001all this meeting to order uh Miss Tanner will you please take the roll call yes bassine here Martin present bson here Thomas here the calero here thank you uh now we're moving on to agenda item 2.01 superintendent's proposed operating budget for fiscal year 25 to 26 Dr good afternoon um Madame chair the calero um Miss Vice chair members of the board staff our community um this evening or this afternoon I will be presenting to you um my fiscal year 2526 operating budget proposal um Mrs spy our chief finance officer will start the presentation I will fill in in the middle and then she will close it up so without further Ado Mrs fing thank you thank you um good afternoon chair de Calera Vice chair Thomas members of the school board and Dr bird song
002um we are pleased to present the superintendent's proposed operating budget for fiscal year 2026 which will begin on July 1 of 2025 um while Dr Birdsong and I will speak about our plans for next year the work of developing the budget included uh Miss Crystal Skinner and her and her staff stand [Applause] please and I will say that the staff is brand new and we had a very positive experience this year with the development of this budget and I attribute that to the leadership of Miss Skinner and members of her team so again I want to publicly an acknowledge you for a job well done I also like the positivity with the green wardrobes for being very hopeful good um and and the and the budget was um guided um by the Strategic plan and
003the school board's goals um topics for discussion um next slide please oh you okay um on this slide are our topics for discussion for tonight next we keep going yes yes yes and um let's see um sorry okay here um our budget process it began in October of of this year and the um the steps that are shown on this slide um going through January actually early February are the steps that have already taken place next slide please okay so um the the things that um we have um left to complete the process of course today we're presenting the superintendent's proposed operating budget for fiscal year 2526 um on March 5th um we will U the school board will have a um public hearing on March 19th that's the date that we're recommending the school
004board approve its fiscal year 2526 um proposed operating budget April 1 is the statutory deadline for submission of the schools the school board's fiscal year 26 proposed operating budget um to be U um for it to be received by norfol city council and um and um so Northfolk city council will appropriate um funding um in the city's budget and then um later in in May it recommended that the school board will address differences between its proposed operating budget and the um norol City council's appropriate ration to north public schools and the school board um um is proposed to um adopt their budget your budget in um by the end of May on um the next slide this shows the um the breakdown of the operating budget that is being propo uh proposed the um the
005total budget um is um 772 Mill million um and it's broken down um into four funds the general fund um is 450 million the uh School nutrition fund 26.9 million the grants and special programs fund 42.8 million and the capital Improvement proposed budget is million SL um the um projected operating Revenue um for the budget is um the the largest amount comes from the state which is 263.50 million the city's portion is 167.5 million the um Federal government provides us um 5.4 million we're um estimating fiscal 24 reversion funds of 10 million and then there are some other local funds that make up about 3.7 million the um this slide uh represents one of our major challenges um in providing a budget for the Nori Public School Division and and um which is our declining
006enrollment and um this graph represents the um the decline that we've had over the past couple of decades and with that I will um our superintendent Dr bird song will speak to you about her vision and specific recommendations embedded in the fiscal year 2526 budget Dr B again good afternoon um Madame chair D calero Vice chair Miss Thomas members of the board staff and Community again good afternoon in a few moments I will outline my proposed recommendations for the operating budget for the 2025 2026 fiscal year for our newly elected school board members this will likely be a new experience for you while you may have participated in budget preparations for other or organizations I surmise you may not have dealt with a budget quite as large as this proposal which stands at approximately 7
0077729 million it is indeed a MAG a budget of great magnitude and yet despite its bread this proposed operating budget it's a lean one while the co pandemic had a profoundly negative impact on public education the remedial funding received from the federal government was quite substantial School divisions Across the Nation primarily receive financial support from three rounds of Elementary and secondary school emergency relief funding referred to as Esser as a part of the American Rescue plan act referred to as arpa altogether norford Public Schools received $1 1766 million over the last three years from these funding sources unfortunately that funding has ended let me say that again that funding has ended as a result and in addition to the anticipation of significantly less reversion funds the FY 2526 operating budget proposal had to be strategically
008shaped to be more fiscally constrained norford Public Schools will have $16.8 million less to work with during the next fiscal year compared to our current fiscal year status consequently this operating budget proposal may not appear to be as stimulating or exciting compared to my previous operating budget proposals as recommended recommendations do not involve the launch of brand new costly programs technology platforms and large scale infrastructure initiatives on the level that I proposed to you in the past however the good news is that this operating budget proposal is an extremely disciplined one one that is designed to build upon the many programs and improvements this Administration has put into place over the past several years please take a moment to again review this slide these and other key Investments have proven to be truly transformative indeed
009our School Division we are well positioned to weather a lean budget and most importantly to serve our students superbly at the same time while preparing a budget proposal presentation I often look at the budget messages of other leaders for inspiration President Barack Obama had this to say while delivering his final budget message yet while it is important to take stop of our progress this budget is not about looking back again we're not about looking back at the road we have traveled it is all about looking forward let's just say President Obama took the words right right out of my mouth this operating budget proposal is decisively forward-looking develop upon the foundation of the school division strategic plan the established goals of the school board and five key priorities these priorities include employee compensation employee Recruitment
010and Retention rightsizing the School Division safety security and Building Maintenance and repairs and instructional resources for our students and schools as a disclaimer the manner in which the priorities are listed on this slide may seem to indicate a ranking however please note that is not the case these five priorities are all important in and of themselves norit Public School operates in a climate of intense challenges a a few of which are listed on this slide however team MPS refuses to be intimidated no matter what right T no matter what this budget proposal is our battle plan for addressing such challenges as I proceed to outline recommendations you will see how my leadership team and I have strategically organized to overcome obstacles I will move quickly through my recommendations out of the board's respect or out
011of respect for board members requests for a streamlined presentation and for your reflection purposes I have provided a supporting fact sheet um so discussions can begin in a whole istic framework and that information is was provided to you at the beginning of the meeting in a study released in March 2024 The anenberg Institute at Brown University estimated that there were 55,000 vacant full-time teaching positions within the United States in the Commonwealth of Virginia the estimated vacancy stood at 2,594 norit public schools has made significant gains in addressing teacher vacancies however it is apparent that this is a lingering Trend therefore it is imperative that the School Division remains competitive in our salary structure please note that the salary recommendations I will outline in the ensuing slides take into account eligible part-time contracted staff as well
012with competitiveness in mind I recommending an increase of 4.5% for the starting pay of our teachers which would be an increase from $ 57,500 provided during fiscal year 2425 to $60,800 increase of 4.5% which includes a one-step increase on the teacher salary scale as well as a cost of living adjustment and as a reminder to all of us who experienced years and years of salary comp compression please be reminded that last school year final salary adjustments were made to the compensation packages of eligible employees to eradicate this compression and at this time I'm happy to report that longtime employees who experien salary comp salary compression have now been made whole and moving forward we will work hard to ensure that this unfortunate situation does not occur again in addition to ensure the Integrity of the
013school division's teacher salary scale we recommend that teachers who have already reached the very top of the teacher salary scale receive a one-time 2.2% bonus this bonus will reward veteran teachers for remaining with the school division but at the the same time acknowledge that there's a top to every salary scale very few teachers will qualify for this bonus as the vast majority of our teachers have between four and 10 years of teaching experience the recommended salary increase for administrators which includes School administrators and cab administrators will mirror how we plan to improve compensation for our teachers the administration will accomplish this by providing a one-step salary increase on the Administrator salary scale and a cost of living adjustment which like teachers will result in a 4.5% salary increase as with teachers those administrators who are
014at the top of their salary scale for fiscal year 2526 they will also receive a one-time 2.2% bonus for classified staff I recommend increasing their starting pay from $155 per hour to $15.72 per hour for current classified employees I recommend providing a one-step salary increase as well as a cost of living adjustment to raise their salary by 4.5% unlike the other two categories of employees teachers and administrators a one time 2.2% bonus is recommended for classified Personnel who are also at the top of their scale and I have more good news to share there will be no increase in healthare premiums for our staff so let me repeat that I propose that there be no increase in health care premiums for staff for fiscal year 2026 this means that current employees will enjoy the fully
015extent of their salary increases I am pleased that the Administration has found a way to keep the cost of healthc care premiums down for our employees especially during challenging Economic Times And before I move on to address other priorities it is important to note that employee compensation makes up 81.2% of the proposed operating budget this means that with the remaining 18 8% we must be extremely strategic and targeted in our priority allocations this budget is built on that imperative the details of the recommended recruitment bonuses are included on the accompanying fact sheet again that I handed out to you before the presentation these stiens range in cost from $250 to $2,000 and were previously underwritten written by Esser funding they have proven to be effective and therefore I recommend that we continue to provide um
016for them and the operating budget to support continued teacher recruitment efforts and as you are aware stiens not only expand the earning power for our teachers and other staff they also help the School Division close operational gaps consequently I am recommending that we maintain specific sty previously underwritten by Esser which now reside in the operating budget those stiens are allocated for PBIS support Wellness Champions at each of our schools and additional Club sponsorships we will also be continuing our use of stiens for grounds Patrol for obvious security reasons as well as for class coverage th this Manpower is critical it's absolutely critical as we work to address address the need for heightened school security and ensuring that our children receive high quality instruction each and every day and the projected cost of these strategies is
017approximately $2.8 million veteran school board members are aware that Lindenwood Elementary School's ignite program was designed as a pilot program this operating budget proposal will fund year three of this pilot program the funded strategies are included on this slide since the pilot Inception teacher turnover has decreased and Lindenwood elementary school has reached a full accreditation status for the first time for the first time in 17 years under the strong leadership of principal Valencia Moore and we certainly are still um celebrating that accomplishment and so the Administration has confidence that the third year will prove just as successful if this level of success continues we will evaluate the feasibility of expanding the pilot program to other schools in successive operating budget proposals and as we all know teacher recruitment efforts are critical they're critical to the
018school division's Success this budget proposal recommends setting aside funds to advertise teaching positions locally and Beyond we also plan to continue supporting the associate teacher program which recruits college graduates who may not hold a teaching license but desire to have a teaching career within norford Public Schools therefore funding is included in this budget proposal for the requisite professional development to help these teachers to be successful in their classroom Endeavors I have also tasked our HR team to expand its teacher recruitment efforts from attending and hosting more strategic recruitment fairs to situationally including teachers principals and other building administrators to assist them with successfully promoting norit Public Schools as a division of choice to prospective teacher candidates Additionally the administration plans to maintain our pool of tuition reimbursement funding as well the total projected cost of
019these strategies is $54,000 beyond the last decade norford public schools has experienced an average annual decline of about 300 students or so today the School Division has the building capacity to serve nearly 35,200 students but our enrollment stands at approximately 37 27,000 students so we must we must rightsize the school division to reflect that reality resulting benefits will include a more realistic allocation of staff and significantly more funding to improve instructional programming employee salaries and benefits as well as facility improvements and David sturz our educational and Facilities planning consultant is here with us um today and so you will be receiving more information about that and just a bit as points of progress this Administration has closed four school buildings and return them to the city for a projected annual Savings of approximately $ 35,000
020to $60,000 per site and that's just for utility cost alone these data points do not include Personnel savings which is significantly more and of course as you all are aware there's so much more to be done in this area so as we move ahead a long range educational and Facilities planning committee will be charged with developing an actionable Citywide plan this committee will meet throughout the end of this school year to review data and explore options for optimizing norford Public Public Schools portfolio of schools there after the board will will receive recommendations for the beginning of a comprehensive School CL osure and consolidation effort Communications and Community engagement efforts in both the committee phase and recommend recommendation phase will be substantial efforts will include Community meetings focus groups Direct Mail surveys and print and electronic
021communications we have set aside $130,000 to underwrite the fees uh associated with educational and facil planning as well as Communications and Community engagement efforts I anticipate there will be considerable discussion and maybe even consternation amongst school board members our city colleagues and Community stakeholders regarding the timing of closures and consolidations some stakeholders may have the opinion that the School Division should close double- digigit numbers of schools all at once as the School Board is aware closures and consolidations involve more than just shutting down buildings and moving children to new locations efforts to close multiple schools at once must take into account any needed physical changes to the receiving schools to accommodate student programs and spaces that meet the needs of all of our children additionally physical improvements require adequate time they require staff and funding
022the administration we're not aware of a magic number of schools that will be recommended for closure or consolidation within each phrase phase however I am extremely confident that this Administration and the school board working alongside our community stakeholders we will working in the spirit of teamwork and collaboration we're going to get this job done and in a manner that is thoughtful and strategic and puts our students first and as a disclaimer as you're looking at the pictures on this slide please know that they were just put on this slide for your for visual purposes this does not mean that we are closing these particular schools before I get 100 emails so this this is just for your viewing purposes and also to demonstrate that this is a division-wide effort over recent years norford public schools
023has made significant investments in expanding personnel and personnel and resources to support the Safety and Security of our students and staff this budget builds upon that progress with the purchase of additional security cameras vehicles to facilitate increased School coverage throughout the instructional day and increased compensation for police security during athletic events to ensure Regional competitiveness now transitioning to the CIP the FY 2526 Capital Improvement plan is significant at $253 million in addition to funds for the re the rebuilding of my high school it includes School Bus Replacements HVAC Replacements and the upgrading of restrooms electrical systems a replacement pool and roof at Camp Young and a in improvements to interior wall systems just to name a few so miss Miss 5y during her closure of this presentation she will provide you more information about our
024CIP instructional resources for students in schools may be the last priority I address this afternoon however as I previously shared this is no indicator of its ranking norit Public Schools must be strategic in linking resources to the needs of our students in that vein this propos operating budget contains the funding necessary to employ an additional 33 english as a second language teachers to support our growing number of English Learners our English learner student population continues to significant significantly increase and so um this year we well starting in school year um 2019 2020 we had 1,18 students and that was about 3.7% of our total um student population and this year that number again has significantly increased to 1,93 students um at 7.1% of our overall student population so we must be better equipped to move
025this vulnerable student population toward successful integration um and into um our predominantly English-speaking academic environment in addition to our commitment to meeting the instructional needs of our English Learners the School Division also strives to be in full compliance with the standards of quality as it relates to the teacher student ratio for our English Learners another vulnerable group of students whose needs must be addressed within this operating budget is our students with disabilities in an effort to provide for the increased instru FAL needs of our students with disabilities this budget proposal seeks to provide an additional 13 special education teachers to include nine inclusion teachers two teachers for our postgraduates one additional teacher for our students with visual impairments and one additional teacher for our students with autism the School Division has also seen an increase
026in the overall percentage of our students who are eligible for special education service from 15% during school year 2024 to currently 177% this school year at 4,6 and7 students and so miss Tanner if you can go away back oh way back way back is this where we are she's trying to rush me along in other words hurry up hurry up I'm almost done just a couple more minutes okay another Personnel Edition I'm recommended within this operating budget proposal osal at the request of my high school principales is increased staff support for daily School attendance student attendance continues to be a significant factor in high schools meeting the benchmarks established within the State's new accountability system and even beyond that we need to employ herculan efforts to ensure our students are moving decisively towards ontime graduation
027we really do and so therefore I am requesting an additional five an additional five attendance technicians so that each High School can have daily dedicated support which they currently do not have the additional reading specialist position to be assigned at Northside Middle School will move norit Public Schools towards full compliance of the governor's Virginia literacy act which requires one full-time reading specialist at other at every school and at this time we have a 0.5 position at North side middle school and with the first year of implementation of bookery Washington High School steam program it has become evident that the school needs a teacher specialist whose primary instructional assignment will be to work alongside the school's Administration and teachers to effectively Implement instructional programming to ensure strategic alignment between steam competencies and daily classroom instruction as
028well as other program components this operating budget proposal also includes funding to support mentors for principles who are new to the principal ship this supporting strategy will provide new principles the guidance and mentorship that they need to be successful in a fastpaced high needs educational environment with guidance from effective retired principles who have been there and done that Shoring up our leadership capacity will undoubtedly improve the instructional environment and the overall culture and climate of our schools and as you may recall Esther funding allowed norford public schools to implement robust tutoring programming supports these instructional supports have proven invaluable as school staff have moved expeditiously toward addressing what has been referred to as learning loss yes we're still talking about learning loss that occurred as a result of the pandemic to maintain this eort the
029operating budget proposal includes continued funding for tutoring supports and finally on this slide maintaining funding for care soless and Panorama which are provided as a resource and instructional tools to support the School Division social emotional learning efforts is recommended to better ensure that seal supports are consistently deployed throughout our School Division thank you Miss Tanner all all right the school division's uh existing equity and Excellence Learning Centers affectionately known as EC's which include PB Young Elementary J Cox Elementary rner School and bookery Washington High have gotten off to an impressive start veteran school board members may recall business meetings that took place this school year whereby parents teachers and students address the board to share what they perceive to be the benefits of our e elc's ranging from additional before and after school enrichment opportunities
030to additional resources to support for families and in their education Journeys to mental health supports for our families so I am recommending that this Innovative program be extended or expanded to the Southside STEM Academy at campus Stella as the children and families of this school could certainly benefit from the offerings of our EC's the projected overall cost of $434,500 stiens for classroom teachers to assist with the extra planning efforts to execute this program within the school the recommended funding will also help provide additional before and after school enrichment programs secure Community Partnerships and purchases of um supplies and resources that will be needed for various programs events and activities held at the school and as you Ponder the overall cost of operating our elc's which is equivalent to almost $1.1 million please be reminded that
031the implementation of programming directly benefits our students our families and our community my next recommendation does not fit neatly into one of the AFF forementioned priority areas however I assert that it will support all five priorities specifically I'm recommending that NPS set aside a pool of funding that will be used to employ specialized contracted legal services from outside firms when needed for decades MPS has been served by the Nori city attorney's office and that service has proven to be invaluable and we have two of our city uh attorneys sitting over here today and I want to publicly an acknowledge them for their daily work with norford Public Schools they have done an exceptional job but they too need a break from time to time so um however the school division is is just one of
032their clients um and they have to address a plethora of Municipal needs and as you're aware education law has become increasingly intense and highly specialized throughout any given year a School Division must seek legal counsel on special education issues labor contract and Human Resources law property rights Freedom of Information and First Amendment law and various liability issues such as school bus accidents which unfortunately occur in previous years and as recently as this year I know the school board did have a discussion about hiring it its own attorney however at this time I am only I'm only recommending that fund need be set aside to support specialized contracted Legal Services when needed and that of course will be under the advisement of our city attorney's office typically I conclude my budget presentations with a piffy quote
033this afternoon I have chosen to end with this quote from Dr condalisa Rice a former United States Secretary of State and National Security advisor Dr rice asserted that education is transformational it changes lives that is why people work so hard to become educated and why education has always been the key to the American dream the force that erases arbitrary divisions of race and class and culture and unlocks every person's god-given potential all of us here this afternoon believe in the power of public education this expend expenditure plan resonates with that belief while lean it has been strategically designed to fiscally provide for what is needed to secure the Improvement we seek for the precious 20 27,000 children whom we serve in our mission to provide equity and Excellence for all no matter what so I
034thank you for your kind attention this afternoon I will now turn the podium back over to our chief finance officer Miss biy who will close out the presentation remaining slides provide um financial highlights the proposed general fund budget is $45.2 million um salaries and employee benefits comprise 81.2% of the operating budget with 18.8% of the um budget covering all other cost next slide please um looking at the budget from a functional are area 71.1% of those costs are for instructional support 12.1% are for operations and maintenance 6% for attendance and health and 10.8% for all other areas um the proposed budget is um $16.7 million less than the fiscal year year um 2025 revised budget the primary difference in the expected revenue is the estimated reduction in reversion um and other one-time funds most of
035the reduction in expenditures is related to salaries and benefits um as the fiscal year 26 budget preparation process included a right sizing strategy involving the estimation of expenditures in light of the current hiring environment and that's also Illustrated on the on the next slide where we show where um we are expecting the um reversion funds um to um end um the um audited um fiscal year 2024 um year um with with most with most of those um being um in instruction and a large portion of those being in salaries and benefits again again that's related to the right sizing of the budget not a reduction in positions um the um this the slide being projected now um as um Dr Birdsong stated a 4.5% increase in compensation is proposed for most employees uh this slide
036shows um examples of um a classroom teacher and a custodian just you for reference of um of what that increase will look will look like um as it shows the um starting teacher salary um would increase to $60,800 and uh and you can see also see on the middle part of that slide um the example of a custodian and um and what the increase would look like for um a custodian and other classified employees um at um in that range um the proposed budget also includes 253 million for um Capital Improvement planning and we we show the revenue sources on um on this slide and then on the next slide um are the the projects themselves um 20 and 31 million is um proposed for the Mory High School rebuild and the remainder of the
037are deferred maintenance projects um for the um schools listed um on the slide as well as um School Bus Replacements um and then in addition to the proposed projects we also wanted to um show the um the active projects that we already have ongoing and these will continue into the new budget year okay and with the last slide I'll re recap um the recommended next steps um on March 19th um we're recommending the school board's approval um of your um fiscal year 26 budget um that is U required to be presented um to city council um honor before April 1st and in the month of May would uh be U when um we U ex um estimate that city council will um appropriate um our budget to us when they adopt their budget and um
038and if there are any differences um the school board will address those differences and um and adopt the school board's budget and that concludes my comments on chair the the calero sorry any uh I will turn the podium back to you anybody have any questions or comments I was listening in on my way in thank you for a well um comprehensive budget to your team Dr song on your team I'm I'm excited to hear about um the um extension um to Discovery um campus I'm getting my divisions mixed up campus Stella Discovery um stem um I'm excited about that um and also I'm excited about um the emphasis on custodians and their p increase as well um support staff and also hearing that the compression did I hear it correct that we have it's been
039res okay and last year was the the last year of implementation for eligible staff I'm glad to hear that as well so I know I'm going to have more questions um as I said I was listening on my way in but um what I see I like you know but I I know I have some more questions but I just wanted to say thank you for those Miss Bine um yes thank you for the presentation um I my I more have a suggestion um given the number of agenda topics for this afternoon if there is still a workshop um planned for the business meeting if we could come back and have an opportunity to to um share questions ahead of time and and continue the budget discussion um I don't know if that sounds like
040something that we could um agree too given that we have a very large 45 minutes and um I know our Consultants are here and um so that way we could get some questions into Dr bird song before uh the workshop everybody in agreement I agree yeah we have a long agenda in addition um chair at the Cal Arrow we are happy to host to by two meetings with school board members if they have questions and they want to come in and sit down with me and my budget team we're more than happy to do that as well thank you appreciate that all right moving on to agenda topic 3.01 educational and Facilities planning update Mr sturs okay good evening thanks for having me good to be here uh some familiar faces and I get to
041meet some new ones it's nice to meet you three this evening good to see you all Dr Bert song uh Miss deal d caler d calero I got it I was practicing ma'am can I just call you Professor D sure I get struts a lot so I get that so my apologies I'll work nice to meet you all uh so tonight I'm going to go over uh our I was asked to present a summary uh for especially given the new board members tonight sort of a wayfinding how did we get where we are right now in portfolio planning what do I mean when I say portfolio planning as I said to the folks here my mother was an English teacher so Define your terms that's drilled in my head among other things so we'll get
042to that and uh then to discuss the committee formation where we stand where we see it going and what the work ultimately leads to so I'm going to start um and I uh miss Karen do I have a clicker up here that I can use or okay yeah beautiful can we what see do do I have to do something is it on it says it's on I see green it's a PDF so it's not gonna yeah oh you know what it's Mouse up there too the mouse is also up there scroll all right mini P same Summit all right what do I say in portfolio planning we're talking about the number sizes configurations and locations of your schools relative to your population that's the whole game and as Dr bird song shared population has changed
043chronically and we'll show that that has that change has been in proportion to the change in the population overall it is systemic in norfol um and it's it's been happening for some time it's going to continue so aligning the portfolio of schools to your population not for arbitrary number balancing but because the number of schools that you operate relative to your population determines how much you can invest per student and that population decreases over time and your fixed assets stay the same the amount that you proportionately can invest per student decreases over time in that same proportion as Revenue comes with student so we're looking for that optimal balance between the portfolio of your schools and the population that you serve so that you can invest in your kids today where they are today as
044opposed to where the schools were created for what they were created for a population when they were created years decades ago okay so I'm going to go over a little bit on our history uh the enrollment and budget and uh facility outcomes the way we're thinking about that some case studies that we that we looked at as a part of this process and I apologize for our three board members who have seen this before um and then uh get into our our committee and next steps in our charge so um with is there a enlarge this I'm sorry to interrupt but the says 71% and hit the plus I'm just wonder if I can get rid of this thing but on the side is there a control that box up there all right this will
045work all right so in the time when we were looking at this in the spring of 23 at that time looking 10 years in uh between 2010 and 2020 we actually saw an average city population decline of 480 per year and a population decline in the district at the time 2010 to 20120 of over 500 so in proportion that has leveled off a bit as Dr Birdsong showed of late but still 300 students a year over the last 10 years is significant um and that is despite single family uh per home permits and multif family permits as shown so that uh that enrollment that population decline is tied to your city decline in many of my clients that I work with uh the city population is stable to slightly increasing while the school population is
046declining because of choice and choice alone driving the driving that decline here it is it is chronic it is systemic it is not Choice alone it is uh is systemic plus we also looked at so what are the conservative estimates of the fixed cost tied to the building of the Personnel tied to the building the operations tied to the building as a planning number at the elementary middle and high so we have some idea about what the reinvestment capabilities are uh when you look at Surplus and buildings in consolidation if you Google school research on consolidation you will find papers that say they don't save money what you will actually find if you read those studies is it is possible to close schools and not save money if you don't actually reinvest in the kids
047it's possible to do it wrong is what they're showing but it's also possible to do it well and to and to pair your portfolio to your buildings and into to your kids and reinvest in those children with the money that you can uh uh efficiencies you can find so we looked at that conservative just under a million 1.8 for midd and 2.6 and this is at the time uh for highs the average building specific operating and Personnel cost we then looked back and said okay what would a rightsize portfolio look like and how much Surplus buildings would you be operating uh have you operating now and what are the estimated costs based upon those models that you're carrying what I did is I looked regionally at elementary middle and high uh high schools and said
048if you took a school offline would your student to capacity ratio be uh 85% less or more my target was to make sure that every region didn't exceed 85% um utilization meaning that you had a little room to grow the goal is not to overpack schools at 100% is to be operationally efficient and allowing for grade level fluctuations over time because they happen right and flexibility so it was if a if taking a school offline in a region meant that that Region's utilization went to 90% you didn't consolidate right it wouldn't make sense because you don't want to overload so I did this estimate by region by grade level and determined that based upon your projections at the time the 2024 to 2031 the district was carrying between the elementaries and and middles and in
049in the outer years Highs but you're not there yet you're not there yet going to say that clear on high schools um 11 million a year in Surplus operating costs from carrying that Surplus that could potentially be reinvested and greater than that close to 16 and by 2030 that assumes zero consolidation so part of the you know the the design here is when we get to that right siiz portfolio what does that look like here are my non-negotiables and we get it we work with the committee on on how to apply this and how to add to it good conditioned schools warm safe cool dry and educationally adequate right size to the population so what is the your newest elementary schools for example as I'm looking at it if you just compare calott to Camp
050Allen because they're right next to each other alphabetically Camp Allen has 25 % more square foot per student than does calcut they have only about it only has about four classrooms more capacity the new your new school but it has a lot more square foot per student because schools today are built for special education for intervention and pullout for adequate gym space for the uh uh spill out space outside the classroom some of that that Flex space it is it assumes you have a nurse it assumes you have counselors it has more square feet per student because the schools are not just sit and get it is a holistic service to children and so the newer schools are larger in that in that sense they have more square foot per student so defining what is
051the model for quality for our schools Okay so we've got good condition the schools that meet the model of quality for total holistic education of our kids and proximate to our families where are our kids today we are the highest population of kids right and we add to that with the committee so this this Vision what we're looking at I want to be very clear and I'll repeat this the what we're looking at a portfolio plan is an instate vision for a rebuilt Norfolk Public Schools consolidation is a means to that just as much as rebuilding is any of your schools need to be rebuilt so we're going to look at those as well so we looked you have room to invest in your kids when you rightsize this portfolio we just need to do
052it well that was phase one let's look at sort of the preliminary enrollment budget and opportunities phase two wanted to look you said at the time and repeat first of all Do no harm we want to look at studies across the state of Virginia across time and look at if we're consolidating newer and fewer in rebuilding this District newer and fewer is there evidence that those larger enrollments are harming kids across the state when we look on over time and we looked over 10 years of data the answer is no we did not find any evidence that larger enrollment schools and in the grade levels elementary middle or high uh had any evidence of causing harm in fact we saw evidence to the opposite in many cases and I'm going to go over that as
053a key part of our data we looked at State means centered scores which meant we looked year over-year what was the mean scores for so passage rate which was our our Rudder that we used over 10 years of data and how did each district uh division uh scores vary from that mean hence the state means centered scores year-over-year from 2013 to 2022 obviously Co year is not available here's the summary on some of the key findings one we found that the FCI or the building condition of schools in Norr public had approximately the same effect size on chronic absenteeism as social economic status social economic status is not in your Control building condition is more in your control that's big secondly that accreditation appears to be influenced by school size across the state generally speaking
054the by the schools with the enrollments on a little bit of the larger side had higher accreditation rates see under 500 credit ration in rates of 88.7 500 to 750 92.5 over 750 97 that's across the div across the state third across the state larger enrollments do not correlate with a decrease in so passage rates and in many cases correlate with an increase in passage rates the hypothesis that we have behind the findings and it was a it was a finding uh that we found we from looking at 10 years of data is that in many cases you simply have more resources per capita in larger enrolled schools than in your very smallest schools key findings one Statewide accreditation appears influenced by school size no evidence small enrollments increase the probability of being accredit accredited
055two looking at NPS data the school condition correlates to to outomes Portables do not we did look at Portables as well we want to get rid of them because for a variety of reasons right um but that's not the that's not the focus here sces had the largest negative correlation to state mean centered scores of course you that's not a a new information for you all that you would expect that but the the tying of FCI to Chronic absenteeism having the same effect size as SCS that was surprising to me and I've done this for a while building utilization by itself does not strongly correlate to straight State means centered scores it's not utilization is a proxy for the data that matters what matters is can you invest in your kids to scale every day
056utilization is just aoxy to that additional findings NPS has more great configurations than any other Virginia division except Fairfax and they're a tick larger than you all the ratio of behavior incidents for NPS was um close to the mean one of the things we wanted to look at was you know is for is NPS an outlier no you're not chronic aism uh 51st percentile right at the mean so scores are in the bottom 11 to 19% for reading math and science there's the there's the target right more resources per kid that is what's driving this red you sometimes see as bad and uh in this case red is high so red is good so red is red is hot there you go warm what this looked at is 10 years worth of data where we
057ranked every student subgroup by ethnicity as provided by uh the Virginia Department of Education across the entire State across the top there these are organized by school size such that and you cannot see this on the bar for some reason but that this little slice of data is schools under 150 enrollment and then it goes 50 to 199 then 200 to 249 so on and so forth the the numbers are the rank so over a 10-year period where did that across the entire state where did students in that subgroup have the highest passage rates in what enrolled schools you can see as you go to the right the numbers tend to get more red again we wanted to make sure if we're really creating a division-wide plan for norfol about newer and fewer schools would
058we do harm probable harm by having more of the larger schools which is we're not talking larger than you currently have we're talking like Camp Allen for elementary schools right as your standard and and we just don't see that data in fact we see suggestions to the opposite we look directly in norfol and of course the smaller the samper size the more noise a data set gets so is a little bit noisier here but their same basic trend line can be observed and your very smallest enrollments one thing to note too is that sometimes your very smallest enrollments are often specialized programs as well and so things get a little apples to potatoes as you get some of our smaller uh smaller schools but the trend line still holds true so recommendations from this preliminary
059study study one get as many students as possible into FC into facilities with low fcis let's let's address that how are you going to do that well you need more money first and for you need more money and for many of these schools it's yes Rick's done doing a lot of work on HVAC and roofs air envelope Interiors a lot many of these schools it's time for a refresh it's time to rebuild once you get to a certain point which uh Mike's hba's recent study will show highlight so we need to increase Capital funding we need to decrease High FCI buildings you need to do both determine enrollment size for each gr grade level that affords the human and programmatic Investments designed for all students what is that model for elementary school and all the
060Investments what are the school what's the school design that fits that model how how many students do you need to afford to maintain all of the human Investments and then that's the model moving forward forward right um and different options include in this we also wanted to look at the configurations because you do operate a lot of configurations and different options to consider are do we M do we move more to a traditional elementary middle and high K5 6 8 9 12 do we move aggressively towards a K8 912 do we add do we do we keep a mix of that what are the different options benefits and challenges and that's what we're going to look at in these next phases as a part of the study after looking at the entire State on school
061size we looked at configuration across different peer districts and outcomes and the summary that I find I can say in brief middle schools are challenging that's the that's the cliff notes version of all of this middle schools are challenging we looked at Baltimore City Urban Ohio districts and the school district of Philadelphia the reason for these is that these districts had um first of all available data serving uh Urban centers and that data was available over time Baltimore Baltimore is a very interesting study between 2000 and 2013 Baltimore more Consolidated Schools while moving to a dominant K8 912 configuration they did this and it it's can see this I have a students per school from Blue to Red this so the school size is getting larger over time okay as their school the numbers of
062schools are decreasing you notice between 2003 and 2013 there was one state test the one test the MSA that was used and they switched to the park in 2015 the MCAT in 2019 and the numbers get messy after that because the tests change right but but if I only showed through 2013 people would ask why did you just show 10y old data so I'm showing the rest but I want to focus on this between 2003 and 20 2013 the 60 in 2003 66% of their of their schools were elementary schools 17 were Elementary midds 17 were midds when you get to 2013 40% % of their schools were Elementary 56 were Elementals 4% were midd they sunsetted middle schools over that period of time and the Topline difference uh from the mean on this is
063a mean state mean centered score on the on their uh MSA test they got closer as time went on from 12 points below down to two back up to for and then you get to the outer years and it gets really messy and noisy with the data right but they converted they Consolidated they converted configuration overall Improvement in in during that period of time importantly I looked at third third grade fifth grade and eighth grade math and reading proficiency looking at uh kids in the same grade level who were attending different configuration schools so in third graders attending an elementary in blue versus elementary middle or K8 in Orange uh slight Improvement uh slight overall better in performance at the k8s in third grade reading third grade math fifth grade um reading and fifth grade
064math is really close fifth grade math is really really close but the reading and and the others um was higher you look at the eighth graders in Middle Schools versus k8s it's pretty noticeable in reading math less so attendance higher and then you compare that to NPS average so passing rates in the same manner and you see a similar trend line Philadelphia we looked at 2023 data and showed that the student students who by different grades attending Elementary k8s or middle schools that students in Middle School settings consistently underperform their peers um in in different in the other settings in K in particular really interesting to me is if you look I'm going to geek out for a minute so apologize but if you look at um the growth rate which is here what I've
065highlighted in this in this bar you see that that sixth graders in an elementary setting make giant growth but their their ending achievement is is similar or below their peers in K8 settings and the middle schools are even below than that there's a bump that I found in the data a trend in the data is that students who were at the very top of their Elementary program fifth graders in a K5 sixth graders in the k6 tend to do very very well being kings and queens of the hill but the K8 settings that tend to they tend to start ahead and end at the same rate or ahead of their peers in the other settings that in in this study in particular middle schools are challenging chronic absenteeism was higher as well um Urban Ohio
066districts akan Cincinnati Cleveland Columbus Dayton and Toledo again same results students in Middle School settings consistently underperform their peers in elementary and K settings while having significantly more disciplined days per student it's worth noting um you know they're small these elementary schools and middle schools in many cases are small um Dayton and Toledo had 712 we're not talking about that here but um we looked at ranking performance discipline teacher evaluations chronic asmm and closing of gaps in all configurations of across all of these Ohio schools because that data was available and then ranked them and middle schools were at the bottom consistently it's just middle schools are tough okay so all of that background cly setting the table for what are we trying to accomplish and what are we trying to solve for how are
067we going to do it the end of the day we're going newer fewer we're trying to invest more in our kidss and and less in maintaining a bunch of buildings the options are you just keep your current configurations as they are and you reduce portfolio two you move your 38s to k8s as part of portfolio reduction in many cases 38s are maintained so you don't have to close a K2 right k8s are are established configuration and any of the cases the schools that host 38 can host a K8 you eliminate a transition we know transitions are hards on kids hard on kids so another option you add some k8s as part of a portfolio reduction you look at your elementary middle and high reduced and you make sure that there's Equitable access regionally to a
068K8 option fourth option is you would move to a dominant like a Baltimore a dominant K8 912 configuration logically the options fall along a Continuum like this which we want to explore with the committee speaking of which this Meandering flowchart with very small text concludes with in this committee what we did is we do want to constitute a new committee with some fresh voices fresh faces and uh to look at this portfolio for that what is the desired instate for norol public schools what does a rebuilt norol schools look like to this end this time I have asked to have a partner in doing this work and have subbed some consult for myself sub worked to the miles agency local Communications team to help with uh with vetting these applications and to help with facilitating
069meetings uh this is sensitive work it's important work I care deeply about it with you all I've been here for a bit but I do not live here and it is important to have somebody here who is my partner in the communication and uh the uh Community engagement who does and who's professional in this field and so I've subw worked to her uh to the miles agency to help with this and and they have helped tremendously with setting up uh this rubric for the committee and we'll help facilitate it our recommendations in consultation with Miles agency is that the criteria include we want direct relationships to the district students employees those who have skin in the game Citywide representation by Ward it's not going to be perfectly proportional but we want to get close we
070want to aim we can take what we get in terms of applications in and we want to to be mind of being representative relevant experience on this type of work indicating while indicating openness to a fresh perspective we ask questions in this in the application um to see willingness to and and ability to handle tough conversations with folks who have different opinions than yourself ourselves and uh what were their responses to that stated commitment to objectivity and working with diverse voices and a manageable committee size can't have 100 people um so looking at a manageable committee size somewhere around two to three dozen so we have done our pass on the approximately 100 applications that were received after I'm not going to read all of the assassinations in this pipeline but we received about 100
071applications for the division did and in consultation with Miles my team has gone through them and uh made some initial recommendations and the uh um the plan is to discuss those in more detail with you later this month and to look into those next steps but I want to conclude with this and I know I've said it but it Bears repeating I'm going to keep doing it we are going to present you all a plan for a rebuilt norfol Public Schools consolidation must be a part of that it is not the only part of that need to look at schools if you were to start today where your kids are where you have school sites how would you rebuild how where would you have schools what makes the most sense we want to start with
072that lens and uh and be U really focused on those three pillars condition right size to allow investments in all kids every day for uh world class education and proximity to students we're not your population density where they are looking at where they are we want to have schools close to that so that's my uh Spiel and review of where we are today and thank you for your time and happy to entertain any comments or questions anybody have a quick question or comment quick okay I know there's lots of data points but I want to concentrate my question just on sir um you were talking about the schools um yes sir okay yeah by grade level and you're using 5% would the you you might practically speaking that would mean you would consolidate and addition
073elementary school or two division wide um because that that percentage point is so little that in many regions uh one school you close one school might be at 84 you close two schools might be at 93 right so it's that it's that division wide you might have one additional two schools to to Nuance it a little bit my rule of thumb is I want to plan at 85 because population fluctuations within 15% is a healthy way to be understanding that you could be plus or minus 5% of that and be okay depending upon a variety of circumstances because no one single set of data dictates the plan you've got to look at Region you've got to look at variety of factors 85 plus or minus 5 is a good rule of thumb I was trying
074to figure out what data you use yes sir that's that information there yes sir so I want see what the value would be if there is value situationally specific there may be cases in which that would make sense um but I like to say sometimes it might make sense to stay at 80 sometimes it might say sense to be at 90 it depends on the totality of data good thank you very much yes sir any additional questions Miss yes um thank you Mr STS for your presentation and and review of Where we've been and where we are today um I think it's helpful especially for new board members um I have a couple of questions so as part of well if we could maybe I'll work backwards so with the committee so the committee right
075now you've gone through the applications working with this um miles subc consultant that you all wport has um brought on board and they're a local agency that's going through them and then we'll we get to see the recommended applicants and then okay and does will the board have a say in in any of that or so uh it's certainly up to the board but I don't know if you want to get in the weeds of who's assigned to committees but that's a board decision yeah and I I'm because we we typically um I had inquired about this and I thought um just like we do with our advisory committees that I was under the impression that they were coming back to the board so that's why I'm asking that question because we do do that
076for other Committees of the board um because ultimately we all make decisions around the the right sizing right and we're representatives of that community so um that's why I asked that I like the U I like that you used EX examples of uh school districts that and I think for the benefit of this board um several of them are part of the Council of great City schools and also um use the effective School Board of governance model um and so we've talked about in the past with your visits here about having our student outcomes be at the focus yes of of you know all the decision making right and so I would I would like to see um or at least call it attention to the fact that they use the districts that especially Philadelphia
077yeah and Baltimore City have used their student outcomes goals and guard whales which we call non-negotiables as the center point of developing their right sizing plan and so um I just wanted to put that out there as we continue our work around this um and and that that should be at the center of our decision making I 100% agree right and then um and I know this is going to be this is a big thing that we're probably not going to have time to get into but also attendance zones and how that's going to be examined um as part of this process that's a great question my recommendation in in phasing is that we start with the qu we start in with answering the question what should the be portfolio of schools be to maximize
078the investment in per student um while being proximate to where our families are we answer that question and then once that's settled we draw boundaries because the the reality is with the kind of rebuilding and reshaping that are is likely given the decline enrollment and the decline in conditions despite best efforts your buildings keep getting older and they need a lot of money it I see it likely rebuilding several and some changes to scale that it would be best to do this in its entirety first bless the plan and then create a redistricting plan accordingly where I've seen some sometimes get tripped up a little bit is when the two processes get conflated and and the notion is well we can't rebuild that school we have to rebuild this school because this boundary process will
079be harder than that boundary process and what we're ultimately talking about is a 100 Years of a building being there when we're done we want to really get that right and then then we'll do the the boundary changes okay and my my final question for now um for now is um oh my gosh like trying to get through everything in my um head and my gosh I just point on what that um oh I know I just looked right so with all of the work that's been done around uh Windows Doors roofs all of that is there an updated FCI there is that is uh that has just been completed a study that that U that Rick had commissioned by um HBA Mike Ross I received a a preview on some of those and you're
080going to get receive a full brief uh here here shortly but yes those fcis have been updated based on the uh Investments okay all right thank you thank you our agenda has us doing two things at the same time um so let's move on to 3.02 as quickly as we can uh feasibility study process update comprehensive CTE High School Mr pole yes Dr pul is going to be pre presenting um an update as it relates to where we are um with our process and we also have with us today Mr Roberts who is going to support the presentation with rrmm and they were the contractor who won um the contract to review the feasibility of our efforts and looking at transitioning uh Lake Taylor High School into a comprehensive CTE site thank you Dr Birdsong
081good afternoon Madame Madame chair de calero Vice chair Miss Thomas members of the board and Dr bong um I appreciate the opportunity to provide an update on the study for a comprehensive High School L High School um as you know this initiative represents a significant investment in our our students future equipping them with skills in high demand career Fields I'd also again like to recognize Mr Rob burs over here to my left in the blue suit um with he's the principal AR a principal architect with rmm who is a word of the contract the primary goal of the study is to modernize Lake Taylor High School into a comprehensive Career and Technical education or CTE High School focusing on renewable Energy Solutions and advanced technology integration into the program uh the program will build upon
082existing course courses at the Nori Technical Center while expanding opportunities for students across the division the redesign facility would accommodate 1300 to 1400 students ensuring capacity for both current enroles at Lake Taylor high school as well as at the Nori Technical Center um and additional students interested in specialized CTE programs across the division to achieve this transformation um our study will focus on stakeholder engagement Gathering input from students parents community members and business partners program development identifying necessary coursework and Workforce aligned training opportunities faculty or facility assessment evaluating the existing building and determining space needs expansion and renovation planning identifying modifications required to support the comprehensive CTE programming and phasing and cost estimation out estimation outlining a clear feasible implementation plan engagement will of course be key to ensuring this project reflects the needs of
083students and the workforce we will host student parent and Community meetings both iners and virtual we'll have business person partner consultations to align with programs and Industry demands surveys and interactive sessions to collect broad input as well as dropin sessions for community members to provide feedback on their own schedules and scheduling some of those during school events so that we have more parent participation additionally a detail study of the existing facility will help us determine how spaces are currently used and what adjustments are necessary programming work will be held over multiple days in various formats to gather input from one-on-one interviews to specifically designed sessions to gather input from larger groups to time frames arranged for community members to drop in to learn about the plan and offer input that fits their schedule this will
084give the team an opportunity to learn specifics about current offerings as well as potential offerings that match with local needs in high need high-paying areas to support the Virginia Department of education's 3E framework around enrollment employment and enlistment once the programming phase is complete we will begin cap conceptualizing how the building can be adapted to support the new com comprehensive CTE High School this phase will again involve stakeholders ensuring their feedback shapes the proposed design and any necessary Renovations or additions the next phase will include more stakeholder involvement and feedback around creating a concept design of what Renovations or possible additions may be needed to support the transition to a fully comprehensive CTE high school and by fall of 2025 in time for the development of the s27 budget rrmm Architects will present Nori public
085schools with a recommended concept design and cost estimate this slide shows an overview of the project timeline stakeholder engagement from February to April 202 program development and space planning for March through May 2025 and final concept and cost estimate by September 2025 and this timeline ensures the study is completed efficiently with ample opportunity for input and refinement throughout the process thank you for your time and attention to this critical initiative this project represents a transformative step in expanding career and technal education opportunities in nor for our Nori students we welcome your questions and look forward to your continued support as we move forward with this study do anyone have any questions or comments this real quick so so this right now you're not asking the board to take any action this is just com this
086is just an overview of the study that's the process to begin corre right okay okay not at this time then that was my question as well but I just want to say who those get into this presentation and someone said we got to go quick very thorough yeah I'm I'm excited to see what the um outcome even if I'm not sitting in this seat I'm excited about that thank you thank you my pleasure is our first candidate ready we just need a moment to transition things take take a 5 minute recess yes that work for everybody yes five minute recess welcome Mr Brown thank you for joining us tonight uh we have seven questions that we're going to ask and each board member will take a turn asking a question um I'm going to ask
087the first question you have a copy of the questions in front of you correct yes ma'am okay great um please take a moment to introduce yourself and explain why you seeking an appointment for the norford school board what skills or qualifications do you possess that you believe will help you as a member of the school board what if appointed will be your priorities I know it's I know it's a mouthful okay well good day everyone my name is Corbin Brown um I am here today to show you all why I'm the best selection for the north public schools W 3 um board Bo seat I am a noric native sorry give me one second to you're fine breathe I'm thankful for this opportunity things that make me qualified I'm sorry why I'm seeking this this
088appointment to the school board it's because of my passion for the community I'm a North native born and raised I have a mother who taught into North public schools for over 25 years so I was raised in the school system seeing her work there in summer school days seeing her grade papers overnight I've been seeing this my whole life um I graduated from norvie high school graduated from Norv and moved on to the Air Force I did four years in the Air Force served at multiple stations um I really enjoyed my time I met a lot of different people um and and I I'm sorry I can't I got out the military and I decided to come back to my home come back to my hometown and be able to pour in to them because
089I I knew what it meant for me when I was a child I had a mentor I had somebody I had a a village who was able to step in and be able to assist me I seen the difference in my life and the ones who I grew up with how it was how I was able to have a different perspective and a vision for my life so I wanted to be able to step in and be that vision for the community so I I came back here I came back here to be to pour in um and to ask why I'm here why I'm seeking this appointment like I said it's not just an opportunity is really a responsibility I have been in place going through what i what I've done in the military
090going through what I've done in with the community going through what I've done as a business owner even had a storefront in janif janif Shopping Center Care more mve boxes and more is the first of its kind moving moving coner service we rent U-Haul um trucks and also had boxes and packaging things for sale as well but I I always had a passion for my city really just understanding that it was Jewels here um a lot of times very much overlooked but I I understood it was really something in the water so I'm scking this position like I said for the for the responsibility to take on and encourage the youth to be able to see something and see the power within their selves the same way I was able to find that Within Myself
091the skills and qualif qualifications that I possess I was say like I said my passion my my community involvement and the way I my responsibility I'm a father of four all four of my children attend nor Public Schools um they're all girls um so they very much needed very much so much attention but it's it's gave me so much skills in just growing as a person growing as a man really understanding myself so that is one of my skills right there just being able to deal with growing children my olders are 12 I'm sorry their olders are 11 they're 20 my next is 10 and then my youngest is seven so we have have all different age ranges having to be able to learn about them and myself throughout the process of having them while
092also running a business while also being a husband while being a fiance so to to understand how to maneuver with the youth and understand who I am it gave me different skills that I had to possess I had to learn it was no it was no guide book on what to do on how to how to become this man but I I figured it out and that's what I do I figure things out even if I don't know it I will figure it out you ask me a question if I don't know I will let you know I do not know right now but I will get that answer for you and I will get it done when I open my first business I did not know anybody who had a business storefront but I
093figured it out and I got it done I didn't know how to get a U-Haul contract a a multi million or billion dollar industry I didn't know how to do those but I figured it out on my own of course I had support that was the biggest thing the support not necessarily somebody telling me what to do but the support so that that is a big big thing that I was say a a skill that I possess that qualifies me for this position also me working inside of the school systems with my nonprofit care more community group I've been able to work inside of multiple schools and teach actually programs that we have produced one of the programs called it finding purpose through ART but finding your purpose who you are what makes you valuable
094to the world and art you know is a very valuable way of learning to express yourself and release whatever you're dealing with mental health is very big to me very big going into the military I seen a lot I did a lot coming in coming up from norol I seen a lot and did a lot I was raised around a lot of different people a lot of different types of people that force me to figure out okay what am I here for not just follow what I see around me but figure out what I can do to to make an impact on this world um and I'm I'm not trying to be very long-winded on this question but I just say like I said I have the skills that I that I've learned over the
095years whether it's military whether it was Community involvement whether it was being a business owner or being a father I have qualified myself to to step into this position okay and if appointed what would be my priorities I said mental health is very important to me I have a wellness company called car on Sunday Sundays we just did a hike this past Sunday in Richmond Virginia I took a group of people well I had I had a group of about 15 15 to 20 people we did a hike around Richmond about six miles getting outside in nature getting connected to yourself getting connected to who you are what getting back to the simple parts of life I feel like it's very much over complicated of what's going on around the world and it's just and
096it's affecting us in ways that we don't even understand so my for mental health is something that's very big to me that I will be presenting to the well add to the school board as a asset my views on my perspective on it me going through it you know really understanding the benefits of therapy the benefits of working together with others the benefits of communicating with others so that would be a a huge thing um that'll be a priority for me seeing that the youth because I the youth coming into the schools it's not just that they're not understanding what to do when it comes to their education they're not understanding what's going on inside of them how they're feeling when they're waking up when they're going to school since Co before Co it was
097already a little hectic but since Co has changed a lot the Dynamics of Everything Has Changed technology has improved they learned so much just from technology that they but they still don't know about who they are so they have the access to the information but they haven't matured and grown spiritually emotionally inside of them so mental health would be a big thing that I'm bringing in and then another piece of another priority that I'll be I'm sorry that I'll be mentioning this be the importance of working as a community like I said my nonprofit is called care more Community this that wasn't by accident it's because I really care for my community I've had this since 2017 so the involvement of the school with the community being that being a point of contact being a
098bridge for the community and the schools being a bridge for yes like I said the schools and in the community the youth and the adults it's a lot of Separation with that the children and adults so community and wellness will be what my priority priorities are coming into the school board thank you Mr Brown thank you welcome thank excuse me Madam chair can I make a point of just a clarifying so for for the interview questions will we be um limiting questions for two two minutes each question or are we we we do we do need to try to limit to about two minutes okay thank you for clarifying okay yeah Sor sorry about that I just wanted to clarify that again good evening uh my name is Tiffany Buffalo I'm a school board member
099here of Northville Public Schools and I have the second question please describe a time you had to make a difficult ethical decision and how you navigated it in 20 in 22 I really found I I was I was in the process of running my business care more movers I'm in Jan shopping center had it had it for five years at that time I'm very successful I was able to employ multiple people from my community um very much take my family and put us in a different position um but I found that I I was missing something inside I was missing that purpose I was I was telling you when I started the company was okay I need to be financially responsible let me do something to take care of myself and my family so I
100started it with the the the vision of okay the the money but I that wasn't enough so in 2022 I had been in the process of finding myself that's when I was introduced to things like meditation and plant-based eating and different ways of taking care of myself and understanding who I was and it got me to a point of understanding okay yes this is successful but it's time to move on and and I and I made a decision in 2022 to move on from my from my moving company and to go full-time in my nonprofit car more community group not understanding or not knowing how I'll be able to take care of myself how the money would be to come in but knowing that that was my mission for the world that was what I
101was good at giving because during the time of Co when recreation centers closed that's who I used to partner with um so when it closed I started using my store actually for a community center so seeing the impact and seeing how it made me feel and I knew okay okay this is it this is the core right here and that was actually my nonprofits was something I started before my moving company but it was nothing that I was always heavily invested in was just I'mma do this it's because I know I'm supposed to do I I feel it but it was nothing that I was just giving my all to so I decided to make the decision to walk away from my moving company and go fullterm into the nonprofit and that that same year
102I'm sorry that was the summer that I'm sorry that was before the summer that following summer I was able to to get a contract to be working inside the schools um contracted with United Way to be able to present my program but that was something I didn't even know was coming but it was for me to take that step that step of unknown walking in faith by my vision to go forward and make that decision to leave behind what I started for something new a new opportunity thank you thank you thank you Mr B and Mr Colonel Paulson name Colonel Paulson and I have a question how uh first of all thank you for your service military service thank you sir how will you engage the community and strengthen our transparency around our dat uh
103decision making proess there is always lots of skepticism and not understanding what we've done and how would you help get the message uh to your community how will I engage the community and strengthen the transparency well I feel like you all definitely um try to engage the community whether it's having these live broadcasts with the public can be present or even watching online um but a lot of times that the I feel the missing piece may be the uh feeling of connection the feeling of connection to the board not stating that that hasn't already been in place but I would be able to really put that connection with the community them understanding who I am and knowing my authenticity knowing the work that I've already done and the work that I will still be doing
104so when it when I when they see me doing an event or they see me um on the school board they see me anywhere in the streets they will be able to ask me questions and of course I might not always um I'm not going to tell them what we're going to do but I will be to transparently tell them what we have in plan what's what is going on what what is the vision um will I engage the community so I will also be to offer like I said I've hosted events I will also be to put together more Community engaged events where it's where it's centered around school school decisions um outside of well not outside of what we're we're already doing but I would be able to mention these things like like
105I said I already mental mentioned mental wealth mental health I mentioned the youth I mentioned the importance of them when I'm when we're having these events and these certain Gatherings but being that I would be in this position they would be looking to me for certain answers so I would be able to just transparently tell them what we have going on um and strengthen the transparency around decision-making process yeah just going back to saying just the community involvement being in being in the community uh being being there when they when they're asking okay thank you okay all right nice to meet you um so I have the next question um the norick school board has adopted goals focused on student outcomes how can a school board know if its goals are being accomplished and its
106policies are implemented the school board will be to know if the goals are being accomplished by the results that we see um we we see our data we look at the data um we see what what we have put in place and seeing what has happened um I know one of our one of our issues um for for the for in the school system was attendance I see that we just had the school um attendance Challenge and that we see that the data improved but just having this challenge so seeing what works and continuing continuing the blueprint seeing what doesn't work and scrapping it moving on to the next solution what what can we do next what what is or or not even necessarily scrapping but trying to add to it rever Rev in it
107seeing what what needs to be done um so how that is that is one way to just know if it's being accomplish really just seeing the data and also by speaking to the community asking how they feel seeing their their views on what we've already adapted speaking on even like I said the attendance challenge asking the teachers asking the students how did you feel about that what made you want to come to school what made you want to be a part of this Challenge and identifying these things and then being able to move on and make an even more deliberate decision on the next on the next goal um and see if the policies are implemented how SCH goals are being accomplished and the policies are being implemented how can we see if policies are
108being implemented by speaking speaking with the ones who are having to follow the policy the staff being involved not telling them what we're going to do but but listening to what their concerns are seeing if okay that was something that we already addressed why hasn't that been okay now we can bring it back to the board we can speak on it now bring it back to the superintendent and see if anything of the policies maybe be may maybe be revised so yes just speaking with the children speaking with the staff and the and other teachers to be able to see what has already been done and their their view on it thank you you hi Mr Brian hello um what do you believe are the greatest challenges currently facing the school division what do you
109see as the board's role in addressing these challenges what do you see as the administration's role in addressing these challenges start with the first question what what do I believe are the greatest challenges we're currently facing um overpopulation of the classrooms a lot of students and not enough teachers um and I and I I know that we have plans even to close some of the schools um to be able to bring more students inside some in the classroom but then have more teachers inside these schools so it'll be less vacancies um with the with too many children inside the schools is making it harder for the children to learn not enough te children are able to get the one-on-one counseling or the one-on-one um sessions that they're they're needing they're also not able to really
110Express how they're feeling like I was going back to that mental that mental well-being they're coming in there and the class is is so large and they they've been dealing with stuff all day they they're not even able to maybe express it to the teacher because they might be a quiet child or a child who maybe not understand how to communicate um and then teaching teaching is over is is very much over stimulating for the teachers not knowing how to not saying they not knowing how to but not being able to really teach the children because they have so many at one time that all need their attention at once and then of course we understand how the the vacancies of each classroom well I'm sorry vacancy and having to bring in substitut substitutes I
111know my daughter had to have a substitute for a couple months um last year just because her teacher went out um and and it did affect her um yeah it definitely did affect her so I would definitely say that overpopulation of the classrooms and needing to consolidate the the schools um also of course the attendance being able to get the children inside the school making them interested what making them want to come to school I'm making them want to stay in school I'm making the parents feel that we actually care to send the children to school um so definitely attendance consolidation B School Division and then just the the connection the connection between the community and the not just the staff of the school but the school board as well um in the administration of
112the school board so that would be the biggest greatest challenges that I would say that the school has facing two minutes thank you all right Miss Martin Dr Martin hi Mr Brown good day good to meet you so my question is how do you plan to address disparities in student achievement and ensure that all students regardless of background have access to high quality education and resources how do I plan to address disparities in student achievement ensure that all students understanding that we come children come from different backgrounds and some children learn differently um they they come from homes where it might be more hectic some children come from homes where like myself had a teacher in there who was able to assist them um on on certain issues so to to address these issues and
113to improve our student achievement definitely highlighting alumni um definitely enriching the children and and highlighting the the strengths that they have though um I know we have award Ceremonies for Honor roles but really highlighting every step along the way what what makes so they will feel so sometimes you need um like a small a task to work for so the children have something to work for other than just saying I want to get my A and B's but okay what am I working for every single day that goes back to even attendance okay I'm working towards this so I can I want to be here I'm working towards this cuz I I see I I see somebody who's already came from where I am I see some I see people who already came from I
114who where I am and they have been able to be successful so being able to address student achievement just speaking with the children speaking with the community speaking with the parents having times where we can have that parent engagement to be able to understand what their child might need what they're looking for um and understanding what they what they how they're feeling about whatever is going on I know they have PTA meetings and every everything already and we're putting together things but just continuing to two minutes sorry thank you thank you do you have any additional items that you would like to share with the board um I would just like to say like again I am grateful for being selected for this opportunity when you look at me I know I look different I
115talk different I may walk different but as really example of nor we are different I grew up around people who fell victim to drugs alcohol the prison system but I've grown into a father who Associates with council members delegates Community leaders and business owners when I am selected as a newly appointed War 3 board member I won't only represent my ward but I'll be a proud representation of what can grow and Thrive from the city of norol so thank you all thank you very much thank you thank you so much this get up yes that's good Miss Tanner Miss Tanner's gonna and again thank you for your um I'm gonna I'm gonna let them each know that after about two minutes Alfreda will give them the warning and then they can take a few seconds
116to wrap up okay thank you thank you knew at this so yeah I was think wait where's the time limit it it didn't occur to me so thank you for I was thinking know how many good [Music] evening Mr Forest hello how's everyone doing today good evening um my name is Sarah de cajero I am the chair of the school board uh each School Board member will ask you a question you'll have about two minutes to answer ma'am Miss Thomas here will'll give you a little bit of a warning and at that point please um wrap up your thoughts yes ma'am we'll do now I know this first question is very hard to do in two minutes so um you should have a copy of the questions in front of you I do all right
117I will start please take a moment to introduce yourself and explain why you're seeking an appointment for the Nori School Board what skills or qualifications do you possess that you believe will help you as a member of the school board and what if appointed will be your priorities okay my name is Cortez Forest um I go back Cory Forest I am an award wining award-winning author um of numerous magazines um and also wrote a book working on my second book now um I am a father of an honor student here at North Public Schools I myself am a proud product of norfor public schools as well I'm going from elementary school all the way up until High School where actually this evening I did see one of my former High School teachers Mr Excuse me
118doctor um pole um who again and I actually showed him um the uh message that he wrote to me in my high school yearbook so again we kind of had a bit of a full circle moment today um again he was very proud of uh my accomplishments that I did uh kind of to go over those with him today um so in addition to um that I'm also a mentor I'm a youth Mentor um prior to me becoming a youth well actually I've always done this but mentoring in my community um I do believe in giving back to the community that did um do so much good in my life here today and um with that being said um my um uh mentoring program um like I said I've been working with nor for public
119schools um I work with a few churches and other organizations um I have lost over 400 hours of um volunteer hours with uh the school board Alone um from February of 2023 until current again that's over 450 hours of I've already logged of volunteer work I'm also um a basketball coach I coach the Sherwood Forest kns basketball team uh 10U um 10y old boys um in addition to that um I'm also a um local business owner um I have a um a website I'm a website developer as well I do have a website where I post inspirational messages to my readers and followers and subscribers um so again I do believe in serviceing giv back to my community um I'm also a member well um I was a member but still currently of the Career
120and Technical education two minutes Career and Technical education um so again those are just a few of my many many uh skills and qualifications that I do have thank you yes ma'am good evening Mr Forest my name is Tiffany Buffalo I'm the school board member I have the second question please describe a time you had to make a difficult ethical decision and how you navigated it okay um again one of the things I do teach my mentoring students is the importance of having Integrity um we do have seven different modules that we kind of cover and go over um so again I always tell them about doing the right thing and just recently I had to situation where again one of my mentees also one of my um students on my basketball team had a
121situation um in school there was a uh student who um uh he made her feel uncomfortable and so like I said with him being one of my students and this is just one of the students I actually interact with um and I have tons of students who just adore me across the school but I had to actually make a decision of number one um protecting her innocence and her privacy um by reporting that um to well number one not having this young man kind of interfere with that but also taking her to her teacher number one um again I do believe in the chain of command taking her to a teacher first and foremost and then taking her to um the office staff and let them know and then upon that again same thing kind
122of letting the uh um the um uh school counselor know as well um I do work uh directly with school counselors um law enforcement individuals again I'm very active in the community so U when it comes to ethics that is uh something I definitely stand by thank you yes ma'am good evening sir good evening I'm Colonel fallson my question is how will you engage the community and strengthen the transparency around the norfor public schools uh decision making process um again I do believe there has to be um a level and line of communication between all parties involved um being parents um Community um organizers and those who live in the community as well as the school staff so again just being able to listen um take everyone's um ideas um to kind of take those
123things to heart and then kind of execute those very things so again just being able to work closely with everyone involved and then listening to what needs to be done okay thank you sir you're welcome hello Mr Mr forus my name is Tanya bassine I'm also one of the school board members um so the Nori School Board has adopted goals focused on student outcomes how can a school board know if its goals are being accomplished and its policies are implemented okay um again the we don't know if this uh the goals will being accomplished by our students I again I believe that our students do um again me being a part of nor Public Schools the students actually are the ones who pretty much are the result of the uh of the education that they
124do receive so with that being said um implementing policies listening to the student staff and again I just believe everything uh has to be in synchros where everyone kind of works together and listens together just to make sure all um dots are all eyes are dotted and sees are crossed excuse me okay okay how you doing Mr Forest Well ma'am thank you um what do you believe are the greatest challenges currently facing the School Division what do you see as the board's role in addressing these challenges what do you see as administrations role in addressing these challenges um one of the greatest challenges currently facing the school division is behaviors and attendance um again with my role again being active in the community um I take a different approach um when I educate the children
125I interact with I believe that one of the things that I do is almost like I like to take and put the medicine in the candy so I use um an informational exercise and I'll also educate them along with that um again whether it's in basketball or at sess at Rec Center or wherever I may be again always let them know how things may be and then also we kind of go over things how we can execute a plan to kind of put things in order thank you good evening Mr Forest my name is Adel Martin um my question is how do you plan to address disparities in student achievement and ensure that all students regardless of background have access to high quality education and Resources by being a resource in itself again um we
126to listen part of my program is um we do it and we lead with love l e we listen with an open heart we validate and then we Empower an educate and so those same principles I use there I also use everywhere I go listening with an open mind open heart because everyone has you know things perception things that they kind of go about doing things and then we validate or value what they may say and then we Empower and educate because what I do believe is again the way things go sometimes with our young people they kind of are impulsive in the way they do things and sometimes it take somebody who is more influential um and more someone they can kind of relate to to kind of get them on the right path
127thank you yes ma'am you're welcome finally do you have any additional items that you would like to share with us um number one I am um grateful for this opportunity to be sitting before you all today um and like I said I just again one of my thing is I love serving um I do believe in serving so again I just want to serve and I am a service and that is all I have today thank you thank you thank you very much for your time this evening for coming in and speaking with us um thank you Miss Tanner will escort you thank you [Music] now [Music] same thing cuz I I've been trying my hardest to pronounce yours mhm cero D calero all right there we go awesome so uh Mr Ang my name
128is uh Sarah de calero I am the chair of the board um each board member will ask you a question and you have about two minutes to respond um Alfreda will miss Thomas I'm sorry I'm so casual Miss Thomas will give you a heads up that you hit your two minutes so then please wrap up your thoughts as quickly as possible um I I'm going to start with the first question it's a very hard question to do in two minutes so take your take your take a moment to to think how you want to respond and you should have a copy of the questions in front of you yes I do uh please take a moment to introduce yourself and explain why you're seeking an appointment for the Nori School Board what skills or qualifications
129do you possess that you believe will help you help as a member of the school board and what if appointed will be your priorities excellent question so first off thank you so much for the opportunity to come here to speak before you for the opportunity to potentially be Ward 3's representative on the North School Board I'm Jason in I am a native of Martinsville Virginia um I have been in norol for 15 years I've been invested in this community and working through various Community organizations um over those 15 years um going um forward I work for the United Way I provide strategic guidance um in our community Investment Portfolio to to local Health and Human Services nonprofits um and some of the skills that I would be able to bring is been I'm going the
130strategist um I like to tackle what those problems are bring the thinkers and the movers in the room that have the problems and tackling those and get getting strategies to get us out um into the community um some of the other qualifications that I have I would say Grant Management um I oversee over $6 million and um Community funds that go out to our local Health and Human Services um organizations as well as um physical responsibility and data analysis um and then just rounding us off on the question of if selected what would be my priorities if selected to this position my priorities is to make sure that we take care of all 27,000 students in Northfolk Public Schools make sure that we address our teachers concerns administrators and making sure that we uphold the
131standards and Excellence of norford public schools because education is the Bedrock and the foundation of which our nation has been on and is the foundation and Bedrock to make our community move forward thank you you're very welcome I I'm very impressed that you did that in two minutes good evening my name is Tiffany Buffalo I'm a school board member I have the second question please describe a time you had to make a difficult ethical decision and how you navigated it oh oh good one good one good one difficult decis I all the time um so um being in my current capacity um as director of community Investments um we go through our community Le process volunteer Le process a community came they had a strong Community impact in what they were doing in the city
132of noran throughout the 757 however they were not able to articulate and produce the information into actual quantifiable data and so in doing that I had to look at um look at the impact that they were doing and then look look at is it going to still be good if they're not going to be able to meet the needs and be able to get the good return on investment and maximizing the investment the dollars that we've put in and so I made the decision that we must uphold the standards that we don't make any exceptions and make sure that the community understands and it's transparent that every dollar that goes in that those dollars have being effectively managed and are strategic and going out into the community so that's where I've had to make some
133difficult decisions thank you you're very welcome good evening I'm Colonel Paulson my question is how will you engage the community and strengthen the transparency Around The NPS decision making process excellent first off thank you so much for your service Colonel um I definitely appreciate you this is my first time learning about you and meeting you I've done a little research on you of course um but for me on my question on what I would do um in strengthening transparency we have to be an open school board we have to work collaborative with our collaboratively with our our school systems all of our schools all of our parents all of our stakeholders who have an invested interest in the city of norfol and ensuring that our students get the best high quality education and so that
134means that if a person comes here like yesterday um not yesterday when the last work session saying hey I have a fouryear request making sure that we honor that for your request and uphold the standards of the law that allow us to give that information and then also to um strengthen transparency talking with our parents meeting them where they are that's where we have to do we have to meet our parents and ensure we increase and encourage parental participation so that if our parents succeed our students will succeed and so that is where I believe that we will be able to increase transparency being able to have public hearings such as this and allow anyone in our community to come ask any of the candidates any of you any questions address their um concern uh
135questions and then you as a board hopefully if I'm with you alongside you to be able to tackle those issues and be able to give them good clear executable action plans to move our community forward thank you very much thank you hello how are you I'm doing good hey there I'm Tanya bassine and I have the next question for you um so the Nori school board has adopted goals focused on student outcomes how can a school board know if its goals are being accomplished and its policies are implemented excellent question so to see let me go back to the question make sure I got it correct here so how do you plan to no that's that's a different question um what do you believe is the greatest challenge is fac in our schools no we're
136on question four I'm sorry question four yes um so adopting goals so what I would like to do if a selected is work with you to make sure that we Implement goals that are effective and Equitable across all school all schools everything from Booker T Washington all the way down to Mary C cut I want to ensure that we're able to get measurable outcomes so to do that we have to look at student attendance we need to look at student grades we need to look at look at satisfaction surveys from our teachers we need to survey our students and also surveying our parents as well to get to see if the policies that we are implementing behind that day is is effective and efficient and making sure that we're doing the best for our students
137administrators and staff thank you thank you all right how you doing Mr an doing good Miss Thomas how you doing I'm doing wonderful what do you believe are the greatest challenges currently facing the School Division what do you see as the boards role in addressing these challenges what do you see as administration's role in addressing in these challenges excellent question so there there are a plethora of different challenges but to prioritize those out we have an agent infrastructure in north public schools many of our schools that we've invested in 50 years ago the life cycle of those buildings are now coming due and we're putting Band-Aids on them so we have to look at those those infrastructures to make sure that they are conducive environments for our students we need to address teacher Recruitment and
138attention making sure that we go where other other school systems may have not traditionally went to recruit um talented teachers um and then also we need to address absenteeism we need to get down to what are the root causes of absenteeism and like I said with you Colonel um to make sure that we meet our parents where they are this is something that happens and starts at home and to address that we have to ask the parents what can we do as a school system to ensure that you as a parent are getting all the support you need because if you're getting the support then your child will get the support they need to come to school on time and get a high quality education thank you you're very welcome okay good evening Mr in
139how are you doing good good all right my question is how do you plan to address disparities in student achievement and ensure that all students regardless of background have access to highquality education and resources good question so there are a lot of different disparities um that we can address I don't have I only have two minutes so I don't have enough time but some of those will be our non-english speaking students um I am very very happy um with the board's position on opening up Rosemont and that it will be a center for our non-english students to be able to go with their families that will address the disparity when our students that cannot speak English now have access to the tools and Technologies to make them warm and welcomeing it's an inclusive environment second
140secondly also addressing our Reading Writing and Mathematics scores we have made some progress in the last years but we still have some ways to go that's that's a true statement from the data that has been supplied by the Department of Education from our parents from our students administrators but I believe that we can address those disparities that are between African-American students that are reading at a lower grade level than their counterparts that are Hispanic and white oh that are Hispanic and are white I believe that we can Bridge those gaps by partnering with nonprofit organizations to help in after school and before school programming as well as also bringing in those counterparts and stakeholders here in norol public schools to address those stakeholders making sure we have the right consultants make sure we have the
141right thinkers the right strategies the right people who have a fully invested interest in making sure that we narrow the gaps between all of our students and particularly our students with disabilities we have to make sure that they feel in included valued here in north public schools thank you you're very welcome do you have any additional items that you would like to share with the board yes um so um I have met when um with you many of you um work with you throughout different various things throughout the years um I hope that I am a person that is selected for this role I look forward to working alongside you and addressing the many different challenges that we do have in our north public schools um I am a collaborative team player I want to
142ensure that we hear all voices that come to the room and that we make sure that we make good decisions that move our school system forward for all of our students not for one just particular student for all I want to make sure that every student is heard seen and valued and that no matter what part of North that you live in in 23513 or 23504 that you are receiving a high quality educ and you are prepared to go out into this world as a successful human being thank you very much thank you so much thank you for your time this evening thank you that's [Music] la [Music] good evening Miss pal good evening my name is SAR cajero I am the chair of the school board um uh each member of the school board
143will ask you a question okay you have about two minutes to respond uh Miss Thomas here will give you a heads up that you fit your two minutes and um then just wrap up your thoughts as quickly as you can um I'm going to take the first question okay and it it it might be difficult to respond to in two minutes so just take a minute to to think about your response okay um please take a moment to introduce yourself and explain why you're seeking an appointment to the norick school board what skills or qualifications do you possess that you believe will help you H as a member of the school board what if appointed will be your priorities okay um I'm ready to answer that so um my main interest is that I am
144a parent in the norx public school district and um and also a huge Community leader in both the nonprofit space Also in the higher education space um as I also lead an Advisory board at ODU so um education has always been extremely important to me um my parents were very involved in my educational process this is simply an extension of who I am um as a nonprofit leader I am extremely um cognizant and understanding of the challenges of you know balancing governance and managerial aspects of any organization um obviously my organization is a private nonprofit so a little bit different from a public school system um but I think a lot of the skills are transferable um understanding that you know the board is largely there to govern to advise to lend volunteerism and advocacy
145um and to really support the staff in what they do rather than trying to um enter into those Management areas and I believe at my organization at least we have a good balance of that and I think that I can bring those skills to bear in this position um uh as far as priorities I was reviewing yall strategic plan and I think the priorities that are under both the community and the safety and climate areas of of your strategic plan most resonate with me um specifically I am very good at stakeholder engagement um particularly with stakeholders who have either felt disenfranchised less engaged than perhaps um they would like or the organization that's trying to engage them would like um I am very good at simply continuing to approach those who should be involved and
146convincing them that their voice is Meaningful ful and should be heard I also think that in the safety and climate areas because I am embedded in the nonprofit Community there are a lot of intersections and um uh cooperation that can be done with the agencies that already serve our community and the public school system to address some of your priorities such as increased phys awesome and um and other so uh increases in social services so there you go thank you good evening Miss pal Tiffany Buffalo School Board member I have the second question please describe a time you had to make a difficult ethical decision and how you navigated it absolutely um so as a fundraiser I have to make ethical decisions on a regular basis uh there is nothing that brings out ethics uh
147more than I think money um and so I have sometimes had to um administrate grants that are government grants which means that we're dealing with taxpayers and um there have definitely been instances where um situations have come up that have made that a little bit sticky I um actually resigned from a previous position because um management was pressuring me to uh basically uh Scorch Earth a relationship with a grant funer um that was um involved government dollars and I simply explained to them that we were going to use the money the way that we had said that we would or um we were going to give them or we were going to give up the grant or I was going to resign those were the those were the options and I ended up resigning um
148it was a very difficult decision um but I believe very strongly in you know when we say we're going to do something we're going to do it so um I have absolutely no problem with making the difficult call um and standing on business as the kids like to say if it comes down to that thank you thank you good evening I'm Colonel pson my question for you is how will you engage the community and strengthen the transparency Around The NPS decisionmaking process yeah so um going back to what I was saying question one um I think that there's something to be said for identifying who's not at the table whose voices we aren't hearing pursuing them and then pursuing them until they are willing to engage with us um I think that you know sometimes
149when we go to do advocacy or we go to engage stakeholders it can be very easy to um maybe give up if they're resistant or if they're not sure that their voice really matters and what I have found is that sometimes it's taken me years to engage certain stakeholders that I knew needed to be part of the process um and for whatever reason they felt disenfranchised or they felt in um unvalued by the organization or by um past leadership or whatever it was um and I'm I'm pretty obstinate in that that I will simp I I won't you know I won't cross boundaries but I will certainly continue to approach and continue to say like hey your voice matters here um and so I think that you know we identify who isn't at the table
150and then we figure out where they are what are the community uh groups or uh stakeholder groups that they are already part of it could be a house of worship it could be all kinds of things and then we continue to go to those venues and invite them into the process um I think that iterates in a lot of different ways depending on what the situation is whether we're drawing them into committee work or to speak at a meeting or something like that but I have absolutely no problem doing that it's actually something that I very much enjoy thank you very much of course thank you hello miss poell my name is Tanya bassine one of the school board members um the Nori school board has adopted goals focused on student outcomes how can a
151school board know if it's goals are being accomplished and its policies are implemented so getting back to what I was saying earlier about the balance between governance and management I think that this is where especially in committee work um it's really important to be engaging with our staff and um you know as as in my organization I'm the staff member of course and I'm working with my board um and you know I think that uh fortunately I am blessed with a board that uh constantly listens to the staff we bring you know our data and our U measures um I am actually a huge fan of data and measures and I think it makes a lot of sense when governance and management can agree on what those measures are report on them regularly um be
152able to freely ask questions about the data set or about what's being reported um it's something that I practice at my own organization um and I you know am not I am unsure of y'all's um you know practice of that in committee specifically where I think it's probably most useful um but certainly that is that is where I look first is I think that everyone needs to agree on what the the measures of excellence and progress are and then report on those regularly and be able to have ongoing discussion hi Miss pal my name is Alfreda Thomas what do you believe are the greatest challenges currently facing the School Division what do you see as the board's role in addressing these challenges what do you see as the administration's role in addressing these challenges so
153I think our greatest challenge um is occurring right this minute um at the federal level um and I think that there's a lot of uncertainty for all levels um and all stakeholders in the public school system whether you're a parent student Administration or governance and board um so I honestly you know one of the reasons that I applied to this position was because I I really feel strongly about what is happening um in our federal government possible future of the doe and um and I want to do whatever I can to protect the Nori public school system because I believe in the public school system um as far as the board's role I I said it earlier I'll say it again I think advocacy is a huge part of what we do championing being the
154face talking to the Press our politicians um as far as Administration uh I was speaking earlier about data sets outcomes that type of thing I love it when I see staff of any organization who is able to demonstrate value using data it's hard to argue with numbers even though sometimes people will ignore them anyway but um I think that you know if Administration can be really really clear about what they are accomplishing and what you know and the if then statements of if such and such program is eliminated what happens then being able to be super clear about that with our elected officials with our constituents with our philanthropic philanthropic uh Community here in norick is going to be really vital in the years to come thank you absolutely hi Miss pal um ad Del
155Martin I'm going to ask you the next question how do you plan to address disparities in student achievement and ensure that all students regardless of background have access to high quality education and resources so I think that's like a huge question um I'll get a magic Wan first but if that fails um then I again I'll speak to um how I'm embedded in the nonprofit Community here I think Campton roads has an incredible philanthropic presence and a number of services funded by that philanthropic presence that is unusual for a community our size like if you think about population size per capita all that kind of thing um the depth and breadth of services that we enjoy here is amazing um and I think you know we do the best we can as an Administration as
156a board as a public school system and then we bring in what we need um and having all of that uh cooperation with the rest of our community only makes that stronger I think that's the broadest and most efficient way to answer that question because I you know I think that the level of disparities and the intricacies of that are too complicated to address in two minutes um but you know certainly something that I would look forward to addressing on a issue by isue basis okay thank you absolutely do you have any additional items that you would like to share with the board um I will just say that uh I have children in elementary middle and high school levels right now I have worked with 504 special education um parts of this Division I
157have worked you know I've I've been in administrative offices I have emailed principles and teachers for advocacy reasons for congratulatory reasons um for all kinds of things um and you know I so I have definitely met challenges with norick public school and also seen some of its best and I still believe like I said earlier that our public school system is one of the best parts of our democracy of our municipalities um and I think that you know it deserves to be protected and so that is just what I will leave you with as far as like my ethos why I'm here today and why I appli to this position thank you course thank you very much for your time this evening absolutely thank you so much for the opportunity thank you [Music] w [Music]
158good evening oh good evening good evening welcome Mr Smith glad to be here um my name is Sarah kagero I am the chair of the board uh each board member will ask you a question um please take about two minutes to respond uh Miss Thomas will let you know when your two minutes is up and uh then just wrap up your thoughts as soon as you can okay um the questions should copy the questions are in front of you okay I'm going to ask the first question please take a moment to introduce yourself and explain why you're seeking an appointment for the Nori School Board what skills or qualifications do you possess that you believe will help you as a member of the school board and what if appointed will be your priorities thank you
159so much for that question well good evening everyone my name is sioban Smith I'm a proud lifetime residents of North Virginia I've lived in my community for my entire life as well as has been a proud student of grand B High School where I graduated in the year of 2015 with Advanced diploma further from that I served in many areas in my community including being the youth board member being the chaplain and moving forward to being the president of the youth board I was able to learn so much with dealing with the adult board if I can say that with dealing with them I dealt with many controversies as well as different Avenues of resolutions for the controversy moving forward after I graduated I was asked to join the Executive Board of my civic league
160when I went further to become the vice president unanimously by vote of the civic league once that occurred I came in and stepped up as president when I stepped down and throughout that I was reelected as president of the civic league I've served the civic league since 2021 as their president and proudly served for over 15 years in this civic league I've learned throughout so much of being a community stakeholder in that Ward as a residence not only that I am a proud member of the United Holy Church of America while I serve in the Youth Department with that I have dealt with dealing with as Treasurer where I've dealt with creating budgets as well as approving budgets and dealing with income and expenditures for a church worldwide to answer the next question what skills
161or qualifications do you possess I've dealt with serving on the bylaws Committee of this same civic league of lindawood cotage heights barad park with being a part of that you dealt with many things that people did not agree with in the civic league when you brought different things to amend to the bylaws with that we were able to come together as a bylaws committee and look at the greater denominator and come back and have an agreement of what we can do to better our community not only that I dealt with the budgetary issues as well um I stepped in at a time where we had to handle a situation and I probably was able to come in and remedy that not only that also I feel as if I'm qualified two minutes thank you good
162evening Mr Smith Tiffany Buffalo School Board member I have the second question please describe a time you had to make a difficult ethical decision and how you navigated it thank you so much Miss Buffalo I was able to take on a situation with dealing with a problematic member of our civic league we step back in the situation and like an elephant you have to make sure that the ground can hold you that you move forward on on I was able to discuss with them privately and to let them know in regards of how we can handle the situation so that way when we came back publicly we came and showing them in the group setting that there was a resolution handled we publicly talked about what was handled in private so that way there was
163no how can I say there was no smoke screen but that people can see that there's transparency with with the situation that was one way of handling it and with that that helped for the greater good of us moving forward and seeing a resolution to the situation not only that coming in as president of a civic league during a pandemic dealing with a older generation they were not used to telecommunications with zoom luckily with Offa Public School Systems going virtual for learning students were able to help their parents and their grandparents at that time to logging on to zoom thank y'all very much and we were able to collaborate with letting them know about social media as well as we implemented Instagram and Facebook to Now 60 and above are able to get on there
164and share and share a story and real and even on Tik Tok we're developing good evening I'm Colonel fallson I have the next question how you engage the community and strengthen the transparency Around The NPS DEC decision making process thank you well within that when I became president I did not just stop in my community I served going throughout the entirety of the community abroad going to different Civic leagues I've learned so much from so many leaders as well as dealing with stakeholders in our community what I bring to the table is this is that I've been within this Ward throughout years of serving dealing with many Advocates and many people dealing with different programs and initiatives that's what I feel as if can allow me and strengthen me to show the people with transparency
165that I'm not just getting here but I've been here serving this community and allowing them to see me as a voice for them thank you very much sir thank you Colonel and thank you for your service thank you okay good evening Mr Smith my name is Tanya bassine um I have the next question um the Nori school board has adopted goals focused on student outcomes how can a school board know if its goals are being accomplished and its policies are implemented great question so again dealing with the civic league you deal with a strategic plan one thing with dealing with a strategic plan you're able to check off and see the things that you're going by your short-term goals as well as your longterm goals your non-negotiables when you see that being being implemented you're
166able to see that these goals are being hit with NAA Public Schools we can Excel on that by making sure literacy mathematics it's the biggest thing that we tackle with this that is one thing to seeing the goal sing accreditation is another goal to being seen being uh tackled excuse me let me slow down a little bit but one thing I do see with us handling and getting to a goal is a strategic plan simple question to be answered yes hi Mrs Smith what do you believe are the greatest challenges currently facing the school dist the School Division what do you see as the board's role in addressing these challenges what do you see as the administration role in addressing these these challenges thank you madam Vice chair so with dealing with this what do
167you believe are the greatest challenges currently facing the school division is making sure that our diverse community of students is reaching their goals as stated in the last question what can we do to reach these goals what are we able to get done one thing with dealing with the school system and being a stakeholder of the school system we we have to make sure that we are all looking at the Strategic plan we have to make sure that we all are in agreement when we make a decision for the greater good of our youth not only for the greater good of our youth but to the staff and teachers that teach them growing up it wasn't just the job to them but it was the well-being of seeing that the students are taken care of
168that is one way we can make sure that the school is being take the schools are being taken care of is making sure that the staff and teachers are having better pay as well as making sure that their resources are able to be uh uh able to be given as well and what do you see as the administration's role in addressing these challenges well with having a school board in place a school board helps to approve the budget to making sure that these things can go forward the school board also makes sure to creating policy to make sure that these things are done thank you Mr Smith my name is Adel Martin I'll be asking the next question how do you plan to address disparities in student achievement and ensure all that all students regardless
169of background have access to high quality education and resources well with one thing of being a stakeholder making sure that we are within the communities of our schools looking at them there's many resources out there that we're able to get to not only that we have that but for example partnering with two of our local schools we've had the principles to come in staff members to come in and voice what did they need from the community and in return we saw grateful we saw great things happen and we were very grateful of that occurring a thing for us to also achieve is to making sure that we have different committees in place to make sure that we stay in contact with the schools to make sure that we also visit them in hearing the voices
170of our students as well as our teachers and staff members that's how we can have a highquality education and as for resources going into the communities and seeing that they have in place thank you do you have any additional items that you would like to share with the board well additional it that I have I again I'm a Life Time resident of lindwood and with that being said I feel like I can serve with you all and know knowing that we can collaborate with one another to making sure that the future can go on I myself was a product of the school system now it's my time to serve I feel as if that serving has been something I've been doing for years and to continue on to serve on the school board will see
171that someone else can come behind me and continue on the legacy of the Cornerstone that was laid for NAA Public Schools thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you I have a point of order question for the board okay MH uh as 5 minutes early and the last interview was not scheduled till 7:30 are we comfortable with moving forward to the public hearing at this point or do we want to delay until 8:00 no go ahead I would say go ahead we don't want to they move forward yeah keep all right keep going so we'll move forward thank you you want to say something Tiffany I was just going to say she can I was just going to say um if we're going to do that you just um doesn't she have to
172close this portion and then open the public hearing no you have it on the agenda as current current okay okay all right so we will move on to agenda item 5.01 public hearing on the w three school school board candidates and Madam chair we have one speaker for tonight and is Dr John Sika um you know what I just thought about something we need to shift so you can have the podium yes sit there [Music] it's right here there we go okay we're ready Dr siika good evening Mr siika good evening chair lady School Board I'm going to try and make this quick because I only have three minutes so I'm Dr John siter III I live off sus Point Road my children went to Norview elementary middle school and high school now I have
173a granddaughter in grany and a grandson in uh north side now that being said I'm here because I'm concerned about what just happened just in this room room did we really serve the stakeholders our stakeholders are the voters each of y'all got elected you weren't appointed you were elected that means you had to answer to voters and all these questions y'all asked that was very impressed I can answer every one of them too because I asked somebody well was it because I didn't have the background or the experience oh I guarantee you I have a lot of experience in background and answering any of these because I had to answer to voters and I was really upset because Mark ask you when we look at the voters in the third W in 2022 Carlos got
174at least 4900 Mark ASU got already 41 I got only 800 but regardless had I not been on that ballot you'd be having mark up here Mark was the one who actually would have won but he wasn't in the mix for interview was he he should have had it just by default alone and if he didn't want it the next person should have been myself because we faced the voters by doing so you made it kind of a good a boy club because they get to pick who's going to be it not the voters now whoever you select has if they want to continue have to face the voters and if the person challenges them anybody let's say Mark challenges them he can go back and say well they were elected they weren't voted in
175now there's six people here Mark got over 4,000 I got over 800 and as for votes let me tell you how hard it is to run for office you had a lot of sharp people up here I would love to see how they would do in an election seriously I only not ran for school board in 2022 I ran for House of delegates in in the 93rd in 2023 and I also ran for US Congress in 2024 and y'all may not realize ize it but how many of you can get 990,000 votes over five cities for $1,400 because that's what VPAP showed me a spinning to get 90,000 votes I guarantee you Schoolboard doesn't need that many votes but how we can we work all I can say is what happened here today that's fantastic
176but keep in mind you left out two critical people you should have interviewed the ones the voters select elected not appointed and that would be my big point tonight and I know Mark would be saying the same thing if he was here he's in surgery but regardless I know his passion I know his belief and I know where he stands on all these issues you just had he knew it in detail he could bring it down and I can tell you from my background and experience I didn't get doctor of Education just by being cute mine was actual dissertation real research and I actually helped build a school from going broken down school from 50,000 to 7 million in 10 years then went down to Texas to a minority college and helped build their program
177and I could tell you about every answer you all had I could have answered every one of those very easily in two minutes and thank you for your time have a great evening and that concludes our speakers for tonight all right uh need a motion to go into close session so moved second all those in favor I I there needs to be a roll call oh there needs to be a roll call I'm sorry and was that Thomas that seconded I couldn't hear it was Martin that second it okay thank you move that the members of the school board of the city of Nora go into a closed session for the purposes which are set out in subsection a of section 2.2 - 3711 of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act as amended for discussion
178consideration or interviews or prospective candidates for employment assignment appointment promotion performance demotion salaries disciplining or resignation of specific public officers appointees or employees of the school board pursuant to subsection 2.2 D 3711 A1 of the act the subject of this portion of the session is a discussion of candidates for temporary appointment to the board seat presenting W 3 pending the November 25th special election cult consultation with legal councel and briefing by staff members pertaining to actual or probable litigation or regarding specific legal matters requiring the provision of legal advice by Council pursuant to subsections 2.2 D 3711 A7 and 8 of the act the subject of this portion of the closed session is for legal advice and connection with the matter set above in subsection a of this motion bassine I Buffalo I Martin I
179Paulson I Thomas d calago [Music] i all right uh do we have a motion to come out of CL session I that we come out of closed session second all right it has been moved by Dr Martin and seconded by Colonel Paulson that we come out of closed session okay a resolution certifying executive meeting of the school board of the city of Norfolk and accordance with the provisions of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act whereas the school board of the city of norfol has convened a close meeting on this date pursuant to to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act and we at section 2.2 D 3712 of the code of Virginia requires a certification by the school board of the city of norfol that
180such closed meeting was conducted in Conformity with Virginia law now therefore be resolved that the school board of the city of Northville kby certifies that to the best of each member's knowledge only public business matters lawfully Exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the executive meeting to which this certification resolution applies and only such public business matters as were identified in the motion conven meeting the exec the meeting were heard discussed or considered by the school board of the city of Norfolk bassine hi Buffalo I Martin hi pson hi Thomas hi the caliro hi I move that as for okay all right do we have a motion on the floor I I move to appoint Jason in in to serve as School Board representative for War 3 until the position is
181filled by a special election is there a second second um Miss Moore Buffalo has moved that the position be filled by Mr Jason in we'll have to have a lesson um until the the Fe seat is uh filled by special election please call the RO please call the rooll thank second I second okay we did second it was Buffalo and Martin second it Buffalo made the motion and Martin second it okay so bassine I Buffalo I Martin I Paulson I Thomas I talro I that's it all right do we have a motion to close well then I'm closing this meeting for