001[Music] good evening uh welcome to this meeting of the board of Tyler ISD um it was previous the meeting was previously called to order there is a presence of a quorum the meeting has been duly called and the notice of the meeting has been posted in the time and manner required as we always do we'll start off this meeting with a a prayer and the Pledge of Allegiance uh Mr some it is it is your [Music] turn maybe bow our gracious Heavenly Father once again we come to you thanking you for being the God that you are God we pray for this board as we sit here and we make decisions regarding the district that we always make decisions that's beneficial to the students first and foremost and to the rest of the district dear
002Lord we pray that you will continually watch over us keep us safe as we go about our daily task of educating children dear Lord we thank you for how good you've been to this District in particular pray that you will continually smile upon us that we can continue to accomplish things that will be meaningful for the community God as we go forth we pray that you will always be there for us and that we can continue to support one another and making this the best District within the state Christ's name I pray amen amen amen I pledge to the flag of the United States of America and to the repblic which stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all the Texas flag IED aliance to the Texas one State under God
003one IND okay thank you for that Mr Nome uh we do have some uh action out of executive session uh to take care of um that's regarding the consider consideration and possible action to terminate the chapter 21 term employment contract of Laura collie do have a motion on that item Mr President following the board proposing termination of Laura col's chapter 21 term Employment contract at our prior meeting on January 23rd 2025 and after the evidence and recommendation presented at hearing this evening I now move that the board terminate Miss K's contract for good cause including outrageous insubordination abandonment her of her position and complete failure to perform the duties of her job okay do I have a second second all in favor say I I I'll oppose eyes have it the motion carries uh we
004have some special recognitions good evening board members and Dr Crawford how are y'all tonight good evening good oh sorry good evening board members and Dr Crawford how are y'all tonight thank you okay um tonight we're GNA um begin with our special recognitions by announcing our February District students of the month um this Elementary student of the month is aan Reyes a fifth grade student at Griffin Elementary and the secondary student of the month is Daniel Harvey a junior at Tyler High School and at this time we're going to watch A Brief video about these two outstanding students that's not me Student Success can be achieved in a variety of ways and it's a journey that looks different for every Learner in Tyler ISD we witness the remarkable transformation of young lives every day let's take
005this moment to applaud their successes share their stories and Inspire one another together let's celebrate the Journey of Student Success in Tyler ISD join us as we meet our elementary student of the month for February my name is Eisen Reyes I am the district elementary student of the month Eisen is an except ceptional student who consistently goes above and beyond both inside and outside the classroom his willingness to assist others is one of his greatest attributes whenever somebody's stuck in a question that our teacher assigned us uh I come in I come in and then ask them hey do you need help and the person's saying yeah I do need help and I try to explain the answer like not give the fully answer but I try to like help them explain it Beyond academics
006eizen is a dedicated member of his school Community his commitment to making a positive impact extends to his peers as well he took initiative in going home getting on I ready and just taking the time to understand different concepts and from there he just decided that the school needed a beautification committee and he went to Mr lad and he spoke to him and he started everything so he really embodies everything that Leader in Me said and habit has now let's recognize our district secondary student of the month my name is D Harvey and I'm the secondary student of the month for February as a junior at Tyler High School Daniel exhibits exceptional qualities both academically and personally over the past couple of years he's had a growing interest in business management and a love for
007cooking at the career in Technology Center it helps me cope with certain skills I'm working with it help helps me like relieve stress when I'm cooking in the kitchen and I get to learn how to become a food handler certification and I'm learning to become a manager right now not only does Daniel excel in the classroom but he balances school and work at two separate jobs he has great plans for his future and knows exactly what he wants to do in order to obtain the successful life that he desires Daniel is a wonderful student I have him for a English teachman English 3 and he's very um self-motivated he's always working hard he just um he's a great great student hard worker I wish I had 30 of them in class he's very ambitious he
008has a lot of plans for himself after he graduates from high school and I'm so very proud of him let's honor these remarkable students as we acknowledge the outstanding achievements happening throughout our district this recognition is brought to you by Christ Trinity Mother Francis Health System [Music] [Applause] and at this time we would like to welcome the board to the front of the room and now we would like to ask aen Reyes to come front of the room [Applause] and and now we would like to welcome Daniel to the front of the GR [Applause] and next we have our Elementary District teacher of the month Justin Malone at Jack Elementary School and here are a few words from his principal Mr Malone you can go ahead and come up if you'd like we're gonna read
009it first we're just gonna make you stand right here um so everybody can hear this uh Mr Malone has enriched our campus culture with creativity and strong connections with students and families as part of Jack's sharp in the saw enrichment clubs he introduced his passion for gaming by creating a class room arcade where students can compete on Vintage video games wow he also uses this as a positive behavior incentive allowing students to earn tokens to play throughout the week his Innovative approach keeps students engaged while fostering meaningful connections okay there you go and next we have um Jessica Dean if you would like to come to the front of the room uh Mrs Dean according to her principle Mrs Dean excels in the classroom using all available resources teamwork and feedback to enhance student learning
010her strong rapport with students motivates them to succeed expectations her research-based behavior supports have improved student conduct and Transitions and I think I forgot to say that she is from bosier Center for exceptional programs um as a Menor mentor and team leader she shares creativity with colleagues and helps Implement new initiatives including a work-based learning site with East Texas Food Bank it's cool recently she received a tylerd foundation Grant with two other teachers she is dedicated to every student she goes above and beyond to support both her classroom and Specialty learning spaces there you go [Applause] [Music] angel wings wings and that concludes our recognitions but we would like to say a special thank you to Trina Stewart she filled in for photographer tonight okay and yes after special recognition some people do file out
011so it's it's not a not a big deal if you don't want to stick around but uh we'll we'll get ready for some public participation do your best to keep it to a dull Roar if you don't mind conat we do have six public speakers tonight um I'll just remind everybody that um we have it every every night and uh we do love hearing thoughts and concerns on all sorts of topics uh just remember that as uh board policy uh we're obligated to to listen but we can't respond so if we sit up here and we're not saying anything it's state law that we sit and listen so we're here to listen um and the first person um speaking on the list is U Remy Fernandez and we give everybody three minutes good evening good
012evening hello my name is Remy Fernandez and I'm discussing the topic of immigration Customs Enforcement of student degrees first I would like to thank the board members and the superintendent and the people coming to support I would like to say a speech that I have prepared schools should be a place of hope they should be filled with the sounds of laughter of curiosity a students daring to dream about their future but for some that dream has turned into a nightmare for some the sound they fear most is not the school bow but the heavy footsteps of immigration officers walking through the Halls imagine being a child sitting in the classroom trying to focus on a math problem or a history lesson but instead all you can think about is whether your mother will be home
013when you return imagine watching friends disappear their death suddenly empty their name whispered in the halls but never spoken Again by teachers too afraid to explain why imagine feeling invisible unwanted afraid to exist in a place that promise your safety and education this isn't just a story this is real life for countless students across our country every time immigration enforcement enters a school fear takes over the child who once raised her hand with excitement now keeps their head down the student who dreamed of being a doctor now wonders if they'll ever finish high school the cafeteria the playground the library places that once feel safe now feel like traps is this the kind of education we want to give one filled with fear instead of knowledge one were students biggest worry isn't a test but
014whether their family will still be together when they get home no child should carry that weight no school should be a place of fear we have the choice we can decide that schools are sacred places where every student no matter where they come from can learn without fear we can fight for policies that protect our children that allow them to dream again to Hope again to Simply Be kids again because in the end education is not just about the books and tests it's about giving every child the chance to build a future and no one no law no officer or policy should have the power to take that away so my question is what are the procedures in place in case immigration Customs Enforcement does come and are you going to form us as a
015community because a community without knowledge is a community that is destined to fail thank you okay thank [Applause] you okay next we have Dr uh n nalita Medina Perez can I move this yes absolutely okay absolutely I'm not as tall as Remy is so good evening board members my name oh crap my time it's okay slow down my name is Dr nelina Medina Perez I'm a bilingual therapist business owner TD alumni but most importantly a concerned parent you might remember reading my email that I sent two weeks ago in regards to the issue of immigration since the email has been out has been sent out several districts across Texas have released written statements on how they are protecting their children in regards to immigration's custom enforcement locally Marshall along with Kilgore Long View ISD have
016informed their parents how they will protect their children in a written statement however TD has yet to do so I am here not seeking a change in policy or laws I am simply requesting a written statement of policies that you already have in place our are our children safe with you within the schools you represent will you allow ice to enter your schools what is a protocol for children who are not picked up by their parents will you call CPS what family plan of preparedness do you recommend for our families will you accept a power of attorney or or a notorized document are the school staff members educated on policies and procedures in the situation how are you protecting our children that we as parents entrust with you daily having released information through your Spanish
017Communication channel was a start but it's not enough your response to my email was a great one why not make it available to to all in a public setting asking for parents to reach out to the schools directly is a problem in itself and shows the lack of connection you have with our community a population that already feels like they have to stay in the shadows will not dare speak out of fear of being s out there are several instances where a parent calls and there's not a Spanish speak person available to speak with them or worse they don't trust the schools at all in my practice I see a large amount of Latino [Music] children since this new Administration has taken office I had I have had to process the fears with them my
018elementary school children are fearful of going to school because they don't know if they will be home because ice might come and get them they believe that because they have golden brown skin they must must be undocumented I have seen an increase in cutting and hair plucking both forms of self harm in my middle school girls girls who are looking who should be looking forward to choosing their schedules for the next year are now worried about their safety at school my community is in crisis are your school counselors aware of that are they offering them support my high school I'm tring my high school boys are thinking about dropping at a school because their fathers and mothers have gone to work out of fear their bills are piling up and they feel responsible for their
019families they are leaving school early or arriving late be because they are driving their parents to and from work are your counselors checking on them my people are hurting and you have refused to put out a statement to to us assuring us that all of our children are safe pler versus do is a case that will always be part of TD I believe that as a district you have worked very very hard to show us that you are inclusive with the growing anti-immigrant anti-latino sentiment I feel that we are heading back down that road our community elected you to represent us we are being marginalized instead please do not turn a blind eye to this situation I'm so sorry okay thank you you okay Emily penal good evening School members my name is Emily Pinal
020I am a resident of Tyler lifelong um I also wrote my statement but I reside in District 5 um I'm a byproduct of attending schools in district three so the side of Tyler um but this is my first year as a Tyler as a parent so in addition to being an active PTA member I'm a local organizer dedicated to advocating with and for communities today what I'm asking is urging you to release a public statement clarifying your stance and internal policies regarding ice our community deserves transparency and reassurance and the school board plays a vital role in fostering a sense of security for all students and their families many families in our district are living in fear as a parent who's constantly engaged with other parents in and out of my children school I hear
021their concerns firsthand I also work alongside other school districts in my um nonprofit World which is LOM one of our strongest Partners which has demonstrated integrity and commit to the vast majority of their students these districts have taken clear steps to communicate their policies and offering resources ensuring that schools remain a safe space for all children at the end of the day what is so difficult about releasing a statement affirming that no individual is allowed inside the school without being listed in a student's file why is there so much hesitancy to release something we can hold y accountable to if there is a valid reason I urge you to lighting our community of East Texas Tyler to be Tyler area to be specific additionally there has been no Mass Outreach or resources provided by tisd
022to families no District Flyers no reassurance in home families need to know that they can send their children to school without fear it is one thing for individuals to place their trust on elected sheriffs who have openly collaborated with ice for over a decade but it is another to question trust we pl place in elected school officials these officials who are responsible for our children's best interest that is why I'm here today I recognize the privilege of not living in constant fear but I cannot say the same for the numerous parents and even School administrators I have spoken to so I will not apologize for demanding transparency I will continue to organize and hold leadership accountable and I will work tirelessly alongside others to ensure that if you do not stand on the right side
023of History you're not re-elected beginning with the races up for election this may our children s start better okay thank you um lith Zavala good evening board I stand before you today to speak about an issue that I FS not just students and families but the very Foundation of our education system we live in a time of Shifting policies increase enforcement actions and heighten fear among immigrant communities these changes directly impact the lives of families students and entire school districts this is why we're asking this District to take a firm stand and respond with Clarity compassion and commitment to protecting every student's right to learn and feel safe schools are more than just buildings where knowledge is shared they are safe heaven Havens for children when students students step through the doors of a school
024they should not have to worry about whether their parents will be home when they return they should not fear that their immigration status or that of their family will prevent them from pursuing their education and dreams yet when immigration enforcement policies change fear spreads like wildfire in tendance drops students become too anxious too Focus families hesitate to send their children to school worried about the possibility of encountering immigration officers this is not an environment in which students can Thrive you have a responsibility to step in and reassure families that they are safe yes under privacy laws such as fura schools are not required to share student information with Federal immigration Authority yet yet without clear policies and Leadership fear misinformation creates barriers to education this is why you districts must proactively communicate their policies and
025stand firm against any action that compromises students rights we learned in childhood that it is important to get an education because schools shape the future of this country but how can we fulfill this Mission if students are too afraid to show up how can we expect children to dream big if they are constantly living in fear so by responding to changes in Immigration enforcement policies you send a powerful message so what you can do is affirm your commitment to all students and families such as making a public statement that reinforces your role as a place of learning and not fear and just like Long View they are educating their families on their rights so you need to establish C policies and ensure that all of your staff understand how to handle situations involving ice and
026immigration inquiries thank you thank you okay we have Matthew Bailey good even board members neighbors and concerned residents my name is Matthew Bailey and I am here on behalf of a Tyler born and based nonprofit organization East Texas monarchs our main goal is to support undocumented students and their academic journey across East Texas beginning right here in Tyler currently I'm a student at the University of Texas at Tyler I believe that many of us now have heard the recent goings on related to the undocumented peoples of these lands and their plight stuck between the natural respect deserved by the shared Humanity of his all and the cold arm of the law here in Tyler we have a population that finds themselves stuck in this in between and we must remember that these are not criminals
027not numbers on a page not some tally on paper these are Sons daughters fathers mothers husbands wives grandparents and most important to us here young students I remember when I was a young student and I remember how mean children can be to one another blunt foolish bumping around as they go and find their way as we all once did all this is natural to our upbringing though for the undocumented children of today a greater force has befallen unto them fears of their parents being taken from them snatched away to not be seen again being ripped away from their friends and loved ones as they leave the school yard this as we can all gather is a great paranoia to be isolated forced to become inert for fear of violence this is not a healthy learning
028of environment for a child it it is stunning paralyzing with the potentiality for academic and personal growth stifled under the boot of Terror I have heard rumors as I've have heard rumors of children as young as four years old pondering into attempting acts and scenarios that no child should ever have thoughts of suiciding the sering of wrists and arms first fears of Abandonment as there as they hear Tales of others family members being taken from them with malicious eyes around every corner these children from kindergarten to the senior class are the most are in the most developmental stages of their lives when I was in primary school I remember being diagnosed with a mental condition not yet widely known let alone understood by my fellow classmates I was diagnosed with tette syndrome where I would
029have involuntary muscle twitches and vocalizations for years I would be side-eyed teased and bullied because of this over time this had hardened my heart and made me increasingly sour to others pessimistic and standoffish we must ask ourselves now that if we if what I had gone through had made me who I am now then what will these children become from the experiences they have today who will they be when they are my age will they be able will we be able to in years time look back on the decisions that we make today and tell ourselves that we made the right decision that we are indeed good people I implore the board to make the right decision on behalf of East Texas monarchs we demand the board to release a statement detailing their commitment and
030insurances thereof to the protection of undocumented students on these school grounds we are here discussing not just the immediate impacts of the fear and the terror of ambiguity but the years to come following what we do and say here today thank you for your time thank you okay uh and the last speaker for this evening is uh Dias Rodriguez good evening members of the board I don't have a speech prepared so I'm going to try to wing it and I'll try to be as coherent as I can I come to you tonight as a father and as a counselor in training I'll speak first to what it's been like as a father my daughter is at one of the middle schools here and today she asked me about my citizenship status uh something in the
031air is asking her is making her ask questions about Dad is something going to happen to you now I'm fortunate that there was a pathway to citizenship for me and that I am a citizen and I'm an American but I remember the fear that I felt as a child when those papers weren't yet legal I remember the fear I had of what's going to happen to my parents now as a counselor I'm seeing an like Folks up here have mentioned of anxiety of depression um I met a student who saw me for the very first time and when I took her back to the counseling room was shaking she didn't know who I was she didn't know what questions I had for her but I was there to support her now when you're in a
032fear State it's very difficult to learn it's actually very difficult to be relaxed even in a playroom like I was trying to do and it's took took a lot of work to get there towards the end of the session we were able to turn it around and she was starting to relax feeling safe but when she goes back to the classroom I think the fear is coming back and for myself what I realized is I don't have guidance neither as a father or as a counselor in training working at TI and I need some guidance from you guys just let us know what is the district planning in terms of what happens if um a parent wants to know about their information what's going to be revealed to ice or to immigration enforcement what coordination
033will there be between the district and ice will TD share Student Records with ice and will TD allow ice to enter the school district we need some guidance we need some information so that I know what we're working with so that families know what we're working with thank you for your time tonight thank you and thank you to everybody who came and spoke okay we will uh go ahead and continue with with our agenda and um the approval of minutes for the regular meeting January 23rd 2025 uh is on the agenda do I have a motion uh on that item I move we approve the minutes from January 23rd thank you do I have a second second all in favor say I I I I'll oppos as hav it the motion carries uh okay we
034have a couple of uh continuous Improvement student outcome uh report rep results early literacy en numeracy update inclass now ready Dr Cass Dr Cassandra Chapa and Dr Johnny deard two School supervisors for Tyler ISD will provide the board an update on your mclass and I ready results for this middle of the year the Moy uh results of that and uh Dr Choppa Dr Ward turn it over to you okay thank you Dr Crawford good evening board president Washman as Dr Crawford said we're here to talk to you about our middle of the year mclass and I ready data I know you guys have heard about mclass a lot um but just want to review uh M classes given to our students in kindergarten through second grade uh is in a oneon-one setting with our teachers
035and the students and it's assess three times per year um as we've been talking about on 3x3 although we have the beginning of the year middle of the year and the end of the year cumulative assessments we are making sure that we're progress monitoring any student that's below grade level or below Benchmark or well below Benchmark every 3 weeks to make sure that our interventions are working uh as you can see here um some data from just cumulative data for kindergarten 1 and second we saw a h increase with our kindergarten students we had 29% of those students that came to us at Benchmark and now we're 56% of our kindergarten students are at Benchmark first grade we saw an increase from 46 to 52 and then second grade we saw a slight increase from
03651 to 56 uh one thing I want to point out with second grade you know that's at the transition it used to be third grade where you were going from learning to read to reading to learn now we're pushing it back to second grade CU you know as you guys know third grade students are definitely having to come in with some really strong skills for comprehension to be prepared for our new star test I will show you in another slide though our second grade students while we didn't see as large of an increase as we saw in kindergarten first that we are seeing some increase in those specific reading skills of fluency um you can see here the data from um beginning of the year middle of the Year by demographics comparison from 2324 cohorts
037to 2425 as you can see we started out stronger in each demographic and we're continuing to Trend upwards um I'll point out like our African-American students went from 38 to 49% uh our two or more students went from 42 to 63% so we did see an increase again as I was saying I wanted to point out the skills I really want you to focus your attention on kindergarten uh a lot of our kids come to us with very few skills um as you can see in letter naming and I will point out to with mclass this is A time test so some of the kids may have the skills but if they can't complete it within that time limit you know it doesn't count for them um but as you can see here decoding we
038only had 11% of our kindergarten students that came to us at the beginning of the year on Benchmark but we're now 54% of those students on Benchmark um word reading 133% to 54% and letter sounds 22% to 54% so that's huge increases um as you guys know I think we were in our fourth third or fourth year reading Horizons which is our phonics program that our teachers are using with Fidelity as well as our wonders program that we've been in the last um four to five years as well which is working on comprehension you can see first grade they also have some increases um but one thing I want to point out in second grade as I was talking about earlier reading accuracy went from 49% to 63% of our second graders are now at
039Benchmark and then reading fluency which is very important I went from 47 to 52% so we did see some increases we will continue to progress monitor those students that are below and well below to ensure that our interventions are working and that our reading Horizons program is working so that we can continue to see increases by the end of the year and I'm going to turn over to Dr Choppa for I ready yes so I ready we are continuing our journey with curriculum Associates and I ready this is year two for us to fully use it as a diagnostic in math and reading for Kinder through 8th grade as well as use it as one of our tools to project proficiency so we know that there is not one tool um that we can use
040solely to help us be spoton with our projections or resource that is going to support all the intervention that our students need but we are investing in time and finding out all the capabilities of this program because we want to be able to stay I ready so we don't have to get I ready so as a refresher for those that are following our updates um and for the board again it assesses math and reading three times a year um it's used in a computer group setting so through a class period students are um online individually with their computers and again it does come with an intervention path um and personalized learning teachers can also access a teacher resource kit through I ready to provide students now I do want to clearly set the stage for
041the data that we're about to show you it's a little bit different than what we might see at beginning of year or what we've seen in the past when students take the Diagnostic in the beginning of the year they are provided their level score but they're also provided two other indicators one is a growth indicator uh for what would be an adequate Year's growth based on where they are the second indicator is called a stretch growth indicator through the I ready research or what we already know about students is when they end the year with us they go to summer and then they have summer slide so it's very typical that we have students at the beginning of year on their diagnostic that may seem to be behind where they ended the previous year so
042that stretch growth indicator is very interesting to us because through the I ready research if students are able to get to that stretch growth indicator for two consecutive years it increases their likelihood to maintain being on grade level or exceeding grade level um in positions where they may have started off behind so that stretch growth indicator is really important for us to work with our campuses and make sure that as they're progress monitoring my path using small group intervention that we're pushing students to that level to recover that so in this first slide we are seeing our cohort data meaning students that took I ready beginning of the year and middle of the year with us and this is the percent of students that have already made one full Year's worth of progress so it's
043pretty incredible to see that half of our eighth graders are already at that first year in uh very close to that stretch growth goal uh I ready is not designed specifically for Tyler ISD curriculum it's not specifically designed even just for the State of Texas curriculum so what this tells us is we may not have given tier one instruction on some of these grade level skills yet but it's a very promising way of looking at student growth towards that end of your target similarly this is by demographic um again celebrations is that we've got a third of all of our students getting to that Year's growth already at middle of the year um there are some questions about the access to my path that students have during the day and outside of the school day
044definitely a challenge is we can't control how students are interacting with their personalized learning plan outside of our school day um and then making sure that we're maximizing the opportunities with students so that they're given are getting that full um instruction through their my paath the second part of data is something that you've seen before it's our comparison data with other districts uh that are like us that utilize I as well as our state comparison data here for reading what we see is a a good number of our grade levels are in uh in line or outpacing what we see with the state for middle of the year uh again um some celebrations would be in in fifth grade and in second grade we're seeing that our our instruction is on Pace and if we
045were to you know potentially take a STAR test today we'd be very akin to what we'd see across the state and for math we see some really amazing gains for our numeracy in those early grade levels and even in eighth grade we're we're seeing us outpace the state um we always know that middle school is a a tricky um spot for us in terms of comparing comparing it with ir ready and trying to make those projections uh but we're seeing very clearly that we're we're trekking in in the right direction I already is currently also learning more about star 2.0 and we're looking forward to some of their studies that they're doing and making sure that what they're putting out there for us as the consumer is aligning with what we'll see on Star and
046in terms of accountability all right well that's what we have for you this evening any questions thank you does anybody on the board have any comments or questions I have a question um on each sheet I see that you always have only students tested for all administrations are included so approximately how many students do we have that are not included I would say I I we know that students that are on um snapshot I think the last we heard from this part last year to this part this year our enrollment is up so there are after snapshot we have seen an increase of students I don't have that exact number for you but that's something we can get is% I was going to say again so do they get any kind of testing do we
047know where they stand they they still take the middle of your Diagnostic and we still use that data to individualize but we don't have any information on that data in in terms of 2% that corre are not inclusive in this okay do we have this um information by School versus just total yes we have it could we get that information by school yes ma'am okay that's it okay anybody else uh a question regarding I think I I may have heard you wrong but you said the tier one instruction has not been given yet did I hear that right well we're in February right so we still have a a scope and sequence for the rest of the year so in terms of where students will be at end of year we still have curriculum left
048to teach um to make sure that we've covered every standard so so on the time timeline when will that instruction begin you said he's just asking like Define tier one it maybe yeah so outside of the my path in terms of outside the computer tier one instruction I was referring to teacher Le or teacher directed so the daily lesson scope and sequence of our curriculum not what's included in the I ready my path because the my path is based on the students their levels so if I'm a kid that's above grade level I may be exposed to some things in my mind path that the teacher may not have directly taught in the class yet so okay thanks appreciate that you done no go ahead okay uh in Reg general in in general looking at
049slide number two or three I think it is where you have the breakdown of the cohorts of the demographics looking at African-American Hispanic and white you know I've been concerned ever since I've been here about closing the Gap we don't get a report directly related to that only way we actually see it is when we if I go back individually and check that and see if we're actually closing the gap between the Hispanics and the African-American and the whites I I would like to see something more official in that regard so that we can actually report to our constituents that we actually achieving that goal of closing the Gap and I it's been hard for me to determine that each time uh and I was wondering if that's a possibility of actually keying in on
050that particular goal of closing the gap between the African-American Hispanics and the whites within the district if there's some way we can accumulate that data that's easy to see and understand we we received that report at the end of the year star they actually have a domain that's closing the gaps right so we do receive that report for the uh well okay well let me say this somehow I missed the summit of assessment do do we have that data from last year right from last year and the previous years ever since I've been on the board I I haven't been able to really pinpoint that as a particular goal we talk about it but I hadn't been able to see that's been a that's been a go that's been a I had seen a a
051diagram like this the gaps being closed uh so if that is possible then I guess we can go back and pull that data from the past five years that I've been here uh and we could actually put it on one chart in that case for each year how successful we've been at closing that Gap and that's easy then if we already have the data okay okay thank you okay anybody else yeah uh just real quickly on the personalized uh learning plan that's what they get they go in they take take their beginning of year test or middle of year and then it comes back with a plan for them as a teacher able to go in and adjust that plan yes yeah because highly doubtful that Middle School boys are doing their absolute best on
052on the I already would you agree yes teachers have the option to also assign specific lessons Okay um and also towards specific skills so teachers have access to personalized lessons that may occur in a in a standard that is a grade below um or a grade above yes and last year if I remember correctly uh I ready was a little bit off uh think more on the math side than the reading and its estim estimating of how we would do is that right a little bit worse on math how do y'all feeling about this year youall think it's closer aligned to how we how we'll perform on the star yeah they are they are currently conducting a study on on how their alignment is improving but that's also why we don't use this as our
053only projection campuses also have their accountability tracker with our unit Assessments in which we're able to kind of also judge whether or not the test that that unit test would align with standards OnStar so we're also using accountability trackers to kind of pinpoint proficiency what's that data showing um I I'm I'm again campus by campus it's going to be different but most of our campuses are on track to reach their goal or improve uh where they are currently I guess in general is it is it aligning with I would you say is it is it close when when it's pretty close last year yes okay thank you no further questions any other comments or questions from the board okay than you thank you for your report appreciate it okay uh advanced placement dual credit and
054CTE certifications update is next Dr christien walls executive director of College and Career is going to provide the report to the board per your board monitoring calendar Dr walls good evening good evening board trustees Dr Crawford and great to see you again I think it was pretty recent so tonight um I wanted to just kind of refresh we did a little Refresh on our goals and percent of Tyler um ISD graduates who are going to be college career military ready I'll use ccmr throughout this um from 77.4% to 86.7 by June 2029 so a little bit more reflective of where um when they change the accountability um as we're moving forward um we've talked about this many times I think the really only difference that we've seen now for our seniors this year is the
055career Readiness component in the past they had to earn an industry-based certification then the next year it was an alignment with one and now it's they have to have a CTE concentrator which means that they have two or more aligned courses plus an industry based certification approved by tea but the others um from the 3 plus on the AP exam the Dual credit and those have remained the same so for goal three and remember um each year this is lag data so on our um reports that we had it was showing 2023 so the graduates of that time so we looked at 2022 at that time we had 71.1% were ccmr and then we did increase to 77% so we had a gain um from that point I can tell you this that from last
056year's graduates and then currently as we're looking today we are definitely moving upwards into the 80s so um last year it was 79% I believe and then today when I looked at the projections of course they're projections um but it was about 84% so we're definitely making strides to moving that and of course what's the goal of school of course is to make sure that our students and they leave is to be college career or military ready so getting closer and closer to getting more of our students there um for advanced placement exams um this was from last year and so over the 2024 we had 546 students who had taken 1,9 exams and then those who scored with three or more with three or four or five was 464 four students we can only
057go by projections because those exams don't happen until May but we have approximately 635 we know that 1352 were paid for and then Based on 5year data we're hoping to see that this aligns like it has been to have at least 546 with three or higher for dual credit um we've seen the numbers kind of increase and there was just a little bit of a dip the number of courses that were taken I'm sorry the number of students who were taking courses but the students who were taking this year um took more courses even though it was less than the previous number of students from the past year and our industry based certifications for the class of 2024 um the number of IBC earned was 668 for class of 2025 and this was of January
05831st so the total number is 677 um today when I looked at it it was 725 so we keep moving up and right now we're in testing season so it starts about the end of December and we test mostly until April um before their senior year finishes out all right do you have any questions very good anybody have any comments or questions pretty straightforward we appreciate it keep up the good work uh let me ask this question just so we know over the last couple years we kind of recalibrated our goals because we were well ahead of it when we first started this back with the new a through F when Mr Brown was the executive director of CC Mr Right Colley career we were really doing well we're still doing well but we did
059stretch those goals out because we've got to because the the commissioner changed on ccmr didn't give us a pause or anything on what a an a looked like in ccmr or a B an a an A so I think which you needed how what was the percentage to qualify for that previously when we first set the goals it was 70% I think it was 68 um for an A but then it jumped up to 88 yeah 88 so we're on the cusp of trying to grab that in that in that domain right there we're going to be really close Poss very soon yeah soon okay good I mean unfortunately it's always behind whenever we have you know your leg but that doesn't stop us from our goals so we're going to head to that 88
060as much as we can we making progress though to being a firm B in that domain though aren't we yeah definitely and a lot of that's on not just on the ibc's not not just on the AP not just on the Dual credit but a lot of the alignment within the the uh the path not the pathways but the uh my gosh what am I look sequence of coures the program of study courses yes yes that that's important because there's requirements over the next 5 to 10 years that that has to remain a big de a big deal for the school system and we keep talking about parental choice right and so calling and switching your major for lack of a better term in year three is pretty impossible for us to to to to
061figure that out for for uh for a student if they're if they're three years in switching their last year is going to be difficult for us well one of the things I think it was back in 2022 knowing that this was happening because they kind of giving us an idea of where we were heading um when I was the director of CTE that was one of the biggest challenges that it is take a look and in line all those programs to study so if a student starts off the their freshman year the majority of our students can become a completer by junior year which also gives some more flexibility their senior year yeah um some of them may decide okay I'm I've completed I've received my IBC but now I want to take more dual
062credit courses my senior year AP courses they have that flexibility or if they decide they want to continue on that's where we really focus in on the work-based learning with practicum and know they get um to go to the hospital more or doing some of the internships that we've developed so well the reason I bring that up and I always use my own children when they go through the system and go through the experience of uh of of what we have my middle kid four years of architecture and doesn't want anything to do with that in his life ever again my point on that is it's great to think about the economy and and having a well-paying job when you get out but we also have to remember that when these kids are choosing that
063they're 13 years old in eth grade usually um what did y'all want to be when you were 13 I I either wanted to be Indiana Jones or I wanted to be the starting second baseman for the New York Yankees so I'm just saying that that there I'm really championing our staff for putting these things together to keep them uh to keep the the main thing the main thing so that we can score in the accountability system that's kind of how we're having to look at that so wanted to have a little bit of a discussion there that the data that we're that we're you know grabbing on this that they're actually achieving it's pretty substantial when you start talking about dealing with the Adolescent mind and um parents that that really want to take care
064of their kids I'm the same way not every parent says no you're going to stick with it until till you complete it and I also understand it's good for the district it's good for the campus it's good for the school uh but our teachers are really the the glue that holds them together and they're sticking with it and they're performing so uh just a little bit of a commentary on that okay thank you thank you for the information thank you um moving on to our consent agenda uh we'll pull items B and we'll also pull item e for individual motions but I'll go ahead and entertain a motion uh through items a through f with the acception of B and E so moved thank you do I have a second second all in favor say
065I I all opposed eyes haven't the motion carries uh okay Item B gifts and donations and Page 15 your packet we've got some outstanding Community organizations and institutions that are so benevolent towards our school system and our students and our teachers we love celebrating them as yall know the CDC local says that the the board actually approves all donations above $5,000 and we've got some to bring to you tonight one being being First Baptist Church Toler Reverend Pike Weisner the the pastor over there good guy but um they they actually provided $5,000 to the Wayne D bosier Center for exceptional programs we recognize one of their teachers tonight $155,000 the RW Fair foundation for the Tyler ISD athletic department youth basketball league what year are we on on that five or six I think and
066what a neat thing we have for our community for eight weekends um pretty much before but Christmas all the way to now I think their tournaments this next coming weekend we give our kids an opportunity to to not only play basketball but to be mentored by adults in the community that are giv back as well but we couldn't do it without the RW Fair Foundation as well thank them for that um ctcu Cooperative teacher Credit Union $38,500 for Tyler iy Communications for district events um think about convocation think about teacher of the year educator of the Year banquet we couldn't do it without Cooperative teacher Credit Union um certainly we want to protect our taxpayers dollars these enterprising funds help us do some of the things that we do to be able to celebrate our
067students and our teachers outside of what the the the taxpayers provide us which those those are what's targeting the classroom so there's your list of donations and it does take board action to approve those well great I'll uh if anybody has any comments go for it otherwise I'll entertain a motion on all of these awesome donations Ive that we approve with great gratitude to all three of these groups very very generous I second thank you and and I have a second okay all in favor say I I all oppos I have it the motion carries with a grateful heart pretty incredible Community we live in okay item e was consider approval of purchases of wireless network equipment and U I'll entertain a motion on that item uh with a knowledge that we'll have to come
068back and uh maybe adjust it possibly yeah the the uh the vendor that we actually approved on that's up for approval on that uh did get us the terms and conditions tweaked like they need to and um providing the superintendent authority to be able to go and execute that along with the board president signing that with something we'd be asking for right now okay I'll entertain a a motion on that item with those conditions Mr President I move that we approve item e contingent are subject to the superintendent reviewing the terms and conditions along with the president of the board thank you second all all in favor say I I I I'll oppose I have it the motion carries thank you for that um okay we have a uh considered approval of a waiver for
069low attendance for January 9th and 10th 2025 y'all remember those days January 9th and January 10th 38 degree weather 37 degree weather and Rain y'all remember those days oh yeah we were at school Tyler Rd came to school no not not because we're sticking our chest out to do that but the data doesn't lie right the tires on the road don't lie and so that's what the the waiver is for we're been a lot of uh discussion about that and guess what we have here in a couple three more days cold weather and then a chance of maybe moisture somewhere so anyways uh this is for the 9th and the 10th when we actually had school we had some low attendance days that those days the Board needs to take action for us to apply
070for that waiver to the state for that those low attendance days okay I'll entertain a motion on that item I move we um approve that item thank you do I have a second second all in favor say I I I all oppos eyes have it motion Carri okay we have an 89th legislative update yeah every two years the state legislature meets in Austin Texas elected officials go down there and make policy for the State of Texas a lot of that's an education policy I didn't realize there was anything going on this year in education down there in Austin really uh legislative sessions the 89th is is what they're calling this one uh Mr wasman uh real quick I don't want to spend too much time but we're certainly going to keep this on our agenda
071until they actually do sign D die uh at at the back end of uh what was that June I guess and um and certainly and we want to give the public opportunity to kind of know what's on our on our hearts on our mind uh Senate's put out there an initial Appropriations Bill I've got some things start here um $3 billion banum uh for new property tax relief increasing the homestead exemption uh you know they did a a really great work and certainly something that was needed to be done of Y all are all we all are property owners here uh sometimes many times over and that's certainly something that that's always on our mind but but your homestead is pretty much the the home that you live in it's not your rental properties it's
072not your commercial properties Etc they're trying to do some work down there $3 billion so far on the Senate side was what they're thinking on the contingency items uh three and a half on the house side uh just kind of going through through a few things that that that may be of interest to y'all uh on the IAL appropriation bill on the that's on the Senate side and then on the house side I told you about the 3.5 billion uh the public education 4.85 billion banum it's 2 point just a little bit over 2.4 um per year in that bium for public education funding on the uh on the on the house side it's about same thing on the on the Senate side as well and there is1 billion dollar uh on on the Senate
073side and on the on the house side they call them education education savings accounts it's easy to call them a voucher as well uh property tax relief uh is is something that that's kind of throughout both the house and the Senate is something that's really U interesting for them uh school safety is is something that that they really are concerned about as well that that probably will get a good look um as along with special education allotments uh house uh has put 450 million out there uh in the Senate 450 million out there uh for the opportunity for TRS Active Care premium increases they really are and of course we are a TRS Active Care District now they're projecting because healthc care is so expensive I don't care if you're self-funded or you're on the
074state plan it's going up exponentially and so they are asking uh TRS Active Care is asking the house and the Senate to throw something their way to maybe knock that down for for teachers um as we go forward because if there is any type of salary increase you don't want that eatting up uh on by by premiums going up and that's something that's really concerns us the the thing that we did as a school district I think that was a pretty a pretty good move for us uh as far as the the stewardship of tax dollars is to get out of the self-funded business for so long and I really do think you you think about people like Elmer and Betsy Ellis they really did give us the hometown discount when we were with ETMC
075Christus did a good job job of doing of of really working with us but it got so expensive on the uh um uh on a lot of that self-funded plan and it just got away from us uh to where we were spending a lot of money out of fund balance to be able to cover some of those extreme cases that were um that were above and beyond what the normal plan uh asked for uh you have a rise of these uh uh the these freestanding ERS that is that is another thing that really does concern us uh at least TRS Active Care uh feels like they've got that taken care of as well um stoploss insurance is what I was thinking of Casey um over there stop loss good job Rojo you you're over there
076Whispering weren't you but that was really starting to hit us and stop loss is certainly for those instances to where you have somebody with a really really tragic uh medical issue that that cost the district a lot of money past um what our healthc care agreements say and that was really starting to hit us so going over to TRS is something that was I spent a little bit too much time on that but that is something that's really Weighing on our hearts as well the governor's emergency items these are um things that they should be working on um and and hopefully have some resolution within the first 60 days of the SE session uh property tax relief water infrastructure teacher pay star that one expanding career opportun uh Career Education opportunities that's pretty big for
077us right school choice we already talked about that they've got the the vouchers that education savings accounts it's out there along with bell reform and Texas um some Cyber Network in security as well on the Senate's priority items obviously the Senate bill one is the Appropriations bill that's pretty important to all Texans right uh Senate Bill 2 school choice and you saw the vote what a week ago that's already been passed through the Senate and they're waiting what the house is going to do on that um Senate Bill three is really not a an education um uh issue but Banning THC in Texas y'all know how we feel about Vapes and that does I do think it does impact our school systems especially in in in regard of student code of conduct and the the
078ever prevalent and uh easily accessible Vapes uh that we have The Vaping issue that we have here and of such a conservative a morally conservative State and morally conservative County and city that we live in it amazes me uh with the availability of Vapes and it does get into your youth it gets to your youth quite quite easily uh you'll go all the way down to Senate Bill 10 10 commandments and schools Senate Bill 11 freedom of freedom to pay in to pray in school not to pay in school but freedom to pray in school Senate Bill 12 parental bill of of Rights and public Ed Senate Bill 13 inappropriate books in public schools you know that's one thing I've I've asked our um local reps and and uh legislators to think about that if
079we're truly concerned about about some of the the moral decay in society and and um you know is it happening inside of schools uh you know put some policy in place if it's important to us to to to eradicate some of those things to fix some of those things if it's important to them if not I think it's an issue that they just want to kind of keep talking about and because you know for some reason we've been identified as the boogeyman uh in a lot of ways unfortunately because there's a lot of good people that are working inside of our Public Schools uh that do have that moral compass and want to convey that to our kids but anytime one uh you know fouls up on that or gets out of line we want
080to want to Broad brush paint every Public School System across this state every school superintendent every school that we have so certainly I'm I'm really glad to see that that there are some bills that are going to be out there to talk about some of these things that are also concerning to us and things that we've actually taken care of from this dice in this school system uh and done adequately so I think uh House Bill 1519 on the house side you're talking about uh required Bond elections to possibly be in a in a in a November uniform election date so usually we we've done some Bonds in in November but we've actually done them in May but they're talking about possibly throwing that all into uh a November election date thankfully our uh that
081doesn't affect us right now 're we're we're at a pretty good place right now as far as our facil fa go over the last 20 years our community has really supported us and being able to get our new facilities taken care of and a very concern fiscally conservative way uh governance uh regulate the school start date House Bill 604 Mr Patterson some of y'all on the dice might want the school start date regulated and might be in favor of such not looking at anyone specifically uh Senate Bill 239 Middleton uh would limit lobbying by local school government there's some triggers in there for some of your state organizations like Texas Association School boards Texas Association School administrators whether to get there or not is to be determined um but there's also some some uh some
082bills out there about superintendent even contacting legislators the LA last time I looked I'm also a citizen of the state and a taxpayer of the state um so limiting people to contact your locally elected representatives it's just a pretty extreme thing I don't know if it'll any legs or not but that's just kind of the the atmosphere that's out there property tax House Bill 217 require a 60% margin uh in in uh Tres tax ratification elections um you know there's a little bit of uh wondering out there about that 60% of the uh super majority there's not a whole lot of things in this world that are requiring a super majority but uh it's certainly something that's going to be uh bantered about down down there over the next 3 or 4 months uh 236
083I don't know if it's got legs on the house side would move funding calculations from Ada to actual enrollment um just a little personal commentary here I think the the reason they've got the Ada in there instead of the actual enrollment um is because they've got algorithm or formulas down there about fully funding schools and then what to expect out of the attendance and I don't know if you could if you could get 100% uh funding and feel good about that from their from the state coffers if uh if we didn't have that 92 to 95% attendance if you win 100% attendance that's a lot of money that gets spent into public education so I don't know if that's got legs or not uh Senate Bill 569 talking about s fsp funding for full-time virtual
084programs we kind of talked about that during the Panic that we had during Co um but but I that might be the way with the future um as as far as being able to do that uh also Senate Bill 568 talking about um actually the the the the funding on special education uh we we know that we've been spending a lot of money out of our M to prop up special education because so many kids have entered the system since the ghost cap was eliminated uh a few years ago that's something that's pretty pretty uh interesting um we've already talked about again there was another slide on uh vouchers and then the last thing we'll talk about is uh something we need to be concerned about is is uh what do we do you know
085how do we go forward on this you certainly you begin with current law until things get passed Casey knows that and then you have contingency planning you're focused on your scenarios for level of change that specific mechanisms and what they do change I think at the end of the day you're going to to talk about teacher compensation increases I think one thing we've got to be concerned about is the largest school system in East Texas um is being lumped in with all the other Urban settings in the state because the urban the urban settings and their cost of Education the way those formulas are set up uh your Dallas's your dfw's your Austin your San Anton's your Houston's your larger school systems they're they're their their their formulas are different than ours um we are
086kind of lumped in there because we have 18,000 plus students well the last uh uh the last round of the 88th legislature they they kind of started out at 20,000 saying that that that $10,000 raise uh could potentially be provided for a rural school teacher and there is kind of a rural school teacher trigger on the the compensation boost this time well that last one got knocked down well below the 20,000 actually knocked us out of that that is something that concerns me but it would Encompass the rest of East texases let's say they CED at 10,000 well that would get everybody else but Tyler ISD in region seven and Region 8 including Long View who shares a lot of the same types of uh uh students that we have a lot lot of the
087same type of uh economic advantages that we have in their city so you know where is that cap going to be if they do decide to say that we're going to provide rural educators this type of raise versus Urban Educators this type of raise um so that's teacher compensation school safety allotment an increasing that it's going to be really good for Tyler ISD because we went all in in 2019 we put a police officer at every campus we we did you know they didn't they didn't really fund it it was an unfunded mandate but we went ahead and said we're going to prioritize school safety on our campuses to where we're going to provide at least one police officer sometimes multiple police officers at every one of our campuses and then of course special education
088which is what I just talked about as well um what you did not hear uh and what we're not hearing much of is an increase in the basic allotment and the increase in the basic allotment allows us to kind of fend off some of the inflationary issues that exist out there some of those fixed cost fuel electricity water um supplies uh everything has gone up whether it be the the cost of a pro a Chromebook or maybe uh a digital board that that we use for instruction at etc etc we're really having to figure out a way to be more efficient with what we're doing and we're going through that process right now uh and at the same time if if if teacher compensation is not um improved we've got to figure out a way
089to win and continue to to keep our streak up and we're fully committed to do so that's your legislative update I'm sure y'all don't want to have any commentary about it but in future meetings y'all certainly may have some questions we'll keep this item on there okay any comments or questions before we move on thank you for putting that on there it is a it's a big year and we we want to stay apprised of everything going on down in Austin so um future business we have March 6 uh Workshop spring break coming up March 17th 321 and uh March 31st we have a regular meeting um so looking forward to all that and I'll go ahead and main a motion for adjournment I Mo we adjourn second all in favor say I I I'll
090oppose I have it the motion carries this meeting is adjourned