001study session to order um at this time we have Surplus property safety and healthy or safe and health safety and health board members in your packet you will um find details on some AEDs and a desk that are being requested to be used as Surplus property the uh accordance to TCA we are recommending the school board that these items be declared Surplus the AEDs are outdated and have been replaced with a new um a new model and the desk as well okay uh 2025-26 special course application first read Dr. Schanda Doughty yes and so I will I will kick that over to Dr Doughty but just for your information every year the um Department of Education has a list of courses that that we choose from and anything outside of that that we are doing
002Special in CMCSS we do need to make that request each year so she has a couple of requests good evening board in your packet you're going to find detailed information and standards about the peer assistant and Leadership and military history courses um these are both special courses that we would like to submit to the state for approval these are currently being offered in CMCSS schools and with your approval and state approval this will allow us to continue to offer both of those courses in our high schools okay uh item three teacher tenure consideration first read I'll kick it over to our chief human resource officer Melissa Izatt to discuss the um teachers that are up for tenure this year for director of schools to recommend a tenure a teacher be granted tenure by the local
003Board of Education the teacher must first be eligible for tenure under the law a list of eligible individuals is then presented to the board for consideration and approval this year the board was provided with a list of 123 candidates recommended for tenure based on meeting qualifications set forth by the state of Tennessee of the 123 candidates 64 from elementary 28 from middle school 29 from high school and two at the district level who makes up the board that's going to be going to review of those teachers how do you compile the board that's going to be reviewing those teachers for a tenure so the qualifications for tenure no no no no no the composition of the board that's going to be mon be making a decision on those people that's you all no you're going
004to bring us a list correct and that's in the packet but that is based on the criteria there's five options for them to be eligible for for tenure okay and so if they meet one of those five criteria then we bring that to the board for review and approval so if they're on that list they've met one of the five criteria one of the five routes for tenure approval so there is no board that actually review that that's based on their record well Human Resources reviews it but the state sets the requirements and so we have to review each candidate to see that they meet one of those Pathways and then that's how we submit them you say we that mean more than one right Human Resources yes so um whole team it goes through
005several people yes several checks in there to make sure that we have everyone so so essentially it's it's a rubric and so the state outlines that so we can we can kind of go through that and make sure that you have all that which I believe you do but essentially if if I'm a teacher and I have taught so many years I've met this criteria then I am automatically eligible for tenure and that's what we bring to you all but it is just essentially a a a list and as long as a teacher meets one of those and we just double check if there's a teacher who believes they qualify for tenure then then and we have missed then we would certainly double check but but typically we have a pretty hearty review of what
006that looks like and one of the main pieces of data obviously is the the LOEs that they receive so an LOE of a four or five that's the the qualifying criteria and then there's different routes whether they've come from another LEA where they had had tenure before um if you know straight out of five year probation there's different different levels and we check for each one of those routes and we track them from the moment they're hired and every year we track and and add that if it's they're four years we know the next year they're going to be up for review and so out of the ones we reviewed I believe we reviewed 145 eligible candidates and 123 met the criteria and you still don't answer my question but it's okay we'll get with
007you but essentially it it's not a it's not a judgment call so to speak it is just a list and so every one of those teachers if it's the list they either make it or they don't it's not like um a packet you submit that that's a a qualitative essay or something that we're judging that's not the case and and I can give you the five the five options if you want so for no I don't need the options I trust you guys for the options I believe that you do right by the options but who in your office is responsible for making the decision other than you I know you said we so more than one is it five is it six is it 10 so it starts with our certified team our certified
008reps they go through the ones that that on board all the certified teachers they go through and pull the list from our employee database that shows the number of years and if they are at that year eligible mark then it goes to Michael Tharpe and he reviews them to determine once he gets the LOEs did they meet the LOE requirement and then he submits that to me and then that goes to you all for approval that's what I'm asked thank you sorry okay um item four state report card yes I'd like to ask um Dr. Kimi Sucharski to come forth as you know the state report card was released um right before Christmas and um we have we have already publicly shared those results but Dr Kimi is going to go through that with you
009all quickly um just to see if you have any questions glorious evening um so there is a a set of guidelines that we must follow in order to meet the rules for the grades that go into the report cards that are posted to the state page um that data comes to the district it's validated by the accountability team and then we send it back and then it's posted that this data includes all achievements so any test that the children take so all content remember this is different different than the AMO data that we go through where it's math and and ELA this is all subjects it's the growth for all of those subjects it's the subgroup when they talk about the lowest 25% they take the performance of all the students in the district and
010those that scored at the bottom 25% they measure how they grow the following year the goal is to catch everybody up get us accelerated so that's a part of this measure and then if you're a high school part of it is the College and Career Readiness each of these based on the level so you're going to have the elementary and the high school have different kinds of Aggregates they put the score together they weighed it and then based on what the weight of the score is a letter is assigned to the school and so here are the key points that you want to keep in mind all the subjects are in them obviously ELA and math which are the goals the Strategic work of the state and the district as well are weighted of slightly
011heavier than science and social studies um it they do schoolwide TVAAS so it's the growth across all of the subjects for them uh and then they do the bottom 25% of growth for those kids how much forward that they grew and then for the college and career readiness they're looking at the kids that scored 21 on the ACT that makes you all um automatically College and Career other things like the percent of kids that are participating in AP and how they did industry certification and the ASVAB the military test achieving a qualifying score which is currently 31 and so here are our grades for this year the elementaries and then the middle and high CMCSS has no Fs I believe we have four Ds and so the overview of this for our district is 90%
012of the schools uh received an average better uh average or better letter grade which would be A, B, or C that means you've done what you need to do or above it um which is an increase uh from 73% on the last round so we're we're moving forward nearly half of our schools performed in the top categories earning an A or a B uh the number of schools earning a D decreased by 64% as I said there's I think there's only four and we have no F CMCSS has not had an F um during the entire time questions thank you all right item five goal number three provide all students opportunities to build academic and technical and professional skills using ready graduate Milestones yes Dr. Becky Padgett and Dr. Dayna Paine are going to present
013on goal three tonight good evening I'm Dayna Paine uh director of Career and Technical education and I'm going to start you off with uh our points of improvement for providing all students opportunities to build academic technical professional skills using ready graduate Milestones so we'll start off by talking a little bit about what we mean um when we talk about academic knowledge that is the understanding of core content meaning Reading Writing math science and social studies our technical skills when we talk about those are the specialized knowledge or expertise needed to complete tasks in a specific career field so when I talk about technical skills in say construction I might be talking about um using a hammer or when I talk about technical skills in cosmetology I might be talking about how you hold scissors but
014we also know that academic skills um can be used in real world context and then they become a technical skill so the way that I use geometry in my construction class now has become a a technical skill we also talk about professional skills um we can call those soft skills or employability skills and those are the things that are transferable across all career fields so things like collaboration or things like being on time are things that we would consider professional skills so our ready graduate Milestones you may be familiar with this graphic um but this graphic shows us all the way from kindergarten through High School different kind of uh Milestones along the way that we expect students to achieve in order to be ready when they leave us uh and so we're going to
015point out a few of those on here and talk about the work that we've done with those uh this school year so one of them is for students to participate in Middle School career exploration courses to identify potential career Pathways based on their aptitudes and interests we have done a lot of work with our sixth and seventh grade students um around a program called pathful explore in that program students um have weekly lessons that include things like interest inventories Career Cluster Explorations short occupational video clips and activities that build their success skills students do this once a week um in their advisory classes in sixth and seventh grade they also can access the pathful Explorer platform any time they want to at home through classlink in addition our eighth grade students um are doing advisory
016lessons uh in YouScience and YouScience is something that helps our students to understand their aptitudes so this is a series of brain games where students actually are learning are they visual processors or are they good at um determining things that are similar and different and it's important that our students understand their aptitudes um because interest alone doesn't help them to find career paths where they're going to be successful so we want students to really understand what they're good at so that they can make connections between what they're good at and the goals that they have moving forward really then um what we want to do is is put those two things together to help them to develop realistic plans new this year and super exciting um we have career Explorations labs in all of our
017middle schools this is a 9 week related arts course that students can take in 6th, 7th, and 8th grade so it's not just something that they're taking one time but they can take it multiple times throughout their Middle School uh time and this is a a Hands-On exploration of technical skills um so students are getting to actually touch real Tools in real world scenarios you can see some pictures here and these are of our students um where they are learning what it's like to hold a baby and feed it or wash it um if they're interested in child development careers they're learning about fire Management Services and how they would um set up a perimeter around a fire if they were a firefighter uh they're doing short um things with uh casting a leg say
018to see if medical field might be of interest to them so it's a rotational model students spend 10 days on each activity um and so each year they are then able to actually put their hands on at least three different career type um activities so that they can really learn what they might be interested in when they get to high school and so really we've set these up so that the programs or the modules that are offered at each Middle School are actually aligned to the modules or the CTE Pathways that are in the high school to make that real seamless connection for students as they move forward so that's brand new this year and really exciting um so those things coupled together YouScience those pathful lessons and then that career Explorations courses will help
019our students to be able to develop ready graduate plans with their school counselors that will help those seamless transitions from our eighth grade into our ninth grade making our students more successful throughout the year in transitioning to the ready grad status the Milestone we are speaking speaking directly to dual enrollment and AP courses next dual enrollment are college courses that are provided at the high school level we partner with various institutions and are able to provide those courses to our high school students uh through the dual enrollment Grant uh you will see here our numbers um our historical numbers with dual enrollment um in from 2022 to 2025 you will see an increase in the number of options available for students that's a good thing and you'll also see an increase in the number of
020student opportunities to take these classes what a total enrollment means for us it doesn't mean that there are 1,600 individual students in these classes it means that these are student opportunities to take these classes so you may have one student taking multiple dual enrollment classes and therefore that student may count three times in this number uh but either way you will see a trend uh moving in the right direction for our students to access early college classes and specifically our dual enrollment Partners um are Austin Peay, Tennessee College of Applied Technology, Nashville State and you will see here UT Martin also advanced placement courses are college level courses available to our high school students um grades 9 through 12 you will see the historical here of the number of of enrollment options for our students
021um has increased over the last three years you will also see that AP exams taken have increased as well as the AP exam pass rate and uh for any one of us that are familiar with AP exams those are very uh difficult um exams to take and that pass rate seeing that increase over the years is a really positive thing for our students as that guarantees them college level credit upon enrollment into a university so that's a good thing also toward our ready graduate Milestones our enrollment into junior Reserve officer training uh program our JROTC program historically our our our schools we have roughly about 1300 students enrolled each year in JROTC that's freshman through senior levels and so you will see this year we have 1288 another piece of this is our industry certification
022attainment um you can see this year we offered or last school year actually we offered more than 30 different industry certifications to our students uh with 1,863 certifications actually earned so that was um an increase uh of almost 700 students earning a certification more than the year prior we also had a 86% pass rate for students who actually sat for certifications that earned them and then moving on up we will see that another ready graduate Milestone as Dr Sucharski mentioned earlier is that ACT score and so supports for ACT in our district we have a plethora of supports for our students we have ACT prep courses we have teacher curriculum resources that are available to teachers on the curriculum Hub we provide as a district practice ACT test for all sophomores and juniors each school
023year so they get to sit in a simulated environment and take a Practice ACT and as a result they get a practice ACT score that would be simulated as if they were getting a Real ACT score and then we also have a CMCSS ACT parent resource where parents can access free resources for their student at home or outside of school and then our district um as provided through the state is offers offers all of our students a senior retake opportunity so all students take as a Tennessee State requirement the ACT and they take it spring of their junior year and as a result um the state allows us to offer a retake opportunity for seniors fall of their senior year so that's another opportunity for our students so we really hope that our students uh
024leave CMCSS with all three of these indicators because if they do they have a competitive Advantage um no matter what they choose to do when they leave us and so work-based learning opportunities um afford our students the the option to really apply what they've learned in real world scenarios we've got a multitude of work-based learning opportunities for students both in traditional high schools and outside of traditional high schools um and so things like our construction students building portable classrooms or our students in cosmetology and barbering actually earning cosmetology licenses and having salon and barber shop Services um or our students in our digital art classes who are doing media art and marketing campaigns for nonprofits um all over the city are examples of times that our students actually get to put their knowledge into um
025real world scenarios in addition we have expanded the number of um work-based learning opportunities that are internships we started a few years ago uh really just in our CMCSS operations department and you can see now the number of um business and industry Partners who've come on board and taken our students in in internship opportunities so that they are uh working with these business partners a few hours a day and then they are attending their classes at TCAT uh in the afternoons to be more prepared when they leave finally we talk about the work ethic distinction um the work ethic distinction is an opportunity for seniors to Showcase that they have learned uh or earned all of the academic Technical and professional skills in one place um you can see that that rubric includes those three
026different categories um and students actually earn points towards each of each of the categories and so there are a total of 40 possible points that a student could earn um and if they earn at least 32 of those points which would be 80% of them then they can earn the work ethic distinction as a senior so that concludes our presentation on goal three which is providing students opportunities to build academic Technical and uh professional skills using the ready grad Milestones questions in this uh enrollment 1601 for the for this school year I know you said that you could take some of those some of those students might have multiple do you know how many students are actually I don't know that off offhand but I do have that data and I would be happy to
027share it with you okay thank you I will get that to you guys okay my my question you said that in the junior year a high school a stu high school student can take the ACT test for for the record I would assume but then the High when they reach the 12th grade they get an option to retake the test which one applies the which one applies the force toward their college career Readiness both the higher score of the two so if a student chooses to take it again and they score higher then they would take the higher score but if they higher score was in 11th grade they get that way yes sir okay that's what I was concerned else okay thank you thank you all right item six EL14 administrative policy review first
028read Mark Nolan good evening you should have in your packet a proposed addition to the board governance policies as you remember Mr Maberry had requested several months ago that we put this on kind of started the ball rolling we went through reviewed policies you know at the board retreat and this is kind of a culmination and this is his proposed addition to the policies which is adding the executive limitation of executive limitation 14 so we wanted you to have it so you had a chance to read it and be ready to discuss it in two weeks so that that's why that so you've got the draft and we'll discuss it in two weeks and and possibly board vote on it or okay anybody questions I guess my question would be if we do have a
029question we should contact you you can contact me yes and and then we'll discuss any questions or details uh next meeting but you can contact me before gotcha okay okay comments from County Commissioners yeah I just uh just wanted to say I really appreciate the um the presentation there especially the part about TCAT I have personal experience with that Ms Constance Brown does an amazing job over there woman that knows every one of her students their strengths their weaknesses really truly cares about them we participated in that program as as a company had an intern it was great for us great for them and uh anything we can do you know at the County Commission or y'all can do at the Schoolboard continue to support that program and grow it would be awesome because we
030are in Desperate in desperate need of uh folks with technical skills plumbers and welders and auto mechanics and truck mechanics and HVAC and appliance repair and it pays really well and uh we need good folks so great program and just I I love it so I just want to encourage us to continue to support that thank you other business um how does a business get on the list to be one of the partners for the work-based learning we can add you just let us know if you'll just if you'll just reach out and let us any business is interested okay um and we can get you in contact with the person who does that work based learning um work and have conversations about where that work fits into our focused elective groups and CTE programs
031can you explain just really quickly um how that works with the business that does the business pay them can you explain that a little bit it can work in a variety of ways it's clearly defined in state law and so um Amy Jackson and Dr Paine can sit down and go through any business and go over that information it's very explicit obviously because kids are involved and lots of training for the teacher to make sure that things are followed through appropriately and so it it's very in depth but we're happy to spend time sharing that information with anybody awesome thank you Jimmie well I just like to say that I wasn't trying to challenge your integrity uh I just had a question and it was in my mind and I just couldn't couldn't leave it
032alone I know that each of you whenever you do whatever you do for the students you do it from the heart uh I can feel it I see it and I have seen it down through the years of the work that you've done and I'm very proud to be a part of this work but if I have a question and if it's deep it might be sound deep to some might sound like I'm trying to intimidate some I don't never try to intimidate anybody but I want you to know that uh I I appreciate you finally giving me an answer that I needed um but that's that's who I am and Dr Luna you have a team that is second to none uh that's the reason why we are level five district today thank you
033okay other business okay it's my turn good evening board members the uh this week was the first week back for students from holiday break and I'm happy to say that we went on time every day um and our Educators have already had students engaged in rigorous lessons as a reminder the application period for the schools and programs of choice will begin on January 15th we want to ensure that families know all about the free opportunities for our students such as our national Blue Ribbon programs at Spanish Immersion Middle College at APSU as well as our K-12 virtual our early technical college at TCAT Moore Magnet STEM as well as nine different High school academies there will also be some open enrollment options based upon Staffing and building capacity uh information has been sent to families
034and we they will have approximately a month um to to complete that application with a deadline of Friday February 14th more information can be found on the website with winter upon us I want to give a special shout out uh to Norm Brumblay and his team despite the fact that we have been able to go on time so far and and some people believe that we have been oblivious to the weather the team has actually been out driving around on roads at all hours and meeting with National Weather Service just to ensure that we are making the best call for students my husband will be happy when the 3:30 a.m. calls stop um but it looks like we may be busy again at the end of this week and uh all of us I know
035are starting to use our meteorology skills so I would like to wish everyone a Happy New Year and I'm looking forward to a strong second semester for CMCSS Mr Lanier this concludes my report okay guess we're adjourned