001you here and my kid's back there too so he can uh help and my kid's gonna be here at 6:30 where your kids have home with Jess okay okay and we're recording yes okay call this meeting to over order at um and this is a nonregular meeting um the Heartland school board so that we can um hopefully approve a budget today um so I'm just going to give an update um on the conversation that I just had um so I called Elizabeth to see what the like if there's anything happening at the legislative level with any of this um and to also present her with some of the challenges that we're facing um mainly that like at the budget that we would have lik to have adopted um that we had a 6% increase uh
002in our budget but that represented a 13% increase in our taxes um and so I just was she and I walked through some of the struggles that we're facing this year um and in exchange she asked um for Larry to produce a school budget which we can talk about later Larry we we'll Define that for you um but assuming that all High School tuition kids get the state average that all High School tuition in Harland cost the state average what would that do to our school budget um I I can but I can do last year State average plus 5 perc and give you an idea if if all your tuition was that what that difference in dollar amount would be is that what you're asking yep and how that would impact our taxes I
003could do that yeah that does to the excess so what she wants to do is write a bill to help us with the tuition impact on excess spending I could I could I could assume that an an estimate of last year's to say what average plus 5 percent and what that would be if every student paid that if if that's all that the high schools got and what that would do to your tax rate that would save you I'm assuming some hundreds of thousands of dollars and then that would do the tax rate yeah and I don't know that 189 placeholder that was in I had a placeholder of 189 I ran a bunch of numbers Larry I had a placeholder of 189 as the average Statewide High School cost is that I have I
004have um last year's was I don't think it was 189 it was little higher than that and then I added 5 percent the one to check would be like Kua right so if I find a Kua family so 19774 last year this this year is a Statewide average because that's what Kua parents get and then they pay the difference so plus 5% would be 20763 so you want me to run if every kid was 20763 how much money Le we pay that to Lebanon or you just estimated that no we it's an independ AA is the Statewide average because the parent picks up the difference right but I was looking I pulled the leanon number from tuition and that's exactly what it was yeah Lebanon Lebanon charged us 23,41 yeah and then they and plus
0055% because they're not part of our Vermont system they don't have to announce their tuition like Woodstock and Windsor and Harford so there's something wrong in the uh High School tuition budget comparison spreadsheet because it says that Lebanon paid 20763 or that that's what we're budgeting for this year okay so are you talking about in the budget book when you say something's wrong do you mean the budget book yes okay so that using the because we talked about this prior uh when we built the budget uh I'm using the fy2 estimated tuition of the time so we can compare apples to apples so what Ed put in the town report last year that's what it was because we didn't have the announced tuition right right and now now we do so in the 26 ones
006I'm using when I have the estimates when I have the actuals I'm using the actuals if I don't have the actual I'm using a 5% estimate because I don't have doesn't have to use number right okay so so you use the state average times 5% yes I love for Lebanon because that's exactly the number that you just rattled off to me yeah no that was Lebanon is 20 24590 I'm using 19774 at last year Statewide average I've add for Kua don't think of Lebanon or Handover Kua gets to Statewide average number that you is in the book because that's what Ed used last year okay for 26 I'm I'm yes but I'm going off of actuals in 26 oh because we're in the 26 year right now so the easiest way to explain the Statewide
007average yeah we're making the budget and I'm looking at the 26 budget so the so the discrepancy that we see is that the average anticipated tuition for this year for high school students is 20763 and yes but the state of Vermont is simultaneously telling us that our weighted cost or I guess unweighted should be 15,000 and if we said that a high school student is one .1 Vermont if they're being consistent in the data should at least be giving us 18875 per high school student because that's the tuition divided by 1.1 right so that that difference of $3,000 in that sort of arbitrary cut off is we being built twice on that $3,000 discrepancy in there but Grant it doesn't pre prek cost less than one yeah yeah yeah so it's not really Apples to
008Apples um but what but I'm you get more for a high school student in your ltwm get well you get 1.1 right you and you get more if there's reduced or they're taex CER kids I believe you get something okay um okay so do we have anywhere in the budget book the 27 tuition numbers 27 is next is the fiscal year after next the budget book and the budget you guys are voting on and the town is going to vote on in March is for FY numbers the tuition numbers in the budget book are fy2 the budgeted numbers that are in the 25 column throughout the budget book 26 I'm using actuals as I get them and if I don't have actuals I'm using an estimate okay so Hartford I have their number it's up
009I have Windsor's number it's a dollar I have you know from the estimate I have I have the actuals I don't have actuals for Handover because they don't have to give it but but it's not matching what you're saying isn't matching what I'm looking at okay but let's but let's you just think about because we we're not going to have all the data point for non Vermont High School tuition points no I'm I'm trying to I need to give Elizabeth numbers to like today or tomorrow yeah and what you're saying is not matching what's in the book no I I think what she wants correct me if I'm wrong you want me to say that every kid gets a Statewide average and what that dollar amount would be in FY 26 right what I estimate
010the Statewide average to be if every kid got that and every right that would be a dollar savings to Harland then you want me to take that dollar savings minus it from the original budget and see what that would do to the excess spending threshold correct right but I also want to I'm trying to put together a spreadsheet for her of what our high school spending and she's trying to look at what our high school spending is and you just said that Lebanon is 24 but in the book it's 20 that's where I'm struggling yeah so I Le yeah Lebanon last year when Ed built the budget he had to pick a number at the moment so he took whatever they charged just the previous year 203 and when he was Building 25 he had
011he added 5% when he did the 25 budget so that's to compare apples to apples if you looked at the to report last year but I'm looking at the 26 and it says 20,000 which it should be over 24 took last year's and did 5% I'm saying that I don't think I have anything to look at for the tuition numbers because 20,7 yes I have to pick a number I don't have Lebon doesn't give yeah so so that's the number you pick for Le but the rest of these are right everything else so Harford is 23,000 I got that today Windsor 2878 I set that one so you know that one's right uh W stock is up 22 21 21 for 21878 right okay so the rest of these are right so the picking Lebanon
012as the example was a bad one Handover because Handover I don't know I'm guessing yep um and then another question just on High School tuition um so we have a bunch of private schools that we're paying more to they're public private so Landmark is public private uh Landmark is but they're charging Ledger a charter school rightmark school it must be on the it must be on the approved list okay non BT private okay I was just curious and we have very few private schools that we charging the state average to that's Sharon Sharon doesn't have to and fford doesn't have to they can do whatever they want really Kua yeah I go off of the Statewide average I go off of Kua because that's the one where the parent picks up the excess no that
013makes sense okay cool okay I got that um I'll need to fix my spreadsheet that I sent to Elizabeth um but so that was the conversation that we had is to try and pull the tuition out of the excess spending because it's a big impact and if we can pull that out it's a big impact that we have nothing no control over and it's also um I think the legislators the legislators who deal with education are all located in Chittenden and have no idea what happens at this end of the state and so I think that they need to see what tuition looks like over here um so that they know what we're dealing with I think the other thing that they could look at as well as making high school kids worth more yeah
014like 1.1 like cu High School teachers you know like you don't have one classroom teacher for a high school kid you've got five right and so they should be should be worth but I mean it's also you say yes we don't have control we don't have control this year necessarily but I we could make the decision to choose a high school I mean that's what would be pushing issue but if we were to choose a high school we're still well over that's what I'm trying to say like if we were to designate a high school we're still way over Aver have to merge yeah and I think even with that so that's what I mean so but that's what I'm saying the state could come back to you and say you do have control right
015you could merge we could merge right which we can't do by next year but we should the town shouldn't be penalized because High School is more expensive on this side of the state I think that their current numbers don't I think they need to see what tuition numbers look like and there's no threshold for school there's no right exactly B an eye charge $1,500 exactly and they don't believe that that actually happens that was the first I know there I watched it exactly I had a parent tell me that happen the other day yeah that the Arts were gonna get cut so they instead just increased tuition for sending Downs $ that and she was like so I think all that I mean I I this is wildly frustrating I think it's going to be
016important to communicate some of this to make sure people understand but it is very much out of our control year so I think we have to focus on the things that we can control if we can get a bill pass so I know we need to push for it that's what I'm trying to do that I'm worried that the likelihood of that by March 4th is very low and that in the meantime we are going we need some type of budget to present so let's move on go Larry yeah real quick sorry Nikki I I don't want to belabor it so you want me to get that number to and what it would do to the tax right if every kid had the Statewide average it's like tomorrow is that what you want yep yeah
017okay not tonight no okay thank you unless you're feeling really ambitious okay let's keep going okay so Lindsay you're in control so you yeah Lindsay youp got it can do all right there we go these are just the first couple where the slide is Larry do you want me to pause here yeah this is uh this has shouldn't much change much than what you saw last time the only change um one second 26114 um the only change is that as I outlined earlier I have I have changed the as the actual tuition announced is announced like Windsor like Hartford I have updated it based taken away my estimates and use the actuals uh announced and I've updated the budget book which has changed your number it was $6,000 total after all the machinations it was
018$6,000 to the wrong side so you your budget's $6,000 higher than you saw it two days ago based on the actual y that makes sense um you want to speak more on this one Larry or keep going yeah just it again it was 13.2% two days ago now it's 13.3 and with the excess bending threshold I think this outlines what's going on at Harland is uh the excess spending threshold is most of the tax increase if you if the excess spending threshold did not exist your tax increase would be up 1% um Larry just out of curiosity like are we done now with changing numbers like no because we don't know okay but no but what I'm saying is is like like are we like most of the number changing is is that sort of
019done now at the state level sure just any levels no the state still your budget number is not going to change the yield could the yield could change these are all estimates for example the yield has a great impact on the tax rate and last year they changed the yield in June like they they will almost certainly change the yield in June that's why I'm I try to be very careful the the tax rates are estimates the budget once you approve a budget number and it goes to the printers and the voters vote on it and hopefully approve it it's done I can't change that number the tax rate could change course yeah thei could change dramatically adjusting the longterm weighted average so they said they are they they said this was the last this
020was the fourth one and this was the last one oh so we got another one we just got another one that's in here just out of curiosity if we so like we are proposing this could be like what people's tax rates are but in the end it maybe could be less could be less could be more yeah and for example Windsor West Windsor passed their budgets Mount scotney last year they had a reappraisal in the interim and it dramatically changed their tax rates for the better well it's a watch right a reappraisal right tax rate went down but the money's the same right okay that's what so are we on the oh uh on that slide I just wanted to highlight that it's a 133% tax increase for a 5.9 budget increase that's correct our
021tax increas is more than double what the budget increases and then the budget increases really only do it at this point from cost of living increases in health insurance yes yeah so that's nothing addition just want to make it Crystal Clear nothing was added to the budget okay let's get into the options okay so option a um is everything list Ed there with winter activities teacher supplies Furniture fixtures repairs maintenance custodian a to be hired PE teacher and an elementary teacher and that is um both of those teacher positions are one is an unfilled the to be hired PE and the other elementary teacher is due to a retirement at the end of this school year and I do want to just point out that it's it's important to note that those teachers those dollar
022amounts I know I mentioned this last time but worth mentioning again those dollar amounts are not salary that is salary as well as benefits so just to make sure that we point out um it is a 2.52% budget increase with a 6.6% tax increase with a total reduction of three 377,000 an SEI a social emotional interventionist uh and a school counselor from 0.9 to7 um our hope and Christine um correct my language if I'm incorrect the hope with the SEI position is to think within our um larger supervisory Union and see if there is any possibility of reallocating um some people that are there currently to help support Heartland during the next year Christine did I get that right yes we have some um some seis in the Su that are funded through special education
023so we could look at um shifting people I think that um I think that an SEI is position is also in the weather's field budget reduction plan so and the SE there's no guarantees but yes we would try to look to to do that the services that the SEI provides are primarily to special education students provide they provide services to all kiddos and so under that umbrella of all kiddos are students that are identified on uh 504 AP right which is the purpose of act 173 and we're sharing your sources right right no I just um so what do you have now for SS they're both locally funded at Heartland we just have two yeah in the building yes what other Behavior Support people are in the building uh assistant principals school counselors uh teachers
024parent professionals the Lindsay the office staff I mean it's a team effort but primarily when the behaviors are we try to be proactive seis are um able to implement some proactive strategies kids that are on plans um and and sometimes reactive situations that they're called um to assist and the school counselor reduction is was that the previously planned reduction the point it was it was the N was previously plann for this one year yeah for this year but this would take budget next year then so so just I I apologize forance but when thinking about the structure of Staffing in the school there's obviously Elementary School teachers who are locally funded there are then par Educators who are locally funded some some in part some areu funded if they are special here for special education
025and then there are you said two seis that are locally fun locally funded and then is that sort of it and then specials teachers like yes I mean for your local budget yeah or just no more like I'm just I just want to like have a a like systems map in my brain of like who is here on a day-to-day basis for the kids like regardless of funding I just want to like be able to imagine yes so classroom teachers special educators special education teachers support staff seis school counselors related arts ad support staff being par Educators the right yeah okay yeah um how about like hcrs and like we don't have we are hope anymore that it's paid um through medic medic funds so it doesn't come out of anybody's budget it's um it's
026a coaching program so it's for kids with specific needs not your kids in Crist Cris that need mental health clinicians but kids with anxiety or that are just struggling um they can uh be referred to this program and it's a they meet with a we are hope coach every day for 30 minutes for about a six week period sometimes it's longer um just to help them teach them skills this is externally funded yes it's not funded in 1.0 in the building or like externally funded with some amount of time in the building just it's internally funded we fund it through Medicaid money um and Lindsay you have a fulltime person in your building correct okay so the oh sorry was there a question yeah do do we also have like hcrs counselors and think like
027correct yes and those are funded mostly mostly special education yeah and in terms of like par numbers of par professional support staff in the building that to some degree is dictated by need as defined by IEPs and so we're sort of making this decision about need about funding in total like total absence of the the actual required need of these people right like no no because the special ed fund provides a lot of it so the locally funded could professionals are yes like supplemented as needed by the Su level like there are not we will not be at risk of not providing appropriate services at the if we were special yeah no because you only have control over the locally funded support staff and so the Su will make sure that the school has sufficient
028right they have to make sure there's sufficient special Educators for IEPs okay yes you have five locally funded um Care Professionals uh we made we made a point to put in kindergarten each kindergarten teacher has one it's very important that they have that support in kindergarten then there's one shared kind of one to um there's one in the middle level who helps with intervention um and there's one I think at the 3 four five level that's shared yeah and then your seis are lovely funded there okay thank you I appreciate that sorry for that I just that's totally fun um okay Lindsay all right so option b um with those in addition to a is a 1.92% budget increase with a 55% tax increase with a total reduction of 442,000 do you want me to
029pause here or go to the next one my next slide is what Hannah asked for last week let's go for D let's look at it option D which would in total cut you 1.4 million just over 1.4 million and it is everything that I had listed before and then additionally and one of the the administrators four teachers two related arts one uh counselor one Administrative Assistant three report staffs the other SEI and the school resource officer getting you a 7.17% budget decrease with an 11.8% tax decrease so option D is option C plus this it's option A B C and this y option D includes everything I listed before and then these I just want to say out loud this is not a real option I asked for this as a way to demonstrate how
030extreme it would be we won't call it I want to be clear about the purpose of asking for this slide was not that this is my hope so this is four teachers on top of one the PE the elementary and world but wait Lindsay also wasn't this supposed to get us just to no tax increase I thought was what no this was to get us to the um under the threshold under the threshold that's right to the okay to what would it look like to be at what Vermont says we should be really seven teachers down but isn't this amazing yeah you have the PE teacher you have the yeah then you have the elementary teacher you have art teachers in there too two art teachers this is that's the four teachers on top ofage
031that's correct language and Elementary really seven teachers now good um okay so would this even be would we even be in compliance with like the no no standards okay no we would not to to answer question no this we would not me um educational quality standards with this model here right so that's really important I think for people really understand that so if we get our budget to the place the state says we ar we are supposed to be at we're not excess spending we are not meting the state's educational quality standards so just make sure anyone who's listening to that really understands the situation right sorry can we just remove go back up to back up to option take off the table yes okay okay um so uh acknowledging that we have Robert's Rules
032of Order and that this is not supposed to be the time for public participation and not also not wanting to put you guys on the spot yeah can I or or everyone or everyone else here but we have some I mean I just it would be I actually would really if you guys are open to just weighing in like what some of these things would feel like um I think in particular I'm curious to know sort of what it what it would mean to to lose an SEI and that school counselor reduction I mean also I think you know I think none of us like the idea of diminishing the student facing roles acknowledging that currently the PE teacher and elementary teachers will be that it's not a human that's in the building now but
033none of us like that idea but if you could if any of you are willing to comment on that okay I'll be The Brave One um I think option b is not not avable because of the needs in the school and the support that is supported it supports teachers and students I mean both because if there's if a child is needing support and we don't have anybody to help that impacts the rest of the class it impacts all staff I just can't those positions impact exponentially and yeah and I will add so like where I'm teaching we are a k a prek five school yeah and we have three seis and we're K8 and there are five okay so larger school for just proportionate increase in SE okay but I mean different commity are you
034guys like the same so you're smaller with more yes and they are they are running all day that's what I see um so okay and I mean then to be clear we we only have two yeah so you would be decreasing us down to one not you yes corre no I would be correct okay but it would it would take us right it would take us down to one for the 240 students nobody I why did I say five there are five because there are three provided by no thank you see this okay I like back okay five pair two seis so the pair educators will often be like assigned if it's special they're assigned to got it okay okay go Lindsay I think um also with what Anna said I think it's important to
035note that when any student regardless of age is in a place of disregulation more often than not not more than a singular staff person is needed to help support that student um especially if a student is in a more extreme place of disregulation to make sure that student and staff are safe it does require more than one staff Personnel so I just wanted to make note of that as well yeah um I'm gonna throw something out there um I with my knowledge of the school um don't I like the program that we have now I don't want to make any Cuts option A I could do I don't think I could do option b um and I don't really don't want to go to option C um I hope that somehow we can find some
036tax savings um I think a 2.5% budget increase is responsible even though it causes a 6% tax increase really well I'm looking it's a 60 6065 tax increase from A to B if you're looking at a $250,000 right yeah so it's helpful if you're thinking about Impact versus money out of your wallet that doesn't and and something I want to say too just for those of us that were here the first iteration of this we have already taken several options and grouped them into option A so for anyone who's listening to this for the first time you know I think it the the danger here is by comparison a you might say like oh well why not go further into the alphabet well we actually in reality if we use the options provided last week
037we're already at you know option option option A was option C for last I think just you know and I want to just sort of say these things out loud that things that are that we would if we went with OP would be proposing to cut are things that are really painful to think about cutting as it is right so the thought of having only one gym teacher for a k through eight school that is already existing in a you know increasingly sedentary world and um and having a health teacher and not having a health teacher right so we're we we already agree that that we are not where we would like to be in that area um you know losing a an elementary teacher um is obviously everybody's least favorite you know idea to
038be cutting a a classroom teacher um and you know it's not as important probably to the voters in town who do not have children in the school but the thought of losing winter activities is heartbreaking right I mean what an amazing thing that we provide to cultivate equity in our town that is a you know a a ski Retreat for people from out of state that oftentimes drive by homes with kids who have no opportunity to go ski and our school was able to make it into something that all kids had access to like that feels horrible to have to cut that um so I just want to sort of say that out loud that even though by comparison it seems like smaller cuts the things on that list are really are real losses for
039our student B and just teacher supplies because it's not like they're going to get cut the supplies like the teachers are goingon to go buy them they're gonna go buy them right so that's know that's not it's not it's all it all is and I agree I mean I think at this point I can just say it like I'm not willing to go past option A no I'm not really either and I just threw that out there because I don't think any of us are and so to be honest I would I mean I think I would and I mean I guess the question is is there some you know objection to is there any objection to like are there things in that option A that do we want to go back to those options
040of last week I I am worried that a tax increase more than six or s% is going to be an automatic um rejection so I am I am worried that we have to provide at least that um I also I'm gonna put this on the record in a meeting we as a school are paying to have a police response to a school where we sometimes get threatened by upset individuals and we sometimes have kids that need police presence and part of that part of what Heartland is forcing us to do through that is to pay additional taxes so that we can have a police response to the school this is not a normal education cost usually schools don't hire their own police so people may not remember like so the hiring of a resource officer
041Yes means we have access to that an individual but the really reason we got this was because we got access to the Windsor Police Department they are our first people whereas before it was the state police and they were not available so time in a in a in a like a the quickness we were wanting so I'm putting that out there because if the community chose to actually have a police presence we would not be taxed at a double rate because that's what happens with the excess spending is we get tax double because we're exceeding the excess spending we would not be taxed at a double rate for having that res I don't think I totally understand that so that when you exceed the excess spending I understand that yeah what does so if we
042like you're saying if we had a police officer on campus no the town any amount ofce I see I see I see I see the school would buy a police contract so in addition to the school which education expense paying for um Mental Health Care exactly exactly also pay for protection yes got it thank you so what happened several years ago is there were several incidences in a row where the state police couldn't resp response in the in the timely manner that that we as a community that part I I just didn't I was just trying to figure out the the calculus that you describing okay so if the community paid for it the school wouldn't be paid for it which would decrease our to shift responsibility to the schools and then yep that to
043people's property taxes EXA Vermont so that is one of the things that is in this and it's not on the Jobing block because we absolutely need it but if the community chose to pay for it we would not be paying excess tax how how do you get the community you'd have to get working on it we need the community to know that they are already paying extra taxes on Services yeah here at school yeah yeah so I will I will make a motion that we uh propose a budget which is reflected by option A ruction Larry we don't actually have that number to make the proposal yeah so option A is uh reducing 377,000 [Laughter] I can put it in the chat Nikki I put a note in the chat for you about the budget
044book and okay so I gave you a thumbs up but you probably notice I miss budget book is correct I was reading a different sheet uh okay that makes sense yeah 11 got a new tab okay 11 million 225,000 9926 and that represents and Lindsay let's just put another return on this so we have it in our notes that represents a 2.52% budget increase yeah and we're projecting a 6.6 tax increase that's correct can you see this screen Nikki or do I need to reshare it oh no you need to reshare I'm see it I'm in it and can we just point out that the inflation for 2024 is 2.9% maybe just we still under inflation under the rate of inflation it's only 2.9% 4.1 but like 500% so here's here's my question um what
045so are we eliminating the elementary school teacher because it's going to be somebody that's just retiring and not filling we are are class low hanging fruit basically or is it dictate because based on the Vermont standards this is all my questions I've been asking recently of Larry and everybody um so the Vermont standards say that 20 kids a maximum it grades K through three and then it increases to 25 at four right we'll only have one kindergarten teacher correct or only one fourth grade teacher right yes and that's what said or I might have said last time or maybe it was in a separate conversation is the amount of stress then that it puts on that fourth grade teacher given that the for the next three years after that teacher is going to have 30
046students no because you'll shift the single like the teachers will shift so that like that cohort that grade class year that is under 25 will remain one class until seventh grade when there will be four teachers sixth grade so for four and fifth grade that class will have one class so it doesn't stay with fourth grade it stays with that class migrates and even to Ryan to answer that even a little bit more it may not NE just because the retirement happens from a fourth grade doesn't always equal that it would be one fourth grade teacher does that make sense yes so it just ends up being like this is your number of classroom teachers and who's teaching how do we fill it so it does mean that teachers will most likely may have to
047shift grade levels as they're teaching which means we could potentially lose teachers that are like I'm a second grade teacher and I don't I I don't care to shift so that's that's a possibility because the thing about it is that I mean I've I've looked at every school relatively close to the same size as ours like within a I don't know 50 mile radius and every school that is our size has two kindergarten even you know the torch bears or whatever Weathersfield comparing us to Weathersfield Weathersfield has two kindergarten two first grade 22 23d 24th and two F Well I'll say I mean so I'm at uichi and we have two of everything as well and there's discussion of combining grades with the same amount of students 250 or whatever we have no probably around
048because we're just a different grades but there so I mean everyone I think it would be interesting to just be you know a fly on thewall at all these different school board meetings because my guess is is there's a lot of those types of discussions that are happening because the state so we're also trying to get ahead of the state because the state may soon Force minimum class sizes and if we have a great 24 split between two it may not well and that's what I mean our current sixth grade silus has there's 12 Goods in this grade I think Christine wants to weigh in in our discussion from the other room I've been I can hear parts of it but um if you're if you're in a good place Weathersfield really needs Larry that's
049all oh uh yeah we're in a good place thanks Larry thank you Larry than you Larry thanks lar um well you guys are like have superpowers I know I hear you it's it's really unappealing the thought of reducing the the size of the faculty it also feels impossible to make a dent in budget without somehow and I and I again I mean I I I for as much as I believe that this school is the heart of this community and is all of our futures and matters so much and we should all you know I also recognize that there are people in this town who are looking at property tax increases which threaten their ability to stay in their homes and I think we are in this unfortunate position of holding both of those challenges
050and there has to there has to be some compromise and I and I don't know how we make meaningful Cuts without looking really hard at the Staffing Dynamics and being willing to accept some imperfections acknowledging I am not the person that has to be in a room with 24 and I think like just to go back to the to the old days our class sizes used to be like our normal class size used to be 35 kids and so the no sorry not grade grade size yes great 35 and actually we had some grades of 50 so like 35 and that's just in the time that I've been on the board we've had 35 to 50 and the current eighth grade is the biggest buz yeah so the current eighth grade is 40 kids so
051those teachers are dealing with 20 kids in each and that's where the structure of two teachers per grade comes from but now we're looking at class sizes that are more in the average of like 24 or 25 and that makes it harder to maintain that right model it also makes it extremely difficult for teachers I don't like I just don't want to talk numbers I know it's extremely difficult to have to like split grades or like I I just don't we luck um so so that's part of that history as well um okay so we have a motion on the table that was made by Hannah I 11,926 th000 budget did it have a second that just get a second um do we have any I yeah I agree and do we have any further
052discussion no I mean really what's our next steps are um hoping pray yeah hope and pray that the tax rate goes down yeah if if the tax rate goes down that to me is like really frustrating because then we wouldn't have done this right do you know what I'm saying like I think we would still have to we still have to just you would still have to make Cuts but like it maybe would have to be we could have another option right yeah Lindsay and I think I don't know if this answer is the more logistical end of this question but the next board meeting first Tuesday of February 3rd fourth um when that meeting is I will bring to you a draft for the annual meeting um that is probably will look more similarly
053to the final one we ended up doing last year if that makes sense yeah okay um okay so I think it sounds to me like we're ready to vote um so I just don't have to do a roll call we're all in person unless you think this is significant enough I think we'll just do an i okay all those in favor of approving a total budget of 1 million one million 1 million that would be we all have lunch we're gonna start over this is the dyslexic trying to read numbers um turn them into words um all those in favor of approving a budget of 11,225 n926 is uh which represents a 2.52% budget increase over the current budget year and a projected 6.6% tax increase please say I that was the least enthusiastic guys
054I know all those opposed Nay n any no I'm not I'm repeating okay so uh any extensions okay so I hear that that was a four to one vote four eyes and one nay um that was a four to one vote and that was what we were supposed to do today um Lindsay can you um just double can you make a total of what option D budget reductions looks like so I can share it with Elizabeth I think it's on there hold on let me double check right down there at the bottom is that what you're looking I thought we renamed it the Hannah option right no but like did I just override that by making this motion yeah no I I want to share with Elizabeth what it looks like to get us um
055under that and so I just want to double check that we have like the right numbers so I'll just confirm this number with Larry is that what you mean yeah and also um like I If if it's seven teachers make it seven teachers right put it total like the total total as if we were just starting with this is the only option we need option and we're not adding things like combine options putting all the options into D represent the total loss does that make sense I I think so I think so yes so I can share the total loss so that I can share what this is looking like from so you're you're meaning a b c and d in total um yeah yeah like what the total of option D if that was
056the only option we presented what is all of those cuts look like that okay so yeah put all that in yeah do you mean also what what I'll do is I'll put the all the um positions and other activities that have would be there and then that 14 1.4 million is reflective of the total reduction but I understand what you're saying is you want it all on one slide I can do that yeah I want everything on one slide so that I can hand it to somebody and say right like this this is what that excess spending threshold does um okay uh anything else um are we doing anything between I feel like we need to be very proactive because don't want option A to then turn into option b and or C right so
057I feel like we have to start being very proactive about like how we are presenting This and like we need to I feel like we need all of us to have like the same words right and the same presentation of whatever it is so when we see community members who are like what's the budget going to look like this year we are all saying the same thing with the like with all the right information and that we start now really going into the community and being like this is this is what we have chosen and here is what this is going to do yeah okay and I think that that that is kind of what our next meeting is about without being defined that way but I like that you just defined it that way
058okay and I would also like for our last vote last year um we pulled in some good Community Messengers yeah I think we just need to do that now and so I think we need to I think we our next meeting let's plan to get that whole thing together to get um sign myar just ch I don't know if I can hear the S um yeah and then um to get those I mean if the same community members are willing to help again that would be fantastic because they were really affected um rather just be proactive instead of reactive yes I would yeah I and I liked the way that we handled the last vote I think it was we got the word out um okay anything else work is done can take a motion
059to adjourn I will motion to adjourn okay Heather moves any seconds ran seconds and everybody says I I we are adjourned thank you guys I really impressed