001good afternoon everyone welcome to the workshop for Wednesday December 18th 20124 uh we're going to start off with calling the role Miss tan Bine Clanton present Gabriel pres Jordan here Martin pres hson present and buffalo presid we're going to go ahead and get started 2.01 Dr bong good afternoon chair Buffalo Vice chair Dr Gabriel members of the board staff community members um this afternoon the administration is prepared to share updates with you related to um our school board goals specifically goal number four um we will be discussing our math data we have some exciting news and of course as always we have great news to share and there's still room for improvement and we we are going going to work towards achieving our end of year goals so without further Ado Dr po please uh
002good afternoon Madame chair Buffalo Vice chair Dr Gabriel members of the board Dr Birdsong community members and staff um as Dr Birdsong said uh today this afternoon we're going to review um it's a Schoolboard goal four interion two and uh Schoolboard goal four focuses on Gap data um to increase reading and math scores while decreasing gaps between specific subgroups um and specifically measure two is looking at our mathematics data so the first part of measure two um focuses on the um proficiency scores um and moving students um in each subgroup up the ranges where we have there for our our black subgroup from 48.5 to 60% uh s swd from 30.4 to 43 SCS from 50.1 to 59 our El from 32.9 to 55 and our Hispanic from 58.9 to 64 um and then the
003uh other table that I'll review in know a little bit later talks about our urgent intervention and how we want to um decrease those rates for our urgent intervention uh prior to scrolling down there I do want to talk about um um I do want to talk about the change in the chart a little bit uh last board meeting um one of the one of the questions and requests was if we could see a comparison side by side with the last fall data and this fall data so there's a lot of green and red on the on the chart that I want to explain and walk through so the spring results because it it is written under the table but it's a lot written under the table to follow the spring results are did we
004meet that goal last spring um did we did we move to where we wanted to move last spring and then the fall actual um results are just a comparison from the fall of 23 to the fall of 24 data um and as you can see here the the fall toall growth um we've seen growth um in in and I'll review this in a second uh more thoroughly but in all of the tested areas we did see a couple increases in gaps from Fall to fall um but we did see some some tremendous growth too from Fall to fall so what what is the data showing overall with both of these charts and the graphs um and I I will comment too I know there was also request for a combined chart on the data but
005again due to the turnaround from Wednesday to happen to submit it Thursday I just couldn't get that data chart in there as well the line graph but I'm working on that for when we upgrade these the next time um continuously improving right that's the goal yes yes so what does the data show so um the from the fall of 23 to the fall of 24 all subgroups saw improvements from Star mathematics data um all subgroups increased in scores and proficiency while decreasing in scores in the UR urgent intervention band in additionally all gaps were reduced for the Urgent intervention band um except for our Hispanic subgroup which Still Remains under 10% um and then the gaps for the um proficiency band um all decreased um except for our Hispanic and non-hispanic and our SES and
006or our s swd and nons swd gaps um had had had a slight growth from last spring to this fall yes you want to I'm I'm controlling it I'm sorry yep um so this is the Urgent interventions uh data right here um the the fall star mathematics data also shows improvements from the spring 24 data in nearly all subgroups while reducing gaps um and this shows that the year is starting off with uh improved data than how we completed the year last year so similar to when we talked about reading um not only were we seeing increased scores from Fall to fall um which is the annual comparison but where we ended the year last year to where we started this year we're seeing improved scores increased scores um so we're starting the year stronger
007than we finished the year with the star data um both with urgent intervention and with Proficiency in almost in almost all areas um students in the following subgroups showed improvements from the spring 2024 to the fall 2024 data in both proficiency and Urgent intervention um while seeing the gaps move closer to 10% those were students in our our black subgroup sces subgroup El subgroup and our non-el subgroup um and then uh what's going well um let me scroll down to the verbal tables now where I'm actually talking through the proficiency data the gaps between students in the black and white SC and nones um and El and nonel subgroups all improve from the spring 24 data so from Spring to Fall which is I think I I'll say that as many times I can because
008that's that's great growth to see where we ended the year to where we're starting the year um students in the following subgroup showed improvements in proficiency scores from the spring to the fall um and that was black white nons swd sces elel nonel and non-hispanic and then specifically within the Urgent intervention data um the gaps between all student subgroups black and white s swd and non SW D sces and non e and nonel um saw decreases from the spring to the fall results so they saw decreases of students in the Urgent intervention group and all students realize decreases in the percentage of students in the Urgent intervention band uh what's not going well as Dr Birdsong said earlier you know when she was introducing it is there's always work to be done there's always areas
009to focus on um in the proficiency data we noticed that students in the white s swd nones and Hispanic subgroups they saw decline from the spring um however from the fall um they did see scores improve so we they're not as strong as others maybe because from Spring to Fall but from Fall to fall we did see the Improvement and then urgent intervention the gap between students in the non-hispanic and Hispanic subgroups increased slightly um however it's still below that 10% range um and then um we ended the the the the term with these action steps so the math office about profc facilitating professional learning um for the new 2023 standards that are that are fully in effect um and they have they facilitated professional learning um during division wide professional development days and provided
010the math specialist with replicable training um to support ongoing implementation at the school level and the math offic has supported grade level planning and engaged instructional coaching Cycles to support implementation of the 2023 standards so they are out and about in full force the math office uh will facilitate professional learning provide instructional coaching support and monit the implementation of RTI based small group instruction um they have provided um administrators and teachers with expectations expectations for small group instruction and theyve provided coaching support to teachers on small group instruction including walkthroughs with feedback modeling of evidence-based interventions and creating additional resources for Effective small group instruction um and uh more professional learning on the in instructional coaching support to model the implementation of zern and AD menum two of our online platforms um as you recall
011ad menum we've this is our fourth full year of implementation and zern was the one the vooe rolled out for tier two and three support last year um the math office is support of The Specialist and Department chairs with repcal PD focused on the zern and Ed menum platforms um and Milestones of teacher usage student usage and lesson proficiency um were established and they're using data um to provide strategic supports throughout the division also Ed menum Representatives have come and been scheduled um with specific schools uh by the math office to support their use and last but definitely not least our next steps as we look at this data and move forward um really monitoring the instruction with the alignment with the 2023 standards um utilizing the evidence-based interventions and aligned instructional materials uh by
012conducting walkthroughs um and then offering supports following the math officer will continue to monitor implementation of zern and AD menum and offer professional learning throughout the year here um they'll monitor implementation of small group instruction by conducting walkthroughs um with feedback to determine next steps um the math office will monitor elementary math specialist support logs for implementation of coaching cycles and replicable professional learning aligned to the standards to strengthen teacher capacity um and to address um the low scores in in of s swd and Hispanic subgroups the math office has planed collaborations with learning support and L's offices to create um replicable professional learning for building math leaders um in addition the collaboration will support planning for aligned differentiated instruction on division professional learning days with teachers so that concludes um the information to share
013with measure 4.2 board members you've heard the presentation you have any anyone have any questions Dr G thank you chair Buffalo um congratulations on the success um um that's a lot of hard work and it's wonderful to see the gaps decreasing I know that if uh Miss camson were here she would be very happy to see um the closing of the gaps um my question really um centers around thinking of um the future and our teaching staff moving forward what does the collaboration right now look like with our University Partners regarding um teachers who are um in training to be Math teachers um or student teachers what what feedback are we able to give them so that way when they do uh come uh in uh and and help to support us um how are
014we preparing them for for helping us accelerate our math improvements especially at the higher level math like calculus and statistics and those harder to fill positions so that is a great recruitment tool where we're able to get student teachers from local universities and um I would say that all of the surrounding School divisions we're all fighting for the same small pool of student teachers um but we're very active and and aggressive and you can speak with uh Dr Agy Scott a little bit more about that particular partnership but they actually get classroom experience hands-on experience right here with our teachers with our veteran teachers our veteran teachers also get paid a small stien but it is a stien for taking on um a cooperating teacher so that's the best training to to sit beside a
015very veteran experienced teacher who gets results so and it's also a wonderful recruitment tool okay thank you anyone else go ahead Miss B I didn't know if it was on presentation so um in in looking at the gaps so we're making progress but we're we're still you know we have it's a work in progress we we have a lot more work that we have to do we haven't quite hit uh the targets that that we've set um so and and while we're trending for some of the subgroups in the direction that we want to see again going back to our students with disabilities um we're seeing a a very different Trend right so where the targets we're we're seeing an increase in the Gap versus h toy um with and so specifically and I'm going
016to keep ask asking this question I know I ask it every time around what's going well what's not going well but specifically what strategies specific to what is going well how we know and what is not going well and how we know um as it pertains to each of the subgroups and in this case because we are um seeing that Gap persist and and even widen with our students with disabilities what are we specifically doing uh with that particular subgroup so I'd like to hear more about that and going forward in these reports I do want to see more um information about that sure miss Bine so um one of the things that we've been focusing on is expanding uh work with the William Mary Tac and ODU Tac as well um with the Strategic
017instructional model the Sim model um we've uh presented that to um um teachers we presented that to principls um and those are um instructional activities focused specifically for supporting our students with disabilities um and how do we break the learning down more uh we're continuing with uh professional development on specially designed instruction um to support you know how you're continuing to teach the standard in ways that support different um Learners needs um and this year again um um we've increased the way we're collaborating centrally to where our our special education coordinators and Specialists meet um regularly at least monthly if not twice a month in some some months uh with the cni coordinators and Specialists when we're doing curriculum development when we're talking professional development and then furthermore the professional development days this year are
018actually done in collaboration this year so the the special education department and the cni department are collaborating on how those are done so that we can see better supports in the classroom based on the data that we saw last year and are you are you seeing that because I know as far as the teacher or HR reports um teachers in special ed you know who teach special education are we making progress and filling those positions which you know I'm sure we know you know that correlates with academic performance are we um are we making any progress there or um in terms of ensuring that we have the Staffing necessary uh to teach those students so I would have to defer to Dr agu Scott as far as the progress of the Staffing but but I
019would like to say even even with new staff that we hiring the professional development for them is more intense and actually met with a A Team it was a vendor team last night or yesterday afternoon about different supports that can provide specifically with new sped teachers that could be even more intense um as a as a possibility to okay thank you and I have one last question um so you talked about Milestones um let me get to that um like certain Milestones were set around teacher usage for zern I think it was in ad mum um teacher usage student usage and lesson proficiency um how like I guess how are you monitoring to see what you know what that usage what those in those three categories like what is producing the greatest results so this
020year with with learn it's our first full year of implementation so what we're monitoring is implementation and usage time and we also monitor um the amount of expected usage so not just a student logged in for five minutes and they're done but a student logged in did the full lesson did the 20 minute maybe time frame whatever the requirement may be for that specific lesson um we meet with uh team members from zern um once a month to review our data by school um and then we also are able to share that that with principles to say here's what we're seeing what we're not seeing where we need to improve um um and then as we start to get the winter data in that's when we'll start to look at are we seeing the results
021from that platform that that that we were expecting to see for our tier two and tier three interventions thank you my pleasure Mr dordan all right uh good evening um so I spent uh hours and hours trying to uh figure out what my struggles have been on uh on the on the monitoring of some of the data that we do and I think I figured out some of it so um we have for our overarching goal we have a relatively smart goal it doesn't say that we started in 22 23 but I think we did and that on the SL uh piece that we would move towards having achievement gaps decrease to be no greater than 10% and then also have uh each subgroup improve over over that time period so when we get down
022to the interim uh at least what I what I think and maybe you can correct me I don't think we have a smart interim goal that says that from uh dealing with the the star data so if our proficient uh dat in our Gap in 2223 was 32.9% do we have a a interim goal that says what we expect to be by 26 27 or or any other time frame so the interim goals we do annually so we we do an annual smart goal on the interim the the main goal has the long-term uh endpoint so the interim so here these numbers would represent what we're doing annually for the interim right here yeah and then here the Gap numbers are our goals for the just for the year for the star data yeah and
023that's that's where it when my light bulb went off and so um we should have a uh least based upon the progress monitoring approach we should have a uh smart goal that the board is adopted and then the interim goals should be smart as well so then with uh with a target from beginning to end then that way when we are monitoring our progress you know how always we'll ask the question are we on track or not that question is really tied to not are we on track year to year so much as are we on track towards uh the the multi-year smart interim goal because we should we should have some indication that if the star data is predict Ive of the so data then if we know that the so goal is to
024get it down to 10% then what is it that the uh what should the star data show over a mult over same time frame that gives us an indication whether or not we're on track based upon what the star data is telling us against what we are uh predicting that the so data will will result and so I so that's where it kind of hit me because when we when we're having a conversation about comparing Spring to Fall I think that's fine but it really needs to be in the broader sense of I don't know let's just say if it's I don't know how many years it is but let's just say it's three years so if over three years we've set a uh overarching goal for the gap to be 10% for the sols
025if we happen to have that same overarching goal for for it to be 10% for at and above on watch then each annual Target would be what it is that we have to hit in order to eventually reach that third year goal that we've set then when we are monitoring our progress from from year to year it gives us an indication as to whether or not we're on track to reach the the 10% or or not and then in doing that three-year period because we would have also annual targets then when we're looking at fall data or winter data or spring data or really fall and winter data it's just given us an indication whether or not what our students did in the fall does it look like we're on track to reach the the
026the goals that you set for for each year is that you following me I do okay so and then that ties to because if for example we were to see that we were way off track then when we talk about the allocation of resources the the progress monitoring and being able to understand where we are and whether or not strategies are producing what we need the conversation would be around well you know is is the strategy correct does it need more resources are there adjustments to be made to really give us an indication whether or not in school year uh 2627 we are on target or not and so I I think that um one of the recommendations I would have for uh for the administration is to revisit what the smart what are the
027smart interim goals that are uh influenceable by the superintendent and are predictive of the goal that the board has set and then the monitoring um that the board is doing trying to understand whether or not the current conditions are matching the goals or the visions that the board has set it would give the board a better sense of where we are and we give everybody a better sense of where we are but I think if we stay down the current path where it where it seems like we are just doing it on an annual basis it it doesn't give us and it doesn't give the board the real sense of what it is that we have to do to make sure that our students are accelerating at the rate that we need them to accelerate
028in order to in order to meet the goal and so um uh sitting in a restaurant with uh two screens in front of me and the in the Cowboy game on it finally the light bulb uh finally went off and I started to write this email but I just didn't didn't didn't finish it but I think that's where we've got to for each of these um goals that we're monitoring make sure that we have um smart interim goals over the period of time so that and I know I'm kind of repeating myself here but just let's just say for example if in order for the so Gap by school year by the end of school year 26 27 to be 10% between black and white students then does do we think that that means that
029the star data gap for math between black and white students should be 5% by the time we get the school year 26 27 and and if and I'm just is making this up but if that were the case then when we see right now that in Spring of 23 24 just doing the black white because it happens to be the first one we were at well in 22 23 we were at 32.9% then a year later we were at 28% so a little bit you know close to close to a 5% change then uh if we have a Target right now for 24 25 of 19% but historically we've seen the the the change be in the two to thre Point range what is it that we really have to do in order to reach
030that 19% Target for this year considering that we came out of last year and we we're at 28% so I think it's good that we're able to see the growth that we're making period to period or quarter to quarter season to season ultimately what we really need to get a sense of are we do we feel like we are on track to reach the 19% if the 19% is a good Target to say 19% in 24 25 and then I don't know what it may be 10% for the next year so I I I I was struggling and struggling struggling struggling struggling but I think if we could truly see the long range in goal for the for the interims it puts the board in a better position to be able to ask the questions
031around you know budgetary impacts resources and so forth because right now we're having a discussion but I don't think we really know whether or not the uh the goals that we set and the reality that we have and the resources and strategies whether or not they're truly aligned to get us to a uh to the end goal so I appreciate that Mr Jordan um I will say the the annual goals that we develop based off the star assessment are derived directly from the long-term goals that were developed within the actual goal so on the actual goal um and I believe it was in the document that was shared at the July Retreat P there's a table that has annual so goals and GAP goals right so you'll notice on the Gap goal for black and
032white um for the sy25 is actually 21% to make the Target on that sheet however here when we looked at our our actual data and and saw where we were now we challenged to go to 19% because the the the closer the the the more rigorous we are in Star the more we're going to make we we we have confidence we'll make it with the so results so each year we're using the data that was preset for the so gaps and growth to create the growth for Star um you know I I I understand I understand what you're talking about and my only dilemma and this is just just me not talking to to the staticians or the rest of the data team or or the admin team is that that's going to make for
033a a really long smart goal up here as as far as how how we're tracking everything which is which I understand but we're trying to pull it so we're consistent for the data that we're we're pulling from so we're still trying to focus on our ultimate goal as SML gaps so that's where we're we're we're creating these data points from yeah I'm not I follow you I'm not because I I actually went back I I pulled the the data from The Retreat I pull like I have your chart that you gave us back in June I pulled that and so I'm not quite sure I I follow the elongated smart goal so let's just say for example um on the Gap side if the if the focus if one of the foca is on the
034Gap then and we're dealing with the uh the star data then if the if in 2223 the gap between black white was 32.9% then by the spring of 2627 we say it should be 5% then at least on the Gap piece that's what it is on the student performance piece it is saying that uh like if you go back up to um to the description of the goal itself it says that all sub group students will not decrease below the established base Baseline and will increase so in that particular case if we follow that same model then just using the black white Gap the established Baseline is 44% 44.6% for black students 77.4% for white students and as we look at the data we can see whether or not those um those numbers are improving
035because the reality of it is as I was playing with it so let's say for example right now in this current chart we started off with the white student performance for spring results in school year 2023 at 77.4 we have a so for the spring Target for this particular one um we are saying that the white student group is 79% so let's bring it was 76.5 right right I'm just going back to the original to the to the starting point correct right so from 77.4 right now we have a target for the school year of 2425 of 79% so just looking at the that uh FL would forgive the usage the white line uh we are saying that in whatever that is two years that we we are targeting the white group to grow by
036uh what's that one point and this is just this year Mr Jordan this isn't two years no no I'm saying from Spring 2223 okay yeah okay so in spring in the the Baseline the white student performance was at 77.4 we but it's one year and then 2425 would be the second year so by the end of the second year we are uh uh I don't know the right word ambition towards the white student performance on Star math proficient at or above to increase by 1.6% if my math is correct over the two years correct okay but let's say we were trying to put the to see the white longitudinal growth to be at 85% then that would mean that in order for the black student for The Gap to continue to decrease if the white
037performance is going up then the Black Performance data is going to have to go up even more towards trying to close the gap so then the conversation becomes around a couple of things one what is it that we must do to make sure that the white performance doesn't stay flat relatively flat and what is it that we have to do to see the black student performance to grow I'm just gonna say this exponentially in order for us by the time we get to 20 2627 we feel that we have pushed both student groups to grow towards greater outcomes and at the same time seeing the rate of growth go for um for the whatever group that may be behind in order to try to close that Gap to 10% that to me is a is
038a is a is the level is the conversation that the data could spark that would truly have the board in the position in conversation with the superintendent Administration around really tell us and let's really have some conversations around are the strategies and the resources aligning with the goal and the and the reality and then that forces or could potentially Force when we especially when we start talking about resources um if if currently the resources the way we have them distributed is you know maybe producing some flatlining then you know there may be some real recommendations that the superintendent Administration would have to come back to the board and say we need you to make some tough decisions if you really want goals because right now whether it's human resources or financial resources or book resources
039whatever it is um whatever it is that that you feel you need in order to truly see us get to the point where um we're going to see both groups progress and gaps closed that to me forces that courageous conversation around really telling us what you need to to to achieve that and I and that's what just kind of like I said came to me as I was just struggling you know starting when we did the the reading one and then looking at this one again I couldn't find um that in goal Target and that's what brought me back to to the conversation that we're having having now so I I think that's something that you know I would encourage the administration to to review because even as you're go as the board going to
040go into into the budget season you could just take this one goal only and say if we if we really need to close gaps then these things that we've been doing with the resources that we have at our disposal if you really gave us you know two and a half times that that was just focused on trying to make sure that whatever strategies we feel we need to implement to get there then the board and administration of superintendent can have a real conversation around um is there alignment taking place between uh achieving the goal and the realities that that we that we face just I thought that was very well stated and I think yeah so that's not just I mean everything that's there and all the green is great the the uh ultimately we're
041trying to get to the point of what does it take to win the Super Bowl oh I'm sorry what does it take to win the the uh Wimbledon what what does it take to win Wimbledon Tanya doesn't know football she knows tennis oh I just thought you were talking about your I know super the Dallas Cowboys oh oh yeah well she wouldn't know she wouldn't know Super Bowl I'm not talking about the five CH I'm just saying for if if if I am a qualifier in Wimbleton what is it that I have to do to actually be able to win in in three to five years and so the type of coaching and resources and practice time and all the things that that I would have to do if I even stood a chance of
042getting there but that was the goal it really forces a different conversation than saying you know I'm winning matches but I but I'm not getting to the point where I can actually qualify to get into the tournament is there anyone else so the other um so we we've talked about this in the last couple monitoring sessions about the impact of the summer programming and looking at those students that were in the summer programs and um there know how where you are with that I I don't have a final report but we should be pretty close one one other thing so I know we talked about um I don't think it impacts the under the conversation we were having before about um uh the the State's new framework none of it impacts this particular goal correct
043cuz we're still doing this one yeah this one's just on so password doing still doing um star so this this goal isn't impacted and then just as a reminder the board agreed to uh eliminate yeah the first goal so it's now four goals right okay okay anyone else all right thank you Dr thank you all have a great evening that was the only report we have for our Workshop so we can um now may I have a motion to go into close session I move that we go into close session I have a second second please read the motion SC yes okay I'm sorry I was just sitting back down moved at the members of the school board of the city of norfol go into a Clos session for the purposes which are set out
044in subsection a of section 2.2-inch assignment appointment promotion performance demotion salaries disciplining or resignation of specific public officers appointees or employees of the school board pursuant to subsection 2.2 D 3711 A1 of the act the subjects of this portion of the session are the discussion of personnel on today's regular Personnel agenda and the ongoing investigation and possible disciplining of a specific Personnel discussion or consideration of disciplinary and any other matters concerning students in norford public schools that would involve the disclosure of information contained in the Scholastic record pursuant to subsection 2.2 3711 a 2 of the act the subject of this portion of the session is the discussion of students on today's regular student support agenda in consultation with legal councel and briefing by staff members pertaining to actual or probable litigation or regarding specific
045legal matters requiring the provision of legal advice by Council pursuing to subsections 2.2 D3 711 A7 and8 of the ACT the subjects of this portion of the session are for the legal advice concerning the provision of special education services and the matters set out above in subsections A and B and legal advice and briefing by staff members in connection with the matters said above in subsections A and B of this motion bassine I Clanton I Gabriel I Jordan I Martin I bson hi and buffalo I take a breather oh yeah that was there's a lot a lot we're now in Clos session I I need to get my computer good evening welcome to the norfol school board meeting for Wednesday December 18th a quorum is present to conduct the business of the school board Miss
046Tanner please call the road theine here Clanton present Gabriel present Jordan here Martin present Paulson present Buffalo present we're GNA have our student representative Carson rice lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance good evening we request that all cell phones and papers to be turned off or on vibrate during the course of this meeting thank you please rise and remain standing for their citing of the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge Alle alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stand one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all please be seated we're moved to 4.04 adoption of the school board meeting agenda may I have a motion to adopt the meeting agenda I Mo that we adopt the meeting agenda may I have a
047second second um motion by Dr Martin second by Mr pson any discussion uh Mrs Mo Buffalo um I'd like to request to have um sorry my computer just closed down um item 5.05 on the consent agenda moved to uh the discussion decision portion of the agenda okay so that makes it 6.03 Miss Tanner please note that on the agenda is there any discussion also uh item 506 the approval of minutes okay thank you okay what did you want what did you want done to the oh I'm I'm going to abstain so you'll have to vote on it they can't be part of the conern yeah so we're going to move that to 6.04 okay Madam chair uh just one point of clarity I know we had a update to the Personnel docket is that do
048we get that straight with the it's posted on board dos the revised one I'm hearing it's it's been okay thank you okay so um now miss Tanner the um cell phone policy will be 6.03 minutes will be also removed out of the consent agenda and move to 6.04 do I hear any discussion or we're good all right so right now the consent agenda is as it is excluding the cell phone policy and the approval of minutes okay ready yes c i Clanton I Gabriel I Jordan I Martin i pson i i we'll go down to 4.0 05 school board members service recognition and School Board clerks report chair of Buffalo we are excited to recognize two of our Schoolboard members tonight who are ending their tenure as of December 31st 20124 Dr Noel Gabriel and
049Mr Carlos Clanton so at this time chairwoman Buffalo and superintendent Dr burdson will you join us at the step and repeat and other board members and then we'll call Mr Clanton and Dr Gabriel forward okay come on you can take your last stroll to the step and repeat but we stay up here yes one at a time I get through okay suck it in all okay we'll call them down separately oh you'll see I'm scared I don't know what y'all doing following directions good evening everyone whoa we are here to uh recognition of service for Dr Gabriel and Mr Clanton so I have two proclamations in uh in front of me and they read Proclamation by the school board of the city of norfol in honor of Dr Noel Gabriel whereas the city of the
050norfol school board and norfol public schools recognized the numerous contributions of the school board member Dr Noel Gabriel over a tenure of 12 Years on the school board and whereas yeah 12 years whereas Dr No Noel Gabriel began her journey as an appointed School board member for a 2-year term 2012 to 2014 and was reappointed for another 2 years 2014 to 2016 and whereas Dr Gabriel represented super War 6 in 2016 and again in 2020 and served in multiple roles board member Vice chair and chair and always with respect and professionalism and whereas Dr Gabriel had the privilege to serve on various committees including the facilities legislative and Hospitality committees and whereas Dr Gabriel's time on the school board included the growth of her family by two more children while managing to maintain a professional
051career as a pediatrician with CHKD and while serving on the board of minus 9-5 and the ODU college of science Advisory Board and whereas the city city of norfol school board gratefully acknowledge her dedicated service to our schools and extend our deepest gratitude to Dr Gabriel along with the greater norfol Public Schools Community now therefore be it resolved on Wednesday December 18th 2024 that the school board of the city of North hereby honors the contributions of Dr Noel Gabriel to the Nora Public Schools and Society as a whole [Music] congratulations please come forward Dr Gabriel to receive your plaque [Applause] [Music] we have this beautiful Proclamation for you you have anything you want to say Dr Gabriel um oh you take everyone come come in family Christmas cactus okay [Laughter] knowing that this was going
052to be my last meeting I wanted to prepare some words and I wanted to make sure that I wrote down uh several things that I wanted to leave uh with and things that I have been reflecting upon for many months now leading up to tonight our priest at Church Father George uh gave a sermon and he had said that there's a difference between pleasure and joy and being satisfied versus fulfilled and I will tell you that this journey here as a school board member for 12 years has brought me incredible joy and much fulfillment I actually started my journey with norford Public Schools as a student at Little Creek Elementary and uh someone found some artwork believe it or not in a hallway at City Hall in a closet that I had done as a
053student and they brought it over to me when I was a board member over here and they look what we found in the closet um and it's hanging up in in our in our house right now um but the journey didn't just stop with myself but it continued on with my mom who ended up going back to school and getting her degree to be a teacher she was one of those folks that got recruited to come back and teach and a math teacher at that um and she served with nor Public Schools until 2012 um when she had passed away so I was like oh man no NPS cannot without a Gabriel I got to get in there so that's when I decided to put my name in the Hat to uh do the appointment
054process because if anybody could speak about how wonderful nor Public Schools is it could be me because norfor Public Schools gave me an incredible education an education that cannot be even valued on the sense of a report card but on skills that I use each and every day and that emergency room with my patient families with my co-workers with my colleagues that you you just can't teach or read out of a book you have to experience it and that's why I am so proud to have all of my children here at norfol public schools and as well as my nieces and nephews I literally have a niece or a nephew or a child in prek 3 all the way to my godson graduated 12th grade last year and I started the board when he was
055in kindergarten and that's how fast it goes that's how fast it goes so much joy much fulfillment I have to give thanks to uh mayor frame and the original council members who were a part of the appointment process they had faith in me um that I could come and serve the board and bring experience and knowledge and uh service to our division and I am very grateful for all of them for that uh those board members included councilman smeel councilman Williams Graves councilman wibbly councilman rck councilman WN and then uh mayor Alexander uh was elected and I cannot thank him enough for being just an incredible mayor someone that um I could pick up the phone and speak with and collaborate with if there was a need that our School Division had um or a
056situation that had Arisen he was a phone call away whatever I needed and just want to say that I didn't really know who our mayor was when I was growing up as a child but all of my kids know mayor Alexander they know their council members they know their school board members they know their superintendent and that is just wonderful for them to be able to have and I I know that our Council right now who I'm incredibly grateful for um the collaboration that we have in their support vice mayor Thomas uh uh councilwoman Courtney Doyle councilwoman M Johnson uh councilwoman Andrew McLaren and again Tommy smeagle and uh councilman Paige very much appreciate the collaborative relationship that we share because we are team Nori we are the biggest budget within the city and people
057want quality excellent schools when they are looking at where they want to live and that's why it is so important for us to work well together um I also want to thank U Mr pishko and Mr cloud and Mr Fox Now is here um to help us since Mr cloud is away um but I understand that he will be back but um our relationship with the city attorneys has been excellent and they've taught me quite a bit uh and I really value all the education that I have Reed received and the assistance from them and I have great respect for what they do and what they do for our students and our staff each and every day I also would like to thank the voters because if they had not voted me in I would
058not be here uh so everyone who voted who supported who hosted events made phone calls I thank you from the bottom of my heart and then to my family I have a great husband could not do this without him uh he stayed um so we meet the first and uh third Wednesday of every month so he is cooking dinner he is taking the kids back and forth to where they need to be and yes I had two other children while on the board Miss Christina here she she um Rodney and I we joke that she learned her ABCs because of all the policies that we had to go through a policy J dbd policy zyx this I said yeah that was Christina um I said she she can't even talk she won't be able to
059say anything and then of course um vasili came along um and my family has been a tremendous support for me they they allow me to help take care of other children and they're very patient and they have sacrificed a lot and now they get Mom back so I'm really happy to have this transition to be with you guys because I have to drive them everywhere my husband and I so like I leave this but then I put the Uber hat on um so I'm very grateful to them and my sisters uh my sister my brother-in-law my brothers and again my dad um could not do this without our village because they were watching them while I was at board meetings while Jeff was at work and so uh in order to do this public service
060which was literally another full-time job if you do it well um they were critical to this success and I really appreciate them because when I was at school visits they were at papo's house getting watched um but transitioning over to the school visits there is um a very important uh quote that is in um Greek culture and it's by Alexander the Great and he says to our parents we owe our life to our teachers we owe the good life and that tells you how elevated educators are and how important they are and the role that they play in our lives and in the lives of our children and I would have to say that um over these 12 years the meetings are great but the school visits are everything that's when you see the rubber
061meet the road that's when you see the things that we do each and every day go into action that's when you see the spark of enthusiasm and you hear the chorus and the band and you see them playing in PE and they tell you about their math facts um and then they tell you what needs to get fixed or they tell you um we want you to come back and do a presentation on such and such or can you bring this up at a school board meeting and so the school visits are probably what I'm going to the most and where I felt like I probably was able to serve the best for the school division um can't leave without um talking about what happened over the weekend um so I'm a comet I graduated
062from graany high school we can live we can live harmoniously all right because my children uh go to Mory and of course car and I what a great year 98 right we we graduated the same year he was at Mory I was at grany it's a good thing he did something different and linoln Douglas and not debate because then oh we would have had real rivalry then but um so uh the my football team as everyone knows won the state football championship second year in a row um the band the cheerleaders the flag ladies um um the dancers the diamond dancers right they're amazing our our division has so much to be proud of and to be there and to be living um that it was just an incredible experience and um it makes me
063so happy and grateful to be part of this NPS family sorry that was more than just a few words um but the school division is in good hands Dr Birdsong okay and I trust you and the course that you are taking us on and I appreciate all of your service to our students and our staff and I have uh great faith in the things that will be for norick public schools and I thank you for your leadership [Applause] Mr Clanton Proclamation by the school board of the city of norfol in honor of Mr Carlos C Clanton whereas the city of nor Norfolk City School Board and norol public schools Community honor Mr Carlos Clanton for his eight-year tender tenure on the school board and whereas Mr Clanton was elected to the city of norfol school
064board in May 2018 representing War 3 and has utilized his platform to promote educational access accountability and Community engagement and whereas his commitment to education is rooted in his strong family background coupled with the guidance of supportive mentors and Educators and future and further strengthened by his experience serving as a norfol public schools administrator and whereas throughout his tenure on the norfol school board Mr Clanton has taken on various leadership roles including chairman Vice chairman co-chairman of the legislative advocacy committee and co-chair of the school facilities and construction committee and whereas Mr Clanton has made significant contributions to Regional and National organizations serving as a chairman of the Virginia governor School for the Arts Regional Board and a member of the cep regional governance board he has been honored with numerous Awards including the prestigious
065Virginia School Board Association vsba School Board member Achievement Award which recognized his exceptional leadership and dedication to public education and whereas the Northfolk City School Board gratefully acknowledge his dedicated career to serving in our schools and the greater norfor Public Schools Community now therefore be it resolved on Wednesday December 18th 2024 that the school board of the city of norfol hereby honors the service and contributions of Mr carer's Clanton to the Norfolk public schools and the society as a whole congratulations Mr than [Music] [Applause] I wasn't like Noel didn't have anything prepared on that one um I knew that this meeting was coming um I guess I'll just say in this respect um there's an old Negro spiritual that says Let The Works that I've done speak for me um and so many of you
066kind of heard some of the things that were there norford public schools has has been and has been a great part of my professional career and my life um I grew up through our schools uh archmont Taylor Blair my on the Governor's School I think it's probably one of the highlights of My Life um to be the first in the history of the school um to be an Alum and then to come back and to serve on the board um and to be able to relate with those students um who had walked those Halls and and then to become chairman of the governor School Board um and um what I've learned here um not just as an admin or School Board member um but from each every one of you all as uh colleagues on
067this board um we don't always agree and I think that we've come a long way um and what has taught me in their respect is to be able to uh disagree but not be disagreeable um to find the things that um we can find connection on um and to work each and every day um to do what's in the best interest um we all have our own lens and eyes um on what we see of our perspective um and I've come to respect each and every one of you may not always agree but I think um I know that I've come to respect each and every one of you um and so I appreciate being able to serve alongside you all and look forward to continue to work with you um in a new capacity
068in this city um to the administrators that are in this room um I know the hard work that you all go through each and every day because I've been on the other side I know the long nights that you have to sit in here and preparing reports and when the board has some new idea or a new report and information that you got to get that done and I always keep keep that in my my mindset and for the teachers that are present in this room whether or not you're a teacher a butt driver um a PA professional um each and every one of you play a critical role in making sure that our students have what they need um in in our school and so I appreciate you all um and so just as
069much as this really nice um yall should have seen uh TI in the background she said y'all can't wait but I just want to say thank you and I look forward to uh continuing to serve the Citi of norick and I appreciate the voters who elected me back in 2018 you know I'll just share this I often have shared it in that respect that um my mother was the one who um encouraged me um my last conversation before my ma mother passed away was just simply this I guess you could say Nike just do it um and she had she told me um to go run um she says you have so much to give to to the people of norfol and so I did it I took that leap of faith and anybody who
070gets out there to run um and put before the public um that's a courageous act in itself and we've all been up here and done that um of the time that that give away from that and so um I appreciate the citizens of norfol um and of ward 3 and and of super Ward 7 um and as we continue to move forward but just know that in a new capacity I will continue to be a champion for public quality public education in our city and I look forward to working with you Dr Birdsong in the members of the school board to build a stronger relationship between the council and this school board and moving forward for all of our citizens and for our youngest our new leaders within our city so with that I say
071thank you all for this great honor and I look forward to continue to serving you thank you did he get a picture of them can we get a picture of [Music] the she need Jeff is bringing it gotta do sides one two three [Applause] chair Buffalo Vice chair Dr Gabriel members of the school board community members and staff as a point of privilege I would like the opportunity to share some brief thoughts following the presentation of resolutions for Dr Noel Gabriel and Mr Carlos Clinton I have had the distinct honor and privilege of working for and most importantly working with Dr Noel Gabriel and Mr Carlos Clanton for several years now first as a member of the division's executive leadership team later as the Acting Superintendent of Schools and finally as the division superintendent beginning
072February 19th 20220 just a couple of weeks before the pandemic I absolutely Marvel at their individual contributions and their Collective commitment to the thousands of children who walk through the doors of nor norit public schools on a daily basis Dr Gabriel is retiring from the school board after 12 years of service service she was initially appointed by the Nori city council to serve in 2012 as we just heard and sub subsequently she was elected by a grateful and I mean grateful public who recognized her extraordinary leadership qualities yes Dr Gabriel has many fine qualities that made her a stellar board member she is quite intelligent and she is incisive and eager to collaborate for the greater good yet when I think of her I believe her most outstanding quality is perseverance the good book has
073this to say about the persevering spirit and let us not grow weary of doing good for in due season we will reap we will reap if we do not give up thank you for not ever giving up that statement so vividly portrays what Dr Gabriel is all about no matter how tough the Myriad challenges we faced Dr Gabriel never succumbed to resignation instead she consistently and I do mean consistently took responsibility for helping to devise Solutions I thank you Dr Gabriel [Applause] when I think of Carlos Clinton's six years of service on the school board I am thankful for his thoughtful probing nature and his drive to take action and as we say in norford public schools no matter what a well-known civil rights activist and brother of alpha F Alpha Fraternity Incorporated WB Deo
074once said now is the accepted time not tomorrow not some convenient season it is today it's today that our best work can be done and not some future day or future Year Mr Clinton's commitment to taking firm steps toward achieving strategic highlevel goals rather than getting lost in the details and not rushing to judgment that was a breath of fresh air to a sometimes extremely weary Administration thankfully he will continue to be an advocate for public education specifically for nor Public Schools right and his new role as a member of the Nori city council again congratulations on your new role Mr Clinton as we are now well poised to say a heartfelt goodbye to these excellent public servants let's not forget the evidence of those persevering and thoughtful qualities they helped lead the School Division
075through a devastating pandemic ensured that salaries and benefits for employees were solid and competitive in nature strongly advocated for funding to support improvements for the division's Aging infrastructure and most importantly they stood up for Equity so it wasn't just a byword but a Hallmark of this school division from increased social tional programs for our children to more outreaches for our English Learners and our students with disabilities to improved gifted Education Services truly Dr Noel Gabriel and Mr Carlos Clinton have made profound contributions that have served all students admirably and for that I will forever be grateful so thank you for allowing allowing me this time to express my appreciation we will miss you both and thank you for your [Applause] service and so noted um Mr Jordan will be leaving us as well and don't
076don't send me no emails don't come for me Mr Jordan will be recognized at our January business meeting all right we're going to move on to 4.06 superintendent report evening again chair Buffalo Dr Dr Martin I said that I'm so sorry so sorry Dr Gabriel I need to say that one more time let me get it right Vice chair Dr Gabriel members of our community and staff um prior to showing um the showing of my video report we have a special presentation this evening honoring Booker T Washington high school here to present this honor this evening is Dr Myra Sawyers who serves as the Virginia state director for cognia Dr sawers has been an educator in Virginia for over 30 years in her role as director she serves over 400 private and public schools throughout
077the state cogia cognia has been accrediting schools in Virginia for 130 years they are globally recognized a globally recognized nonprofit organization leading and serving schools and accreditation and meeting the highest standards in education they serve over 40,000 schools and divisions in 90 countries focusing on improving education opportunities for all students so at this time I would like to welcome Dr Sawyers to the podium please thank you Dr B oops good evening members of the school board honored guests and the norfol community I am Dr Myra sawers state director of cognia it is an honor and a pleasure to be here with you this evening to recognize Booker T Washington High School in achieving 100 Years of accreditation with cognia we applaud and celebrate your years of commitment to your students to your community and to
078uh continuous Improvement accreditation from cognia is a valuable Mark of Distinction recognized around the world fewer than 30 schools have received this distinction Booker T Washington is a historically significant School in Virginia this recognition honors your great history and your namesake in continuing to demonstrate an unwavering commitment to meeting the highest standards in education and striving to help all students reach their fullest potential expectations standards and practices have certainly changed in the last 100 years but what hasn't changed is the dedication of your community to Educators to meet the many challenges along the way we commend your leadership faculty staff and Educators who share in this commitment in this achievement you have cognia best interests and best wishes for the continued Vitality of your institution and for many more years of dedicated and meaningful ful
079service to students and families celebrate this accomplishment far and wide it is truly something to be very proud of our cognia team is deeply honored to have been part of your improvement journey and will continue to work together for future success so all students of norfol public schools will Thrive so on behalf of cogni now please accept the banner and the frame certificate commemorating this achievement Dr Sawyers at the podium is principal Deon Garner to Washington High School [Applause] a and thank you very much and now for excited we have so many things to share with you um this evening in our video and um I think it was Dr Gabriel who stole stole a little bit of our Thunder about the mo High School win second year in a row state championships had a
080wonderful time I believe it was probably 25° outside but we didn't feel it at all we were too busy clapping and cheering the team on so let's roll the [Music] video NK sister city Association brought the culture of timana to sixth graders at the academ of international studies at Rosemont today we came to enrich enhance and and help the children expand their knowledge of uh cultural Ghana I think it's always great for children to learn about different cultures it's important that they do understand and appreciate other cultures and other people so that they can be better citizens for this United States I am here in a teaching capacity in sharing jimbe life with the students here at Rosemont I think it's nice you get your swap cultures and if you can't get out of the
081country you can somebody can come in the country and share some ideas with you it's cool to see how other cultures dance and how is their tradition and stuff it was all just really gripping and new for me and I really liked it I think the food it was really really good in the culture and the artifacts too those were pretty cool it's really amazing cuz uh not all middle schools can do this it makes me feel good that uh all of us are learning about new cultures and all of that [Music] [Applause] [Music] this is the culminating presentation of our um project called rhyme reading in music education this first series is based on the story of Pinocchio uh the Rights and Wrongs that we do in society and how we overcome our mistakes
082each third grade student was given a book published by the Tidewater winds in their classrooms students read and completed writing activities about the story which complemented what they saw on stage so literacy is our Rock and norfor public school so any opportunity that we can have to enhance that experience for them and um allow all of our students to see themselves as readers I think this really brought that a lot for them it's not just for the art it's not it's for the message and it's for the reading the reading comprehension to instill a love of reading in our students The NPS schoolto School attendance challenge is in full swing across the division schools are bringing creativity and enthusiasm to the Forefront as they compete to highlight the importance of being present on time and
083ready to learn each day this friendly competition underscores a vital message when students miss school they miss out chronic absenteeism missing 10% or more of school days for any reason has a significant impact on learning we're proud to share that your efforts are making a difference norick public schools has seen a steady decline in chronic absenteeism dropping from 24.3% in 2122 to 16.8% in 2324 this progress is a testament to the commitment of our families Educators and Community each month as part of the schoolto school attendance Challenge and PS recognizes the schools that are leading the way in combating chronic absenteeism congratulations to the following schools for having the best attendance and for earning the most improved attendance for the months of August through November keep up the great work congrats to the gramy High
084boys volleyball team for a successful and historic season the comment set a record for most wins in a season as they made it all the way to the state semi finals for the first time we have a great group of guys um Karen guys athletic willing to play their hardest um whenever they can they just never give up I think they just like to give me a headache and scare me a little bit um but they always have that uh you know never quit uh mentality this team also took home top individual honors as Michelle nees was named Regional coach of the year and AJ Angeles was named Regional player of the year for a second time in conjunction with college football's national Signing Day six football players from Mory High announced and signed where
085they will continue their academic and athletic careers School Personnel family friends and teammates were on hand to see the culmination of years of hard work it's a blessing you know most of us play little leag together so like it's really a blessing for us most of us to be signing today this is what the bigger cause is um you know putting these guys in this position or helping them get in this position these guys do their job in the in uh in the classroom academically then they come out there and put on a performance on the football field so you put the two together and you have good character this is kind this is what happens with that so I love it another round of Rockstar Awards went out administrators visited schools throughout the division
086to present outstanding teachers with Rockstar Awards this award recognizes exceptional teachers for excellent attention or reaching at least 95% student participation on their star literacy assessments both teachers and their students were surprised and grateful for the recognition it felt so amazing I was caught by such a surprise um it was super exciting it definitely made my morning so proud that all of our hard work did not go unnoticed um they've worked really really hard and I'm just so glad that it shows through their scores and results I'm kind of shocked right now CU I don't don't pay attention to that kind of stuffff so I'm really shocked so proud of them we work hard every day and so I'm so glad that they are achieving Royster Presbyterian Church welcomes students with exceptional needs from Lake
087Taylor High School to their kitchen to teach them how to prepare a Thanksgiving dinner volunteers from the church assisted students with everything from preparing the food to cleaning up afterwards this was the culminating activity for a 5we course and these delighted students receive certificates while waiting for their meal to cook so this is for our self-contained students and it's helping to develop their Independent Living skills and their employment skills at the same time because they're not only cooking for themselves today but they're also cooking for another group that will get this meal later on this afternoon it is important for the young people to learn to cook um food is a real problem in our community and in others and learning how to cook is and enables people to learn how to provide for themselves
088in a way that is cheaper than the pre-made stuff at the grocery store it also teaches them how much fun it is they excited and what I like about it they have a teachable spirit if they don't understand they asked and they'll tell you what they like the best and this is what it's all about seeing The Human Side of us cuz I I like it I like it it's great it made me feel good makes me feel healthy and strong you know I like cooking with all my classmates and stuff I just like it and I think it's fantastic and I love my classmates they love me and I like doing all current certain stuff and I'm enjoying it with the upcoming General Assembly session quickly approaching NK Public Schools invited legislators principles and
089the community to learn about their priorities during their annual take your legislature to school day it's a wonderful opportunity that must must continue and have that opportunity repeated just as often as we possibly can it's always good to come before our school board members and our legislative um leaders and know that norick is a priority for them and that they're willing to fight for what students and our staff need so um to be reaffirmed that our priorities are their priorities that's what I learned and that's what I appreciate it following the meeting about legislative goals the delegates had the opportunity to visit schools and see up close what the day-to-day operation looks like I think it was important to participate today uh because you see firsthand what's going on in our schools U you know
090seeing their teachers and what they're dealing with and um all the issues and really not only issues but successes they have here uh so it was great to see and have a firsthand uh and person an experience here at Lenwood Elementary School delegate Bonita Anthony not only got to visit my high school staff and students to learn more about their needs but she also had the honor of presenting three resolutions to the football team and the Career and Technical education program it was just a joy to be able to present the commending resolutions um here at my high school I mean it's great it's always good that they connect with folks that are making decisions just help to reiterate what are the needs um and to really drill down what are the issues within school
091[Music] districts congratulations to Norview grad Jordan Lee on being elected as vice president of the freshman class at Morehouse College [Music] backto back that's what the myy commodor did as they won their second consecutive State title with a 46 to nothing victory over Brier Woods on the campus of James Madison University spurred on by great traveling crowd support and the high energy cheerleading squad the commodor jumped out to a 14 nothing lead and never looked back they finished the season undefeated at 15 and0 just thinking about my seniors who stuck it out stay here um went through the battles went through the went through the hard times um and we're not the program where y are without the senior class man if guys sticking it out they're just dealing with what it takes to do
092this year in and year out so I'm proud of him um I'm happy for him man like I just keep thinking about them man I'm happy for our kids man I'm happy for our coaches January 1st B to B no sale January toell no sell hello I'm Dr Mike Calo from the office of student support safety and information in accordance with Governor Yan's executive order 33 norford Public Schools is developing a new self policy that will prohibit the use of personal electronic devices from Bell to Bell which prohibits usage during the instructional day this means no cell phones personal electronic devices will be permitted during the school day including lunch or between classes students will be expected to power off their devices and place them in their bag or backpack before entering School devices cannot
093be in students Pockets purses hands or on their desks a personal electronic device is considered any personal device capable of making calls transmitting pictures or video and sending messages through electronic means we appreciate your support as we make this important change to enhance student learning January Bell to Bell no sale put your cell phone and personal electronic devices away until the end of the school Day January 1st build a build no seal be ready [Music] for complete video stories and more division-wide information about NK Public Schools visit The NPS website and check out our YouTube channel Facebook page Instagram app and The NPS newsletter with Dr catalo that he cannot even think about another career try that concludes my video report thank you so much oh thank you for that we're going to move on
094to 4.07 Citizen comments Miss Tanner Madam chairin for today's citizens comments we have six speakers today's speakers signed up for public comments before the start of today's business meeting if you would like to provide public comments you are required to State the agenda items or topic you are addressing prior to providing your public comments at this meeting when your name is called please come forward to the speaker's Podium state your name and whether you have a child in norford public schools or if you are employed by the district and state your agenda items or item one person is to speak at a time if you're are representing a group State the group's name you may ask your group me members to stand in place to be recognized speaking time is limited to 3 minutes a
095timer is set with an alarm that will signify the end of your speaking time State your position relevant facts and other data avoid saying anything that identifies students or personel information about individual employees Personnel disciplinary and confidential matters may be addressed directly to the school board via email at Schoolboard npsk12.com comments should be addressed to the board and not addressed to an individual member Schoolboard members do not respond to public comments at the time they are given and any written statements or supporting materials should be given to the clerk chairwoman Buffalo our first speaker for day is Charlotte Smith warley followed by Liz Alpert welcome thank you chair Buffalo Vice chair Gabriel school board members and Dr Birdsong my name is Charlotte Smith Worley I do not have children in Nori schools I am here
096tonight for a different reason than I have been in the past I want to say a heartfelt thank you to two individuals who undoubtedly have been the board's finest example for astute unselfish public service Dr Noel Gabriel and Carlos Clanton Dr Gabriel's responsiveness will be missed she has an Earnest desire to connect with the stakeholders she serves I have watched countless school board meetings over the year and I was always impressed how she could take a complex subject and boil it down to its real meaning I counted on her to for cutting through the verbal clutter to hone in on what was best for our children on more than one occasion I sat at home at watching a board meeting and found myself sighing in relief when she spoke such common sense I would smile
097shake my head and say something like thank God for Noel Gabriel she has good sense a big heart and the right motivation as for Mr Clinton I was likewise impressed with his incisiveness I could count on on count on him to ask the right question often the very question I was probably shouting at the TV he came across as reflective but not indecisive while he could be very congenial he was never a pushover I admired how quick he was to stand up for what he perceived as the route most likely to ensure equality for students and staff I am thankful he is not leaving public service because we need his grit President Hoover once said being a politician is a poor profession being a public servant is a noble one so thank you Dr Gabriel
098and Mr Clinton for choosing to be true public servants I appreciate how they both put all the children of NPS first never pushing their personal agendas to divide the board and never failed to do what was best for our children you have set excellent examples for new school school board members who will follow you my prayer is that they will take those examples to heart thank you thank you for your [Music] [Applause] comments welcome oh thank you thank you chairman Buffalo School born members in Dr bird song my name is Liz Albert I do not have children in Public Schools however I am a longtime advocate for this City's increased investment in public education I come to you tonight with a grateful frame of mind I am thankful for the contributions of two departing school
099board members Dr Noel Gabriel and Mr Carlos Clanton who over their years of service have remained powerful voices for the needs of children I Marvel at Dr Gabriel's commitment to children as a pediatri pediatrician in a busy emergency room she deals regularly with trauma and pressing need as a mother of four school children she must be their guide and example yet no matter how busy her professional and personal life may have been she always came to a board meeting well prepared intent on shaving just the right response to the issues of the day she is a picture of Grace Under Pressure for there were times over her 12 years of service that she became a target for the people who were supposed to be working with her for the benefit of children yet I do
100not recall one time where she showed public bitterness or spite she refused to play politics instead she pushed on and kept working for the best outcomes for students and stakeholders also I salute Mr Clanton for his intelligent analysis of any issue the school board was studying at the time he is an articulate Advocate who was able to spell out the challenges and impacts of any changes in a thoughtful manner while watching Schoolboard meetings I always listen carefully when he talked because he did not talk for talking sake alone his comments were always significant and thought-provoking as a resident of superward 7 I am thankful he will be serving on city council Dr Gabriel and Mr Clanton thank you for your service in my view you are absolutely the best best part of the Norfolk school
101board if the new members coming aboard our astute they will capitalize on your Collective Legacy I pray that will be the case thank you thank you for your comments next we have Calvin Williams followed by Amanda keading welcome welcome good afternoon good afternoon North Schoolboard members and everyone in attendance today my name is Calvin Williams I'm a little allergist is messing with me right now but Mr Calvin mic's to you you won't have to lean over so much yeah I like for y'all to imagine for a moment what it's like to be a child standing at a bus stop i'msure if today would be the the day that you encounter violence bullying or Worse picture the fear of a parent heart they send their children off the School hoping they make it home they make
102it back safely and the real it's just the reality far too much inside Norful families these days um mat 2K Foundation we couldn't stand by and let fear dictate the lives of our children that's why for the last past three school years we have we have stood at the bus stops at those schools Crossings in front of your schools not just as protectors but as mentors mediators and advocates for peace we deescalate conflicts before they turned into violence we stepped in fights stepped in front of fights and stopp fights and prevented bullying deterred those who had harm intended harm such as know we understand that it been we started because there a lot of shooting at the bus stops and basically we've been working on it I can safely say that haven't been in shooting
103at the bus stops since we've been involved uh this isn't just work for us it's a calling a calling that we have saved our lives and to saved lives it's a calling that has given hundreds of children the chance to feel safe in spaces that that where safe shouldn't have been a question by but the the reality is the challenges that are growing the threats are escalating from children trafficking to shootings from bullying to traffic accidents of school Crossings the risk of lot of real things happen inside the community and we have took on of challenges every every single day rain sleep or snow you can find us inside the community making sure that them children are safe getting off them buses and through through the byways and highways we make sure they navigate safely
104home to the to the respective houses we're not just a complemental to the school system we are filling in gaps that cannot afford to be remain empty today I'm here to ask for you the school board the school system to pick up the fight with us my 2k Foundation cannot do this alone it's to truly to protect our children and ensure their safety we need the North School Board to stand up as official partners with us we need y support to be withing in the Fabrics of this community to expand our work and to create a legacy of safety for generations to come by incorporating my 2k found cin your time has expired and if you have it in writing feel free to email that to us we appreciate it have a blessed day thank
105you'all Amanda [Applause] key uh bonjour U my name is Amanda keing I am a high school French teacher in norick public schools and teach Lo locally as an Adjunct professor despite the varying views and opinions on education as a first generation college student I was grateful to have a steady income and happily worked for varying school districts over the last eight almost 9 years this is my sixth year working for the district this Academic School Year my rose-colored glasses were lifted when I asked for help regarding a matter of safety within my school I've been told that people often get involved with an issue when it affects them personally and sadly once my livelihood and reputation were threatened I took off my figurative glasses of ignorance requested accountability and support only to then realize that
106I had stepped into a political world of Chess I was not prepared for tonight the debate is over Governor Yan's executive order 33 cell phone free education policy that will go into effect early 2025 last night Channel 3's Leandra headed shared different community members opinions however it was interesting to me that no teachers opinions were shared then I remembered why many staff members are silent fear of retaliation The NPS policy about speaking to the media and an overall plague of neutrality and apathy affecting Educators Nationwide as an educator I agree with the belief that cell phones are a distraction they however are also a tool students you will be okay without your phones I promise however I do hope that exceptions for cell phone use will be made at times neurological brain breaks for one
107or translation devices for English language Learners to the parents who are worried about their children's safety when was the last time you were inside the school schools should be safe places for teaching and learning but it takes a community effort and often when the cat is away the mice will play to all community members please volunteer in the schools please show up students can exaggerate but there's often some truth to what they say is happening in their school do not leave them in unsafe places and then later be outraged when something goes wrong teachers are not babysitters we are Educators and it takes a village to raise a child a respected recently retired teacher from NPS said to me recently admin and general takes sides with the students and leaves teachers to give up and
108then they wonder why teachers are leaving when I first moved here in the early 80s NPS was unrivaled Virginia Beach was almost as good Chesapeake was struggling to all our tax money is being used this very minute let's be better stewards over our money and hold NPS accountable for providing a safe environment for teaching and learning however community members need to be equal participants in the school and when something goes wrong we should stop pointing the finger of blame when we are ourselves could have done more in the first place to end join us in pushing for policies that protect faculty members rights and ensure School leaders are accountable so our schools are safe respectable places for both students and staff like what happened in Newport News a teacher shouldn't have to sue their school
109district to be protected and Inspire policy change there's a mass Exodus of teachers and school Personnel bring them back thank you you're welcome thank you for your comments next we have Lisa Walker followed by Nathan Whit Whitlow welcome good evening welc thank you thank you good evening to the board Dr Bird Song and all in attendance my name is Lisa Walker and I'm the reading specialist at Southside STEM Academy at campus Stella as we close out 2024 I want to share with the board that your words really do matter do you really understand that this school year has brought us new standards in English we have written thousands of student reading plans we adopted a new K2 curriculum a handwriting curriculum has been implemented we have created intervention schedules that require a level of planning
110close to sending a rocket to Mars additionally we must progress monitor the implementation of each the central administrative team has kept me grounded and supported I just want you to realize that helping your St staff is urgent and that is what matters then a declaration was made that the kids just can't read 32% of fourth graders and 31% of eighth graders were proficient readers that's a very small number The NPS literacy plan addresses this emergency with conciseness Clarity of thought and the action steps to match Additionally you have a quarterly data discussion with color grass for board goals 2 3 and four your word speak speak volumes I listen to understand the non-negotiables and goals and I want you to consider a couple of things as we move into the New Year all goals should
111be reworked to align with the Virginia school performance and support framework additionally without highly qualified teachers the goals and non-negotiables are unsustainable and most likely unreachable and they directly impact non-negotiables 1 through three for our superintendent I'm very proud of the work that is happening in NPS I deem it a privilege to serve I just want us to remember that we need each other to accomplish the mission of being the Cornerstone of a proudly diverse Community with highly qualified teachers and staff dedicated to providing a variety of teaching and learning opportunities for all of our students I wish each of you a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year thank you for your comments Nathan Whit welcome thank you uh good evening uh chair Miss Buffalo Vice chair Dr Noel uh Gabriel and uh school
112board members and uh Dr BD song and other attendees I am Dr Nathan Whit low I am the chair of your special education advisory committee I'm here at the direction of the committee uh to share some of our concerns about uh priorities for students with disabilities as we uh approach next fiscal year and start consider during uh budgeting process um to that end um we'd like to commend Dr Walter and the the special education and learning support staff uh for the excellent work they do um they're always doing a great job and supporting our students with disabilities and we really appreciate all of their work however we know that one of the challenges that is faced is the teacher and Staffing shortages that continue to be a problem uh and that we think is a
113significant and immediate concern for our students with disability to that end uh we recommend as you approach these conversations that you consider uh improved compensation uh for uh teachers and staff who work with students with disabilities to include salary stiens access to tuition assistance and reimbursement for exam uh licensing things like that um also we ask that you consider dedicated funding allocations specifically towards faculty development um for our teachers and staff who support students with disabilities um and we uh ask that you consider investment in programs to assess the uh work climate and retention um concerns that may exist uh within our schools so that we can try to maintain the Educators that we have um we you know have students out there that may have disruption in the education that they're receiving if they
114have staff or teachers leaving in the middle of school year and they're dealing with temporary staff for half the school year and then their parents are sitting there at an IEP meeting talking about how they're failing to meet curriculum or failing to meet IEP goals and you have they have to be sitting there thinking you know has the school system failed my student because they they can't um uh provide the resources that they need so we just ask you to consider that as you move forward uh and uh we invite you to continue collaborating with us our next uh C meeting will be at Grand B high school on Thursday uh February 6th um so we'd be happy to see anybody from the school board uh there in attendance to join us in our discussions
115thank you very much thank you for your comments chairwoman Buffalo this concludes our speakers for this evening thank you Miss Tanner we're going to move on to 4.08 approval of the consent agenda and remember um the cell phone policy and minutes have been removed may have a motion to approve the consent agenda Madam chair I move that we approve the consent agenda may I have a second second any discussion hearing none Miss Tanner please call the rolline I Clanton I Gabriel I Jordan I Martin I pson I and buffalo I we're going to move on to 6.01 monthly financial report Dr burong good evening again chair Buffalo Vice chair Dr G members of the board staff and Community sh Spivey our CFO will present our monthly financial report hi good evening tonight we'll um be
116reviewing our November monthly financial report and Miss Tanner if you can um get it where the primarily the numbers show that would would be great so um this is financial highlights page the November report covers five months for the fiscal year that started July 1 2024 the report reflects transactions that were recorded oner before December 5th as shown on the um financial highlights page general fund collections for the first M five months totaled 187,000 7 87.1 million or 40.1% of the general fund budget collections during the same period in the two previous years ranged between 35.9 and 36.6% um as with prior years collections are based on cash collected during the period as shown on the next to the last line uh by the end of November we spent or encumbered 17.1 million or 36.4%
117of the budget during the two previous year spending through November ranged between 32.4% and 35.7% um as shown on the bottom line of the statement actual Revenue collections at this point in the year are $17.2 million greater than expenditures and incumbrances note that incumbrances are obligated but are not yet payable um there are other um pages in the report that are available for more specific and drilled down information and um chair Buffalo that is the um end of my report and I'll accept any um questions thank you Miss by the school board members you've heard the report does anyone have any questions well thank you Miss spy well well I'm sorry Miss Bine sorry I was getting to my page um sorry um thank you Miss spy um I had um so the last couple
118I just wanted to know if you had an update on the um estimates for the revenue sharing formula and if you could also remind us again what the um the amount of the reversion funds are for uh Sy school year 24 um we do not yet have an estimate um for the um for either one um either the um school funding formula results which we um expect to receive from this city shortly okay right okay thank you thank you Miss Bine anyone else Mr Jordan just just one point of clarification on the the chart with the revenues over expenditures yes that includes the where you have the reversion from fiscal year 2023 as part of those part of those revenues correct yes okay all right thank you anyone else thank you Miss VY have that
119we approve the financial report subject to audit that okay thank you Dr Gabriel May I have a second second goe Dr Gabriel motion Mr Clanton second any discussion hearing none Miss Tanner please call the role the I Clanton I Gabriel I Jordan I Martin I pson I and buffalo I we're going to move on to 6.02 School Board legislative priorities board members you were um you receive a presentation at the work session um I'm going to ask for a motion if on the floor to approve this Madam chair I move that we adopt the school board legislative priorities for 2025 thank you Mr Clinton may I have a second second thank you Dr Martin any discussion uh Madam chair just one U there's some uh minor uh typos in here and I just think we
120need to make sure they get cleared up before we publish them and take them to to Richmond noted Mr Jordan thank you for that any other discussion hearing now miss Tanner please call the role Bine hi Clanton I Gabriel I Jordan I Martin I hson I Buffalo I we're going to move on to 6.03 uh policy J xxz personal electronic communication device cell phone policy um board members you have the policy in your packet may I have a motion to approve this policy I move to approve policy J xxz personal electronic communication device cell phone policy Mr Clanton second any discussion Madam chair yes um though I am seconding this um motion and I believe that we we've got to move forward with it um in conversation with the community and from community members um
121myself and there's no y'all have seen hear me every once in a while when I beep when my blood sugar is too high or too low um but my blood sugar monitor is connected to my phone and so one of the concerns that I have in that that we'll continue to look at is for medical devices I know that many of our students may be in situations where they need their it's connected to their phone that device um and so uh even though we're adopting this here I hope that we'll look at that um and some type of Regulation around medical devices that might be needed at the particular point where can still be in their backpack but be able to be on so that they can receive um you know needed medical attention point
122taken Mr Clanton any other discussion Miss Bine um thank you um while I understand that this uh policy while we've had a cell phone policy in place and this policy has been revised to reflect um executive order 33 um I do want to share that at this time um while I completely recognize and understand and support the impact that uh social media the negative impact that social media can have on a student's mental health I also know um that our cell phones and devices are also tools Educational Tools for our students and one of the things that I have um heard a lot from students is that how they use their phones in our school building for educational purposes um and I think that that is something that we really need to um consider and
123Shore up in our school buildings to make sure that that they still have access to techn technology um because we are it is 2024 technology isn't going away and I think digital L literacy is important I think um we have e textbooks we have um today I even heard a concern about how music is also shared that they have they're learning music using their iPads um and don't have actual physical uh music so I think there's lots to be considered before we put this uh policy in place so at this time I'm not ready to support a full cell phone bell-to-bell cell phone ban um so that's where I stand note taken thank you for your comments m M chair yes Mr Jordan uh so first I just like to thank the administration for uh
124uh hearing hearing the concerns at the work session and updating the regulations uh moving the the staggers into the regulations and also identifying the consequences of uh policy violations I appreciate the the warning system uh that exists the notification of the potential for confiscation of device um nothing in those first four offences dealing with uh suspensions or expulsions or any of the any of the type of pun punitive measures that could result in um loss instructional time um I do think it's important that as we continue to share this that those uh uh policy violation consequences are not only communicated um but adhere to uh to the greatest extent it as possible uh equally across every school so that we don't have situations where uh some schools are unforced it one way or other schools
125are enforcing it uh another way I um saw my uh younger daughter a couple weeks ago and um I remember when she was in the the IB program that uh um getting called down to the to the office one day because of something she had done and the response that I got back from the folks I were talking to at the school was well their IB kids they deserve a break and uh uh I had to say back to the person it didn't matter if my child was an IB kid or not I feel like they should be held to the same standards as all other students and so I want to make sure that when we are implementing this that we are implementing it fairly and equally and then also would just like to
126re-echo the concerns that I think all the all my colleagues have brought up during the work session that Miss Bine just reemphasized having having that technology infrastructure and making sure that the students have the devices that they need is um extremely important I imagine there may be some hiccups uh you know come come January but just like to encourage the uh the upcoming board and for the superintendent Administration to do whatever is necessary to prioritize to make sure that our students are not missing instructional time due to lack of devices or lack of bandwidth or any other technology uh impediment so I just wanted to again acknowledge and thank you for uh what you propagated in propagated in the regulations and for uh uh identifying a series of consequences so that not only that the
127students know and the parents know but also the teachers and administrators know that there is an effort to make sure that there are um processes to hold everyone accountable for the for the policy as is being implemented at this time so thank you thank you for your comments Mr Jordan hearing no more discussion Miss Tanner please call the role Bine nay planton I Gabriel I Jordan I Martin I Paulson I Buffalo I we're moved down to 6.04 approval of minutes from November 6 and November 13 may I have a motion to approve Madam chair I move that we approve the minutes thank you Mr Clanton may I have a second second thank you Dr Gabriel any discussion hearing none Miss Tanner please call the role the I Clanton I Gabriel I Jordan hi Martin I
128pson I abstain and buff I was not pres okay and buffalo I well school board members we are at the end of our agenda but before we leave I would like to um give this our student representative a moment to share any comments she would like to share this evening I think the cell phone policy is very controversial for students this year it came in a little bit unannounced um and some students are coming up to me and saying why do we have cell phone policy this year and actually implementation is very difficult um for teachers and staff members at high schools elementaries and middle schools I think we need to examine how implementation is followed through because as mentioned often rules are said but not followed throughout um there also needs to be an
129emphasis on actually providing technology throughout um the district if we are taking away cell phones then we need to provide computers throughout the classroom so that students are able to actually use devices throughout because often there's trouble with actually having workable devices to supply all students in the classrooms thank you Miss Bryce It's always important to get our students perspective we appreciate your voice on this board thank you so with no other business I have to say Dr Gabriel Mr Clanton it's been real appreciate serving with you all and like you said before we we all have come from different lens different perspectives but all in all we want to do what best for our students and staff so with no other business this meeting is adjourned