0012024 and at this time uh I'd ask you to join me in saying the Pledge I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all it's it's on now good okay at this time I'd like to go to um having the approval of the agenda so move second all in favor say I I all oppose same sign the agenda is passed okay this time we're going to go to scheduled or under scheduled audience and I think we don't have any if I remember right okay on to school reports and the Fanfare and uh the first one we'll have is the immigration day Creekside Elementary [Music] there we go thank you for having us here
002today uh at Creek Side we we have often prided ourselves in in really trying to involve the community and parents in coming to our school and and being involved and this is a unit that uh third grade all of our third grade teachers do and uh I will tell you uh for as long as I've been here I believe they've done this unit so it's pretty cool um today presenting with for us will be Jessica schaf and Christy wrath they're our teachers and then Nyla Owens and Eva Williams were students that participated in it and they will also particip share so I'll ask them to come on up thank you thanks hi guys uh Jessica schaf third grade um yeah student taught did this presentation when I was here and have kind of taken over
003but it is a cross-curricular um unit that we do we do writing journals or they research their family heritage and they write a journal as if they're an immigrant Coming to America from preferably their home country um takes them um through their journey to Ellis Island from whatever country you can go to the next uh reading we read tons of books stories Diaries Tales of immigrants and their Journeys and their travels their hardships and everything like that and who came to America and then social studies we do the why people left their home country to come to America um what their Journey was like and how it was like to get through Ellis Island in addition to the cross-curricular aspects of this it's also a great home home school connection uh to begin the unit
004we always send home like a Heritage worksheet that they sit with their parents and work through to try to trace their Roots back and it's cool because you they come back and they talk about oh well my great grandma or my great grandpa or they made phone calls to grandparents and learned about their Heritage so it's a great homeschool connection and in addition to that we have parent volunteers so we have eight third grade classes and we usually get oh we had so many last year probably five to eight per class so that's 40 to 64 parents that come in and they help with all the immigration stations and they get to work with the kids and it's just it's a wonderful day and we get parent lot of parent volunteers it might be one
005of our biggest parent volunteer things when students go into the medical room parents check Eyes Ears skin hair and nose for any signs of disease nurses try to make sure that anyone could be sick didn't into the United States right away students pack their suitcases before they Trip To America with only essential items when they get to Alice island workers in the baggage room check immigrant suitcases to make sure they weren't bringing anything unsafe into the country in the information room we had to fill out an information sheet about ourselves as an immigrant we had to write about our name our age the language we speak where we are coming from how we would make a living and what was our first thought of the Statue of Liberty in the interview room we were asked
006questions about ourselves and our family what country we were coming from and why how much money we brought and how we were going to support ourselves and our family okay are there any questions for them I don't any questions but I have gotten to experience it with my kids and it is truly one of the most memorable events you guys do an amazing job so thank you amazing thank you thank you thank you very much [Applause] next is the Spartan coffee cart okay well um while Mr gy hooks everything up I'll kind of introduce him uh so last year when I started I had a chance to spend some time Mr G's room getting to know him his students and everything that goes on uh in his classroom is just great stuff and so we
007started chatting about some other things that we could do and we came up with the idea to do a Spartan coffee cart and so I'm not going to spoil what that is yet but this is something that we've been doing this year and it has had a lot of great uh impact on our school and on students so with no further Ado here they are hi uh my name is Chris gei I'm a special education teacher at spish high school um I just I want to give a huge thank you to the spish foundation for public education for giving us this grant to allow us to get this uh coffee shop started and I'm going to turn it over to Ron and Molly hello everyone my name is Ren espanosa and this is Molly I'm
008Molly Clover okay let's get things started sparton c c so this is how we got started we got the Grant from the Spearfish foundation for public schools and this has given us job opportunities and we bought a fun VPS Series coffee maker 2 espresso machines and a three coffee grinders I have number three never mind so this is our mission our mission is we are learning drop skills by answering the phone and taking orders from our teachers We are following instructions on how to make the coffee and we are delivering coffees to our teachers and working with money and making change what we offer this is our men you that the teachers are the fr you have you will have menus on the on your uh thing you can check out if you want to
009see all about what we sell SE no flavers we offer different seasonal flavors for the fall winter and spring Seasons that's it so these are our punch cars as you can see so we have our prepaid card which we we offer for $20 and each punch you get the last punch you get a free one and our punch card you get up to 10 punches and the last one you get free how business going we love our new coffee shop and our teachers are ordering us from us and thank you for listening to us [Applause] thank you do you have any questions for us I do how many cups of coffee do you typically do in a day uh maybe around five or six a day okay right any any other questions the floor is
010open what's what's the most popular coffee that's ordered um our popular coffee is probably right now the what apple butter latte sounds great does anybody else have any questions got any samples any samples we should have bought samples Chris you would have brought it yeah is it is it only teachers that can get coffee or can other people stop by when you're open to get coffee right now it's just teachers but maybe in the future we'll open it up okay do both of you like to drink coffee yes and Alicia knows cuz I drink coffee every day at her house when we have a holiday yes we do Rowan do you like to drink coffee Rowan do you like to drink coffee [Laughter] Yes sounds like this was a very good project thank you so
011much thank you for having us [Applause] do we have any conflict no conflicts of interest okay there are no conflict of interest waivers the next item up is number seven which is the notice and this notice is given uh open meeting laws on December 18th at 5:00 p.m. a quorum of the school board members will attend the bhsu list tour reception at the joy Center no official School business will be discussed or conducted and this is something where we have been invited to the the whole board has been invited continuing on we're going to number eight and that's the informational items from the superintendent update yeah just a few different things here um I did get a a track proposal from rener track um interesting enough it is the track is much more expensive than
012um we're looking at about 2.1 million for the track however the artificial turf is just under 400,000 where uh Monument or not Monument Mammoth was uh 1.3 somewhere in there so the total cost is uh we're looking closer to 2.5 rather than the 3.2 if we were to do the entire package if you're looking just at a track uh certainly rener track is much more expensive than than Mammoth still waiting for uh from fiser track I've called them I've left messages figured it was the holidays I don't know what but they're not returning calls nor nor emails so I don't know if they bowed out but at least they can do was return a call I would think or an email but I'll still continue to try to get in touch with them um I'm
013not so sure we shouldn't look at a committee to sit down and look at this a little bit further and then make a recommendation to the board um so those that are on sitting on the facility committee I know I've been asking a lot of board members lately on different committees but uh if it's something that we're looking to possibly do this fall or this next summer and maybe we need to put it off till summer 26 anyway uh but yeah proposals are quite high so uh next thing uh I am on the interview committee for the chief of police interviews uh starting tomorrow about noon uh there's four candidates and we'll get through all the candidates tomorrow not sure exactly when they hope to make an announce make a selection and an announcement but
014uh interviews are tomorrow uh PD active shooter training uh they have classroom training on December 17th at 4M I did get Nathan asked if he could attend I did get permission for you to attend if you want to do the classroom training then they have the actual active shooter training on December 29th when we're not in session uh at 1M and um if you don't necessarily have to do the classroom training if you want to do the active shooter training starts at one but you have to be there for the safety brief prior to the training do you know what time the safety brief is I would just be there by 12:45 okay to be certain and is that at the high school yep at the high school yep um last thing I have here
015is uh we are attending and I say we it's an admin team and admin and SRO team is attending I love you guys training in Rap City on December 18th uh it is a training on safety protocols and re reunification methods for schools and organizations so it kind of goes hand inand with our crisis plan now uh but just offers us some different options that we might utilize especially in the re reunification side of things but um so we'll go we'll learn more about it it's free training put on by the uh uh South Dakota uh safety school safety organization I guess can't think of the actual name right now and then I've had five people interested in the principal interview oh drop so okay if we can Whittle that down Ellen said she'd drop
016out she said Ryan served on high school so you guys AR wrestle I'm good with whatever you just like d put our names in a half okay we'll flip a coin we'll let I'll let you you know okay that's all I have okay thank you so much moving on to number nine the action items uh to appoint an Associated School Board of South Dakota legislative Action Network land member and Nathan has done it in the past so I'm going to ask if we can submit the entire board every board member's name if we cannot we just need to at least name one I I gathered that's what they were looking for but if not I mean it doesn't matter I think you pick one of us and do it but I think we all per
017their recommendation Associated school boards are all land members so that we're all okay in case we can't do all if we can just narrow it down to one tonight and then you can throw my name on me give Nathan a break okay all right but if we can submit everybody's name we will do so okay okay thank you Eric continuing on motion on that motion yeah we do we need yeah yeah we do okay so almost made it out just to to clarify do you need a motion yes to nominate all of us no or I mean Eric okay uh move that we appoint Eric the asbsd legislative Action Network member second all in favor say I I I I'll oppose same sign it has passed okay moving on to the consent agenda and um
018number 10 I'm with it so for our Personnel we have down there that Dan Olen will be retiring at the end and I'm we're going to say thank you very much for all of your years hard work [Applause] and Dan just so you know all the board members have this already it was it was taken two days after I was born what's kind of interesting about that article is that my high school classmate was the one that interviewed me and did [Laughter] the okay I would move to approve the consent agenda second okay all in favor say I I I'll oppose same sign actually down we're all opposing it okay continuing on to number 11 discussion and at this time the first thing is the um policy committee's reporting and recommendation for our first reading
019for the revision to the following policies so um so I will go through each one of these and and briefly discuss what the changes are uh keep in mind if they if they were policies that we did not think need to be amended repealed changed attitude or any anything like that there is not on this list because there was a lot of crossover between the 5,000 and the 6,000 Series so if we did it last year uh some of them didn't need changes or updates so uh first one uh school calendar uh we Chang that because it said uh to develop the ensuing Year's school calendar we like to do it two years in advance so we just put on there two develop the school calendar uh will be determined by the Spearfish Board of
020Education in today annually uh next one School dismissal for emergencies or inclement weather uh we have crisis management plan that struck out in it's District Emergency Operations plan only change there uh 6205 is the FM in there and all we did is take the challenge materials form and we put it right behind the selection of instruction materials and we put it form and renumbered it behind the selection of library media so each form they're identical but they just now follow each one of those two policies next one 6215 exceptional children educational plan that was that name is a bit outdated uh we just relabeled or retitled it to special education services 6220 field trips that is now and our 5160 student travel so this one looking to repeal again 6220 academic testing uh that is
021uh we we kind of gutted the old one and put in this new one and talked about just academic testing and so you can see what it all entails there but again to assess the strengths and weakness of current curriculum and instruction to evaluate student growth provide teachers by diagnostic of information about uh student groups and to serve as a basis for long-term studies of student achievement everything that we need like need for our data assessment or data analysis uh the next one 6235 human growth and development instruction again that was somewhat gutted still has the same thing team but it was also added in there the emotional health and social health um just because you go down to the curriculum review and parental opt out we've had parents in the past that have opted
022their child out of some human growth and development type things whether it be at the high school uh with uh some of uh Mr Tyson's curriculum or whether it be uh in our elementaries with our kiddos when they're talking about maybe Safe Touch things like that that parents don't feel comfortable with their students hearing the actual ual Anatomy I think that seems to be a catch word whereas when they they want to talk to their kids about that type of stuff so anyway this includes not just sexual type things it's also the emotional and social health all right again same thing as I mentioned before 6240 is just the uh form that follows uh uh instructional materials or library media next one is an AR and that's 62 it's going to be renumbered to 44420
023and all we did is we had two different policies we had one on our email and then we had it on the retention of email so we just combined those it made sense to combine the two uh 6250 non-credit courses called continuing uh units of Education this was implemented back in 1984 I'm not sure what they did back then but we certainly haven't utilized it since I have been here where something was offered and it wasn't uh uh credit wasn't awarded in the high school so uh we're just looking to repeal this uh 6255 and the next one 6256 kind of go together our old policy had uh a partial definition and uh how I guess the notification process if you will for alternative instruction students and then it also had the placement and credit
024approval of students not from accredited schools there was enough information here that we thought we needed to put it in two different policies so this is all about uh notification so it had goes through it it talks about Open Enrollment it talks about uh withdrawal from an alternative school if they are homeschooled or private school how they come back it talks about the process okay so that's 6255 6256 is not just about high school students but it's also about elementary and middle school and how they are placed uh other than just a bi biological age there might be some type of testing that's required uh to put them in the proper at the proper grade level but then it also does go into the Waring of credits 6260 uh District involvement in political activity this
025is a bit more descriptive uh where the board prohibits uh these different actions so uh when you get a chance make sure you're looking through that and uh you're okay with what it is but it's essentially we right now we have legislative candidates come in and talking gayes or nida's government classes and things like that we'll continue to still do that but to hold uh particular political uh meetings in our schools and so on that prohibits that episod next one 6280 is School volunteers this is a new policy for us and so it just is more uh descriptive as to what needs to happen if we have a school volunteer so there's three really different types of volunteers there's one that comes on a routine scheduled basis and if that happens they need to fill
026out a volunteer form and they need to go through the fingerprint background check if it is somebody that non- routine non-scheduled but comes in um and there's a possibility of not being alone with students and being unsupervised we need at least an electronic background check if it is a room parent they're coming in for a holiday party of some kind all they got to do is run their ID through the Raptor system and they don't need any type of application for that what's an electronic background what you what do you mean by that so it's just it does it just searches an online database oh okay the other one the FBI the fingerprints FBI and DCI it's much more thorough y uh extracurricular philosophy again it was kind of gutted and Rewritten I guess uh
027the part I like most about this is the middle uh paragraph while competition winning are natural elements of many extracurricular activities it is important to maintain a balance between the pursuit of excellence and the promotion of good sportsmanship the district is committed to fostering a positive and supportive environment where students can learn valuable life skills such as teamwork perseverance and respect for others so it kind of includes a little a little bit of the old policy but that is somewhat new in the middle there uh 6315 extracurricular rules and enforcement procedure if you go to the third page you can in red you can see in addition to the assessment the student will enroll show a record of participation and complete an alcohol drug diversion program by an approved certified chemical dependency counsel or licensed
028health professional we had that under the alcohol and tobacco violation but we didn't have anything for a Sub controled sub through marijuana so we included we took what was in the uh alcohol and uh tobacco violation and we included in in the uh controlled substance or marijuana moving on another one that we kind of gutted and uh started new with I thank Mr Williams and the high school counselors for going through this very thoroughly but the new graduation requirements and we had these on two separate there's the diploma require requirments on the second page they were two separate documents before we included them and they're now combined uh but it kind of goes through everything that somebody would need to know if they were looking to graduate from uh Spearfish next one 6600 copyright policy
029another one that was fair uh gutted fairly well and uh replaced with what's in here uh a lot of this what you see in here is about um the fair use policy at least the second half of it is about fair use and it's essentially saying you can take bits and pieces of an article or movie or whatever and use it for instructional purposes but at the end of the day you can't just take Frozen and show it for a classroom party unless we have a license and we have done that in the past we've done licenses so uh they can do various things and I think Mrs Binga she helped me out quite a bit on that policy class size 6625 uh this is has been expanded on uh has changed a little bit
030from um what the policy committee had recommended we split out and made it more like our old policy in the sense of of uh how it was split out so we had kindergarten was a standalone on the old one so we have that in there primary grades one through three intermediate 4 through five Middle School 68 and high school 912 all the numbers are the same same from our old policy with the exception of kindergarten uh we used to have no less than 19 it is uh 18 now so we could possibly drop one more there okay all right building facility use another one that we spent a lot of time on a lot of discussion the admin team uh Mr wadean went through this quite a bit and uh found some uh comparables with
031other school districts that we could look at but uh we have the building facility use policy 1310 can see that and then we have the regulations so AR uh the granting approval cancellations operational service functions custodial food service and then board actions affecting use agreements what I need you to look for is on page two uh the following groups May use school facilities without payment of rental fees if the district incurs an additional labor cost these costs will be charged to the group however it goes through school board approved student organizations or clubs Spearfish nonprofit Community organizations or individuals who sponsor educational events or activities involving Spearfish school age students Spearfish High School alumni reunions ptas and booster clubs uh the foundation state or Regional professional organizations and any political subdivision in the state of
032South Dakota so I guess I need you guys between this meeting and next if you'll take a look at those and see if there's anything in there that needs to be deleted or omitted or something added as far as uh no charge for the facility when it gets down to political sub subdivisions of the state of the South Dakota BH is would be included in that certainly the city would be included something like that okay also look at the class A and class B uh uh facility rates and then I guess just let me know if there's anything else on the policy or the AR that uh you'd like to know more about and then the very last thing here uh FM 1310 or 1310 FM is the lease agreement form are there any questions
033if they weren't being charge they would they still just sign the lease agreement form and they just put zero in there or something right yep y something new is also charging if you'll see you'll see in here is charging a deposit uh security deposit we've had uh some need to do that where damages or additional cleaning needs to take place uh so we want to make sure we have a security deposit we didn't put it overly high it's only $200 uh but we think that fall in line with what others are doing so last thing I would say on this is just if there are anything between now and any of the policies between now and uh the next school board meeting let me know we can talk on the phone you can come in
034email whatever it might be if I need to clarify anything for you but all of these again with the exception of the class size was approved as written from the policy committee and I would like to say thank you to the policy committee they've done a lot of good work Y and thank you too to Mr Easton okay moving on to be the governor's budget address get to well if you had the opportunity to listen to the governor uh the uh revenue forecast isn't all that great there's uh it's not coming in the way they predicted uh in this current budget year so next physical year is looking kind of Bleak so for public uh school funding uh she uh she recommended a 1.25% increase so it's roughly 11 to 12 million increase in funding
035for public schools uh but part of that uh she recommended $4 million out of the unclaimed property fund uh $4 million to fund Esa so education savings accounts uh most commonly known as vouchers and so um we knew it was coming in some form if it wasn't going to be from the governor it was going to be from uh some legislators and we're still likely going to see some uh voucher bills uh from legislators what the governor has done though she is this will not be in the form of a bill it will will be in the department of educations that'll be a budget line for them so they will oversee it they will get the funding they will distribute it so they will send out the collect applications and they will determine it's uh
036uh on a need basis so U yeah they will they will process all of that and they will be sending out the funding to parents uh I sent this form here the educational savings account kind of talked a little bit about what it was about but uh interesting enough it says it's uh again it could be used for uh students that are going to private schools to help pay for their tuition what's interesting here is if you look at say sou Falls Christian their High School tuition is $10,000 and so $33,000 to pay for that these families that are going to qualify for this they can't afford the other 7,000 to send their child to to private school so being a on a needs basis is interesting but uh again the use of funds they
037can purchase curriculum or classroom equipment um so U not so sure about uh sure about that the other part of her address that I guess I will point out is not necessarily about what she said but what she didn't say so she has a slide that again wasn't she didn't speak to but it's in our on the website uh for the governor's address and it was budget reductions so again interesting enough the tan the temporary assistance for needy families again she's cutting that by $5 million but she's going to turn around and give money back to needy families to either homeschool or go to private school it just to me it doesn't make sense anyway South Dakota public broadcasting funding adjustment are 3.6 million so our reduction funding there border regions a reduction in 2
038million graduate medical education by 1.7 dual credit and have to learn a little a few more details on this but dual credit it is a 50/50 adjustment of 1.1 million uh subsidized subsidized Assisted Living uh 1.1 million State Library just a little over a million and it kind of goes on there again the ones that we're most concerned with because that we've already heard from these entities so like South Dakota public broadcast and we've heard without this funding they probably won't be able to do uh our state tournaments so they won't be able to broadcast them concern there now again are they saying this in order to get the educational group behind them the Activities Association behind trying to get this refunded or not being cut the other one I'm concerned about is the State
039Library there uh we've heard from the State library that if that is cut the online book database that is being supplied to public schools for students who go on to find different books and so on will not be available again I don't know if it's a tactic to get the State uh to get us to get on board with the State library to fight this uh budget cut I'm not sure but that's part of the talk right now is uh those [Applause] reductions the other thing that you have in front of you uh or at least was sent to you and it's a part of the agenda is uh resolution to oppose the educational savings accounts in South Dakota um I'd like to go through each whereas a little bit and then after I'm done
040with this then just open it up for discussion so the first whereas South Dakota public schools are a Cornerstone of the state and the pride of their communities welcoming all children educating and feeding them connecting them with friends and mentors and helping shape their future while preparing them to be the next generation of our state's Workforce whereas a proposed educational savings accounts for the 2025 legisl legislative session is simply a different tile title for a school Voucher Program whereas while the proposed educational savings accounts esas are being marketed as offering school choice this claim is misleading as South Dakota has a long-standing tradition of school choice offering families a variety of educational options for decades including open enrollment private schools and home homeschooling we have had homeschool and private schools for years and years and
041years as of 1997 we have had open enrollment so that is school choice nothing is changing with school choice it is the the now pay somebody to keep their child at home or send him to private school whereas numerous Studies have consistently demonstrated that school voucher programs failed to improve student academic performance and offer often students to uh take an assessment South Dakota does not uh it has shown that they're not doing any better in fact they're doing worse than their Public School counterparts the other part of that is the students that go to home school they come back and we're and they're finding that the students that come back to public school are behind their public school peers and again this is as a whole I'm sure there's some families that are doing a
042wonderful job and it's not the case but this is as a whole how how widespread is that study that shows that either behind public their Public School counterparts is that a is that a robust study across a large group of students or is that narrowly focused I don't think it's narrowly focused on one particular State uh it's the gentleman that uh Cowan that did that I think that is uh the states that when he was doing the study the number of states that offered that okay and Nathan as a teacher I saw but I I can send out the the white page if you will that gives the information and you can look for the look I don't remember I watched I watched his uh presentation I don't remember if that was provided in there
043so I'd love to see that it was sent out afterwards so I can send that yep um whereas the proposed program will be implemented by using millions in in public taxpayer dollars to fund non-public schools that may pick and choose who they admit while also charging tuition raising millions of dollars in scholarship funds or to fund homeschool programs with no transparency or accountability measures to prove success similar to those required in public schools again we have state assessments where students are required to take them uh the assessments and we report out what those results are there is absolutely no assessments or required accountability uh for hom school or private school students uh now there are 35 private schools in South Dakota that are State accredited and take the assessments you'll be hard press to find
044their results on their website you may find their ACT scores which again it is a student population that wants to take the ACT and finds value in it and so the scores are pretty good ours pretty darn good as well so um anyway uh whereas a state budget which provides a funding increase for public education faces constraints due to stag re stag Revenue Collections and as a result the proposed increase in state aid for public schools is less than the level of inflation again we're looking at 1.25 I believe inflation is just a little over two and a half to three uh whereas the lower and expected Revenue nope I just did that one whereas the school voucher program will not stop at the initial amount as the intent as the intention to grow School
045voucher funding has already been stated even before it has been adopted again the governor says that she expects this program to grow year after year after year uh whereas the school voucher programs planned inevitable growth will be damaged to the future of our Public School System students and communities and then whereas we as the Schoolboard members call for legislators to oppose the proposed School Voucher Program because of the foreseeable detrimental impact will have on South Dakota public school system at the expense of our students so the governor has said that this will not impact funding for for uh Public Schools is not coming out of that pot well when the state only has a certain amount of Revenue it's got to come out of somebody's pot so whether it's out of public broadcasting whether it's
046out of tanif whether it's whatever also keep in mind that there's already five million in tax Insurance credits that uh uh insurance companies can take that tax credit and write uh a scholar or do a scholarship for a student to attend um a private school so there's $9 million out of the state budget that could be utilized for something else I don't know it's if you look at other states you look at Arizona that what did they say it went up by it ballooned over what they thought the cost by over, 1400% it's up into like 323 million I think it is so I mean the expense is ballooned and this with no end in sight who knows how far it will balloon has there been any conversation between superintendents and legislators to try to
047figure out what their version of a bill will look like to try to find some common ground and uh not necessarily we're all talking to our legislators one you know in each of the legislative districts sure uh I'm meeting with mine on December 16 okay yeah December 16th so outside of signing a letter and I mean the letter goes into great detail obviously about all the negative aspects of the voucher program I mean say this goes through in some some version I mean have you started to formulate an idea or a plan on why because the the whole point of this usually is about competition makes us better so have you started to think about what you might say to people why we should be a School of Choice well I would say I don't
048mind competition as long as we're all on the same playing field untie my hands if it's a popularity contest untie my hands let's do away with standards let's do away with assessments let's make sure teachers aren't don't have to be um don't have to be uh certified I mean we have a lot of Hoops that we have to jump through and it's not always so popular with these folks back here uh if it is really about a popularity contest untie my hands and we'll we'll make it about aular cont that could be part of this is educating people the differences but I mean I think we should formulate a plan on why we would be a School of Choice why we would be as good or better you know than than a private school for
049example what what can we do that they can't do so I I think it would make sense for us to to have some of those ideas start formulating and even if this doesn't go through there's obviously a population out there that feels that public schools aren't the answer and how can we educate and show them that they they are the answer yeah but it's going to be I I should say it's not going to be should say it's going to be hard to to formulate that again the reason why they go to home school or to a private school is they have probably lower class sizes uh they have uh the ability to to weave religion Christianity into whatever they're doing um some there's some schools that are not based on you know it's not
050a Christian belief or a religious base but there's there's something that's appealing that allows them to go there smaller class I mean yeah there's just there's some things like that um that's hard just hard to compete with but I I would think that we could come up with some things that that we do well that we need to point out that we might we might know this but does everyone sure so I mean we need no doubt we need to tell the story if we just send a letter and that's all we do that's not good enough so I'm just I think you need to have some type of idea on how we educate the masses about the differences people are going to make their choice sure but if you don't give them any information
051their choice might not be an educational Choice it might not have been based on facts or substance so let's let's provide some facts and substance and how How would how do you I mean well could could I bet I bet a principal could come up with five reasons why they think their building is a great building they've got great things going on there only five he's not asking I didn't ask ni but well obviously we're going to find things in there but it I mean are the things that they finding can they be duplicated that's what I'm trying to figure out are the differences between can they be duplicated there as here I'm not saying we can't do it we got awesome schools and we got great staff great great teachers I mean we we
052can come up with them I'm just trying to think of things that are the differences between a private home school and in our schools there's a great $17 million example sitting outside the the high school right now there's no way even a home school or a private school Consortium could come up with a facility like that programming that we have there are we referring to like specifically spish School District or public education I just keep the Spearfish because not all public schools are equal sorry they're not so yeah no I feel agree I think that's a great I for me so a couple things one if if no if this doesn't pass and legislators get something passed is that coming more directly from our funding that they're proposing or do we know where that they're
053getting the voucher yeah I haven't seen the bills uh that you know that they're going to probably propose if you were looking at past ones I think rep representative Odin box was for 3500 and uh it was to go for towards tuition uh to a private accredited school that's pass I don't know if it's changed or you know how much it's changed what other bills might be coming forward and does that come would that directly impact our school district or is it coming from a big pot in the state does that make sense again the pot's only so big if you take it from somewhere it's not going in another place yeah I think that the larger over overarching question for me in all of this is the those that are proponents of esas and
054vouchers are using the district report cards and the proficiency percentages to fuel the fire that they're trying to light under this what and I know we spoke at nauseum on this what metrics do we have to show that those numbers aren't accurate and they're not an accurate representation of our students in this District how how can we parse that out my uh I spoke with my cousin a lot over Thanksgiving he uh actually used to have Brady's job before Brady was here and he's in Watertown now and I asked him I said that's not accurate and he said uh he could speak to his district that graduation rates are high because teachers want to graduate kids and they may grade on a curve or change something so the the graduation rate might not be as
055drastically different if they were held to the same as state standards are so I'm I'm lost in the middle of because it doesn't seem reasonable to me that we only have 48% of students that are proficient in math that's not that's not conceivable to me that that number would be that small so how do we how do we harness that and figure out where the facts are so we can even have a conversation around something like this yeah and I would have to uh rely on the principles and their actual buildings and and stuff but I mean that is yeah by and large more than 50% of our kids are proficient math and ela's a little bit higher um and I'm not going to make make excuses for them I mean it's something that we
056got to get better at but I think a lot of it is not so much of our on our teaching and learning it's more on uh test preparation so it's more on getting students um uh expose them to the interim assessments that are uh the state assessments U get them accustomed to the types of questions that are on there and uh get in front of them I think there's some other things that we're doing like in high school with their math um we're look we're changing our scope and sequence a little bit on our high school math programs there's just some small things that we can tweak to to automatically make things a little bit better we test all students to correct correct have some special needs but I mean to Nathan's point and you're
057right we did bring this up to the last meeting but uh I mean that that is used against public schools and a chart and a graph for just numbers without context is very it can be dangerous because you read it one way someone else reads this in another way so you need to provide some context to it well it's interesting the very proponents of esas who are utilizing our scores against us absolutely want no accountability whatsoever so if somebody a homeschool Advocate or an Esa Advocate says we need this okay then provide some accountability yeah mandate State assessment that's how we should maybe look at approaching M so I graduated through homeschooling and I loved it it was anazing amazing thing it was great my concern is how we just recently there's laws that have
058changed there's there is no accountability at all and I know that there's a lot of kids have been maybe should have graduated too I mean so I think how can we if there's account there's more accountability maybe that's the approach to looking at encouraging if this does somehow go through can we encourage okay then you need to be held accountable to the same um there has to be some accountability because right now there's none at all and that's scary to me that's very scary but I do also like to rhyme your approach of like we can we have some great qualities how can we share that how can we show again I I mean I I think having that homeschooling background and yet knowing how valuable our public schools are what my kids have learned
059here with these principles with our educ it is phenomenal and how can we show that to set I super important we're very blessed I think we need to look at the growth that will happen with it with how much taxes are going to be happening from uh if we look at the other states that have already done this and we can see that they theirs have grown I can't understand how they won't tax us Higher and Higher and Higher and I don't think people really want it to be higher and higher and higher so I think that is something that needs to be out there too so it should have started I don't think there's any administrator in here myself that is against school choice yeah there's all of us agree that parents should have
060the right to choose whether it's home school private school or public school that parents should have that choice it's about funding U that other uh the other entity if you will or the other entities U the other thing I would say and again this is what you know where I hesitate a little bit to some degree Nathan when you mentioned the CTE Center homeschool and private school kids they have access to that yeah so it's not just a public school and as well they should because those tax those tax dollars are going to it our activities they should have access to their tax dollars are going to it I I just think that any public tax dollars need to be going to Public Schools that's I guess my feeling uh as far as the um
061unclaimed property uh money or fund that's you know how many how many bridges across South Dakota they talked about need to be replaced in the millions of dollars I mean it could go to that I mean there are so many different things that it could go toward um well then eventually that account runs dry when you start making large expenditures like that out of it and then something gets shifted and eventually there's a bill that's passed that says it's a division of property taxes and then it does start to reduce funding for public education y I would say I agree with everything that's been said but I think and along the same lines we can we can sign and agree to a resolution all day but we don't proactively show why why we believe in
062that why we sign it why we you know passed a resolution we're not doing ourselves any favors so we have to be we have to continue to to be in front of legislators continue to to be the voice for it and stand by it we can't just stop you know after we paper and show our work and show why um because just signing it um doesn't do much if we aren't going to go out and show and put ourselves on display um and prove our Point as to why we believe the way we believe it's just it's just really frustrating to me that uh there are private schools that have on their website that they will not accept students of special needs they will not take uh students of poor academic uh performance or behavior
063issues and they're going to get Public Funding when they can discriminate against those populations of students that just that really frustrates me is that is is there even is there laws that would play against that well there or is I guess it's just more it's your funding it's a private well it's it's the parents that are accepting the money not the schools the parents are taking the money and you know they'll they do it whatever they want they can do what what what they wish the other thing is that and we call it a group of no school students per se but we have a number of students that that go to home school because they're being held accountable in public schools whether it be for treny for grades for Behavior whatever and at some
064point parents think you know it's just as easy to homeschool them then I don't get the phone calls or the emails or the certified letters or whatever and so there's a certain contingency of students that are just what we term as no school and again now they're going to have or their parents will have an opportunity to collect on this uh based on their needs that's frustrating as well again I didn't I wasn't looking for the resolution for tonight I just wanted to put it in front of you uh have a discussion have a discussion about it and then be able to think about it and possibly have on the January board meeting agenda any other questions we will work on uh putting a list of things together of uh things that I guess that
065we have that I guess public or H school does do not have and we'll we'll have that uh the next couple of weeks apprciate okay yes thank you thank you very much okay I guess we can go continue on and our next one is number 12 the minutes consider the regular meeting minutes of November 11th 2020 24 I make a motion to Second all in favor say I I all oppos same sign the minutes have passed moving on to number 13 the financial reports and bills I'll move to approve as presented second all in favor say I I all oppos same sign the financial reports and bills have been approved at this time we're at the adjournment do I have a motion I'll make a motion to Second all in favor say I I I'll
066oppose same sign the meeting is adjourned thank you all for being here [Music]