001to call this meeting to order Miss tner would you please do the roll call yes bassine here Buffalo here Martin Olson here Thomas here Calo here all right we'll move to school board uh agenda items two Schoolboard Workshop uh item 2.01 Foya COA training good afternoon everyone um for those I haven't yet had the pleasure of meeting my name is Margaret Kelly and I am an assistant City attorney here for the city of norfol which means I am also an assistant City attorney helping out the school board I get to do all of the Foya and Freedom of Information Act and conflict of interest act matters um so I'm here for you if you need me in the future Mr pishko and his entire office are of course always here but for today we're going
002to start off with some training um Foya requires that certain public bodies including the school board have to receive training within two months after assuming their local elected office and thereafter at least once during each consecutive period of two calendar years commencing on the date you last completed your training session um your Schoolboard clerk keeps a record of when your training was we do try to do these for you once a year so you may get more foa than you need but that's better than having no Foya um this training can usually also be done online sometimes the the current online version that the Foya Council which exists all the way up in Richmond has is down for that for some reason so that's why I'm here today to give it to you but there
003is always sometimes that option in case you can't miss one of these training sessions I am from the north so I speak very fast please stop me if I'm going too fast if you have any questions just let me know I'm happy to answer them as we go or them to the end or you can call afterwards whichever you feel most comfortable with we are here to help you all with your um learning of Foya the basic principle of Foya is always I think the most important part to start with because it guides as long as you stick to this principle usually you're going to be fine and that principle is that the Affairs of government are not intended to be conducted in an atmosphere of secrecy since at all times the public is to
004be the beneficiary of any action taken at any level of government and this applies to a public body like the school board really in two ways Foya has two main sections to it one is public records what is a public record within the public body's possession or its uh members possession and another is a meeting of a public body like we are doing today so we're going to go through them step by uh one by one it's important to keep this uh idea of transparency in mind because the Foya statute explicitly says that it is to be interpreted liberally that means if the starting assumption is everything is open to the public there are exceptions especially when dealing with the schools you also have furpa you have a bunch of other laws that do protect
005anytime you're dealing with scholastic information especially when you're dealing with children and juveniles but the starting point is supposed to be that the records and the meetings are open and then we move from there to find exceptions if there is a debate about whether or not an exception to this open openness applies to on the side of letting the public know so again that's why this is a great way to starting uh point to keep in mind for everything we're about to talk about with Foya all right so who has the right to use Foya um again this isn't furpa furpa is a different issue um it is controlled under federal law this is specifically the Virginia Freedom of Information Act and for the Virginia Freedom of Information Act the people who have the right
006to invoke Foya are the people of the Commonwealth which is um described as the citizens of the Commonwealth and then representatives of newspapers and magazines that circulate within the Commonwealth so the Watchdogs if you will the people who are there to um keep the citizens in the know about what's actually happening there is no definition of citizen in foia um so there's some common law definitions out there that we can use but generally speaking the way your Foya officers work is as long as the person can provide an address in the Commonwealth of Virginia um we're going to treat them we're not going to question we're not going to do a background check try and find out if they are a citizen or not again the goal of Foya is transparency so we'd rather you
007know be open about a record than try to fight somebody whether or not they're in the military and they live here or they don't live here something along those lines the question about what a public body is is one that I always want to touch on a little bit because obviously the school board is a public body but you also have various committees and commissions um and even those count as public bodies the Foya specifically says that it shall not the definition of a public body which is what Foya applies to shall not exclude any committee sub committee or entity because as private sector or citizen members so if you are forming a committee with that is made up of citizens it can still be a public body it doesn't matter that they're not elected
008all right so we'll get into what the public meetings are generally speaking um I like to refer to this as the good old fashioned kindergarten buddy School uh system a meeting is anything that is is a is a group it's a it's a gathering of as many as three members or more of a public body if your public body has a quorum that is less than three so say it's a committee only made up of three people and the Quorum is two that quum that too does become a public body but for the purposes of school aard it would be three or more members um so if you're traveling in groups of in and pairs of two you're fine you're not in a meeting um but once you have that third person come in and
009you get in start touching on what the uh subject matter of a meeting would be which I'll get to in a second um that's when you come into Foya territory a meeting can be physical or electronic so phone calls can constitute meetings if you have three or more people on the line um um chat rooms if you are in an instant chat type of situation that will turn into a meeting we get the question a lot whether or not emails constitute a meeting because if you have three or more on there the Supreme Court has issued of Virginia has issued some in some uh sort of guidance on this it's a few years old and I'm sure it's going to change with the times that guidance is as long as the emails a fun is
010functioning essentially like a letter would it's not a meeting yet so you've all seen those emails where uh one person sends an email and then within the next 20 seconds everybody's responding right away that can become a meeting that is more of an instantaneous you're not physically gathered but you are getting into dangerous territory if you've sent one email out to the entire group and then that person responds to you individually you're not in a meeting if somebody has waited a few hours or so to respond and they respond to the group again that's not that wouldn't probably be considered a meeting because you do have that more correspondence angle to it uh but I always advise it's just safest if you get an email to all of you don't CC everybody um maybe you
011can CC your chair that's always a safe option I think if you want to keep somebody else on the school board and the know about what's happening um you can CC your attorneys over there Mr clad or Mr Fox they don't count as being in the meeting um but don't it's always safe it's not to hit reply all and keep everybody on that chain it doesn't include C Gatherings of your employees either so while government isn't supposed to operate in TR in um in secrecy there is also a fair recognition by the general assembly that if citizens were allowed to come sit in and watch every single thing your employees are doing 247 there's very little that could get could get done it would it would sort of bring government to a screeching halt so
012again it's not supposed to be secret what your employees are doing is why you have the public record section that we'll get to in a little bit so they're not doing things in secrecy either they're still open to public inspection um but these meetings are where the discussion and transaction of public business is really taking place is where we want to make sure that um the public can know what's happening and like we talked about a meeting can be virtual or it can be uh in person like you are today um all virtual public meetings are an option for some committees and subcommittees they're not an option for the school board the school board isn't allowed to have everybody appear electronically you are allowed to have and I believe you do have a policy that
013allows individual members to appear electronically for a certain number of meetings each year um for various different reasons for health reasons um if they have a work commitment that they can't get out of but they have free time and they can in hour commitment um so those are all options they still count as true meetings all right so once you have three people together what do you talk about that brings you into this territory of a meeting um I will say first of all it's generally safe to avoid being in groups of three uh because some citizens do get concerned and there have been um not by the school board that I'm aware of but uh there have other school boards and other public bodies have done meeting violations so some some citizens are you
014rightfully concerned always that there are meetings happening that aren't being properly noticed so if you're in groups of three it's and it's not a CLE clear you know sort of nonwork function like you can go to somebody's birthday party you can be a member of society you can go to a Tides game and say hello to each other that's allowed you don't have to avoid each other entirely um but if you're at something like you are at maybe a civic league and a parent starts talking to you and there's two more school board members nearby even if they're not engaging in it just for the sake of propriety for the sake of keeping everybody um you know aware that there's no secrecy happening it's always best to have somebody exit because a meeting is this
015ly list it goes on for a second slide um so I'm not going to read it all aloud but it is something where there's discussion or transaction of public business taking place among the members um there are exceptions like I said um for public forums informational Gatherings um just these sort of uh social Gatherings that you're at again we want you all to be able to engage with your community engage with each other outside of school board so that it is allowed um just make sure you're not discussing or transacting public business and the Supreme the general assembly has helpfully finally for the first time this year defined what that means um there was some concern for the past few years about what's public business what isn't in is something like the school board where
016anything dealing with a child anything dealing with teachers um there is a concern that becomes public business so the general assembly has defined it public business needing means any activity a public body has undertaken or proposes to undertake on behalf of the people it represents so like I said if you're at the tides game and somebody's talking about you know the um how amra's going to work with the casino obviously that is public business for city council it's not public business for you all um so you can engage in those conversations that's not a problem but once somebody starts talking about any type of um subject that uh you have already undertaken or proposed to undertake um then it is something that will trigger this meeting clause and you should not be in groups of
017three or more when you're talking about it um pretty much everyone's allowed to attend a public meeting um the entry must be free uh that doesn't mean you can't require identification it just means that the form of the identification has to be free as well so for example there can't be a rule that uh identification has to be a driver's license because driver's licenses cost money um you can do some sort of photo ID uh you can do um like a picture in the moment that then just gets deleted identification is allowed for safety reasons like I said the point is that entry has to be accessible to everyone and so there can't be a monetary barrier we do of course um have closed meetings exceptions which I'm going to get into in a second
018um there are some times when you're going to need to be able to discuss things without the public there and we'll talk about that in a minute uh but I will say one other thing when we talk about who all is allowed at meetings there is also a rule under foia that anyone is allowed to record these public meetings um they can't be right up in your face when you're on the dis with a camera blocking you from everyone or getting in your way you are the school board is allowed to set up policies about um where these kinds of filming equipment will take place but the meetings can be found people cannot be prohibited from filming or recording the meetings it is all a part of this idea of transparency and in fact it
019is encouraged but it's not it's not required by Foya but it is actually encouraged to record them yourselves um to get them out there so you know your citizens who can't make it down there whether it's um for a a a permanent reason or it's just in that day they're very busy they can't make it that way they can watch what's happening too and this isn't to say you can't ever have meetings you can't ever um have these discussions of three or more other than your Schoolboard meetings the important point of Foy is the public needs to be able to see them so the public has to have notice that they're going to happen um and that is when foia uh comes into play with meeting notices and it says that for these meetings three
020or more uh you there has to be a notice posted three working days prior to the meeting that's working days it's not just calendar days so it doesn't include Saturdays and Sundays and holidays um and I'm sure your clerk would appreciate more than a three working days heads up for that but the minimum is three um I wish I could change it on the slide Karen I'm sorry I can't um so to do to post notice it has to be at three different locations it has to be posted on the official government website it has to be at a prominent public location and at the office of the clerk or the chief administrator and once that's posted you can have the meetings um that is there's no barrier to having them at that point in
021time there are exceptions for when you need an emergency meeting there are exceptions for when a meeting runs over and you need to continue it and if everybody agrees to continue it tomorrow there are those certain situations and our offices here Mr cloud and Mr Fox um are always willing to uh they know that law backwards and forwards too so I'm a little nervous they're watching me as I present this to you but um I'm also here for help on that as well we've got we know how to do those we're happy to help you get them in play if they need to happen and where can a meeting be it can be pretty much anywhere um we get back to it can't be a place where you are um prohibiting people from entering it
022can't be a place where you're prohibiting recording devices from being uh from from being in there but there isn't a rule about the size of it so for example you're after your normal sessions are in your bigger room where more people can come watch your work sessions might be in the smaller room um as long as you're not choosing a room that's deliberately chosen to be small so people can't come in and see it that's fine the um Foya recognizes things like Fire Marshall safety rules are there for a reason um we can't pack more people in that will'll be safe but again that is where this idea of the public body itself being encouraged to record its own own meetings and um transmit those electronically as well helps so if you know people can
023still have a chance to see what's happening all right so now we're getting to the closed meetings um there's about 50 specific limitations which is very high uh for why a public body can have a closed meeting there are various ones that you will probably run into more often things like discussion about identifiable Personnel is a major one um since the the employees are your employees you are in a different situation than many public bodies where they are technically the employee of the chief executive officer in this case they're yours so you may very often need to be going into closed sessions to talk about Personnel matters for identifiable Personnel um there are still rules about it to make sure that the public can still have a transparency of what's happening so the statutes say
024that even even when there's a closed meeting that no resolution ordinance rule contract regulation or motion that comes out of the closed meeting is effective unless it's been voted on in an open meeting where the substance is reasonably identified so the people still have an understanding of what went home behind closed doors you know the room where it happens from Hamilton type of a thing they need to know what's going on there and the statute is very explicit about the procedure for how to close a meeting um and what votes need to be taken afterwards uh that includes things like uh we had mentioned um there has to be an affirmative recorded vote in an open meeting um almost right at the same time that you're doing this closed session and that has to identify
025the subject matter State the purpose purpose of the meeting as authorized by that state code and the applicable exception from the open meeting requirements you don't have to memorize all of this um again that's what our office is here for to help you draft them your clerk can help you draft these motions um and make sure we're following all the right rules and procedures um but they do happen sometimes you do have to go into a closed session where the public can't be um and in those cases we do want to always make sure we're following procedures so the public is still kept and um level of knowledge about what's happening all right any questions about meeting so far see how am I doing on time doing good okay all right so for public records
026um you have Freedom of Information officer and I thought I saw Mr Walker walk in there he is um he uh is the Freedom of Information officer is charged by State coach to know Foya uh so they are there they're there to assist um and they are to be the Public's point of contact for these public records um they must be designated and publicly identified which Mr Walker has been and their job is to be that go between between the public body and the public and help them um help both sides understand and make sure that they're complying with Foya um now I will say when we talk about the custodian of a record technically Foya says um very interesting language that the records that a records request would be to the custodian of the
027record um and Foya does not like to give me helpful definitions so it doesn't Define what the custodian or the record is um so often times poor Mr Walker I think winds up operating sort of as that custodian of record he's the one who goes to the different departments um a citizen would go online to the just Foya portal submit the the request for what they they want um and then he and his team um try to get that request to the correct custodians to the Departments to the various um uh employees and officers who might have those records but it is important that a records request does not have to be made to the foyet officer nothing in the state code says that that is where the request has to go so if a
028parent stops you um and says I want this record again I would argue in court that you're not the custodian unless it's a record you're physically holding at that time but for safety's sake if an if somebody asks you for a record let Mr Walker know immediately and he will take it from there he knows everything I'm about to tell you next about deadlines and times and proper responses and he is there to make sure that this happens as seamlessly as possible uh foyer requests do not have to be in writing they can be verbal they can be oral so somebody can come to a Schoolboard meeting and say from the microphone I want this contract that is a foyer request it does have to be processed that way so if you're getting those make
029sure you're getting down as much information about the requestor as you can particularly how to contact them and what they're looking for and let your Foo officer know as soon as possible so what is a public record it's pretty much anything everything except the furniture um so it's all writings and recordings that consist of letters words or numbers or the equivalent in any of its forms it is Data it is the background running data on on program like people soft that is all technically a public record um it is the the key part is that it is prepared or owned by or in the possession of a public body or its officers employees or agents in the transaction of public business so technically your emails you know wishing somebody a happy birthday even if it's
030on your uh work email it's technically maybe not a a public record um if you're just telling your best friend a happy birthday from there but it is in the possession of the public body so odds are it may even if it's just accidentally get turned over a foyer request so be very careful about what of your personal business you're doing um on your school board emails because those will get swept up in some foas and like I said when your Foya officers and your it are trying to sort through sometimes thousands of emails those innocuous little ones may um slip through and they may not be making that distinction is this technically in the transaction of public business or not they're going to air on the side of it was on a Schoolboard email
031it's going um you don't have to create a record to respond to a foyer request and I always put this in there because very often um I think uh public officials try to be helpful when it comes to foyer which is great and we love that um but if somebody sends a foyer request in asking for um the record explaining why something happens and there's no record but you respond back in an email saying well it didn't happen because three paragraphs later why now I've got a record and so now it gets turned over so there's nothing wrong with just writing back I don't have a record there's nothing wrong with picking up the phone and calling your foer officer to find out what actually is going on what needs to be requested what's not
032um there's no re requirement to create one sometimes we will Del the city uh the school board will deliberately create one um there is a section of Foya that says that the school the public body can abstract or summarize information if agreed so like I said everything all those um all the information that is kept on all of your programs that your um like HR keeps anything like that Finance may keep technically every piece of data of that is a public record so very often uh a requestor will be just looking for a specific set of information they don't want an entire um budget necessarily printed out or an entire account printed out they're looking for something specific so it will be agreed to abstract or summarize and a record may be created at that
033point all right and this is the part where why you've got a foyer officers keep us all in check the public body must respond to a foyer request within five working days of receiving the request and there's these technically there are these four responses that have to happen there is a fifth one that I'll get to in a second and they are that the records are being provided in full and the records are actually in fact provided in full that they're being entirely withheld at which case you they do have to cite the approximate amount that is being withheld so approximately 100 Pages 100 emails and the subject matter of what's been withheld that they're being provided in part and withheld or redacted in part or they cannot be found or do not exist to
034withhold or uh redact even entirely or in part there has to be a specific law that allows that withholding and the response has to include that citation for the person so the person can know not only the general subject matter of what's withheld but where that Authority is coming from the fifth option which isn't on here the fifth option is actually that it is practically impossible for the public body to respond within five working days and we need an extra seven working days because the general assembly understands your employees have other things to do um they have to do their jobs Foy is a part of their job but on top of it they have their actual spelled out job description your teachers have jobs um they have duties and responsibilities so and especially and
035when you're dealing with um uh public bodies that are of the size um of all of your employees everybody in the norfol public schools um uh family it does turn into very often we can't get it done in the five days plus all the redactions have to happen in the in within that time period and that can take up a lot of time as well again when we get these requests that say I want I think uh Dr berong had one somebody wanted every email that had the word investigation for the last year right and that was a lot um it includes spam it includes news emails it was a lot uh sometimes you know Outlook wanteded to be more helpful and we're like well this word is like investigation so we're going to put
036that in there so we have to sort through all of those and it can take a very long time all right so why can some records be held um there does have to be a specific exemption to it that is listed at canp because it's embarrassing that we don't like it uh that don't want anyone to know about it at this point there has to be a specific legal reason why it's being with and those are spelled out um and like I said when we do um apply the exemption even then transparency is still at the Forefront they person has to be told approximately the volume of what's being withheld the subject matter and where they can go and find what that exemption is and where are they they are all throughout Foya they are
037all throughout the code of Virginia um there are some sections of the code of Virginia that don't even mention Foya but we'll say things like this record is confidential and it's a misdemeanor to release it things like CPS records and whatnot um so we have to look throughout pretty much the entire code you also have issues um with furpa and Hippa tax information juvenile records the public procurement act there are a bunch of laws out there for the most part a lot of information can go for the most part especially when we're dealing with furpa or Hippa issues the request as a parent or somebody Guardian who would have the right to it anyway um but it is especially when we are getting those news requests that everyone has to be very careful um while
038we want to be as transparent as possible um the school also recognizes that you know their children children have the right to a level of privacy and um parents want their children to have a level of privacy all right this is a fun exception that applies to you all um the school does have the option of char does have the ability to charge for the cost of production of the records so that's the time it takes to search and produce um and redact the cost of copying um if somebody wants paper copies the cost of printing that can all be in there um interestingly furpa allows for the charging of these copings as well but the general assembly has recently changed Foya so that under Foya if it is a record that someone would be
039entitled to under furpa the school can no longer charge for that cost so it's essentially um voided the provision in fura that allows for the charging of those records so think of any record that a parent or um a child over the age of 18 an eligible student could get um that they would be entitled to under fura the school can't charge for it anymore and I touched on this a little bit brief briefly uh how to request records um and the able one is to do it through the just Foya platform um I would like to reiterate we can't tell someone they have to use the just Foya platform Foya doesn't require a foyer request to be in writing like i' mentioned they can make it orally they have that right to make it
040orally um it is easier to do it through the just fo platform um sometimes people find it easier because they can have that direct communication so there's no harm saying I'm happy to take down all this information for you or if you would prefer to use our just foa platform you can but if they decide that they want to continue giving it to you orally they can continue giving the request orally uh the request does have to State their name and a legal Virginia address and it does have to um identify with reasonable specificity what record it is they're looking for um so as soon as you get a foil request or a request for a record that you think like I said please send that on to your foil officer uh Mr Walker has
041his personal or his direct email but um it's always easiest to reach them I think at Foya at np. k12.ca.us because then you just have to remember the word Foya and it'll go straight to him and um I'm just going to put words in his mouth but I think he'd appreciate knowing as soon as possible so he can get the ball rolling on those five days could said it better myself there you go uh all right so how do how can citizens um enforce their their foyer rights they can file a petition for mandamus which is when a court would order a production or order somebody to do something um in the case of something like a public meeting that's being held they can file a petition for an injunction to stop it does have
042to be supported by an affidavit showing good cause um but they can file in General District Court or Circuit Court General District Court has a little form it's very easy uh it's supposed to be heard within seven days of the date when the petition is made and just in case I haven't um harped enough on this topic that fo is important um to the people and to the general assembly the general assembly did something very strange in our American System which is the moved the burden of proof so I think we're all generally aware of this idea that a defendant in a civil or criminal case the burden of proof starts with the person who's brought the suit in a case of a Foya case against a public body the burden of proof has shifted
043to the public body it's still a preponderance of the evidence standard but the burden is now on the public body so Voya is incredibly important it is a priority for the general assembly um and so it's should be a priority for all public bodies and there are some penalties and we get into this this is um not to scare you in any sort of way uh but they are there a willful and knowing violation of Foya can result in a civil penalty of between $500 $2,000 it gets paid to the literary fund and a second uh violation goes up in price if it's a record if there is a failure to provide the record because the record was altered or destroyed with the intent to avoid Foya so not because you know the records are
044subject to the records reten to the um public records Act of Virginia Which sets records retention schedules which means certain records do have to be destroyed and they are supposed to be destroyed on a certain basis and that's all set out by the Library of Virginia so if a record was just destroyed because we're following along with it schedule and it's not with his intent to avoid Foya that's not what we're talking about the sheare fact that a record can't be found or doesn't exist doesn't mean somebody's violated Foya um however if you get a foyer request somebody got a foyer request for a record and the next day the record went missing and it was there the day before I think a court might ask a couple questions um and for meetings that are
045not compliant for for their for those uh requirements about how to close a meeting there can be a civil penalty of up to $1,000 paid to the literary fund which is imposed on the public body um if a violation is p is found the petitioner is also entitled to recover reasonable costs including legal fees uh so that is also something to always keep in mind um Foya can a Foya VI viation can be brought against the individual so somebody could bring a Foya um lawsuit against the school board in general or they might bring it against you individually so that is why we do these trainings um the Foya statutes are all available online on L if you're ever curious about something I always I it just lives open on my desktop and I'll control
046FWS and just make sure that we're doing everything as well as we can um but because it does have that individual issue I do always want to make sure that that is clear that it's it's on you if you have been asked if a record exists please check for the record please um make a at least a make make a reasonable effort to try to find it all right some interesting updates um let's see I don't think many of these um if you'd like to hear uh me uh being a legal nerd about some of these updates I'm more than happy to do so um but not many of them with the with that exception of the change for fura uh accessible records um are really specific to the school board uh there was another
047change that has been very helpful too which is if a committee is formed and it happens to have three members of a different public body appointed to it the sheer fact that those three are now part of this committee does not make them attending that committee meeting a meeting of the prior board so if three members of the school School Board are appointed to a committee on attendance and the committee on attendance is noticed and the three school board members show up it is not now a meeting of the school board it used to be it used to be two meetings happening at once because you had three school board members um but when the general assembly went through and uh changed the definitions to include public business and whatnot they looked at that and
048they're like they're there for that committee that committee has been noticed the members of that committee are public are public uh publicly available to the the citizens there's no no transparency harm as long as the committee's been noticed so it's no longer a Schoolboard meeting um which again your clerk is a little bit happy about because now she only has to notice one meeting she doesn't have to notice two at the exact same time in place right and then I am going to spend a little bit of time talking about the conflict of interest act um this is not your official conflict of interest act training you are like Foya um uh local elected officials are required to participate in conflict of interest act training uh and it must be we at with again same
049amount of time within two months after assuming the local office and there thereafter at least once during each consecutive period of two calendar years while you hold such office commencing on the date you last completed the training session while Foya allows me as the um the local body's um attorney to provide the training for you the conflict of interest act has to be provided to you by the Virginia conflict of interest and ethics advisory Council there's is online uh so you can do that at your discretion we will make sure you get a copy to the link for where you can just go and at your convenience as long as it's within those two months of assuming office so that's even if you've been reelected you still have to redo it within those two months
050and we'll make sure um if you haven't already gotten that link you can um and you get a nice little certificate at the end and just make sure uh your clerk gets a copy of that too but the name is not on it your name isn't on it yeah um it's there is no personal penalty if you haven't completed the COA training you should so um I always L to say that you're supposed to do it but just make sure that when you get a copy of that certificate you send it to your Clerk and say I completed it on this day here's my certificate and she'll um keep track of that for you all right and why um I here we go not it's not uh it's not required this isn't your required training
051um now why I still want to do this even though this does not count as your training is because the conflict of interest act not that Foya isn't important um I probably us said that enough times I think um but unlike Foya the conflict of interest act can carry criminal penalties if it's been violated so it is incredibly important um again this isn't to scare you off it is just to keep your attention on it so you're paying attention closely while you're doing this qua training um there can be uh it is a misdemeanor a Class one misdemeanor which can result in jail time of no more than 12 months or a fine of no more than $2500 either or both um there are different exceptions too um if it's a if I'll get into
052a little bit more detail but there are some that are considered a class three misdemeanor which um have lesser jail time and a less their fee but in the end of the day there can still be criminal penalties don't think anybody really cares if it's a class one Class 2 class three uh matters is it's not good uh so we want to avoid that and in addition to these um they can they are will ALS anybody who knowingly violates any prision of qua is also guilty of Mal fusin in office or employment um they may order the forfeiture a judge if someone is found guilty can be order the forfeiture of the office in employment there's a whole other list of penalties that can come with that specific crime and in case this wasn't um
053scary enough there is also a civil penalty that can be imposed in addition to that $2500 and that can be um in the amount equal to the amount of value or thing of value that was received as a result of the violation um it's even I mean even if the general assembly decides to uh increase the value um the of what you're allowed to accept which I'm going to get into in a little bit of time fortunately then the greater value decides the amount of the Civil penalty but still um you can have that civil penalty in that amount and whatever it is that you've received that was a thing of value uh could be ordered to be forfeited um there are disclosure forms that I think you've all already received um you will continue
054to receive them yes uh and there is an addition to that Norm and an exception to that other civil penalty rule there's yet another version of the penalty for COA which says that anyone who uh who is required to file the disclosure form and fails to file it within the period of time is assessed to civil penalty equal to $250 so uh what all right I've got another penalty I'm sorry um anyone who knowingly and intentionally makes a false statement of a material fact on the statement of Economics interest is guilty of a class five felony which is um I've listed it down there too um now the statute of limitations for it is one Year from the time that the attorney for the Commonwealth um is uh finds out about it has actual knowledge
055of the violation um or 5 Years From the date of the violation and then like I mentioned a malfeasance of office is a separate criminal uh offense as well okay so what is it that we need to be aware of to avoid all of these penalties the the actual context of it and it goes back again to that idea of transparency and that the government is there for the people so the guiding policy of COA is that um it the entire system of representative government in America is based on the idea of Citizen legislative members um who are representing the public fully that the citizens must be able to maintain the highest trust in their public officers and employees um and so therefore they are entitled to be assured that the Judgment of public officers
056employees is Guided by law that by a law that defines and prohibits inappropriate conflicts and requires disclosure of economic interests uh so therefore COA has been established um you have to do this training um and it's it's not just a part of of a one-time thing that you do once every two years you are required to read and familiarize yourself with the provisions of this chapter so at all times you are expected to have knowledge of COA and everything that it includes all right so there is generally prohibited conduct and there is a whole list of them that I'm going to go through um pretty fast like I said it's online you'll get it in your specific trainings this first one is really I think what encapsulates the theme of everything that's going to follow
057which is no officer employee of a state or local governmental advis advisory agency shall solicit or accept money or other things of value for services performed within the scope of your official duties accept the compensation expenses or other remuneration paid by the agency of which you're an officer employee so as you are U um civil servants essentially at this point you are there to serve the people not get we're not here to get um fringe benefits to get perks to get anything like that it is there for the sake of serving the people so to that end there's a few more these always apply no matter what and this is a section to always keep coming back to that includes um accepting something of value to help somebody obtain employment a an appointment a position
058um a contract uh anything of economic benefit for another person um this is the big one that I think um can be the most that I would be the most wary with which is accepting um anything that seems to reasonably tend to influence you in the performance of your official duties um so this I mean this even comes down to accepting honoraria for acceptance for appearances speeches or articles where um you're you're pining on your official duties um that unfortunately fortunately that doesn't apply to you but it applies to the governor and lieutenant governor but again this why I say you always have to go back to that idea that you're not supposed to be receiving any compensation beyond what you're actually being paid by law for what you were doing um can't use your
059position to retaliate or threaten to retaliate against someone um this gets out of the the money views of it uh but it is also in there um and so the general idea is you can't accept a gift and what theer term gift is it's pretty um lengthy they try to cover everything and then they just summed it up with saying basically anything of monetary value there are then 17 separate exceptions to that because they want to keep you active um you're the school board you like education so they want you to uh look through it they are cont text in case specific and um our office is here if you have a question about if one of these exemptions applies to a gift we are happy to help um the uh the ethics Council has
060an attorney who is incredibly responsive she is always willing to um listen to the facts and see what she can do as well so um you've got us as your first round of advice and then we also have her that we can fall back on whenever there's any questions this is to say you can't ever accept gifts it's kind of like Foy it's not to say that you can't ever talk to each other um COA has a limit um it's all supposed to the limit is that you can't a solicit accept or receive a single gift with a value in excess of $100 or any combination of gifts with an aggregate value in excess of hundred within a calendar year and Foya says that that is $20 so if you are given something of value
061that is $20 or more that counts toward towards your 100 and you can only have $100 um from that person entity that is giving you a gift and here are the three exceptions to it you can get gifts from your family that's allowed you can get gifts from your personal friends that's allowed that doesn't count towards this $100 but it does include a lobbyist registered pursuant to the uh code of Virginia a lobus principle as defined um in the code of Virginia which includes the city of norfol I will tell you that the city of Nori is a lobbyist principal so you can accept gifts from the city of norfol um in excess of $100 per calendar year um and then any person organization or business who is or is seeking to become a party
062to a contract with the school board um this applies to your immediate family members as well so if you want to gather them around when it's time to do the coet training and have them um watch it they you can or or you can just let them know if you guys are receiving gifts let me know who and where they're from um if it is in excess of $100 um you it has to be reported uh for if if it's allowed to still be accepted so I'm trying to think of the most coherent way to say this um you are limited to the $100 there are certain situations like if it's a widely attended event which is an event at which at least 25 people have been invited to attend where there's a reasonable expectation
06325 people will show up because not everybody always shows up uh and then it's an it is an event that's opened to any of these three entities the members of these types of organizations are from a particular industry or profession or represent someone interested in a particular issue you can attend those events um and the value of attending this widely attended event if it's a ticket if it's something along those lines can be an excess of $100 as long as that event meets this definition but you have to report that you have to report that on your disclosure form again it comes down to this idea of transparency with the people um I would note this definition changed a few years ago probably seven years ago now and so I will be I'll try to
064be as clear as possible a person who who represents persons interested in a particular issue that doesn't mean going to a basketball game because you're all interested in whether or not your team wins um that is it was specifically changed to exclude those kinds of events football games basketball games concerts wine tastings things along those lines just the sheer fact that everybody is interested in what's happening on stage does not make it a widely attended event so please if you if you've been invited to one of these and you're not paying for your own ticket um if somebody's offered you the ticket for free talk to us ask us if it's okay to go um we'll be more than happy to walk you through whether it is or it's not um and if it's then
065if it needs to be reported or if it doesn't but again even with this in mind even when it is something like a widely attended event that can go over the $100 even if it is a gift that is below $20 um so it doesn't technically count as a gift remember you still have those General prohibitions we talked about at the beginning which means that there is a Prohibition against receiving anything of value other than your set salary or toine benefit for your work so just because it doesn't necessarily fall into the specific categories of of the $100 or if it's within your $100 always keep that in mind the end of the day even if it's $5 don't do it um you can accidents happen um you can cure an unlawful gift so if
066um you know like I mentioned this also implies if it's a family member who's kind of accepting these um but if you or somebody H you found out has accepted uh a gift um in violation this chapter um it's not a violation as long as the gift or its monetary equivalent is returned or delivered to a charitable organization within a reasonable period of time and then it's not claimed as a charitable contribution on your federal um tax returns um or you could just pay for it so like I said you can still go to these parties you can still go to these um concerts and events um just pay your own way uh type of type of attitude there are other okay on there are um other exceptions for contracts um you can have a
067personal interest in a contract this comes up um a little bit more sneakily I think sometimes than a gift it's it's I think it's obvious when somebody's trying to give you something of value um but a personal interest in a contract can mean a financial benefit or liability uring to you uh or to a member of your immediate family because of that contract it exists for a number of reasons that are outlined in the code um that includes ownership in business if ownership exceeds a certain percent the annual income exceeds or would be anticipated to exceed a specific amount um salary fringe benefits that are that same amount which I think is 5,000 um ownership of real or personal property if the interest exceeds 5,000 in value um personal liability um can also count as
068a personal interest in a transaction or an option uh for ownership of a business or real or personal property if it kicks you back to to those Above So a personal interest in a contract is defined by the state code is a personal interest that you have in a contract with your governmental agency so if a contract comes before the school board and it is something you have a con you have a personal interest in there are requirements um for how you either have to recuse yourself from it or in certain situations you can just disclose on the record that you may have this personal interest but you are able to proceed without any conflict um there are procedures that your school board has for how to do those things again there is an understanding
069um it it appears by the general assembly that you live and work in this community your homes your families are here your jobs are here you need to still to be able to function without um the body shutting down every single time a contract comes before it but we still need need to be transparent to the public about what's happening which is why in certain situations it is possible um to um have a personal interest in either a contract or in a transaction and still um proceed um with the participating in the vote on that contractor transaction as long as it's disclosed and this is there will be much detail and examples in your official COA training and I won't take up your time with those um but just remember again our office is here
070to always help you through if you think you have a personal interest in a contract or any type of transaction that's coming before the school board let one of us know and we'll be happy to talk you through um what to do and and what not to do these are all specific examples like I said I'm not going to get into them in detail for you uh just so you can see there are there are a number um but there are also exceptions to them um so this is the one that I had sort of mentioned if you are a member of if you have a personal interest in a transaction you can still trans um participate as long as you file certain disclosure requirements um you those disclosure requirements uh are located in state
071code 2.2 3115 it is all clearly spelled out there um they use the general assembly tries to use um as layman's term as possible and avoid legal ease so it is actually very friendly um of a statute to read i' always ask and do we have any questions right um I'll make sure uh that Miss Tanner has a copy of that link and she will send it out to you so you all can complete your COA training and um you obviously know Mr Fox and Mr Cloud if you have questions but I'm here as well um our whole office is here if you need help just feel free to reach out thank you very much thank you we'll move to agenda item 2.02 School Board goal number five inter measure number three thank you chair
072the calero um Miss Thomas Vice chair members of the board this afternoon the Administration has prepared a couple of reports for you the first is around our school board goal number five inter a measure number three and Dr pole our chief academic officer is ready to present that data to you m pammer you put the wrong one up I had emailed you on on this one earlier today this is here we go sorry you got it yeah all right uh good afternoon uh Schoolboard chair decero Vice chair uh Miss Thomas members of the board then Dr Birdsong uh this afternoon we'll follow up from our last meeting and finish the third um Ina measure for the fifth goal which is a focus on um students um increasing the amount of students that graduate with an
073advanced studies diploma and measure 5.3 specifically um and I do apologize I noticed um there was a typo here this is supposed to be the 32% on the on the paragraph that's in the data as well is 32% not 34% my apologies on that in this measure specifically 32% of the 2025 graduating cohort will successfully complete and the appropriate courses to be on track to graduate with the advanced studies by the end of the um of of this the current school year so um as a reminder um this is our oldest cohort that we started tracking so they were already well established into their High School careers when we started tracking this data um so as the data does show um the 2025 cohort has a lower rate than the first quarter of s24 by
0740.9 points so there there are fewer students on track right now and currently the high percentage of the 2026 cohort 2025 cohort that can reach this is is um 32% based on the metric devis for this measure um what's going well um based on course enrollment for students in the 25 cohort the rate can increase 2.2 points from the final rate at the end of 2024 school year so we can still see a little increase based on their enrollment um but not as much growth um there was a decline of 5.4 points from the final grade from sy24 to the first quarter sy25 and due to the courses um cohort 25 students are enrolled in the final Target for this year is two points lower than last year um based on the metric that's being
075used to determine success so a few next steps um and these are somewhat similar um using the district recomend remediation practices and post test procedures throughout the year um using uh District recommended backwards design protocol and providing timely feedback to students and parents um we've shared lists of the 2025 cohort members that could still be on track but are not because of their grades at the moment um and then um uh you know this course selection process for our seniors um we're into the second semester now but some of them could have taken a virtual uh course to to try to make something up that we had tried to push as well um so that's the conclusion of the update on measure 5 three are there any questions um thank you thank you Dr pole
076for the presentation and for the information and I appreciate um you and Dr Birdsong for providing um um additional information on the questions that I had posed prior to the meetings was very helpful uh to me and um I think again you know useful be useful to have in the uh progress report as well um one question I have so one additional question beyond that that I have is around um the when you're creating a shared list of students is that like a is that a digital like do we have a a a database that we're able to do it so that it's not burdensome on our counselors or yes so we provide it to the counselor centrally okay yeah okay okay so so Mr Brady and his team uh provide that okay and has
077there has there been any discussion about like Auto enrolling students so that um because I recent last week well I was actually meeting with a legislator there several bills around math um and so there's one around Auto enrollment and so we were talking about it a little more and I was thinking um you know and I was with a group of board members from other districts too and I know some districts have policies in place where students are Auto enrolled which they have found to decrease um well increase access to Advanced programming but also and then you know longitudinally they've seen it reduce um achievement gaps so I was just wondering like is that is that something that Nora has considered in the past and if if is that something is that a strategy that
078could be put in place to to um help increase access and and I guess retention in in the uh Advanced courses so uh to my knowledge we have not Auto enrolled student however the program that we follow is when they meet with their counselors is that the counselors really do try to push the courses to put them on the highest course of studies that they they can have um the when with our registration process as you're probably well aware as as a parent is um you know the the registration happens then a a notice goes home to verify and check the reg you know the course registration and that's where a lot of changes are made from time to time coming back up um it it could be a strategy that that we could look
079into I think also as discussed at the last meeting as we um uh transition into 4x4 I think opportunities are going to change for students anyway um and we've already had those discussions around how we can do language quicker for better acquisition and and that is our biggest barrier is is the is the World Language so as as we look at that if that's still not making the difference possibly looking to something like like an auto enroll um would would be feasible okay thank you my pleasure any other questions thank you Mr my pleasure move on to agenda item 2.02 2.8 2.03 uh School Board non-negotiable number two interim measure 2.1 and interim measure 2.2 all right and for this one I also have my wonderful colleague Dr agnu Scott here for question on the
080followup but I will present the report um as always so for non-negotiable two uh this focuses on the superintendent not allowing underperforming schools to have low teacher fill rates for prolonged periods of time or make extensive use of substitutes low performing or provisionally licensed staff without implementing high impact strategies underperforming schools are defined as schools that are accredited with conditions which we know will still be soon soon changing that language as the accreditation accountability system comes in or maybe not based on a bill that's out there who knows and low performing teachers are def his teachers on performance Improvement plans specifically with this one measure 2.1 uh focuses on decreasing the percentage of schools accredited with conditions that are not fully staffed with licensed teachers by the first day of school from 83.3% in the
081fall of 2022 to 0% in the fall of 2027 and as the data show as the first day of this Academic Year um we had 18 schools that were accredited with conditions and none of them were fully staffed with licensed teachers which gave us a 57o gap um from the target um what's going well since the first day of school um 78% of the identified schools have now reported zero classroom vacancies so we've seen hiring since the first day of school in many cases associate teachers are obtaining licensure therefore the number of licensed teachers is gradually increasing for those schools as well and additionally teacher Recruitment and hiring continues further reducing the vacancy count as schools accredited with with as are with our schools with credit with conditions um what's not going well is that
082none of the identified schools were fully staffed by the first day of school for syy 2025 um and although the process is being made in the Staffing of school or progress is being made in the Staffing of schools as associate teachers complete their programs there are typically a very few licensed and properly endorsed applicants in the candidate pool um early in the higher in season to fill all the the positions that we have so some next steps Human Resources staff are prioritizing schools according to need therefore recruitment efforts will revolve around the sourcing and hire of licensed teachers for schools accredited with conditions and for our equity and Excellence schools ex exp Excellence Learning Centers um early contracts will be issued to proactively secure licensed candidates for these schools in Innovative marketing strategies such as
083Geo fencing and Geo farming are bring being used to advertise employment opportunities in norford public schools uh in many different states Across the Nation so that's the conclusion of measure 2.1 are there any questions um again um again thank you for the presentation and for responding to uh the questions that I have posed uh regarding some of the the some of the clarifying questions I had here um and just for my board colleagues to know so this this non-negotiable um was was put in place to kind of so that we could examine what schools you know certain schools have higher vacancy rates than others and so this was a way of um and as if you go up to the table uh the yeah so and this this particular one is focused on those that
084are um I guess identified schools so or should I say like harder harder to staff no I mean is that tech tech I mean the schools that were identified were schools that were accredited with conditions well correct but a lot of those have been harder to staff is is what I'm saying I mean right would wouldn't you say uh Dr ading Scott yeah some but not all it it just depends um on the school and um we have seen that there are several schools uh that are um in this category who have zero vacancies um so it just depends on the school and uh various other factors and like you I think had clarified in my in the questions that I had asked so the vacancy rate currently as it is written in this monitoring
085report does include the associate teachers correct right so that's also something that you know as we I mean it's a wonderful wonderful program and I was um heartened to see the retention rate um among the associate teachers and how many were in the program and trying to advance um so I think that's a great a great start um one thing we also may want keep an eye on too is is the percentage of associate teachers in those schools that are um identified you know as right now that we're calling accredited with conditions but going forward you know may be classified and you know they're classified differently but um because we we were trying to not have those schools that have the percentage a greater percentage of students with greater need have a higher percentage of
086of less experience less certified teachers so if that makes sense so that was what was behind um this but again I appreciate uh the feedback that you Pro provided to the questions that I asked ahead of time and um I don't have anything further right now thank you thank you a question is there any way we can get a list by the Nam the schools yes you can and yeah and can I clar so um you may not have seen but we get an HR report every month month um which Miss Tanner usually sends out so that has um you know the school by school um it has the vacancy rate how many associate teachers certified teachers and it tells you also um like by subject area grade level you know there's there's a different
087tables within that um so you should be getting that every month too ahead of this business meeting thank you thank you bless you bless you we're going to motion to go into close executive SE session um I'm sorry Mr K we have one more oh you have one more I please excuse me two point that's right you do have two my apologies for interrupting um so again good afternoon and we'll roll into the second uh measure of the same non-negotiable and that is the percentage of underperforming schools with low teacher fill rates or making extensive use of substitutes to low per Performing um that do not have a high Impact Staffing strategy in place um so this this data is trending in the right direction um the um the the progress being made 7.8 points
088from the um 20 24 2025 Target so you can see the Gap is smaller but we are we are trending up so what's going well here um uh since the first day of school six of the identified schools are now reporting either one or no classroom vacancies so we have seen even improvements since the first day of school in many cases associate teachers are obtaining their license just like with the last one um and additionally the the recruitment is is um reducing the vacancy count at schools at our schools that are accredited with conditions um uh what's not going well um although the pro progress being made with Staffing uh the associate teachers complete their programs there are typically very few licensed properly endorsed applicants at the early in the hiring season um and there
089are still um 12 identified schools with more than one teacher vacancy so next steps are a little similar but there's a couple differences uh the human resources are prioriti prioritizing according to need um the teacher residency programs are being initiated in various schools through grant opportunities this enables the teacher pipeline to be filled with teacher candidates who work side by side with a norfol public schools classroom teacher to learn the craft of teaching while working towards their degree in lure um spring hiring fairs will occur on hiring teachers for these schools for next school year um and we're continuing to review the data of the strategies in place in order to consider adding high impact strategies to additional schools and that concludes this one are there any questions I don't have a question but I
090have a statement um in in order to have this done our next step we have to take care of other things that's going on in other departments so we can get to this point so are we looking at that I'm not I'm not sure the direction of the question Miss Thomas um far as other departments like security and other departments Staffing right staff in order to get to this because we we not gonna get to this are you talking about for the staffing of all the other departments oh of course ma'am we're looking at the Staffing of of all of our areas this is just gen this is focused on this specific measure because it was directed towards the board non-negotiable um Miss Thomas um just like the report we get every month we will
091get one as far as Staffing as well it is on the support staff so you'll be able to see that as well all right thank you Mr P all right thank you CL as I now we will make a motion to go into close executive session I move we go to close session I second those in favor I I oh everybody say that okay that's fine okay move that the members of the school board of the city of norford go into a Clos session for the purposes which are set out in subsection a of section 2.2-inch respective candidates for employment assignment appointment promotion performance demotion salaries disciplining or resignation of specific public officers appointees or employees of the school board pursuant to subsection 2.2 D 3711 A1 of the act the subjects of this portion
092of the session are the discussion of personnel on today's regular Personnel agenda and of candidates for temporary appointment to the board seat representing W 3 pending the November 25th special election discussion or consideration of disciplinary any other matters concerning students in norfor public schools that would involve the disclosure of information contained in a Scholastic record pursuing to subsection 22- 371 3711 A2 of the act the subject of this portion of the session is the discussion of students on today's regular student support agenda and consultation with legal counsel and briefing by staff members pertaining to actual or probable litigation or regarding the specific legal matters requiring the provision of legal advice by Council pursuing to subsections 2.23 7 11 A7 and 8 of the act the subjects of this portion of the Clos session are for
093the legal advice in connection with the matters said above in sub sections A and B of this motion and you all said I or do I need to continue I I I so move all right call the business meeting to order uh Miss Tanner will you please do the roll call Bine here Buffalo here Martin present hson here Thomas hereo here we all please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right uh 4.04 adoption of the business meeting agenda we have a motion to adopt the business meeting agenda I move that we adopt the business meeting agenda I second thank you okay board moves that we
094adopt the business meeting agenda Madam chair yes ma'am I just wanted to clarify that the Personnel docket was already yes yes okay okay sorry thank you all right um do we need to do a roll call yeah bassine hi Buffalo yes Martin hi pson hi Thomas hi to cero hi uh now we'll move on to section 4.05 uh School Board Clerk's report recognition of the my high school football team yes and before we call them forward we would like to give a special thank you to The Talented culinary art students at Mor High School for the delicious dinner tonight we dined on spinach and cheese stuffed chicken breast over yellow rice baked spaghetti and toss Garden salad and had a special sweet treat with lemon pound cake and cheesecakes so you guys stay awake up
095here prepared under the direction and Leadership of Chef Gainer wave Chef Gainer [Applause] yes and our culinary arts department chair Allison [Applause] copelan and our talented culinary students who prepared this meal includes Aubrey coochi Rihanna Williams annia Marshall and Aubrey is going to give some quick remarks tonight tonight let's give her some [Applause] encouragement good evening my name is AR kohi and I'm a junior at myy high school and a second year culinary student culinary arts can mean a lot of different things depending on the way you interpret it it often represents creativity a way to express oneself through flavor and techniques for some it's about mastering skills and The Joy of Cooking while for others it might involve the science of ingredients and the magic of transforming them into something extraordinary for me it's
096a connection to cultural and history and a sense of community as food brings people together whether I'm crafting a dish for family and friends or collabing with my fellow culinary students in class is a shared experience that goes beyond the plate creating more memories and connections over the last two years in my culinary class I have developed many skills which have boosted my self-confidence in and outside of classrooms it has allowed me to be more creative in expressing myself it is it has enhanced my knowledge of food and has made me more aware of making better choices and understanding the impact of food on my well-being as it relates to my health and safety cooking requires multitasking and and planning I have developed better organizational and time management skills lastly I had an opportunity to
097explore the cultural significance of various dishes which has fostered a greater appreciation for diverse culinary traditions and thank you for allowing me to share a glimpse of what culinary means to me awesome [Applause] job next we are excited to recognize and we high school football team who won backto back class five state championships under the leadership of Coach McCain and his phenomenal coaching staff also present with us today is principal Karen ber come on in Karen Berg athletic director Tommy Staples and our senior coordinator coordinator of Athletics Steve seiller [Applause] now I'd like ask the board members to please come to the step and repeat and board chair if you could come here at the end of this day as for me I'm going show you where to line up at keep it simple line
098over there there you go perfect this is the first one all right and now huh okay and now let's give a warm Round of Applause and recognize the game-winning coach of the myy commodor coach McCain come on in we want to thank you for your service for your teamwork and your phenomenal work okay and next the coaches who work with you every day to build your championship team when I call your name please come forward let me see that s let me see that real quick when I call your name please come for it y'all keep clapping now keep the fun [Applause] going were all the coaches here oh just you what's your name Warr coach Warren [Applause] Davis coach Davis you're going to be the representative the hold is for the other coaches and
099then shake the superintendent's hand I'mma hold on to this one second Sarah okay and next we have our phenomenal team players put your hands together for our backtack Championship my high school Conor football team oh we also have are the manag wait a minut before we call the team are the managers here can our managers come through let's give them a warm round of appla [Applause] [Music] okay we have Joshua Bo get you can be the representative to hold that for the team Leon Clark Leslie Hines Daniel Jones amarius Mitchell artor newerk Cameron Simmons Isaiah Simmons Nazar Tate lq tesley Teasley and Javon wi give them a round of applause we can do better than [Applause] that congratulations we want to get some pictures Mr Walker if you can come forward and get pictures and
100then after after that we're going to let Coach McCain come and say a few remarks about this backtack championship team we got to get Sarah in yeah word members we need you guys come to the front there you go there you go kayani come on in yeah oh yeah all right all right look at me please one two three one two three get one for social media oh one two three one two three excellent and everybody stay in place McCain can share a few words coach McCain everybody stay in place coach McCain wants to share just a few remarks about this Championship season go coach all right well good evening everybody good good evening can everybody hear me yes all right um we appreciate you guys inviting us having us here uh it's been a
101long journey um certain guys that we do have here are our seniors and um our captains um the reason I have them here is because um these are the guys who um paved the way and and did the back toback it's the first time in school history that has been done been done um so I just felt like it was important for these guys to kind of get their shine um in today for something they've done usually you see these guys in helmets so you don't get to see their face so um today I wanted to make sure that these guys were known um a lot of our seniors aren't here uh today because a lot of them are um already enrolled at their school at um South Carolina Indiana uh Clemson um Maryland just
102to name a few um that's where some of those guys are now so um we're missing a few but I just felt like it was important for these guys to kind of get their shine um they did something that's never been done they'll forever be remembered in history um and hopefully they go and make history in their lives as um as men and our two managers that we have here as women so hopefully the program set them up for success and hopefully they enjoy success um at this level and go make it into their adulthood life in their 20s and 30s so um let's make history in that that's kind of the biggest goal for them moving forward so um good Milestone here great um but let's do it in in life when we finish
103and graduating and we appreciate y'all congratulations to your student athletes congratulations thank you all so much thank you all for coming tonight thank you thank you for being here thank you okay thank you oh sorry Miss Alf I keep forgetting now I'd like to move to agenda item 4.06 the superintendent's report thank you um chair de calero Vice chair Thomas members of the board staff and Community um as you know every month we have a video that we we would like to share with you to share all the of the exciting things that are taking place in norford public schools um this month's video happens to highlight the future leader education day it was the first time ever with Nori State and our children and we were very happy to participate with that um our
104continued schoolto School attendance challenge so I want to thank our teachers and building principles for making this a priority because it is one of our big rocks and I know it takes a lot of time to take daily attendance but we do it and we we've been doing a great job with it and we have watched our data significantly increase because of our focus on that um we also so uh we have some clips of our teacher of the year program which was very very exciting most of you in the room were there and participated participated in that event and it was just a lovely lovely event and so without further Ado there are a couple of other Clips in there that you'll enjoy watching so channel 47 please roll the video [Music] students from
105every Middle School in the division visited Norfolk State University for their Future Leaders education day they got a real taste of college by watching nsu's lady Spartans defeat Shaw University in basketball this is at the middle school level they need to start to see uh experiences and just to be on a college campus uh to experience uh what these student athletes are going through is is the number one thing it's awesome it's good for them to see that you know what it is to be in college it's not just studying and all that but we also want them to know it's about being educated it's about being a scholar and about getting your degree the Willard Model sharks went swimming around in Dolphin territory just before winter break when they tapped Suburban Park Elementary for
106The NPS School School attendance challenge the Dolphins picked up after break with a Marty gr themed spirit week that featured lots of beads and masks as they demonstrated perfect attendance and a mantra to show up and shine the week concluded with a festive Parade When the Dolphins handed over the flag to Crossroad School across the division schools are creatively and enthusiastically highlighting the importance of being present on time and ready to learn each day proving that attendance counts at NPS this friendly competition underscores a vital message when students miss school they miss out chronic absenteeism missing 10% or more more of school days for any reason has a significant impact on learning it can hinder early reading skills Middle School achievement and even high school graduation as part of the schoolto school attendance challenge NPS
107recognizes the schools that are leading the way in combating chronic absenteeism congratulations to the following schools for having the best attendance and for earning the most improved attendance for the month of December keep up the great work some of our best and brightest teachers were at the Double Tree Hotel for our annual Citywide teach teach of the Year ceremony 56 teachers along with the school board Central Administration principles and families enjoyed dinner and a performance by the strolling silver strings excitement mounted throughout the night as superintendent Dr Sharon B ber song announced what we were all waiting for ladies and Gentlemen please rise and and join me in a joyful and enthusiastic Applause for the 2026 Nori Public Schools Citywide teacher of the year Miss Katherine Flanigan pretty uh amazing I just I I really
108didn't expect it you know I heard all those amazing teachers the other two and U yeah I just it hasn't quite sunken yet I'm so proud and grateful to be among these these excellent Educators and to be considered um one of the best with them you know as a teacher of the year also named were the middle and high school teachers of the year I feel so honored and I feel like it's an outof Body Experience like I can't believe that I'm here it's I've only been teaching for 5 years I've NE I never imagined that I would ever be in a room with so many wonderful Educators it feels great it's it's an honor I'm very grateful it just means so much um it makes makes me feel like the work that I'm doing
109is being recognized and I'm just looking forward to doing more work in computer science I really want computer science to be accessible for all [Music] NK Public Schools spent time prior to the winter break giving back to the Community School nutrition provided a variety of shelf stable Foods along with fresh produce to families with children experiencing food insecurity during their second annual winter food pantry distribution donations from Community Partners including Old Dominion University and Peta enabled them to distribute approximately 5,000 lb of food to over 200 households over at Grandy Village The Early Learning Title One Department was busy making others holidays a bit brighter after loading a school bus with gifts from the Salvation Army at Green Brier mall they packed them together with food and books at the Grandy Village Learning Center our
110high school sent over their chuses to spread some mulai cheer while Title One staff members delivered items to cars as they pulled up to the Learning Center special shout out to the Department of student wellness for their generous monetary donation to Sean youth services please join us to discuss the proposed updates for the new Mory high school with a focus on sustainability Coastal resilience and Community engagement the project will preserve Mor's Legacy while meeting the future needs of Mor students teachers and [Music] parents attention all NPS families mark your calendars for Family University happening Saturday March 29th 2025 at Booker T Washington High School from 9:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. join us for a day of Hands-On learning and access to valuable resources designed to support your family's educational Journey transportation and lunch are all
111provided so bring the whole family don't miss this opportunity to grow connect and learn together at Family University [Music] for complete video stories and more division-wide information about NK Public Schools visit The NPS website and check out our YouTube channel Facebook page Instagram app and The NPS newsletter thank you madam chair that concludes my video report thank you now move to agenda item 4.07 citizens comments Madam chair for today's citizen comments we have four speakers today's speakers signed up for public comments before the start of today's business meeting if you would like to provide public comments you're required to State the agenda item or items or topic you in you were addressing prior to providing your public comments when your name is called please come forward to the speaker's Podium state your name and whether
112you have a child in nor for public schools or if you're employed by the district and state your agenda item or items one person is to speak at a time if you are request representing excuse me a group State the group's name you may ask your group me members to stand in place to be recognized speaking time is limited to 3 minutes a timer is set with an alarm that will signify the end of your speaking time State your position and give facts and relevant data avoid saying anything that identifies students or Personnel information about individual employees Personnel disciplinary and confidential matters may be addressed through the Schoolboard directly via email at Schoolboard npsk12.com comments should be addressed addressed to the board and not addressed to an individual member Schoolboard members do not respond to
113public comments at the time they are given any written statements or supporting materials should be given to the clerk chairwoman de Calera our first speaker for today is Charlotte Smith warley followed by precious white good evening chair Vice chair school board members and Dr bird song My name is charlot Smith Worley I do not have children in norfol schools I am a longtime advocate for adequate Capital Improvement of Norfolk schools I am here this evening because I am hopeful the school board may be entering into a new era of collaboration and cooperation with the administrative leadership as well as the community My Hope stems from the election of that has brought three new members to the table and the impending appointment process that will bring a forth it is no secret that the previous version
114of the school board has divided was divided many times some members seem to challenge the administration just to be contrary rather than focus on the positive aspects of what the administration was trying to achieve so I ask the new school board to sincerely commit to a new Dynamic of cooperation and collaboration that doesn't mean you need to rubber stamp everything the administration brings before you it means that you review the recommendations with diligence and you make intelligent revisions and improve the input to involve the input of the entire School Board a perfect example of this would be the recommendation for converting Lake Taylor High School into a comprehensive Career Technical High School under a public charter this would be a game-changing Initiative for Norfolk Public Schools what a great opportunity for this new board to
115come together to finally bring into reality at long last let me also ask the school board to refine its focus continuing the drive strategic plan needs to be the guiding force of your work right now there's a mishmash of so-called guiding principles from non-negotiables written in a Thou shalt not matter to Schoolboard goals that seem designed to the administration I support aspirational goals but steady incremental growth needs to be celebrated and not diminished finally as you begin the process of interviewing for the vacant for w for position listen for evaluative shared philosophy this may truly become a school board that your stakeholders deserve thank you precious white oops you okay Jack precious white okay Liz Albert good evening school board members and Dr bird song my name is Liz Albert I do not have children
116in public schools however I am an officer of a local civic league who has long supported increased investment in Norfolk Public Schools to the three new school board members let me first say how glad I am that you are here in the beginning of this new year I feel some hope that it will not be business as usual for the Norfolk School Board you see the prior version of the board was not known for its transparency I am hopeful you three will be the Catalyst for needed change in that area earlier today the school board received training on the Freedom of Information Act which enforces the Public's right to have access to government meetings and public records if the new members are not familiar with Foya law I hope you took good notes I and
117other citizens and the media are very watchful about how the school board and city council conduct business we expect strict adherence to foyil law at this very moment I'm awaiting a written opinion from the Virginia Freedom of Information Council regarding the violation of the public meeting requirements the Foya Council has already given me the verbal opinion that indeed three Norfolk school board members did violate Foya when they met with the school system's educational planning consultant at a conference last year and discussed High School redistricting two of those members are still on the board and one has retired I have asked for a written opinion because I believe it was a serious violation that spoke of a definite political agenda it is probable this agenda will become apparent to the new board members once the school
118board grapples with impending decisions on closures and consolidations after the training I'm sure the new board members are keenly aware that three or more members of a public body cannot gather to discuss public Business Without adhering to public notification requirements I also hope a commitment to transparency will be evident in the appointment process for the ward 3 seat prior to the February 5th the public deserves to see the résumés and applications of all applicants so we can weigh in on their qualifications therefore based on foil law I am verbally requesting copies of those résumés and applications in your possession again let me say welcome to the new school board members I hope you don't regard my remarks as negative but instead instead see them as cautionary I sincerely want the best version of a school
119board that Norfolk can possibly have thank you Michael Dyer good good evening returning board members chairperson and welcome to the new board members my name is Michael Dyer I have no children attending norfol Public Schools but I have been employed at gramby high school for the past 14 years I stand before you tonight as a teacher but as a representative for 12 Inc teachers in Norfolk all of whom are facing serious issues that have been left unresolved for the past eight months I'm here to speak on behalf of my colleagues and to implore you to listen with an open mind and a commitment to fairness many of many of you may recall last year's Schoolboard budget uh had Provisions for step pay raises for all full-time employees at Northfolk Public Schools we were hopeful expecting
120that each of us depending on our hire date would receive at least a step pay raise if not more but when contracts came none of us saw those step increases reflected in our pay I reached out to clarify the discrepancy with HR only to be told that Navy nrtc teachers were exclude it from the pay raise this was a blow to my colleagues and myself and Al to also to our morale we are teachers we serve our students and we deserve to be treated with the same respect and fairness as the other teachers in the district pay increases are always a topic that requires thoughtful discussion but tonight I'm not here just to ask for AR raise I'm here to ask for fairness for equality and to demand the pay discrepancies between the Navy jotc
121teachers and other staff members be addressed over the past eight months we have attempted to resolve these issues but we have heard nothing but excuses we were told we didn't receive the step increases because we were off step however surveying the teachers at my school there were only 16 of them out of 162 that I surveyed that were on step so this doesn't hold water we were also told that our raises were not within the budget however our average salary paid by Northfolk Public Schools is less than 44,000 $144,000 less than a brand new teacher and we average over 10 years of experience in teaching this is not just a discrepancy it's a disparity and just last October I received a doc a letter from Dr agnu Scott stating that the immediate plans to change
122the compensation structure for there were no NE immediate plans to change the compensation structure for nrtc teachers it was a longstanding practice let me ask you should we continue to accept outdated practices and that permeate inequality should we continue to allow a system exist where certain teachers are un undervalued and underpaid simply because the programs they teach this issue is not just about pay it's about dignity and respect it's about ensuring that every educator regardless of their role or subject is compensated fairly and equitably that's why I'm here tonight asking for your help I thank you for your time and I look forward to working with each of you to resolve this issue as soon as possible let's make Northfolk Public Schools a place where every educator regardless of their position is treat it with
123respect fairness and dignity and a correction to our speakers is just three all right moving on to agenda item 4.08 approval of the consent agenda I move that we approve the consent agenda I have a second second all right the school board moves that we accept the consent agenda and I apologize I was trying to flip the screen who made the original motion Martin okay thank you all right bassine I Buffalo I Martin I hson I Thomas I to calero hi right move to item agenda item 6.01 the mon monthly financial report good evening um chair de Calera um Vice chair Thomas school board members and Dr bird song um tonight I'm presenting the period six financial highlights U this is the December report which covers six months of the fiscal year that started July
1241st um as um this report reflects July through December transactions that were recorded on or before January 17th at the the Highlight page as shown on the financial highlights page the general fund collections for the first six months total 22.1 million and represents 47.3% of the um annual general fund budget collections during the year during the same period for the two previous years ranged between 44 and 43% of the budget looking at the expenditure and incumbrances line um as um by the end of December we spent or encumbered million um or 46.8% of the budget during the previous two years um spending through December 31st ranged between 41.4% and 46% as shown on the bottom line of um the financial highlights you can see that um at this point in the year actual Revenue collections
125are 2.5 million above expenditures and encumbrances um following the um Financial um summary are um detailed pages that provide more detail for the general fund budget um there were no general fund budget transfers exceeding $50,000 during the month of December our next report is the quarterly grants report so looking at the quarterly grants report um as of December 31st we had $17 million of grants in in progress of which 60 million was spent or encumbered we had one Grant it's the top one on the schedule the American Rescue plan HVAC Grant it had an end date of December 31st um of 2024 um and was 100% spent by the deadline on the HVAC project at Booker T Washington High School um 40 um 54.9% of the $86 million in Grants that end in 2025 have
126been spent and 29.1% of the 26 million in Grants with end dates in 2026 have been spent um the date to the um next closeout date is um March 31st of this year and we will have until May 15th to um close out th those grants um and ask for reimbursements um you have a you have a copy of the grant report does anyone have any questions on the Grant's report or Madam chair M chair oh I'm sorry I didn't see okay recognizes Miss Bine thank you thank you very much thank you for the presentation um I think uh I appreciate this particular report and I I bet what is weighing heavily on everyone's Minds is what's going to happen next given um uh you know the executive orders around um you know the the
127federal grants um and how the federal grants will be how that will impact our School Division what we might be doing to prepare which I know that you're not going to have the answer for that right now but I just wanted to hear you know from your perspective and the administration's perspective um what is being discussed I'm happy to address that that um so at this time um I think there was a three-day pause that the administration um has communicated and um I also think that perhaps um because there has been a lot of confusion around it um that we're not it it doesn't feel like the administration is is confident that they're moving forward um in the manner that we thought they were originally going to um certainly we are extremely concerned about tital
128one funding and as well as impact Aid that could have a negative impact on our School Division if we do not um realize all of those funds because certainly we we plan for those funds we need those funds and um it would be quite devastating to lose any significant portion of of those funds and so like everyone else we're we're waiting to see what happens we we don't know we won't know until we are given guidance and information but at this time there was a pause and then you know there was lots of information about confusion and perhaps that being pulled back but we don't have anything definitive at this point all right thank you any questions oh Madam chair I'm sorry I thought you were asking if there were any other questions related to
129this report I do have um some general questions um and again if I wondered if you had any updates regarding the estimate from the city's funding formula um I do okay great yes um the um the city is estimating that the local contribution um this um for the upcoming budget as um would be 160 67.7 million thank you and I also wanted to on the financial report so the reversion fund total for Sy I mean for school year 24 um if you could just uh confirm for me is 11 11.2 million essentially our our um conservative estimate is 10 million okay um given where we are with the budget right now I mean with the audit right now okay and have we asked for that to be reappropriated to us or I mean based on
130what I think I'm looking at on page six um you could if you could just clarify if I'm understanding so that I'm I know that what I'm looking at I'm understanding Inc correctly um so where it says uh FY 2024 encumbrance carry forward on page six again my pages aren't numbered it's the very bottom yeah it's the very bottom okay um something different so so this um this the that's this is the last line of the detailed um report okay right these are the um fiscal 24 incumbrances so that was contracts we had in place POS we had in place at the end of June and that the budget for those because those are already committed funds carries over to um fiscal year 25 so so that's what this bottom line oh okay so those
131aren't those aren't the uh reversion funds exactly okay that's why I was I just wanted to clarify because I was like were we reappropriated those funds already and um okay so all right so we have not yet requested reappropriation of those not not no all right and any idea uh do you do you know when we might be doing that or uh well that I'm happy leave that with the so next week um I will be presenting my budget proposal in collaboration with Miss FY and the board members should have received that report already it was uploaded last Friday I believe we uploaded it and so um you'll see within that report my plan the administration's plan for what we we believe um uh in terms of the funding that we'll have available for us
132next year which will include reversion all right thank you any further questions any further questions no have a question nope M Madam chair I move that we approve the monthly financial report subject to audit have a second second the board moves that we approve the monthly financial report subject to audit Tanner will you please take the role Bine I Buffalo I Martin hi pson hi Thomas hi calero hi all right moving on to 6.02 the Personnel report uh we need a motion to approve the Personnel report I move we approve the Personnel report second uh the board motions that we approve the Personnel report um Miss Tanner will you please take the roll call yes bassine I Buffalo I Martin I hson I Thomas abstain talro I all right moving on to 6.03 school board
133announcement of the candidate I pulled the wrong pad out of my bag just a second we the school board has decided to um interview the following candidates K Katherine Powell CTI or Curtis Forest Corbin Brown Brown sioban Smith and Jason ing can you say again what what we're interviewing them for oh I apologize we are interviewing these five candidates for the ward 3 seat to to be filled for the AC for the following year with a special election in November of 2025 their resumés and applications will be made available tonight online uh and do I need to repeat that to repeat the candidates yes please Madam chair all right the the five candidates are Katherine Powell orti Forest Corbin Brown sioban Smith and Jason ing and Madame chair we can let them know it'll be
134on the Schoolboard work session agenda item on board docs and social media IM media release okay so moving on to item 7.01 do we have a motion to adjourn all moved I second go Ahad okay no go ahead Tanya seconds put her down a second uh the board moves that we motion to adjourn can we do that by the by eyes or do we need to take a roll call all in favor I all in favor say I I I I e