority three times uh with the state um on refining changing and everything and so um by the time you got here uh

041on the thing um the plans you know were done uh we had already made large presentations at the Mill and everything um why do I use the the word we we're the city that activated the Housing Authority uh we appoint the board members to the Housing Authority I sit on their board for um their remote voucher program and review the data and so U yes it's it's very much um um and and then I sign um their certification letters um for the State uh in the uh feds and so that's why um we know and have been in step with our project as to what um uh sort of allar numbers that that we have versus um what they have um you know and I want to Circle back on the comment about you know

042you know when you look at you know 50 or 60,000 to the county that money actually would be would be eaten up um with one CBA no question about it um whereas um the airor renewal agency actually creates jobs flip side is the numbers for the school District uh when you look at what the transfer is back and forth of the state and the FPS thing um we actually have data that shows that it's two or three times what we actually get back to the school district that you don't actually see in a direct pass through um for instance like you have contracts with the school resource officers um um you know as you know there's grants in place um but what the district doesn't pay for is you don't pay for the cars you

043don't pay for the Academy um and you don't pay for the training you are actually only paying for the actual officer themselves okay and so we actually um uh the same thing the bridge uh grant program that we're working on with the district in tum so the city is actually financially much greater partner to the school district than you probably realized we just recently uh in in the last few months uh donated about $20,000 to your Culinary Institute of brand new equipment um uh and so we actually have trkking data that we can share with Ford if you so choose that actually shows you all of the services since 2020 um that we actually provide to the school district that far seeds um this amount annual amount in uh in uh the urban Reno Agency

044and um and exactly because it's a partnership why we're serving some of the same people you know and and that's the reality of of the partnership there's a lot that that that's occurred you know um uh under the current Administration and and and we'll continue and and that's that partnership can I ask but you touched upon it earlier um and you know I'm living I'm not leaving I don't I plan to grow old here Lord willing and um I don't want to see someone in Safeway and say and they say you did that over there so I guess I have a little a little concern on who gets to rent these these homes because housing why is there a housing crisis we could spend days on that and I have some very strong opinions because

045I'm I'm in that space but um one thing you mentioned like who gets so when these are completed is it people just new people coming to the area or is it anybody can the currently lives here so um we actually can't discriminate against where you're coming from and so we actually know that potentially some existing would actually you know make application um if they did their current residents would be available absolutely and exactly it's no different than you know one one of one of the things that is our um housing needs analysis um that we are trying to figure out how to do um and we have two projects that we believe are going to address this issue which is senior housing uh uh seniors are aging in their house can't maintain the property and

046they have no real option of anywhere to go and so we're hopeful ultimately to have a condo project uh we have been talking about a um small home project and then we actually for the first time through our um planning and zoning and then on to the council have approved a small home project um and if I recollect the smallest is five or 600 square feet and then they go up to 2,000 in this development um uh that is on the books now where um for some reason my head um I say E Street um and it's by the church over there um and so yes and and all this is transparent you can see it on the plan Z and so those are opportunities to move because at the end of the day um

047there's a whole lot of land that folks are holding up and they're not letting it go and then we have um as a governing body we say we it's always the Royal we because I don't B anything um but um uh we the city uh have uh implemented the um the uh uh limits on short-term rentals uh and then we actually have now audited um short-term rentals um trying to identify folks that have been operating under the radar and so those are housing issues are you talking about like airbnbs like short yeah and those so those are limited in our area absolutely there is actually they have to be registered licensed very much like in K Bay um kbay is actually more aggressive um on on new stuff they actually require um uh fire suppression

048um and so um uh and then uh they actually have to collect uh uh Transit lodging taxes and then report that um so yes I just want to make sure that I address your concern CH you know is is your concern just trying to clarify that someone might identify you as like hey like you're the one making decisions on who lives or decision and look what happened that's more you approved it what districts in like Portland I mean you were talking about you guys working with one there um I've seen multiple ones up there where they're talking about pulling back everything because every time they've done something they fail like I I've seen Urban renewals fail well way more often than they succeed like the the ideas are all wonderful and they all sound great

049um but uh every time you go and look there's there's failure and you see it in larger cities U people fight back again against it they I they used to call it what gentrification or whatever in those kind of areas where you price the people that were living there out of their homes because that you essentially raised the value by putting in all this new development and the people who are there can't afford the taxes on the home so you chase out the elderly which you're talking about building another facility for them to go into um so for me to see that fail like that my questions here would be if this is such a good idea for our community and and I think it would be great to be able to offer housing and

050have all that bring in more students all that's wonderful if this is such a great idea for our community why wouldn't we want to go out and bring in an investor who would do this instead of having the city go into business because government's not supposed to make money government's supposed to get out of the way so people can't so why can't we um just go out and bring in investors if it's a good idea and if it's a money maker like you guys are saying then it shouldn't be hard to find somebody who wants to throw a whole bunch of money into a project that the city can give them tax incentives to do because that's one thing you guys can do right is incentivize the building there um but I don't I haven't

051heard any talk about that it's um that's seems like where I would start I don't know um why we would go directly to going there because my fear on that is is that we're going to freeze the tax base for all city services so everybody has to operate within that for the next 30 Years so what happens when you got cvas you got to have officers getting paid more city workers getting paid more they get to stay on that same tax base does that mean we lose services does that mean that water board fees go up U where is that extra money going to come from this property has to be managed who's managing it who's who's paying for the management of it is that in your urban renewal um it's going to have to

052have maintenance where's all that come from where's that money come from that tax base of services is Frozen that's still going to have costs where does it come from there's a lot of money that needs to go at it and all that worries me on that side what those my thoughts there's a lot of thoughts but what's the question because I have a lot of questions for you and a lot of feedback back on what you said so what's the question my question is did we look at trying to U recruit investors yes and actually it's um partially addressed in the document in fact um it actually exactly I don't expect you to I as much as I could today yeah it's a lot Trust me and so um this was actually marketed um U

053Joe Gary um at the time was with Pacific Properties he's um a broker um he's now gone out on on his own company with others um uh he actually was contracted with the county and the county aggressively marketed this not a single bidder on the entire project uh we uh uh did through the UR um they actually had it um my collection um you know I verified everything in there but my memory says somewhere in the $850,000 range um it was going nowhere uh when we put our uh bid in for 125,000 we actually put in a letter with the vision of what we were going to do with it which was a shared Vision um and that's that's a salent point um uh I was then notified that a backup bidder had come and

054I'm like okay all right good some independent person is going to come in and and they're going to do exactly what you said well the county actually then called and accepted our bid because the only backup bidder was the spouse of a cting city uh a county commissioner who knew exactly what our bid was and increased it just a slightly amount so that they could actually outbid us actual through record through factual statement um that's the reality all right and so um we then once we had it we actually engaged um a outside professional to actually come in and work with us to actually go out and shop as many investors could be nobody went to come to North B why because government can only do certain things you have to Abate all of the

055asbest and all the environmental there you have to Abate the underground storage tanks you then actually have to demolish it get every all the utilities everything up to code and then and then only then can you start to build it once we put in so the tax credit project here um when you talk about tax credits most folks don't understand how tax credits work um some do I'm not assuming that you do or don't but I will tell you for the benefit others is that if you want to entertain in here downtown somewhere in the six heed 80 to 90 uh percentile of um a batement on salary you now talking about low income you can try it usually takes about five years if it was a senior housing project but there are not tax

056credits for Workforce housing in fact we are the only project in the entire nation that got 4 million dollar for a Workforce housing it has not been done in the state of Oregon before back we don't know Nationwide where it has because we're able to do the 30% um for actual living working wage folks um versus when I say 60 70 80 those are the tax credits that means that they're only paying about 10% uh versus it flips to the other side okay that's the reality um and so without government intervention so um uh the other reason is that why is the government um in the business because that's exactly what urban renewal agencies were created in the state and at one time there's 358 and I know you say failed give me an example

057of a failed Ur um and I'm sure that there are some but I want to know if you actually are aware of one and the reason I mentioned that is because I just sat on a board with Portland and the state city of Portland by the way that city is over $100 million shy of making their budget match right now it's probably even higher than that however before they would extend their uras they actually did an entire exhaustive financial analysis it had to be third party independent did it flying colors and they were able to show all of the data that ur's actually not only brought jobs Economic Development vitality and other money and development growth and I gladly share it to anyone that wants U because I I'm a member of uh the Oregon

058OA Economic Development Association and I sit on their tax increment financing uh committee and so I'm aware of when folks move on this topic and that's exactly what they found out because Portland was in the same boat they're like do we want to be able to give up this money or not when in fact the independent study showed it actually was more beneficial to the city financially job-wise economic and because cities are the economic engines if you don't have housing we can't get Workers to come here that's just the reality um and so um as as we build um and and you have places that they can live they'll actually stay here when you have a decent mix where they can move and have starter um and move all the way up to senior um

059you then have accomplished what our housing needs analysis St says and that's again yet an independent third party um report and again on our website as is the implementation so we don't make this stuff up we're actually required by the state every city every county has to go through this process and now we're working to implement it so I think that if you take the time to understand and roll up your sleeves and and see tax increment financing and what does if it's properly managed that's the ke I'll be the first to say there are executive directors out there and boards that don't always properly do what they're supposed to do I won't go as far as saying that you know maybe North Bend for all of these years probably should have been following the

060letter of the law crossing the te and went in debt and got those projects out but if you did you'd probably have a little trolley station down here with bus service between kbay North Bend because that's what was in the the plan and is that North Ben Cruz Bay so again um we're just trying to address the needs of the community as established by the community um which is what the studies do in the interest of time we're we're at 655 and we probably probably going to save the last hour for some semester discussion but I two questions I think that others others may have had but uh the first question is will the city of B promised to not take the school district admin buildings by any means including eminent domain unless the school

061district is an agreement we as the Council on a heartbe to put that in a resolution or Proclamation or anything you want I don't know why that question keeps coming up because the the city has no interest in the building so oddly enough I'm involved in a negotiation I'm on the seller side of the piece of property the buyer has that in the contract and has what in the contract I mean they they can use the condemnation process who is AKA eminent domain and so my my comment and this is a great comment is that we responded with a counter offer you'll delete that that so I all I know is is what it says in there right this is talking about this this other agreement all I know and it's the same thing well

062doesn't involve the city I know no no no no not the city not I mean I know my Council and and that's not but anyway all we did was we said you know on the counter strike that whole paragraph It's not and if you don't want if you got to have that we're we're done here but anyway that's my answer to whoever came up with this is uh if we feel strongly about it we can have that language removed second question is the when you say removed meaning what no eminent domain language meaning the state law gives us the right in fact in in the form I was amaz actually at how much power the school board has on EMT domain and in fact it's actually far greater than our you actually can even go

063outside your your District it's like it fascinated me and I also um uh had a legal review done because I wanted to know could the school district do an eminent domain of our property the answer was yes the answer the legal answer was yes nice we might yeah and so that's why that's why you that question and answer is so detailed because I didn't just come up on that on my own um uh it was uh very detailed however there is process before you can ever do that and for instance like in the urban renewal agency law let's say that we we were not only do you actually the law says under urban renewal not only do you have to give fair market value you actually have to assist with relocation how fair market I

064I'll move on to the next question but how fair market value is determin is kind of around where some of the the conversation was because you can find an appraiser who looks it a certain way sayable and so can you yeah and so that's where that's where [Music] because they all M between they do lawyer but I will tell you um um you know um and and this is for full disclosure I mean I have no problem disclosing this um uh we have a a um a letter in principle to buy um the um the the old theater here that separates ours well I surprised to see it you know this past week go on the market for 1.2 million and I'm like well hold it I have a letter that actually shows that I

065buy it cheaper it's not going to sell for 1.2 million now I'm guessing that's because Wayne trunk owned it and we had lots of meetings over a year and a half and so the pastor actually sent paperwork because he's like I got to reserve my rights because you all might am in domain I'm like like you don't know my Council they don't meain anything let alone a church I mean you know we take off enough heat as we do but you know but I always say that's the sitting Council and so you know if you all want it and if that's going to help you to have you know a formal resolution by just ask for it and the governing body and that that that is uh standing um you know that is is being

066on the you know with a lawyer of the city I mean that's that's a legal document so okay next question but great question is the city able to guarantee that the school district will not in the next 30 Years lose their funding amounts from the state of Oregon that's our other that's our other big I don't think anybody can guarantee that we got we have two great attorneys here who's an attorney not oh okay because I'm notor I'm like I'm not going to practice lot without license so I I called the um legislative uh Council um it was a fascinating conversation to have and um uh they're like no nobody in the state can ever guarantee that um however the funding formula has been in you know in fact uh his answer was longer than

067he was alive um because he researched it um he said that um this is the way that the law would work if the funding formula changed um under organ law all just uras would have the sunset and could not extend meaning that if we went and it said for 30 years that would be the end of ours and then it would revert back and so he said that the deals that are made were um um engrossed in state law for how they are created and were authorized and so if they changed it the word property rights and a couple other things I basically grandfathered in to be basically um if the law changed and they had to figure out how to fund you differently our working relationship would be grandfathered in until that time ended

068to know so and and so that's that is my perfect understanding uh from them he's like nobody can guarantee what the legislature will do um uh but he's like it's not just uras that are are wrapped up in this uh Special Districts and he went down a list of a couple couple others that were uh in the same uh bucket and my my research and all this with the way school districts are tied into urban renewal agencies uh depends on how it was formed whether it affects you positively or negatively I think in 4J if their Ur were to go away they would lose about $4,000 a year not a lot that's eug okay okay I'm sorry sorry and Moma area would gain about $200,000 a year if the UR went away so just depending

069on your district and how it's integrated with the UR and and I guess how it was formed CH as how that would go because I was reading articles where they were talking about if the agency went away how would that affect the school district and the the two that I found one was positive one was negative and it just depended on on the the structure of the UR which I don't know because you're saying that they get backfill and that actually talked about that it's supposed to keep us whole but there are there are fluctuations in that and there are a few districts in Oregon too and these might be some of them where their property taxes are over the amount the state spends so that they they get nothing from the state they just

070get their whole revenue from yeah and I I I didn't go that deep into it I just I was uh looking for the relationship between school districts and uras um and one said positive one said negative and I mean different amounts obviously larger and smaller school just go Um I couldn't see anything that directly tied us to a negative effect or postive say yeah we're down low enough well we have so much State back it would you would have you got we got we're two or three Urban renewals away from yeah the um um you know the positive thing is is that I mean you look at what we've been you know doing with grants in the last four years we actually have generated just over 25 million with it grants um 14 million to

071the benefit direct to the city they're like well hold it where's the rest um that's because we've assisted others with grants um some reason Vince and you may know this better than I do for some reason I think this bridge Grant is like six million um does that ring a bell um over Pony that we're working on with you all on you were talking about what that Grant was going to be was that a safe safe but also had to do with the pathway more bridge I thought was only 500,000 yeah so the whole project itself because like all the Pony Village the the Pony slw all that get done all the way from all the way from up that you know the whole thing the bridge he was talking about putting that in and

072s, yeah so it's the bridge and and the whole Safe Streets and so when you when you start to you know look at those um you know those those those are the big dollars where we've used if it's in the UR District that's where we've used that's how we make up the match on the grants to be able to leverage and so that's how we've been so you know a significant amount of the grant um obviously benefit the city directly but there are others that they benefit directly inside um and then there's the Main Street program um uh that also has direct reporting and so um Kay Northend you know Bandon we all have programs and so we actually have to track everything from occupancy the jobs created and everything and so we parlay that

073data together um to um track all of the uh increments so yeah off the top of my off top of your head Jeff either one of you just I'm curious about if for every person who is new to our community what the estimate of the number of dollars they bring into our community over the course of the year so I mean if you think about you have a town that has a thousand and all a sudden you have a town that has a th10 okay then there the economic impact with 10 more people living in the community um is is essentially a plus um presuming that they don't have to access services that put them in negative in terms of their employment and their purchasing power and all those kind of things so do you

074have is there some sort of a formula that you just kind of happen to know that for every hundred people that come into our community that it has a NE a positive economic impact on average of X point something million dollars or something a few hundred thousand doll per per person per group do you have anything like that we don't have it is it available yet um because South Coast Development Council is our Edo um and so they they can access databases we have data uh for instance uh Jeff Scott uh I think you've got the data there um we can tell you for instance every single thing that happened in the county in the housing market all of last year compared to you know the previous year um public record thank you you made

075a quite of investment uh in our community um yes uh and um and uh and and if everyone if if if home prices no if the um tax rates were established on sale prices um we all probably wouldn't be here talking about this right now um the reality is is that be a um well we have a really nice police force and new fire yeah we' all be a lot work but but the reality is is that there are actually some streets that do not generate enough tax revenue on their street for the services provided um and you ask well how the heck do you know that well because I have data on every single uh parcel in the the city um uh what what they pay in taxes um and we map it out

076and then we can actually see um in the entire Community you know where our Sor data yes please to follow them obviously we're headed with this you're talking about the number of people that we estimate might live over here um would they you know what's the estimation as to what kind of a positive or negative impact they're going to have financially on city of because you know we can talk specifically about you know $10,600 for kid coming through the door but part of the answer is that um that 50 50 people 50 units over here I'm just going to round off to 50 50 units over here they have 50 families in them um that it's Workforce housing and so they're um so they have a job and they live in our community and they're

077spending in our community um if 50 families over here here would have an impact of two or three or four 10 or 2020 million in our community ripple effect of that kind of could go beyond some of the costs that even the county pass absolutely you know does so and I'm not saying that's why I asked the question because I have no idea what those numbers were those numbers could break even and it could so the reason I know it's it's available so again another disclosure you guys are learning a whole lot more than but it's because you ask question um so we just went through a whole process with windco that uh for the last four months has given our community a hard look and had considered locating to North B um uh they

078this week announc that due diligence is done and they're not coming here why do you think they're not coming here Place St people so they it's because they cannot generate one million per day is about Walmart makes that so they did their data analysis they did their data analysis well um you know I happen to know you know I I have the data un like what Ross does I I um but it's because um I'm I'm on the board of um the economic development um corporation that that does everything from from the California line to to Florence and so um I happen to know that TJ Max um uh stalled on committing to the 101 location because it was looking at another location in K Bay and two different Developers were playing pingpong with one

079another and it took Greg drebot the developer to uh do a sweetheart deal the land it which is very important for us because we have the Broadway uh Virginia quarter and he's also looking to do the 250 house development in K Bay so this you know for us 400 400 so it's very very important and and so we watch that but yeah they couldn't generate and so that data that you ask is actually available and then um we have a report um we know how many houses sell what they sell for um you know what the trends are um and that tells us who's coming in buying um I wish at the water board when they um signed up that they' just fill out some survey data you know but they don't um and so

080we have to rely on and then we uh follow aggressively the state's economic reports that they put out for our community for uh K and Curry and that also then helps us follow you know what jobs are being created um and what industries are they in and then Jeff also got sort of the range of the four categories of Housing and those are the primary housing so that's they they they get you know first priority um and then it it can open um so if you have different fixes of of houses um uh then folks move the interesting thing is is that the realtor data shows that when you come here um after two years if you're not happy you leave you you either love it or you don't and you're out in two years

081um they'll also tell you that within five years um folks that are new to the area um sell their home and buy another one or they keep the one they have for rental and they move to do one where are these people go to work um there's actually um existing jobs we uh just met with a cardinal um which is uh you know one of the uh two big staffing agencies um and so we actually know how many available jobs are in the community which is um I can get you the report we'll follow up with you there's lots of people I see on Facebook all the time who's hiring where where why can't the jobs are there everyone that's the answer you should respond to them and say everywhere go to atlas go to

082Cardinal the jobs are there they don't hire the people that are looking why is that just because they're on Facebook and could say hey who's hiring you know I mean there's you know would you hire anyone that comes in the door no I don't think so you have qualifications and so is that necessarily the folks you want um uh we're we're pretty um excited um you know some of the jobs we've been posting lately we've been blown out um one in particular we're like we cannot believe how many applications we got um we had 108 applications um for a position our Parks par Parks we're like blown away well how much does that job pay so that the people can afford to live in these houses um our salaries are actually Well published um they're

083right in the back of our budget book and so if you want that I'll gladly get that page it's on our website we actually show um and so yeah um but that's the cool thing this is Workforce housing at 30% and so Jeff give me a range for the Educators if you will of of what the data showed for salaries of uh Educators we Educators if we don't have students but again if you don't have housing how you going to grow how else are you going to grow you have to have jobs that come to to grow yes and the jobs are here and and and if the port project goes that'll even be more projects har I've been trying to promise that for years well I mean you can be negative but um they

084just got over hundred million doll just to permit that to go and they have already secured over 50% of independent investment in into that project independent actual contracts for a $2.3 billion project so you know I much rather um be optimistic and work with them to land industry here as opposed to say we're not going to have industry so hey uh Vince I'm going to save the remaining time for your semester and board comments any last question that's on your heart I just wanted to thank David and his team because as I was sending these to the board members as you were putting them together and there's a ton of information in time that went into these answers so I I do appreciate that on behalf of absolutely yes well thank you I know this

085isn't always an easy decision but I would say it's outside our if you were to say the board had a core competency I would say this is outside so hence the question trust me I learned a lot from this myself because like I said I didn't know wow I I go Jeff like wow did you know they had this Authority and I learned a lot about the funing you know I I had to do a lot of research I didn't just you can see that in the document yeah I learned a lot as well so it was a um you know I always tell folks you don't know what you don't know um if your mom says she loves you check it out get it in writing verify verify verify and um you know don't

086allow the facts to get in the way of a good story so thank you appreciate it all right thank you guys you do look good in Stripes but not in the context that I want to see them I'll take it and thanks for the sandwich I absolutely food enables a lot of things here it gets participation it does everybody shows up all right thank all right take care bye bye Jim not gonna have opportunity for discussion oh well we can well we saying we need to go on for something for we're like here our piece can probably be done in minutes okay put them on the clock no go ahead I mean yes yeah let's have a break and then let's let's come back and think it's important I think it would be good that

087we do kind of open it up to what sounds can we use so are we coming back to discuss this semester we're going to we're going for a seven minute break and then we're going to discuss urban renewal about that uh I'm interested in I'm I'm very uncomfortable with certain words that have been used like if anticipated not dedicated unintended you know anybody who's ever anything of a project the unforeseen is the killer in anything like that I don't think government should be a landlord amen amen and about these bills and situations with the state not changing as of December 23rd a 24 year old Bill the SRS funding for Rural counties they failed to uh reauthorize the House of Representatives well it's 24 years you know they'll always no they won't always um I

088I I don't know I I think because of the improvements this school is actively doing we're going to draw students here we're still getting a fairly good amount from where the um is it banger school is coming in of students and I can remember when I came to the area man North B's the place to go for your kids to go to school to go to school and I think that's going to even grow more and more um I I don't like unforeseen issues 30 years is a long time it's a long long time um and I just don't honestly don't Mindy it I just don't bu it so oh Dallas save me save you so Carol I guess what your what you're add one of the questions uh that was was essentially uh is

089the CD able to guarantee the school district will not in the next 30 Years lose their money so should uh there be a positive vote we could say have prepared a document say hey um there's there's two risks we don't want to take we want uh we could say look you will the city will guarantee uh continue School fund sure for 30 years can change that's a long time now they may object to that Jeff you're I see you're sitting there you can eagerly writing the notes buten I have a question you mortgage yes three years yes okay well when you wonder that mortgage you had the same kind of concerns you'd have now I mean that's the same kind of situation I mean you don't know what's yeah but people get get out of

090mortgages all the time I guess part of my thing is we can look at all the what if and things that could happen or we can look at the good things that could happen as well so there there's two sides to look at a coin we have to look at the positives and the negatives and what outweighs the other and we could all find in every decision we make in life bad things that could happen Y and so just to always just ch just to look at what could happen potentially happen that probably won't happen I don't think is a good way to make a decision not to say that you can not do whatever you want I'm just saying it's really important to like look at both sides of the coins equally there's just

091a lot here that seems to be a lot of words and I 100% agree with a lot of words and that is troublesome to me can I data that has that's not a lot of words not a lot of words um and also hope to bring Clarity not try to sway okay I'm not trying to sway just ask the current distribution system for schools is really what we're talking about whether or not that much um because the backfilling of the urban renewal dollars that get siphoned out is not about urban renewal it's about the state school system yes so it doesn't have um kind of doesn't have anything to do with Urban it has just how you how they P fund scores so that began early in my teaching per and it was after measure

092five is best because before measure five the money that we got was the money that our people voted on our so when it became a state distribution model they created this f um and in and around the time that I taught in Glendale School District in the 90s the amount per student that you were getting was about 5 to 6,000 more so in in the 30 years let's say 95 to 2025 we talk about 30-year periods in a 30-year period we've gone from getting about $5,000 for kid to $10,000 kid okay so if we assume that continues over the next 30 Years okay um the state has talked about a different model for funding students and after the Portland strike we heard the most conversation about that that I I have really heard at the

093most leverage over the course my entire career and in the 12 months since strike happened Cricket right nobody's going into the legisl not a single bill right now educational Bill legisl and just got updated uh yesterday with what call off the Record being and so legislative update not a single bill in the legislature that Morgan Allen was talked about changing the funding system for um for schools in or because they can't find something that they feel like is like better right so it's not just that it's been around for 30 years or more it's that even when they really really died in to talk about it they're not coming out any good answers right so we could also maybe then presume that over the next 30 Years what we're now getting a $10,000 for kid

094and and and I'm not I'm making this is not a politicized statement but if that doubles in the next 30 Years then um then for every every home that could potentially have students in it if if a segment if there's a housing and there's going to be or not using say the Bel like down by where I live right 20 more houses come in and over the course of the next 30 Years 40 Kids come out of those 20 houses on average per year right now that's $400,000 per year and and by the time we get to 55 okay 30 years from now if that's double that's you know $800,000 $2 million a so if what we have to think about as we're thinking about the potential positive that comes from it if we put

095on average 50 kids in the seats or if you get 40 kids whatever it is over the next 30 Years the amount School District gets on a per kid basis if the pattern is the same that's going to be double what we're getting right now so um and and what way does does that offset what we perceive to be potential risk risks or costs um that might happen in the next Years I I having spent a career and I will be dead by the time this thing's over no Dana you won't be dead but maybe the rest of us'll she 30 years ago when we had an urban renal but but I would say you know there's no certainty but if we think about what are the odds what is the risk that state of

096Oregon is going to put in a system that would end up costing us money because it wouldn't backfill what gets siphoned out of the bottom of an renewal thing and I would say the risk of that happening is probably less than a percent and that's what I wanted to come tonight to ask both Tim and you where your comfort level was with that being finance and so forth that makes a big decision that helps me make a decision better if you guys not saying that you know what just your comfort level of the risk well and I think I mean I think even if the state school fund goes up it'll be offset by payroll costs and everything else you know like that really isn't the issue but when you talk about Jeff how much

097was it the school district would lose if it wasn't offset it it wasn't it wasn't a number okay that was so worrisome that we couldn't find a way to overcome it without I mean as long as you're I think exactly how old and not as young as to be fair our area because we discussed this a lot of times with the college um our area actually funds schools and the college um a lot better than other communities right so we would Fair pretty well if we only got to keep the stuff that we made here in our County oh versus some of the other counties they're really small like Oregon Coast Community College if they had to be funded based on their local community wouldn't exist the only reason Oregon Coast Community College exist is

098because of this of the funding formula for tunity colleges right so all of the funding goes into a pool and it gets distributed so that all those schools can run so other schools are funding uh organ Co Community College um similar here we don't really get like you were saying a whole bunch of back bill for our our schools here because we're funded so well in our in our area but not all areas are the same so that would be a big thing but I'm not worried about that what you were thinking about which is funding and I'm not worried about that at all My worry is exactly the question that did not get answered when when Dave was talking which was um we're GNA have to have somebody manage this we're gonna have somebody

099run maintenance on this and our tax base is frozen so that that tax base for all services is frozen so where do you create the position how do you fund them that's well I think he answered that question a little bit last time and that was generated from the income of the units to help offset some of that so I don't know thought I thought I thought the well yeah say I thought for maintenance but uh and then the other thing is is uh how are we going to fund everything for 30 years because in 30 years you know 30 years of raises for employees we'll get we'll get that from the state we will know how I'm not talking I'm talking about city services right so I'm talking about stuff outside of our control

100I understand that it's not really it's a negative or nil impact on on the school district that that's not my concern my concern is as a citizen we're talking 30 years of freezing a tax base right and then all of those increases which is if you do the math on it's probably like 127% increase over what we get right now in taxes over the next 30 Years um if you take the 3% as you keep going 12 123 something like that um over the 30 years all that will be in the urban renewal District it does not come to the basic Services I mean they don't get they don't get a % on top of no the 3% goes to the urban renewal yeah that's what happens is when you put in an urban renewal

101and you start it it freezes your tax base and what you get now is what you will get for the next 30 Years all the 3% increases go each year no more money no more money period yeah no so each year that 3% goes to fund your urban renewal to pay it back to pay that loan out that you took out to do the things that you wanted to do which is why what I was saying earlier which was they fail more often than they don't because they take out all this money and then uh the idea for what they were going to do sort of gets diminished and so they they get started on a project and there are a lot of places you can go look at Cincinnati and all these other places

102around the country where they've gone in and they've leveled city blocks and now they ended up becoming parking lots parking lots or empty lots because the city the the need for it diminished in the years that it took to get to the part there where they're talking about getting rid of a batement because a lot of the buildings that they're getting rid of have asbestos in it and that's expensive uh time consuming and by the time you get to the end of it sometimes the need for the project is gone like we might might not have a hospital in 10 years if you read some of the literature that I've been seeing um because they're they're giving it to a a company that basically what they do is they shut them down in small in

103small communities right and they might commit for 10 years but we might not even have it the hospital is going to get rid of transitory workers so the people who are here are either going to live here or they're not they that's an expensive cost to them so the number of workers that are coming into the community may be going down right so we might have vacancies opening up that we wouldn't have had in in smaller units um and uh and and vrbos but uh um but that's my concern is that all of our costs are going to go up over the next 30 Years nobody can tell me that it's not right um your needs are going to go up if the city expands because they they should right you're going to have growth

104um how do we how do we fund that how do we fund that growth through positions and police and fire and everything else I know the is going to grow a little bit exactly that's how you do it the growth incre but North B is sort of landlocked and on the other hand right so we can only grow so much right unless we can grow up and they're trying and we've been trying for years I've been here for 30 years and there's this much growth I've seen in North B the growth that I've seen in C Bay in the past three years is the most growth I've seen in this community in over 30 years so unless we see something like that in North B the next 30 Years yeah but no wants to come

105here wico says can't make a million dollars a day so and that's part of the problem yeah it really does because they can't compete yeah with the food site but um but there's a lot of things to to see that growth and so the the potential may be there but I don't see how it gets funded for the 30 years from my part um and Dave had an opportunity to answer that question and he didn't yeah um and the financial part of it is a huge piece for me because the thing that I see is they use the water board at the piggy bank and so then they'll just increase the fee at your water board so they can get more money to backfill the things that they're losing with 3% that they're giving to

106the urban renewal and it's just a sneaky way of getting that fee in plus the people who do the urban renewal they're not they don't answer to to the voting public because they're an appointed body it doesn't really matter they're what they do has no ramifications on them personally it has ramifications on us that's not true I mean who who's on who's on the urban board isn't the city council a lot of the city council and who do the city council answer to well you hope that's right uu hope so to get voted out that's what happens on the other hand I mean take a look at that building that that that is it's a BL it's a BL there's no doubt what's Urban and cour to avoid to to to address blight if the

107city I mean and this is this is what I've learned through really years me and the City attorney is that you know there are occasions when um uh private development is just not going to happen and based what I'm hearing Bas what I'm seeing there it's not going to happen that's just going to stay there the only way it's going to be addressed is through government action and I know a lot of you here don't like government action but in this particular case in my opinion anyway it it's it's a way of addressing this blight and it's a way of moving forward and if you don't move forward there's no ST staying status quo either you move forward or you're falling back and I think in this particular case adding adding um um um livable

108work workplace housing along with an improved uh building and when you see an improved building like that getting rid of that blight a nice new building that does have an positive effect in the community and and I think I think in the long run it's going to be helping uh just like I mean I don't agree with everything he says the way he puts it but I think it's a positive for our community as the whole and um you know that's that's my thinking on it yeah I I don't think replacing the building is isn't a good idea but again if we can't if you can't attract a business to come here and want to do it if there's no money in it for them that's when the government steps in and does it I

109get very famous politician once said yes whatever the question is government is not the answer yes so I'm just gonna say that I'm from the government and I'm here to help that's and so so for me if we can't fix it through private means it they're telling us something yeah and what I asked him was tax right but I was I was talking to him about tax incentives and he talked about a different way to do taxes how they could qualify for for rebates I'm not talking about qualifying for rebates this is something the city can offer specifically you know like the city of Portland went to you know Nike and Columbia originally and said you don't have to pay taxes forever as long as you'll bring your home office here and then at some

110point they said well we lied we won you to pay a bunch of taxes in Columbia said see you later by right so um it's about giving them the right incentives and the city council has the ability to do that and that wasn't addressed either um but it was talking about rebates tax rebates and do they qualify for rebates if they do low-income housing and all right I'm not asking them to do low housing I'm I'm asking them the city council would they be willing to offer somebody rebates to draw in an investor if we can't get investors here if it's not a worthwhile investment we aren't a worthwhile investment to an outsider then uh we need to find a way to make it more attractive as far as I'm concerned because again for me

111government is never the answer why is it 30 years because how much cost yeah bu any money got to stretch it off yeah right got to pay it off yeah it's they only get 3% a year of what your starting budget is and that grows I mean obviously that grows every year so it's not 3% later on that 3% grows as you keep going but it's the incremental pay to get it well it's not just the 3% if if you if you have U Urban Development which increases the the the fundamental value of the area forget about the 3% right then that increases the the value and increases the amount ofs well so that's kind of how they fund it as as as the values go up there's more money for the urban andal to

112spend to in turn hopefully improve it even more and that can have positive and negative effects in our downtown area where you put in this brand new building and it raises the the value of all the buildings around it which means that the people who own the buildings will charge more for the tenants them which can make them more or less attractive to people wanting to come in with businesses so you can chase off small businesses because it becomes too expensive to rent space to have a small business in a community that's small because of the raise in in property taxes and values in the area and sometimes you get the opposite sometimes you bring in enough people that there's enough income here that will be able to afford the raise to well I don't

113see how it's not going to increase taxes property taxes well I I assume it would I mean I would hope that it would actually he want go up property values property which which just increases tax you know if anybody's add do an addition or remodeled very much on their home you know property taxes went up you know yeah tax rates locked in it's the value that would go up okay yeah yeah yeah until they reassess and then they slap you with it well then that's when they go up yeah that's what you because that gives more if you're a city you want the property values to go up and your ass when you're paying the mortgage then no you don't that's exactly what I was saying when when the values around here go up because

114of the the development and the and the people around here want to uh cash in on that because you own the building and now you can charge more for your tenants because you have to pay more taxes right um then does is that does that help harm yes you know the people and I know I can't I can't answer that because I don't know what how the rest of the businesses and wages and how everybody else does but but there are positive and negative effects of all that but that's all that has to be considered when we're talking about 30 years it's different when we're talking about seven years like which is what they previously had right so when you're asking four times what you were had before um you're asking me to to answer

115and say okay for an entire Generation generation and a half that's that's a big ask that's that's looking really far out in the future and it's not something that I feel super comfortable going sure we declare without asking a whole bunch of questions previous one also 30 years yeah it was why do you keep saying seven I thought somebody said the previous one was seven years I think that was from the last Amendment maybe was it okay it was years it's been 30 years since the last Amendment okay it was like seven years before they it was like seven years until they amended it for that but but that was measure five that triggered the the last Amendment what happens to the $4 million loan if it doesn't go through not loan grant grant they

116have to pay it back is it just would be nice they just go ahead and clear the place yeah it's it's not spent it's it's approved and just it hasn't been drawn on at all it just wouldn't be used it just would yeah go away reassigned or something but yeah right now this been Town yeah me too just I just one of my questions was the existing infrastructure that I read that they can handle all of this new building so we're talking about all the old water systems and they're they're all great and in place and none anticipated basically what they said in the in the document here was that I'm just telling you what here they answer that they answered that in here yeah he actually said that this commercial commercial grade water and

117utilities already and they' just be able to tie into that without having to do any major upgrades so a a highrise apartment complex is gonna fall into that category then based on what David wrote in there yeah I'm sure's done his research for that that probably consulted with the works director and that may change because I would do building projects when you open everything up everything looks different than what would what you right we're told was supposed to be there always at 30% the unforeseen there wasn't a contract we did with Elmer in construction for years and I had to write them out that we did not have that Clause involving the unforeseen would make a difference in the bid in what we're doing everybody everybody always says what's there but it doesn't always mean

118it's exact in the condition that you would hope it would be to get down there so right it has been there for what 70 years I 60 years with the build yeah long assum most of that's C which is you know pretty tough semester yeah we done okay think so we will close that discussion and on to Vince on discussion um excuse me when I came to the door year and a half ago uh one of the early conversations we had revolved around whether or not it was um good for us to continue to be on a trimester calendar system uh with the school and so um we had the conversation in erest about a year ago because we were getting ready to have our calendar meetings and and we were going to try to

119bring two two years worth of calendars to you to adopt and so there was this well there's conversation about we should that we go on a semester trimester we were also kind of processing how we were going to handle the new state requirements uh with um center for the College and Career Readiness and personal finance that kind of thing because they listed those as half credit requirements so one semester well we do trimester so so how are we going to have kids meet that those requirements and so it became kind of a trick for us to do that um so what we did was um we met with uh people from the schools and at the end of the conversation there was this kind of sense that no let's go ahead and stay with the

120trimester so you know so we still okay because we had to build a c so we couldn't just talk about it for so we decided to go with the trimester come back to the T year and we start we start again entering in the conversation but not with some sort of sense of super fast urgency to it we're just kind of kind of talking about it getting it some input from the staff putting it out at DT and and so um it has the greatest impact on the high school a little bit less of an impact on the Middle School um John says no big deal if we switch you know no problem I mean it's pretty easy to do at the middle school level partly because even in their even in their electives the

121middle school kids uh typically are do in groups age groups and things like that and so the it's it's it's not really the same so um so our DT got together and we have kind of rehashed the conversation now for over a year and got to a point where we said where I asked them and what's your Rec what do you what do you think we ought to do and uh we had consensus at the DT level that we should switch to semesters uh that for a lot of reasons that we cut out um I had an opportunity Chris asked me if I would go chat with the High School staff and so I went for the high school staff who would be the most affected um back on the Friday right after tunami tsunami

122Friday yes um so a week later I'm in front of the staff um and uh kind of talking about some of the pros and cons and that kind of thing and taking questions and then at the end of the staff meeting um we had asked that they would submit some uh some data and do a survey we got the survey back and uh when we analyzed Sur it was like almost across the board it was vast majority said yeah whatever like neutral totally neutral whatever we could we can make it work okay and and that's and that's that's what I got from them whenever I was having the conversation you know what we get was going to be some kind of and it was like yeah we can make it work U worried a little

123bit about the respons the CTE teachers Mitch came up me Welly teacher came up to me afterward said this I would love it I have to teach safety at the beginning of every trimester I'd only have to do that twice a year and right now I have to have 10 differents to meet what I need to meet I could reduce it to seven um so um so we sat down and we kind of we then recently put together uh a sample calber um and and so as you can see up on the board could you uh you make that a little larger those of us who are not live for years there uh alignment between the grading days obviously if you have two different systems because the elementary schools have been operating under a semester

124system for a whole bunch of years why have they been different yes good question which is one of the reasons why we're talking about this okay um that's one we had more time I had explain it to you it's it's complicated it is yeah that's so interesting okay you don't have to do it copy of that but part of it is um yeah we can part of it is um that we um the fact that we're working on two different systems mean we have a lot of auditing in our in our calar like times when this group has a day off and that group doesn't and and so um so we're trying to definitely like that so does it just boo on who's currently on the semester is it the elementary school elementary school okay

125I guess just my high Lev thought thoughts is I'm for more instructional time and and if there's also some efficiencies that you know there's the instructional time and and if you don't have to teach safety and some things you're doing it twice instead of three times and is there what's the rest of the state and what does the US do almost all of the state is on a semester TR okay everything from the state of Oregon if fact what we have to do is we have to take policy our our policy ikf which we talked about quite a few times in the last six months here uh with this group um all of the numbers that we have to say 72 credits and you have to have this that kind of thing the real policy

126is all based on 24 credits okay so we have to we have to do the migration whenever we get a we have to plug in our numbers because the states oh everybody does there's probably we kind of asked around a little bit looked around I think there's I'm going to guess there's probably less than 5% of the high schools in the state um the only one that I've ever encountered in my entire career is this school district I have never been in the district use triesters um what about this the state school system uh like colleges aren't they on trimesters they are on a term system that is three terms during the school year that's what I thought um so how did the transfer except except swap has some classes that go over a term

127traditional term length so they're more like a semester with a lot of their classes but it's weird but but ironically they start a month later so they start late September finish and like you went to Fox you had semester I did yeah but I graduated from a school with semester so my question is transferring credits from a semester to trimesters that might make it trickier but I guess if the whole state of Oregon's doing it which is one of the reasons why we talk about it so for example when we've got a kid that comes from Marshfield over here process of trying to figure out their credits yeah switching from the 24 credit system to our system is a trick and then say vice versa whenever we're sending kids over there so what happens these

128kids that are here one of the things that you end up with two-thirds of it end up with what you be 2/3 of a Marshfield credit because a credit is a whole year of instruction so instead of having one credit for the first trimester one credit for the second trimester and one credit for the third trimester in ninth grade English so you get three credits for a whole year in this system you finish the semester you get a half credit you finish the year you get a full credit so one credit equals an entire year of instruction one carneg unit 130 hours a seat time so um so when you go from here and you've got 2third of a credit in US history when you go to mareld and they say well we can't all

129we have is half credits we'll give you a half a credit you've gone two-thirds of the school year you're only getting a half credit of Marshville or you might go to somewhere else and only get a half credit it's up to the school that you're going to because you don't because the systems aren't the same um then the other two and one half is more than well yeah they come here they so they've taken a half credit or something let's say our new requirement for personal finance so we get a kid that comes over from mareld to us we're offering two Personal Finance in two different trimesters two different years so instead of one session one half a credit we're offering a third of credit here and a third of credit here what we call

130one credit kid can come from Marshfield they'll have a half Credit in the books they've already met the requirement we're going to say they're a little bit less we requ requ more than right um and so we're over teing it because because we have a trimester Su and there's inefficiencies in that really over personal right right so we also also we also built a calendar and because of the efficiencies in the calendar um we ended up if you adopt the calendar that that we have as a draft to bring to you which hasn't G through the calendar committee yet but um if you adopt the calendar we bringing to you on here you'll notice that at the elementary level I think there's 15 additional hours of instruction 14 um at the middle school level there's

131an additional seven High School level there's an additional six and how do they how does that happen I'm just trying it happens because of grading days that we're in there okay the element how many different Fridays versus how many different other days of the week okay are in the calendar and so on and so forth so so what happens is that Melanie her job is to take the calendar and she creates the thing because we have to the state right and so she created like we took a look at what we currently have with our Tri Min and then we took the sample calendar and had her do the exactly the same thing she would do for the state came back with the numbers and we have actual instruction then you throw in that you

132talked about the concept that you know had really thought about is if you have to do safety training every time I have to do it twice instead of three times you get more real time on real machines yeah if you have if you have two two final weeks instead of three final weeks MMS then what you have is you have kids spending less time taking Finals over the course of the whole year which means you have more time getting direct instruction right so there's some efficiency there that wouldn't chill up on right um and so so if I may Vince I just I think it's important that um to just to highlight what Vince is saying about that we listed that as hours like additional hours that would be buy back because it wasn't ever

133days it wasn't like oh you know here's an 8 hour day or a six hour day there there there was just like pockets of time and we started calculating looking going 14 hours look at that and so um just just just to kind of clarify that I think my the only negative I can even see is on your cons list is just it's going to be kind of a nightmare to transfer the current kids so as we talked about that because yes absolutely yeah our seniors are not affected right our freshmen are minimally affected because you're going to have one year to migrate into the system and then obviously our sophomores will have a second year the hardest group is our current Juniors to migrate into the current into a new system um but but

134we've we talked with Chris and he's had conversations with with Rob and with Amanda the counseling department um and if you think about all of the scenarios in which a student took a full year of instruction those are the easy ones okay it's um it's the ones in which you have less than a full year of instruction so um but we have the ability in our system to go to hand enter the number of credits I mean I've done it myself like at Mitchell I can I could go into the system and go as I would bring kids kids would come in from somewhere else and I would have to say that because I I was also the counselor I would sit down with their transcript and I would say okay and then doll and

135I would be working together to to plug in numbers and you can override you can hand override so if we have a student who had who passed points six7 of his US History um and he failed you know a a term of US History we can put in to his transcript at the s67 and it'll count that it'll just add up whatever we plug in so it's very doable which is one of the reasons why we're bringing this to you in February because that's the kind of time it's going to take for a counseling group to move forward and to make that actually work and to do what we need to do and Synergy to set up the next school year as a semester system and so on and so forth so um it's it's

136just doing the nap kind of taking the time make it out the register over there Mindy was not real thrilled about it at first because she said that's a lot of work but then she said oh my gosh I only have to do it twice a year I'm just GNA say in the end it'll be less work yeah was was scheduling kids yeah so if you think about it those of you who have or had high school kids know that they got to go through this process three times right and so every time a new schedule happens they you look at their schedule and go I don't want to take that I want to take this and they got to go back and there's a time frame that they have to switch their schedule and

137they got to redo their schedules they got all that kind of stuff um you do that three times a year now you do that twice a year and if you talk with the department and talk about how much time they spend you I had 30 people in my school how much time I spend trying to swap around stuff like that um again it's one of those efficiencies or the things that are that really make a take a lot of the counseling department time and so when when Bruce says it hey wait I only have to do that twice a year instead of three times comes up one of the netive I see I mean You' have there fewer electric choices for the students you know really like that so so what we the way we

138process kind of how to think about that and and it's it's one of the things is being a high school principal myself and being in a situation where I had I was working with small schools um there where some of the efficiencies we're to come come in the notion of okay a Buy offer I don't know I'm I'm a social stud guy so let's say um I'm Destin and I don't know to schedule you know by heart but let's say I'm offering a semester of psychology a semester of sociology and a semester of uh current events right those are all typical social study electives that might only be one trimester or in the new case a semester long if I offer those every year the kids always has those options every year they can they

139can take one or all of those three things they only take two because you only have a few semesters so the way I adjusted that okay is I do what small schools do with other classes for example I've re you know ree Ford and and Mitchell we didn't offer physics every year we rotated physics and chemistry so over the course of a 4year time frame you're both you still have the opportunity so on one year I may offer s uh psychology and sociology the next year I may offer current events I may offer one of the other two like uh there's kids every year that really want psychology so I teach psychology every year I flip back and forth with sociology and go them maybe I offer a fourth option so that every other year

140so the number of times that a kid has the opportunity to take a particular elective that they might be in it's only offered for part of the Year those the number of opportunities would chose but it doesn't necessarily mean over a course of four years that they're not going to have a chance to take the thing that they're really interested in on the flip side like you think construction if they only took at one trimester versus one semester they're going to get more instruction in the in that one semester semester right they just take it once the other one is you actually have more electives in some respects because you're not taking four well two personal finance and two career related learning classes you're only taking a year of that instead of a year and

141a third so you have an extra elective built into that both both of those are coming basically the extra gets shipped out of the uh of the elective category um and so anything you're doing more than a half credit even even those even the credit because currently you're required to have six elective credits when those are implemented at a half credit each they're reducing the required number of electives from six to five if we are requiring 2third of a year then we're essentially requiring that that six which would be 18 for us instead of dropping to 15 we're saying that's really dropping down to like 14 or 13 because we have to over te the the new requirements I know some students likes us and I agree it change change is difficult oh yeah it's

142um and and honestly like my kids graduated or my daughter graduated my son was here for two years my son had to go from here and then he followed me to Culver where I was the principal so we had to figure out his creds right there on the spot I had to do this right um and uh I was fortunate that he passed everything he needed the best but but it was a trick to like um he took band so it was all year long um really the ones that it impacts are the Singleton electives that kids take that are not full year a full year yeah everything else is just pretty much status quo I mean what I taught us history you could divide it into into 10 or five or four or six

143or whatever it didn't matter because I'm I'm starting you know starting at the beginning of the book and hoping I could make it through Vietnam War okay this is um so so that doesn't really change too much there are efficiencies and conveniences that that are built in but that there are some losses and that's just a like concept of of Singleton Coles that um but again the side benefit of the Singleton elective is if I'm taking photography I get to take it for 18 weeks instead of taking it the 13 also I I just it always has bugged me that we start a new trimester like two weeks before Christmas vacation so were this probably the semester would end right at Christmas break that's actually week after oh so it's kind of the same there's

144no there's the colleges are like that kind match up that's the thing the college right at Christmas break because they started they start early the thing that as we sat down as a Cabinet team and a leadership team and talked about was what can we do with our current system to increase instructional hours we know we can't add days necessarily because that's a contractual issue but within the calendar that we have what can we do to provide more seat time and more learning time for kids and and that's what really led us to to move toward that semester system as we did that and then also the second thing we looked at is what can we do to align professional development because when you have two you have an elementary school or elementary schools on

145one schedule and a high school middle school on another schedule it's really difficult to align those professional development opportunities and one of the big things that the teachers unions have said is our PLC days are constantly interrupted with a lot of things the calendar where you a chance to look at that you're going to look at a calendar that has very few interruptions on those Fridays so we'll be able to provide time for teachers and some targeted PD in there you know much more effectively than we've been able to do in the past with the schedules that we've had instructional time is would just a hint on some other things that would be coming to you if if if what we're offering up is essentially accepted we currently don't have any any conferences that are

146high school we're building some high school conference time into this um in into this County so that um so that high school kids and families who might be struggling will have an opportunity to go in and talk to some teachers um that hasn't been in place for a long time so we're trying to bring a little bit of that back we're trying to uh we're putting in the disc calendar and align conference time so the district is aligned with that middle Middle School would be aligned with the high school on conference days and the elementary would be aligned for the most part on conference days to it takes a little longer at the elementary reducing the number of days in which we have on like like there was in and around that time there was

147the day that the conferences were happening and the high school was the only School in session right okay and everybody else was not in session because they had conferences so if the high school has conferences that day we have a day where everybody's out not um you know so it's we recommend it we recommend it because we think the number of of positives that we've really vetted we really tried paid attention and just try to like we're not throwing stuff up there um uh and hopes that we can get that I mean we're we're trying to be um we're trying to do this in really the right way including me having a chance to go stand up all by myself in front of the high school and wonder if I'm going to come out alive

148and are you actually do you know after my conversation they did survey and to have the survey data yeah there's a portion of the group to say no I don't support it but ultimately um those numbers I have to look at it again but less than 25% of the people at the high school were saying like I don't really report it um and and everybody else is basically either neutral which really most of the people were or they said yeah let's go there so um we' I mean we've been wanting to do this for years it's that the elementaries was like the start and then it just it never took traction and so now I think we can make it happen and hope we hope you support it I think anything it adds more instruction

149time consistency structional time it's a winwin there's the you spend less time administrating your class and more time actually teaching your class and that's way way more beneficial to students and less of the management in between yeah that's yeah and and I think that you know Vince you you you had just said this but to reiterate um that when we did look at the calendar that we're proposing to the calendar team and then B bring to you we did um try to look through um like the lens of a parent also because that could be very difficult if your Elementary and your middle school student is not in school but your high school are supposed to for the day so that was another lens that we looking yes right we exactly that because our current

150calendar does leave some days that may be real difficult for a family and so we tried to eliminate that as much as possible and align those things yeah just another lens to look for it well there's a there's another positive when you're negotiating your CBA hey look we were taking difficult work away from you and giving you more time for instructions you have less administrative time and less big work to do we're working for you so one L one less yeah you can frame the arum will this be on the February agenda I think the game plan is yes this is on the February agenda if if you uh approve the move then we will be telling the high school um and the Middle School to have a green light to begin building a master

151schedule for next year and high school start the process of trying to to um to migrate uh trimester to semester uh I would then expect that in the month of March we would have to do it March because um because Joe needs to have the adopted calendar in place to um to do the rollover for Synergy and that includes I mean we open up our kindergarten oh yeah registration April first so March would be a c mon so and and I asked the question by the way of Chris and high school like Chris it seems a little ambitious to do it for 25 26 are you okay with that he says yes talk to my counselors they said we have to we have to do it now but the question was asked and the answer

152was given yes we can Implement next week wow it's a lot ofont that's true whether it's this yeah it's just a matter of the time frame like if they had a whole year to do it they but they can't change they can't really change anything until true after school's out because you can't change the credits until summertime yeah we got to know how many crur to change him but then but there are but there are you know some some prep that can be done to make that happen and and really you know your your kids are not going to be in terms of migration are not going to be the issue no I understand because your your kids your kids are passing all their classes right and they're and they're taking classes that for the

153most part are year-long classes and things like that so um and um so uh so it's not it's not going to be difficult for them to have that migration Happ U the ones that are going to be more difficult really are the ones that are difficult anyway that's the ones that are not passing all three sections than that social studies well the reality the ones that will be the problem are going to be the students that have transferred in that don't have a one credit on each course they have a one five or 85 because I came in from somewhere else those are the ones that are be our students will be losing we do have means making that up right but but our students will be able actually on the back end without anybody

154touching it just automatically change our credits to what they need to do it's going be the students that don't have a one credit for their course that have to manually recalculate yeah so it'll the credit part is going to be fairly easy for 80 to 90% of our kids and if we have to go Case by case on 10% of our kids it seems daunting but at the high school we're talking about 10% of our kids you know 70 kids and you start you start sitting down with a transcript and you start saying okay this is this is how we do this we're not letting a machine necessarily do those that's where a human being is looking at and go this this is how many credits you're going to get for this this and you

155start plugging it in by hand and once it's in the system everything you add to that just adds to it just making and and the reality is the only ones that are extremely important are going to be next year seniors because they need to know where their credits are through most of the year but your Juniors next year Juniors and sophomores they already kind of know where they are and it's not like you're trying to get into college or anything so focus on the seniors and work down it but I don't I don't see it being a huge deal unanticipated um yes unanticipated things yes we don't know might be out there certainly they're you know but like he said it doesn't matter if it's this year or next have to go through those unanticipated

156we're going to try toate for those there could be could be bridges that more instruction we're gonna have to cross we don't know that we have to cross right now but um but we'll cross it I think it's good yeah I'm uh I'm really glad that most of them were on board so it's it's good to have a three quarter I yeah Buy in the last thing I wanted to do was just come in and have to be evince thing and just push it through and like I don't care we're going to make this happen the do wants it using he's got a brand new contract he's got a [Music] mandate person did you go get it no I think it's a good idea and and we buy him that that helps it a lot

157you have a lot less push back should bee because you're have to go so fast it better be easy going can I ask I need to ask has nothing to do with anything sort of except just sort maybe okay um Michelle applied for a grant that she thought was $1,500 to allow the board to go to like uh osba or Summer Conference on like a scholarship get a grant so you can go and so she got the grant approved yay then we found out the grant was actually to help pay for osba board training right so like they would come here kind of like kind of like we did at the beginning of last year whenever Rob P came okay now so way go Michelle it back wait let's find out where it's it's in

158Hawaii but the question the question is um it's it's when because when I first looked at when we both first looked at it it it wasn't like this is for this okay so we thought it was for this she says should I apply I said sure apply so we got we got money there that we could spend uh to have them come down here but um but we thought we'd bring it to you to see if you wanted us to just kind of send it back and just say no we're kind of not interested in that what kind of training they give us would we get to decide on or decides sure I think uh I you know what I'm a big fan of continuous Improvement and training falls into this if if it if

159we could decide on what we can with thep let's I'll tell you what Michelle we need to contact the person who's running the Grant and say can we pick the topics that are part of the training and I'll tell or even if they give you like a bunch of options we can choose yes if that is not the case then we'll turn it down if that is the case then then how about if we say or just come back to us and tell us what they what they are going to so we'll end it a little farther we won't just turn it down but we'll we see if we can customize yep we can get that in one of your Friday memos what they're going to offer us if we can if Michelle's off tomorrow

160so we won't know tomorrow one of your fredd tomorrow yeah well of course it's before the next osga but thank you for um crying Michelle she like I was trying to do something really cool it turned out I just doing a training generally speaking in life if you receive a check let's go ahead and R but yeah I think great ideas I appreciate that Michelle and I think the board canens Pi some training finish okay the last thing is uh agenda item five any board comments thank you guys thank the city for coming and explaining a lot it very helpful it's a lot to take in I appr app all okay with that we shall enure thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.