001good afternoon welcome to the work school board work session for Wednesday December 4th thank you everyone who is here in person and viewing online Miss Tanner would you please call the role Bine here Clanton present Gabriel present Jordan here Martin present bson present Buffalo present and as uh before we even go any further I'd like to welcome Mr Ken Paulson here he has joined us for his first school board meeting with us so everyone say welcome thank you very much uh I'd like to thank everybody that's here for coming and being involved and particularly the school board members uh the staff Dr Birdsong I may forget everybody but not knowing everybody and then we also have two other distinguished electees who will join us in January welcome to both of them so thank you very
002much all right thank you sry to take so much time oh just want you to know again thank you so we're going to move on because we do have a very um lengthy agenda we're going to move on to 2.01 School Board legislative priorities Dr bsaw yes good evening Madam chair bu Buffalo Dr Gabriel Vice chair members of the board staff um community members here in viewing um our first agenda item includes an update from our legislative liaison Kathy berter and she's here today to provide an update and to help us work through legislative priorities for this school year so without further Ado good afternoon um good afternoon Dr bong chair H members of the board good to see you welcome um to the newest member of the board I'm Kathy burcher advaned strategies um
003I am the consultant that uh works with Nori public schools to advance the legislative priorities of the school division but also helps you work through what those priorities are and what the um top priority should be for the school division this is a process we've gone through with me now this is my third session I can't even believe at working with you um but with advantas for years before that with Ron Jordan as well um Lauren Gilbert who also works on our team actually had to be in another part of the Commonwealth today um so apologize that she can't be here a couple of things about this upcoming session um just to kind of level sad it is a short session 45 days um the general assembly and the Commonwealth of Virginia operate on a
004two-year budget so we are in fiscal year 25 the budget that was adopted last session covers fiscal year 25 and 26 um and so what we will be doing is amending that banial budget and so when the governor comes before the money committee um December 18th to present his amendments to the budget that's the first step towards that process um important other things to keep in mind too um a short session 45 days amending the budget at the end of this session um in the upcoming election and I that's important and you all know this from having elections here um the house of delegates and the house of delegates all 100 members will be up for election and so we know we anticipate um some action related to ensuring that they are advancing those priorities
005um and also we'll have statewide election so Governor lieutenant governor and attorney general in November so we anticipate um a whole lot of posturing as well during session as we always see in advance of an election year um so all that being said we're going to try to negotiate a budget and prepare for elections um in a short session um and so a couple of things I did I I have sent along and I know you have access to um a rewrite kind of a redraft of your legislative program again with in my my third session of working with you all in advant in our long time working with you we really started to think about what makes the most sense when it comes to ensuring that we are telling the story of nori Public
006Schools you have a unique story here an important story um and you have unique requests from the general assembly to match the student populations you're trying to move um forward to grit to student outcomes and so really how do we look at that a little bit differently and there's some things we took into account as we started to think through maybe we need to present the document differently and I know that seems odd to say we're going to change the look of the paper but what the paper does and you all know this is it presents um who you are and what you care about and that's the important component here I me so when we looked at it it was really again the unique needs the highlighting the good work oftentimes we fail to
007do that I mean it actually goes to the fourth bullet which is about removing deficit language sometimes we have failed and not just norfol Public Schools a lot of times local governments and school divisions fail to talk about their good work or the goals they're setting and then in talking about that and the needs we have to achieve those goals and oftentimes we leave out the good work and we talk about the deficits we have um and so trying to remove that language aligning to your strategic plan so your documents documents talk to each other was important um the resources you need the authority you need and the other thing that was important is ensuring that you all have a document that you can amend year-to-year and not fully rewrite year toe I think that
008that's important as well and hopefully will be a document that is easier for you all to really put your input in um and decide like you know that item that needs a little bit more that needs to be elevated to a priority versus trying to rewrite the document each year and so again um when we think about NPS and and the work I've done here I won't read through all of these but there are been themes that we have seen consistently um as we've looked at your legislative program and as we've gone through session the items that you all have really cared the most about um when it comes to supporting your students your staff your families and your communities they're all captured here here I hope um C obviously very broad categories here but
009these were some of the themes that really Rose to the top in all of our conversations over the years and also the work we know is going on at the general assembly and I'm going to talk about that one in just a second and actually I was just having a conversation about um maintenance of buildings so um and obviously when we talk about the unique story of of um Nori Public Schools the infrastructure here is part of that unique story and so when we looked at putting together this rewrite we really looked at the previous program what were our successes what were our challenges with it an analysis of the Strategic plan so that we could align those stories and then um I really took a look at other school divisions to see how are
010they managing their priorities and their positions in a way that allows their School Division to amend the document and then Elevate the priorities every year um and then also um anticipating what we will see this upcoming session and I'm hopeful um that there's some agreement that we got there in our planning um and part of the unique story and this is directly from your strategic plan and it to me it just Reign to who you are what you stand for and what what supports and Authority you need to continue the good work here and again if we're removing deficit language that's how we want to talk about um you know again the Cornerstone of a proudly diverse Community with highly qualified teachers and staff dedicated to providing a variety of teaching and learning opportunities that
011takes a significant amount of resources and supports and that's the important and unique story of NPS that we tried to capture a really big piece of this and a recommendation as a top priority for you all in this session is the um continuing work that is going on around K12 funding and the findings of the jart K12 um funding report and I always make sure every member of the general assembly knows and every School Division that I know and that I work with knows um does anyone remember where this study originated yes yes Public Schools um you all had legislative priority in 2020 to to conduct this study um it was drafted out of work you all did it was patroned by Senator Monty Mason part of your delegation it Advanced through the general assembly
012and frankly after years and years of the General Assembly not wanting to study it be careful what you study because you're going to get an answer um and they got the answer we knew they would get right um and so I always remind folks that thank you Nori public schools for ensuring that the study moved forward um they have formed a joint committee that has been working the inter members of the education committees in the House and Senate and money committees looking at some of the components of the recommendations um it is a very heavy fiscal lift um there are no surprises in this room how far the state recognizes they are underfunding K12 that came as no surprise I would assume to anyone in this room so as we look to this session some
013important pieces of what we know will come from the funding side we have been hearing about a surplus I'm going to do air quote Surplus I did cut my finger during Thanksgiving so I apologize for my big fat finger um that Surplus is really because we were we forecast a budget anticipating all sorts of things coming out of the uh out of covid including a recession which hasn't happened there are a lot of other reasons too but we are we really tightened up the belt in Virginia and forecast a budget to reflect that and so the Surplus that exists does allow for a significant amount of one-time funding that will be available for the general assembly and the governor to spend important um much of it has statute requirements um has to go into reserves
014it has to go into water quality that's going to happen we have a very big Bill in Virginia for Medicaid UMC partially because of the expansion during covid and the unwinding of folks the coverage that was that existed during covid not as many people fell off the roles um after Co after the federal extension as we anticipated so we have a very big Bill there um the rest will be left up to the general assembly and the governor to spend but what's important is those are one time those are 20 fiscal year 25 Surplus dollars however um there are still opportunities to address the K12 funding report and so prioritizing this for Nori when I think about your strategic plan and your student outcome goals and I know Mr Jordan pointed out to me and
015I appreciate that um you're going to need additional resources and onetime funding just to start ensuring that you're getting the funding you need to support those student your students and so these are three of the bullets that I recommend as your top priorities um moving into session so when we think about your strategic priorities and I'm going to advance this is so small but this is directly these are your student Focus outcomes that um I know Mr Jordan sent along that you all are familiar with these are very very linked especially around accreditation um and student performance on the assessments not just performance and Mastery of the assessments but growth on those assessments and um advance Advanced study diplomas and so all items that will require additional resources I.E additional funding from the general assembly
016and additional Staffing from the funded through the general assembly as identified in the jarch report so I think that's just a natural link to achieve your strategic goals and these outcomes you are going to need action on the jlar report to me that's a top priority for Nori the other one that I I recommend as a top priority is addressing assessment and accreditation um obviously we have been talking about so assessments um for a long time here in Virginia we have the standards and then we have the assessments that measure them the board of education has been doing significant ific work um over the last three years to update the accreditation and accountability model in Virginia they are rolling out a new school performance framework which I'm sure you have heard about um in the
017upcoming school year we anticipate and I say this because we have seen a range of numbers and we haven't gotten confirmation yet on what the actual numbers look like there'll be four categories of schools um the two lower ends will be in need of intensive support and off track then there will be on track and exemplary or well above um um at different points of time we have heard as many as 60% as few as 30% of schools will fall into either needs intensive supports or off track and so when we talk about assessments and accreditation to meet those student outcomes that you have in place you are going to I would highly anticipate and I know you haven't gotten all the modeling data I would highly anticipate that many of your schools that were
018moving forward because of growth Mastery is a bigger component now are going to fall into categories where they will either need intensive support or be off track and so we need to ensure and these bullets talk about first of all ensuring we are capturing growth um ensuring that we are sending the resources to the schools and students the most in need as identified if we're going to roll out an accreditation system like this and then the other one um the English language language learner component English language Learners scores will now count after just three semesters um of being in school and so think about language acquisition and what that would mean and so I recommend this again if we look at your strategic goals your student outcome initiatives you all really in my my my
019Council to you is to prioritize as your top legislative priorities funding and the components of the jar report to drive more State dollars to NPS and to have the general assembly take a better and deeper look at the impact of any new assessment or accreditation system on schools and ensuring that the supports are in place as we are rolling out or before um there's certainly some debate about delaying um that's that recommendation is not here but there is certainly some conversation about the general assembly looking to delay so we can ensure the supports are there so those are my recommendations for your top priorities from there everything else becomes the positions what do you stand for and this is part of the redraft and rewrite and what I sent to you and so I hope
020it it wasn't too convoluted I took your previous legislative program and ensured every idea was captured in these positions and you got that long document where everything ended cross ended up crossed out every time I captured something in a category from your strategic plan I went and eliminated it from your previous um document so I could ensure I got everything it's just categorized differently um to align to the components of your strategic plan and again I won't through read through all these and in fact these bullets don't capture all of the positions that are in the proposed draft just the ones that I know are probably the most important to you um and again when we're talking about equ equitably supporting every student every student so this talks about the at risk this talks about
021El's and sliced life students are students with limited or interrupted formal education um this talks about Mental Health Services work-based learning the homework Gap and so that Broadband Gap that we've talked about over the years and ensuring that every student has access to high-speed internet so again equitably supporting every student the next category is around supporting your staff um compensation of course being an important component competitive compensation for difficult to staff positions not just teaching positions but including psychologist um school psychologist pathologist school counselors barrier to entry including for school bus drivers we have heard that and we've talked about the shortage of school bus driver so what can we do from a state perspective to open up doors for you all to have more flexibility there um incentives and then additional incentives um support
022for new teachers and um pre-service teachers those teachers that are preparing to come into the classroom ensuring they are prepared to come into all classrooms um and so that you have the luxury of having fully prepared staff that are ready to work with every single one of your students um grow your own programs which are important and then the other piece that I I put in here just from conversations there's a lot of talk about affordable housing um and I I anticipate the language we will see kind of Rise is Workforce housing um and so there used to be programs in Virginia to support educate so that they could live and work in the community the same community and so looking at ways that we could H include Educators and School staff in any of
023Workforce housing programs that we may see and then school safety the next bullet captured some of the top ones here safe and and ensuring that you all have the authority to continue to decide what resources and um environments you all want to create instead of State mandates that you all have that Authority mental health professionals because as much as we know that we need to to support our students in their learning a big component of school safety is ensuring that we have mental health supports for our students um and social worker psychologist behavioral specialists are captured here as well the other piece that again I added this because it is something that has been coming up and you are an urban School Division is ensuring that you have the authority to keep your Walkers and
024your pedestrians safe um and have some tools and funding Poss available to you that you might want to use to ensure that you can keep traffic flows safe in front of your schools and keep your pedestrian safe again that was one that I I had seen in when I talked about evaluating other school divisions I had seen that in another Urban School division's legislative position and I thought it was something that was worth bringing to you as a draft um and again local Authority um this is again the constitution of Virginia grants the authority to run the schools to the Local School Division so this goes through um the opposition to any any efforts to impede on that Authority um including and we saw some of this last year you're all the the authority of
025this board um on the adoption of curriculum instruction of materials policy support and disciplinary actions we are starting to see um and I know there's a bill filed on the cell phone policies we are starting to see some school divisions that are talking about implementing discipline um related including suspension not here um related to the um cell phone policies we will see legislation the session that will codify what the governor put forward in his executive action but will Pro prohibit the use of suspension and so again making sure we're talking about all of that and maintaining your authority to do what you know is right for your schools um in the last bullet I think we had 995 bills that added new training components to either School staff students and I'm 995 is an exaggeration
026but not tremendously um and so this is is speaking to um limiting that number but also ensuring that when a decision is made out of the general assembly that they are aligned to the timelines of your School Division um and so that you all are able to implement that training or those requirements in the timelines that you already have as opposed of trying to figure out how you're going to make it fit um School construction um again this has been a big issue for a long time so this category is specific to those items the 1% that would allow um noric to be included in the list that could raise ta local taxes by sales taxes by 1% ensuring that the standards of quality include a construction component when it's in the standards of quality
027there's a required State funding component um and then um ensuring that you have the opportunity as you look at improving your school buildings that you have every freedom and flexibility available to M use renewable energy whenever you can I'm putting that in there as part of your draft because we are seeing an increase in the number of schools are that are taking advantage of legislation that was passed a few years ago to install solar panels and that kinds of thing um to not just um for Energy Efficiency but for cost reduction and there are some things currently in the law that can um create some issues for schools we've seen that in a couple of school divisions in Northern Virginia where they had an unexpected cost at the end because of some requirements for some
028additional funding to do that kind of Last Mile work that they didn't anticipate and then um accessible to all and so these are your opposition statements these are very unchanged um from your previous uh your previous legislative program but I captured under this whole idea of again it's removing the deficit we're just not going to stand in opposition we we are committed to providing an equitable high quality education and so therefore we would oppose these things and that's the framing so everything that you would normally see grading systems or scales um to rating systems unfunded mandates vouchers anything that would remove Public Funding um anything that would reduce and remember we saw this two sessions ago there was a proposal to reduce um and eliminate some of the sales tax on groceries and not replace
029that funding that came back to local school boards we were able to put that back both in code and budget and then any efforts to mandate the placement or Banning of books um that was one that we've added in the last few years as we saw some action in those categories and that's actually I won't go into your um I just want to kind of wrap like that's the proposal as far as um the draft and rewrite I'm not going to surprise you with any of this your delegation you have two members of the Virginia Senate on your in your delegation um Senator Bill and Senator Angela Williams Graves in the house you have four members and actually let me go back a couple of things um it's important to note that you you do
030not have a member in the Senate who serves on the education and health committee that's important for a lot of reasons a lot of again Senate committees are smaller um it's important because a lot of times your delegation won't see a bill until it comes from the committee and it's on the floor and so that's where we are on the ground making sure they know your positions on bills but that's where there is real value in ensuring you're having conversations with your delegation about bills they may not see until they go to the floor and we are ensuring that we are flagging them for Kath be is is Senator Lucas the closest Senator that we have that's on education uh I'd have to think about who's on education I would assume so because that's I
031think so but I'll confirm for you it seems that way I don't have the full education list in front of me and she's a champion for sure of um of krol funding which we're super grateful for and obviously Senator Lucas um is also the chair of the Senate fun Finance finance and Appropriations Committee she's very powerful in the Senate and then on the house um in good news um a delegate asku does serve on the education committee and um is very actively engaged in reviewing um educa education legislation as a part of this committee all of them are actively engaged but it's just important to note that when legislation first appears and has its first Hearing in a subcommittee the first person that will have the opportunity to react to it will be delegate ask
032you and so ensuring that the whole delegation knows but that that he in particular is is very prepared um to represent norfol so what comes next we have a draft in front of you edits feedback um I did I did incorporate um and I have changes I didn't send I I have copies um but I get this is a public meeting so I'll hold on um I did incorporate feedback for Mr Jordan and have elevated the two recommended priorities to the top um and so it turned it into more of a legislative package for you all um because that would be my next recommendation and the edits that I would made I sent those along if if you want to see them I have paper copies as well adopting of the final program obviously tomorrow
033we'll have take your legislature to school day um the other piece too is we want to help in any way possible to start building out any Communications you need we are hopeful that this approach of telling norick's story and presenting your legislative program as a place of we are doing good work we we need support from the state to continue to ensure that our students families communities have the resources they need we'll help inform your delegation speak more even more um effectively on your behalf and your Coalition Partners as well building support again um and then the governor's budget announcement on December 18th is really kind of the next big item um he has mentioned that he intends to put at least $50 million onetime money into that category of schools that will need either
034intensive support or off track in the upcoming school year so we'll see what else there is in the governor's plan for K12 um as we look at his amended budget and with that I'm happy to take any questions all right thank you for your presentation board members you've heard the presentation are there any questions so Senator Lucas is on the education and health committee oh education was that I'm sorry Health yes education the house separates education and health into two separate committees the Senate combines them into one which makes for a very robust docket every time can imagine anyone else oh miss Bine yeah thank thank you so much I like the way that you have laid out um the legislative program this year um and I think it makes total sense and I appreciate
035the inclusion of our of our outcomes goals um as well cuz um so as you're presenting a picture that is unique to MPS you know the issues that are unique to MPS and we have the the goals in front of us and you know you've itemized areas including um you know around special education and our English language Learners do you anticipate any specific bills based on what came out of the recommendations in the education report specific to those populations where we need to we need greater investment in um you know it's easy to say support these programs but what those programs should what they are and um you know even in terms of language support like devices and you know things things that we need uh to ensure that we're providing an equitable education for
036um for every student particularly those two subgroups that we see also in our data that that really uh require um you know highly trained staff um language support programs you know whatever whatever the research shows is um evidence-based to improve outcomes for those students so I was just wondering if you're anticipating um anything from the general assembly absolutely chair Buffalo um yes um to your question we actually saw legislation last year we called it the Omnibus Bill which is not normal and Norm you hear this in the federal government the Omnibus Bill where they throw in the kitchen sink um we have done that with the jar recommendations the last few sessions so we we will have an Omnibus Bill again this year in the Senate and I anticipate in the house as well that
037will capture all of the jar recommendations and the full cost associated what happened last session with that great big Omnibus Bill is it stayed an omnus Bill and they kept the general assembly kept amending it until they got to the piece they were able to afford and then they funded that piece and so what they funded last year included improvements to El Staffing ratios um the atrisk add-on changes were also included but captured in budget as opposed to in code which putting it in code is something that we have been talking about for a few years and was included in the jar recommendations so I we will see that great big huge bill I also anticipate and I've been trying to nail down who the patrons are on these things components of the jar recommendations
038also so instead of the big Omnibus Bill we will see bills specific to specific pieces of it including I would anticipate additional improvements to E staffing ratios U we had a they made some changes last year and they put a delayed enactment on it so School divisions didn't have to fully staff and so I would not be surprised to see try to see that extended um I I understand it is very challenging to hire additional El staff um but at the same time if you delay it the state funding isn't there to help you fund them um we have seen also when it comes to devices and other outside of just the Staffing for El students and other students with special needs we have been we have seen and I anticipate we will see again
039from a couple of um advocacy groups specific device and other um technology improvements for schools and the funding for to support the kinds of students that need whether it's hearing or visual um support through some of the modern technology that's available now to really help those students so I would anticipate all of that we do track all of those bills and that's when and I I know it's an unfortunate Friday or sometimes Saturday depending on on how long it takes me to get the report out to you that is an unfortunate email in many ways you get from me because we track on your behalf last year I think it was 380 bills all of them are captured in there and it is a lot um but I will I am certainly particularly knowing your
040your and I I know your focus and your desire to really look at that I will do my very best to highlight those as they come up in the report for you so that you can see them there but we do track all of those and I'll keep you updated I would anticipate an extraordinary number of bills particularly in the house related to K12 because remember I said an election is up in November and everyone supports public education so we will see everyone position themselves but um we'll have to see at the end of the day remember a lot of onetime funding we'll have to see at the end the day what resources they're going to drive okay and so to to your point so um you know I know so the Omnibus Bill was
041broken down into specific pieces and I find it interesting when they they break it down so for instance like the Staffing ratios you can't reduce the Staffing ratios if you don't have the qualified staff to fill those positions so it's like how where's the legislation around creating a pipeline for instance and and um you know it's like we're starting with legislation here when we haven't figured out out the the route of getting to here and so I'd like to see legislation really think about that piece like starting from where you need to start in order to get to that the ideal um place that we need to be to serve our students and so you know I I look forward to um reviewing uh that with um when you send us all those emails that
042we get I know um with all the bills in it um and the same thing around special education you know so that's um trying to think and and if I chair if I may we did see special education legislation last year um some additional dollars but the commission on youth is in the process of looking at the dispute resolution process for instance um we did that bill ini started with a Statewide IEP system um it didn't go there quite yet because there are School divisions that develop their own um and so I I anticipate that delegate coiner had the bill in the house U I know she's coming back with something this year related to not necessarily additional um staff related to special education but streamlining IEPs um and ensuring and it and it's always
043interesting when you come to an area of the Commonwealth where's where there's a higher percentage of military families um that would would allow those IPS to more easily move with the student in a system and format that is um usable by school divisions in other part of the Commonwealth and so I would anticipate something like that coming back um as well part of the issue with Staffing right now is the jar report one of the big findings of the jar report was Virginia is one of um a handful of states that use a staff funding formula method to send State dollars and so a big part of the work of this joint subcommitte is figuring out should we do something different should we look at students should we look at a student funding formula and
044what unfortunately that has done is given them a reason to put the breaks on Staffing models and improving Staffing models until they figure that out um but again I anticipate an El um El Staffing is going to be addressed again I would anticipate the session it would not surprise me to see special educ psychologist but there is there has seemed to be this pause around let's let joint subcommittee that's working on Nori's report as we like to call that jayar report um figure out how they want to fund this first the problem there is that's a yearslong process I think Tennessee we keep hearing about Tennessee they did it in a year I'm not sure Tennessee would jump up and down and say we did it great and we want to get it right you
045know that's an important component So based upon what you just said do you anticipate that they won't carefully look at removing the or eliminating the cap for support positions so um chair um so the I they have over the last few sessions been doing that they have been again recession air cuts are and and the support staff cap is probably the biggest one that has the greatest dollar-to-dollar impact for school divisions there is a series of them that still exists that put a real that really tap down the funding that comes to all School divisions but in particular um norfol I would anticipate again onetime dollars they're going to they are going to work and they have been working on addressing the support staff cap what they did last session was actually apply a staffing
046ratio in the code um versus we used to just we used to just fund it through the budget um so they have started putting a staffing ratio in the code to send additional dollars down I know there will be legislation to move that further it will be interesting to see how do they look at it from do we have one time dollars we can send to kind of fill the gap or are we going to continue to look at Staffing formula is for support staff just so that we can get that fixed because it's been around for so long and school divisions have have rightfully been asking for a reversal of these recession cuts and so I know that's the vaguest answer uh but there's a lot of components going on and support staff cap
047without question and a lot of it has to do for the work that school boards across the Commonwealth have been doing pushing this issue superintendents have been doing across the Commonwealth parents have been doing um they have finally heard us 15 years later um 10 12 um so I I anticipate work on it I just don't yet know where it will land but that's not a best practice to use onetime funding for positions yes Staffing onetime funding for Staffing yeah and what we have found pretty consistently in the general assembly did two sessions ago they they set aside $418 million in onetime funds for schools that's a tough one for schools to utilize in a way that will really drive your student outcome goals um because that's Staffing that's some devices that's technology that have
048an ongoing cost so the general assembly that's the other trick here is they recognize that onetime dollars are not the kinds of dollars that school divisions trust me we'll take them but um and and certainly they can hold us over it's but it's not something and when school divisions use those kinds of dollars for things with recurring costs then the general assembly said we told you they would do that and so it's it's a it's a careful balance for sure so this is one we'll watch really really carefully um and an important one to make sure we're talking with the delegation about thing y can I piggy back on so that another question I had was going to was going to be around with the expiration of all the Esser funds and you know which
049we've had for the last few years that allowed School divisions to do a number of things to improve academic performance how is the general assembly um examining um the need the current need of based on what we've been given um for the last few years um chair buo um that again is all tied up in the jar funding formula subcommittee and they're looking what they're trying to figure out is what is the true cost of educ educating students in Virginia and that includes what improvements did we make in some of our instructional components because we had the additional federal dollars that are now gone but we know we're effective um and so yeah that's a big piece of the overall cost and interestingly when we look at K12 how the state how the state kind
050of takes the budget apart when they look at rev benchmarking they actually included all of those federal dollars into the Cal initial calculation and so they had to pull them out it's called the federal deduct they put them all in and then they take out from what the state has to pay they take out the federal component the federal deduct was enormous this year because of Esser and it will be enor or this bench re benchmarking it will be enormous nextory benchmarking um and then they figure out what does the state have to left pay in good news they have the dollar figure for and the components of what was involved in the full cost for those years when we did have eser dollars and that is something and other states are doing that the
051good news is Virginia is not alone in this every state in the in the country has been through this and so tapping in and that's one of the things the the committee is doing is tapping into National experts on this and try to figure out how do we ensure that if we're really going to look at the true cost we're ensuring that every dollar of that true cost that help kids including the federal dollars are included in that calculation I am not saying they're going to get there because as you know that was an extraordinary in investment um and the jar report probably captures some of it because it talks about some of the things we know we funded with Sr funds um but not all of it it's a it's a I don't know
052that it's a cliff because I think school divisions were really good in managing those dollars it's um it's a the first it's the first dip in the roller coaster though we'll say that not quite a cliff follow up to that one because I think I asked this question before Dr ber song um with the Esser federal dollars that were we knew we going to Sunset we in our last budget the one that we just passed had already begun to make preparation for that correct we were proactive in doing that for this year got it all right thank and I will also say if I remember correctly and apologize no um you all included as part of your legislative package last year or the year before what you spent what you were spending those categories I
053think they little buckets on your one page you gave your general assembly members your delegation um because that's an important piece of this too is so that they can articulate what you were spending your money on um not to mention how and I not just the reports I'm hearing about just today but the volume of reports that had to be sent to the Department of Education about how you were spending your Sesser dollars all of that data exists for your delegation um I actually had a colleague up in another School Division that printed it out and brought it to his delegation and they were each like that I mean I'm so um you all have volumes of data on how you spent that um and so we have that certainly have that information for any
054member of the delegation or general assembly who has questions chair Buffalo yep Mr Jord just uh couple of things um first thank you for uh for the reformatting and for integrating the the student outcome Focus goals uh so one just the language student outcome Focus goals make sure that we're consistent with with that description because it has student Focus outcome goals and student outcome Focus goals and um on the uh on page three where it lists the Strategic goals I was sitting here looking I think there's one missing um which is the student Excellence um description so you you don't show the categories but the descriptions align with the student Excellence Workforce resources Community safety and climate so in those four bullets it should be five okay and um and then perhaps we could consider
055putting the student outcome goals first and then the Strategic goals second as the outcome goals as what the the board is prioritize in the strategic planning efforts is how to go about uh uh achieving it but other than that I I think it's a a very good document um the other thing I just want to share I was at the bsba conference and was doing a session with Rono and so what they did was they had this little card and then on their QR code you can go to their website and then get a single page description for how we have these documents so just moving for in terms of what we have that we can uh hand out I just I just thought that was a nice way that they did that they did
056that and and chair I'm happy to make and and certainly if I eliminate it and it may have been in my cutting and pasting so I apologize for that I will ensure that all of the but the bullet components from the Strategic plan are Incorporated there and I am happy at the will of the board put to to take that order in any way um it does sound like um there is agreement on including both the iic goals and the student goals um but I'm happy to put them in any order around the table Mr Jordan's recommendation to the um the goals School Board goals first then the Strategic and how they're going to do get to those yes Dr Mark yeah okay y I will make that change and then the one thing that
057I will mention and it was part of our our My Bullets around um you know moving forward how do we advance this um and one of them was again I know every school division is different and the superintendent well he's he's no longer he's not the superintendent he is their government relations and 87 other jobs that he has um Alan Sebert who worked on ensuring that they could come up with a document like that their Communications team took the legislative program and and did that um and so not certain of what the capacity is here but if we think about telling the story of norick and then those two focused priorities everything else positions you QR code to the positions um and then you put the two priorities on a card like that that is
058certainly um everyone is showing their own City Public Schools card and I just cleaned out a bag and I had eight of them in my bag um and so it is it is a really um in my opinion a useful helpful tool to hand out and the QR code that would link to um again a public facing document that tells the story of nori Public Schools is always helpful and we've done that in the past we've had the one pager which talked about our our needs and and what we've done in the years past and and what our asks were um and that that document right there with nice shiny glossy QR code that's just 2.0 right well I will I will make the the changes to um the document and it sounds like um
059you all agree or there is agreement it seems to me but I will leave that to you um around the prioritization the top legislative priorities being K12 funding and the assessments and accountability and the ree compositions um is my recommendation and I'm happy to do the will of whatever is the will of the board yeah sounds good well I look forward to seeing everyone tomorrow right early you thank you all right we're going to move on to 3.01 Dr beraw yes thank you chair Buffalo um we have some good news to share today um while we're making progress there's still some areas of focus that will require our attention um today Dr Paul will provide an update on proficiency levels as it relates to reading and Mathematics and we have some great data on closing
060gaps between certain subgroups of students while increasing the proficiency of all so Dr Pole thank you Dr Birdsong and good evening uh Madam chair Buffalo Vice chair Dr Gabriel members of the board Dr bong community members Administration everybody else um I'm here to share tonight um SPO Schoolboard goal four measure 4.1 so uh as a reminder the actual goal is uh focused on reading in mathematics and and reducing the gaps to be no greater than 10% um by the um by the uh 2728 um it's accountability year that that language will change with this goal as well um once we figure all that out um uh and specifically tonight with measure 4 4.1 we're going to focus on our reading data and then next board meeting we'll focus on our math data so the reading
061data for measure 4.1 there are two areas we're looking at students within the black uh student with disability our socioeconomic status English Learners and Hispanic subgroup scoring proficient um on the star reading assessment um and you'll see here um we've mapped out from where where we ended last spring to the goals this spring um and and that's the the areas for um each of the subgroups to improve so that we can reduce gaps because part of this goal as we recall is that we don't want to see decreases in scores we want to see everybody Rising while we're closing the gaps that was a big a big Focus point of this goal um so as Dr Birdsong said there's a lot of uh good news to share um uh the the data is is really
062starting to show uh the majority of the gaps improved within the proficiency and Urgent intervention bands between subgroups scores also showed improvements with all subgroups with improving uh while improving the Gap so we are seeing that movement that that we're looking for um with students in the following subgroups improvements were seen in both proficiency scores raising them while lowering urgent intervention scores um and moving them out of urgent intervention while seeing the gaps move closer to 10% and those subgroups were our are black with white sces and non and our eel and nonel groups so all those groups in both areas saw growth everywhere and closure of the gaps um and I'm sorry I didn't scroll down through all all of our graphs this is the one where we minimized the graph size so we
063could we could get them all on here on separate graphs um and then here was the Urgent intervention that we've reviewed that as well um so what's going well I separated out into two areas one the proficiency data the gaps between students in the black and white subgroups SCS and nons subgroups and El and nonel subgroups all improved from the spring data additionally all subgroups saw Improvement in the fall star reading proficiency rates as compared to Spring 2024 data this shows students are starting the year off with stronger proficiency rates than how last year was ended so we're beginning better than we ended last year within the Urgent intervention data the gaps between the students the student subgroups black and white s swd and non swd sces and nones El and nonel saw decreases from
064the spring 2024 results to the fall 2024 results which is wonderful and all student subgroups realize decreases in the percentage of students in the Urgent intervention band so I want to say that one more time that when you look at the numbers here every single student group saw decreases in the Urgent intervention band from the spring to the fall so we've raised students from last spring to now um and seen seen the differences in the scor so that's some exciting news CL thank you very [Applause] much um you know and always you know like Dr Ron said there's always work to be done continuously work to be done so you know some of the areas that aren't going so well with the proficiency data the gaps between the students uh with disability and and non-student
065with disability students increased we saw a little increase there and additionally all the Gap although the gap between the Hispanic and non-hispanic students increased it is still within our range it's below 10% that Gap is but we did see some growth in that Gap um which is which is common when you're talking about that 10% range to see some fluctuations up and down with the Urgent intervention data the gap between the students in the Hispanic and non-hispanic subgroups increased and now that one slightly over 10% I believe that one ended up at 10.9% 10.8 thank you Dr bong um and then I'm not going to read through all these These are similar since we're on reading we've talked a lot about reading with our our previous goals with the grade three and with the students
066specifically in the black subgroup um and and these were areas of the previous action steps in yellow and then the green were what we've done these are these are similar to what what have already been reported because they were they were all similar compared to reading now with next steps specifically for um for our Gap groups um we are focusing again on the reading plans that Target interventions um and as you may recall those are required this year for students in K through three and the anticipated requirement for next year students in K through 8 however to to uh kind of get on that road already we've started that in grade six as well so we're doing reading plans in K through three and grade six and that is an additional workload for our reading
067Specialists and our teachers I just want you to know but it it should be good focused work um on on how we're doing the reading plans uh reading specialist will provide families with targeted resources to to support the individual student reading goals at home um we'll monitor master and intervention schedules to ensure that interventions complement um rather than replace core literacy instruction um there's continued professional development for intervention providers so really focusing in our special education teachers um and and our paas our ESL teachers our tutors that we've hired on our evidence-based literacy interventions so sips Lexia um uh Core 5 and PowerUp so that they're very familiar on the use of those um continuing to analyze and disaggregate Lexia data to monitor achievement gaps and provide timely interventions and the English office will monitor
068evidence-based interventions by conducting coaching and feedback Cycles with teachers trained in the sips program uh monthly PD sessions for teachers on evidence-based literacy strategies in high quality instruction materials uh monitor reading specialist support logs to increase modeling and team teaching opportunities strengthen teacher capacity and enhancing hqm implementation so I just want to say on that one just you know really focusing on you know getting down to the nitty-gritty of of what the reading specialist are doing to support teachers and students in the buildings and making sure those logs are filled um so that we're on top of that um and then the English office will analy unit test data emphasizing strand Mastery and subgroup performance to identify priority supports and guide instructional planning so again using that that data on The Daily to really focus
069on where our students needs are um and then collaborating with learning support to provide professional Vel mment on special design instruction to scaffold tier one instructions for students with disabilities and assist schools with developing implementing and monitoring of comprehensive School support plans um so I know this was you know one of our longer one because of all the graphs but um that's the conclusion of measure 4.1 hey school board members you've heard the re um monitoring report from Dr pole Dr beraw you have any [Applause] questions I questions okay we'll go Dr Gabriel Miss Bine did I see your hand Miss and Mr Jordan okay thank you chair Buffalo um Dr pole so we're um in December now and based upon um the assessments that our students are taking um what are what do the
070rest of the check-ins look like for reading um and I guess math if you don't mind uh going into 2025 and leading up to Theos so you know our we are now looking at unit assessment data we're looking at Lexia data um and you know we're we're really getting down to the standard level now with teachers and focusing on the the star data that came in um and matching that to where we're seeing um strengths and weaknesses on the unit assessments uh it it's hard division-wide to say you know where we definitely are star is really our next Benchmark that we'll see in the in the winter testing module um but we are seeing stronger readers um this fall than we've seen past fall with our data and math is is um we haven't seen
071quite as much of a spike but we are seeing growth do you anticipate and I know there was a a calendar that that went out with the assessments about two more assessments before the students go in to take their s sols so we'll definitely have the winner star and then the Statewide winter growth assessment will will be out there and we'll have a few more unit assessments um as well as the you know daily format of the teachers offer as well as the you know for reading specific the Lexia modules that students will go through um and then for our our intervention services With Sips they'll get even more data okay thank you my pleasure and for sorry for younger ones we'll have vows winner assessment as well okay Miss Bine um yeah and Mr
072Jordan if you'd like to go I asked a lot of question questions on the last agenda topic um um so with this I I thought uh I appreciate the presentation um I thought it was really interesting if we could go back to the proficiency um the comparison going from Spring 2022 to 23 to 23 24 um and then seeing this big uh what seemed to be a a much greater Improvement for the fall of 2425 what do you attribute that um that Improvement to I think you know my answer is going to be similar to last time is just really consistency of of implementation of um our our tier 2 tier three supports that we put in place for for this is our fourth year now like using Lexia our fourth year using the sips
073curriculum um our students you know in third fourth and fifth grade now all had opportunity to work with uh literacy tutors in K you know K12 um because they've they've just moved up so the consistency of implementation of programming I think is huge in what we're seeing um the the I think we were more consistent at uh having less turnover in teachers from last year to this year um and you know all those things I think benefit our students okay and and um so so then um I think some of the some of so there are no fall targets here so similar to last month when we reviewed or the last monitoring session you know we talked about that in the fall targets and I know there was some exchange between um that last session
074and and this one about how we could develop those fall targets based on historical data have you had a chance to look at that or have any thoughts about that that yeah so we for next fall we'll definitely do it but this for the for the star assessments right now I think it's kind it's it's called Data snooping we've seen all the data so we don't really want to create targets when we've seen the data so next fall we'll have fall Targets in place okay all right and then I'm I I have two things that I want to um ask questions around but I also want to make sure everybody has a chance to speak so I can um I can either come back or if it's okay okay um so students with disabilities so
075that group did not see um the improvements that other groups saw right so I mean they saw 5% gain I mean they saw right some but even with they're still not at the level of the other student group subgroups right so what do you what do you think that that suggests I mean because we know like so when I look at the you know what's going well what's not going well and I know it probably sound like a broken record but it's I really want to get to a point where we're understanding the board is understanding um what actions are successful so what actions are really uh advancing outcomes for students and what are not and so with students with disabilities uh in particular where we you know in even among other goal in our
076other goals we're we're that as a group where we're not seeing um the the same level of improvement or or movement so it really begs the question of what barriers are in place are we looking at compliance are we looking at um training of of our staff are we looking at um you know the IEPs like what what are we I guess doing to really strengthen that um teaching and learning for that particular subgroup so I two comments on that one you know I think when you're looking at the raw data going 21.7 to 26.5 from Spring to Fall percentage wise I do think we're seeing good growth with our students with disabilities we have a lot longer a lot further to go with our ST which we which we've known I I think one
077of the things that's important is to have a continued focus with instruction and the instructional model with our special education teachers um because we we can focus on compliance and compliance and compliance and we can make sure that all all accountability in and everything on the IEP is is perfect which needs to be done I have no no not saying it doesn't need to be done however if we only focus on compliance then no one will know how to really Implement that instructionally so the focus with not only special ed teachers but core teachers on specially design instruction um this year the specific Target we've had with um with really merging professional development with our um special education staff and our curriculum instruction staff to make sure that they're all on the same page I
078think the more we focus on what instructional supports do we have in place to meet the accommodations is important and I think we're starting to see that more and more um especially with a lot of the collaboration that's that's been going on this fall and then coming into the school year Jordan thank thank you and thank you for the report um I'm I'm still struggling a little bit with just trying to follow the the trend analysis um so but first want to go back what was what was it your uh can you repeat again the terminology that you use for uh why we don't why we didn't do the fall targets sure so um the since we had and we had talked about this last meeting why why we didn't do them was was because
079we were last year I don't know that the targets were set properly and we knew coming into it if we saw the fall data we could know if our annual Target was set properly um this this um fall the reason we didn't do them now on this one coming to the board um even though it was you know when we talked about fall targets is um I talked to our statistician Greg Williams he said it's called Data snooping snooping yeah he said if you know the data and you're making targets then you know there could be concerns around creating targets after you know the data say say it one more time for data snooping no I mean that you say if you know the so if you know the data for the fall data already
080and then we're making a fall Target you know yes yeah yeah no I get that so that's why that's why there's no fall targetting right I guess I guess what I'm trying to is determine the um the ability to have some type of uh estimate or predictive analysis based upon Trend data so the way the report is it's it's hard for me to to follow so for example we on the charts we're mapping spring to Spring well yes so spring to Spring is the is the goal then our conversation is about Spring to Fall so what I'm trying to see is you know at least on the on the interim basis uh fall to fall winter to winter spring to spring so for for example cuz I pulled up the report that you gave us
081in June and that's how the best way I could try to follow it for myself so in for last year our you mentioned the target so we had a spring Target of 52% so we if I'm reading it correctly if we started off with um I'm just looking at the first line for black students we start off with the 2223 results of 39.8 we had a target of 52% we our actual was 42.6% so then when we look at this current report we so we didn't make the Target that we set but when I look at the graphs it's hard for me to see the line of how our actual performance is against our targets that we set and then we did set that 52% uh spring Target and I guess just by chance because
082it's I assume it's just by chance that the fall actual ended up being about 52% but when you are looking at um student performance in a uh rollup like this and there's some way of being able to say based upon the last three years four years whatever it's been this is what we uh are seeing in the trend and as a result of that prior to the students taking the fall assessment being able to have a indication of what a fall Target would be based upon their historical testing patterns and whatever other types of uh data input you would you would consider so I understand why it's not on the report now I guess what I'm trying to figure out is why we wouldn't be able to have fall targets um calculated based upon last
083year's or based upon the trend analysis prior to getting to monitoring the the report so in the future we will do that and that is possible to do with Trend data but again the like I said at the last meeting the reason why we didn't do that this year because last year every time we presented the data we talked about where the target set properly and you know you know do we feel like we you know that that that we set something that was able to be accomplished or not able to be accomplished so seeing the fall data give us a better eye on our annual targets that were already preset so you know the annual targets haven't changed here so you know really looking at that to see did we need to have a
084discussion around our annual targets you know based off the fall targets but when we saw the fall results we were like no we're good we we feel really comfortable with our data this fall um and then really on this one when you're looking at the graphs Mr Jordan as a reminder this this these graphs are really looking at the gaps right so you're not looking at any performance you're looking at the gaps decreasing right because that was actually that was gonna be my other comment that I think because in the in the goal um and I can't remember what the interim goals are but in the overarching goal there's uh two pieces to it right so one is the closure of the Gap and two is not seeing any of the groups go down but
085like you like you just mentioned on the chart it's showing the the Gap analysis but I don't think we have a chart unless I missed it that's showing we we don't okay we but so we have it in the table and purposefully that's why we put this in the table so we could see the the data live in the table we just don't have another graph with it and when we tried to graph it then your percentages are so different the the graphs get confusing when you when you try to put like all of them on one graph so if if if it's the will of the board you know we can add it would be another two pages of graphs to show the the scores of all the subgroups yeah I'm not I just
086think that at least for me when I'm looking at it it's hard to to follow it and and so if there is some way of of charting it um without having what you described I think it would be some value to us because if I look at uh so let's look at the the first chart on the on the left so we have the 34.6 black white gap for spring 2223 then we have the 31.8% which is for 23 24 then we switch to this fall point but then the the dotted line to the right those are supposed those are our targets targets but there's are you why isn't it not some way that the Target that starts with the first point of winter 2425 why couldn't that point go backwards so that we would
087be able to see the so in the so in the future there will be a Target here so when we report out in the winter this line will continue the solid line will continue and the dotted line will stay and then in the spring the same thing so the solid line will continue and we'll have a double line here we'll have the dotted line and a solid line which will show you you know so right now if you look at our Trend we're trending towards the 18% right um our our trend line looks good um and as we go on then as we get so when I present in the winter the winter data we'll see is our DOT below or above our Target for the winner and and I think that's what you might
088be talking about Mr Jordan is when when we'll see two lines okay maybe I'll I'll try to work on it maybe I'll try to graph it out what I what I'm trying to visually understand and see um is do you consider this um on track off track or or what because there's no indicator there for the so yeah there's no indicator since we didn't have a fall Target but I would say I would say based on the number of gaps that have closed in the improvements that we are on track for for the most part you know I think it separates by by group in some instances the the other thing I I not noticed when I was looking at the June report and this report in the June report for the gap for black
089white we showed it as red be I think because the uh the white student performance did not improve prove and then on this one we're showing it as as yellow is there so the yellow for the the the gap for the yellow was because we we did not make the goal but our Gap improved right but but again the Gap improved in part because of the performance of black students but then also because of the slight drop with white students and I thought what I was saying earlier I thought we were trying to say that that that wouldn't be the case that all the all the groups would either at least stay the same or grow but if one went down while one went up we could see a Gap close but the Gap could
090be closing because of a drop for a particular uh student group so in the future I can add the color coding to the um scores as well I have a question is it because it's only only 0.1% or Point well I mean it's they didn't drop by much but Mr Jordan's point is they saw decline um instead of instead of moving up or staying the same um and the the the so that should Tech the 74.4 should be read because that went down and and yeah and it's not right it's not so much to me about the color it's just to give the the board the sense of uh you know like we said you can have Gap closures by Adele you running slower uh since you run faster than I do right know you
091f know you could you could slow down you could slow down and I could close the gap with you or or you could still be running the same and I can speed up and close the gap maybe and so when we had that we had the conversation that was why we had the other piece that what we're trying to say is we want to make sure that all the student groups are uh improving hopefully or at least staying it's not statistically significant I'm not I'm not I agree I just I just think whatever we do I just want it to be consistent with it that's all but it but I think what I'm hearing is that it is a guard so whether or not if it's it's a guard we put in place that part
092of the goal yeah it's part of the goal so whether or not it's a small minutu or whatever else just to be true and transparent it that's why we're we and then the the other question I had on the recommendations of around coaching support can you remind us um I know we've asked about this before but there's there's allocation of coaching support um by school and how can you just remind us in terms of the allocation of coaching support what that what that looks like sure so every Elementary School has a reading specialist and the reading specialist primary job is to coach and then to work uh you know small group of students from time to time and to follow up with the reading plans wasn't there some other type of uh coach or resource
093that um so we have 12 instructional coaches instructional coaches that we paid for out of title one and we pay for I think one or two out of title two so that we didn't have to only lock them to Title One schools um and those coaches um if they're at an elementary they're split between two schools and again that's for instructional coaching to okay so that isn't those instructional coaches don't have any bearing on they're they're so they will work with teachers on and they may be teaching reading when they're doing it but theirs is more on on General instructional practice in pedagogy our reading Specialists are specifically coaching them on the instruction of reading and the Improvement of student reading data and then those instructional Cod coaches and the reading Specialists is there um
094some prioritization around putting them in front of the students who need them the most so the reading specialist the requirement is to have those we follow theq requirements for those now and we over staff those a bit because they're done by number as well right of students so um you know those we have in in place already the instructional coaches are done specifically every year here their reset based off need um um academic need of schools and is it is this type of data uh part of what feeds into that determination of acemic need Absolut the so and star data um we look at those in the spring and we start to decide you know where where our students needed or where the instructional coaches needed the most thank you my pleasure I have one
095question participation rate what is our particip ation goal rate first star first star uh we try to State the 95% participation rate and I I don't have the exact number for me but we are we are right close um with with our participation I think in the fall we were at like 92 93% and the the reason was the 95 was that was the Federal so requirement so we try to really enforce that St okay just me is there any other questions thank you Dr pole my pleasure board members we're going to move on to 3.02 Dr beraw thank you um chair Buffalo um this afternoon or this evening um we have an update to share with you related to the booker to Washington steam program um it's our first year of implementation with our
096freshman and so this evening principal Deon Gardner is here to present some information I think Dr Paul will introduce introduce um principal Garner and then we'll get started all right uh good evening again Madame chair Buffalo Vice chair Dr Gabriel members of the board Dr Birdsong um I'm here this evening with Mr Garner the proud principal Booker Washington High School to provide you with a steam program update um this afternoon Mr Garner will provide an overview pertaining to professional development courses some field trips pathway selection for students and Community Partnerships um and at this time I'm going to turn it right over to Mr Garner this Booker T sweater on nice welcome well good evening good evening uh Dr uh Dr chairwoman Buffalo uh Dr bird song Vice uh chair Dr uh Dr Gabriel and
097all the steam board members thank you all so much for the opportunity to be able to present just briefly an update on our steam program our initiative the work we're doing at Booker T Washington High School um as you may recall the last update we presented was in June 2024 and during that presentation we were able to share some key uh ideas in terms of implementation and preparation uh for the work to include PD opportunities curriculum brainstorming some site visits uh to current steam schools outside of our state and have some concrete plans for implementation relative to professional development we have retooled our Booker T Washington steam leadership team where we had a group of in uh just selected individuals to give us insight to brainstorm what this would look like at Washington uh since
098then we've retooled that team to narrow down to the people who are really really interested in the work in terms of pro providing ideas and resources and then also being a part of planning and preparing the implementation of the steamwork uh throughout the building and within our uh fresh orientation model called Booker prep and we'll talk about that later uh these teachers have played an intrical part in defining and refining the career Pathways and providing form to the steam skeleton and I do want to take an opportunity to recognize is tressy Moore she's our chair she's not here this evening but she is our chair of the uh CT department at Burger washhington uh she's kind of my my design in terms of taking on a core leadership role in the implementation of steam monitoring
099and and just offering suggestions and input and direct support to our freshman Booker prep uh teacher so I do want to give her that Accolade even in her absence she's shown that natural passion for the work and she demonstrated commitment to the Su success so in keeping with our districtwide practices the steam leadership team is undergoing a book study of the work entitled Project based learning handbook uh circling back to the team site visit to Tennessee Cleveland Tennessee uh in April of this of this year we learned that steam is more than just science technology engineering building it's the approach to which we Implement those Concepts and how we teach those Concepts uh we learned at Walker Valley High School that the idea of uh of approaching a steam initiative is based on passion-based learning
100project based learning and problem based learning and because of that this uh book a pro uh Project based learning handbook has been integral or will continue to be integral in the work that we're doing to have a true PLC model uh uh centered on uh the steamwork we know that Science and Technology are the vehicles to deliver pbl and the book study adds to this individual skill set the individuals being the teachers and allowing the implementation of steam to be focused in the right direction and again keeping with District priorities and practices monthly power planning sessions have been hosted and facilitated by our office of curriculum and instruction and these sessions have to formalize our school's approach to the steam curriculum development and it's also important to note that the curriculum has been developed but
101as it is taught we make necessary changes to provide that best uh implementation and experience for the students uh currently the Cornerstone piece of our steamwork to date has been the creation of the booker Prep course uh this course was not in the original design or plan or model for steam at Booker T Washington and again and your PD dollars are are working for us and that it's an outgrowth of our site visit to Tennessee uh at Wild in Tennessee a team of a four other teachers and myself we walked and we toured and we interviewed and we talked to students and faculty members and administration and we found that just kind of jumping into the steamwork was not necessarily the best practice way so there was a transition piece and they called it Freshman
102Academy where in Freshman Academy it was an opportunity for students to become acclimated to the high school work to become acclimated to the steam work and then understand the end goal which is to have a career pathway with some solid credentialing after that so because of time we wanted to be able to kind of model that in a practical and realistic sense here go the book of prep course this came out of a work that we took that we took part in in June at our three-day steam retreat at Old University and in that Booker Prep course as an opportunity uh for them to kind of for them meaning students to Define and refine their interest and select the career pathway after being exposed to field trips guest speakers uh all of those areas uh
103high school life becoming acclimated to being a high school student uh working being organized and diligent in their work uh and some of the topics in this course are communication and Leadership introduction to steam so they know what is this thing called steam that we're a part of and an introduction to the career Pathways and the goal is to plan a Booker 101 module for the coming 25 26 school year that will incorporate the rich history and culture of the school to include a study on Booker T Wast in high school historical attendants and and and and uh historic attendants of the school and we plan to call on some not alumni to help us develop that that giv them a significant seat at the table helping them continue to feel like they are part
104of the booger culture that's great the end goal of the steamwork is schoolwide integration of the steam model this means that courses will will integrate not just steam principles and components but will approach those their coursework through that problem based passion based and performance-based uh perspective and just hear some of the work uh that was uh that was mentioned earlier the idea of the problem based practices it'll be a great alignment to to what I know that we're doing as a district in terms of making sure that we are completely aligned and we're working on the goals that the district has set forth for us as relates to State priorities funding practices Etc and as we continue to put these systems in place to support uh support and solidify that integration we're going to continue
105to call on our curriculum leaders to promote seamless and Sate connection between Steam and the Sol objectives because we do know at the end of the day how do the students do well on those attested areas so how do we Infuse Project based and uh passion based and uh uh problem based learning to ensure that we're still meeting the objectives that have been set forth by the state so we keep all this in mind as we're going airgo that monitoring and adjusting as we implement the curriculum uh keep in mind that the implementation of the steamwork is a gradual process where cohorts were introduced yearby year to the steam model the beginning of school year 2728 which is tomorrow will be the first year of full implementation of the steam work where all students will
106be involved in the career Pathways work and steam of curriculum across all the content areas Additionally the 2728 school year will'll see the first set of culminating experiences as well as the first set of students who could graduate with a concrete and and and tangible credential relevant to their chosen uh career pathway it's almost their major as they graduate high school our goal is always to introduce theme to all students at all time so even though we're not officially uh addressing Juniors and seniors in the steam work if they are relevant opportunities we don't deny them that that exposure those experiences to this end we have engaged in some steam and career pathway driven activities uh you'll see here in the PowerPoint uh we have you can if you can make up Miss vdet Spelman
107under the steam field trips title uh we had a number of our students in our CDP and autism program and we wanted to highlight this this uh particular trip because we want to show how we're infusing or exposing all of our students regard regardless of ability level or cognitive level to the benefits of being in a steam infused centered school here uh Miss Spelman and Cynthia Bennett took a group of these students CDP and autism students to attend the agriculture and natural re resource horiculture class in Hampton students were introduced to gardening growing crops and how to best care for plant life uh beginning in October Mr Ed Williams an art teacher to advantage of an opportunity with the NASA hunch program where students are involved in Project based learning in various areas such as
108construction culinary arts and artwork and currently of those students are involved in developing I believe a commercial or video that displays some of the art that represents Aerospace technology so he's been working really really hard with a small group of students that are doing that work as a springboard to even future work so we're excited about the things that he's going to do uh with that particular program and in this month here uh Mr Isaac marrow uh who's the owner of the company boards by q a shk cery board specialist will deliver a talk and demonstration around it around his own story about how he began his own business to support and Advance the hospitality and culinary arts pathway so we're doing a lot of good things in those areas and again always trying to
109make sure that what we put together is practical and realistic and sustainable but at the same time we want things that are out outside of the box kind of thinking so not our regular uh worksheets classwork Etc but things that are going to be different and that will be impactful to our students Dr John hadti noted educational theorist discusses the importance of visible teaching and learning when one enters a classroom student engagement should be evident and the outcomes of that engagement should also be evident given this a steam night is being planned for the month of May 2025 of course everyone will be invited to that particular opportunity this theme night will be a public display of teaching and learning and our Booker prep class and surrounding our career career Pathways the steam night will
110be one of a number of culminating activities for year one of the work and will serve as a bridge to year two Incorporated in this night will be a steam career fair which will be our second career fair we actually had one last year that kind of springboard into this work so we hope to have a bigger and better opportunity uh with more uh uh vendors if you will to be a part of of that career fair an introduction to incoming fresh freshman to continue to bridge the gap between middle and high school and networking with corporate and Community Partners amongst are amongst some of our planned activities so here are our Pathways in the future courses uh through the thorough discussion and research our team decided on six career Pathways based on the recommendations
111made by our our school board in the initial proposal and these areas are specific but they're broad enough to allow some freedom of thought and Discovery uh within the particular pathway and I will share again the Tennessee trip was was a very uh fruitful and beneficial trip because it allowed us to see the importance of having specific Pathways that allowed that latitude of growth but it helped Focus the work that students will undergo so we appreciate the opportunity to be able to go uh to Tennessee and we look forward to more uh more opportunities like that so our pathways are cyber security environmental technology and research hospitality and tourism Human Services Maritime and Aerospace technology and you'll see how those even though Maritime and Aerospace are kind of they're in they're different planes but the
112technology that's involved in both is what brings them together that's why they're in one pathway multimedia arts for commercial design uh the instructional model involves an introduction to the coursework in that particular pathway with subsequent and more advanced courses in the third and fourth years of high school so the first year of high school would be the booker prep class that freshman orientation then in year two would be your intro to culinary art to intro to cyber security with our more advanced courses taking place at the junior senior year at Junior Senior levels and then of course we're going to uh expose our students to Partnerships with with TCC and NTC there's no need to recreate a wheel that's already there en rolling so we're going to use what we already have here in terms
113of the great work here in nor public schools to expose our students to these Pathways at higher levels so career pathway selection is going to be embedded in the booker Prep course so it won't be the separate and apart uh a module or thing that will happen it's a part of the curriculum and work students will choose their Pathways and select their steam courses for their second year as a part of the book of prep uh curriculum during the winter of 2425 so that's happening as getting ready to happen as we speak I just got an email yesterday from one of our counselors asking about uh the career Pathways and what the students knew and where they were in their course so we're excited about that impending work this is done under the guidance of
114the students professional school counselor and it is important to note that the Academy of Arts remains focused on exposing students to the Fine Arts to deepen their proficiency and love for the Arts we always want to ensure that the Arts are not left out but we talk about the a in Steam it's more so about arts for that commercial design and piece and we look at the Academy of Arts exposing students for the Purity and love of the Arts Community Partnerships and EC connections so we'll continue to forge our Partnerships with what we will call or soon call the Steam Community uh as we uh work on uh having Partnerships business community and even philanthropic uh Partnerships we want to be ensure that we give them a label a nomenclature so that way when we
115refer to them we'll know who we're talking about and who we're talking to so they'll be soon so they'll soon to be come to know as our Steam Community this will serve as a network of businesses organizations and individuals who have contributed to the Booker T Washington High School steam work some Partnerships already include n NSU boards by q and noted alumni community members we're particularly excited about a partnership between Booker T and the northw department of storm water risk management through the school's EC Network thank you to Dr White and Miss Jerry Smith and connecting with that department we are planning a steam driven parent student engagement event that gives families the opportunities to kind of come in and get in more insight into how storm water risk management works it's it sounds very
116exciting it's going to be a big map on the floor in the gym and people can actually walk through the city on this map and understand the goods and the bads and positives and negatives of how storm water actually works and how it's managed and what the risks are uh throughout the course of the throughout the the landscape of the city so we're excited about exposing students to that through some talks initially and then having parents to be involved and with our EC connections we're really really focused in this you see our four pillars there and one is uh is uh we are working on our pill one of our pillars which is extended and enrichment learning opportunities through clubs and organizations and where we can be steamy if that makes sense uh we definitely
117incorporate that work but we're looking at the family and Community engagement piece and every time we have the opportunity to incorporate families and communities in the work we do so that way it's a holistic view of what the steamwork is giving parents an opportunity to see what they're students are doing firsthand so our overall goal the overall goal remains unchanged at Booker T Washington High School through the implementation of this work we want to expose our students to a robust curriculum that use steam as a vehicle for career exploration bottom line problem based passion based and Project based learning are the instructional Avenues to promote the 3E framework here's our connection to some of the work that we have to do in terms of being in align with our federal um kind of our federal
118accountability system we're promoting the 3E framework which mean meaning being enrolled in a college after graduation enlisting in the military or being employed in a high wage high demand job after graduation every Booker T Washington High School graduate will have a tangible credential that will support their postsecondary plans and want to be able to not guess what students are going to do but they have a plan I I even told two students today in separate meetings with them and their parents that what's going to be the plan after graduation after you have the cookouts and the graduations and grandma give you $20 you know and you know how it is and you have a good time with your friends that night when you wake up on Monday morning what's going to be the next step
119and we want every student to have that plan and not live in this abyss of unsur and uncertainty we want every Young young man and young lady who walks across Booker te stage to know that they're going to do something that's going to be employable a part of the military or going to the next level in college or postsecondary education so we thank you so much for the opportunity to present to give the update and I apologize for my quick tone I know I talk kind of fast so I do apologize I now stand ready for any questions or comments you may have well school board members you've heard the Booker T uh presentation update Dr Martin thank you principal Garner for your presentation um one of the things that I'm con I'd like to
120hear more about is so you've talked about the um the different areas of uh the what steam represents and the different Pathways that you're introducing um there's a lot of research that shows that you know creativity is um so creativity is really important to problem solving and getting people getting students together Scholars together to from different backgrounds and so I'm wondering if you've planned on areas where they can you know once they get in more involved in the the curriculum their pathway if you're going to um offer some opportunities for some cross collaboration so that that different perspectives they can learn to work with different perspectives and um and because we see right now in technology I mean you pretty soon we'll be growing our own computers right so I mean so all of this
121is really getting intertwined and so so I I just am concerned and I'd like to hear from you your perspective on how you plan to not only have them master and you know Master a particular area but also learn to work with others that they may potentially have to work with as you know as our technology advances and and there's a lot more crossover in the workplace sure your question is timely actually and and I didn't say anything about it because we are literally in the planning stages stages and I'll be more than happy to share the information with you a new earth science teacher M Hillary Thompson come to us from Wisconsin and about a month ago said Mr G I want to plan an exchange opportunity between us and Wisconsin I said wow
122that's pretty that's pretty big it's lofty I said well put it together and you know let's let's see so before the break her task was to give me some bullet points kind of what she was thinking about I said this this was good let me chew on this so long story short we are planning an exchange opportunity um and and trying to incorporate and if this makes sense I'm I'm working really hard I don't want things to be like this on top of this on top of this on top of this on top of this right it has to be a true infusion so whenever there's a program or a project how is this eel CES and title oneish and steam like and how do we bring all these pieces together so so to answer
123to hopefully address your question we're looking for an opportunity for students to be able from Wisconsin to come to us for a week three days either either during the school year or after the school year to be able to walk in to tour and to teach and to learn with some of our students it won't be the entire freshman class or all the Earth students but just the idea that they have the opportunity to hear from others the goal is for those students to travel to Wisconsin and to be able to do the exact same thing so that way they're learning the environmental systems piece Environmental Research and Technology but the perspective is different and it let it does a couple of things one it just broadens their experience because the world is bigger than
124North Virginia or even Virginia of the United States and then two number two it lets them understand that environmental systems research exists in other places and so that becomes the spring board for example if we look at cyber security how does cyber security look in terms of US policy and governance versus maybe another country right and then or let's at the culinary arts and and tourism Hospitality tourism uh pathway how do we do things here in Virginia versus maybe how things are done in Alaska and so we are looking at the idea of crosscultural exchanges or even virtual opportunities where we can you know who do you know in this state who do you know there and let's bring some folks together to be able to have cross crosscultural exchanges to share information to share
125ideas and for students to get a more well-rounded and my favorite word robust experience in Steam and so I do appreciate that so we are looking at opportunity for for the learning that to take place at 1111 Park Avenue how do we extend physically literally and virtually did that address your question yeah all right so so it is on the table you know have we put together a curriculum or a set of activities no but but because of the passion based uh uh learning piece we want to see how we can extend beyond the box and the thinking Works outside the box and so the students can exist outside the box because their world is bigger than the box but I also think that it can start right in your in the school building sure
126at with the four um Pathways that you've already oh yes and then and then a part a part of that is the the schoolwide infusion of the steam process so so the steam approach of problem-based passion based and and and Project based learning becomes you see that in the theater class and you'll see it in the health n class and you'll see it in the English class so it's not just about science and techie and technology and Industry per se but the approach so yes so even within the school building you're exactly right so I hear from my book or prep teacher or from my intro to cyber security teacher what this looks like but I also kind of see the same work in a different fashion in my theater class even in my chorus
127class in my science class and so the the flavoring is different but the food is the same I hope I address your question but the food is the same okay Mr Clanton thank you um and thank you principal Garner for the uh presentation I've got a couple questions um just to add some additional Clarity here um so I see the um the pathways that we have here in future courses um so what is the anticipated completion for full rollout um of all of these different courses I mean I know we've got got so we've got this year one freshman group in and pilot roll out um but you have all of these I guess there's six different Pathways um that you presented here so when will all of those be ready to fully I thank
128you for your question ideally all six will be ready next year because the the the pathway selection is based on student Choice got it so as the entire freshman class is they work and I'll give you an example even today I talked with Miss Chapman who's one of our lead Booker prep teachers they're in the Environmental techn ology systems coursework right now and so they're being exposed to each area before getting to the choosing the pathway uh uh uh kind of closing at toward the end of the year so ideally we'll have work in all six Pathways right and and so now of course that will look at you know if we have no one to choose cyber security that may not be offered because practically it doesn't it wouldn't make sense to offer it
129if no one wants it but it doesn't go away because we have an incoming group for the following year and so then then of course as we Monitor and adjust we may have to retool some p ways well this is just not a popular selection whatever the this may be at that time so but ideally the plan is for all six to be rolled out with their intro level courses more guest speakers more experiences and opportunities so then that dovetails to the other piece that I have so I know that we had an application or something that went out this year right for this first group what do you mean an application this is schoolwide it's schoolwide it's not an academy model so it's schoolwise all freshman any student who's going here has this opportunity
130right okay okay which I will leave this to those who go forward um getting to the broader thing which is creating Choice opportunities because if I'm a student who's zoned to go to norw high school but I would like to be a part of this Academy because it is more in tune and align to my career pathway how do we get there yeah so pushing the envelope to be bold get rid of this attendance P boundage or whatever else so create opport unities for students and parents to create choice so that they can follow their career Pathways um that and I'm not saying that's the thing but I I'm I just wanted to get clarity as to where we are with this um the other thing that I had was um I want and for
131the benefit of the new colleagues that are coming on this board there is still a feasibility study that is sitting on a shelf um and that feasibility study is sitting because we had to finish the curriculum so my question question was about when will the curriculum be done so Fe we'll have this done by when when we say again so the curriculum and instruction team they are committed to having this this was will be ready for our sophomore kids so by next school year oh absolutely so my followup to that one was the teachers will need to be trained over the summer the spring of the school year compon what I'm talking about what I'm talking about is when the professionals from NBA here they told us that we could not move forward with the
132feasibility study until the curriculum was done meaning that you cannot design the school building until the educational component was done and that's not their responsibility that's ours so if we're saying that next school year that the curriculum is done new colleagues board wherever else take this feasibility study off the shelf and get moving on the feasibility study because I'm quite sure with what you're trying to do you may have identified that you need some LA new Labs or some new things to be figured throughout that building fig some things so I'm just raising that up because we we've gone through a period of time um so we can just leave that there that next year once this kin's done that there is a feasibility that has been paid for that we need to move forward
133with Booker T Washington High School um the last thing I had in that one was and I'm glad I love you using the example of the stone water um I've been kind of um Na trying to focus on some new stuff but you know with the city they're talking about all these job opportunities that are sitting in there storm water management um I'm looking at one right now for a permit specialist um you know it's 50 some out, and you've got sign on bonuses and all these other things and I just put a charge back to my colleagues as a whole when we start looking about these career Pathways and some other things here that there are opportunities right at our city level and locally um that we don't want to overlook because City's having
134a hard time trying to fill these positions but I think there's great opportunities for some of our students if we can TR to get that into the conversation that these things don't require a four or even a twoyear um but the same certifications that I know Miss Goan has been talking about and that we that we come every year with our students at their opportunities but I appreciate everything that um to have you um come in midy year um have run um and and gotten this thing running and I want people to understand that literally got here in January six months to you know to end out of a school year had a summer and then be ready for a freshman to come in and to have something for them to go so I think
135you should be commended along with your team for that nothing's perfect but I'm glad that we're still moving along with this but I just reiterate that this is one drop in the bucket for what I believe should be a much larger discussion about when we talk about school um consolidation whatever that stuff may be but how do we move northa Public Schools forward and have a better relationship Cityside and whatever else moving forward so that we meet the needs of our Workforce and for the city moving forward so that's my two Miss ping and then Mr Paulson um I'll let our go thank you thank you uh principal Gardner uh I just have a suggestion on on one of your Pathways and that's the environmental one okay yes sir um have you considered working with
136uh the Virginia Institute of Marine Science it's called vims yes oh yeah on the Eastern Shore yes sir okay oh yes sir it's in there uh cvf the ches pig Bay Foundation they they do tours they they put on education these are mostly groups that do education and they may work for you and they may not but I just bring them up yes yes sir I'm I'm I'm logging okay uh Wetlands watch which is a an environmental advoc advocacy group that they deal with only uh problems in in the wetlands area yes and then Noah Noah yes right right down the street and then Erp Elizabeth River Project yes okay all right good thank you and if you don't mind I'll ask I may reach out to you or can you send me that I
137don't want the wetlands watch what I'm not familiar with okay so I would like some more information about that so we can we can you know try to incorporate right they they they Center only on on Wetlands where some of these others CBF particularly they're they cover fish and and other indeed the environment and and if this is connected I know with that it was Consin exchange what I'm calling it right now it when that happens we're looking at having our guests to come in to have some Watershed experiences and so I know that that's been a a large part of our curriculum over the years since I was a teacher in Hampton and Newport News so I just know that that and even now I know some of our students they they they have
138those experiences so I'm hoping that that's part of maybe some of the group that you're that you're talking about but yeah definitely I would like that information right and things like the vims they they have programs that run unfortunately in the evenings and on weekends but or you know they can come to you also yes but they but they also give you Hands-On train uh experience yes I appreciate that yes sir okay I appreciate yes sir thank you very much thank you very much sir sorry back to you thank you um so he touched on a little bit of what I wanted to get to but before um I get to that so big picture this is a board you know for the board you know every time we have an ed planning uh discussion
139facilities discussion programming new school programming discussion I'm big picture what are we what are we doing in the district and how does one program impact another and you know I'm all for Choice expanding this allowing other students to have the opportunity to access um the curriculum um and I in a you know that's something I would really love to see um because I was going to ask about you know application selection process and what that looks like cuz I I believe we have um and Dr bson correct me if I'm wrong are we currently allowing um like if an out of District student wants to uh attend Booker T Washington are we for for this program have we have not closed out a district Booker T okay Washington High School but specific for the program
140is what what I mean like well that's not something that's come up yet not even with the board of course that would be you know something that would be disclosed to you on a report like a reason for an out of District transfer okay I thought we had one that's why I'm asking new and so no we haven't explored that but it's certainly something we would be open to okay okay so you know I would would like to hear more of that but it sounds like right now it's just it I think this is the springboard like uh like board member Clanton said I think this is the springboard for for that type of work uh right across the water of Hampton has been doing a phenomenal job for a sustained number of years in
141the Academy's model and and and and not just a steam model in terms of but I mean the robotics program has been longstanding since I was a student there 1995 right and you and then they their culinary arts program in the same building high school then with the legal studies and the health study Healthcare studies and then have the Performing Arts at at kikan high school so the model is it's it's very much active and alive and well so this could very well be that springboard and even in Walker Valley uh uh High School in Tennessee that's what we saw we saw where because of the the size of the school buildings you know I mean it was a brand new facility I mean a multi-million dollar facility and and that where there was literally
142a Freshman Academy hallway and then there was a there there was uh the legal studies pathway hallway and then there was the cyber security hallway and so not to say that we have to duplicate that model but this starts as a springboard to get to that and so I think success at this level is what will get us to that o opening the doors to any student who wants to come to Booker T to be a part of the steam work and or the Academy of the Arts just like the IB program at grany high school or the military Sciences Academy I believe at at Lake Taylor high school so it's so I very much think it's very much a possibility right yes and and I think the intentionality behind it is what is going
143to be critical because because you know when I hear um you know the the six Pathways that you have there um and just wondering you know how many students would sign up for each pathway but if you plan for each pathway you have Partnerships with you know for instance what I do want to hear more about Partnerships with Nori state with their cyber security like having you know where are has that partnership been established you know because I know dual enrollment is part of the plan like what does the big scope look like and where are we um in terms of getting to that point if we're rolling this out next year where are we currently with with those Partnerships um so that day one you know if that's the intent then like where are
144we in that process and I'll share with you if I just as a point of clarification it's already being rolled out so we're already in the work and we're already doing that and we are preparing for year one of these of the intro courses fortunately we have the intro courses kind of already here when in terms in terms of establishing the Partnerships those will be your guest speakers the field trips the experiential activities that will support what happens in the classrooms and so we are s we're putting that together kind of now you know it's and I I my favorite phrase has become we're building the airplane in the air and so as we're flying we're trying to figure out kind of what needs to happen and What needs to occur to make sure that
145it's saing and always practical so that way we're not kind of thinking above our our means and I know one of my personal areas of of improvement in work is that sometimes I am a big thinker I'm a big I'm a big big Visionary like I want to turn the entire first floor into the steam lab I mean the all four wall all four areas and you know because we've had some mention of working with some other organizations newship building is one nothing concrete but just possibilities of partnership and having establishing a maritime lab and establishing a cyber security lab you know in various areas and then kind of replacing and and and you know moving some other folks but that's that's the big picture thinking but in order to get there we want to
146be really focused in terms of the true Partnerships with our guest speakers and our part in our funding mechanisms and uh site visits and team visits so like I shared with you earli we have a partnership and I'm calling it a partnership that's what it is through the NASA hunch program and hunch it had I don't know what the acadm stands for forgive me but I know it's a it's an opportunity where students in various schools throughout the state of Virginia have the opportunity to compete and develop projects in culinary arts in the Arts in media and in instruction that are all uh Aerospace connected M Yolanda Simmons is our contact there we've been working really really hard so we're formulating that partnership so as we're doing that work we're saying hey can we get
147a field trip oh sure come on so we're just kind of we're getting ourselves kind of in that door and opening the door uh similarly with norol State University we haven't gotten into the cyber security uh portion yet but we have the mentors from various departments in the school we're just we're getting in the door and having true uh kind of ground Roots up if that makes sense uh partners so that way we have a sustainable relationship with the school and the building I know we have Mr Jordan here who's definitely going to be a resource and and I know we have some other folks who are alumni in our school building who are resources and so we're going to use those opportunities kind to get in that door so that that's where we are
148now okay okay and do we still so Nori Public Schools used to have a partnership with the National Science and Math initiative the nimy and we used to so but so I was going to ask if we currently had that uh that Grant you know that program that we were able to provide you know AP expand AP opportunities and yeah so we we we haven't had nimsey for a few years now um actually Mr Brady and I talked about it just a few months ago to see if if it's something we can resurface or not it's changed a lot and there's some costs involved so we're looking at it has um uh but it is not an active Grant Force right now the nimsy portion yeah so yeah so some of the things that they're
149offering I noticed could um be useful so I was curious what sort of partnership we had with them if if at all um right I'll let others ask questions Mr George yeah I appreciate the presentation and the update I just want to say at least to the to the board and administration I guess my understanding or perhaps misunderstanding was that um that the comprehensive steam at Booker T was going to provide for uh student Choice into uh into Booker T um as as part of the the fact that we were having uh high schools that had different acmis but the opportunity for um for the Booker T steam was a comprehensive Steam School that was being added to the mix that would not only serve the existing attendance Zone but would also have seats available
150for students throughout the city that had had interest there so I would just like to encourage the board to go back and revisit that I um pulled up the the 2017 memo I didn't probably can go back and look at the the resolution but I'm pretty confident that as part of that educational planning that's where that grew out of and that it was supposed to provide for additional opportunities especially as we were looking at uh enrollment patterns and um and potential seats seats available so I just don't want to see that get get dropped and uh and just kind of pushed pushed along so uh I just hope we can revisit that and take another look at that on the Staffing side um can you talk a little bit more about um as you see
151this growing uh any I don't want maybe mismatch is not the right word but what what is it that you are doing now with some intentionality trying to make sure that you have the Staffing with the requisite credentialing and experience is in order to support the curriculum and the coursework that you have in mind good question and thank you for the question the courses that that we've offered that we've designed and planned are courses that are already taught at Booker T so we have an intro to cybercity course there is an environmental science course that's on the books that we can teach uh we do have a forensic science one course that kind of slide in you know another area if we need to we have introduction to culinary arts we have introduction to the
152Arts as a matter of fact through TCC we have freshmen that are taking a dual enrollment art 100 course and attempt to kind of support them having uh uh Associates degrees of fun graduation so the courses that we're offering they're not brand new courses that just haven't been out there we're just kind of we're funneling them and putting them under this steam umbrella to be that that first year so in terms of credentialing these are courses that are already being taught that have people assigned to them and so it's just a matter of just the more training to make sure that we're marrying the curriculum of that course with that Project based and and and and pro problem based uh instruction yeah I'm asking I appreciate that I guess I'm trying to get a sense
153of as we expand as you expand as you grow not not the base not where you are now but as you look at the pathways and the curriculum and the offerings and the uh differentiator that will make the Booker T steam program you know the demand steam program in the state as you were talking about the different Pathways and um uh in Opportunities that's that's where I'm trying to figure out is it have you begun that process of really thinking about the match between the teaching skill set or the instructional skill set that you need that would align with the offerings that you would like to make available to to students I have two answers the first answer is I would say yes and I and maybe maybe it was you Mr Jordan in our
154June meeting it was mentioned that let's not forget the jewels that we have having our own backyard which means to use Norfolk State and to use NTC I mean I'm TCC and NTC because those courses are already being taught by the qualified professionals under the dual enrollment format the students are being uh transported there there's no need to create a wheel that's already rolling and and so so that's the first answer is the answer is yes we already have what's there a matter of pulling it together and making it fit and making it make sense now the second answer would be as we continue to grow and discuss and plan there may be some new and fabulous courses that we have not thought of yet so it would be incoming upon us to to propose
155the courses to see what's already kind of on the books if you will in terms of the state of Virginia and then find the folks who would be willing to and able to teach those courses at those higher levels so so the answer is yes I think we have it in norfor public schools through our already existing Partnerships through the work at Norfork State and what a great way for us to expand those Partnerships Northfolk State even old University even Virginia Tech through virtual learning depending on the course and then of course TCC NTC Etc and then be open enough to to be able to propose and and and and and create new courses that'll meet new needs because our class now won't look like the class in five years right so what those needs
156will be what those Pathways will be so we're just going to be open to to that work in terms of intentionality the answer is yes and in that three-day planning session and and I feel like not to put on the SP I think it was Miss go who reminded us hey don't forget we have courses that are already on the books that are offered here that we can utilize not just the springboard but to be those Advanced courses for for these selections so so we have the richness already here one thing we learned again in Tennessee was that a lot of what we're doing is already in the pathway it's already on this course it's just organizing it and putting that shell around it yeah and I and I asked that in part because you
157know we we see the uh HR reports and we know that there school I think the last one I recall looking at that you may have some uh vacancies that you're trying to fill in biology they may be filled now but I just I just think important that um that you consider laying that out now sir and that the uh and that the board Administration give you the supports that you need and whatever resources that you need to be able to retract and retain that talent and being able being able to grow it and not constantly trying to chase behind the ball so to speak being being out in front of that thank you for that sir the last question maybe somewhat related to that um can you explain again you you made a comment
158earlier I think you were given it in the context of cyber security and student choice and that um that the student um that the student Choice may drive the course offerings that I understand that correctly yes so a part of the work is that it that the initiative has to be student driven and and when it say student student driven when we look at we have the six offered Pathways and we want to offer experiences in every pathway so that way they can make it students can make an educated Choice based on interest passion and just overall just excitement about that particular area you know unlike College where we kind of go and think I want to major in math or I want to major in English I was a pre-law major I ended up
159being a Spanish major you know that that was that was the goal but of course times change and people change and things change so as opposed to saying well here are your prescribed areas choose one we're kind of doing that but we find that if an interest isn't in a particular place and we find that for a number of years then we may need to retool and rethink what we offer because if students aren't interested in an area we need to let's find something that is interesting to students that can be profitable and that can be marketable for them to be in college and that can be used in in a military in military uh portion so my point is cyber security was just an example if there's a particular pathway that's that students show
160no interest in why continue to offer and poor resources into that when we can kind of retool and rethink Monitor and adjust I'm I'm not smart enough to to to speak to that but I'll just tell you a a a concern I have with with that description so in one sense we are trying to make sure that we are exposing students to New Opportunities yes we are you're clearly trying to make connections between what is in demand in the workforce and future opportunities that may be in demand and so I don't know how to articulate it but it understand where you're com from some some hesitancy around was trying to get out I think maybe it's a maybe it's a dual path there's what the students want and then there's um uh uh creating the
161the knowledge and exposure and the passion so that students will find courses and and opportunities attractive and that that's I just wrote that down because it because it caught my attention and you know just as one who has you know spent my whole life dealing with uh stem stuff um you know you g ask a whole lot of students today about math and they answer go I don't have any interest in it right but once you get the exposure to how can it be applied what it relates to the math behind the math algorithms behind Tik Tok and all other kind of things then it then it may engender a whole different level of passion and I would just hate for us to miss the opportunity to Spur that um creativity and that imagination and
162just simply base things off of student Choice es or student desire especially in the early early early part of the program and to your point it's not a one and done and when I say that it's that well since students don't like it we Chuck it that that's not what we're saying at all we have to make the consideration after and mind you after they have been exposed to all the pathways through the coursework through the experiences guest speakers so on and so forth students have an opportunity to choose based on what they've experienced our goal is to make those experiences Rich experiences so that way they can have make an educated choice and we're very much aware that you know these are 14 and 15 year olds that are making these selections and you
163know they'll change their mind as as you know as the time changes and we we aware of that and so there is a level of uh uh um inflexibility if that makes sense that's involved but if we're finding that there's an area that's not getting any traction that's something we have to at the very least consider so so no I don't and forgive me I'm not trying to say that oh no one likes let's get it out of there but that's something that's that's that qualitative data that we look at as we continue to grow the program thank you Dr Mar I just want to um going off of what Mr Jordan was saying and I I agree with them on that that you know but um I think it's a really good opportunity as
164we're transitioning we keep transitioning is to build that maybe into a summer program like an orientation summer program so that the CH you're not waiting until they start as a freshman you're you're getting them you're getting they're getting exposure over the summer and you know because I'd hate for them to not be interested and start the school year like GH what am I what have I got myself into type thing so and long range Vision again my my my my big thinking would be between an infusion between High School and Middle School eighth grade work and a summer transition program that this would happen there and it would that that this book of prep experience would be in a continuation of their eighth grade work and if I understand I don't want to misquote I
165not in conversation with Miss Fleming who's the principal of Ruffner uh Academy is that there is a a similar type of uh exploratory course exploratory program we want to latch on to that and begin the work there continue it during the summer as opposed to having a one and two day freshman transition experience let's make it a rich experience so that way when selection time comes in December of that that particular year students have had all of the opportunities to look at what they want to do going into the next school year so definitely agree with you yes ma'am yes m b i was goingon to say I I personally really love the idea of the booker prep you know having that year even the transition to high school yeah is uh is a big
166deal for many of our foru all of our students um so and I like the exploratory opportunity at that ninth grade level you know but I also you know start building that exploration into the middle school programming and you know so that they and of course you know it is my hope that we're going to open it up and offer it to anyone who could come in and um who has an interest in uh you know the steam Pathways that are being offered at if the will of the board will make it work yeah and the other thing is you know I'm going to go back to I I had picked up on that uh too and when I was asking about the intentionality of the programming around the pathways yes and the Partnerships with
167you know our highered partners and um you know I I can't stress that enough that i' I'd like to see that and that the board you know really support um support and encourage that there is strong intentionality around the pathways um and and to support that um and to build that out now you know and if we're not ready to not put it out there until we are ready we're ready yeah yeah um so I appreciate that um all right that's so for me yeah Mr Clanton I'm just G to leave this parting word um parting word on this particular topic here because I mean just hearing the discussion here I'm you know I'm somewhat disappointed um but I would hope that the board would be bold enough to really and I think that Mr
168Jordan going back to some of the stuff that you were talking about and I think you you said about we talk about head planning um I think that there needs to just be a uni voice from the board to say at some point we want to change the way we do education and try to if it means that we go to a Career Academy model or we bring some professional in here that look I mean I know that we we're looking at right now which really just seems to be about physical structures but it goes back to the same thing when I'm sitting here thinking about NBA when they were talking about the feasibility study in Booker T well that's not what we do you got to have the curriculum first and then we'll come
169back and and do the building to me I still feel like there students going to be losing out if you're not zoned to go to Booker te or you now have to come before the board that creates a barrier we need to be removing barriers and creating opportunities and the only way we do that is by being bold and robust across the division and seeing at a high school level that needs to be the focal point that create opportunity across we're creating cies or whatever else or whoever's model is but creating and that everything moves with that and as we start talking about school consolidation and whatever else down there now you've got a a vision that the board has said that we're going to work towards that will help us make the decisions about
170what schools and things and how those things align I just I I just can't and I know we got to get to other piece but that's just on my mind and all my heart that we got to be bold um and I'm sitting here reading you know and I don't care if it's not if it's not the for nextg learning which is what Hampton use or somebody else's model there needs to be something because I already see us right now being slipping right back into a thing and not saying anything what you're doing principal Garner but I can very easily see us getting back into a per school yeah thing here and not being bold and students still missing out we want to keep kids in school same thing all I hear is my nephew's
171voicing me Uncle see how do you know kids so school's boring well you know it's boring because they're not excited about it unless they get into something music was my thing technology was my thing how do we reach kids and how do we get them in here and where they want to come to school and we make that connection I still didn't hear and I wasn't going to drag it out here about the curriculum piece you know and I think I heard Miss go talked about we were starting to do that through some of our schools and I think Del we had went through where if you're doing cyber security then you know you're doing your math and your science and social studies and English teachers are creating lesson plans that dovetail and support so
172that just like I think what you were just saying Mr Jordan and respect that it Peaks the attention well now it makes it practical and and makes a real reality why I need to care about geometry if I'm doing criminal justice because I need to map out a crime scene I I just want to say that we got to be bold and I think we need a look big picture how do we you know um how do we address that and and coming out in a different way yeah before you get to the schools and and all this other stuff this bolded big time at that level so I'll be quiet if I'm a Norview High School school student and I want to study cyber security or military science or military science I should be
173able to you know go to book or two Washington High School to get yeah but you got to take this I don't just think it's I we have to change I love these discussions but I get i i i some resolution and we did before I'm sitting you trying to find it it's in the resolution no I'm saying that the the whole any kid where we where we started was doing just where you were we were looking at the the specialty programs we did an assessment analysis of inequities and gaps that existed between the programs we saw that we had three high schools that were more reust and two high schools that weren't and and being bold in what you described is where we were and I just um would would would agree with what
174you said and that um and that as you have to you have to create the desire you have to create the desire and what I see here is a leader who is creating the desire you're laying the groundwork and when you lay that groundwork and you get these students excited there is no better referral process than one student telling another student I'm here and I really like what I'm doing and you need to come here or a mom to say my kid is waking up and they want to go to school and and then you start to hear the chitter chatter and so what I see here is you're laying the foundational piece which is very critical uh and then these items right here which it speaks to the bigger vision of of where the
175board wants to go then you can incorporate that into the process you've got to create that that winning model and that's what I see you doing with your Partnerships and your curriculum and driving that desire so I I think you're you're you're on the right track um we just have to put those things in place for when um you know the students can apply and we can really leap off into that Academy model we have we have the infrastructure it's there it's just we got this the the community survey that we received the report on in 2023 uh should the steam program be open Citywide 92.3% yes 7.7% no and we've been talking about that from that's why that's why it caught my attention when it was saying that it was going to be that
176because I believe that was always the the intent so we can talk about it in two weeks all right hey thank you very much have a wonderful even up here thank you thank you so much all right we are down to our last item someone who's not um shy to the the podium right welcome back on our agenda 4.01 Schoolboard policy review Dr birsa yes so to conclude the evening our last agenda item is around um our cell phone policy for at Public Schools as everyone is aware in July of this year our governor governor yunan put forward uh executive order number 33 um and has provided guidance for cell phone free education pursuant to this executive order the Administration has worked to develop a policy a draft policy around um cell phone free education
177within norit Public Schools um this is our second reading today and so Dr pole is will provide some information related to survey results and we're happy to receive feedback from the board thank you Dr Birdsong and good evening getbody um as Dr Birdsong said this is our second review typically with a second review there's not a lot of discussion we we just it's open to the community again but given the nature of this policy and the amount of feedback we got we thought it was appropriate to share a little bit more information so um Within anticipated vote at the December business meeting I wanted to share that um as of November 20th when we Clos the survey just so we can get some data work done um to post it in time for the the
178board's requirements um there was a 625 comments already at that point um in this overview um you'll notice the overview that was posted there were there were five categories um safety and emergency concerns which had 61 of the comments distraction and academic focus with 98 of comments um compromise and moderation with 265 of the comments which shows you a lot and really in that area the majority of the comments were totally get it don't want it during the classroom but really want it during Hall changes in cafeteria unfortunately executive order 33 is very clear Bell to Bell open of school to close of school um so that that's that decision's kind of driven for us um parental monitoring and trust with 119 of the comments and then policy criticism and broader issues just with 82
179of the comments those are the ones that were just this this you know the the policy is ridiculous why would you do this kind of kind of comments in there um and then on the bottom of that page there was a you know a graphic that just showed you the percentage of of where each of them fell um I'm not planning to go through all 625 comments um for the sake of time but I did give you the overview sheet and just really wanted to to bring it back up for a second reading um so that the the community knows that it it it's still out there and and you know comments are still welcome before the vote on the 18th um and I would like to add that a survey has gone to all
180middle and high school students um talking about the implementation of the policy because really you know if we sent students and said what do you think about the policy we know what they're going to say um that that we want our cell phones in schools but it's really around how is the implementation going to be affected um and and what's what do they see as best practice and what feedback can they get can they give us so we're collecting that information right now all right well you've heard um let me go Mr Clanton Miss bassine did I see and Dr Gabriel and Mr Paulson and then Mr Jordan okay let's do this again just go just go around Mr Clanton we'll come back around this way great thank you uh chair Buffalo um I just
181want to make a couple clar clarifications up here I know that the division's already started rolling out some marketing and and some social things around there but Bell tobell well first of all this is coming from the governor this is an executive order that may potentially roll into something else from from the um state board of education but right now it's an executive order um and most importantly is that we're not saying that they can't bring their phones but that the phone has to be turned off and stored in their backpack correct correct so I know that there's a major concern about um whether or not you know if you know we hear so many things about active Shooters and so many different things like that and parents are concerned about being able to reach
182their um their child but they would still be able to have this device so even if they we have walkers like my niece is a walker um from um from Blair she could still have her device turn it on on her way home still be able to track her when she's leaving the school um and and that sative measure there um the other thing is is that I guess there's been some concern about being a to utilize phones because like a lot of us were in school we we pull calculator out we didn't have no phones we had a pager um didn't have that I didn't go that far back that was a bad thing I mean that wasn't like that I mean but 82 to be specific was I know that some individuals because
183I've I've heard it about you know in some of our buildings um internet is it's is um sporadic it's you know we have some issues there and so devices have been used to be able to to do some things to get on the internet to um be able to use a calculator function and some other things there so um but again the executive order says no correct this is not an offer public school thing we're doing this policy to be in Conformity with the executive order correct okay that was mine are you trying to go other way you tring Mr Paulson um I noticed that there's no uh consequences for not complying is that going to be in the final draft or or is this what we're going to see on the 18th so that
184this is what you'll see on the 18th consequences aren't aren't generally in policy those go in the student handbook um okay so so uh consequences have been uh um have been worked on and created I don't know if I grabbed that document off my desk I did what about how was how was the notice of the survey done so the the we did a few surveys so uh on October we did an initial survey around the policy notice was done through robocalls through all social media channels um that we have um when we did the policy um you know feedback than that was done through again robocall social media channels um and now the student surve that we've done we've uh social media um and it was also directly emailed to every student through their
185student email address too okay I be just because of the the reason I asked a question is the number of responses to this very significant uh action is is is very small and I'm just making sure that that we have done as as a as a board as a school done the right thing to get as many people involved as possible because there will be tons of other comments coming after this goes out for sure to to add Mr Paulson um we've also done uh uh PSA um so we've done a public service announcement video that's gone out we've done it in English and Spanish um um and we've asked principes as well to um work with students and maybe give a little class time in health and PE or something like that so students
186have the opportunity to to give input um as well um and the six the 625 that that we had pulled at this point um it is is with with our the amount of student population it's a small number however when it comes to policy usually we get about three so you can tell how much more involved they are and in knowledgeable of this policy coming out and about than than other policies well thank you and your staff for for your efforts appreci If the parents are not going to respond or but we still need to move forward so thank you my next okay um one of so I have you know two high schoolers and who are on their phones constantly so this is a b battle at home as well as in school um
187I'm I'm really a supporter of this policy and um the Bell to Bell and I know there was a lot of comments about what about using it in their um lunch time in their uh Hall time or lunchtime and and I I don't agree with that um there's another component um you know of course we we talked about the um educational component them being on their phones being distracted um but there's also the mental health and physical health component um and the way that the cell phones are being being used in in um in the hallways and and in the cafeterias and I'm not saying about by all students but we did see an increase in um bullying fighting videoing the fighting um you know picking fights to be on video you know and and
188it it's horrific and a few of us here had attended the v a vsba uh conf or Symposium earlier this year and the statistics were heartbreaking and the one that stuck out for me was that bullying was it bullying among females was up 146% since 1990 when cell phones became more U popular we have to do something to make sure that these children are safe and then to the comment of safety in our schools meaning I'm going to have to get a hold of my student when they're in lockdown well if they're in lockdown and you're calling your student stent whatever that threat is is going to know exactly where your student is right I that is not safe so these are just the areas that are standing out to me and and I I
189so I 100% support the executive order as written the policy as we discussed it in the policy committee um and I hope that uh the rest of my colleagues will as well we're going around we're just going around this way okay um so I've had some really great conversations with people um about this executive order and the um suggested policy that we have here and really um I mean I think you'd be surprised about what some of our students have to say about it um not necessarily what you might assume um and so right now the responses that we have in front of do not include students they do oh they do it was open for every just put it out there were several first person comments like I want to keep my phone and
190those were clearly students okay because I know we got some emails but I just wanted to be sure that that information has already been captured absolutely all right um so one of the one big concern is enforcement right so what impact this is going to have on our teachers and administrators in terms of enforcing it so so you know we have we've had a cell phone policy in place it has no teeth it has you know that that it's taken up so much instruction time instructional time that teachers just I think they lost the battle you know be or chose not to uh engage in that battle because it was taking away from instructional time what does enforcement of this look like so no matter what it's gonna it's going to take time it's going
191to take time of employees to enforce the policy so the the enforcement goes with the first is a is a verbal warning and contact to the parents you know just just put it away um the second is verbal warning or the second is verbal warning or written warning rather send something home to the parents um then the third they it gets confiscated by the office and held in the office until a parent comes to pick it up um and that process will continue um to to be picked up the prior to holiday break there will be information going home to all students and parents um that they sign off on and when a parent has to come get a phone a cell phone they uh if there's not ass signed you know understanding of the
192policy and the and the enforcement of it they'll be required to sign off it before they get the phone back um so you know it's going to be a matter of you know some of this will likely turn into insubordination um as well so there it's going to be it's going to be hard to enforce I'm not sugar coating that it's going to be hard to enforce yeah so so we kind of really don't know until we we start I mean we we have we're starting to see that since you've already you know started um implementing it but um what do you what do you can you share what you are hearing from your building principles and right now um as it relates to the implement so we some of our High School principles and
193some of our middle school principales started at the beginning of this year just kind of foreshadowing where we were going um and you know and the the toughest Parts aren't in the classroom the toughest parts are in the hallway in the cafeteria okay okay and have they come back with any suggestions or um anything that may not come through in these comments but you know through your principal meetings or so we met specific speically with High School principles and Middle School principles and some Elementary School principles when we develop the policy and the um and the consequences for the policy so we had feedback directly from principles on on putting this into place so that it was done with a very collaborative effort right and does does so I was looking I was going back
194to the executive order does the phone have to be off yes okay it has to be turned off not away okay on not on your person okay in the backpack well yeah but as soon as so like Mr Clinton did your your point earlier as soon as the last bell of the Day rings they then it they can grab it and they can turn it on because so many of our students are active in school they might be going to marching band might be going to you know field hockey or whatever it might be they might be walking home whatever it may be so they want to have that communication so that's the Bell to Bell part okay and if there you need it for instructional person purposes how is that going to work so
195it's off it's for instructional purposes it's off so they they have the the Chromebooks and the technology and the schools for that but certainly if there's a child with an IEP or 504 accommodations plan sure like a medical need that that will all be beess exemptions extion yeah I I guess you know and I think uh we had a student speaker at our last board meeting speak to it and you know I hear it from students all the time also having um school to students in the school system but the different ways that the phone is used in a instructional manner um and so I do have concerns about that um and that is our infrastructure strong enough to do all the things that some of our students are using their phones for for instruction
196C purposes um before we start putting this in place so that's that's a concern and then the other concern is the communication plan around this because I know a lot of the comments um you know there's still clearly a lack of understanding about what the executive order is actually telling us but I think they also people need to understand what the consequence of not following the executive order what that is um if we were to say we're not going to put you know we're not going to follow that so you know I'd like to hear more about that too yeah so so that's so that's where we've already started with the public service announcements that's where we're starting with when the um when the information goes home before the break it will have the consequences
197right on it um for the parents and the students to sign off on so we're starting that we're starting that already even before the policy's been voted on um just saying this is what the policy is about and this is this is where we're going with it and we'll continue that in into the new year clearly and then understanding all the different ways that the phones have been used for instructional purposes and making sure that you know I know you're saying they have access to the Chromebooks and they have this and that but does making sure that every child truly has access to you know a device if needed and also you know the other thing is the phones aren't going away I mean so we're also missing an opportunity to create digital you know
198the the digital safety piece um I think is critically important so you know I I struggle with it because I I know those phones are being misused as well and I know the dangers around it from a mental health standpoint um but I also know that there needs to be they're not going anywhere so there needs to be some real intentional effort around digital safety and um how to use these phones in a way that's beneficial and not destructive so I just say that okay Madam chair just because it's 6:31 i' just like to move without objection that we extend another 10 minutes we got a 6:30 time ad German okay I'll second I'm sorry don't me to take time off for you just you do two three minutes huh no it's talking yeah we
199can do a hard stop at 6:45 6:45 okay U thank you um the cell phone is definitely here to stay and it's just going to evolve and it would be wonderful if we could teach our children and our parents how to use it properly uh because there are lots of benefits um to the technology that we have have in our hand uh we have um kids using it who have diabetes that help to alert their blood sugar or it keeps track of the number of steps that they're taking um their water intake and so there there's lots of benefits for it but unfortunately what um I have heard loud and clear from lots of teachers uh and others is that it is such a distraction in the classroom that it is impeding high quality teaching
200learning and our Focus um which is I believe the uh reason for why the governor has come down and you know made this decree is because he wants to be able to say for all of the schools within Virginia not just nor public schools because we're going through this Virginia Beach is going through this suffk Newport News we're we're not unique um but we've we've got to be able to kind of put some guide guidelines around the phones and I think what you have come up with here is um it's a good first step and I know it's going to be a work in progress I would encourage you all to reach back out to your principles and to directly message the students to say you have something in your email I really would like
201for you to send in a response uh because we do value their feedback in fact I'm going to go home and make sure that my kids have responded to the survey uh because we we want to know what they're thinking because sometimes they have some thoughts that we've never even considered and they're they're great thoughts um I would um and you probably have already done this put some dates on the calendar to revisit the plan once it's been initiated so January 1 policy rolls out and you're going to get a lot of feedback and so have something on the books already with teachers and your your um Senate group Dr bird song and your student Advisory Group that says we we want to make sure that we're getting some feedback on this because I I
202definitely see it as a work in progress um and let me see I I do agree that we need to have a very strong finger on the pulse of the Technologies technology ability and the Wi-Fi capability Within of our buildings and there are some challenges that we have with buildings built with cinder blocks that I know that we cannot you know overcome but to the extent that we can use any of these maybe onetime funds to really secure up our infrastructure for the technology capability um I I definitely see that being a need because you know Desmos is just a calculator that comes to mind that I know that they have to use in middle school and in high school and they're pulling it up on their phone and then of course the other component
203to it is all of the um the after school activities that have apps the sports hu and the remind and the dojo and all of that um to send messages to the students about the activities and things that are I I I'm sure there's going to be or if not there there there has already been discussion about okay how are we going to message our students so that way they get information in a timely manner um because of the Athletics and the after school activities so that's it thank you for those two things the phone after school yeah they can use the phone and we're just oh right but I'm saying like sometimes we get reminders you know then we'll have to go um such and such you know is not working so the game
204is going to be CH going from this time to this time um and I I know they'll send alert to the parents but you know for the kids I just have to go back old school announcements from the main office at the end of the day that's right um also I'm quickly say that we talk about the phones but we also have to talk about any electronic device that con connects to the Internet so there's a lot of kids are going to get some of these for Christmas um headphones that connect and those kind of things so it's just not just the the phone but actually anything electronic that can connect to the Internet so um all those devices Mr Jordan yeah um attorney Fox I'm coming to you uh you got to turn your
205little light on C can you just um I know we're referencing the the governor's executive order can you just remind me again of the executive order in in terms of providing guidance versus the executive order being able to uh uh make make local decisions can you just kind of Flesh that out for me again Mr Jordan the executive order as you say it directs various state agencies to direct to issue guidance toward a policy that's essentially the policy that you have in front of you uh it doesn't specifically say that I recall I've read it a couple times over last week doesn't specifically say no more cell phones in schools it says cell cell phones cause these various problems mental health problems educational problems the people that work for me I'm directing you to to
206issue this guidance on how to implement a cell phone free educational policy throughout the Commonwealth um and then there's a longer document issued by the vdoe that gets a little bit more granular even down to the elementary school middle school high school level um I think we've gone with a simplified approach of just saying Bell to Bell as as a Dr Paul says which which in the guidance is referred to as school day but essentially the same concept um but uh in terms of are you asking you know sort of who decision is it and where's the authority lie it's it's a it's the local board ultimately I would I would think but I just wanted to make sure just in terms as it's being referenced as though the guidance is the guidance I I
207don't have any real objection to what we're trying to achieve but I just wanted to get some personal Clarity around uh things that come from the executive office that are guidance documents versus those things that are mandates like when we had a state of emergency and there were mandates that came versus guidance that still gives the local school board some some flexibility I just want to make sure much more of a gray area there Mr Jordan I agree with you okay all right thank you um specific to the to the policy um maybe I'll go to the second item I have first on the on this question of um enforcement or uh disciplinary approaches so doct Paul I I just want to ask your Clarity so I thought I heard you say that the letter
208may go out explaining the the enforcement process or the discipline process and that there may be items put in the code of conduct associated with that can you just clarify what the proposed discipline process is sure sure sure so the first offense is a verbal warning communicate it with the parent of the guardian and entered into Synergy um the second offense is a written warming something uh sent home communicated with parent of guarding and again entered into Synergy on the third offense the cell phones confiscated um or the device is confiscated um and it can be returned to the the parent at the uh or to the student at the end of the school day entered into Synergy fourth offense confiscated and then it's um entered into Synergy but a parent has to pick it
209up and then it repeats the parent has to continually come back to school okay yeah I I um um I don't know if that falls in a regulation to the policy but it seems to me there should be as part of this process the board should be clear on this is the policy and this is the administrative handling of the process I hate to say discipline but the administrative handling of it as I looked at some other examples like I just happened to pull up Hampton City Schools um procedures that they put out so they include a discipline process and they're very similar to what you described some other school divisions have done that and I'm not sure we should just leave it up to whatever may get placed in the handbook because typically what
210gets placed in the handbook to my frustration is pretty much the whole uh policy Manual of the school system as relates to to student discipline so if these if this process is going to be attached to the policy then I think we should attach it to the policy whether it's in a regulation of implementation of the policy or whe in the policy itself and um and not leave that to bifurcation the the other thing is um in the policy I know we include um the definitions of the school day and we tie it to the staggers I would almost recommend that that that piece also go into a regulation because you know the staggers are what they are now and if they change for any reason it just seems to me that it just adds
211for additional maintenance maintenance concern and then um I noticed in some of the school divisions they spell out um that cell phone use is allowed on the school bus what is what is our position our is Bell to Bell so school bus is allowable yeah so I think whether it's in the in the um communication of it or whether it gets further identified in the in the policy that that that piece be be be clarified um um you know I tend to be libertarian and uh um but I I get the the point behind this concerns that have been raised about um um interrupting the the the instru instuctional time um but I would like to to recommend to the board that we um have Clarity around the discipline process or the administrative process um
212as it relates to uh the policy that we consider moving the staggers or that definition to um uh to the regulation and that we also clarify U around this the school bus can I ask a clarifying question Mr you had said originally the table for the staggers are you talking about putting all the definitions in the regulation or just the table defining the staggers well that one caught my attention because I just know that it could change it could just change and so I don't know about other folks I could never remember remember the staggers anyway so but Bell to Bell makes sense to me school day makes sense to me but if we're going to Define it down down to the Stagger that I'm just saying if we put that in a regulation so
213keep the definitions here and definitions there that's what I want to clarify at least that's that's my thought as I'm as I'm looking I agree with that I agree with those we can develop regulations before the next board I I can't well I we pass we passed the policy and you but usually we make you aware of the regulations when the policy's passed I I can I I don't know that I can have it done by tomorrow to be uploaded because that's the upload date all all I'm saying is that because of all the communication that's been going out the podcast and all of that I just think it's important that we tie it all together now and not promate the the policy and then some letter goes home and then somebody says I never
214saw the letter it wasn't connected I think the more we can communicate those expectations across the board and CommunityWide the better we'll do we'll do and thank you for bringing that up I forgot uh Mr we also did a podcast sorry we did a podcast podcast thank you so yeah that and that could be the conversation around the dinner table over the holidays get that communication out um because it it will be a culture shop come January I'm Sorry Miss Clanton you have a comment let 645 all right oh so well thank you Dr po um so it is 6:45 thank you all for ma'am I Mr P yeah yes um I think the board should take up the issue of right sizing the schools in January I think isn't that on the agenda if
215we didn't talk about any agenda I I just this thing came up and I'd like a little clarification but I think we need to start the process thank you thank you anything else for the order of the school board all right this meeting is adjourned for