001a disability inclusion partner this award is to highlight the district's commitment creating workplaces that are welcoming for all employees who rely on accommodations to carry out their work successfully inclusion is of course uh a crucial aspect in retaining High quality employees and talented employees who are dedicated to serving our families and our students within our schools the district was nominated by the ambassadors at lifescape and we thank them for recognizing our commitment to uh disability inclusion as well and one of the award you can see on the graphic here off to the right hand side is a a sticker that we are able to proudly display at the entrance of our building and it is in fact displayed there already so I had to just take a a photo of that to share that with
002you um but in researching a little bit more about uh disability inclusion according to the National survey of consumer attitudes towards company that hire companies that hire people with disabilities 92% of the American public view companies that hire people with disabilities more favorably and 87% of the public also prefers to give their business to companies that hire people with disabilities and certainly we know that uh you know our students become adults and become very employable in our community and our community Embraces uh all employees and uh puts them to work in in whatever area they're um interested in so we thank Vicki and Patty for um stopping by to share that Award with us and encourage of course all other Employers in our community to embrace those uh who are are working and needing an
003accommodation of some sort and next uh Public Service as you know is uh a high level job you all are at the front of our room here and no higher level perhaps than um taking place in our nation's capital Washington DC and tonight we are joined by a young man champ B Garten who is a student at Jefferson High School he will be in Washington DC in March to witness it all happening firsthand he received an honor and award that was bestowed on him by the South Dakota Department of Education and champ has prepared a few words for you this evening and I will invite him up to share those good good evening everyone I'm excited to announce that I have recently been selected by the South Dakota Department of Education to join Senator th
004and rounds and represent our state as a delegate at the United States Senate youth program in Washington DC for a week this coming March during this week I'll have the honor of meeting the president a US Supreme Court Justice and various different cabinet leaders additionally this scholarship comes with a a $10,000 um scholarship provided by the heurst foundation with an encourage enement to continue public service and government in college I I would like to extend a big thank you to everyone in my community and particularly my school family at Jefferson High School I would also like to extend a special thank you to principal D Dan Conrad and my councelor Mr matky under principal Conrad's leadership Jefferson has truly embraced its values of inclusivity and respect for all this has inspired me to continue my
005interest in public service and to pursue opportunities such as the US Senate youth program Mr mski you have encouraged me to pursue New Opportunities and take risks shaping my high school Journey our school district's willingness to give flexibility to its students has allowed me to study abroad in Taiwan and serve as a US Senate page last semester both instrumental in my um in leading me to this moment I also wanted to mention how important the Spanish Immersion program has been to me Sonia soda mayor with Dr V and all my Spanish teachers has opened up so many opportunities I just got an early action to Yale to study economics international relations and foreign languages this is one of my top options I will weigh all my options when I get admission decisions this coming March
006but I plan on coming back to South Dakota after my education to help out my state in some way thank you everyone to the school board my teachers and fellow students for being a part in this journey I'm eager to come back and bring new knowledge and experiences to share with all of you thank you awesome C would you like to introduce your guests with you they might get a thank you too my dad Dr bomb Garten and my mom Sarah Keen have any questions for champ questions comments go ahead so wow congratulations on this and I know you will represent Jefferson and Su fall School District well thank you very much you have a bright future thank you you're gonna have some fun out in DC yeah that's a wonderful place have fun yeah
007um I was I had the opportunity to be in girl State okay when I was a junior so those opportunities truly stuck with me and got me to where I am now so it's really neat to see the long list of leadership things that you've already done congratul ulations on getting accepted into Yale that's a big one we look forward to seeing what you decide but I'm more looking forward to you coming back thank you so thank you for that dedication I appreciate it yeah congratulations that's a lot of hard work in school and out of school and I know you have worked hard on not just Spanish but other languages as well and have some have had some amazing opportunities so it's fun to see when students take all of those opportunities and really
008um take advantage of them and put them to work uh to see where their future will go so congratulations and I hope you can come back and give us an update of what you learned and what your experience was of course thank you so much thank you champ I've known you from for quite a while and Sarah and Keith and I just think sometimes there is some negativity to Youth and people your age and having you here tonight just solidifies just the goodness that is happening out in the world people your age and the opportunities that you have and you're seizing them and it also such a bright light on public education so to the extent while you're out there um you can just talk about the opportunities you have had in from South Dakota
009being a public educated uh student I think that would say a lot to our nation and to South Dakota of course I will thank you very much thank you I would also like to thank uh livescape for nominating the district for the award livescape is a place that's near and dear to my family's heart so that's awesome that for the district to be recognized by them thank you all right can I get a motion in a second for approval of the minutes from the meeting held on December 19th and December 23rd please so move second I have a motion and a second all those in favor signify by saying I I oppose same sign those minutes are approved I don't have any comments or wishing people wishing to address us can I get a motion
010in a second for approval of the agenda tonight so second I have a motion in a second all those in favor signify by saying I I I oppose same sign that is approved we don't have any conflicts tonight can I get a motion and a second for approval of the consent agenda 9 a through D so second I have a motion and a second all those in favor signify by saying I I oppose same sign the consent agenda is approved and 10A so the supplemental consent agenda can I get a motion in a second please second I have a motion and a second all those in favor signify by saying I I oppose same sign the supplemental consent agenda is approved with one absens by myself uh next we have some policies to review Brett
011will take those on behalf of the policy Review Committee um we have as a part of our review revise of our policies we have nine policies and they're accompanying regulations up for review tonight uh you'll see the majority of the policies do not have any changes um just two uh small changes one in policy be which is for um school board meetings there's just an update there for executive sessions to update a change in the law that took place in 2022 so that just recites what the change in the law was and then the other change is in policy B and that is just an update to the order of business for Schoolboard Mee meetings to reflect what our current practices um so those are the the changes just again on a review Revis they're
012up for approval tonight if you don't have any questions I'd ask for approval of the policies at this time so second okay I have a motion and a second for review revise approval of a through I on the policies uh all those in favor signify by saying I I oppose same sign those are approved thank you Brett uh next on the agenda is a resolution that um was sent to us uh from uh asbsd in response to the school proposal and so I guess maybe I'll start by reading it um and if you're not aware of uh the legislation that's uh being recommended for school vouchers please educate yourself um and we hope to do some of that with you here tonight as well so whereas South Dakota public schools are a Cornerstone of the
013state and the pride of their communities welcoming all children educating and feeding them connecting them with friends and mentors and helping shape their Futures while preparing to be the next generation of our state's Workforce whereas the proposed education savings account for the 2025 legislative session is simply a different title for a school Voucher Program whereas Research indicates School voucher programs consistently fail to improve academic outcomes whereas the proposed program would be implemented by using millions in public taxpayer dollars to fund non-public schools that may pick and choose who they admit while also charging tuition and raising millions of dollars in scholarship funds or to fund homeschool programs with no transparency or accountability measures to prove success similar to those required of public schools whereas the state budget which provides the funding increase for public education
014faces constraints due to stagnant Revenue Collections and as a result their proposed incre increase in state aid for public schools is less than the level of inflation whereas with lower than expected Revenue collections created a lean state budget the introduction of a new ongoing funding system for a school voucher program will eventually lead to an unbalanced state budget or a decrease in funding for public education whereas the school voucher program will not stop at the initial amount as the intention to grow School voucher funding has already been stated even before it has been adopted whereas the school Voucher Program planned and inevitable growth will be damaging to the future of our Public School System students and communities whereas we as school board members insist our legislators oppose the proposed School Voucher Program because of the
015foreseeable detrimental impact it will have on South Dakota's public school system at the expense of our students so tonight um I would just invite the board to have a conversation about this so we can decide um how we feel about this uh and share kind of what our experiences and knowledge has been um over the past so if anybody wants to start with any comments I'll start obviously well maybe not obviously but I am opposed um there's a couple things the biggest thing for me is accountability when I was running for office I would get questions like uh why are you against homeschooling I'm not against homeschooling I'm not against anyone attending a private school but for me it's an accountability the issue and I made mention at a public speaking engagement uh I was
016told that we won't send our kids to your schools because your test scores are so low and I said well what are your test scores and she said that's none of your business now maybe that's true but if we're going to spend tax dollars to support either private paril voucher whatever then there's got to be some accountability I mean I it baffles me that we don't ask people to show us or measure what's going on so that's my big issue my other issue is rural South Dakota is I think is going to be really harmed by this because they don't have any options I mean I don't I well maybe there are but they're they're small and far and few between in this area sou Falls uh Watertown Aberdine Rapid City um there's 's probably
017a lot more options but for many of the students in South Dakota there's not going to be an option and they're going to be cut in their funding or it's going to have to come from somewhere um so those are two of my major ones and I as a longtime teacher I went through this whole Spectrum when we started um having homeschooled kids which there are people out there doing a great job I'm sure but at that time you had to have a teacher or at least a certified teacher to begin the home you have an home school and then uh that changed which was whatever works and then we went to where they would come in at the end of the year to the public school and do some testing to measure there how
018things are going and there were General tests that everybody else took that went away now kids that are homeschooled are able to participate in extracurricular activities depending on what how the Schoolboard rules on it I mean I don't know and I'm not saying that people are misguided by wanting homeschooling or vouchers or whatever but I don't think it's I don't think it's fair I don't think it's fair okay right now the way I understand it and you guys can help me out if you don't want your child in public education anymore you just make a phone call to the school and fill out a piece of paper and send that paper to Pier then I don't know I don't know I don't know where they're at and I'm not saying it's my business where they're
019at but as a public as the people of South Dakota that pay taxes were somewhat responsible for kids so we have people that do have that opt out and they leave our district and we also have many of them that come right back now I don't know how many what you would want to call that uh I don't know what the name would be but if I wrote a check for you to 3 ,000 and then you took your kid out of school for a month and then you decided you know this isn't so fun or it's not working out we're going to go back do they have to pay that back um and we do have kids that their parents determined that they're going to homeschool him and then we get them back three
020months later six months later the next year and now depending on how things went they're further behind than they were so that's my concern I I'm not against any kid anywhere to get an education and I know that there are parents that do a good job but to uh fund it without whatever they don't have to participate those schools in the same standards that we do with special education kids with needs they're not going to take them they're not going to take them we open the doors and whoever shows up we take in regardless of your academic achievement regardless of your income we take you on and we are very proud of that and that's what we should do but I don't understand how they can insinuate that we're just going to and I don't
021know if cut them loose is a good word but I I worry about this trend and I feel that we live in South Dakota and our public schools are pretty darn good we have some really good things going on so before I get too emotional I'm going to shut down somebody else can take over thank you Mark Mark you led with accountability and something that gives me great pause and I'm looking at it from from a slightly different angle because we're supposed to have more of a conversation about this correct my pause in terms of accountability comes more from the angle of House Bill uh 1020 that was offered up I've got some questions around the swell of support behind that who's who's promoting this because we're elected officials here in the board and have
022any of you received any type of communication from people that are supportive of this have we heard from any Mayors have we heard from any City councilors County Commissioners um heads of Chambers of Commerce business owners business owners so I'm I'm curious as an elected official particularly when you're in the state legislature one of your primary responsibilities is being connected with the people of South Dakota and then as Governor you're to take on tasks and particularly develop a budget that's responsible to the needs of South dakotans So based on all of you as my colleagues you've not heard anything of support towards a voucher program or has anybody heard of support from private schools so where is this ground SW support coming for V Voucher Program I'm just being really pragmatic what's the accountability piece
023and who's supporting that um abs absolutely I agree parents should have a choice and they currently do have a choice um if we're looking at a voucher program to give $3,000 to each student and then they can decide where they go and I think she said particularly those students that are economically challenged when you're looking at an education of $10,000 at a Gorman let's be realistic here and you get 3,000 off of that that's for one child if you're economically challenged how far does that really go so at the end of the day we're taking a long approach to this um and trying to move kids towards a public education to Mark's Point public education or private education move them to private education they can pick and choose who they educate so do we want
024Society move to an elitist Society where some people get an education some don't and then we label kids right off the bat with where they go to get their education who they are and what they're about maybe we should pause and really think about if that's the intention and the outcome that we want um on the upside well there may be some support for um the school choice and using vouchers to it um well there may be some support what I'm seeing and this is being um observant to what our constituents are saying what I am seeing is a groundwell support for public education the reason why is that it's an economic driver it's a recruitment tool for our city as well as our state you heard the gentleman here earlier look at the success
025that he's had and many others that's because 80% of students in South Dakota are public educated so to have state legislators supporting a 20% that we're not sure if they're homeschooled or a private education that has me really question if they're representing We the People um you know there's few things in um the public life getting to be a public official that really we have the ability to take a long-term look and really give it some significant consideration and we pick and choose based upon our the significance and the impact of what those issues have and I don't know anything that's more important to all of us um in South Dakota we the people than taking a real long-term approach of on public education I wrote something so I wanted to be methodical with my
026thoughts because there's a lot that circulates um as one who has kids in the district currently I feel very strongly about this so I'm going to read what I have um but again open to conversation on where this goes as we enter this legislative session I want to speak clearly about an issue that threatens the future of public education in South Dakota School voucher programs as a product of public schools a parent guardian of three children in the sou fall school district and a proud School Board member I have seen firsthand the critical role public education plays in shaping individuals and communities Public Schools do more than educate they provide opportunities and resources and strive to build a sense of belonging for all students regardless of their background or circumstances School vouchers however threatened to
027undermine these opportunities by diverting public funds away from public schools to private institutions often without accountability or Equity here's what that means for our district and state public schools serve all students in the Su fall school district 44.6% of students represent diverse backgrounds 46.7% qualify for free or reduced meals 16.2% are served through special education programs and over 3,000 students speak one of six languages private schools receiving voucher funds are not required to serve these populations equitably or at all special education undermined our district currently serves over 4,100 students in special education providing them with individualized education plans under the protections of idea voucher programs je jeopardize these critical supports leaving vulnerable students without Services they need to succeed rule schools are hit the hardest as Mark mentioned as a graduate of wab high school
028where I was part of a class 18 it's real I know the importance of rural schools in their communities rural districts which rely heavily on state funding due to lower tax local tax revenues stand to lose the most under this Voucher Program any reduction in state funding for education has a disproportionate impact on Rural schools potentially leaving them unable to sustain vital Services vouchers critical Resources with over 24,000 students enrolled in the soupal school district in new programs such as Jag egg Pathways expanded Aviation and ASL courses cyber security Partnerships and Esports that's just to name like a tiny handful of what we offer we are constantly evolving to meet the needs of our community and we listen to our community diverting public dollars to private schools would hinder these advancements and opportunities they provide
029research from the national board National School Board Association confirms that vouchers do not raise student achievement universally and primarily benefit families already in private schools meanwhile public schools are left to add CH address challenges like attendance truancy Workforce shortages and parental engagement with fewer resources this isn't just about funding it's about values public schools are built on the principle providing every child regardless of ability income or background a fair chance to succeed vouchers abandon that principle in total there are over 137,000 K12 students in in South Dakota's Public Schools I urg us to take a clear stance against School vouchers let's prioritize public education for the communities who rely on us to advocate for their future together we can ensure that public schools remain a Cornerstone of opportunity and Community strength in South Dakota thank
030you when I taught I did not teach history our government but sometimes I think it's important to look to our history to help us guide our future so I'm going to give us a little historical perspective tonight and the push to divert taxpayer dollars from public to private schools has a long and sorted history in our country after the Supreme Court's 1954 Brown versus the Board of Education decision some districts closed their Public Schools then to get around the Court's ruling against segregation they used the money to provide vouchers for private schools that rejected integration that's an ugly history but that's how vouchers began in the country I'm not suggesting that segregation or integration is involved with this bill or this voucher scheme but that ugly history needs to be kept in the past and
031we can be very proud that our Public Schools admit and serve all students which my colleagues have mentioned in fact our state constitution tells us this in article 8 it is the state's ultimate responsibility to provide an education to our children so section one quote I'm going to read this uniform system of free public schools the stability of a republican form of government depending on the on the morality and intelligence of the people it shall be the duty of the legislature to establish and maintain a general and uniform system of public schools wherein tuition shall be without charge and equally open to all and to adopt all suitable means to secure to the people the advantages and opportunities of Education end quote note that it does not say that our responsibility is to provide to
032or scholarships to nonpublic schools or students so how can a voucher program be in line with the words of our own state constitution to me it doesn't matter what we call them K12 education savings accounts esas vouchers scholarships whatever regardless of the name you know the impact to me is the same vouchers and voucher inspired schemes like scholarships divert public money from public schools and it erodes public education the foundation of our democracy and I too have a very very strong feeling about public education I'm a retired educator and spent 41 years in public schools and I too am proudly serving on the school board of a public school public education is the heartbeat of our nation and we need to cherish it for what it is you know I will defend like anybody here
033I will defend any parents right to homeschool or to send their child to private schools I will defend that all the time just not on the Public's dime it's not appropriate to use public money for private education educational research like someone else spoke of there's some education research from seven states and this is provided by the economic policy Institute that really defends that causal uh relationship between school funding and student achievement denying Public Schools the funds necessary to educate students negatively impacts student academic outcomes and the converse is true we need to fully fund our Public Schools if we want to improve student achievement one of my main concerns and it's been spoken about but having a special needs child in my family who attended the sou Falls Public Schools and received in not only
034an appropriate but a fulfilling education is the fact that private schools control who comes through their doors the students who may be medically Fragile the students like have been mentioned before have special needs they're more likely to be turned away from a private school public schools follow the federal law and we believe in a free and appropriate education for all kids we try to provide the best education we can for any student who walks through our doors in a year where the governor is also proposing 1.25 funding for public schools School vouchers are not the way School vouchers are a means in an agenda to divert public dollars and to weaken and Destroy Public Schools therefore I wholeheartedly support our proposed resolution thank you thank you I think uh you guys have all brought up
035great points I think we've all thought a lot about this um and what the impact might be whether that's because we have kids in the district grandkids nieces nephews or because we just live here and we care um you don't have to have somebody in the school system to care about the quality of Education that we provide and when you look at things like vouchers that are supposed to help students be able to select a better school for them how do those students get to that school there's Transportation issues issues there's attendance issues things that we are already struggling with as a district is getting our kids to school so creating additional uh barriers to to that is not helpful to the education that the students would be receiving um we talked about rural schools
036and they don't have options they they can't choose to go to a school that's an hour and a half away that's not a realistic thing and as people maybe start to do homeschooling maybe then that school that their Community is so proud of it doesn't exist anymore because there's not enough students there to support teachers and to support um the community so um this isn't even just about soup Falls this is about the state and how we as a state need to Rally around having public school education um the number of people who have graduated from public schools and have gone on to do amazing things uh is high and we continue to uh educate people again of of every need of every background um and be proud of that as well so um like
037my colleagues here I also am very supportive of this resolution and anything that we as a a group or individuals can do to help people to understand the need to talk to their legislators and help them to understand that like Dan said they're there to represent us and there hasn't been anybody that has said to us hey what do you think what are the risks of this what are the benefits of this um I would venture to say that nobody has reached out to any school board to ask that question um even the private school school boards have they reached out to them to say do you want this because I don't know that they do either so um I know people who home school and homeschool very well and that is an amazing opportunity
038for their kids they might travel they might get to do all sorts of things those are not the kids that we're worried about we're worried about the kids who are sitting at home by themselves while their parents may be using drugs or alcohol uh we're worried about the kids who maybe uh aren't eating they don't they don't have the resources at home um they might be then LED more to committing crimes which all of us as a community should be concerned about um so when we can keep our kids in a structured environment learning and having positive influences of the adults uh around them that makes a huge difference and the sad thing is is that many of these students sign that piece of paper their parents sign that piece of paper and then they
039come right back to us and not only then is that hard for that kid to try to get back into that classroom that's also a stress on our teachers now to try to bring their students back up to speed knowing that that student or another student may leave again in a couple months because they signed the paper again and then they'll be back so you've got this yo-yo this Boomerang whatever you want to call it which is just a huge disservice to the kids um and their learning and also a huge disservice to uh the amazing work that our teachers do and the job that's already difficult um for them to have to try to overcome that as well so I think we've all touched on several uh different topics and um are all very
040supportive of what this resolution States and we'll continue to speak out about how we feel and how how can we educate the public to know about this as well so with that uh I think I can say that now therefore be it resolved that we the sou Falls School Board oppose the proposed School voucher program for the 2025 legislative session can I get a motion to acknowledge so moved second all in favor signify by saying I I oppose same sign that is acknowledged thank you all for your thoughts uh on that note being a school board member is a very important job uh locally here in sou Falls but also uh in the state and being able to network with people and support people and we have an election that's coming up and we want
041to make sure that people who are interested and want to learn more about it uh can come and find out about what it's like to be a school board member uh what what is the time commitment what uh what what do you have to do what do we do besides sit here on a second and fourth Monday night in front of all of you because I can tell you there's a lot more to it than that so we are having a a meeting on January 21st at 6 right here in this in this room where we will share some of the um the things that we have done there are a lot of easy things and there are a lot of challenging things that we that we face on a weekly monthly or even annual
042basis and so we would love to invite anybody that wants to learn more about that we are not giving you a petition and making you fill one out when you leave there is no commitment um if nothing else come and learn more about what the service of a school board member is um and if you have somebody in mind maybe encourage them to come sometimes people don't see themselves in a role until someone says that to them that they see them in doing something so if you think that there's somebody a friend a family member somebody in your community um that lives in the sou fall School District that would like to be a part of our board um please invite them as well all right um we will be going into executive session can
043I get a motion in a second for moving into executive session sdcl 1- 25-22 can I get a second second all those in favor signify by I I I oppose same sign we are in executive session