001good evening everyone today is Wednesday December 11 um it's 6:30 right now we're here at the multi-purpose Center we're going to go ahead and call this meeting to order first roll call Veronica present Rene Peña present Eduardo Ramirez present noi Castillo pres paty Garcia presentent Jesus Al uh Solis presid and basilo presid okay so we have a quorum we're going to stand now for the Pledge of Allegiance by Mr Jesse Solis Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisual liberty and justice for all and now uh followed by an invocation by Mr Peña let's go ahead and bow our heads de only father Lord today we just want to thank you Father for once again Gathering as a rgc g
002family father uh we ask you for your guidance we ask you for wisdom father as we go through this meeting that we always keep s our our children uh first in mind father uh when we make decisions and then our staff father and our families father once again we want to thank you Father that we may hold this meeting and that we may uh come up with uh Solutions father that moved our district forward all things these things we ask in Jesus name amen amen at this time we're also going to um have a moment of Silent for the three young kids adults that we've lost uh from the district so if I can have a moment of silence okay we're going to move on to section four approval of minutes public hearing September 10
0032024 regular board meeting October 15 2024 special board meeting November 18 2024 and special board meeting November 22 202 22 202024 do I have a motion I well move Madam president second and second all in favor uh raise your right hand okay all in favor uh motion passes uh section five public forum do we have anybody nobody signed up let's go on to section six reports and information item number one presentation on departments breakdown of costs for non-campus administrators and non-campus hourly employees compared to tasby recommendations good evening madam president members of the board superintendent schools Miss Morris uh I did have a binder provided for each board member and superintendent so the objective for today Madam president members of the board is is specifically what the what the item reads and we're looking at
004cost for all non-campus personnel which we the item reads admin and hourly which in the memorandums attached in your binder will be referred to as exempt and non-exempt which means exempt means that they're exempt from from the hourly wages and non-exempt meaning they're hourly so just so we we're on the same page with those terms um so like I mentioned the goal today is look at that cost and two compareed to task B recommendations so as you see on Tab one we start off with the cost for central office you see the first thing you see is a memorandum written to superintendent to the board we have all district non-campus Personnel broken up by department and the cost the associated with each department I'll let you sift through it as you can see on p
005on Tab one page three you get the total summarized which is 25 million 77,78 that is the payroll allocated for these departments so this is all non-campus Personnel both hourly and professional as you see on the third page of that tab that comprises of 30% of the total payroll so the total payroll for the entire district is $84,999 293 so what I just presented here is the campus breakdown I'm sorry the department breakdown for all non-campus Personnel is 30% of the total payroll budget that's which is a 25 million correct which is a 25 million Dr this this not does not include stiping overtime yes sir this just annual base salary great Point sir thank you thank you for pointing that out that is correct this is only annual based salary no stiens no overtime
006all payroll expenditures that may fall under that category thank you for pointing out sir that's correct there are any questions I'd like to proceed to tab two so on tab two what we see here is the second part of the item reads in comparison to tasby recommendations as you may know the last board meeting I did present on tasby recommendations as per campus allocations and that's pretty clearcut for one reason you have teachers nurses counselors Librarians all Campus based and those are defined in PS as a teacher nurses counsel Librarians as you come up to central office these positions differ in coding it could be a director could be an assistant soup it can be a chief of this chief of that it could be several coding so as you notice in your memorandum I
007did point out out that tasby themselves in their memorandum on tab two page three mentions that there's several factors involved that can differentiate comparing one District to another or what they call a state comparison so what I'm trying to say is the last board meeting I did I did pass out a tasby recommended criteria for campus Personnel because it's clear-cut a teacher is a teacher a Liberian is a Liberian at the district level you have several factors and I've outlined them for you in that memorandum and the memorandum reads that coding is different throughout the state okay depending on how we can code certain Personnel non-exempt Personnel me might be filling in for a exempt position in District a and vice versa in District B working calendar days which I'll point out in the auxiliary
008breakdown that I have later on in the presentation calendar days are different campus assignments versus a district assignment we may have a position that serves as a district assignment and District B may have it as a campus assignment so these factors i' like you to keep in mind as I proceed with the presentation I wanted to point that out any questions on that and before I proceed to tab three I do want to recommend that I just want to point one thing out that in that same memorandum from tasby they come out and say we recommend 1.6 admin at central office per every thousand kids okay 1.6 for every thousand that that would calculate to 15 central office admin which we know we're past that okay but keeping in mind what I just mentioned with
009the four factors that do skew the data and they do skew the data and I'll show you that in a minute on tab three with the memorandum you see that I have an administrator administrative support breakdown and the item reads that you want to comparison to tasby just mentioned that tasby says follow this but it could be skewed because of these four factors so what you're going to see here moving forward on this presentation is you're going to have the tasby recommendation okay and you're going to have what we call a side by side we created a side by side that's an internal comparison and that internal comparison is you're going to see the years of 202 20 2024 2025 which is this current year you're going to see 2016 2017 and you're going to
010see 2019 19 and 2020 why 16 17 why 19 why 20 because you look at the enrollment the enrollment varies and obviously we hit optimal enrollment at 1617 versus where we're at now so again the second part of the item reads that we want a comparison as per tasby models and we made that clear that that model could be skewed at the district level for those factors that I mentioned so we went ahead and ran a side by side comparing Rand to riand to Rand in several years okay due to enrollment so I want I want you to follow me on that okay so on tab three which is tab three I have the memorandum we have the side by side and the first page on tab three page one this is the side by
011side for all admin okay and you see the 2425 by position titles you see the 16117 I've included the enrollment for 2425 is 9,315 for 16 17 we were at 10,460 and 1920 we were at 10,193 and the first page basically the first page you see a a title of a position was that position in 167 no was it here in 1920 no so this is an internal model in compar comparing to in the past with those snapshots gives you a total of 47 positions that are here now that weren't here in 1617 and it continues on tab three page two you start seeing no yes which means in 1617 that position was not here and it was in 1920 and if there's no questions with the internal model you shift over to tab two
012tab three I'm sorry tab three page three I'm sorry let me ask a question yes sir the 47 additional positions that did not exist prior to 2019 20 2020 16 2017 those are 47 additional positions at an average salary of 880,000 average average it could be more it could be a little less yes correct and then at the bottom it says other 17 additional positions at also an average of 80 80,000 yes if What What In in essence Mr P what you do is you subtract the 17 from the 47 because we're comparing those two years so it's 30 but if you look at it holistically from 16 it's 47 yes sir Mr s let me ask you I know you're giving us comparisons here I know we got grants left and right how many
013positions are considered administrative that are Grant funded and that we have additional because we got grants that that that's a good question sir the only thing I included then that handout are you exactly right where s are funded the ones in yellow highlighted in yellow because I know we have the last two Grant and we have several grants where we have uh different Specialists and directors and I I I believe we got several millions of dollars and we have Administration which the grants basically allowed for basically right so my my just question is any ideas how many of those are Grant funded yes sir I I don't have that that's a great question sir I I'll get that for you and the only issue the only issue with that is they might have been Grant
014started initiated but then when the grants they're not perpetual and when the grants are no longer here they're still on salary that was actually one of my concerns with I was uh speaking with Miss Morris yesterday about trying to find grants for uh mental health and so then they said there was a you know a grant there was some money and then my first question was okay but wait a minute because what's going to happen when we hire this we're talking with Miss marisel about it when we hire a new LPC under a grant and then we run out of the grant money and we're left with these employees so that's something that us as a board we have to see for the future and sometimes it seems easy oh we can we can get
015this money use it but we always have to think ahead and see what's going to happen once that Grant um is done and over you know so yes we do need to look into that but I think that we need to be very try to get as much money from Grants as possible but always with the mentality of being resp responsible and knowing what's going to happen ahead can we maintain those uh employees after the grant money is over or are we going to have another Grant coming and replacing the one that we had yes ma'am and even if we take the 30 an additional salary at an average salary of 80,000 that's 2.4 million correct year every year yearly correct that's re that's requring cost yes sir and that's if I'm not mistaken I
016know I don't want to put you on the spot but I believe this is not including Fringe either not including friende either which is TRS health insurance much less typin overtime corre etc etc if there any further questions on that there's a tab three page three this is where we get the tasby model we talked about but keep in mind those four factors we talked about possibly skewing um there's 20 I'm sorry there's uh let me see there's this is the comparison we used was Los Fresnos and cherland ISD due to enrollment and there's 23 administrative positions that we compared them to and you'll see on the breakdown um this is as close as we can get to that state model that they're talking about this is really a survey that we use for salaries
017across the state but we did I did include it because the item does read comparison to task be recommendations I want to be clear about that so you do see that there's 23 that we found comparable and for the most part if you have you know one director for a usually another district has one director for that so that's pretty clearcut you'll see a difference in the PA professionals and auxiliaries in just a minute I don't know there's any I know there's quite a few I don't know if you want to sift through them or you have any question through it's really sad to see that in for example the licensed specialist in school psychology we have two San Benito has three Sheran has five so there we're under staffed or we don't have what
018we need but then in um Child Nutrition we have four and then Shar has two and so and we go on and on director of Fine Arts G has two sanito and sherland have one so it's it is I'd like to point out just a couple things Dr B thank you for mentioning that just like on the Child Nutrition I know we we've added supervisor but we do have a a spending plan that we have you know they they have a very healthy fund balance and one of the initiatives we had we did add Administration and later on in the presentation you're going to see auxiliary but you see a high spike in number because it part of that ending plan we did hire um uh campus um cafeteria managers assisant cafeteria managers so that
019number even though they're CNP funded which is a good thing because we need to it skews a number saying Hey we've added x amount of auxiliary which I'll show you in a minute so it could happen here too that maybe those districts I didn't look into their fund balance for Child Nutrition but it could be an issue that we have a good problem they might not have the same thing I'm not sure on that and with the directors with the with the fin Arts has pointed out I know there we do have one director and the other the other individual is not a director but they're classified because like I'm saying in this this tasby recommendation is is done for salary purposes Mr Salas say for example we're talking the cafeteria isn't the C cafeteria
020people more or less s funded already because they generate their own money yes sir that's correct so basically they don't they have their own funds they don't hit the district correct yeah that's correct it would also be a fact like we have special AED don't they don't we get uh for example charge monies from Special Ed and things of that nature yes sir let's say career technology don't we get three times of weight plus plus uh Transportation that's correct for student yes so there are certain programs that generate money and there's other programs that don't generate money maybe that's what I'm trying to get it correct yes sir and and just with the with the lssp as you mentioned the special ed over the years and I I can't give you exactly how many we've
021graduated from outside contractual Services which are expensive in nature and brought those services inhouse so we do have two we did want to add a third one and you cut that outside contract so that's where we're phasing it out so I you know having the two I believe is is positive in nature for curriculum we have 13 staff when other districts have one or two so I did noticed that on the directorships our response to when we had the survey was that we have the directors not the way I understood it when I saw that for example it says District a has one curriculum director it could be specific to curriculum director as far as my response was we have directors under the curriculum Department if it made sense what I just said we do
022have several directors under the C cni department and when I saw one for district A and B I figured they answered one director for specifically curriculum I guess it's easier to explain with my department if I would have a director for HR then that director specifically HR and we have multiple departments under cni or directorship so did we have less admins when we have more students that is correct we have more admin with uh and and the number there that I I I added in the first Miss Garcia I think it's on page if you look on tab three page one you do see a decline with the side by side model that we created with the district we have minus 1,145 kiddos yeah in the last presentation the same thing we address the same
023thing where our numbers of students is going down yet our administrators is going up so that's a big problem yes Dr s has the other issue I see is the side-by-side comparison I know it's 2016 2017 2019 2020 but if we bring realistic the numbers have dropped even more student population yes and I think the number of positions or whatever the list we're looking at stayed the same and not increased correct am I correct that is correct sir let me ask when we first started Gua high school we had about 100 kids right yes sir and we're down to 700 in South cor 700 so decreases in population exists everywhere I think it's not but it's Statewide yeah no was telling me for uh certain schools we shutting down schools two two districts in Houston
024we're setting down five and five schools so I think decreases in population why that is I don't know but everybody's decreasing in populations look a lot of charter schools ideas coming in um so yeah but we need to you know go with with with the trend we need to go keep up with what's happening and not continue to hire more and more administrators if we're seeing that we're losing kids to all these other options because if not we're going to have to eventually one day we won't be able to function anymore so on the next tab tab four memorandum we address the side by side SL District model for our par professional groups and you can see on Tab four page one there's an article that I chose to to include for the board and
025tasby just gives a recommendation on what they feel that District clerical models should look like and we fall under the three clerical staff at the district level per th000 kids which gives us approximately 25 clerical positions um at the district level non-campus and as you can see on Tab four page two that is a list of our clerical staff and we're at 41 okay and right behind that number of that the positions we have for the district you see the district side by side comparison and it's the same I use the same years duut to enrollment to keep it consistent and over from 16 to now we've grown by 10 10 clerks at the district level and if I include it's the same enrollment because I'm using the same snapshots for that internal comparison and
026if there's no questions on that side by-side internal comp uh side by-side comparison you look on Tab four page eight and we found five comparables to Los Fresnos and sherland this is your tasb model that we keep referring back to I'm going to keep going back and forth from the tasby recommendation to the internal model for those three years I don't know is there any questions on that by no means I mean to speed you up I know it's a lot of information but so you're the expert in this m dradio um to wrap this up in just plain terms what is your opinion on on all this that you're showing us just your opinion what's going on with our district so um from being there at the department and seeing what I've seen I
027believe that we had a charter move into our community 2012 we had an opportunity because that Charter grew by grade levels so it was not a full-blown District per se the charter grew by grade levels each and every year about 200 250 kids if I remember correctly it was in 2012 and then we had this large covid situation that hit us and hurt us to get back on track with enrolling kids and getting kids to come back to school attendance still struggling proud to say that I think Rand is one of the highest attendance rates in the in the region one if I'm not mistaken now the charter is a full-blown campus and to wrap it up didn't act accordingly and our staffing doesn't match the trend so as we saw that Charter come in
028we didn't we didn't do anything about it we kept hiring and hiring and hiring I would be comfortable to say yes ma'am because of the comparison from 2016 to now so sitting here it's a big responsibility that we have because we're coming into this with already a big problem which is overstaffing at the administrative level um and it's it's it's it's sad that we're the ones that are now up here having to deal with this problem um but I wanted to hear it from you because you're human resources you're the person that does the the hiring you're the one that knows the numbers knows you know all this information and so I think that the community needs to understand that the problem and one of our problems is that we have over Staffing in the
029administrative level correct Dr Salas and do we have some options to try to level this the the first option I would recommend Miss Garcia is of course by attrition is what attrition as soon as a POS someone retires or someone leaves or trans aners then we need to close that position and condense departments to maybe what we see in the 2016 snapshot condense departments as you see in the 2016 snapshot some of us that were around you know you you in a department and you had multiple duties under you that's that's an option for attrition and so for all these people that you know hopefully people are watching these meetings um there's a lot of people that say oh you know we want the work we want to you know we want different positions um
030you know that they come to you I always refer everybody you know talk to Dr Salinas he's the one in charge of all that um I think that it's it's time that they understand that we're trying to survive right now it's not that we don't want to hire people as a district that we want to help out you know our community with more opportunity job opportunities but right now we're um in survival mode and I think that that's important for all of us was to understand um as a board you all our employees and all the community to understand that right now we're um in survival mode we basically need to freeze we need to not hire any new people um for now and like I think I spoke to you about who you were
031hiring and it would be people that have degrees with math science because those we need teachers that are actually uh certified in those areas but other than that the district is in in no capacity to hire you know more administrators or any other pretty much any other employee that is correct how many administrators are we over stopped by number more or less that's a tough question Mel because I I've looked at this tasby model which has some to me it's skew data because of different factors that we talked about then we looked at we look at the internal so if I would have to give you a hard number I would say 47 because of the 2016 model where we're at 10,600 kiddos and if we had the staff operating at that function um but
032I do want I I do want to make it clear that and I mentioned this at the campus level that there is a lot of Staffing patterns with grants there's uh philosophies on how we're going to do initiatives come up you know right now the district is dealing with a tough situation with our kiddos we might have to do something to create a new Department I'm not saying we're going to but that might have to happen so there's different initiatives that happen since 2016 so there's a lot of factors involved aside from just saying we're hiring people okay um I I do agree that we are on survival mode but I I I want to hold that back because I believe that as a community as a district we do need to stand up and
033say hey kiddos we're here for you I mean we're not going to Echo that do we need to hold off on hiring yes ma we do but there's so many factors that come into play when you hire somebody or when you have an initiative when there's a grant when things just you know are are needed to be addressed and sometimes they have to be addressed at the district level so I would have I would ask to keep that in mind but if I had to answer that question sir I would say 47 but then again grants come to an end so it's like Dr B was saying earlier once that Grant is over what do we do with a staff that is running that Grant and what I understand is that we move people to
034run grants and the vacancy they left behind prior to that we fill that vacancy with somebody else correct so we can't set that send that individual that when that Grant finishes we're not able to send that individual back to her original place of employment because it's already been uh taken over by someone else that is correct sir am I correct that is correct now if I'm not mistaken a big thing when you when you start a grant initiative you you're looking to not only take in the Personnel but you also want to continue that initiative you got to find a way to continue that initiative because obviously it's being piloted for a reason and if it's working and especially if it's helping the kids then you want to absorb not only the staff but the
035initiative so that's it's a it's a let me ask when we first started our PD we got a cops Grant and they and we write in our PD the cops ran ran out and we contined with a with a with a police department correct that is correct sir and if I may I I don't want to be the bear of bad news but somebody's got to say it we also have and this is to the board uh tea also allows us this is this is a bad word in education it's a bad word in in any public entity but it's called a reduction in force so so if the district can show that we have lowered our uh enrollment which we have if the district has can show that we're not being properly funded which
036we're not then the district the school district can apply to the bad word an R RI which is a reduction and force that means that all administrators contracts term contracts would basically become null and void but that's an extreme uh uh that's an extreme you know right side but I do have to say it cuz I do have an obligation to my client the board and the school district to let you know that there is another more crucial option that again that's something that the board has to deal with and you've got to look at the at the at the numbers but I I do believe that this is at least a good start that we're letting everyone know administrators part in particular that we are topheavy so I do have to say that because
037I think I'd be remiss if I didn't tell the board that that is one of the options thank you all right any other questions concerns comments discussion all right so we'll move on thank you Dr Salinas thank you ma'am we'll move on to item two updated report on bond projects [Music] good evening word president members of the board superintendent um this item I will be giving you an update on the bond series 2021 construction projects and the first slide you will find the construction projects for proposition a and so under proposition a we had the guya middle school the cafeteria distribution warehouse Fort wringle Renovations career and Technology Editions Buzz barn expansion hbac districtwide Roofing districtwide Fort wringle Paving and school buses so basically uh the top priority under this proposition was the new guya
038middle school and so the original budget under the bond was 36,200 th000 and the bid came out or uh the original bid had come up at45 uh million and it was negotiated down to 41.5 million and so we do have an estimated cost of $4,743 and that's basing including architect fees uh engineering fees clearing of the land Etc so uh as of November the 30th we have expanded 37 m359 ,000 from that uh proposition we have also amended some of the other propositions into guya middle school because that was a top priority and again the bid had come up above what had been proposed to the taxpayers then we have the cafeteria distribution warehouse and the original W budget was $3 million and we have expended $3.1 million there Fort wringle Renovations $250,000 and we
039expended $238,000 the career and Technology additions were budgeted or we as the taxpayers for $2 million but the cost was at $3.5 million and so we also use some of the other uh projects within that proposition to cover that cost and so as of of November the 30th we have a balance of $276,000 which is to pay the rest the bus barn expansion 300,000 we haven't um started or completed that project agback districtwide $1.5 million was the original budget and so we expended $278,000 throughout the district and we moved from that propos or from that project we moved about 1.2 $ million to the other projects Roofing districtwide $1.5 million was the original budget and we expended $513,000 Roofing uh for roofing throughout the district and so we moved about $986,000 to cover the other
040projects Fort wringle Paving original budget $550,000 and we expended $63,500 $ so we also use some of the other projects uh to cover that total cost and finally we had school buses for $1.7 million we expended 1.2 and we also took about $512,000 to cover the other projects that I mentioned any questions right there uh di really quick I know that the original budget for the GU Middle School was a 362 and it ended up costing 415 .5 yes just the construction now how are we how are we fixing to cover the difference between the 36 milon2 200,000 and the 41 mil 500,000 well as I mentioned we're covering 952 th000 from the other projects within proposition a but we also uh sought funding additional funding and at the beginning we were using sr3 to
041cover it uh also uh we had start funding for the Performing Arts Center and so at the end it was decided to use all of Esser in order to continue with a project with a new g guya Middle School uh Administration uh and the board felt that the we had we had already promised the taxpayers that we were going to get uh gura middle school and so that is why that decision was made so basically the additional funding is coming from Esser how however at the end we decided to use erer to cover salaries because of the requirements audit requirements for construction projects under federal funds and so that's what we're doing that's what sther 3 was the original intention to use it for the construction I believe that the last conversation we had uh
042between us uh there was U going to be have we're going to have to take out some money from the general fund to be able to cover the cost for Gan Middle School am I correct or was that was I was actually it was a wash off um the only effect that that decision is going to have on the tunal fund is on the timing of the payment so basically last year uh where we just closed the year we reclassified salaries from general fund to Esser so general fund that's why we saw a small increase in our fund balance last year so this year general fund will cover whatever erer covered last year for en fund salaries was that the 7 million or yes yes ma'am 7 million from general fund right let me ask
043for because of in eer you put 77.5 million $7 million from eer into salaries yes and then after you did that then you took it out to pay for the from the general fund back to the school but it's a wash because it's it's eer to here and here to the building yes so the effect on the general fund but it still put us in a deficit of seven 7 million yes but not because of the gam school I just want to make that clear erer helped for the construction but instead because I felt that we were not going to met the requirements if we were audited by tea since uh the contractor had said since you're using Federal funding and we were requiring them to have certified payrolls from their subcontractors they mentioned the
044cost might go up and so we just did not want that and then I did not want to have the risk used the what was we kind of shouldn't have used the ERS because of the the legality if we wouldn't have known since the very beginning that we were going to use eser before we went out for bids and we would have disclosed that to the contractors well then the bid would have come up higher and so we S as funding for the construction after we went for the bid so the contractors were not aware and I was afraid that if we were audited by tea under eer 3 and under the construction they would disallow the cost completely so instead of using those $7.5 million for something else and we were not even going
045to be able to use them for construction we were just going to lose that money and so that is what why I had made that U recommendation to use general fund for construction and aser for salaries which is a safer best we could do yes okay so right now 7 million we are in deficit additionally to what we were like our general fund yes so just I just want to clarify because people do not understand these things they think that our our budget fund balance is doing great and and last meeting we said it and now I want to make sure that everybody understands there's reasons yes there's reasons but they need to understand that our general fund is another 7 million now in De yes okay um um the fund balance could have been
046lowered last year because of this let me ask a couple of questions when the bond issues were passed didn't construction because of uh covid didn't they almost double in price yes sir in other words the estimates that they had gotten for the everything we gotten was $200 something a square foot 240 250 and after Co it went $450 a square foot more or less let me ask another question the reason you know correct me I'm wrong the problem we're having today is losing students in our district correct that's what's hurting us more as far as fund balances and and how how much money we have is that we're losing hundreds of kids every every year correct right enrollment has gone down Ada and so but at the end of the day the the citizens themselves
047approved a an original Bond budget for 36 million not for 41 million right thank you and I know uh Mr Peña is in charge of these projects can can you please give give us a little bit more of details on this Mr Mr paa thank you good evening Miss president board members uh Miss Morris what questions might you have Miss can you give us more details Okay g Middle School at this time m' uh is way ahead uh of their construction I do have uh exact figures as to what percents the cafeteria and the Fine Arts building is 98% complete already uh so that's very close to 100% then we have a building seven the seventh grade Hall that one is 70% and so is the eighth grade Wing that's 70% already completed then we
048have the gymnasium that one is uh 50% completed and then we have the administration that one is the very one in the very front but that's the last one that they've been working on so that one is still at believe at a 35% what would be the estimated time to finish the the contract date is May 11th of 2025 thank you Mr B I can I ask a couple of questions number one the old guya or maybe I can ask Mr how old is the old guya middle school that old middle school with the elementary is back from 1956 56 uh and the the new edition of the of the Middle School the the front part I believe the last Edition was in 1979 if I'm not mistaken I think it was earlier than that
0497274 was in 70s yeah and the bottom line is that you ever go look at those facilities at at at that school they're they're very correct me I'm very dilapidated they're they're in terrible shape and I think the the kids from Lya Middle School deserve a middle school but uh I let me ask one last question Mr P haven't construction costs even gotten higher from the from the bid dat to right now what imagine correct yes sir while we were working through uh you know after the bond uh when we went out on uh the different bids you know contractors Architects kept telling us it's going to there's going to be a time that it's going to plateau and then it might go down we never saw that you know even to today prices continue
050to go up and that is why we're faced and every time we were going out on bids I'll give you an example and and I know we're not on the Aquatic but it's one of the bond projects like the Aquatic you know we had gone for 10 million and then 2 million for the wrestling and we started looking at that but during those months months that's when prices went up drastically so we had to Halt the planning and we had to go back to the board and administration and discuss okay what are we going to do are we going to still be looking at what we're proposed or because of prices increasing are we going to try to consolidate and build one so at that time you know we met with the architect and others
051to give us recommendations and there was no way we're going to be able to build two different at two high schools uh because of inflation because of the numbers uh going back also to gura middle school if you've been out there you know the kids are exposed to increment weather you know a lot their buildings are individual so every time there's cold weather rainy weather you know uh thunderstorms the the students either they have to keep them back and lose instructional time or let them go out so you know Mr paa was there as a principal and that's long overdue so you know as a school board and administration I'm glad that we all went forward to build the school but now we have some obstacles that we really have to you know try to
052address and we did address it like Miss robas mentioned through erer we Tred to save those 7 million but unfortunately the timing wasn't there last year we were hoping that we would get construction but then there was a delay instead of starting in March we didn't start till June July you know and it delays kept going on but then again I go back to square one the the citizens of our district approved the 36 .2 not a $41.5 million budget am I correct yes or you're correct on that but the kids and staff do deserve a new building they deserve it but I think that we can always um give them what they deserve you know within budget we had the Bud closer to budget we had it with esis but unfortunately the timing they
053the state gave us we have emails Miss roess has giving us the okay uh then they set up a deadline of September 24 I Believe Miss 2024 and we had to expedite use all of those funds by that time I understand so right now I guess what's what we're trying to discuss it's not whether the guran middle school was needed or not I think it was I really really am glad that if we did something it was this uh I got pictures in the past two three years of horrible conditions and they needed a new school I I agree um I disagree with you know a little bit of sometimes you have to stay within budget or as close as possible uh but right now it's mainly to make everybody understand that why we're in
054this uh deficit okay it's it's not we're not questioning uh that we needed that school I think we can all agree that that it was needed and it's needed and I'm glad that it's getting done uh but mainly so that everybody understands is that because of you know certain decisions and certain things that were done now we have a $7 million additional deficit and so that's all right now I don't know if anybody else has any any questions comments concerns pretty much the same thing it's just the way you know the people said yes we do need a new one no one's arguing that part that's actually a good thing yes with with what you mentioned it's just a matter of you know now robbing Peter to pay Paul is creating additional uh strains on
055what what we have to face and that's that's I heard 7th grade 70% 8th grade 70% sixth grade was there a little below that sir a little bit below that yes sir gymnasium 50% Administration still 35% so there's still some work to be done there yes sir obviously with with what we coming up here and the cost going up and all these things I know the bid is already set but are we going to be seeing any additional U surprises you know with this with these things still not finished I don't know I'm actually curious now thank you there is a contingency fund so M robes can let us know how much is left in that area I know there's some change orders coming up tonight uh those are unforeseen as we're going through the
056project uh as any other project but uh you know we do have a contingency so hopefully it'll cover thank you thank you Mr P you're welcome thank you so the now the uh proposition B so under proposition B uh we had the swiming complex which we had an original budget of $10 million and so um this is combined with a wrestling complex under Proposition E so um for the at the beginning we were going to have two one for Rio high and one for guya high and so we have expended 416,000 for the Rio high and gurua high 358,000 that's mainly architectural fees and then we have the rgc jsd swimming complex the one that was Consolidated that was being worked on for the one that is going to be here or was going to
057be here at Fort Ringold and so we have expended $358,000 mainly also AR architectural fees and Engineering fees and so we have a a balance under this proposition of 8,866 th000 and this is all an architectural plans yes what we have expended yes do we have those plans available to see or to see what the is here also but we do have the pl Sir Mr Canto or Mr Lopez Mr Lopez do you know anything on those plant for the swimming complex Mr yes madame president members of the board uh Miss Morris yes we do have the plans okay sir I'm sorry just for my information uh who was in charge of these projects when the bond started uh Mr adolo Peña oh in okay yes thank you okay now originally uh Jita it was
058was a swimming and a wrestling complex at both high schools am I correct yes and then we went down to one to one right now currently we're just building one swimming nitorum and one wrestling Center yes a swimming wrestling complex here at the fort at the Fort Ringle so the ones that real high G high are scrapped right so yeah it's important that people also understand that because they were promised something but then now because of the situation circumstance now we're only having to do one which will be the for ring and so the estimated cost uh 16,6 and this is included the highest bid of $15 million and then architectural fees engineering fees soil testing Etc are we going to any other costs uh from the fund balance to pay off the the the
059project well right now we're over the budget total over over the total budget so how much well it's we have 8.8 million here and then in and the cost is Proposition E we have 1.3 million left so we're about five we don't have enough to cover the cost no no sir no we have not but that's the estimated cost yes and those 5 million that we're missing would be just for the rgc GISD swimming complex or that includes the wrestling facility like to get combined no it's 16 for both the combined for both yes the problem again uh is inflation I know that when they got these Bond issues it was $250 a square foot and it went to $450 a square foot and I believe that at the at the at the time uh
060we just couldn't afford it correct right the problem we have today is I guess and I'm going to keep saying it over and over again is we're losing students to tune of hundreds of students every year and that's what's really hurting all the projects everything we've done and and one thing I have to add CU I always do add to that is that I understand inflation I understand all this but there are districts out there also suffering from Charter Schools also suffering from inflation and they are still finishing their bond projects so I really my opinion is that I think we when we propose these bonds I personally think that we went too low uh when we when we propos them more when we ask for the money and we should have you know you
061whenever you're going to build a house you don't ask for just what you need you you foresee issues you foresee inflation you foresee and you ask for a little bit more because there's always going to be something that could you might need more dirt we might need more of this you might need something and so I think that's my opinion and that's all I have to say about that that I think we it's a past it's done but we need to learn from our mistakes and our past I think part of part of the equation is the loss of the students part of the of that equation the other part is remaining static or increasing the I'll be honest if we were to build the gria middle school right now we'd pay an extra3 to4
062million the prices keep going up but what I'm saying is on payroll and all that that part that prong that that well the pr is hurting us what hurting us we're losing students so we right what I'm saying that's part of the equation the other part is maintaining or static so this just yeah exactly keeps widening exactly I'm not saying about inflation I'm saying about you know no no I'm talking about the loss of students the administration's here teachers everything and we're losing students so we're getting less money and less money and less money okay we've lost the allotment for the students also like we had nothing has gone up for 5 years so we've been been getting the same amounts of money so all that affects how much we get funded and I know
063we're talking about um like said from the past but you know uh what are we going to do going forward I know we're talking a lot about the past it's done you know the board's made decision along with the recommendation of staff and it's already done and over with what are we going to do next you know um you guys have the majority and you know the plan would be the what we're going to do be doing next and just not only focus on the past but there's a lot of good stuff that's come out of the past too you know our students have done great our teachers our staff you know that hasn't been highlighted we're just looking at the numbers and I know why you're why we're doing it because you want people
064know what's going on but what's the we could be here for two hours discussing this and you know I think uh you know what's ahead of all this is there a plan you know what's the conversations for educating us on what's going on because even I didn't know some of this information uh Mr Soliz I know in the first meeting asked me Veronica I'm not comfortable um uh accepting some of these uh voting on some of these subjects because I do not know about the bonds I want information Miss py same thing uh so this is what we're doing first we're coming in right now we really can't do too many changes but what we can is learn they're explaining to us how all this works the bonds the uh projects that we have yes
065we're we're saying that there's mistakes uh that we're going to learn from them but after this then we move on but we we have to understand what's going on we have to know what's going on so that we can have a plan and move forward if we don't understand what's happening behind how do we plan for the future I understand that um I know that uh all you guys have long days also we could have a workshop if that's what it would entail and then you could bring this back uh in a newsletter what would happen or what was put out there um there's there's a lot of questions from the community with these bonds you I'm serious there's a lot of people that ask but what's going to happen to the N ter every
066day somebody and what's going to happen with this and what's going to happen people want to know we can't do these workshops on our own and just have the answers within people need to understand what's going going on they need to know why it's not getting done why it is what where it's coming from and that's why we're doing this the truth be told is that inflation hit us hard uh nobody could have predicted a pandemic and that's really where we got caught and now we can when when they did the estimates an architect came and gave us some good estimates and but everything doubled the other thing that happens and I think we hit it right on the numbers when's the last time we got an increase in our allotment for students 219 correct
067219 think about it 219 construction cost were $250 219 we haven't gotten a penny from the state since the year 219 it's tough everything's much more expensive these days you I know that other school districts were comparing they're losing they're closing elementary schools and uh kind of redistricting and doing other things due to the same issue that we're having here and that's North Texas that's all the all over the uh the place so you know uh we as a board have uh fallen into uh issues and problems as go decisions are made and as we go forward we're going to continue to have those issues in different aspects of what happens you know we've seen what's going on throughout the country uh with violence and everything else you know we have to shift and we
068are shifting as to what's going on and I think that that uh something that we really need to focus on moving forward and you know um a lot of these questions could be asked about um or answered by staff and you know I think uh if uh the the community wants to they need to know what's going on I agree you know um but I think uh there's things that happened in the past that we just uh need to move forward on and see what the solution for that is and that's just my under the rug under the rug no and at the end of the day you know I think that regardless of how we look at it it's impacting student learning I mean it doesn't matter how you look at it we're we're
069we're in a we're in a deficit where we can't provide the best quality education because we're in deficit you know because we have to be conscious that we can't go spending like crazy anymore uh we have to be very conscious what to invest in and I think that the most important thing is our children okay so we move forward to Proposition C so Proposition C we have the Performing Art Center in which the original budget was $7.4 Million I'm sorry about the typo there uh and we have expended $856,000 and that's basically also um architectural Fe and some soil testing uh we have a balance of $6.5 million and the estimated cost provided by the architect the last time was at $19.5 million for that did the previous board have any ideas I remember in
070one of our board meetings Mr paa um I asked what were our options with to the Performing Arts Center I know they spoke about renewing the auditorium then making a smaller performing art and then he said he would take it out to the Architects and bring back some ideas of what we could do Mr Bea do you recall was any of that done do youall that talk we had yes ma'am you had requested so we got an architect to come and look at the building here the old Auditorium Ford wringle Auditorium um and they have recommendations but every time we ask an architect it's going to be costing us and they're going to be charging us on the bond so at that time there was no more further discussion on it okay and I like
071to go back to the Aquatic we do have Mr moika here he has a presentation he has some slides but I do want to let the board know that we went out on bids but we never awarded so that that project is still on hold the bid was not awarded for the swiming Aquatic and wrestling Aquatic and wrestling and there's still decisions that can be made you know uh the full amount that they gave you includes enclosed includes uh air conditioning you know uh if you want to lessen the cost then you would consider other some of those options now that that estimate was done when when was that estimate done for the 15 million on the Aquatic on the Aquatic yes let me pass it on to it's been a while so I'm just
072curious good evening members of the board my name is Juan Mika I'm with the senior project manager with gentic Architects for the benefit of the new board members uh that estimate originally I think we started about it was 7 million for each high school we merged it together we were about 12 million for the combined project that was right here great um but that happened I'm going to say about maybe almost two years ago right and I don't know if you I mean you guys you keep talking about but I I will say real quick I don't want to kill the dead horse raw materials price of gas Freight labor force suppliers subcontractors general contractors all those going to play into the cost of construction and every one of those has had an increased cost
073and continues to increase their cost and so we hear of changes increases we heard of of increases in January that were upcoming in May and they were projecting it again in December for the following year and they continue to go we thought that after Co come 21 we were going to Plateau we said how much more can you charge everybody's finding a way to charge some more and and we don't control it it's all over the it's a global issue it really affects every public entity in the nation and and the further we are from the raw materials the more it's going to cost and that's part of our problem as well I just want to say that but I hope I answered your question the quote right now would be the same if not
074more oh if I were to give you an estimate right now i' I'd be I'd be afraid to but I'll give you an example I did an estimate for a project in city of Harlington and I thought it was being silly I estimated $475 a square foot and this is two years ago two years ago we had seven bids from contractors from L to um Brownsville seven of them the lowest bid came in at $700 a square foot that was a l bit The Higher One came in at 955 so right now we would not be able to build it for the 12 million that abolutely not the bids that we received in may we got two of them and uh we asked him to hold the price for 90 days we've s surp passed
075that we're like at six or seven months now right now so I I seriously doubt that the contractor and not just the contractor but the subcontractor would be unable to hold those prices not so much them it's a supplier because they have to get materials from suppliers and those prices are going up so basically what the 12 million right now would not cover what we're right now well it doesn't the bid that came in was a 15 yeah Mr yes sir can I ask before Co hit what were the prices per square foot before they hit before all this mess or all uh in 2019 you were right they they were just under $200 a square foot I would tell you you know High School would cost you more simply because they probably like 225
076yeah basically for the old prices in 219 we could have built both pools at both schools oh absolutely yes without a doubt without a doubt that's not the only thing you know things have changed you know we used to purchase patrol cars for $30,000 there $65 5,000 now and that was prior to co and this is after Co so it's not only buildings it's h it's everything that's around there so that's something that not controllable and the decision had to be made at some point right but uh it's gotten up it's supposed to go down it like you said Mr it hasn't gotten down so that is an issue and a problem that uh you know is not going to be sustainable in the future regardless you know I don't know how you're going to
077buy a police car for the patrol officers for 70 80,000 you need 10 of those imagine that's just vehicles and equipment and you know buildings and construction and it's just getting ridiculous so it is I I would advise everybody go talk to your uh you know your elected officials and tell them to push this for funding or you know how how to get uh money to do this because it's going to get uh more complicated as we move forward and you know these are the decisions need to be made in the future and uh they're hard to do because there's other things that uh that need to be taken care of also I will say m president I was asked to bring a presentation that I presented back in in March one of our Cardinal
078rules and jic architect is to not make an order fall in love with something they can't afford but I'll be happy to show you the the presentation if you'd like to see yet uh I think it's here but it's it's up to you again I don't want basically this presentation was done in March our con construction documents were finished at the end of April we went out to bid and we pushed this back because originally we had trouble getting contractors to to attend our preconstruction meetings but again it's it's it's just enough I was asked to bring it it's here I don't want to burn you more again I don't want to get excited about something we simply can't afford right now but it's your call that's why I'm here whatever you like well thank
079you for being here but I think that we sorry we we don't have the money yeah I I understand that I um so yeah I think I had asked them time back if with that Bond money could we give it back you know if we're not building and I think we're paying interest on it correct like on this money we're not we're making oh we're making interest okay but uh I think we get penalized if we give it back so right now what I'm thinking about is doing a committee just for Bond projects and have people from the community some experts people that work with bonds meet with us um and find a plan and have the community also involved and and see what is it that they want you know what can can we
080make it smaller do does a community want to spend money on making another architect uh draw up a smaller plan um finding other resources I don't know if they're available from the city I know that there was a Performing Arts Center from somewhere in the valley that they combined City and the school district because they're both going to be using it if they could help us it would be the same thing for the for the nitorum if we could combine and and they' use the facilities as well as us so there's there's there has to be options um but I think that I well not think I will propose that we do a committee for Bond projects uh so that we can communicate with the public and we can go on with this because this
081is a big issue with our district and so I think that that would be the best thing for now to um set up a committee have some members some experts sit in there um weekly monthly meetings and uh develop a plan and and implement it yeah well we are ready to sit down with you guys and and look at options and and look at possibilities I will tell you that what we design is pretty bare bone I mean we we we knew the budget was tight from the get-go and so we were designing as such we made revisions we cut back wherever we we could but it's pretty bare Bon but to have a functional Aquatic Center you need certain equipment and that's very costly and so that's part of the issue as well specialized
082equip I'll apologize for having you here tonight we asked Mr call you but we thought we were getting an aquatic center for 12 million yeah I apologize for that too I knew that wasn't going to happen a long time ago but that's that's you know you always you can to you can throw the the coin oh anyways but I'm here to help we're here to help so again the when whatever the the board wants to do we we'll make ourselves available to offer our experience and and offer whatever options we can thank you so much for being here you're well welcome proposition D and that's for the Joe R Sanchez Stadium we started with a budget of $1.8 million and we have expended 1.7 million so we have a balance of $96,000 there what's the
083plan I'm sorry with those $96,000 does that include the restroom renovation and things like that or something I believe that's what um yes yes yes is that it just the restroom Renovations or anything else yes I think that's what it's the that's the only thing that you're pending right good evening ma'am yes uh that's the only the project that's pending but based on the fund balance that's left there uh we have I think Mr Chris and the district went out on bids twice already and he's got some numbers% down the line on the agenda but yes that is the only project that's pending based on the money that's left over and it's way over I'm sorry and the bids way over this I I believe that there's the lowest bid is under the the amount
084that's left on the budget 58 58 or 56 58 correct if I Rec correct 8,000 the lowest bid the only thing I'm going to recommend rate I know that when they start projects like that uh there's a lot of change orders that come along uh as they're moving on with the project just make sure that we stay under budget under the the the 0 I agree it's a small project it's a renovation it's a building that's already existed it's existing there uh and just again to kind of bring it up to Power replace the roof all the toiletries uh ceiling tiles everything that needs to be replaced we need it because it's it's in bad shape only they come up with change orders they change orders you change orders and it ends up costing you
085more than what is actually available for you to to spend on I agree we'll stay within budget yes let me ask a question but all change orders have to come to the board correct correct we're the ones that ultimately have to approve so no change orders can happen unless the board approv Ramirez do we have the breakdown for the for the restrooms uh yes yeah I got a copy here I believe I know it's going to be discussed later in the agenda but uh to answer your question uh there were four bids they came in uh the lowest bid was 58545 and the highest bid was 299,000 to renovate some small restrooms so you can see the difference and prices and and again those plans were also submitted uh to to get those bids they
086were engineered uh by Mr umir Noosa engineering so those those plans were used to uh sub submit for those bids But to answer your question yes the lowest bid that comes in under the the budget that we have remaining for that project okay I have some questions once we get to that it thank you and finally we have Proposition E and under this proposition we had uh the baseball and Sala fields at Rio high and Gua High we had golf facilities at Gua high and wringle middle the track lighting uh the VMS and other middle schools the Ringle middle school and gria high school track resurfacing the real high school and Gua high school wrestling Center and we also had the VMS gym floor Renovations and basically the only thing that we have pending there
087is the wrestling uh Center and as I mentioned before the original budget was $2 million and we have $1.3 million left there to proposition a proposition a uhhuh those two are for cafeteras yes I believe there's another item where that is going to be discussed on the agenda the gya middle school and the warehouse yes right all right so we'll move on to item number three updated report on the Child Nutrition warehouse and District shipping and receiving Warehouse projects so the cafeteria distribution and Warehouse uh projects were under proposition a the original budget was $3 million and two uh properties were purchased with this uh money and we have a property uh that is right next to the pain Fort here in durande and we paid $1.7 million for that uh building and we also
088purchased the Tractor Supply here in rande and we paid uh close to $ 1.4 million there uh total of$ 3.1 million what why two different locations and not for the same I don't have the answer for that I don't know if Mr P can help you with that um I know that the or the original or the first building that we purchased was the pain building which was going to be used for both the cafeteria and then our district uh shipping and receiving Warehouse at that time uh you know we had Administration and school board look go look at the facility at pain that's the one that came up for sale first and uh you know recommendations given to us was that there was a great deal uh so we went ahead and and we
089got that board approved uh then later on and we were starting to look the architect started to design plans and cost of construction again went up so it was going to be more costly to renovate that building than when Tractor Supply came up and they offered the 1.4 and it's already built it's already painted it has lighting air conditioning it has everything it was cheaper just to purchase another building than renovate the Ping any other administrator I would like to discuss but those were some of the discussions that were made with the with a school board I believe that a few months back we had one of our board members mentioning that the property at pay was a bus barn that that was going to be used as a bus barn am I correct on
090that or is that not uh true it was discussed at one time mrpa because if you can look at it it has a huge uh roof on it so very easily it could be a buzz Barn as well it's a huge facility as long and it was also for shipping and receiving but originally it was purchased for the food for cafeteria and and shipping and receiving for both thank you Mr P let me ask uh I know there's been a lot of complaints where we parked the buses and what do I mean complaints that the buses are parked right next to the river and that we have illegal Crossings and things of that nature I know there's always been a big concern of parking the buses where we're at and I think the idea was
091to pull them out of there next to the river and put in some place where they could be seen correct yes sir where safety wouldn't be an issue Mr what are the plans for the usage of these two buildings the Tractor Supply Miss py LZ has besides the bond she has her funds and she would she could elaborate on that uh I haven't been included I was here only when it was purchased after that I have not been included in that project do you know anything about the the one in the the pain pain for the pain once we purchase the other building ma'am uh that one was put on hold so we could make sure that the other projects would continue are we still hold on both yes ma'am not on both no bids
092have been awarded not not on Tractor Supply it's it's getting Miss P MZ is getting it ready to make use of it so it seems like the focus is now going to be on the Tractor Supply building yes sir not necessarily on the pain right correct any plans or any thoughts on on that particular this was as of July yes after that I have no idea anybody have any idea for plans Madam president members of the board so referring to the new Tractor Supply uh we did inform the board in the board meeting that we were proceeding with this facility um we do have a deadline a hard deadline of March where Miss ramz and her staff have over a million dollars in in in in ovens and other um what's the word I'm looking
093for here equip equipment there you go thank you equipment that we're look that we're needing to bring in by that deadline so with a tractor supply acquisition but we have is uh we wanted to make sure that any 199 or general fund expenditures could be reimbursed by m raas along the way but uh in meeting with her recently because of this item she I believe she has some great news that that I feel is great news good evening everyone uh right now the Child Nutrition program has been slowly and gradually transitioning into the new storage facility we currently store non food all non food items that are used for the program to feed the kids USDA Lo at Foods chemical and janitorial items that are used for the operation of the Child Nutrition program at
094the new facility we don't expect to fully move in there till probably about a year and the reason for that is because our plan that has also been approved by the Texas Department of Agriculture and USDA is to purchase equipment that's going to be housed in that facility for example we're looking at purchasing a freezer for our Cold Storage currently our our storage is very limited and uh we pretty much store everywhere around the district so uh there's going to be a lot of benefits to that because we're going to go ahead and we're going to have increased storage uh capacity we're going to be able to maintain stock levels we're going to go ahead and you know have a better uh uh inventory of items we're going to of course store items in a
095single location rather than all over the district we're going to also uh manage our labor costs because we're not going to going to be all over the place we're going to be more efficient in in our order fulfillment and of course it you know gives us buying power when we go ahead and we have it all in one central location but aside from all of that all of the expenses that have been associated with this new Facility have been incurred by the Child Nutrition program and not the 199 so we've taken care of you know the security and surveillance uh cameras and system for that we've evaluated the fire protection system there's some uh things that need to be corrected and we're covering that expense as well we tested for asbestos and everything was fine
096and we paid for that and we've also taken care of electrical and plumbing repairs so far so as of yet the 199 has not incurred any cost for this project it's all been the 101 yes sir I ask a question the old cafeteria that we all know the old cafeteria the the how much I know that we got estimates of trying to repair that do you remember what the estimates looked like I don't call that but I know that the uh we pretty much used every square foot in there to store everything and anything came at something like 3/4 of a million dollars I want to say it was over $250,000 just to repair the roof just to repair the roof and we're not talking about the interior the walls and what I'm saying that
097the Tractor Supply came out relatively cheap because I think that the when the warehous the old cafeteria was going to be done and its entirety was going to be be close to a million dollars and over there you got a huge building concrete uh state-of-the-art for another couple hundred thousand we no longer have to worry about you know that we don't have the items that we need for our kids where we used to go ahead and bring in items on a weekly basis because we lacked the storage now we can purchase enough to hold for three months you had bucking Bay so that makes a big difference so we're able to go ahead and ensure that we're going to have everything available yes ma' um do you think this new facility can help us with
098the Improvement of the quality of our food with improving the quality of the food ma'am I believe that the quality of the food right now is excellent so I don't know for it to be anything less than that I have complete confidence in my staff at all schools to provide the kids with the best Services possible and I stand behind that 100% about that I I I won't like let you know that's fine anytime I at your cafeteria theas everything's fantastic so that's I stand behind that menu and everyone else that works hard every day to prepare those meals for our kids and I uh can tell you that we do the best job that we possibly can and we include our students in every uh aspect of the menu planning process so uh anytime
099you're welcome to come and visit us and have a lunch uh or breakfast with us thank you yes I know the kids have food tastings at the cafeteria we sure do so it I understand the the changes that have come along you've brought a long way the only thing P that I want to make sure uh and that I'm understanding correctly is that we're as from the general fund we're not going to incur any cost from Tractor Supply or the old uh paying Ford uh we're trying to go ahead and cover all the expenses associated with the moving into that building if by any chance something does come up and TDA or USDA says it's an unallowable expense we'll evaluate it at that point okay and I'm only the only reason I'm saying is because
100of the situation we find ourselves in right now finally and I think the concern or the question that they brought up was the pain building like we know that the Tractor Supply is now getting you know used but what is the purpose of the pain building that I cannot answer I don't know Dr Selenas or anyone else if anybody has any what's like because he's saying about a barn but the buzz barn but what is it so far like is it going to be a um buzz Barn is it going to be a warehouse or what is it that we're going to use it for uh just to clarify Mr P's Point uh the general fund question you asked Mr paa we're answering in reference to the Tractor Supply nothing to do with the pain
101center correct just want to clarify that um to answer your question Dr Baretta the last conversations we had as administrators was that facility being a prime location was to be used for our central warehouse shipping and receiving and possibly a bus barn but the first time that we bought that pain wasn't it with a money of the nutrition it was no it was from Mone it was never with a bond money for no bond money yes Bond money but but not not 101 Associated correct so the the original plan from the from the from the pain center was to have a Child Nutrition Warehouse SL central warehouse so we can still use it as a central Ware that's what it's going to have to be used that's the last conversations we had ma'am yes ma'am
102but then again it's going to need a lot of repairs just like py you know it it it wasn't feasible for her to invest money in there because it was going to take a lot it's going to be the same correct with a busz barn correct it's going to take some time for us to get actually and as you may know Mr P I mean you're you're in the business for many years uh Child Nutrition does have several Hoops we need to comply with um so you're looking at possible Foundation changes we had certain you know I don't know insulation I guess you could say for lacer better word for for our refrigerants there's a lot of things I need to comply with to get in that 1.1 million in equipment that we're looking at
103that they that they didn't foresee when they purchased it that's the first statement okay M RZ one question after we bought the building we have not spent one penny from from our general fund correct correct you've incurred all the costs so correct okay thank you py all right so item four we update report on new Middle School is there an additional presentation on that um well basically that's what I explained when you asked the questions in in the other item think it's covered okay item number five updated on students and staff highlights oral presentation good evening Madame President esteemed board members Miss Morris and everyone in attendance you know upon speaking to my staff we always talk about that the uh the best part of our job in public relations Is that we sometimes most
104often times get a front row seat to all of the wonderful activities and all the wonderful events that happen in our district I guess the worst part of that is sometimes summarizing in it into one two-minute video that we show at the end of the board meeting that's a good problem to have that means we have a lot of great things happening uh from the students to the staff and everything that's going on we hope you enjoyed this presentation this is the highlights for the month of November special thanks to our student from Dr Madu ramz who ENT her voice to this presentation hopefully you all [Music] enjoy Rio Grande City guya ISD proudly hosted the superintendent free throw challenge for art talented third through sixth grade boys and girls a big thank you to
105all the athletes coaches and everyone who contributed to making this event a tremendous success RG CG ISD proudly hosted a Veterans Day program at the Fort wrangled Auditorium our heartfelt gratitude goes out to all students faculty and staff who helped organize this meaningful event on Veterans Day veterans Middle School held a meaningful ceremony to honor the newest names added to our veterans memorial wall Roberto Gutierrez estan Rivera J J Ela Garcia Tolson cryistal Ela ranel and Jesus M Garcia Jr the real Grande City guya ISD migrant education program in partnership with college first held an exciting stem Camp focused on space exploration for fourth for fifth grade migrant students out of 26 bands competing at the area EU UI marching band competition our Mighty guya band proudly took eighth place we are incredibly proud of
106all they accomplished this year our Mighty Rattler band competed at the State marching band competition in alamoo Dome simply making it to this year's level is an incredible honor and we couldn't be proud of all they've accomplished this year Rio Grande City guya I public relations department presented volume 4 issue one of inspiring lives one mind at a time the RG CG ISD magazine are public relations graphic designers teamed up with school PR representatives and central office staff to highlight student achievements across the District we are proud to congratulate Veronica barera as president Rene baa as vice president Eduardo Edie ramz as secretary and paty Garcia and Jesse Solis as board members the RG CG I Federal programs division parent and family engagement appartment hosted the sixth annual Thanksgiving baskets event for selected families at
107each RG CG ISD campus thank you to everyone who contributed to making this event a success my name is Kaye Andrade I'm in eth grade and I am the student council president from Dr Mario EES that was at the end so so let's take this time and congratulate the accomplishments from our band and Mariachi students which they've been doing awesome and they make us very proud and the coaches and the family and you know everybody that supports them yes ma'am thank you very much um the next I think it's the next item on the agenda is the uh projects update and a lot of the things that we were discussing earlier you're going to see a lot of the pictures uh we focused this month on the uh gria Middle School the welding uh program
108and the barber shop at real high school and the bus uh the food distribution warehouse that we were discussing right now so you're going to see some of those pictures right now [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] a [Applause] [Music] that's thank you for that um so that was item number six now we're moving on to item number seven um report on inor detection Auto report findings I believe we can move that to Executive for safety reasons um item number eight report on tax collections for the month of October 2024 no discussion just go to the section SK okay so we're going to move on to section seven recommending approving the consent agenda the board has agreed to discuss the following items all the cons items below that are not called out will
109be approved by consent item number one consider and take possible action on donations to real Grandy City guya ISD and we're just going to briefly mention out those that donated to thank them oh missana the donations for the month of November were received from rgc wrestling booster club Ena development Veronica's Physical Therapy EF Trucking and materials five star clar construction Sandy who promis fund David Hall McCoy and Dr Stanis LA and that's thank you thank you item number two consider and actually Madam president I moved the we approve items one and two uh as presented I second that motion all right all in favor raise your right hand all right so all in favor same sign motion passes action items item number three consider and take possible action on travel request from General Sanchez Elementary
110one principal to attend Blue Ribbon Schools of Excellence conference in Orlando Florida on December 2nd through December 6th I know want is here she's already she already went but we still have to do we still have to approve this item okay so I move to uh approve item as present item three as presented second all in favor raise your right hand so all in favor same sign motion passes item number four consider and take possible action on request for use of school facilities from Texas A&M AG agif star County Extension to host the star County Fair pageant mam president I would move that we approve items four five six and seven they're all requests for use of school facility school facilities it's pretty much um the typical pattern they've also they've always typically used the
111or requested the use of school facilities um as long as they of course provide the liability insurance and the documentation that the school district requires which I believe they have D is that correct so I move to approve item 4 through 7 I second the motion um on this one uh there will be some discussion on item six okay all right is there anybody here for item number six 15 from no from the city yeah just briefly if you can tell us what um you're going to be using the stadium good afternoon Madam president board members uh the use of the stadium would be for our football program our tackle football uh so uh it's the mic I'm Char there you go thank you okay sorry about that uh so it's for our football program
112uh we're about to get started I know in the past we've used the football F at the high school which was recommended by the district uh athletic director uh so but it was there's a conflict where the soccer program has started and we don't want to interfere with them because I know they have their program going going on so that's why we are requesting to use the football field all right um so I I would think as long as you all can coordinate on times absolutely he just he just got with me to call him tomorrow to coordinate something I think well all the students from the city are the same kids that we service in the district so I think that it we'd be doing a dis Justice an you know Injustice for them
113not to give them that uh field to practice you know even if it's for after school uh activities so I really really hope that from here on we can work together um to provide we've done it in the past with the softball fields but I'm glad that you're doing it now with we always want to promote more activity for our kids because the more activities they have the less their mind is going to be doing other stuff so then um um thank you for for doing that and um no I thank you guys appreciate it thank you so much I have a question for you sir yes sir real quickly I know that in tackle football we have tle football obviously in our schools corre the other thing I look at is Insurance do you
114have do you have insurance for yes we have the we have the proper Insurance uh let me finish do you have insurance for catastrophic injury and what I mean catastrophic injury a neck uh spinal injury and things of that nature if not you should look at it because if somebody gets hurt and they become a paraplegic people can be out of it can get very dicey so catastrophic insurance not regular Insurance catastrophic I would definitely look into it and I'll will definitely give you that information okay traffic Insurance thank you thank you okay so a motion yeah motion by myself second second all in favor raise your right hand I'm a good except item number abstain Miss abstain all right so um so motion passes with a vote of 6 to1 well one abstention one
115AB uh abstain abstaining item number eight consider and take possible action on Star County Appraisal District allocations payment schedule for year 2024 2025 Madam president move that we approve item 8 as presented second second all in favor raise your right hand so all in favor same sign motion passes item number nine consider and take possible action on contingency change order number N9 from NM Contracting LSC for new welding shop at real Grandy City High School Madam president I Mo we approve item 9 10 and 11 as presented I believe there's going to be some discussion though 9 through1 have second second second motion can I have a discussion yes sir discussion are are those facilities finally going to get finished Mr they were promised to us at the beginning of the year and then in
116the middle of the year are we going to have them right before the beginning of the when we come back from Christmas break uh uh good evening Madame chairman members of the board super Morris uh we have a substantial completion uh on NM projects on all three of the projects the this building the welding and the cosmetology uh Barber so what that means is uh the building can be used for intended purposes we have been given uh oapin permits by the fire marshall so that clears the way uh you know for the use of these buildings uh we still have uh contract balances on all all three projects uh there's a couple of minor uh punch list items that haven't been made but we're holding a lot of money on them uh but uh the
117buildings are ready for use so let let me ask you liquidated damages because they're late is there going to be any liquidated damages that you know uh that's your prerogative uh we we could look at that uh I would like to meet uh with uh the School District representative and sit down and uh and see you know what we can come up with is this the only project they're late on or are they late on anything else cuz I know they're there um they're pretty much late on all of them probably the cosmetology not so much the cosmetology I believe is uh on time okay but the welding really dragged out and this one uh this building also dragged out quite a bit what does the contract have as far as liquidated damages are concerned
118you know per day uh more L noidea it's between $300 and $500 and I'll agree with uh Mr V I believe that You' been some time since I've heard you meeting after meeting we're not paying them till it's complete and I agree uh I agree that we should not pay for for this until it's fully complete and fully usable uh with all the students I mean uh I think they've we've given them ample time to completed it hasn't been completed as so I think that uh it's due uh for it to get done completely some there were some change orders uh that uh that came in at the very very end and uh so if a change order comes in at the end then uh they still need some time to complete so there was
119a little bit of that but by and large uh you're right they were they were late because I know they were hired to do a lot of different multiple projects right yes sir are we still using them for anything else anything new that you know of Mr um the the contractor you mean yes sir well we're not using them right now for anything and there was a contingency amount and all that good stuff um I think the balance that was left was 33784 that was refunded to us so anything from now on that's not going to be that's not going to be used uh and probably the this building has a balance of uh 57,600 uh the cosmetology has a BAL balance of uh 47300 so all all three of the buildings have a balance
120contingency left okay in the construction but we they are going to be in the classrooms when we come back from Christmas right the kids the children well it it's certainly your decision but we have G given the green light to occupy the buildings I don't I don't hear I'm so ined but I hope so all right okay no further discussion um all in favor raise your right hand all right so all in favor same sign motion passes item number 12 uh consider and take possible action on change order request 024 backflow for fire line with accessories from gerlock Builders LLC for new gurat Middle School Madam president I approve items 12 13 14 and 15 uh with some discussion second so those are all having to do with the guya middle school okay uh my
121question to you is on the I know that originally had placed a certain backflow valve uh for the fire line uh accessories and I believe that it did not pass uh inspection with a fire chief so they requested a larger uh they requested at a cost of $664,000 is that included in a contingency or is that additional cost to the district uh so far the uh the balance uh let me see um the contingency balance for the middle school I believe is 87,000 and 87,000 I'm sorry 87 87 that's correct and pay the Val we still have 30 something th000 I guess yeah yes sir uh well like these items would have to be deducted from that and and like like this item number 12 is something that the fire marshall added uh in addition
122to what we already had so uh it was uh requested by the fire marshal you know after the project was completed and bids were in so that's that's what this item is about let me ask uh Mr G I'm a little familiar with backflow Valves and stuff isn't that a little expensive for a backflow valve it it seems to me now uh of the 67,000 $6,150 uh is for uh like general contractor's fee if you pay uh this amount from the contingency we would have to deduct $6,150 from that so uh it would be right around U um at 61,000 what size is the back flow valve any ideas I I don't know this is like a civil civil engineers item and it's actually uh it's in the project but it's in my not not
123in my contract but I believe uh they're probably from 2 to 4 Ines you know so the Fire Marshall is the one who requested it that's correct yes sir but we already had a back flow valve before we we had some we had several and they added uh some more what was the reason they wanted another backflow up I don't know they they added these to the fire line not really to the water affordable water for the project so it was something that uh that wasn't expected so what the fire marshal requested is 36 in and 1 8 in back flow that is for fire line with with accessories just to be exact uh we've got a representative from uh gerlock here he can elaborate a little bit more faan Ooa good evening ladies and
124gentlemen of the board uh my name is Fab noo I'm the project manager here for the G project the back flow preventers are extra that the fire marshall requested we have two back flow preventers but those are for your potable water only if we don't add this backflow perers for the fire sprinkler line then all the contamination from those sprinkler lines are going to come back to your pable water that is why these were required and these are three uh 6 in back perers and 1 8 in perer so something you all didn't know prior to giving us an estimate no ma'am you did not know that no that was added after the uh bidding process and everything what was on the plan is what we provided which is the two pable water back flow
125preventers um and the risers that belong to the school district for each building did not have any put on the plans for it so this is extra above what we had that they're requesting so it's not one back flow valve it's four four it's four backflow valves you got three 6 in and 18 in okay that makes more sense yeah Mr CH I have you here do we have a deadline for the completion of that you're aware it might be off topic yes sir what what deadline is that it's in it's in may just may may and general the beginning of May uh exact date I can't tell you I would say um May about miday miday okay cuz you don't like this board like to sue for liquidated damages so oh no oh no
126we'll be finished way before that very well very good sir thank you no further discussion okay so all in favor raise your right hand I'll be abstaining from those four all right so uh motion passes with six um in favor and one abstaining no we Cal item number 16 consider and take possible action on pay application 13 uh July from NM Contracting LLC for cosmetology and barber shop at Rio Grande City High School mam president I move we approve items 16 17 and 18 I'm sure we're going to have the same discussion as before with this company is that Mr time on these uh I can tell you that U item item uh is uh they're asking for 189,000 $228 yes sir and uh the contract balance after this is $1,791 okay so um they
127still have uh and I believe that's going to be the the final payment for retainage at at the end uh so we're still holding that on some little bitt uh punch list items uh so uh uh even the 111,000 probably you know all but $20,000 uh no maybe $40,000 would be held back later in the future payment for for some items that are still missing uh for example uh there was a there was a question on on a uh Inlet uh it's it's outside it's an in that catches drain water from around the area area and it was done kind of in a bad way and it's probably a $5,000 fix but we probably hold back like $20,000 on that one item so uh we we we we we heavy hand that an item like
128that so we make him come back and take care of it so we leave a lot of money on the table uh and and what what happens is they' come back and fix it a soon as possible okay and on item 18 for the faculty and student Training Center at Ford Ringold which one is that one number 18 ma'am yeah 18 18 okay uh that's 23,000 pay application number 19 23,6 67648 uh uh and uh right now after that there would be a contract balance of $260,800 so that's still not paid what is it that we're paying for with that with that pay application what do it entail the faculty and students Training Center where is it in the wringle mid no next door the new addition oh it it's this building this building yes
129let me ask your question F sir have we connected the Gen or the emergency power in case uh storm H or because I know that internet works off here so if this building goes down we're down all over the district have we has the generator already been connected to have power if if B things happen the the generator is here there were working on it uh I don't know if the last items have been connected yet but uh uh I think there were the the work had been ordered and the the the person that does the generator and has to do the connection hadn't been here as of a week ago I don't know if that has already occurred or not I couldn't the reason I tell you I think it's really important because right
130now when we have hard freezes and some bad winter storms and the light goes out because there's big demands and it's important that we have that thing up because if not our all our internets all over the C all over the rgc GD is going to be out so I think that's urgent that we connect that Chan or what I don't I know it's gener that the emergency generator generator and to add to add I know that the testing uh the testing sessions are coming up exactly so that would be that we would need for backup uh to keep the the program running if it hasn't been done already it's imminent uh that's the only thing I can tell you because it was in progress can you ask them and make sure that they hopefully
131get it done in the Christmas holiday yes sir um the I think um I have some update on that the issue has been that they did come out first we needed a permit so we got the permit Mr baa went out and got the permit from the city then they did coordinate with the company that was going to come and connect the generator when they came to connect the generator the plug that was installed for the generator was not compatible to what they had to connected to so now that required a change order and the change order has not been passed to be able to change the adapter on that Genera or generator to connect it so we just finished start testing luckily uh we did not go down but we did go down during
132the Thanksgiving break uh there was a a short power outage and we still didn't have the generator connected so I know that if any District employees were trying to use the Internet or trying to access the school email they had issues because it went down and the generator has not been connected so it is a concern for us and it is something that we continue to struggle with because we've been trying to get this connected I don't know Mr paa can probably say since the summer since maybe June Mr paa and it it just has happen and it's been one excuse after another the latest was that the plug was not compatible and it required a change order to change the the plug and that was the last uh contact that we had so who
133fault is it that the plug is not compatible I don't know but uh I can't imagine that that's a a huge item you know uh uh so uh let me let me talk to these people and see what it is I I can't believe that a plug like that uh would be worth a couple of hundred dollars you know I mean I I don't know what what what it is that they're waiting for and we came in on Saturdays uh myself Mr Gonzalez TJ to open uh several Saturdays and that was the excuse then we even tried to see if we could connect a regular generator that we had you know within our capacity without having to purchase one and it would not support the amount of electricity that was required from the server so
134that was not something that Mr SS advised us to do because they would not be able to handle the energy but I I don't know Mr paa do you want to it's like Mr paa saying we're going to be getting into testing pretty soon and it's imperative that that thing gets fixed up because otherwise you're going to throw a big monkey wrench into it well I've been dealing with it since last December when we moved in uh we had to rent a generator during last year's testing and they kept telling us it was going to come it was going to be powered up I say hold this check let's hold till we get it connected sir is that something we could do or does thato the warranty if we do it ourselves Poss effective warranty
135you can hold their check there's nothing wrong with that and you approve it subject to them putting that gener online if not then they don't get their check period so that's to hold back and this is on which one on the on the student training yeah student Training Center 18 okay so we going to hold back on that you you can either pass it till January or and of course if you pass it till January they probably won't get it done but if you pass it subject to them connecting the generator and it functioning properly if you make that motion then I bet you they'll they'll come out there and fix it well let me amend and adopt the language you just dat so uh with regards to item 18 so first we pass 167
136no you can I think can we do that with this Mr yes you can well I'll make a motion to approve whatever you said okay so so the motion subject I already said it you you said it I'm sorry would be to to pay I second it then sorry you're not going to get paid till the they to pay item 18 subject to them bringing the generator online and operating properly before Miss robas is uh is asked to issue the check all right so that that would be the motion okay so you you second motion second so all in favor raise your right hand and all in favor same sign motion passes that was item number 16 to 18 now item number thank you item number 19 consider and take possible action on invoice number
137three for from gig Associates architects LP for the real Grandy City guya ISD aquatic wrestling facility at Fort ringles Madam president I move to approve items 19 and 20 um I think with some discussion you have some discussion I know I know that with gigack I know uh I don't know Mr paa would be able to answer this questions if you got to them or not about the plans I know that uh there are plans out there for the nitorum uh at at G high school do we have those 100% complete and uh we're not building at G high school but what what what can we do you know I mean we got to pay them cuz they probably did the work already the the planning no the architectural work so this invoice is for
138$1,740 the plans that we have are for the ones that the board gave us the direction that we will build one only here so the plans that were developed to final Chris has them and uh you know we do have those the ones at the high schools you can explain that so you have two invoices for us I don't know which one is which but one of them is when we're working on the two high schools one of deals with a uh additional services from our pool consultant and that's what that $177,000 is for that was something that somehow didn't get paid the second invoice is for the completion through re of bids on the project here and so that's why there's two different projects and the amounts are different is this the only Bill
139where do you foresee another uh DED on the on the lagya that should be the last one because we we stop work at 75% CDs and that if you look at it everything 75% including the pool Consultants work I bring it up is we you know of course we have the bond so we're Limited at that understand so we start making changes to whatever can then you have to change your design can be further cost there which takes from Bond money or whatever aail money is available so you know something we got to take take into account corre so so on the project here what the bill is for is for the receipt of bids and that's basically through the contract should we come back and and revise the drawings then we can sit down
140and talk about it and and it wouldn't be like from the start I mean it just if it's going to be at the same site and we're going to do some value engineering design we can talk about that it wouldn't be the full price again we negotiate on that to to make it fair to you guys so that we we're not going to have to start from scratch is what I'm saying so you wouldn't have to pay from scratch either I hope that makes sense yes it does it does thank you so that uh first invoice is 4,585 that is the one for this project here so they one in the old the old plans of real high those are already the second bill was for the up to the work that we completed on
141the other two projects is that what you're asking me yes right we we were stop we were told to stop at 75% CD so we sto working that that invoice you have there is an invoice that somehow got lost in in the paperwork it just hadn't been paid that that invoice is kind of old and some so testing as well is what I'm being told but the that's why there's two invoices one is for the Lya site and the second site with the large larger amount is for the site right here at that bit Ford wringle r all this him getting paid comes from Bond it doesn't come from the general fund correct it comes from the bond No Sir the bond series 2021 yeah but all right it comes with the bond but the
142issue still becomes it's coming the money is going to come from the budget so it's another ex amount that we're going to have to find somewhere else you know so that's what I'm saying we just something we need to keep into account you know because $400,000 is $400,000 you know so that's why the question was if you anticipate much more changes is another bill going to be for 100,000 100 50 200 300 then there's another million that goes by so then we got to what accumulate four another 4 million just to try to finish the project if that because you're telling me the costs have gone up and the board has said it enough inflation inflation if you haven't seen the flag you I'm sure you got it hit in the face with it we
143have to be cognizant and be smart about it you know we we have to adjust for it we can't just keep saying hey here it is here it is and red hair and flash flash flash right but look over here you we have to account for so I'm just the question was not that it's not coming from B Money I know it is the question becomes do are we anticipating much more because these are not small bills and we hopefully it comes to fruition you made it seem earlier like it was not going to happen based on the cost so maybe maybe we're arguing over you know not not not for 12 million right so it's not going to get done for 12 million so as it is it's to you it's not going to
144get done for million yes okay yeah no that that facility the way it's designed now it will not cost 12 do you have a more or less an idea how much is going to uh the bids committed 15 and that was 5 months ago so for now seen about 2 and half% cost increase monthly anybody have 3 million that wants to donate to the district it is Christmas but I don't know I at a minimum let me ask you when you first started the plans the prices were somewhat cheaper when you first started it oh absolutely absolutely you first started the plans for this one yes sir they were going to come more or less in budget and then just everything broke again more expensive like said right yeah and and what we what we
145did and and and the plans are here but we designed it so that the base bid had condition but we we knew that given the construction cost and then the trend that was going on we designed an alternate so that it would be open a a deductive alternate and that that first bidder was a deduction of $1 million just about $996,000 so we I was hoping it be more than that but we knew that the price that come in potentially would be higher that's why we designed that alternate to give you guys an option to take that alternate but it's it's designed that it can be enclosed at a later time air condition it and you can do it time obviously I don't know if you're going to find 7 million later what would be
146the option what would be the op the cost of that second option without the without the enclos well actually during the value Engineering Process we said uh with with Miss Morris and we had several options we asked the contractor to give us I don't have those numbers with me tonight but there was I think there was three different prices it was do you remember was less than a million dollar different for the alternate 14 like 14 million it wasn't like a big it was like 900 and something 996 instead of 15 it's going to cost 14 were never in budget no no no it was still over budget yeah yeah yeah so we thank you you're caught up in the in all this discussion I apologize but yeah the the bottom line is we just
147went over budget absolutely n we have no issue with that ma'am okay open just wanted to understand because this bill was from July 2023 and so we just were concerned understand was thank you thank you so much okay so that was item 18 and 19 all in favor uh uh all in favor raise your right arm you yeah okay so all in favor same sign motion passes item number 20 yes right yes item 21 consider and take possible action on resolution on annual review of investment policy and investment strategies M president I'm going approve item 21 and 22 as presented so item 22 is also related to investment responsibilities so um any questions discussion on this item 2122 second all in favor um raise your right arm no discussion um Mr VI all in favor
148raise your right arm I did okay everybody right arm yes okay so all in favor same sign motion passes item number 20 three three consider and take possible action on delivery contract method for security window film at all elementaries and successful and successful transition and rewarding transformation Start Center M president I move to approve item 23 with a little bit of discussion my second the motion just discussion what what is this window well if we don't if we're not getting too much suppos to do if we're not getting too much into safety I don't know it's about safety it might it might be about safety my first question was funding is that through the grant that we have for safety or mean it's through another grants it's a grant okay and then can we discuss
149it Mr I don't I didn't want interrupt but it might be safety related okay it is it is safy yes so this is if I may this is just for the contract delivery method which like it says there is a competitive seal proposal so that's what we're recommending so that way we can advertise and bid it out I'm sorry I didn't hear was it Grant the funding source was from where it's from a grant that's from one of the safety grants so all in favor has been AED no further discussion no no this is only to choose a contract method to award so they're going to go out and bid it and then once they get the bids then they'll bring this item as far as details we can discuss in ex but it was
150sealed but we wouldn't discuss the details until after it's awarded okay got you so all those in favor raise your right arm so all in favor same sign motion passes item number 24 consider and take possible action on requisitions under task B policy CH logo purchasing and acquisition I'm Mo to approve item 24 as presented Madam president do I have a second second second all in favor raise your right hand okay so all in favor same sign motion passes item number 25 consider and take possible action on requisitions 5,000 and0 over discussion first do I have a motion there some discussion discussion on 25 there a motion in a second I had a motion with discussion depending on the discussion but we need a second well I haven't made the motion okay we do that
151second so any motion Mr second and discussion yes 26 we're looking at yeah it's 25 yeah uh Chris I know that when I I you you all turned in the total invoices and uh that were requested for 3GS in particular okay I I calculated the amount that is on the this graphic that you turned into us and it calculated to $29,980 54 cents okay on what graphic that was the one you you submitted last meeting ah okay the total for the total for 3GS that I calculated if I'm correct was for $19,988 with 54 but when I calculate all the invoices or the the the quotes that it turns out to be $138,600 54 so there's about an $8,000 discrepancy that they're charging more than what we're paying out what we bring to the board
152is what's entered on the requisitions so then once it gets approved then let's say something is off when I go back I only approve up until the amount that was approved by the board yeah now a second question is I noticed that when we asked for the for the quotes and you gave us a copies of the of the quotes but I noticed that the first the first quotes that they turned that you listed for us have a date as to when it was initially uh submitted or worked done but after that they're all Whited out is there a reason why we Whited out those uh dates on those uh quotes I the first eight invoices have a date everything else it's actually it looks Whited out it looks like a little line and these
153are invoices I know that in my in my career if I do a note if I do an assessment it has to be dated if not it's not valid I know if we get a bill for like our business um the tape and float we'll put tape and float this house this date this amount you know how many they use you know it's a little bit more specific so I didn't understand why something would not have a date yeah so what's presented to you are actual quotes they're not invoices what's on there I yeah so those are quotes let me just so do they give you invoices once they we receive invoices after so once I run a purchase order then we get an invoice so if you check on any of the ones that
154are on there it does have there where the x is marked for quote Yeah but we asked you for for yeah for the invoice like that's what submitted to me that's what I get that's what attached to all my had you noticed that all the dates I saw some yes so was I was going through them I noticed that some of them have the date not listed on there yeah the majority of them don't have it and I I'm just think think was there a reason why they didn't want to show a date on it because for me I could be paying a an invoice from two years ago and not knowing what dat it's under you know I would like to be thinking that we're paying current on on invoices yeah so I know
155they're should be current year but I know whenever we do process we do check to make sure that the dates are on there if I miss them I mean that is on me um but they should have the dates once I do go back and process them so if they have something that does not have a date or like you mentioned Dr if something is you mentioned like uh whiteed out or something I mean I would need to check with TJ because I don't do that how do you receive those invoices or course by email through email they're attached me when I when I receive them when when I go into the system there's a requisition as you all can see and it's attached on there so it's based off of whatever maintenance submits to
156me what's attached and the work order is uh like how does it work the work order yes uh this this building needs air condition I know because I had a lot of messages complaints about parents teachers people telling me this air condition hasn't been working okay address it to you know the person in charge so I know that these people complain right that their air conditions aren't working what's the process after a teacher tells their principal the principal will call and send an order through email I believe that's the the protocol good evening uh board president members of the board Miss Morris yes the the process for submitting a work order we have a system called incident IQ and uh usually it's the secretaries or even the principal that input the the requis or the
157ticket they're actually called tickets not work orders anymore and if you saw in that little presentation that I provided um the requisitions have most of them have a ticket number which was uh correlated with the work order that was submitted uh I believe the the if the DAT were white at out was for time sensitivity sometimes things take a while to process they're all from this year um and if they don't get get processed within 30 days I believe the the way works in purchasing if they're older than 30 days they're no longer valid the the vendor will honor the the actual quote regardless of you know if it takes 30 or 60 days they will honor it so that's why um we put them in that way did you just give us this yes
158just today right now yes ma'am okay I because I asked for this um from Mr Canto last board meeting we did provide something similar this is a more refined uh instrument I know some of our our tickets were put under general maintenance not HVAC so I had to mentioned the last time that we had 300 and some uh tickets that were in the system but it's actually if you look at your packet on the first tab there's about 645 so is this report from the system from the system yes you can generate a report from um uh the inet and IQ for the for the work orders and then my uh secretaries put together the the next few tabs where it's all the invoices I mean all the requisitions and it has if you look
159at the First Column it has a vendor then the requisition number the location of where those items were used um the description and I apologize for the misspelling of the word description at the top the amount and then the ticket number and then an explanation if there was no ticket number for those some of those included U preventative maintenance and what have you things that came up that we as a department decided needed to be you know have to be done an actual report of the system from the system the the one for the work orders yes and then the other one was generated by our staff and and we're cognizant that air conditioning issues we've had I mean I had them when I was at at my campus yes I know that there there
160are issues TJ the only thing that uh I'm I'm I'm I'm a little concerned about is not not showing the dates just to make sure that I mean I we understand that it may be from this year or not or you may be telling us you may take your word for I mean honestly uh like I mentioned the last time it's all about making a safe and comfortable learning environment a working environment for for students a learning environment for a working environment for our staff and we want to expedite everything as soon as possible so that our facilities are that is correct but always following the protocol and always making sure that what we're paying for is what is needed and and that everything's done importantly and I have a concern is I from my
161calculations I might be wrong but in nine weeks from August to October did we consume about 9 $8,000 in Freon that's normal like no I don't know if that's accurate I haven't made that calculation just for the for the refrigerant 90 $90,000 in Freon like if we were if we're having to call these people all the time for I don't blame them you know they're business and they're going to come out we need I'm sorry can I if I can explain I'm sorry to interrupt um on the tab that says materials and supplies that is materials that we purchased from them they are an approved uh vendor on on our uh bid I believe it's bid 2432 um and uh so they are a vendor for for parts and supplies and those we we do
162inhouse uh when it's an installation we do or a service we do uh hire our vendors to come in and help out I mentioned the last time we do have four technicians uh in our department only uh sometimes when these vendors come in they send four or five people to install a new unit and they do it within a day or to and honestly we cannot afford to send all our four technicians to one area you know how many calls you mentioned it early how many calls we get you guys get aside from the calls that we get um aside from these 640 some uh different uh work orders that we have in the system there's also the calls that we get that where they don't input the work order but we you know tend
163to their needs uh and surprisingly enough even though it's cooled down quite a bit we are still getting the the calls very consistently and we want to make sure that we comply with everybody's needs well um you you also know that buying wholesale I saw the prices on some of these freance where it's more than double than what it is in any place you would go and buy and I'm thinking you know if we are more proactive about trying to save a buck it we would be cuz we need to save right uh we would be buying these if we're needing all that Freon we would have to be buying it you know wholesale and saving uh 50% of what you know for all this um items that we're buying like I said this V
164these vendors are either on the bid or they're part of a co-op like uh buyboard or I don't know what other board uh teams I think or some of those co-ops where they're they're approved that's why we utilize them uh this bid was opened and I think we have uh three different vendors on that bid for supplies which we utilize to um we did bid out of course last year and we sent out an to 81 vendors that take care of this and when we came back to the board we only had three that submitted a bid I mean for whatever reason they did not submit the rest didn't um so we have three three bids for this we have three bids thing I think that I would like me personally I don't know about
165the board but I would like to have us rotating through different businesses and so if we have three people that provide this same service I would like to I have my own business I'd like for people to give me the opportunity and then give I always tell people that are my competition hey you know I I don't B mouth them they're great you know send them over there doctors you know send to all of them if they're from that side of T send them to me if they're on that side send them to them you know that's that's how I work um I would like to see that since you you know like that's what I would like to see that we give business to different people that we give business and and we kind
166of have a rotation yeah and that that would be Mr Gonzalez you would have to reach out to the vendors and for them to submit those quotes so we have differents going back to the invoices I think we need to be transparent with I mean if we're purchasing stuff what what's the date going to do you know we purchased it we we got to pay it but it's awkward not to see a date there it just caught me caught me off card we'll make sure to go back and that all of them have dates and that they're signed off on um maybe you I'll approve them uh tonight um and then of course like I said the invoices we don't see them until we do run a purchase order so that's why there is a
167quote on this there yeah I've got a question TJ how many how many texts do you have four sir um and how many do you have the specialize in chers could I ask one one and I know uh this is my second uh uh round at at being the maintenance director the first time I remember which was back in 2015 or so uh we had a total of about 12 certified HVAC techs and uh due to attrition or other reasons we were down to four and two to assist accurate information for the amount of money that we spend on air conditioning would it be wise to try and hire a couple of more tchs because we're we're paying it in in in repairs I know we're in tough times but I think that is a
168a great idea I think that maybe if that we could look into that uh possibility I think that would help us out sign significantly yeah because then we got Dam Texas Chiller Supply Johnson right so it's three different vendors we use others as well that are not part of ended up being like 178,000 with all three vendors that we owe for AC I got a question for you miss Ro I noticed that in real Grandy City High School there's quite a few I guess air conditioning repairs are we taking the monies out of the lawsuit that we got for the high school or not because any repairs to the r City High School we could take them from that particular we do use uh the high school settlement funds for major repairs only not for
169minor no why would we use it for minor because it it's not not a major defect from the settlement so it's through where and so you don't think you can use it for minor defects why don't you get a legal opinion and the reason I say that they're minor but if it's $900 and you got 20 of them you're already at yeah at $225,000 you you can I believe there's got to be structural has to affect the structural integrity and I don't think that those small can you look at the settlement and maybe let us I I've I've actually I've seen this settlement before and Mr and I've had this conversation at least twice before a couple of years back and the question is is it is it a structural defect and we're talking about
170regular wear and tear repair maintenance that's not a structural defect so you're looking like Roofing or what we're looking like a roof or or maybe an envelope that's that's improper that has humidity coming in okay but that those are not answer we have looked at it several times but those are earmarked so that the district doesn't go out and spend it on maintenance instead of spending it back when you do have a roof repair if you do have a roof repair then you could use it okay so going back to being proactive Mr TJ um is your department doing everything that they can to maintenance air conditions uh check for leaks if you know we have all this free on being spent um what are you doing do you have could you add later well
171right now tell me what it is that you're doing but maybe also having a a more thorough conversation as far as what is the plan what is what are your what are your what's your crew doing to help with this issue because a lot of money is going into this and it's again we're in times of we cannot we have to be very very picky and and really do as much as we can in house before having to call other people uh yes ma'am we do try to do as much as we can in house uh our our uh technicians are constantly you know getting calls especially I mean more so like in the summer you could imagine when we have 110 112° heat um we do have two gentlemen working solely on filters and
172they're trying to cover you know start at one end of the district finish off at the other end where they're tell doing that preventative maintenance to make sure that our machines are clean and you know maintained properly so you are doing everything on your end for that and checking for leaks uh it just whenever there's a certain place that you're having to constantly put free on free on fre on do you all what no they they they repair the leaks in the house yes ma'am whenever they they find a leak in a coil or in line they do repairs um it just so happens I mean I think it's just were there a lot of leaks in this there throughout these September October no on some of them it might be where they I believe
173they changed compressors or did some type of uh adjustment to the actual unit not so much that it was a leite it's because I see a lot of um Freon a lot of a lot a lot of gallons of um Freon that's why I'm asking when it's a new unit that's uh installed they it requires quite a bit of refrigerant to fill so some of those are for new units as well let me ask TJ like if you're going to get Freon and you have three vendors I guess you go to Every vendor and you get the low cope yes sir but you go to all three vendors correct yes we reach out to different vendors and we've been purchasing from the vendor that had it at the lowest price yeah so we have to
174go through three vendors every Ser in every service call no uh these vendors that you see presented uh some of the vendors are specialist in chillers especially well Texas chillers and we have other vendors that we use for our chillers some are propri proprietary like uh Rio High when they serveed those tillers it's uh the the brand of the machines is dyin and that that that's a person that comes and service those particular CHS okay so I respectfully uh ask that you approve these items as presented amend so do we have a motion based on discussion with legal I'm going to go ahead and um amend my motion just to pay those that actually are dated um that's myed motion and we could provide uh the dates to all those like Mr uh Chris mentioned
175when you know with your approval uh once we get those invoices and we'll make sure the dates are there bring them back okay do I have a second I'll second that motion uh just make sure that do the cave that we you get those dates on those uh those uh quotes that were submitted without dates under yeah and I just re wanted to reiterate on what Mr Gonzalez said um in reference to the 30 days um it's in reference to when we get it serviced um I know it might have been a little confusion is from 30 days when it was serviced or when we received the products um so that's when we're trying to pay the vendor and that's probably why the dates are not there um but moving forward just making sure that
176I will make sure to check that everything and anything has the date on there whether it was a date that it was serviced because sometimes I have a date on top but then I'll have a different date within the body of itself because let's say the quote is for today but it's serviced until tomorrow or Friday whatever the case might be so I'll be sure to be more Vigilant on that because I know sometimes we do get like let's say chopping cards to take from Amazon or things like that they don't have dates um but we will be sure to have that as well when we do print outs just to make sure everything has a date just rest assure on that okay so all in favor raise your right arm so I have to
177say with an amendment with the amendment that only the invoices that are dated in the back that will be paid and then the other ones will come back at a later meeting with the correct dates all right so do I see it I already did okay I just wanted to mention that they're quotes the ones that are provided on on here they might have a date from back then but if you see it it's an actual quote so once I run the purchase order then they send us the invoice so I just wanted to reiterate on that instead of putting the quote why don't you put the invoice instead I can put the quote in invoice but that's I think that would probably clarify the the the miscommunication I like to interrupt and explain the
178process for purchasing okay uh basically we need to request or submit a requisition to become a purchase order and the required documentation for that is a quote once we have the purchase order it is sent to the vendor so that they can provide the service and once the service is provided or the supplies are delivered then an invoice is sent to the school district and that is when we pay so basically for requisitions to become purchase orders quotes is what is required if an invoice is submitted that means that the service was already uh delivered without a and so that would be part of the requisitions that are approved on the item before this one under the tasby policy then we just got to keep the date keep the date on there and that's that
179I think that's the board's point is that we do get quotes but Quotes come with dates right so when they give it I want to that makes sense they're not redacted quotes or dates the dates yeah then I did want to mention that the reason we put it on the requisitions over five is because the amount is obviously over five yes that's so all in favor of the amendment amended motion amended motion uh raise your right hand okay so all in favor same uh sign motion passes and we're moving on to item number 26 consider and take possible action on awarding of the following bits um RFP 2439 copers lease districtwide family restrooms for Sanchez Stadium Consulting Services food service facility Consulting and design two forklifts for Child Nutrition program two cargo vans for Child
180Nutrition program do I have a motion discuss discuss or any discussion yes discussion on the first one the copy release like I think that's going to be recall that bit or something yes so in reference to that one first and a second before we go to discussion correct I don't I think you you can discuss first it's it's motion or discussion no it's a a motion and a second to discuss discussion right do I have a motion first I move motion and now discussion like the discussion I'll take later go all right so now discussion now we can discuss I discuss item 2439 the copy rele okay so in reference to this one the RFP 2439 the carpet release so what we're doing is we're respectfully requesting to resend the proposal that we had originally
181approved and rebid it um if you see after the decision- making form we provided the decision- making form when it was approved only because later on we brought back an item that was for inform K12 where we're transitioning to a lot of our forms being done online so we're trying to go back revisit the copies that we currently have at campus and departments to see it maybe we can size down so we can save some cost on there so that's the reason why we're trying to rebid this item that's why we're bringing this one back to the board and as you can see if you uh I believe it's page 230 on your agenda pcket it has a breakdown of the prices so we're trying to see if we can get better pricing than that
182of course granted we're able to downsize on the copers at the campuses or departments but you still haven't rebid it yet uh no I can't because since we had awarded the vendor um we have to come back resend the original approval and then be able to rebid it so we have to advertise and then uh bid it out and that's the reason why we're bringing it back all right any other further discussion yeah I just want on the forklift is a fork Le being paid by by USDA also or by your program so it's not costing the district to pay it's also so to clarify the Child Nutrition will purchase you know with their own funding the forklifts and cargo vents that's correct I have a question I'm sorry for the family Resturant for Sanchez
183Stadium I saw their bids and there's one two three there's four bids which is good um but I don't see again I had already asked two three santu please provide with us the references and um like specifications for example the lowest bid is 58,000 the highest bid is 299,000 I'm interested in knowing are they providing the exact same things that um in in each of the bid yes um do we have that breakdown for the of what is it that they're going to be providing the person that's going to provide this service for $58,000 the other one's willing to pay uh a to uh bill is 299,000 there's a big discrepancy and I don't see exactly what is it that they're going to be doing what are what are we getting for what are we
184getting for that money yeah so I believe what you're asking for is the schedule of values so that way you can see the breakdown schedule values is what it's called okay yeah schedule of values because also we we've said before we don't want to compromise the quality for you know a cheaper a cheaper price yes we want to save but we don't want to you know sometimes and we end up paying more if it's not what we really needed so for me as for me I would like to table that one until we let me ask do they have Bing they have everything if you check on page 234 I did provide their the pricing the time it would take to complete uh the lability insurance or bid Bond and of course that it was
185a signed big because they have bonding and they don't do it the right way you can go to the bonding company correct uh yes we could it just doesn't have like the specifics the schedule of values bre the schedule of values and then I know you mentioned the references is there anything else that you would like for me to provide I believe that's it I do want to state that for purposes of the record on item which it it's RFP it it should be 257 it should be that's the one you just gave us that's the one you just gave us an addendum because the in the packet itself there was no amount price listed on there yes so you provided us one today at this meeting and that's for the 67,500 for cost per
186Associates Incorporated that's correct that's correct and uh Corner Bakery Cafe I guess it submitted their basic information but no no amount they provided no proposal so that was technically that's the only bid correct and then just on the while we're on the bids on this one for I believe on the agenda item itself it says says RFP but it should be a CSP the family restrooms okay just an okay so um I make a motion to approve um item 26 RFP 2439 2517 2518 2519 um and table 2512 until we receive the additional information we've just asked for do I have a second second second all in favor you raise your right hand okay so all in favor same sign motion passes can I what what are we going to get on the restrooms what
187are we waiting for the restroom I wanted them to give us an explanation of what is it that they're going to do okay like two restant do we have an engineer or an architect that did it the plans or something or not they we can have them present for the next time that we bring the meeting so they can also explain more mainly because there's a very big discrepancy between the bids okay thank you thank you uh item 27 consider and take possible action on agreement for third party administrator for workman's compensation claim between setwidth claims Management Services and real Grandy City gr ISD Madam president to facilitate things a bit further uh I move to approve items 27 28 29 30 31 and 32 okay I will read them um the I will still
188read them can you yeah item 28 is consider and take possible action on the professional Learning sth grade math teachers aligning instruction with star standards item 29 consider and take possible action on the renewal of the power score enrollment number uh item 30 consider and take possible action on the effective advising framework Grant item 31 consider and take possible action on extended constructed response professional development region one ESC item uh 32 consider and take possible action on special education program student activ for the 2024 2025 school year do I have a second second any discussion on item 27 is uh basan is she here you haven't had any problems with Cedric at all right they've been pretty effective pretty good good evening uh board president members of the board Miss Elsa Morris and everybody that's
189present no we've had them for 32 years who's that Zed claims Zed for workers compensation what number is that 27 I know we had them for it's pretty much early annual renewal right that is correct sir okay on on work comp we have our own workman comp right that is correct they're only third party Administration basically is that for like they handle all the paperwork do we have uh excess coverage on those things or not do you know yes sir we do yes yes and I know that our attorney already went over uh the contracts and all we have to have so much uh money and all that on the excess we're still funded correct yes sir that is still correct any further questions or discussion no all in favor raise your right hand thank
190you thank you thank you ma'am um okay all in favor same sign motion passes the board will convene and close session in accordance to the Texas open meeting act Texas go quote sections 55010 71 55076 and 55108 2 55184 I know people are going to leave before you leave it's Eddie science's birthday make sure and say happy birthday happy birthday sir all right it is 10:35 and we're reconvening an open session uh possible action on item a Madam president I don't think the item a requires any action no action no okay possible action on Item B and Madam president I move that we approve Item B as discussed in executive session do I have a second second all in favor raise your right hand all in favor motion passes possible action on item D no
191action required wa we possible action on item C no action possible action on item D no action possible action on item e do I have a motion Madam president I move that we approve item e has discussed in executive session second second which item are we talking about e okay oh in favor raise your right hand uh I in favor uh Mo um item passes possible action on item F no action possible action on item G and whether we approve item G as discussed intive session do I have a second second all in favor raise your right hand all in favor motion passes and uh possible action in item h no action and act uh possible action in item I no action that is it adjourning this meeting at 1036 p.m.